Preferences, Budget Constraint and Optimal...

Preferences, Budget Constraint and Optimal ChoicesECON 212 Lecture 5

Tianyi Wang

Queen’s Univerisity

Winter 2013

Tianyi Wang (Queen’s Univerisity) Lecture 5 Winter 2013 1 / 32

Preferences

3 axioms of preference (basics of consumer theory)I CompletenessI TransitivityI Monotonicity

Ordinal ranking VS Cardinal ranking

Utility Functions: math expressions of preferencesI e.g. U(x) = x1/2

I e.g. U(x , y) = x1/2y1/2

Hard to draw on blackboard (3-D)

Tianyi Wang (Queen’s Univerisity) Lecture 5 Winter 2013 2 / 32

Indifference Curves

2-D representation of 3-D Utility surface.

I Combination of bundles that give the same level of utilityI Contour plot (mountain), easy to drawI Have nice properties

"well-behaved" ICs have 4 properties:

1 Slope is negative (when you like both goods)2 ICs cannot intersect3 Every bundle lies on one & only one IC4 ICs are not thick (nonsatiation)

Tianyi Wang (Queen’s Univerisity) Lecture 5 Winter 2013 3 / 32

Indifference Curves

2-D representation of 3-D Utility surface.I Combination of bundles that give the same level of utility

I Contour plot (mountain), easy to drawI Have nice properties

"well-behaved" ICs have 4 properties:

1 Slope is negative (when you like both goods)2 ICs cannot intersect3 Every bundle lies on one & only one IC4 ICs are not thick (nonsatiation)

Tianyi Wang (Queen’s Univerisity) Lecture 5 Winter 2013 3 / 32

Indifference Curves

2-D representation of 3-D Utility surface.I Combination of bundles that give the same level of utilityI Contour plot (mountain), easy to draw

I Have nice properties

"well-behaved" ICs have 4 properties:

1 Slope is negative (when you like both goods)2 ICs cannot intersect3 Every bundle lies on one & only one IC4 ICs are not thick (nonsatiation)

Tianyi Wang (Queen’s Univerisity) Lecture 5 Winter 2013 3 / 32

Indifference Curves

2-D representation of 3-D Utility surface.I Combination of bundles that give the same level of utilityI Contour plot (mountain), easy to drawI Have nice properties

"well-behaved" ICs have 4 properties:

1 Slope is negative (when you like both goods)2 ICs cannot intersect3 Every bundle lies on one & only one IC4 ICs are not thick (nonsatiation)

Tianyi Wang (Queen’s Univerisity) Lecture 5 Winter 2013 3 / 32

Indifference Curves

2-D representation of 3-D Utility surface.I Combination of bundles that give the same level of utilityI Contour plot (mountain), easy to drawI Have nice properties

"well-behaved" ICs have 4 properties:

1 Slope is negative (when you like both goods)2 ICs cannot intersect3 Every bundle lies on one & only one IC4 ICs are not thick (nonsatiation)

Tianyi Wang (Queen’s Univerisity) Lecture 5 Winter 2013 3 / 32

Indifference Curves

2-D representation of 3-D Utility surface.I Combination of bundles that give the same level of utilityI Contour plot (mountain), easy to drawI Have nice properties

"well-behaved" ICs have 4 properties:1 Slope is negative (when you like both goods)

2 ICs cannot intersect3 Every bundle lies on one & only one IC4 ICs are not thick (nonsatiation)

Tianyi Wang (Queen’s Univerisity) Lecture 5 Winter 2013 3 / 32

Indifference Curves

2-D representation of 3-D Utility surface.I Combination of bundles that give the same level of utilityI Contour plot (mountain), easy to drawI Have nice properties

"well-behaved" ICs have 4 properties:1 Slope is negative (when you like both goods)2 ICs cannot intersect

3 Every bundle lies on one & only one IC4 ICs are not thick (nonsatiation)

Tianyi Wang (Queen’s Univerisity) Lecture 5 Winter 2013 3 / 32

Indifference Curves

2-D representation of 3-D Utility surface.I Combination of bundles that give the same level of utilityI Contour plot (mountain), easy to drawI Have nice properties

"well-behaved" ICs have 4 properties:1 Slope is negative (when you like both goods)2 ICs cannot intersect3 Every bundle lies on one & only one IC

4 ICs are not thick (nonsatiation)

Tianyi Wang (Queen’s Univerisity) Lecture 5 Winter 2013 3 / 32

Indifference Curves

2-D representation of 3-D Utility surface.I Combination of bundles that give the same level of utilityI Contour plot (mountain), easy to drawI Have nice properties

"well-behaved" ICs have 4 properties:1 Slope is negative (when you like both goods)2 ICs cannot intersect3 Every bundle lies on one & only one IC4 ICs are not thick (nonsatiation)

Tianyi Wang (Queen’s Univerisity) Lecture 5 Winter 2013 3 / 32

020

4060

80100 0

2040

6080

1000

20

40

60

80

100

Figure: Utility Surface in 3D

Tianyi Wang (Queen’s Univerisity) Lecture 5 Winter 2013 4 / 32

0 20 40 60 80 100 0

50

10010

20

30

40

50

60

70

80

90

Figure: Utility Surface (IC Skeleton)

Tianyi Wang (Queen’s Univerisity) Lecture 5 Winter 2013 5 / 32

0 20 40 60 80 100

0

10

20

30

40

50

60

70

80

90

100

Figure: Indifference Map

Tianyi Wang (Queen’s Univerisity) Lecture 5 Winter 2013 6 / 32

Marginal rate of substitution (MRS)

Defined as the rate at which consumers is willing to substitute onegood for another, while holding utility level constant.

I negative slope of indifference curve, since MRS usually defined as apositive number.MRSx ,y = −∆Y

∆XI Notice ∆U = MUx · ∆X +MUy · ∆YI set ∆U = 0, so that stay on the same IC.I get MUxMUy

= −∆Y∆X = MRSx ,y

Diminishing MRS

I MRS decreases as consumption of x increases.I direct consequence of Diminishing Marginal Utility

Example, see class notes

Tianyi Wang (Queen’s Univerisity) Lecture 5 Winter 2013 7 / 32

Marginal rate of substitution (MRS)

Defined as the rate at which consumers is willing to substitute onegood for another, while holding utility level constant.

I negative slope of indifference curve, since MRS usually defined as apositive number.MRSx ,y = −∆Y

∆X

I Notice ∆U = MUx · ∆X +MUy · ∆YI set ∆U = 0, so that stay on the same IC.I get MUxMUy

= −∆Y∆X = MRSx ,y

Diminishing MRS

I MRS decreases as consumption of x increases.I direct consequence of Diminishing Marginal Utility

Example, see class notes

Tianyi Wang (Queen’s Univerisity) Lecture 5 Winter 2013 7 / 32

Marginal rate of substitution (MRS)

Defined as the rate at which consumers is willing to substitute onegood for another, while holding utility level constant.

I negative slope of indifference curve, since MRS usually defined as apositive number.MRSx ,y = −∆Y

∆XI Notice ∆U = MUx · ∆X +MUy · ∆Y

I set ∆U = 0, so that stay on the same IC.I get MUxMUy

= −∆Y∆X = MRSx ,y

Diminishing MRS

I MRS decreases as consumption of x increases.I direct consequence of Diminishing Marginal Utility

Example, see class notes

Tianyi Wang (Queen’s Univerisity) Lecture 5 Winter 2013 7 / 32

Marginal rate of substitution (MRS)

Defined as the rate at which consumers is willing to substitute onegood for another, while holding utility level constant.

I negative slope of indifference curve, since MRS usually defined as apositive number.MRSx ,y = −∆Y

∆XI Notice ∆U = MUx · ∆X +MUy · ∆YI set ∆U = 0, so that stay on the same IC.

I get MUxMUy= −∆Y

∆X = MRSx ,y

Diminishing MRS

I MRS decreases as consumption of x increases.I direct consequence of Diminishing Marginal Utility

Example, see class notes

Tianyi Wang (Queen’s Univerisity) Lecture 5 Winter 2013 7 / 32

Marginal rate of substitution (MRS)

Defined as the rate at which consumers is willing to substitute onegood for another, while holding utility level constant.

I negative slope of indifference curve, since MRS usually defined as apositive number.MRSx ,y = −∆Y

∆XI Notice ∆U = MUx · ∆X +MUy · ∆YI set ∆U = 0, so that stay on the same IC.I get MUxMUy

= −∆Y∆X = MRSx ,y

Diminishing MRS

I MRS decreases as consumption of x increases.I direct consequence of Diminishing Marginal Utility

Example, see class notes

Tianyi Wang (Queen’s Univerisity) Lecture 5 Winter 2013 7 / 32

Marginal rate of substitution (MRS)

Defined as the rate at which consumers is willing to substitute onegood for another, while holding utility level constant.

I negative slope of indifference curve, since MRS usually defined as apositive number.MRSx ,y = −∆Y

∆XI Notice ∆U = MUx · ∆X +MUy · ∆YI set ∆U = 0, so that stay on the same IC.I get MUxMUy

= −∆Y∆X = MRSx ,y

Diminishing MRS

I MRS decreases as consumption of x increases.I direct consequence of Diminishing Marginal Utility

Example, see class notes

Tianyi Wang (Queen’s Univerisity) Lecture 5 Winter 2013 7 / 32

Marginal rate of substitution (MRS)

Defined as the rate at which consumers is willing to substitute onegood for another, while holding utility level constant.

I negative slope of indifference curve, since MRS usually defined as apositive number.MRSx ,y = −∆Y

∆XI Notice ∆U = MUx · ∆X +MUy · ∆YI set ∆U = 0, so that stay on the same IC.I get MUxMUy

= −∆Y∆X = MRSx ,y

Diminishing MRSI MRS decreases as consumption of x increases.

I direct consequence of Diminishing Marginal Utility

Example, see class notes

Tianyi Wang (Queen’s Univerisity) Lecture 5 Winter 2013 7 / 32

Marginal rate of substitution (MRS)

Defined as the rate at which consumers is willing to substitute onegood for another, while holding utility level constant.

I negative slope of indifference curve, since MRS usually defined as apositive number.MRSx ,y = −∆Y

∆XI Notice ∆U = MUx · ∆X +MUy · ∆YI set ∆U = 0, so that stay on the same IC.I get MUxMUy

= −∆Y∆X = MRSx ,y

Diminishing MRSI MRS decreases as consumption of x increases.I direct consequence of Diminishing Marginal Utility

Example, see class notes

Tianyi Wang (Queen’s Univerisity) Lecture 5 Winter 2013 7 / 32

Marginal rate of substitution (MRS)

Defined as the rate at which consumers is willing to substitute onegood for another, while holding utility level constant.

I negative slope of indifference curve, since MRS usually defined as apositive number.MRSx ,y = −∆Y

∆XI Notice ∆U = MUx · ∆X +MUy · ∆YI set ∆U = 0, so that stay on the same IC.I get MUxMUy

= −∆Y∆X = MRSx ,y

Diminishing MRSI MRS decreases as consumption of x increases.I direct consequence of Diminishing Marginal Utility

Example, see class notes

Tianyi Wang (Queen’s Univerisity) Lecture 5 Winter 2013 7 / 32

Several Utility FunctionsCobb-Douglas utility function

I U(X ,Y ) = AX aY b , where A, a, b are positive constantsI MRSx ,y = aY

bX and ab measures relative importance of X and Y

I (Constant returns to scale when a+ b = 1)

Perfect Substitutes

I U(X ,Y ) = aX + bY , where a, b are positive constantsI MRSx ,y = a

b = CONSTANTI always substitute at the same same rate (perfect subs).

Perfect Complements

I U(X ,Y ) = min{aX , bY }I How to get ICs:

1 equate two arguments to find the cut-off line2 start at a point on the line, then increase X while holding Y constantand/or increase Y while holding X constant.

3 bundles have the same level of utility as the initial bundle

I see class notes for another way.I always consume in fixed ratio (perfect comp.)

Tianyi Wang (Queen’s Univerisity) Lecture 5 Winter 2013 8 / 32

Several Utility FunctionsCobb-Douglas utility function

I U(X ,Y ) = AX aY b , where A, a, b are positive constants

I MRSx ,y = aYbX and a

b measures relative importance of X and YI (Constant returns to scale when a+ b = 1)

Perfect Substitutes

I U(X ,Y ) = aX + bY , where a, b are positive constantsI MRSx ,y = a

b = CONSTANTI always substitute at the same same rate (perfect subs).

Perfect Complements

I U(X ,Y ) = min{aX , bY }I How to get ICs:

1 equate two arguments to find the cut-off line2 start at a point on the line, then increase X while holding Y constantand/or increase Y while holding X constant.

3 bundles have the same level of utility as the initial bundle

I see class notes for another way.I always consume in fixed ratio (perfect comp.)

Tianyi Wang (Queen’s Univerisity) Lecture 5 Winter 2013 8 / 32

Several Utility FunctionsCobb-Douglas utility function

I U(X ,Y ) = AX aY b , where A, a, b are positive constantsI MRSx ,y = aY

bX and ab measures relative importance of X and Y

I (Constant returns to scale when a+ b = 1)

Perfect Substitutes

I U(X ,Y ) = aX + bY , where a, b are positive constantsI MRSx ,y = a

b = CONSTANTI always substitute at the same same rate (perfect subs).

Perfect Complements

I U(X ,Y ) = min{aX , bY }I How to get ICs:

1 equate two arguments to find the cut-off line2 start at a point on the line, then increase X while holding Y constantand/or increase Y while holding X constant.

3 bundles have the same level of utility as the initial bundle

I see class notes for another way.I always consume in fixed ratio (perfect comp.)

Tianyi Wang (Queen’s Univerisity) Lecture 5 Winter 2013 8 / 32

Several Utility FunctionsCobb-Douglas utility function

I U(X ,Y ) = AX aY b , where A, a, b are positive constantsI MRSx ,y = aY

bX and ab measures relative importance of X and Y

I (Constant returns to scale when a+ b = 1)

Perfect Substitutes

I U(X ,Y ) = aX + bY , where a, b are positive constantsI MRSx ,y = a

b = CONSTANTI always substitute at the same same rate (perfect subs).

Perfect Complements

I U(X ,Y ) = min{aX , bY }I How to get ICs:

1 equate two arguments to find the cut-off line2 start at a point on the line, then increase X while holding Y constantand/or increase Y while holding X constant.

3 bundles have the same level of utility as the initial bundle

I see class notes for another way.I always consume in fixed ratio (perfect comp.)

Tianyi Wang (Queen’s Univerisity) Lecture 5 Winter 2013 8 / 32

Several Utility FunctionsCobb-Douglas utility function

I U(X ,Y ) = AX aY b , where A, a, b are positive constantsI MRSx ,y = aY

bX and ab measures relative importance of X and Y

I (Constant returns to scale when a+ b = 1)

Perfect Substitutes

I U(X ,Y ) = aX + bY , where a, b are positive constantsI MRSx ,y = a

b = CONSTANTI always substitute at the same same rate (perfect subs).

Perfect Complements

I U(X ,Y ) = min{aX , bY }I How to get ICs:

1 equate two arguments to find the cut-off line2 start at a point on the line, then increase X while holding Y constantand/or increase Y while holding X constant.

3 bundles have the same level of utility as the initial bundle

I see class notes for another way.I always consume in fixed ratio (perfect comp.)

Tianyi Wang (Queen’s Univerisity) Lecture 5 Winter 2013 8 / 32

Several Utility FunctionsCobb-Douglas utility function

I U(X ,Y ) = AX aY b , where A, a, b are positive constantsI MRSx ,y = aY

bX and ab measures relative importance of X and Y

I (Constant returns to scale when a+ b = 1)

Perfect SubstitutesI U(X ,Y ) = aX + bY , where a, b are positive constants

I MRSx ,y = ab = CONSTANT

I always substitute at the same same rate (perfect subs).

Perfect Complements

I U(X ,Y ) = min{aX , bY }I How to get ICs:

1 equate two arguments to find the cut-off line2 start at a point on the line, then increase X while holding Y constantand/or increase Y while holding X constant.

3 bundles have the same level of utility as the initial bundle

I see class notes for another way.I always consume in fixed ratio (perfect comp.)

Tianyi Wang (Queen’s Univerisity) Lecture 5 Winter 2013 8 / 32

Several Utility FunctionsCobb-Douglas utility function

I U(X ,Y ) = AX aY b , where A, a, b are positive constantsI MRSx ,y = aY

bX and ab measures relative importance of X and Y

I (Constant returns to scale when a+ b = 1)

Perfect SubstitutesI U(X ,Y ) = aX + bY , where a, b are positive constantsI MRSx ,y = a

b = CONSTANT

I always substitute at the same same rate (perfect subs).

Perfect Complements

I U(X ,Y ) = min{aX , bY }I How to get ICs:

1 equate two arguments to find the cut-off line2 start at a point on the line, then increase X while holding Y constantand/or increase Y while holding X constant.

3 bundles have the same level of utility as the initial bundle

I see class notes for another way.I always consume in fixed ratio (perfect comp.)

Tianyi Wang (Queen’s Univerisity) Lecture 5 Winter 2013 8 / 32

Several Utility FunctionsCobb-Douglas utility function

I U(X ,Y ) = AX aY b , where A, a, b are positive constantsI MRSx ,y = aY

bX and ab measures relative importance of X and Y

I (Constant returns to scale when a+ b = 1)

Perfect SubstitutesI U(X ,Y ) = aX + bY , where a, b are positive constantsI MRSx ,y = a

b = CONSTANTI always substitute at the same same rate (perfect subs).

Perfect Complements

I U(X ,Y ) = min{aX , bY }I How to get ICs:

1 equate two arguments to find the cut-off line2 start at a point on the line, then increase X while holding Y constantand/or increase Y while holding X constant.

3 bundles have the same level of utility as the initial bundle

I see class notes for another way.I always consume in fixed ratio (perfect comp.)

Tianyi Wang (Queen’s Univerisity) Lecture 5 Winter 2013 8 / 32

Several Utility FunctionsCobb-Douglas utility function

I U(X ,Y ) = AX aY b , where A, a, b are positive constantsI MRSx ,y = aY

bX and ab measures relative importance of X and Y

I (Constant returns to scale when a+ b = 1)

Perfect SubstitutesI U(X ,Y ) = aX + bY , where a, b are positive constantsI MRSx ,y = a

b = CONSTANTI always substitute at the same same rate (perfect subs).

Perfect Complements

I U(X ,Y ) = min{aX , bY }I How to get ICs:

1 equate two arguments to find the cut-off line2 start at a point on the line, then increase X while holding Y constantand/or increase Y while holding X constant.

3 bundles have the same level of utility as the initial bundle

I see class notes for another way.I always consume in fixed ratio (perfect comp.)

Tianyi Wang (Queen’s Univerisity) Lecture 5 Winter 2013 8 / 32

Several Utility FunctionsCobb-Douglas utility function

I U(X ,Y ) = AX aY b , where A, a, b are positive constantsI MRSx ,y = aY

bX and ab measures relative importance of X and Y

I (Constant returns to scale when a+ b = 1)

Perfect SubstitutesI U(X ,Y ) = aX + bY , where a, b are positive constantsI MRSx ,y = a

b = CONSTANTI always substitute at the same same rate (perfect subs).

Perfect ComplementsI U(X ,Y ) = min{aX , bY }

I How to get ICs:

1 equate two arguments to find the cut-off line2 start at a point on the line, then increase X while holding Y constantand/or increase Y while holding X constant.

3 bundles have the same level of utility as the initial bundle

I see class notes for another way.I always consume in fixed ratio (perfect comp.)

Tianyi Wang (Queen’s Univerisity) Lecture 5 Winter 2013 8 / 32

Several Utility FunctionsCobb-Douglas utility function

I U(X ,Y ) = AX aY b , where A, a, b are positive constantsI MRSx ,y = aY

bX and ab measures relative importance of X and Y

I (Constant returns to scale when a+ b = 1)

Perfect SubstitutesI U(X ,Y ) = aX + bY , where a, b are positive constantsI MRSx ,y = a

b = CONSTANTI always substitute at the same same rate (perfect subs).

Perfect ComplementsI U(X ,Y ) = min{aX , bY }I How to get ICs:

1 equate two arguments to find the cut-off line2 start at a point on the line, then increase X while holding Y constantand/or increase Y while holding X constant.

3 bundles have the same level of utility as the initial bundle

I see class notes for another way.I always consume in fixed ratio (perfect comp.)

Tianyi Wang (Queen’s Univerisity) Lecture 5 Winter 2013 8 / 32

Several Utility FunctionsCobb-Douglas utility function

I U(X ,Y ) = AX aY b , where A, a, b are positive constantsI MRSx ,y = aY

bX and ab measures relative importance of X and Y

I (Constant returns to scale when a+ b = 1)

Perfect SubstitutesI U(X ,Y ) = aX + bY , where a, b are positive constantsI MRSx ,y = a

b = CONSTANTI always substitute at the same same rate (perfect subs).

Perfect ComplementsI U(X ,Y ) = min{aX , bY }I How to get ICs:

1 equate two arguments to find the cut-off line

2 start at a point on the line, then increase X while holding Y constantand/or increase Y while holding X constant.

3 bundles have the same level of utility as the initial bundle

I see class notes for another way.I always consume in fixed ratio (perfect comp.)

Tianyi Wang (Queen’s Univerisity) Lecture 5 Winter 2013 8 / 32

Several Utility FunctionsCobb-Douglas utility function

I U(X ,Y ) = AX aY b , where A, a, b are positive constantsI MRSx ,y = aY

bX and ab measures relative importance of X and Y

I (Constant returns to scale when a+ b = 1)

Perfect SubstitutesI U(X ,Y ) = aX + bY , where a, b are positive constantsI MRSx ,y = a

b = CONSTANTI always substitute at the same same rate (perfect subs).

Perfect ComplementsI U(X ,Y ) = min{aX , bY }I How to get ICs:

1 equate two arguments to find the cut-off line2 start at a point on the line, then increase X while holding Y constantand/or increase Y while holding X constant.

3 bundles have the same level of utility as the initial bundle

I see class notes for another way.I always consume in fixed ratio (perfect comp.)

Tianyi Wang (Queen’s Univerisity) Lecture 5 Winter 2013 8 / 32

Several Utility FunctionsCobb-Douglas utility function

I U(X ,Y ) = AX aY b , where A, a, b are positive constantsI MRSx ,y = aY

bX and ab measures relative importance of X and Y

I (Constant returns to scale when a+ b = 1)

Perfect SubstitutesI U(X ,Y ) = aX + bY , where a, b are positive constantsI MRSx ,y = a

b = CONSTANTI always substitute at the same same rate (perfect subs).

Perfect ComplementsI U(X ,Y ) = min{aX , bY }I How to get ICs:

1 equate two arguments to find the cut-off line2 start at a point on the line, then increase X while holding Y constantand/or increase Y while holding X constant.

3 bundles have the same level of utility as the initial bundle

I see class notes for another way.I always consume in fixed ratio (perfect comp.)

Tianyi Wang (Queen’s Univerisity) Lecture 5 Winter 2013 8 / 32

Several Utility FunctionsCobb-Douglas utility function

I U(X ,Y ) = AX aY b , where A, a, b are positive constantsI MRSx ,y = aY

bX and ab measures relative importance of X and Y

I (Constant returns to scale when a+ b = 1)

Perfect SubstitutesI U(X ,Y ) = aX + bY , where a, b are positive constantsI MRSx ,y = a

b = CONSTANTI always substitute at the same same rate (perfect subs).

Perfect ComplementsI U(X ,Y ) = min{aX , bY }I How to get ICs:

1 equate two arguments to find the cut-off line2 start at a point on the line, then increase X while holding Y constantand/or increase Y while holding X constant.

3 bundles have the same level of utility as the initial bundle

I see class notes for another way.

I always consume in fixed ratio (perfect comp.)

Tianyi Wang (Queen’s Univerisity) Lecture 5 Winter 2013 8 / 32

Several Utility FunctionsCobb-Douglas utility function

I U(X ,Y ) = AX aY b , where A, a, b are positive constantsI MRSx ,y = aY

bX and ab measures relative importance of X and Y

I (Constant returns to scale when a+ b = 1)

Perfect SubstitutesI U(X ,Y ) = aX + bY , where a, b are positive constantsI MRSx ,y = a

b = CONSTANTI always substitute at the same same rate (perfect subs).

Perfect ComplementsI U(X ,Y ) = min{aX , bY }I How to get ICs:

1 equate two arguments to find the cut-off line2 start at a point on the line, then increase X while holding Y constantand/or increase Y while holding X constant.

3 bundles have the same level of utility as the initial bundle

I see class notes for another way.I always consume in fixed ratio (perfect comp.)

Tianyi Wang (Queen’s Univerisity) Lecture 5 Winter 2013 8 / 32

Several Utility Functions (Cont’d)

Quasi-Linear

I U(X ,Y ) = v(X ) + bY , where b constant, v(.) any increasing functionI MRSx ,y =

v ′(x )b , independent of Y

I have just enough curvature to get interior solution (more later)I (no income effect)

One Good, One Bad

I U(X ,Y ) = aX − bY , where a, b are positive constantsI MRSx ,y = − ab , ICs slope upward!I e.g. return and risk; leisure and labor.

Exercise: Draw IC for the following utility function

I U(X ,Y ) = X 1/2Y 1/2

I How to get ICs:

1 fix level of utility, say U = 92 find 3 pairs of (X ,Y ) on this IC.3 connect

Tianyi Wang (Queen’s Univerisity) Lecture 5 Winter 2013 9 / 32

Several Utility Functions (Cont’d)

Quasi-LinearI U(X ,Y ) = v(X ) + bY , where b constant, v(.) any increasing function

I MRSx ,y =v ′(x )b , independent of Y

I have just enough curvature to get interior solution (more later)I (no income effect)

One Good, One Bad

I U(X ,Y ) = aX − bY , where a, b are positive constantsI MRSx ,y = − ab , ICs slope upward!I e.g. return and risk; leisure and labor.

Exercise: Draw IC for the following utility function

I U(X ,Y ) = X 1/2Y 1/2

I How to get ICs:

1 fix level of utility, say U = 92 find 3 pairs of (X ,Y ) on this IC.3 connect

Tianyi Wang (Queen’s Univerisity) Lecture 5 Winter 2013 9 / 32

Several Utility Functions (Cont’d)

Quasi-LinearI U(X ,Y ) = v(X ) + bY , where b constant, v(.) any increasing functionI MRSx ,y =

v ′(x )b , independent of Y

I have just enough curvature to get interior solution (more later)I (no income effect)

One Good, One Bad

I U(X ,Y ) = aX − bY , where a, b are positive constantsI MRSx ,y = − ab , ICs slope upward!I e.g. return and risk; leisure and labor.

Exercise: Draw IC for the following utility function

I U(X ,Y ) = X 1/2Y 1/2

I How to get ICs:

1 fix level of utility, say U = 92 find 3 pairs of (X ,Y ) on this IC.3 connect

Tianyi Wang (Queen’s Univerisity) Lecture 5 Winter 2013 9 / 32

Several Utility Functions (Cont’d)

Quasi-LinearI U(X ,Y ) = v(X ) + bY , where b constant, v(.) any increasing functionI MRSx ,y =

v ′(x )b , independent of Y

I have just enough curvature to get interior solution (more later)

I (no income effect)

One Good, One Bad

I U(X ,Y ) = aX − bY , where a, b are positive constantsI MRSx ,y = − ab , ICs slope upward!I e.g. return and risk; leisure and labor.

Exercise: Draw IC for the following utility function

I U(X ,Y ) = X 1/2Y 1/2

I How to get ICs:

1 fix level of utility, say U = 92 find 3 pairs of (X ,Y ) on this IC.3 connect

Tianyi Wang (Queen’s Univerisity) Lecture 5 Winter 2013 9 / 32

Several Utility Functions (Cont’d)

Quasi-LinearI U(X ,Y ) = v(X ) + bY , where b constant, v(.) any increasing functionI MRSx ,y =

v ′(x )b , independent of Y

I have just enough curvature to get interior solution (more later)I (no income effect)

One Good, One Bad

I U(X ,Y ) = aX − bY , where a, b are positive constantsI MRSx ,y = − ab , ICs slope upward!I e.g. return and risk; leisure and labor.

Exercise: Draw IC for the following utility function

I U(X ,Y ) = X 1/2Y 1/2

I How to get ICs:

1 fix level of utility, say U = 92 find 3 pairs of (X ,Y ) on this IC.3 connect

Tianyi Wang (Queen’s Univerisity) Lecture 5 Winter 2013 9 / 32

Several Utility Functions (Cont’d)

Quasi-LinearI U(X ,Y ) = v(X ) + bY , where b constant, v(.) any increasing functionI MRSx ,y =

v ′(x )b , independent of Y

I have just enough curvature to get interior solution (more later)I (no income effect)

One Good, One Bad

I U(X ,Y ) = aX − bY , where a, b are positive constantsI MRSx ,y = − ab , ICs slope upward!I e.g. return and risk; leisure and labor.

Exercise: Draw IC for the following utility function

I U(X ,Y ) = X 1/2Y 1/2

I How to get ICs:

1 fix level of utility, say U = 92 find 3 pairs of (X ,Y ) on this IC.3 connect

Tianyi Wang (Queen’s Univerisity) Lecture 5 Winter 2013 9 / 32

Several Utility Functions (Cont’d)

Quasi-LinearI U(X ,Y ) = v(X ) + bY , where b constant, v(.) any increasing functionI MRSx ,y =

v ′(x )b , independent of Y

I have just enough curvature to get interior solution (more later)I (no income effect)

One Good, One BadI U(X ,Y ) = aX − bY , where a, b are positive constants

I MRSx ,y = − ab , ICs slope upward!I e.g. return and risk; leisure and labor.

Exercise: Draw IC for the following utility function

I U(X ,Y ) = X 1/2Y 1/2

I How to get ICs:

1 fix level of utility, say U = 92 find 3 pairs of (X ,Y ) on this IC.3 connect

Tianyi Wang (Queen’s Univerisity) Lecture 5 Winter 2013 9 / 32

Several Utility Functions (Cont’d)

Quasi-LinearI U(X ,Y ) = v(X ) + bY , where b constant, v(.) any increasing functionI MRSx ,y =

v ′(x )b , independent of Y

I have just enough curvature to get interior solution (more later)I (no income effect)

One Good, One BadI U(X ,Y ) = aX − bY , where a, b are positive constantsI MRSx ,y = − ab , ICs slope upward!

I e.g. return and risk; leisure and labor.

Exercise: Draw IC for the following utility function

I U(X ,Y ) = X 1/2Y 1/2

I How to get ICs:

1 fix level of utility, say U = 92 find 3 pairs of (X ,Y ) on this IC.3 connect

Tianyi Wang (Queen’s Univerisity) Lecture 5 Winter 2013 9 / 32

Several Utility Functions (Cont’d)

Quasi-LinearI U(X ,Y ) = v(X ) + bY , where b constant, v(.) any increasing functionI MRSx ,y =

v ′(x )b , independent of Y

I have just enough curvature to get interior solution (more later)I (no income effect)

One Good, One BadI U(X ,Y ) = aX − bY , where a, b are positive constantsI MRSx ,y = − ab , ICs slope upward!I e.g. return and risk; leisure and labor.

Exercise: Draw IC for the following utility function

I U(X ,Y ) = X 1/2Y 1/2

I How to get ICs:

1 fix level of utility, say U = 92 find 3 pairs of (X ,Y ) on this IC.3 connect

Tianyi Wang (Queen’s Univerisity) Lecture 5 Winter 2013 9 / 32

Several Utility Functions (Cont’d)

Quasi-LinearI U(X ,Y ) = v(X ) + bY , where b constant, v(.) any increasing functionI MRSx ,y =

v ′(x )b , independent of Y

I have just enough curvature to get interior solution (more later)I (no income effect)

One Good, One BadI U(X ,Y ) = aX − bY , where a, b are positive constantsI MRSx ,y = − ab , ICs slope upward!I e.g. return and risk; leisure and labor.

Exercise: Draw IC for the following utility function

I U(X ,Y ) = X 1/2Y 1/2

I How to get ICs:

1 fix level of utility, say U = 92 find 3 pairs of (X ,Y ) on this IC.3 connect

Tianyi Wang (Queen’s Univerisity) Lecture 5 Winter 2013 9 / 32

Several Utility Functions (Cont’d)

Quasi-LinearI U(X ,Y ) = v(X ) + bY , where b constant, v(.) any increasing functionI MRSx ,y =

v ′(x )b , independent of Y

I have just enough curvature to get interior solution (more later)I (no income effect)

One Good, One BadI U(X ,Y ) = aX − bY , where a, b are positive constantsI MRSx ,y = − ab , ICs slope upward!I e.g. return and risk; leisure and labor.

Exercise: Draw IC for the following utility functionI U(X ,Y ) = X 1/2Y 1/2

I How to get ICs:

1 fix level of utility, say U = 92 find 3 pairs of (X ,Y ) on this IC.3 connect

Tianyi Wang (Queen’s Univerisity) Lecture 5 Winter 2013 9 / 32

Several Utility Functions (Cont’d)

Quasi-LinearI U(X ,Y ) = v(X ) + bY , where b constant, v(.) any increasing functionI MRSx ,y =

v ′(x )b , independent of Y

I have just enough curvature to get interior solution (more later)I (no income effect)

One Good, One BadI U(X ,Y ) = aX − bY , where a, b are positive constantsI MRSx ,y = − ab , ICs slope upward!I e.g. return and risk; leisure and labor.

Exercise: Draw IC for the following utility functionI U(X ,Y ) = X 1/2Y 1/2

I How to get ICs:

1 fix level of utility, say U = 92 find 3 pairs of (X ,Y ) on this IC.3 connect

Tianyi Wang (Queen’s Univerisity) Lecture 5 Winter 2013 9 / 32

Several Utility Functions (Cont’d)

Quasi-LinearI U(X ,Y ) = v(X ) + bY , where b constant, v(.) any increasing functionI MRSx ,y =

v ′(x )b , independent of Y

I have just enough curvature to get interior solution (more later)I (no income effect)

One Good, One BadI U(X ,Y ) = aX − bY , where a, b are positive constantsI MRSx ,y = − ab , ICs slope upward!I e.g. return and risk; leisure and labor.

Exercise: Draw IC for the following utility functionI U(X ,Y ) = X 1/2Y 1/2

I How to get ICs:

1 fix level of utility, say U = 9

2 find 3 pairs of (X ,Y ) on this IC.3 connect

Tianyi Wang (Queen’s Univerisity) Lecture 5 Winter 2013 9 / 32

Several Utility Functions (Cont’d)

Quasi-LinearI U(X ,Y ) = v(X ) + bY , where b constant, v(.) any increasing functionI MRSx ,y =

v ′(x )b , independent of Y

I have just enough curvature to get interior solution (more later)I (no income effect)

One Good, One BadI U(X ,Y ) = aX − bY , where a, b are positive constantsI MRSx ,y = − ab , ICs slope upward!I e.g. return and risk; leisure and labor.

Exercise: Draw IC for the following utility functionI U(X ,Y ) = X 1/2Y 1/2

I How to get ICs:

1 fix level of utility, say U = 92 find 3 pairs of (X ,Y ) on this IC.

3 connect

Tianyi Wang (Queen’s Univerisity) Lecture 5 Winter 2013 9 / 32

Several Utility Functions (Cont’d)

Quasi-LinearI U(X ,Y ) = v(X ) + bY , where b constant, v(.) any increasing functionI MRSx ,y =

v ′(x )b , independent of Y

I have just enough curvature to get interior solution (more later)I (no income effect)

One Good, One BadI U(X ,Y ) = aX − bY , where a, b are positive constantsI MRSx ,y = − ab , ICs slope upward!I e.g. return and risk; leisure and labor.

Exercise: Draw IC for the following utility functionI U(X ,Y ) = X 1/2Y 1/2

I How to get ICs:

1 fix level of utility, say U = 92 find 3 pairs of (X ,Y ) on this IC.3 connect

Tianyi Wang (Queen’s Univerisity) Lecture 5 Winter 2013 9 / 32

Budget Constraint

Cannot purchase infinite goods due to budget constraint.

Assumptions:

I A1: Two goods: (X1 and X2), example: bananas and applesI A2: Your income: mI A3: P1 the price for good X1 and P2 is the price for good X2

F take as give for now, can be determined in equilibirum (Chapter2).

I A4: spend all your income on the two goods.

BC expresses the combination of X1 and X2 the consumer can buygiven her/his income

written as P1X1 + P2X2 = m

I What are the values of the interceptsI What is their interpretation?I What does the shaded area represent?I What is the slope of the line?

Tianyi Wang (Queen’s Univerisity) Lecture 5 Winter 2013 10 / 32

Budget Constraint

Cannot purchase infinite goods due to budget constraint.

Assumptions:

I A1: Two goods: (X1 and X2), example: bananas and applesI A2: Your income: mI A3: P1 the price for good X1 and P2 is the price for good X2

F take as give for now, can be determined in equilibirum (Chapter2).

I A4: spend all your income on the two goods.

BC expresses the combination of X1 and X2 the consumer can buygiven her/his income

written as P1X1 + P2X2 = m

I What are the values of the interceptsI What is their interpretation?I What does the shaded area represent?I What is the slope of the line?

Tianyi Wang (Queen’s Univerisity) Lecture 5 Winter 2013 10 / 32

Budget Constraint

Cannot purchase infinite goods due to budget constraint.

Assumptions:I A1: Two goods: (X1 and X2), example: bananas and apples

I A2: Your income: mI A3: P1 the price for good X1 and P2 is the price for good X2

F take as give for now, can be determined in equilibirum (Chapter2).

I A4: spend all your income on the two goods.

BC expresses the combination of X1 and X2 the consumer can buygiven her/his income

written as P1X1 + P2X2 = m

I What are the values of the interceptsI What is their interpretation?I What does the shaded area represent?I What is the slope of the line?

Tianyi Wang (Queen’s Univerisity) Lecture 5 Winter 2013 10 / 32

Budget Constraint

Cannot purchase infinite goods due to budget constraint.

Assumptions:I A1: Two goods: (X1 and X2), example: bananas and applesI A2: Your income: m

I A3: P1 the price for good X1 and P2 is the price for good X2

F take as give for now, can be determined in equilibirum (Chapter2).

I A4: spend all your income on the two goods.

BC expresses the combination of X1 and X2 the consumer can buygiven her/his income

written as P1X1 + P2X2 = m

I What are the values of the interceptsI What is their interpretation?I What does the shaded area represent?I What is the slope of the line?

Tianyi Wang (Queen’s Univerisity) Lecture 5 Winter 2013 10 / 32

Budget Constraint

Cannot purchase infinite goods due to budget constraint.

Assumptions:I A1: Two goods: (X1 and X2), example: bananas and applesI A2: Your income: mI A3: P1 the price for good X1 and P2 is the price for good X2

F take as give for now, can be determined in equilibirum (Chapter2).

I A4: spend all your income on the two goods.

BC expresses the combination of X1 and X2 the consumer can buygiven her/his income

written as P1X1 + P2X2 = m

I What are the values of the interceptsI What is their interpretation?I What does the shaded area represent?I What is the slope of the line?

Tianyi Wang (Queen’s Univerisity) Lecture 5 Winter 2013 10 / 32

Budget Constraint

Cannot purchase infinite goods due to budget constraint.

Assumptions:I A1: Two goods: (X1 and X2), example: bananas and applesI A2: Your income: mI A3: P1 the price for good X1 and P2 is the price for good X2

F take as give for now, can be determined in equilibirum (Chapter2).

I A4: spend all your income on the two goods.

BC expresses the combination of X1 and X2 the consumer can buygiven her/his income

written as P1X1 + P2X2 = m

I What are the values of the interceptsI What is their interpretation?I What does the shaded area represent?I What is the slope of the line?

Tianyi Wang (Queen’s Univerisity) Lecture 5 Winter 2013 10 / 32

Budget Constraint

Cannot purchase infinite goods due to budget constraint.

Assumptions:I A1: Two goods: (X1 and X2), example: bananas and applesI A2: Your income: mI A3: P1 the price for good X1 and P2 is the price for good X2

F take as give for now, can be determined in equilibirum (Chapter2).

I A4: spend all your income on the two goods.

BC expresses the combination of X1 and X2 the consumer can buygiven her/his income

written as P1X1 + P2X2 = m

I What are the values of the interceptsI What is their interpretation?I What does the shaded area represent?I What is the slope of the line?

Tianyi Wang (Queen’s Univerisity) Lecture 5 Winter 2013 10 / 32

Budget Constraint

Cannot purchase infinite goods due to budget constraint.

Assumptions:I A1: Two goods: (X1 and X2), example: bananas and applesI A2: Your income: mI A3: P1 the price for good X1 and P2 is the price for good X2

F take as give for now, can be determined in equilibirum (Chapter2).

I A4: spend all your income on the two goods.

BC expresses the combination of X1 and X2 the consumer can buygiven her/his income

written as P1X1 + P2X2 = m

I What are the values of the interceptsI What is their interpretation?I What does the shaded area represent?I What is the slope of the line?

Tianyi Wang (Queen’s Univerisity) Lecture 5 Winter 2013 10 / 32

Budget Constraint

Cannot purchase infinite goods due to budget constraint.

Assumptions:I A1: Two goods: (X1 and X2), example: bananas and applesI A2: Your income: mI A3: P1 the price for good X1 and P2 is the price for good X2

F take as give for now, can be determined in equilibirum (Chapter2).

I A4: spend all your income on the two goods.

BC expresses the combination of X1 and X2 the consumer can buygiven her/his income

written as P1X1 + P2X2 = m

I What are the values of the interceptsI What is their interpretation?I What does the shaded area represent?I What is the slope of the line?

Tianyi Wang (Queen’s Univerisity) Lecture 5 Winter 2013 10 / 32

Budget Constraint

Cannot purchase infinite goods due to budget constraint.

Assumptions:I A1: Two goods: (X1 and X2), example: bananas and applesI A2: Your income: mI A3: P1 the price for good X1 and P2 is the price for good X2

F take as give for now, can be determined in equilibirum (Chapter2).

I A4: spend all your income on the two goods.

BC expresses the combination of X1 and X2 the consumer can buygiven her/his income

written as P1X1 + P2X2 = mI What are the values of the intercepts

I What is their interpretation?I What does the shaded area represent?I What is the slope of the line?

Tianyi Wang (Queen’s Univerisity) Lecture 5 Winter 2013 10 / 32

Budget Constraint

Cannot purchase infinite goods due to budget constraint.

Assumptions:I A1: Two goods: (X1 and X2), example: bananas and applesI A2: Your income: mI A3: P1 the price for good X1 and P2 is the price for good X2

F take as give for now, can be determined in equilibirum (Chapter2).

I A4: spend all your income on the two goods.

BC expresses the combination of X1 and X2 the consumer can buygiven her/his income

written as P1X1 + P2X2 = mI What are the values of the interceptsI What is their interpretation?

I What does the shaded area represent?I What is the slope of the line?

Tianyi Wang (Queen’s Univerisity) Lecture 5 Winter 2013 10 / 32

Budget Constraint

Cannot purchase infinite goods due to budget constraint.

Assumptions:I A1: Two goods: (X1 and X2), example: bananas and applesI A2: Your income: mI A3: P1 the price for good X1 and P2 is the price for good X2

F take as give for now, can be determined in equilibirum (Chapter2).

I A4: spend all your income on the two goods.

BC expresses the combination of X1 and X2 the consumer can buygiven her/his income

written as P1X1 + P2X2 = mI What are the values of the interceptsI What is their interpretation?I What does the shaded area represent?

I What is the slope of the line?

Tianyi Wang (Queen’s Univerisity) Lecture 5 Winter 2013 10 / 32

Budget Constraint

Cannot purchase infinite goods due to budget constraint.

Assumptions:I A1: Two goods: (X1 and X2), example: bananas and applesI A2: Your income: mI A3: P1 the price for good X1 and P2 is the price for good X2

F take as give for now, can be determined in equilibirum (Chapter2).

I A4: spend all your income on the two goods.

BC expresses the combination of X1 and X2 the consumer can buygiven her/his income

written as P1X1 + P2X2 = mI What are the values of the interceptsI What is their interpretation?I What does the shaded area represent?I What is the slope of the line?

Tianyi Wang (Queen’s Univerisity) Lecture 5 Winter 2013 10 / 32

Budget Constraint (Cont’d)

Tianyi Wang (Queen’s Univerisity) Lecture 5 Winter 2013 11 / 32

Budget Constraint (Income Increase)

1

Tianyi Wang (Queen’s Univerisity) Lecture 5 Winter 2013 12 / 32

Budget Constraint (Price Change)

1

Tianyi Wang (Queen’s Univerisity) Lecture 5 Winter 2013 13 / 32

Budget Constraint (summary)

Changes in income cause BC shift.

Changes in price cause BC rotate about intercepts.

Application 4.4I Suppose consumer chooses between two phone plans.I Plan 1: $40 per month for call up to 450min, additional minute costs$0.40

I Plan 2: $60 per month for call up to 900min, additional minute costs$0.40

I Income $500, price of other goods $1.I draw BC.

Tianyi Wang (Queen’s Univerisity) Lecture 5 Winter 2013 14 / 32

Optimal Choices: Interior Solution

Consumer maximizes utility while facing his/her budget constraint.

Let consumer choices over x and y .

Let U(x , y) denotes her utility function and I denotes her income.

Consumer’s problem can be formally expressed as:I max(x ,y )

U(x , y)

subject to : Px x + Py y ≤ I

Note in our case budget constraint holds at equality, since consumerdoes not derive utility from holding income.

Interior: At optimum, consume both x and y .

How to choose?

Tianyi Wang (Queen’s Univerisity) Lecture 5 Winter 2013 15 / 32

Tianyi Wang (Queen’s Univerisity) Lecture 5 Winter 2013 16 / 32

Tianyi Wang (Queen’s Univerisity) Lecture 5 Winter 2013 17 / 32

Tianyi Wang (Queen’s Univerisity) Lecture 5 Winter 2013 18 / 32

Tianyi Wang (Queen’s Univerisity) Lecture 5 Winter 2013 19 / 32

Tianyi Wang (Queen’s Univerisity) Lecture 5 Winter 2013 20 / 32

Tianyi Wang (Queen’s Univerisity) Lecture 5 Winter 2013 21 / 32

Graph Summary

1 Start at arbitrary bundle A, know there is an IC goes through A.2 Ask if can increase utility by shifting IC to the right.3 Stop if IC detaches from BC (non-affordable).4 Utility maximized when IC "just touches" BC.

Tianyi Wang (Queen’s Univerisity) Lecture 5 Winter 2013 22 / 32

Optimality Condition

Notice at optimum slope of BC equals slope of IC (tangency).

Slope of IC = ∆Y∆X and MRSx ,y = −

∆Y∆X =

MUxMUy

Therefore, Slope of IC = −MUxMUy

Slope of BC = −PxPyThen we have the following Optimality Condition:

I MUxMUy

= PxPy

To understand, rewrite is as:

I MUxPx

=MUyPy

Marginal Utility derived from last dollar equals.

"bang for the buck"

Tianyi Wang (Queen’s Univerisity) Lecture 5 Winter 2013 23 / 32

Optimality Condition (Con’t)Why bundles like A and B are not optimal?For instance, at A slope of IC is steeper than slope of BC:

−MUxMUy

≤ −PxPy, or

MUxPx

≥ MUyPy

Last dollar on X gives more utility than on Y .How to solve Consumer’s Problem? In 3 steps:

1 Calculate MUx and MUy .2 Use Optimality Condition to express X in terms of Y .3 Sub into BC to solve for Y . Then get X from step 2.

See class notes for example.See class notes for opportunity cost argument.

Tianyi Wang (Queen’s Univerisity) Lecture 5 Winter 2013 24 / 32

Optimal Choices: Corner Solution

At optimum, some goods are not consumed (when chooses amongmultiple goods).

In our case, only one good is consumed.

Graphically, for any interior points on BC, slope of IC issteeper/flatter than slope of BC.

See class notes for example (short sales).

Tianyi Wang (Queen’s Univerisity) Lecture 5 Winter 2013 25 / 32

Example: Savings Decision

A simple two-period model: present (1) and future (2).

Consumer cosumes in both period

I U(C1,C2) = U(C1) +U (C2)1+ρ

ρ rate of time preference, usually a small positive number (0.05).

Income endowment in each period I1 and I2.

Can borrow or save at given interest rate r .

Write down BC, draw Budget Line.

Present consumer’s problem and solve for optimum.

Tianyi Wang (Queen’s Univerisity) Lecture 5 Winter 2013 26 / 32

Consumer’s problem:

I max(C1,C2)

U(C1,C2) = U(C1) +U (C2)1+ρ

subject to : C1 +C21+r ≤ I1 +

I21+r

MRSC1,C2 =MUC1MUC2

= (1+ ρ)U′(C1)

U ′(C2)

Slope of BC = −(1+ r)Then at optimum (1+ ρ)U

′(C1)U ′(C2)

= 1+ r

When will she save/borrow?

I (1+ ρ)U′(I1)

U ′(I2)Q 1+ r

See class notes for example.

Tianyi Wang (Queen’s Univerisity) Lecture 5 Winter 2013 27 / 32

Changing Interest Rate

Tianyi Wang (Queen’s Univerisity) Lecture 5 Winter 2013 28 / 32

Changing Interest Rate

Tianyi Wang (Queen’s Univerisity) Lecture 5 Winter 2013 29 / 32

Changing Interest Rate

Tianyi Wang (Queen’s Univerisity) Lecture 5 Winter 2013 30 / 32

Changing Interest Rate

Tianyi Wang (Queen’s Univerisity) Lecture 5 Winter 2013 31 / 32

Different Interest Rate for Borrowing and Saving

Tianyi Wang (Queen’s Univerisity) Lecture 5 Winter 2013 32 / 32