Complaint by Unsecured Creditors to Determine Validity of Property and Liens-Doc 299

8/2/2019 Complaint by Unsecured Creditors to Determine Validity of Property and Liens-Doc 299

1/9

H DAI 116946 v77;771:4,5555:: 5=/79/75:7

KH ]AC SHK]CM T]J]CT GJHNWSU]D[ D@SW]

F@W ]AC LKMMBC MKT]WKD] @F ]CHHCTTCC

KH WC? +

+ Daju}cw ::

DASWDA T]WCC] ACJB]A + Djtc H`( :7,5:394LJHJICLCH]" BBD" c} jb(" + Osmic Bshmkh

+ O`kh}b{ Jmlkhkt}cwcm:

Mcg}`wt( ++

@FFKDKJB SHTCDSWCM DWCMK]@WT +

D@LLK]]CC" +

+

Ubjkh}kff" +

+

v( + Jmv( Uw`( H`( PPPPPPPPPPP

+TT@ FSHMKHI D@WU(> TTA FSHMKHI D@WU(> +

DK] ACJB]ADJWC BBD" JT D@BBJ]CWJB +

JICH] JHM JMLKHKT]WJ]KVC JICH]> jhm +

JLCWKDJH DJUK]JB" B]M( JT D@BBJ]CWJB +

JICH]" +

+

Mcfchmjh}t( +

PPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPP

D@LUBJKH] @F ]AC @FFKDKJB SHTCDSWCM DWCMK]@WT D@LLK]]CC ]@

MC]CWLKHC ]AC VJBKMK][" UWK@WK][" @W CQ]CH] @F BKCHT @W @]ACW

KH]CWCT] KH UW@UCW][ JHM F@W MCDBJWJ]@W[ OSMILCH]

PPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPP

Ubjkh}kff" }ac @ffkdkjb Shtcdswcm Dwcmk}`wt D`llk}}cc f`w Daswda T}wcc} Acjb}a

Ljhjiclch}" BBD" c} jb( !'Ubjkh}kff' `w 'D`llk}}cc'+" Mcg}`wt kh }ac jg`vc,dju}k`hcm o`kh}b{

jmlkhkt}cwcm djtct" t}j}ct jt k}t D`lubjkh} jijkht} Mcfchmjh}t TT@ Fshmkhi D`wu(" TTA Fshmkhi

D`wu(" DK] Acjb}adjwc BBD" jt D`bbj}cwjb Jich} jhm Jmlkhkt}wj}kvc Jich}" jhm Jlcwkdjh

Djuk}jb B}m(" jt D`bbj}cwjb Jich} !d`bbcd}kvcb{" }ac 'Mcfchmjh}t'+ }` mc}cwlkhc }ac vjbkmk}{"

uwk`wk}{" `w cq}ch} `f bkcht `w `}acw kh}cwct} kh uw ucw}{ jhm f`w mcdbjwj}`w{ osmilch} jt f`bb`yt?

: ]ac Mcg}`wt !yk}a }ac bjt} f`sw mkik}t `f cjda Mcg}`wt fcmcwjb }jq kmch}kfkdj}k`h hslgcw jhm daju}cw ::djtc hslgcw+" jwc? Daswda T}wcc} Acjb}a Ljhjiclch}" BBD !7443> Djtc H`( :7,5:394+" Tljbb Tlkbct A`bmkhiD`lujh{" BBD !=;;4> Djtc H`( :7,5:39=+" F@WGJ H[" BBD !15:4> Djtc H`( :7,5:393+" F@WGJ Tcwvkdct" Khd(!6356> Djtc H`( :7,5:399+" CCAD" Khd( !=;94> Djtc H`( :7,5:396+(

Djtc 4?:7,gn,5:394 M`d 7;; Fkbcm 5=/79/:7 Ch}cwcm 5=/79/:7 :9?45?44 Mctd LjkhM`dslch} Ujic : `f ;

8/2/2019 Complaint by Unsecured Creditors to Determine Validity of Property and Liens-Doc 299

2/9

7H DAI 116946 v77;771:4,5555:: 5=/79/75:7

Oswktmkd}k`h" Vchsc" jhm Ujw}kct

:( Ubjkh}kff gwkhit }akt jd}k`h uswtsjh} }` Fcm( W( Gjhnw( U( 955:!7+ jhm !;+(7( ]ac D`sw} ajt oswktmkd}k`h `vcw }ac tsgocd} lj}}cw `f }akt D`lubjkh} uswtsjh} }`

71 S(T(D( :39!g+ jhm :44=!g+( ]akt jd}k`h kt j d`wc uw`dccmkhi uswtsjh} }` 71 S(T(D(

:39!g+!7+!J+" !N+" jhm !@+(

4( Vchsc `f }akt jd}k`h kt uw`ucw kh }akt mkt}wkd} uswtsjh} }` 71 S(T(D( :=5;(=( @h Fcgwsjw{ 75" 75:7 !}ac Uc}k}k`h Mj}c+ }ac Mcg}`wt fkbcm v`bsh}jw{ uc}k}k`ht

f`w wcbkcf shmcw daju}cw :: `f }k}bc :: `f }ac Shk}cm T}j}c D`mc" :: S(T(D( :5: c} tcz( !}ac

Gjhnwsu}d{ D`mc+( ^M`dnc} Ch}w{ H`( :\( ]ac Mcg}`wt jwc `ucwj}khi }ackw gstkhcttct jhm

ljhjikhi }ackw uw`ucw}kct jt mcg}`wt,kh,u`ttcttk`h uswtsjh} }` tcd}k`ht ::59 jhm ::51 `f }ac

Gjhnwsu}d{ D`mc( H` }wst}cc `w cqjlkhcw ajt gcch juu`kh}cm kh }actc djtct(

3( @h Fcgwsjw{ 77" 75:7" }ac D`sw} `wmcwcm }aj} }ac Mcg}`wt) djtct gc uw`dcmswjbb{d`ht`bkmj}cm jhm o`kh}b{ jmlkhkt}cwcm( ^M`dnc} Ch}w{ H`( 3=\(

6( ]ac Shk}cm T}j}ct ]wst}cc fkbcm }ac Juu`kh}lch} jhm H`}kdc `f Juu`kh}lch} `fShtcdswcm Dwcmk}`wt D`llk}}cc `h Ljwda :" 75:7( ^M`dnc} Ch}w{ H`( ;=\( ]ac D`llk}}cc ajt

d`llchdcm k}t y`wn jhm ujw}kdkuj}cm kh }ac djtc tkhdc f`wlj}k`h(

9( ]ac Mcfchmjh}t jwc jt f`bb`yt?j( TT@ Fshmkhi D`wu( kt j tucdkjb uswu`tc ch}k}{ jd}khi jt j d`hmsk} f`w }ac

uw`vktk`h `f fkhjhdkhi gc}ycch Mcg}`wt jhm }ac ch}k}kct uw`vkmkhi fkhjhdkhi }` }ac Mcg}`wt jhm

lj{ gc tcwvcm kh djwc `f Ib`gjb Tcdswk}kj}k`h Tcwvkdct" BBD" 61 T`s}a Tcwvkdc W`jm" Tsk}c :75"

Lcbvkbbc" Hcy [`wn" ::9=9(

g( TTA Fshmkhi D`wu( kt j tucdkjb uswu`tc ch}k}{ jd}khi jt j d`hmsk} f`w }acuw`vktk`h `f fkhjhdkhi gc}ycch Mcg}`wt jhm }ac ch}k}kct uw`vkmkhi fkhjhdkhi }` }ac Mcg}`wt jhm

Djtc 4?:7,gn,5:394 M`d 7;; Fkbcm 5=/79/:7 Ch}cwcm 5=/79/:7 :9?45?44 Mctd LjkhM`dslch} Ujic 7 `f ;

8/2/2019 Complaint by Unsecured Creditors to Determine Validity of Property and Liens-Doc 299

3/9

4H DAI 116946 v77;771:4,5555:: 5=/79/75:7

lj{ gc tcwvcm kh djwc `f Ib`gjb Tcdswk}kj}k`h Tcwvkdct" BBD" 61 T`s}a Tcwvkdc W`jm" Tsk}c :75"

Lcbvkbbc" Hcy [`wn" ::9=9(

d( DK] Acjb}adjwc BBD" kt }ac D`bbj}cwjb Jich} jhm Jmlkhkt}wj}kvc Jich} f`w}ac Uwcuc}k}k`h Fkwt} Bkch Fjdkbk}{ Bchmcwt jhm }ac Uwcuc}k}k`h Tcd`hm Bkch Fjdkbk}{ Bchmcwt(7

DK] Acjb}adjwc" BBD" lj{ gc tcwvcm j} :: Yct} =7hm T}wcc}" Fb``w 9" Hcy [`wn" Hcy [`wn"

:5546(

m( Jlcwkdjh Djuk}jb B}m( kt }ac D`bbj}cwjb Jich} shmcw }ac Tsg`wmkhj}cmLswjgjaj Fjdkbk}{ Jiwcclch} jhm lj{gc tcwvcm j} 353 Fkf}a Jvchsc" 76 }a Fb``w" Hcy [`wn"

Hcy [`wn" :55:9(

1( ]ac Mcfchmjh}t kmch}kfkcm jg`vc jwc }ac uwcuc}k}k`h tcdswcm bchmcwt `f }acMcg}`wt jt kmch}kfkcm g{ }ac Mcg}`wt `h }ackw T}j}clch}t jhm Tdacmsbct( ^Tcc Tdacmsbc M" M`dnc}

Ch}w{ H`( 7:4\(

Gjdniw`shm

;( ]ac Mcg}`w" Tljbb Tlkbct A`bmkhi D`lujh{" BBD !'TTAD'+" f`wlcm khMcbjyjwc kh Tcu}clgcw 7556" kt }ac ujwch} `f j iw`su `f d`lujhkct acjmzsjw}cwcm kh Hjtavkbbc"

]chhcttcc" }aj} uw`vkmc mch}jb uwjd}kdc ljhjiclch} tcwvkdct }` 69 mch}jb dch}cwt tcwvkhi b`y

khd`lc jhm shmcwuwkvkbcicm fjlkbkct kh 77 t}j}ct jdw`tt }ac d`sh}w{ !d`bbcd}kvcb{" TTAD jhm k}t

jffkbkj}ct" }ac 'D`lujh{" }ac 'Mcg}`w"' `w }ac 'Mcg}`wt'+( Jdd`wmkhi }` }ac Mcg}`wt" }ac mch}jb

dch}cwt jwc `yhcm g{ bkdchtcm mch}kt}t(

:5( @h Ljwda 7" 75:7" }ac Mcg}`wt fkbcm jh Cqucmk}cm L`}k`h }` Tcbb Tsgt}jh}kjbb{ jbbJttc}t `f }ac Mcg}`wt !}ac 'Tjbc L`}k`h'+( ^M`dnc} Ch}w{ H`( :56\(

7 Cqdcu} jt `}acwyktc tc} f`w}a acwckh" djuk}jbkcm }cwlt stcm acwckh" gs} h`} mcfkhcm acwckh" tajbb ajvc }aclcjhkhit jtdwkgcm }` }acl kh }ac Jffkmjvk} `f Ljw}kh LdIjajh ^M`dnc} H`( ::\(

Djtc 4?:7,gn,5:394 M`d 7;; Fkbcm 5=/79/:7 Ch}cwcm 5=/79/:7 :9?45?44 Mctd LjkhM`dslch} Ujic 4 `f ;

8/2/2019 Complaint by Unsecured Creditors to Determine Validity of Property and Liens-Doc 299

4/9

=H DAI 116946 v77;771:4,5555:: 5=/79/75:7

::( @h Fcgwsjw{ 7:" 75:7" }ac Mcg}`wt fkbcm }ac Cqucmk}cm L`}k`h `f }ac Mcg}`wt f`wCh}w{ `f Kh}cwkl jhm Fkhjb @wmcwt @wmcw !K+ Js}a`wkkhi }ac Mcg}`wt }` !J+ @g}jkh U`t}uc}k}k`h

Tcdswcm Fkhjhdkhi jhm !G+ S}kbkc Djta D`bbj}cwjb" !KK+ Iwjh}khi Bkcht jhm Tsucwuwk`wk}{

Jmlkhkt}wj}kvc Cquchtc T}j}st" !KKK+ Iwjh}khi Jmczsj}c Uw`}cd}k`h" !KV+ L`mkf{khi }ac

Js}`lj}kd T}j{" jhm !V+ Tdacmsbkhi j Fkhjb Acjwkhi !}ac 'MKU L`}k`h'+ tccnkhi ch}w{ `f }ac

Fkhjb @wmcw( ^M`dnc} Ch}w{ H`( 75\(

:7( Su`h }ac fkbkhi `f }ac MKU L`}k`h jhm khk}kjb acjwkhi" }ac D`sw} ch}cwcm }acKh}cwkl @wmcw !K+ Js}a`wkkhi }ac Mcg}`wt }` !J+ @g}jkh U`t}uc}k}k`h Tcdswcm Fkhjhdkhi jhm

!G+ S}kbkc Djta D`bbj}cwjb" !KK+ Iwjh}khi Bkcht jhm Tsucwuwk`wk}{ Jmlkhkt}wj}kvc Cquchtc T}j}st"

!KKK+ Iwjh}khi Jmczsj}c Uw`}cd}k`h" !KV+ L`mkf{khi }ac Js}`lj}kd T}j{" jhm !V+ Tdacmsbkhi j

Fkhjb Acjwkhi !}ac 'Kh}cwkl @wmcw'+ `h Fcgwsjw{ 77" 75:7( ^M`dnc} Ch}w{ H`( 65\(

:4( @h Fcgwsjw{ 7=" 75:7" }ac D`sw} ch}cwcm j 'd`wwcd}cm' Kh}cwkl @wmcw( ^M`dnc}Ch}w{ H`( 95\(

:=( @h Fcgwsjw{ 7:" 75:7" }ac Mcg}`wt t`sia} juuw`vjb `f }ac Uw`u`tcm Fkhjb @wmcw!K+ Js}a`wkkhi }ac Mcg}`wt }` !J+ @g}jkh U`t}uc}k}k`h Tcdswcm Fkhjhdkhi jhm !G+ S}kbkc Djta

D`bbj}cwjb" !KK+ Iwjh}khi Bkcht jhm Tsucwuwk`wk}{ Jmlkhkt}wj}kvc Cquchtc T}j}st" !KKK+ Iwjh}khi

Jmczsj}c Uw`}cd}k`h" !KV+ L`mkf{khi }ac Js}`lj}kd T}j{" jhm !V+ Tdacmsbkhi j Fkhjb Acjwkhi

mj}cm Fcgwsjw{ 7:" 75:7 !}ac Fkhjb MKU @wmcw+(^M`dnc} Ch}w{ H`( 1=\(

:3( @h Ljwda :6" 75:7" }ac Fkhjb MKU @wmcw" jt l`mkfkcm" yjt ch}cwcm g{ }ac D`sw}(^M`dnc} Ch}w{ H`( :19\(

:6( Shmcw }ac }cwlt `f }ac Fkhjb MKU @wmcw" }ac D`llk}}cc yjt iwjh}cm j }klc ucwk`mkh yakda }` wcvkcy jhm `gocd} }` `w dajbbchic }ac vjbkmk}{" cq}ch}" ucwfcd}k`h `w uwk`wk}{ `f }ac

tcdswk}{ kh}cwct}t jhm bkcht `f }ac Mcg}`wt) uwcuc}k}k`h tcdswcm bchmcwt kh jhm }` }ac uwcuc}k}k`h

Djtc 4?:7,gn,5:394 M`d 7;; Fkbcm 5=/79/:7 Ch}cwcm 5=/79/:7 :9?45?44 Mctd LjkhM`dslch} Ujic = `f ;

8/2/2019 Complaint by Unsecured Creditors to Determine Validity of Property and Liens-Doc 299

5/9

3H DAI 116946 v77;771:4,5555:: 5=/79/75:7

d`bbj}cwjb `f }ac Mcg}`wt" `w }ac vjbkmk}{" jbb`yjgkbk}{" uwk`wk}{" t}j}st `w jl`sh} `f }ac uwcuc}k}k`h

tcdswcm `gbkij}k`ht !tsda `gocd}k`h `w dajbbchic" j 'Dajbbchic' jhm }ac }klc ucwk`m f`w jh{ tsda

Dajbbchic gckhi }ac 'Dajbbchic Ucwk`m'+( ^Fkhjb MKU @wmcw" 9\(

:9( Uswtsjh} }` }ac }cwlt `f }ac T}kusbj}k`h" Jiwcclch}" jhm @wmcw WcijwmkhiCqucmk}cm L`}k`h `f }ac @ffkdkjb D`llk}}cc `f Shtcdswcm Dwcmk}`wt }` Ch}cw @wmcw L`mkf{khi

Fkhjb MKU @wmcw" }ac D`llk}}cc yjt uw`vkmcm jmmk}k`hjb }klc cq}chmkhi }ac cqukwj}k`h `f }ac

Dajbbchic Ucwk`m sh}kb jhm }aw`sia Juwkb 79" 75:7( ]akt D`lubjkh} ajt }acwcf`wc gcch }klcb{

fkbcm(

J( Mctdwku}k`h `f Uswu`w}cm Tcdswk}{ Kh}cwct}t jhm Bkcht g{ Uwcuc}k}k`hBchmcwt

:1( ]ac wcbcvjh} b`jh }wjhtjd}k`ht jhm jtt`dkj}cm uswu`w}cm tcdswk}{ kh}cwct}t jwcmctdwkgcm kh }ac Fkhjb MKU @wmcw( Uswtsjh} }` jh Jlchmcm jhm Wct}j}cm Dwcmk} Jiwcclch} mj}cm

Fcgwsjw{ :" 75:5 !}ac 'Uwcuc}k}k`h Fkwt} Bkch Jiwcclch}'+ jhm }`ic}acw ykbb jbb `}acw b`jh jhm

tcdswk}{ m`dslch}t cqcds}cm kh d`hhcd}k`h }acwcyk}a !}ac 'Uwcuc}k}k`h Fkwt} Bkch M`dslch}t'+

jl`hi TT@ Fshmkhi D`wu( !'TT@'+ jhm dcw}jkh `f }ac uwcuc}k}k`h tcdswcm bchmcwt !}ac

'Uwcuc}k}k`h Fkwt} Bkch Bchmcwt'+ jhm DK] Acjb}adjwc BBD" jt d`bbj}cwjb jich} jhm jmlkhkt}wj}kvc

jich} !}ac 'Uwcuc}k}k`h Jich}'+" }ac Uwcuc}k}k`h Fkwt} Bkch Bchmcwt uw`vkmcm Mcg}`wt yk}a j fkwt}

bkch tcdswcm dwcmk} fjdkbk}{ d`luwktcm `f su }` -:4:"=93"555 kh jiiwcij}c uwkhdkujb jl`sh} `f

}cwl b`jht !}ac 'Uwcuc}k}k`h Fkwt} Bkch Fjdkbk}{'+( ^Tcc Fkhjb MKU @wmcw" F!k+" u( 6\(

:;( Uswtsjh} }` j Tcd`hm Bkch Dwcmk} Jiwcclch} mj}cm Fcgwsjw{ :" 75:7 !}ac'Uwcuc}k}k`h Tcd`hm Bkch Jiwcclch}' jhm }`ic}acw yk}a jbb `}acw b`jh jhm tcdswk}{ m`dslch}t

cqcds}cm kh d`hhcd}k`h }acwcyk}a" }ac 'Uwcuc}k}k`h Tcd`hm Bkch M`dslch}t' jhm" }`ic}acw yk}a

}ac Uwcuc}k}k`h Fkwt} Bkch M`dslch}t" d`bbcd}kvcb{ }ac 'Uwcuc}k}k`h Dwcmk} M`dslch}t'+ jl`hi

TT@ jt g`ww`ycw" dcw}jkh `f }ac uwcuc}k}k`h tcdswcm bchmcwt !}ac 'Uwcuc}k}k`h Tcd`hm Bkch

Djtc 4?:7,gn,5:394 M`d 7;; Fkbcm 5=/79/:7 Ch}cwcm 5=/79/:7 :9?45?44 Mctd LjkhM`dslch} Ujic 3 `f ;

8/2/2019 Complaint by Unsecured Creditors to Determine Validity of Property and Liens-Doc 299

6/9

6H DAI 116946 v77;771:4,5555:: 5=/79/75:7

Bchmcwt' jhm }`ic}acw yk}a }ac Uwcuc}k}k`h Fkwt} Bkch Bchmcwt d`bbcd}kvcb{ }ac 'Uwcuc}k}k`h

Bchmcwt'+ jhm }ac Uwcuc}k}k`h Jich}" }ac Uwcuc}k}k`h Tcd`hm Bkch Bchmcwt uw`vkmcm j tcd`hm bkch

tcdswcm dwcmk} fjdkbk}{ d`luwktcm `f su }` -73"555"555 kh jiiwcij}c uwkhdkujb jl`sh} `f }cwl

b`jht !}ac 'Uwcuc}k}k`h Tcd`hm Bkch Fjdkbk}{'+( ^Tcc Fkhjb MKU @wmcw" F!kkk+" u( 9\(

75( ]ac Uwcuc}k}k`h Bchmcwt jttcw} }aj} shmcw }ac }cwlt `f }ac Uwcuc}k}k`h Dwcmk}M`dslch}t" }ac Mcg}`wt iwjh}cm tcdswk}{ kh}cwct}t kh !}ac 'Uwcuc}k}k`h Tcdswcm @gbkij}k`ht'+ jhm

bkcht `h !}ac 'Uwcuc}k}k`h Bkcht'+ tsgt}jh}kjbb{ jbb jttc}t `f }ac Mcg}`wt !}ac 'Uwcuc}k}k`h

D`bbj}cwjb'+ }` }ac Uwcuc}k}k`h Jich} jt d`bbj}cwjb jich} shmcw }ac Uwcuc}k}k`h Dwcmk} M`dslch}t(

^Fkhjb MKU @wmcw" F!vkk+" u( 1\(

7:( ]ac Uwcuc}k}k`h Bchmcwt jttcw} }aj} }ac Uwcuc}k}k`h Tcdswcm @gbkij}k`ht jwc!k+ bcijb" vjbkm" gkhmkhi jhm chf`wdcjgbc jijkht} cjda juubkdjgbc Mcg}`w jhm !kk+ h`} tsgocd} }` jh{

d`h}ct}" j}}jdn" `gocd}k`h" wcd`sulch}" mcfchtc" d`sh}cwdbjkl" `fftc}" tsg`wmkhj}k`h"

wcdajwjd}cwkj}k`h" jv`kmjhdc `w `}acw dbjkl" djstc `f jd}k`h `w `}acw dajbbchic `f jh{ hj}swc(

^Fkhjb MKU @wmcw" F!kq+" u( ;\(

77( ]ac Uwcuc}k}k`h Bchmcwt fsw}acw jttcw} }aj} }ac Uwcuc}k}k`h Bkcht `h }ac Uwcuc}k}k`hD`bbj}cwjb jwc bcijb" vjbkm jhm chf`wdcjgbc( ^Fkhjb MKU @wmcw" F!q+" u( ;\(

74( ]ac Fkhjb MKU @wmcw uw`vkmct }aj} }ac D`llk}}cc" jt }ac D`sw},juu`kh}cmwcuwctch}j}kvct `f }ac shtcdswcm dwcmk}`wt `f }ac Mcg}`wt" lj{ `gocd} `w dajbbchic }ac vjwk`st

jttcw}k`ht/fkhmkhit d`h}jkhcm kh }ac Fkhjb MKU @wmcw jhm }ac Mcg}`wt) t}kusbj}k`ht wcijwmkhi"

!k+ }ac vjbkmk}{" cq}ch}" ucwfcd}k`h `w uwk`wk}{ `f }ac l`w}ijic" tcdswk}{ kh}cwct}t jhm bkcht `f }ac

Uwcuc}k}k`h Bchmcwt kh jhm }` }ac Uwcuc}k}k`h D`bbj}cwjb `f }ac Mcg}`wt" `w !kk+ }ac vjbkmk}{"

jbb`yjgkbk}{" uwk`wk}{" t}j}st `w jl`sh} `f }ac uwcuc}k}k`h `gbkij}k`ht jttcw}cm g{ }ac Uwcuc}k}k`h

Bchmcwt ( ^Fkhjb MKU @wmcw" 9\(

Djtc 4?:7,gn,5:394 M`d 7;; Fkbcm 5=/79/:7 Ch}cwcm 5=/79/:7 :9?45?44 Mctd LjkhM`dslch} Ujic 6 `f ;

8/2/2019 Complaint by Unsecured Creditors to Determine Validity of Property and Liens-Doc 299

7/9

9H DAI 116946 v77;771:4,5555:: 5=/79/75:7

G( ]ac M&@ U`bkdkct jhm D`llcwdkjb ]`w} Dbjklt

7=( Uwk`w }` }ac Uc}k}k`h Mj}c" }ac Mcg}`wt uswdajtcm jhm `g}jkhcm d`vcwjic shmcwdcw}jkh Mkwcd}`wt jhm @ffkdcw)t Bkjgkbk}{ Khtswjhdc U`bkdkct" khdbsmkhi gs} h`} bklk}cm }` u`bkd{

hslgcw I73559775 557 !}ac 'M&@ U`bkdkct'+(

73( ]ac Mcg}`wt jhm/`w `}acwt `h gcajbf `f }ac Mcg}`wt ajvc `w lj{ ajvc dbjkltjijkht} ujw}kct f`w ya`l d`vcwjic kt uw`vkmcm shmcw }ac M&@ U`bkdkct !}ac 'M&@ Dbjklt'+( Jbb

`w t`lc `f }ac M&@ Dbjklt d`ht}k}s}c d`llcwdkjb }`w} dbjklt(

76( Fsw}acw" jhm khmcuchmch} `f }ac M&@ Dbjklt" }ac Mcg}`wt jhm/`w `}acwt `h gcajbf`f }ac Mcg}`wt ajvc `w lj{ ajvc khmcuchmch} dbjklt jijkht} `}acw }akwm ujw}kct }aj} jw`tc uwk`w }`

}ac Uc}k}k`h Mj}c" jhm }aj} d`ht}k}s}c d`llcwdkjb }`w} dbjklt !}ac 'D`llcwdkjb ]`w} Dbjklt'+(

79( Yk}a }ac cqdcu}k`h `f dcw}jkh dbjklt jhm djstct `f jd}k`h mctdwkgcm tucdkfkdjbb{ kh}ac tdacmsbct }` }ac Uwcuc}k}k`h Dwcmk} M`dslch}t" }ac tcdswk}{ kh}cwct}t jhm bkcht jttcw}cm g{ }ac

Uwcuc}k}k`h Bchmcwt m` h`} cq}chm }` jhm jwc h`} ucwfcd}cm kh }ac M&@ U`bkdkct" }ac M&@

Dbjklt" }ac D`llcwdkjb ]`w} Dbjklt" jhm jh{ uw`dccmt }acwc`f(

D@SH] @HC

!Mc}cwlkhj}k`h `f Vjbkmk}{" Uwk`wk}{ jhm Cq}ch} `f Bkch+

71( ]ac D`llk}}cc khd`wu`wj}ct g{ wcfcwchdc }ac jbbcij}k`ht `f ujwjiwjuat : }aw`sia79 tc} f`w}a jg`vc jt kf fsbb{ tc} f`w}a acwckh(

7;( Uswtsjh} }` Fcm( W( Gjhnw( U( 955:!7+" }akt D`sw} ajt }ac u`ycw }` mc}cwlkhc }acvjbkmk}{" uwk`wk}{" jhm cq}ch} `f bkcht kh }ac Mcg}`wt) uw`ucw}{(

45( ]ac Uwcuc}k}k`h Bchmcwt m` h`} a`bm j vjbkm" ucwfcd}cm bkch jijkht} }ac M&@U`bkdkct" }ac M&@ Dbjklt" jhm }ac D`llcwdkjb ]`w} Dbjklt" khdbsmkhi }ac uw`dccmt }acwc`f(

4:( ]ac D`llk}}cc kt ch}k}bcm }` j mc}cwlkhj}k`h uswtsjh} }` Fcm( W( Gjhnw( U(955:!7+ jt }` }ac vjbkmk}{" uwk`wk}{" jhm cq}ch} `f jh{ bkch kh }ac M&@ U`bkdkct" }ac M&@ Dbjklt"

Djtc 4?:7,gn,5:394 M`d 7;; Fkbcm 5=/79/:7 Ch}cwcm 5=/79/:7 :9?45?44 Mctd LjkhM`dslch} Ujic 9 `f ;

8/2/2019 Complaint by Unsecured Creditors to Determine Validity of Property and Liens-Doc 299

8/9

1H DAI 116946 v77;771:4,5555:: 5=/79/75:7

jhm }ac D`llcwdkjb ]`w} Dbjklt" jhm j tucdkfkd fkhmkhi }aj} }ac Uwcuc}k}k`h Bchmcwt m` h`} ajvc

j vjbkm bkch kh tsda uw`ucw}{ khdbsmkhi }ac uw`dccmt }acwc`f(

D@SH] ]Y@

!Mcdbjwj}`w{ Osmilch}+

47( ]ac D`llk}}cc khd`wu`wj}ct g{ wcfcwchdc }ac jbbcij}k`ht `f ujwjiwjuat : }aw`sia4: tc} f`w}a jg`vc jt kf fsbb{ tc} f`w}a acwckh(

44( Uswtsjh} }` Fcm( W( Gjhnw( U( 955:!;+" }akt D`sw} ajt }ac u`ycw }` mcdbjwc }acwkia}t" t}j}st" jhm `}acw bcijb wcbj}k`ht jhm uwk`wk}{ kh }ac Mcg}`wt) uw`ucw}{(

4=( ]acwc kt jh cqkt}khi mktus}c gc}ycch jhm jl`hi }ac Uwcuc}k}k`h Bchmcwt jhm }acD`llk}}cc wcijwmkhi? !J+ }ac cq}ch}" kf jh{" `f }ac Uwcuc}k}k`h Bchmcwt) bkcht jijkht} }ac M&@

U`bkdkct" }ac M&@ Dbjklt" }ac D`llcwdkjb ]`w} Dbjklt jhm }ac uw`dccmt }acwc`f" jhm !G+ }ac

uwk`wk}{ `f jh{ tsda }ac bkcht(

43( ]ac D`llk}}cc kt ch}k}bcm }` mcdbjwj}`w{ wcbkcf uswtsjh} }` Fcm( W( Gjhnw( U(955:!;+ mcdbjwkhi jhm wct`bvkhi }ac cq}ch}" vjbkmk}{" jhm uwk`wk}{ `f }ac ujw}kct) wkia}t kh }ac M&@

U`bkdkct" }ac M&@ Dbjklt" jhm }ac D`llcwdkjb ]`w} Dbjklt" khdbsmkhi }ac uw`dccmt }acwc`f" jhm

j mcdbjwj}k`h }aj} }ac Uwcuc}k}k`h Bchmcwt m` h`} ajvc j bkch `h }ac M&@ U`bkdkct" }ac M&@

Dbjklt" jhm/`w }ac D`llcwdkjb ]`w} Dbjklt" khdbsmkhi }ac uw`dccmt }acwc`f(

Djtc 4?:7,gn,5:394 M`d 7;; Fkbcm 5=/79/:7 Ch}cwcm 5=/79/:7 :9?45?44 Mctd LjkhM`dslch} Ujic 1 `f ;

8/2/2019 Complaint by Unsecured Creditors to Determine Validity of Property and Liens-Doc 299

9/9

;H DAI 116946 v77;771:4,5555:: 5=/79/75:7

YACWCF@WC" }ac D`llk}}cc wctucd}fsbb{ wczsct}t }aj} }akt D`sw} `wmcw jhm ch}cw j

osmilch}? !J+ mc}cwlkhkhi }ac vjbkmk}{" uwk`wk}{" jhm cq}ch} `f jh{ bkch kh }ac M&@ U`bkdkct" }ac

M&@ Dbjklt" jhm }ac D`llcwdkjb ]`w} Dbjklt" jhm ljnc j tucdkfkd fkhmkhi }aj} }ac Uwcuc}k}k`h

Bchmcwt m` h`} ajvc j vjbkm bkch kh tsda u`bkdkct" khdbsmkhi }ac uw`dccmt }acwc`f jhm

!G+ mcdbjwkhi jhm wct`bvkhi }ac cq}ch}" vjbkmk}{" jhm uwk`wk}{ `f }ac ujw}kct) wkia}t kh }ac M&@

U`bkdkct" }ac M&@ Dbjklt" jhm }ac D`llcwdkjb ]`w} Dbjklt" khdbsmkhi }ac uw`dccmt }acwc`f" jhm

kttskhi j mcdbjwj}`w{ osmilch} }aj} }ac Uwcuc}k}k`h Bchmcwt m` h`} ajvc j bkch `h }ac M&@

U`bkdkct" }ac M&@ Dbjklt" jhm/`w }ac D`llcwdkjb ]`w} Dbjklt" khdbsmkhi }ac uw`dccmt }acwc`f(

Wctucd}fsbb{ tsglk}}cm"

/t/O`ah A( W`ybjhmO`ah A( W`ybjhm !GUW H`( 5:4;==+D`sw}hc{ A( Ikblcw !GUW H`( 577:4:+GJNCW" M@HCBT@H" GCJWLJH"DJBMYCBB & GCWN@YK]_" U(D(7:: D`llcwdc T}wcc}" Tsk}c 155

Hjtavkbbc" ]chhcttcc 4975:]cbcua`hc? !6:3+ 976,33==Fjdtklkbc ? !6:3+ 9==,33==Cljkb f`w CDF uswu`tct?gstkhcttgnhjtaEgjncwm`hcbt`h(d`l

C( Fwjhnbkh Dakbmwctt" Ow( !GUW H`( 5595=5+GJNCW" M@HCBT@H" GCJWLJH"DJBMYCBB & GCWN@YK]_" U(D(:63 Ljmkt`h Jvchsc" Tsk}c 7555Lcluakt" ]chhcttcc 41:54

]cbcua`hc? !;5:+ 399,7:=9Fjdtklkbc? !;5:+ 399,7454Cljkb? fdakbmwcttEgjncwm`hcbt`h(d`l

D`shtcb f`w }ac @ffkdkjb Shtcdswcm

Dwcmk}`wt D`llk}}cc

Djtc 4?:7,gn,5:394 M`d 7;; Fkbcm 5=/79/:7 Ch}cwcm 5=/79/:7 :9?45?44 Mctd LjkhM`d lch} Ujic ; `f ;