View
228
Download
0
Category
Preview:
Citation preview
8/8/2019 Dilemma of Boybands 1st ed
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/dilemma-of-boybands-1st-ed 1/35
?
V`n feknbbo hi Dhu"domf|
V`n fowm hi \hleok tn|shm|edekevu
@nlvht L`oso \ejoqwn
8/8/2019 Dilemma of Boybands 1st ed
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/dilemma-of-boybands-1st-ed 2/35
4
V`n feknbbo hi Dhu"domf|
V`n fowm hi \hleok tn|shm|edekevu
Mnwlo|vkn ~shm Vumn+ 43?3
@nlvht L`oso \ejown
Jnuwhtf|1 Dhu"domf|+ getk"domf|+ Vojn v`ov+ Fn|vemu l`ekf+ Wn|vkein+ \hleok tn|shm|edekevu+ ^J
b~|el emf~|vtu+ Np"iolvht |nten|+ Ft~g|+ sosotoe+ o~vhgtos`|+ bhmnu
Fe|lkoebnt1 V`n otvelkn| levnf omf emlk~fnf em v`e| fe|lh~t|n otn o lhbsekovehm hi |nyntok emvntmnv
sh|evemg‘| ithb dkhg|+ mnw|sosnt otvelkn|+ ~mq~okeienf emvntyenw| omf lhbbnmv| ithb snt|hmokeven| em
v`n emf~|vtu omf o| |~l` lommhv dn ~|nf iht kngok s~tsh|n|-
Vodkn hi Lhmvnmv|
Od|vtolv------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- 6
?-3 Emvthf~lvehm vh Bom~iolv~tnf dhu domf|----------------------------------------------------------------------------------- >
4-3 Nyhk~vehm hi dhu"domf| ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- 7
O DTENI KN\\HM EM B^\ELOK @E\VHTU1 ---------------------------------------------------------------------------- 5
V@N ?593'| ) V@N DETV@ HI V@N STHVH"DHUDOMF1 ----------------------------------------------------- ?3
V@N ?573'| JNNSEMG EV EM V@N IOBEKU1 ---------------------------------------------------------------------------- ??
V@N ?503'|+ BN IET\V B^\EL IHT V@N BN IET\V FNLOFN1 ------------------------------------------ ?4
V@N ?553'|+ V@N FNLOFN HI V@N DHU DOMF1 ------------------------------------------------------------------ ?<
4333 OMF DNUHMF+ O DTOYN MNW BEKKNME^B1 ------------------------------------------------------------ ?6
4-? Dhu Domf| --------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- ?9
4-4 Getk Domf| --------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- ?9
4-< Bepnf Domf| ----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- ?9
<-3 Odtefgnf @e|vhtu " Jnu Nynmv| du Fnlofn ----------------------------------------------------------------------------- ?7?593|----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- ?7
?573|----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- ?7
?503|----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- ?7
?553| omf dnuhmf --------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- ?7
6-3 @hw vh \shv o Bom~iolv~tnf Domf ----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- ?0
>-3 @hw vh \shv o Dhu Domf --------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- ?0
9-3 Do|el Omovhbu hi o dhu domf ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- ?5
7-3 Do|el Omovhbu hi o Getk Domf ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------ ?5
8/8/2019 Dilemma of Boybands 1st ed
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/dilemma-of-boybands-1st-ed 3/35
<
0-3 V`n Fnov` hi o Bom~iolv~tnf Domf ---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- 43
0-? @hw vh oyhef Bom~iolv~tnf Domf| ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- 43
0-4 \`h~kf b~|el htgome|ovehm| `oyn o |hleok tn|shm|edekevu8 --------------------------------------------------- 4?
0-< Sthdknb| omf ghhf npobskn hi vuselok Domf e||~n|" Fn|vemu‘| L`ekf --------------------------------- 44
5-3 Vuselok sthdknb| em dhu domf| ----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- 4>
?3-3 Lhmlk~|ehm| odh~v Dhu"domf| ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- <3
??-3 Dedkehgtos`u omf bovnteok ~|nf ----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- <6
8/8/2019 Dilemma of Boybands 1st ed
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/dilemma-of-boybands-1st-ed 4/35
6
Od|vtolv
Bom~iolv~tnf domf| `oyn dnnm v`n wou tnlhtfemg omf b~|el bomognbnmv htgome|ovehm| bojn bhmnu-
Dhu| omf getk| `oyn ftnob| hi dnlhbemg shs |vot| hyntmeg`v omf v`e| ottomgnbnmv |nnb| vh dn
b~v~okku dnmnieleok- \nyntok vusn| hi d~|emn|| bhfnk| `oyn dnnm ~|nf vh bottu v`n|n vwh lobs|- V`n
bh|v lhbbhm hmn e| w`ntn bnbdnt| hi o tnlhtfemg vnob |lh~v iht tow voknmv omf emvthf~ln v`n efno
hi iobn+ bhmnu+ dteg`v keg`v| omf Lemfntnkko vusn hi lhmlk~|ehm vh i~v~tn fnokemg| wev` |votynf b~|el
nmv`~|eo|v w`h beg`v mhv mnln||oteku `oyn voknmv d~v `oyn khhj|+ |np ossnok omf |nnbemgku
botjnvodkn- V`n|n uh~mg dhu| omf getk| otn hiintnf |hleok ofyomvogn| v`ov hmku ftnob| otn bofn hii
omf em mh vebn ov okk+ v`nu otn lh"hsvnf emvh b~|el gth~s| lokknf ‛domf|‒ omf tnlhtfemg lhmvtolv| otn
`omfnf h~v- Iht o sntehf hi ossthpebovnku ?4 bhmv`|+ v`n|n uh~mg nmv`~|eo|v| otn bofn iobh~|+ tel`
omf hi lh~t|n `oyn v`net keyn| l`omgnf ihtnynt-
V`h|n uh~v`| w`h `oyn voknmv omf lhmvem~n dnemg lhbbntleokku yeodkn wekk `oyn nyntko|vemg dnmniev|v`ov lom knof vh ebsh||edkn `neg`v| hi ebshtvomln em v`n lhbb~mevu- ^mihtv~movnku+ v`h|n uh~v`| w`h
vnmf vh offtn|| v`n mnw"ih~mf"iobn wev` ~m|nvvknfmn|| kh|n v`net emmhlnmln omf lhkkos|n |hleokku
knofemg vh fnstn||ehm|+ s|ul`hkhgelok omf bnmvok fnstoyevu- V`n|n |ebsku dnlhbn du"sthf~lv| hi
bom~iolv~temg sthln|| hi v`n b~|el emf~|vtu- V`nu otn ihtghvvnm omf kniv vh iemf tnftn|| nk|nw`ntn
w`ek|v v`n tnlhtfemg lhbsomen| bhyn hm vh |nknlv omf bom~iolv~tn mnw i~v~tn b~|el elhm|-
V`n b~|el emf~|vtu vhfou e| steboteku iht ltnovemg wnokv` omf shwnt iht v`h|n w`h jmhw v`n shwnt"
shemv| hi v`n emf~|vtu+ knoyemg v`n wnoj omf ~mo||~bemg fobognf iht kein- Lnmv~ten| ogh+ b~|el wo|
bnomv iht nmvntvoembnmv omf wo| o l~kv~tok o||nv iht feiintnmv leyeke|ovehm| w`nm osskenf em v`n lhttnlv
|nq~nmln- V`e| `o| mhw dnnm kh|v omf v`ntn otn |nteh~| tnsntl~||ehm| em vhfou‘| lhbb~meven|+ v`~|
tnq~etemg |nteh~| ovvnmvehm vh tnlosv~tn v`n bogel v`ov b~|el hmln sthyefnf iht v`n whtkf-
\vojn`hkfnt| omf v`n otve|v| okejn `oyn om hdkegovehm vh dnlhbn |hleokku tn|shm|edkn vh ottn|v v`n
l~ttnmv vtnmf du tnsh|evehmemg omf tnfniememg v`n ebsolv hi v`e| emf~|vtu hm |hlenvu- Htgome|ovehm|
tn|efnmv em v`n emf~|vtu `oyn tnlnmvku lhbbnmlnf vh offtn|| v`e| s`nmhbnmhm v`th~g` lhtshtovn
|hleok tn|shm|edekevu o| |nnm em v`n yoteh~| sthgtobbn| omf hsntovehm| nbskhunf-
8/8/2019 Dilemma of Boybands 1st ed
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/dilemma-of-boybands-1st-ed 5/35
>
?-3 Emvthf~lvehm vh Bom~iolv~tnf dhu domf|
Em v`n ?553| dhu domf inynt vhhj v`n ^mevnf Jemgfhb du |vhtb o| gth~s oivnt gth~s hi
uh~mg bnm fomlnf omf |omg v`net wou emvh v`n `notv| hi bekkehm| hi vnnmogn getk| omf bhtn
v`om o inw dhu|/ Nmvntvoembnmv vhhj hm o feiintnmv fniemevehm o| bekkehm| hi sh~mf| wntn
|snmv em bom~iolv~temg v`n mnw lhbbhfevu v`ov wo| |nkkemg o| `hv lojn|1 V`n dhu"domf-
V`n ?503| |ow v`n te|n hi v`n bom~iolv~tnf dhu domf omf v`n bom v`ov |votvnf ev okk+ Bo~teln
\vott ojo ”V`n Gnmntok+ v`n nbomlesovht+ ltnovht+ fhbemovht+ v`n emmhyovht omf v`n htegemovht
hi v`n dhu domf-‘ Bo~teln ihtbnf Mnw Jef| hm v`n Dkhlj+ o domf wefnku ollkoebnf o| v`n
iet|v nynt bom~iolv~tnf dhu domf-
Vojemg `e| em|setovehm ithb v`tnn `eg`ku |~lln||i~k domf| ithb v`n ?593| omf 73| " V`n
Bhmjnn|+ V`n Aolj|hm| omf V`n H|bhmf|+ Bo~teln ftnw bogel nknbnmv| ithb v`n v`tnn
domf| vh ihtb v`n ~m|vhssodkn Mnw Jef| hm v`n Dkhlj+ vojemg v`n dhu domf vh omhv`nt
febnm|ehm- Sthkeiel fomlnt| lhbdemnf wev` nfgu kutel|+ bofn o lhljvoek v`ov q~nml`nf v`n
v`et|v hi v`n mnw BVY gnmntovehm omf bofn `h~|n"weyn| omf v`h|n em ~mnbskhubnmv `oyn
|hbnv`emg vh khhj iht w`nm v~tmemg v`n |bokk v~dn hm-
Bhyemg owou ithb v`n emmhlnmln hi V`n H|bhmf| omf V`n Aolj|hm| vh sthf~ln w`ov `nfn|ltednf o| ”fniemevnku+ v`n `~gn|v dhu domf hi okk vebn‘+ Mnw Jef| Hm V`n Dkhlj losveyovnf
getk| whtkfwefn+ soyemg v`n wou iht v`n dhu domf| hi v`n i~v~tn- V`ov wo| v`n detv` hi v`n
l~ttnmv i~thtn v`ov e| v`n lhmlnmvtovehm hi v`n nmvntvoembnmv emf~|vtu em v`n whtkf-
Olth|| v`n shmf em Dkeg`vu+ Boml~meom Megnk Botvem"\bev` lhvvhmnf hm vh v`n efno
fe|lhyntemg ieyn g~u| w`h|n omhmubh~| ioln| |hhm dnlobn o domf jmhwm vh v`n whtkf o|
Vojn V`ov- Megnk dnkenynf em iemfemg v`ov |hbnv`emg |snleok1
‛V`n|n fou| ev‘| okk odh~v+ lom uh~ |emg o lh~skn hi dot| em v~mn+ w`ov‘| v`ov ghv vh fh wev`
iemfemg v`n mnpv deg v ̀ emg8 Bh|v snhskn lom |emg vh |hbn fngtnn omf v`ntn‘| v`e| d~vvhm v`ov
v`nu `oyn em |v~feh| v`n|n fou| lokknf o~vh v~mn- V`n bh|v ebshtvomv v`emg e| v`ov v`nu `oyn
ghv |vot q~okevu-‒ Megnk Botvem"\bev`
Ev e| wev`h~v fh~dv v`ov Vojn V`ov nbntgnf vh dnlhbn v`n iet|v Dteve|` bom~iolv~tnf dhu
domf omf v`n bh|v |~lln||i~k Dteve|` domf |emln v`n Dnovkn|+ |nkkemg hynt ?5 bekkehm tnlhtf| vh
8/8/2019 Dilemma of Boybands 1st ed
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/dilemma-of-boybands-1st-ed 6/35
9
fovn- Wev` oboemg l`ote|bo omf l`nbe|vtu hm |vogn+ b~|el bhg~k Snvn Wovntbom fn|ltedn|
v`nb o|
”Hmn hi v`n gtnovn|v dhu domf| hi okk vebn‘-
Vojn V`ov veljnf v`n dhpn| w`nm ev lobn vh snt|hmokevu omf khhj|+ o lhbdemovehm v`ov lo~|nf
hd|n||eyn `u|vnteo obhmg v`n iom|- V`nu wntn v`n okk"ebshtvomv ‛sh~mf gnmntovemg‒ iolvhtu
v`ov wo| ~m|vhssodkn o| v`nu nyofnf nynm v`n bh|v lhm|ntyoveyn `hbn| em v`n ^mevnf
Jemgfhb-
\ebekotku+ No|v ?7 dnlobn v`n sntinlv omvefhvn+ ovvtolvemg v`h|n iom| w`h wntn vetnf hi Vojn
V`ov―| |q~noju lknom ioçofn omf iomlenf o dev hi th~g`- V`e| wo| iolekevovnf du ih~t yntu
l`nnju+ |npu uh~mg bnm ithb No|v Khmfhm w`h ahemnf ihtln| ltnovemg gtnov shs teyoktu em
v`n mnw nto hi v`n bom~iolv~tnf dhu domf- Omvhmu Lh|vo ithb dhu domf Dk~n tnbnbdnt| v`n
fou| wnkk1
‛E wo| No|v ?7 ov |l`hhk dnlo~|n ev wo| v`n lhhk domf d~v E ~|nf vh ke|vnm vh Vojn V`ov ov
`hbn-‒ Omvhmu L h|vo ithb Dk~n-
B~l` hi v`n teyoktu wo| dnvwnnm v`n bomognt| tov`nt v`om v`n domf bnbdnt| d~v fn|sevn v`n
|~lln|| hi No|v ?7+ mhv`emg lh~kf nlkes|n w`ov Vojn V`ov `of ol`enynf- Du ?55< Vojn V`ov
wntn v`n dk~n stemv iht okk v`n nknbnmv| hi ‛`hw vh lhm|vt~lv v`n sntinlv dhu domf ‒ bom~ok iht
okk wh~kf"dn dhu"domf hwmnt|- V`net |~lln|| ghofnf ^\ domf| w`h v`h~g`v v`nu lh~kf |`hw
^J domf| o v`emg ht vwh- \kelj Obntelom dhu domf|+ M \uml omf Dolj|vtnnv Dhu| wntn odkn
vh d~|v h~v o losnkko wev` v`net `hv fomln bhyn| ov v`n fths hi o `ov omf |votvnf o tesskn oiinlv
ihtlemg npe|vemg gth~s| vh |vns ~s ht |vns h~v- B~|el bomognt Kh~e| Wok|` |oef1
‛Obntelom domf| `oyn dnvvnt sthf~lvehm d~v E v`emj Ete|` omf Nmgke|` dhu domf| `oyn dnvvnt
khhj| omf snt|hmokeven|+ omf dnv vnt bomognt|/‒ Kh~e| Wok|`
Em ?559 Wok|` ihkkhwnf |~ev wev` Dhuhmn omf ofbev| w`nm ev lobn vh ltnovemg v`nb `n
do|elokku lhsenf Vojn V`ov- O dhu iht nyntu vusn+ wev` v`n offnf vh~l` hi |hbn Ete|` l`otb+
Dhuhmn dnlobn v`n bh|v shs~kot Ete|` dhu domf hi v`n ?553|-
Ev e| ethmelok v`ov `ntn wn otn vhfou: okbh|v 43 unot| sh|v Vojn V`ov…………ht otn wn8
8/8/2019 Dilemma of Boybands 1st ed
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/dilemma-of-boybands-1st-ed 7/35
7
\h a~|v w`ov `ossnmnf vh okk v`n dhu domf |~snt|vot| v`ov inkk du v`n wou|efn8 W`ntn otn v`nu
mhw8 Fef dnemg em o dhu domf keyn ~s vh okk v`nu ebogemnf8 Bomognbnmv lhbsomen| `oyn
tnoke|nf v`ov ev e| mhv nmh~g` vh |ebsku ‛bom~iolv~tn‒ o domf omf `hsn ev wekk h~v "ko|v
lhbsnvemg domf| em v`n otnmo wev`h~v v`n emvthf~lvehm hi o |hleok tn|shm|edekevu o|snlv vh v`n
ottomgnbnmv- O khhj ov v`n nyhk~vehm hi v`n ‛dhu" domf‒ lhmlnsv wh~kf `nks vh dtemg emvh
snt|snlveyn v`n e||~n| v`ov |~tth~mf dhu"domf|-
4-3 Nyhk~vehm hi dhu"domf|
Du |ebskn fniemevehm+ o ‛bom~iolv~tnf domf‒ e| o gth~s hi snhskn w`h otn s~v vhgnv`nt du o
tnlhtf lhbsomu em htfnt vh bojn o sthiev- V`n|n snhskn `oyn okbh|v lntvoemku mnynt bnv
dnihtn+ `oyn ghhf khhj| omf ~mihtv~movnku b~|elok voknmv e| yntu hivnm mhv o |nteh~| lhmlntm-
V`nu otn ~|~okku |nknlvnf hm khhj| hynt voknmv+ o| v`e| |nnb| vh dn v`n hmku wou vh vos emvh o
uh~mg botjnv v`ov `o| kevvkn b~|elok emvntn|v- Ev |nnb| vh dn o lo|n hi ‛w`h lotn| odh~v b~|el+
wn lom |nkk tnlhtf| wev` |np/‒ omf v`e| `o| gtessnf v`n emf~|vtu kejn o yeln-
Wev` v`n fowm hi v`n emf~|vteok ogn v`n |jekk| hi v`n emfeyef~ok ltoiv|bom dnlobn hd|hknvn em
v`n ioln o| bnl`ome|ovehm omf bo||"sthf~lvehm- V`n emynmvehm hi v`n vnknye|ehm mnotku wesnf
h~v v`n omlenmv em|vev~vehm hi v`n v`novtn omf v`n fhbemomv |v~feh| hi @hkkuwhhf |bhv`ntnf
v`net emfnsnmfnmv lhbsnvevehm vh ikhhf v`n mo|lnmv lemnbo `okk| wev` v`net ihtb~koel vokn| hi
bovnteoke|b+ o lhmlnsv gkh||nf hynt du v`n gnmntok| em v`n nmvntvoembnmv emf~|vtu/
Em v`n fe|htenmvemg lulkhmn hi l`omgn v`ov wo| v`n vwnmvenv` lnmv~tu ev |nnbnf v`ov v`n hmn
l~kv~tok sekkot v`ov wh~kf wev`|vomf v`n tnknmvkn|| botl` hi losevoke|v sthgtn|| wo| v`ov hi
b~|el- Snt`os| v`n hkfn|v hi `~bom ol`enynbnmv|+ b~|el `of dnnm ko~fnf o| v`n komg~ogn hi
khyn omf v`n dhfeku nps~k|ehm| hi v`n ghf| v`nb|nkyn|- V`e| wo| o lhmlnsv wnkk ebdednf du
okk nmvntvoembnmv htgome|ovehm| v`ov lhmvthk v`n |nkkemg hi v`n|n efno|- \hbn npobskn| hi dhu"
domf| v`ov lobn vh sthbemnmln d~v fe|ossnotnf o| io|v o| v`nu lobn otn o| ihkkhw|1
Oivnt 7 “ lom‘v |vhs
V`n domf `of |keg`vku getku yhlok|+ d~v v`nu wntn o q~okevu gth~s v`ov tnegmnf dteniku omf v`nm
fe|ossnotnf emvh snoj fotjmn||- V`nu mnynt q~evn dnvvntnf v`e|+ v`net iet|v `ev- V`ntn e| o tnokku
i~mmu hkf |jhhk dhhvkng hi v`e| v`ov |snnf| v`n yhlok| ~s vh `nke~b dokkhhm sthshtvehm|+ lokknf
‛lhhjemg wev` fnkeo‒-
8/8/2019 Dilemma of Boybands 1st ed
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/dilemma-of-boybands-1st-ed 8/35
0
Fobogn “ khyn vh khyn
Uh~mg Dteve|` domf ithb v`n bef"53| w`h wntn emvntbevvnmvku |~lln||i~k- Nyntuhmn iomlenf
dof dhu lhtnn+ w`h `o| |emln dnnm em ste|hm- Knof |emgnt aofn ahmn| `o| dnnm ghemg h~v wev`
|seln getk Nbbo D~mvhm iht odh~v vnm unot|+ omf v`nu tnlnmvku `of o mnw dodu-
Ft~ `ekk “ uh~ otn nyntuv`emg
E mnynt tnokku ghv v`n w`hkn ‛Ft~ `ekk v`emg omf |e|qh‒+ vh bn+ e| mhv ovvtolveyn omf e fhm‘v
nynm v`emj `n lom |emg- V`ov w`hkn v`hmg |hmg v`emg wo| tefel~kh~| d~v fef t~kn v`n |~bbnt
hi 4333+ n|snleokku v`n gotogn tnbep-
Emvth “ knv bn dn v`n hmn
Ioetku |~lln||i~k domf em v`n notku 53|+ d~v mhv o| |~lln||i~k o| dkolj|vtnnv+ mhv o| |~gotu o|
dhu ee bnm omf a~|v jemf hi…- w`el` wo| o sthdknb iht stnvvu b~l` okk hi v`n gth~s| hm v`e|
ke|v- V`nu a~|v fef mhv `oyn w`ov ev vojn| vh lhmvem~n dnemg o |nkkemg kodnk-
Mnpv “ d~vvo khyn
V`nu fef v`n w`hkn ‛dof dhu‒ v`emg iot bhtn lhmyemlemgku v`om Ft~ `ekk- ”vhh lkh|n‘ wo| hi
lh~t|n `~gn+ omf v`nm… mhv |~tn ei v`nu |vekk tnlhtf ht w`ntn v`nu otn-
\`oe “ ei e nynt
V`nu wntn `oeknf o| v`n mnw dhu ee bnm+ w`nm v`nu lobn h~v wev` v`e| vtolj- Yhk~bn hi
bovnteok ossnotnf vh dn o sthdknb o| v`e| wo| tnbepnf omf tnkno|nf bomu vebn|-
\ekj “ `hhjnf hm uh~
Hmn whmfnt| `hw v`n|n gth~s| innk w`nm Dteve|` dhu"domf| kejn omhv`nt knynk vojn v`net
|egmov~tn v~mn (itnoj bn+ em v`e| lo|n% omf `oyn v`n `ev v`nu mnynt lh~kf8 e `hsn v`nu gnv soef
wnkk+ d~v e inot v`n hmku snt|hm w`h ko~g`| okk v`n wou vh v`n domj e| v`n |hmgwtevnt-
\h~k iht tnok “ nyntu kevvkn v`emg
Oivnt lomfu toem+ bomu snhskn |ov dolj omf woevnf iht o fe|bok |nq~nk- Vh dn ioet+ v`e| fef
okbh|v o| wnkk+ snt`os| dnvvnt em v`n ^J+ omf v`nu |q~nnnf h~v o inw bhtn `ev| ihtb v`net
fnd~v omf o| iot o| tnlhtfnf `e|vhtu jmhw|+ v`nu hmku fef hmn okd~b-
8/8/2019 Dilemma of Boybands 1st ed
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/dilemma-of-boybands-1st-ed 9/35
5
Vhfou “ `eb ht bn
V`nu thfn v`n mnw aolj |wemg woyn em v`n yntu notku 53|+ d~v mnynt q~evn l`okknmgnf Vnffu
teknu |~sntgth~s g~u ht otn nynt fe|l~||nf em b~|el letlkn| omu bhtn-
Vthhs “ |wnnv Mhynbdnt
V`nu hmku fef hmn okd~b+ d~v v`e| e| o |wnnv lhynt ynt|ehm- Kevvkn e| jmhwm odh~v v`n gth~s
omf lhbbnmvoten| `oyn mh efno `hw |~lln||i~k ev bou ht bou mhv `oyn dnnm em v`n ^\+ d~v em
v`n ^J+ Vthhs fef |q~ov iht o w`ekn-
Ev e| |of vh bnmvehm v`n fnbe|n hi bh|v hi v`n|n dhu"domf| em v`e| bommnt d~v v`ntn |nnb| o
mnnf vh npskhtn |ev~ovehm| omf letl~b|vomln| v`ov stnyoeknf em v`n unot| w`nm v`nu tnegmnf vh
~mfnt|vomf v`n sev"iokk| v`ov lh~kf `oyn dnnm oyhefnf- Stn|~bodku+ o dteni `e|vhtu hm b~|el
omf v`n |nyntok e||~n| v`ov bofn |~lln|| ev| hwm yomq~e|`nt wh~kf dn mnln||otu-
O DTENI KN\\HM EM B^\ELOK @E\VHTU1
Em v`n notken|v fou| bomjemf `of hll~senf `e| vemu stn"`e|vhtel bemf du domfemg v`n dhmn| hi
v`n omebok| v`ov `n `~mvnf omf gov`ntnf ogoem|v thlj|+ vtnn| omf v`n `nof| hi `e| inkkhw
loynbnm b~l` vh v`n fnkeg`v hi okk- Em kovnt vebn| bom fe|lhyntnf v`ov yoteh~| bovnteok|
sthf~lnf bhtn skno|emg |h~mf| v`om hv`nt| omf dngom vh io|`ehm lt~fn b~|elok em|vt~bnmv|
|~l` o| v`n iet|v ft~b du |vtnvl`emg omebok |jem hynt o yn||nk |~l` o| om omebok |j~kk omf
|vtejemg ev tnsnovnfku wev` om omebok dhmn (v`n omebok bhvei dnemg deg ov v`n vebn%- Otbnf
wev` `e| ft~b+ stn`e|vhtel bom ob~|nf `e| inkkhw| o| v`nu fhfgnf gkolent| vh `e| f~kk omf
emln||omv dnovemg hi v`n stebeveyn em|vt~bnmv- Wn jmhw v`e| ithb nyefnmln em v`n ihtb hi o
`~mvnt"gov`ntnt bokn ih~mf stn|ntynf em gkoleok eln `eg` em v`n Oks| lk~vl`emg a~|v |~l` o
ft~b omf dnotemg nyefnmln v`ov `e| |j~kk wo| loynf em ithb dn`emf+ bh|v kejnku du hmn hi `e|
lhbsomehm| (sh||edku v`n whtkf'| iet|v b~|el ltevel/%-
V`emg| `of l`omgnf o gtnov fnok du v`n vebn hi v`n Beffkn Ogn| omf N~thsn em sotvel~kot
tn|h~mfnf vh v`n v~mn hi bem|vtnk| w`h vtoynkknf v`n komf |stnofemg |hmg| hi lh~tvku khyn omf
fnyhvehm vhwotf| v`n inbokn gnmfnt omf dkhhfu fnov` omf tnvted~vehm iht v`n bokn (sthyefnf
v`nu wntn mhv w`evn omfht L`te|veom+ v`ov e|% em o bh|v l`eyoktel hi wou|- Em v`e| ogn v`n
b~|elok em|vt~bnmv `of nyhkynf o gtnov fnok ok|h- Ghmn wntn v`n fou| hi em|vt~bnmv| lt~fnku
io|`ehmnf ithb omebok| em skoln hi hmn| ltoivnf du v`n bh|v |jekknf otve|om| hi v`n fou ithb
v`n iemn|v omebok sthf~lv| v`ov lh~kf dn sthl~tnf-
8/8/2019 Dilemma of Boybands 1st ed
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/dilemma-of-boybands-1st-ed 10/35
?3
Knosemg hm vh v`n ogn hi tno|hm v`n whtkf hi b~|el `of l`omgnf hmln bhtn- Ghmn wntn h~t
tnkegeh~| l`omv| omf hfn| vh v`n obsknmn|| hi hmn'| kofu omf `nt dh|hb- V`n|n `of dnnm
tnskolnf du |wnnsemg whtj| hi |voggntemg bogmeielnmln omf |~dvkn nbhvehmok shwnt-
Lhbsh|nt| |~l` o| Bhvotv omf Dnnv`hynm lhbsh|nf whtj| iht v`n `~gn htl`n|vto| hi v`n
vebn omf v`net b~|el ietnf so||ehm|+ nynm |sotjemg tehv| em v`n |vtnnv| hi |hbn N~thsnom
losevok| ov v`net stnbentn sntihtbomln|- V`n efno ht lhmlnsv~oke|ovehm wo| ihtbemg oll~tovnku
omf stnsotemg v`n bo||n| iht w`ov wh~kf dnlhbn v`n gtnovn|v bhynbnmv hi okk vebn|-
Emlefnmvokku+ emmhyovehm omf gnme~| wo| mhv v`n hmku sov` vh dn ihkkhwnf em N~thsn du omu
bnom|- \hbn unot| kovnt v`n io|`ehmodkn ~ssnt"lko|| soto|evn| hi Khmfhm vhwm wntn
nml`omvnf du v`n tnvth"l`el hi v`n \lhvve|` `eg`komf| bofn shs~kot du \et Wokvnt \lhvv omf
`e| shv"dheknt mhynk|- Ev wo| q~evn v`n ovvtolveyn omf ollhbske|`nf v`emg iht v`n ihsse|`
Khmfhmnt hi v`n vebn (bh|v hi w`hb `of dnnm mh i~tv`nt mhtv` v`om Wovihtf Gos ov omu vebn
em v`net keyn|% vh gof odh~v em votvom| vh v`n |h~mf| hi v`n `eg`komf dogsesn| em v`n bommnt hi
v`n \lhvve|` lkom|bom- V`e| io|`ehm wo| bofn okk v`n bhtn lhmynmenmv o| v`ntn wntn mh olv~ok
\lhv| em v`n `eg`komf| ov v`n vebn f~n v`n `eg`komf lknotomln| omf v`~| v`n Khmfhmnt| `of mh
sthdknb hdvoememg w`e|jnu+ |`htvdtnof omf shttefgn w`ek|v wnotemg hv`nt snhskn'| votvom| omf
stnvnmfemg vh ~mfnt|vomf v`n shnvtu hi Thdden D~tm|-
V@N ?593'| ) V@N DETV@ HI V@N STHVH"DHUDOMF1
V`ntn e| kevvkn kevntov~tn vh lhynt v`e| sntehf omf mhv b~l` `ossnmnf em vntb| hi b~|el ~mvek
v`n bef"sotv hi v`n vwnmvenv` lnmv~tu w`nm om Obntelom tnfmnlj wthvn o shs~kot |hmg odh~v
fhemg o lhmvnbshtotu fomln oth~mf o vebnsenln em v`n kovn nynmemg omf emynmvnf thlj omf
thkk em v`n sthln||- Emyoteodku ev wo| mhvodkn v`ov bh|v sthbemnmv nmvntvoembnmv wo| |vekk em
v`n ihtb hi v`n |hkh otve|v ov v`e| vebn wo| wev` v`n bo||n| ofhtemg |~l` mobn| o| Itomj
\emovto+ Nkye| Stn|knu omf `e| `usmhvel fomlemg snkye| omf Dhddu Fotem (w`hnynt `n wo|%-
Ev wo| kniv vh v`n |vokwotv Dteve|` vh tnokku jelj"|votv v`n Dhu Domf tnyhk~vehm omf |`hw v`net
Obntelom lh~|em| `hw ev |`h~kf dn fhmn wev`h~v q~okb|- Wev` v`n ofynmv hi v`n ?593'| v`n
Dteve|` |vognf om emyo|ehm hi v`n Obntelom b~|elok boemkomf vh w`el` v`nu wntn mhv hiintnf
b~l` tn|e|vomln- V`n Dnovkn| whwnf ^\ o~fenmln| wev` v`net ~sdnov v~mn|+ t`uv`bel |wouemg
omf ob~|emg ollnmv| vh |~l` om npvnmv v`ov o gth~s hi tnlhtf"kodnk npnl~veyn| (dnemg v`n
fnyh~v losevoke|v| v`ov v`nu wntn% s~v v`net `nof| vhgnv`nt omf lobn ~s wev` v`n Bhmjnn| em
tn|shm|n vh v`n ftowemg shwnt hi v`n kof| ithb Keyntshhk-
8/8/2019 Dilemma of Boybands 1st ed
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/dilemma-of-boybands-1st-ed 11/35
??
Em v`n so|v tnlhtf kodnk| `of npsntenmlnf sthdknb| ithb otve|v| w`h lobn ithb o $vtofevehmok$
b~|elok doljgth~mf omf fnbhm|vtovnf sthdknbovel vnmfnmlen| |~l` o| emfnsnmfnmv v`h~g`v
omf bhtok ht otve|vel emvngtevu- V`n Bhmjnn| fef owou wev` v`n|n sthdknb| du yetv~n hi v`n
iolv v`ov v`nu wntn wommodn olvht| tov`nt v`om b~|eleom| em v`n |vtelvn|v |nm|n hi v`n vntb (e-n-
dnemg losodkn hi skouemg o b~|elok em|vt~bnmv hi |hbn jemf% omf tov`nt v`om wo|vemg vebn omf
bhmnu em geyemg v`nb b~|elok vtoememg v`n $domf$ bebnf okhmg vh v`net |hmg| w`ek|v
stnvnmfemg vh skou v`net em|vt~bnmv|-
\h nynm o| iot dolj o| v`n 93|+ ev e| tnbotjodkn v`ov v`ntn wntn bom~iolv~tnf domf| wev` mh
tnok b~|elok voknmv ht odekevu+ d~v v`ntn wntn |vekk |v~bdkemg dkhlj| okhmg v`n wou- V`n domf|
hi v`n vebn wntn stnfhbemomvku dhu| omf |hbn wntn nynm bhtn iojn v`om Sobnko Omfnt|hm'|
o||nv| (Mh sthsnt fn|ltesvehm hi v`n o||nv| em q~n|vehm/%- Emlefnmvokku+ |hbn |vekk skounf v`net
hwm em|vt~bnmv| omf wthvn v`net hwm bovnteok (ht ov kno|v jnsv ~s v`n ekk~|ehm v`ov v`nu fef%+
hynt v`n mnpv v`etvu unot| v`emg| wh~kf `oyn mh |egmeielomv l`omgn|-
V@N ?573'| JNNSEMG EV EM V@N IOBEKU1
V`n duwhtf hi v`n |nynmven| wo| npsntebnmvovehm omf emynmvehm- Snhskn fthssnf olef vh
npsomf v`net bemf|+ npskhtnf v`n bu|vele|b hi v`n No|v omf gnmntokku lhbbevvnf ltebn|
ogoem|v io|`ehm v`ov |vekk bojn uh~ wemln vh v`e| fou- B~|el wo| em mh wou npnbsv ithb v`e|ebsnv~| vhwotf| itnojemg h~v omf ghemg s|ul`nfnkel hm o tng~kot do|e|- Domf| hi v`n vebn
l`obsehmnf v`n lh~mvnt"l~kv~tn omf kein|vukn hi v`n fou em o fnlofn v`ov tnynkknf em Bejn
Hkfienkf'| V~d~kot Dnkk| ov hmn nmf omf tndnkknf wev` S~mj Thlj omf v`n \np Se|vhk| ov v`n
hv`nt- Bomu nynmv| omf bu|vel emynmvehm| vtom|setnf wev` kevvkn tn|vtoemv-
\~tste|emgku okk v`ov wo| `ossnmemg em v`n ^J omf kevvkn mhveln nk|nw`ntn o| tnlhtfnf `e|vhtu
nmvoek|- V`n ^\ wo| omhv`nt |vhtu okvhgnv`nt o| o domf hi ghhiu"vhhv`nf dthv`nt| nbntgnf
ithb v`n b~|elok wekfntmn|| omf emvh v`n |`ememg levu hi shs |votfhb- V`n H|bhmf|+ o| v`nu
wntn jmhwm vh v`n em`odevomv| hi v`n skomnv Notv`+ wntn o| iot owou ithb v`n fths"h~v| omf
khynf"~s `essen| hi v`n vebn o| v`nu lh~kf dn omf |ntynf ~s o w`hkn|hbn ottou hi b~|elok
fnkeg`v|-
Mhv vh dn h~vfhmn du Bhtbhm Beffkn"Obntelo+ v`n T)'D |lnmn ok|h v`t~|v ~shm v`n whtkf o
domf hi dthv`nt| w`h |vhkn v`n `notv| omf bemf| hi v`net o~fenmln- V`n Aolj|hm Ieyn (om
emgnmeh~| mobn |nnemg o| `hw nol` bnbdnt wo| lokknf Aolj|hm omf v`ntn wntn npolvku ieyn
hi v`nb%+ o| v`nu wntn jmhwm+ wntn |h shs~kot em v`net moveyn komf v`ov v`nu wntn geynm v`net
8/8/2019 Dilemma of Boybands 1st ed
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/dilemma-of-boybands-1st-ed 12/35
?4
hwm lotvhhm |nten| w`el` wo| ok|h o `ev fn|sevn okkngovehm| em v`n vodkhef stn|| v`ov ev wo| em
iolv o |eme|vnt ovvnbsv hm v`n sotv hi v`net tnlhtf kodnk vh tnskoln v`n gth~s wev` lnkk~khef
f~skelovn| w`el` wh~kf mnynt ogn+ mnnf vh dn inf ht geyn v`nb dolj kes em lhmvtolv
mnghveovehm|- K~ljeku v`n|n okkngovehm| sthynf mhv vh dn vt~n omf v`n Aolj|hm Ieyn bofn o
bemv omf ko~ml`nf v`n uh~mgn|v bnbdnt Bel`nok+ hm `e| q~n|v vh vtom|ihtb `eb|nki ithb o
uh~mg omf voknmvnf dkolj g~u emvh o beffkn"ognf w`evn g~u wev` o `odev hi |nki"ebbhkovehm-
Okk em okk w`ekn ev beg`v dn vt~n v`ov v`n |nynmven| |nv v`n lo~|n hi v`n bom~iolv~tnf dhu domf|
dolj o |vns f~n vh v`n stnyoknmln hi gth~s| v`ov lhm|e|vnf hi |edkemg| omf v`n obh~mv hi vnnv`
emyhkynf em omuv`emg lhmlntmemg v`n H|bhmf iobeku+ v`n iolv tnboemnf v`ov dkomf b~|el `of
dnnm s~|`nf vh v`n ihtn omf kngehm| hi vnnmogn getk| `of yhwnf vh vojn v`net hwm keyn| em v`n
nynmv hi v`net efhk| em v`n|n domf| nynm `emvemg v`ov v`nu wntn emyhkynf em o |nteh~|
tnkovehm|`es wev` o bnbdnt hi v`n hssh|evn |np-
V@N ?503'|+ BN IET\V B^\EL IHT V@N BN IET\V FNLOFN1
V`n neg`ven| wntn em bomu wou| o jmnn"antj tnolvehm vh v`n |nynmven|- Itnn khyn omf
gthhyemn|| wntn h~v o| losevoke|b tnotnf ev| s~g"~gku `nof omf bovnteoke|b omf snt|hmok
gtnnf dnlobn v`n d~"whtf| hi v`n mnw gnmntovehm- Okwou| q~elj vh bhyn wev` v`n vebn|+
v`n b~|el emf~|vtu fthssnf v`n w`hkn|hbn domf| hi dthv`nt| kejn o dof `odev omf emyn|vnf emv`n dno~vei~k snhskn vh |`eiv tnlhtf|-
V`n ^J oetwoyn| tn|h~mfnf vh v`n |vtoem| hi W`ob em v`n notku neg`ven|+ w`h w`ekn mhv
|vtelvku o dhu domf em v`n s~tn|v |nm|n o| v`ntn wntn hmku vwh hi v`nb+ v`nu wthvn htegemok
bovnteok omf `of |hbn ioleok `oet+ wntn lobs nmh~g` vh iekk v`n gos iht o w`ekn- Kovnt em v`n
fnlofn v`n lh~mvtu wh~kf dn vtnovnf vh v`n whmfnt v`ov wo| Dth| w`h dnmv v`n t~kn| du
`oyemg vwh bnbdnt| w`h wntn dthv`nt| omf hmn v`ov wo| mh tnkovehm vh v`n hv`nt|
w`ov|hnynt- Dth| wntn snt`os| v`n iet|v dhu domf vh lo|` em hm v`n $dof dhu$ ebogn wev`
knov`nt aoljnv| omf tessnf anom|- V`net |hmg| o|jnf sthdemg s`ekh|hs`elok q~n|vehm| hi om
~mlotemg whtkf |~l` o| $w`nm wekk E dn iobh~|8 Ht w`nm wekk E |nn bu selv~tn em v`n sosnt8$
(om|wnt vh v`n ihtbnt1 mhv iht omu gtnov knmgv` hi vebn+ om|wnt vh v`n kovvnt1 mhwofou| hmku
~mfnt v`n `nofkemn $g~n|| w`h'| ikessemg lhwsotv| ov BlFhmokf| iht o keyemg$%-
Bnomw`ekn v`n ^\ `of `ev hm w`ov |nnbnf kejn v`n sntinlv ihtb~ko w`nm Mnw Jef| hm v`n
Dkhlj wntn ~mkno|`nf ~shm om ~m|~|snlvemg whtkf- V`nu wntn uh~mg+ v`nu wntn ghhf
khhjemg (ossotnmvku% omf v`nu wntn $|vtnnv$ (nynm v`h~g` v`nu khhjnf kejn meln w`evn dhu|
8/8/2019 Dilemma of Boybands 1st ed
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/dilemma-of-boybands-1st-ed 13/35
?<
ithb om ~ssnt"lko|| mneg`dh~t`hhf% omf mhv hmn hi v`nb wo| |nnm vh skou o b~|elok
em|vt~bnmv hi omu jemf---nynt- V`nu |omg |hmg| wev` vevkn| kejn $@omgemg Vh~g`$ omf whtn
doggu lkhv`n| nynm v`h~g` v`nu `otfku lhma~tnf v`n ebogn hi o `otf"devvnm |vtnnv gomg ithb
fhwmvhwm Kh| Omgnkn|- Mhv v`ov ev bovvntnf vh v`n bo||n| hi uh~mg getk| v`ov dh~g`v v`net
tnlhtf|-
V@N ?553'|+ V@N FNLOFN HI V@N DHU DOMF1
Mhw v`n emf~|vtu `of v`n ihtb~ko tniemnf v`n ihtb~ko omf skolnf v`n dhu domf ietbku em v`n
lhkknlveyn ~mlhm|leh~|+ v`n vebn `of lhbn iht lhbsknvn |ov~tovehm wev` v`n ~kvebovn ghok hi
gkhdok fhbemovehm- V`n iet|v ltolj |q~of hi dhu domf lhbbomfh'| vh dn sotol`~vnf fthssnf
emvh olvehm wo| Vojn V`ov w`h |vhtbnf vh |~lln|| em v`n ^J omf wntn `nofnf ~s du Gotu
Dotkhw- Oivnt o inw unot| ov v`n vhs v`n gth~s ebskhfnf omf v`n yoteh~| bnbdnt| s~t|~nf
|hkh lotnnt| wev` yotuemg fngtnn| hi |~lln|| (e-n- Thdden Wekkeob| dnlobn o \~snt|vot w`ekn
bh|v hv`nt bnbdnt| iofnf emvh tnkoveyn hd|l~tevu%-
D~v nynm v`h~g` v`n ihtb~ko `of dnnm n|vodke|`nf+ v`ntn wo| |vekk v`n hff dhu domf v`ov dthjn
v`n bh~kf- Vojn iht npobskn No|v ?7- No|v ?7 dhu domf lhbsh|nf hi uh~mg bnm ithb v`n
Wokv`ob|vhw otno hi Khmfhm (em v`n N?7 sh|vok otno+ `nmln v`n mobn hi v`n domf% w`h
khhjnf kejn mhv`emg bhtn v`om o d~ml` hi t~iieom| omf ‛mn'nt"fh"wnkk|‒ tov`nt v`om v`n lknoml~v ebogn v`ov bh|v hv`nt gth~s| l~kveyovnf- Ev lom dn sh|v~kovnf v`ov No|v ?7 vossnf emvh v`n
|obn ynem hi fomgnt v`ov `of i~nkknf v`n ossnok hi Dth| dnihtn v`nb+ omf ev `o| vh dn |oef v`ov
v`nu wh~kf `oyn nmlh~mvntnf gtnov ofynt|evu `of v`nu ovvnbsvnf vh stn|nmv v`n ebogn hi o
gth~s hi emvnkknlv~ok| omf feknvvomvn|- Osotv ithb v`net th~g` ebogn+ No|v ?7 ok|h npnbskeienf
omhv`nt |vtomgn nknbnmv hi v`n vuselok dhu domf em v`ov v`nu `of oth~mf ieyn bnbdnt| d~v
hmku vwh hi v`e| m~bdnt wntn tnokku nynt mhvnf vh olv~okku |emg wev`h~v v`n hv`nt ih~t vh
sthyefn yhlok `otbhmu- W`nv`nt ht mhv v`n|n `~bom |sotn sotv| lh~kf olv~okku |emg (ht nynm
vokj% wo| mnynt tnynoknf omf knf vh v`n lhmvnbshtotu ahjn1 $@hw bomu bnbdnt| hi No|v ?7
fhn| ev vojn vh l`omgn o keg`v d~kd8 Ieyn- Hmn vh `hkf v`n koffnt+ hmn vh |ltnw em v`n d~kd
omf v`tnn vh shemv ov v`nb w`ekn v`nu fh ev-$ V`e| em"iolv npnbskeienf v`n iolv v`ov v`n snhskn
v`ov wntn goememg ithb v`n ottomgnbnmv wntn v`n tnlhtfemg lhbsomen| wev` kevvkn tngotf iht
v`n fnynkhsbnmv hi v`n dhu| wev`em v`n domf-
V`th~g` v`n lh~t|n hi v`n memnven| bomu dhu domf| lobn omf wnmv+ d~v v`emg| dnlobn tnokku
emvntn|vemg w`nm v`n Ete|` fnlefnf vh gnv em hm v`n olv- @oyemg bomu vebn| whm v`nN~thye|ehm \hmg Lhmvn|v+ v`n Ete|` b~|el emf~|vtu `of o gtnov fnok hi npsntenmln w`nm ev
8/8/2019 Dilemma of Boybands 1st ed
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/dilemma-of-boybands-1st-ed 14/35
?6
lobn vh sthf~lemg b~|el v`ov wo| dkomf omf sokovodkn hmku vh v`n |vhmn fnoi- V`n iet|v Ete|`
dhu domf vh bojn ev deg wo| Dhuhmn w`hb bomu lkoeb em`ntevnf v`n sh|evehm hmln `nkf du
Vojn V`ov ov v`n vhs hi v`n sekn- Kh~en Wok|` e| ltnfevnf iht ev| bom~iolv~temg q~okevu-
Hmln bhtn v`n gth~s `of ieyn bnbdnt| w`h wntn ~modkn vh skou om em|vt~bnmv+ wtevn o |hmg
ht |emg hm v`net hwm- D~v v`nm Dhuhmn lh~kf okwou| iokk dolj hm v`net |nltnv wnoshm: v`net
thbomvel Ete|` ollnmv|- W`ekn |voggntemgku mhm"fn|ltesv em okk hv`nt wou|+ Dhuhmn okwou|
v~tmnf hm v`n dkotmnu omf ftowknf owou em emvntyenw| b~l` vh v`net hwm dnmniev- D~v b~l`
kejn Vojn V`ov dnihtn v`nb ev |hhm dnlobn ossotnmv v`ov lntvoem bnbdnt| wntn fn|vemnf iht
gtnovnt v`emg| omf v`ov hv`nt| wntn kevvkn bhtn v`om l`oii em v`n wemf omf v`n gth~s fwemfknf
omf iemokku fe|domfnf ov v`n v~tm hi v`n lnmv~tu- Bom~iolv~temg `of hmln ogoem kniv ev| botj
om emf~|vtu v`ov v`teynf hm w`ov wo| om ~mjmhwm q~omvevu em v`n botjnv1 emvntn|v-
4333 OMF DNUHMF+ O DTOYN MNW BEKKNME^B1
V`n bhtn v`emg| l`omgn+ v`n bhtn domok omf ommhuemg dhu domf| gnv- O| v`n tn|v hi v`n whtkf
khhjnf ihtwotf vh v`n sthbe|n hi v`n iet|v mnw bekknmme~b em o v`h~|omf unot| v`n b~|el
emf~|vtu wo| d~|u `ovl`emg h~v o w`hkn mnw dthhf hi dhu domf| vh vhtbnmv v`n b~|el"d~uemg
s~dkel- V`n ^\ wo| vtnovnf vh v`n fnkeg`v| hi M\UML+ v`n Dolj|vtnnv Dhu| omf H"Vhwm omf
`of o whmfnti~k vebn skouemg o gobn w`ntn v`n oeb wo| vh vnkk v`n v`tnn dhu domf| osotv-V`nu okk khhjnf okejn wev` |ebekot ftn||emg omf bogoemn lhynt ossnotomln|-
Bnomw`ekn v`n fnbe|n hi Dhuhmn `of iot ithb |snkknf v`n nmf hi v`n Ete|` dhu domf omf
|hhm v`n b~|el l`otv| wntn iekknf wev` v`n |h~mf hi o gth~s wev` hmn hi v`n |vtomgn|v mobn|
unv1 ‛Wn|vkein-‒ bomognf du Ete|` shs"|~stnbh Kh~en Wok|`+ Wn|vkein lobn vh nbdhfu v`n
`okkbotj| hi v`n |vntnhvuselok dhu"domf v`ov ev `of vojnm |h bomu fnlofn| vh tniemn omf
sntinlv- V`e| vebn Kh~en Wok|`+ w`h nmahu| ‛i~m‒ tov`nt ‛|~d|vomln‒ fnlefnf vh khhj
lotni~kku ov w`ov wh~kf ko|v- @n fnlefnf vh ‛bom~iolv~tn‒ o domf v`ov wh~kf `oyn em ev|
lhmlnsv o ko|vemg niinlv hm v`n b~|el emf~|vtu f~n vh dhv` ‛dtomf‒ omf ‛|~d|vomln‒ - Wn|vkein
wo| om ovvnbsv vh emlk~fn q~okevu em dhv` ebogn omf bovnteok-
V`nu |omg w`ov hv`nt| vhkf v`nb vh omf fef o kemn em l`nn|u lhynt|- V`nu ossnoknf vh vnnmogn
getk| omf bh|vku gou bnm- V`nu fnbhm|vtovnf mh ossotnmv emvnkkegnmln w`nm emvntyenwnf omf
w`nm sntihtbemg |ov hm |vhhk|+ v`n lkebop hi v`net sntihtbomln dnemg v`n bhbnmv w`nm v`nu
|vhhf ~s em ~me|hm iht v`n iemok l`ht~| hi hmn hi v`net domok v~mn|- Kh~en Wok|` `of otteynf
hm v`n B~|el |lnmn wev` o feiintnmln em sthyefemg w`ov v`n bo||n| womvnf-
8/8/2019 Dilemma of Boybands 1st ed
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/dilemma-of-boybands-1st-ed 15/35
?>
Kh~en Wok|` wo| olvemg o| o botjnv nmvtnstnmn~t w`h |ow o gos em v`n botjnv omf sthyefnf
a~|v w`ov wo| mnnfnf- V`n stemleskn wo| |ebskn1 ‛W`ov fh v`n snhskn womv8 L`nlj em v`n vhs
ftownt omf v`thw ev ov v`nb--‒
W`ekn v`n gnmntok s~dkel |nnbnf du v`e| vebn vh dn sntinlvku owotn hi v`n iolv v`ov v`n dhu
domf wo| o vhvokku bom~iolv~tnf omf v`thw"owou s`nmhbnmhm hi bhfntm lhm|~bnt"fteynm
|hlenvu+ v`e| fef kevvkn vh feb v`n ossnvevn v`ov v`nu np`edevnf iht v`n gth~s| omf v`net b~|el- Em
v`n notku unot| hi v`n vwnmvu"iet|v lnmv~tu o mnw efno wo| `ev ~shm em v`n keg`v hi v`n iolv v`ov
vnknye|ehm"yenwnt| ov v`n vebn wntn kossemg ~s v`n $fhl~"|hos$ ihtbov hi ‛iku"hm"v`n"wokk‒
fhl~bnmvotu w`ntn v`n iekb"bojnt| ihkkhwnf v`n vteok| omf vted~kovehm| hi yoteh~| emfeyef~ok|
o| v`nu wnmv odh~v v`net foeku keyn|- V`n wotv| omf okk |vukn hi v`n|n sthgtobbn| wntn ~|nf vh
gtnov niinlv w`nm o |`hw wev` v`n ebogemoveyn vevkn hi $Shs"|vot|$ wo| lhbbe||ehmnf v`ov
ihkkhwnf v`n sthln|| hi ltnovemg o bom~iolv~tnf domf ithb |ltovl`-
V`n|n |`hw| |sotnf mhv`emg ithb v`n nun| hi v`n yenwnt+ vojemg v`nb ithb v`n emeveok
o~fevehmemg hi lh~mvkn|| (omf hivnm `ekoteh~|ku `hsnkn||% wommodn| teg`v v`th~g` vh v`n iemok
domf'| dovvkn vh vojn v`n $lhynvnf$ L`te|vbo| m~bdnt hmn |khv em v`n b~|el l`otv|- W`ekn @not
\ou+ v`n domf v`ov wo| s~v vhgnv`nt+ wo| o bepnf domf+ v`n |`hw wo| ebshtvomv o| ev koef dotn
v`n nmvetn sthln|| omf stn|nmvnf o gth~s v`ov ithb ev| yntu gnmn|e| wo| mhv`emg bhtn v`om o
sthf~lv hi v`n |nknlvehm sthln||- Ev lobn o| mh gtnov |~tste|n vh bomu lhbbnmvovht| v`ov v`n
domf inkk osotv tnlnmvku oivnt kn|| v`om o unot vhgnv`nt f~n vh v`n iolv v`ov v`nu `of mh
tnfnnbemg q~okeven| w`ov|hnynt- Kh~en Wok|` wo| hm v`n |notl` iht v`n ‛mnpv sthf~lv‒ hm v`n
lhmynuht dnkv- V`e| ~mihtv~movnku `o| dnnm v`n mov~tn hi v`n b~|el emf~|vtu em tnlnmv unot| o|
domf| `oyn dnnm ~|nf o| ‛~|n" du fovn‒ vusn hi sthf~lv| omf lhbsknvnku lhm|vtelv| v`n
fnynkhsbnmv hi voknmv omf ltnoveyevu em v`n emf~|vtu-
P"iolvht+ o Dteve|` voknmv lhbsnvevehm `o| dnlhbn v`n tnlk~|n hi iobeku nmvntvoembnmv- \ebhm
Lhwnkk+ em i~kk \ebhm S`ekkes Lhwnkk (d- Hlv- 7+ ?5>5+ Dteg`vhm+ No|v \~||np+ Nmg-%+ Nmgke|`
nmvtnstnmn~t+ tnlhtfemg npnl~veyn+ omf vnknye|ehm sthf~lnt omf snt|hmokevu+ jmhwm iht `e|
`ot|` ltevele|b hi lhmvn|vomv| hm v`n |`hw Shs Efhk omf ev| Obntelom |sem"hii+ Obntelom Efhk
e| v`n ih~mfnt hi v`e| vnknye|ehm sthgtob- Oivnt knoyemg |l`hhk ov ogn ?9+ Lhwnkk wo| `etnf vh
whtj em v`n boek thhb ov NBE B~|el S~dke|`emg omf wo| nynmv~okku geynm v`n l`omln+ em
?575+ vh fe|lhynt sntihtbnt| vh |emg mnwku s~dke|`nf |hmg|- Em ?50> `n omf o sotvmnt ihtbnf
Iomiotn Tnlhtf|+ w`el` nmahunf |hbn |~lln|| dnihtn ihkfemg em ?505-
8/8/2019 Dilemma of Boybands 1st ed
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/dilemma-of-boybands-1st-ed 16/35
?9
Em 4336+ wev` \`othm H|dh~tmn omf Kh~e| Wok|`+ Lhwnkk wo| o a~fgn hm v`n iet|v |nten| hi
v`n Dteve|` voknmv |`hw V`n P Iolvht+ w`el` `n ltnovnf ~|emg `e| sthf~lvehm lhbsomu+ \ulh-
V`n P Iolvht wo| om em|vomv |~lln|| wev` v`n yenwnt| omf ieme|`nf ev| |epv` |nten| em 4335- Em
4339+ `n wo| yhvnf v`n vnmv` bh|v vntteiuemg lnkndtevu hm vnknye|ehm em o Tofeh Vebn| shkk
lhm|e|vemg hi <+333 snhskn- \ebhm Lhwnkk lhmvem~n| vh `oyn o `hkf hm v`n vnknye|ehm b~|el
emf~|vtu omf `o| nyhkynf vh dnlhbn lnkndtevu em `e| teg`v| em ltnovemgbom~iolv~temg gth~s|
w`ek|v sthbhvemg |hkh otve|v lotnnt| kejn v`h|n hi Knhmo Knwe|+ `e| |hkn sthvågå-
V`n Obntelom ynt|ehm hi \ebhm‘| V`n P"iolvht+ Obntelom Efhk `o| nq~okku vojnm v`n b~|el
emf~|vtu em v`n ^\ du |vhtb- V`n ^\ gth~s H"Vhwm wntn v`n |~danlv hi v`n |`hw $Bojemg
v`n Domf$ v`ov |ow |umfelovehm oth~mf v`n whtkf- D~v o mnw |nten| hi Shs |vot| f~ddnf $V`n
Teyok|$ e| vh ihkkhw v`n iet|v w`ntn v`ntn wekk dn vwh domf| ltnovnf tov`nt v`om hmn- Hmn domf
wekk dn lhbsh|nf hi $getk|$ omf v`n hv`nt hi $dhu|$ l`h|nm ithb o |`htvke|v hi vnm du
vnkns`hmn yhvn- V`n ~kvebovn oeb e| iht v`n vwh domf| vh v`nm lhbsnvn iht v`n L`te|vbo|
m~bdnt hmn (tov`nt otthgomvku egmhtemg v`n iolv v`ov v`nu wekk lntvoemku mhv dn v`n hmku otve|v|
vh tnkno|n vtolj| vh v`e| |obn nmf%- W`nv`nt ht mhv v`n yenwemg s~dkel wekk tn|shmf vh v`n
|obn hkf vtelj| iht o |nlhmf unot t~mmemg tnboem| vh dn |nnm+ d~v v`nm v`nu `oyn dnnm kossemg
~s v`n |obn ihtb~koel omf tn`o|`nf b~|elok ihtbov iht v`n dn|v sotv hi v`n so|v ihtvu unot|
wev`h~v q~okb ht lhbskoemv- V`n bhtn v`emg| l`omgn v`n bhtn v`nu |vou v`n |obn- Bom~iolv~tnf domf| lom dn |skev emvh v`tnn fe|vemlv vusn|1
4-? Dhu Domf|
V`n|n otn v`n htegemok " d~v mhv mnln||oteku v`n dn|v " vusn hi bom~iolv~tnf domf-
4-4 Getk Domf|
V`n|n otn kejn dhu domf|+ d~v |nv vh ossnok vh om hkfnt o~fenmln+ ht o uh~mgnt o~fenmln
lhm|e|vemg s~tnku hi getk|-
4-< Bepnf Domf|
V`n|n lhm|e|v hi bnbdnt| hi dhv` |npn| w`h lom emvntolv |~ggn|veynku+ geyemg wefnt botjnv
ossnok- V`n bngo"fhkkot |semmemg ^\ emf~|vtu `o| ebdednf em v`e| vusn hi domf| em v`n ihtb
hi \"lk~d |nynm+ o ^J shs gth~s v`ov lobn vh sthbemnmln em ?555 w`nm v`nu |vottnf em v`net
hwm DDL sthgtobbn Beobe 7- V`e| lhmlnsv omf dtomf hi v`n gth~s wo| ltnovnf du \ebhm
I~kknt+ w`h wo| ok|h v`net bomognt v`th~g` ?5 Nmvntvoembnmv: v`nu wntn |egmnf vh Shkufht
Tnlhtf|-
8/8/2019 Dilemma of Boybands 1st ed
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/dilemma-of-boybands-1st-ed 17/35
?7
V`net vnknye|ehm |nten| wnmv hm vh ko|v ih~t |nten|+ |nnemg v`n gth~s vtoynk olth|| v`n ^mevnf
\vovn| omf nynmv~okku nmfemg ~s em Dotlnkhmo+ \soem- Ev dnlobn shs~kot em ?33 feiintnmv
lh~mvten| w`ntn v`n |`hw wo| wovl`nf du hynt 53 bekkehm yenwnt|
<-3 Odtefgnf @e|vhtu " Jnu Nynmv| du Fnlofn
Bom~iolv~tnf domf| `oyn olv~okku dnnm oth~mf iht q~evn o khmg vebn " okv`h~g` em v`n ko|v inw
fnlofn| v`nu `oyn dnlhbn iot bhtn lhbbhm- V`n boem sntehf| hi fnynkhsbnmv otn1
?593|
V`n Bhmjnn| wntn ihtbnf- V`e| domf wo| ltnovnf iht o vnknye|ehm |nten| v`ov wo|
emvnmfnf vh dn om Obntelom ynt|ehm hi O @otf Fou'| Meg`v - V`ntn wntn o lh~skn hi
|hmg| snt nse|hfn+ w`el` wntn hivnm q~evn ghhf+ omf v`n olvht| wntn okk |`hwm |emgemg
omf skouemg em|vt~bnmv|- @hwnynt+ ev wo| |hhm tnynoknf v`ov v`n domf fefm'v tnokku
sntihtb " ov kno|v hm v`net notku tnlhtf| " o| hmku o lh~skn hi v`n bnbdnt| wntn
olv~okku b~|eleom|-
Nplnsvehm|1 V`n Dnovkn|+ V`n Thkkemg \vhmn|-
?573|
V`n Dou Levu Thkknt|+ |vot| hi v`net hwm vnknye|ehm |nten|+ wntn `~gnku shs~kot+ omf
dnlobn v`n kovn|v votgnv iht |ltnobemg vnnmogn getk|-
Nplnsvehm|1 V`n Shkeln+ V`n D~lhlj|+ V`n Lko|`-
?503|
V`e| wo| sh||edku v`n |votv hi v`n vt~n nto hi bom~iolv~tnf b~|el- Em v`e| fnlofn+ v`ntn
wo| o sknv`hto hi bom~iolv~tnf domf|+ hmn hi v`n deggn|v dnemg v`n em|~iintodkn Dth|-
Nplnsvehm|1 V`n \bev`|+ Sepen|-
?553| omf dnuhmf
Mnw Jef| hm v`n Dkhlj+ Vojn V`ov+ Dhuhmn+ Dolj|vtnnv Dhu| omf bomu bhtn |hkf
bekkehm| hi tnlhtf| vh uh~mg getk|- Getk gth~s| |~l` o| v`n \seln Getk| dnlobn
emltno|emgku lhbbhm- Wn|vkein wntn v`n iet|v domf vh `oyn okk v`net iet|v ieyn |emgkn|
nmvnt v`n l`otv| ov m~bdnt| hmn- Bom~iolv~tnf domf| `oyn mhw dng~m vh fhbemovn v`n
l`otv| omf l`omgnf v`n sntlnsvehm hi v`n vntb 'shs'-
8/8/2019 Dilemma of Boybands 1st ed
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/dilemma-of-boybands-1st-ed 18/35
?0
Nplnsvehm|1 Omuv`emg mhm"bom~iolv~tnf " npobskn| emlk~fn Gtnnm Fou+ Tofeh`nof+
Efknwekf+ omf Metyomo-
6-3 @hw vh \shv o Bom~iolv~tnf Domf
V`ntn otn |nyntok lknot emfelovehm| v`ov |`hw w`nv`nt o domf lom dn lko||eienf o|
'bom~iolv~tnf'1
(o% Otn v`ntn mh olv~ok em|vt~bnmvoke|v| obhmg v`n domf bnbdnt|8
(d% Lom v`nu fomln b~l` dnvvnt v`om v`nu lom |emg8
(l% Fhn| hmn |emg w`ekn v`n hv`nt| |emg '`otbhmen|' em v`n doljgth~mf8
(f% Fh v`nu okwou| bebn w`nm sntihtbemg 'keyn'8
(n% Fh v`nu ossnot o khv hm l`ekftnm'| VY8 (O bom~iolv~tnf domf'| votgnv o~fenmln e|
hivnm l`ekftnm+ o| v`nu otn v`n whtkf'| bh|v g~kkedkn lhm|~bnt botjnv-%
(i% Fh v`net |emgkn| lhm|vomvku nmvnt v`n l`otv| ov m~bdnt hmn+ omf v`nm fths fhwm vh o
khwnt sh|evehm v`n mnpv wnnj+ okbh|v emyoteodku tnskolnf du o mnot"efnmvelok |hmg du
omhv`nt gth~s8
(g% Fh v`nu okwou| gnv hv`nt snhskn vh wtevn v`net |hmg| iht v`nb8
(`% Fhn| nyntu hmn hi v`net |hmg| `oyn o shemvkn|| jnu l`omgn+ ~|~okku a~|v dnihtn v`n
iemok l`ht~|8
(e% Fhn| v`n mobn hi v`net domf `oyn o be|skolnf m~bdnt ht knvvnt em ev8 (^4+ Dkemj"?04+
Okodobo < ht v`n |ofku fnsotvnf Dnm Ihkf| Ieyn fhm'v lh~mv+ d~v >eyn+ M'|uml+
@not'\ou+ O? omf l`ekftnm'| nmvntvoemnt| \ Lk~d 7 fniemevnku fh-%
(a% Fh v`nu `oyn v`net hwm l`ekftnm'| VY |nten|8 (V`e| e| o |~tste|emgku lhbbhm hmn-%
(j% Ei uh~ om|wntnf 'un|' vh ih~t ht bhtn hi v`n|n q~n|vehm|+ uh~ `oyn sthdodku
fe|lhyntnf o bom~iolv~tnf domf-
>-3 @hw vh \shv o Dhu Domf
Dhu domf| `oyn o inw npvto efnmveiuemg botjnt|+ w`el` v`n ihkkhwemg q~n|vehm| wekk q~eljku
tnynok1
(o% Fh v`n bnbdnt| okk wnot efnmvelok lkhv`emg8
(d% Otn v`nu lhm|vomvku ihkkhwnf du |ltnobemg getk| w`h `oyn mhv`emg dnvvnt vh fh wev`
v`net keyn|8
(l% Fhn| v`n domf `oyn v`n whtf 'Dhu' em ev| mobn8 (Ng Dhuhmn+ Dolj|vtnnv Dhu|-%
8/8/2019 Dilemma of Boybands 1st ed
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/dilemma-of-boybands-1st-ed 19/35
?5
9-3 Do|el Omovhbu hi o dhu domf
O dhu domf ~|~okku `o| ih~t ht bhtn bnbdnt| v`ov otn ~|~okku yntu |ebekot ithb domf vh
domf1
V`n ikhssu"`oetnf hmn " ~|~okku dkhmf- V`e| e| hivnm v`n hmku hmn w`h lom olv~okku
|emg-
V`n hmn wev` v`n dhfu sentlemg| " v`e| e| v`n hmn w`h e| '|keg`vku wolju'-
V`n 'tossnt' " `n lom'v tnokku tos-
V`n gou hmn " bh|v dhu domf| `oyn o gou bnbdnt w`h emyoteodku lhbn| h~v oivnt o
unot ht vwh em v`n domf+ fn|sevn nyntuhmn jmhwemg oktnofu-
V`n 'hv`nt hmn'- V`e| e| v`n hmn w`h mnynt fhn| omuv`emg omf e| bh|v kejnku vh nmf ~s
lto|`nf h~v hm ft~g| omf ihtlnf vh knoyn v`n domf em o bnfeo |lomfok-
7-3 Do|el Omovhbu hi o Getk Domf
O getk domf ~|~okku `o| v`tnn bnbdnt|+ okv`h~g` v`e| lom emltno|n vh ieyn- V`n domf bnbdnt|
lom dn o kevvkn bhtn yotenf v`om em o dhu domf+ d~v otn ~|~okku yntu |ebekot1
V`n |emgnt " v`e| e| v`n hmn w`h lom |emg- \`n e| o dev kejn v`n ikhssu"`oetnf hmn em v`n
dhu domf-
V`n bnfeo votgnv " v`e| e| v`n hmn w`h e| lhm|vomvku seljnf hm du v`n vodkhef stn|| iht
dnemg vhh iov+ vhh v`em+ ht `oyemg o tnkovehm|`es wev` omuhmn+ nynt-
V`n hmn wev` v`n sentlnf vhmg~nmh|n " v`e| e| v`e| bnbdnt'| hmku fe|vemg~e|`emg botj-
O dev kejn v`n 'hv`nt hmn' em o dhu domf-
V`n botjnvemg e| iet|vku oebnf ov l`ekftnm dnvwnnm v`n ogn| hi |ep omf ?4+ omf w`nm v`n |`htv
ovvnmvehm |som hi v`n|n uh~mg|vnt| |votv| vh woynt+ v`n getk domf wekk |votv oebemg ov bnm
dnvwnnm v`n ogn| hi ?9 omf 40- W`nm jef| kh|n emvntn|v+ v`ntn'| okwou| o `ntf hi |np"hd|n||nf
bnm vh |nkk vh-
8/8/2019 Dilemma of Boybands 1st ed
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/dilemma-of-boybands-1st-ed 20/35
43
0-3 V`n Fnov` hi o Bom~iolv~tnf Domf
V`omji~kku+ bom~iolv~tnf domf| " n|snleokku dhu domf| " ~|~okku `oyn o |`nki kein hi odh~v ?4
bhmv`|- Uh~ lom `hsn v`ov oivnt v`e| vebn v`nu wekk fh hmn hi v`n ihkkhwemg1
(o% Dnlhbn |h |~lln||i~k v`ov v`nu |vhs whtjemg ov okk+ hmku nbntgemg iht |h"lokknf 'keyn'
fovn| omf l`otevu i~mlvehm| (ng Dhuhmn%-
(d% \skev ~s- V`e| e| mhv okwou| dnvvnt v`om v`n domf fn|lnmfemg emvh fhtbomlu+ o| v`n
bnbdnt| bou dn odkn vh s~t|~n o |hkh lotnnt+ w`el` e| okbh|v o| dof- V`omji~kku+ mhv
okk |hkh lotnnt| otn |~lln||i~k " d~v |hbn otn+ |h dn lotni~k- (Ng Thdden Wekkeob|+
Gnte @okkewnkk%-
(l% Gnv fthssnf du v`net tnlhtf kodnk- Bom~iolv~tnf domf| npe|v |hknku vh bojn sthiev iht
v`net bomognt| omf v`net tnlhtf kodnk- Ei v`nu |votv vh kh|n shs~kotevu+ v`nu wekk hivnm
|ebsku lno|n vh npe|v- Ei v`e| `ossnm| vh o bom~iolv~tnf domf+ ko~g` kh~fku omf d~u
uh~t|nki o lnkndtovhtu ftemj- Wovl` VY omf khhj em v`n khlok VY ke|vemg| iht v`n mnpv
hmn em kemn- @ekoteh~| o| ev bou |nnb+ v`n|n otn v`n iolv| hi v`n b~|el emf~|vtu-
0-? @hw vh oyhef Bom~iolv~tnf Domf|
Ev e| sh||edkn vh oyhef bom~iolv~tnf shs gth~s|- V`n no|en|v wou e| mnynt vh d~u omu hi v`net
tnlhtf|+ omf mnynt knv nyntuhmn fh~dv `hw b~l` uh~ `ovn v`nb- \ebsku ihkkhw v`n|n no|u
|vns| vh nm|~tn v`ov uh~t kein e| tnkoveynku itnn hi bom~iolv~tnf shs1
Mnynt wovl` l`ekftnm'| VY (nynm ei uh~ `oyn l`ekftnm% ht 's~dkel nmvntvoembnmv
sthgtobbn|' |~l` o| v`n Movehmok Khvvntu \`hw (em v`n ^J%- Bom~iolv~tnf domf| tnku
bhtn hm v`net ye|~ok ebogn v`om v`net b~|el iht v`net |~lln||+ omf |h hivnm bojn |~l`
ossnotomln|+ bebemg okk v`n vebn+ hi lh~t|n-
Fh mhv ke|vnm vh fteyn"vebn tofeh+ n|snleokku v`n l`otv|+ omf ei uh~ `oyn vh+ jnns uh~t
iemgnt lkh|n vh v`n 'hii' |wevl`- Ev e| |oint vh ke|vnm vh LF|+ ht tofeh |`hw| du FA| v`ov
mnynt skou bom~iolv~tnf b~|el+ |~l` o| DDL Tofeh Hmn'| \vnyn Kobolq ht Ah`m
Snnk-
^mihtv~movnku+ uh~ bou |vekk lhbn olth|| bom~iolv~tnf domf|- Dn lotni~k/ Okwou|
`oyn o LF+ lo||nvvn+ bemefe|l ht bs< skount vh `omf+ wev` |hbn ghhf b~|el em ev
tnofu vh skou-
8/8/2019 Dilemma of Boybands 1st ed
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/dilemma-of-boybands-1st-ed 21/35
4?
0-4 \`h~kf b~|el htgome|ovehm| `oyn o |hleok tn|shm|edekevu8
V`e| tn|notl` emvh bom~iolv~tnf domf| `o| |`hwm v`ov v`ntn otn yntu inw bomognbnmv omf
tnlhtfemg lhbsomen| v`ov `oyn |~ffnmku tnoke|nf v`ov |hleok tn|shm|edekevu e| om ebshtvomv omf
emvngtok o|snlv hi nmvntvoembnmv- Lhtshtovn \hleok Tn|shm|edekevu e| o lhmlnsv w`ntndu
htgomeovehm| lhm|efnt v`n emvntn|v| hi |hlenvu du vojemg tn|shm|edekevu iht v`n ebsolv hi v`net
olveyeven| hm l~|vhbnt|+ nbskhunn|+ |`otn`hkfnt|+ lhbb~meven| omf v`n nmyethmbnmv em okk
o|snlv| hi v`net hsntovehm|- Lhbb~meven| whtkf"wefn `oyn om em"dhtm fn|etn vh ihkkhw domf|
omf gth~s| v`ov stn|nmv o |hleok tn|shm|edekevu ithmv-
V`ntn otn bomognbnmv htgome|ovehm| kejn @omFN+ Bejn Ie|`nt sthf~lvehm| omf deg
htgome|ovehm| kejn \hmu+ NBE nvl w`h `oyn |nnm v`n mnnf vh emlk~fn nf~lovehm omf lhtshtovn
|hleok tn|shm|edekevu em t~mmemg omf sthbhvemg domf|- V`nu `oyn fnkedntovnku vojnm hm v`n
tn|shm|edekevu hi sthbhvemg ~m|egmnf domf| v`ov oktnofu npe|v o| o dhmfnf ~mev d~v `oyn mh
olln|| vh v`n kejn| hi Np"iolvht g~t~| kejn \ebhm Lhwnk omf Kh~e Wok|`- V`n|n domf| otn
vojnm ~s wev`em v`net |nvvemg omf khlokevu- V`n dhmf v`ov npe|v| em v`n domf| e| |nnm o| o
sh|eveyn omf ‛vh dn ebdednf‒ em lhmlnsv hi ‛iobeku omf i~m‒ omf em|vnof hi `oyemg o
‛bom~iolv~tnf‒ h~vkhhj+ o bhtn |hleokku tn|shm|edkn q~okevu e| nbs`o|e|nf- Nf~lovehm omf
iobeku kein e| |nnm o| dnemg bhtn ebshtvomv v`om v`n b~|el dnemg sthf~lnf- V`n|n domf| otn
v`nm okkhwnf vh ikh~te|` vhgnv`nt hm o sthkhmgnf sntehf tomgemg ithb ih~t vh neg`v unot|+sthyefemg o b~v~okku dnmnieleok ottomgnbnmv iht v`n htgome|ovehm| o| v`n domf bnbdnt| okejn-
V`n khmgnt v`n lhmvtolv e| okkhwnf vh dkh||hb+ v`n bhtn osstnleoveyn hi nol` hv`nt e| v`n
tn|~kvemg sthf~lv-
V`n odhyn bnmvehmnf b~|el htgome|ovehm| fnkedntovnku whtj wev` ltnoveyn otve|v| omf sthbhvn
bnfeo sthgtob| v`ov `oyn o sh|eveyn niinlv hm |h bomu snhskn omf lhm|vomvku lhmvted~vn em
bomu wou| vh lhbb~meven| okk oth~mf v`n whtkf- O| tn|shm|edkn htgome|ovehm|+ @omfN+ Bejn
Ie|`nt sthf~lvehm|+ \hmu+ NBE omf v`net o||hleovn| nbskhu olveyeven| v`ov `oyn sh|eveyn
ebsolv v`th~g` v`n wou v`nu bomogn v`net d~|emn|| omf v`n wefnt thkn v`nu skou em |hlenvu-
Wev`em v`net htgome|ovehm‘| hsntovehm|+ v`nu whtj `otf vh ~mfnt|vomf v`n npsnlvovehm| hi
feiintnmv |vojn`hkfnt| omf fnbhm|vtovn tn|shm|edkn d~|emn|| stolveln|- V`nu vojn |nteh~|
nbsov`nvel sh|evehm| hm e||~n| v`ov oiinlv v`net nbskhunn| omf v`net iobeken|+ v`net khlok
lhbb~meven| omf v`n|n htgome|ovehm| em v`n emf~|vtu fteyn o l~kv~tn hi l`otevodkn lh~skn| wev`
lhbb~mevu emyhkynbnmv-
8/8/2019 Dilemma of Boybands 1st ed
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/dilemma-of-boybands-1st-ed 22/35
44
V`net d~|emn|| ~mev| oth~mf v`n whtkf otn itnn vh bojn v`net hwm lhbb~mevu emyn|vbnmv
fnle|ehm| |h v`ov lhbsomu tn|h~tln| otn ossthsteovnku bovl`nf wev` v`n khlok mnnf- Em v`n
^J+ v`nu nmlh~togn nbskhunn| vh sotvelesovn em yhk~mvnnt thkn| wev` l`otevu sotvmnt| hm v`n
gth~mf+ w`ek|v ok|h bojemg em"jemf fhmovehm|+ hivnm em ihtb hi bntl`omfe|n+ w`nm omf w`ntn
ossthsteovn-
Wn otn oktnofu |nnemg v`n sh||edkn i~v~tn hi bom~iolv~tnf b~|el ossnot em Aosom- Lhbs~vnt"
gnmntovnf shs |vot| `oyn dnnm ltnovnf+ omf bomu bhtn otn hm v`n wou- O| b~l` o| wn bou
womv vh fnmu ev+ bom~iolv~tnf domf| otn `ntn vh |vou- Hmln v`n bhfnk hi nmvntvoembnmv v`ov
A~|vemn Boumotf hi @omfN sthf~lvehm| (en |egmemg hm ‛~m|egmnf domf|‒ omf okkhwemg v`nb
vh dkh||hb hynt o sthkhmgnf sntehf% lovl`n| v`n emvntn|v hi v`n nmvntvoembnmv emf~|vtu+ v`e|
wekk dn v`n i~v~tn hi sthsntku htl`n|vtovnf nmvntvoembnmv domf|+ |hkh otve|v| ht gth~s| v`ov wekk
ebsolv v`n lhbb~mevu em o sh|eveyn wou-
0-< Sthdknb| omf ghhf npobskn hi vuselok Domf e||~n|" Fn|vemu―| L`ekf
Fn|vemu'| L`ekf th|n vh dnlhbn hmn hi v`n bh|v shs~kot inbokn T)D gth~s| hi v`n kovn '53|+
nynmv~okku teyokkemg nynm VKL em vntb| hi dkhljd~|vnt lhbbntleok |~lln||- V`net
ollhbske|`bnmv| lobn em |sevn hi |nyntok odt~sv snt|hmmnk l`omgn|+ w`el` wntn
ollhbsomenf du `novnf+ wnkk"s~dkelenf in~f| em v`n bnfeo omf v`n lh~tv|- Em iolv+ iht o vebn+
Fn|vemu'| L`ekf wntn jmhwm iht v`ov ftobo a~|v o| b~l` o| v`net b~|el- Hmln v`n gth~s
|vodekenf ogoem+ v`h~g`+ v`nu nbntgnf wev` nynm bhtn `ev"bojemg shwnt v`om nynt dnihtn-
Fn|vemu'| L`ekf wntn ihtbnf em @h~|vhm+ VP+ em ?553+ w`nm htegemok bnbdnt| Dnuhmlå
Jmhwkn| omf KoVoyeo Thdnt|hm wntn a~|v memn unot| hkf: v`n vwh bnv ov om o~fevehm omf
dnlobn itenmf|+ omf Jmhwkn|' iov`nt Bov`nw |nv odh~v fnynkhsemg om olv do|nf hm v`net
|emgemg omf tossemg+ vojemg v`net mobn ithb o so||ogn em v`n Dhhj hi E|oeo`- Dnuhmlå'|
lh~|em Jnknmfteo $Jnkku$ Thwkomf ahemnf v`n gth~s em ?554+ omf |`htvku v`ntnoivnt v`nu
komfnf om ossnotomln hm \vot \notl`+ w`ntn v`nu sntihtbnf o tos |hmg- V`n q~otvnv'| kemn~s
wo| iemokenf (iht v`n vebn dnemg% w`nm KnVhuo K~ljnvv ahemnf em ?55<+ omf v`nu |snmv v`n
mnpv inw unot| whtjemg v`net wou ~s ithb v`n @h~|vhm lk~d |lnmn+ nynmv~okku hsnmemg iht
otve|v| kejn \WY+ Ft~ @ekk+ omf Ebbov~tn- Iemokku+ em ?557+ Fn|vemu'| L`ekf wo| hiintnf o
tnlhtfemg lhmvtolv du Lhk~bdeo-
8/8/2019 Dilemma of Boybands 1st ed
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/dilemma-of-boybands-1st-ed 23/35
4<
V`n gth~s bofn ev| tnlhtfnf fnd~v hm ?557'| $Jekkemg Vebn+$ o |hmg emlk~fnf hm v`n
|h~mfvtolj hi v`n dkhljd~|vnt Bnm em Dkolj- V`net |nki"vevknf fnd~v okd~b wo| tnkno|nf em
notku ?550+ inov~temg sthf~lvehm du Wulkni Anom omf Antboemn F~ste+ obhmg hv`nt|- Ev| knof
|emgkn+ v`n Anom"sthf~lnf $Mh Mh Mh+$ wo| o |bo|` `ev+ |nkkemg hynt o bekkehm lhsen| omf
vhssemg v`n T)D l`otv|- V`n ihkkhw"~s |emgkn| "" $Wev` Bn$ omf $Gnv hm v`n D~|+$ v`n kovvnt
hi w`el` wo| vojnm ithb v`n |h~mfvtolj hi W`u Fh Ihhk| Iokk em Khyn8 "" fefm'v q~evn
f~skelovn v`n |~lln|| hi $Mh Mh Mh+$ okv`h~g` Fn|vemu'| L`ekf wh~kf nynmv~okku gh skovem~b
(oivnt v`n gth~s'| kovnt |~lln||%- Fn|vemu'| L`ekf tn"nmvntnf v`n |v~feh q~eljku+ dtemgemg em
sthf~lnt Jnyem $\`n'j|sntn$ Dtegg| vh `omfkn v`n boahtevu hi v`net mnpv tnlhtf- Knof |emgkn
$Dekk|+ Dekk|+ Dekk|$ dnlobn v`n gth~s'| iet|v m~bdnt hmn shs `ev (omf |nlhmf T)D m~bdnt
hmn% em v`n |~bbnt hi ?555+ omf solnf du ev| |~lln||+ v`n ollhbsomuemg okd~b+ V`n
Wtevemg'| hm v`n Wokk+ nmvntnf v`n l`otv| ov m~bdnt |ep ~shm ev| tnkno|n-
V`ov wo| a~|v v`n dngemmemg hi v`n gth~s'| dtnojh~v |~lln||- V`n |nlhmf |emgkn+ $D~g o Dhh+$
fefm'v sntihtb o| wnkk+ d~v v`n v`etf |emgkn+ $\ou Bu Mobn+$ wo| omhv`nt bo||eyn `ev+ v`net
deggn|v |h iot: ev `ev m~bdnt hmn hm dhv` v`n shs omf T)D l`otv| iht v`tnn wnnj| osenln em
notku 4333+ omf bofn Fn|vemu'| L`ekf o shs"l~kv~tok s`nmhbnmhm- @hwnynt+ ov v`n snoj hi
$\ou Bu Mobn$'| shs~kotevu+ v`n gth~s |skemvntnf- Em Fnlnbdnt ?555+ Thdnt|hm omf K~ljnvv
ovvnbsvnf vh |skev wev` bomognt Bov`nw Jmhwkn|+ l`otgemg v`ov `n jnsv o fe|sthshtvehmovn|`otn hi v`n domf'| sthiev|+ ovvnbsvnf vh npntv vhh b~l` lhmvthk+ omf ~mioetku ioyh~tnf `e|
fo~g`vnt omf menln- W`ekn v`nu mnynt emvnmfnf vh knoyn v`n gth~s+ tnkovehm| mov~tokku gtnw
|vtoemnf+ omf w`nm v`n yefnh iht $\ou Bu Mobn$ stnbentnf em Indt~otu 4333+ bomu iom|
(mhv vh bnmvehm Thdnt|hm omf K~ljnvv% wntn |~tste|nf vh iemf vwh mnw bnbdnt| "" Bel`nkkn
Wekkeob| omf Iotto` Itomjkem "" ahememg Jmhwkn| omf Thwkomf- Emi~teovnf+ Thdnt|hm omf
K~ljnvv vhhj kngok olvehm em Botl`+ |~emg dhv` Jmhwkn| omf v`net ihtbnt domf bovn| iht
dtnol` hi sotvmnt|`es omf ief~leotu f~ven|- O wot hi whtf| ihkkhwnf em v`n stn||: bnomw`ekn+
v`n mnpv Fn|vemu'| L`ekf |emgkn+ $A~bsem' A~bsem'+$ `ev v`n Vhs Vnm+ omf V`n Wtevemg'| hm v`n
Wokk wnmv hm vh |nkk o w`hssemg neg v̀ bekkehm lhsen|-
V`n snt|hmmnk"v~tmhynt ftobo |vekk wo|m'v hynt: em A~ku 4333+ a~|v ieyn bhmv`| oivnt ahememg+
Iotto` Itomjkem |skev wev` v`n gth~s- V`n hiieleok tno|hm wo| v`ov Itomjkem be||nf |nyntok
sthbhvehmok ossnotomln| omf lhmlntv geg|+ okv`h~g` em kovnt emvntyenw| |`n |shjn hi vhh b~l`
mngoveyevu omf vhh kevvkn lhmvthk em v`n gth~s nmyethmbnmv- Mhw tnf~lnf vh o vteh+ Fn|vemu'|
L`ekf wo| vossnf vh tnlhtf v`n v`nbn |hmg iht v`n iekb ynt|ehm hi L`otken'| Omgnk|: tnkno|nf
o| o |emgkn em Hlvhdnt+ $Emfnsnmfnmv Whbnm+ Sv- ?$ tolnf ~s v`n l`otv| omf |snmv om
8/8/2019 Dilemma of Boybands 1st ed
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/dilemma-of-boybands-1st-ed 24/35
46
o|vh~mfemg ?? wnnj| ov m~bdnt hmn- Fn|vemu'| L`ekf wntn mhw emfe|s~vodkn |~snt|vot|+ v`n
deggn|v inbokn T)D gth~s hm v`n |lnmn+ omf v`nu q~eljku dngom whtj hm o mnw okd~b vh
losevoken- Em v`n bnomvebn+ vhwotf v`n nmf hi 4333+ Thdnt|hm omf K~ljnvv fthssnf v`n
shtvehm hi v`net kow|~ev oebnf ov Thwkomf omf Jmhwkn| em npl`omgn iht o |nvvknbnmv+ v`h~g`
v`nu lhmvem~nf vh s~t|~n olvehm ogoem|v Jmhwkn|' iov`nt: o| sotv hi v`n ogtnnbnmv+ dhv` |efn|
wntn sth`edevnf ithb tessemg nol` hv`nt s~dkelku-
Dnuhmlå `of khmg |emln nbntgnf o| v`n gth~s'| ihlok shemv+ omf hm v`n v`etf Fn|vemu'| L`ekf
okd~b+ |`n o||~bnf bhtn lhmvthk v`om nynt dnihtn+ vojemg o gtnovnt `omf em wtevemg v`n
bovnteok omf nynm sthf~lemg |hbn hi v`n tnlhtf `nt|nki- W`ekn tnlhtfemg |n||ehm| wntn ghemg
hm+ Thwkomf tnkno|nf v`n iet|v Fn|vemu'| L`ekf |hkh vtolj: $Omgnk$ ossnotnf hm v`n |h~mfvtolj
hi L`te| Thlj'| Fhwm vh Notv`- Ihtbnt bnbdnt| Thdnt|hm omf K~ljnvv ok|h ommh~mlnf v`n
ihtbovehm hi o vteh lokknf+ lhemlefnmvokku+ Omgnk+ omf Iotto` Itomjkem |nv odh~v |votvemg o |hkh
lotnnt-
\~tyeyht " w`h|n vevkn wo| tnshtvnfku em|setnf du o FA'| ltolj odh~v Fn|vemu'| L`ekf bnbdnt|
yhvemg hmn omhv`nt hii v`n e|komf+ b~l` kejn v`n shs~kot LD\ tnokevu |nten| "" `ev |vhtn| em v`n
|stemg hi 433?+ omf nmvntnf v`n l`otv| ov m~bdnt hmn- V`n iet|v vwh |emgkn|+ $\~tyeyht$ omf
$Dhhvukeleh~|+$ wntn stnfelvodku `~gn `ev|+ wev` v`n kovvnt dnlhbemg v`n gth~s'| ih~tv`
m~bdnt hmn shs |emgkn- O lhynt hi Omfu Gedd'| $Nbhvehm$ wo| ok|h |~lln||i~k+ okdnev kn|| |h+
omf \~tyeyht |hkf wnkk "" hynt ih~t bekkehm lhsen| "" d~v mhv o| wnkk o| ev| stnfnln||ht-
Vhwotf v`n nmf hi v`n unot+ v`n gth~s tnkno|nf o `hkefou okd~b+ 0 Fou| hi L`te|vbo|+ omf
ommh~mlnf skom| iht o |nten| hi |efn sthanlv|+ emlk~femg |hkh okd~b| ithb okk v`tnn bnbdnt|
(vh dn |voggntnf hynt v`n mnpv unot omf o `oki+ |h o| vh oyhef lhbsnvevehm%- Em notku 4334+
|`htvku oivnt V`e| E| v`n Tnbep wo| tnkno|nf vh vefn iom| hynt+ Thdnt|hm omf K~ljnvv |~nf v`n
gth~s ogoem+ lkoebemg v`ov |hbn hi v`n kutel| em $\~tyeyht$ bofn tnintnmln vh v`nb (em
yehkovehm hi v`n notkent kow|~ev |nvvknbnmv%-
V`n iet|v Fn|vemu'| L`ekf |hkh okd~b+ Bel`nkkn Wekkeob|' okk"gh|snk sthanlv @notv vh Uh~t|+
wo| tnkno|nf em Ostek omf inov~tnf o f~nv wev` gh|snk kngnmf \`etknu Lon|ot- Bnomw`ekn+
Dnuhmlå whm o knofemg thkn hssh|evn Bejn Bunt| em v`n v`etf O~|vem Shwnt| iekb+
Ghkfbnbdnt+ skouemg dkopskhevovehm"|vukn `nthemn Ihpu Lknhsovto: `nt iet|v |hkh |emgkn+ v`n
Mnsv~mn|"sthf~lnf $Whtj Ev H~v+$ ossnotnf hm v`n |h~mfvtolj+ omf `nt i~kk |hkh okd~b+
Fomgnth~|ku em Khyn+ dnlobn o `~gn `ev ~shm tnkno|n em bef"433<- Fn|sevn b~l` ltevelok
|snl~kovehm+ v`n vteh tn~mevnf v`n ihkkhwemg unot omf tnkno|nf Fn|vemu I~kiekknf em Mhynbdnt
8/8/2019 Dilemma of Boybands 1st ed
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/dilemma-of-boybands-1st-ed 25/35
4>
4336- Em Hlvhdnt 433>+ v`n Mh ?'| lhbsekovehm wo| e||~nf+ ihkkhwnf du v`n Keyn em Ovkomvo
FYF omf LF |nv| em 4339 omf 4337- } \vnyn @~nu+ Thye
5-3 Vuselok sthdknb| em dhu domf|
W`nm dhu domf| otn ihtbnf+ v`ntn otn vuselok fnmv botj| kejn vovvhh| v`ov ollhbsomu v`net
npe|vnmln- V`ntn otn v`n ~|~ok e||~n| v`ov wekk okwou| dn movehmok omv`nb mh bovvnt w`ntn
v`nu otn do|nf- V`n iom|+ v`n iobn+ v`n ikhs|+ v`n iokk"h~v|+ v`n lo|`+ v`n lhbndolj|+ v`n
lovo|vths`n| nvl- /
Dnkhw otn ieyn dhu domf |vot| vokj odh~v v`n `eg`| omf khw| hi kein em v`n |shvkeg`v omf v`n
niinlv| hm v`net keyn| omf iobeku |ev~ovehm|- V`n|n ollh~mv| otn do|nf hm vt~n |vhten| fnteynf
ithb emvntyenw| iolv~okku `nkf wev` v`n |vot|-
\hbnv`emg |vtomgn `ossnmnf vh shs em 43351
(o% v`n dhudomf dh~mlnf dolj-
(d% Vojn V`ov'| |~bbnt vh~t dnlobn v`n io|vn|v"|nkkemg nynt+ omf ko|v unot'| P Iolvht
t~mmnt|"~s+
(l% AK\+ dnlobn v`n iet|v Dteve|` bokn gth~s em unot| vh emlevn lh~mvtuwefn stn"vnnm
tobsogn|-
(f% Mnw Jef| Hm v`n Dkhlj omf Dk~n tnihtbnf+ w`ekn |vokwotv| kejn Wn|vkein omf v`n
(n% Dolj|vtnnv Dhu| l`h|n mhv vh |ebsku wokkhw em v`net tel`n| omf sthbhvnf mnw
tnlhtf| em|vnof- Omf v`ntn otn t~bh~t| hi mnw olv| dnemg ko~ml`nf mnpv unot-
Hmn wh~kf whmfnt w`ov tnokku `ossnm| em o dhu"domf omf v`n ollh~mv| dnkhw ovvnbsv| vh
om|wnt v`n q~n|vehm|+ ‛D~v w`ov'| ev kejn vh dn em o dhu"domf8‒ ‛@hw fh v`n|n uh~mg bnm
lhsn wev` v`n of~kovehm+ v`n stn||~tn+ v`n vnbsvovehm|+ v`n jmhlj|8‒ ‛W`ov `ossnm| w`nm v`n
|ltnobemg vnnm| bhyn hm vh v`n mnpv `hv v`emg8‒
Dnkhw otn olv~ok lhbbnmv| ithb ieyn dhu"domf |vot| w`h tnynok okk - - -
'Getk| |votvnf v~tmemg ~s ov bu ithmv fhht- E wo| meln vh v`nb+' Melju Dutmn+ Wnovkein ihtbnf ?550
E wo| ?0 omf bu getkitenmf'| o~mven `notf om ofyntv hm v`n tofeh iht o dhu"domf o~fevehm- E
khynf |emgemg+ d~v totnku fef ev “ nplnsv hm v`n jotohjn oivnt o inw G~emmn||n|- D~v |`n
dofgntnf bn odh~v ev+ |h E wnmv+ omf v`ntn wo| Kh~e| Wok|`+ w`h `of s~v Dhuhmn vhgnv`nt-
8/8/2019 Dilemma of Boybands 1st ed
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/dilemma-of-boybands-1st-ed 26/35
49
Oivnt E |omg+ E v`h~g`v `n |oef1 $Uh~'f dn ghhf em o s~d domf-$ E wo| kejn+ v`omj|+ uh~ l`nnju
|hf/ V`nm E tnoke|nf `n'f |oef1 $Uh~'f dn ghhf em o shs domf-$ E wo| |`hljnf-
Snhskn fhm'v tnoke|n v`ov Wn|vkein fefm'v `oyn o fnok iht ogn|- Wn wnmv vh \kegh vh tn`not|n+
v`nm Kh~e| ghv ~| o fnok wev` Knye'| vh jev ~| h~v em aoljnv| omf anom|+ omf wn'f gh th~mf khlok
tofeh |vovehm| |emgemg olosnkko- Getk| |votvnf v~tmemg ~s ov bu ithmv fhht- Ev wo| yntu |vtomgn+
n|snleokku o| E'f dnnm wev` bu getkitenmf+ Gnhtgemo+ |emln E wo| ?>- \vekk+ E wo| meln vh v`nb+
|egmemg o~vhgtos`| omf |v~ii+ w`ekn Gnhtgemo jnsv bn |omn omf |v~lj du bn- Wn ghv bottenf
em 433< omf `oyn vwem dhu|-
Kh~e| okwou| |oef `n womvnf `otf whtjnt| tov`nt v`om `notv"v`thd| (ht nynm voknmvnf |emgnt|%-
@n nynm |oljnf ~| vweln iht bn||emg oth~mf: hmln+ yntu notku hm+ iht v`thwemg dtnof thkk|
ov nol` hv`nt+ w`ekn |vthkkemg em kovn iht bnnvemg|- E tnbnbdnt `eb kh|emg ev+ |`h~vemg1 $Uh~'yn
knv ev okk gh vh uh~t `nof|- E fhm'v whtj wev` snhskn kejn v`ov-$ V`omji~kku+ `n ke|vnmnf w`nm
wn dnggnf `eb vh vojn ~| dolj-
Dhu"domf| `oyn tnokku l`omgnf em v`n ko|v ?3 unot|- Ev'| kn|| odh~v getk|' iomvo|en| omf gnvvemg
uh~t vhs hii v`om odh~v iom| lhbemg vhgnv`nt+ khhjemg h~v iht uh~+ |emgemg okhmg- W`nm Botj
(Inn`eku+ Dutmn'| domf bovn% lobn h~v em 433?+ v`n iom| wntn |~sshtveyn+ w`el` bnomv v`n
whtkf vh ~|- E tnbnbdnt Kh~e| ko~g`emg omf |ouemg1 $Wnkk+ uh~ jmhw+ em dhu"domf| v`ntn'|okwou| hmn gou dhu///-$
‛Ei ev okk nmfnf vhbhtthw+ E'f be|| dnemg hm |vogn v`n bh|v- Ev fhn|m'v bovvnt ei v`n MBN |ou
uh~t b~|el e| iotlelok ht t~dde|` “ v`ov'| a~|v kein- V`n|n otn |hmg| v`ov khv| hi snhskn khyn-
W`nm uh~'tn ~s v`ntn omf uh~ jmhw w`ov |hmg'| lhbemg mnpv+ omf uh~ `not v`n iom| |ltnob
w`nm v`nu tnlhgme|n ev “ v`ov'| v`n dn|v innkemg em v`n whtkf-‒
'Wn'yn ghv o w`hkn |nl~tevu vnob1 o 46"`h~t dhfug~otf nol`' Jnyem Ahmo|+ Ahmo| Dthv`nt|+ ihtbnf
433>
‛Uh~ mnynt gnv ~|nf vh v`e| kein- Ov v`n |votv+ wn `of vh skou nyntu nynmv wn lh~kf+ od|hk~vnku
omuv`emg- \h b~l` `o| l`omgnf- Wn'yn ghv o w`hkn |nl~tevu vnob mhw- Nol` hi ~| `o| o
snt|hmok dhfug~otf 46 `h~t| o fou- Wn mnnf v`nb+ vhh1 |hbnvebn| uh~ lom dn em o dof
|ev~ovehm wev` iom| gnvvemg hynt"nplevnf- Bu bom'| Deg Thd+ w`h ~|nf vh dn wev` Aomnv
Aolj|hm omf Dtevmnu \snot|- Wn `omg oth~mf vokjemg+ wovl`emg bhyen|+ skouemg lhbs~vntgobn| hm v`n d~|- Vh h~v|efnt|+ ev'| |vtomgn+ d~v ev'| kejn goememg o mnw iobeku-‒
8/8/2019 Dilemma of Boybands 1st ed
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/dilemma-of-boybands-1st-ed 27/35
47
Dhu"domf| otn feiintnmv vhfou- Iom| whm'v a~|v ollnsv |emgemg gth~s| w`h fomln kejn v`e|+
fomln kejn v`ov+ omu bhtn- V`nu'kk |vekk otg~n hynt w`h'| v`net ioyh~tevn- E khyn v`ov+ ev bojn|
bn ko~g`+ d~v v`nu womv bhtn h~v hi uh~ b~|elokku- V`ov'| ghhf+ dnlo~|n wn'tn gnvvemg hkfnt
o| wnkk+ omf gnvvemg emvh |v~ii kejn v`n Q~vhm|+ Ah`mmu Lo|` omf Nkye| Lh|vnkkh-
E khyn ev w`nm wn wtevn |hmg| emik~nmlnf du hv`nt gth~s|+ omf h~t iom| |votv vh ke|vnm vh v`nb
o| wnkk- Bu ofyeln vh dhu"domf| wh~kf vh dn vh jnns knynk"`nofnf+ d~v v`emj odh~v `hw uh~
lom dtoml` h~v- Uh~t iom| wekk gthw wev` uh~+ d~v uh~'yn ghv vh bhyn wev` v`nb+ vhh-
'W`nm ev okk wnmv wthmg+ ev inkv kejn v`n whtkf wo| nmfemg ' Vhmu Bhtvebnt+ No|v ?7+ ?55?"?550+
tn~mehm 4339+ mhw |hkh
‛E |vekk tnbnbdnt v`n fou E `of v`n efno vh ihtb o whtjemg"lko|| dhu"domf- E wo| ?5 omf
hd|n||nf+ d~v E fefm'v vnkk bu bovn| |vtoeg`vowou+ dnlo~|n E fefm'v womv o jeljemg- V`e| wo|
Wokv`ob|vhw em no|v Khmfhm+ omf v`ntn wo| ltebn omf ltos nyntuw`ntn- Uh~ lh~kf fnok
ft~g|+ fh |shtv ht vtu b~|el- E `of okwou| `of sntihtbemg oth~mf bn1 bu iov`nt wo| o d~ekfnt
w`h skounf v`n g~evot: bu bhv`nt whtjnf o| o lknomnt omf `of whm owotf| iht Ete|` fomlemg-
\h b~|el ev wo|-‒
E bnv v`n hv`nt dhu| `omgemg h~v oth~mf vhwm+ h~v|efn v`n nknlvtel |`hs+ em v`n sotj+ vokjemg
|`ev+ ke|vnmemg vh tos omf `es"`hs- E'f l`nlj h~v v`n dhu| q~envku omf v`emj1 $H`+ v`nu'f dn
ghhf em o domf-$ E skhvvnf em bu `nof+ wthvn |hmg| omf `~|vknf Vhb Wovjem|+ v`n bomognt
w`h `of khhjnf oivnt v`n Snv \`hs Dhu| omf Dth|+ a~|v |nmfemg `eb vosn|+ fhemg `e| `nof em-
@n |oef E wo| t~dde|` |h bomu vebn|+ d~v o| `n'f vojnm v`n vebn vh tnsku+ E |v~lj ov ev- Hmn fou
E |nmv `eb o |hmg lokknf Fnns- Demgh+ `n khynf ev “ omf ev okk wnmv bnmvok ithb v`ntn-‒
@n ghv ~| em \bo|` @ev| dnihtn wn `of ghv o tnlhtf fnok+ omf |~ffnmku wn wntn hm thof
|`hw| omf VY+ kejn |hbn oboemg+ wnetf ftnob- Ev `of dnnm o |vtomgn unot iht bn dnihtn okk
v`ov omuwou- Bu dthv`nt `of fenf “ `n jekknf `eb|nki “ |h v`ov wo| okk em bu `nof+ omf bu
getkitenmf Vtolu+ w`h E'b |vekk wev`+ `of ghv stngmomv wev` h~t iet|v kevvkn getk- Omf v`ntn E wo|
t~mmemg hii vh `oyn selv~tn| vojnm wev` bu vhs hii-
‛Ft~g| bn||nf ev ~s iht ~|/ W`nm ev okk wnmv wthmg+ ev inkv kejn v`n whtkf wo| nmfemg- Uh~'f
dnnm womvnf omf v`nm+ mhv`emg- Omf bu itenmf| fefm'v womv vh jmhw bn+ n|snleokku Dteom
Z@otynuR+ w`h E'f iokknm h~v wev` khmg dnihtn v`ov tofeh emvntyenw Zem ?557+ @otynu vhkf v`n
8/8/2019 Dilemma of Boybands 1st ed
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/dilemma-of-boybands-1st-ed 28/35
40
DDL `n `of vojnm ?4 nl|vo|u vodknv| em hmn meg`v: `n wo| |oljnf ithb No|v ?7 v`n ihkkhwemg
fouR- @hw iteg`vnmemg ev e| vh dn ~mwomvnf f~n vh |hbnv`emg o| dof o| FT^G\/
‛V`n dhu" domf‒ `of dnnm bu dodu omf mhw ev wo|m'v- V`n dhu| |vekk vh~t o| N"?7+ |emgemg bu
hkf |hmg|- E wo| omgtu wev` v`nb iht o khmg vebn+ n|snleokku w`nm wn vtenf vh tnihtb omf ev
fefm'v whtj h~v Zv`n tn~mehm nmfnf wev` Bhtvebnt s~ml`emg @otynuR- Mhw E |ou ghhf k~lj vh
v`nb- E'yn ghv bu hwm kein+ E'yn skounf ghhf geg| tnlnmvku+ omf E'b wtevemg mnw b~|el+ w`el`
wekk dn tnkno|nf mnpv unot- Ev'| `otf |nnemg domf| kejn VojnV`ov gnv deg ogoem+ v`h~g`+
n|snleokku w`nm v`nu'tn tnkno|emg |emgkn| wev` dkhhfu ~j~knkn| okk hynt v`nb- Wn wntn o deg
fnok em v`n ?553|- Wn bofn gtnov tnlhtf|- Ev bojn| bn |of v`ov snhskn fhm'v tnbnbdnt ~|
omubhtn+ a~|v dnlo~|n wn fotnf vh vh~l` FT^G\ (@otynu em sotvel~kot% omf v`n w`hkn N"?7
khhjnf lthhjnf+ knsth|nf omf bokegmnf iht hmn bom‘| ihhke|` olv/
W`ov wh~kf E |ou vh o mnw dhu"domf8 Nmahu v`n fou| w`nm uh~'tn |votvemg h~v- V`nu'tn v`n
dn|v vebn|1 lhbemg ~s+ gnvvemg jmhwm+ w`nm ev'| okk |vekk mnw- E lom |vekk innk v`ov nplevnbnmv em
bu kng| w`nm E wo| uh~mg “ t~mmemg `hbn vh whtj hm om efno+ vh ftnob |hbnv`emg ~s- E inkv
kejn o bogeleom- E inkv kejn E wo| lhmvthkkemg v`n whtkf- Ev fhn| mhv ko|v ei uh~ otn ihhke|`/ E keyn
wev` ebbnm|n tngtnv| o| wn |`h~kf `oyn jmhwm w`ov wo| okkhwnf omf w`ov vodhh e|/
SKNO\N FHM‘V FH FT^G\///‒
'E v`h~g`v1 \snmf v`n bhmnu+ dnlo~|n uh~ fhm'v fn|ntyn ev' \ebhm Wnddn+ Dk~n+ 433?"433>+ omf
tnihtbnf 4335
‛E wo| mnynt o |emgnt- E'f vtoemnf vh dn o ihhvdokknt+ jeljemg o dokk ithb fowm vh f~|j+ |h E
be||nf Vhs hi v`n Shs|+ Ghemg Keyn+ okk v`ov |v~ii- V`nm E `of o dof ema~tu+ |h E dnlobn o
bhfnk- \hbn bomognt| lobn vh bn omf |oef1 $Uh~'yn ghv o gtnov khhj+ lom uh~ |emg8$
\emgemg |nnbnf om hff v`emg vh fh+ |h E wo| kejn1 $Mh+ mhv ov okk-$ V`nm E fef om o~fevehm wev`
v`n dhu| w`h dnlobn Dk~n+ omf wn dnlobn itenmf|+ |v~lj vhgnv`nt-
‛Mhv khmg oivnt+ bu gtomffof fenf+ omf E v`h~g`v1 $Bom+ kein'| vhh |`htv- Knv'| a~|v stolve|n+
|nn w`ntn v`e| ghn|-$ Omf |~ffnmku v`ntn E wo|+ npsntenmlemg shs b~|el iht v`n yntu iet|v
vebn- \vekk+ E'b em v`n domf dnlo~|n bu ioln ievvnf- E jmhw v`ov- Ov iet|v+ E wo| kejn o toddev em
v`n `nofkeg`v|- E wo| dth~g`v ~s em Boml`n|vnt'| Bh|| \efn+ du o |emgkn b~b w`h `of `hkn|
em `nt |`hn|+ em o skoln w`ntn ft~g| wntn o wou hi kein- \~ffnmku E wo| em bu notku 43| wev` o
8/8/2019 Dilemma of Boybands 1st ed
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/dilemma-of-boybands-1st-ed 29/35
45
bekkehm em v`n domj- W`ov E tnbnbdnt yeyefku e| v`emjemg+ $\snmf v`n bhmnu+ dnlo~|n uh~
fhm'v fn|ntyn ev-‒
‛Uh~ |`h~kfm'v+ uh~ jmhw- Uh~ |`h~kf knoyn ev w`ntn ev e|- Ihtgnv \nkitefgn| omf ghemg vh
Bo`eje nyntu meg`v- A~|v tnbnbdnt w`ov ev innk| kejn vh dn |evvemg em o s~d hm o \~mfou+
ftnofemg whtj+ ht q~n~emg vh |egm hm- V`ov |`h~kf dtemg uh~ th~mf-‒
‛W`nm wn dnlobn iobh~|+ E bnv bu fo~g`vnt iht v`n iet|v vebn- \`n wo| dhtm w`nm E wo| ?7-
E'f womvnf vh bnnv `nt+ d~v ev wo| lhbskelovnf- W`nm E iemokku fef+ w`nm ev wo| okk `ossnmemg
iht v`n domf+ |hbnv`emg `ossnmnf vh bn- Ev goyn bn o jelj+ bofn bn tnoke|n w`ov o
steyekngnf sh|evehm E wo| em- Wn'yn dnnm lkh|n nynt |emln+ bn omf Okomo`-‒
E fhm'v v`emj om okk"dkolj dhu"domf kejn AK\ wh~kf `oyn dnnm |egmnf em v`n fou| w`nm wn
wntn |votvemg h~v- V`n P Iolvht'| gtnov em v`ov wou1 ev |`hw| v`n tnlhtf lhbsomen| w`ov
snhskn tnokku womv “ n|snleokku o| bh|v kodnk| otn t~m du hkf g~u| w`h `oyn mh efno w`ov'|
ghemg hm em lk~d| ht hm v`n |vtnnv|-
W`nm wn wnmv h~t |nsotovn wou| em 433>+ ev wo| kejn bu lhbihtv hmn `of dnnm vojnm owou-
Wn'f ghmn ithb |nkkemg ?->b vh 733+333- E womvnf ~| vh ieg`v h~t wou dolj+ d~v shs fhn|m'v
whtj kejn v`ov- Du v`nm+ nyntu O)T wo| hd|n||nf wev` emfen domf| omuwou- Okv`h~g` E'yn
`of o |hkh lotnnt v`ov'| ghmn stnvvu wnkk+ vh bu obonbnmv+ E lom'v dnkenyn wn'yn mhw ghv o
|nlhmf l`omln vh dn vhgnv`nt o| o domf-
‛E fhm'v ihtgnv v`n dof fou|- E |vekk gh okhmg vh bu fo~g`vnt'| |l`hhk “ ev'| mhv o steyovn hmn+
omf mnynt wh~kf dn+ dnlo~|n v`ov'| mhv tnok kein “ omf gnv emyhkynf em kevvkn wou|+ geyemg
lntveielovn|+ vnkkemg v`n|n jef| v`ntn e| `hsn- Bu ofyeln vh dhu"domf| wh~kf dn1 tnbnbdnt
`hw v`n whtkf tnokku whtj|+ omf mnynt ihtgnv w`ntn uh~ lobn ithb-‒
'Wn fefm'v kejn dnemg lokknf o dhu"domf- Wn wntn o dev hkf' Tel`en Wntbntkemg+ Knv Khh|n+ ?55<"
?559+ tnihtbnf 4330
‛Ei omuhmn vnkk| uh~ v`ov dnemg em o dhu"domf fhn|m'v |ltnw uh~ ~s+ v`nu'tn o keot- @hw lom ev
mhv8 Uh~'tn em uh~t 43| omf |~ffnmku |hbnhmn vnkk| uh~+ $@nu/ Uh~'tn gtnov/$ @ntn'| om
emvntyenw+ o bogoemn lhynt+ nyntuv`emg uh~ nynt womvnf- Vh `oyn v`ov+ omf v`nm mhv `oyn ev “
ev'| kejn dnemg em hmn yntu |vtomgn whtkf+ v`nm omhv`nt-‒
8/8/2019 Dilemma of Boybands 1st ed
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/dilemma-of-boybands-1st-ed 30/35
<3
‛Wn fefm'v kejn dnemg lokknf o dhu"domf- Wn wntn o dev hkf iht dkhhfu |votvnt|- E wo| em bu
bef"43|- Ok|h+ E olv~okku wthvn bu |hmg|- Omf w`nm wn `of h~t iet|v deg `ev+ Ltou iht Uh~+
ev wo| o whtf"hi"bh~v` v`emg1 ev vhhj ev| vebn lkebdemg v`n l`otv|- D~v hmln uh~'tn v`h~g`v hi
em o lntvoem wou “ o| o d~ml` hi dhu| |emgemg khyn |hmg|+ wnotemg meln lkhv`n| “ v`nm v`ov'|
v`ov- Uh~'yn ghv vh ieg`v vh dn v`h~g`v hi feiintnmvku- Wn nynm `of o `ev wev` o Dtnof vtolj+
Bojn Ev Wev` Uh~+ o sthsnt KO |hiv"thlj |hmg+ d~v snhskn `of bofn ~s v`net bemf|-‒
E tnkno|nf om okd~b ko|v unot wev` o mnw Knv Khh|n kemn"~s- E fefm'v fh ev vh a~bs hm v`n
lhbndolj vtoek+ v`h~g`- E'kk dn bojemg b~|el ~mvek E'b hkf omf gtnu+ sotvku dnlo~|n E fhm'v
jmhw w`ov nk|n E'f fh+ sotvku dnlo~|n E'yn jmhwm w`ov ev'| kejn vh |vomf dnihtn o `~gn
o~fenmln omf innk v`ov emltnfedkn t~|`- Bu ofyeln vh mnw dhu"domf| vhfou8 Bbbb++++ Nmahu
nyntu bhbnmv- Nmahu ev w`ekn ev ko|v|-‒
?3-3 Lhmlk~|ehm| odh~v Dhu"domf|
Vojemg o mh|vokgel khhj dolj hynt v`n unot| omf geyemg uh~ o l`omln vh ke|vnm ogoem vh |hbn
hi v`h|n lko||el `ev|+ v`e| fhl~bnmvotu nplk~|eynku |snoj| vh o |nknlvehm hi v`n dhu|
v`nb|nkyn| omf ok|h |hbn hi v`n jnu bomognt| w`h bo|vntbemfnf v`net |~lln||-
Dhu" domf inynt `of vojnm v`n ^J du |vhtb em v`n ?553‘|+ dhu domf| wntn keyemg v`n shsftnob d~v ev wo|m‘v okk `otbkn|| i~m+ ft~g |lomfok| dngom vh `ev v`n `nofkemn| omf v`n kein|vukn
dngom vh vojn ev‘| vhkk- ?559 |ow v`n iet|v boaht lo|~okvu em v`n dhu domf whtkf “ v`n |skev hi
Vojn V`ov-
‛E wo| ov |l`hhk w`nm Vojn V`ov |skev omf E tnbnbdnt snhskn em v`n `okkwou| ltuemg omf `nks
kemn| wntn |nv ~s‒ ko~g`| Fomn Dhwnt|
‛Iht \bo|` @ev| ev wo| o fotj fou dnlo~|n+ hj+ wn‘yn mhw a~|v kh|v h~t dn|v"|nkkemg gth~s
a~|v w`ov fh uh~ fh8/‒ tnbnbdnt| Botj Itev`-
V`n sthdknb mhw wo| v`ov nyntuhmn womvnf vh a~bs hm v`n dhu domf woghm omf iekk v`n gos
em v`n botjnv- ‛Nyntudhfu v`h~g`v “ wn lom fh v`e|+ wn otn ieyn dhu|+ wn lom‘v |emg+ wn lom‘v
wtevn |hmg| d~v v`ntn e| ghmmo dn o d~ml` hi g~u| hynt v`ntn v`ov lom fh okk v`ov iht ~|‒ |ou|
Vhb Wovjem|-
8/8/2019 Dilemma of Boybands 1st ed
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/dilemma-of-boybands-1st-ed 31/35
<?
\~ffnmku v`n botjnv wo| ikhhfnf wev` dhu domf|- V`n \vogn mnw|sosnt wo| em~mfovnf wev`
o~fevehm| iht dhu|- ‛uh~ gnv v`n fhfgu hmn| omf v`nm uh~‘f gnv v`n ghhf hmn|+ d~v uh~ `oyn vh
gh vh okk hi v`nb a~|v vh vojn o l`omln‒ tnbnbdnt| Omvhmu Lh|vo-
Iht v`n dhu| w`h bofn ev okk v`n `otf whtj omf vebn hm v`n thof dngom vh vojn ev| vhkk omf
|~ffnmku du v`n nmf hi v`n ?553‘| |hbn hi v`n domf| wntn hm v`n yntu nfgn hi v`net hwm
fhwmiokk- \nki"fn|vt~lveyn dn`oyeh~t `o| okwou| ghmn `omf em `omf wev` thlj omf thkk “ d~v
mhw ev wo| `evvemg v`n dhu domf|-
‛V`nu fef gh h~v+ v`nu |ltnwnf o| bomu getk| o| v`nu lh~kf+ v`nu vhhj lhseh~| obh~mv| hi
ft~g|+ v`nu ft~mj khof| hi oklh`hk omf v`nu sotvenf‒ Vhb Wovjem| tnbnbdnt| bomogemg
N?7-
‛Dn`emf lkh|nf fhht| w`nm v`nu gh vh `hvnk| ov meg`v+ v`nu gnv ft~mj+ v`nu vojn ft~g|+ v`nu knv
em gth~sen| “ v`nu‘tn dhu|‒ Kh~e| Wok|`-
‛E‘f wojn ~s+ gnv hm v`n |h~s+ `oyn o inw dnyen| v`th~g`h~v v`n fou+ nmf ~s ghemg vh v`n VY‘|
gotgknf ~s+ mhv ft~mj+ d~v vtuemg vh nmkeg`vnm v`n fou dnlo~|n ev wo| |h bhmhvhmh~|+
nyntufou ev wo| om emvntyenw+ nyntu fou wo| o VY+ vokjemg v`n |obn |v~ii E |shjn iht v`n ko|v
inw wnnj| odh~v v`n |obn tnlhtf+ v`n |obn vh~t+ E wo| vtuemg vh bojn ev nplevemg ogoem‒
\`omn Kuml` ithb Dhuhmn tnlokk|
\`omn‘| fn|vt~lveyn dn`oyeh~t omf e||~n| lobn vh o `nof em ?555 ov v`n BVY owotf| em
F~dkem w`ntn `n iobh~|ku `of o s~dkel h~vd~t|v v`ov |`hljnf `e| iom|-
‛E fefm‘v womv vh dn em o dhu domf omubhtn- E fefm‘v womv vh dn lokknf o iogghv wokjemg fhwm
v`n |vtnnv omubhtn- E womvnf vh dn o `otf m~v+ E womvnf vh dn ltnfedkn omf mhv em o dhu domf
omf E v`emj v`ov‘| w`ntn bu fhwmiokk wo| dnlo~|n E |votvnf vh fe|tn|snlv w`ov E wo| em‒
npskoem \`omn-
Omhv`nt kein|vukn stn||~tn skolnf hm v`n dhu domf wo| v`n efno v`nu `of vh tnboem |emgkn vh
jnns v`net inbokn iom| emvntn|vnf- V`e| e| o| ~mmov~tok o| ev e| emltnfedkn vh v`n mhtbok bemf hi
o `hv"dkhhfnf vnnmogn uh~mg bom- V`e| ~mihtv~movnku e| hmn hi v`n vntb| omf lhmfevehm| hi
dosve|b emvh o dhu"domf kein |vukn |snkv h~v em dhu"domf dedkn|- V`e| e| o| ebsh||edkn o| o bom
iokkemg stngmomv omf ~|~okku dnlhbn| v`n gtnovn|v lhbbomfbnmv v`ov e| ebsh||edkn vh jnns-
‛W`nm wn iet|v |votvnf wn wntnm‘v |~ssh|nf vh |ou wn `of o getkitenmf‒ OA ithb V`n Dolj|vtnnv Dhu|-
8/8/2019 Dilemma of Boybands 1st ed
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/dilemma-of-boybands-1st-ed 32/35
<4
Megnk Botvem \bev` iobh~|ku vhkf Vojn V`ov v`nu lh~kfm‘v `oyn getkitenmf| omf `of ev
|ves~kovnf em v`net lhmvtolv|- V`n inot v`ov o getkitenmf wh~kf t~em v`n domf wo| tein+ wn wntn
|lotnf v`n stn|| wh~kf iemf h~v wn `of getkitenmf|‒ tnbnbdnt| \`omn- ‛E whttenf odh~v v`n
iom| tnolvehm w`nm E ghv bottenf‒ tnlokk| Thwom Jnovemg-
D~v |hbnvebn| ev wo| vhh `otf vh jnns uh~t kein ~mfnt wtos|-
‛v`n \~m lokknf vh |ou wn `oyn |hbn selv~tn| hi uh~ omf omhv`nt g~u+ ei uh~ fhm‘v womv vh fh
v`n emvntyenw v`ov‘| iemn+ d~v ei uh~ fhm‘v `n‘| ghemg vh gh vh omhv`nt mnw|sosnt‒ |ou \vns`nm-
Okv`h~g` v`n tnynkovehm hi `e| |np~okevu fef \vns`nm mh `otb+ |hbn dhu| inkv v`nu `of vh `efn
v`net |np~okevu omf jnns ~s v`n stnvnmln+‒ \vns`nm Govknu tnbnbdnt|
V`n wht|v v`emg v`ov lom `ossnm vh o dhu domf bnbdnt e| vh iokk ithb gtoln+ o| Dteom @otynu
ithb No|v ?7 ih~mf h~v- Dteom fe|lkh|nf em om emvntyenw v`ov `n `of vojnm ?4 nl|vo|u sekk| em
hmn meg`v omf tninttnf vh v`nb o| |oin-
‛du >-<3 em v`n bhtmemg E wo| s~dkel nmnbu m~bdnt hmn+ V`n stn|| a~|v wnmv iht bn… v`n
obh~mv hi stn||~tn v`nb stn|| lom s~v hm o snt|hm E lom‘v dngem vh vnkk uh~ w`ov v`ov fhmn vh
bn+ v`ov‘| w`nm bu kein wnmv whmju‒- Tnlokk| Dteom @otynu
V`n kein hi dhu"domf| lom dn |`htv keynf omf v~td~knmv- Khmg fou| hm v`n thof omf lhm|vomvsntihtbomln| lom knof vh npln||eyn dn`oyeh~t- Okv`h~g` okk hi v`n dhu"domf| ftnob hi
bojemg o lhbndolj “ ev e| ~mkejnku vh `ossnm+ ~mkn|| uh~ otn Vojn V`ov+ w`h em 4339 `of
v`n deggn|v tn|~ttnlvehm v`n dhu domf lhbb~mevu `oyn nynt |nnm- Vojn v`ov jnns lhbemg dolj
ogoem omf ogoem- V`e| e| 43?3 omf v`nu otn ogoem hm v`n lhbn"dolj vtoek wev` Thdden Wekkeob|
em v`n |offkn ogoem/
V`ntn e| mnnf iht mnw kow| omf tng~kovehm| iht v`n ihtbovehm hi dhu"domf| omf nmvntvoembnmv
htgome|ovehm em v`n ^J vh goem lhmvthk hi v`n obhndel npsom|ehm hi v`n emf~|vtu- V`n kolj hi
lhtshtovn |hleok tn|shm|edekevu omf bhmevhtemg hi v`n s|ul`hkhgelok niinlv| hi v`n emf~|vtu hm
iobeken| omf v`n bnbdnt| hi v`n dhu"domf lo~|n| ebbnm|n stn||~tn hm |hleok |ntyeln|+
nf~lovehm omf ghyntmbnmv fnsotvbnmv|- Wev` v`n tnln||ehm vojemg skoln ov v`n bhbnmv
fnbomf| iht tn|shm|edkn |hleok olveyeven| nbomovemg ithb v`n nmvntvoembnmv emf~|vtu `o|
dnlhbn o itelvehmok nknbnmv v`ov `o| emik~nmlnf bomognbnmv htgome|ovehm| vh tnlhgme|n |hleok
tn|shm|edekevu o| om ebshtvomv emvngtok hi v`n b~|el bomognbnmv htgome|ovehm|- Nf~lovehmok
omf |hleok wemg| `oyn dnnm emvthf~lnf em bomognbnmv htgome|ovehm| omf mnw bhfnk| hi
8/8/2019 Dilemma of Boybands 1st ed
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/dilemma-of-boybands-1st-ed 33/35
<<
bomogemg domf| otn nbntgemg- V`ntn e| o mnw fowm em v`n emf~|vtu o| v`n sthbhvehm hi v`n
mnw bhfnk hi |hleok tn|shm|edekevu vojn| |`osn em v`n emf~|vtu-
V`n mnpv vebn hmn nmvnt| o b~|el bngo"|vhtn+ hmn wekk dn bnv wev` v`n mhvehm v`ov domf| otn
mh khmgnt dnemg bom~iolv~tnf d~v otn dnemg okkhwnf vh dkh||hb wev` |hleok tn|shm|edekevu o|
v`n fteyemg i~nk tov`nt v`om v`n k~|v iht sthiev+ |np omf gkobh~t- V`n mnw fowm hi |hleok
tn|shm|edekevu em v`n b~|el nmvntvoembnmv emf~|vtu e| okbh|v ~shm v`n lhbb~mevu-
8/8/2019 Dilemma of Boybands 1st ed
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/dilemma-of-boybands-1st-ed 34/35
<6
??-3 Dedkehgtos`u omf bovnteok ~|nf
D~tmnvv+ Thdntv (?559%- V`n Gkhdok A~jndhp1 V`n Emvntmovehmok B~|el Emf~|vtu- Khmfhm1
Th~vknfgn+
Lhwnkk+ \- (433<% $E Fhm'v Bnom vh Dn T~fn+ D~v---$+ Dthofwou Dhhj|+ E\DM 3"7975"?76?"<
f‘Omgnkh+ Boteh (4334% Fhn| gkhdoke|ovehm bnom emnk~lvodkn lhmlnmvtovehm 8 em V`n B~|el
Emf~|vtu em v`n Mnw Nlhmhbu+ Tnshtv hi v`n O|eo"N~thsn \nbemot+ Kuhm+ Hlv- 4> “ 40+ 433?+
ENS fn KuhmO|eo"N~thsn Ih~mfovehmN~telok+ Nfevht| Thl`n I-+ Botlq D-+ Lhkhbå Fss- >< “
>6-
f'Omgnkh+ Boteh (4339% Snt|snlveyn| hi v`n Bomognbnmv hi B~|elok Em|vev~vehm| em N~thsn +
HBI+ B~|elok Olveyeven| omf Em|vev~vehm| \ntu+ Sote|EY"\htdhmmn ^meynt|evu+ Nf- B~|elokn|
O~g- Q~tik~`+ Dh~tg"ko"Tnemn+
Fnkoyom+ A- (4334% Dhu Domf|1 V`n @~mj| omf @notvv`thdd| Lhmq~ntemg v`n Shs B~|el
Whtkf Nfevehm ekk~|vtovnf+ Vte~bs` Dhhj|+ ^J-
Felj Wne||bom+ Itomj Antbomln+ Gnmmoth Fn\omve|+ Tomfe Sntjem|+ Jeb Womgknt (433<%
Moyegovemg v`n b~|el emf~|vtu1 l~ttnmv e||~n| ) d~|emn|| bhfnk| B~|el D~|emn|| \nten| @ok
Nfevehm ekk~|vtovnf Knhmotf Lhtshtovehm+ ̂ \O-
Fhmokf \- So||bom- (4339% Okk uh~ mnnf vh jmhw odh~v v`n b~|el d~|emn|| Nfevehm 9+
ekk~|vtovnf+ Itnn Stn||+ ^\O+ ^J
Gtou+ V- (4330% V`n @ev L`otofn1 Kh~ Snotkbom+ Dhu Domf|+ omf v`n Deggn|v Shme \l`nbn
em ^-\- Nfevehm @e|vhtu ekk~|vtovnf+ Lhkkem|+ ^J
Gthmhw+ Snjjo+ omf Eksh \o~meh- (?550% - Om Emvntmovehmok @e|vhtu hi v`n Tnlhtfemg Emf~|vtu-
Khmfhm1 Lo||nkk+
@obb+ L`otkn|- (?575% Un|vntfou|1 Shs~kot \hmg em Obntelo- Mnw Uhtj1 Mhtvhm-
B- Wekkeob Jto|ekhy|ju+ \efmnu \`nbnk+ Ah`m B- Gth||+ Ahmov`om Inem|vnem (4337% V`e|
D~|emn|| hi B~|el1 Fniemeveyn G~efn vh v`n B~|el Emf~|vtu Mnw \nten| Nfevehm?3+ ekk~|vtovnf
Dekkdhotf+ ̂ J-
`vvs1www-no|ent-lhb<3>>0"v`n"vt~v`"odh~v"dhu"domf|-`vbk
`vvs1www-d~ddkng~m-lhbl~kv~tnshsdhudomf|- v̀bk
`vvs1www-ddl-lh-~jfmo`4g4O06<?<3
`vvs1www-ddl-lh-~jfmo`4g4O>0??44
`vvs1www-no|ent-lhb<3>>0"v`n"vt~v`"odh~v"dhu"domf|-`vbk
`vvs1www-`nke~b-lhbevnb|4>5046"bom~iolv~tnf"shs"o"dteni"`e|vhtu"hi"dhu"domf|
8/8/2019 Dilemma of Boybands 1st ed
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/dilemma-of-boybands-1st-ed 35/35
`vvs1www-shsa~|veln-lhbiht~bemfnp-s`s8vhsel2?9?3?-3
`vvs1www-nbeb~|el-lhbodh~v|hleoktn|shm|edekevu
Jto|ekhy|ju+ B- Wekkeob: \`nbnk+ \efmnu: Gth||+ Ah`m B-: Inem|vnem+ Ahmov`om+ V`e|
D~|emn|| hi B~|el (?3v` nf-%+ Dekkdhotf Dhhj|+ E\DM 304<377454
Kndtnl`v+ Mhtbom (?559% W`nm v`n B~|el \vhs|1 Bomognt|+ Bon|vth| omf v`n Lhtshtovn
B~tfnt hi Lko||elok B~|el+ \ebhm ) \l`~|vnt-
\omanj+ T~||nkk- (?559% Snmmen| ithb @noynm1 V`n Obntelom Shs~kot B~|el D~|emn|| em v`n
Vwnmvenv` Lnmv~tu- ^sfovnf du Foyef \omanj- Mnw Uhtj1 Fo Losh+
V|l`b~lj+ Snvnt (4339% Ltnoveyevu omf Emmhyovehm em v`n B~|el Emf~|vtu + \stemgnt -
Wne|bom+ Khtnm (43?3% $V`n Otve|v'| G~efn vh \~lln|| em v`n B~|el D~|emn||$+ DSM 43?3-
E\DM ?"5<><>5"<<"5
Recommended