Research Skills for Dissertations - Bodleian Libraries · • Or a stunning, hydra-headed...

Research Skills for Dissertations: 2015

Sue Bird Bodleian Subject Librarian Geography

The digital architecture facilitating research & study

Oxford Libraries Information

Platform

Literature & Data Search Engines e-Journals

e-Books

On-line data bases

Subscription

Dbases

Data Portals

(expanding)

Course Information Management

Research Skills Tool Kits

Science

Blogs

Science & Ideas Media

PodOxfo

rd

Networking, Communication &

Living

Data Visualisation

Tools

You & Your Devices (and WiFi connection –

Eduroam, OWL)

Cloud

computing

Note: commercial products cited merely represent commonly

used services rather than endorsements

Data Mining &

workflow tools

Policies & Guidelines

SoGE Intranet

Cloud

computing

OUCS

Personal

Page

Data & File Sharing

OxFile

Oxford

iTunes U

Reference Management Tools

This session

How to cite sources correctly & therefore avoid

plagiarism

How to use Reference Management Software

SOLO & OXLIP+

Reference works

Google Scholar v. Bibliographic Databases

Searching Techniques & Keeping up to date

Dissertation Techniques

Avoiding Plagiarism

"...You must always indicate to the examiners when you have drawn on the work of others; other people's original ideas and methods should be clearly distinguished from your own, and other people's words, illustrations, diagrams etc. should be clearly indicated regardless of whether they are copied exactly, paraphrased, or adapted... ...The University reserves the right to use software applications to screen any individual's submitted work for matches either to published sources or to other submitted work. Any such matches respectively might indicate either plagiarism or collusion...

...Although the use of electronic resources by students in their academic work is encouraged, you should remember that the regulations on plagiarism apply to on-line material and other digital material just as much as to printed material..."

Section 9.5 Proctors' and Assessor's Memorandum

https://intranet.ouce.ox.ac.uk/undergraduate/fhs/plagiarism.html

Good academic practice

So follow the citation principles and practices in

place in your subject area, develop a rigorous

approach to academic referencing, and avoid

inadvertent plagiarism.

Be uniform in your referencing system:-

Probably use the Harvard system as suggested

on the School’s web-site – but whatever you do

use – just be consistent

https://intranet.ouce.ox.ac.uk/undergraduate/fhs/dissertation/referencing.html

Citing your references

Just a few of the more common points

An article in an online journal which also exists in print should be cited in the same way as print.

To cite something which only exists electronically, e.g. a web site, follow special rules which include the date viewed.

A specific quote must include the page reference in the citation. (This also applies to tables & diagrams you have taken directly from another source.)

Using quotations

• A specific quote must include the page reference

in the in text citation.

• They must also be enclosed by quotation marks.

• If you don’t then TURNITIN software will ping it

back as plagiarism, even if you have given the full

reference.

• THAT means straight to the Proctors – a whole

load of hassle and a £50 fine!!!

https://intranet.ouce.ox.ac.uk/undergraduate/fhs/dissertation/preparation.html

TURNITIN

Your Bibliographies

• Not just your dissertation

• Don’t forget your Extended Essays

• If you are asked for a specific style – USE it

e.g. Biogeography Option asks for bibliography to

be formatted according to the style of the ‘Journal of

Biogeography’ (2013 Finals no-one followed this so

marks deducted)

• How to find a particular style?

Citation practice

A large number of manuals are available to give

guidance and sound practice.

1:Doing a literature review / Chris Hart (London, 1998) [H 62 HAR ]

2:Manual for writers / Kate Turabian (7th ed. Chicago, 2007) [LB 2369 TUR ]

3:Communicating in geography & the environmental sciences / Ian Hay (3rd ed. Oxford, 2006) [G 70 HAY ]

4:Cite them right /Pears & Shields (2013 ed.) [LB 2369 PEA]

5: Complete guide to referencing & avoiding plagiarism / Neville (2nd ed. 2010) – available on-line via E.B.L.

What’s the point of reference

managers?

• Staying organised

• Collect information about everything you’ve read in one place.

1

• Saving time

• Speed up adding citations and creating bibliographies in documents.

2

References / Bibliography

Organize your research and manage your database of references

Import references from many different data sources including direct from databases like Scopus or Web of Science, or library catalogues like SOLO.

Store links to documents – pdf’s, images, etc.

Include citations while you write your paper and format them in a particular style at the touch of a button

Software available

• Many different packages are available

• The principles are the same but the details are

different

• Variations in price and features

Reference Management Systems

• RefWorks - web based – access your records anywhere

- free to members of university – even after you leave

• EndNote - works without web access – but software

needs to be installed on own machine – charge of c£95

from IT Services Shop

• EndNote on the Web - free to members of university, but

has limited feature set – designed to be used alongside

desktop version

• Zotero, Mendeley, ColWiz, Papers - free software for

reference management

About RefWorks

• University subscription

• Online – accessible from anywhere

• Plugin allows adding references to

your Word documents

LibGuide : Reference Management

R.T.Tally is actually the translator of this item

Right-click on this

RefGrab-It

bookmarklet link

RefWorks Overview

Dropdown menus Search

your

references

Brief view of

references in

your collection

Folders list Quick function buttons

E-Journals

I didn't check for the hard copy

- so used to getting online access!

“I had just googled the article rather than using

SOLO, so that was the issue & why I’d been

asked to login, or use Athens or pay a fee”

Newspapers

Electronic newspapers

• Some are freely available. Alphabetic list on

OxLIP+

• Best source for the “Text Only” of huge range of

newspapers and magazines is Nexis UK. Goes

back approximately 10 yrs in most cases and is

very current i.e. today’s daily news items

Newspapers

Electronic newspapers

• Factiva - from Dow Jones & Reuters Company

• Business news & challenges, market trends & info.

• 14,000 + sources inc. local & global newspapers,

newswires, trade journals, newsletters, etc.

• Archive back to 1969 - 28 languages from 159

countries

• Dun & Bradstreet company profiles, Reuters

Fundamentals, etc.

Legal Resources

Jurisdictions, topics, cases etc.

• Lexis Library

• WestLaw – both UK & US editions

• But there are a lot more

(if necessary ask the Law Library for help)

Bodleian Maps

Catalogues The main map catalogue is a physical card

catalogue in the Map Room, containing records of

all of the sheet maps in the collection, together with

most of the atlases. The general arrangement is by

map scale, but records for maps dated before 1851

and all atlases are arranged chronologically

Currently in the process of digitising our

physical catalogue and deploying it on SOLO.

(c.5000 post-1850 sheet maps & atlases published

after 1988)

Illustrations

Interesting new resource now available

Glass Lantern Slides from Oxford collections

Historic Environment Image Resource (HEIR)

Naples c. 1890 Vesuvius Railway early C20th Vesuvius 1923

Dissertation Techniques

Use SOLO or OxLIP+ to access

Reference tools

Abstracting and Indexing services

Reference Sources

General reference tools

CREDO Reference : Reference works incl.

Dictionaries, encyclopaedias etc

International Encyclopedia of Human Geography

Dictionaries. OED; Oxford Reference On-line

E-books

Reference books Blackwell Reference Online

SAGE Reference Online

SAGE Research Methods Online

Text books EBL (officially) the E-Book Library

Oxford Scholarship Online

Ebrary Academic Complete

NetLibrary now hosted by EBSCOhost Ebook Collection

Subject searching

SOLO and Oxford e-journals cover Oxford

holdings only by title

Better to use specialist indexes covering the

world’s literature to find articles

Access via OxLIP+

Use inter-library loan for items not held in

Oxford and not online

Bibliographic Databases

Excellent for locating journal articles, book

chapters & book reviews (NB. References only,)

General or specific subject coverage

Different interfaces but similar functionality

Not tied to library holdings

Frequently will provide a link to full text

So what about Google?

• Is it just a search engine?

• Is it a publisher?

• or merely a platform, an intermediary?

• A content kleptomaniac and parasite (- in Rupert

Murdoch's famous characterisation )

• Or a stunning, hydra-headed incarnation of the zeitgeist?

• Is it a stunningly resourceful and ingenious servant?

• or is it on the way to becoming our master?

Popham, P. (29/09/2012) The Independent, p. 20

Or indeed Google Scholar

• Let’s modify our algorithm so it excludes non-scholarly

material (how do we define that?)

• Let’s look at citations so when one article we index

cites another one we index, we can move it higher up

the relevance ranking

But let’s not allow:

• creation of sets / or combining of searches

• controlled vocabularies

• info on what is included & what is not / indication of

update frequency

Databases vs. Search engines

• Contents are indexed by subject specialists

• Subject headings

• Limiting functions e.g. publication types, language

Allow you to

• View Search history

• Combine searches

• Mark and sort results

• Print/save/email/export

• Save searches

• Set up alerts

• Searches done by

automated “web

crawlers”

• No thesaurus / subject

headings – just free

text searching

• No limiting functions

• Usually none of these!

Bibliographic Databases

Abstracting and Indexing Services

Vast range.

SCOPUS (includes GEOBASE)

OVID SP

ProQuest

Web of Science

Search Strategies

• Boolean logic

• Truncation

• Wild cards

• Synonyms

• Which language are you using?

Boolean connectors

• AND – combines terms to restrict results

• OR – useful for covering synonyms

• NOT – excludes unwanted areas of research

• Use Boolean operators

– AND – narrows down

– OR – broadens out

– NOT – excludes

• Use brackets to group

operations

• “Global warming” OR “climate

change”

• “(glaci* PRE/5 retreat*)” AND

• (“Global warming” OR

“climate change”)

Amazonia Biodiversity

Biodiversity

AND Amazonia

Renewable Energy Supply

Energy

Supply

NOT Renewable

Travertine Tufa

Travertine

OR Tufa

Improving Searching –

Boolean Operators

SCOPUS

• THE bibliographic database for

Geography, Earth and

Environmental Sciences

SCOPUS

Abstract & citation database containing peer-reviewed research literature.

22,000 titles from more than 5,000 international publishers.

Now starting to include more book material

55 million records:

29 million records back to 1995 (of which 84% include

references).

21 million records pre-1996 which go back as far as 1823.

6.5 million conference papers from proceedings & journals.

Bibliographic Searching

Search Tip : 1

– Important to remember that although each database

covers thousands of journal titles no single database

is ever comprehensive.

– If you are having difficulty finding material on a topic

use the keywords you find in any relevant reference

and search again.

Synonyms & Language

• Topic = Retreat of the Arctic sea ice

• Search:

• A) Arctic sea ice retreat

• B) “Arctic sea ice retreat”

• C) (“global warming” OR “climate change”) AND

( arctic OR polar OR greenland) AND ice

• Context : “glacial retreat” OR glacier melt / decay

Bibliographic Databases

ProQuest

• IBSS: International Bibliography of the Social Sciences

• Sustainability Science Abstracts

• Worldwide Political Science Abstracts

• PAIS International – government & other ‘grey’ literature

• EconLit

• Environmental Sciences & Pollution Management

Bibliographic Databases

OVIDSP

• CAB Abstracts – natural resources

• Forest Science - biogeography

• GeoRef – physical geography & geology

• Zoological Abstracts (1864-2009 only)

Bibliographic Databases

Web of Science/Knowledge :

Core COllection

– Includes Science, Social Science & Arts and Humanities Citation Indexes

– Citation indexes can be used in the same way as any other abstracting and indexing service. Their extra facility is the option to search the bibliographies of any articles- a citation search. Academics use the citation index to find out who has cited their work.

Bibliographic Searching

Search Tip : 2

Take time to explore the various databases & platforms available.

Some will be more useful to you than others.

• Scopus

• OvidSP

• ProQuest

• Web of Knowledge

Bibliographic Searching

Search Tip : 3

Boolean Logical Operators AND, OR, NOT

Proximity operators

Adj (literally adjacent); Near(same sentence); With(same

field)

Field descriptors: AU(author); TI(title); AB (abstract);

SO(source or reference); DE (general descriptor) etc are

likely to be specific to each database and won’t operate in

‘cross searches’

Combining searches: #1 and #2

Other tricks:

Use symbols for wildcards and truncation

? or $ for a single character

globali?ation / globali$ation (is it an ‘s’ or a ‘z’)

* for truncation or variant spellings

govern* for governance, governmentality, etc

use quotation marks for searching for phrases e.g. “resource management”

Bibliographic Searching

Search Tip : 4

• Consider subject synonyms & British and US spellings.

• Apply truncation, usually * to find plurals/alternative word endings and ? to replace a single character.

• Expand search by following hypertext links esp subject headings

• Use tagging facilities within database to mark articles for printing, emailing, downloading or exporting.

• Authors names: Check the online help for formats. Use the database index to find different forms of author’s name, otherwise truncate first initial.

Bibliographic Databases

Search :- Impact of La Nina and oceanic circulation on climate

change (2014-15 only)

Scopus = 45 articles

ProQuest = 33 articles (22 not found by Scopus)

Ovid = 27 after de-duplication (adds another 11 to the total)

Web of Science = 46 articles (a further 19 unique items)

RefWorks de-duplication = 97 !!

Bibliographic Searching

Three ways to keep up to date:

• Saving and rerunning searches – you save a search and run it

again in the future.

• E-mail alerts / RSS feeds:–

– Specify a search to be repeated and the results emailed to you at

chosen intervals or on a continuous basis

– Select your favourite journal(s) & the database will tell you when

the next issue of a journal is available.

• Citation Alert – you will receive an email every time a particular

article is cited in another WoS or Scopus indexed article.

Dissertation Techniques

Apart from Bibliographic Electronic Resources there are some factual databases available

via OxLIP+ e.g.:-

• World development indicators,

• EIU Country Reports,

• Demographic Yearbook etc.

If they are CD-ROM based they may require you to download software

GUIDE to RESOURCES

http://libguides.bodleian.ox.ac.uk/geography

Further assistance:

This presentation available via WebLearn & on-line

http://www.bodleian.ox.ac.uk/science/training/training-presentations

More courses available: http://www.oucs.ox.ac.uk/itlp/

Other presentations: http://ox.libguides.com/workshops

Guidance for references:

https://intranet.ouce.ox.ac.uk/undergraduate/fhs/dissertation/

referencing.html

Sue.bird@bodleian.ox.ac.uk

Dissertation Techniques

Your feedback is greatly appreciated

Please complete a short survey @

https://www.surveymonkey.com/s/GNKM3YR

Appendix

• Results from Google Scholar

• Record for : “Sensitivity of different

convection schemes …” in

a) Scopus & b) OVID

• Record for : “Strong sensitivity of Pine

Island ice-shelf melting …” in

a) Scopus & b) Web of Science

Databases (Scopus or Web of

Science) enable you to:

• Refine results overview to find the main journals, disciplines and authors that publish in your

area of interest.

• Click on the cited by and reference links to track research trends and make connections.

• Find out who is citing you or your supervisor, and how many citations an article or an author

has received.

• Use Author Identifier to automatically match an author’s published research including the h-

index

• Use Journal Analyzer to provide quick insight into specific journal performance

• Analyze citations for a particular journal issue, volume or year.

• Use this information to complete grant or other applications quickly and easily.

• Use Alerts, RSS and HTML feeds to help you stay up-to-date

• Data export via bibiliographic managers such as RefWorks, EndNote and BibTeX