1
An Innovative and Proven Solution for Repelling Water Ingress into
Concretes Structure
Dr Ian McFeat Smith
Technical Directors, Hydrotech Asia Ltd
2
80% of all concrete failures in buildings and structures in Hong Kong are caused by WATER INGRESS.(Chris Stanley, Chairman HKCRA)
3
How does Water Ingress Occur ?
• Water penetrates concrete fabric by three primary mechanisms:
. Capillary action.
. Temperature differentials.
. Hydraulic pressure.
• “Water drawn into concrete by capillary action is over 10,000 times more powerful than gravity”. Prof. Andreas B. Fourie (Australian Centre for Geomechanics)
• The smaller the pores the greater the capillary action. 4
Early Stage in Hydration of Portland Cement Cement Hydration after 25 days
5 6
Capillary forces draw water up sides of tubeCohesion and Adhesion
7
Capillary Action through Pile Foundations, Floor Slabs and Walls
8
Horizontal Capillary Action Through Walls
9
Can we find a Cost Effective and
Permanent Solutionto Water Ingress problem?
10
MULTI-PULSE SEQUENCING SYSTEM
IS A VIABLE SOLUTION TO STOP WATER INGRESS INTO
CONCRETE STRUCTURES
MPS MPS ®
11
What is Multi Pulse Sequencing System and the scientific principle behind it?
Multi-Pulse Sequencing (MPS) System is a highly advanced form of electro-osmotic technology that uses low voltage and low current to ionise water and direct it to a specific area.
12
13
MPSMPS® –– Multi Pulse Sequencing SystemMulti Pulse Sequencing System
• 1807, the German professor Russ, who was living in Russia discovered the theory and principles behind the movement of liquids in capillary structures.
• in 1930. The Ernst brothers in Switzerland discovered how to move fluids in capillary structures through applying an electrical charge between a cathode and electrode
• in 1962. Principles behind the effect was established by E Franke. Subsequent experiments by Prof. Andreas Fourie at Newcastle U/T University over 10 years to move water in concrete failed, because there was no efficient control system.
• In 1987, the Norwegian inventor Kjell Aage Utklev discovered that a pulsating current would continue to transport water in concrete for as long as the current was applied.
• In 1988 this discovery was patented in 1988. Kjell Aage Utklev is a shareholder and consultant to Hydrotech International.
• MPS is new technology, but the principles are universal.
Brief History of the Technology
14
The MPS System in action
Underground water source
Reclaimed Land
Negative Electrode
• Using 240 volt transformed down to 40 volts DC • Water molecules are pushed back into the water table.• We can counter up to 60 bar of pressure• The system works continuously however after drying the power usage falls to a minimum level • Normal drying time is ONLY 4 to 8 weeks• The structure stays permanently dry
MPS Control Equipment
Positive Electrode
15 16
17
DIFFERENCE BETWEEN ELECTRO-OSMOSIS AND CATHODIC PROTECTION
1. CATHODIC PROTECTION HAS SACRIFICIAL ANODE WHILST ELECTRO-OSMOSIS DO NOT.
2. CATHODIC PROTECTION CONNECTS TO THE REBARS WHILST ELECTRO-OSMOSIS DOES NOT.
18
MPS System InstallationMPS System Installation
19 20
21
A marine concrete structure in Chai Wan that started to deteriorate before the construction was complete.
22
Alkali - Glass ReactionDeterioration of mosaic clad render
23
Spalling of concrete from expansion of rebar leading to secondary corrosion
24
Water Ingress is One of the Oldest Problems in Civil Engineering For this Tunnel Singapore spent
millions fixing the cracks but the water ingress problem remained
Water ingress accelerates the degradation of the structure
25
Attempts at repair
Flooding
Examples of Asset Degradation caused by Water Ingress
26
Water leaking through construction fissures
Large area of water ingress leading to stray current issues.
27
Mould, Odour, Airbourne Bacteria
How water ingress can manifest itself
28
Chinese Electronic Periodical Services 21/12/07
Results from Testing Air Quality and Odour Problems in Shenzhen Metro
99.2% of 9460 samples yielded bacteria
100% yielded Mycete
11 Hemolytic Streptococcus
CONCLUSION: The contamination in the air of Shenzhen Metro is very serious.
29
Review of some options for WATERPROOFING CONCRETE
• Concrete can be made waterproof using admixturesthat are mainly pore-blockers
• Concrete structures can be made waterproof by means of sheet or spray membranes
• Grouting using Jetting methods can be applied to adjacent ground
• Multiple Pulse Sequencing (MPS) using electro-osmosis can be installed on walls and slabs of existing and new build structures.
30
THE MULTIPLE INSTALLATION PROCESS FOR MEMBRANES IS COMPLEX, TIME CONSUMING, INVOLVES THE USE OF EXPENSIVE MATERIALS AND IS
THEREFORE HIGHLY EXPENSIVE
31
BUCKLING AND WRINKLING OF MEMBRANES COMMONLY OCCUR. DAMAGE RESULTS FROM INSTALLING ANCHORS,
CUTTING MEMBRANE TO SUIT SHAPES
32
• This had to be grouted as shown.
• Supplier advises that membrane can only be applied to dry surfaces ?
33
REPAIRS TO EXISTING STRUCTURES
OBJECTIVES CRACK REPAIRS - SPRAY ON RESINS COATINGS
CRACK INJECTION
Preventing capillary actionSealing large cracks >0.2mmMinimise cracking from corroding steelWater exclusion
Long term humidity, mold and odor controlCost - Installation
Savings Heating/Ventilation/A/CPerformance Monitoring
-Effective -Partially effective - Marginal n/a - not applicable34
REPAIRS TO EXISTING STRUCTURES
OBJECTIVES CRACK REPAIRS - SPRAY ON RESINS COATINGS
CRACK INJECTION
Preventing capillary action
n/a n/a
Sealing large cracks >0.2mmMinimise cracking from corroding steelWater exclusion
Long term humidity, mould and odour controlCost - Installation High – does not stop water ingress High – does not stop water ingress
Savings Heating/Ventilation/A/C
n/a n/a
Performance Monitoring
n/a n/a
-Effective -Partially effective - Marginal n/a - not applicable
35
WATER INGRESS PROTECTION FOR NEW CONCRETE STRUCTURES
OBJECTIVES
ADMIXTURES MEMBRANESGROUTING
OF GROUNDSHRINKAGE REDUCTION
CAPILLARY ABSORPTION REDUCTION
SHEET(OUTSIDE
CONCRETE)
SPRAY - ON(INSIDE AT AIR
INTERFACE)
Reducing / preventing capillary absorption
Minimise ingress through cracking*
Long term water exclusion
Prevent corrosion of rebar
Long term humidity,odourand mould control
Heating/Vent/A-C Savings
Performance Monitoring
*Thermal and shrinkage cracking
- Effective - Partially effective - Marginal n/a - not applicable
36
WATER INGRESS PROTECTION FOR NEW CONCRETE STRUCTURES
AIMS
ADMIXTURES MEMBRANESGROUTING
OF GROUNDSHRINKAGE REDUCTION
CAPILLARY ABSORPTION REDUCTION
SHEET(OUTSIDE
CONCRETE)
SPRAY - ON(INSIDE AT AIR
INTERFACE)
Reducing / preventing capillary absorption n/a n/a n/a n/a
Minimise ingress through cracking* n/a n/a n/a n/a
Long term water exclusion
Prevent corrosion of rebar
Long term humidity,odorand mold control
Heating/Vent/A-C Savings n/a n/a n/a n/a n/a
Performance Monitoring n/a n/a n/a n/a n/a
*Thermal and shrinkage cracking
- Effective - Partially effective - Marginal n/a - not applicable
37
MPS Scope of Application
• Underground projects such as railway stations, car parks and all other basement structures
• Tunnels such as road and rail, pedestrian tunnels, cable and gas and other tunnels.
• Hydroelectric and dam projects etc
• Marine structures, underwater foundation projects and embankments
• Bridges and viaducts.
38
Examples of Significant Projects
LondonLondon Underground Railway StationWalthamstow Central Subway
Hong Kong International Finance CentreHong Kong Central Station, Airport ExpressHong Kong Hang Seng Bank HeadquartersCity Plaza Taikoo Shing CentreHong Kong XinHua Agency
China Projects
Norway ProjectsTafjord DamSira Kvina Power StationDrammen Central Railway StationSkien Central Railway StationOslo Housing Society (OBOS)Norway National Museum
Zheng Zhou High-tension Electric Cable Tunnel
Projects under investigationWarehouse Basement, Kowloon Tong (completed)Zhongliang Highway Tunnels, ChongqingFengman Dam, Jilin ProvinceGuangzhou Metro Railway tunnels, Chonqing, Metro Station
39
MTRC Central Station, Artwork Area
40
No MPS installation at theRight behind of the Artwork
MPS System was installed at the Left behind the Artwork
41
Before MPS Installation
After MPS Installation
42
International Finance Centre One, Hong Kong
Year: 2000 Location: Hong KongProject: Lift Machine RoomClient: Hendersonland
Background:
• Severe saline water ingress through the walls resulted in a lift machine room being extensively flooded
• All the plant was submerged.
• Following installation of MPS in 2000, water ingress has been completely ceased.
MPS System Control Unit Installation
43
• IFC below Car park Area• Machine Room flooded out• Completely dried out after
MPS Installation
44
• CITY PLAZA 4 Loading Area• Diaphragm wall was saturated
due to flooding from ground water ingress
• Frustrated, Swire Properties tested several methods for preventing water ingress
• MPS selected as the only successful method
• Wall remains bone dry after 10 years of monitoring
• Maintenance costs are negligible
45
Electrode Placement in City Plaza 4
46
Walthamstow London Underground Station Central Subway. MPS Works
47
Walthamstow Station - Central subway. MPS Circuits in Subway
48MPS Layout at Walthamstow
49 50
Electro-Magnetic ComplianceCertificate
51
Water ingress problem at the Underground Railway in Singapore
7th May 2008
52
Oslo Central Railway Station
Year: 1990 Location: NorwayProject: Central Railway StationClient: NSB AS
Background:• Water ingress had occurred in block work located 100 meters from the sea and below ground water level.
• The wall had been constructed with an external membrane and back filled.
• In 1990, anode lines were installed in the inside wall with an external ground spear.
•The problem has been completely solved
53
TAFJORD Dam Norway
Year: 1997 Location: NorwayProject: Dam StructureClient: S.N. Electric Company
Background:• The concrete dam in Tafjord is Europe’s second highest at 96meters.
• The structure is 12 meters thick at the top and 40meters thick at its base.
• By early 1990’s, a number of cracks were appearing that resulted in significant leakage. On the assumption that nothing could be done to remedy the situation, the structure was eventually condemned and schedule for demolition.
• Electro-osmotic technology was employed to address the defects and the leakage was stopped.
• Following on from the drying process, the physical cracks could be repaired by conventional sealing methods.
•The problem did not reoccur54
Sira-Kvina Power Station
Year: 1992
Location: Norway
Project: Power Station
Client: S.N. Electric Company
61
FACT MPS Removes the Need to
Waterproof Concrete
62
MPS System Permanently Protects your structure from Water Ingress
Cost BenefitThe cost of MPS is less than
HK$ 150/m2
The cost of repairing concrete damaged by water ingress is more than
HK$4,000/m2
Enormous savings in life-cycle costs
63
WATER INGRESS PROTECTION BY MPS
OBJECTIVES SYSTEM PERFORMANCE
Reducing / preventing capillary absorptionMinimise ingress through cracking* <0.2mmMinimise ingress through cracking* >0.2mm
n/a
Prevention of Corrosion of steel rebar
Prevention of cracking from expansion of corroding steelLong Term Humidity, Mould and Bacterial ControlHeating/Vent/A-C Savings
Performance Monitoring
*Thermal and shrinkage cracking - Effective n/a - not applicable
64
65
TESTIMONIAL LETTERS
66
CONCLUSIONS
• MPS provides a viable, easily installed and cost – effective solution to STOP WATER INGRESS
• Long term humidity, mould and odour control
• MPS provides a unique long term control and performance monitoring system.
• Operational costs using MPS are negligible and savings in life cycle costs are considerable.