Module 7A for Elementary
Teachers
Florida Standards for ELA & Literacy: Focus on Assessment and Data Use
2
Professional Development Session Alignment
Set 1Governing Board
School Leaders Module 3PARCC
Module 6 Florida Standards Math Module 7
ELA & Data Use
Teachers Math
Leadership Teams Session 2
Session1
ELAData Use
Data Use ELA Math
Data Use
3
Professional Development Session Alignment
Set 2Governing Board
School Leaders
Module 5 Florida Standards ELA
Module 6 Florida Standards Math Module 7
ELA & Data Use
Module 8 Math & Data Use
Teachers Math
Leadership Teams
Session 4
Session3
ELAData Use
AssessmentsData
AnalysisVAM
Florida Standards
Data &ELA
Data &Math
Session 5
Session 6
4
Module 2FL CCRS
ELA
Module 1 Data Use
Module 3Math
Module 4 Data Use
Module 5 FL CCRS
ELA
Module 6 Math
Module 7 ELA & Data
Use
Module 8Math &
Data Use
You Are Here
Module 5ELA
Module 2ELA
5
Module 7A Outcomes
Understand the contributions that annual summative, ongoing interim, classroom performance tasks, and formative assessments make to a comprehensive assessment framework.
Incorporate principles of backward lesson design to create units that align with the Florida Standards for ELA & Literacy, essential questions, and assessments.
Use the EQuIP rubric and review process to assess the quality of Florida Standards for ELA & Literacy aligned units and lessons.
Use the instructional data cycle to analyze student work to make decisions regarding progress toward proficiency on the Florida Standards for ELA & Literacy and to inform instructional practice.
6
7
8 Components of Full Florida Standards Implementation
Today’s Agenda• Welcome and introductions• Pre-assessment• Purpose and use of annual summative
assessments• Interim assessments to inform instruction• Lunch• Designing units of instruction• Classroom performance task assessments • Classroom formative assessments• Instructional data-use cycle: Looking at
student work• Post-assessment
8
Pre-Assessment
Introductory Activity
9
Guide Page
5
Sharing Lesson Plans
Section 1
10
11
Activity 1: Sharing Aligned Lessons
Share Florida Standards for ELA & Literacy Aligned Lessons
1. In table groups of K-1, 2-3, and 4-5 teacher leaders, share your experiences developing and delivering Florida Standards for ELA & Literacy aligned lesson plans that specify:
•Text selection•Florida Standards for ELA & Literacy•Key ideas and understandings•Text-dependent questions•Targeted academic language•UDL technology and scaffolding support strategies for representation, expression, and engagement
What were breakthroughs, successes, challenges, and/or lessons learned?Where are you or your school in implementing aligned lessons?
2. Use the EQuIP rubrics to assess alignment relative to the standards, instructional shifts, and scaffolding support.
Guide Pages
7-8
Annual Summative Assessment
Section 2
12
• How are annual summative, interim, classroom performance tasks, and classroom formative assessments changing in response to the demands of the new Florida Standards?
Essential Question of the Day
13
14
Annual Summative Assessment
Interim Assessments
Classroom Summative Assessments
Classroom Formative Assessment
A Comprehensive Assessment System Includes:
Alig
nmen
t
Assessment Systems
Summative --- Annual student performance on a defined set of standards; for accountability or to inform policy.
Interim --- Ongoing, three to four times per year to predict student performance on the annual standards-based assessment.
Classroom Performance Tasks --- End of unit, quarter, or semester summative performance tasks or tests using rubrics that align with the Florida Standards for ELA & Literacy; also used formatively to inform instruction across classrooms within grades or courses.
Classroom Formative --- Everyday assessment embedded in current lessons; used to diagnose student learning gaps and help teachers improve teaching and student learning.
15
Fundamental Purpose of the Florida Standards for ELA & Literacy Annual Summative Assessment
16
The annual summative assessment is designed to assess proficiency on the Florida Standards for ELA & Literacy.
It affirms quality instruction aligned to the Standards, so the assessment will be worthy of preparation rather than a distraction from good work.
Purposes of the Annual Summative Assessment
17
Determine if students are college and career ready or on track
Assess the full range of the Florida Standards for ELA & Literacy and student performance
Provide data for accountability, including measures of growth
18
Transition from FCAT to FL Standards AssessmentsAssessments in 2012-13 and 2013-14 Assessments in 2014-15
FCAT 2.0 Reading Grades 3 to 10 Florida Standards English Language Arts Grades 3 to 11
FCAT 2.0 Writing Grades 4, 8, 10 No longer given
FCAT 2.0 Mathematics Grades 3 to 8 Florida Standards Mathematics Grades 3 to 8
Florida Algebra 1 EOC Florida Standards Algebra 1 EOC
Florida Geometry EOC Florida Standards Geometry EOC
New Florida Standards Algebra 2 EOC
FCAT 2.0 Science 5, 8 Same FCAT 2.0 Science 5, 8
Florida Biology 1 EOC Same Florida Biology 1 EOC
Florida US History EOC Same Florida US History EOC
Florida Civics EOC Same Florida Civics EOC
English Language Arts Instructional Shifts Toward College and Career Readiness
19
• Texts worth reading
• Questions worth answering
• Tasks worthy of engagement
• Fidelity to Florida Standards for ELA & Literacy
• Integration, integration, integration• reading, writing, language conventions, speaking, listening
from both literary and informational text
Implications of the Florida Standards for ELA & Literacy for Instruction and Assessment
20
Focus on citing evidence;possibly more than one
right answer.
Informational texts across a variety of
content areas.
Simulate research and performance-based components within
assessments.
Build and present knowledge through
research, comparison, and synthesis of ideas.
Read and compare sufficiently complex text independently.
Write effectively when using and analyzing
multiple sources; including narrative, expository, and
argumentative writing.
Not just ELA but a full range of reading and writing across the disciplines of science and social studies.
English Language Arts & Literacy Assessment Shifts
21
Grades 4-5 FSA ELA Writing Prompt
22
Activity 2: Annual Summative Assessment
23
Annual Summative Assessment
1. In table groups of K-1, 2-3, and 4-5 teacher leaders, review the sample annual summative assessment performance task items.
2. On the right side of the page summarize what students must know and be able to do to show proficiency on each of these items.
3. How will your instructional approaches change to align with Florida Standards for ELA & Literacy performance tasks as part of the annual summative assessment? What changes will you expect to see in students’ literacy practices?
Guide Pages 10-13
Let’s Take A Break
24
Be back in 15 minutes….
Interim Assessments (FAIR-FS)
Section 3
25
26
Annual Summative Assessment
Interim Assessments
Classroom Summative Assessments
Classroom Formative Assessment
A Comprehensive Assessment System Includes:
Alig
nmen
t
Interim assessments are given over specified time intervals
Universal screeners Predictive assessments including predicting
likely performance on the annual summative assessment
Snapshot (3-4 times per year) Scale scores for growth Provide formative information to target
instruction to student needs
27
What is the FAIR-FS for ELA?
• A screening and diagnostic assessment to monitor student progress 3 times per year
• FAIR-FS tasks aligned with the strands of the ELA Florida Standards
• K – 2 FAIR-FS: A computer-adaptive system that is administered one-on-one
• 3 – 10 FAIR-FS: A computer-adaptive system; provides information about individual standards as well as probability of literary success (PLS) on summative assessment
Resource: FAIR Aligned to CCSS ELA Presentation FCRR, 2013
28
3-10 FAIRVocabularyWord RecognitionReading Comprehension84% and below- additional testing ↓Syntactic Knowledge (Diagnostic)
MAZE and Word Analysis now retired
Optional Open-Response Item Bank- oral fluency, oral & written response
Yields a Probability of Literary Success (PLS) on Florida’s annual summative assessment
2014-15 FAIR for ELA
29Resource: FAIR Aligned to CCSS ELA Presentation FCRR, 2013
1. Which reading skills are strengths and weaknesses for each student?
2. What skills should be targeted in order to improve reading comprehension?
3. What is the likelihood that the student will be proficient on the end of year assessment?
4. Has the student made progress since the last administration? (if FAIR-FS was taken previously)
Questions Assessed by FAIR
30
Resource: FAIR Aligned to CCSS ELA Presentation FCRR, 2013
Item Bank and Test Platform (IBTP)
Districts can build and administer local assessments;compose, review, construct, deliver, and score items based on course content standards
Provides item bank in all subject areas
Formative, interim, and summative assessment purposes
Not a part of the teacher accountability system
Florida Interim Assessment Item Bank
31
Activity 3: FAIR/Florida Interim Assessments
32
Discuss Curriculum, Instruction, and Assessment PracticesIn table groups of K-1, 2-3, and 4-5 teacher leaders, think about the curriculum, instruction, and assessment practices at your school.
• Does your ELA and Literacy and Content Area curriculum provide enough instruction, support, and practice to help students show progress on FAIR and Florida’s annual summative assessment?
• Do your instructional practices provide enough instruction, support, and practice to help students show progress on FAIR and Florida’s annual summative assessment? Your assessment practices?
• What more will be needed?
Guide Page
15
Classroom Assessments and Backward Design
Section 4
33
A Comprehensive Assessment System Includes:
34
Annual Summative Assessment
Interim Assessments
Classroom Summative Assessments
Classroom Formative Assessment
Alig
nmen
t
Place your DOT on the chart paper under the heading that best describes your level of comfort with the following:
Aligning Florida Standards to objectives, creating aligned ‘I can’ statements, essential questions, formative assessments, performance-based summative assessments, and rubrics and scales in order to determine proficiency on the Florida Standards.
Take a DOT
35
1Need to
Know More
2Somewhat
Comfortable
3Comfortable
4Can teach
this to someone
else
Aligning Assessments to Standards
Florida’s ‘New Way to Work’: Process for developing an assessment that aligns with the Florida Standards
Choose one or more standards to address
Chunk the course content standards and identify the “big ideas” that each standard requires, including what students will know and what students will be able to do
Develop learning goals and describe learning progressions or scales that align to the standard(s) and the big ideas
Design an assessment that will enable students to demonstrate mastery of the learning goals
Check to ensure the assessment aligns to all sections of the standard and learning goals
Plan how to evaluate, provide feedback for growth, and score student work
36
Guide Page
17
37
BACKWARD DESIGN
(Wiggins & McTighe, 2005)
1. Identify desired result
2. Determine acceptable evidence
3. Plan learning experiences and instruction
Stage 1: DESIRED RESULTS – standards, objectives, ‘I can’ statements, big ideas, and aligned essential questions.
Stage 2: EVIDENCE OF LEARNING - performance tasks and other assessments aligned to the standards and assessment shifts with UDL supports.
Stage 3: LEARNING ACTIVITIES - aligned to the standard, instructional shifts, and assessments with UDL supports.
Backward Design of Units and Lessons
38(Wiggins & McTighe, 2011)
• Stage 1: What should my students know and be able to do by the end of this unit?
• Stage 2: How will I know and how will they know if they have learned it?
• Stage 3: What do I need to do to get them there? What do I do if they need more? (accelerate or remediate)
Unit Backward Design Questions
39
Bon Appétit
40
Stage 1: What should my students know and be able to do by the end of this unit?
41
Text sets Standards Objectives‘I Can’ statements ‘BIG IDEAS’ Essential Questions (up to 2)
Stage 1: Determine Desired Results
42
LAFS.4.RL.2.6: Compare and contrast the point of view from which different stories are narrated, including the difference between first- and third-person narrations.
Objectives What do you want your students to know and be able to do?
1. Understand and recognize point of view.2. Understand how a story is impacted by points of view.3. Compare and contrast stories based on point of view.
Standard
43
LAFS.RI.3.9: Compare and contrast the most important points and key details presented in two texts on the same topic.
Objectives What do you want your students to know and be able to do?
1. 2. 3.
Your Turn
44
Guide Page
18
‘I Can’ Statements
‘I Can’ statements clarify expectations for students and teachers. • Create ‘I can’ statements for each standard assessed in the unit. • Create the statements from the standard using student-friendly
terms.
45
LAFS.3.RI.1.1 Ask and answer questions to demonstrate understanding of a text, referring to the text as a basis for the answers.
I can ask questions to show that I understand the text. I can answer questions to show that I understand the text. I can go back into the text and show where I found my answers.
LAFS.4.RL.2.6: Compare and contrast the point of view from which different stories are narrated, including the difference between first- and third-person narrations.
Objectives What do you want your students to know and be able to do?
1. Understand and recognize point of view2. Understand how a story is impacted by points of view.3. Compare and contrast stories based on point of view.
Create ‘I can’ Statements 1. I can recognize different points of view. 2. I understand how the point of view of a story can impact a story. 3. I can compare and contrast stories according to their points of
view.
46
LAFS.RI.3.9: Compare and contrast the most important points and key details presented in two texts on the same topic.
Objectives What do you want your students to know and be able to do?
1. 2. 3.
Create ‘I can’ Statements from Objectives
Your Turn
47
Guide Page
18
Stage 1: Effective Essential Questions for a Unit
Essential Questionso Set the focus of the unito Raise other questionso Require support and justificationo Identify what students will be able to do and know o Assist in determining proficiencyo Lead to deep and critical discussions, debate, and writing
(Wiggins & McTighe, 2013)
1. How does fear threaten freedom? 2. How can people be a catalyst for change? 3. What makes a good writer great? 4. When is blindness not physical? 5. How are themes developed by writers? 6. What is effective research?
48
Essential Questions and Guiding Questions
49
Overarching UnitEssential Question(s)
Lesson GuidingQuestions
Text-based Questions
Lesson GuidingQuestions
Text-based Questions
(Wiggins & McTighe, 2013)
ELA Essential Questions and Guiding Questions
50
How do authors develop points of view?
What are the different kinds of points of view?
Text-based Questions
How does the author develop the point of
view of… in…
Text-based Questions
Content Essential and Guiding Questions
51
Why do people migrate?What factors caused migration in the early
1900’s?
Text-based Questions
What factors cause today’s global
migration?
Text-based Questions
Guide Page 19
1. Align to Florida Standards for ELA and Literacy2. Ask higher order, open ended questions3. Get students to think and discuss more by asking:
How do you know?What makes you say that?What evidence proves your point?
ORTurn to a different student and ask: Why do you think student X said that? Do you agree with X’s thinking/ Disagree? What’s your evidence?
Deepening Students’ Understanding
52
Stage #2: Determine Evidence of Learning
53
How will I know, and how will they know, if they have learned it?
Instructional Cycle
Instruction Formative Assessment
EnrichmentInstruction
Summative Assessment Re-teach
no
54
Assessments aligned to standards Performance-based tasks Aligned scales or rubrics Various assessments: pre-assessment, formative, summative,
and self-assessments Universal Design for Learning supports by providing flexible and
multiple means for expression
Remember to include the essential questions and guiding questions as a part of the summative assessments.
Stage #2: Determine Evidence of Learning
55
Stage #2: How will I know and how will they know if they have learned it? Summative Assessment: Determine Evidence of Learning
1. Select Response (MC, T/F, Matching, Fill-in)2. Written Response - short or extended essays3. Oral Evidence - interview and conferencing4. End of Unit Performance-Based Tasks
56
57
Performance-Based Assessment“Performance-based learning and assessment represent a set
of strategies for the acquisition and application of knowledge, skills, and work habits through the performance
of tasks that are meaningful and engaging to students.”
Features:• Demonstrate knowledge; thinking critically and deeply in
addressing the topics in both writing and speaking• Cite research and evidence from multiple sources• Guidelines, rubrics, or scales aligned to Florida Standards
provide guidance for students to demonstrate proficiency
Hibbard, K.M., Van Wagemen, L., Lewbel, S., & Waterbury-Wyatt, S.
Teacher's Guide to Performance-Based Learning and Assessment. 1995
58
Objective, I Can, Essential Question, and End-of-Unit Performance Task
Objective Specify the critical content that students will learn in this unit.Example: Students will examine academic language, read complex texts, and write an argument supported by textual evidence.
Create ‘I Can’ Statements
I can write an argument supported by evidence in the text.
Essential Question Specify 1 - 2 essential questions that will be the basis of the end-of-unit performance assessment.Example: How do authors present an argument in a text? How do authors use academic language to strengthen their argument?
End-of-Unit Performance Task
Specify the common assessment performance task relative to the focus standards. Example: Students will compose an argument using supporting evidence from _________ text.
Team determined common assessment for unit
59
Padagogy Wheel by A. Carringtonwww.edudemic.com
Guide Page
20
o Diary entrieso Different ending to a storyo Brochures and pamphletso Wiki entrieso Character sketcheso Myths and Fableso Playso Book reviewso Interviewso Articleso Letterso Short storieso EditorialsoTestimonials
o Speecheso Sequelso Multimedia presentationso TV /Movie scriptso Diagrams, charts, graphso Displayso Science fictiono Reportso Illustrationso Answer Essential Question with Evidence o SatiresoArgumentso With Rubrics or Scales
Types of Performance-Based Tasks
60
Guide Page
21
Building a Performance Task
61
GRASPSGOAL Provide a statement of the task.
Establish the goal, problem, challenge, or obstacle in the task.
ROLE Define the role of the students in the task.State the job of the students for the task.
AUDIENCE Identify the target audience within the context of the scenario.Example audiences might include classmates or parents.
SITUATION Set the context of the scenario.Explain the situation.
PRODUCT Clarify what the students will create and why they will create it.
STANDARDS & CRITERIA INDICATOR(S)
Provide students with a clear picture of success.Identify specific standards for success.Issue rubrics to the students or develop them with the students.
GRASPS Ideas
62
G Design, teach, explain, inform, create, persuade, defend, critique, improve
R Advertiser, illustrator, coach, candidate, eyewitness, newscaster, editor, news show host, politician
A Classmates, neighbors, pen pals, travel agent, jury, celebrity, historical figure, community, school board, government
S The context of the situation – Create a real life scenario
P Essay, letter, advertisement, script, debate, story, proposal, brochure, slide show, performance
S What success looks like: Scoring guide, rubric, and examples
After reading chapters 1 – 7 of Sarah Plain and Tall, think about the decision Sarah must make to stay or go back to live with her brother.
1. Think about what you would do. Now, what do you think Sarah should do?
2. Pretend you are a good friend of Sarah’s. Write a letter to Sarah giving her advice on what to do. Make certain to support your opinion with evidence from the text.
3. You will present your letter to Sarah as a speech to the class. The class will use a listening rubric to determine how well you support your point of view.
Assessed Standard: LAFS.3.RL 2.6 Distinguish their own pointof view from those of the narrator or character.
Elementary Example
63
Guide Page
21
LAFS.RI.3.9: Compare and contrast the most important points and key details presented in two texts on the same topic.
1. Read the 2 texts about The Best Pet in the Vermont Writing Collaborative handout.
2. In grades K-1, 2-3 or 4-5 teams of 2 to 4, use the Types of Performance Tasks, Bloom’s Wheel, the GRASPS acronym for Building a Performance Task and the above standard to build an end of unit performance task that addresses the identified standard. On a piece of chart paper list:
a) Additional standards, objective(s) and ‘I Can’ statement(s)b) An essential question(s) for the unit
c) A performance task indicating Goal, Role, Audience, Situation, Product, Standards
3. Place your work on the wall for your grade band, K-1, 2-3, 4-5.
Activity 4: Building Performance Tasks
64
Guide Page
22
The performance task provides evidence that students are able to use their knowledge in context.
Rubrics help determine the levelof proficiency on the performancetask.
Rubrics Aligned with Standards
65
Rubrics are reviewed with the students when the performance task is assigned so expectations and criteria for success are explicitly understood.
66
Determine the criteria
Establish exemplary
performance
Define the lowest level of
performance
Identify what is between the top and the bottom
Write clear expectations that lead to corrective
feedback
4. Exemplary“4” goes beyond what is required.
3. Proficient“3” should reflect the target for the student.
2. Foundational Knowledge“2” should reflect some prerequisite knowledge that is
necessary to accomplish the goal identified in “3.”1. Little understanding or skill
“1” indicates that much support is still needed.0. No understanding
Simple Four Point Rubric
67
68
Align Standards, Objectives, and Rubric
LAFS.4.RL.1.3: Describe in depth a character, setting, or event in a story or drama, drawing on specific details in a text (e.g., a character’s thoughts, words, or actions).
4 In addition to score 3.0 performance, the student demonstrates the standards with in-depth inferences and applications beyond what was taught.
3 The student describes in-depth characters, settings, or events in a story or drama, drawing on specific details in the text.
2 The student recognizes characters, settings, or events from a story or drama; identifies details that support the description of a character, setting, or event in a story or drama.
1 The student demonstrates partial understanding of some of the score 2.0 elements.
Rubrics Review these Elk Grove California sample rubrics • K-5 Opinion/Argument Rubrics• K-5 Informational/Explanatory Rubrics• K-5 Narrative RubricsRetrieved from http://blogs.egusd.net/ccss/educators/ela/rubrics-k-12/. Reprinted with permission.
Other sources for rubrics• CPALMS- Most lessons each have attached rubrics.• RubiStar is a free tool to help teachers create quality rubrics.
http://rubistar.4teachers.org• iRubric is a free comprehensive rubric development, assessment, and
sharing tool. http://www.rcampus.com/indexrubric.cfm
Guide Pages 48-54
69
Stage 3: Determine Learning ActivitiesWhat do I need to do to get them there? What do I do if they need more? In Modules 2 and 5, we considered:
70
UDL Coding the Text
Close Reading
Academic Language
71
Formative Assessment “a process to continuously gather evidence
and provide feedback about learning while instruction is underway.”
Heritage, Kim, Vendelinski and Herman (2009)
Other features: On-going, every day in classroom Provides immediate feedback Student-centered Helps instructional decision-making Identifies gaps Most likely type of assessment to immediately impact instruction
How often do we do this?.
72
Everybody got it?Does everyone understand?Does that make sense?Everybody O.K.?... Let’s move on.ORCall on students that may have it right.
A Teacher’s Daily Practice Video
73
Discussion prompts:
1. How does formative assessment help to inform instruction?2. What makes for effective formative assessment?3. How could you adapt the three categories of feedback for
your classroom?4. What other questions would you consider asking your
students?Guide Page 23
Take out a sheet of paper and list as many characteristics of …..as much evidence as you can find that…as many applications of…How ____and____ are alike (or different)
D o t s , P o l l s , R e s p o n s e C a r d s
- I don’t understand yet - I need more help - I can do this by myself - I can teach someone else
L i s t i n g
74
On an index card• students summarize the big ideas of the lesson
and any sticking points• or ask a question
Or complete these stems• Something I learned…• Something I still don’t understand…• Something more I need to know…• Something I need you to know…
T i c ke t O u t t h e D o o r
75
Compare notes with a partner:• Summarize the most important information.• Identify (and clarify if possible) any sticking points.• Make additions to your own notes.
Take a minute to come up with 3 text-dependent questions together.• See if you can stump another pair.• Ask your best question to the class.
76
Discussion Prompt: Share ideas of what processesand practices you use to gather evidence of learning while learning is underway.
R e v i e w t h eFo r m a t i v e
A s s e s s m e n tE x a m p l e s
77
78
Timely Specific Understandable Actionable Questions
1. Begin with a description of the expected performance.
2. Follow with specific guidelines of what to continue doing, then what to change.
3. Pose a question to extend thinking. (example: How do you think this can be improved?)
4. End with encouragement to persist.
5. Ask students to re-do and provide one-on-one time to discuss.
Feedback 101
79
Backward Design Review
80
Determine Multiple Standards
Create Objectives
and‘I Can’
Statements
Consider the BIG
Ideas and Create
Essential Questions
Develop Formative
and Summativ
e Assessme
nts
Align Learning Activities
and Experienc
es
Place it on the chart paper under the heading that now best describes your level of comfort with aligning:
• Florida Standards to objectives, creating aligned ‘I can’ statements, essential questions, formative assessments, performance-based tasks, and rubrics and scales in order to determine proficiency on the standards.
Take a different colored DOT
81
1Need to
Know More
2Somewhat
Comfortable
3Comfortable
4Can teach
this to someone
else
How can analysis of student work help plan future lessons?
Think About It…
82
“The work that kids produce is the most tangible evidence we have of our effectiveness as teachers. That work warrants our close scrutiny.”
-Ann Borthwick
Looking at Student Work: Format
• Focus on the work, the learning it reveals, and on instructional decisions that might be made based upon this analysis.
• Select several work samples; low-medium-high.• Engage in discussion of colleagues’ interpretations
of the student work samples using the protocol.• Reflect on the implications and applications of
what is learned to teaching.• Reflect on the one-on-one feedback you will
provide to the student.
Looking at Student Work website http://www.lasw.org
Examining Student Work Protocol
Part I: ProficiencyWhat do I want my students to know and be able to do?
Standards addressed?What was mastery/proficiency?Did the assignment and rubric measure proficiency?
Part II: Diagnosing Strengths and WeaknessWhere are my students? How do I know?
What did the student demonstrate?What wasn’t the student able to demonstrate?What information was wrong or missing?What did an error analysis show?
Part III: Effective FeedbackWhat feedback do I give that will inform and instruct?
What questions do I ask?What feedback will I give in a conference to promote thinking?
Part IV: Next Instructional StepsWhat do I do if they know?What do I do if they don’t?
What and who need re-teaching?Who needs enhancements and extensions?
84Source: School Improvement in Marylandhttp://mdk12.org/data/examining/protocol.html
Guide Page
25
Activity 5: Reviewing Student Work
85
Reviewing Student WorkLook at the student work samples on pages 28-32 in your Participant Guide. Using the rubrics on pages 26-27 and the protocol for looking at student work on page 25, discuss each sample and answer these questions from the protocol:
What standards are addressed? What was mastery/proficiency?Did the assignment and rubric measure proficiency on the standard?
What did the student demonstrate? What wasn’t the student able to demonstrate?What information was wrong or missing? What did an error analysis show?
What questions do I ask the student?What feedback will I give in a conference to promote thinking? Guide
Pages 24-32
Activity 6: Reviewing Lessons
86
Review Your Lessons1. In the Participant Guide on page 33, answer the big question: How are classroom
assessments changing in response to Florida Standards for ELA & Literacy?
2. Revisit your lessons. Discuss adding to your lessons the following:Overarching EQs and Guiding Questions, ‘I Can’ Statements, Formative Assessments and Summative Assessments,Performance Tasks, and Rubrics.
3. View sample lessons and lesson templates on pages 34-42 of the Participant Guide and discuss how UDL principles and accommodations can be utilized for students who may need more including: multiple means of expression, representation or engagement.
Guide Pages33-42
87
Essential Questions for Teachers
Did I offer my students a challenging and rigorous World Class Education?
Did I give them something to talk about? Think about?
If I were a student, would I have wanted to be in my class today?
Closing Activities
88
Module 7A Outcomes
Understand the contributions that annual summative, ongoing interim, classroom performance tasks, and formative assessments make to a comprehensive assessment framework.
Incorporate principles of backward lesson design to create units that align with the Florida Standards for ELA & Literacy, essential questions, and assessments.
Use the EQuIP rubric and review process to assess the quality of Florida Standards for ELA & Literacy aligned units and lessons.
Use the instructional data cycle to analyze student work to make decisions regarding progress toward proficiency on the Florida Standards for ELA & Literacy and to inform instructional practice.
89
Where are you now?
Assessing Your Learning
Post-Assessment and Session Evaluation
90
Guide Page
44