35
Ways of “researching multilingually” at the borders of language, the body, law and the state Prue Holmes (Durham University) with Jane Andrews (The University of the West of England) Mariam Attia (Durham University) Richard Fay (The University of Manchester) University of Melbourne 15 July 2016

Ways of "researching multilingually" at the borders of language, the body, law and the state

Embed Size (px)

Citation preview

Page 1: Ways of "researching multilingually" at the borders of language, the body, law and the state

Ways of “researching multilingually” at the borders of language, the body,

law and the state

Prue Holmes (Durham University)

withJane Andrews (The University of the West of England)

Mariam Attia (Durham University)Richard Fay (The University of Manchester)

University of Melbourne15 July 2016

Page 2: Ways of "researching multilingually" at the borders of language, the body, law and the state

Preview“Researching multilingually”

1. The two projects:– RMly network project (AH/J005037/1)– RMly@borders project (AH/L006936/1)

2. Building the framework: Contributions from:– Translanguaging & translingual practice– Critical & indigenous methodologies – Ethics and RMly– Multilingual/intercultural relationships and capabilities

3. Building the methodology: Our “ways of working”4. Contributions from one case study:

– CS5 Developing TASOL in Gaza – researcher experiences

5. Conclusions

Page 3: Ways of "researching multilingually" at the borders of language, the body, law and the state

1. The two projects

• RMly network project (AH/J005037/1)http://researchingmultilingually.com/

• RMly@borders project (AH/L006936/1)http://researching-multilingually-at-borders.com/

Page 4: Ways of "researching multilingually" at the borders of language, the body, law and the state

Aim of the initial RMly network project

To investigate and clarify the epistemological and methodological processes of researching in more than one language—whether dialogic, observational, textual, or mediated—and their implications for research design, instruments, data collection and generation, translation and interpretation, and reporting.

implications for understanding, reporting, and representation of people of other languages

Opportunities, affordances, challenges, obstacles

Holmes, P., Fay, R., Andrews, J., Attia, M. (2013). Researching multilingually: New theoretical and methodological directions. International Journal of Applied Linguistics, 23(3), 285-299.Holmes, P., Fay, R., Andrews, J., & Attia, M. (2016,). How to research multilingually: Possibilities and complexities. In H. Zhu (Ed., pp. 88-102). Research methods in intercultural communication. London: Wiley.

Page 5: Ways of "researching multilingually" at the borders of language, the body, law and the state

The “Researching Multilingually” process

… from the inception of a research project, to designing the project, the lit review, research questions, research framework, choice of methods, ethics and reflexivity, analysis, modes of (re)presentation

Page 6: Ways of "researching multilingually" at the borders of language, the body, law and the state

RMly conceptualisation

1. Intentionality (purposefulness)• Making informed and intentional researcher decisions• Researcher reflexivity & sensitivity, identity

2. Relationality/interculturality• Researcher, supervisor, participants, translators/interpreters/transcribers• Trust, ethics, power

3. Researching multilingually spaces • Research phenomenon (the “what”)• Context of research (the “where”)• Linguistic resources of researcher (the “who”)• Representational possibilities (the language(s) of dissemination,

the “for where” or “for whom”)=> Interdisciplinary insights ??

Page 7: Ways of "researching multilingually" at the borders of language, the body, law and the state

www.researching-multilingually-at-borders.com(AH/L006936/1)

(AHRC large grant under the “Translating cultures” theme, 2014-17)

Page 8: Ways of "researching multilingually" at the borders of language, the body, law and the state

Concepts of borders and security/insecurity raise important practical and ethical questions as to how research might be conducted.

Focus on Methods: comparing across discipline-specific methods, interrogating arts and humanities methods where the

body and body politic are under threat, developing theoretical and methodological insights as

a result. There are some pockets of work in disciplines but no

overarching framework across multiple disciplines.”

Context of the AHRC large-grant project:Languages under pressure and pain

(at borders)

Page 9: Ways of "researching multilingually" at the borders of language, the body, law and the state

The project structure

Multimodal complementary methods

Processes(exploratory, reflexive, ethical)

Researchers

(Research teams: Two hubs, five case study sites, five PhDs)

CATC hub

Performance, artisticcreative methods

RMTC hub

Academic, investigative, comparative methods

Page 10: Ways of "researching multilingually" at the borders of language, the body, law and the state

The five case studies

CS1: Translating the Emotional Impact of Sexual and Gender-Based Trauma [Uganda] (University of Glasgow) CS2: Translating Vulnerability and Silence into the Legal Process (UG & University of Nijmegen)

CS3: Working and Researching Multilingually at State (and European Union [Romania & Bulgaria]) Borders (UG)

CS4: Multilingual Ecologies in the American Southwest Borderlands (University of Arizona)

CS5: Arabic as a Foreign Language for International Learners (IUG, Gaza)

Page 11: Ways of "researching multilingually" at the borders of language, the body, law and the state

RMly@Borders brief …

… the members of the RMTC 'hub' will lead the development of integrated conceptual and methodological approaches, tools, and methods for researching translation processes and practices at borders where bodies are often at risk, in pain and/or in transition

Page 12: Ways of "researching multilingually" at the borders of language, the body, law and the state

RMTC Hub RQs (from proposal)

• How do researchers generate, translate, interpret and write up data (dialogic, mediated, textual, performance) from one language to another?

• What ethical issues emerge in the planning and execution of data collection and representation (textual, visual, performance) where multiple languages are present?

• What methods and techniques improve processes of researching multilingually?

• How does multimodality (e.g. visual methods, ‘storying’, performance) complement and facilitate multilingual research praxis?

• How can researchers develop clear multilingual research practices and yet also be open to emergent research design?

Page 13: Ways of "researching multilingually" at the borders of language, the body, law and the state

RMTC developments in the RMly@Borders project

To develop a theoretical understanding of how researchers draw on their multilingual resources, and those of others, in multilingual contexts of pressure and pain, e.g., where people are stateless and homeless due to war, poverty, persecution, and economic instability.

• Generally, we are concerned with the following:– what it means to “language”, “be languaged”, “be languagers”, and “language

oneself” in the world today– what alternatives or other modes of researching and representation might be

possible– what is unsaid, liminal– the messiness, precarity, unpredictability of RMly experience

Page 14: Ways of "researching multilingually" at the borders of language, the body, law and the state

2. Building the framework - Contributions from:

• Translanguaging & translingual practice• Critical & indigenous methodologies • Ethics and RMly• Multilingual/intercultural relationships and

intercultural capabilities• Reflective practice

Page 15: Ways of "researching multilingually" at the borders of language, the body, law and the state

Languaging Languaging“… a way of articulating the full, embodied and engaged interaction with the world that comes when we put the languages we are using into action.”“… being a person in that language in the social and material world of everyday interactions.”

Languagers…“… engage with the world-in-action, … move in the world in a way that allows the risk of stepping out of one’s habitual ways of speaking and attempt to develop different, more relational ways of interacting with the people and phenomena that one encounters in everyday life.”

(Phipps, 2011, p. 365)

Page 16: Ways of "researching multilingually" at the borders of language, the body, law and the state

Languaging

Languaging is …•relational - about the feelings we experience with others, through place, positioning

– Intercultural, interpersonal, interagentive

•involves a language ecology that includes the senses and sensory experience•phenomenological – how people perceive the world

Page 17: Ways of "researching multilingually" at the borders of language, the body, law and the state

Translation as a languaging response to phenomena “… a way of living in translated worlds, the worlds that meet in relations and that come to make sense through relations” (Phipps, 2011, p. 372).Languaging – not just cultural work, but translation as embodiment of feeling, and ways of relating to place and to words; shared through habitation

Yolland speaks of the land to Marie using the Irish names Maori identity – whakapapa, mihi

How can researchers draw on languaging in their researcher praxis?

Languaging

Page 18: Ways of "researching multilingually" at the borders of language, the body, law and the state

Translingual practice

“My aim has been to provide new research insights into the ways in which mobile semiotic resources are negotiated for meaning in global contact zones, and also to suggest pedagogical [methodological] approaches to develop such co-operative dispositions and performative competence for cosmopolitan relationships” (Canagarajah, 2013, p.202).

Our concern – how can a translingual approach be nurtured in researcher praxis?

Page 19: Ways of "researching multilingually" at the borders of language, the body, law and the state

Critical theory - Southern theory

“Southern” emphasises “relations of authority, exclusion and inclusion, hegemony, partnership, sponsorship, appropriation—between intellectuals and institutions in the metropole and those in the world periphery” (Connell, 2007, p. ix).

Page 20: Ways of "researching multilingually" at the borders of language, the body, law and the state

Critical indigenous methodologies

Indigenous communities seek a “set of ethical principles that are feminist, caring, communitarian, holistic, respectful, mutual (rather than power imbalanced), sacred, and ecologically sound”

Denzin, Lincoln and Smith (2008, p. 569)

Page 21: Ways of "researching multilingually" at the borders of language, the body, law and the state

Critical indigenous methodologies …

seek to address injustices through research processes that demonstrate an ethical and reciprocal relationship between researcher and researched.

acknowledge marginalised people and “recognize the need to avoid forms of representation that maintain power in traditional locations” (Cannella & Lincoln, 2011, p. 82).

For RMly researchers, they enable the examination of privilege and exclusion created by language in research practices.

Page 22: Ways of "researching multilingually" at the borders of language, the body, law and the state

Critical indigenous methodologies …

… offer frameworks for democratic research that advocate for voices to be heard—that have been, and continue to be, marginalised and unauthorised by dominant (and often colonial) regimes of power.

(Linda Tuhiwai Smith, 1999; 2012)(Freire, 1972; 1976)(hooks, 2003)

Page 23: Ways of "researching multilingually" at the borders of language, the body, law and the state

Ethical practice and languages

‘There is a need to recognise the role of languages and how they are brought into being by all concerned as researchers “join with,” and “learn from” rather than “speak for” or “intervene into” others’ lives’ (Cannella & Lincoln, 2011, p. 83).

Page 24: Ways of "researching multilingually" at the borders of language, the body, law and the state

Ethical practices in Rmly work

Speaking back (and listening)We have to find ways in which the marginalized can enter our discourses in their own genres and their own terms so that we can learn to hear them. They have a universal right to impart information and ideas through any media [and any language] and regardless of frontiers, and we have a duty to listen and understand them through engaging in new acts of becoming (Krog, 2011, p. 384).

Page 25: Ways of "researching multilingually" at the borders of language, the body, law and the state

3. Building the methodology: The “Ways of working” document

• Exploratory practice- Linked to exploratory practitioner (teacher) research (Allwright)

• Reflective practice- Reflection in, on, and for action

Page 26: Ways of "researching multilingually" at the borders of language, the body, law and the state

4. Contributions from one case study

• CS5: Arabic as a Foreign Language for International Learners (IUG, Gaza)

Page 27: Ways of "researching multilingually" at the borders of language, the body, law and the state

CS5: TASOL

Researcher ecologies

The researchers –Located in Glasgow –Working with researchers/teachers in Gaza–Multimodality – using communication technologies & creative arts–1 German, 2 Italian, 1 Danish/Egyptian

Page 28: Ways of "researching multilingually" at the borders of language, the body, law and the state

Researcher ecologies (cont.)

ContextOffices and classrooms at UG and IUGKatja’s home (Glasgow) to make a filmMona’s bedroom (Gaza) - by skype Nazmi’s office at IUG (vacated for the teachers to work in)

Page 29: Ways of "researching multilingually" at the borders of language, the body, law and the state

Researcher ecologies (cont.)

Positioning – Both Rs and R/Ts were co-producers of the knowledge“Researcher”/”teacher”/”participant” distinction was collapsedAll in a position of “becoming”, of “being stretched” (Katja)Reciprocity; reflexivity; intersubjectivityTrust as a language – Linguistic vulnerabilityFour researchers (all multilingual, none English as lst lang) Qualified to achieve their research objectives?Student teachers in Gaza (Arabic)=> Crucial to build a language of trust between researchers and teachers

Page 30: Ways of "researching multilingually" at the borders of language, the body, law and the state

Researcher ecologies (cont.)

Rapport building - Power sharing—no micromanaging Important in exploring the modalities of communication (Grazia)Patience, resilience, motivation - in realising the project, to make it successfulModes of communication – Languages (English; Arabic); technologies (Moodle, Skype); nonverbal communication (to allow space for thinking)

Page 31: Ways of "researching multilingually" at the borders of language, the body, law and the state

Theoretical insights• These ecologies aligned with the values of the researchers in resisting

methods developed in the global North (Southern theory - Connell)• => Resisting translation of methods - exportation of language

learning methods developed in TESOL depts in the UK and US => Acknowledging and drawing on methods appropriate to Gaza (indigenous methodologies - Tuhiwai Smith)

• Ethics – reciprocity/speaking back/listening (Cannella & Lincoln; Krog) – Rs & R/Ts experiment, share, give back => “offerings” & “remakings”

• Ethics of equality and “plenty” – All researchers realise their capabilities => humaneness of the researcher role/context

• Languaging & translingual practice (Phipps; Canagarajah) – multilinguality of Rs & R/Ts

Page 32: Ways of "researching multilingually" at the borders of language, the body, law and the state

4. Conclusions

Page 33: Ways of "researching multilingually" at the borders of language, the body, law and the state

Researching multilingually …To ensure the trustworthiness of the research (in contexts of language marginalisation and discrimination), RMly researchers might consider the following:•investigate the in-between communicative spaces—the silences, interruptions, apprehensions, unexplored and unarticulated tensions and decision making—invoked in the minds of researchers and research participants•build and nurture relationships underpinned by linguistic power and positioning among all stakeholders •contest the language rules, values, and motivations of those initiating, undertaking, and evaluating the research (project funders, managers, other researchers, policy implementers)•Negotiate language policies and regimes at all levels of research (examination, dissemination, publication)

Page 34: Ways of "researching multilingually" at the borders of language, the body, law and the state

Where to next?

• How do/might these approaches inform researcher multilingual practice, especially in conditions of language precarity, marginalisation, and discrimination?

• What opportunities do they offer for the in-between, unexplored spaces in researcher praxis?

• What challenges?• How can the outcomes support change in language

attitudes and policy implementation?

Page 35: Ways of "researching multilingually" at the borders of language, the body, law and the state

Building a wider RMly researcher knowledge base and network:

www.researchingmultingually.com

www.researching-multilingually-at-borders.com

1) What is your experience of doing research in more than one language?

2) What is your experience of becoming aware of the complexities in this area?

Send 300 – 500 words (same text can be offered in different languages) and photo (JPEG) to [email protected] or [email protected]

3) Durham conference – 21-23 October 2016“Education and migration: Language foregrounded”http://researching-multilingually-at-borders.com/?page_id=1468

An invitation to participate