ORS Root TLD Evaluation ※ ORS : OID Resolution System ※ TLD : Top Level Domain

1 CJK10, Beijing, China

ORS Root TLD Evaluation※ ORS : OID Resolution System

※ TLD : Top Level Domain

Document number

Beijing, China

22nd -24th July 2009

Seung-Jai Yi(sjlee@nida.or.kr)

2

ddddddd

ddddddd

1. History

2. New gLTD

3. oid.arpa

4. Etc.

5. Plan

3 CJK10, Beijing, China

1. History (1/2)

2008 : ISO/IEC SC6 WG9 & ITU-T SG17 - Raising an issue about Root OID TLD

2009 : ISO/IEC SC6 WG9 & ITU-T SG17 - new TLD(.oid) VS existing TLD(.arpa, .int, .com, etc.)

2008 : ISO/IEC SC6 WG9 & ITU-T SG17 - Raising an issue about Root OID TLD

2009 : ISO/IEC SC6 WG9 & ITU-T SG17 - new TLD(.oid) VS existing TLD(.arpa, .int, .com, etc.)

Root

{0}

{1} {n}

{1}

{1} {n}

{2}

{1} {n}

<OID Tree>

… … …

4 CJK10, Beijing, China

1. History (2/2)

2009, June : ISO/IEC SC6 WG9 & ITU-T SG17 - Result of the meeting

2009, June : ISO/IEC SC6 WG9 & ITU-T SG17 - Result of the meeting

The joint meeting now believes that there are sufficient costs and problems with obtaining a gTLD that this approach should be abandoned.

Homework was given to NIDA and CNNIC to jointly obtain a list of gTLDs (and whether oid or ors or oid-res or some other look-alike is taken) and the cost and conditions for getting a name below them. If it is possible full details of how to reply and who to would be helpful.

(Example)Parent Name Cost Difficulty of getting itOID Very Large Large/ImpossibleARPA None Heavy perhapsCOM $7/Annual EasyINT Small May not be allowed?ITU.INT Zero EasyORG $7/Aunnual Easy

The joint meeting now believes that there are sufficient costs and problems with obtaining a gTLD that this approach should be abandoned.

Homework was given to NIDA and CNNIC to jointly obtain a list of gTLDs (and whether oid or ors or oid-res or some other look-alike is taken) and the cost and conditions for getting a name below them. If it is possible full details of how to reply and who to would be helpful.

(Example)Parent Name Cost Difficulty of getting itOID Very Large Large/ImpossibleARPA None Heavy perhapsCOM $7/Annual EasyINT Small May not be allowed?ITU.INT Zero EasyORG $7/Aunnual Easy

5 CJK10, Beijing, China

2. New gTLD

Process

Cost - About US$ 50,000 / Annual

e.g : .pro, .mobi, .travel, .jobs, .cat, .tel, .asia

Process

Cost - About US$ 50,000 / Annual

e.g : .pro, .mobi, .travel, .jobs, .cat, .tel, .asia

ApplicationSubmission

Peroid

AdministrativeCompleteness

Check

ObjectionFiling

InitialEvaluation

Transition toDelegation

ExtendedEvaluation

DisputeResolution

StringContention

※ New gTLD program : 24 Oct 2008

ICANN Draft Applicant Guidebook

2003 2005~72 ~ 4 years

6 CJK10, Beijing, China

3. oid.arpa

History - 2002 : Raising an issue about ENUM TLD at ITU-T SG

- 2003 : Creation of ITU-T ENUM TLD evaluation group - 2003~2005 : Making Evaluation report between e164.arpa and .e164

History - 2002 : Raising an issue about ENUM TLD at ITU-T SG

- 2003 : Creation of ITU-T ENUM TLD evaluation group - 2003~2005 : Making Evaluation report between e164.arpa and .e164

Case study of ENUM (tElephone NUmber Mapping)Case study of ENUM (tElephone NUmber Mapping)

Classification e164.arpa .e164Technical Aspects Almost same

Administrative Aspects Almost same

Financial Aspects Cannot predict

Feasibility simple Complicated

<Summary of Evaluation report about ENUM TLD>

7 CJK10, Beijing, China

[Info.] ENUM (tElephone NUmber Mapping) (1/2)

[Appliction]

(ITU-T)RIPE-NCC

221864551Email, Web, Cell

…… 821

<Tier 0>Root

<Tier 1>National Management Agency

<Tier 2>Telecom company

[ENUM Tree]

+82-2-2186-4551

③ Choose of service

Webemail

MobilePhone

http://www.nida.or.krsjlee@nida.or.kr010-1234-5678 02-2186-4551

-PC- Mobile Phone

- PDA - VoIP

① Query ② Respone

8 CJK10, Beijing, China

[Info.] ENUM (tElephone NUmber Mapping) (2/2)

RootRootDomainDomain

.com.com .KR.KR.CN.CN .JP.JP

… .ip6… .ip6

.arpa.arpa

.aaa .bbc .ccc.aaa .bbc .ccc

www news sportswww news sports

.e164.e164. In addr. In addr

9 CJK10, Beijing, China

3. oid.arpa

Operation of oid.arpaOperation of oid.arpa

RootRootDomainDomain

.com.com …… .edu.edu.net.net .org.org .arpa.arpa.arpa.arpa

.ip6.ip6.e164.e164.oid.oid. In addr. In addr

10 CJK10, Beijing, China

4. Works

Contents Contents 1. Background

2. Scope

3. Research

4. Evaluation

1. Background

2. Scope

3. Research

4. Evaluation

gTLD (21) - http://www.iana.org/domains/root/db/# - aero, arpa, asia, biz, cat, com, coop, edu, gov, info, int, jobs, mil, mobi, museum, name, net, org, pro, tel, travel

gTLD (21) - http://www.iana.org/domains/root/db/# - aero, arpa, asia, biz, cat, com, coop, edu, gov, info, int, jobs, mil, mobi, museum, name, net, org, pro, tel, travel

Parent Name Cost (Annual) Rule to register Registry (Profit/Non-profit) oid oid-res`COM $7 Freely, not limited Verisign (Profit) X O

Parent Name Cost (Annual) Rule to register Registry (Profit/Non-profit) oid oid-res`COM $7 Freely, not limited Verisign (Profit) X O

11 CJK10, Beijing, China

4. Works

Duty between CNNIC & NIDA

-CNNIC : aero, arpa, asia, biz, cat, com, coop, edu, gov, info

- NIDA : int, jobs, mil, mobi, museum, name, net, org, pro, tel, travel

Duty between CNNIC & NIDA

-CNNIC : aero, arpa, asia, biz, cat, com, coop, edu, gov, info

- NIDA : int, jobs, mil, mobi, museum, name, net, org, pro, tel, travel

12 CJK10, Beijing, China

4. Works

Proposed plan for ORS TLD evaluation report-Step 1 : Research on ORS TLD-Step 2 : Merge and review by CNNIC & NIDA-Step 3 : Review by CJK NID WG-Step 4 : Submit to SG17

Proposed plan for ORS TLD evaluation report-Step 1 : Research on ORS TLD-Step 2 : Merge and review by CNNIC & NIDA-Step 3 : Review by CJK NID WG-Step 4 : Submit to SG17

1st Aug. 7th Aug. 14th Aug.

STEP 1STEP 1

STEP 1STEP 1

STEP 2STEP 2 STEP 3STEP 3 ModifyModify

Step 5:Submit to SG17

30th Aug.

www.tta.or.krwww.tta.or.kr