1 Session 4: ECONOMIC AND DEVELOPMENTAL OBJECTIVES OF GOVERNMENT PROCUREMENT Dar as Salaam, 14-17...

1

Session 4: ECONOMIC AND DEVELOPMENTAL OBJECTIVES

OF GOVERNMENT PROCUREMENT

Dar as Salaam, 14-17 January 2003

Vesile Kulaçoglu, WTO Secretariat

2

SIZE OF PROCUREMENT MARKETS

POLICY OBJECTIVES

INSTRUMENTS USED

TRANSPARENCY

3

System of National AccountsSystem of National Accounts

GDP = C + I + [X -M] + #inv. GDP = C + I + [X -M] + #inv.

GDPGDP = C = Cnon-gnon-g + I + Inon-gnon-g + + GG + [X -M] + #inv.+ [X -M] + #inv.

GG = Cons = Consgov gov + Invest+ Investgovgov

4

Government ProcurementGovernment Procurement

GG = CONS + INV = CONS + INV

Tradable sharesTradable shares (Theoretical)(Theoretical)

GG - - CCompensation ompensation EEmployees mployees (CE)(CE)

GG - - CE - DefenceCE - Defence

5

World GP Market in 1998World GP Market in 1998

G = Consumption + Investment World World

G G - CE G - CE - DefTrade

1998

GDP 1998

US$ billion 5,500.6 2,563.5 2,083.0 6,743.0 29,357.7

% of GDP 18.9% 8.73% 7.10% 22.97%

6

Other Other CountriesCountries

G = Consumption + Investment

G G - CE G - CE - Def

19.96% 9.17% 7.57%

14.48% 6.89% 5.10%

7

POLICY OBJECTIVES

MINIMIZE PROCUREMENT COSTS

Value for money

ECONOMIC DEVELOPMENT

NON-ECONOMIC OBJECTIVES

8

ECONOMIC DEVELOPMENT

OBJECTIVES Industrial Development

infant-industry

Transfer of Technology local content requirements

Offset market failures SMEs

9

NON-ECONOMIC OBJECTIVES

Support of minority enterprises(affirmative action, women)

Foster environment or labour protection

National security

10

INSTRUMENTS

To attain

objective of value for money

competition

transparency other objectives

limit competition

11

Instruments used to limit competition

import bans

preferences in favour of domestic

supplies and suppliers (e.g. Buy

American Act)

offset requirements

set-asides for SMEs, minority businesses

12

Instruments used to limit competition

policies favouring a region, labour-

surplus areas in national development

framework

furtherance of agricultural support and

human feeding programmes

13

PREFERENCES

PRICE PREFERENCES

Price differentials varying from 3 to 20%

SPECIFIC PREFERENCES

categories of goods and services (syringes,

telecom)

sectors of economy (transportation, electricity)

TIE-BREAKS

14

OFFSETS Local content requirements

(% of human resources or domestic inputs)

investment requirements (venture capital)

licensing of technology; R&D counter-trade training sub-contracting

15

Sources:

Slides 3-6 : Denis Audet, OECD Study on Government Procurement Markets, 2002.

Slides 7-10: Bernard Hoekman, Word Bank, WTO Symposium in Transparency in Government Procurement, 9-10 October 2002, Geneva