2010 07-15 rbeem nahbrc marine miranda 07-15-10

Marine Climate Case StudyMiranda HomesNAHB Research Center

Residential Building Energy Efficiency Meeting July 2010

p. 2

Details Unique aspects

Construction Energy Analysis Energy

Monitoring Comparison

Summary

p. 3

Project Location

p. 4

Miranda Homes • Harbor View Clackamas, OR

p. 5

Miranda Homes • Harbor View Clackamas, OR

Harbor View Model Harbor Home 1

Marine Climate 1,569 sqft Crawlspace

foundation Panelized Walls Steel framed homes Affordable, ↓cycle

time

p. 6

System Description Specifications

Foundation Unvented Crawlspace R-23 (ICF)

WallsPanelized Walls

Continuous SheathingSpray Foam Insulation

Exterior Rigid Foam Insulation

Advanced steel framing (2 x 6)OSBR-24R-4.4

Roof / Attic Spray Foam R-45 unvented attic

Windows High Performance Windows Low-e; U = 0.30 / SHGC = 0.31

Heating System Electric Heat PumpLocated in Conditioned Space 8.5 HSPF

Cooling System Central Unit Located in Conditioned Space 15 SEER

Ducts Located in Conditioned Space 100% interior5% leakage to exterior (28.4 cfm25)

Ventilation Fresh Air Ventilation 38 cfm exhaust ventilation

Water Heater Electric Hot Water Heater 0.92 EF electric tank

Lighting 75% fluorescent CFL and permanent

Appliances Energy Star (where supplied)

Air Infiltration Air Sealing Details 2.31 ACH50

Details Miranda Homes • Harbor Home 1

p. 7

Construction ProcessMiranda Homes • Harbor Home 1

Manufacture steel studs

Panelize Walls Steel studs OSB Exterior rigid foam

Set walls on foundation ICF Conditioned crawl

Manufacture roof trusses

All SPF insulation AG

p. 8

Panelized 2x6 WallsMiranda Homes • Harbor Home 1

p. 9

Wall InteriorMiranda Homes • Harbor Home 1

p. 10

Spray Foam AppliedMiranda Homes • Harbor Home 1

p. 11

Ducts & HVACMiranda Homes • Harbor Home 1

p. 12

Lighting & AppliancesMiranda Homes • Harbor Home 1

p. 13

Energy AnalysisMiranda Homes • Harbor Home 1

House Feature Typical Construction Miranda Homes Design Floor Area 1569 square feet, single story 1569 square feet, single storyWindow area 252 square feet 252 square feetFoundation Crawlspace, R-30 floor Crawlspace, conditioned, R-23Bathrooms 2 2Ceiling Flat ceiling, vented attic R38 Unvented attic, R-45Roof framing Wood MetalWall framing Wood, 2x6, advanced framing Metal, 2x6, 20% framing factor1

Wall insulation R-19 cavity R-24 cavity, R-4.35 exteriorWindows U-0.35/0.4 SHGC U-0.30/0.31 SHGCInfiltration 0.35 ACHnat2 0.122 ACHnatVentilation None 100 CFM, runtime 20% minimumCooling System Efficiency 13 SEER 15.5 SEERHeating System Efficiency 7.7 HSPF 8.5 HSPFDuct Location Interior/Crawlspace, insulated InteriorDuct sealing Assumed air-tight As measuredTemperature Set-point 76 Cooling – 71 Heating 76 Cooling – 71 HeatingLighting Energy 2,064 kWh/yr 1,183 kWh/yearAppliances and Plug 4,399 kWh/yr 4,399 kWh/yr1 Framing system optimized using panelization software and engineered components2 Based on ASHRAE 62.2 minimum infiltration before mechanical ventilation required

p. 14

Energy AnalysisMiranda Homes • Harbor Home 1

46% Energy Savings Over BA

Benchmark HERS Index

69 (w/out PV)

p. 15

MonitoringMiranda Homes • Harbor Home 1

Instruments were installed to monitor: Indoor and outdoor

temperatures Whole-house electricity

use Heating system electricity

use Water heating electricity

use Duct supply and

ventilation temperatures

p. 16

Weather Data ComparisonHeating Degree Days

Temperature difference between indoors & out

During monitoring period

15% fewer heating degree days 2,941 HDD monitored 3,468 HDD

simulations

p. 17

Weather Data ComparisonDaily Temperature Profile

p. 18

Temperature DataDaily Average Temperature Profile

p. 19

Temperature Data Profile

Measured Temp Daily Average: ≈ 2°F higher

than TMY3 Average Min: ≈ 1°F higher Average Max: ≈ 3°F higher Average Interior: within 1°F Daily Interior temperature

range is larger (over 2°F during heating season)

p. 20

Monitored DataMiranda Homes • Harbor Home 1

p. 21

Performance ComparisonSimulated vs. Measured for Period

Performance Metric Simulation Data

Measured Data Unit

Difference between Measured and Simulated Data

Average Outdoor Temperature 48.3 49.0 °F +0.7 °F Average Daily Maximum Temperature 56.6 60.1 °F +3.5 °FAverage Daily Minimum Temperature 39.9 41.0 °F +1.1 °FAverage Indoor Temperature 71.7 70.8 °F -0.9 °FHeating Energy Use 2,646 2,319 kWh -12.4%Hot Water Energy Use 1,819 1,427 kWh -21.6%Appliance and Lighting Energy Use 3,179 2,692 kWh -15.3%Whole House Energy Use 7,644 6,438 kWh -15.8%

p. 22

Heating ComparisonElectric Energy & Temperature

p. 23

Heating ComparisonHeating System Performance

p. 24

Company StructureMiranda Homes • Harbor Home 1

Miranda Homes staff construct homes Vertically integrated Minimize construction

time Minimize callbacks

Integrated Quality Management

p. 25

Conclusions & Next Steps Miranda Homes • Harbor Home 1

Energy efficiency enhancements have enabled successful use of steel framing

Monitored data is fairly well matched with predicted data & confirms savings

Simulation model adequately predicts energy usage

Further analysis is needed using annual data

Based on data further enhancements may be identified

p. 26

Questions?

Amber WoodProgram Manager, Energy Efficiency

NAHB Research Center301-430-6309

awood@nahbrc.com