Local community perceptions of Terramin’s · 4/11/2018  · Local community perceptions of...

Local community perceptions of Terramin’sproposed underground gold project

MINERAL RESOURCES

Naomi Boughen | Senior Researcher

11 April 2018

Presentation to The Woodside Community Consultative Committee (WCCC)

Outline of presentation

•Who we are – CSIRO

•What we do and why – Reflexivity

• Insights from the Terramin project

•What’s next?

•Q&A

Local community perceptions of Terramin’s proposed underground gold project | Naomi Boughen2 |

Who we are - CSIRO

3 |

Big ideas start here

4 |

EXTENDED WEAR

CONTACTS

POLYMER BANKNOTES

RELENZA FLU TREATMENT

Fast WLANWireless Local Area Network

AEROGARD

TOTAL WELLBEING

DIET

RAFT POLYMERISATION

BARLEYmax™

SELF TWISTING

YARN

SOFTLY WASHING

LIQUIDHENDRA VACCINE

NOVACQ™ PRAWN FEED

Our mission

Projects and teams – creative, entrepreneurial, collaborative teams tackling big challenges through science, technology and innovation

Customer value – delivering value through innovative solution for customers in industry, government and community

Impact delivery – creating new economic, environmental and social impact for Australia

5 |

Create value for customers

through innovation

that delivers positive

impact for Australia

Our business units and focus areas

Agriculture and Food

Energy

Health and Biosecurity

Land and Water

Manufacturing

Mineral Resources

Oceans and Atmosphere

6 |

Astronomy andSpace Science

Australian Animal Health Laboratory

Data61

Marine National Facility

National Computing Infrastructure

National Research Collections of Australia

Our business units and focus areas

Agriculture and Food

Energy

Health and Biosecurity

Land and Water

Manufacturing

Mineral Resources

Oceans and Atmosphere

7 |

Astronomy andSpace Science

Australian Animal Health Laboratory

Data61

Marine National Facility

National Computing Infrastructure

National Research Collections of Australia

Working with industry

8 |

Working with

1200+SME’s every

year

2800+industry partners

totaling

$220M+per year

370+multinationals

130active licenses

Australia’s largest patent holder (1862)

159Aussie companies

started from CSIRO technology

What we do and why - Reflexivity

9 |

Contact experience

Fairness

Impacts

Trust Approval/

acceptance

Resources in Society

Operational Social Licence to Operate

National insights and trusted datasets

• Layered multi-scale data

Global comparisons for sustainable development

• Supporting relationships between stakeholders

• Reflecting industry structure

• Systematic understanding

The problem

• Companies have complex and important relationships with their communities

• Companies do not have a systematic way of understanding these relationships

• Communities do not have constructive ways to influence development

12 |

• Reflexivity is a social performance data provision service

• We deliver real-time community insights in a language companies can use to inform their practice

• By tracking key drivers of social acceptance, we help companies identify community issues before they become conflicts

• We give communities a constructive way to be heard

13 |

The process

14 |

The process

15 |

The process

16 |

Consistent, systematic social performance data

Site-based data is aggregated through HQ Licence

Social Licence to Operate: | Naomi Boughen7 |

The Masazane Project

• 5 sites• Australia and South Africa• 1,937 community members• 12 months

Local Voices

19 |

20 |

Life of mine

21 |

Exploration

Feasibility

Planning & Design

Construction

Operations

Decommission & Closure

Post-closure management

Insights from the Terramin project

22 |

Background to the project

To understand the current attitudes regarding concerns about, and benefits of, a proposed underground gold mine development in the Adelaide Hills, to support an engagement strategy by the mine that

speak to these concerns and aspirations

Approved by CSIRO’s Social Science Human Research Ethics Committee (088/16) in accordance with the National Statement on Ethical Conduct in Human Research

23 |

Community workshops

(Oct 2016)

‘Anchor’ Survey (Dec 2016 –Mar 2017)

‘Pulse’ Surveys (Quarterly)

Survey design(Nov – Dec 2016)

Funding

• 40% Terramin Australia Limited

• 40% Innovation Connections, an initiative of the Department of Industry, Innovation and Science to assist SMEs access knowledge, engage with researchers and innovate

• CSIRO contributed 20% of the associated costs as elements of this project represented strong alignment with CSIRO strategic research priorities

24 |

Measures

• Demographics, including near neighbour status

• Community wellbeing and resilience

• Knowledge (mining in general, the proposed mine and State government regulations related to mining)

• Potential impacts and benefits of the proposed mine

• Sources of information about the proposed mine

• Quantity & quality of contact with Terramin

• Procedural & distributional fairness

• Trust & acceptance

25 |

Community participation: Anchor to Pulse 4 (ALL)

26 |

Responded

294

Invited

444

Response Rate

66%

Completed all 4 surveys

211For the purpose of this report, only data from those community members that completed the anchor and all four pulse surveys are included

Demographics

27 |

Gender Postcode

Knowledge of proposed mine

28 |

Participants who identify themselves as a ‘near neighbour’

29 |

The proportion of community members responding to the surveys that consider themselves ‘near neighbours’ has increased over time

50%

12%

38%

39%

36%

25%35%

35%

30%

In the past 3 months, how much contact have you had with Terramin?

30 |

Contact qualityExperience of those who did meet people from Terramin in the last 3 months over all four time points

31 |

Perceived impacts

32 |

1

2

3

4

5

6

7

A N C H O R P 1 P 2 P 3 P 4

1= S

TRO

NG

LY D

ISA

GR

EE -

7=ST

RO

NG

LY A

GR

EE

IMPACTS OVER TIME

Groundwater availability

Groundwater quality

'Clean and Green' reputation

Discourage tourists

Visual amenity

Quality of life

Road safety

Road quality

Perceived benefits

33 |

1

2

3

4

5

6

7

A N C H O R P 1 P 2 P 3 P 4

1=ST

RO

NG

LY D

ISA

GR

EE -

7=ST

RO

NG

LY A

GR

EE

BENEFITS OVER TIME

Local jobs

Training opportunities for youngpeople

Opportunities for local suppliers &contractors

Taxes & other income for the stategovernment

Increased tourism

Local shops and businesses will benefit

Investment in new & existinginfrastructure

Trust & Acceptance

34 |

The change between surveys are not statistically significant.

Not at all

A great deal

Anchor Pulse 1 Pulse 2 Pulse 3 Pulse 4

Trust Terramin to act responsibly

Accept the underground gold mine being proposed by Terramin

Credibility & Legitimacy

35 |

The change between surveys are not statistically significant.

Terramin has credibility within the community

Terramin has legitimacy within the community

Strongly disagree

Strongly agree

Anchor Pulse 1 Pulse 2 Pulse 3 Pulse 4

Procedural Fairness

36 |

The change between surveys are not statistically significant.

Terramin is prepared to change its practices in response to community sentiment

Terramin listens to and respects my opinions with regard to community issues

Strongly disagree

Strongly agree

Anchor Pulse 1 Pulse 2 Pulse 3 Pulse 4

What’s next?

Presentation title | Presenter name37 |

What’s Next?

• Terramin and Innovation Connections to fund CSIRO to continue surveying for another 12 months.

• Invite existing participants to continue, but also open participation to new participants.

• Revised rewards approach – community based rewards.

• Great transparency and access to results via a project specific website hosted by CSIRO.

38 |

Mineral ResourcesNaomi Boughen Senior Researcher

t +61 7 3327 4109e naomi.boughen@csiro.au

Mineral ResourcesDr. Kieren MoffatGroup Leader, Reflexivity

t +61 7 3327 4724e kieren.Moffat@csiro.au

MINERAL RESOURCES

Thank you. Questions?