View
4
Download
0
Category
Preview:
Citation preview
Quality control in cardiac nuclear medicine and cardiac CT
Klaus BacherGhent University
Department of Basic Medical SciencesDivision of Medical Physics and Radiation Protection
IMIC 2013, IAEA, Vienna
Quality control in medical imaging
• Medical imaging instrumentation: increasing complexity (e.g. hybrid systems)
• Quality in medical imaging relies on proper function and calibration of the instrumentation
• When using ionizing radiation, balancing image quality and patient radiation dose is very important
Need of objective and standardized procedures to evaluate the performance of the instrumentation
Why?
Quality control in cardiac nuclear medicine and cardiac CTKlaus Bacher
Quality management and quality control (IAEA)Quality control in medical imaging
Quality control in cardiac nuclear medicine and cardiac CTKlaus Bacher
Quality control in medical imaging
• Medical imaging instrumentation = hardware
AND software
What?
Quality control in cardiac nuclear medicine and cardiac CTKlaus Bacher
Checking the correct functioning of analysis tools is needed (also after updates/upgrades!)
Quality control in medical imaging
• Key person = medical physics expert • At least once a year a detailed quality control of the
instrumentation by the medical physics expert • More frequent tests to follow up calibration/stability of
equipment: mostly delegated to technologists• Analysis of image quality and software performance: help of
physician is needed
Who?
Quality control in cardiac nuclear medicine and cardiac CTKlaus Bacher
Close collaboration between medical physics expert and physician and technologist is needed!
How?Quality control in medical imaging
Quality control in cardiac nuclear medicine and cardiac CTKlaus Bacher
How?Quality control in medical imaging
Quality control in cardiac nuclear medicine and cardiac CTKlaus Bacher
How?Quality control in medical imaging
Quality control in cardiac nuclear medicine and cardiac CTKlaus Bacher
How?Quality control in medical imaging
Quality control in cardiac nuclear medicine and cardiac CTKlaus Bacher
• Nuclear medicine: Activity measurement chamber Gamma camera, SPECT PET
• X-ray imaging: Cone-beam CT or CT
Quality control in cardiac nuclear medicine and cardiac CTKlaus Bacher
Quality control in medical imaging
Specific co-registration test
Activity measurement chamber
• “Dose calibrator”• Detection of ionisation of
radiopharmaceutical in well geometry by means of an ionization chamber or scintillation detector
• Accurate activity measurement important for radiation dose
Quality control in cardiac nuclear medicine and cardiac CTKlaus Bacher
Activity measurement chamber
• Accuracy of the build-in clock, if applicable• Battery voltage• Detection of contaminations: background activity < 100kBq• Drift of zero adjustment of activity• Measurement of stability with reference source (e.g. 57Co,
137Cs,…): < 5%
Quality control – daily checks
Quality control in cardiac nuclear medicine and cardiac CTKlaus Bacher
Activity measurement chamber
• Analysis of energy response Measurement of reference source (e.g. 57Co) Using all isotope selections Check calibration factors of different isotopes over time <5%
Quality control – energy response
Quality control in cardiac nuclear medicine and cardiac CTKlaus Bacher
Activity measurement chamber
• Analysis of linearity Measurement of different levels of activities of 99mTc or 18F,
starting with high activity Measurements at different time points (decay) Response should be linear, within 5%
Quality control – linearity
Quality control in cardiac nuclear medicine and cardiac CTKlaus Bacher
Activity measurement chamber
• Analysis of reproducibility Perform 1O measurements of reference and calculate standard
deviation Reproducibility <1%
Quality control – reproducibility
Quality control in cardiac nuclear medicine and cardiac CTKlaus Bacher
Activity measurement chamber
• Analysis of geometry/volume dependence Dilution of activity of 99mTc from 0.5 to 5ml and register
readings Variation in readings should be <2%
Quality control – geometry dependence
Quality control in cardiac nuclear medicine and cardiac CTKlaus Bacher
Gamma camera
• Detection of counts• Reconstruction into image format• Stability of instrumentation may be an issue
Quality control in cardiac nuclear medicine and cardiac CTKlaus Bacher
Gamma cameraPerformance parameters
Quality control in cardiac nuclear medicine and cardiac CTKlaus Bacher
• Daily check by NM imager (position of the peak)
Gamma cameraQuality control – energy peak accuracy
Quality control in cardiac nuclear medicine and cardiac CTKlaus Bacher
• Yearly by MPE (energy resolution) <15%
Gamma cameraQuality control – energy resolution
Quality control in cardiac nuclear medicine and cardiac CTKlaus Bacher
Gamma cameraQuality control - homogeneity
• Non-uniformity = problems with calibration and/or PMT
Quality control in cardiac nuclear medicine and cardiac CTKlaus Bacher
Gamma cameraQuality control - homogeneity
• Using reference flat source (extrinsic, with collimators)
• Using point source at distance > 5 x FOV (intrinsic)
• More than 2500 counts/pixelQuality control in cardiac nuclear medicine and cardiac CT
Klaus Bacher
Gamma cameraQuality control - homogeneity
• Build-in software• Uniformity <7%
Quality control in cardiac nuclear medicine and cardiac CTKlaus Bacher
Gamma cameraQuality control - homogeneity
Quality control in cardiac nuclear medicine and cardiac CTKlaus Bacher
Gamma cameraQuality control - resolution
Quality control in cardiac nuclear medicine and cardiac CTKlaus Bacher
Gamma cameraQuality control - resolution
Quality control in cardiac nuclear medicine and cardiac CTKlaus Bacher
Gamma cameraQuality control – spatial distortion
Quality control in cardiac nuclear medicine and cardiac CTKlaus Bacher
Gamma cameraQuality control - sensitivity
• Deviation between detectors < 10%
Quality control in cardiac nuclear medicine and cardiac CTKlaus Bacher
Gamma cameraQuality control – system alignment
• 360° acquisition of point source
• Test if mechanical and electronical rotation point is the same
• 2-monthly by the NM imager
• Yearly by MPE• Build-in software
Quality control in cardiac nuclear medicine and cardiac CTKlaus Bacher
Gamma cameraQuality control - COR
• 360° acquisition of point source
• Test if mechanical and electronical rotation point is the same
• Build-in software• <1 pixel
Quality control in cardiac nuclear medicine and cardiac CTKlaus Bacher
Gamma cameraQuality control - COR
Quality control in cardiac nuclear medicine and cardiac CTKlaus Bacher
• 360° acquisition of point source
• Test if mechanical and electronical rotation point is the same
• Build-in software• <1 pixel
Gamma camera
• SPECT uniformity• SPECT resolution < 15mm
Quality control – other tests for SPECT
Quality control in cardiac nuclear medicine and cardiac CTKlaus Bacher
PET
• Coincidence measurement
Quality control in cardiac nuclear medicine and cardiac CTKlaus Bacher
PET
• Energy window (daily by NM imager)• Sinogram test (daily by NM imager)• PET uniformity (4-monthly by NM imager)• SUV reproducibility (4-monthly by NM imager)
• Build-in software
Quality control
Quality control in cardiac nuclear medicine and cardiac CTKlaus Bacher
PET-SPECT/CT
• Hybrid imaging systems: increasing importance• Combining anatomical and functional information
Quality control in cardiac nuclear medicine and cardiac CTKlaus Bacher
CT hardware
• PET in combination with ‘conventional’ multi-slice CT• SPECT in combination with:
‘conventional’ multi-slice CT GE, Siemens, (Philips)
‘low-dose’ CT systems GE (Hawkeye), Philips (BrightView XCT)
Quality control in cardiac nuclear medicine and cardiac CTKlaus Bacher
PET-SPECT/CT
• Co-registration QC• CT quality control issues• CT patient dose issues
Quality control
Quality control in cardiac nuclear medicine and cardiac CTKlaus Bacher
• As CT doses are high, CT procedures should be optimized taking into account the required image quality: In-depth study of image quality and dose parameters (at
acceptance/yearly) by a medical physicist Daily/Weekly/Monthly checks by medical imaging staff
To detect minor changes in image quality performance before clinical performance erodes
PET-SPECT/CTQuality control
Quality control in cardiac nuclear medicine and cardiac CTKlaus Bacher
• Daily/weekly/monthly checks are mostly automated• Most of them are performed at start-up of system:
X-ray tube warm-up and sometimes automated measurement of some X-ray tube characteristics
Image quality tests using a manufacturer-specific phantom
• Exact measurement methods depend on the manufacturer
Philips Medical
PET-SPECT/CTQuality control
Quality control in cardiac nuclear medicine and cardiac CTKlaus Bacher
CT image quality
• In most situations following parameters are measured CT number of water in ROI in water phantom Noise level: standard deviation of CT numbers in ROI
Routine image quality tests
Quality control in cardiac nuclear medicine and cardiac CTKlaus Bacher
CT image quality
• In most situations following parameters are measured CT number of water in ROI in water phantom Noise level: standard deviation of CT numbers in ROI CT number uniformity: measurement of CT numbers in 5 ROIs
Routine image quality tests
Quality control in cardiac nuclear medicine and cardiac CTKlaus Bacher
CT image quality
• In most situations following parameters are measured CT number of water in ROI in water phantom Noise level: standard deviation of CT numbers in ROI CT number uniformity: measurement of CT numbers in 5 ROIs
• Sometimes following parameters are also measured High-contrast resolution (visual inspection or calculation)
Routine image quality tests
Quality control in cardiac nuclear medicine and cardiac CTKlaus Bacher
CT image quality
• In most situations following parameters are measured CT number of water in ROI in water phantom Noise level: standard deviation of CT numbers in ROI CT number uniformity: measurement of CT numbers in 5 ROIs
• Sometimes following parameters are also measured High-contrast resolution (visual inspection or calculation) Low-contrast performance (visual inspection or calculation)
Routine image quality tests
Quality control in cardiac nuclear medicine and cardiac CTKlaus Bacher
• CBCT systems do have an inferior low-contrast detectability compared to conventional CT
Image quality in function of CT system
CT CTDIvol = 6.5 mGyCBCT CTDIvol = 6.5 mGy
CT image quality
Quality control in cardiac nuclear medicine and cardiac CTKlaus Bacher
CTDIvol
• CTDIvol takes into account effect of helical pitch• CTDIvol measured within
• 16cm PMMA phantom (adult head/pediatric scans)• 32cm PMMA phantoms (adult body)
pCTDICTDI w
vol
Measuring CT dose
CT centre
CT periphery
pcw CTDICTDICTDI ,100,100 32
31
Quality control in cardiac nuclear medicine and cardiac CTKlaus Bacher
• In CT, CTDIvol is considered as being the “mean radiation dose within one CT slice”
• In chest region, CTDIvol is measured in a 32 cm PMMA phantom• CTDIvol will significantly underestimate the mean radiation dose
in a reference person Example:
CTDIvol=5.2mGy Mean simulated dose reference person=11.4mGy
Interpretation of dose quantities
Quality control in cardiac nuclear medicine and cardiac CTKlaus Bacher
Measuring CT dose
• Effective dose is often used risk-related dose-indicator • Sometimes indicated on CT systems• Methodological errors are being made when calculating the
effective dose: ICRP 60 vs ICRP 103 Effective dose conversion factors:
Example: in cardiac CT a factor of 0.017 mSv/mGycm is often used, whereas a factor of 0.024-0.027 mSv/mGycm is more appropriate
Quality control in cardiac nuclear medicine and cardiac CTKlaus Bacher
Interpretation of dose quantitiesMeasuring CT dose
• Quality control is needed within quality assurance program• Quality control ≠ a single yearly test• Quality control needs multi-disciplinary approach
Quality control in cardiac nuclear medicine and cardiac CTKlaus Bacher
Quality control in medical imaging
Recommended