A Question of Management. the Economist

8/10/2019 A Question of Management. the Economist

1/4

!"# %&'(')*+, !! #$%& '(()* +$&,-./% /0 12%23&1&%-4 !"#$#%&"' )#"*'

-". /' +' )0(. 10/2. 34( &')50(*#+ +436*6#7

5/ 6/-7 .-, 281.9&9, 2%8 .-, &%&1.&,: -7& 1/,- 2;&2=.-2?.,1 .,

.-, 9$-7?&,, &00.>.&%>@A B% -7&/9@: =//9?@ =&90/91.%3 0.91, 29& ,7/;% %/ 1&9>@A 57&@

29& >9$,7&8 2%8 >2,- 2,.8& 2, 0.--&9 9.C2?, >/1& $= ;.-7 ,$=&9./9 3//8, 2%8 ,&9C.>&,

/9 >7&2=&9 1&-7/8, /0 =9/8$>-./%A B% 02>-: -7& ,@,-&1 ., %/-7.%3 ?.D& 2, 9$-7?&,, 2, .-

., >92>D&8 $= -/ 6&A E?&%-@ /0 ,$==?.&9, 02.? -/ 8&?.C&9 3//8, /% -.1&A F/-, /0 0.91, 29&

,?/; -/ 28/=- %&; -&>7%/?/3@A G2%@ 12%23&9, 29& 7/=&?&,, 2- 1/-.C2-.%3 -7&.9

,-200A *%8 628?@ 9$% 0.91, >2% ,$9C.C& 0/9 @&29,: &C&% .% -7& ,21& .%8$,-9@ 2, ,-2-&7 ;.8& 8.00&9&%>&, .% -7& =9/8$>-.C.-@ /0 >/1=&-.%3 >/1=2%.&,I J&>/%8: ;7@ 8/

-7&,& 8.00&9&%>&, =&9,.,-: 92-7&9 -72% 6&.%3 ,+$&&K&8 -/ %/-7.%3 6@ -7& 9&1/9,&?&,,

129D&-I 57&@ 2,>9.6& ,/1& /0 -7& 32=, -/ 8.00&9&%>&, .% -7& +$2?.-@ /0 >2=.-2?

&+$.=1&%-: /9 .% ;/9D&9,L ,D.??,: /9 .% -7& 8&C&?/=1&%- 2%8 .%,-2??2-./% /0 %&;

8/10/2019 A Question of Management. the Economist

2/4

!"# %&'(')*+, !! #$%& '(()* +$&,-./% /0 12%23&1&%-4 !"#$#%&"' )#"*'

-&>7%/?/3@A M$- -7&9& 72, ?/%3 6&&% 2 ,$,=.>./% -72- +$.-& 2 ?/- /0 -7& 8.,>9&=2%>@

6&-;&&% 0.- 2%8 0?266@ 0.91, 72, -/ 8/ ;.-7 -7& +$2?.-@ /0 12%23&1&%-A

57& 8.00.>$?-@ ?.&, .% =$--.%3 2 %$16&9 /% .-A B0 &>/%/1.,-, 29& -/ &N=?2.% >/1=2%@

=&90/912%>& .% -&91, /0 12%23&1&%- =92>-.>&,: -7&,& 1$,- ,/1&7/; 6& +$2%-.0.&8A

M$- 7/; 8/ @/$ 1&2,$9& -7& O+$2?.-@O /0 -7& ?2@/$- /0 2 ,7/= 0?//9: >/11$%.>2-./%

;.-7 ;/9D&9, /9 .%>&%-.C&, 0/9 &1=?/@&&,I *% .%-9.3$.%3 %&; ,-$8@P 6@ Q.>D M?//1

2%8 #/7% R2% S&&%&%: /0 -7& F/%8/% J>7//? /0 T>/%/1.>,: 2%8 J-&=7&% U/932%: #/7%

U/;8@ 2%8 5/1 S.==.%: 2?? >/%,$?-2%-, 2- G>V.%,&@: 2--&1=-, -/ 8/ W$,- -72-: 2%8

3/&, /% -/ &N21.%& ;7@ 628?@ 9$% 0.91, ,$9C.C&A

57& ,-$8@ ., 62,&8 /% .%-&9C.&;, ;.-7 12%23&9, 2- 1/9& -72% XY( 12%$02>-$9.%3

>/1=2%.&, Z%/%& /0 -7&1 G>V.%,&@ >?.&%-,[: 92%3.%3 09/1 )( &1=?/@&&, -/ !(:(((:

.% *1&9.>2: M9.-2.%: H92%>& 2%8 \&912%@A 57& .%-&9C.&;&&, D%&; /%?@ -72- -7&@

;&9& -2D.%3 =29- .% 2 O9&,&29>7O =9/W&>-: %/- -72- -7&.9 12%23&1&%- =92>-.>&, ;&9&

6&.%3 2==92.,&8A 57& 2%,;&9, ;&9& 3.C&% 2 ,>/9& 6&-;&&% /%&: -7& ;/9,-: 2%8 0.C&:

-7& 6&,-: .% &2>7 /0 !] >2-&3/9.&,A H/9 .%,-2%>&: $%8&9 /%& 7&28.%3 2 M9.-.,7

>/%,$1&9-, 0.91 ;7/,& 12%23&9,L /%?@ 1&2%.%30$? =&90/912%>& -293&- ;2,

C/?$1& Z;.-7 %/ 1&%-./% /0 +$2?.-@ /9 ;2,-&[ ,>/9&8 /%&^ 2 \&912% .%8$,-9.2?$,&8 /% 129D&- ,729& 2%8 -&>7%/?/3.>2? ?&28&9,7.= Z6$- 8.8 %/-

12D& ,7/=/9&8 -79&&^ 2%8 2% *1&9.>2%

12%$02>-$9&9 -72- >/11$%.>2-&8 0.%2%>.2? -293&-, -/ .-, ,7/= 0?//9 6@ -&??.%3

;/9D&9, -72- -7&@ =2>D&8 6/N&, $%-.? ?$%>7-.1& -/ >/C&9 /C&97&28, 2%8 20-&9 -72-

0/9 =9/0.-21& /$- /% -/=: 2C&923.%3 YAYX: 0/??/;&8 6@ -7& \&912%,

ZYAY'[: -7& H9&%>7 ZYA!Y[ 2%8 -7& M9.-.,7 ZYA(][A _/;&C&9: .% &2>7 >/$%-9@ -7&9& ;2,

2 ;.8& 92%3& /0 ,>/9&,4 /%?@ Y` /0 -7& C29.2-./% >/$?8 6& &N=?2.%&8 6@ -7& >/$%-9@ /0

/=&92-./%A a%&>/$%-&8 0/9 6@ C29.2-./% 6&-;&&% .%8$,-9.&,A 579&&

8/10/2019 A Question of Management. the Economist

3/4

!"# %&'(')*+, !! #$%& '(()* +$&,-./% /0 12%23&1&%-4 !"#$#%&"' )#"*'

+$29-&9, /0 .- =&9,.,-&8 21/%3 0.91, .% -7& ,21& >/$%-9@ 2%8 .%8$,-9@A 57$,: &C&%

21/%3 >/1=&-.%3 %&.376/$9,: -7&9& ;2, 7$3& C29.2-./% .% 12%23&1&%- =92>-.>&,A

U.00&9&%>&, .% 12%23&1&%- =92>-.>&, 8/ ,&&1 -/ 12--&9A 57& 2$-7/9, &,-.12-& -72-

-7&@ 2>>/$%- 0/9 !(-/9 =9/8$>-.C.-@ Z20-&9 ,-9.==.%3 /$-

8.00&9&%>&, .% >2=.-2? .%=$-,[ 6&-;&&% *1&9.>2% 2%8 M9.-.,7 0.91,A *%8 7.37&9

12%23&1&%--.>& ,>/9&, >/99&?2-&8 ;.-7 7.37&9 9&-$9%, /% >2=.-2? &1=?/@&8:

,2?&, =&9 &1=?/@&&: ,2?&, 39/;-7 2%8 39/;-7 .% 129D&- ,729&A J/ .0 =//9

12%23&1&%- 8/&, %/- =2@: ;7@ 8/&, .- ?2,-I

57& 2$-7/9, ,$33&,- -79&& 9&2,/%,A H.9,- ., -7& 8&39&& /0 >/1=&-.-./% .% 2% .%8$,-9@A

B% .%8$,-9.&, .% ;7.>7 =9/0.- 1293.%, 29& ?/;: -7&9& 29& 12%@ 9.C2?, /9 .1=/9-, 72C&

2 6.3 129D&- ,729&: 12%23&1&%- =92>-.>&, -&%8 -/ 6& 6&--&9A 57&9& ., ?.--?& &C.8&%>&:

-7/$37: -72- >/1=&-.-./% 92.,&, ,-2%8298, 6@ 0/9>.%3 12%23&9, -/ ;/9D 6&--&9A G/9&

.1=/9-2%-: ,2@ -7& 2$-7/9,: ., -7&.9 ,&>/%8 &N=?2%2-/9@ 02>-/94 -7& 23& /0 >/1=2%.&,A

b/1=&-.-./% ;/9D, 12.%?@ 6@ ;&&8.%3 /$- @/$%3: 628?@ 12%23&8 0.91,A

89# 0(/ /#&0.

a% -7& /%& 72%8: @/$%3&9 >/1=2%.&, 1.37- 6& &N=&>-&8 -/ 6& 6&--&9 12%23&8 -72%/?8&9 /%&,- 8/1.%2-&,4 0.91, -&%8 -/ 6&

;/9,& 12%23&8: -7& /?8&9 -7&@ 29&A B% -7& 1/,- >/1=&-.-.C& .%8$,-9.&,: 12%23&1&%-

.1=9/C&, ;.-7 23& 0/9 2 0&; @&29, 6&0/9& 8&>?.%.%34 -7& ;/9,-& /0 =//9 12%23&1&%-

=92>-.>&, ., 9&3$?2-./%-.C& ?26/$9 ?2;,-

?233298,A 57&@ 0.%8 -72- -.37-&9 ?26/$9 ?2;, Z,$>7 2, -7/,& .% H92%>& 2%8 \&912%@[

8/ ,&&1 -/ 8923 12%23&9.2? =&90/912%>& 8/;%A 57& &00&>- ., 123%.0.&8 ;7&9&

8/10/2019 A Question of Management. the Economist

4/4

!"# %&'(')*+, !! #$%& '(()* +$&,-./% /0 12%23&1&%-4 !"#$#%&"' )#"*'

12%23&9, 72C& 6&&% .% -7&.9 W/6, ?/%3&,-7 12%23&9, 29& ?&,,

.%>?.%&8 -/ .%.-.2-& >72%3&A

B- ., ,$9=9.,.%3 -72- -7& ,-$8@ 0.%8, ,/ ?.--?& .%-&9%2-./%2? C29.2-./% .% -7& +$2?.-@ /0

12%23&1&%- =92>-.>&A 57&9& .,: 7/;&C&9: 1$>7 -/ 6& ?&29%&8 09/1 0/9&.3%&9,A 57&

2$-7/9, 9&>D/% -72- *1&9.>2%/1=2%.&, .% T$9/=& 8.8 6&--&9 -72% =$9&?@

?/>2? 0.91, /9 -7/,& /;%&8 6@ T$9/=&2% 1$?-.%2-./%2?,A S&1&16&9: -//: 7/;

#2=2%&,& >29 =?2%-, /C&9,&2, ?&0- -7& ?/>2?, -92.?.%3: &C&% .% *1&9.>2I *%8 .- ;/$?8

6& .%-&9&,-.%3 -/ &N-&%8 -7& ,$9C&@: 2, -7& 2$-7/9, =9/=/,&: -/ b7.%2: -7& ;/9?8L,

%&;&,- 12%$02>-$9.%3 =/;&9: 2%8 ,&& 7/; .-, 0.91, 1&2,$9& $=A