Transcript
Page 1: Using a Social Networking Site to Engage Students in Online Discussion about War

Using a Social Networking Site to Engage Students in Online Discussion

about WarJust War Ning

Page 2: Using a Social Networking Site to Engage Students in Online Discussion about War

Just War Home Page

Page 3: Using a Social Networking Site to Engage Students in Online Discussion about War

Participating TeachersBrian Bechard – Pioneer Ridge Middle School, Gardner,

Kansas (7th grade social studies)Thomas Fulbright – Hope Street Academy, Topeka,

Kansas (9th grade world history)Kori Green – El Dorado Middle School, El Dorado,

Kansas (8th grade U.S. history)Nick Lawrence – East Bronx Academy, Bronx, New

York (8th grade U.S. history)Jamie Sawatzky – Rocky Run Middle School, Chantilly,

Virginia (8th Grade U.S. history)

Page 4: Using a Social Networking Site to Engage Students in Online Discussion about War

Behind the ScenesDr. Joe O’Brien- University of Kansas

Professor of Social Studies EducationTina Ellsworth- University of Kansas

Doctoral Student

Page 5: Using a Social Networking Site to Engage Students in Online Discussion about War

2 Groups of StudentsSchool-based, face-to-face (f2f)

Groups (Used for f2f, synchronous discussions)

Interschool, online class period groups (Used for online

discussions)

Page 6: Using a Social Networking Site to Engage Students in Online Discussion about War

Sample School-based f2f Group Page

Page 7: Using a Social Networking Site to Engage Students in Online Discussion about War

Sample Online Discussion Group Page

Page 8: Using a Social Networking Site to Engage Students in Online Discussion about War

Instructional ApproachFormative Round: Students engage in f2f and

online discussion to generate list of reasons for what justifies going to war.

Application Rounds: Students engage in f2f and online discussion to apply their list of reasons to handful of hypothetical situations grounded in U.S. history

Summative Round: Students synthesize their list thinking, finalize the list, and present online to group of teachers in mock U.N. hearing.

Page 9: Using a Social Networking Site to Engage Students in Online Discussion about War

Common CoreGrade 6-8 Standards1. Write arguments focused on disciplined-specific

content: a. Introduce claims about a topic or issue…b. Support claims with logical reasoning…c. Use words, phrases, and clauses to create cohesion

and clarify the relationship(s) among claims, counterclaims, reasons, and evidence.

d. Establish and maintain a formal style.e. Provide a concluding statement or section that

follows from and support the argument presented.

Page 10: Using a Social Networking Site to Engage Students in Online Discussion about War

3 “Rounds” of Discussion:

Round 1 - FormativeStudents are placed in role of

advisor to the president as described earlier and post their

initial thinking. They then engage in online discussion between several classes of

students.

Page 11: Using a Social Networking Site to Engage Students in Online Discussion about War

Should this man use the U.S. armed forces or find another

solution?

Page 12: Using a Social Networking Site to Engage Students in Online Discussion about War

Students take on a similar roles with peers from 4

other schools…

Page 13: Using a Social Networking Site to Engage Students in Online Discussion about War

…on this site to engage in a series of online discussions

about what justifies war.

Page 14: Using a Social Networking Site to Engage Students in Online Discussion about War

As with any class or social situation there are

appropriate ways to act. For example…

Discussions depend upon respect for one another

Discussions are an exchange of ideas

 

Critique ideas, not people

 

Discussion require broad participation

 

Opinions are a beginning, reasoned thinking is the desired end

Page 15: Using a Social Networking Site to Engage Students in Online Discussion about War

How will we get started?Presentation to Students:Since you are the most important people in this

series of ongoing discussion, we would like to start by learning about what you think justifies a war.

To help you get started, we have created the following situation for you…

Page 16: Using a Social Networking Site to Engage Students in Online Discussion about War

Setting Stage: Opening ActivityOne of the hardest decisions a leader has to make is whether to send people off to fight,

and possibly to die.   While few people ever face such a decision, as citizens we are expected to elect a president who is required to make this decision.  What is it like to

confront such a decision? What should leaders consider when deciding whether to use military force against another nation?  What ideas might guide them when selecting

among several options? 

      While the president consults advisors, in the end the president alone decides.  On rare occasions the decision is an “easy” one.  After the Japanese bombed the U.S. navy at Pearl Harbor in Hawaii, President Franklin Roosevelt knew that declaring war was the right decision.  He realized though that a lot of people would die because of his “easy” decision.  At other times the decision is harder to make since what is right or just is not

as clear.  For example, how many people would have to die to make the decision to declare war against a nation a just decision?

        You are about to embark on a several month online journey with your classmates and those from around the U.S. to try and answer such questions.  You first will decide when it is just or okay for a leader to declare war against another nation.  You also will

discuss what types of military action are just or okay for a president to use against another nation.  For example, should a president use a nuclear bomb if this might help the U.S. win a war?  After crafting some guidelines for when a president is justified in

going to war and what military actions are justifiable to use, we will consider situations where presidents faced such decisions.

Page 17: Using a Social Networking Site to Engage Students in Online Discussion about War

The U. N. has asked each nation’s leader to decide on a list of reasons

that justify going to war

Page 18: Using a Social Networking Site to Engage Students in Online Discussion about War

What Reasons Justify Going to War?

In groups you need to answer this question…

Page 19: Using a Social Networking Site to Engage Students in Online Discussion about War

Student List of Justifiable Reasons to Go to War1. Self defense – another nation(s) attacks the U.S.

Examples include: A. Another nation bombs us

B. If U.S. ships are invaded C. Make sure soldiers/citizens outside U.S. have access

to food/shelter 2. “Preemptive” self-defense – if another nation seems

prepared to attack or harm U.S., then is justified in attacking first. Examples are:

A. Stop another nation from developing weapons of mass destruction.

B. If it appears another nation(s) planning to attack U.S.

C. Ensure national self-respect – if U.S. doesn’t act, other nations are likely to lose respect and believe U.S. won’t act if a future crisis arose.

Page 20: Using a Social Networking Site to Engage Students in Online Discussion about War

Reasons – cont.3. Help allies/friends – even if U.S. is not attacked, U.S. can go to war.

Examples include: A. Another nation forcing one of our allies to stop trading. B. Another nation is keeping us from entering our ally’s territory.

4. Protect what we believe in. There are some ideals or democratic principles that are so important, the U.S. needs to make sure that they are honored. Examples include:

A. Freedom – if another nation keeps a people from becoming free, then U.S. can go to war.

B. Religious beliefs – if another nation is killing or even persecuting people because of their religious beliefs, then it is okay to use military force to protect them.

C. Oppose dictators – the U.S. is permitted to remove bad dictators from power

Page 21: Using a Social Networking Site to Engage Students in Online Discussion about War

Reasons – Cont.5. Protect U.S. economic interests – health of U.S. depends

upon getting goods such as oil and food. If a nation keeps oil from U.S., then U.S. can use force to get the oil.

6. Protect innocent & punish the inhumane treatment of other people. Examples are:

A. Killed citizens on live television. B. Another nation is killing a large number of people. 7. A nation is not willing and/or able to stop something that

harms U.S. Examples are: A. Mexico & drug cartels are fighting a war. Mexico is unable

to stop flow of drugs into U.S. Also, U.S. citizens are getting killed in the drug war.

B. A nation can’t stop illegal shipping guns. These guns are a threat to U.S.

Page 22: Using a Social Networking Site to Engage Students in Online Discussion about War

Reasons – Cont.8. Stop war between other nations. If a war threatens

U.S. interests, such as the shipping of important goods such as oil or food.

 9. Fight threats to U.S. that are not caused by a nation.

Examples include: terrorism. 10. Remain strong – if other nations realize your

strength, then they are not likely to take advantage of you. It is okay to fight simply to prove that you can and you will.

Page 23: Using a Social Networking Site to Engage Students in Online Discussion about War

Chief Diplomat Page:Additional “Audience”

Page 24: Using a Social Networking Site to Engage Students in Online Discussion about War

TO: U.S. President and advisorsFROM: Joe O’Brien, International Delegate

First and foremost, I am very impressed with how well you have thought through this question of what justifies war. For those that had a chance to participate in the online discussion, your thinking and the respectful manner in which you carried on the discussion impressed me. I reviewed what you wrote, grouped together common ideas, and gave a name or title to each group of common ideas. For example, most everyone said that self-defense was a good or just reason to go to war. I used ideas expressed during the online discussion as examples of how you defined each group of common ideas. For example, when talking about self-defense, people said things like if another nation bombs the U.S. or attacked U.S. ships. Since so many people participated in the discussion, forgive me if you do not recognize your exact words.

On the following page is a list of reasons for going to war and examples to help explain each reason. The order of reasons roughly follows how much support each reason received. For example, since most everyone thought that self-defense was a reason to go to war, I put it first.

Page 25: Using a Social Networking Site to Engage Students in Online Discussion about War

Round 2 (Application)Last year, after generating list of reasons when

it is okay for a president to go to war, they applied their thinking to 5 hypothetical

situations, grounded in U.S. history. Added one for this year

Adams & undeclared war with FranceNative Americans

War of 1812Civil War

Spanish-American WarWorld War I

Page 26: Using a Social Networking Site to Engage Students in Online Discussion about War

Sampling Situations

Page 27: Using a Social Networking Site to Engage Students in Online Discussion about War

Setting StageDo you remember what it was like moving from

elementary to middle school? While exciting, for some of you, did it also seem a little scary? How big did the 8th graders seem to you at the time? How likely were you to socialize with 8th graders? In a way, new nations are like 6th graders entering a world school or society of nations. New nations typically are weaker, less confident, and have more to lose in a conflict than older nations.

Page 28: Using a Social Networking Site to Engage Students in Online Discussion about War

Historical Context Imagine you are a leader of a new nation called Jayhawk.

About 15 years ago you were a colony of the Bronx. You & many other people wanted to create an independent nation. Knowing the “enemy of my enemy is my friend,” you sought El Dorado’s help. The Bronx & El Dorado had fought each other for many decades. El Dorado agreed to become your ally or friend because it would hurt the Bronx. El Dorado’s help was crucial in the last battle of the war with the Bronx. While not happy, the Bronx agreed to let Jayhawk become a new nation. The violent struggle between the Bronx and El Dorado though had continued since Jayhawk became independent. To make matters worse, the El Dorado people became so angry with their ruler, they violently kicked him out. Many El Dorado people wanted a more democratic government. Jayhawk has found itself once again drawn into the struggle between the Bronx and El Dorado.

Page 29: Using a Social Networking Site to Engage Students in Online Discussion about War

Situation After the war, the Bronx became Jayhawk’s greatest trading partner. Jayhawk’s economic health depended upon good relations with the Bronx. Since Jayhawk traded with El Dorado as well, the Bronx started seizing Jayhawk commercial ships. Jayhawk’s prior leader wanted to protect trade with the Bronx. He made an agreement or treaty with the Bronx. As part of the agreement, the Bronx stopped seizing ships. This angered El Dorado’s leaders for several reasons. First, they had been Jayhawk’s ally since the nation’s beginning, yet Jayhawk now had made friends with the Bronx. Second, guaranteeing good trade or economic relations with Jayhawk better enabled the Bronx to fight El Dorado. Finally, the El Dorado leaders got rid of their ruler to become more democratic, yet Jayhawk had made friends with the Bronx ruler that they opposed 15 years ago. El Dorado felt betrayed and could not permit the Bronx to get stronger. El Dorado started seizing hundreds of defenseless Jayhawk’s trade ships headed to the Bronx. People in Jayhawk that oppose you want to end the treaty with the Bronx. They fear that the treaty takes Jayhawk back to when it was a colony of the Bronx. As the leader of Jayhawk, you think that war with the Bronx would prove disastrous. The revolution in El Dorado is continuing and getting more violent. As El Dorado continues to seize Jayhawk ships, your own supporters are demanding that Jayhawk go to war against El Dorado. Since you just learned that El Dorado tortured a Jayhawk ship’s captain, you understand why so many want war. What can you do? What should you do?

Page 30: Using a Social Networking Site to Engage Students in Online Discussion about War

“New Kid” (Adams & undeclared war with France) Discussion

Page 31: Using a Social Networking Site to Engage Students in Online Discussion about War

War of 1812You represent a young nation known as Jayhawk. While you have

a lot of land, your army & navy are very small. You have benefited from conflicts between 2 powerful nations. An ocean separates you from the 2 nations. 1 of the 2 nations, known as Topeka, has a large, strong navy & the other one, called Gardner, has a strong army. Both of them import food from your nation…

You are Topeka’s leader, a very powerful nation. You have territory on several continents & the strongest navy in the world. You have fought an on-again and off-again war with Gardner, another powerful nation. Gardner has conquered several nations on its continent & has a very strong army. You are concerned that Gardner will keep conquering nations until it controls the continent & then threaten your trade empire. Since Topeka is fairly small, yet with a large population, you need to import a lot of food from Jayhawk…

Page 32: Using a Social Networking Site to Engage Students in Online Discussion about War

Visual for War of 1812

Page 33: Using a Social Networking Site to Engage Students in Online Discussion about War

Final Activity: A Call for Clarity

Representatives of the United Nations Security Council seek your wisdom…

Page 34: Using a Social Networking Site to Engage Students in Online Discussion about War

Round 3 - Summative

Finalize List & Apply to Contemporary Situation

Spring, 2012 – Addressing the Situation in Syria

Participants:300 students

American Air Museum (UK) Project LeadersLeaders of NYC iZone Initiative

Additional Teachers and Colleagues

Page 35: Using a Social Networking Site to Engage Students in Online Discussion about War

A Call for Clarity

Page 36: Using a Social Networking Site to Engage Students in Online Discussion about War

International Delegates

Page 37: Using a Social Networking Site to Engage Students in Online Discussion about War
Page 38: Using a Social Networking Site to Engage Students in Online Discussion about War

So what did they decide?Tier I: Consensus

Self-defenseGet/Protect Resources

Stop inhumane treatment

Page 39: Using a Social Networking Site to Engage Students in Online Discussion about War

…and?Tier II: Majority or close to it

Protect what we believe in (freedom) Defend allies

Protect territory Assassination of a leader Tier III: Strong support

Prevent WMDs Fight to preserve peace

Page 40: Using a Social Networking Site to Engage Students in Online Discussion about War

Students Buy-InTeacher observationsSurvey resultsTenor of online commentsWhat do they like?The contentWorking with one anotherUsing technologyDoing something “real”Interacting with multiple audiences

Page 41: Using a Social Networking Site to Engage Students in Online Discussion about War

Making it Work!Curricular Alignment – while wars abound in state curricula,

some wars deemed more significant than others. Also, scope of U.S. history curricula differ.

Scheduling Logistics – different time zones & daily/weekly schedules. Just the beginning….

Technology Logistics – student access to social networking site; wireless access; availability of computers….

Online decorum – a need to socialize students to online academic discussion.

Integration into Ongoing Instruction – online discussion opportunity to enrich, not begin, thinking about topic.

Facilitating & Monitoring Discussion – synchronous, yet time lag due to keyboarding

Page 42: Using a Social Networking Site to Engage Students in Online Discussion about War

Next StepsFinesse use of online discussionBetter sequencing of online discussionsConduct content analysis of students entries across

course of year to chart the growth in their thinking Incorporate of more primary text documentsRefine alignment to the Common CoreExplore more mediums for interaction

Video (live and recorded), chat functions, etc.


Recommended