View
12
Download
0
Category
Preview:
Citation preview
Env
ironm
enta
l Rep
ort -
Sec
ond
Rev
isio
n, V
olum
e 2,
Jun
e 20
14
204
EDIN
BU
RG
H G
AR
DEN
DIS
TRIC
T SO
UTH
H
ousi
ng S
ite A
sses
smen
t W
ho m
ade
repr
esen
tatio
n(s)
rela
ting
to th
e as
sess
men
t are
a?
M
urra
y E
stat
es (H
olde
r Pla
nnin
g)
Si
te a
sses
smen
t crit
eria
YE
S / N
OC
omm
ents
/ m
itiga
tion
pote
ntia
l
App
ropr
iate
Loc
atio
ns
Is th
e si
te lo
cate
d on
bro
wnf
ield
land
? Y
/N
Maj
ority
of t
he s
ite is
ara
ble
farm
land
but
doe
s in
clud
e ex
istin
g pa
rk a
nd ri
de fa
cilit
y to
war
ds th
e no
rth w
est o
f the
site
and
indu
stria
l use
s in
the
north
eas
t cor
ner.
Can
the
site
be
mad
e av
aila
ble
for d
evel
opm
ent?
Y
R
epre
sent
atio
n re
ceiv
ed d
urin
g M
IR c
onsu
ltatio
n, a
nd P
ropo
sed
Pla
n re
pres
enta
tion
prom
otin
g th
e si
te fo
r res
iden
tial d
evel
opm
ent.
Par
ts o
f the
site
und
evel
opab
le d
ue to
fluv
ial f
lood
risk
. 1.
Doe
s th
e si
te h
ave
good
acce
ssib
ility
to e
xist
ing
publ
ic
trans
port?
2. W
ould
suf
ficie
nt
enha
ncem
ents
be
feas
ible
?
Y/N
Y/N
Sou
ther
n ha
lf of
site
has
a s
core
of A
with
acc
essi
bilit
y im
prov
ing
tow
ards
the
north
with
sco
res
of
B u
p to
E in
the
north
wes
t cor
ner o
f the
site
. N
o m
easu
res
avai
labl
e to
incr
ease
acc
essi
bilit
y fo
r sou
ther
n pa
rt of
the
site
with
out l
arge
sca
le
rero
utin
g of
pub
lic tr
ansp
ort s
ervi
ces.
1.
Doe
s th
e si
te h
ave
good
infra
stru
ctur
e ca
paci
ty?
2. W
ould
suf
ficie
nt
enha
ncem
ents
be
feas
ible
?
Y/N
Y
Dra
inag
e: S
eafie
ld W
wTW
ope
rate
d by
PFI
(Stir
ling
Wat
er);
no c
onst
rain
ts id
entif
ied
and
any
requ
irem
ent f
or a
dditi
onal
cap
acity
wou
ld b
e re
spon
sibi
lity
of P
FI o
pera
tor b
ut c
ould
be
dela
y in
de
liver
ing
capa
city
. W
ater
sup
ply/
stor
age:
Ade
quat
e ca
paci
ty (n
ew G
lenc
orse
WTW
, alo
ng w
ith e
xist
ing
Mar
chba
nk
WTW
). P
rimar
y an
d S
econ
dary
sch
ools
: Rev
ised
Edu
catio
n Ap
prai
sal i
dent
ifies
the
educ
atio
nal
infra
stru
ctur
e re
quire
d to
sup
port
hous
ing
grow
th. T
he a
ctio
n pr
ogra
mm
e in
clud
es a
list
of t
he
actio
ns, c
ostin
gs a
nd c
ontri
butio
n zo
nes
whe
re a
ny d
evel
opm
ent w
ithin
will
be re
quire
d to
co
ntrib
ute
to th
e ac
tions
on
an e
quita
ble
basi
s.
Tran
spor
t: Tr
ansp
ort A
ppra
isal
add
endu
m id
entif
ies
the
trans
port
infra
stru
ctur
e re
quire
d to
sup
port
hous
ing
grow
th. T
he a
ctio
n pr
ogra
mm
e in
clud
es a
list
of t
he a
ctio
ns, c
ostin
gs a
nd c
ontri
butio
n zo
nes
whe
re a
ny d
evel
opm
ent w
ithin
will
be
requ
ired
to c
ontri
bute
to th
e ac
tions
on
an e
quita
ble
basi
s.
Land
scap
e se
tting
and
iden
tity
Wou
ld th
e si
te, i
f dev
elop
ed, a
ffect
the
wid
er la
ndsc
ape
setti
ng o
f
the
city
?
Y
Thro
ugh
its a
dver
se e
ffect
on
the
rura
l lan
dsca
pe o
f rol
ling
farm
land
to th
e w
est o
f the
city
, whi
ch
prov
ides
an
open
fore
grou
nd to
vie
ws
to E
dinb
urgh
’s b
uilt
skyl
ine
and
back
drop
Pen
tland
Hills
fro
m s
trate
gic
appr
oach
es to
and
from
the
City
and
recr
eatio
nal r
esou
rce
of th
e U
nion
Can
al,
deve
lopm
ent o
f the
site
wou
ld a
ffect
the
land
scap
e se
tting
of t
he c
ity. D
evel
opm
ent w
ould
als
o re
sult
in a
con
tinuo
us b
uilt
up a
rea
to th
e w
est o
f the
city
, whi
ch w
ould
impa
ct o
n th
e se
para
te
iden
titie
s of
Edi
nbur
gh, H
erm
isto
n vi
llage
, Bar
berto
n, C
urrie
and
Jun
iper
Gre
en.
The
over
all s
patia
l stra
tegy
for t
he C
ity w
ould
be
alte
red
by d
evel
opm
ent i
n th
is lo
catio
n w
hich
is a
ke
y gr
een
wed
ge b
etw
een
the
exis
ting
settl
ed c
orrid
or a
long
Lan
ark
Roa
d W
est a
nd th
e A
8 (G
lasg
ow R
oad)
to th
e no
rth.
Wou
ld th
e si
te e
nabl
e cl
ear a
nd d
efen
sibl
e gr
een
belt
boun
darie
s
to b
e fo
rmed
?
N
The
exis
ting
gree
n be
lt bo
unda
ry is
cle
arly
form
ed b
y th
e C
ity B
ypas
s an
d its
woo
ded
cutti
ng to
the
east
.
Env
ironm
enta
l Rep
ort -
Sec
ond
Rev
isio
n, V
olum
e 2,
Jun
e 20
14
205
W
hils
t the
railw
ay to
the
sout
h pr
ovid
es a
stro
ng p
hysi
cal b
ound
ary
feat
ure,
dev
elop
men
t of t
he
site
wou
ld h
ave
impl
icat
ions
for t
he ro
le o
f lan
d w
ithin
the
gree
nbel
t to
the
north
of C
urrie
, Jun
iper
G
reen
and
Bab
erto
n. T
o th
e w
est,
the
gree
nbel
t bou
ndar
y w
ould
lie
to th
e so
uth
and
wes
t of t
he
Ric
carto
n C
ampu
s, w
ith th
e U
nive
rsity
and
Res
earc
h P
ark
bein
g re
mov
ed fr
om th
e gr
eenb
elt
thro
ugh
the
LDP
. To
the
north
, the
M8
prov
ides
a c
lear
phy
sica
l bou
ndar
y bu
t the
site
lack
s a
stro
ng e
dge
to G
ogar
Sta
tion
Roa
d to
the
sout
h of
the
Can
al, w
here
it a
djoi
ns p
art o
f the
wid
er 6
50
acre
Edi
nbur
gh G
arde
n D
istri
ct P
ropo
sal.
Can
the
site
be
inte
grat
ed in
to a
nd in
kee
ping
with
the
char
acte
r
of th
e se
ttlem
ent a
nd lo
cal a
rea?
N
Dev
elop
men
t of t
he s
ite w
ould
intro
duce
, lar
ge s
cale
urb
an re
side
ntia
l dev
elop
men
t, ac
ross
a
broa
d ex
tent
of r
ollin
g fa
rmla
nd to
the
wes
t of t
he c
ity, e
xten
ding
dev
elop
men
t bey
ond
the
exis
ting
urba
n ed
ge o
f the
City
Byp
ass.
Dev
elop
men
t wou
ld im
pact
adv
erse
ly o
n th
e op
en c
hara
cter
of t
he
land
scap
e, w
hich
pre
sent
ly p
rovi
des
an o
pen
setti
ng to
the
Sch
edul
ed M
onum
ent o
f the
Uni
on
Can
al, C
ity B
ypas
s, A
71 a
nd G
lasg
ow -
Edi
nbur
gh v
ia S
hotts
railw
ay to
the
wes
t of t
he C
ity. T
he
open
con
text
to th
e ea
st o
f Her
mis
ton
villa
ge w
ould
be
encl
osed
, mer
ging
this
sem
i-rur
al v
illage
w
ith th
e C
ity.
Whi
lst t
he C
anal
, Wes
tbur
n A
venu
e an
d le
vel c
ross
ing
prov
ide
acce
ss p
oint
s to
the
exiti
ng b
uilt
up a
rea
to th
e so
uth
and
east
of t
he s
ite, t
he M
8, B
ypas
s, A
71 a
nd ra
ilway
line
wou
ld
rest
rict t
he c
lose
inte
grat
ion
with
the
exis
ting
tow
nsca
pe a
t Wes
ter H
aile
s to
the
east
and
Bab
erto
n to
the
sout
h.
In a
dditi
on to
thes
e ba
rrier
s, s
urro
undi
ng la
nd u
se w
ould
als
o di
scou
rage
del
iver
y of
a w
ell
inte
grat
ed u
rban
exp
ansi
on. T
o th
e no
rthea
st o
f the
site
, new
resi
dent
ial d
evel
opm
ent a
djoi
ning
the
Can
al w
ould
be
sepa
rate
d fro
m e
xist
ing
hous
ing
at W
este
r Hai
les
beyo
nd th
e B
ypas
s by
indu
stria
l an
d co
mm
erci
al la
nd u
se. T
o th
e w
est,
the
non-
Inve
ntor
y de
sign
ed la
ndsc
ape
at R
icca
rton
is s
et
with
in p
erim
eter
tree
bel
ts. T
he U
nive
rsity
and
Res
earc
h P
ark
build
ings
are
focu
ssed
inw
ards
upo
n th
e ca
mpu
s la
ndsc
ape
and
wou
ld n
ot in
tegr
ate
phys
ical
ly o
r vis
ually
with
a n
ew re
side
ntia
l to
wns
cape
to th
e ea
st o
f Ric
carto
n M
ains
Rd.
To
the
sout
h of
the
railw
ay, B
aber
ton
Gol
f Cou
rse
and
arab
le la
nd s
urro
undi
ng th
e el
ectri
city
sub
-sta
tion
at C
orsl
et p
rovi
de s
epar
atio
n be
twee
n th
e si
te a
nd e
xist
ing
built
up
area
s of
Bab
erto
n, J
unip
er G
reen
and
Cur
rie.
In a
dditi
on to
resi
dent
ial d
evel
opm
ent,
this
are
a of
the
Gar
den
Dis
trict
pro
posa
l, in
clud
es th
e op
tion
of a
sta
dium
, ind
oor a
nd o
utdo
or s
ports
faci
litie
s. T
he s
iting
of t
hese
faci
litie
s to
the
east
of t
he s
ite
wou
ld fu
rther
dim
inis
h th
e in
tegr
atio
n of
new
resi
dent
ial d
evel
opm
ent w
ith th
e ex
istin
g bu
ilt u
p ar
ea
of th
e C
ity to
the
east
and
rein
forc
e se
para
tion
of th
e si
te to
the
north
and
sou
th o
f the
A71
. Th
ese
chan
ges
wou
ld im
pact
adv
erse
ly o
n vi
ews
expe
rienc
ed b
y a
wid
e nu
mbe
r of h
ighl
y se
nsiti
ve
recr
eatio
nal r
ecep
tors
from
the
Uni
on C
anal
, whi
ch ru
ns w
ithin
a ru
ral s
ettin
g to
the
wes
t of t
he
City
, des
pite
the
pres
ence
of s
ome
war
ehou
se b
uild
ings
at E
ast H
erm
isto
n.
Sou
thw
ard
view
s to
th
e P
entla
nd H
ills fr
om th
e C
anal
and
Gog
ar S
tatio
n R
oad
wou
ld b
e ob
scur
ed b
y de
velo
pmen
t.
The
loss
of o
pen
view
s ac
ross
ope
n fa
rmla
nd to
the
east
of H
erm
isto
n vi
llage
and
the
north
of t
he
A71
, wou
ld a
lter p
erce
ptio
ns o
f the
villa
ge’s
sep
arat
e id
entit
y.
Whi
lst v
ehic
ular
trav
elle
rs g
ener
ally
hav
e a
redu
ced
sens
itivi
ty to
land
scap
e ch
ange
, it i
s co
nsid
ered
that
dev
elop
men
t of a
site
of t
his
scal
e in
this
loca
tion
wou
ld im
pact
adv
erse
ly o
n la
rge
num
bers
of v
ehic
ular
trav
elle
rs.
Dev
elop
men
t of t
he s
ite w
ould
obs
truct
vie
ws
acro
ss th
e si
te’s
si
mpl
e, o
pen
fore
grou
nd to
war
ds th
e C
ity s
kylin
e an
d ba
ckdr
op o
f the
Pen
tland
Hills
from
stra
tegi
c ap
proa
ches
to a
nd fr
om th
e C
ity, i
nclu
ding
the
A71
, City
Byp
ass
and
mai
n ro
ute
to C
urrie
via
R
icca
rton
Mai
ns R
oad.
Tra
vellin
g so
uthw
ards
from
the
A71
to C
urrie
on
Ric
carto
n M
ains
Rd,
de
velo
pmen
t wou
ld b
e pe
rcei
ved
as a
con
tinuo
us b
uilt
up a
rea
with
Cur
rie, B
aber
ton
and
Juni
per
Env
ironm
enta
l Rep
ort -
Sec
ond
Rev
isio
n, V
olum
e 2,
Jun
e 20
14
206
Gre
en.
Due
to th
e sc
ale
of v
isua
l cha
nge,
dev
elop
men
t wou
ld h
ave
som
e ad
vers
e im
pact
on
view
s fro
m
the
north
ern
slop
es a
nd s
umm
its o
f the
Pen
tland
Hills
. D
evel
opm
ent w
ould
be
prom
inen
t in
the
mid
dle
grou
nd o
f vie
ws,
site
d to
the
north
of J
unip
er G
reen
and
Bab
erto
n, w
here
it w
ould
read
as
an e
xten
sion
of W
este
r Hai
les,
bou
nded
by
woo
dlan
d at
Ric
carto
n an
d G
ogar
. C
ount
rysi
de re
crea
tion
Wou
ld d
evel
opm
ent o
f the
site
avo
id im
pact
ing
upon
exi
stin
g
acce
ss to
cou
ntry
side
recr
eatio
n?
Y
Ove
rall
asse
ssm
ent
Not
cur
rent
ly a
reas
onab
le s
ite. S
outh
ern
part
of s
ite h
as p
oor p
ublic
tran
spor
t acc
essi
bilit
y w
ith n
o sc
ope
for e
nhan
cem
ents
with
out m
ajor
rero
utin
g of
pub
lic tr
ansp
ort s
ervi
ces.
D
evel
opm
ent w
ould
impa
ct o
n th
e la
ndsc
ape
setti
ng o
f the
city
, wou
ld n
ot p
rovi
de s
uita
ble
gree
n be
lt bo
unda
ries
and
wou
ld n
ot b
e in
kee
ping
with
the
char
acte
r of t
he s
ettle
men
t and
lo
cal a
rea.
La
ndsc
ape
and
Visu
al A
sses
smen
t
Site
Loc
atio
n Th
e si
te li
es to
the
wes
t of t
he C
ity, e
ast o
f Her
mis
ton
and
Ric
carto
n, a
nd to
the
north
of C
urrie
, Jun
iper
Gre
en a
nd B
aber
ton.
It i
s bo
unde
d by
the
M8
and
Her
mis
ton
Junc
tion
to th
e no
rth,
the
City
Byp
ass
to th
e ea
st, m
inor
road
of G
ogar
Sta
tion
Rd
and
Ric
carto
n M
ains
Rd
to th
e w
est.
To
the
sout
h, th
e si
te a
djoi
ns th
e Ed
inbu
rgh
– G
lasg
ow v
ia S
hotts
railw
ay a
nd th
e na
rrow
ro
ad to
Bab
erto
n H
ouse
link
ing
via
Wes
tbur
n Av
enue
from
Wes
ter H
aile
s to
the
sout
heas
t. Th
e si
te fo
rms
part
of th
e w
ider
650
acr
e E
dinb
urgh
Gar
den
Dis
trict
Pro
posa
l, pr
omot
ed b
y M
urra
y E
stat
es, w
hich
incl
udes
land
to th
e no
rth a
nd s
outh
of t
he U
nion
Can
al to
the
wes
t of t
he
City
Byp
ass,
in a
dditi
on to
land
to th
e ea
st o
f Millb
urn
Tow
er w
ithin
the
Wes
t Edi
nbur
gh S
DA
. In
add
ition
to h
ousi
ng, t
he in
dica
tive
mas
ter p
lan
prop
oses
the
optio
n of
a 2
5,00
0 ca
paci
ty
stad
ium
, ind
oor s
ports
faci
litie
s an
d pl
ayin
g fie
lds
to th
e w
est o
f the
Byp
ass.
La
ndsc
ape/
Tow
nsca
pe C
hara
cter
Fr
om a
hei
ght o
f 60
m a
bove
sea
leve
l alo
ng th
e M
8/H
erm
isto
n Ju
nctio
n to
the
north
of t
he s
ite, l
andf
orm
gra
dual
ly ri
ses
to th
e so
uth
to a
ppro
x. 1
05 m
abo
ve s
ea le
vel a
long
the
railw
ay li
ne
to th
e so
uthw
est.
The
site
form
s pa
rt of
the
wid
er la
ndsc
ape
patte
rn o
f rol
ling
farm
land
to th
e w
est o
f the
City
, whi
ch e
xten
ds s
outh
war
ds fr
om th
e co
asta
l mar
gin
to th
e fo
ot s
lope
s of
the
Pen
tland
Hill
s, a
cros
s a
serie
s of
ste
pped
eas
t-wes
t rid
gelin
es.
To th
e no
rth o
f the
ridg
elin
e of
Cal
der R
oad
(A71
), lie
s a
rela
tivel
y na
rrow
er s
ectio
n of
the
site
, app
roxi
mat
ely
0.5
km fr
om e
ast-w
est a
nd 0
.6 k
m fr
om n
orth
-sou
th.
To it
s w
est l
ies
the
Con
serv
atio
n A
rea
of H
erm
isto
n vi
llage
, cha
ract
eris
ed b
y its
line
ar a
rrang
emen
t of s
ingl
e st
orey
cot
tage
s w
ith c
ateg
ory
B L
iste
d H
erm
isto
n H
ouse
set
to it
s w
est i
n a
treed
non
-Inve
ntor
y de
sign
ed la
ndsc
ape.
To
the
north
and
eas
t, th
e si
te is
bou
nded
by
plan
ted
cutti
ngs
of th
e M
8 an
d C
ity B
ypas
s, b
eyon
d w
hich
lie
Her
mis
ton
Gai
t Ret
ail P
ark
to th
e no
rthea
st a
nd S
ight
hill
Indu
stria
l Est
ate
to th
e ea
st.
The
site
is c
ross
ed fr
om e
ast-w
est b
y th
e U
nion
Can
al a
nd to
wpa
th, s
et w
ithin
a tr
ee li
ned
corri
dor,
whi
ch fo
rms
Cor
e P
ath
15 a
nd p
asse
s un
der t
wo
List
ed
brid
ges.
To
its n
orth
lie
two
arab
le fi
elds
sep
arat
ed b
y a
tree
lined
sec
tion
of m
inor
road
, sev
ered
by
cons
truct
ion
of th
e m
otor
way
. S
outh
of t
he c
anal
, tw
o la
rge
arab
le fi
elds
adj
oin
the
A71
an
d G
ogar
Sta
tion
Rd
to th
e so
uth
and
wes
t, w
hils
t to
the
east
of t
he s
ite li
e w
areh
ouse
faci
litie
s an
d E
ast H
erm
isto
n Fa
rm.
The
area
has
a s
emi-r
ural
cha
ract
er, p
artly
con
ferre
d by
ope
n ar
able
land
and
tree
cov
er a
nd h
edge
row
s lin
ing
the
cana
l, ro
adsi
des
and
field
s bu
t with
urb
an in
fluen
ces
due
to it
s pr
oxim
ity to
maj
or tr
ansp
ort i
nfra
stru
ctur
e, w
areh
ouse
s an
d ur
ban
edge
to
the
east
. To
the
sout
h of
the
Cal
der R
d, th
e si
te b
road
ens
out t
o fo
rm a
wid
e ex
pans
e of
ope
n, 1
9th c
entu
ry to
pre
sent
am
alga
mat
ed a
rabl
e fa
rmla
nd, w
ith s
ome
post
and
wire
fenc
ing
and
rem
nant
st
rips
of h
edge
row
but
lim
ited
tree
cove
r. T
he fa
rmla
nd e
xten
ds s
outh
war
ds o
ver a
ppro
x. 1
km
to E
dinb
urgh
– G
lasg
ow v
ia S
hotts
railw
ay li
ne a
nd W
estb
urn
Aven
ue, t
o th
e so
uth
of w
hich
lie
impr
oved
gra
ssla
nd a
nd a
llotm
ents
resp
ectiv
ely,
to th
e no
rth a
nd w
est o
f the
woo
ded
edge
of B
aber
ton
and
Bab
erto
n G
olf C
ours
e. L
and
falls
acr
oss
the
mid
poin
t of t
he s
ite, w
here
the
Env
ironm
enta
l Rep
ort -
Sec
ond
Rev
isio
n, V
olum
e 2,
Jun
e 20
14
207
Murra
y B
urn
flow
s w
est-e
ast a
cros
s a
prom
inen
t dep
ress
ion,
line
d by
scr
ub v
eget
atio
n an
d sc
atte
red
trees
. To
the
sout
hwes
t Ric
carto
n M
ains
is s
et w
ithin
a w
oode
d en
clos
ure,
whi
lst t
o th
e w
est,
the
site
is b
ound
ed b
y th
e pe
rimet
er tr
ee b
elts
of H
erio
t-Wat
t Uni
vers
ity’s
Ric
carto
n ca
mpu
s, a
larg
e sc
ale
non-
Inve
ntor
y de
sign
ed la
ndsc
ape.
Tea
chin
g, re
side
ntia
l and
adm
inis
trativ
e bu
ildin
gs a
re s
et w
ithin
a w
ell p
lant
ed c
ampu
s la
ndsc
ape
arou
nd a
cen
tral w
oode
d ar
ea w
ith a
n op
en la
wn
and
loch
. Th
e so
uthe
rn p
art o
f the
cam
pus
is la
id o
ut a
s pl
ayin
g fie
lds
with
de
velo
pmen
t of t
he R
esea
rch
Par
k es
tabl
ishe
d to
the
north
of t
he c
ampu
s fro
m 1
980s
onw
ards
. To
its
north
wes
t, lie
s th
e C
ounc
il’s H
erm
isto
n P
ark
and
Rid
e fa
cilit
y, s
et w
ithin
pla
nted
bun
ds
but w
ith p
lann
ing
cons
ent t
o ex
tend
eas
twar
ds o
nto
the
site
in o
rder
to p
rovi
de c
apac
ity fo
r 100
0 ve
hicl
es.
The
site
is tr
aver
sed
by tw
o hi
gh v
olta
ge p
ower
lines
from
eas
t to
wes
t, st
emm
ing
from
the
sub-
stat
ion
at C
orsl
et to
the
sout
hwes
t. B
aber
ton
Mai
ns li
es to
the
sout
heas
t cor
ner o
f the
site
, whe
re W
estb
urn
Ave
nue
links
acr
oss
the
Byp
ass
from
Wes
ter H
aile
s. P
assi
ng u
nder
th
e ra
ilway
, the
road
lead
s so
uthw
ards
to c
onne
ct to
196
0-70
’s d
etac
hed
and
sem
i-det
ache
d ho
usin
g at
Bab
erto
n, c
onne
ctin
g w
estw
ards
und
er a
furth
er ra
il br
idge
to B
arbe
rton
Gol
f Cou
rse
and
stea
ding
at W
hite
law
, als
o fo
rmin
g a
Rig
ht o
f Way
. To
the
sout
hwes
t, th
e si
te is
cro
ssed
by
a na
rrow
road
bet
wee
n R
icca
rton
Mai
ns R
oad
and
Mui
rwoo
d R
d on
the
north
ern
edge
of
Cur
rie, w
hich
form
s a
Rig
ht o
f Way
, Don
key
Lane
. To
the
sout
hwes
t of t
he ra
ilway
line
lies
a p
rom
inen
t kno
ll an
d te
leco
ms
mas
t, be
yond
whi
ch a
rabl
e la
nd e
xten
ds to
urb
an e
dge
of C
urrie
an
d su
bsta
tion
to th
e so
uth.
Vi
ews
and
Visi
bilit
y Th
e si
te is
pro
min
ent i
n vi
ews
from
the
wid
er a
rea,
as
expe
rienc
ed fr
om m
ain
road
s an
d a
num
ber o
f rec
reat
iona
l rou
tes
to th
e w
est o
f the
City
. Th
e ar
able
land
on
the
ridge
to th
e no
rth o
f the
site
is p
rom
inen
t fro
m th
e ea
st e
nd o
f the
A71
, vis
ible
acr
oss
a br
oad
gras
sed
verg
e bu
t enc
lose
d fro
m v
iew
by
hedg
ing
to c
lose
r to
Her
mis
ton
to th
e w
est.
The
vie
w is
exp
erie
nced
by
larg
e nu
mbe
r of v
ehic
ular
trav
elle
rs, a
rrivi
ng a
nd d
epar
ting
the
City
, whe
reas
vie
ws
to th
is p
art o
f the
site
from
the
M8
to th
e no
rth a
nd C
ity B
ypas
s to
th
e ea
st a
re s
cree
ned
by p
lant
ed c
uttin
gs.
The
site
form
s a
back
drop
to v
iew
s fro
m H
erm
isto
n vi
llage
to th
e w
est,
whi
ch is
alig
ned
east
-wes
t and
has
an
east
war
d st
reet
vie
w to
war
ds th
e si
te, f
rom
whi
ch lo
cal r
esid
ents
wou
ld b
e su
scep
tible
to v
isua
l cha
nge.
Vie
ws
from
the
villa
ge a
re e
nclo
sed
by p
lant
ing
to th
e A
71 to
the
sout
h bu
t the
set
tlem
ent r
etai
ns a
n op
en a
spec
t to
the
Can
al to
the
north
. Th
e si
te is
ove
rlook
ed b
y th
ose
wor
king
at t
he w
areh
ouse
s to
the
east
and
resi
dent
s of
Eas
t Her
mis
ton
Farm
. Fr
om G
ogar
Sta
tion
Rd,
sou
thw
ard
view
s fe
atur
e op
en
farm
land
to e
ither
sid
e of
the
road
, with
the
linea
r pro
file
of H
erm
isto
n vi
llage
to th
e ea
st, s
et a
gain
st th
e di
stin
ctiv
e sk
ylin
e of
the
Pent
land
Hills
. Tra
velli
ng n
orth
war
ds v
iew
s ar
e en
clos
ed b
y pl
antin
g to
the
east
but
to th
e w
est r
evea
l ope
n ar
able
fiel
ds s
et a
gain
st s
ever
al n
on In
vent
ory
desi
gned
land
scap
es a
long
Gog
arba
nk, w
ith th
e M
8 sc
reen
ed fr
om v
iew
by
a cu
tting
. B
eyon
d th
e C
ity B
ypas
s an
d w
areh
ousi
ng a
t Eas
t Her
mis
ton,
the
surro
undi
ng fi
elds
pro
vide
a ru
ral s
ettin
g to
the
Can
al to
the
north
and
sou
th, i
nclu
ding
vie
ws
back
to H
erm
isto
n vi
llage
to th
e so
uthw
est,
whi
ch w
ould
be
expe
rienc
ed b
y m
any
user
s of
this
pop
ular
rout
e, in
clud
ing
boat
ers,
wal
kers
, cyc
lists
and
jogg
ers,
with
an
inte
rest
in th
eir s
urro
undi
ngs
and
high
sus
cept
ibilit
y to
ch
ange
s to
vis
ual a
men
ity.
The
mai
n pa
rt of
the
site
to th
e so
uth
of th
e C
alde
r Roa
d, fo
rms
an o
pen
fore
grou
nd o
f rol
ling
arab
le fa
rmla
nd in
long
er ra
nge
view
s fro
m th
e C
ity B
ypas
s, C
alde
r Rd
and
north
sec
tion
of
Ric
carto
n M
ains
Rd,
whi
ch o
nly
exis
ts to
the
east
of e
nclo
sing
pol
icy
woo
dlan
d at
Ric
carto
n an
d D
alm
ahoy
. Th
e si
te fe
atur
es p
rom
inen
tly in
sou
thw
ard
view
s ac
ross
to th
e w
oode
d rid
ge o
f B
aber
ton,
Bab
erto
n G
olf C
ours
e an
d th
e ra
ilway
line
, set
aga
inst
the
skyl
ine
of th
e P
entla
nd H
ills.
Pla
ntin
g ac
ross
the
mid
-sec
tion
of R
icca
rton
Mai
ns R
d pa
rtial
ly e
nclo
ses
east
war
d vi
ews
acro
ss th
e si
te.
From
the
sout
hern
sec
tion
of R
icca
rton
Mai
ns R
d, a
ppro
achi
ng C
urrie
, the
re a
re v
iew
s to
the
back
drop
of t
he P
entla
nds
and
east
war
d vi
ews
to th
e C
ity s
kylin
e an
d Ar
thur
’s
Sea
t. V
iew
s to
the
north
from
Ric
carto
n M
ains
Roa
d an
d ch
anne
lled
to th
e so
uth
and
east
by
perim
eter
tree
bel
ts o
f the
Ric
carto
n ca
mpu
s. R
oads
ide
view
s in
clud
e gl
imps
es o
f the
coa
stal
m
argi
n to
the
north
bey
ond
the
ridge
of C
alde
r Rd,
Cor
stor
phin
e H
ill to
the
north
east
and
city
sky
line
of C
astle
Roc
k an
d A
rthur
’s S
eat t
o th
e ea
st.
Whi
lst e
xper
ienc
ed b
y ve
hicl
e tra
velle
rs,
with
a re
duce
d su
scep
tibili
ty to
land
scap
e ch
ange
, vie
ws
exis
t ove
r rel
ativ
ely
prol
onge
d st
retc
hes
of o
pen
road
and
pro
vide
som
e sc
enic
val
ue o
n ro
utes
to a
nd fr
om th
e C
ity a
nd C
urrie
to th
e so
uth.
The
pre
senc
e of
ove
rhea
d po
wer
lines
, the
Par
k an
d R
ide
faci
lity
and
flatte
d de
velo
pmen
t at W
este
r Hai
les
does
not
ove
rly d
etra
ct fr
om th
e w
ide
scop
e of
vie
ws
acro
ss th
e op
en
land
scap
e to
the
wes
t of t
he C
ity.
Nor
thw
ard
view
s, fr
om th
e ro
ad a
nd R
ight
of W
ay b
etw
een
Wes
tbur
n Av
enue
and
ste
adin
g at
Whi
tela
w a
re in
par
t con
tain
ed b
y ro
adsi
de h
edge
s an
d ra
ilway
line
to th
e ea
st; h
owev
er,
elev
ated
pan
oram
ic v
iew
s ex
ist a
cros
s th
e si
te fr
om it
s w
este
rn e
nd, t
o th
e so
uth
of W
hite
law
leve
l cro
ssin
g. A
sim
ilar o
utlo
ok c
an a
lso
be g
aine
d tra
velli
ng a
long
the
Rig
ht o
f Way
bet
wee
n C
urrie
and
Ric
carto
n M
ains
, Don
key
Lane
, to
the
north
and
sou
th o
f the
leve
l cro
ssin
g. T
hese
vie
ws
enco
mpa
ss a
bro
ad e
xten
t of r
ollin
g fa
rmla
nd in
the
fore
and
mid
dle
grou
nd, s
et a
gain
st
the
back
drop
of t
he O
chils
to th
e no
rthw
est,
Forth
Roa
d an
d R
ail B
ridge
s, B
enar
ty H
ill a
nd th
e Lo
mon
d H
ills w
ithin
Fife
, and
to th
e no
rthea
st fl
atte
d de
velo
pmen
t in
Wes
ter H
aile
s an
d C
orst
orph
ine
Hill.
Fro
m m
id-w
ay a
long
the
Rig
ht o
f Way
bet
wee
n W
hite
law
and
Ric
carto
n, th
ere
are
open
vie
ws
to th
e ci
ty s
kylin
e to
the
east
, inc
ludi
ng th
e C
astle
and
Arth
ur’s
Sea
t, in
ad
ditio
n to
Cra
iglo
ckha
rt H
ills
and
the
Bra
id H
ills.
Ove
rhea
d lin
es a
re m
ore
dom
inan
t in
thes
e vi
ews
due
to p
roxi
mity
to th
e vi
ewpo
int a
nd p
ylon
tow
ers
bein
g si
lhou
ette
d ag
ains
t ope
n sk
y.
Thes
e vi
ews
wou
ld b
e ex
perie
nced
by
loca
l res
iden
ts a
nd re
crea
tiona
l rec
epto
rs fr
om m
inor
road
s an
d pa
th ro
utes
with
in th
e gr
een
belt
with
a h
igh
susc
eptib
ility
to c
hang
es to
vis
ual a
men
ity,
with
rail
trave
llers
, hav
ing
a m
ore
pass
ing
inte
rest
in th
eir s
urro
undi
ngs.
Th
e si
te is
ove
rlook
ed b
y re
lativ
ely
few
resi
dent
ial p
rope
rties
and
vie
ws
from
the
univ
ersi
ty c
ampu
s to
the
wes
t are
enc
lose
d by
per
imet
er tr
ee b
elts
, with
the
exce
ptio
n of
the
mai
n av
enue
ap
proa
ch.
Ric
carto
n M
ains
is re
lativ
ely
encl
osed
by
surr
ound
ing
slop
es a
nd it
s pl
ante
d cu
rtaila
ge.
Nor
thw
ard
view
s ac
ross
the
site
exi
st fr
om B
aber
ton
Mai
ns, W
hite
law
Cro
ssin
g C
otta
ge
and
Whi
tela
w to
the
sout
h. V
iew
s to
the
site
from
the
rear
of p
rope
rties
at M
uirw
ood
Rd,
Cur
rie to
the
sout
hwes
t wou
ld g
ener
ally
be
cont
aine
d by
pla
ntin
g al
ong
the
railw
ay li
ne a
nd th
e kn
oll
Env
ironm
enta
l Rep
ort -
Sec
ond
Rev
isio
n, V
olum
e 2,
Jun
e 20
14
208
to th
e w
est o
f Whi
tela
w.
Nor
thw
ard
view
s to
the
site
als
o ex
ist f
rom
ele
vate
d am
enity
gre
ensp
ace
with
in B
aber
ton
to th
e so
uth,
whe
re th
e si
te c
an b
e vi
ewed
acr
oss
roof
tops
in th
e fo
regr
ound
set
aga
inst
the
coas
tal m
argi
n, F
orth
Roa
d B
ridge
and
bac
kdro
p of
the
Och
ils.
The
site
is a
lso
likel
y to
be
visi
ble,
par
ticul
arly
in a
bsen
ce o
f sum
mer
folia
ge c
over
to g
olfe
rs a
t B
aber
ton
Gol
f Cou
rse.
D
ue to
the
scal
e of
the
site
and
the
cont
rast
of i
ts o
pen,
ara
ble
farm
land
aga
inst
pla
ntin
g to
the
City
Byp
ass
and
urba
n ed
ge to
the
east
, pol
icy
woo
dlan
d at
Ric
carto
n to
the
wes
t, G
ogar
to th
e no
rth a
nd B
aber
ton
to th
e so
uth,
the
site
is p
rom
inen
t in
long
er ra
nge
view
s fro
m th
e no
rther
n sl
opes
and
sum
mits
of t
he P
entla
nd H
ills.
C
an th
e si
te b
e in
tegr
ated
into
and
in k
eepi
ng w
ith th
e ch
arac
ter o
f the
set
tlem
ent a
nd lo
cal l
ands
cape
? D
evel
opm
ent o
f the
site
wou
ld in
trodu
ce, l
arge
sca
le u
rban
resi
dent
ial d
evel
opm
ent,
acro
ss a
bro
ad e
xten
t of r
ollin
g fa
rmla
nd to
the
wes
t of t
he c
ity, e
xten
ding
dev
elop
men
t bey
ond
the
exis
ting
urba
n ed
ge o
f the
City
Byp
ass.
Dev
elop
men
t wou
ld im
pact
adv
erse
ly o
n th
e op
en c
hara
cter
of t
he la
ndsc
ape,
whi
ch p
rese
ntly
pro
vide
s an
ope
n se
tting
to th
e S
ched
uled
Mon
umen
t of
the
Uni
on C
anal
, City
Byp
ass,
A71
and
Gla
sgow
- E
dinb
urgh
via
Sho
tts ra
ilway
to th
e w
est o
f the
City
. Th
e op
en c
onte
xt to
the
east
of H
erm
isto
n vi
llage
wou
ld b
e en
clos
ed, m
ergi
ng th
is
sem
i-rur
al v
illag
e w
ith th
e C
ity.
Whi
lst t
he C
anal
, Wes
tbur
n Av
enue
and
leve
l cro
ssin
g pr
ovid
e ac
cess
poi
nts
to th
e ex
iting
bui
lt up
are
a to
the
sout
h an
d ea
st o
f the
site
, the
M8,
Byp
ass,
A71
an
d ra
ilway
line
wou
ld re
stric
t the
clo
se in
tegr
atio
n w
ith th
e ex
istin
g to
wns
cape
at W
este
r Hai
les
to th
e ea
st a
nd B
aber
ton
to th
e so
uth.
Be
yond
thes
e ba
rrier
s to
acc
ess,
sur
roun
ding
land
use
wou
ld a
lso
disc
oura
ge d
eliv
ery
of a
wel
l int
egra
ted
urba
n ex
pans
ion.
To
the
north
east
of t
he s
ite, n
ew re
side
ntia
l dev
elop
men
t ad
join
ing
the
Can
al w
ould
be
sepa
rate
d fro
m e
xist
ing
hous
ing
at W
este
r Hai
les
beyo
nd th
e B
ypas
s by
indu
stria
l and
com
mer
cial
land
use
. To
the
wes
t, th
e no
n-In
vent
ory
desi
gned
la
ndsc
ape
at R
icca
rton
is s
et w
ithin
per
imet
er tr
ee b
elts
. Th
e U
nive
rsity
and
Res
earc
h P
ark
build
ings
are
focu
ssed
inw
ards
upo
n th
e ca
mpu
s la
ndsc
ape
and
wou
ld n
ot in
tegr
ate
phys
ical
ly o
r vi
sual
ly w
ith a
new
resi
dent
ial t
owns
cape
to th
e ea
st o
f Ric
carto
n M
ains
Rd.
The
ope
n ex
pans
e of
the
Park
and
Rid
e fa
cilit
y to
the
north
wes
t of t
he s
ite w
ould
als
o fo
rm a
siz
eabl
e ga
p in
any
ne
w u
rban
layo
ut.
To th
e so
uth
of th
e ra
ilway
, Bab
erto
n G
olf C
ours
e an
d ar
able
land
sur
roun
ding
the
elec
trici
ty s
ub-s
tatio
n at
Cor
slet
pro
vide
sep
arat
ion
betw
een
the
site
and
exi
stin
g bu
ilt
up a
reas
of B
aber
ton,
Jun
iper
Gre
en a
nd C
urrie
. In
add
ition
to re
side
ntia
l dev
elop
men
t, th
is a
rea
of th
e G
arde
n D
istri
ct p
ropo
sal,
incl
udes
the
optio
n of
a s
tadi
um, i
ndoo
r and
out
door
spo
rts fa
cilit
ies.
The
siti
ng o
f the
se fa
cilit
ies
to th
e ea
st
of th
e si
te w
ould
furth
er d
imin
ish
the
inte
grat
ion
of n
ew re
side
ntia
l dev
elop
men
t with
the
exis
ting
built
up
area
of t
he C
ity to
the
east
and
rein
forc
e se
para
tion
of th
e si
te to
the
north
and
sou
th
of th
e A
71.
Thes
e ch
ange
s w
ould
impa
ct a
dver
sely
on
view
s ex
perie
nced
by
a w
ide
num
ber o
f hig
hly
sens
itive
recr
eatio
nal r
ecep
tors
from
the
Uni
on C
anal
, whi
ch ru
ns w
ithin
a ru
ral s
ettin
g to
the
wes
t of
the
City
, des
pite
the
pres
ence
of s
ome
war
ehou
se b
uild
ings
at E
ast H
erm
isto
n.
Sout
hwar
d vi
ews
to th
e P
entla
nd H
ills
from
the
Can
al a
nd G
ogar
Sta
tion
Roa
d w
ould
be
obsc
ured
by
deve
lopm
ent.
The
loss
of o
pen
view
s ac
ross
ope
n fa
rmla
nd to
the
east
of H
erm
isto
n vi
llage
and
the
north
of t
he A
71, w
ould
alte
r per
cept
ions
of t
he v
illage
’s s
epar
ate
iden
tity.
W
hils
t veh
icul
ar tr
avel
lers
gen
eral
ly h
ave
a re
duce
d se
nsiti
vity
to la
ndsc
ape
chan
ge, i
t is
cons
ider
ed th
at d
evel
opm
ent o
f the
site
wou
ld im
pact
adv
erse
ly o
n la
rge
num
bers
of v
ehic
ular
tra
velle
rs.
Dev
elop
men
t of t
he s
ite w
ould
obs
truct
vie
ws
acro
ss th
e si
te’s
sim
ple,
ope
n fo
regr
ound
tow
ards
the
City
sky
line
and
back
drop
of t
he P
entla
nd H
ills fr
om s
trate
gic
appr
oach
es to
an
d fro
m th
e C
ity, i
nclu
ding
the
A71
, City
Byp
ass
and
mai
n ro
ute
to C
urrie
via
Ric
carto
n M
ains
Roa
d. T
rave
lling
sou
thw
ards
from
the
A71
to C
urrie
on
Ric
carto
n M
ains
Rd,
dev
elop
men
t w
ould
be
perc
eive
d as
a c
ontin
uous
bui
lt up
are
a w
ith C
urrie
, Bab
erto
n an
d Ju
nipe
r Gre
en.
Dev
elop
men
t wou
ld a
lso
impa
ct a
dver
sely
on
north
war
d vi
ews
expe
rienc
ed b
y lo
cal r
esid
ents
, pat
h us
ers
and
rail
trave
llers
from
the
sout
h, w
here
dev
elop
men
t wou
ld o
bstru
ct n
orth
war
d vi
ews
to th
e ci
ty s
kylin
e an
d C
orst
orph
ine
Hill
to th
e no
rthea
st a
nd n
orth
war
ds to
the
coas
tal m
argi
n, F
orth
Est
uary
, For
th R
oad
and
Rai
l Brid
ges
and
dist
ant h
ills
beyo
nd.
Whi
lst t
he m
ajor
ity o
f dev
elop
men
t wou
ld b
e sc
reen
ed b
y pe
rimet
er tr
ee b
elts
sur
roun
ding
Ric
carto
n C
ampu
s, d
evel
opm
ent w
ould
impa
ct a
dver
sely
on
open
vie
ws
to th
e ea
st fr
om th
e m
ain
aven
ue a
ppro
ach.
D
ue to
the
scal
e of
vis
ual c
hang
e, d
evel
opm
ent w
ould
hav
e so
me
adve
rse
impa
ct o
n vi
ews
from
the
north
ern
slop
es a
nd s
umm
its o
f the
Pen
tland
Hill
s. D
evel
opm
ent w
ould
be
prom
inen
t in
the
mid
dle
grou
nd o
f vie
ws,
site
d to
the
north
of J
unip
er G
reen
and
Bab
erto
n, w
here
it w
ould
read
as
an e
xten
sion
of W
este
r Hai
les,
bou
nded
by
woo
dlan
d at
Ric
carto
n an
d G
ogar
. In
add
ition
to re
side
ntia
l dev
elop
men
t, th
e si
ting
and
desi
gn o
f a s
tadi
um fa
cilit
y w
ould
hav
e to
be
just
ified
in te
rms
of it
s us
e an
d po
sitiv
e co
ntrib
utio
n to
the
skyl
ine
of th
e C
ity.
Its p
ropo
sed
loca
tion
on th
e lo
cal r
idge
line
of th
e A
71 w
ould
mak
e it
prom
inen
t in
view
s fro
m th
e su
rroun
ding
road
s an
d P
entla
nd H
ills to
the
sout
h. T
he e
xist
ing
flatte
d bl
ocks
at W
este
r Hai
les
prov
ide
som
e in
dica
tion
with
rega
rd to
the
visi
bilit
y of
tall
build
ings
in th
is lo
catio
n.
Env
ironm
enta
l Rep
ort -
Sec
ond
Rev
isio
n, V
olum
e 2,
Jun
e 20
14
209
Wou
ld th
e si
te if
dev
elop
ed, a
ffect
the
wid
er la
ndsc
ape
setti
ng o
f the
city
? Th
roug
h its
adv
erse
effe
ct o
n th
e ru
ral l
ands
cape
of r
ollin
g fa
rmla
nd to
the
wes
t of t
he c
ity, w
hich
pro
vide
s an
ope
n fo
regr
ound
to v
iew
s to
Edi
nbur
gh’s
bui
lt sk
ylin
e an
d ba
ckdr
op P
entla
nd
Hills
from
stra
tegi
c ap
proa
ches
to a
nd fr
om th
e C
ity a
nd re
crea
tiona
l res
ourc
e of
the
Uni
on C
anal
, dev
elop
men
t of t
he s
ite w
ould
und
erm
ine
gree
n be
lt ob
ject
ives
. D
evel
opm
ent w
ould
als
o re
sult
in a
con
tinuo
us b
uilt
up a
rea
to th
e w
est o
f the
city
, whi
ch w
ould
impa
ct o
n th
e se
para
te id
entit
ies
of E
dinb
urgh
, Her
mis
ton
villa
ge, B
arbe
rton,
Cur
rie a
nd J
unip
er G
reen
. Th
e ov
eral
l sp
atia
l stra
tegy
for t
he C
ity w
ould
be
alte
red
by d
evel
opm
ent i
n th
is lo
catio
n, g
iven
the
exis
ting
settl
ed c
orrid
or a
long
Lan
ark
Roa
d W
est a
nd th
e W
ater
of L
eith
to th
e so
uthw
est a
nd fo
cus
of
deve
lopm
ent w
ithin
the
Wes
t Edi
nbur
gh S
trate
gic
Dev
elop
men
t Are
a to
the
north
. W
ould
the
site
ena
ble
clea
r and
def
ensi
ble
Gre
en B
elt b
ound
arie
s to
be
form
ed?
The
exis
ting
gree
n be
lt bo
unda
ry is
cle
arly
form
ed b
y th
e C
ity B
ypas
s an
d its
woo
ded
cutti
ng to
the
east
. W
hils
t the
railw
ay to
the
sout
h pr
ovid
es a
stro
ng p
hysi
cal b
ound
ary
feat
ure,
dev
elop
men
t of t
he s
ite w
ould
hav
e im
plic
atio
ns fo
r the
role
of l
and
with
in th
e gr
eenb
elt t
o th
e no
rth o
f Cur
rie,
Juni
per G
reen
and
Bab
erto
n. T
o th
e w
est,
the
gree
nbel
t bou
ndar
y w
ould
lie
to th
e so
uth
and
wes
t of t
he R
icca
rton
Cam
pus,
with
the
Uni
vers
ity a
nd R
esea
rch
Par
k be
ing
rem
oved
from
the
gree
nbel
t thr
ough
the
LDP
, in
line
with
nat
iona
l pol
icy.
To
the
north
, the
M8
prov
ides
a c
lear
phy
sica
l bou
ndar
y bu
t the
site
lack
s a
stro
ng e
dge
to G
ogar
Sta
tion
Roa
d to
the
sout
h of
the
Can
al, w
here
it a
djoi
ns p
art o
f the
wid
er 6
50 a
cre
Edi
nbur
gh G
arde
n D
istri
ct P
ropo
sal.
Env
ironm
enta
l Rep
ort -
Sec
ond
Rev
isio
n, V
olum
e 2,
Jun
e 20
14
210
EDIN
BU
RG
H G
AR
DEN
DIS
TRIC
T W
EST
Hou
sing
Site
Ass
essm
ent
Who
mad
e re
pres
enta
tion(
s) re
latin
g to
the
asse
ssm
ent a
rea?
Mur
ray
Est
ates
(Hol
der P
lann
ing)
Site
ass
essm
ent c
riter
ia
YES
/ NO
Com
men
ts /
miti
gatio
n po
tent
ial
App
ropr
iate
Loc
atio
ns
Is th
e si
te lo
cate
d on
bro
wnf
ield
land
? Y
/N
Maj
ority
of t
he s
ite is
ara
ble
farm
land
but
doe
s in
clud
e cl
uste
rs o
f exi
stin
g ho
usin
g to
the
north
and
so
uth
and
indu
stria
l use
s in
the
north
eas
t cor
ner o
f the
site
. C
an th
e si
te b
e m
ade
avai
labl
e fo
r dev
elop
men
t?
Y
Rep
rese
ntat
ion
rece
ived
dur
ing
MIR
con
sulta
tion,
and
Pro
pose
d P
lan
repr
esen
tatio
n pr
omot
ing
the
site
for r
esid
entia
l dev
elop
men
t. P
art o
f the
site
und
evel
opab
le d
ue to
fluv
ial f
lood
risk
. 1.
Doe
s th
e si
te h
ave
good
acce
ssib
ility
to e
xist
ing
publ
ic
trans
port?
2. W
ould
suf
ficie
nt
enha
ncem
ents
be
feas
ible
?
N
N
Maj
ority
of s
ite h
as a
sco
re o
f A. A
cces
sibi
lity
impr
oves
tow
ards
the
sout
h ea
st c
orne
r of t
he s
ite
with
sco
res
of B
up
to E
in th
e co
rner
of t
he s
ite n
ext t
o th
e pa
rk a
nd ri
de s
ite.
No
mea
sure
s av
aila
ble
to in
crea
se a
cces
sibi
lity
for m
ajor
ity o
f thi
s si
te w
ithou
t lar
ge s
cale
rero
utin
g of
pub
lic tr
ansp
ort s
ervi
ces.
1.
Doe
s th
e si
te h
ave
good
infra
stru
ctur
e ca
paci
ty?
2. W
ould
suf
ficie
nt
enha
ncem
ents
be
feas
ible
?
Y/N
Y
Dra
inag
e: S
eafie
ld W
wTW
ope
rate
d by
PFI
(Stir
ling
Wat
er);
no c
onst
rain
ts id
entif
ied
and
any
requ
irem
ent f
or a
dditi
onal
cap
acity
wou
ld b
e re
spon
sibi
lity
of P
FI o
pera
tor b
ut c
ould
be
dela
y in
de
liver
ing
capa
city
. W
ater
sup
ply/
stor
age:
Ade
quat
e ca
paci
ty (n
ew G
lenc
orse
WTW
, alo
ng w
ith e
xist
ing
Mar
chba
nk
WTW
). P
rimar
y an
d S
econ
dary
sch
ools
: Rev
ised
Edu
catio
n Ap
prai
sal i
dent
ifies
the
educ
atio
nal
infra
stru
ctur
e re
quire
d to
sup
port
hous
ing
grow
th. T
he a
ctio
n pr
ogra
mm
e in
clud
es a
list
of t
he
actio
ns, c
ostin
gs a
nd c
ontri
butio
n zo
nes
whe
re a
ny d
evel
opm
ent w
ithin
will
be re
quire
d to
co
ntrib
ute
to th
e ac
tions
on
an e
quita
ble
basi
s.
Tran
spor
t: Tr
ansp
ort A
ppra
isal
add
endu
m id
entif
ies
the
trans
port
infra
stru
ctur
e re
quire
d to
sup
port
hous
ing
grow
th. T
he a
ctio
n pr
ogra
mm
e in
clud
es a
list
of t
he a
ctio
ns, c
ostin
gs a
nd c
ontri
butio
n zo
nes
whe
re a
ny d
evel
opm
ent w
ithin
will
be
requ
ired
to c
ontri
bute
to th
e ac
tions
on
an e
quita
ble
basi
s.
Land
scap
e se
tting
and
iden
tity
Wou
ld th
e si
te, i
f dev
elop
ed, a
ffect
the
wid
er la
ndsc
ape
setti
ng o
f
the
city
?
Y
Thro
ugh
its e
ffect
on
the
rura
l set
ting
to a
nd v
isua
l am
enity
from
the
Uni
on C
anal
, City
Byp
ass,
M8
and
A71
, dev
elop
men
t wou
ld im
pact
adv
erse
ly o
n pe
rcep
tions
of E
dinb
urgh
and
its
wid
er
land
scap
e fro
m a
n im
porta
nt re
crea
tiona
l res
ourc
e an
d st
rate
gic
appr
oach
road
s to
the
wes
t of t
he
city
. The
con
cent
ratio
n of
rela
tivel
y in
tact
des
igne
d la
ndsc
apes
and
rolli
ng a
rabl
e la
nd o
n th
e w
este
rn e
dge
of th
e ci
ty h
as a
lso
been
reco
gnis
ed a
s of
city
-wid
e la
ndsc
ape
valu
e th
roug
h th
e C
ounc
il’s
Rev
iew
of L
ocal
Lan
dsca
pe D
esig
natio
ns.
The
land
with
in th
e si
te to
the
east
of t
he
Gog
ar B
urn
has
been
foun
d to
be
cons
iste
nt w
ith th
e vi
sual
qua
litie
s an
d ch
arac
teris
tics
prop
osed
fo
r des
igna
tion.
W
ould
the
site
ena
ble
clea
r and
def
ensi
ble
gree
n be
lt bo
unda
ries
to b
e fo
rmed
?
N
The
exis
ting
gree
n be
lt bo
unda
ry is
cle
arly
form
ed b
y th
e C
ity B
ypas
s an
d its
woo
ded
cutti
ng to
the
east
. Th
e A7
1 an
d ad
jace
nt p
olic
y w
oodl
and
at R
icca
rton
and
Dal
mah
oy to
the
sout
h, th
e w
oode
d rid
ge
of G
ogar
bank
to th
e no
rth a
nd p
olic
ies
of A
ddis
toun
to th
e w
est f
orm
phy
sica
l and
vis
ual f
eatu
res
capa
ble
of fo
rmin
g an
alte
rnat
ive
gree
n be
lt bo
unda
ry.
The
site
lack
s a
defe
nsib
le b
ound
ary
to th
e no
rthw
est,
whe
re it
is b
ound
ed b
y he
dger
ows.
Env
ironm
enta
l Rep
ort -
Sec
ond
Rev
isio
n, V
olum
e 2,
Jun
e 20
14
211
Can
the
site
be
inte
grat
ed in
to a
nd in
kee
ping
with
the
char
acte
r
of th
e se
ttlem
ent a
nd lo
cal a
rea?
N
Dev
elop
men
t of t
he s
ite w
ould
intro
duce
urb
an re
side
ntia
l dev
elop
men
t acr
oss
rolli
ng, a
rabl
e fa
rmla
nd to
the
sout
h of
Gog
arba
nk a
nd n
orth
of t
he A
71.
Dev
elop
men
t wou
ld im
pact
adv
erse
ly
on th
e op
en c
hara
cter
of t
he la
ndsc
ape,
whi
ch p
rese
ntly
pro
vide
s a
rura
l set
ting
to o
ver 2
km
of t
he
Uni
on C
anal
to th
e w
est o
f the
city
and
set
ting
to s
ever
al n
on-In
vent
ory
desi
gned
land
scap
es.
Dev
elop
men
t wou
ld e
nclo
se th
e hi
stor
ic v
illag
e of
Her
mis
ton
Con
serv
atio
n A
rea,
whi
ch b
enef
its
from
an
open
, rur
al s
ettin
g an
d re
latio
nshi
p to
the
Uni
on C
anal
to th
e no
rth.
The
M8,
City
Byp
ass
and
A71
, pro
vide
a p
hysi
cal b
arrie
r to
the
clos
e in
tegr
atio
n be
twee
n th
e si
te a
nd e
xist
ing
city
to
wns
cape
to th
e ea
st a
nd in
the
case
of t
he M
8, th
e la
nd to
the
north
and
sou
th o
f the
site
. W
hils
t a
num
ber o
f cro
ssin
gs to
the
Can
al e
xist
, the
se w
ould
requ
ire to
be
supp
lem
ente
d to
ach
ieve
a
fully
inte
grat
ed s
ite la
yout
.
Thes
e ch
ange
s w
ould
impa
ct a
dver
sely
on
view
s fro
m re
crea
tiona
l rou
te o
f the
Uni
on C
anal
, al
terin
g th
e op
en v
iew
s to
Her
mis
ton
villa
ge a
nd th
e P
entla
nd H
ills
to th
e so
uth
and
the
woo
ded
back
drop
of G
ogar
bank
to th
e no
rth. T
he a
dditi
onal
hei
ght o
f dev
elop
men
t wou
ld b
e pr
omin
ent i
n vi
ews
from
the
A71
to th
e so
uth
and
sect
ions
of t
he M
8 to
the
north
, the
reby
impa
ctin
g ad
vers
ely
on v
iew
s fro
m s
trate
gic
appr
oach
road
s, fr
om w
hich
an
impr
essi
on o
f the
City
and
its
cont
ext c
an
be u
nder
stoo
d by
larg
e nu
mbe
rs o
f veh
icul
ar tr
avel
lers
. D
evel
opm
ent w
ould
impa
ct a
dver
sely
on
view
s fro
m a
num
ber o
f min
or ro
ads
with
in th
e gr
eenb
elt,
man
y of
whi
ch p
rovi
de o
pen
view
s ac
ross
the
surr
ound
ing
coun
trysi
de a
nd a
re u
sed
for a
var
iety
of l
ocal
trav
el a
nd in
form
al
recr
eatio
n to
the
wes
t of t
he c
ity.
C
ount
rysi
de re
crea
tion
Wou
ld d
evel
opm
ent o
f the
site
avo
id im
pact
ing
upon
exi
stin
g
acce
ss to
cou
ntry
side
recr
eatio
n?
N
A la
rge
stre
tch
of th
e U
nion
Can
al is
loca
ted
with
in th
e ce
ntre
of t
he s
ite. D
evel
opm
ent w
ould
si
gnifi
cant
ly e
ffect
the
rura
l set
ting
of th
e ca
nal a
nd it
s ro
le in
pro
vidi
ng c
ount
rysi
de re
crea
tion
betw
een
Edin
burg
h an
d R
atho
. O
vera
ll as
sess
men
tN
ot c
urre
ntly
a re
ason
able
site
. Site
has
poo
r pub
lic tr
ansp
ort a
cces
sibi
lity
with
no
scop
e fo
r enh
ance
men
ts w
ithou
t maj
or re
rout
ing
of p
ublic
tran
spor
t ser
vice
s. D
evel
opm
ent w
ould
im
pact
on
the
land
scap
e se
tting
of t
he c
ity, w
ould
not
pro
vide
sui
tabl
e gr
een
belt
boun
darie
s an
d w
ould
not
be
in k
eepi
ng w
ith th
e ch
arac
ter o
f the
set
tlem
ent a
nd lo
cal a
rea.
The
pr
opos
al w
ould
als
o im
pact
on
exis
ting
acce
ss to
cou
ntry
side
recr
eatio
n.
Land
scap
e an
d Vi
sual
Ass
essm
ent
Si
te L
ocat
ion
The
site
lies
to th
e no
rth a
nd s
outh
of t
he U
nion
Can
al to
the
wes
t of t
he C
ity.
It is
bou
nded
by
the
Cal
der R
d (A
71) t
o th
e so
uth,
Add
isto
un F
arm
Roa
d to
the
wes
t, G
ogar
bank
Rd
and
the
Edi
nbur
gh –
Gla
sgow
Que
en S
t rai
lway
to th
e no
rth a
nd M
8/H
erm
isto
n Ju
nctio
n an
d G
ogar
Sta
tion
Rd
to th
e ea
st.
The
site
form
s pa
rt of
the
wid
er 6
50 a
cre
Edi
nbur
gh G
arde
n D
istri
ct P
ropo
sal,
prom
oted
by
Mur
ray
Est
ates
, whi
ch in
clud
es la
nd to
the
east
of H
erm
isto
n an
d R
icca
rton
and
to th
e w
est o
f the
C
ity B
ypas
s, in
add
ition
to la
nd to
the
east
of M
illbur
n To
wer
with
in th
e W
est E
dinb
urgh
SD
A.
Land
scap
e/To
wns
cape
Cha
ract
er
The
ridge
line
runn
ing
alon
g th
e C
alde
r Roa
d (A
71) f
orm
s th
e so
uthe
rn e
dge
of th
e si
te a
t app
rox
80 m
abo
ve s
ea le
vel,
from
whi
ch p
oint
land
form
gra
dual
ly s
lope
s to
the
north
and
eas
t to
appr
ox 6
0 m
abo
ve s
ea le
vel,
boun
ded
by th
e rid
ge o
f Gog
arba
nk to
the
north
, whi
ch fa
lls fr
om 7
5 m
– 6
0 m
abo
ve s
ea le
vel f
rom
wes
t to
east
. Th
e G
ogar
Bur
n cr
osse
s th
e si
te to
the
wes
t, se
t with
in a
nar
row
val
ley,
bef
ore
runn
ing
east
war
ds a
long
the
sout
hern
edg
e of
Gog
arba
nk.
To th
e w
est o
f the
Gog
ar B
urn,
land
form
is re
lativ
ely
flat.
The
Recommended