Transcript
Page 1: Cable Stay Replacement and Deck Rehabilitation of I-310 ... · Cable Stay Replacement and Deck Rehabilitation of I-310 Luling -Hale Boggs Mississippi River Bridge AASHTO SCOBS ANNUAL

Cable Stay Replacement and Deck Rehabilitation of I-310 Luling - Hale Boggs Mississippi River Bridge

AASHTO SCOBS ANNUAL MEETING SPOKANE, WAJUNE 15, 2017

Paul Fossier, P.E.Bridge Design Engineer Administrator

Louisiana Department of Transportation and Development (LA DOTD)

Page 2: Cable Stay Replacement and Deck Rehabilitation of I-310 ... · Cable Stay Replacement and Deck Rehabilitation of I-310 Luling -Hale Boggs Mississippi River Bridge AASHTO SCOBS ANNUAL
Page 3: Cable Stay Replacement and Deck Rehabilitation of I-310 ... · Cable Stay Replacement and Deck Rehabilitation of I-310 Luling -Hale Boggs Mississippi River Bridge AASHTO SCOBS ANNUAL

Opened in 1983, 1222 FT. MAIN SPAN, STEEL ORTHOTROPIC DECK, STEEL BOX GIRDERS, STEEL TOWERS, WEATHERING STEEL,

72 CABLES IN GROUPS OF 2 OR 4

Page 4: Cable Stay Replacement and Deck Rehabilitation of I-310 ... · Cable Stay Replacement and Deck Rehabilitation of I-310 Luling -Hale Boggs Mississippi River Bridge AASHTO SCOBS ANNUAL
Page 5: Cable Stay Replacement and Deck Rehabilitation of I-310 ... · Cable Stay Replacement and Deck Rehabilitation of I-310 Luling -Hale Boggs Mississippi River Bridge AASHTO SCOBS ANNUAL
Page 6: Cable Stay Replacement and Deck Rehabilitation of I-310 ... · Cable Stay Replacement and Deck Rehabilitation of I-310 Luling -Hale Boggs Mississippi River Bridge AASHTO SCOBS ANNUAL
Page 7: Cable Stay Replacement and Deck Rehabilitation of I-310 ... · Cable Stay Replacement and Deck Rehabilitation of I-310 Luling -Hale Boggs Mississippi River Bridge AASHTO SCOBS ANNUAL

Statement of Problem

Rusting and water leakage in anchoragesCracking/splitting of cable cover pipesSigns of compromise in cables safetyWind-rain cable vibration issuesWearing surface over steel deck has reached its service life.LADOTD initiated a project for Structural Evaluation of the Stay Cables

Page 8: Cable Stay Replacement and Deck Rehabilitation of I-310 ... · Cable Stay Replacement and Deck Rehabilitation of I-310 Luling -Hale Boggs Mississippi River Bridge AASHTO SCOBS ANNUAL

Old Stay CablesParallel Wire System

Page 9: Cable Stay Replacement and Deck Rehabilitation of I-310 ... · Cable Stay Replacement and Deck Rehabilitation of I-310 Luling -Hale Boggs Mississippi River Bridge AASHTO SCOBS ANNUAL

Lower Anchorage

Page 10: Cable Stay Replacement and Deck Rehabilitation of I-310 ... · Cable Stay Replacement and Deck Rehabilitation of I-310 Luling -Hale Boggs Mississippi River Bridge AASHTO SCOBS ANNUAL

Upper Anchorage

Page 11: Cable Stay Replacement and Deck Rehabilitation of I-310 ... · Cable Stay Replacement and Deck Rehabilitation of I-310 Luling -Hale Boggs Mississippi River Bridge AASHTO SCOBS ANNUAL

Inspection, Condition Rating, and Life-Cycle-Cost Analysis

Page 12: Cable Stay Replacement and Deck Rehabilitation of I-310 ... · Cable Stay Replacement and Deck Rehabilitation of I-310 Luling -Hale Boggs Mississippi River Bridge AASHTO SCOBS ANNUAL

Assessment of Overall Integrity

Difference between design and measured profile

0.00

200.00

400.00

600.00

800.00

1000.00

1200.00

1400.00

NE

I - T

E

NE

I - T

W

NE

I - B

E

NE

I - B

W

NE

II - T

NE

II - B

NE

III -

T

NE

III -

B

NE

IV -

TE

NE

IV -

TW

NE

IV -

BE

NE

IV -

BW

NE

V - T

E

NE

V - T

W

NE

V - B

E

NE

V - B

W

NE

VI -

T

NE

VI -

B

Forc

e (K

ips)

Measured Force

Design Force

Cable Force Measurement

Page 13: Cable Stay Replacement and Deck Rehabilitation of I-310 ... · Cable Stay Replacement and Deck Rehabilitation of I-310 Luling -Hale Boggs Mississippi River Bridge AASHTO SCOBS ANNUAL

Anchorage Inspection

Page 14: Cable Stay Replacement and Deck Rehabilitation of I-310 ... · Cable Stay Replacement and Deck Rehabilitation of I-310 Luling -Hale Boggs Mississippi River Bridge AASHTO SCOBS ANNUAL

Cable Free Length Inspection

Page 15: Cable Stay Replacement and Deck Rehabilitation of I-310 ... · Cable Stay Replacement and Deck Rehabilitation of I-310 Luling -Hale Boggs Mississippi River Bridge AASHTO SCOBS ANNUAL

Inspection findingsDamage Severity Levels

Severity Level Status Description

1 Satisfactory Minor deterioration and anomalies noted

2 Poor Deterioration of the protective elements and potential for degradation. Cables with this level of damages need to be routinely monitored and corrective action needs to be planned.

3 Critical Deterioration or potential for deterioration of the main tension elements (steel wires) exists. Action (repair) is necessary. Cables with this level of damages shall be closely monitored until repairs are applied.

Page 16: Cable Stay Replacement and Deck Rehabilitation of I-310 ... · Cable Stay Replacement and Deck Rehabilitation of I-310 Luling -Hale Boggs Mississippi River Bridge AASHTO SCOBS ANNUAL

Severity Level 3 - Critical, Damage Examples

Page 17: Cable Stay Replacement and Deck Rehabilitation of I-310 ... · Cable Stay Replacement and Deck Rehabilitation of I-310 Luling -Hale Boggs Mississippi River Bridge AASHTO SCOBS ANNUAL

Summary

40 out of 72 cables were rated critical All cables had at least damage Level 2Increasing rate of deterioration was evidentTimely corrective action was neededBased on a Life-Cycle-Cost Analysis, public safety concerns, and importance of the bridge, LADOTD decided to replace all cables

Page 18: Cable Stay Replacement and Deck Rehabilitation of I-310 ... · Cable Stay Replacement and Deck Rehabilitation of I-310 Luling -Hale Boggs Mississippi River Bridge AASHTO SCOBS ANNUAL

Cable Replacement Design, and Construction

Page 19: Cable Stay Replacement and Deck Rehabilitation of I-310 ... · Cable Stay Replacement and Deck Rehabilitation of I-310 Luling -Hale Boggs Mississippi River Bridge AASHTO SCOBS ANNUAL

Cable Replacement Design

Develop a cost effective design.Minimize impact on traffic.Analyze for live load, wind force, and construction load effects.

Objectives:

Page 20: Cable Stay Replacement and Deck Rehabilitation of I-310 ... · Cable Stay Replacement and Deck Rehabilitation of I-310 Luling -Hale Boggs Mississippi River Bridge AASHTO SCOBS ANNUAL

Replacement Cable DesignSelected cable system

Parallel Strand System withIndividually Greased Sheathed Seven-wire

Strands Encased in HDPE ribbed Cover Pipe

Page 21: Cable Stay Replacement and Deck Rehabilitation of I-310 ... · Cable Stay Replacement and Deck Rehabilitation of I-310 Luling -Hale Boggs Mississippi River Bridge AASHTO SCOBS ANNUAL

Replacement cable designParallel strand, preferred system

Larger anchorage and cable envelope– Require modifications to existing structure– Increase wind load – Change aerodynamic characteristics

Old Cables; 103 to 307, ¼” wiresNew Cables; 23,45,57,67, 0.62” strandsAdditional 24 reference strand for follow-up inspections

Page 22: Cable Stay Replacement and Deck Rehabilitation of I-310 ... · Cable Stay Replacement and Deck Rehabilitation of I-310 Luling -Hale Boggs Mississippi River Bridge AASHTO SCOBS ANNUAL

Temporary cable designNeed for Temporary cables

Uncertainty in cable condition Large cable group spacingNeed to maintain traffic w/o load limits

Page 23: Cable Stay Replacement and Deck Rehabilitation of I-310 ... · Cable Stay Replacement and Deck Rehabilitation of I-310 Luling -Hale Boggs Mississippi River Bridge AASHTO SCOBS ANNUAL

Temporary cable design

Page 24: Cable Stay Replacement and Deck Rehabilitation of I-310 ... · Cable Stay Replacement and Deck Rehabilitation of I-310 Luling -Hale Boggs Mississippi River Bridge AASHTO SCOBS ANNUAL

Temporary Cables

Page 25: Cable Stay Replacement and Deck Rehabilitation of I-310 ... · Cable Stay Replacement and Deck Rehabilitation of I-310 Luling -Hale Boggs Mississippi River Bridge AASHTO SCOBS ANNUAL

Construction SequenceInstall Temporary Cables

Page 26: Cable Stay Replacement and Deck Rehabilitation of I-310 ... · Cable Stay Replacement and Deck Rehabilitation of I-310 Luling -Hale Boggs Mississippi River Bridge AASHTO SCOBS ANNUAL

Construction SequenceDetension and lower cable

Page 27: Cable Stay Replacement and Deck Rehabilitation of I-310 ... · Cable Stay Replacement and Deck Rehabilitation of I-310 Luling -Hale Boggs Mississippi River Bridge AASHTO SCOBS ANNUAL

Construction SequenceModification of Anchorage Zones

Page 28: Cable Stay Replacement and Deck Rehabilitation of I-310 ... · Cable Stay Replacement and Deck Rehabilitation of I-310 Luling -Hale Boggs Mississippi River Bridge AASHTO SCOBS ANNUAL

Construction SequenceModification of Anchorage Zones

Page 29: Cable Stay Replacement and Deck Rehabilitation of I-310 ... · Cable Stay Replacement and Deck Rehabilitation of I-310 Luling -Hale Boggs Mississippi River Bridge AASHTO SCOBS ANNUAL

Construction SequenceModification of Anchorage Zones

Page 30: Cable Stay Replacement and Deck Rehabilitation of I-310 ... · Cable Stay Replacement and Deck Rehabilitation of I-310 Luling -Hale Boggs Mississippi River Bridge AASHTO SCOBS ANNUAL

Construction SequenceWeld PE Pipe

Page 31: Cable Stay Replacement and Deck Rehabilitation of I-310 ... · Cable Stay Replacement and Deck Rehabilitation of I-310 Luling -Hale Boggs Mississippi River Bridge AASHTO SCOBS ANNUAL

Construction SequenceHoist PE Pipe

Page 32: Cable Stay Replacement and Deck Rehabilitation of I-310 ... · Cable Stay Replacement and Deck Rehabilitation of I-310 Luling -Hale Boggs Mississippi River Bridge AASHTO SCOBS ANNUAL

Construction Sequence Install Strand and Stress

Page 33: Cable Stay Replacement and Deck Rehabilitation of I-310 ... · Cable Stay Replacement and Deck Rehabilitation of I-310 Luling -Hale Boggs Mississippi River Bridge AASHTO SCOBS ANNUAL

Lower Ends and Anchorages

Page 34: Cable Stay Replacement and Deck Rehabilitation of I-310 ... · Cable Stay Replacement and Deck Rehabilitation of I-310 Luling -Hale Boggs Mississippi River Bridge AASHTO SCOBS ANNUAL

Upper Ends and Anchorages

Page 35: Cable Stay Replacement and Deck Rehabilitation of I-310 ... · Cable Stay Replacement and Deck Rehabilitation of I-310 Luling -Hale Boggs Mississippi River Bridge AASHTO SCOBS ANNUAL

Maintenance of Traffic

Page 36: Cable Stay Replacement and Deck Rehabilitation of I-310 ... · Cable Stay Replacement and Deck Rehabilitation of I-310 Luling -Hale Boggs Mississippi River Bridge AASHTO SCOBS ANNUAL

Cable Vibration Suppression Measures

Page 37: Cable Stay Replacement and Deck Rehabilitation of I-310 ... · Cable Stay Replacement and Deck Rehabilitation of I-310 Luling -Hale Boggs Mississippi River Bridge AASHTO SCOBS ANNUAL

Cable Vibration Suppression Measures

RIBBED HDPE PIPE – WIND/RAIN ISSUES

Page 38: Cable Stay Replacement and Deck Rehabilitation of I-310 ... · Cable Stay Replacement and Deck Rehabilitation of I-310 Luling -Hale Boggs Mississippi River Bridge AASHTO SCOBS ANNUAL

Background: Deck Wearing SurfaceOriginal - (SMAC) Stone Matrix Asphalt Cement

Observed failure and delaminations of significant areas (1994)

1994 - (SMAC) Stone Matrix Asphalt Cement 1st Rehab - Removed and replaced the area over 4 Travel LanesApplied a test section utilizing Polymer Modified Asphalt Cement (PMAC)

1999 - Observed failure and delaminations of significant areas2nd Rehab - Removed and replaced the area over 3 Travel Lanes utilizing PMACApplied a 320’ test section utilizing Conventionally Reinforced Concrete Pavement (CRCP) - Norhbound Barrier to Barrier

2004 - Applied another 320’ test section utilizing Steel Fiber Reinforced Concrete (SFRC) - Southbound 2 Lanes

Page 39: Cable Stay Replacement and Deck Rehabilitation of I-310 ... · Cable Stay Replacement and Deck Rehabilitation of I-310 Luling -Hale Boggs Mississippi River Bridge AASHTO SCOBS ANNUAL

Deck

PMAC

Page 40: Cable Stay Replacement and Deck Rehabilitation of I-310 ... · Cable Stay Replacement and Deck Rehabilitation of I-310 Luling -Hale Boggs Mississippi River Bridge AASHTO SCOBS ANNUAL

Deck

CRCP

Page 41: Cable Stay Replacement and Deck Rehabilitation of I-310 ... · Cable Stay Replacement and Deck Rehabilitation of I-310 Luling -Hale Boggs Mississippi River Bridge AASHTO SCOBS ANNUAL

SFRC

Page 42: Cable Stay Replacement and Deck Rehabilitation of I-310 ... · Cable Stay Replacement and Deck Rehabilitation of I-310 Luling -Hale Boggs Mississippi River Bridge AASHTO SCOBS ANNUAL
Page 43: Cable Stay Replacement and Deck Rehabilitation of I-310 ... · Cable Stay Replacement and Deck Rehabilitation of I-310 Luling -Hale Boggs Mississippi River Bridge AASHTO SCOBS ANNUAL
Page 44: Cable Stay Replacement and Deck Rehabilitation of I-310 ... · Cable Stay Replacement and Deck Rehabilitation of I-310 Luling -Hale Boggs Mississippi River Bridge AASHTO SCOBS ANNUAL
Page 45: Cable Stay Replacement and Deck Rehabilitation of I-310 ... · Cable Stay Replacement and Deck Rehabilitation of I-310 Luling -Hale Boggs Mississippi River Bridge AASHTO SCOBS ANNUAL
Page 46: Cable Stay Replacement and Deck Rehabilitation of I-310 ... · Cable Stay Replacement and Deck Rehabilitation of I-310 Luling -Hale Boggs Mississippi River Bridge AASHTO SCOBS ANNUAL
Page 47: Cable Stay Replacement and Deck Rehabilitation of I-310 ... · Cable Stay Replacement and Deck Rehabilitation of I-310 Luling -Hale Boggs Mississippi River Bridge AASHTO SCOBS ANNUAL
Page 48: Cable Stay Replacement and Deck Rehabilitation of I-310 ... · Cable Stay Replacement and Deck Rehabilitation of I-310 Luling -Hale Boggs Mississippi River Bridge AASHTO SCOBS ANNUAL
Page 49: Cable Stay Replacement and Deck Rehabilitation of I-310 ... · Cable Stay Replacement and Deck Rehabilitation of I-310 Luling -Hale Boggs Mississippi River Bridge AASHTO SCOBS ANNUAL

Project Team (2002-2016)

LA DOTD, PAUL FOSSIER, PROJECT MANAGERCABLE INSPECTION & REPLACEMENT

CTL GROUPBRIDGE ENGINEERING SOLUTIONS (BES)TRANSYSTEMSABMBINTERNATIONAL BRIDGE TECHNOLOGIES (IBT)KIEWIT, GENERAL CONTRACTOR– VSL, INC., STAY CABLE SUB-CONTRACTOR

DECK OVERLAY STRUCTURAL DESIGN & REHABILITATION (SDR) CEC, INC., GENERAL CONTRACTOR

Page 50: Cable Stay Replacement and Deck Rehabilitation of I-310 ... · Cable Stay Replacement and Deck Rehabilitation of I-310 Luling -Hale Boggs Mississippi River Bridge AASHTO SCOBS ANNUAL

Recommended