View
215
Download
0
Category
Preview:
Citation preview
8/10/2019 Bernartita Moses, A206 352 760 (BIA Dec. 9, 2014)
1/12
Emmanue G. Gueero Esquire
pn Ju
Executive Oce r mmigration Reew
Q
l
Law Oices of Emmanue G GuerreoLLC
SCE Office of Chief Counse ON595 Ala Moana ouevaonoulu I 9683999
8 South King See Suie 202onoluu 9613
ame MOSES ERNARTITA A 206-32760
Dae of his notce 12/9/214
nclosed i a copy of h Boar' decin n orer n te abo-rerene ae.
re
b
Sineel,
D cDon Cr
e rk
Dck
For more unpublished BIA decisions, visit www.irac.net/unpublished
Cite as: Bernartita Moses, A206 352 760 (BIA Dec. 9, 2014)
8/10/2019 Bernartita Moses, A206 352 760 (BIA Dec. 9, 2014)
2/12
MOSES, BERNARTITA038-1A06-35-760FDC HONOLULUPO BOX 30080HONOLUU H 9680
Name: MOSES BERNARTITA
n u
Execuive Oce Imigration Review
rd Immigrtn ApelsOce the lerk
HSCE Office of Chief Cunsel ON595 Aa oana oulevardHonuu, HI 96813999
A 06-35-760
Date of this notce: 1901
nlosed is a opy of the Board's ecison n e aboe-reened case. Ts opy is benprovded o you as a couresy You atoe o repesenaie as bee sered tsdeiso pusuant to CFR S I te aaced esion odes ha you eemoved om he United Saes or as a igaion Judges deison orden a youe reoved, any peon r evew o te aahe decision us be led wt and eevedy the appropate ou o appeas tin days o e ae o he deso
closue
bil Nl
inceey
D cDonna CmTe ek
s:
Cite as: Bernartita Moses, A206 352 760 (BIA Dec. 9, 2014)
8/10/2019 Bernartita Moses, A206 352 760 (BIA Dec. 9, 2014)
3/12
MOSES BERNARA02-22A206-52-60FDC HONOUU5 EOT SREETHONOUU, H 969
Name: MOSES, BERNARA
U n u
xectve Oce r gr evew
Bod of Io lO of h Ck
5 /07 Leesburg Pik. Sut 2000Fa Church Vrgna 20530
HSCE Offce of Chef Conse - HON595 Aa Moana BoevardHono H 96-999
A 206-52-60
Date of ths notce 2920
ced cpy the Brd decs he verereced ce cpy s begprvded t y curey r ttey r repreettve hs bee erved wh thdecs prt t CR 1(a). te ttced dec rder tht yu bereved the ted Stte r r grt Judges decs rderg tht ybe reved y pet r revew te tched dec e ed wth d reevedby the pprpre cr ppel wth dy e dte the decs
cre
bil! Ni P.
cerey
b { CrrChe Cerk
s
Cite as: Bernartita Moses, A206 352 760 (BIA Dec. 9, 2014)
8/10/2019 Bernartita Moses, A206 352 760 (BIA Dec. 9, 2014)
4/12
U.S Departmnt of JusticeExecutive Oce r Imiaon Revew
Decson of e Board of mgration Appeals
Fals Churc, Vgna 53
Fie: A206 352 760 - Honolulu, I Date: DEC - 9
In re: BENARTITA MOSES ka Bemita Moses aka Bemta Mo Mose
MOVAL PROCEEDNG
PPEAL
ON BEHALF OF RESPONDEN: Euel G Guerrero, Esqre
ON BEHALF OF DHS: e KeshgeAssstt Cef Counsel
The respondent, rough coune, e a tey appeal o n Igraton Juge's decsionnding her ubject to reova as chrged by e Depent of Hoe Secuty ("DS) orerng her reo o the Unted States.1 In esponse to the respondent appea, DHSurge the Bod to the grton Judge's decson The appea wl be sustained de recod wl e reed to e Iaion Juge r er proceedng
On appe, te esponent ers tat se was dened a a eng suppor o erguent, e responent, essence, assers that te Iaton Judge ee b not atgher recenty rene atey a contnuce orer to y reew her case d repesent erere e co he esponent ao, in essence, assers that the Igraton Jdge led toly expain ho he reached e concson at e aegaton (eg, concton of e n thesecon degree) suppored he chge at se had een concted o a ce invoving ode
We agree wh e respondent tat te gaton Juge erred n not contung proceengsto ow her aoey a engl opport to reiew and peent her ce bere te cohe record dcates at e responent, bere she obtned counse, experience cutiesdersdng he proceeings a we as e cour provided nterprete The aton Judge,in s decson, acknowedges that her coune was etaned at the ast nute Whe weappreciate Igation Judges esre to keep a detane docket ovng ecenty, t s asoesenta at Igration Juge be ind of a espondent's nvocaton o procera rightsd prvleges See Mate ofB, 25 I&N Dec 888 20 We a e esondeneened o e contne
In addtion, we agree wt e respondent at te Iation Juge dd not enngyepn hs reasons r nding that the conction records subted y DHS suppored thecge o reovab J at 4; r at 3738) Since e Igration Juge did not ly expn
1 e epondent' reques o wve te appeate ng e gted
Cite as: Bernartita Moses, A206 352 760 (BIA Dec. 9, 2014)
8/10/2019 Bernartita Moses, A206 352 760 (BIA Dec. 9, 2014)
5/12
why he convicin constud a crime of oral uitude, t responnt wa eprived oporty to contest suc deinaon on apal.
Accrdingl, he respondnt's appea l be sustand d te record wl be reded r
her poceding, d he en f a nw dcision
2
8/10/2019 Bernartita Moses, A206 352 760 (BIA Dec. 9, 2014)
6/12
\
UNIE SAES DPARME OF JUSCEXECUIVE OFFCE FOR MMIGAIO REVW
E SAS IIGRAON CORHOOLUU HAWAI
Fe: A206352760 Seember 18, 204
In he er of
BERNARA MOSES)))
)
N EOVAL POCEEDIGS
RSPONEN
CHARGS
APPLICATIONS
Seco 237a)2)A)) of he mmgrao ad aonaly Ac ad237a)2)A)) of he mmgraon and Naonay Ac
ON BHAF OF RESODEN: EMMANUEL GUERRERO squre
ON BHALF OF HS: HIH KAESIG, sssan Che Cousel
ORAL ECSON OF HE MMGRAIO JUDGE
he esonde s a 59year-od femae who s a ave and czen o he
ederaed Saes o Mconesa he Deaen o Homeand Secury naed
removal proceedgs ursuan o her auoy uner he Immgraon and Naoaly
Ac upon flg e Noce o pear wh e onou mgraon Cour Augus 26
204 The Noce o Appear aeged a he espone s no a czen or aoal of
he Ued Saes and ha he resonden s a nave of e Fedeaed Saes of
Mcronesa and a cze of he Federaed Saes of Mcnesa e oce o Apear
1
8/10/2019 Bernartita Moses, A206 352 760 (BIA Dec. 9, 2014)
7/12
-
fuher aeged tha te respondet was aded to the Unted Sates a Guam o or
aout ugus 3 200 as a onmmgrat uder the Copact o Free ssocatio wh
the Federaed Saes o Mcronesa he Noce to ppear aso aeged ha he
respode o Ar 8 2008 was covced he Sae of Hawa Crcu Cou o he
Frs Circut a Hoou Hawa r the oense o he n the second degree cotted
o or_ aou pr 1 2003, thugh Septeer 30 2004 voao of Section 708-8302
and 708-83- o he Hawa Revsed Saues. he Noce to ppear uher aeged
ha for tha oese a sentece o one year or oger may be imosed
he resonden appeared nay at a Master Caendar hearg o Sepeber 2,
204. The respondent ndcated hat she speas kese. The Cour utzed a rkese
nterpreter he Cou was requested o aow the respodet a oppouty to have
her ow erpreter nerpre for her so that she would understand he proceedgs. he
respoe proceeded o ask sustatve questons hrough he erpreter ceed to
ransate fro Engsh to rukese ad Truese to Engsh he Cou made a
deenaon ha because o the substatve questons hat the respodet was asng
hat pceeding wth the ceed nterpreter woud be approprae he respodents
case. he respodent was advsed of her rghts n these proceedgs. The Cou
advsed her of her righs over a perod of a haf an hour stoppng utple tmes to
ensure ha the respodet uerstood wat was tang pace. he respondet was
fred that her heang woud e reset to Sepemer 1 6, 204 at 8:30 a.m. and that
the Cour woud per the dvdua a she defied as he terpreer tha she
wshed o use to provde erpretao cjc w e cefe erpreer
The respodet dd ot have the dvdua dente appear a her hearng o
Septeer 1 , 204, at 8:30 am The respondet requese hat he Cou ca hs
ndvdual he Co dd no aow fr a eephoc conneco wth ths iterpreer u
206352-760 2 Septemer 1 8, 24
8/10/2019 Bernartita Moses, A206 352 760 (BIA Dec. 9, 2014)
8/12
stead allowed the resondent addtoal te to have the vdual aear the
Hoolulu Igrato Co he Cou ade a deternaton that t would e too
colcated or unnecessaly colcated n order to coduct a hearg wth a
ndvdual that the Cou has o nrato on relatg to ther qacatons to teret
let alone telehonlly to nterret o the resondents ehal n conuncton wth the
terreter that s ceed to translate ro Englsh to rukese a Trukese to Englsh.
he resodent had ultle faly eers n Cou and the Cou was ve clear
aout what would take lace n todays roceedngs. hat ths matter would roceed
today ad that the Cou would gve the resondent an addtonal oouty to have
her terreter reset ad also to have counsel reset
In todays rceedngs Seteer 8 20 the resodet aea ad the
resodent has cousel resent Consel or the resondent ormed the Cou that
he had had an oorunty to eet wth hs cet or a very bre erod o te and had
ot had the eet o a tereter durg the eetg or nteracto wth ths clent and
aso that the resodent dd not g her docuets to the eetng area n whch the
resodet was ertted to eet wth her atoey. he resondet's cosel
nfored the Cou that he aga had lted ootes to coucate wth hs
clet Resodet's counsel assues the case the ostre that t was n
Resodents counsel dd ot revew the Cou's records here s o nrato n the
Co's record reectg that the record was revewed y resodet's cosel ad
resondents counsel has ot take eos to ursue under due dlgece a revew o
the Record o Proceegs n ths atter.
Resodents cosel essetaly was aculatng crcustances whch would
rase ssues o a cotuance, whch a cotuace the resodet's couse was
nfored o ot take lace today as the esodet had een sustaall me
8/10/2019 Bernartita Moses, A206 352 760 (BIA Dec. 9, 2014)
9/12
-/
a ese proceedings would take pace oay t s nnate tha responns
counse di no eview e rcor t s ununae tha espondents counsel was
etaied las minue t s unnae a reso d ot pursue more vgoosy
the opponity o mmnicate wih counsel and to convey an pove e necessa
ocments o espondes counsel. Howeve n evewng te case the Co as had
te oppounty ove weeks o evew he documents at ave been submte as a
matte o recod the Depament o Homeand Securys evdence avng een
submed a e r astr Canda eang, o wc e resonden a an
oppoy o ocae an atorney o o ave a terete apear, o wch the
resodet d no poceed wt locang an atorney or avng he intepreer at se
aculaed wou be ncessa order o assst her wt nerstanng these
proceengs
Te Cou at tis ime o toay's heang conucted subsana nquy of te
responen to eteme wat ree om emova any he esondent woud be
eigbe .
he Co fond ta e Depamen o omelad Securty ha sbmed
cnvcton ocuments to sppo te carge o emova uder Secon 237(a)(2)()() of
te mmigraton an Naionaty ct and as sc sstane fca alegaion 4
contaned n the Notce o ear an aso susaned th chage o emova unde
Secon 237(a)2)()() of te mmgration an Naionaity ct.
e Cou nqure o he responen weter o no s wou have any ea o
etnng o her coun rmova ce cessa e rspone aiclae tat
se has no amy emanng n te edeated Saes o Micrnesia and at she s
takng cae o a disabe chd hat neds e cae an ta the espoden erse s l
Te responent i no arcuae any ass wc wo supo bty o
206352760 4 September 8, 204
8/10/2019 Bernartita Moses, A206 352 760 (BIA Dec. 9, 2014)
10/12
cosieaion o asyl wihholing o emova o oecio e e Coveion
agains Toe.
The Co inqie of he esone o e maia sats The esponen is no
mae o a nie Saes ciizen o egal peanen esie o he ne Saes. he
esoes aens ae o e Saes ciizes o lega pemaen esiens o he
nie Saes. The esonen as e chie ienife in he eco The
esponen as a 1 7yeao chi who is a nie Saes ciizen The esones
ohe chile ae no nite Saes ciizes a, eeoe ae abe o ile eiions
on e espones bealf alowig he o emai he ie Saes. The
espones yonges chi is o of e age o ie a peiion alowig fo he
espoent to emai in he nie Saes.
he Co evalae e esponens case, inqie o espones cose
wehe o no e was abe o ieify ay ee om emova a he espoen wol
be eligibe Resones cosel was able o aicae any ee fom eova
a he esponen wo be eigibe . Te Co acoweges ha esoes
cose i o ave sbsaial me o eview he case o mae a ime ecision
base pon eseach Te Depamen of omean Secy was iqie wehe o
o e Depaen o Homean Seciy was awae o any eie om emova a e
espone wol be eigible o Te Depame o oelan Seciy was nable o
ieify any elie fom eova a he espoe wol be eligible o. The Co,
pon maig an iepenen a sepaae evaaion s a he espoe wo
o be eigibe ay eie om emoval a is ime.
Te Co in evaang e seco chage o emova in he esones case
ne Secio 237(a(2((iii of he mmigaon a Naionaity c, he Co i o
ake a ning as i eaes o he aggavae eoy oense. The Co in evalaing
A206-352705 Sepebe 1 8 201 4
8/10/2019 Bernartita Moses, A206 352 760 (BIA Dec. 9, 2014)
11/12
e esponen's elglty vounay epaure woul a e esponen woul
e elge or vounta epaue as e Co as no ae a inng o e
ggavae elony oense Howeve e Cou, n conseing volunry ee o
e responent wou ny he espoens eques o volnary eaue as a ae
o sceon ase upon te seosness o e oense n wich he esponen has
een convce
Te Cou at s e wou sse e llowng oe
OERS
T S OREE ta he esponents eqes o volnay epaue e ened
T S ODEED a he espone e oee eove o the nie
Saes.
Te esponen as ndicae he ese o appeal he Cous ecson Te
Depaent o Hoeland Secuy as ncae he ese to wave appea ts
ae
20-3270
CAENCE WAGE, Jigao Juge
Septee 1 2014
8/10/2019 Bernartita Moses, A206 352 760 (BIA Dec. 9, 2014)
12/12
.
_ ,
CERTFCTE GE
heey ce that the attached proceedg eoe JDGE CRECE
WGNER n the matte o
BERRT OSES
2632-760
HONO HW
was held as heen ae and that ths s the orginal tanscrit theeo or the ile o
the Executve Oce o mmgation Review.
OR GOC HN O R (Tanscrer)
REE STE REORTG nc2
OCTOBER 24 204
(Cometon Date)
Recommended