View
223
Download
1
Category
Tags:
Preview:
Citation preview
Biostatistics coursePart 14
Analysis of binary paired data
Dr. Sc. Nicolas Padilla RaygozaDepartment of Nursing and Obstetrics
Division Health Sciences and EngineeringUniversity of Guanajuato
Campus Celaya-Salvatierra
Biosketch
Medical Doctor by University Autonomous of Guadalajara. Pediatrician by the Mexican Council of Certification on
Pediatrics. Postgraduate Diploma on Epidemiology, London School of
Hygiene and Tropical Medicine, University of London. Master Sciences with aim in Epidemiology, Atlantic International
University. Doctorate Sciences with aim in Epidemiology, Atlantic
International University. Associated Professor B, School of Nursing and Obstetrics of
Celaya, university of Guanajuato. padillawarm@gmail.com
Competencies
The reader will know how show paired binary data.
He (she) will apply hypothesis test for paired binary data – McNemar’s Chi-squared.
He (she) will calculate confidence interval for paired binary data.
He (she) will obtain Odds Ratio and confidence interval for cases-controls paired studies.
Introduction
In Parts 12 and 13 of the biostatistics course, we knew, the methods for comparing two proportions estimated from independent samples.
If the observations in a study are not independent, we need to use different methods.
Often we use two types of studies that give rise to observations that are not independent: Repeated observations in the same individual Matched case-control studies
Example
Tuberculosis can be diagnosed to use a culture media and looking if Mycobacterium tuberculosis is growing.
In a experiment to compare two culture medias for the tuberculosis diagnosis, samples of expectoration from 100 patients were planted in the two medias.
The half of the sample was planted in media A and another half of sample, planted in media B.
Example
In a study, to examine the relation between breast cancer and oral contraceptives, women with a breast cancer were matched with women without breast cancer, selected from electoral registries.
This is an example of cases-controls study, where each individual with breast cancer is matched with an individual with similar age, for control the potential effect counding, of age.
Showing categorical paired data
To use Z test or Chi squared test with paired data is a mistake, because we do not take into account the paired nature of data.
Patient Culture A
Culture B
1 - -
2 - -
3 + +
4 + -
5 + +
6 - -
7 - +
8 - -
9 - -
10 - -
11 + -
12 + +
13 + -
14 + +
15 + -
Patient Culture A
Culture B
16 + +
17 + +
18 - -
19 - -
20 + -
21 - -
22 + +
23 + +
24 + +
25 + -
26 - -
27 + +
28 - -
29 + +
30 + +
Patient Culture A
Culture B
31 - -
32 + +
33 + +
34 + -
35 - -
36 + +
37 + +
38 + -
39 + +
40 + -
41 + -
42 + +
43 - -
44 + +
45 + -
Patient Culture A
Culture B
46 + +
47 - -
48 + -
49 - -
50 - +
Showing categorical paired data
Patient Culture A
Culture B
51 - -
52 - -
53 + +
54 + -
55 + +
56 - -
57 - +
58 - -
59 - -
60 - -
61 + -
62 + +
63 + -
64 + +
65 + -
Patient Culture A
Culture B
66 + +
67 + +
68 - -
69 - -
70 + -
71 - -
72 + +
73 + +
74 + +
75 + -
76 - -
77 + +
78 - -
79 + +
80 + +
Patient CultureA
Culture B
81 - -
82 + +
83 + +
84 + -
85 - -
86 + +
87 + +
88 + -
89 + +
90 + -
91 + -
92 + +
93 - -
94 + +
95 + -
Patient Culture A
Culture B
96 + +
97 - -
98 + -
99 - -
100 - +
Showing categorical paired data
The experiment compared the capacity of culture media to detect Mycobacterium tuberculosis.
The results were positive (+) or negative (-). We have interest in to compare the samples positives of both culture
media. The table summarize the results
Culture media
+ - Total
A 64 36 100
B 44 56 100
Showing categorical paired data
From this, do you think that media A is better that media B to detect the tuberculosis bacilli?
To make an adequate analysis, we need to compare the results with both media in each subject.
There are four combinations of results that can occur in each subject:
Combination Media A Media B Pairs
1 + + k
2 + - r
3 - + s
4 - - m
Showing categorical paired data
To compare the results of each subject, we need count how many times occur each combination.
AN easy form to show the calues is tabulate the results from a sample against another sample.
Media B+
B-
A + k r k + r
A - s m s + m
k + s r + m N
Showing categorical paired data
The pairs with same result are pairs with agreement, and they do not give any information on what media is better to detect bacilli.
Of the remaining results were different between the two media: 24 were positive for the A and negative for B. 4 were negative for A and positive for the B.
The pairs whose results were different between both media, are called discordant pairs.
Media B+
B-
A + 40 24 64
A - 4 32 36
44 56 100
Hypothesis test for binary paired data If there were no difference between the medias, we should expect
similar numbers r and s, r ≈ s We can use a call McNemar test to assess whether the difference
between the numbers of discordant pairs is greater than what you would expect by chance.
To test the null hypothesis that there is no difference between the two proportions, we used the McNemar test:
(|r-s|-1)2
X2paired= -----------------
r + s
Subtracting 1 gives us a continuous correction.
Hypothesis test for binary paired data In the study of two culture media for tuberculosis bacilli:
24 were positives in media A and negatives in media B 4 were negatives in media A and positives in media B
(|r-s|-1)2 (|24-4|-1)2 361
X2paired=---------------= --------------- = -------- = 12.81 p<0.05
r + s 24 + 4 28
Rejected the null hypothesis of non-difference between media.
Confidence intervals for the difference of two paired proportions We know thta the difference between proportions of paired data can be
calculate by: r – s / N
Where: r and s are the number of discordant pairs N is the total number of pairs Standard error from the difference between paired proportions is:
√r +s
SE(p1-p2) = -----------
N
Confidence intervals from difference of two paired proportions General formula to calculate 95% confidence interval is:
Estimate ± 1.96 x SE
From the table of results of cultures from expectoration, with medias, A and B, we are using r and s values, and can calculate 95% confidence interval for paired proportions:
r-s / N ± √r +s/N = 24-4/100±1.96 √24+4/100 = 0.2±0.10 = 0.1 a 0.3 = 10% a 30%-
Confidence intervals from 0.1 to 0.3 mean that the percentage of positive cultures for the bacilli could be between 10% and 30% higher in media A than media B, in the population.
Odds Ratio for paired data
In case-control studies, usually, we want to evaluate the risk with the exposure at a risk factor; for these studies, we need an effect measure.
In case-control studies, we are using OR, that is a Ratio between odds of the exposure in the cases divided by odds of the exposure in controls.
Calculate of OR with matched data, is based in discordant pairs, the same that the difference between proportions od paired data.
Odds Ratios for paired data
Table of exposure in cases against exposure in controls
Controls
Cases Exposed Non-exposed
Exposed k r
Non-exposed s m
k = number of pairs where the case and control were exposed r = number of pairs where the case was exposed and the control was not
exposed s = number of pairs where the case was not exposed and the control was
exposed. m = number of pairs where cases and controls were not exposed.
Odds Ratio for paired data
Odds Ratio is calculate as the Ratio of two groups of discordant pairs.
r cases exposed controls not exposed
OR = ---- = -------------------------------------------------
s cases not exposed controls exposed
Odds Ratio for paired data
The table show the results of a matched case-control study, designed to investigate the association between the use of oral contraceptive (OCC) and thromboembolism.
Controls
Cases Use OCC Not use OCC
Use OCC 10 57
Not use OCC 13 95
Confidence intervals for paired OR
To calculate confidence intervals is a little more complicated.
It is calculate using square root of the value of McNemar X2 test, instead of standard error.
95% confidence intervals for OR from apired data is: OR1±1.96/ X
Odds Ratio for paired data
OR = 4.4 X²paired = 26.41
Xpaired = 5.14
Then, 95% confidence interval is: From 4.41-1.96/ 5.14 to 4.41+1.96/ 5.14 4.40.62 to 4.41.38 2.5 to 7.7
Bibliografía
1.- Last JM. A dictionary of epidemiology. New York, 4ª ed. Oxford University Press, 2001:173.
2.- Kirkwood BR. Essentials of medical ststistics. Oxford, Blackwell Science, 1988: 1-4.
3.- Altman DG. Practical statistics for medical research. Boca Ratón, Chapman & Hall/ CRC; 1991: 1-9.
Recommended