View
4
Download
0
Category
Preview:
Citation preview
P. Schwalbach, F. Lipcsei, M. Boella, P. ChareDG ENERGY Dir Nuclear Safeguards, LuxembourgK. Casteleyn, L. Duinslaeger, K. Lützenkirchen, P. van Belle, E. ZulegerJRC ITU KarlsruheY. Aregbe- JRC IRMM Geel
On Site Laboratories of Euratom at Sellafield and La Hague
Ten Years of Excellent Results with Nuclear Reference Materials
�
| 2The Future of Reference Materials – Science and Innovation – IRMM Geel 24/11/2010
� Contents
.Introduction: nuclear safeguards in Europe
.On Site Laboratories at the reprocessing facilitiesin Sellafield and La Hague
.The methods for the analysis of nuclear material
.Quality Control: use of reference materials
.Conclusion
| 3The Future of Reference Materials – Science and Innovation – IRMM Geel 24/11/2010
�
| 3
�
Introduction
.Implementation of Euratom’s nuclear material control» in 25 non nuclear weapon states and» in 2 nuclear weapon countries (FR, UK).Implementation of Verification Agreements under the
Non-Proliferation Treaty in co-operation with the IAEA.Assuring implementation of other international nuclear co-operation agreements.More than 120 inspectors (~1500 inspections/year).More than 1000 installations in 27 countries.Full fuel cycle, including Pu and U bulk handling» Enrichment plants» Fuel fabrication plants » Reprocessing plants: FR, UK
DG ENER Directorate E: Nuclear Safeguards
The Future of Reference Materials – Science and Innovation – IRMM Geel 24/11/2010
| 4The Future of Reference Materials – Science and Innovation – IRMM Geel 24/11/2010
�
| 4The Future of Reference Materials – Science and Innovation – IRMM Geel 24/11/2010
�.Compliance Control» Accounting checks» Verification of construction and process declarations
(Basic Technical Characteristics- BTC).Performance Control» Audit the quality of operators
Nuclear Material Accounting System .Credibility Control» Physical Verifications: measurements etc
Three Types of Control
Physical Verification of Nuclear Materials
�
.Item counting and Identification.Non Destructive Assay.Destructive Assay
Gross deviations
Partial deviations
Bias/small deviations
Introduction
| 5The Future of Reference Materials – Science and Innovation – IRMM Geel 24/11/2010
�
| 5The Future of Reference Materials – Science and Innovation – IRMM Geel 24/11/2010
�
.Reprocessing» ~ 800 t HM/y – 8000 kg Pu/y.MOX fuel fabrication» ~ 100 t HM/y – 8000 kg Pu/y.LEU fuel fabrication» ~ 700 t HM/y .Measurement methods with
highest accuracies are needed
to detect small deviations.Use Destructive Assay methods
Material Balance Challenge:Bulk handling → high throughput
Introduction
| 6The Future of Reference Materials – Science and Innovation – IRMM Geel 24/11/2010
�« Take the analyst to the material –
not the material to the analyst »
| 6The Future of Reference Materials – Science and Innovation – IRMM Geel 24/11/2010
�
.1992 EC decision On-Site Laboratories (OSL). No transports (time, cost, risk, public acceptance). Timely analysis . Quick response to discrepancies. Analysis of unstable samples,
highly active samples. Sample authentication.Waste disposal on-site. Economic benefit vssample transport off-site
On Site Laboratories
Where to analyse the material?
| 7The Future of Reference Materials – Science and Innovation – IRMM Geel 24/11/2010
�Commercial reprocessing plants
Areva NC, La Hague, France
Laboratoire Sur-SiteStart-up June 2000
Sellafield Limited, Sellafield, UK
On-Site LaboratoryStart-up October 1999
On Site Laboratories
| 8The Future of Reference Materials – Science and Innovation – IRMM Geel 24/11/2010
� Sellafield On-Site Laboratory
.Glove box environment
.Hot Cell environment at THORP
.Two active laboratories
Robotised glove box for separation chemistry and alpha counting
On Site Laboratories
| 9The Future of Reference Materials – Science and Innovation – IRMM Geel 24/11/2010
� La Hague On-Site Laboratory
.Three active laboratories » Hot cell facilities» Product (PuO2) lab» Mass spectrometry lab» Hot cell environment plus
glove boxes for low
activity work
Hot cell suite for handling of dissolved spent fuel samples and their assay by Hybrid K-edge densitometry and/or spiking
On Site Laboratories
| 10The Future of Reference Materials – Science and Innovation – IRMM Geel 24/11/2010
�Type and number of samples
| 10
�
About 8200 samples(since 2000)
21400 measurements
On Site Laboratories
| 11The Future of Reference Materials – Science and Innovation – IRMM Geel 24/11/2010
� The tasks of the on-site laboratories are:
.Determine the concentration and isotopic composition of Pu and U in process liquors .The same in solid product samples (powders).Safeguards key measurement points par excellence» the reprocessing input
(here the amount of plutonium generated in a reactor
can be accurately determined for the first time)
» The product output (PuO2 nitrate, powder)
.Criteria for selecting the analytical methods were based on a combination of highest possible accuracy (up to 0.1 %) and minimum resource consumption
Analytical Methods
| 12The Future of Reference Materials – Science and Innovation – IRMM Geel 24/11/2010
� Analytical methods for element assay
Hybrid K-Edge Densitometry (HKED)
- An alternative X-ray technique- Not as accurate as IDMS, but simple- Analysis completed within 1 hour
Isotope Dilution Mass Spectrometry (IDMS)
- Primary reference method- Highest accuracy, but sophisticated - Analysis not completed within 1 day
©H. Ottmar
Analytical Methods
| 13The Future of Reference Materials – Science and Innovation – IRMM Geel 24/11/2010
� Hybrid K-Edge Densitometry
2) X-ray fluorescence:Pu and U conc, 0.5-40 g/l
Accuracy: 0.5 – 0.6 %
and Pu/U ratio, acc. 0.3-0.65%
1) K-edge densitometryPu and U, 50-350 g/l
Accuracy: 0.2 %
Photon Source
(X-ray tube)
Transmitted photon beamfor KEDG
Sample
HPGe
detector
HPGe
detector
Fluoresced
X-ray beam
for K-XRF
1) + 2): HKED – Hybrid K-edge
Accuracy: 0.2 % for U
0.3 – 0.65 % for Pu
Analytical Methods
| 14The Future of Reference Materials – Science and Innovation – IRMM Geel 24/11/2010
� Isotope Dilution Mass Spectrometry
.Thermal Ionisation Mass Spectrometry» JRC developments
• Use of LSD (Large-Sized Dried) spike (IRMM)• Total evaporation (ITU)• Robust reliable procedures (ITU)
.Accuracies» U: 0.07 %
» Pu: 0.06 %.Used for:» Quality control
» Calibration
» Resolve operator –
Inspector differences
Analytical Methods
| 15The Future of Reference Materials – Science and Innovation – IRMM Geel 24/11/2010
� Elaborate quality assurance to stay routinely within ESARDA Target Values
.5 independent levels» Instrument operation
» Procedural accuracy» Duplicate sample measurements with comparison to
reference materials
» Permanent method inter-comparison
» External quality control
.Basis of quality control» Primary method IDMS
» Certified Reference Materials provided by IRMM
Quality Control
| 16The Future of Reference Materials – Science and Innovation – IRMM Geel 24/11/2010
� Certified Reference Materials
| 16The Future of Reference Materials – Science and Innovation – IRMM Geel 24/11/2010
�.First level QC instrument check + mass calibration» HKED
• IRMM 3501 U/Pu K-edge CRM 250/2.5 g/l• BC 2113 U/Pu mixture RM of various concentrations
(200/1.3, 150/1.5, 150/1)• BC 567 low enriched U RM (270 and 90 g/l)• BC 831M natural U RM (360 and 180 g/l)
» Mass Spectrometry• IRMM 183, 184, 185, 186, 187: U isotope CRM with
235U abundances ranging from depleted to lowenriched (0.3 %, 0.7 %, 2.0 %, 3.0 % and 4.5 %)
• IRMM 290 A1 to G1 Pu isotope CRM with abundance ratio 239Pu/242Pu from 0.1 to 10
• IRMM 199 U isotope CRM with 33.3 % each of 233U, 235U, and 238U
Quality Control
| 17The Future of Reference Materials – Science and Innovation – IRMM Geel 24/11/2010
� Secondary Reference Solutions
| 17The Future of Reference Materials – Science and Innovation – IRMM Geel 24/11/2010
�.Second level QC material undergoes the same treatment and measurements as the samples
» HKED• CRMs as used for first level QC• Reference materials prepared out of sample
material and certified using IDMS
» Mass Spectrometry• Reference materials prepared out of
sample material and certified using CRMs (as used for first level QC) and IDMS
Quality Control
| 18The Future of Reference Materials – Science and Innovation – IRMM Geel 24/11/2010
� HKED calibration
| 18The Future of Reference Materials – Science and Innovation – IRMM Geel 24/11/2010
�.Energy-dispersive X-ray methods are not primary ones,they require calibration and frequent re-calibration» Calibration solutions
• Prepared out of samples to achieve various concentrations and U/Pu ratios
• Certified using IDMS using IRMM 1027 LSD spike
» Accuracy of OSL element assay results is dependent on LSD spike which provides traceability to the SI unit
• Increased accuracy• IRMM 1027 e uncertainty U: 0.087 %
Pu 0.089 %
• IRMM 1027 m uncertainty U: 0.019 %
Pu: 0.040 %
Quality Control
| 19The Future of Reference Materials – Science and Innovation – IRMM Geel 24/11/2010
� External Quality Control
.Eqrain quality control programme for uranium CETAMA
Quality Control
| 20The Future of Reference Materials – Science and Innovation – IRMM Geel 24/11/2010
� External Quality Control
.IRMM REIMEP round robin quality control isotopic ratios
Quality Control
| 21The Future of Reference Materials – Science and Innovation – IRMM Geel 24/11/2010
� Conclusion
| 21The Future of Reference Materials – Science and Innovation – IRMM Geel 24/11/2010
�
.Direct physical verification of nuclear material is fundamental to Euratom Safeguards
.The On-Site Laboratories –» deliver now for 10 years high-quality, independent
measurements –» play a crucial role for safeguards at reprocessing
plants
.Nuclear Reference Material providers, mainly the Institute of Reference Materials and Measurements, support directly the OSLs to achieve the required high level of detection probability for small deviations
Conclusion
Recommended