View
1
Download
0
Category
Preview:
Citation preview
D1.2 Analy
preventive
Impr
D
Lead bene
Delivery da
Revision:
Dissemin
PU: Publi
PP: Restr
RE: Restr
ysis of the c
activities
roving the
D1.2 Ana
eficiary:
ate:
nation Leve
c
ricted to oth
ricted to a g
current
e Effective
alysis o
Crisis
M6
6.0
el
her program
group specif
PRO
eness of C
of the cu
Manageme
mme particip
fied by the c
Public
OJECT TITL
Capabilitie
urrent p
ent Centre F
pants (includ
consortium
LE:
s (IEC) in
preventi
Finland (CM
ding the Co
(including t
S
EU conflic
ve activ
MC Finland)
mmission)
the Commis
Contract
Start date:
Duration:
ct prevent
vities
)
ssion)
IECEU
no 653371
01/05/2015
33 months
tion
X
5
s
Analysis of
T
Revision
Rev. D
1.0 0
2.0
3.0
4.0 0
5.0 2
Master 2
Master 2
Master 2
Master 2
Master 3
6.0 0
f the curren
This project has rece
n history
Date
03/07/2015
13/08/2015
14/08/2015
05/09/2015
2/10/2015
22/10/2015
27/10/2015
28/10/2015
29/10/2015
30/10/2015
09/10/2015
nt preventive
eived funding from the
Autho
5 CMCF
CMCF
CMCF
CMCF
CMCF
CMCF
CMCF
CMCFMänty
UNILJ
CMCF
LAU,
e activities
e European Union’s
or
Fi, J. Musto
Fi, J. Musto
Fi, J. Musto
Fi, J. Musto
Fi, J. Musto
Fi, J. Musto
Fi, J. Musto
Fi, J. Mustoymäki
JU, R. Zupa
Fi, J. Musto
K. Hyttinen
PU
Horizon 2020 resear
onen
onen
onen
onen
onen
onen
onen
onen & E.
ančič
onen
rch and innovation pr
Notes
Template c
Formulatinfirst texts: iavailable b
Inserting ch
Inserting chactivities by
Adding the
Inserting EConclusion
Incorporatiworkshop f
Final comm
Final comm
Finalisation
Final Versi
S
rogramme under gra
creation
g the contentroductiony 31 Augus
hapter on P
hapter 2 ony Rok
intro text
xecutive Suns -chapters
ng the survfindings
ments to the
ments to the
n of the deli
on to be su
CSA projeStart date:
Duration:
ant agreement No 653
ent, insertingn texts to best
PS by Arnold
n Preventive
ummary ands
vey and
e draft
e draft
iverable
ubmitted
IECEU ect: 65337101/05/2015 33 months
3371 2
g the e
d
e
d
5 s
2
Analysis of
T
Content
EXECUTIV
ACRONYM
1 INTROD
1.1 PREVE
1.2 STR
2 EU PREV
2.1 CUR
2.2 CHA
2.2.1 P
2.2.2 M
2.2.3 D
2.2.4 Cpreven
2.2.5 O
2.2.6 R
2.2.7 R
2.3 CON
3 POOLIN
3.1 INTR
3.2 DEF
3.3 POO
3.4 THE
3.5 CUR
3.6 CON
4. CONCL
BIBLIOGR
ANNEXES
f the curren
This project has rece
ts
VE SUMMA
MS
UCTION
ENTIVE AC
UCTURE O
VENTIVE A
RRENT PRE
ALLENGES
Planning an
Mandates
Deployment
Cooperationntion and cr
One nation’s
Relations be
Relations be
NCLUSION
G AND SHA
RODUCTIO
INITIONS A
OLING AND
FOUR LEV
RRENT DEB
NCLUSION
USIONS
RAPHY
S
nt preventive
eived funding from the
ARY
CTIVITIES A
OF THE DE
ACTIVITIES
EVENTIVE
IN CSDP M
nd setting up
t
n of CSDPrisis manage
s or the EU
etween the
etween the
ARING WIT
N
AND FORM
SHARING
VELS OF P
BATES AND
e activities
e European Union’s
AND CONFL
LIVERABLE
S AND CHA
INSTRUME
MISSIONS A
p a mission
P missions ement
’s mission o
CSDP miss
CSDP miss
THIN THE E
MS OF COO
WITHIN ED
OLITICAL R
D FUTURE
PU
Horizon 2020 resear
LICT PREV
E
ALLENGES
ENTS AND
AND OPER
or operatio
and operat
or operation
sion or oper
sion/operati
EU
OPERATION
DA
RISKS IN P
POSSIBILI
rch and innovation pr
VENTION
AHEAD
ACTIVITIE
RATIONS: K
on
tions with o
n?
ration and “
ion and the
N
P&S
ITIES IN P&
S
rogramme under gra
S
KEY OBSER
other actors
Brussels”
local stake
&S
CSA projeStart date:
Duration:
ant agreement No 653
RVATIONS
s involved
eholders
IECEU ect: 65337101/05/2015 33 months
3371 3
5
6
8
8
1
1
1
1
1
2
2
in conflict 2
2
2
3
3
3
3
3
3
4
4
5
5
5
6
5 s
3
0
2
3
9
9
1
3
5
6
9
1
2
5
5
7
9
2
8
1
4
7
3
Analysis of
T
Annexe
Annex 1. O
Annex 2. O
Annex 3. PFixed Resp
Annex 4. PResponse S
List of f
Figure 1. E
Figure 2. E
Figure 3. P
Figure 4. T
f the curren
This project has rece
s
Online Surv
Online Surv
Presentationponse Segm
PresentationSegments
figures
Excerpts of t
Excerpts of t
Priority list o
The levels o
nt preventive
eived funding from the
vey on EU c
vey on EU p
n of results oments
n of results o
the civilian
the military
of the Capa
of political r
e activities
e European Union’s
conflict prev
pooling and
of the Onlin
of the Onlin
CSDP miss
y CSDP ope
ability Deve
isk in pooli
PU
Horizon 2020 resear
vention instr
sharing
ne Survey o
ne Survey o
sions' mand
erations' ma
elopment Pla
ing and shar
rch and innovation pr
ruments
n EU Confl
n EU Poolin
dates
ndates
an
ring
S
rogramme under gra
lict Preventi
ng and Shar
CSA projeStart date:
Duration:
ant agreement No 653
ion Instrum
ring - Fixed
IECEU ect: 65337101/05/2015 33 months
3371 4
ments -
d
5 s
4
Analysis of
T
EXECUT
The purpo
the Delive
(IECEU) p
preventive
crises. In a
activities, t
The report
prevention
analysis d
surveys, in
tanks expr
and sharin
The curren
term, conf
activities o
assessmen
conducted
and Defen
visible par
role as a to
a clearer m
One possi
and conce
and foremo
around na
application
manageme
logistics ha
capabilities
f the curren
This project has rece
TIVE SUM
se of the re
rable 1.1 o
project and
activities t
addition, in
the report w
t is based
activities b
eriving from
n which EU
ressed their
g within the
nt preventiv
flict prevent
of the EU c
nts, diplo
as part of t
ce Policy (C
rt of the EU
ool of EU co
mandate and
bility to imp
pt of poolin
ost, pooling
tional sove
n. Utilising
ent and con
ave been id
s.
nt preventive
eived funding from the
MMARY
eport "Analy
of the “Imp
to presen
that the EU
relation to i
will introduce
on the rev
by the EU,
m this desk
officials, m
r perception
e EU.
ve activities
tion and op
can be outli
omatic mea
the Commo
CSDP) miss
U's conflict p
onflict preve
d improving
prove the a
ng and shar
g and sharin
ereignty - o
the princip
nflict preven
dentified as
e activities
e European Union’s
lysis of curr
roving Effe
nt the curre
U employs
mproving th
e the conce
view of exi
including p
k study pha
ember state
ns of the EU
s of the EU
perational, s
ined as inc
sures, med
on Foreign a
sions and o
prevention
ention, coul
g their cohe
activities of
ing which a
ng applies to
r the loss t
ple could b
ntion where
s potential
PU
Horizon 2020 resear
rent preven
ectiveness o
ent activitie
as part of
he utilisatio
ept of poolin
isting literat
pooling and
ase is com
e represent
U conflict pre
can be ca
short-term c
cluding, but
diation, dem
and Securit
operations.
activities, t
ld be furthe
rence as pa
the EU in c
aims to impr
o defence c
thereof - ha
be expand
e, inter alia,
areas that
rch and innovation pr
ntive activitie
of Capabili
es of the E
its respons
n of EU con
ng and shari
ture and re
sharing of
plemented
tatives and
evention ac
ategorised a
conflict prev
not limiting
marches, st
ty Policy su
Whilst CSD
he conduct
er developed
art of overa
conflict pre
rove the av
cooperation
ave been th
ded also to
training an
could bene
S
rogramme under gra
es of the E
ties of EU
EU in confl
se to intern
nflict preven
ing within th
esearch on
capabilities
with the fin
members o
ctivities and
as represen
vention. Th
g to: Early
tatements,
ch as the E
DP actions a
t of CSDP
d for instanc
ll EU contrib
vention is t
ailability of
in which co
he key con
o the conte
nd recruitme
efit from po
CSA projeStart date:
Duration:
ant agreement No 653
EU" is to co
Conflict Pr
flict prevent
national con
ntion capab
he EU.
n the curren
s within the
ndings of tw
of the acade
the other o
nting structu
he current p
warning an
as well as
EU Common
are but one
missions, a
ce by provid
bution.
to foster the
EU capabil
ontext cons
nstraint for
ext of civil
ent of perso
ooling and s
IECEU ect: 65337101/05/2015 33 months
3371 5
mplement
revention”
tion - the
nflicts and
bilities and
nt conflict
e EU. The
wo online
emia/think
on pooling
ural, long-
preventive
nd conflict
s activities
n Security
e although
as well as
ding them
e practice
ities. First
iderations
its proper
lian crisis
onnel and
sharing of
5 s
5
Analysis of
T
ACRONY
AAR
AWACS
BENESAM
CDP
CFSP
CMPD
CPCC
CSDP
DEVCO
DRC
ECHO
EDA
EEAS
ENP
ESDC
ESDP
ESCPC
EUMC
EUMS
EULEX
EUSR
HTP
HR/VP
f the curren
This project has rece
YMS
Air
Air
M Bel
Cap
Com
Cri
Civ
Com
Dir
The
HuCom
Eur
Eur
Eur
Eur
Eur
Eur
Eur
EU
Eur
Eur
He
Hig
Pol
nt preventive
eived funding from the
r to air refue
rborne Warn
lgian-Dutch
pability Dev
mmon Fore
isis Manage
vilian Plann
mmon Secu
rectorate Ge
e Democrat
umanitarian mmunity H
ropean Defe
ropean Exte
ropean Neig
ropean Secu
ropean Secu
ropean Sate
ropean Unio
U Military S
ropean Unio
ropean Unio
licopter Tra
gh Represen
licy/Vice-Pr
e activities
e European Union’s
elling
ning and Co
h Naval Coo
velopment P
eign and Sec
ement and P
ning and Con
urity and De
eneral for In
tic Republic
Aid and Humanitarian
ence Acade
ernal Action
ghbourhood
urity and De
urity and De
ellite Comm
on Military
taff
on Rule of L
on Special R
aining Progr
ntative of th
resident of t
PU
Horizon 2020 resear
ontrol Syste
operation
Plan
curity Polic
Planning Dir
nduct Capa
efence Polic
nternational
c of the Con
Civil Proten Aid Offic
emy
n Service
d Policy
efence Coll
efence Polic
munications
Committee
Law Missio
Representat
ramme
he Union for
the Europea
rch and innovation pr
em
cy
rectorate
ability
cy
l Cooperatio
ngo
ection (forme)
lege
cy
Procuremen
e
on in Kosov
tive
r Foreign A
an Commiss
S
rogramme under gra
on and Deve
merly know
nt Cell
vo
Affairs and S
sion
CSA projeStart date:
Duration:
ant agreement No 653
elopment
wn as the
Security
IECEU ect: 65337101/05/2015 33 months
3371 6
European
5 s
6
Analysis of
T
IcSP
IECEU
ISR
MARSUR
MONUC
NATO
NORDEFC
OHQ
OPCEN
OSCE
P&S
PESCO
PFCA
PSC
R&D
RAF
RCA
SATCOM
SSR
TEU
UAV
UN
VAT
WP
f the curren
This project has rece
Ins
Imp
Inte
Ma
Un
No
CO No
Op
Op
Org
Poo
Per
Pol
Pol
Res
Roy
Cen
Sat
Sec
Tre
Un
Un
Va
Wo
nt preventive
eived funding from the
strument con
proving the
elligence, S
aritime Surv
nited Nation
orth Atlantic
ordic Defenc
peration Hea
perations Ce
ganisation f
oling and sh
rmanent Str
litical Fram
litical and S
search and D
yal Air Forc
ntral Africa
tellite Comm
curity Secto
eaty on Euro
nmanned aer
nited Nation
lue-added t
orking Pack
e activities
e European Union’s
ntributing to
Effectivene
Surveillance
veillance
ns Organizat
c Treaty Org
ce Cooperat
adquarters
entre
for Security
haring
ructured Coo
mework for C
Security Com
Developme
ce
an Republic
munications
or Reform
opean Unio
rial vehicle
ns
ax
kage
PU
Horizon 2020 resear
o Stability a
ess of Capa
e and Recon
tion Mission
ganisation
tion
y and Co-op
operation
Crisis Appro
mmittee
ent
(Républiqu
s
on
rch and innovation pr
and Peace
abilities in E
nnaissance
n in the Dem
eration in E
oach
ue centrafric
S
rogramme under gra
EU Conflict
mocratic Re
Europe
caine)
CSA projeStart date:
Duration:
ant agreement No 653
t Prevention
epublic of th
IECEU ect: 65337101/05/2015 33 months
3371 7
n
he Congo
5 s
7
Analysis of
T
INTROD
1.1 PREV
Conflict pre
as accord
strengthen
the horrors
conflicts is
successful
rights, just
As an inte
EU's Com
Security an
since the
capacities
manageme
interventio
The EU in
prevention
conflict pre
only one li
term activit
The overa
part of the
activities u
conflict pre
1 Article 21 o2 Draft Europ2001. 3 Janina JohPublication o57. 4 The definitio
f the curren
This project has rece
UCTION
VENTIVE A
evention is
ding to the
n internation
s of the Se
s by default
example o
ice and soli
gral part of
mmon Forei
nd Defence
outset aim
in conflict p
ent has bee
ns within th
terpretation
, and on th
evention.3 It
mited instru
ties, CSDP
ll objective
e project, th
under the E
evention ins
f the Lisbon T
pean Union Pr
hannsen, Theof the Institute
ons have been
nt preventive
eived funding from the
ACTIVITIE
considered
e Lisbon T
nal security"
econd World
t at the ver
of conflict p
darity, econ
f the extern
ign and Se
e Policy (sin
med at stre
prevention a
en primarily
he framewor
n is that cris
he other han
t must be e
ument of th
instrument
of the IEC
e task at h
European E
struments. W
Treaty. ogramme for t
e EU's Compre for Peace Re
n presented in
e activities
e European Union’s
ES AND C
d a key obje
Treaty "the
"1. It can be
d War, and
y heart of t
prevention,
nomic prosp
nal relations
ecurity Poli
nce 2009 th
engthening
and crisis m
y – but not e
rk of the CS
sis manage
nd, CSDP c
emphasised
e EU in reg
s contribute
EU project
and aims to
External Ac
Whilst the lo
the Prevention
rehensive Apesearch and S
n detail in the
PU
Horizon 2020 resear
ONFLICT
ective of the
EU shall…
e said that
d therefore
the Union a
based on
perity and s
s of the EU
icy (CFSP)
he Common
the capac
managemen
exclusively
SDP, and th
ement in its
capabilities
d, however
gard to con
e to the so c
is to enha
o address a
ction Servic
ong-term co
n of Violent Co
pproach to CrSecurity Policy
project deliver
rch and innovation pr
PREVENT
e EU's exter
…preserve
the historic
the idea of
and its acti
democratic
sustainable
, conflict pr
) and the
n Security a
ity of the
nt. In the E
– used in r
he IECEU p
s broad inte
are by and
r, that CSD
flict preven
called opera
nce EU con
and presen
ce (EEAS),
onflict preve
onflicts, Coun
risis Managemy at the Unive
rable 1.1.
S
rogramme under gra
TION
rnal relation
peace, pr
cal roots of
f preventing
ons. The E
values and
developme
revention h
developme
and Defence
EU to take
EU context,
reference to
roject follow
erpretation a
d large inten
P missions
tion. Prima
ational conf
nflict preven
t the curren
including s
ention instru
cil of the EU, 9
ment. Premisersity of Hamb
CSA projeStart date:
Duration:
ant agreement No 653
ns and forei
revent con
the EU are
g further br
EU prides it
d respect f
ent"2.
has also bee
ent of the
e Policy, C
e action th
the concep
o military an
w this unde
also include
nded to con
s and opera
rily linked w
flict prevent
ntion capab
nt conflict p
short and
uments will
9537/1/01 RE
ses, Ambitionsburg: Volume
IECEU ect: 65337101/05/2015 33 months
3371 8
ign policy,
flicts and
e linked to
reakout of
tself as "a
for human
en part of
European
SDP) has
hrough its
pt of crisis
nd civilian
rstanding.
es conflict
ntribute to
ations are
with short-
ion4.
bilities. As
prevention
long term
be briefly
EV 1, 7 June
s, Limits (A 204, 2011),
5 s
8
Analysis of
T
presented,
in line with
examples
can be use
better con
practices b
missions a
This task w
EU policy
and aims t
prevention
missions a
considered
prevention
security th
task in gen
more cybe
also have
East.5
The surve
increase, a
regarding
borders of
as an instr
identified f
general, it
at the foref
Furthermo
context of
aims to id
5 IECEU Onli6 Ibid.
f the curren
This project has rece
, the focus
h the objec
of success
ed to suppo
ntributing to
by which th
and operatio
will build on
priorities, i
to identify a
. In this reg
and operatio
d. As part
capabilitie
reats and c
neral sugge
er and relat
religious o
ey responde
and that cris
CSDP miss
Europe. It
rument migh
future threa
was observ
front of CSD
re, the deliv
the EU. In
dentify the
ine Survey on
nt preventive
eived funding from the
of this stud
ctives of the
sful EU ope
ort and stre
o conflict p
e EU has a
ons. Therefo
the review
nstruments
areas of fu
gard, the po
ons to incre
of the proj
es and CSD
conflict scen
est that futu
te to migrat
r cultural o
ents also f
ses and con
sions theref
was also n
ht not be pr
ats, such a
ved that ma
DP activities
verable at h
addition to
potential of
EU Conflict P
e activities
e European Union’s
y yet rema
e IECEU pr
erations and
engthen EU
prevention.
already bee
ore, this asp
and analys
and capab
rther streng
otential of, a
asingly con
jects' forwa
DP instrum
narios. The
ure conflict
tion. Accord
origins and
foresaw tha
nflicts are b
fore is that
oted that th
repared to d
as uncontro
aritime secu
s.6
hand will pr
o introducing
f increased
Prevention Ins
PU
Horizon 2020 resear
ins on the o
roject; one
d mission in
missions a
This woul
en contribut
pect will be
sis, conduct
bilities in co
gthening an
and opportu
ntribute to c
ard looking
ments also
results of t
scenarios
ding to the
their geogr
at "non-stat
becoming clo
new missio
he Petersbe
deal with no
ollable flow
urity and/or
resent the c
g the conce
d applicatio
struments.
rch and innovation pr
operational
of which is
n order to i
and operatio
d include
ed to confli
addressed
ted under T
onflict prev
nd developi
nities for cu
onflict preve
g stance, th
needs to ta
the online e
concerning
survey res
raphical foc
te" threats
oser to the
ons might h
erg tasks w
on-state thre
w of refuge
border ma
concept of
ept of pooli
on of poolin
S
rogramme under gra
conflict pre
s to identify
dentify way
ons in the f
identifying
ct preventio
in the study
ask 1.1 of t
ention and
ng of EU c
urrent CSDP
ention will a
he develop
ake accoun
expert surve
g the EU wi
pondents, f
cus will be
such as te
EU. One of
have to be c
ere still vali
eats. With re
es or large
nagement w
pooling and
ng and sha
ng and sha
CSA projeStart date:
Duration:
ant agreement No 653
evention. Th
y and collec
ys and met
future, with
good meth
on through
y.
the project,
preventive
capabilities
P crisis man
also be iden
pment of E
nt of possi
ey conducte
ill be more
future confl
in Africa an
errorism co
f the future
conducted
id but that t
regard to so
e scale mi
would conti
d sharing (P
aring, the d
aring princip
IECEU ect: 65337101/05/2015 33 months
3371 9
his is also
ct positive
thods that
a view to
hods and
its CSDP
of current
e activities
in conflict
nagement
ntified and
U conflict
ble future
ed for this
complex,
licts could
nd Middle
ontinue to
scenarios
within the
the CSDP
ome of the
gration in
inue to be
PS) in the
eliverable
ple in the
5 s
9
Analysis of
T
context of
primarily li
potentially
would be
manageme
pooling an
better cont
1.2 STRU
The delive
activities o
provides a
EU, and f
analysing
missions a
emerging
Working P
effectivene
Asia. Buil
opportuniti
prevention
expert pan
manageme
themes tha
Chapter 3
defining th
7 As part of thwithin the EUwere sent viaand Europeaof Septemberather low, brespondents Responses a
8 A small scanon-EU coun
f the curren
This project has rece
f civilian cr
inked with
be utilised
in line wit
ent: instead
d sharing (
tribute to co
UCTURE O
erable will i
of the EU (C
an outline o
focuses on
lessons ide
and operatio
lessons fro
Packages (W
ess of selec
lding on t
es and po
and crisis
nel8; utilisin
ent. This p
at can be ad
will introdu
he concept
he report, two
U - were conda email to key an think-tanks er, and reportsbetween 20-25
to the surveyand remarks in
ale expert panentries, was org
nt preventive
eived funding from the
risis manag
military cri
d outside of
th the prom
d of merely
of not just C
onflict preve
OF THE DE
in its main
Chapter 2)
of the long-t
the short-
entified and
ons and the
om the mis
WP) of the
cted CSDP
the introdu
otential for
manageme
ng the expe
art will serv
ddressed w
ce the conc
and prese
online surveyucted. The suEEAS officialwho took part
s from the surv5%, and the y on EU confln these survey
el or workshopganized in Got
e activities
e European Union’s
gement and
sis manage
f the "milita
minent idea
coordinatin
CSDP instru
ention.
ELIVERAB
chapters a
and poolin
term (struct
term (opera
d key obse
eir contribut
ssions and
e project (W
missions a
uction, the
future de
ent, will be
ertise of pro
ve the purp
when assess
cept of poo
nting the c
ys - one conceurvey questions and Membet in the surveyveys were comrandom sampict prevention
ys are integrat
p, comprising tenica, Sloven
PU
Horizon 2020 resear
d conflict p
ement at t
ary sphere"
a of a full
ng different
uments but
BLE
address tw
ng and sha
tural) confli
ational) con
ervations an
tion to conf
operations
WP2, WP3
nd operatio
identificat
velopment
e primarily c
ominent ex
pose of pro
sing the mis
oling and sh
current form
erning EU conns can be founer state represys anonymousmpiled on 8 Ople of the surn, and 12 respted throughou
17 participantnia, on 21 Octo
rch and innovation pr
prevention.
he nationa
". Better ut
y compreh
CSDP instr
t other capa
wo primary
ring within
ct preventio
nflict preve
nd challeng
flict prevent
s, this chap
3 and WP4
ons in the B
tion and a
and actio
conducted t
xperts in EU
oviding a s
ssions and o
haring, and
ms of coope
nflict preventiond as annexesentatives as wsly. The surveOctober 2015. rveys subseqpondents to tht the chapters
ts representinober 2015.
S
rogramme under gra
The conce
l (Member
ilisation of
hensive EU
ruments and
abilities of th
themes: the
the EU (Ch
on instrume
ention instru
ges from th
tion. By pre
pter will con
4) that focu
Balkans, Afr
analysing o
ns, both in
through on
U conflict p
napshot of
operations.
its applicati
eration, as
n and the othes to the reportwell as represeeys were launc
The responseuently remainhe survey on s.
g eight EU me
CSA projeStart date:
Duration:
ant agreement No 653
ept, which
States) lev
pooling an
U approach
d activities,
he EU as w
e current p
hapter 3). C
ents availab
uments, in
he conduct
esenting so
ntribute to
us on asse
rica, Middle
of the po
n regard t
line survey
prevention a
possible to
ion within th
well as the
er on pooling t. The links to entatives of thched during the rate to the s
ned relatively EU pooling a
ember states a
IECEU ect: 65337101/05/2015 33 months
3371 10
has been
vel, could
d sharing
to crisis
optimally
well) could
preventive
Chapter 2
ble for the
particular
of CSDP
me of the
the latter
essing the
East and
ossibilities,
to conflict
ys7 and an
and crisis
opics and
he EU, by
e different
and sharing the surveys
he academia he last week surveys was modest: 10
and sharing.
and three
5 s
0
Analysis of
T
discourses
also beyo
compleme
what exten
far and h
manageme
on which
Assessme
also take s
conduct of
The prepa
also drafte
University
designing
the Survey
Centre for
prepared t
Once appr
partners w
including u
f the curren
This project has rece
s. Additiona
ond the "tr
nted with th
nt, and in w
ow pooling
ent and con
the remain
nt of selecte
stock on ho
f current mis
aration of th
ed the follow
of Ljubljan
the content
ys. Universi
r European
he Bibliogra
roved and p
will be encou
utilising soci
nt preventive
eived funding from the
lly, the cha
raditional"
he results o
which areas
g and shar
nflict preven
ing Workin
ed CSDP m
ow pooling
ssions and
he deliverab
wing chapte
a drafted C
t of the Onl
ty of Mayno
n Perspect
aphy.
public, the
uraged to sh
ial media pl
e activities
e European Union’s
pter takes s
military/def
of the online
, the poten
ring could
ntion. The p
g Package
missions and
and sharin
operations.
ble was coo
ers: the Exe
Chapter 2 a
ine Surveys
ooth, Irelan
tive planne
deliverable
hare the info
atforms.
PU
Horizon 2020 resear
stock on the
fence coop
e survey w
ntial of pool
be further
purpose of t
es will build
d operation
ng has bee
ordinated b
ecutive Sum
and AIES d
s, launched
nd, analysed
ed and con
will be dow
formation ab
rch and innovation pr
e future pos
peration re
which shed l
ing and sha
r utilised in
this chapter
d upon in r
s, within W
en, or could
by Crisis Ma
mmary, Intr
drafted Cha
d the Surve
d and repor
nducted th
wnloaded o
bout the pu
S
rogramme under gra
ssibilities of
mit. The d
ight on two
aring has b
n the conte
r is also to
elation to p
orking Pack
be increas
anagement
roduction an
pter 3. Enq
ys and com
rted the find
e Expert p
onto the pro
blication thr
CSA projeStart date:
Duration:
ant agreement No 653
pooling an
desk study
o primary a
been implem
ext of civil
provide a f
pooling and
kages 2, 3 a
singly, utilis
t Centre Fin
nd Conclus
quirya partic
mpiled the f
dings of the
panel/works
oject websit
rough their
IECEU ect: 65337101/05/2015 33 months
3371 11
d sharing,
y will be
spects: to
mented so
lian crisis
oundation
d sharing.
and 4, will
sed in the
nland that
sions. The
cipated in
findings of
e Surveys.
shop and
te. WP1.2
networks,
5 s
Analysis of
T
2 EU PR
Based on l
prevention
operations
in details,
aid of the E
exceed the
conducted
through the
extensively
The main a
the lens of
operations
sides of t
activities),
CSDP mis
the art) and
This chapt
the Expert
operations
when the t
immensely
and militar
conduct of
9 As noted bcivilian ESDPKempin, "ES(2011), 178-1Price, JenseProcess (Bru10 New typeimplementatipiracy etc. Seof Comparati11 Muriel AssInternational
f the curren
This project has rece
REVENTIV
literature re
activities o
s. Thus, the
into which a
EU, the EU
e scope of t
. The instit
eir preventi
y analysed
aim of this c
f conflict pre
s, and seco
the CSDP
with presen
sions and o
d the norma
ter would se
t Panel, w
s, as one p
tasks were
y in more th
ry crisis man
f missions a
by Asseburg aP/CSDP missiDP in Practice199. For anot
e Van der Waussels: Directoes of CSDP on of ceasefiree: Marhic, Give and Internaseburg and RoPeacekeeping
nt preventive
eived funding from the
VE ACTIV
eview, this c
of the EU.
outline will
also other a
Neighbour
the IECEU
tutions of th
ve activities
in the Deliv
chapter is tw
evention ins
ond, derivin
missions a
nting a cros
operations.
ative docum
erve as a p
which will b
art of the E
to be imple
an a decad
nagement w
and operatio
and Kempin, tons was prepe: Crisis Manather example al, Marlene G
orate-General missions and
re agreementsilles, ‘Recent ational Law 2 onja Kempin, g 15 (2011): 1
e activities
e European Union’s
VITIES A
chapter aim
The main f
not discuss
activities of
hood Policy
project, an
he EU task
s, as the ro
verable 1.1 o
wofold: first
struments a
ng from this
and operat
ss-sectoral c
The study,
ments adopt
pool of the i
be conducte
EU’s preve
emented.10
de, when the
were ready
ons will ser
the first compared for the magement withoof lessons lea
Gottwald, Nicofor External Pd operations s, strengtheninDevelopments(2014): 283."ESDP in Pra78-199.
PU
Horizon 2020 resear
ND CHAL
s at outlinin
focus of thi
s the EU’s c
the EU can
y instrumen
d second, d
ked with co
le of the EU
of this proje
, to analyse
available to
s framewor
tions (as a
comparative
based on t
ted by the E
deas for th
ed within t
ntive engag
However, t
e EU back
to be deplo
rve as a sta
prehensive asmeeting of GAout Strategic arned in CSDole Koenig, C
Policies of the are emergin
ng of aviation s in European
actice: Crisis M
rch and innovation pr
LLENGES
ng the past
is chapter w
conflict prev
n be catego
nts etc.). Su
detailed stu
nflict preve
U’s conflict
ect.
e the preven
the EU in th
rk, to scruti
an importan
e analysis o
the review o
EU, is by no
e questions
the Delivera
gement in t
the complex
in 2003 dec
oyed.11 Und
arting point
ssessment of ERC in DecemPlanning", JouP missions anCSDP MissionUnion – Direc
ng, and the security, cap
n Union crisis m
Management
S
rogramme under gra
S AHEAD
and the cur
will be the
vention inst
orized (such
ch an analy
udies on tha
ntion will b
prevention
ntive activiti
he realm of
inize the po
nt part of t
of the lesso
of the existi
o means the
s of both the
able 1.2. C
the world, w
xity of the m
clared its in
erstanding
for the field
best practicesmber 2009; Murnal of Internnd operationsns and Operactorate B, PolicEU nowadayacity building,management
without Strate
CSA projeStart date:
Duration:
ant agreement No 653
D
rrent releva
CSDP miss
truments an
h as the dev
ysis would,
at have alre
be mentione
institutions
ies of the E
f CSDP mis
ositive and
the EU’s p
ns learned
ng literature
e first such s
e Online Su
CSDP miss
were never
mandates h
nstruments f
the lessons
d work, whi
s and lessonsuriel Asseburg
national Peace, see: Elisa Dations: Lessocy Departmen
ys has to de, the preventiooperations’, IL
egic Planning"
IECEU ect: 65337101/05/2015 33 months
3371 12
ant conflict
sions and
nd policies
velopment
first, fairly
eady been
ed merely
has been
U through
ssions and
d negative
preventive
in various
e (state of
study.9
urvey and
sions and
r at ease,
has grown
for civilian
s from the
ich will be
s learned in g and Ronja ekeeping 15 Dari, Megan
ons Learned nt, 2012). eal with the on of acts of LSA Journal
", Journal of
5 s
2
Analysis of
T
conducted
upon the c
missions a
opportuniti
prevention
The chapte
analysed t
second pa
presenting
2.1 CURR
With regar
and operat
done in o
applying ot
Among lon
the most v
Union, trea
developme
measures
products fr
sector, su
addressing
prone regio
12Javier NiñoEuropean UnZupančič, "Mthe EuropeaScience 1 (20term developemphasising
f the curren
This project has rece
within the
completion o
and operati
es for the
potentials
er consists
through the
art dwells on
the key ob
RENT PRE
rd to the cur
tions are th
other delive
ther conflict
ng-term (or
visible and
aties betwe
ental and
for the org
rom non-EU
pport for h
g the root c
ons.12
o Pérez, "EU nion and Con
Modern "don-qn Union and 010): 71–94. T
pment cooperathe importanc
nt preventive
eived funding from the
selected ca
of these tas
ons in the
current a
will be iden
of two part
e prism of c
n the CSDP
bservations
EVENTIVE
rrent preven
he most vis
erables of t
t prevention
structural) c
used: pros
een the EU
humanitaria
anizations w
U countries
human righ
causes of po
instruments f
nflict Preventiquixotism" or a
the OrganizaThe respondeation as well ace of timely en
e activities
e European Union’s
ase-studies
sks, which w
Balkans, A
nd future C
tified.
ts. In the fir
conflict pre
P missions a
from the im
E INSTRUM
ntive activiti
ible. Nevert
the IECEU
n instrumen
conflict prev
pects and
U and third
an aid etc
working on
to access
hts protectio
otential con
for conflict preon: policy anan emerging ation for Secuents to the onlias economic cngagement thr
PU
Horizon 2020 resear
of the IEC
will draw mo
Africa, the
CSDP miss
rst part, the
evention ins
and operati
mplementatio
MENTS A
es of the E
theless, it m
project th
ts, which w
vention inst
promises to
countries o
c.), initiativ
nuclear no
the EU ma
on etc. Th
nflicts, and
evention", in Vnd legal aspecnorm of intern
urity and Cooine survey on cooperation arough the diffe
rch and innovation pr
CEU project
ostly from th
Middle Eas
sions and
current pre
struments th
ions throug
on of past a
ND ACTIV
U, diplomat
must be em
at the EU
will be briefly
truments of
o neighbou
on various
ves for reg
on-proliferat
arket, progr
hese instrum
thus contrib
Vincent Kronects, 93–117 (national relatio
operation in EEU conflict ps important eerent activities
S
rogramme under gra
(WP2, WP
he lessons
st and Asia
operations
eventive ac
he EU has
h the scope
and current
VITIES
tic activities
mphasized a
engages p
y described
the EU the
ring countr
issues (ec
gional coo
tion, financi
rammes for
ments are
buting to th
enberger and Haag: TMS Aons? Preventiurope," Romarevention instrlements of EU
s of conflict pre
CSA projeStart date:
Duration:
ant agreement No 653
P3, and WP
learned in t
a, the poten
s embodyin
ctivities of th
at its disp
e of lessons
missions.
s and CSDP
again, as it
preventively
in this subc
following a
ries to acce
conomic coo
peration, s
ial assistan
r a reform o
primarily m
he stability i
Jan Wouters Asser Press, tion of Armed anian Journalruments cons
U conflict prevevention.
IECEU ect: 65337101/05/2015 33 months
3371 13
4). Based
the CSDP
ntials and
ng conflict
he EU are
posal. The
s learned,
P missions
has been
y also by
chapter.
are among
ede to the
operation,
supportive
ce for the
of security
meant for
n conflict-
(eds.), The 2004); Rok Conflicts in
l of Political idered long-
vention, also
5 s
3
Analysis of
T
On the oth
on a short
applied in
not been
prevention
measures,
diplomatic
finding mis
armed forc
armed forc
The import
expert resp
diplomatic
conflict pre
The officia
from 2009
going crisi
where the
instrument
measures
The princip
issues is In
crisis resp
13 Ibid. 14 IECEU On15 Council of Council of http://www.ee16 IECEU On17 Andrew Bybuilding and on 3rd SePrevention.pd18 Andrew Bybuilding and on 3rd SePrevention.pd
f the curren
This project has rece
her hand, th
t-time basis
the cases w
applied in
n instrument
issuing de
envoys to
ssions, obse
ces, threat
ce.13
tance of the
pondents to
measures
evention ins
al line of th
, argues th
s shall be
responden
t of EU co
to strengthe
pal financia
nstrument c
ponse oper
line Survey onthe European
the Europeas.europa.euline Survey onyrne, The EuMediation Ins
eptember 20df. yrne, The EuMediation Ins
eptember 20df.
nt preventive
eived funding from the
he EU has a
s, when the
where long-
the first p
ts the follow
marches or
a crisis are
erver or mo
with the us
ese operatio
o the online
and media
struments.14
e EU, build
hat the use
promoted i
nts regarde
onflict preve
en mediatio
al EU instru
contributing
ations and
n EU Conflict n Union, Concpean Union u/cfsp/conflict_n EU Conflict uropean Unionstruments; Dir015, http://eu
uropean Unionstruments; Dir015, http://eu
e activities
e European Union’s
a variety of
e outburst
-term preve
lace. Amon
wing are mo
r declaration
ea, mediatio
onitoring mis
se of armed
onal conflict
e survey, wh
ation and C4
ding on the
of mediatio
in the first
ed diplomat
ention. 16 Th
on capabiliti
ument direc
to Stability
long-term
Prevention Inscept on Streng
on 10th _prevention/doPrevention Insn and Conflicrectorate for Sukonvent.org/w
n and Conflicrectorate for Sukonvent.org/w
PU
Horizon 2020 resear
other, more
of conflict
entive meas
ng the so
ost often us
ns calling fo
on in peace
ssions, eco
d force or,
t prevention
ho consider
CSDP all a
e EU Conce
on as a too
place.15 Th
tic measur
he current
es of the EU
ctly address
y and Peace
stabilizatio
struments, resgthening EU M
November ocs/concept_sstruments, res
ct PreventionSecurity Policywp-content/up
ct PreventionSecurity Policywp-content/up
rch and innovation pr
e concrete
is imminen
sures have e
called ope
ed by the E
or a peacef
e talks, mec
onomic or po
at last and
n measures
red early wa
as either im
ept on Med
ol of primar
is is also s
es and me
preventive
U.17
sing conflict
e (IcSP), wh
on measure
sponses to quMediation and2009. Acce
strengthening_sponses to qu(Brussels: Di
y and Conflictploads/2014/10
(Brussels: Diy and Conflictploads/2014/10
S
rogramme under gra
instruments
nt. In other
either failed
rational (or
EU: political
ful resolutio
chanisms of
olitical sanc
d rarely use
s was also a
arning and
mportant or
diation and
ry response
supported b
ediation as
activities a
t prevention
hich implem
es.18 The in
estion numbed Dialogue Capessed on 2_eu_med_en.estion numbevision for CoPrevention –
0/8.-The-Euro
vision for CoPrevention –
0/8.-The-Euro
CSA projeStart date:
Duration:
ant agreement No 653
s that can b
words, the
d or where
r short-term
l dialogue, d
n of conflic
f early-warn
ctions, deplo
ed, the actu
acknowledg
conflict ass
r very impo
Dialogue C
e to emergi
by the expe
the most
also involv
n and peac
ments both s
nstrument
er 2. apabilities, ado2nd Septempdf.
er 2. onflict Prevent– EEAS, 2015opean-Union-a
onflict Prevent– EEAS, 2015opean-Union-a
IECEU ect: 65337101/05/2015 33 months
3371 14
be applied
ey can be
they have
m) conflict
diplomatic
t, sending
ning, fact-
oyment of
ual use of
ged by the
sessment,
ortant EU
Capacities
ing or on-
ert survey
important
ve various
ce-building
short-term
has been
opted by the mber 2015,
tion, Peace-). Accessed
and-Conflict-
tion, Peace-). Accessed
and-Conflict-
5 s
4
Analysis of
T
discussed
that the Ic
conflict pre
The EU als
instrument
more cohe
of conflict
for more co
(i)
(ii)
(iii)
(iv)
An interes
prevention
overall EU
security". T
coherence
a problem
strategic c
indicated a
the need
responden
19 Regulationinstrument http://ec.euro20 Andrew Bybuilding and on 3rd SePrevention.pd21 Ibid.
f the curren
This project has rece
more exten
cSP is by fa
evention pro
so aims for
ts. The mai
erent, multi-
prevention
oherent and
Early warn
Crisis Res
Diplomatic
demarches
New multi-
Combining
long term
developme
Foreign an
sting observ
activities d
U aim of
The most re
e - a compre
atic feature
coherence
a lack of un
for clearer
nt noted: "I
n (EU) No 23
contributinopa.eu/dgs/fpi/yrne, The EuMediation Ins
eptember 20df.
nt preventive
eived funding from the
nsively with
ar the most
ojects so far
closer co-o
in institution
dimensiona
instrument
d comprehe
ning and co
ponse Platf
c measures
s, statemen
-annual Fina
g external a
m developm
ent instrum
nd Security
vation, gain
described a
"preserving
ecurring cha
ehensive ap
e of EU ca
between E
derstanding
r linkages b
In particula
0/2014 of theng to /documents/14
uropean Unionstruments; Dir015, http://eu
e activities
e European Union’s
in the Deliv
t comprehe
r, with the b
operation be
n for preve
al and effect
ts (the EU o
ensive confl
onflict asse
form (inform
s, includin
nts, mediatio
ancial Fram
ssistance in
ment meas
ments; them
Policy, inclu
ned through
bove were
g peace, p
allenge for t
pproach - be
pabilities a
EU conflict
g of conflict
between E
r CSDP in
e European Pstability
40311_icsp_rn and Conflicrectorate for Sukonvent.org/w
PU
Horizon 2020 resear
verable 1.1.
ensive and
budget €2.3
etween diffe
entive enga
tive EU exte
officials rath
ict preventi
essment (E
mal);
ng (formal)
on/facilitatio
mework 201
nstruments
sures; hum
matic instrum
uding CSDP
h the onlin
assessed a
preventing
the EU was
etween the
as the onlin
prevention
t prevention
U political
nstruments
Parliament andand pe
reg_230_2014ct PreventionSecurity Policywp-content/up
rch and innovation pr
.19 Hence, a
financially s
billion for 2
erent conflic
gement is
ernal action
her call the
on:
U Delegatio
) policy d
on of dialog
4-2020;
and action
manitarian
ments, and
P missions.
ne survey,
as only hav
conflicts a
s described
different in
ne survey a
and peac
n and peace
goals and
have to be
d of the Couneace. Ac4_en.pdf. (Brussels: Di
y and Conflictploads/2014/10
S
rogramme under gra
at this point
strong instr
2014–2020.
ct prevention
EEAS, whi
n’.20 Overall
em ‘tools’) w
on reports,
dialogue w
ue, etc.;
s to link reli
aid instru
d last, but 21
is that the
ving a limite
and strengt
as the lack
nstruments a
also reveale
cebuilding t
ebuilding thr
operationa
e carefully
ncil of 11 Marcessed o
vision for CoPrevention –
0/8.-The-Euro
CSA projeStart date:
Duration:
ant agreement No 653
t it is sufficie
rument of th
.
n and peac
ch aims ‘to
, the EU ha
which can b
EU Situat
with third
ief, rehabilit
ument; geo
not least,
e current E
ed contribut
thening int
k of coordin
and activitie
ed a need
thinking. Th
roughout th
al missions
linked to l
rch 2014 estaon 29th
onflict Prevent– EEAS, 2015opean-Union-a
IECEU ect: 65337101/05/2015 33 months
3371 15
ent to say
he EU for
ce-building
o facilitate
as a range
be utilized
ion room,
countries,
tation and
ographical
Common
U conflict
tion to the
ernational
nation and
es. This is
for better
he survey
he EU and
s. As one
long term
ablishing an August,
tion, Peace-). Accessed
and-Conflict-
5 s
5
Analysis of
T
developme
and locally
As mention
are CSDP
both in aca
activities. T
of the over
strategic c
a country
twofold in
in this cha
important i
the other h
the curren
and militar
of overall E
This obse
IECEU pro
learning fro
propose ne
to long-ter
instrument
Currently
manageme
conceptua
project, an
the mission
22 IECEU OnWorkshop on23 IECEU On24 European and-operatio
f the curren
This project has rece
ent strategie
y owned."22
ned earlier
missions a
ademic circ
They shall a
rall conflict
onflict prev
or a regio
this regard
apter, the re
instrument
hand, howe
t CSDP mi
ry, only had
EU conflict p
ervation em
oject, one
om the ong
ew solution
rm stability
ts - in the re
there are
ent mission
lization of
nd shortly ex
ns and ope
line Survey on
n the current pline Survey onUnion – EEASns/ (Accessed
nt preventive
eived funding from the
es in a mo
in the intro
and operati
les and the
also be und
prevention
ention fram
on. The ex
. On one ha
espondents
of the EU i
ever, the res
ssions and
d demonstra
prevention a
mphasises
of the ob
oing CSDP
s to enhanc
- also thr
egions and c
7 ongoing
s.24 The cu
conflict pre
xplained als
rations’ ma
n EU Conflict preventive actin EU Conflict S. Ongoing md 23 October 2
e activities
e European Union’s
ore systema
ductory par
ons, which
EU institut
erstood tha
policy of th
mework of th
pert survey
and, and as
considered
in conflict p
spondents e
operations
ated a limite
activities.23
the impor
bjectives of
P missions a
cing the EU
rough the
countries it
g CSDP m
rrent preven
evention –
so within thi
ndates.
Prevention Insvities of the EPrevention Insissions and op2015).
PU
Horizon 2020 resear
atic way so
rt of this cha
are, as we
ions as only
at way – as
he EU, whic
he EU towa
y findings
s noted ear
d CSDP as
prevention.
estimated t
s, both civil
ed role as p
rtance of
f which is
and operatio
U's contribut
use of CS
engages in
military op
ntive CSDP
as establis
is deliverab
struments, resEU, Gotenica, struments, resperations. Ava
rch and innovation pr
o as to mak
apter, the m
e have see
y one of the
one, but ve
ch shall be
rds
are
rlier
an
On
that
lian
part
the
by
ons
tion
DP
n.
perations a
P activities o
shed within
le – can be
sponses to quSlovenia, 21 Osponses to quailable at: http
"Th
m
unand
inpr
denot
(Re
S
rogramme under gra
ke EU inter
main focus o
n in this su
e aspects of
ery importan
put in the f
nd 10 ong
of the EU, w
Deliverabl
seen by ha
estion numbeOctober 2015.estions numbe
p://www.eeas.e
he main obstaof the EU c
mechanisms] cfollows: l
nderstanding d peacebuildinsufficient lirevention povelopment at sufficient li
longer t
espondent to on EU Co
Ins
CSA projeStart date:
Duration:
ant agreement No 653
rventions su
of the IECE
ubchapter,
f the EU’s p
nt type of in
framework o
going civil
which fall in
e 1.1 of th
aving a clos
er 2 and 3; IEC. er 2, 4 and 5. europa.eu/csd
acles [to the conflict prevcan be summlack of a comof conflict ping throughoinks between
olicies and acand humanitainks betweenterm measure
IECEU Onlonflict Prevestruments)
IECEU ect: 65337101/05/2015 33 months
3371 16
ustainable
EU project
perceived
preventive
struments
of a wider
ian crisis
to a wider
he IECEU
ser look to
CEU
dp/missions-
functioning vention marized as mmon prevention out the EU; n conflict ctions and arian ones; n short and es."
ine Survey ntion
5 s
6
Analysis of
T
Figure 1: E
Civilian CSDP missions EUAM Ukraine
EUMM Georgia
EUPOL Afghanista
EUBAM R
EUPOL COPPS PalestiniaTerritorieEULEX Kosovo EUBAM L
EUCAP SMali
EUCAP SNiger
EUCAP NESTOR
f the curren
This project has rece
Excerpts o
Man
AssiprovaccoStabpartiadjacand
an AssiAfghinstitcrimcrim
Rafah Monwithcontrbuildcapafor f
an es
AssiPalein adeveAssithe p
Libya Suppthe coper
Sahel Imprminireinfmannorth
Sahel Helpopercomband inter
EnhaIndiacounmariprosment
nt preventive
eived funding from the
f the civilia
ndate (excer
sting Ukrainviding strateountable secuilisation, nories to prevencent to the ASouth Ossetisting in instihan Nationaltutions; supp
minal justice aminal investignitoring, verih regard to thributing to Pd confidenceabilities for afuture operatisting the Pastine in the a
accordance welopment of tsting and sup
police, judiciporting the Lcountry’s lanrational levelroving operaistries of defforcing the agement andh of the counping Niger's rating stratebating terrorlogistics m
rnational coo
ancing maritan Ocean (nter-piracy anitime securitecutors, judtoring, and tr
e activities
e European Union’s
an CSDP m
rpts)
ne in securitegic advice urity servicesrmalisation at any return t
Administrativia safe and seitutional refol Police, incluporting improactors such agations ifying and ehe implementPalestinian cae and mediaa quick redeping there (woalestinian Auareas of policwith the bethe police anpporting the iary and custLibyan authond, sea and l through advational efficifence and secrole of judi
d supervisionntry
security foegies; Strengrism and org
management ordination in
ime capaciti(Djibouti, Knd maritime ty in each hdges and oraining)
PU
Horizon 2020 resear
missions’ m
ty sector reffor the d
s and confidento armed con
ve Boundary ecure for the
orm of the Muding the devoved interactas cooperatio
evaluating thntation of theapacity buildating betweeployment to orkshops, trauthority in bcing and crimest internationd judicial in
Kosovo authtoms areas orities in dev
air bordersvising, traininiency of intecurity; re-esticial and adn of their mi
orces in achigthening thganised crimpolicies; Suthe fight aga
es of five coKenya, Som
governance;host countryother actors;
rch and innovation pr
andates
form (includdevelopment
nce-building mnflict, as welLines of the
e local populaMinistry of Int
velopment otion among A
on between p
he performane Agreed Prinding in all aspen the confli
the Rafah Caining sessionbuilding the minal justiceonal standarstitutions horities in th
veloping bor; capacity-bung and mentoernal securittablishing thedministrativeissions; facil
ieving interohe Nigerien me; Improvinupporting thainst terrorism
ountries in thmalia, Seych
; working wi (coast guar; mission e
S
rogramme under gra
ding police aof effectiv
measures; wll as to help mbreakaway r
ation terior; profesf local traini
Afghan law eolice officers
nce of the Pnciples for Rpects of bordicting parties
Crossing Poinns and studyinstitutions under Palesrds; support
he rule of law
rder manageuilding manoring Libyanty forces andeir respectivee authorities litating their
operability asecurity s
ng the humae developmm and organ
e Horn of Afelles and Tth the main ard, navy, civexperts main
CSA projeStart date:
Duration:
ant agreement No 653
and the rule ve, sustaina
working with make the areregions of A
ssionalizationing capacity enforcement s and prosec
Palestinian ARafah Crossinder control; hs; enhancingnt and PA’s
y trips) of a future
stinian ownerting the ref
w area, speci
ement and sendate at stratn counterpartd the officiae hierarchica
s with regarr redeployme
and developsector's expan resources,
ment of regionised crime
frica and theTanzania), iactors responvilian coastanly provide
IECEU ect: 65337101/05/2015 33 months
3371 17
of law); able and
all eas Abkhazia
n of the and and utors in
Authority ng Point;
helping to g the PA potential
State of rship and
form and
ifically in
ecurity at tegic and ts als at the al chains; rd to the ent to the
ping their ertise in , training onal and
e Western including nsible for al police, e advice,
5 s
7
Analysis of
T
Figure 2: E
Military operationEUFOR ALTHEA B
EUNAVFOMedditeraSea EUMAM Central African Republic EUTM Somalia
EU NAVAtalanta (Somalia)
EUTM Ma
EUSEC Congo
As already
the preven
only preve
institutions
overall, ca
causes of
seen from
category o
refugees in
within the
structural c
protect all
f the curren
This project has rece
Excerpts o
ns Man
BiH Capasuppover
OR anean
DisruMed
Suppwith
Traincompof Dadm
VFOR
ProteAfricpiracSoma
ali Restmap theirterro
DR Suppcondauthhum
y explained
ntive activitie
entive activit
s and agenc
n have stab
conflicts (e
both figures
of direct pr
n the Medit
current CS
conflict prev
the people
nt preventive
eived funding from the
f the milita
ndate
acity-buildinporting BiH rall EU compupting the b
diterranean; c
porting the Ch respect to th
ning activitieponent on bu
Defence and Ginistration, aecting World Fcan Union Miscy and armed rali coast on a toring constit
adopted byr sovereigntyorist threats porting the ditions condorities in ta
man rights, int
, the IECEU
es, as purs
ties of the E
cies of the
bilization eff
economic a
s, some pre
reventive a
terranean S
DP mission
vention (tra
of the coun
e activities
e European Union’s
ary CSDP o
ng and trainefforts to m
prehensive stbusiness modcontribute to
Central Afriche armed for
es of nationauilding long General Staffand legal affaFood Programssion on Somarobbery at seacase by case btutional and
y the Nationy over the w
Congolese ducive to a ailoring the ternational h
U project ta
ued within
EU. On the
EU, also h
fects in vola
assistance,
eventive act
ctivities (pr
Sea etc.), w
ns and oper
ining armed
ntry; training
PU
Horizon 2020 resear
operations’
ning to the Amaintain the trategy for Bdel of humanreducing the
can authoritierces of the Ce
al armed forcterm capabilf with regardairs).
mme vessels dealia shipping;
a off the Somabasis; monitordemocratic oal Assemblywhole of the
authorities ireturn to esecurity sec
humanitarian
akes a wide
CSDP miss
e contrary, c
have an imp
atile regions
developme
tivities of th
reventing p
while the m
rations, hav
d forces tha
g judges, po
rch and innovation pr
’ mandates
Armed Forcsafe and seciH n smugglinge further loss
es in preparinentral Africa
ces (focus onlity and capad to the areas
elivering aid tdeterring, pre
ali coast; protering of fishingorder throughy; helping the country; n
in rebuildingeconomic anctor reform law and goo
er approach
sions and o
certain instr
pact on the
s, as many
ent aid, hum
e CSDP mi
piracy and
majority of p
ve an indire
at will be pr
olice etc.).
S
rogramme under gra
ces of Bosnicure environm
g and trafficks of lives at s
ng a reform an Republic
advisory anacity within th of operation
to displaced peventing and recting vulnerag activities offh the implemhe Malian auneutralizing o
g armed fornd social de
to foster dod governanc
h to conflic
operations, a
ruments of
e reduction
of them try
manitarian
ssions and
armed rob
reventive a
ect impact,
rofessional,
CSA projeStart date:
Duration:
ant agreement No 653
nia and Herznment; suppo
king networsea
of the securi
nd mentoringthe Somali Mns, plans, log
persons in Somrepressing actable shipping of the coast of Smentation of uthorities to organized cr
rces and in evelopment; democratic sce
ct preventio
are by no m
the EU, led
of risks fac
to deal with
assistance
operations
bbery at se
activities, as
and as suc
and as suc
IECEU ect: 65337101/05/2015 33 months
3371 18
zegovina; orting the
rks in the
ity sector
Ministry gistics,
malia, and s of off the Somalia the road-exercise
rime and
creating assisting tandards,
n. Hence,
means the
d by other
ctors and,
h the root-
etc.). As
s fall in the
ea; saving
s pursued
ch fall into
ch able to
5 s
8
Analysis of
T
2.2 CHAL
2.2.1 PLA
Despite th
deploymen
...), the CS
conflict pre
inherent co
operations
UN, NATO
activities w
conflict cyc
An importa
finding exe
proposed e
concerning
reasons fo
capabilities
However,
beginning
the local e
lesson the
member st
resources.
Another le
deploymen
25 Muriel AssInternational 26 Emil Kirchnlearned", Eur
f the curren
This project has rece
LLENGES
ANNING A
he absence
nt of a CSD
SDP deploym
evention (a
omplexity o
s require effe
O and the O
with from th
cle.
ant lesson le
ercise prior
effort, an ev
g the appro
or that is t
s.25
the recent
of CSDP m
environment
e EU has le
tates not on26
esson learn
nts usually
seburg and RoPeacekeepingner, "Commonropean Securi
nt preventive
eived funding from the
IN CSDP
AND SETT
e of clear c
DP mission
ments have
and crisis m
of such env
ective coop
OSCE are of
e very begi
earned rega
r to the lau
valuation of
priate time
that the EU
missions a
military and
t, where the
earned is th
nly to approv
ned, which
proceeds m
onja Kempin, g 15 (2011): 1n Security andity 1 (2013): 3
e activities
e European Union’s
MISSION
TING UP A
criteria for
or operatio
e been in pla
managemen
vironments,
peration amo
ften found a
inning, as a
arding the p
nch of the
f appropriat
frame in wh
U still fund
and operatio
civilian eng
e mission w
hat it is wis
ve the miss
h is not su
more smoot
"ESDP in Pra97.
d Defence Pol6-54.
PU
Horizon 2020 resear
NS AND O
A MISSION
deciding w
on (e. g. num
ace for mor
nt) actors in
, the plann
ong various
among the ‘
also they try
planning is t
mission, c
te instrume
hich the inte
damentally
ons have b
gagement,
was to be d
e to invest
sion, but als
urprising, i
thly and qu
actice: Crisis M
licy peace ope
rch and innovation pr
PERATIO
N OR OPE
what constit
mber of dea
re than a de
n conflict- a
ing and co
s actors alre
‘usual susp
y to addres
that there is
concerning
nts to cond
ervention is
lacks indep
been, comp
better equip
deployed. In
igate thorou
so to contrib
s that the
ickly, comp
Management
erations in the
S
rogramme under gra
NS: KEY O
ERATION
tutes the p
aths, degre
ecade. Due
and post-co
ordinating
eady at the
ects’ the EU
s most or a
s almost nev
the aims a
duct the mis
s to be impl
pendent (c
paring to th
pped with th
n this regar
ughly the w
bute human
process
aring to the
without Strate
e Western Balk
CSA projeStart date:
Duration:
ant agreement No 653
OBSERVA
precondition
ee of violenc
to the conu
onflict zones
CSDP miss
planning ph
U shall coo
all of the ph
ver enough
and objectiv
ssion, and a
emented. O
common) in
hose launch
he informat
rd, another
willingness
, financial o
of setting
e large dep
egic Planning"
kans: impact
IECEU ect: 65337101/05/2015 33 months
3371 19
ATIONS
ns for the
ce, region
undrum of
s and the
sions and
hase. The
rdinate its
hases of a
h of a fact-
ves of the
a decision
One of the
ntelligence
hed at the
tion about
important
of the EU
or material
up small
ployments,
", Journal of
and lessons
5 s
9
Analysis of
T
regardless
Asseburg a
»on thmembpoliticaadditiorecruitpopula
Another le
operations
experience
efficient p
missions’
taken this
the EU Mil
Centre tha
operations
civil and m
numerous
CSDP sha
states wer
hesitant w
Centre.28 It
time in Ma
CSDP mis
implement
some diffic
Operations
Horn of Afr
27 Muriel AssInternational 28 Fiona SchAffairs Revie
f the curren
This project has rece
s of whethe
and Kempin
he one handber states hal will is givonal difficuting and seations.«27
esson learne
s, which is
ed in the fie
planning an
and operat
decision a
itary Staff w
at would b
s, in particu
military res
declaration
all be stre
re, as argu
with regards
t took almo
arch 2012 i
ssions and
ation. The e
culties, the
s Centre we
rica.
seburg and RoPeacekeepingnell and Fabiw 20 (2015) -
nt preventive
eived funding from the
r the civilia
n mention s
d, recruitinghave direct ven), while clties in fednding civilia
ed with reg
based on
eld, is that a
nd impleme
tions’ mand
already in D
was asked t
be able to
ular in thos
ponse was
ns of the m
engthened,
ed by Schn
s to the u
ost 8 years
in order to
d operation
experiences
activities an
ere an impo
onja Kempin, g 15 (2011): 1ien Terpan, "Special Issue
e activities
e European Union’s
an missions
ignificant di
g personneaccess to
civilian persderal systean staff is g
gard to the
the difficu
a joint opera
entation of
date. The
December
to set up an
plan and
se cases w
s required.
member sta
those sam
nell and Te
use of the
to activate
coordinate
ns in the H
s, on which
nd the coor
ortant step t
"ESDP in Pra91-192. Member State
e: 63–82.
PU
Horizon 2020 resear
s or military
ifferences b
el for militarthese pers
sonnel cannems such agenerally ea
planning a
ulties the fi
ational cent
f the CSD
Council ha
2004, whe
n Operation
run CSD
where a join
Despite th
ates that th
me membe
erpan, rathe
Operation
e the Opera
activities a
Horn of A
h the lesson
rdination of
towards gre
actice: Crisis M
es Resistance
rch and innovation pr
operations
between the
y operationsonnel resonot just be das Germanasier to jus
nd impleme
rst CSDP
tre needs to
P
as
en
ns
P
nt
he
he
er
er
ns
ations Centr
and increas
Africa from
ns can be le
missions a
eater synerg
Management
e to the EU O
"Havof
councoor
(Resp
S
rogramme under gra
s are in que
e two:
ns is easier ources (at ldrafted and ny). On thtify to the m
entation of
missions a
o be establ
re, which w
se synergie
the planni
earned, have
nd operatio
gy of variou
without Strate
Operations Ce
ing one cenf the all EU try would mrdinating the
insti
pondent to IEon EU Conf
Instr
CSA projeStart date:
Duration:
ant agreement No 653
estion. Nev
r in principleleast when deployed (e other ha
member sta
CSDP mis
and operati
ished for th
was used fo
es between
ing phase
e shown th
ons conduct
us EU activi
egic Planning"
entre", Europe
ntre for cooactivities on
make more be tasks of eitution."
ECEU Onlinflict Preventruments)
IECEU ect: 65337101/05/2015 33 months
3371 20
vertheless,
e as the
with and, ates’
sions and
ons have
he sake of
or the first
the three
until the
at despite
ted by the
ties at the
", Journal of
ean Foreign
rdination n one benefit in each EU
ne Survey tion
5 s
0
Analysis of
T
The online
order to lin
coordinatio
and Kemp
particular t
on. Namel
member st
general po
the missio
activities o
should be
contribute
Better linka
society..."3
This is inhe
a CSDP m
EU. If the E
not sufficie
planning p
supported
employing
Balkans, w
prevention
2.2.2 MA
If the EU w
impact, it
29 IECEU On30 Muriel AssInternational 31 Responden32 Annemarie(2012): 414-4
f the curren
This project has rece
e survey rev
nk EU actio
on among E
in, referring
taken into c
ly, it has to
tates, that
olicy and ap
on or opera
of the EU wa
put into pla
to the wid
ages with n31
erently linke
mission or o
EU wishes
ent to add
phase of the
by a wide
a few of th
which is, co
engageme
NDATES
wishes to pu
must en
line Survey on
seburg and RoPeacekeepingnt to IECEU O
e Rodt and St430.
nt preventive
eived funding from the
vealed that
ons with oth
EU offices
g to the ana
consideratio
o be repea
CSDP miss
pproach (po
ation is to
as also ech
anning cap
der national
national acto
ed with the
operation is
to make a d
ress the ro
e mission,
e spectrum
he instrume
ompared to
ent, more st
ursue a sus
sure that
n EU Conflict onja Kempin, g 15 (2011): 1
Online Survey tefan Wolff, "
e activities
e European Union’s
t planning p
her actors.
in the miss
lysis of the
on, when th
ated to the
sions and o
litical, econ
be deploy
oed by one
acities as w
l and intern
ors, UN act
underpinnin
only one o
difference o
oot causes
it is recomm
m of compl
ents availab
o the other
able place t
stainable co
the mand
Prevention Ins"ESDP in Pra90. on EU ConflicEuropean Un
PU
Horizon 2020 resear
phase is oft
Responden
sion area.29
EU, empha
he planning
e wider aud
operations
nomic, secu
yed. 30 This
e of the resp
well as into
national eff
tors, region
ng logic of t
of the confl
on the groun
of the co
mended tha
lementary
ble. This ha
r regions w
than it used
onflict preve
date, resou
struments. actice: Crisis M
ct Prevention Iion Conflict M
rch and innovation pr
ten superfic
nts also sta9 In addition
asizes that o
g of a CSDP
dience man
cannot ser
rity etc.) tow
linkage be
pondents in
o thinking h
forts of pea
al actors, d
the IECEU
ict preventi
nd, the CSD
nflicts in a
at the CSD
EU peaceb
as, for exam
where the E
d to be in th
ention missio
urces (both
Management
Instruments. Management i
S
rogramme under gra
cial and ne
ted the imp
n to this, the
one lesson
P mission o
ny times, a
ve as a su
wards the re
etween the
the online
ow CSDP a
ace-building
developmen
project, wh
ion instrum
DP mission
n appropria
DP missions
building ac
mple, happe
EU is invol
e 1990s.32
on or opera
h financial
without Strate
n the Wester
CSA projeStart date:
Duration:
ant agreement No 653
eeds more t
portance of
e study of
learned sh
or operation
nd especia
urrogate for
egion/count
different p
survey: "Mo
activities at
g and state
nt banks, do
ich presupp
ents availa
or operatio
ate way. D
s and opera
ctivities, no
ened in the
lved with it
ation with a
and hum
egic Planning"
rn Balkans", C
IECEU ect: 65337101/05/2015 33 months
3371 21
thought in
improved
Asseburg
ould be in
n is going
ally to the
r the EU’s
try, where
preventive
ore efforts
t best can
e-building.
onors, civil
poses that
ble to the
on alone is
During the
ations are
t only by
e Western
ts conflict
long term
man) and
", Journal of
Civil Wars 3
5 s
Analysis of
T
implement
as well as
sustainable
operation
lesson wa
needed – a
the long pe
One of the
Asseburg a
knowledge
institutions
The EU ha
and opera
occasional
operation,
value of th
been. Suc
between th
much inde
that the go
or distorted
One of the
institutions
make a be
33 Muriel AssSystematic AWissenschafOctober 201534 Emil Kirchnlearned", Eur35 Muriel AssInternational 36 Responden37 There areprocess, hasthe EU as thmission (Ass
f the curren
This project has rece
ation strate
s the needs
e and long
not to be o
s learned i
at the peak
eriods.34
e challenges
and Kempin
eable on th
s that have
as a Specia
ations were
lly present
possess a
his expertis
ch consider
he Commis
ependency
oals of the m
d assumpti
e key poin
s are subor
etter use of t
seburg and RAssessment oft und Politik, 25. ner, "Commonropean Securiseburg and RoPeacekeepingnt to the IECE, of course, e
s been very mird party for theburg and Ke
nt preventive
eived funding from the
egy of each
s on the gr
g enough.
overambitio
in Kosovo,
k EULEX ha
s with rega
n.35 They d
he conflict
a primary s
al Represen
e or are d
in the vola
lot of usefu
se has often
rations wer
ssion and th
and not int
mandates a
ons about
ts identified
rdinate eve
their expert
Ronja Kempinof ESDP Mis2009); IECEU
n Security andity 1 (2013): 3onja Kempin, g 15 (2011): 1
EU Online Survexceptions to uch involved he Rafah bord
empin, "ESDP
e activities
e European Union’s
mission and
round.33 In
On the oth
us, or lavis
when it se
ad 3000 per
rd to the de
escribe how
zones, hav
say in the de
ntative in al
eployed. F
atile area e
ul informatio
n not been
re also not
he EEAS w
terconnecte
are often no
the politica
d in this re
n in the pr
ise.37
n, "The EU asions and Opworkshop on
d Defence Pol6-54. "ESDP in Pra90. vey on EU Cothe rule. Ma
in preparing thder crossing ain Practice", 1
PU
Horizon 2020 resear
d operation
other word
her hand, i
sh, in terms
eems reaso
rsonnel – a
evising of
Recommended