Graphic Organisers for L2 Reading Presentation at JALT East Shikoku National Conference 2014 This presentation will report on a study that investigated the effects of direct instruction and guided practice in using graphic organisers as an expository text comprehension strategy in a college level EFL reading context. Participants in the study were two intact groups (n =21, n =31) of 1st year undergraduate engineers at Kochi University of Technology. The study utilised a mixed method research design, based on both quantitative and qualitative data collection and analysis techniques. The researcher examined if using graphic organisers (GOs) transferred into quantitative improvements in reading comprehension as measured through an 18-item multiple- choice test at the end of a 6-week study period, and if students perceived they had improved. Results showed that both groups had made quantitative improvements over the course of the study period; however the gains were significantly higher in the mapping group in non-parametric analysis (p < .05). Subjects in the treatment group also reported that the treatment had improved their overall reading skills and understanding of text organisation, and felt that using GOs was an effective strategy for L2 reading.
Citation preview
1. G R A P H I C O R G A N I S E R S M I C H A E L S H A R P E
K O C H I U N I V E R S I T Y O F T E C H N O L O G Y s h a r p e m
i k e 1 9 7 0 @ g m a i l . c o m for L2 READING
2. Problem Graphic organisers Contextual background Methodology
Results and Discussion Conclusion P R E S E N T A T I O N O U T L I
N E
3. B A C K G R O U N D Reading L2 reading tasks invariably
based on expository texts Worldwide: Considered most important
aspect of EFL literacy for college students* Reading work
prioritised in many students EFL study schedules. In Japan: Many
college EFL programs focus on reading
4. B A C K G R O U N D L2 Reading in Japan Common assumption
College freshmen have the skills needed to negotiate EFL reading
tasks** Established fact At high school students work primarily on
building L2 literacy* *Browne, 1996. **Browne, 1996
5. B A C K G R O U N D Inadequate English reading skills So in
many situations teachers/students rely on supplementary
translations. 1. Lack of lexical and grammatical knowledge* due to
*Kitao and Kitao (1995), Laufer and Yano (2001), and Okumura and
Miyamoto (2010) 2. Inability to understand English text
organisation** ** Okumura and Miyamoto (2010) Evidence suggests
that many Japanese college students struggle with reading tasks L2
Reading in Japan
6. B A C K G R O U N D Information dense Frequently based on
unfamiliar topics Structurally complex Conceptual relationships are
implicit To comprehend English expository texts readers therefore
need a whole range of literal and inferential reading skills*
*Armbruster, 1984; Meyer and Freedle, 1984; Williams, et al,1984);
Armbruster,1984; Meyer et al, 2002; Reutzel and Cooter, due to The
nature of English expository texts L2 Reading in Japan Evidence
suggests that many Japanese college students struggle with reading
tasks
7. B A C K G R O U N D Methodological paradigms at Japanese
high schools High school EFL curricula Mostly prep. for senta
shikken and nyugakku shikken Test students grammatical knowledge
through multiple-choice questions. Test reading ability through
questions based on NS level i reading passages* Typical EFL
learning activities Grammar-translation (yakudoku) Grammar analysis
At most high schools students are required to read difficult
English texts while translating word-for-word, reordering the
translated words to fit Japanese word order**. Hino, 1988; Gorsuch,
1998; Mantero and Iwai, 2005; Porcaro, 2005*; Takase, 2007**;
Underwood, 2012. due to Evidence suggests that many Japanese
college students struggle with reading tasks L2 Reading in
Japan
8. Consequences for students B A C K G R O U N D Lack
motivation to read* Students leave school with little interest
either in reading or in English in general (John, 2013:6). *Kimura
et al, 2001; John, 2013, Norris-Holt, 2002; Okumura and Miyamoto,
2010. Can translate in the literal sense* .but cannot understand
inherent message** *Kitao and Kitao, 1995; **Mantero and Iwai,
2005. Believe that reading is simply obtaining meaning from print.*
*Mantero and Iwai, 2005 L2 Reading in Japan
9. B A C K G R O U N D Summary High-school EFL reading classes
fail to teach L2 reading skills and strategies nor engage students
interest. Undergraduates struggle with expository text reading
tasks Need for research into approaches that: Improve performance
in reading tests. Improve reading confidence Improve motivation to
read Browne, 1996; Iino, 2002; Laufer and Yano; 2001; Robb and
Susser, 1989; Torikai, 2003). Much input but abilities among
Japanese undergraduates are poor* L2 Reading in Japan
10. Graphic organisers: definitions B A C K G R O U N D (Also
known as knowledge maps, concept maps, story maps, cognitive
organisers, advance organisers, or concept diagrams) (Jiang and
Grabe, 2007:34). (Robinson and Kiewra, 1995:455). (Jones, Pierce
& Hunter, 1988:20). National Centre for Accessible
Instructional Materials Visual representation of information in the
text GOs use a spatial format to convey concept relations Graphic
representations (that) are visual illustrations of verbal
statements. A graphic organiser is a visual and graphic display
that depicts the relationships between facts, terms, and or ideas
within a learning task.
11. Graphic Organisers:Examples
12. B A C K G R O U N D Research also supports GO use in these
subject areas* *(Bulgren, Schumaker, & Deshler, 1988; Darch,
Carnine, & Kammenui, 1986; Herl, O'Neil, Chung, & Schacter,
1999; Willerman & Mac Harg, 1991) Graphic Organisers - Teaching
Applications Language ArtsReading Social studiesScience Math Most
studies have been on reading Graphic organisers - research
13. B A C K G R O U N D Graphic organisers - research L1
contexts 500 + empirical studies L2 contexts ~20 empirical studies
Gap in our knowledge about GO based L2 reading instruction needs
filling. Jiang and Grabe (2007); Howard and Ellis (2011) GOs
adopted as one of seven recommended (US) National Reading Council
reading strategies
14. Theoretical basis for GOs Ellis (2004) states that the main
theoretical basis for these claims, lies in turn, in the more
general theories of learning proposed by Ausubel, by Pavio, and by
Sweller. Claims for GOs B A C K G R O U N D Cognitive Theory of
Meaningful Verbal Learning (David Ausubel, 1963). Overview:
Learning and retention of unfamiliar materials occurs when newly
acquired information is assimilated into the extant cognitive
structure that makes up an individual's knowledge base. (Ausubel,
cited in Novak and Caas, 2006). For meaningful learning, as opposed
to rote learning, to occur. input must be presented in a way that
allows it to be easily linked with existing schema. Information
that fits into existing schema is much more easily comprehended and
stored within the hierarchy. The advance organiser that Ausubel
developed based on these theories activate prior knowledge and
relate new material to existing information, so that the
information is more familiar and meaningful.(ibid) This advance
organiser is considered to be the conceptual model for graphic
organisers. Dual Coding Theory (Allan Paivio). Overview: Readers
encode information according to two separate but interrelated
information processing systems via which they process both
non-verbal imagery and language. Each of these systems is
independently controlled, but they are closely interconnected,
thereby allowing for dual coding of information. Imagery is
processed and stored as imagems whereas linguistic information is
processed and stored as logogens. Readers hold both logogens and
imagems in short-term memory in parallel forms. Thus, memory for
text information and the retrieval of that information are
facilitated by verbal-non-verbal dual coding (Paivio,
2001:112-113). Graphic organisers present information in a way that
makes it possible to codify the information both verbally and
visually, so the information is more memorable. Cognitive Load
Theory (Sweller,1988) Overview: Short term memory has a limited
capacity in terms of the number of elements that can be held at any
one moment. For schema acquisition to occur, instructional
approaches that reduce working memory load are most effective in
order to facilitate the changes in long-term memory associated with
schema acquisition. Graphic organisers are an effective means for
reducing working memory load. Jones, Pierce, and Hunter: 1988:21
Tang, 1991:37 Can show the key parts of a whole and their
relations, thereby allowing a holistic understanding that words
along cannot convey Help students select important ideas as well as
detect missing information and unexplained relations. Communicate
shape of knowledge and make visible the knowledge structure they
represent, so providing a schema which can be accessed again and
again, thus facilitating comprehension. Process of creating or
completing graphic representations of the topics and main ideas in
a text i.e. reconstructing messages in the text, helps to show how
these topics or ideas are interrelated and that this resulting in
improved comprehension and recall.
15. Research rationales Summary evidence from dozens of studies
has supported recommendations in the L1 reading literature to use
GOs as part of reading instruction. Currently, graphic organisers
are widely used in L1 reading instructional curricula designed for
learner readers, and are frequently included in L1 reading
textbooks. (Jiang and Grabe, 2007). The recommendations to use GOs
as part of reading instruction are commonly found in the first
language (L1) reading literature they are generally less common in
second language (L2) contexts. On the basis of the strong claims
for GO effectiveness made in the literature, they conclude that, an
important goal would be to generalize the results of GO use to the
L2 student population (Jiang and Grabe, 2007:34). (Grabe and
Stoller). B A C K G R O U N D
16. Is there any relationship between using graphic organisers
in the reading classroom and students actual comprehension of
expository text? Is there any relationship between using graphic
organisers in the reading classroom and students perceived
comprehension of expository text? Can anything be inferred from:
Learners attitudes to classroom mapping activities. Observations of
learner behaviours during classroom activities. M E T H O D O L O G
Y Research questions
17. M E T H O D O L O G Y Research design Mixed method design,
quantitative/qualitative data collection and analysis techniques.
Experimental component Aims. a) To determine if the treatment
resulted in a quantitative increase in reading comprehension b) To
determine if using graphic organisers during reading resulted in
any short-term perceived increase in reading comprehension.
Qualitative components Aims. To record students attitudes
regarding: Overall effectiveness of mapping activities for
enhancing their EFL reading skills Reading motivation, Reading
confidence, Knowledge of text organization and text structures Aims
To record significant events/trends/patterns of behavior. Levels of
participation/motivation in regard to the assigned tasks between
the two groups. Levels of interaction among subjects while
completing assigned tasks. Time taken to complete and ability to
complete assigned tasks. To reinforce validity of the quantitative
data and explain meaning of comparisons made. Materials Classroom
observation protocol. Materials 9-item Likert-type mapping
questionnaire Pre-program-post-program non-equivalent group design
(N-O-X-O) Materials a) 18-item pre/post test b) 9-item self-rated
comprehension questionnaire Post-treatment survey Systematic
classroom observation program.
18. M E T H O D O L O G Y Groups: 1st year (18 yrs old)
undergraduate engineering students at a Japanese public university.
Treatment Group (Information Systems Engineering majors (n = 31)
Control group Environmental Systems Engineering majors (n = 21)
Level: Beginner (~CEFR A1) Schedule: 6-week study/assessment period
Materials: A. Six 300-350 word reading texts (used in the treatment
and testing phases) B. Mapping templates (used in the treatment and
testing phases) Constructed by researcher, on the basis of studies
in L1 contexts indicating that teacher-generated frames are more
successful than either purely teacher-generated maps or purely
student-generated maps. Integrate principles of several different
text visualization approaches include Novaks concept mapping
principles (Novak and Caas, 2006). Focus readers attention on the
selection of main ideas, in order to represent both the overall
rhetorical organization and the text structures in the previously
described expository texts. On showing how these ideas are
connected On displaying the rhetorical framework of the text.
Follow Novakian principles of spatial arrangement by having a
hierarchical concept array, in which general information is at the
head and more specific information below.
19. M A T E R I A L S P O S T T E S T R E A D I N G Kansai
International Airport Airports are very important for trade and
tourism. In Japan, Kansai International Airport is one of the most
important airports. Every year, about 14 million people use the
airport for domestic and international flights. In the 1960s,
businesses in the Kansai area wanted a better airport for the
Kansai area because they were losing business to Tokyo. Osaka
already had an international airport at Itami, near central Osaka.
However, it was impossible to expand Itami Airport for two reasons.
First, there were too many buildings around Itami. Also, many of
the people living near the airport did not like the noise and
pollution from the aircraft. Therefore, planners decided to build a
new airport on a man- made island in the middle of Osaka Bay. The
main advantage of building the airport in Osaka Bay was that it
could stay open 24 hours a day. Itami Airport has to close at
night. The main disadvantage was the high risk of earthquakes and
typhoons. In 1987, after 20 years of planning, construction of
Kansai International Airport began. First, workers constructed a
rectangular seawall using rocks and 48,000 concrete blocks. The
seawall was finished in 1989. Next, workers created a man-made
island by putting a 33-meter layer of earth over the seafloor
inside the seawall. They used 21 million cubic meters of earth from
three mountains. However, during construction of the island, it
began to slowly sink. As a result, the project was delayed and the
project costs increased. When complete, the island was four
kilometers long and one kilometer wide. Then, workers constructed a
three-kilometer-long bridge between the island and the mainland.
Following that, workers constructed the runway and the terminal
building. Kansai International Airport finally opened in September
1994. The terminal has several interesting features. First, the
total length of terminal is 1.7 kilometres, so it is the longest
terminal in the world. Inside the terminal is an automatic people
mover system for passengers and aircrew. Second, the terminal is
shaped like an aircraft wing, to improve air circulation through
the building. Finally, because the island is still sinking, it is
necessary for engineers to raise the roof. To raise the roof,
engineers put thick metal plates under the roof supports.
Flesch-Kincaid 9.3
20. M A T E R I A L S - M A P P I N G T E M P L A T E F O R T E
X T
21. Self-Rating Reading Scale Using the scale below rate your
ability to comprehend the Kansai International Airport text. Circle
one number only. 9 I understand everything. I am able to read the
text from beginning to end with no comprehension problems at all. 8
I understand almost everything. A few items of grammar/vocabulary
confuse me, but I can usually guess their meaning. 7 I have no real
problems reading the text. I understand all the main points and
most of the supporting details. There are only a few sentence
structures, items of vocabulary or expressions I do not understand.
6 Although I understand most of the main points of the text, some
points are confusing. I do not understand all the supporting
details. 5 I am able to understand at least half of the main points
and some of the supporting details of the text. There are many new
words and expressions I do not understand. 4 I often get confused
when reading the text. I am unable to identify most of the main
points and supporting details. I understand about 30% of the text.
3 I understand very little of the text. I cannot identify the main
points or supporting details. The parts I do understand are
limited, e.g. title. 2/1 I do not understand the text. M E T H O D
O L O G Y - A S S E S S M E N T M A T E R I A L S
22. R E S U L T S - S E L F - R A T E D C O M P R E H E N S I O
N O N P O S T T E S T Summary: There was high variability in terms
of self-rated reading comprehension across the two groups after the
time- limited reading exercise. Control group rated their
comprehension of the text higher; non-parametric analysis showed
that the difference was significant (p < .05). 0.00 1.00 2.00
3.00 4.00 5.00 6.00 7.00 8.00 9.00 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14
15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 24 25 26 27 28 29 30 31
SelfRatedComprehension Case number Treatment Group Control
Group
23. M E T H O D O L O G Y - P O S T T E S T ( E N G L I S H / A
B R I D G E D ) Post-reading multiple choice This test has three
parts. Part A (Questions 1 - 7). The answer is directly stated in
the text. Part B (Qs 8 - 15). The answer is not directly stated in
the text, but implied. This means you have to deduce the answer
from context clues. Part C (Qs 16 - 18). The answer can be deduced
using critical thinking. Circle the answer that you think best
matches the information in the text. You have 20 minutes to
complete the test. Part A 1. The text states that the length of the
bridge that connects the island to the mainland is.... a) 3
kilometres long b) 4 kilometres long c) No information 2. The text
states that the material used to construct the man-made island
was.... a) concrete b) earth c) Both a) and b) Part B (Remember,
this information is NOT stated directly in the text. However, there
are clues in the text from which you can infer the answers) 8. The
text implies that businesses in the Kansai region were losing
business to Tokyo because... a) There was no international airport
in the Kansai Region. b) Businesses in Kansai do not have good
management. c) The international airport in Kansai could not be
developed any further. 9. The text implies that engineers could not
expand Itami Airport because of.... a) Lack of space. b) Lack of
money. c) Lack of space and local opposition. Part C (Remember,
this information is NOT in the text. You need to infer the answers)
16. There is a people mover system from one end of the terminal
building to the other because... a) It makes moving around the
building safer for passengers. b) It makes moving around the
building more enjoyable for passengers. c) It makes moving around
the building more convenient for passengers. 17. The island is
sinking because.... a) The materials used to construct the island
do not float. b) The weight of the island is causing seabed
subsidence. c) The sea levels are rising.
24. R E S U L T S - P R E / P O S T C O M P R E H E N S I O N T
E S T Summary: There was high variability in scores for both groups
in the 18-item pre- and post reading comprehension tests; in
non-parametric analysis baseline and post-test scores for the
control group were significantly higher (p < .05). 0.00 10.00
20.00 30.00 40.00 50.00 60.00 70.00 80.00 90.00 100.00 1 2 3 4 5 6
7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 24 25 26 27 28 29
30 31 Percentagescoreontest Case number Treatment Group (pre)
Control Group (pre) Treatment Group (post) Control Group
(post)
25. -12% 0% 12% 24% 36% 48% 60% 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13
14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 24 25 26 27 28 29 30 31
Relativepercentagegains Case number Treatment group Control group R
E S U L T S - R E L A T I V E P E R C E N T A G E G A I N S D U R I
N G S T U D Y P E R I O D Summary: Both groups improved over the
course of the study period; however the relative gains were
significantly higher in the mapping group in non-parametric
analysis (p < .05).
26. M E T H O D O L O G Y - M A P P I N G Q U E S T I O N N A I
R E Please read the following statements about the information
mapping activities that our class has done over the past two
months. For each statement tick one box only. A. Maps and texts a)
I could understand the information maps that were provided by the
teacher. Strongly agree Strongly disagree b) I could understand the
texts that were provided by the teacher. Strongly agree Strongly
disagree B. Reading skills a) Using information maps improved my
knowledge of text organization. Strongly agree Strongly disagree b)
Using information maps improved my knowledge of sentence
structures. Strongly agree Strongly disagree c) Overall, using
information maps improved my English reading skills. Strongly agree
Strongly disagree C. Reading confidence and motivation a) Using
information maps encouraged me to interact more closely with the
texts. Strongly agree Strongly disagree b) Using information maps
improved my reading confidence. Strongly agree Strongly disagree c)
Using information maps encouraged my interest in reading English.
Strongly agree Strongly disagree d) Overall, information mapping
was a useful activity for me. Strongly agree Strongly disagree
27. Strongly agree Agree Undecided Disagree Strongly disagree
Median Q1. I could understand the information maps that were
provided by the teacher 2.9% 68.6% 22.9% 5.7% 0 4 Q2. I could
understand the texts that were provided by the teacher. 5.7% 60%
25.7% 2.7% 0 4 Q3. Using information maps improved my knowledge of
text organization 11.4% 48.6% 34.3% 2.7% 0 4 Q.4 Using information
maps improved my knowledge of sentence structures 5.7% 40% 48.6%
5.7% 0 3 Q.5 Overall, using information maps improved my English
reading skills 8.6% 51.5% 28.7% 5.7% 0 4 Q.6 Using information maps
encouraged me to interact more closely with the texts 8.6% 34.3%
40% 17.2% 0 3 Q.7 Using information maps improved my reading
confidence 5.7% 31.4% 48.6% 11.4% 0 3 Q.8 Using information maps
encouraged my interest in reading English 5.7% 40% 48.6% 2.7% 0 3
Q.9 Overall, information mapping was a useful activity for me 5.7%
71.5% 17.2% 2.7% 0 4 R E S U L T S - M A P P I N G Q U E S T I O N
N A I R E ( E N G L I S H )
28. R E S U L T S - S U M M A R Y Student observations GO based
activites Improved overall reading skills Increased understanding
of text organisation ? Increased understanding of L2 sentence
structures, ? Increased L2 reading confidence ? Increased
motivation for L2 reading. Mapping questionnaireClassroom
observation program Teacher observations: GO-based activities.
Encouraged greater engagement and interaction with texts compared
to activities assigned to control group.
29. C O N C L U S I O N Higher actual comprehension gains in
treatment group Generally positive response to GO activities Higher
levels of engagement in reading tasks among treatment group
Overall, perhaps the clearest conclusion is that students respond
positively to new methodologies, which they have not encountered
before in language learning. Present study supports general claims
for GO use for teaching L2 reading