View
216
Download
0
Category
Preview:
Citation preview
7/29/2019 Mutual Fund as a Tool for Financial Planning
1/88
Mutual Funds as a Tool for Financial Planning
Executive Summary
India has been amongst the fastest growing markets for Mutual Fund since 2004, witnessing
CAGR of 29 percent in the five year period from 2004-2008 as against the global average of 4
percent. The Increase in revenue & profitability however has not been commensurate with the
AUM growth in the last five years.
Low customer awareness levels and financial literacy pose the biggest challenge to channelising
the household savings into mutual funds. Further fund houses have shown limited focus on
increasing retail penetration and building retail AUM. Most AMCs and distributors have a limited
focus beyond the top 20 cities that is manifested in limited distribution channels and investor
servicing. The Indian Mutual Fund Industry has largely been product led and not sufficiently
customer focus with limited focus being accorded by players to innovation and new product
development. Further there is limited flexibility in fees and pricing structures currently.
As we all are aware how mutual Fund Industry has become one of the most powerful & popular
tool for Investments across globe. It plays one of the vital roles in the economic factors of India.
They act as mirrors that reflect performance of the economy as a whole.
A Mutual Fund is a trust that pools the savings of a number of investors who share a common
financial goal. The money thus collected is invested by the fund manager in different types of
securities depending upon the objective of the scheme.
This project tries to bring out the existence of the Mutual Fund Industry in India, how popular they
became as one of the best mode of Investments for Individual as well as FII Investors, how one
has to do the planning of their investments, what are the risk involved etc.
Thus this project aims to give both a macro point of view of the importance of Mutual Fund and
their functionalities.
1
7/29/2019 Mutual Fund as a Tool for Financial Planning
2/88
Mutual Funds as a Tool for Financial Planning
INTRODUCTION
The mutual fund (MF) industry has been one of the fastest growing financial sectors; it has
been growing at a CAGR of 20-25 percent in the last ten years. As per AMFI chairman
A.R.Kurian, the asset base is expected to grow at an annual rate of about 30-35 percent over
the next few years as investors shift their assets from banks and other traditional avenues.
The Mutual Fund Industry came into existence with the setting up of UTI in 1964. UTI
continues to dominate the mutual fund industry with a corpus of 700bn (54% of the industry
assets), but the investors confidence is shaken by the recent crisis.
The mutual fund industry in India has completed 36 years and the ride through these years
has not been smooth. Investors have still to overcome their experience with mutual fund like
Morgan Stanley, Mastergain, Monthly Equity plans of SBI, UTI and Canara Bank.
The nationalized banks entered the mutual fund business in the early nineties and got off to a
good start because of the stock market boom. But these banks did not understand the mutual
fund business nor did they have the required skill, experience or the technology. As a result
they failed miserably.
Investors experience with Morgan Stanley, the first foreign mutual fund was also not too good.
The Morgan Stanley fund in its initial public offer (IPO) raised 10bn. The entire fund raising
exercise was centered on the hype that the fund was first of its kind, promoted by an
internationally acclaimed asset management company. It was marketed like any other public
issue. Investors rushed in hoping for superior returns without realizing that the functioning of a
mutual fund is different from investing in an equity fund IPO. Nor did they realize that the
scheme was a closed-ended scheme with lock in of 15 years. The equity market also did not
favor Morgan Stanley and investors lost heavily.
2
7/29/2019 Mutual Fund as a Tool for Financial Planning
3/88
Mutual Funds as a Tool for Financial Planning
As a result of all this, investors confidence in mutual funds was shaken up.
Though the experience of mutual fund investors in the past has not been good it does not
mean that all funds have performed badly. In fact, if one looks at income funds and recent
performance of equity funds, they have done quite well. Due to which investors are relooking
at mutual funds as a tool for investments. Most traditional avenues have become unattractive.
Investors are realizing the benefits of investing in the capital markets through mutual funds
rather than investing directly. The awareness about mutual funds is slowly but steadily
growing.
Investors are realizing that they need to look no further than mutual funds for their complete
set of investment needs. However like any other investment a disciplined approach is required
for investing in mutual funds.
A mutual fund is the ideal investment vehicle for todays complex and modern financial
scenario. Markets for equity shares, bonds and other fixed income instruments, real estate,
derivatives and other assets have become mature and information driven. Price changes in
these assets are driven by global events occurring in faraway places. A typical individual is
unlikely to have the knowledge, skills, inclination and time to keep track of events, understand
their implications and act speedily.
The industry is also having a profound impact on financial markets. Fund managers, by their
selection criteria for stocks have forced corporate governance on the industry. By rewarding
honest and transparent management with higher valuations, a system of risk-reward has been
created where the corporate sector is more transparent then before.
One thing is certain - that the mutual fund industry is here to stay.
3
7/29/2019 Mutual Fund as a Tool for Financial Planning
4/88
Mutual Funds as a Tool for Financial Planning
The study has been divided into two sections:
Section I, talks about the genesis of mutual fund, the evolution of mutual funds in India and the
mutual funds registered in India. It also explains the concept of a mutual fund, the benefits of
investing in a mutual fund, the types of mutual fund schemes. It talks about the regulatory
framework within which mutual funds in India operate. The concept of NAV and the tax
benefits have also been explained in detail.
The last chapter in this section covers the most important aspect of mutual fund, Investment
Management. This chapter covers the different styles of debt and equity management, the
securities in which debt and equity funds invest and the risks associated with these
investments.
Section II. Describes the different avenues available to the retail investor. There was a time
when Indian investors did not have many investment schemes to choose from. It was easy
then for the agents to simply point out the benefits of any currently available scheme to a
prospective investor. The investor then decided whether the schemes suited to his needs or
not. Now, the Indian mutual funds industry offers a wide choice of investment schemes, unlike
ever before. Different schemes are suited to different investor needs. In this scenario, an
investor not only has to choose from this variety of investment options available, but also
design a proper investment strategy that is suitable to his situation and needs. In this scenario
an investor should develop the right approach to investing, and avoid ad-hoc investment
decisions. All this has been covered in section II.
It explains in detail the concept of financial planning, the benefits and the steps in financial
planning. Asset Allocation, which is an important aspect of financial, planning, has also been
explained in detail.
The final chapter talks about choosing a mutual fund scheme and investing in it, keeping in
mind the costs involved and the risks associated with it.
4
7/29/2019 Mutual Fund as a Tool for Financial Planning
5/88
Mutual Funds as a Tool for Financial Planning
To summarize, as Jacobs puts it, mutual fund investing is not a get-rich-quick scheme.
Investors should have an Investment Program and ought to set their sights on long term
goals, in other words, investment decisions to be taken in terms of clear, long-term goals, not
on an ad-hoc basis.
Each investor should expect only realistic wealth accumulation goals, no dramatic result
overnight. For example, in the current Indian market conditions, investors can expect 20% plus
returns in equity investments, 11 or 12% returns in debt investments and 8 to 9% in money
market investment. These expectations can change over time. Specific investments or funds
can give greater return or less return, but higher returns will be in most cases achieved by
investors or their fund managers taking greater risks.
5
7/29/2019 Mutual Fund as a Tool for Financial Planning
6/88
Mutual Funds as a Tool for Financial Planning
The History of Mutual Funds
Mutual funds came into existence for the 1st time when three Boston securities executives
pooled their money together in 1924 to create the first mutual fund; they had no idea how
popular mutual funds would become.
The idea of pooling money together for investing purpose started in Europe in the mid-1800.
The first pooled fund in the U.S. was created in 1893 for the faculty and staff of Harvard
University. On March 21st, 1924 the first official mutual fund was born. It was called the
Massachusetts Investors Trust.
After one year, the Massachusetts Investors Trust grew from $50,000 in assets in 1924 to
$392,000 in assets (with around 200 shareholders). In contrast, there are over 10,000 mutual
funds in the U.S. today totaling around $7 trillion (with approximately 83 million individual
investors) according to the Investment Company Institute.
The stock market crash of 1929 slowed the growth of mutual funds. In response to the stock
market crash, Congress passed the Securities Act of 1933 and the Securities Exchange Act of
1934. These laws require that a fund be registered with the SEC and provide prospective
investors with a prospectus.
The SEC (U.S. Securities and Exchange Commission) helped create the Investment Company
Act of 1940 which provides the guidelines that all funds must comply with today.
With renewed confidence in the stock market, mutual funds began to blossom. By the end of
the 1960's there were around 270 funds with $48 billion in assets.
6
7/29/2019 Mutual Fund as a Tool for Financial Planning
7/88
Mutual Funds as a Tool for Financial Planning
In 1976, John C. Bogle opened the first retail index fund called the First Index Investment
Trust. It is now called the Vanguard 500 Index fund and is the largest mutual fund with over
$100 billion in assets.
One of the largest contributors of mutual fund growth was the birth of the Individual Retirement
Account (IRA) in 1981. Mutual funds are now popular in employer-sponsored defined
contribution retirement plans (401k's for example), IRA's and Roth IRA's.
Mutual funds are very popular today, known for ease-of-use, liquidity, and unique
diversification capabilities.
Structure of the Indian mutual fund industry
The Indian mutual fund industry is dominated by the Unit Trust of India which has a total
corpus of Rs700bn collected from more than 20 million investors. The UTI has many schemes
in all categories i.e. equity, balanced, income etc with some being open-ended and some
being closed-ended. The Unit Scheme 1964 commonly referred to as US 64, which is a
balanced fund, is the biggest scheme with a corpus of about Rs200bn. UTI was floated by
financial institutions and is governed by a special act of Parliament. Most of its investors
believe that the UTI is government owned and controlled, which, while legally incorrect, is true
for all practical purposes.
The second largest category of mutual funds is the ones floated by the private sector and by
foreign asset management companies. The largest of these are Prudential ICICI AMC and
Birla Sun Life AMC. The aggregate corpus of assets managed by this category of AMCs is in
excess of Rs.250bn.
The third largest category of mutual funds is the ones floated by nationalized banks. Canbank
Asset Management floated by Canara Bank and SBI Funds Management floated by the State
Bank of India are the largest of these.
7
7/29/2019 Mutual Fund as a Tool for Financial Planning
8/88
Mutual Funds as a Tool for Financial Planning
Recent trends in mutual fund industry
The most important trend in the mutual fund industry has been the aggressive expansion of
the foreign owned mutual fund companies and the decline of the companies floated by
nationalized banks and smaller private sector players.
Many nationalized banks got into the mutual fund business in the early nineties and got off to a
good start due to the stock market boom prevailing then. These banks did not really
understand the mutual fund business and they just viewed it as another kind of banking
activity. Few hired specialized staff and generally chose to transfer staff from the parent
organizations. The performance of most of the schemes floated by these funds was not good.
Some schemes had offered guaranteed returns and their parent organizations had to bail out
these AMCs by paying large amounts of money as the difference between the guaranteed and
actual returns. The service levels were also very bad. Most of these AMCs have not been able
to retain staff, float new schemes etc. and it is doubtful whether, barring a few exceptions; they
have serious plans of continuing the activity in a major way.
The experience of some of the AMCs floated by private sector Indian companies was also very
similar. They quickly realized that the AMC business is a business, which makes money in the
long term and requires deep-pocketed support in the intermediate years. Some have sold out
to foreign owned companies; some have merged with others and their general restructuring
going on.
The foreign owned companies have deep pockets and have come in here with the expectation
of a long haul. They can be credited with introducing many new practices such as new product
innovation, sharp improvement in service standards and disclosure, usage of technology,
broker education and support etc. In fact, they have forced the industry to upgrade itself and
service levels of organizations like UTI have improved dramatically in the last few years in
response to the competition provided by these.
8
7/29/2019 Mutual Fund as a Tool for Financial Planning
9/88
Mutual Funds as a Tool for Financial Planning
Mutual Funds in India (1964-2000)
The end of millennium marks 36 years of existence of mutual funds in this country. The ride
through these 36 years is not been smooth. Investor opinion is still divided, while some are for
mutual funds others are against it.
UTI commenced its operations from July 1964 .The impetus for establishing a formal institution
came from the desire to increase the propensity of the middle and lower groups to save and to
invest. UTI came into existence during a period marked by great political and economic
uncertainty in India. With war on the borders and economic turmoil that depressed the financial
market, entrepreneurs were hesitant to enter capital market. The already existing companies
found it difficult to raise fresh capital, as investors did not respond adequately to new issues.
Earnest efforts were required to canalize savings of the community into productive uses in
order to speed up the process of industrial growth.
The then Finance Minister, T.T. Krishnamachari set up the idea of a unit trust that would be
"open to any person or institution to purchase the units offered by the trust. However, this
institution, is intended to cater to the needs of individual investors, and even among them as
far as possible, to those whose means are small."
Mr. T.T. Krishnamachari ideas took the form of the Unit Trust of India, an intermediary that
would help fulfill the twin objectives of mobilizing retail savings and investing those savings in
the capital market and passing on the benefits so accrued to the small investors.
UTI commenced its operations from July 1964 "with a view to encouraging savings and
investment and participation in the income, profits and gains accruing to the Corporation from
the acquisition, holding, management and disposal of securities." Different provisions of the
UTI Act laid down the structure of management, scope of business, powers and functions of
the Trust as well as accounting, disclosures and regulatory requirements for the Trust.
9
7/29/2019 Mutual Fund as a Tool for Financial Planning
10/88
Mutual Funds as a Tool for Financial Planning
One thing is certain the fund industry is here to stay. The industry was one-entity show till
1986 when the UTI monopoly was broken when SBI and Canbank mutual fund entered the
arena. This was followed by the entry of others like BOI, LIC, GIC, etc. sponsored by public
sector banks. Starting with an asset base of Rs0.25bn in 1964 the industry has grown at a
compounded average growth rate of 26.34% to its current size of Rs1130bn.
1999-2000 Year of the funds
Mutual funds have been around for a long period of time to be precise for 36 yrs. but the year
1999 saw immense future potential and developments in this sector. This year signaled the
year of resurgence of mutual funds and the regaining of investor confidence in these mutual
funds. This time around all the participants are involved in the revival of the funds ----- the
AMCs, the unit holders, the other related parties. However the sole factor that gave lift to the
revival of the funds was the Union Budget. The budget brought about a large number of
changes in one stroke.
It provided center stage to the mutual funds, made them more attractive and provides
acceptability among the investors. The Union Budget exempted mutual fund dividend given out
by equity-oriented schemes from tax, both at the hands of the investor as well as the mutual
fund. No longer were the mutual funds interested in selling the concept of mutual funds they
wanted to talk business which would mean to increase asset base, and to get asset base and
investor base they had to be fully armed with a whole lot of schemes for every investor. So
new schemes for new IPOs were inevitable. The quest to attract investors extended beyond
just new schemes. The funds started to regulate themselves and were all out on winning the
trust and confidence of the investors under the aegis of the Association of Mutual Funds of
India (AMFI)
10
7/29/2019 Mutual Fund as a Tool for Financial Planning
11/88
Mutual Funds as a Tool for Financial Planning
One can say that the industry is moving from infancy to adolescence, the industry is maturing
and the investors and funds are frankly and openly discussing difficulties, opportunities and
compulsions.
Future Scenario
The mutual fund (MF) industry has been one of the fastest growing financial sector, it has been
growing at a CAGR of 20- 25 per cent in the last ten years. As per AMFI chairman, Mr. A. P.
Kurian, the asset base is expected to grow at an annual rate of about 30 to 35 % over the
next few years as investors shift their assets from banks and other traditional avenues. The
market is expected to witness a flurry of new players entering the arena. Some big names like
Fidelity, Principal, and Old Mutual etc. are looking at Indian market seriously. One important
reason for it is that most major players already have presence here and hence these big
names would hardly like to get left behind.
The industry is also having a profound impact on financial markets. The new generations of
private funds which have gained substantial mass are now seen flexing their muscles. Fund
managers, by their selection criteria for stocks have forced corporate governance on the
industry. By rewarding honest and transparent management with higher valuations, a system
of risk-reward has been created where the corporate sector is more transparent then before.
Mutual funds are now also competing with commercial banks in the race for retail investors
savings and corporate float money. The power shift towards mutual funds has become
obvious. The coming few years will show that the traditional saving avenues are losing out in
the current scenario. Many investors are realizing that investments in savings accounts are as
good as locking up their deposits in a closet.
India is at the first stage of a revolution that has already peaked in the U.S. The U.S. boasts of
an asset base of mutual funds that is much higher than its bank deposits. In India, mutual fund
11
7/29/2019 Mutual Fund as a Tool for Financial Planning
12/88
Mutual Funds as a Tool for Financial Planning
assets are not even 10% of the bank deposits, but this trend is beginning to change. Mutual
Funds are going to change the way banks do business in the future.
The first phase - 1964 and 1987, when the only player was the Unit Trust of India, had a total
asset of Rs. 6,700/- crores at the end of 1988.
The second phase - 1987 and 1993, during this period 8 funds were established (6 by banks
and one each by LIC and GIC). At the end of 1994, the total assets under management had
grown to Rs. 61,028/- crores and numbers of schemes were 167.
Currently there are 34 Mutual Fund organisations in India managing over Rs. 92,000/- crores.
The mutual funds registered in India are
A) Unit Trust of India
B) Bank sponsored
a. BOB Asset Management Co. Ltd.
b. Canbank Investment Management Services Ltd.
c. PNB Asset Management Co. Ltd.
d. SBI Funds Management Ltd.
C) Institutions
a. GIC Asset Management Co. Ltd.
b. IDBI Principal Asset Management Co. Ltd.
D) Private Sector
1. Indian
a. Benchmark Asset Management Co. Ltd.
12
7/29/2019 Mutual Fund as a Tool for Financial Planning
13/88
Mutual Funds as a Tool for Financial Planning
b. Kotak Mahindra Asset Management Co. Ltd.
c. Reliance Capital Asset Management Ltd.
d. J.M. Capital Management Ltd.
2. Joint Ventures - Predominantly Indian
a. Birla Sun Life Asset Management Pvt. Co. Ltd.
b. Cholamandalam Cazenove Asset Management Co. Ltd.
c. HDFC Asset Management Company Ltd.
d. Sundaram Newton Asset Management Company
e. Tata TD Waterhouse Asset Management Private Ltd.
3. Joint Ventures - Predominantly Foreign
a. IDFC Asset Mgmt Co. Pvt. Ltd.
b. ING Investment Management (India) Pvt. Ltd.
c. Prudential ICICI Management Co. Ltd.
d. Templeton Asset Management (India) Pvt. Ltd.
13
7/29/2019 Mutual Fund as a Tool for Financial Planning
14/88
Mutual Funds as a Tool for Financial Planning
Concept of a Mutual Fund
A Mutual Fund is a trust that pools the savings of a number of investors who share a common
financial goal. The money thus collected is invested by the fund manager in different types of
securities depending upon the objective of the scheme. These could range from shares to
debentures to money market instruments. The income earned through these investments and
the capital appreciations realized by the scheme are shared by its unit holders in proportion to
the number of units owned by them (pro rata). Thus a Mutual Fund is the most suitable
investment for the common man as it offers an opportunity to invest in a diversified,
professionally managed portfolio at a relatively low cost. Anybody with an investible surplus of
as little as a few thousand rupees can invest in Mutual Funds. Each Mutual Fund scheme has
a defined investment objective and strategy.
A mutual fund is the ideal investment vehicle for todays complex and modern financial
scenario. Markets for equity shares, bonds and other fixed income instruments, real estate,
derivatives and other assets have become mature and information driven. Price changes in
these assets are driven by global events occurring in faraway places. A typical individual is
unlikely to have the knowledge, skills, inclination and time to keep track of events, understand
their implications and act speedily. An individual also finds it difficult to keep track of ownership
of his assets, investments, brokerage dues and bank transactions etc.
A mutual fund is the answer to all these situations. It appoints professionally qualified and
experienced staff that manages each of these functions on a full time basis. The large pool of
money collected in the fund allows it to hire such staff at a very low cost to each investor. In
effect, the mutual fund vehicle exploits economies of scale in all three areas - research,
investments and transaction processing. While the concept of individuals coming together to
invest money collectively is not new, the mutual fund in its present form is a 20th century
phenomenon. In fact, mutual funds gained popularity only after the Second World War.
14
7/29/2019 Mutual Fund as a Tool for Financial Planning
15/88
Mutual Funds as a Tool for Financial Planning
Globally, there are thousands of firms offering tens of thousands of mutual funds with different
investment objectives. Today, mutual funds collectively manage almost as much as or more
money as compared to banks.
Benefits of Investing in Mutual Funds
If mutual funds are emerging as the favorite investment vehicle it is because of the many
advantages they have over other forms and avenues of investing. The following are the major
advantages offered by mutual funds to all investors.
Diversification
The first principle of mutual fund investing is broad diversification of securities. For nearly all
investors, cost alone generally recludes achieving adequate diversification without using
mutual funds.
For example, if an investor had Rs. 50,000 to invest and he was keen on acquiring stocks like
Bajaj Auto, Hindustan Lever or Infosys, he would be unable to purchase even 100 shares (the
market lot) of any of these companies. While investing through a mutual fund could make him
a part owner of all these stocks with an investment of as low as Rs 1,000.
Professional Management
A mutual fund is managed by skilled, experienced professionals who are judged by the total
returns they generate over time. As an individual investor, one may not be in a position to keep
track of the performance of various companies. A fund manager, on the other hand, has
access to extensive research inputs both from its own research analysts as well as reputed
broking firms.
15
7/29/2019 Mutual Fund as a Tool for Financial Planning
16/88
Mutual Funds as a Tool for Financial Planning
Liquidity
In many cases, mutual funds offer more liquidity than individual stocks or bonds. Large
amounts of money can be invested or redeemed at a price based on the funds net asset value
(NAV). Further, money can be efficiently switched between, say, a stock and a money market
fund at little or no cost.
Convenience
Mutual fund investment provides simplicity and convenience. On every purchase or
redemption, an investor receives an Account Statement similar to a bank statement. An
investor avails of features like reinvestment of dividends, tax reporting, switches, systematic
investment and withdrawal and cheque writing on money market funds. Moreover, an investor
is not required to physically take delivery of securities, so problems of bad delivery, theft or
loss in transit are minimized.
Tax Benefits
There are several tax benefits available for investors in a mutual fund. A detailed explanation
is provided in the ensuing report.
Structure of Mutual Funds in India
Like other countries, India has a legal framework within which mutual funds must be
constituted.
Unlike in the UK, where distinct trust and corporate/ approaches are followed with separate
regulation, in India, open and closed end funds operate under the same regulatory structure.
There is one unique structure as unit trusts. A mutual fund in India is allowed to issue open
end and closed end schemes under a common legal structure. The structure which is required
16
7/29/2019 Mutual Fund as a Tool for Financial Planning
17/88
Mutual Funds as a Tool for Financial Planning
to be followed by mutual funds in India is laid down under SEBI (Mutual Fund) Regulations,
1996.
The structure of each of the fund constituents is explained below,
The Fund Sponsor
Sponsor is defined under SEBI regulation as nay person who, acting alone or in combination
with another body corporate, establishes a mutual fund. The sponsor of a fund is akin to the
promoter of a company as he gets the fund registered with SEBI. The sponsor will form a Trust
and appoint a Board of Trustees. The sponsor will also generally appoint an Asset
Management Company as fund managers. The sponsor, either directly is acting through the
Trustees, will also appoint a Custodian to hold the fund assets. All these appointments are
made in accordance with SEBI Regulations.
Mutual Funds as Trusts
A mutual fund in India is constituted in the form of Public Trust created under the Indian Trusts
Act, 1882; The Fund Sponsor acts as the Settler of the Trust, Contributing to its initial capital
and appoints a Trustee to hold the assets of the Trust for the benefit of the unit-holders, who
are the beneficiaries of the Trust. The fund then invites investors to contribute their money in
the common pool, by subscribing to units issued by various schemes established by the trust
as evidence of their beneficial interest in the fund.
It should be understood that a mutual fund is just a pass-through, rather it is the Trustee or
Trustees who have the legal capacity and therefore all acts in relation to the trust are taken on
its behalf by the Trustees. The trustees hold the unit-holders money in a fiduciary capacity.
17
7/29/2019 Mutual Fund as a Tool for Financial Planning
18/88
Mutual Funds as a Tool for Financial Planning
Trustees
A mutual fund is governed by trustees. The trustees have oversight responsibility for the
management of the fund's business affairs and safeguarding the interest of the unit holders.
The trustees are expected to exercise sound business judgement and keep a watchful eye on
the functioning of the asset management company. As per the Securities and Exchange Board
of India (SEBI) regulations, at least half of the board of trustees shall consist of independent
persons, who are not affiliated with the asset management company or any of its affiliates.
The Asset Management Company
An AMC is involved in the daily administration of the mutual fund and also acts as investment
advisor for the fund. An Asset Management Company is promoted by a sponsor, which usually
is a, reputed corporate entity with sound track record of profitability.
An AMC typically has three departments:
A) Fund Management comprises of fund managers, research analysts and dealers
B) Sales & Marketing which is involved in generating sales through brokers, agents and
financial planners.
C) Operations & Accounting oversees back office and operational activities. It consists of fund
accountants and compliance officer.
The other fund constituents are
Custodians and Depositories
Mutual funds are required by law to protect their portfolio securities by placing them with an
independent third party as custodian, typically a bank or trust company. The custodian also
handles payments and receipts for the funds security transactions.
18
7/29/2019 Mutual Fund as a Tool for Financial Planning
19/88
Mutual Funds as a Tool for Financial Planning
Bankers
A funds activities involve dealing with money on a continuous basis primarily with respect to
buying and selling units, paying for investments made, receiving the proceed on sale of
investments and discharging its obligations towards operating expenses. A funds bankers
therefore play a crucial role with respect to its financial dealings by holding its bank accounts
and providing it with remittance services.
Transfer Agents
A share transfer agent is employed by the AMC on behalf of the mutual fund to conduct record
keeping and related functions. Share transfer agent maintains records of unit holder accounts,
prepares and mails account statements confirming transactions and account balances. It also
maintains customer service departments (termed as "Investor Service Centres" or ISCs) at
main cities and towns to facilitate daily purchases and redemptions by investors.
Distributors
Mutual fund operate as collective investment vehicles, on the principle of accumulating funds
from a large number of investors and then investing on a big scale. For a fund to sell units
across a wide retail base of individual investors an established network of distribution agents is
essential AMC, usually appoint Distributors or Brokers, who sell units on behalf of the fund.
A draft offer document is to be prepared at the time of launching the fund. Typically, it pre
specifies the investment objectives of the fund, the risk associated, the costs involved in the
process and the broad rules for entry into and exit from the fund and other areas of operation.
In India, as in most countries, these sponsors need approval from a regulator, SEBI (Securities
exchange Board of India) in our case. SEBI looks at track records of the sponsor and its
financial strength in granting approval to the fund for commencing operations.
19
7/29/2019 Mutual Fund as a Tool for Financial Planning
20/88
Mutual Funds as a Tool for Financial Planning
A sponsor then hires an asset management company to invest the funds according to the
investment objective. It also hires another entity to be the custodian of the assets of the fund
and perhaps a third one to handle the registrars work for the unit holders (subscribers) of the
fund.
Types of Mutual Funds
Mutual fund schemes may be classified on the basis of its structure and its investment
objective.
On the basis of its structure they are classified as open ended and close ended schemes.
Most schemes floated by AMCs are open-ended schemes as investors need liquidity and
these schemes allow investors to enter or exit any time.
Open-ended Funds
An open-end fund is one that is available for subscription all through the year. These do not
have a fixed maturity. Investors can conveniently buy and sell units at Net Asset Value ("NAV")
related prices. The key feature of open-end schemes is liquidity. In open-ended schemes
investors can enter and exit on any business day hence the corpus of the schemes is not fixed
and keeps fluctuating.
Closed-ended Funds
A closed-end fund has a stipulated maturity period which generally ranging from 3 to 15 years.
The fund is open for subscription only during a specified period. The corpus of the scheme is
fixed. Investors can invest in the scheme only at the time of the initial public issue and
thereafter they can buy or sell the units of the scheme on the stock exchanges where they are
listed.
20
7/29/2019 Mutual Fund as a Tool for Financial Planning
21/88
Mutual Funds as a Tool for Financial Planning
On the basis of investment objective they are classified as growth, income or balanced
schemes
Growth Funds
The aim of growth funds is to provide capital appreciation over the medium to long- term. Such
schemes normally invest majority of their corpus in equities. It has been proven that returns
from stocks, have outperformed most other kind of investments held over the long term.
Growth schemes are ideal for investors having a long-term outlook seeking growth over a
period of time.
Income Fund
The aim of income funds is to provide regular and steady income to investors. Such schemes
generally invest in fixed income securities such as bonds, corporate debentures and
Government securities. Income Funds are ideal for capital stability and regular income.
Balanced Funds
The aim of balanced funds is to provide both growth and regular income. Such schemes
periodically distribute a part of their earning and invest both in equities and fixed income
securities in the proportion indicated in their offer documents. These are ideal for investors
looking for a combination of income and moderate growth. The advantage of investing in these
schemes that when equities are performing well the fund manager can increase his exposure
in equities and in a falling market he can increase his exposure in debt. Such a fund is ideal for
investors who do not desire high volatility.
Money Market Funds
The aim of money market funds is to provide easy liquidity, preservation of capital and
moderate income. These schemes generally invest in safer short-term instruments such as
21
7/29/2019 Mutual Fund as a Tool for Financial Planning
22/88
Mutual Funds as a Tool for Financial Planning
treasury bills, certificates of deposit, commercial paper and inter-bank call money. Returns on
these schemes may fluctuate depending upon the interest rates prevailing in the market.
These are ideal for corporate and individual investors as a means to park their surplus funds
for short periods.
Apart from the types of schemes mentioned above mutual fund schemes can be further
classified as follows,
Load Funds & No load Funds
Load Funds
Marketing of a mutual fund scheme involves initial expenses. These expenses may be
recovered from investors by the mutual fund in the form of load. The load is used to cover
expenses incurred on distribution, sales and marketing. Three ways in which load is charged is
Entry Load: This is charged at the time the investor enters into the fund by deducting a
specified amount from his initial contribution. However with the recent SEBI circular no load will
be charged to the distributor.
Exit Load: This is charged at the time the investor redeems from the fund by deducting a
specified amount from his redemption proceeds.
No-Load Funds
A No-Load Fund is one that does not charge a commission for entry or exit. That is, no charge
is payable on purchase or sale of units in the fund. The advantage of a no load fund is that the
entire corpus is put to work.
22
7/29/2019 Mutual Fund as a Tool for Financial Planning
23/88
Mutual Funds as a Tool for Financial Planning
Tax Saving Schemes
These schemes offer tax rebates to the investors under specific provisions of the Indian
Income Tax laws as the Government offers tax incentives for investment in specified avenues.
Investments made in Equity Linked Savings Schemes (ELSS) and Pension Schemes are
allowed as deduction u/s 88 of the Income Tax Act, 1961. The Act also provided opportunities
to investors to save capital gains u/s 54EA and 54EB by investing in Mutual Funds, provided
the capital asset had been sold prior to April 1, 2000 and the amount was invested before
September 30, 2000.
Special Schemes
Industry Specific Schemes
Industry Specific Schemes invest only in the industries specified in the offer document. The
investment of these funds is limited to specific industries like InfoTech, FMCG, and
Pharmaceuticals etc.
Index Schemes
Index Funds attempt to replicate the performance of a particular index such as the BSE
Sensex or the NSE 50.
Sectoral Schemes
Sectoral Funds are those, which invest exclusively in a specified industry or a group of
industries or various segments such as 'A' Group shares or initial public offerings.
23
7/29/2019 Mutual Fund as a Tool for Financial Planning
24/88
Mutual Funds as a Tool for Financial Planning
The Regulatory framework of Mutual Funds in India
SEBI The Capital Markets Regulator
The Government of India constituted Securities and Exchange Board of India, by an act of
Parliament in 1992, as the apex regulator of all entities that either raise funds in the capital
markets or invest in capital market securities such as shares and debentures listed on stock
exchanges. It was formed to protect the interests of investors in securities and to promote the
development of, and to regulate the securities market and for matters connected therewith or
incidental thereto.
Mutual funds have emerged as an important institutional investor in capital markets securities.
Hence they come under the purview of SEBI. SEBI requires all mutual funds to be registered
with them. It issues guidelines for all mutual fund operations, including where they can invest,
what investment limits and restrictions must be complied with, how they should account for
income and expenses, how they should make disclosures of information to the investors and
generally acts in the interest of investor protection.
SEBI (MUTUAL FUNDS) REGULATIONS, 1996
A comprehensive set of regulations for all mutual funds has been accomplished with SEBI
(Mutual Fund) regulations 1996. These regulations set uniform standards for all funds and will
eventually be applied in full to Unit Trust of India as well, even though UTI is governed by its
own UTI Act. The regulation governing Mutual funds are as follows,
Registration of the Fund
The regulations lay down the procedure of registration for the Fund with the SEBI board. For
the purpose of grant of a certificate of registration, the applicant has to fulfil the following,
namely: -
24
7/29/2019 Mutual Fund as a Tool for Financial Planning
25/88
Mutual Funds as a Tool for Financial Planning
The sponsor should have a sound track record and general reputation of fairness and
integrity in all his business transactions;
In the case of an existing mutual fund, such fund is in the form of as trust and the trust
deed has been approved by the Board;
The sponsor has contributed or contributes atleast 40% to the networth of the asset
management company.
The sponsor or any of its directors or the principle officer to be employed by the mutual
fund should not have been guilty of fraud or has not been convicted of an offence involving
moral turpitude or has not been found guilty of any economic offence:
Appointment of trustees to act as trustees for the mutual fund in accordance with the
provisions of the regulations;
Appointment of asset management company to manage the mutual fund and operate the
scheme of such funds in accordance with the provisions of these regulations;
Appointment of a custodian in order to keep custody of the securities and carry out the
custodian activities as may be authorised by the trustees.
Constitution and Management of Mutual Fund and Operation of Trustees
A mutual fund is constituted in the form of a trust and the instrument of trust is a deed, the
same has to be registered under the provision of the Indian Registration Act. It lays down the
contents of the trust deed. The trust deed shall contain such clauses as are necessary for
safeguarding the interests of the unit holders. A mutual fund shall appoint trustees in
accordance with these regulations. An asset management company or any of its officers or
employees shall not be eligible to act as a trustee of any mutual fund.
Rights & Obligations of Trustees
The trustees and the asset management company shall with the prior approval of the
Board enter into an investment management agreement.
25
7/29/2019 Mutual Fund as a Tool for Financial Planning
26/88
Mutual Funds as a Tool for Financial Planning
The trustees shall have a right to obtain from the asset management company such
information as is considered necessary by the trustee.
The trustees shall ensure before the launch of any scheme that the asset management
company has;-
a) systems in place for its back office, dealing room and accounting;
b) appointed all key personnel including fund manager (s) for the scheme(s) and
submitted their bio-data which shall contain the educational qualifications, past experience in
the securities market with the trustee, 15 days of their appointment;
c) appointed auditors to audit its accounts;
d) appointed compliance officer to comply with regulatory requirement and to redress
investor grievances;
e) appointed registrars and laid down parameters for their supervision;
f) prepared compliance manual and designed internal control mechanisms including
internal audit systems;
g) Specified norms for empanelment of brokers and marketing agents.
Asset Management Company and its obligations:
The asset management company shall take all reasonable steps and exercise due
diligence to ensure that the investment of funds pertaining of these regulations and the trust
deed.
The asset management company shall exercise due diligence and care in all its investment
decision as would be exercised by other persons engaged in the same business.
The asset management company shall submit to the trustees quarterly reports of each
year on its activities and the compliance with these regulations.
In case the asset management company enters into any securities transactions with any of
its associates a report to that effect shall immediately be sent to the trustees.
26
7/29/2019 Mutual Fund as a Tool for Financial Planning
27/88
Mutual Funds as a Tool for Financial Planning
The asset management company shall not appoint any person as key personnel who has
been found guilty of any economic offence or involved in violation of securities laws.
The asset management company shall appoint registrars and share transfer agents who
are registered with the Board.
The asset management company shall abide by the Code of Conduct as specified in the
Fifth Schedule.
Investment Objectives and Valuation Policies
Investment objective:
The moneys collected under any scheme of a mutual fund shall be invested only in
transferable securities in the money market or in the capital market or in privately placed
debentures or securities debts.
The mutual fund shall not borrow except to meet temporary liquidity needs of the mutual
funds for the purpose of repurchase or redemption of units or payment of interest or dividend
to the unit holders.
The mutual fund shall not advance any loans for any purpose or for options trading.
Method of valuation of investments:
Every mutual fund shall compute and carry out valuation of its investments in its portfolio
and published the same in accordance with the valuation norms.
General Obligations
To maintain proper books of accounts and records, etc.
Limitation on fees and expenses on issue of schemes and annual charges.
27
7/29/2019 Mutual Fund as a Tool for Financial Planning
28/88
Mutual Funds as a Tool for Financial Planning
Advertisement Code
An advertisement shall be truthful, fair and clear and shall not contain a statement, promise
or forecast which is untrue or misleading.
The advertisement shall not be so designed in content and format or in print as to be likely
to be misunderstood, or likely to disguise the significance of any statement. Advertisements
shall not contain statements, which directly or by implication or by omission may mislead the
investor.
Advertisements shall not be so framed as to exploit the lack of experience or knowledge of
the investors. As the investors may not be sophisticated in legal or financial matters, care
should be taken that the advertisement is set forth in a clear, concise, and understandable
manner. Extensive use of technical or legal terminology or complex language and the inclusion
of excessive details, which may detract the investors, should be avoided.
Code of Conduct
Mutual fund schemes should not be organised, operated, managed or the portfolio of
securities selected, in the interest of sponsors, directors of asset management companies,
members of Board of trustees or directors of trustee company, associated person or in the
interest of special class of unit holders rather than in the interest of all classes of unit holders
of the scheme.
Trustees and asset management companies must ensure the dissemination to all unit
holders of adequate, accurate, explicit and timely information fairly presented in a simple
language about the investment policies, investment objectives, financial position and general
affairs of the scheme.
28
7/29/2019 Mutual Fund as a Tool for Financial Planning
29/88
Mutual Funds as a Tool for Financial Planning
Trustees and asset management companies should excessive concentration of business
with broking firms, affiliates and also excessive holding of units in a scheme among a few
investors.
Trustees and asset management companies must avoid conflicts of interest in managing
the affairs of the scheme and keep the interest of all unit holders paramount in all matters.
Trustees and asset management companies must ensure scheme wise segregation of
cash and securities accounts.
Trustees and asset management companies shall carry out the business and invest in
accordance with the investment objectives stated in the offer documents and take investment
decision solely in the interest of unit holders.
Trustees and asset management companies must not use any unethical means to sell
market or induce any investor to buy their schemes.
29
7/29/2019 Mutual Fund as a Tool for Financial Planning
30/88
Mutual Funds as a Tool for Financial Planning
Valuation and Taxation
Net Asset Value
Net Asset Value refers to the price at which a mutual fund investor purchases or redeems units
of a scheme.
Mutual Funds value their investments on a mark to mark basis with reference to the date on
which they are valued i.e. valuation date. For e.g. if the fund announces its NAV every day, it
will have to value its portfolio daily. The norms of valuation are laid down in SEBI (Mutual
Fund) Regulations 1996.
The most important part of the NAV calculation is the valuation of the assets owned by the
fund. Once it is calculated, the NAV is simply the net value of assets divided by the number of
units outstanding.
Taxation
Mutual funds of all types serve as an important savings tool in two ways: directly, by investing
in them, and indirectly, by offering you various tax benefits.
These tax advantages provided by investing in a mutual fund also give it an edge over certain
comparable investments.
The following is a general description of the tax laws in effect as of the date. Tax laws may
change in the future and the applicability of these laws may vary from person to person,
depending on each particular circumstance.
30
7/29/2019 Mutual Fund as a Tool for Financial Planning
31/88
Mutual Funds as a Tool for Financial Planning
Tax benefits to the Mutual Fund
Under Section 10(23D), Income including Capital Gains earned by Mutual Funds is exempt
from tax.
Tax benefits to the investors
Under Section 10(33), Dividends declared by Mutual Funds are tax-free in the hands of the
investor. Schemes investing 50% or more in equities are exempt from distribution tax. Other
schemes are liable to 20% dividend distribution tax plus surcharge.
Under Section 2(42A), a unit of a mutual fund is treated as a long term capital asset if held
for more than one year.
Under Section 112, capital gains chargeable on transfer of long term capital assets are will
be taxed @ 20% after indexation or @ 10% of capital gains, whichever is lower.
Under Section 194K & 196A, No Tax is deducted at source for income distributed by
mutual funds.
Under Section 88, subscriptions upto Rs. 10,000/- made in an equity linked saving scheme
of a mutual fund will be eligible for 20% rebate.
Short term / Long term Capital Gains and losses can be offset against each other.
31
7/29/2019 Mutual Fund as a Tool for Financial Planning
32/88
Mutual Funds as a Tool for Financial Planning
Investment Management
One foundation on which a mutual fund is built is the portfolio management skills. The
performance of the fund, the returns produced for the investor are accounted for largely by
success in the portfolio management function.
Equity Portfolio Management
A Review of the Indian Equity Market
Mutual fund managers generally invest only in market-traded stocks. Even then, the Indian
fund manager has a vast universe of shares available to him for investment. As of 1999 year-
end, major Indian stock exchanges had over 6400 shares listed. The market capitalization of
all listed stocks now exceeds Rs. 700,000 crores and often approaches Rs. 10 lakh crores.
There are a large number of indices also available, from BSE 30-share index to S&P CNX 500
index. The number of industries or sectors represented in various indices or in the listed
category exceeds 50. Of course, the number of actively traded stocks is smaller, but still
exceeds 1500. BSE has 140 scrips in its Specified Group a list, which are basically large-
capitalization stocks. B 1 Group includes over 1100 stocks, many of which are mid-cap
companies. The rest of the B 2 Group includes over 4500 shares, largely low-capitalization.
NSE has a special mid-cap index that includes selected 50 companies. A fund manger must
review all these candidates to choose from.
Indian economy is going through a period of both rapid growth and rapid transformation. Thus,
the industries with growth prospects or the blue chip shares of yesterday are no longer certain
to continue to be in that category tomorrow. New sectors such as software or technology
32
7/29/2019 Mutual Fund as a Tool for Financial Planning
33/88
Mutual Funds as a Tool for Financial Planning
stocks have emerged recently. In this process of rapid economic change, the stock selection
task of an active fund manager in India is by no means simple of limited.
An equity portfolio managers task consists of two major steps:
Constructing a portfolio of equity shares or equity linked instruments that is consistent with
the investment objective of the fund and
Managing or constantly rebalancing the portfolio to produce capital appreciation and
earnings that would reward the investors with superior returns.
Stock Selection
The equity portfolio manager has available to him a whole universe of equity shares and other
instruments such as preference shares warrants or convertible debentures issued by many
companies. Event within each category of equity instruments, shares of one company may be
very different in terms of their potential than shares of other companies. So, how does the fund
manager go about choosing from the different types of stocks, in order to construct his
portfolio? The general answer is that his choice of shares to be included in a funds portfolio
must reflect the investment objective of the fund. However, more specifically, the equity
portfolio manager will choose from a universe of investible shares in accordance with
The nature of the equity instrument, or a particular stocks unique characteristics, and
A Certain investment style or philosophy in the process of choosing.
Thus, you may see a mutual funds equity portfolio include shares of diverse companies.
However, in reality, the group of stocks selected will have certain unique characteristics,
chosen in accordance with the preferred investment style, such that the portfolio as a whole is
consistent with the schemes objectives. We will now, therefore, review how different stocks
are classified according to their characteristics. Later, we will explain two major investment
styles. But first a short review of the size of the Indian stock markets.
33
7/29/2019 Mutual Fund as a Tool for Financial Planning
34/88
Mutual Funds as a Tool for Financial Planning
Types of Equity Instruments
Ordinary Shares
Ordinary shareholders are the owners of a company, and each share entitles the holder to
ownership privileges such as dividends declared by the company and voting rights at
meetings. Losses as well as profits are shared by the equity shareholders. Without any
guaranteed income or security, equity shares are as risk investment, bringing with them the
potential for capital appreciation in return for the additional risk that the investor undertakes in
comparison to debt instruments with guaranteed income.
Preference Shares
Unlike equity shares, preference shares entitle the holder to dividends at fixed rates subject to
availability of profits after tax. If preference shares are cumulative, unpaid dividends for years
of inadequate profits are paid in subsequent years. Preference shares do not entitle the holder
to ownership privileges such as voting rights at meetings.
Equity Warrants
These are long term rights that offer holders the right to purchase equity shares in a company
at a fixed price (usually higher that the current market price) within a specified period. Warrants
are in the nature of options on stocks.
Equity Classes
34
7/29/2019 Mutual Fund as a Tool for Financial Planning
35/88
Mutual Funds as a Tool for Financial Planning
Equity shares are generally classified on the basis of either the market capitalization or the
anticipated movement of company earnings. It is imperative for a fund manager to understand
these elements of stocks before he select them for inclusion in the portfolio.
INVESTMENT PRODUCTS
Mutual Fund Investment viz. a viz. other products
Physical and Financial Assets
The ranges of investment options available in India cover both physical assets and financial
assets Real estate and Gold are examples of physical assets. Traditionally, gold has been a
favorite asset for many Indians.
In the financial assets category, Indian investors have generally had guaranteed or fixed return
products such as bank deposits, company deposits and Government Savings instruments
such as Public Provident Fund, Indira Vikas Patra and National Savings Certificates.
Financial assets also include capital market securities such as equity/preference shares, and
bonds/debentures issued by companies or financial institutions, money market instruments
such as commercial paper or certificates of deposit. Individual investors can buy capital market
instruments but do not have any direct access to money markets instruments.
Guaranteed and Non-Guaranteed Investments
Quite distinct from the above-described investment instruments are the mutual fund units.
Unlike capital market or money market instruments, where the investor lends directly to the
borrower/ issuer of securities, mutual fund units represent indirect investments through an
intermediary the fund. However, unlike the bank deposits or government savings
35
7/29/2019 Mutual Fund as a Tool for Financial Planning
36/88
Mutual Funds as a Tool for Financial Planning
instruments, where the intermediary or the borrower guarantees the capital protection and
interest rates, investment in a mutual fund is not guaranteed for returns or capital.
The salient features of the investment products available in India are given below.
Physical Assets: Gold and Real Estate
Indians are the largest investors in Gold in its various forms. Investment in Gold is not subject
to erosion on account of rupee depreciation, which is perhaps its biggest advantage.
Historically, Gold has been perceived as a hedge against inflation or as a means of security in
bad times. Hence, investors do not always look for returns while investing in gold. Recently,
the government has deregulated the import of Gold significantly. Nevertheless, it is the
average Indians obsession with Gold that has maintained its place as a key investment option.
An interesting development recently has been the permission by the government for banks to
issue Gold Bonds. These bonds represent securitization of gold. Investors can hold these
bonds and earn some returns, instead of holding the metal and incur costs and risks
associated with storage. The instrument is till in its infancy.
Real estate the also been a preferred investment alternative with the Indian investor. However
the capital required is often beyond the means of the small individual investor. Also, the real
estate market has been in a recession for the past few years, and even during and upswing, it
is not easy to liquidate holdings quickly at an appropriate price. Even high net worth individuals
have tended to keep away from real estate purely as a form of investment.
Once again, for those investors who like investing in real estate, an attractive option may
emerge soon with some Mutual Funds planning to offer Real Estate Mutual Funds an indirect
36
7/29/2019 Mutual Fund as a Tool for Financial Planning
37/88
Mutual Funds as a Tool for Financial Planning
form of investing that still offers to the investors the benefits of both real estate investing and
mutual fund investing.
Financial Assets
Products by Issuer
Issuer Product Available To
Banks Fixed Deposits Investor
Corporate - Shares
- Bonds, Debentures
- Fixed Deposits
- Investor, MFs
- Investor, MFs
- Investor, MFsGovernment - Govt. Securities
-PPF
-
- Investor, MFs
-Investor
FIs - Bonds - Investor, MFs
Insurance Cos - Insurance Policies - Investor
Banks
Bank deposits have been a favored investment option with the India investor, mainly because
of the liquidity and safety benefits they offer. Most Indian banks are promoted either by the
government or by leading financial institutions. The liquidity and safety offered by banks does
however come at a price. Yield on bank deposits is negligible after accounting for inflation and
tax. While the bank guarantees the return of the capital, deposit is not a secured investment,
its perceived safety coming from the soundness of the bank management or ownership.
Investors should be advised to park only a part of the savings in bank deposits
37
7/29/2019 Mutual Fund as a Tool for Financial Planning
38/88
Mutual Funds as a Tool for Financial Planning
Corporate Papers
Securities available in the capital market include equity instruments, debt instruments and
quasi debt-quasi equity instruments issued by companies.
Equity instruments are in the form of shares in companies either issued privately and unlisted,
or issued publicly and listed on a stock exchange(s). The investor may acquire such shares,
either at the time of the initial public offering by the company or subsequently, though the stock
exchanges at which they are listed. The benefit of investing in equities is the high growth
potential that this avenue offers. Also, the listing at stock exchanges ensures a high degree of
liquidity. Historically, equities have yielded the highest return as compared to other investment
options. However, for the individual investor, it is challenge to identify shares which are likely to
appreciate in value, and even if the succeeds in doing so, he may be unable to raise capital
that is required to develop a diversified portfolio. Besides, a risk-averse investor should be
advised to refrain from investing heavily in the equity market.
The corporate borrowers- companies- also issue debentures paying fixed rates of interest. In
India, these debentures are generally secured by the assets of the borrower. However, credit
standing of the borrower has to be determined with the help of the credit rating that a particular
debentures issue is given by a rating agency. Companies pay different rates of interest
depending upon how strong their rating or their market acceptance is. Borrowers with lower
rating need to pay higher interest. Companies can also issue unsecured bonds, like Financial
Institutions, though the instrument will not be called a debenture.
Both bonds and debentures may be subscribed to either in a private placement or in a public
issue. Many companies privately issue debt securities with less than 18 months maturity; as
such issues are exempt from the requirement of credit rating. Investors need to be extremely
careful about such investment and need to be sure that the issuing company is really
38
7/29/2019 Mutual Fund as a Tool for Financial Planning
39/88
Mutual Funds as a Tool for Financial Planning
creditworthy. Public issues and other private issues have to be rated, so some guidance is
available to the investor to judge the risk of default by the borrower.
Investing in company fixed deposits is yet another avenue available in the market. While
company fixed deposits may carry a higher rate of interest as compared to bank deposits, they
are also an unsecured investment. Each companys deposits must be evaluated with reference
to the risk rating assigned to them by credit rating agencies such as Crisil, ICRA and CARE.
Also, the tax effect could make the net returns on these instruments less attractive than other
debt instruments.
Financial Institutions
In recent times, financial institutions such as ICICI and IDBI have issued bonds on a regular
basis. Sometimes, these are general-purpose bonds issued to augment their resources.
Sometimes, they are issued with the intent of financing infrastructure development in the
country. These bonds are available for investment in the form of alternate options. One option
allows the investor to receive periodic interest payments (monthly, quarterly, and annually)
over the term of the instrument. The deep discount option does not pay interest on a periodic
basis. Instead, it yields a redemption value, which is higher than the issue price, the difference
being chargeable to tax as interest. Both options qualify for tax rebate under Section 88 of the
Income Tax Act. Deduction of interest income under Section 80L is not applicable. The Third
option gives interest at periodic interval and qualifies as investment specified under Section
54EA/EB of the Income Tax Act. Institution bond schemes usually have 3, 5, 10 and 15- year
maturities with annualized compounded returns ranging between 11% and 12.5%. A savvy
investment approach can make these bonds a very attractive investment option. It must be
noted that these bonds are unsecured.
39
7/29/2019 Mutual Fund as a Tool for Financial Planning
40/88
Mutual Funds as a Tool for Financial Planning
Government
Public Provident Fund
Public Provident Fund is a government obligation, hence virtually risk-free. Besides, tax-free
interest of 12% p.a. and contributions up to Rs.60000/- eligible for tax rebate under Section 88,
make the Public Provident Fund (PPF) one of the best options available to the investor. An
individual is allowed only one account in his name. The scheme requires annual contributions
(between Rs.100 and Rs.60000) to be made over 16 years, with the option to withdraw 50% of
the 4th year balance in the 7th year. Assured tax-free interest, which can be compounded over
16 years, makes this scheme a truly attractive option. There are restrictions on withdrawals,
which does reduce liquidity for the investor.
Indira and Kisan Vikas Patra
These were originally introduced as post office schemes in order to tap savings in rural India,
but also became popular with urban investors. However, their current yield (12.25% over 6
years, fully taxable) has made them unattractive. Nevertheless, Indira Vikas Patra continues
to appeal to investors with unaccounted income because the post office does not record the
identity of the investor. Consequently, they are easily transferable and liquid.
Other Scheme from National Savings Organization.
Besides PPF and Indira Vikas Patra, the NSO offers schemes such as post office accounts,
recurring deposits, relief bonds and the scheme for retiring government employees. However
these schemes have ceased to be attractive after the advent of PPF and institutional bonds.
Government Securities.
This is government paper normally issued on a long-term basis and defines the yield curve to
a great extent. Only primary dealers specially appointed for this purpose deal in government
40
7/29/2019 Mutual Fund as a Tool for Financial Planning
41/88
Mutual Funds as a Tool for Financial Planning
securities. From the individual investors perspective, government securities are not a direct
investment and are accessible through mutual funds.
Life Insurance
Life insurance in India was monopoly of the Life Insurance Corporation of India (LIC), till
government decided to privatize the Life Insurance.
LIC offers two types of policies- without profits and with profits. A without profits policy
purchased by an individual promises to pay a certain sum of money (the sum assured) to his
survivor nominated by him in the event of his death within a specified period (the term of the
Policy). If the individual services the term of the policy, he does not receive anything. A with
profits policy not only pays the sum assured in the event of death during the policy term, but
also pays a bonus as declared by LIC from year to year. If the individual services the term of
the policy, he receives the sum assured plus bonus accrued. Most policies require the
individual to pay a fixed premium on a yearly basis. If the individual decides to discontinue the
policy during its tenure, he would be entitled to the policys surrender value, which is a percent
of premium paid till date.
In India, life insurance is viewed more as an investment option than as a vehicle for risk
protection. In fact, very few individuals evaluate the need for insurance. Instead, they tend to
opt for it on account of tax benefits. Premium paid on life insurance qualifies for tax rebate
under Section 88 and proceeds at the time of death or maturity are exempt from tax. Certain
investors prefer life insurance because it acts as a forced saving (the policy would lapse if
annual premium is not paid to LIC). However, a careful evaluation of life insurance reveals
that the opportunity cost is significant when compared to other secure investment such as
PPF. It is important for an individual to evaluate the need for insurance with respect to his
earning potential and the financial impact on his dependents in the event of his untimely death.
Proceeds in the event of his surviving the term of the policy do not make insurance a
41
7/29/2019 Mutual Fund as a Tool for Financial Planning
42/88
Mutual Funds as a Tool for Financial Planning
worthwhile investment. Surrender values paid by LIC are not attractive leading to lengthy
lock-in period. LICs plans also offer very little flexibility and are not attractive due to a lengthy
lock-in period. LICs plans also offer very little flexibility. Therefore, an investor would be well
advised to buy insurance, not just as an investment, but mainly to provide for his dependants
in case of his untimely death.
The table below compares the investment options discussed above under the broad heads viz.
return, safety, volatility, liquidity and convenience.
Products Return Safety Volatility Liquidity Convenience
Equity High Low High High or
Low
Moderate
FI Bonds Moderate High Moderate Moderate High
Corporate
Debenture
Moderate Moderate Moderate Low Low
Company Fixed
Deposits
Moderate Low Low Low Moderate
Bank Deposits Low High Low High HighPPF Moderate High Low Moderate HighLife Insurance Low High Low Low ModerateGold Moderate High Moderate Moderate LowReal Estate High Moderate High Low LowMutual Funds High High Moderate High High
Although the table provides a qualitative evaluation of various financial products, the
comparison serves as a useful guide towards determining the best option.
It is clear from the above that equity investing in general has good potential in terms of return,
liquidity and convenience. However, individual stocks can give varied performance, one stock
being more liquid than another or one stock giving lower return than another. For this reason,
equity investing is fraught with risk and is not ideal for every individual investor. It is
recommended only for investors who are willing to invest the time required for research in
42
7/29/2019 Mutual Fund as a Tool for Financial Planning
43/88
Mutual Funds as a Tool for Financial Planning
stock selection (or have access to sound financial advice) and possess the capacity to bear
the inherent risk.
Bonds issued by institutions are an attractive option, particularly now with the liquidity that
accompanies their listing on stock exchanges. Bonds are a stable option in terms of fixed
returns, and are recommended for the risk-averse investor. However, bonds can lose value
when general interest rates go up. Bonds are also subject to credit risk or risk of default by the
borrower. In case of corporate bonds, the risk must be assessed in terms of the strength of
the borrower as indicated by the credit rating assigned to the bonds. In the absence of credit
rating, it is extremely difficult for the investor to decide on the quality of the bonds or
debentures. The secondary market in corporate bonds in India is also very thin, leading to
lack of liquidity for the investors who wish to sell.
Company fixed deposits fall short on several counts and are recommended only if the issuing
company and the deposits on offer are rated highly by credit rating agencies.
The major advantage of bank deposits relative to other products is the liquidity they offer.
Banks are usually willing to give loans against fixed deposits at a nominal charge over the
interest rate applicable to the deposits. Deposits rates offered by banks vary as per RBI
directives and the interest rate scenario in the economy. Bank deposits score high on safety,
as the return of capital is guaranteed to the depositor by the bank. However, the financial
soundness of the bank is important to look at.
PPF combines stability with a respectable return. Its tax-exempt status makes it an attractive
mechanism for the small investor to build his savings portfolio. However the lock in period
involved in PPF means that the investor loses out in terms of liquidity, particularly during the
early years of the scheme. Being a government supported investment, PPF scores very high
on safety, compared even to bank deposits.
43
7/29/2019 Mutual Fund as a Tool for Financial Planning
44/88
Mutual Funds as a Tool for Financial Planning
Insurance could become a serious investment vehicle once the insurance market in India is
opened to private players. In todays scenario the opportunity cost in terms of return is too high
for insurance to be compared on even terms with the other option. Its liquidity is also
extremely low, though safety is considered high at present for the government-owned LIC as
the only insurer.
Direct Equity Investment versus Mutual Fund Investing.
As mentioned earlier, investors have the option to invest directly in equities through the stock
market instead of investing through mutual funds. However, a practical evaluation reveals that
mutual funds are indeed a more recommended option for the individual investor. A
comparison between the two options is given below:
Identifying stocks that have growth potential is a difficult process involving detailed
research and monitoring of the market. Mutual Funds specialize in this area and possess the
requisite resources to carry out research and continuous market monitoring. This is clearly
beyond the capability of most individual investors.
Another critical element towards successful equity investing is diversification. A
diversified portfolio serves to minimize risk by ensuring that a downtrend in some
securities/sectors is offset by an upswing in the others. Clearly, diversification requires
substantial investment that may be beyond the means of most individual investors. Mutual
funds pool the resources of many investors and thus have the funds necessary to build a
diversified portfolio, and by investing even a small amount in a mutual fund, an investor can,
through his proportionate share, reap the benefit of diversification.
Mutual funds specialize in the business of investment management, and therefore
employ professional management for carrying out their activities. Professional management
ensures that the best investment avenues are tapped with the aid of comprehensive
information and detailed research. It also ensures that expenses are kept under tight control
44
7/29/2019 Mutual Fund as a Tool for Financial Planning
45/88
Mutual Funds as a Tool for Financial Planning
and market opportunities are fully utilized. An investor who opts for direct equity investing
loses out on these benefits.
Mutual funds focus their investment activities based on investment objectives such as
income, growth or tax savings. An investor can choose a fund that has investment objectives
in line with his objectives. Therefore, funds provide the investor with a vehicle to attain his
objectives in a planned manner.
Mutual funds offer liquidity through listing on stock exchange (for closed-end funds) and
repurchase options (for open-end funds). This is in contrast to direct equity investing where
several stocks are often not traded for long periods
Direct equity investing involves a high level of transaction costs per rupee invested in
the form of brokerage, commissions, stamp duty, etc. While mutual funds charge a
management fee, they succeed in keeping transaction costs under control because of the
economies of scale they enjoy.
In terms of convenience, mutual funds score over direct equity investing. Funds serve
investors not only through their investor services networks, but also through associates such
as banks and other distributors. Many funds allow investors the flexibility to switch between
schemes within a family of funds. They also offer facilities such as check writing and
accumulation plans. These benefits are not matched by direct equity investing.
It is clear that investing through mutual funds is far superior to direct investing except
perhaps for the investor who has truly large portfolio and the time, knowledge and resources
required for direct investing.
Bank Deposits versus Debt Funds
It needs to be understood that bank deposits cater to a segment of the investor class that
looks for safety and accepts a relatively lower return. Equity Funds cannot clearly be
compared with the bank deposits, as investors can expect higher returns from equity funds
only at the risk of losing part of the capital also. Given the risks, Indian investors are currently
45
7/29/2019 Mutual Fund as a Tool for Financial Planning
46/88
Mutual Funds as a Tool for Financial Planning
investing heavily in debt funds. However, before a bank depositor considers shifting his funds
to debt funds, he should compare the two in a meaningful manner.
A bank deposit is guaranteed by the bank for repayment of principal and interest. Any risks
associated with investment of the investors funds have to be borne by the bank. The depositor
has a contractual commitment from the bank to pay. A mutual fund, on the other hand, invests
at the risk of the investor. Hence, there is no contractual guarantee for repayment of principal
or interest to the investor.
The bank depositor does not directly hold the bank portfolio of investment, as he does in case
of a fund. The investor needs to assess the risk in terms of the credit rating of the bank, which
provides an indication of the financial soundness of the bank. However, a debt fund is not
rated by any agency. The investor has to assess the risk on the portfolio held by the fund. The
investor needs to know whether the fund invests in high quality assets or lower rated debt.
Unlike in case of bank deposits, therefore, the investor needs to know his own investment
objective and risk appetite before investing in a debt fund. The expected returns will be
commensurate with the level of risk assumed by the fund.
It can be seen that the bank deposits are not totally free from risk, while generally giving lower
returns. A conservative debt fund can give higher returns than a bank deposit, even if there is
no contractual guarantee as in a deposit. Investors seeking higher returns form the capital
market securities, a diversified debt portfolio while still investing small amounts and a portfolio
that matches his objective and risk appetite is well advised to consider part of his investment in
debt funds.
The Investor Perspective: Funds vs. Other Products
Product Investment Objective Risk
Tolerance
Investment
HorizonEquity Capital Appreciation High Long Term
46
7/29/2019 Mutual Fund as a Tool for Financial Planning
47/88
Mutual Funds as a Tool for Financial Planning
FI Bonds Income Low Medium to
Long TermCorporate Debentures Income H-M-Low The Same
Company Fixed Deposits Income The Same MediumBank Deposits Income Generally
Low
Flexible
All TermsPPF Income Low Long Term
Life Insurance Risk Cover Low Long Term
Gold Inflation Hedge Low Long Term
Real Estate Inflation Hedge Low Long Term
Mutual Funds Capital Growth,
Income
H-M- Low Flexible
All Terms
The comparison above highlights the flexibility offered by mutual funds from the investors
perspective. An investor can choose form a wide variety of funds to suit his risk tolerance,
investment horizon and investment objective. Bank deposits offer similar flexibility in
investment horizon and risk level, but only a fixed income. An investor looking for capital
growth has to potential, but a high risk and without the benefit of diversification and
professional management offered by mutual funds. Gold and real estate are attractive only in
high inflation economies. Other options are largely for the risk-averse, income-oriented
investor. Mutual funds present the widest choice to the investors.
Mutual Funds the best Investment Option
From the comparative analysis provided above, it emerges that each investment alternative
has its strengths and weakness. Some options seek to achieve superior returns (e.g. equity),
but with correspondingly higher risk. Others provide safety (such as PPF), but at the expense
of liquidity and growth. Options such as bank deposits offer safety and liquidity, but at the cost
of return. Mutual funds seek to combine the advantages of investing, in each of these
alternatives, while dispensing with the shortcomings. Clearly, it is in the investors interest to
focus his investment on mutual funds.
47
7/29/2019 Mutual Fund as a Tool for Financial Planning
48/88
Mutual Funds as a Tool for Financial Planning
However, a note of caution is in order. While the mutual funds are one of the best options for
the individual small investor, there are many mutual funds already available for the investor to
choose from. It must be realized that the performance of different funds varies form time to
time. Also, the Indian mutual fund sector has been in an evolving phase over the past five
years during which time several investors have encountered some poorly performing funds,
while others have been fortunate to be with good performers. Besid
Recommended