Lecture 6: Financing Based on Market Values I Discounted Cash Flow, Section 2.3, 2.4.1-2.4.3 ©...

Lecture 6: Financing Based on Market Values I

Discounted Cash Flow, Section 2.3,

2.4.1-2.4.3

2.3 Adjusted present value

Definition 2.4 (autonomous financing): A firm is autonomously financed if its future amount of debt is certain.

Theorem 2.4 (APV): If a firm is auonomously financed, then

Proof: trivial.

2.3 Constant debt

Theorem 2.5 (constant debt, MoMi): If and

const, then

Proof:

.l ut t tV V D

Tf sl u

t t s ts t f

Tut f t s t

ut f t

r DV V

V r Dr

2.3 Constant debt, againAn altered representation would be

We come back to this (or at least a similar) equation in the next lecture when talking about the Modigliani–Miller–adjustment.

l u lt

V V l V

E FCFV

2.3 The finite exampleWe now look at our finite example with

Hence,

This is also the value of the firm threatened by default.

.50,100,100 210 DDD

0 1 20 0 2 3

0.5 0.1 100 0.5 0.1 100229.75

1 0.1 1 0.1

0.5 0.1 50240.30.

f f fl u

r D r D r DV V

2.3 Future firm values

For later use we evaluate future firm value ,lV1

1 21 1 2

0.5 0.1 100 0.5 0.1 50

1 0.1 1 0.1

199.88 if up,

164.74 if down.

f fl u

r D r DV V

2.3 Debt and leverage ratio

Attention: The corresponding leverage ratio

is uncertain!

Hence, a certain amount of debt implies an uncertain leverage ratio! (And vice versa. . . )

50.03 % if up,

60.03 % if down,l

The finite case with default

Since we can use the APV-formula,

Another way of obtaining this value is by evaluating and discounting it with the riskless rate.

In addition let us determine the cost of debt,

0 240.30.lV [ ]uQ tE FCF

,2 2 3 3 2 3

1(1 ( ) ( | ) ( ( ) ) ( | )

1( ) 1

1(1 0.32962) 50 0.5 (48.4 0.5 50)0.5

1 0.5 150

13.281%.

D nom u

Dk dd D P u dd FCF ddd D P u dd

2.3 The infinite example

Here and constant debt

.100tD

2.4 Financing based on market values

Definition 2.5 (financing based on market values):

Financing is based on market values if debt ratios are certain.

The amount of future debt is uncertain! The tax advantages from debt are uncertain as well! APV does not apply! Instead three different

procedures. . .

2.4 The general procedure

To evaluate the company.1. We start with «appropriate» cost of capital.2. We assume that these costs of capital are deterministic

and apply (as usual) a corresponding valuation formula.3. We then look at the connection of these procedures: they

aregiven by textbook formulas.

There are three «appropriate» cost of capital, hence there will be

three valuation procedures: FTE, TCF, WACC.

Notice that default is not ruled out!

2.4.1 Flow to equity (FTE)

With FTE we are looking at the stockholders and their cost of

equity. The cash flow to stockholders is given by

Definition 2.6 (cost of equity): Costs of equity are conditional

expected returns

free cash flows

repayment and interest .

11 1 1

ltt t t t

E E FCF I Rk

2.4.1 FTE approach

Theorem 2.6 (FTE): If are deterministic, then

Proof: see our general valuation theorem (Theorem 1.1).Remarks:-FTE requires deterministic cost of equity.-The theorem does not yet require financing based on market values!-The leverage ratio does not appear in FTE.-The knowledge of expected repayment is necessary.

1 ... 1

lTs s s t

t E l E ls t t s

E FCF I RE

2.4.2 Total cash flow (TCF)

Now we are looking at the stockholders and debtholders, or the

cost of equity and debt.

Definition 2.7 (weighted average cost of capital – type 1):

WACC type 1 are conditional expected returns

lltt t

E V FCFk

TCF approach

Theorem 2.7 (TCF): If deterministic, then

Proof: see our general valuation theorem (Theorem1.1)Remarks:- TCF requires deterministic WACC type 1.- The theorem does not yet require financing based on market

values!- The leverage ratio does not appear in TCF.- The knowledge of expected debt is not necessary.

FØ Ø

1 t s-1

lTs tl

E FCFV

2.4.2 TCF textbook formula

What is the connection between FTE and TCF? The answer is the textbook formula.

Theorem 2.8 (TCF textbook formula): It always holds that

Ø , 1 .E l Dt t t t tk k l k l

2.4.2 ProofStart with definition cost of equity and use

1 1 1 1

,1 1 1 1 1

lt t t t t t

E l l lt t t t t t t t

E l l l Dt t t t t t t t

E l D l lt t t t t t t

E lt E E E FCF R I

k E E V FCF R D I

k E E V FCF D k D

k E k D E V FCF

D lt t t t

E l D l lt t t t t t t t

E l Dt tt tl l

E k D k V

E k E D k D V k V

E Dk k k

t t tUseV E D

2.4.2 Proof

,1 1 1

E l lt t t t t t

E l D l l

t t t t t

k E E FCF R I

k E E V FCF D k D

k E k D E V FC

E l D lt t t t t

E l Dt tt tl l

k E k D k V

E k E D k D V k V

E Dk k k

2.4.2 ProofUse definition of cost of debt

,1 1 1 1

E l lt t t t t t t

E l l lt t t t t

Dt t t

k E E E FCF R I

k E E V FCF

k E k D E V FCF

D lt t t t

E l Dt tt tl l

E k D k V

E k E D k D V k V

E Dk k k

2.4.2 ProofUse rule 5

,1 1 1 1

,1 1 1 1 1

E l lt t t t t t t

E l l lt t t t t

Dt t t

k E E E FCF R I

k E E V FCF R D I

k E E V FCF

k E E V F

D lt t t t

E l Dt tt tl l

E k D k V

E k E D k D V k V

E Dk k k

2.4.2 ProofUse definition of WACC type 1

,1 1 1 1

,1 1 1 1 1

l lt t

E l lt t t t t t t

E l Dt t t t

k E E E FCF R I

k E E V FCF R D I

k E E V FCF D k D

k E k FED C

lDt t t

E l Dt tt

E k E D k D V k V

E Dk k k

2.4.2 ProofRearrange terms,use l

t t tV E D

,1 1 1 1

,1 1 1 1 1

E l lt t t t t t t

k E E E FCF R I

k E E V FCF R D I

k E E V FCF D k D

k E k D E V FCF

D lt t t t

E l D lt t t t t

E l Dt tt tl l

lt t t

E k D k V

k E k D k V

E Dk k

2.4.2 ProofltDividebyV

,1 1 1 1

,1 1 1 1 1

E l lt t t t t t t

k E E E FCF R I

k E E V FCF R D I

k E E V FCF D k D

k E k D E V FCF

D lt t t t

E t tl Dt tl l

E k D k V

E k E D k D

k k kV

2.4.2 Proof.tApply definitionof leverageratio I QED

,1 1 1 1

,1 1 1 1 1

E l lt t t t t t t

k E E E FCF R I

k E E V FCF R D I

k E E V FCF D k D

k E k D E V FCF

D lt t t t

E l Dt tt tl l

E k D k V

E k E D k D V k V

E Dk k k

2.4.2 Remarks to TCF, I

The costs of debt are not reduced by the tax rate in the TCF textbook formula. The formula holds regardless of whether the relevant variables are deterministic or stochastic.

In particular: financing based on market values is not necessary!

But: if WACC type 1 as well as cost of equity and debt arecertain, then debt ratios must be certain as well! In this case, FTE and TCF can be used alternatively.

2.4.2 Remarks to TCF, II

On the other hand, in the case of no default: if the debt ratios are uncertain, either WACC type 1 or cost of equity has to beuncertain.

If WACC type 1 is deterministic TCF has to be used; youcannot apply FTE since costs of equity are uncertain.

If cost of equity is deterministic FTE has to be used; you cannot apply TCF since WACC type 1 is uncertain.

2.4.3 Weighted average cost of capital

We are now stockholders and debtholders again.

Definition 2.8 (weighted average cost of capital – type 2):

WACC type 2 are the conditional expected returns

Remark: These are costs of capital of a firm that is on the one hand levered

and on the other hand unlevered . Apples and oranges mixed here.

F1 1 |

: 1.l u

E V FCFWACC

WACC approachTheorem 2.9 (WACC): If is deterministic, then

Proof: see our general valuation theorem (Theorem 1.1)Remarks:– WACC requires deterministic WACC type 2.– The theorem above does not yet require financing based on market values!– The leverage ratio does not appear in WACC.– The knowledge of cash flow of an unlevered firm is necessary.

1 .... 1

uTs tl

ts t t s

E FCF FV

WACC WACC

WACC textbook formula

What is the connection between FTE and WACC? The answer

is another textbook formula.

Theorem 2.10 (WACC textbook formula): Always

, 1 1 .E l Dt t t t tWACC k l k l

2.4.3 ProofStart with definition cost of equity

,1 1 1

,1 1 1 1 1

lt t t t t t

E l l lt t t t t t t

E l l ut t t t t t t t t t

E l l u Dt t t t t f

E E E FCF R I

k E E V FCF D I

k E E V FCF D I I R D

k E E V FCF D r D k D

2.4.3 Proof

,1 1 1 1 1

E l lt t t t t t

E l l ut

t t t t t t t t t

E l l ut t t f

k E E FCF R I

k E E FCF D I

k E E V FCF D

D F| .D

t t tk D

t t tUseV E D

2.4.3 ProofMind tax advantage

,1 1 1

1 1 11

E l lt t t t t t t

E l lt t t t t t

E l l u Dt t t t t f t t

ut t t t

k E E E FCF R I

k E E V FCF D I

k E E V FCF D r D k D

t t tIFCF FCF

2.4.3 ProofUse definition of cost of debt

,1 1 1

E l lt t t t t t t

E l l ut t t t t t t

E l l ut

D Dtt t t t t

k E E E FCF R I

k E E V FCF D I

k E E V FC

kD D k DF .t

2.4.3 Proof

,1 1 1

,1 1 1 1 1

E l lt t t t t t t

E l l ut t t t t t t t t t

E l l u Dt t t t t f t t t

k E E E FCF R I

k E E V FCF D I

k E E V FCF D r D k D .

2.4.3 Proof, continued

Use rule 5

1E l l ut t t t t

E l D lt t t t t

tE l tt f tl

k Dk E E V FCF

k E k D WACC V

E k E D k D V WACC V

E Dk r WACC

Use definition of WACC type 2

11 1 1

E l Dt t t

tE l tt f tl l

l ut t t

k E k D

E k E D k D V

E V FCF

WACC V

E Dk r WACC

2.4.3 Proof, continuedRearrange terms and use

1 1 1 |

E l D l ut t t t t t

E l D lt t t t t

tE l tt f

lt t t

tl lt t

k E k D E V FCF

k E k D WACC V

E Dk r WACC

t t tV E D

Divide by

1 1 1 |

1 1 1 1

E l D lt t t t t

tE l tt f l

k E k D E V FCF

k E k D WACC V

E k E D k D V WA

E Dk r WACC

Apply definition of leverage ratio , q.e.d.

1 1 1 |

1 1 1 1

E l D lt t t t t

tE l tt f tl l

k E k D E V FCF

k E k D WACC V

E k E D k D V WACC V

E Dk r WACC

And this was to be shown. QED

2.4.3 Remarks, I

The costs of debt are reduced by the tax rate in the WACC

textbook formula. The formula holds regardless of wether the

relevant variables are deterministic or stochastic.

In particular: financing based on market values is not necessary!

But: if WACC type 2 as well as cost of equity and debt are

certain, then the debt ratios must be certain as well! In this case,

FTE and WACC can be used alternatively.

2.4.3Remarks, II

On the other hand, in the case of no default: if debt ratios are uncertain, either WACC type 2 or cost of equity has to be uncertain.

If WACC type 2 is deterministic WACC has to be used; you cannot apply FTE since costs of equity are uncertain.

If cost of equity is deterministic FTE has to be used; you cannot apply WACC since WACC is uncertain.

Summary

Lecture 6: Financing Based on Market Values I Discounted Cash Flow, Section 2.3, 2.4.1-2.4.3 ©...

Documents

Löffler 2013 Katalog

Psychoanalytische Therapien Henriette Löffler-Stastka

Grundinformation Forstwirtschaft 15. Jänner 2014 DI Werner Löffler

Das Elektrokardiogramm (EKG) Inhalt · 20.10.2017 1 © 2016 Löffler Notfallmedizin • Florian Löffler Das Elektrokardiogramm (EKG) © 2016 Löffler Notfallmedizin • Florian Löffler

PostGIS 2.4.3 Manual - OSGeo Download Serverdownload.osgeo.org/postgis/docs/postgis-2.4.3.pdf · 8.1 PostgreSQL PostGIS ... Manual. PostGIS 2.4.3 Manual. PostGIS 2.4.3 Manual. PostGIS

Bürostuhl Löffler BRASILIAN Chair KN - Pape+Rohde · Title: Bürostuhl Löffler BRASILIAN Chair KN Author: PAPE + ROHDE Büroeinrichtungen Düsseldorf - Keywords: Bürostuhl, ergonomisch,

Lecture 3: Business Values Discounted Cash flow, Section 1.3 © 2004, Lutz Kruschwitz and Andreas Löffler

Prof. Dr. Dr. Andreas Löffler - ifu.ruhr-uni-bochum.de · Wirtschaftswissenschaftliches Forum Prof. Dr. Dr. Andreas Löffler Universität Paderborn „Investitionsneutrale Steuersysteme

Presskit ArtofAgeing 150315 · Cast: Sabina Bijan / SophSabina Bijan / SophSabina Bijan / Sophia Löffler / Jan Andreesen / Col ia Löffler / Jan Andreesen / Colin Buzoianuia Löffler

Discounted Cash Flow - wacc.de · Discounted Cash Flow A Theory of the Valuation of Firms Lutz Kruschwitz and Andreas Löffler

Lutz Kruschwitz Stand vom 13. Juli 2020 · 2020. 7. 13. · Lutz Kruschwitz Schriftenverzeichnis Seite 5 42. ” Berechnung der Eﬀektivverzinsung“, Wirtschaftswissenschaftliches

CE203 - Application Programming Autumn 2013CE203 Part 01 Udo Kruschwitz udo@essex.ac.uk

Baubericht Grumman Bearcat F8F - condor-elsdorf.de Bearcat_2.pdf · Die Cat-Familie von Grumman F4F Wildcat F6F Hellcat F7F Tigercat . von Michael Löffler Michael Löffler Seite

Psychoanalytische Psychotherapie H. Löffler-Stastka

Nikola Langreiter, Klara Löffler (Hg.) - Buch.de · Do’it!’Yourself?’ Fragen"zu"(Forschungs0)Praktiken"des"Selbermachens" NIKOLA LANGREITER UND KLARA LÖFFLER Satzzeichen,

2.4.3. sz zrt

Sindrome de löffler: Neumonia eosinofila. Presentacion de

New DCF-Verfahren, Finanzierungspolitik und Steuern · 2012. 11. 16. · DCF-Verfahren, Finanzierungspolitik und Steuern Prof Dr. Lutz Kruschwitz*) undProf Dr. Dr. Andreas Löffler**)

Natur Massiv - Möbel Löffler

Lutz Kruschwitz & Andreas L¨offler Discounted Cash Flow