146
:24 +Bf /4;.'S r ^ ,i .. **.1 t r13 4 - ADA L A I ' w>' ' v <' a--K Public Disclosure Authorized Public Disclosure Authorized Public Disclosure Authorized closure Authorized Public Disclosure Authorized Public Disclosure Authorized Public Disclosure Authorized closure Authorized

World Bank Document€¦ · tIT 1997 L* t iflfO * Alex F. McCalla4gt 28X ~j, JfiNlit . Wendy Ayres, Hans Binswanger, Arturo Cornejo, Sanjiva Cooke, Douglas Forno, Dean Housden f David

  • Upload
    others

  • View
    1

  • Download
    0

Embed Size (px)

Citation preview

Page 1: World Bank Document€¦ · tIT 1997 L* t iflfO * Alex F. McCalla4gt 28X ~j, JfiNlit . Wendy Ayres, Hans Binswanger, Arturo Cornejo, Sanjiva Cooke, Douglas Forno, Dean Housden f David

:24

+Bf /4;.'S r ^ ,i

.. **.1 t

r13 4 -

ADA

L AI ' w>' '

v <' a--K

Pub

lic D

iscl

osur

e A

utho

rized

Pub

lic D

iscl

osur

e A

utho

rized

Pub

lic D

iscl

osur

e A

utho

rized

Pub

lic D

iscl

osur

e A

utho

rized

Pub

lic D

iscl

osur

e A

utho

rized

Pub

lic D

iscl

osur

e A

utho

rized

Pub

lic D

iscl

osur

e A

utho

rized

Pub

lic D

iscl

osur

e A

utho

rized

Page 2: World Bank Document€¦ · tIT 1997 L* t iflfO * Alex F. McCalla4gt 28X ~j, JfiNlit . Wendy Ayres, Hans Binswanger, Arturo Cornejo, Sanjiva Cooke, Douglas Forno, Dean Housden f David
Page 3: World Bank Document€¦ · tIT 1997 L* t iflfO * Alex F. McCalla4gt 28X ~j, JfiNlit . Wendy Ayres, Hans Binswanger, Arturo Cornejo, Sanjiva Cooke, Douglas Forno, Dean Housden f David

,r3

z :

Im, jQ �tl 911 4-t i��

-6� Il A )A- �k W�&-

-L4- -* �K f�

* -4 +,Q, 4 v

Page 4: World Bank Document€¦ · tIT 1997 L* t iflfO * Alex F. McCalla4gt 28X ~j, JfiNlit . Wendy Ayres, Hans Binswanger, Arturo Cornejo, Sanjiva Cooke, Douglas Forno, Dean Housden f David

tIT 1997 L* t iflfO * Alex F. McCalla4gt

28X ~j, JfiNlit . Wendy Ayres, Hans Binswanger, Arturo Cornejo, Sanjiva Cooke, Douglas

Forno, Dean Housden f David Steeds0 T 1'VkIXtAk, tEL

Alicia Hetzner II Virginia Hitchcock Mt M l f I. Gaudencio Dizon 1 t f IE f t r T n ! M

:i; 811 : A iL itif Th tt~4~ MIJ 1 Caio Koch - Weser ± Te1'IeIsmail Serageldin Xf*N t1rq1At rfkttW-

Page 5: World Bank Document€¦ · tIT 1997 L* t iflfO * Alex F. McCalla4gt 28X ~j, JfiNlit . Wendy Ayres, Hans Binswanger, Arturo Cornejo, Sanjiva Cooke, Douglas Forno, Dean Housden f David

IJ

VI 3* 14~1:o ff

, #5 ffi tjitgf f

FPO g9tr)JD4. 7Y13fl J(±{ 7fi4*7If o 7hft1W IO Hw f

ITT 1o 8 f I I*II 22 - iii '1ff4 Fl] * f i w M T, iil 'P.tfill -L 4 gEt m f RgA +i T.-h-1R X 4L -fXooMgfo WHt t

AetS ffr ERl ,k L' ti + fl6Xtj to - k4~ 4,

E '-f ARAtt aaAS Pi qt 0 I'll 9 YE,19ttA H -: - e2tl diA , iR 1 )1X N

-*tS k$t1)14WR ttt f.f.>:srS,+t.,

A3+> 93 tX tt, -4 Pt 11X it -AZLL PIM S,J% < -1 -f R

9-3180I k nf f(tR' i -tkr i -tft Oif IT, % a0 f 1 jiffi fAt W tG )t l A KA--A5J) H R~

4,0/if tg AP'l 4tf- Efts *XmlE * iks#-Rtl:t J+$ifI

bMo41Ix0-tfE QT 7 '15k071(:tik F t, , s El ItEI Y-7t4 Ff'MTH 'tUJ klf

loll 'gA. V ft X rI'JA4 *Xn i* RRT!*L t t ** #1F#4;+1;t -k Dgs -T Zf;F r f

Page 6: World Bank Document€¦ · tIT 1997 L* t iflfO * Alex F. McCalla4gt 28X ~j, JfiNlit . Wendy Ayres, Hans Binswanger, Arturo Cornejo, Sanjiva Cooke, Douglas Forno, Dean Housden f David

ISNAR (International Service for National OPR (Operations Policy Department) Ž1kAgricultural Research) 1X1 Ž1k21BlFT R* PHN (Population, Health, and Nutri

IT (information technology) . tion Department) A 11Lk

LAC (Latin America and the Caribbean 19 4Region) kT J i H hff 111 IuPX PHRD (Policy and Human Resource De-

LEG (Legal Department) itHi velopment Fund) A- tt Xi ,

LLC (Learning and Leadership Center) g M QVgkJq4P rIL,PRD (Policy Research Department) il

MALSIP (Malawi Agriculture and Livestock 3EJX

Investment Project) QAr1, fl PSD (Private Sector Development Vice

#t@ tIg ;Presidency) fL M ] '1 t W qJ t cM&E (monitoring and evaluation) .111" 9,

PSP ( Poverty and Social Policy

MENA (Middle East and North Africa Department) #iB'#_:AJX

Region) rPtWt1JL4i*.V QAG (Quality Assessment Group) 1<A

MIGA (Multilateral Investment Guarantee iA/1'14

Agency) I RDV [ Rural Development Department

NARI ( National Agricultural Research (formerly Agriculture and Natural

Institute) N*VRifTf1Z Resources Department, or AGR)]

NARS ( national agricultural research : h ( I A 'n i

system) P4*VR JAi, A AGR)NEAP (national environmental action plan) RMT (regional management team) A X

NGO (nongovernmental organization) 14 RUTA ( Regional Unit for Technical

1RLWRg, Assistance) tt7.At&1# 1NRM (natural resource management) t RVP (regional vice president) * 10*lP.

tt'M eX INIJ

O&M (operations and maintenance) kE SAR (staff appraisal report) IT'fAMi{

OD (Operational Directive) S11' 5G2000 (Sasakawa Africa Association Global

ODA (Overseas Development Association) 2000) 4t JilI4 iA WZ"Z4 2000+

* #F e 'f/t Iritt'J

OECD (Organization for Economic Co- SIL (sector investment loan) W13 floperation and Development) R i t

f ) - 4t ISOD (sector operations department) PI

OED (Operations Evaluation Department) ] Ilk iAkti i SPAAR (Special Programme for African A-

Page 7: World Bank Document€¦ · tIT 1997 L* t iflfO * Alex F. McCalla4gt 28X ~j, JfiNlit . Wendy Ayres, Hans Binswanger, Arturo Cornejo, Sanjiva Cooke, Douglas Forno, Dean Housden f David

lx

gricultural Research) dr Yi1 t Al a Trade and Development) m I H

SRISTI (Society for Research and Initiatives UNDP ( United Nations Developmentfor Sustainable Technology and Programme) 4<P H[ff9it1'JwInstitutions) J UNEP ( United Nations Environment

Progyamme) 1 H M ;SSPM (sustainable soil productivity man- UR (Uruguay Round) *4j±L

agement) $ USAID ( United States Agency forT&V (training and visit) ti)ll-blQ International Development) 4H FHTWU (Transportation, Water, and Ur-

ban Development Department) i WDR (World Development Report) (tit

UNCSD (United Nations Commission on WFP (World Food Programme) 4* HSustainable Development) W< 1 -tH! n 1g4 ,Wf i .~ WTO (World Trade Organization) t -

UNCTAD (United Nations Conference on C

Page 8: World Bank Document€¦ · tIT 1997 L* t iflfO * Alex F. McCalla4gt 28X ~j, JfiNlit . Wendy Ayres, Hans Binswanger, Arturo Cornejo, Sanjiva Cooke, Douglas Forno, Dean Housden f David

i

I

I

I

iii

Page 9: World Bank Document€¦ · tIT 1997 L* t iflfO * Alex F. McCalla4gt 28X ~j, JfiNlit . Wendy Ayres, Hans Binswanger, Arturo Cornejo, Sanjiva Cooke, Douglas Forno, Dean Housden f David

t:riP. t mZ E i J A IKi fft; 1t ft. 12020 #FTTf 1)-v 10Jo VA,

kWIlEtinpo: ftiTt#EA4ix lJtY> ltMJb$t ~ifl#B4 ftWAn# 4'1KJ~TWtAlTh1jL i-]) LUt A 1 t 9L t} t.:YI4htj 1.93 VA±f I 2020 Wt 2

(1) MkJfttF1; -- T P 3/4 W}\UiTiXt{ft

(3) f iUt +, U?kjŽW.S4 IQ tPR xt±tit1t #4nrw, *ftl

rtElX@WU:r-FzU4tA tA;tm.fEtl tetitwzmgtt kVt; 4WlqtfUlthq~ lWkttAnQio8M@7tttUII

4f ) t4hjt WtkjS -1-V L;2- Ffti [84fTr, ;V IXP A J1 f7- 7f ) ;, H 1tN P P + ",?J~ II t EX - . T tflhikMU. A iZt S9 pA'tAIfi4

kgW-tib @sl±±, t k-rmSswP. Eflt$L1&) t1zAtLi 1 1 1e4 Ui ' P i ThiAtit 0 8 E1fitt #1& hT h--t±fi& U M f1i*A:¶i

it.1 .~I kL@ JAS# R 'SflT 7JC l f|Vi<l ETr C ( ft f«1.tW - W, -K,IrT,

it-gJXX -:tAtffiAn4- St ZtA>, $>O ER'tfi S:Wt 4 6E T-11 -f T ftW V- IL ,j

mll*v-kjRAMT2 tl .rWH Tr 1- ; S -k

A 9A ffl t#A l'1 IitMf5 - ) -m f%% at - ')IIA ?I-te 21 )"T

8 l ii;Eb4lA -YAltUX tl

Page 10: World Bank Document€¦ · tIT 1997 L* t iflfO * Alex F. McCalla4gt 28X ~j, JfiNlit . Wendy Ayres, Hans Binswanger, Arturo Cornejo, Sanjiva Cooke, Douglas Forno, Dean Housden f David

2 Vf,~R %kI2,YJHz0j

A k t FT - bo VTAl A ŽW4h * ftyMRO, t

9MII±fEff ~O

A 1 R s~ t T P h A t fA Rt 4 ItM'7 M t. #m fT, 6p'tI

A jf4,iT 704kf$l80 ~ 6 lT MilI )31 H k.

f~0 'IAffi}K , R k ~ '0,A UA it67E K.

Page 11: World Bank Document€¦ · tIT 1997 L* t iflfO * Alex F. McCalla4gt 28X ~j, JfiNlit . Wendy Ayres, Hans Binswanger, Arturo Cornejo, Sanjiva Cooke, Douglas Forno, Dean Housden f David

J~ 20

f+ Ti -A-,'1ttt t¢aT- o- -w''-l- ol 7E: tt' i f*1 XU

W,, A -M -4ti A l t W-20 141 i

,&'M 4a 0 T- X<it I4L *n ,,4j Aatif 'in% AR f S v pnr ITAll'-' ft t

-t,/t R if, a2,.0 H I S% FIf T R t@ Ial9- -R. ft ff]AiR llet bi .11t g t IfA F t- TI M l4 Xt E IIV f

tXIif-EiM', jql;l,

WMtrOP-1i4t l "WIf fiRf"TRAPi. fliiJw-L iA Hi;Q lqt R p ;t* r± EM If* fp 5lt) M R T ;t

t4ii , 2tf R- Ih, m A7<', i J , {(t9I P t%P1 4 fi T r* .j Wj-fW 1 FN fl j~ M

f;EliV o~ tlU I' A E-- 4 3X *A rh 12 5ER /W@ 11 A #; J #tr

30 f"If ft EX ir2ul-, #*fi

IEPA, o of ?W IT1\ Ki M tN ffli MxIXIXffItR a ol l 11!TAJ,St;1t; @P;MpHtSt1p Ss};4glilZT % tgs-

VaA-WR 1lr 41. 8o18 4:-tale5> It t f"fi M ' Tr W II I t/~R&

I,I E wVI nPqV,'j rIX fge t /Qw? l X0 R, Ma, , q f.I r8 f--7Cby 0Tif 11

Page 12: World Bank Document€¦ · tIT 1997 L* t iflfO * Alex F. McCalla4gt 28X ~j, JfiNlit . Wendy Ayres, Hans Binswanger, Arturo Cornejo, Sanjiva Cooke, Douglas Forno, Dean Housden f David

4 Jtt R: 1 U.. jly ,- t'll IJ

:e 1 1tT&*4gA k tQ* ui.

* 258tAtl tgt, t1gA .K (tt•2I T1N j 7 l- tJiL

* entx@-*@B tAt-wKt it1 2 I''t A!liA -f |- Wi f* §A V, +J

±5j~' tU4* tt~ 'Fr I r 1995a - ±±-t95 4tW -iŽti

IIe4 I11 iI tl WI-Tf A-R),Ntt 5K gy, , rf At e7@«W5 A tp .S1T ) W ):allq 4 ei

Ii , M.<t iYo 1- f* -0I f ff j89 H (1j t ;t:

JAM-T), HliE & tR TfiXZ/L YIJR4Rrl W* M , [9*rEaY -RMf$ff

ht It-m

1992W> *$#X4IX TThftWWER>-lJt0 #1, R1bThL, ASJzh

~{WŽ •kik•hv+2-$i ±11T CAe6 ±I,9Ht& t*t$

i#iSAt V, I W a, LLWrlWTA> MJit t{ SItMES

RJM8H ;t;8lthitlPOK A& eUThitt 0R "-1htQit-A" tWl o t;A¶44A4±t

to 1996M tetALagThHI, 78% mLF4Ttt<+tM 0 atUititt

ThALsX7t½ 100 tXt Ug ThMA, KS-4 * 4itZf§t%AF. ' .t*fiz

Page 13: World Bank Document€¦ · tIT 1997 L* t iflfO * Alex F. McCalla4gt 28X ~j, JfiNlit . Wendy Ayres, Hans Binswanger, Arturo Cornejo, Sanjiva Cooke, Douglas Forno, Dean Housden f David

Z1tIt 41Th MUTh A ThT' ThffAb i* AW itti:itM hi T A

rffAFMftR T-1ffq4tL, H 5i t tT 4Th&91fl®Jil m r'I

'ttT M4T@j PK-T%% IAol IITh, 1420 thThDtt 150 B0RT

* * fi& . 4tittWtET h XtT hTh ±Rtih

9 $P..il -L To jfit# t @p4R e Pffl , -) TrW1i tHg Nt +02 Ix't,

1Wi%O tE$lgTht%Ni±#'JTi.t BAStEEI$f@Po i@-%Lt&em

* L4kts-fiElo ~t+w±tRJES J;k, IA nQt-@ta t2tX-R4O&T, t, $Mkiff X ½O . t tv1&E wo

'K{f 4fllt, ILk 'f hS4AL * 4

0W$a Tt,l iE±TT-fh1 4* '41±t, ktfO -Al 3Eit, t -tttt N

ThT NA f3i- LiR o;xt hf FL ;LW "rJX I PAt H" 'f 4 Yf iiEl %IT

* '4 $#mThtAktA. lLAiIX*tl-l, tft P4AiATi '-J 0PJ f it 4'

WOLL4RO *j 44cW-t Q,ihiKtf i nPtAf ltn#*S-fff

A, VXTtttftLT~Jt £4 4ITh$ , Vtt; (2LtEikittlJAf¶

a tii t t X4 4iNX t H I aI~{fl~O#t3f~k * 4batiti*t i& 5WfALk½QMI{E

)X t@#lt+Dk: {e'J4tifr)I {IIrMQggi, 4VArIt#

Mcffia.8~~~~~~~~~ 4g IA3e uptij$g;!3 WMIF$;tHii

HM tHE i#gg U 1S iJ * ff tHX HA

Page 14: World Bank Document€¦ · tIT 1997 L* t iflfO * Alex F. McCalla4gt 28X ~j, JfiNlit . Wendy Ayres, Hans Binswanger, Arturo Cornejo, Sanjiva Cooke, Douglas Forno, Dean Housden f David

*4 2 a&ttI,**

Co iX1±T,ft rma43gt?SiThiiFOi- 9'l T, AlMR2 9±l O W-tkEtO R n4 tE ,WDU , 'z>

* SY;<tflh±uk itIM. WKJ72± t 4$i&RtE WIECWJW

A* k 1 t 11-OI IŽ4 t flY 1m * 4 -

91 jiA R- , " L4, at A E A M tr *' J 1t1'gtE1e gM @

t( I $ tfCT ftYi

* Ht@L# U f m A RX 0 eSiAt ol 7 tioulft*#Jsii, bl%t Ju-A

:ix tJq9ktttU. iQit. O 1E9tt2

* WL8 MtSAT$g X± ttMtlig4)ttM#fUAt4.

fifttiVX +tftatflTtNt

it a#{ŽLME iSki%tŽj4JgtS tbtWMitA, ThttR-PtRW4 GAi

IE;t*trP0 t$WAQt jtttSJ Rttt,tt

IIQtt8g fr,1il f4fFMt@t¢4EXL tMJ

Ai^X A+6JX *iIbTh, $#•Ti'< ttg'tt&tk½flTWT ½tT

Page 15: World Bank Document€¦ · tIT 1997 L* t iflfO * Alex F. McCalla4gt 28X ~j, JfiNlit . Wendy Ayres, Hans Binswanger, Arturo Cornejo, Sanjiva Cooke, Douglas Forno, Dean Housden f David

ih t 7

XI- 4lpaAtX, It11 ftMtkpStSw

-r± i A, -1 F'-2-$: t- #F;+Y sX tti ;r S-3s At -Ef l

fRtW#ttWhMl iti'4lnH@X1 * t@2WS-I

ETlA . i) 4g *g 1z fgS 5 It il( X, fl 4W4- I A i , :1

Ji,B '~RA tttM,+fJtL WSS{tt MPbL Tt4

tA25Th$#+ff&Tp, 4 r * I4 20I

tT-AktHWtd 0 ietThTh;wA

tijLWM%ttit4,2 21 *~ ¶~~ tXX,tW t-''eThmS

Wit tl IKAH tf tl&tt (ItPiLs) O Att4T4JIIhII--2 I -izu8tk #@HX' ,&ri5,i,> :tt - t

v HtTfSIt*0 T0ti1, ttt *7iJ CtY4JLit) iŽOtThSR

tt4- ll itX -itTrW¢iW) *Tf-MHf {tiiW 1t1v"1 & vl't ht-M, K4Tr¾M

Ž T hy -f' t4F 4 1tnt U Xf 'L I kfj% ffi tlM A ettArvIfTt lF -1-ti*t;i )tg7iX00; Ct\1 TF M7- g (bqa OQk, i*t) 'PitAo .)

P-, t 4tT Ute1";mWJ, I 5 A&W, fM{J3Tft RIA , *N: I9¾-fJLb aMt f %;DH&W -ti it' j *4 A ^ i4 - AA ;ffXotj+T X+t MtI f fft' f4t '-,IIA 8ns ITLMt 4 f 1~ ITi

fi,1lr11 WIJ-- -t:RA0 Wwn4 vtffgal vTgX-rT:A tkWkQXHI ;XWffit "EITI) t A g Af#OlMAvt:jln1ko ±A-MfP±*uk*,X:

4XtffiEffl IJ i'p 1 G AjHt ol n r, I5 1 '-I.: In,ffitt& 1 R - Wflf An, -XliJ;L kIR Q N k $1i- = , iT1 A iMXe 1- t' 'A-'V

4RfWURIA# , ffl k 4k 0 T- fltt anv

I'*O A0 f It, tRSf- PEl T'2 Hi rLn Shs k MA Et ri 7gf fr t YO -A- 9A A t PI X 2

iTt t@tti*f f " V T+-X 't iiTS Trf 4Xj-tt k

Page 16: World Bank Document€¦ · tIT 1997 L* t iflfO * Alex F. McCalla4gt 28X ~j, JfiNlit . Wendy Ayres, Hans Binswanger, Arturo Cornejo, Sanjiva Cooke, Douglas Forno, Dean Housden f David

NR oRTfROk#.iLTHR&fV i It f At ia'ttn iE #1 o ii

t2 OAI A, A J2002 4-9- f _ X-V{+O w- iE)ko #EA -T1 Q t ' 80% kt,iL ffi A Ai4 ; i t Ra T A 1@ A )t ,

~WiTA, L0 f LVI1•xL r A9TfaJV JFt t E - If, PC M 1 4.AMM

IAP la IQ *, W f lX 'El ,i9-* T I 1'-

PT-1 AR , iI O xi0k i XI

T, jR o l!t itW ] l MftU3XItt -Tq tef', tSat11Ze

5a Ifj 80%it At tT& 0 A .

V9 ff -21Z01 'iJPAt NA t>Aa #mo AtSkE lw Lt. M

t2+rc tFZ4k>fEQv T 1gf -It jol i'ffi 4e ff+ f"';'t

TfikM-J2:I1, (Omar Kabbaj) ff~JJ~h 3- Lbpq* IWL

*7 Yr I itI -i-o -k + ' Ms(f e W 9 M) A t Exll

21datteetMSt8tt,.t4p OWtQIJ4o

t±- H- LKt.W o,A4iM/' ;p t~

Page 17: World Bank Document€¦ · tIT 1997 L* t iflfO * Alex F. McCalla4gt 28X ~j, JfiNlit . Wendy Ayres, Hans Binswanger, Arturo Cornejo, Sanjiva Cooke, Douglas Forno, Dean Housden f David

9

d ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ itt k i]11 Elf1 1-21 iW T2ttt t-t 41 ffi -13E o rV-tti-f+ f-A EX t A, N - TAW4-5t U| -W kgi it X Sk 70 %6 A '

t;I[RlAXo JtP*X11i1U i Ijt1R170% X iigI}i~ UlA'-StH1SYtl!f'F *tB> W!I{ @ LLTht GDP L30 %, tQ2 .P f P± O 4,40%, ~PR,)t@RM 70%o *,VO, td tR E [email protected] t

w a Tl kXA 1wJ - I { IM t 9s 3XiJ gojJt -i J ?v- 1 4m 9E, it -, Iv9t .1 TU ' 7 kI W iEA f X [f T 4 fW WE f 1 iaL, iN 1 9 M t fiA it EX

LH ff t AA AT li- 11 Xtt 4 A gtLtg X, r I < tt v P'- "a tt 2

tAt;--~~ ItA 4-,uIttES f rEFk-.i-ill C< Qft f 7t f X~'k r± 3 fit- f-W,]1+4 <A; iff ) tt ,@> A gh :2 IR IEl tMl tA m1-:5 "OET

IV & xltK[t p ILL 19 +1 gx@ vXr 4t fll--U, f I I: v 901 .ro

t-i-,,,,.,r,,,1993 (41: P4HE PT-, t,%< tIX t- 't# G tQ sR i JE

X@rMivTL%fffMAR"t],NU /*rfTu. fp9lVrl i-tal, A t F- lE'l t--r 6

A@ - A; A A'A, f\ IF) i Ett « t t"2Wff lbtW RMRo

ftnl P-;k ml;. g-- [N-Ltt (W: W-D;I I-: fRS illitrx-AW f-IAff

#t%iafiftTh tt^Jll@ Iatng X'i'gR2i .0It

tuE ift-E R MifiE s S 4X iL-l - {f2W tXl,i-- 1

Page 18: World Bank Document€¦ · tIT 1997 L* t iflfO * Alex F. McCalla4gt 28X ~j, JfiNlit . Wendy Ayres, Hans Binswanger, Arturo Cornejo, Sanjiva Cooke, Douglas Forno, Dean Housden f David

-' I, 1,-tds -- I 7K W, MOM R- O'f - -f~ 1 L

X''I T-tl f&% 7j437tg'9 tF *J171t huA Exg$T V

-X,3:-A AE 't- Mk ft wA 7Rb$kS TTt kfi7R4ttttkttE @\ X f " Vp

hpiWE Eg%-XQUtb5Fi@; 1tolS:bM R#EM:KtQA W,*IM,

t ER$fAv, VAtAi"-- JA*:X-XMEt,&MjTE:gE, t-+,)BiX*#l ttAS%fitr, lfi: AR bAol AtSAt#N iA; tXt A N

k1:7Jib9JtHE ulr Mq ,ll f,iM.lij- Xi ettb 0F f- ftLb5ZJ 1Blt

A )4-L5bF ; 117 L fMikbM-11*'A#rf itQJQ tTtC N, 130-l1f3Xgtj

$xf T tR )j rT -flRffW, Jr i3- L- 0,tSb ¢ A It XQ bM --TE t[ :0 *J

iX. 11R A, xM 11e"tu7 lt itflw4 R3rjit¢m A Ait 11

ff IYJ PIM: it Ex JR f g*H]r± f* -4 * 7X ftM -[& 47 It8 iq f-iE'-&tZta%A*- (198t;X*4*OM;<4%,>

KA Et-i-ff i#A( x t Bl W r AL l-IFEl . iN:A E ElsbM XP;ll--W/If/Qi'd-(IJ l;ft <i-T. -7f)q wv

KL+-;ifil¢u filu:xti,k Twh-r)MfiA- R -*k T tri *3

Page 19: World Bank Document€¦ · tIT 1997 L* t iflfO * Alex F. McCalla4gt 28X ~j, JfiNlit . Wendy Ayres, Hans Binswanger, Arturo Cornejo, Sanjiva Cooke, Douglas Forno, Dean Housden f David

A llWtiE T fMt xltt itt t, * 4A zIff-ak a M f¢tfff*, '' Ettatif f,Nttt< -t~fm Ht, -ww-

IttrfMITXt>t LN D-iL Na v/1 1qE AtttihA:Nflj tEXXTt 7Je09ffo 4F'K t'1I>K * t 3 1L A I -,

ffi ,I th1}gr -@T*, ) J

J ~ ~ L~k~AI (-stLTtflsJPJJb-) %-;lJK',g-- i * * 'fiC .& iR-qiT-MSb

4 Xlt T-. Pk * b? -1 t s Mk -ti f -4 fiC ; -16 Y- gP g ~ * f R- 'IS r t l t, g,,,

ffi* , =K -) !

k it I 1tLkF, - T_ ~z

* 4/k I~kiŽf t R T~12 t~ wA tAo

-Iof)9 rilgRfOC MPA1'Xt ' tV Atgt iIJ PI I'' If -i+ * Ro .AX- il. i

M Nli ff t{| I1- r- laj itt ^ ^,l X 1 tfi AMtWf fttW Ma;@ SWtli

kL* TI faT- --̂ -t JK§ Tr1 f~ )1 -M) -] PF4III? LH YiJA W jt ~I,

t#h-ttt%t,~Fx W:ftE jlJffiSw -tE r

4 i2 A, .AfLitilJU 1iA*.itANii ;lifM ttWTfWO n 199 1L2 tHIIfV

LW M @fi 1 tH+i TL s 5ii Jl t A#J 3d # t t(Xwit AtAtff(, -fMUI BzLtVtlw']NM, #J'A P113

Page 20: World Bank Document€¦ · tIT 1997 L* t iflfO * Alex F. McCalla4gt 28X ~j, JfiNlit . Wendy Ayres, Hans Binswanger, Arturo Cornejo, Sanjiva Cooke, Douglas Forno, Dean Housden f David

lafJEFt½t,1 , ff, I, 7t R/J'Et It , W 48 rJA j M., A+lM SZX/<W TF ttWt$ 71 nt h%t LA jjIr-6 f :

APIfl ;& W4if-lQi o 1996 1j1{g2,J q ER 7

o wi1$rZfi t 1 fl Kin, 4 R-2PA t t W ft 7;i j V1T ~ 3i1A 1Arbt D- Ill- i A -t t tI

t TIA;tyo - M 90 tz J:n M a A# JJ ;t MWM pg1ffxf#*#lj>tfi WStZ. i.oItVEA* -igt 9A7L

lAiMolXJfiit X/Thiitt<JB;0 * 196Ei1 5H

Z9-* Mfqf b qITi:f 196V ff/ K K , 4iT , Ai'~ WQtH

19 9 6 IF- UX3 2 3i H ZQrt t1A lA ±I rJh H

(J 4 1997 0f 1000k t*R 19 M A t96,b MBM11L

M01996 *- 3 1q 23MAtXS\Attli ft,0ii4W,<1tM ^

go 1 5X47t IkttE-Wt )W 4*fi,mot# lOeftlS7i4S

kitAc, OA. 196*11k 5 H

S~il--I A 993,Wj 1 96 'Vv i,-'4J iT t I fT ttW / A$FX MEXM ftt-lbi2JIitt X1MaW t i T T tft -1fitt -6 qg il ttR)-

HA 1-iXJ"S n ,I,4 Qit 1- '+1-i 4R AT Y'R ft~l- f 91S

* -ThU M t-i ... &, 1965t7 t' tt'@t:@R/M 1t

( 1 )9 4 T,)o 1997 Mf+A*Pg7- 1000 Ak 1996 V- 11 A lC At f 0, j$f tW Vffit-nV

XtP*# AMt , f'lJ o 71(tiE f7 H AiR1 J-Q o9 7;rX 'J t f S1;2t f t 3

PI IXtMI) X_i Aa thkJc M, AtAslX tXt ;. 7 *J Ad *a MR

fto:jr Y13r iEiEa iSfjZ l P;b]-- Mj,lr-(eeo

Board) c.i3At A < i/t z:l

A -4;W', P27.IT-,./< A;M 4 SKPAtl~J t W lw#ffiEtflti;S:IJfiBIElatk*iifZ9 ,6Wff EM Mtlj V, lkt ;tfi Pl MqV fi T;i P'l W (product

Page 21: World Bank Document€¦ · tIT 1997 L* t iflfO * Alex F. McCalla4gt 28X ~j, JfiNlit . Wendy Ayres, Hans Binswanger, Arturo Cornejo, Sanjiva Cooke, Douglas Forno, Dean Housden f David

13

lines) 3SjfkX 7g 69ttj i t) t-

tR 1 0,Rfi 7Y Ni REk rt - i X ru A thR t tRM 4t EXFYt, MTh{ruMCfr-O [rki

* 7Jtz5i-tH4e3hf; %hE,''XtStlj Jim

* 1 t'%±Rti -i i iS

{0g#SAA tt$-tW 3ZI. {9 fIktTTY ti -f 'Xttf fitAE WIt t iMit.

X%tft)ItS SKXIt/; i1'Ft (1T hW4Fi) V S2JTU5!%1;*s &1URtJJt lt70 VlEfPtT{thMtŽtik+7Jf; tUIi (ft#tUfiIWXI XlE0l±AiŽ051) t~i!thE; UkTu$TWA4FkT (ITA ttttS:J$akTitbtThRKM4470 A,

.)MKY~ 11#i3Wt8Lht14E7g ttuNThH 100 &k0 tfI3ff{F1P)Vt

Htfl'WSIMJittl1XftttZ%, XTtftWtRITh fV4WtJO HtiXLt t4ttkAtE7tE,

iffi%iS V f|lu -pfltYBUl f?JS$4, MtŽ2IL4it <tRiWP&IEtXl.JnE { ItETh A tt'JPitblE if ?.:tt'$ii[W;'W1ft%tZ "E$K}"5tSg¢M9tB;"

Z ttT44#t@IT, {*tK:l 1tll TWA RICYtittL4WIW, U7XtJAF 5

-Xtt{t ¾4LM4, itffiRMt0+# {*flMNWLtt 3@-A1ttTLtTh , U X't

:%1MY X *i ggX//t b U t ff FA -a S

At,~-fIiZtMM A; tuMWtWIWX

XtLLrIn&, 4$f+jS 20%o {M5lEtWtn X0 Kilt:

tt'YX T fFIt *, rTiA k,tTWX 470

*A) 9:"i#r IVritt't 36%g tt 0 #31ihtM?RiT,MdI

* t$%WdHSmTW<ittlJ@39%I4kul1tW WxtK JSiltff1Xt

* LE.A it'RIitACt 1t5ThŽ=7tf W ttt*l; 4fi*ti KltL #ffihtiXtSS

,#,rtAVWg2IJkz To, $CTI f9iAAt1qj T2% fP $WMA7-tAlUbr 7 5

Aic ItuPL3 34%,, ,&>bGJ$B SkZ2 t fPi X 1* tAT NJIkt LliR A , t l AZ-AI ttVM1s VfltVJQF t A

$ Tdsff1h ATht-±ft f&I t yI%.ff i4$SL (M;-4R J), ,

Page 22: World Bank Document€¦ · tIT 1997 L* t iflfO * Alex F. McCalla4gt 28X ~j, JfiNlit . Wendy Ayres, Hans Binswanger, Arturo Cornejo, Sanjiva Cooke, Douglas Forno, Dean Housden f David

14 A#V: &RtYIrfie

1 -84t Ajt 19"BI A' iE A, t!, rt WJ g t i4TV

1.I # , 'L, I I

M* I -f J9 qut- -iJ A4Rt, lg I -5 Mw Al I T: 40&E-&tjD>zE)lliiJE9XM; t#1#WE $L~AMPT$/>hL4i ttRJi)II0 J

o 19 9 6 a--j, f 0, k f3f, 1 xITff,H f f)ff~ Fi PT i f rxMMfNH0

19%RIE T44AlIMtAJP@o 1. ij SA-IIog

Ln hI, UR WFT 4. t Vi 4 l kI- Q -

*it @%0 b 199 8 4tfl1' tfl0 tIn , 18e

L p

ill Rf ,t}- )lo

19a f r±t f,J 'Tt$NHExt ff R 4E AffiJn9iei-

fitlfI4 0ll%;k4o f-IMJ Xt lT::~ f mll l i.9* iJth2Jtl 8>@Xt,i

19 9 M it V- Pt , ;T' Et1;k R F, ::fMI r iftf #fl jof~

fLfl4 0, X JV V, ff g-Ju M: , ~ ;glv4 A 09iRt-

E XIE{S> Re3E 'TjtI

ik JEEtbJA+tt4K A ;i A 6. lASxi@t

T , 4t I -i i --A I " T,q iR oq

7. f+tt9S@X 0X 7. ft, t k A * @S (t W Wi1)ftgt, stut5ftffilt, A)jW, MUMN, (4kfm) t%m*goi t I At ,k 'A ft In EI1 ,)qF fT t, I X R 1ei f . f3t 'tt -rWf R kl q I YulJ T-

,288iIJ$AQ2, tt$'t 50%o httfitS

El tkit It ffl t6ri, tl M E4 M J jt4vAo 1h14 rQS),

AtuktEX4fi tlxRt I- a * fAto vf, o 6MV

Page 23: World Bank Document€¦ · tIT 1997 L* t iflfO * Alex F. McCalla4gt 28X ~j, JfiNlit . Wendy Ayres, Hans Binswanger, Arturo Cornejo, Sanjiva Cooke, Douglas Forno, Dean Housden f David

15

-ig tttW 1'g &t g A i 4 ffr tA -*)7 kA1 4 ise II * Z O

k6guA3sSt4< (AA 'i F$2lXlaT eXp2 I F lr:R] F It- -3atU ^e X"s+ b t6-$t4t J]o P9Ao MI fI]i+k14-LM*i?. ±

-tAt 1' f ol; WAM flAl A*t v vM Ik /h ob ;t7t Tt ~fi o1 it 4lF 11 .' 4 y 11 49 Aihi n vA f v1 I :& Rl i, @ Tt 14 6W a 7-1 4 M f f ol ip f If i L 9 gy tu 4 q N t r, f1 ti H, -K it

a "W±-.( HD4R,

* i{fiR%ERt1, %Ii i1 't f' $ A3

,T J4F . i4t t iL

* I I V 'k 23 I X fO 1' I Wr V K f

iT J* if;1-1fQ 1J

T* ;t i -45p t tZ t -F] tti-Th;tALd f'l: ii Tf A0<l i t-! Ai t)l, -f A, .~- i; t ff . 2 Il t nk R{ a % W o4tJ+ s ! t s8f T I, bJit- f'l 11 r,O X ukfHT f , fg. fF-t4l |: I -t ;[ |~ FQ / t X '1A5: W RI t

* As, -T 44tr §;i*,*5.< N f WA 1'Pri) 6il T,X pg Xg wX.g

t,4VA 1't.tttt11tWZZt

i pff_A-E_tkg I,KkEW ttt

Vf-11 F\ERW \11t4-Mflot,D1

tkq X ff -aE0t @h ISr kr ,11X m lk tz i it plDl A ii;tt Ylii fl O

) A R 1t-i Nr t 41d fu UR j&k YIJ 2002 tRr t*1) a H IP f 80 % it, Yii AX*K I tet 31 ;L §Q + 40 A t ilt A AP t) ; iiF w 4 Ro

Wt i5' )j itt+Xg ITZ1JJ&4 1.4 sifil T X, H A kof T Ak

;tg -11.2 ['tE,r 09 28ffR4 ffW MI J1, R i A1 ')I lk' -t-t11 gt*ir @-- -f -rXLV-J%

Klll4Fit}q,<61Hto attAtlj eQ ,r]t4'k:&X

Page 24: World Bank Document€¦ · tIT 1997 L* t iflfO * Alex F. McCalla4gt 28X ~j, JfiNlit . Wendy Ayres, Hans Binswanger, Arturo Cornejo, Sanjiva Cooke, Douglas Forno, Dean Housden f David

j:Fj ?t itWnt jA fIp IA ag'i

eAitSA4+% 1E,~~ tX'ttiS,6 3*3W1

M at;Ttg1 Mw Ni g4 IQrL Ma rj- 99 0 ffJ

;R 17 W t rl :1X1g- Rl,3_ t t L* I] A N Eto t0, flrt )eY1lz tNOll:tf MRtHtthitiiNil

'-]mlMAt$i0 f F q p . trrWf (@ E19+ JlMJtg 0,9 T , 6,A m:AVT gr v4F,MK V l F t A *-) -i -1 _g r.4 N r NT )NJA 2 3 < T

OlAwfvfJf @g'g+6EV'%t 1.P#tolm RN%t Aff&MW:T;2iJ'4)

f 4 Xi$ tX 4al42 .`U 1P fl R |' a .q _)X At +g 1 t E X t- tt

tlf b'j 3~ttt S; -'j'f @T ff 7rA A@ O~

-1f )j ? i-X -LE tt f; wK IN }J it t IJ t (

ttX+lqF -L ,F- VI 00TR, b (WRe)

-Fi- SE 8$ 5E8,ttt0A 9 S W4 A V "PP_RA rI t W, V4 iX s1

F3iT VzA :FhE T, M i.t$R; , i b111i$ 1WARFK 71V9K; J Mft*ME, tllfe)'lkM T-I-ltttIo N:;*71TiR 21

Page 25: World Bank Document€¦ · tIT 1997 L* t iflfO * Alex F. McCalla4gt 28X ~j, JfiNlit . Wendy Ayres, Hans Binswanger, Arturo Cornejo, Sanjiva Cooke, Douglas Forno, Dean Housden f David

17

* 1T~~ " ioL

H ' ,L Nit4q oLfL WhkL-it@. Ho

V ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ a ft Yt Rk kf I 3M R -TlI 11 jA -J':- f F ffi T 9

ijakfX 1 9I}tfiit4 < 1.93 fa1 2020

*dA3MttWtRt ti2 A ~X.~bT~L±PR

-it LA 4 , P t i I t([

MlMIPf, fwph-Lolfk f VfqA -Ik I-1 -:jVftt - 13 A;fZ A,-f- +4T- Z H T,,- - -E X- -kM+8 I7- t" , H1.i)I0 2020 CAh'Nt 10 'I t

1, t7l 9 -f- Af T, A -,-, ,, ) L -t M ,'1 f * '* iA f tt 1 t WiI )5 T 1.93V 58 12020

JI A 58 t #,nW8tQktl f tJ

t~~~~~~ ~ ~ ~ i% J Ieit ; l A ig- ft .t riP ftY SQ $J M1587WK 2iQ\ , JtItt I 4E"iI' rX 10 {rK, 72% f2/* It& Ff t .i f fli Iikt M t ItIi- [ •tI V

* 21a7 T1kg t it-W ieggWS, a' legiSiTU l tiat tE77;St lSE -T,|l -

Page 26: World Bank Document€¦ · tIT 1997 L* t iflfO * Alex F. McCalla4gt 28X ~j, JfiNlit . Wendy Ayres, Hans Binswanger, Arturo Cornejo, Sanjiva Cooke, Douglas Forno, Dean Housden f David

-f -T R knTt(I nl At l lR,m tT1 1960 1 1 1. 2) 2

3 . t t Tit A h A 30 'it3f A V[@4# - Arx tol 'A- tiL m -lklti<et

2 /

/lE f lrtb~M'tft, j' n E XfT#.'IQ rE B 3

1P ' t tEWfiRa o~ Y -X H lTf Attxjtb

950 1960 1970 1980 1990 2000 2010 2020i

1I t-1SS JlttES;ffiti L. k ; Ik

oFVRDS _ _ _3

A t, A4 Ex*1)Lwt1q Yet t

-2

tnTE7ttSKttAs,:ffiW.<14;et S1. 2 1115-- 1989 44AmR

*Al 0 9 *18 Wo I -1 2 -1 0 1 2

St Vk Oc/7 N9 V -itilJto ~ Xto q Ai I-K 0I -2

T,~~ ~ ~ W 145rtR 0 t C~i tA

,;r lJI fVR~ % ;t iB tt.f 1P E8 ,-- 2- 2 3

ftf 90* f:1 r a' ? t V f *9.- M t 5 ;, A l, GPfr-* Jf *~L

YSE1 70 *Jtfr&iMf 80 *ft+AMVb4ltZk K I l Al" * i W OLI;4 U57 lLt±E,. k * An Braun RU lt -2 99 -

llnu@9lTt\lkiiiX?Vo nlull o -3r-a-1n 19293 4 5 6

Page 27: World Bank Document€¦ · tIT 1997 L* t iflfO * Alex F. McCalla4gt 28X ~j, JfiNlit . Wendy Ayres, Hans Binswanger, Arturo Cornejo, Sanjiva Cooke, Douglas Forno, Dean Housden f David

I'nH1 19

* 1.1 ai4ifftg±t%: =flfltiSE8hi

i 'P it I'r1tP lit 1995 4 5 Z7{, 1Kfon 5 q-ffl 17.5 4{wt&, TlAtLTri 1996 5 AR M I'6, XI IN tIfl [I 0V 1 82 % V.91Wo

/1J -lit 65 % )K -L Ai21% o 1995 FAt 6A 1S1 -P N < t%t ti &1 [A1 '-j ;lit Iq 9 Ki~F *f i9J;*tt, htfffttWfftt* 4, rAthiLo. *1±isktl9±j, hft ff,flLbt. -1995-1996F-4T -ITAtflL, ftWrtWiTP$ *tAEk'k I *i:Th, N 1986 4VL(*, ttr-3.2%, tr7 Wh :-rl JA 49 T>f 3AA fljNttiiPi P1 Jl itf. 3A-1M it k 1996

17 35ZRI rT {PT>LZ, tU1&t5tb9fl WT-tWftWY9 f&fl.A. X Et l AY-Ji ) 69 -K, ffi E 80 4Ff Tti-,+ YJ 81 )Xo *ib V 3S A na I, U 1foI0 f +itRpx IPt * A Wbl| VI I3 WI N$ h

I-jLA,ES 'aY l."'/.ith <iiPim tAww 9MiJI 80 '4 f O- (f Pt,'lfklM. f J BtOrt;,flittj 1995*Wft5007o1{. 1993-1994WFP 1M1A jikOtlH"t, Y 'Th%tIitF d S1i ni 1100 ] o Jli tftO lit R

80 'ŽWfF{-t1 k{WItFl, e-"T-t 1r t

M s 80) $ #it Wtr ff r?t ? Pttx A 3 * T1986 iT9iWb ik3 : < iUt3t4.65 f Wti ftU $iN Rk4 O28.1%. A Lz; 72 ai sti P4;ijWt A @«

III] 1,:Y- f';iEiT Lt-t ftdi ii IN ThM' t 4tAl t It lt$ t -tW. f N

I$4 & > H. K,qIIIui:N ~tffi%W RUT gt#4tX g{'r,lkf tA4t, ftA, LW 43500 h'z'tW, WI&flW ±fJRT *it4 -is, WI pr ,ZPA HIiLi 50 4

J,qi Of t0 1. 5 fEUti tf f t A ttfl 1995 M-FrCl .% iSTh){T, 111t,f4# ftAni:rit 2.36 176. 1995 4WIfWi$tWjs 17 M.

1 fB4tWiMT0P7 T 1966 i 1990 #tIf± 6 -MtQE Ylbt4JThk l, fJt9 20 ±tElV'O 9lt)80%, 4O%*fM*Th7 tftZ?

hi] I92iXtW; J 2EX025ttt#Xui24Z o X1J 4KMtb+j{XWo {nMiI pGHti,tkti$5, 3SZtJP30±Ifl5Z, ±Stu iUfti aliLi%t#r0 Th4lm2j?tw,mn1t

RnI+H4X3Th¼ 3 {eUIOtflkhiAtA, W tbi t tt%'$iUL{tu-f, tUt4±gKex±)\ituetu1#mur1, RJK fStAt1 MTRwWn½$t;4T PJftM JSiNMt .- -- gz-3 BYL rl 0g 32 (A .),Z-^-iR fL- -- fl- ffttft-ft -%L93!M R -sttt'0l-rz,7X 1e 1.

JftfI f 1t I tAThTA`7t 30 *0, tSt* W *tge,±t t te'# LI, &2'tnxk1'tM-Tht#Et5N %t'

Page 28: World Bank Document€¦ · tIT 1997 L* t iflfO * Alex F. McCalla4gt 28X ~j, JfiNlit . Wendy Ayres, Hans Binswanger, Arturo Cornejo, Sanjiva Cooke, Douglas Forno, Dean Housden f David

I1 3 r±g4ASJR ±@W+&, (5

IT ''syL McCalla, 1994 ),

1.8

1.6~

1.4 | io7Jl, Z

1.2. A M r 70% -lL k M-T fl Ht, Ir tO t

06 tir R, 4 Jt [l;P Jit )4P 2 5 /Zt340i2>

0.26 4^Xt90 4

O - - - l 3 Jt 30 A't1966-74 1974-82 1982-90

* rUT, eM 1ES, W"nX44Sto gItW

ut~0

NAVMt A tEXA RI fZ'S#TP n

M-EuMatn rt,i ij 1' -

4II 30l 7UTO J+0 *li uI *&1

R i tM'1i ftt o

HA f# PI)Z :gRq ri 46tA 0, ' 3Y riT A -- $ rilAitS O DNA : C tb .......... §tWXaZ

Page 29: World Bank Document€¦ · tIT 1997 L* t iflfO * Alex F. McCalla4gt 28X ~j, JfiNlit . Wendy Ayres, Hans Binswanger, Arturo Cornejo, Sanjiva Cooke, Douglas Forno, Dean Housden f David

, Vl'.' HJ t~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~- '.-y p vo t!9$j oL/y IM .1'/ 1`1 II 2 1MhJk /YJU 9HqXt

,M VI -VEVMfk -,o {.tAn M- ri?1 R t,,

tAi- fil RI t.,~- *A-tXA'tln ' UE~fmM ff WI t"tEBiJAtetWljval-*jvt tA 4t 2, Sg-zx{4X XX<WE4

( t In I (j -[f,, - ,- L, 9A i $ -T ri fri fC L, +- [

pr R, t t¢ X ; t ta81 E A X X M k rr i M r.

ll;A25+:eM W jtl t XlXkt 4 t P, An tl !-t 44iafr m-Iftt Lv

+e ? t' %-[gTI *@E 9/ I- A, fq)]¢m ,XEol +--A4

flWXL;h2A1 1 ]FE,-.fE, 44" -rfl,h0 E$SjtOASTRWArf 1akLS

9 X f* IrII1 *!:g t,'b 'AE# ~t V VI -lk -Tg MP- Al k J-f t hb+tL [JMf tliR )p T)W 1gi t -4 it f A"'W XI ft- ff -#I 4t t t I (f jtJLt4 a'til$ # rXl- r, lk ffjg mt:C;glihphrftL

,ltg iE A 'L-';H fl 4QTTi W,* ~f* V11 P YktAV:j 'f 4 A A vff -ii fh T

fl, -1 t * 4RA WS I ft t]Aj -4$,&> ' 1f IHlSt2X A K ful It.l

Page 30: World Bank Document€¦ · tIT 1997 L* t iflfO * Alex F. McCalla4gt 28X ~j, JfiNlit . Wendy Ayres, Hans Binswanger, Arturo Cornejo, Sanjiva Cooke, Douglas Forno, Dean Housden f David

22 V fl, t~ : M)< L 4J |f

-V?% @ iE ~-ft- 4 It, it "JI 'a'e'1 l -

ft TrV iH t t et A- A f1 ~A V 1 T 0Jff4 I p- l MI "t IM t I 7?f fi1 k.~lf

t kVP ']a i 1-TtR f - IAXA f f I9H WI]S# e

-B4liQl).;: t 41i-S, }EX fXi

I TFr W l 'iFA;tk it IffH -Li-M il4 4j Fjt.[k. tZ

a: -L it L.M IlW1 9 4t- f fiXttE4B I A4Jt0t-fXs trE -tA O't' iti

'Ifnlik, 7rCX r4fL2LIX aK E -is21 t,I IXF-) 1'jJ t -l t -Fv-l- t

f l I'rli R, lMii Lk V 4r4- 4t /1 :A 114 0 ;XtE l RI H ji WR-i ~ At 'A w kl- ol Mk. n't I IJ,

tE . kA 4t' Q WL f1 1- X. f:, - IN klA lffi PIg -'t Wr U i m =1 A,xt -f -f aQ -P Ia8 ]0 42 T- it

tEtQkt@ffitXt,l i"-t S.BM M4a3fi ME W at+f- M 9

W 9a~~~~~1 JR 1 t it 1-T *-l Il J3 4KWt;$;A4 XtW, <PSa8Xis1 J

t ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~~~~~~fS I'h @4; iR >BfiXg\kLIt ti] M%Iwt-

itXEitt~~~~~~R M2 Iq ]§*gi jp t It F jj;,< i , I li, 11 4 = itti

WU fi, fA8 b, 9511 &t f't A O~ 4X 0, PHl FT, M' itt 41 NkIA W)vj5

1AP54\/k 1tM tAlfi fT oAS1 t TE tER If, -J V N iA .Y r IM X, A; LAV X

ta;R3lk M o a1R11 REAOI1 aiSi t V4eXtph it$ t1X1g.WM il ;tI rc ff lt

Z@@lttWto IA-E ExlUJlkWllt BIrlj SA rttt f -I IaCfs Lh t HP 1

RS I'] 0, 41t Il rStLS 4 -5 M J A' MIf-

t4~~~ ~ ~ ~ IA #l RI t~ AI 2+X -1d & f1 1 t4 3IE? Rt ORk5!% f4t rJ A -1V [& A4 i-j IXJ VI Ir it&7 q1W ;g kxt &

"I-31,lg*oj,4y-~1J , fMlv1VM I[*.ot iAe RIC l tE1 H. M N 9E I ;> X

ZI Ittt R t k f k t 5t S I] I gwX i'31- -,:y fi $#

tgfIMLEMN 4bM$MIFbayEltMf E.xR

Page 31: World Bank Document€¦ · tIT 1997 L* t iflfO * Alex F. McCalla4gt 28X ~j, JfiNlit . Wendy Ayres, Hans Binswanger, Arturo Cornejo, Sanjiva Cooke, Douglas Forno, Dean Housden f David

I4Ji'GLH 23

4S#4X W+Aflfil2{X{#tltA&$ftt

52t a/MaN kf>b5k3XttTh /rN ThhJW@BttIfr~YRWtltLU]o 5Ž%tlt ZtUt L~ t~4N ~AQ > I If Ui ViltHX # #; 1g1 3T ) Rt lli 4kXt 7 ; t R A F ffi f p} , W WIh @ la w IMJ

{21t7J 5K4Mt T-toQT t flLh4 tftJ *i 1gl

P0V*j1Y7 t V, ft PI f & t1.o tt#tPitt

11 t)bLAt$4ht< tbiWthLtntW4btt 0 {fl 9t, tu413tkWjtb , 4{t2ThERtXJgg@>i4fi, W:WW3 tl~ttO tfiThThtE -

f ti' jiTlS 1tt! IR$lA Witt U, XrAlt Hdt fAi'5,T tI$t

tttd11, tH P.if- trlfl1MfqIjt W -i)J t,cHI*,jrtV

* VhTW+^JiTR;I {It1g,~h iEQ#1 UL4fftR*A 4HtfliXiQT,j ,TT ENTh R

* 4TV -f ½ItS X <¾l'] %4;ti% (ATl A*W&Ii

* Wi- -Li- ,LAttA Lkfflt; 0tIFftAL4 f t 4iA, Wi

Vt WI? W.] rt4 ThJTh tIMO Xi[4tt 0&ftosfl%tA1t

fI{o %&WiY;&tli tt4 fli]4tIKae%!rn; wTh&. }Jt4U ttt

jvr _'5 -f- *4^ PI fiAiOj;1L'rt 1 t4IJT tt Al lMJKS ;h

Page 32: World Bank Document€¦ · tIT 1997 L* t iflfO * Alex F. McCalla4gt 28X ~j, JfiNlit . Wendy Ayres, Hans Binswanger, Arturo Cornejo, Sanjiva Cooke, Douglas Forno, Dean Housden f David

I

Page 33: World Bank Document€¦ · tIT 1997 L* t iflfO * Alex F. McCalla4gt 28X ~j, JfiNlit . Wendy Ayres, Hans Binswanger, Arturo Cornejo, Sanjiva Cooke, Douglas Forno, Dean Housden f David

25

&tnigLLiXy, ff4YJFf1Efk?

Al- l W 14zty t: mo l { Tfff t

4zP 1 B J : ll~XlfVft f"lIb) ol l H Ai"Ai&/, A, r+ OECD[q*1, $fi MXb

ffgi IA iL 4 t 11 Qt V ff t.tttt

il 2XtSRStt1 *- M4&t; tA FRU M ol id ta XEi

4A x LJA Mo tE3fitSi MM W ?1RiiIMMtrM A1- f (1 I tlkX JTA r n,1

0 ~ f 4t Eit Y;) Ell¢ A-L ;, 1 6W A g6A Il t

fAMt1pf tfj2 , A 0 inMT1A

O ~ ~ ~ ~ ~~~~~~i )t It ff Wo f ~ nV j 5O-

itE.aet 1;tatA IAqI - 1 Rtt y,t I tHTSEh R,

WS XRtHe rat>tatAb?t$eq@X§18o S Z

(,~~~~ ~ ttt $ 1t GP 4 t t W

tEEAXFil'fI@Sk@W Wt*R62b*46tgt>E0t~

Page 34: World Bank Document€¦ · tIT 1997 L* t iflfO * Alex F. McCalla4gt 28X ~j, JfiNlit . Wendy Ayres, Hans Binswanger, Arturo Cornejo, Sanjiva Cooke, Douglas Forno, Dean Housden f David

26 j,'t : aKXl j-YjF

.ipt +lr-tbt<-t -rpo iS flt M bW itf * o;f hU%

4AWFo 7O 1(q 4ISf * V 4f1- 1AL, 0 9 iT

wr±i A; A %tmR -T N ltA A gi fld o1 ± i -M 10- 3W fpA t ; v #tu /t alil ti ge *

4etttXIMRlpffl+AWi; -,5qpA, VA- Mett

FSlBtEAtWm [bl G Igv0 1 xt i,oGo 9 I* t ;ghtS t t PI; TR .,fls ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ T *gI -.4XK X1 f4y8t£11;t1] ± *- i! 9 IN * 2 ti f I v fX It, -4 ARi

{ -97)I] iV 1995 l 6 4L41(I£Ht t

* -~ I \- Il 1 9 fll ~ E i

* V 1992 1 -- tv *k- hJo

1995 6St hp qil2iJ @GA4 jt t iJ M -4, #, In, iIJ

* PI aRW,Ml J (g<2.12. 1 YJ #4, tJ4,J

ft - W4it m8 0 tWm Bt iS 21 r A Ab Q Wit, 1PTAI:ko

tSIif ix L Au I A lT fRXt -A t+y Iiitt *kY9*1S]8fi

JLH ~ I' ll>nl ~

wSt4- --$t w# A Il t 0, It

*T-f 'l-±A d9H Aq 4A A 6 I 31 46tb.-rt :SEIIWfi f LM, $ IT A A-q0kt tMkA f ';kR f xt etXtt\%i F-- jR 4 A As M ,t f Ma X 4t, *- VMWAPMf ij

A, 1X A * Xit:PIX I& a B 1"k trt nm , tgl

it tn. it YW ff OY itct -$ ) 'I: ITJ r;r H4L* l

Page 35: World Bank Document€¦ · tIT 1997 L* t iflfO * Alex F. McCalla4gt 28X ~j, JfiNlit . Wendy Ayres, Hans Binswanger, Arturo Cornejo, Sanjiva Cooke, Douglas Forno, Dean Housden f David

2.1 7&AkiR Yt£ tkrn

LS' (IFC) it¢tfi ttt ":A imtl1992%o IFCE :tohiLt - -t#t{f1992*, lFCAl.-#Rt•tiM l

M1'WS;t-{±!ThA;fNNll/FPtt. 4¶TO%T ~t77tW&IFCYtt$vi-skY.Wfltbt$%, 8T

-S '.@uJt R5 II FCTMM,[ 3W7 @ plj iWit 10% R s ly ts -W T, et MAt 0tL It4ik R R I'so

ft if f iWkt. A tlM W H M, NA ATIk ' I, iLt9l2W AV_t-V'J it- f I ]

1 fi ilk, fg 4 )£t, V O A;t%taT. I ,1 11 : i;,,,I ffi j

2. i g 7 jw

1992I r IFCM ATe -At 'A i - -iw jftyh t Hk _r Ik'i-L-h fX t Ot W. Ft, I 72i$7T E'Ap ,K R TA tktl -L I FC Aft .1-L- [L@T AM '17, c k

.I IF11962t1 8FT fl $LtNt$ y 1 A 0 V A rTr 9. iSR a t L, 1992 4m0n4-{Lt1Mtn 8 ft

J -T 1 k 4L r4, i+ & b JR M Vill ft' iYti, t J0I 7* l- l 1X T L 81 ff tJ M 3JJ %X P 111 'g HS ;j - f, I Wj 4P i4;tI FC Xt J * x Tf-T Xf V AL , .;l I j J I k f jMl

',l|* T1 il 3, m jlke/ C PT A kg CT ft i M S ij 1- If b , 'l IIT (e k'j g{tl;Q '§i ii fy :,, a

Vo IFC J' 1996 if 2 f( 12 1 6 ? {Jl f** ffk X# ift! A tlik _A J/ tLk & Vt o l - it-; i-t rr_l t v tilS 'vv4 ~ 11'ATo kfX f A

| I, i1 fT; 'I M . . 1 F -|ZZR, -W M, i# $-k -X- k 4 V 8 tjvft /< w 6A *r <j ll Mr E .

2. 1 T, M g_WR f A _VIL V,t-t &R t TI-V- # , n fX/t a 3 )R , j n 3 f1it

T ilv )~~~ ; TR ffi i 15 IML f Ifi

t X(1996 f 2e4A IA F/450 8,000 3,000

400 7,000

650 6,000 2,500300 ,0

250 iW:RuiI 5,000

400 4,000 2,0002000

150 3,000wr.100 2,000 1,500

50 1,0000 0 I 1,0001986 1991 1996 2001 86 88 90 92 94 96 89 90 91 92 93 94 95 96

ai l>Thtfj#E1'4tU4. &Akfl. MttMg 9Ak. Wi1t$. t. *. t6CIS4. $Wit*J. -'ftfVt. tc

,- t lJ - IL 4.

ffJ ySbTWag

Page 36: World Bank Document€¦ · tIT 1997 L* t iflfO * Alex F. McCalla4gt 28X ~j, JfiNlit . Wendy Ayres, Hans Binswanger, Arturo Cornejo, Sanjiva Cooke, Douglas Forno, Dean Housden f David

28 A#tVJU : i ' 1'i . -T -

tPt-_ ONt$t 2. 1 ) o T-/fIRkj4X%tf8

* *TK I, f1t i-F*k 0 ; o t OECD Q Po

-1- 4fft4 ft Mi F, -tH

t 4R4SO 1986q*. X'g'dtEtRi:AK1

/FT'Tifr5%o %fI1tIWThi>t td1t

fteX -r4 te f Y A~ iltt Wi- -q it it

bI ;$R t#1> 1R1g$>h4[I tiKSt A V ff N-X1141' 4J Eo-U) A f-t W] fftA t1iE f ;lt t M0 HI, -k 1T 't¢IJ W, iiiEt )YX

48, % tMLTIio * ftiJt-TIR t T a M t

*~- 1993 1h[ 5 fl Yh 1996 T- 5 'k iiN iT t )t AR.lR XlAA, ;its l4 Yhk;E T

*1 10 1 ,MR9AWfal-101 '

tAi VAfr F _R-r tT) tstt * IffF H _ittq H tn ltV Ao

m 9 m if WE PT F_ H fiLR,z . 4JQ

* pl t At J l Ak on. f Th, T

8(4 9 El j+ tf-;i i-L 4P fi g 0 ,*1 T ittGlt lJJ

iEC f i tAXt% Ti_-- zrI(j ) * 4 to@ @ t3J tt W

VK P99 7V 5 r15 HIJ f1996 rA 5f MMRA Tiittfit Ie It

-rfftip H1 _Z35N_ § N-k ift - it 50 % I %, IAI4{rS )'s ±1' it Et if rn )g JG H l I- - tp__ t!IT

*~d_ 8()+R tR 4 fE fit + K '4 * 4 '" bR t TiF, fit W

LX@QfI'r t,>, :14FJJ< iSX A tTitl/IRO'

t7 S,tttik 2ew e$ tk

*1 P$ JUXWaZtfi gM1{%t<8HGmf

Page 37: World Bank Document€¦ · tIT 1997 L* t iflfO * Alex F. McCalla4gt 28X ~j, JfiNlit . Wendy Ayres, Hans Binswanger, Arturo Cornejo, Sanjiva Cooke, Douglas Forno, Dean Housden f David

t i 9HA -p f* 1 CTkW ( C, 3f Eif h tES f BaR I %fi:. N H W it i~ l J P Rl 4 4 < W1 f St -E ff LL , 9.k ltieastn[i . RvfficRQW1SN WlZvAlAs,3 F,O fP-5Srlr

it 9M z 3,AKLb ip 1t t9k t 3Rgta WkW M laA . i,p s A t ) It4 fat r ft -t

; t E57ITI) H k 1981 - 1989 5 58% % i l {r1kIHW$lhuJ 19 9 5 7 8 % -- -46 lt @rW V> IIal P O f-1. N , -r± W)t t4a:i

,t iJ I I;PkTlN 'p& -r-IV -, E f (I'pfi- m:3t Af" --* ittijA A" 5 P T i 3 .9 (Ot 2.4 tf 2.5)o th{ft EHJ@tEL#l

lkp> It1 T I MJI fRtL tS; 7Wo I-ItE>q 4k[EMEAS IEfilt N >tMt. j L f U Ikt T trO lt A H

it ffi&X;i Al xt rj0I31'1~T,41+t fl Vi-lROoW1. l,~T

*HFMTIai 4a74Pt, M tt L t -t 1 I44 IZ; @.7 i; c4tJ i?t ra a< 41 3d *J lli f k~ WJ #;f Mf GX ttJ XT1 O 4J tM ffL

fIt V2 t -k il - :X TYI H jlt +'Maktll (At2 l)o , Pf

ftfft rF',U Fri, ~ ~ ~ ~ A --L T)f H 0, Af ri V I' R~C It r± gE 1- -i t} f n ttR'p

fT, A V ol iSt EX . I' I i/A;It i it Mo A -, H-, * 3-T R 9g

3-t T' WU ~t ?~3*- A :t k 7'M * ~A iR t i- @Et 2.2)A PtIlltIT 'P t 2 f I t * AW lttp ra AikPalk fllll, V

* ~ }i£i48A8> 0 fu$t i{:feTitltJiQitTh@P (~ti£tREKt rkttiwt~2.2) 0

'A>^ ful ) ,;o +* iF, 8Kf f0 -'j W ai-E, rli*PItO 7, if Ill* Fb20 -'I

711 it4o tWM q 150 t fq l S<- tg . It %** 4i S' 1-II tfo - 7PIa t ALh J;IJ11 (IiH2.1)o

ttx ~ ~ stJemtI. L{ttX WIL'4

Page 38: World Bank Document€¦ · tIT 1997 L* t iflfO * Alex F. McCalla4gt 28X ~j, JfiNlit . Wendy Ayres, Hans Binswanger, Arturo Cornejo, Sanjiva Cooke, Douglas Forno, Dean Housden f David

V4t 2.2 a* #tVAk:i

&i*iit9fI3t4ThiIZfftYRai di#3fXTP9 44EISX-ktTX$?tbA 1979 *# ItUWO 50 ff)iAlAki A*P --!MLft'i tj if]i N F t--tT it 2-ok;HC 'Er AM a t f YU ) ;M rp"l ifit1 Wt xlf T.ft¶W{UTh! 1 i.- "H 1t80f-tN, Wt * X&U,RA J r '*2iAA 'P4 Itt- 3/4W)

V rL 180 14 f t , :ffi -tf! %J1 " Id ¶4 (f- P iIf L7- "akitQ) "PiltWTht[

ti" -- k 5tvALVk ittt S m t -H i Lt{PThTtH0 @K/t*ffi ROd[XfMlt * R7tR eR-F LtitCJi.Wf 'lff&VTHkPi Ya l l IQ AS I , ,X &t X S tA W ,, ,- X - 4 I Pi 'k

IkXiWitfPtiJ, ff 1S40 _ at lA i , J4Ž1tW fSfiJ Th Ti

* i Pt IrJ I ffkt4 I t t:fiV l ,i V It IA,Ll Ai &IWIk2t 0 e F t X f- fW -,lA ft WPL YJ41 lll GX/$'t i Q

pit#, W'4IWAYt"U*A ½bf L' Pi t¶1t, IA4ŽJ -tJ,iZAUt

1'RIiI7f I F,l"NY'] 0 "i4 ' XI A ½IJ tT RV, .IN E , I t :'Thi1i rLY i* 4 AxiF,

7513 14 iJe T l P t rt 14 v> R rIk (I im. v IR TV f 1:p a,i f iP tr .o 1t P PE ffiW 1# ri L~ r iufY±k'I5Yh nJF4@ 25l "ti itfIeJ& t&Ž1kP3k-$ j iux aJ4tfWut-, ri> Li ThLkh,

83% (Gs Pi'LLi!) it A fTt LtO 1fit{ t i- tELS )A iAj &v lairIit

* kisOV1fiAktt h4'ft ftl -k:01P k&?ftUKti7WTdWUA9R'fO f1&tFPL1 &%, £RLIVXW217>5

it$fiTh~Aflfr~kE* JT449 ff-SIXhfQttYi

v~IPO~N 2 # 5Th aAflYV'IN r *n rI tiQ litMFw) r.fft¶Qt t9

iHFENtlAIAICMs 7) j 0M1 3,:S 1J-Ii-Wblito N a

p(ttŽ6lO. 6 V9A.

4%fi#mllMHAI$A htft, SThft IT, 41 All Ait t (fl

(¶l tm6r. 10 t4 , ) o H W O f -0 14 fiP- 7, 3f M A 3 ftl 44* A iR aE*Fs iNtX t9flWettt9 6124M,tt AtkkXc

d3ffJW9se49 it*PttEiE6.83).

Page 39: World Bank Document€¦ · tIT 1997 L* t iflfO * Alex F. McCalla4gt 28X ~j, JfiNlit . Wendy Ayres, Hans Binswanger, Arturo Cornejo, Sanjiva Cooke, Douglas Forno, Dean Housden f David

4t±i%, 4JJjtTh1WKIQt4'C 5J~ttt$T TOWtt4+tt' t-<fiJki

* 4Atx,ti i*@ 4mit&w tf{tX5t$#t±tUflstfIJtjtt 9{tt

{lfl3tS Thrl$It&lttcf~ 'in}rJl, ;ttiT 4#tt"rt* ti4rttf,f~IVt'#hnitl~ 4~y~n; TtttJta flT,~6.3) tnU-Vi (th6X6), f1FHEKE*4 ititH E Iqt Pfr tttMJfKf-hlihtWit 1 tJ

C3g1t4'•4}Ki t 5 IP k?t2IThY MXJ twf -tiRki4fhi*'ti Li 4W P-Min

_r H f ,i lp lt t't 4 i $ 0u-tM i-;1 - -E _1 - tt

rfl tt~t~~tijtWP x4tr l.j J ft:j t ¶U 1 :. ' 1- IJ+|I 1 --t

i t , it i -P]# J t i RF if, X 1 I t d fit ½ Fr

t Tf 5JR ti Xi N U,,il:fT i T A;Ft) £ t I I [P iE !tEhtRiLx,I 7.i¾.'P qJj ( tt4i, ITt4J AWtLffTh,It& H42kK)tn6.3) frflF'r (M-Xt1IMXWA-') -WT~ ill i A,t Ii f X 4;t f-, .-L R--h N Mk 4fti, K¢~

j~Vi A !- -- -', i rJ fEtn,-u FMi %tg T. t N ff P lFs

MUi rb 'U ±li RI , ihT t T t ftT R fA t IF ,i Li i .

~4i 2.3 'IIflJfltE

ŽPfr2/Ltt&'ttT 7W WIJrFlHl, 80-

90%i^ Lltk4St]J tjftŽW. /EkiIIsft±sAt,i (+2.) i- 1 t-ki {JAkhLt x;

it-SL,, tlj,9 |tir fir irAt tt- g4fitkt1 'it [± bLFU tt&X*{fiM2-3 A '2t Ifi1t-to

A -1 Lrt[', iik T -rS;7 t It- ,b ihk%fi QibF liaif Wt¢@r2\tl A0 i- 4 P- H t OPT 1A;1i;

3'' K -x xf 11 1~ ., PU fE Wf- U)l P1 ^ / tCX-" t -a£/j rp fi T K -4 fX t 9n g t 1 t f-

A)> tK §T~i~ Pt oZl A tr F-PTri if Ph T tpA tt 9t ']4t, -alx k iPr k 't 1h , E -, @

-90k4 k?j 90 % Wj if, %@ latffift V-4i#As RA T.lMPb't

it:SA3 -jo-JrIr f 11- ti n ril -l W< Jg + . I2 t c m bn 9 tf /

tE3 JLp -¢E At IYI va g .f T1 -I t tt 3@ttX f> t N -riJ Ink -4 Ih {i tl R

I'ff]P ~ l t --it «c : t r± EAi-f ~fw I f L f i lit tlI f -K- 3 CZo-.

Page 40: World Bank Document€¦ · tIT 1997 L* t iflfO * Alex F. McCalla4gt 28X ~j, JfiNlit . Wendy Ayres, Hans Binswanger, Arturo Cornejo, Sanjiva Cooke, Douglas Forno, Dean Housden f David

32 tt J: 9^Jjji4j

Htt, M$ti+hA£ wtSThWutt 0E tU §4A-O tIflJltPtfl3UiFh'L'

itlJt @gRWts itXtttiti' W4tJNH 4tg ThAoH II H (tI'

t^J&g, it 1XGE!tR#Ntf1L<tu1hIiN1; A-1il,...FX3A*O,titl) mVhPJ9 (z54 453fi AIX9X53t4Žt-R WjV4 Xt'lflilitbJ), PaJSbu

Z4TIj t. ti*iPJfBtt IUtt fi1X< X

WeAiF- liXT 4t I,,

x fiht J ft W U, i i A M T 0 f 1 'r

Y? ':.uI, jWI~i RE f4L &~~Rj$ k4# M X 'iX tdtiI'tEot hWS

llX _~tR it- f X i AI fAgW 8 Wtt __q iM51 RE?t3st IN J12ll;It^ist|

{tt/•WOi, 11Th+ Ri1T#it 1 it"' JIIW t%J'MA EgtA

Jtti3i l4±I - ifIII, % a V~ t,:JH WXi iZi-{i1it7t tt, itt' lc 'dL4Pq2>ti

ifR f&&A'iffl ttZ0 i' iY,l{ M 1M ~~ - t' T~H Ar-q

*2.4 tX X

hc& 1kftats flUi "Itf -Ki- IfhJA iMtWity-t -f t;eR{;a-;lit lk k R

'Ii Ii F W ; WJvS ai lIn Fv#TUilX-Z T,& IH f tt)ttI t !Jffi½s Kfl$--\ >t7Jtt{;lt <s ,fMitJfrUWtlJ i4tiArt uftt?

Th2-T bt'4 'T #R$tPJ,:'tfrMNSE"]a ntJY m-rnattI1fSe,li,l-TJtUitQgl

X 'J$t1 y t 'FtW 4 it, {fPtg-R*i% Ut WL ItF['T w AY tg4 4UflU >tTt# 4tn

,'t'i¢ %Wf4>BK R§B1&T U- ±{r4' fft-t 4#tThPt LUtt-Jt'B4F,'>i'tŽ 0 ff

1 dT -StR , x44 W, ,, 4-,, i t 4 V f* . . it | L 1/

4 S J80IZfSLtVPJ A ft ,Lr'oE lft Effl*r-?J tWPW R{T 1994 f, At1 0, 4kC t X Jtz ,f1 . Gt |, S -t t t ,;4t i fggtH.R nRXft .M F

TS t tt I rKOL if, P-1 116"er II ff t O]P ! a4 ifFl

x W ' '%; f FA . 'T Fl 9, T iil tw Vf *,9 M , f r -F 0, Ml tt X 4 N- e 7 NJ , -1 -fL r 14 - f J,$ 1 fj111 i-; -/ F , A. . f - e litJ M' n I I-i ' 1; I,so

-j p - it 1 h J V W ik n- ti wR ffi W t fy (fJ ftwr nFk

fb8ate" t t J WY OEj H_llI AI MJ 'k Gf IYI j0,If t3_Y~ffi 1994 iFo

Page 41: World Bank Document€¦ · tIT 1997 L* t iflfO * Alex F. McCalla4gt 28X ~j, JfiNlit . Wendy Ayres, Hans Binswanger, Arturo Cornejo, Sanjiva Cooke, Douglas Forno, Dean Housden f David

L3f.tttftJi+4flLL'tt, I JILiRfAf J? 33

Vt 2.5 %Etf **kAfl I# 1`U3

80 ftP 4VI I' li i- L * 'U STi4VI IxtfAt 8 Uk V ik f ff Q I fi : V -L W , -A 41 ALL1JVtA J I t Li §I

tB 450 hA P lt ( 1980 4 fT ii i), f- Wrlt TrN- t iA K[ Ž YttA ikh i4 X 1 6R K I t > #I AYVK- t fi] E11 H1, [1f h itf Y] Vz 1 FT tkV, 11t 41 -Ik K- 1 111 kll~~ fl I xY| fQ1 PL rNfyR-t I]t A t Ai Y I] EPt 1 i1 t rli

0'H I { LIV imiftfJ 0. 7 %, FL F. K4 O J I':' t I t r, L- L: fiiWt ] HL J- ItJl iLIY L A ' fIAf YW

2 (Y. {I V ,- A LL H 4 'I V`} 5 U tf x3, t t It tli I V O ' VtAL.i; r ); XJ JIJi( 1 YLA YiR & yJ t a;

AU itLEfttC lI II4jU h Lo W it'' IIIR]I vflojA]Tt41lniLJ4tftA It IV-

'tIL,H'A4PIV4'v 'it 41 H FR tn ; T J - i E, QJ J.AIJ 1& L- i L 1 4e O

1 r S t i -f- uJ A ki 14 * 44K6'7a [Y] J?Z tVG d S%Pr-± i pER~J Ii II |r .It, v lt '1 41i -l l* wl!"

kt r i z 11, 1- 5- IQ ' Vj f -Rf 'WL Ml .- It 1- j; _ M_ t] eS X- :1; jit J|. |- N% +A rN *S PT 't'k:-fLg ii 2t i f l'i -'tzftU itY -t hLV-i, rI ' 7 W A UJL bi; W5 A

0i1 it }l ii A'k I iH th 41 F I 1t-17 4L A1 ' 1 I' tAhiE AL FU t [31 . f1 '1 S p , A

J11 1, r Il PT F7 , tK S/ I g lr iZ t I , !' 1 !IJ , gtlJ4 ' t j' I'J -T ij 11 1- A- |L- I e L A t 1, I I 1 I f* 7' KME i. -b I 'J9A jt4'L I rd ATXL t>AWA. K s thn 17rF'J A>k nH1 11@X 1 e¢Lfi-tAi l

V VI~A 'i *Lt ): i f itJT, VlF 111tt4- - r 4 Z-l41 ' t~'t! CLKn I J , 7rk i I tU jLbS c ? KA ft . K 1ItA 45 fq ,FI [ I

A; RI ] i' 'F { , WA i tff ]Ui 'a 5 1 bt, aI Y if IUn * I f t- r I !k ,1 f A IIIi'nl 1 Kit 41'

'i{'; tfPJ -F ' A1Y AfTt A1 1 i 1. 1l, iXS , A I '| 11 AlV Al thn 'iF 'I tY,1 F ,IJ

;L B J | FI'H J! h 1 [Y] V- Ar:. I i 1I I I < ji; F ;;lIIIII II, jh- X I;I!IJ I

t'Iltit. 115¾Z$PA wI$I ,tK. IJUIMV{F^J fItA: ft FlAiT 1996 t-a

#:! AT f jl& ft9 T iF 4j '1 ;} fF R1 0, fj fF S tE #S 7J |ft I TM S5 AF I AM # x Pt JT MA 1 4 !1 -

rll JM rQ J 1 tf 1, rt ti a R ? -l-X ! U, 1@ g, [;f V --~R 0, /1J Al i-ST it TU 0 F3 iJI I )t ff 1¢ t I Xq Ox tV4t I,Er4 k 1k R ft p;-pR r T n<a tiK A f<MkV~1f fEEX gqjW-)q ; FUE -2t-

f f I ol A A , W A 5l; fk lS l t a l @R $1 if * t v UER4 ft WI] 0 c ±afIR0 tl a 44 f fl TH 1-, T?M1

N1 R RI- ! c * WI] *) l ft t I :Tj If AE 4i IT t t Pt ol it 'k fl )` o it ; Fi 4 i ffi i I2 irk 1itr

vP L, f fI] Pi sniE elm ftLi t,l if - I ig ,o R =g)fl ~f14 1 ') i' M -10 , tJ I~ i i1 3, -, NMIX tFLAS X,

*AtAt ti, L4 4K t O WP WS2-H

- lS X1XF , , E -r I ± , *X 4 , * ;1I

A i.it 4 Re ;# --F iV- it +- qk YIJ Xc I t- j t1 9 -t af t , S k1 VIt E ; fit tK_ Rq T U

E;AIi+ %taL4f I4$ft> iJ4tA7 AitMAI' J , t.f lr I, - , ,

Page 42: World Bank Document€¦ · tIT 1997 L* t iflfO * Alex F. McCalla4gt 28X ~j, JfiNlit . Wendy Ayres, Hans Binswanger, Arturo Cornejo, Sanjiva Cooke, Douglas Forno, Dean Housden f David

a ft * f- R*R9i o -2o uuH*tHS t "@A?@gtl~k )~ti m h n 4 -aJ' ff1ittilJ

A&VAiM) 2ttf$t1ttTo 'JI4 + -t QIt (91t- 6.2)0 E @t

t1!1pa V-tth T- Igt- itA * M#1b91 44F t;tJAi Mt2M 683%aEXf if -i t@ l4 Z#d f al']ll' J, riii t,S n NI/t Itt@ T 1000 11i3E 4

Xg4 I~~~t1 1A81 m Arx RI8 RI H t 4i IM t It AIS ff O l bMt4 Qa b$ :

tt* o fgtt Tf H A IIRf #PCw 'Tit til -T#, M t

171+

T _ *t ; I ITin i If't- t @

N Hg 01If @ ri bR-M)9, tt .3)

7gWia A f M3ff+ tt /J8K ttS4 4u E,u(L t~tj-~fi

Page 43: World Bank Document€¦ · tIT 1997 L* t iflfO * Alex F. McCalla4gt 28X ~j, JfiNlit . Wendy Ayres, Hans Binswanger, Arturo Cornejo, Sanjiva Cooke, Douglas Forno, Dean Housden f David

35

g1 3I,

/-ll

t,X,rI T,Z%JX RtZ -PTt ttESH4 iftgtttM ift f

Aw~~~~x RR Pet : t F, ttt -L 'AXt

Page 44: World Bank Document€¦ · tIT 1997 L* t iflfO * Alex F. McCalla4gt 28X ~j, JfiNlit . Wendy Ayres, Hans Binswanger, Arturo Cornejo, Sanjiva Cooke, Douglas Forno, Dean Housden f David

36A iiRAttllA' iiA T tWAStq9ttT*t

AAN fiLi@0 t @ts t'419t0q-l p ]T fo FAgg rkI TR '[Pfr R 49 '5A

f k t iLf'-it5R ml IrT IAAt E# AiN t0;h ;1q6 gPAsTf a$ ht it it A r ; i 1 )AT,J

teaL--rt-l~~~~~~~ ,i:5 ,:Ll4t:t6tJI -l\@ EEI- a'4aS g 6

ri 01, t V',d fEJt -ft >J iW t!t gv,,g'-S-1- i N L 0,-Tq tf 'M 9

k I / Pf Jtis, '0W 9 pl f 4 /1-E A t 'fiiff f8g SWM#> ugfiFtQ

-h it f1 j tuA 1 1 *V9 W ig-It, t A:-jto .E AX pjfjiXv*ff o

NfjtJVhH-Rhl]MM k , RitfflN-Ttl P 3. t gAut M fs 1),X

t Wtr w'j rt ---'4 fll 0- Ex4 iX@tM O iR- itJI1-Wx 01 WXI] * /tfi4IN V+f A Rd -l'Xi WVI ,)R , T 9fH - , )StM Mt- tkIA tRWA f *AN f

PI RE7 Fy Z5 W-0@9;lMl ril'l IF] A 1 XS e h PR,iA Vfl o-FXtt tLLg, ES-tt4 [g _nJzkF% tZAt

-vl. - xl+?t T fl; It19 ik, tr -NI it Wr t-2Yl pirFi pf J lf t /Qw 0'7 WX, K k L i, iffi2k A

4R4l)z7 k -X i,:r,r T 1'JIF 3, 4 Yff) H fUtl C AitIt1

3t f-t W 7A *i,u, . it ']t e t: ASi w- X4an Ak hlXlJ2,-'14'i AIT.,

13 n, ra 45ig tt 4--1 m $1 4ff To AT' t¢ t t t

A M 4V-. 7AL a Wj f Y. G A -'-5;4 -A-4l tAMtEff4 *W0 0i*hMl4¢alkiiJ3d o AbXtti h0- mL 4% r±:3 T4 i-.l 7iq RM,

*tXih0k4<ihto itPPtti tAXIt 5j* t-kAS4

ra A t z u, IHtMJ7t MEM#Lt,k SMS4 WiK@lt 2tl

Page 45: World Bank Document€¦ · tIT 1997 L* t iflfO * Alex F. McCalla4gt 28X ~j, JfiNlit . Wendy Ayres, Hans Binswanger, Arturo Cornejo, Sanjiva Cooke, Douglas Forno, Dean Housden f David

R7t -tA1U, 37

WNt 3.+1 A¼K'5 f. t flFf lj

-. ifAW#T-rf It- iIP i]ff X -. iffi , tri- RIAff

+A -sŽ tr-t, ljJjTsQ@ ;t1 At $oS, A ii, .t * Iy -t

a t S i Rol3 I1 R~ P14± di 4HIQl? A A,T--ofr$ni Q f bM1~ Y#± )ji-itMHA f I

MfitU* tU<t 2H, 4E IJf , V;2 Sl4 ( ifth fi I' t titilt 1 4 th'I' i t A J-ML-, 4Ž

Th) 4'V-iŽ) RH F #$ ih -, i, HEtt ±xt friMIW'iel f6 .tl, Zl, Lk Vt- iRkfR ± E I ] .QV11 i.-i,M A & h , -th)L-.5.X -ftIJ i f' ............. )l, - itl

ftiu 1' ' B I 3 .-I, ( It - il§ k jt Fi Wj J , 11tfWZ L 1, ifAl1Žgtut'j4zk- i

jt kf ti T' r. V . 1 g 1 1 k tkl r1u 4 r5, A 'R K i 71A 1 { i [hir, C84i VI, '

@~~~~~~~~ ~~~~ 4 1irtt,< Mg<n .z.-A 'et .^||i .~ . ,,, fr t _j Xt f _I ,~ i A f!k ff f)( 0; 1 J ,

cfJ9I'gAt?t), ktg,t[t-#t4tHthi+± M i4t|-%i23E'iAL±#3tJXtfi #HEnc i tAt, kj14 1tunfflt, tKkj4 W t Ii if rCO 1 I |ff i- iq NlL fr1j XI tJ fi 0 S

it- lM eF lt ig ',) b t M J( A IQ f- T4 I' I Ck U01 J6eo NA, Mr 1'l&vE1 I i 4 Jt

klkEgXc RX I,WX 'it]1,-;- tu'ftLtF4lJ{*ft¶.

tnkb IS-,tt, jTr4i%t- I. PA

A#t )t tx M W:M ,A M I Th, o f s ETh

Q$Ae WFTh JDJ kJE%filiFAt¢tn9IM S i~&h tifl4flht41J+BA-•s

T-h j, Im,7¢tLMSJEi

tff tR z ffi fp< t At i ]T- Tvfl r±k tiuuR If N i vftlS [w A-tti a t ~t w 6l> h t14

ftiX tnt ff@tt&I-W, WItThfflhkkt X PHt+i 9zLWtItt3I t llTS-It

kt#l 3.[ C �1 M7 tbA{tPBi@t 0 Ai, VRTit *WH , m h y 10t11 f,-ti-k L Ul p-t:Lj'l11iJit .o EWo~ L-1 F t2 ettA i itw 6 fi /I At ,) M"LJ?5I if1efA I 11 . njIIg), rT- WtE, 4fi fE t , kA * -1t t. H IN> ff Pr T4 ~A!t S'- ,Tl t@U

Page 46: World Bank Document€¦ · tIT 1997 L* t iflfO * Alex F. McCalla4gt 28X ~j, JfiNlit . Wendy Ayres, Hans Binswanger, Arturo Cornejo, Sanjiva Cooke, Douglas Forno, Dean Housden f David

38 VA : k' I' ALxfTIxA ~ It~,t-- #1flz i24 @ - R IT- 94 f(t RU Xfb~J1 FT--. WSthl¢ Mf Q)A ltA- NI-Ao =Al-

it<E 1lt%JX- iE2'2X'ttfi~ tEttJM (1Ehaetf

1996 P 99 - a T f± ~ft~fkIt M Rl

ftJ#1 1-781taq1 341#- WI PR mt SM#iibl HL i -H Jl- f t t ilt[E A r PI TJi, [ ES ~f-,J V A O b 4k O M -1 4 l\E it -14 Xig-R YA +e ZbM f l Ex < N s a X i 0q, -i /go 4ml RL llr

V J -: -o 4t WH- 3k f+ - -L, / 3:EV- t -- ffi4y4j l4 f L X)ff Tt

f -, I ( J f tJ3-ki

TtAto,41t - IETh; E*]ttlT X i;{l ltlMo J

M ;Xk vMN aIMX ito EXA l *plz 'H k38946 fEt~ z 3kNI tE WA kJJl #t Ys li-i- l-; N 7j:

ALhIE. {I fWM640#

19 9 6 If9 A BeMaWb-AW .f 0, T VI- K t , X u-z'- *M ' - 1996 4 1 1 MMtiittt4 i2U M W Ij v- 11 ig

i, #-tx f A u 1= v ,- -fi -1 -, 16i bM 1- 11: v fq ti -- NS; . i4 gf 2X

KQ V,J Rij A. PI; OQ f ft MJ iL )A T R AJ (AM

ti¢g%ARl*<tAlf 8]RLSt ffl alW A

XitRot4WD tWD&tiaat *WCSTrV t A-Xpi NA t F v a'N9IITt 11 /E% ,keAl F ± .t * o gE-)I I-T! pfit ilXEt ol fTI

-4; ittt7W5f Lt +ffiX ff,!11 3f 1 kA7E l t); fT4V

X, ~ ~ ~ ~ t 442, Itt ,tn4L- it Ex: h1-i it-~ g* ft IlMlJ \* a

k E RS,1 f M i f'- <W il 0 r f Lot 40 X_

0)[ q-I gHtS 1. A tjag3fMt1;tW O-tdEMR+g F

ffir±-Eff tTA tk'll' «P * itt IL 4$,

I-,L f*f]it tE ttlnliJl ftMsLJAVl )ltW:WS 11o%tt7

<bffth)i/R o t" rT,sfJI iF T8EJ9X8 MH*-~A~ 1980-1993 *-,Wt1h1l 3N

Page 47: World Bank Document€¦ · tIT 1997 L* t iflfO * Alex F. McCalla4gt 28X ~j, JfiNlit . Wendy Ayres, Hans Binswanger, Arturo Cornejo, Sanjiva Cooke, Douglas Forno, Dean Housden f David

39

3 50% -Tf-li Il n hp R t it Ex 4 tJ U flT2%, 2% _)i, 4iET-K 1fH ,0%

tt : r:i N li tEktXtfiS EX¢t"i

tD LL9R X Slf±iR i]A- rAJ Sl

* P Pi) IL 31 f -:fr Ki ,DP l 10, %, {Pt L I {;P 30,T, lIIL4r-V <H .. < t 2 7% , 4 PAl-TX?,i f t0 ,Ag# 0%,t mf.iA IX1htrt soL rh11L^1l -lT1RF ,-IM2tJ;F_tkSeg

7.% K3 12tiwn ol 4 I o I a INl l$ A 7

fl tXN,t-~ f1 WTATT,- 2 "II gE ll b6g AT-M 40%,- I l- 70 09 t;.tl n. O.iX? K

a FL It %X t l fl, R E Ul' A l T-i Zt - -ff i lW p tlS wlt$$ v 01Ni t WR r

3X% ( R'tflJ iJt& 1- 4 !J 4% tL) { f t ltTIIEc; , AWAi@o, ftf]E10 X , *ft, it ,-{ 5%o TAU N$ t Z lu I @ 4N $'t4IJ i9

-fx 25@4%X@ -%2Ri1 filJ T. g ,T 4 6m-ai f t R-)qf IS:L ! 4tS1 1ItfiaX7d -A-E 190199 4AT-W aEt- -HRX %@te A ASp At; i

3 % f Il J fJS F-,L 211> -H: 21 tMftt jYfl(gatg 4g %% N -),

7 25 % A1 -it. -1-W , il Ex, ntIT z IEaJ

* 1rI+13rfl -AGP, 1 5%UarT Vfftl3r(TJW$MTA 4Rtt),Al t $ftI; YE X9E. 5Xf

Rn o tQ r X fil f% RttL'9St&t f- tt M'!,tg fJc 2'Milt-~iF4 tE 7'iJ te MI RtfAA(, tE K Y11,M I 0,f-n U 1-i '

.11 r I ol A f 1171 t Il ff vl19iAi 1 993+ it * J7 i GDit 1 *. 5kaA

Page 48: World Bank Document€¦ · tIT 1997 L* t iflfO * Alex F. McCalla4gt 28X ~j, JfiNlit . Wendy Ayres, Hans Binswanger, Arturo Cornejo, Sanjiva Cooke, Douglas Forno, Dean Housden f David

40 ttta : ARJPdJJ

Vt 3.2 $*Att: "4ibtX*t4

1995 4 11 T !TF d'<i s II' ig tl, U t

ItPA-,t Ft O 42@ t *T- WII , il jX A S ik tJ-i flfnij, f

1996 +f 3 -Q$1ijiX, -- tg*bUT1. l-tXJt*M7W i!t2. if tT

MAtJT, iAqii f$ tJ3. 9 fl4'. Z ¶1$IE VT iT- 3132 ( tt iti

ta R *k t& WI ]At Rffi

43Di Th&4W it i3L W iO ifIa5. tR 1-i io

4.16 z F! 9 1 M|iq-+t2Wt ld Is1" tt- ,5A <buXk 0722;

5ttIftt . S A A KS T. J$ t °

k, " t'A fn .W1 ThW tf l±ItV, (AtP

1%Kfl t1 LH H,@Wk UWi [b 'tii ' E A t'tfhitt4F3LA

T,QAt %?t#Wtkb, 4QtTMf , AtEX Zi{51t $Atf4kXI *kAO R%4 A '. AtA ExWft, 44 -#!, ATE-TiTf

1¶{FtQ Zttflt7t288tAtAio&-

il A -yj 5- -r i Iboli %; : ath 3ltko ldl ts 1XX7 B2oX>f4$ 1

ff A A *A A tla hp # t ¶ UVA Lfi N a A E J J W

Page 49: World Bank Document€¦ · tIT 1997 L* t iflfO * Alex F. McCalla4gt 28X ~j, JfiNlit . Wendy Ayres, Hans Binswanger, Arturo Cornejo, Sanjiva Cooke, Douglas Forno, Dean Housden f David

'I'! LMl 1'i 'A -Y t LtSJi 41

ttiQtHtVF Mt Vlt)tiFtl 3tP~~l fjUEThi'tt 1 ~ ) : ~ 7BVJI,INV14

tki4itb 0o7fft 't t+&1 L2## Fz7tKftYi]2t1}fi[i' t?-4i'i'U' 4AThRIgA9 {fr-4 09 3T, M 4Qj1¶fI' I 9 4?& IRAW i 3'll'lTlhtXt

4tfftA<t#fftniT %=tTh]}JZMXti R7WIStfI7H]IrW 0 ], 15T.lllll' SS

;Attt3P- 1 c #t F j. Pt> N P t@Ji N /f it),f# _3oiEitc,t

+JTiW*HTh±it, flWT$zQt,fj tYAgk, :*il Wi±St {5ftt; IPTWh2ll&A3WO t &4ltWa;tl EtbBWtE+W (Zlt'MllfrAE h) tfi'iT'%:A hXf1 l

½k±LERflAM LHPAO ±}Wj RMQtittTIW X

i4i a i i T Lt) ;TtI F ¾4LH1t ItJ(*itTtttRd i Pth*WPiflEbto- t

*fCKVIx -. tPArw Xmr,bt7ft± W t I RTh- 19ftt; IR bW' ff :i) 1Rt.0W'RX xtJ<Wba+M I;i Mofl:Xl4AWmtAB t(m

iklXtttt Jit t77$zfb i3-, ifER A te4n tE4MA k Xy

JEXfituf KEWbtAGlAEXi )Q 1229f -Y5IA t z- 1 N. R I hO MA>tWkt A m Ift,

t iETRk ± 3t1 R; +fi ttUDt4±zL-2Th½#1

i%Apt lVo M A a4 lz +t E -A!Q iii it Ix.Iif T- MEg I A, ri )II WI

f 9 A1- L, tE VtiA EA T J, LMt 0-W, R DA r -&t V. 41-ikMPH,, 0 fE0 ank?R i T T t,

E*. MEt M ;lŽ AltF VJl#A; LPIIIWi rt%; Uk< BMflIJAt*VtO. ,dA

IAl;Ao ;ttTFi ix'Jt#, {A VtPTt2Jljl14 R) nt jl; I%Mll i:t?X, lVl.AAxi MvR. XItk iA t XEx O - -,"[ AHfc KA. !?A A:E.13:tW qAM,

PM H;tI$I<1t, r. x(~K- 1 ~Ar-t 8d ex )Flu;bfi¢m silk>Xetp

jj:E9S W3ti; tl$@ At Xt

Page 50: World Bank Document€¦ · tIT 1997 L* t iflfO * Alex F. McCalla4gt 28X ~j, JfiNlit . Wendy Ayres, Hans Binswanger, Arturo Cornejo, Sanjiva Cooke, Douglas Forno, Dean Housden f David

42 t4t: AZ§IJ'h

ff,0 _ i t (:*K A f 9

Ag f fic -m* KPr~ ikvE -t3 v; Xe 4ttA.n P5 1t lq--rJLEl-jj*

Yk fa]. _A-)I I La

It IffiffiV4)X M. A) r;T Ag 0 fi

bi- VTAt 0 A. A it t t Tt

,A r±t tAf (F98 ik4+ tXWktHA" ,&* X SM4I H AM -fNPAA

N lf A,flT 4%),f lA@SA tkX gy, RJtlEb,%iAJSA%JR

XtR o IR E ll tA (6 a 9 MtISffi 11bb 3iN Ab l% ; -t4I/Et f-tI fEfi

WANIMYX *WMT&Y*

HJ~ *q~ jN +;E1L-tThi;V1Sttg

AffiXll 1t1M 4#Rt t<4 At a A<t^A * Z ao'iE'GAt0

'kn iAMITR * R.' A It FjJ a tIf4M

rr~t A l7p- if l- ffIo 7 mTA if, 9;EX (6 -P$it R ; Alp )t rkt

1A itE*fX * Xtt AllEP 14 isf- +;fiTtttSt,Q,W; I/Jtt( ''tt 15 IWtMV1Xf*

Page 51: World Bank Document€¦ · tIT 1997 L* t iflfO * Alex F. McCalla4gt 28X ~j, JfiNlit . Wendy Ayres, Hans Binswanger, Arturo Cornejo, Sanjiva Cooke, Douglas Forno, Dean Housden f David

( * WI \14' 4#,3 4 -a' ftt % Y U

V*CYITtr 1r YWT WU ra 4:4wix44A yIlA r F444+

(4- V v43 ' fqJ4V 'it"' b6 r4YR44.

ffafFIfflT

Iti

9SbsSitlBliXliX4W Xibt4W5}3WW44 14-11;9i ' llfiq($ XiZ1

Page 52: World Bank Document€¦ · tIT 1997 L* t iflfO * Alex F. McCalla4gt 28X ~j, JfiNlit . Wendy Ayres, Hans Binswanger, Arturo Cornejo, Sanjiva Cooke, Douglas Forno, Dean Housden f David

F3 fi5: t R ' P t I:f. t, J I- JgtFk t& .f ,1 II tl] t4 tt5

I F. tr#

- tfQ f) k 1- Exr 1Aq 1~,: i~ -FA9 rl' ' fThtF ['- 1997! 12

h f tiI I I i i : >.-PI -;. I ff IR 1A ' U{AL

gmk4i3# 'iltt I . . . [...i......'i.r.....'I'.'5... .W - 1120(11); .. . Vt14I ll[A- ir

-NS3gl]I,LsIAAitAttv[A- -1ji 9 ffi t ttf IQ w At RK t N A gl RhM

5flhXff Pfi 2000t#rxt Ff- f,4t t 5 ftL fi%fif |L -f

et4; fAtI i,llj r iit

iT 1; H VT 15 't* 6-' 2 ' :'1 3r>t2I

f4 f t7i M. t5 |l - I !l r jl- R W, 4` t Vt 51I ff. *;.... t t Y'- 11tjL "2 PI ..... % M M I + -XF .TM , iflf'Th4 I R 3 ntiR

[At *te [Ai[A WI 1[7 to 1:

11IJR-[-AtI@E• I' *R- c'.ri ta4t ANlt ½T [A & JU t" t1[ P'tt i4'111I h]

Page 53: World Bank Document€¦ · tIT 1997 L* t iflfO * Alex F. McCalla4gt 28X ~j, JfiNlit . Wendy Ayres, Hans Binswanger, Arturo Cornejo, Sanjiva Cooke, Douglas Forno, Dean Housden f David

4X 3.1(t)

.. 4:

#-tef ' t T a

-~ - - -rT ly t+t&1 4MN '+iitI-I.

ThttS1$VdV] 'IM&ttt f Ea 412 I f* HRE '4fItARbtSO

ltt-t$±/VIE.'St . t4If tk ,Tt1t1 % tt , [ ,' 19 11m 3 3%

'iSi&EYE S r rt' mW A ' i i t Pi ti c 1 ' :-

f{14jyMf l']illlo 3 IIA, rp IL, 44 t t5 9l %m ttlWE tit l'R # -Wa- P SSt 'e f: Ii 1997 F ,33%

Af.S^XM4X -- , ,Yx;,.rTig F2'S 14tW t%tM v&e, ifEKi i1998'1,F

&0Xtfltit, 4Af 1-3 'J li 9 Pi 66%,1999 -T v:

g AA

Af ff &W-Q 4X jR 9-ettltt OFtW ,fitgt , 1998 T- 1 H ff zit i't$

4V

Page 54: World Bank Document€¦ · tIT 1997 L* t iflfO * Alex F. McCalla4gt 28X ~j, JfiNlit . Wendy Ayres, Hans Binswanger, Arturo Cornejo, Sanjiva Cooke, Douglas Forno, Dean Housden f David

46

M 4i

tIL 1996 V12 P 31 Ei,P A ,If A %tt1t1 J<l)v k% iffiz IA ;lA 0MIttl-:1-#, -J 350 tt I-) H , k9 *, il M; R~ V : l fi

200 1Z ( #4XJf 1993-1995 I

17%)o A P 120 47 Q-f40i Žt2L * XA 1N37Tt, Ht),WTi 14%0 js

A[ti- Ep h 1 ri 1lrp l1 t4fifi71G 11M 9{X 3jHFfli d t it M I l 4-]0tlT ltui I9/B . o

Vf-fMISI4OV), fA9lt S)AMNN ftt t+Z bff7ir WMLR 1 4 -A&>

1995 *, T Li

U ITv A -Tff fyj P VI 41v A f- lif, t L/;At sI d llt s1~ 1 -.E1 i MJ rIIflkI<tALXH @tA3<{ikXH U * kIJWt 1XII UAIiA--tflLW

: 1981-1989 -A1 tI'g, V HL1 -T L L t Ah t ft H;X10 ! 2 1989000 * i

-TqH *Yl g A, J ~ t, -,6tX 52% rT 1990- .tXhg rm MA,hH19 94 tgff 4s 6 4 % 0 P ' T.T)a I it 5 I -@tig -M M AjT*

RlFiigEtgt7,I Att ffiffit 7tg * 1t A Jgp I -,T JR-f-tk i Tt

I,ffER 5%o . t 19 95 U 6IF-I I, t R TIff F] 0, ttZ

itlWi htt#+t3Wt+t7ff(78%0 ,-l-g<t;utw#gtt

tA -k-r) Ho ik iT x t I, git,fl f~ rq b t6Ht;T, q, iIJ 2 0 00 " k AERALZ P

F] , A 'rS J t 6 8 %) A Ft mTT f, M,TIgT)qN 80 %it IA i- Q,l@ KA& OK

Page 55: World Bank Document€¦ · tIT 1997 L* t iflfO * Alex F. McCalla4gt 28X ~j, JfiNlit . Wendy Ayres, Hans Binswanger, Arturo Cornejo, Sanjiva Cooke, Douglas Forno, Dean Housden f David

x ik t 47

, !~ rIL (M&E) tf`V,, f1x1

' 41 i 4.1 AAIr4 {I]T-', I4[ F]a- "IoII'] f i'T iAL V?Lf 80 t3 'fkh1 4 T,- ME ji, ''S - eg !-,T,k -rr, ,.; 4l M glj j , Tr f 1,t'Ll m t--;,lll )i ol l/ A i Lkt#X8 W

#t: 4. t '-P RII i-t ifr-ik liiPf)M '- i -Z 'Wl iYFkJ 't'4HiLJ

f j i jl ffi k I I N'ini : fi A ° t M4 I . i °Y '- i L/j f 1 f T - S V - f -LtII' [- . ["i j i [X fIIt kJ 'VrJ J t -4 - -f M

I Yt iR : 7 9 IAt XJA R KA A ri V f~fI'T,~

#Eg~-f- P ift ei -TF' A-14'i 4Z- P 7f t4 P Lf f l l TRtXL-eRb 0ii1X-rj *, 4Hl]j t fUI s it -L

F,; i}'i7 TV ,hfj Kt f I -F-t 1 J1i') -

L Wr -X X4:t/A MV-,ifi- liL ft-Tf F], iZl Nr±A'1 Mit 'nt Itt Jl' ,ltJ-! ll*- I M ,}t

(- III , t A i4 f T t if L1] r At 7 -8-, aH t Ex I

t f in H t7, h ! t i 1 fT -f T ti I t si -Z m A $ Jili A i -- t P f* ih.

1,j2r~i K~ AJI 1Iti f'u4 ki~ - l OH- I K YJ AjJ~ 52:,frh~ 1

,K-, rIl -99 tFf-'l Wt IJi! :t1, f t7.F': E i

t., lik ,k s it + V 81;tI IJ rl tiA .i Tgft]i t (- f--\ `rX Af-fiiPfsi-i0t

' .A, K 4 ;f K,; l t ? i -W I t f -f 1 9 9 6 4

iAJfz3 [l ./i l i~ 199 #,i't7rt 4Er4 T3Tl#, 4@ t I5 ;zL; Th4Rg -t74

Page 56: World Bank Document€¦ · tIT 1997 L* t iflfO * Alex F. McCalla4gt 28X ~j, JfiNlit . Wendy Ayres, Hans Binswanger, Arturo Cornejo, Sanjiva Cooke, Douglas Forno, Dean Housden f David

*?h M 'Y 47 -4r A MW $AWi~]H 1,dNW4YTiTTF/M43-oV4iEU

-TMI R -M4 WFXW -I r I 4 V t*" *4rM,.Yke '4rW4 D i 'QIK4 4 * 0-T4°f?<WJU 'T#A WWII{v fl k 'BhXV XWT4lTVSL44V*WtI

i4* ' tW '*flli 'f WI4-uW4 a

°(11W4%14iM1V ' l#4 h ' % Vt404JV 'Th'O*4It2W UPE'@F$ f• W H4X

UrV Y144 $ -j OC4 'IY j4q °W 44ggt rWQ

B }il4L4 '1) bV 4Tf 4 kt4 #K t* 4' W4 kx Y4I*T h

Z Ift ' 'Qff rI u tIX r1~ I rW4 T, Itrk bE Y1 [ik YAtIr W5y-

'W1Ylirtkth} " ALU WWt4H r E 0 'YX44- TtMWŽV°Q: IW 4S-HNt#KH1S 0Wpr& T4WWW*14'4th4

)yK4-ySXs$ 'yEy.LW4WNT4 . *WW14C*.4

X J'! l +j X, y@ th-it WS L.]4 -W WS W:lXq5-,l1 L itW r1 ri ' t7 T, .L 41 '. 3 fw IK Z!!:-.'1.1ly i 9r W N -i- I [4 S H If +

9 gc- 3 14 -Y Ht+B tXDrl . 1'IEi 0 14 'yM U -Tpi >-,, '4 + 6 Y1

4f ?BXW, WH Hf fvSw xH > Y 4LD X . RIXtr1, 8 -W> IS H kI H t4

- J7LG E4lt A hWBI f.

(Il Wf :1X 1 ii % F'4H I'pJf $PWS* WY lli h ' kTl,h 24Iiffr*wwi1at

V iil33T u.fgU4g ri 3w?LV rn MiL:fIu*tA

* U i'$fyJ4

tttf? [1• *111'114 HbX iM W(At]2dHIW

'i_(fl Pt . )T £Y liI• U* 8

KIY5~ L !i$W 4 [t41Th414an• >4g:t 8

Page 57: World Bank Document€¦ · tIT 1997 L* t iflfO * Alex F. McCalla4gt 28X ~j, JfiNlit . Wendy Ayres, Hans Binswanger, Arturo Cornejo, Sanjiva Cooke, Douglas Forno, Dean Housden f David

3sfi3%4J1J-, 11. i 49

4±49

* MR4t, I E tIy%,

it 2 0 0 a X E T F2 i£ it rP Z iL ffpi bi 7Y A ]ffi

* 199774-g , t1+ŽVtIC if i, , 1

0 I A 8 gR7 f , 1 0

ilWOf 4I-TI 9g -1 k lk 4 Rilff 4iX r ft tW ft. 1w [t tA-tait t r l tlJ oftRl r.lMj&& ~TOIJ 2000 $2lrr9 -@,tt1tXM Xt-z

ffflll 2 00 2 IF, 4 1h 8 0 % T)q ] LY1 -1j11*1to l T) fi flU [email protected] iR, Niff If,WTA

91997!8+g MEEtll-f g Ttl-?9 ,Nf ~it5 5l2- Et ilt t fli ?kft it t;L]X0

JtfittW Athk -T-)f HW*X4A- H Ti 1'Jf)f H14R

t A19 98 VI tE W@ tiR Pi"i & ta

Page 58: World Bank Document€¦ · tIT 1997 L* t iflfO * Alex F. McCalla4gt 28X ~j, JfiNlit . Wendy Ayres, Hans Binswanger, Arturo Cornejo, Sanjiva Cooke, Douglas Forno, Dean Housden f David

SFp2002 IYJ g+80' ,ttl,t T, ff.@Zti4tt

kAt t X ? ff f^t e ,. .'- 1llfSti

_ _ __JR . r l

E2% WC M;h@I E RiM+ ki£t qiX 1- st} t:-tMI<t K R

ttN{ f D, /1W , l31])4 PAM, Mt W 2 101E ill I ir lttt M1 r1 If Fl - it kt't a JR i 1 $24tif R1 3IT@J t

Ill. Ilk

iEt H IRI.;. .9Vt ffi Rtltt a a si Ik Wf:Ml 'A1S f PI It b5~ 1 ,7 6ft& 4 F o)ci M X11 -k f

¾~pJ ii 19J7k

ti9!ldgi$ettiWl;|]1 I w A it:-l s M. IN -EXMW. F l

Ri I!r 33 Fi A ff IkA*WA M:gffltgftt A 4M11M fttkf+)F *-:lf. bK 14 fT tI

XT ME M £aHAH4 1f 'MWeS;C kfX. A. xf m Sg k t Ei:fTTWt H JR a

Att l tv iYx.

Ik H #L fT il R ki , rl., -1 I tr i 4tM M - RJ 311 Ag +e Tt:) -f- PA I4v u RPf

1Y 3 i h;714 1 At J MS Rp A. t 9 i@ /I yE 3 N;h it tij *-; f J r I t i4 ti -T f+ *A xt PTit til Af -V 1fa I& ,WibgiAS 1s t7R Vit lqZli)1iijI, gl f0. &A "o

ffl TIW* Rfi Miv'jKfl gfo

7fEtfitiKKAK;% atE32tiiljrRtilitkIt@Xfi-tiERit1997it)X BXi! HliX% lXiy t#g21 Xiti tg 3 lUl li t 1l I' rl | 1+< i+et Xgj tflf t tk I f 12

Page 59: World Bank Document€¦ · tIT 1997 L* t iflfO * Alex F. McCalla4gt 28X ~j, JfiNlit . Wendy Ayres, Hans Binswanger, Arturo Cornejo, Sanjiva Cooke, Douglas Forno, Dean Housden f David

51

g5ig

5IJS -V

rRExtl MlJ#fM fiff]ItM, AV "1 S*4~~ 8

PEZt)Rk>tSt r't!r M T, i Si67nE ik

1996 4,L TS TR r- 4- Xt4L R+ 0, tfL ARJLl *ftffiS %

It_At 4! @ PJ o 1997 */ 1n t C, 70 Tt (1/3 tkFM

;h VT 0, tjL .T' t J ±Xf AO i t t fA f 1997 + EPCOT If

L7-+ ii

9 f1996 ffl 1997 EPCOT * T1996+9 h, t 9

,Fq tI1 tdiSio~ -'EPCOT m4tr6A-tkf V#L. -tgff3Ji2 t

tn> * iA$wGnt Aut ilvwa T +t -, f R,- ,a f* A W t

Page 60: World Bank Document€¦ · tIT 1997 L* t iflfO * Alex F. McCalla4gt 28X ~j, JfiNlit . Wendy Ayres, Hans Binswanger, Arturo Cornejo, Sanjiva Cooke, Douglas Forno, Dean Housden f David

94O4U 9 6 6I u 9 V Y LU4( 9X TT 966T

t'6 £ 61'0 L rK 4IKj 4V ~ IzJ-J, 91~ y- I~f' iVA D m ,i

% fŽ @ I 4-81 aXJIOC) '@' 7 p461 Y'A6 h L6 R 1'T IWri o

061f ' ( : 9661) %Z&1I 49 4W4 i'Tr A'2 ° Y R?:4f)W $

*-9:4W 'Ll 4 A 4W9 4f 7

'@S4Wl*4 "/4fWff 4+ 1 IIID -j76 44}# :& °B4b7I [/ Xi

V Lily 1~9 la u IfN liki 4:9,rl E W ti (MID % SL @o7 a~,~ NWL ,W[l f-I

@ jl4 °X7> L Z@*56692kt766T@ W S W }w4@ @3''4

b661[lfff@XSS @*f661+fw!;llilwlil +4tq« 9 f 4XgkW9X IO-JY7

TY+4 'e kOKV W °tB@?1W Zq),W4pTBWSDL, ZX k --,966)

*?) rlI o9 M [ OW k i Q.I tq "31 W iS1 '8RI: °NKWlvh-14W

B : °tgW*WkWE%Lu Y 'mfilS Ll4N X>/ 0XL}3 -W¢4 s 2 n r

gW n ooz J g%ig 4BX4X wID a4X34a woz XWu@SMg093

B.@ @ ;uff4Ti Xf44 'X$ X8 @t1 4XM\/2Z °M0q4 9

Page 61: World Bank Document€¦ · tIT 1997 L* t iflfO * Alex F. McCalla4gt 28X ~j, JfiNlit . Wendy Ayres, Hans Binswanger, Arturo Cornejo, Sanjiva Cooke, Douglas Forno, Dean Housden f David

f'iŽ-&t#i$t 53

bMIttU4tJ1 RuT- MtlMWfltl rIFj t4 UlFl VT,tL± Ek1{ L 8'f%htlA; *ittt!JT0, RCHIM. b9 T -'jV@ [9 6fJtf F-l1 i-t b1J7 R It) WI' H7 t i24o tI14 PJ-12 Pol T tifltkmt&flS*t½tkh bTS Mt '4ffiiTi5J2o * WP2Jt{+ dt-h J Rt f iP WT

tR+Sh'tW4jA o f flJi 1- 'x fi F,Ž ti f T I R hJ' Mi 3t t Q O

W tf~ T P 1o ol f /$1t i-itJ. ( -il v 'ItT 1,3 pg t -, pl- - WSE :-A/I ' k Wj 4 @

Th*fL H 4 tAKPYE , i'0t,,tt'1?'Aui-'Pt N j'U

* tYt , tf WPt A4 5 i S flt-t. 4*fvH t - T a IA Hj t 1-ii - 14' wl rl iR f q i)l /1 u 0 m R 4q t a 0 Ap '* 4 R; s 4t ?T 71H

bnt#Ht, It 4Ti3UMkA I ID QTt'J\ua )ft hTtrt iItVT f- (- EX WT htt r itWl 2t M Al &

X m t 4, Ig. 1 ji {4'"It f i HWI QPI T, ZTh1s 1998

41 H.$SAS 84. JE E 1-'5UJLf, #) F ) Th1 a F\(At5 ,

*fIPM4Uff. XYJŽThft#HJ AktI*[tWX ThA

F5R.7-LLt!JWV2 ~ktiitCH-I;t, SJFthl X-{h'g'Njt: ŽtLl-wttxF7i)

A w ol ffffT rj- yli-Y] bG a- -R N.i F t~r f f9 s I rWM bI T31, il AL ;X r± 19 98

* I ±Thk*iIItJ 0 ) t WI <U t tt t-Tr W N

J tt<, ITl Jr fqttjII (SftItW/2

ntizAm S u:Wt B Kv~llt 7-ti it-1'1 It(r ttIdnl'tWijhLh, hvrtt

*EoG JW IE-- JiJlt-w$t Itt JiK nn+4I']'ikL igitU

* + j.}t iel+ Fitij o H 4 < i ; j l9 i t } t 2 t t .

~~~~~~~~~~~1 / 4nAa ti[ !<3

Page 62: World Bank Document€¦ · tIT 1997 L* t iflfO * Alex F. McCalla4gt 28X ~j, JfiNlit . Wendy Ayres, Hans Binswanger, Arturo Cornejo, Sanjiva Cooke, Douglas Forno, Dean Housden f David

54 ttt:%k,t,iBb

tttM"tetfi'ta feE Wnt9VNlAVfik, RfTm*Kf (t4t-XVA91

s WY -tMH/EEtIi NWtka -T{,-S MI't &[V9 ~ VT, RIth-kff ~ k H II 9Et~K 4i h-

a%Wtn, 1 * K:I,Bt#JtDThktN (ft

* itlft#tEIL AN>l ) itiŽhtitWW f Xt 11 P J

* 7tteHSX X IThStJ@Pz, tti~tUtW0, --1 I ,lt1lLXA

* i43l ThThflttitttiZi.tt¶ Ji:;rit-

I ftfWI ataT3iiito -M4-t V M (5.1 fl 5.2)

* Th4f'k4#Thti 'BuE wS$' '4F rt' f-,t,e < t A 0 t li TP A1A $ t LS l'% fAf+i 1 t,4 I'-'t.,! 4-l oq T i:

½,4-8iXi7#o htt, #EIt-T4Ytrt&tE IbThi]xtT-fltTWhThit>ZWi "

W;WgllJ<-fFiot ~j P 11,1St hirApatzRSJ Jgltl 99 XtU PTf f;lfAiTGi ti; /Tfto WtW (t1 1K,f tPtKTEtM97 fSLSMT#ffZ4&%#IJ-RtZ

ITh h Xn-Et. iEN* fW?I~TfTEn-PTk, 3A1i&JRZD ~

X)~~~~~ VIbn N -T<tfi it ff )w Ai Pr,t Dok,(-tE3f284l-Zl 2iT

~~AA13V1X±. ~ ~ iiitlfi41±ktRa} RtTlltu<251TiSlfht;XfiuKt+tK trw. I'

"'ElitI tR AL t3tmgLk{l m t pir C

RW4$ijtttnfi#l4t-Thlrt t<<86lr 4lltEFtk% iprp

*4i5.2 t** t!t.Wt^1T: W*^tNkPI

g9Th , (FAO) WRtI4tttt #ff4ifi 1000 7ffLTc

R)77Xf tx k4 A1964 VXtfliT T - f f it ti -i. ;E ASr 1X IT hlRA O S

#bi,t $-I{tXMi.; FAO iit it 11x, tJtUwi % {irm { t i Im !!

U, tS WH:§iiJFBiiIIt, M Ek itt 0J sTtU3E FAQ. 8Tt, tUrS t1iEAE

Lt, R bL h h t : 1 11t ' & vit ti FAQ & 'A FAO: & + fi 2k V bt Lt - tWj1 : UiJ If t- itk!. lot)-

ti4ThSotlitt, rnttlff{ifltUo5 W#ŽW tft5 A4rJ1¢, Pin r NBM>$ tX

FAO W.ffi13#l. tES#P, 42 Ii t lAttALXltO StLtgITS4±tl3O

Page 63: World Bank Document€¦ · tIT 1997 L* t iflfO * Alex F. McCalla4gt 28X ~j, JfiNlit . Wendy Ayres, Hans Binswanger, Arturo Cornejo, Sanjiva Cooke, Douglas Forno, Dean Housden f David

#um~it55

tt 5.3 *X Utt.W%&Afl (wTo) *A(WTO)

tE4k<tI1Ui¶,t fltTh k, 7'2<<-t LI Yf,i!-t11t3 SToi tM /i- (GATT) AXIt, lO 11MT$J Y W kPnJY.""i ''jf t-i-tXIf i#jWT()

;i2@k ( t9 PI X gr VA)-MinP 'AZA -$X%t It MoFAITeFR&VAYJffiIJth PVR16%gq46,ftitofik tZR70 mfl -m, M A + IN&VT, CYlit h-l , -I,

bu A@ J7't . q, 3sAPrtl tRFP[4*9 VF J, 2N AN2X A -uFt f (j f AHE I Jl?t30 Eg H

i+;f±i 0t FZ kh iFp{ft BK A R it ItN ' EAqtTiftXA WTO A WEZl 1996 * fP *S "Ptt F ,~p 1> 3q- IS t II/ka+19 * , -t tls 71~ :ffi to r- -tA 00 FP tA N WTO ~, Pf MiW 1' I, ,.! I I Il tz'l

V E fXt W 21~_UR til 1 i v t-fft t sWi Lit:ot r Lr-1 ir <o1(Jji|, 6 -1 N =±3 f ltA 41ŽAfT GATT/WTO R1I Initmt 1 VT, t)1Mf )'tnI] R

Z TfOiT U 1Th -tmf ATJ;. Wf :ftfl:fT 1 t> 4*I E t ft m ;$J r O& fiQ rL tfsj n n ; I.1 fi t, tn @ ft .5.C TI,&OttViC JI4f 1999 tJftZ, ,HC TIThrP*F0 XtAKg nThfl&Sj{r fViS AeTh4Zfl¾ &RRA;Qixf-~$+#>lJ36%, 4.4tWfct A0*f-[*f f20%.c tffiT,-4; , ltiW9m*. X3tt4tUliI § t XtRZ

Z$1i It9 :; V&Atb4XJLi+thP1I tW rfr-t ,-nbttrtfttZiifUthn ie O5t~IVA(kl ~A * r3; X~ VT, _ it U 1Yl riS __ if lg VI T A11 It oS^ ;AS Rstiz n3 - -11! r fi .l S;jl f t l'H ;S Ar 11b ft ol Mr

Fi ,, lAf(J [f t -1 JhE 4'- 'l4A fiEA l Xti, A ,g, 0-ltr -T i,R;: P lW4f >i4-,; *. 1 9 A, - 11ih N R fr Ll rb/t frJThX°O

A(UNCTAD) th U 1 kftXITh:A ImfE ft

ftTh{Rt&4fg7T 1996 6f t1Xr 04;4af Iq4i : 1993 t 6 ~4 1996 t 5 .4Th itPkT1, Aft T998tV4_ M|J, fttwTar& TDYrP-1R, T_IItF

It > ttt E X ZttrJti4g teM fttf F T 56% tt t#f,{Th4ir9ITh,f i, ,A5Žf t/4&iE WR`q I I%, f&XA 0 Thn# d teM kF

$W&RM9St0. *1%5±Itb. ~t&J~~lt A P14 f1 ft tttWThi W_T FI TP V, plA@ A4 It ?liI3it I @4g r1g;I- t S4W i,A+ tg4t 19991Vtil, S- f X ttMOt±W 4MW4-l5k AIIt,R W*ftaWtH

xettXThTt&X W 5nYflt: iS 4)0

h;t +rF;2 Sl 7ig I At , f3 _WA X1 21 O km1t t X, i, , ,lt I;F]

Page 64: World Bank Document€¦ · tIT 1997 L* t iflfO * Alex F. McCalla4gt 28X ~j, JfiNlit . Wendy Ayres, Hans Binswanger, Arturo Cornejo, Sanjiva Cooke, Douglas Forno, Dean Housden f David

56 %kk2iti#t

V: 5.4 m *" AU4fl%

Sf4gmt9tW * 4wHtA t~t, M'% s

* ' 0 4t-RO 1993 +X A 1700 W 4ftf -ft

Mt EM{o t 91/4¶HT $ufQ i Tht4fTffl T 7

gRtiLlit- Ngt E,kR M*,gpat49XIM

Uj3WfiM@ffi8%QilgtgtX8f]V it-A 4tt"gftXG t@Ri 1 M ftq 2/30 f>M3$RlU H 'ttftE M,ANit iT 1992 W

tt Bb iE r± A Mt lf:t !tt N 0 V* GJ tf ik ffi N i# 'L V ff T zi Gj ~T tf* S$zm M'1 hS t n ojtLA iff[ M'tl- Hi

" n~~~~ ~ 81R M AX* St t t 4* Gl NC+ g w+ 1afI M tO AT 5nV.9 I HE4U&gThA

* }5f 4kTt'1 hflg1 1R9 <11 LLAthEN tJi1k t8flgJIstZ

* rMV ftRW2a' Ai VoTj _4 N f4A -o tSiiltM ;W R )gFE2f11M1:3 :fitJ

t: TlhI4-tŽMWRAk (CCFF) fHliX * 44t4814iT ±tt1ML4, :XThiTt

HL CCFF Ul Fh tl t tlu V AA; ; b Ai JM, ht+i-P9t& MN A; A M, t 0. A M

<4Wi l 3[gvyt)*MfiRxm I b'fi' , II1 1 [4E 1992LtEt tfrLJL, tffR#V

A't R [A W ;j L;, ?W ;1 tt ft j# at

T. I G f PN t t. id A t± CF M T A I At , h R a 4 iff T S

V ~~~4WIfipT4flWJItWAR 4WhiAt4jM. iAsMiit A LtZ, PJ6I4ThSXWU5, PFThflT

.2.tJWW-tLSf*gtiTh ?W§Sf SirW: 9z4Wt5#iR. {UZ

Page 65: World Bank Document€¦ · tIT 1997 L* t iflfO * Alex F. McCalla4gt 28X ~j, JfiNlit . Wendy Ayres, Hans Binswanger, Arturo Cornejo, Sanjiva Cooke, Douglas Forno, Dean Housden f David

~~A % - rK

tt t t % Z e //~~~~ .""..? h fXI t1 sz ll 1 - fTste.~~~ t@t ,-F q

.IN, tI T If1J K S Z 9 996 -T 9 9A Pf 4W A JK ;; Vg + A lt J] 1- lJ :r k .1 , S k b m & X @ t 99 +nE

A,ZAA 49~ f fAPT 44q 'I , .. I - W il

5fi*( W- .:',ih 'a I I , itK

xMk*K2-lMffX CGIAR 25 A+ vrl tafe A ff rt : *Ii- 1996H4 rNf0Q WXt C(rlAR M,

.2.f f A lfl1,A1-

1 itt *$ 49I f f-bRL 1996 $-FAOt3tliikiSttt ttt'W/St:E,-- 1996$ IL .T-ff(q f va ,t54 iIg i# it t *fn Wxffi iN - i A MM WI IIF r ff fi

eRgidJU '1~1-b.f-l- "

I N PT li j 2000 5 P Ji-Xt P*~~~~~~~~ D. < f f{1 ,.}1 - T , k Li t ft ~t W Wttti ttW%tttfi=4tt

81tX~ ~~~ ~ %1 M2 JX4l 3 F

vo (t A / |t Nt f!R lxS t t ik- t )7 E3 W +; T W fi 4 T ff 4 )1 L ) J511y 1 ;1 1 998 0pf l .ttX Y

v -t P f ! ff tt=1$t3 W wrrj ,l;±- Flll eT t'k il3fzzi. IA Pe M; l t f ti 9I4t tiJ WE t M1 1999 W f*aL N 5Xff )/9~M

.~~~~~~M 3Ft s0 gt! tr1 t-11-- ;; J 4 TfT F'< + ffa 5 it a +

34 i: 4 ff n it fll P3 V,F P I[5 JK 4 1999 V, I I- "V i., 0 ,'@'Tt& 'iX42 t t11 S . ' 1 11!F-it .g

Page 66: World Bank Document€¦ · tIT 1997 L* t iflfO * Alex F. McCalla4gt 28X ~j, JfiNlit . Wendy Ayres, Hans Binswanger, Arturo Cornejo, Sanjiva Cooke, Douglas Forno, Dean Housden f David

~TIft~ft A R 1996 199

MAEK TtY 9r ftA te 199 4- t¢ 199 ffT A .t WR&[ A rX,SE_l~T

t tFi14; M1%NAimW Nilt OECD 1Xtt*; *aattk:R 0, I ffif ol_A M?ZtiO4 _t X GAr ff i tl ffi

MPAii#f-k@ Kii

J* 119 A A

44-& 401 WP fct VS rI $$4 ff 11f !? & J ti

1lfttt, tfeItf> Q tIfit -nx it" F EC/M A Vrt Ak V 0 9tff IR, 1997 fif *A"( rTf$'

a M gffiWsX 5J le, Ll Ft * 4 110 fj

aj(l999 I, 5tfr ANiM

f $ff*etA1995+ S w fi 996Ae5% XSnS t$fS4iT3Ht U M W ta M fiff t tt| ff.f 19 M INTA M itR

fie -6 Vl ff lfi1

Rt .r t fi ~

fitA> t; 39 ilav-

Page 67: World Bank Document€¦ · tIT 1997 L* t iflfO * Alex F. McCalla4gt 28X ~j, JfiNlit . Wendy Ayres, Hans Binswanger, Arturo Cornejo, Sanjiva Cooke, Douglas Forno, Dean Housden f David

59

F9 1#rZ l,- 'MIt'.ghEwJt aS<M ifiR W+fit a 2A1R 1"-1Ri

At, z^tXtSt3Mt tA)

lSgli~ ~~~~4 ItPTikKt AMfi£E2i; )tAMfilfiA IJ+t4fQAvv[v , u

Xt#KPstWntJbfLSta- 3jfn 93lKM-fWRt tJiLN.t t

tWd¢to Vff9~ *PKARAtO W )c2/AtSIJ',teg

Af iif A-;W 1 t0 - MT-f~f0fU V l, o40 l - ,M

ACfV, Ko ftu T Nf#ff 1 t 'iZ. MI'"] R

4. JUAFJl$e51 t1;1aL" t8l|3MkRGi@K A:1- ffl T3--1! AbMEttSRtgRsEitt5 SE+XHgZ rr S r T f T$ tgI 2

Page 68: World Bank Document€¦ · tIT 1997 L* t iflfO * Alex F. McCalla4gt 28X ~j, JfiNlit . Wendy Ayres, Hans Binswanger, Arturo Cornejo, Sanjiva Cooke, Douglas Forno, Dean Housden f David

a ur tt A f j{ 11 L I t t s t - A

!&Th&tt o{IMH½At#>tTiUtKt4tgao *+t¢Fzlttig4 44o t #5H%MAiiERISWt

ft J3ri) (1996 #'3 A 27 fl o, t 9 ER tA Ift t t

tiitAgRttl.AS

PM a F t ~ThW ft , {ThfiK AltŽT

{{T#tUItH 4ftW~ x RJif1&#BJZiLtfOIy 4- 4 lAt I tM- t hWffARTTh*o i WYVJ11XtktWI tH1m NA

f28Zt V yjt A 0 1; HA At z o t Ak l 1 g4 E 1#j -; iXfL MJ0 PXj 19 4; ml'

WEtfiAR4$XH (taAAHOOM fqSRX S t2MtYUPqAr

*t kE. $'l4UfŽIIWztt!(IT (lH 1)o 4 1oXH

*t i~t &1TiJTWt 4'ql t&Y.QAl; 0 fŽf7t4,:

* ASfl; AAŽI IAhXQq*, -ittRIPit*V ThrP X i t FW T*A ± &TitThI+#* it4k#rn 0 ttM, ,M@ztXTh lTW4ii 805 •XtFTi~Wl9t QiMtHEtet&O

* '4' f;S MR7 o. 'k'+Nll AEW¢ ttl"Rg* Ann k4MXtXrar

# fi, Htl t FtU 4P 4Nt t± 4t t*. ''tlttWfRITT 8 *RfMP l;R O ffiX2ilA MXtERk `H7 V

22. V A TY TS%t+Af @tql, t la O A'ftWtiA I j1X ' t fr J

L*A'RITflF.t G,< tf AI9YAfWl ftfXh+tJ m o r±i~tot$tSt, @*itXt')T.ThLF, trn:it4PsS SThtitAL*N X t3#HnaX<ffiA,Th4W 1t#tI

itnvwtrw tF m tUtwAxm@+"n r[tn Žw*#i+bM+3±Wi4gtT0 In

Page 69: World Bank Document€¦ · tIT 1997 L* t iflfO * Alex F. McCalla4gt 28X ~j, JfiNlit . Wendy Ayres, Hans Binswanger, Arturo Cornejo, Sanjiva Cooke, Douglas Forno, Dean Housden f David

t iftI A A **I%- 61

*t 6.1 i il" t" v M t"z § I 1-V g - Rf t ?R6 l VIUti -ttot tY Xli t-, H * SitŽll{. (t2{ .MI) T Aqx1tu, JLhtt t

* Wzi Ph'tti l '-. A lr P t tI Att ft !'-,'ii ,2t I

* t4zl4h 3LLk~fl±S/H, ~t ht jl40. -a t$tZ t# 0 tt I' JJflc I 4ffi+T f -a

*, ft i [xl Wi? *@'4tr. t , W rll A3 9 rf 1 M At :1iU ItW l A I r -cti te

L H

*tt, T$& _ #I&-3P , [Wit42 AtAji'Ytf l 1 {f, t{Th 4UTt SI

I'n QX5I' Tit'flB "44 FIA,I o 9 1n3g< T> TihtWq 0 1 ! -EMI

InN tfl 1 Nff f

ts Ft fu fj rP1_r t l iE fiW~4~ yA T ,n4 R,X ft 1t A% t i n Soo itiSt*. ri s 114 IMiW@ R

'P t 211•. M l1K- R4t g- 49 tot1A A tt$i 44'Q ttti

afi la L . T i t Il-p:rlf?I9: rIr: A1V A# f E4tt aKt, M+g

wP -:f-r.ttkilmiffifnA* b?Q'lCT)R.

uliAi MP 29-fl a, I' f , fit a tQThNfY. t-rt I f __ ) O

k~tkI~W titŽ f Wti±ThXM+,tWM

~ t+~X{~L~Pdt tQ Mu1 S§kI 2LSum itjitrtTJFT VflJ

t-hy%fupty¶tinE, iM. MuUfftUIBTh 1 WTli-tt%Z¢w4Y33tto t8$ti

Page 70: World Bank Document€¦ · tIT 1997 L* t iflfO * Alex F. McCalla4gt 28X ~j, JfiNlit . Wendy Ayres, Hans Binswanger, Arturo Cornejo, Sanjiva Cooke, Douglas Forno, Dean Housden f David

i* [. 43-Y,t PLP M th ) 'AffA f A i 4Tl; hn

(WAl' -4'fiT, fO " St RX -Axtl 11, tt4 @t§ i-t RR* Q

If-*,ft T.VTT. gR K§g 'A r;SBTl ft <fWet@gfI f4l -g K Ti J "1 f.i Pg [VT a PI -f fs J4 -' A t w ; hatRA IJf# W `t 2

W $RA ,f~fl-gT -I0 ~ :-2 gVT,1 i 4,aEf@ a a X ' Ifl M) -*-ttAt -_ m~ Vi r± 5E )c It

a t~ PI E 1- R R< K B X' lA a t e ; e t L A t t (a

K RX r] TqF .,rNT thi-2 T [A VgT, ilt $S a ; a]Mfi ol@ ASS Z

-i -fl, -* St ( &h/ gj t~ w a Ag 5f T PC it- f t M | |/~ f Zi a R) -t1 %t

| 4 , ; o 2 p PR t A P.A t$ ffin. rT 'p 11 N *' Kq RL W ,~ ' t -1- PI I',f 0, A" u ffi )( W* - r LFST t-+-, ffiMtrnn

-3 H ftl I o .g. Iit. tA fg4* V--- 1' IS ri ol~- n A tA

4j+. ttTW@'TOl ¢MfAtxlwl AW4Rjc

VtE:%A-iliL :i #

±F r ' "t %O @ rt fH * {b--$IT { 0 F w 9 a t -i

~, AeAttWWSAt * tXSK+T-e0

V0 . h1 ;7)i 0 *tb tVl$Tg tJgttt JL{t: * b3 A

A WE r 1~~~ -11,11k, Zt 1 4 A I -W ml VT 'i f LIwt m y M*f W1"l mR W1 -A N

Page 71: World Bank Document€¦ · tIT 1997 L* t iflfO * Alex F. McCalla4gt 28X ~j, JfiNlit . Wendy Ayres, Hans Binswanger, Arturo Cornejo, Sanjiva Cooke, Douglas Forno, Dean Housden f David

i@S *t 63

Wig~ ~ ~ ~~~T MM- ;* ol P W SR ftuk t lEtot4 99/t Rt20JJ fIJl;,!1454 2t;f

Xff RtR@ *wbeaet 'Htl [M f -f i * t 0 ~t T, -3t f i TM iRM t tO jl gt It it ( Yaron, RV.

McDDnald fU Piprek, 1997 *). ItL*, tFWVTTZf4-4 : ZgE A -; 94 tX- rp 1a : 7t2>+X;M ffi f p vICR V l n

-IEWP4ERWMA IRkr }i

19 6 ) .t r Vff RIJ;@X 1Ef, XtR ,E * 1% At$Xa8 XAX nA tjg N N'1-i it I ( -A i K ,L N gfI1996c)o tt/WAI iE Af1 $Afft 1t 4 rr

i :- (Xt6.2f6.3). 0 rgj;"fLl VP9ta, WavKZRAft

* 6.2 ~#/'lF> flEga/: 'ilkkIitWi]

- W t 0I4 ix1 (CGAP) k--:g-kA; CGAPPb 1ALJA: K t t O

E,gg ,>it3E*!!tl § CGAP t0Xs;iJitl$ F] VT t1Se d!tlA94! t g h tVI3t0IRRJ

im, flA it ff kt 19 l** itt A I, VI R t, ifr

CGAPf 1995 -6 PIE itf, MRt4th9 ±14WJ ItO

tMMW*I,T, HrijP-rkIJ 23 /O, I E fCGA P 50%,

Et 4-' M A 4 fi W o ft Yfi V 'f! E A f# 7 3000 W X {]-i t, +t4 fi

J7, t fi A -I -4 - mPA LI ,4 It: 0 Wm Au- Eb Whn,xt,-Ol X41tii;J.llA

Page 72: World Bank Document€¦ · tIT 1997 L* t iflfO * Alex F. McCalla4gt 28X ~j, JfiNlit . Wendy Ayres, Hans Binswanger, Arturo Cornejo, Sanjiva Cooke, Douglas Forno, Dean Housden f David

fl t6.3 44{ft

E J23ll7.0kR`0WfIt 1992 W , 't 1 (65%); f+#f I 721 fiJl-iL, R (25%); 9

i ff t38 1.4 2&LtA Tfl ThR4 (6%), LL&#IPt (4%), t4 (VJkA) 9I -4t1A WA, T-0-± 'R k,ft JL, L%4Ek6%tTYJU 10%. no JEEE 1995 #i9if

fflHf~M~F117AL, ± fith4Th±t4 tVI 2 8%0

AT itrt-i' J, I, EITEUIIEIr j Ai fi t v4rtstf#4,tpgR*t w IMP. i 0s

3t ttf@It I444fk rVT,ttm hkl. Rpt#H l ' RaIJH47T 50 aw3 MVJE,

lMIt 'C&M4 ilK~--~ u3 r L tttthfU fz L. rn,i)K Al ) f Nik I xi in ME a~ K I i- a t ol A Y t 1,' il fR $ Li iz l a it f u -e f I< M %R I- Y,~

tk f Nf R la-i 11I,E f E 11 t£ b -4- At ffX, P,n f fi X rt 'P, -H, bM i it Z r1 In WJ' tH Tfi -f#H{tt>4gC JWWCM h4IEM§WSJ4± Z5tfttP'rCMitkti#;tfThtMt7UF, gi

71 -g-'S I mfvi) I I f P f I ft-E g-k il 51i-t i'L I,jj ',q1'1'.; t )Q M 'tX %-, I-) j4;it-1g

t1I 1A 011 f4;i gy ri *1 A 1 O.J5 5 tt t A/T'. hU 2

%5ttgWfitA*Th4ht, F#l#l'UTh4tt Fgtj7: i- I2000& 4JTh 720N fit tft1T±; -

X~kI*th tl 'T Ii jb Yftk±1 Hiff 'Iit .ŽWt 1f# t;i P$V ThŽiTht±4, g 14 iE

IJ1995t12 f, LQlttT93i1& ttf 4T 4i 11 . i,l JJ;^ j5Z Wu 1t tffit ILiS, 4

ZN, jt4300 t-V4, $±-JR 350A7L )1iIL A Ai tf , It kl f t Vt itL L 4titI

-T- fft4 c% ftkt'fl J r ml JStWS't i: 'T JTfi

it-L, 6 WtHt f t ,#,JIT tWStAfl'&

+Tht~ŽI~V4 JL Tt{f1o,•VfWJt, t1.Ththj$ttn4o 4t

f* 1*1 q3:flit-tA41N Rf; X(i; *a lt) WfV4.iRi

4500 Et.h. 4t }tt 2.2 1htx YW, M H II]tJ, ol iTrf,I-^, g

P7- t E , ThttNVA.Ai

(t6 EA-1-~ ~,o 1fT 4) 43e<>l1F_u Mt f-wil ,ff:cL l f EMV ik:5Xi A t A gtJt191 fs I

M, ftfi:4trgfiEWW« #*11' n 4T<,~ If-, i.'S',

hh . W -i:T r gf/Eg l4t V 1Aol :l-'t atT W I-T m -19 5a o1 :t,a IR w I'1 ;4A1tti o q

Page 73: World Bank Document€¦ · tIT 1997 L* t iflfO * Alex F. McCalla4gt 28X ~j, JfiNlit . Wendy Ayres, Hans Binswanger, Arturo Cornejo, Sanjiva Cooke, Douglas Forno, Dean Housden f David

$t iPfTO A t@r 65

Vt 6.4 Mt*-btFEAHl3nA

f44QzAk± t4+tc {#W-lt ff1 WkiA2tEtt? tERjg$* m it I8 -,E A A At 3t F IT o iv a G T Bij I'Q a V fv ffll%Q tr VA ftgitt

* AJttF, 4Sil it vtt6iet, 'k 1SS . 4 4k4r4it 0+ Z* At*f'&?

MfttMSS+ ioi.;%AL"i rCi;tiJffi>?e Q # fiX..tS-'fa') |f - ' 81 ]1 ''r-1| /J\ j4 4 fr; Ed )-t *+ t4ti; ?

* -P ) lq ,fA?l ? ks;6$44S4- * 1 i * ? ~ ~nP Ef*11?mr-IA i Z #- 9Ifok giirim 1h 4t,o tKz-

*ttfii*J2f tI2*T.ttSi? itt; 7i, I? e11-4T t elŽ* Sr, I4aW1aXF{#-%En: 17 tV?ftPt,B~RJ IQi ,E1 t 'O -A it.#?gX -t@ t ;rri tA' t

Aif t Aj -L IKt it+7f #Fit 4i 'K 4)1 t ? A A T <+tj i

g,W qfl Hm t-t$I 'F 5, 100o4to f k? gtr WJSI A- fl' ,M-Ekj 9I# igRt

H* *i, tA Q*it 15 % -Y;i4 zE i*? 1]t 1k A t% i L tTJf 4T*iiA

mTifLFlu1tTh44tAh, , xgfl titt. 3, T Jhi tAAiS-ft Pz LZS * #t R lt Al$rr t<rt@ WJfi W'f 1)1 Ar - :J3K--_i

. 'k',; A ai t t R* d 0 fh 1 4-e 2. ) ? 14 il ja I fx -?

___ * ' +5 Serageldin, 1996to

IRI'[frYlc tH+S ,X 42S Th

LE 0h% n%t ½ M ;t FTh A LPThj qTP

tthQW1'O -, +WR{i#4SX1W t r i4)t i\j1t½iH:t{RtLUW )ff&M ;Wi4aLg fJLltt4 * 3 F H4 MAtW ii-S% A)-Tl * i -JL,L, ff;gttuA[ f.;39g t I ,;F-ir6 J8U PqetR

FTT, V ff F E 4 A/J'\fi 4-,RJt -IS tXf 0 f<4Xtf

0( t 5. 1 )o ( 51 -t 2. 4 2.5 fl 2. 6 )@ Tt W Olmi.eIl;at$AuCJAt

*hts1 tWtJtii) t7tTh fffTh AR*½t, titt±i•tlfrpF

,',', 1 tu 4SB 149fTf., LW]kXt5&ft_4f4AtntMrMPZ 4uWtLItf_L Thtt~t±I j4A * Et &O UfltŽEfift# itWS tt I#S&tKtiAtTtJ Miflf At 6 5)o

t5EX-#t9'Ati, 4*AlkQ4M,-k 1Mft ,2a14A 1t%1 P )( .E fMgN 7t7J )Qt-kTN 1,Aitl

t)SCj4JtioHSUI0sitJRbttttXrL.gAt9Wri

Page 74: World Bank Document€¦ · tIT 1997 L* t iflfO * Alex F. McCalla4gt 28X ~j, JfiNlit . Wendy Ayres, Hans Binswanger, Arturo Cornejo, Sanjiva Cooke, Douglas Forno, Dean Housden f David

66

*4 6.5 t

S*tktIt, >-X#g ti* ll i Z .i1050INA%p, ;h1040-IjiE--iEI-'j I , t

1ED (T&V) A*F-)M (<2.4), fR;htIT--A N *fflT3500+ @t o V(tf&JXiteRt 160 3

9IEE7tIiAdVj-A0tf{t>tt V''Lt 5+99K°tZ-F P4A

"W A& YCiJV&CO, J12.5 Th

90) ItrVRAe--vlFPl ieXJL+0r*A)nf ,di'Cet fl W;f T -4 t PIr - rffit V Y0 . iff T jq J As A0 - 1 1

io4lF6f%iE4t4tQ 7 *Mf * t Jo

XtW4 A f EA

AiNYMAI#ONMR tL*j8)IJ3FAIUt&tFIAT4AXM\k>

*k)j it Ifl± iltQ. JE ±

4§ X+ Rt f t # K-a ,]- f j 9, ff H AffP1

,Mt.

*-£

Page 75: World Bank Document€¦ · tIT 1997 L* t iflfO * Alex F. McCalla4gt 28X ~j, JfiNlit . Wendy Ayres, Hans Binswanger, Arturo Cornejo, Sanjiva Cooke, Douglas Forno, Dean Housden f David

67

S, 21 ki7An4@J;* X,e

k.Lat ftyM:TT-r±*M [Y ffLnA tC V# i ix

A* Tf O r 1a5w MIA 4 it

* 6ll M T , h i -EIItfiS4fiS -M titl f a i,&t f1 at i4 'li T fU 1O Wt aSlltft If 11t Rf MN. F

*0 xltit fl f- mml 9 8hI lq4--f A k V O, lr±Rvr!k*vtnUqlbt+ittWx BS3mTf)WtR* (ARfAPJIAMA) TilXitffligglff *QPit6toffl, ;JE4 b'*

IOWA. N9t1

R At ifiA\l X-J l1 A I L8A a OA ; n

*ger t 1wA, ±2AvjJF , ) w 1Xt ok,

*st9W!k ft '' X(6.6),ffto ±'] 2X. g

TASXA4ix. rR%l, i{lAAAT4

14 L g;tn n A I f-, 11WIRA ttSiA;TlE H FPN W W, ft A otWBe,. ),U qliEnste *1 *4 AAt Ht e A *O4T #H

Page 76: World Bank Document€¦ · tIT 1997 L* t iflfO * Alex F. McCalla4gt 28X ~j, JfiNlit . Wendy Ayres, Hans Binswanger, Arturo Cornejo, Sanjiva Cooke, Douglas Forno, Dean Housden f David

144V 'Y4 0 L$ XflO*+ LK#TW '.to * 4*:fk 2 ffIW

}74IbUWI *#PYW '2LII6HBn '8i& MU>)8U WT#h 0 WN4t '

Ci444-$~~ wrw

14oF ~~'-4 T12 4 °L :Wf ' -A 3 0 A g4 W f^K-:rl '@f 0£ $$R° @X

140;-AW U Tf'W#4hT '9$Th44fA*iWU

WtfIIR I II U4UoU I~+44V4a T-4Z 414 04D i I o H(PThk 4,I

.9•kW{4twW?4 'uUt4A54 YV U* 'rl T t4@ E Ctf °U TxŽ$

°NI61*2@WW@ '........&... 'BXf-kUWT 4S4$Xt@? '$I-Xu 14 14

fl'Y.1[U liii 0it4%Y4 II9Wf4V UVrM&'I + TWit4

I {ln oz I T -ff 144-AL4k 9 9 I iv T X6+- w p 4 W+ IT T4 T@ m fi + #

0 9Y 0 & l T* ~4p 01 fl '1# 'lr $VW '~tt 966 If4 iY2yI, It41 '

AB@htgtB O°HMf T X MIJ M'jj9o9W}

s8 4VU4Bt '*flTh@'01tV66I U

14;)ElAY)RINYWOZ M-L<W * _1HIEhXgW;@7HIgV HBW WLifiS ° ff4g>W4£ Z~m ' i4*8

°tOSOCnf- {4L 01 ~44VWt @HIi8u@,*S6

XX ~ R~Yh~• oInTWi>W ° ~ fwi 9. UgWX44@M O

ti+492f}t 89Wt @ 8 H I- 'W T0i6l8° i

Page 77: World Bank Document€¦ · tIT 1997 L* t iflfO * Alex F. McCalla4gt 28X ~j, JfiNlit . Wendy Ayres, Hans Binswanger, Arturo Cornejo, Sanjiva Cooke, Douglas Forno, Dean Housden f David

IW@{ Lgx-t C- 3kTh, P f iU- T Htt, AXQX o $OmRtASO ffiRM, 4lttALttttW SR ff,, Ttt4X-fIWa9ttt, AITtALt-thJLOl tQ~AL, fiR4gr±SttI0t4 hmttlXX

* f~~ f~( PI )TTIA4n4'A"t4i h1±. Ilkkt*tfl ro 1t0HACjlt

ttRAR$ F@t~AtLk{Th tPt1't~ t4+tJ{h fltf&tHn+fit&Hi, W#

ft WWThAR{ #AL±4A4t S tt@{ttL2 i&tT$T'At3I tFz#tit @MtP

T#; ' g O ftn Ff'IL P JR$T ]i ' l j tt @1994U,&*S# L fi?'Tht

W-t J88A,gl ft LL. =l oz 7itWqp ts JSg of tsti t v ig*itt H,))f$$XibM m 4 i tT::Xge ol fR$ tRr i< ,u

%tnJ1jyi7 p; Xfl h$fii 14fi Ntt'flUrhMT 4,.; t$j'AŽtEAThnt4, 11-&~&T jt fik{) ~ j fttfitA' WUtI Xth#IfllxH1944 *

345fflfEff, INvia Ž1W 1LtH'fl EtFITP$O Xh, 1tT hXtVT

f f i 4 lT 4AIVl p JBg6 XT If? tt H½ lJ!-nliZxi :% fttR it. t ti*I tr ff

It fAttP4T l]Th EI pfr;t±tth f t 4 S " ** MWL 4l3f-W

It{v $n in #f* &~tP4* f VI. flF 81

Ntth$tt<, fff#AtihX 0 -t )Efii lrI¢WX8aa

+ThW4R4i 1991 4T-ThtitliPIti4 t%0 iE4Rt 199 +4t'. If7t 1996IW-4-itivif,raUm tE8iAL g # t t sl It: MP A o l {

thEt4MR4 NJ-Gfi fiSg gl 2@, kf#RIAOI'glEiTROC 1994*N*l-:u

±d,V ohJhA',rtFIjMjj,i1t4EThTh&. AL2tl#l$Ttf)tI84~Mtm AELkltlX% gntk 4ti. iM+ft$ttAL 31M i r f4 J HII hi;Atot 1 1/ a P< EAJ 4 ;tg A 7Y 1 1:y; i t.

te ff W-15 21 -T1tif T- fe Kt Iip r 1, m O-)

;t 4 t t&f _3khtst A0 t tt4Uit ft tvT(iiFIb* WflE1t, t49k I'JOi< EJaX .A iSW , k IR xlt A 1~aW-+O Tf~tA la

Page 78: World Bank Document€¦ · tIT 1997 L* t iflfO * Alex F. McCalla4gt 28X ~j, JfiNlit . Wendy Ayres, Hans Binswanger, Arturo Cornejo, Sanjiva Cooke, Douglas Forno, Dean Housden f David

70 &:Utb

A Jfi 4a *-'A, A IL 1- A$ 41WG, A 4 t S'°

to f- 7titrb§, t If-, XAnX Xvfi ff, I t- v Iff RIl

attSgA @g# e$fi*fiAlJ -A k fi4 fl- fOt A V-f- g

~6.7*flk * D &

Ak0 N*9I i 7fWIAkL•-4ff 1500A,k, ~~~ ~h59000tOA~,IM 1AWhE-'V6 1-F ~ ~ f ,~

3M-13)ttAitlq0

Wr A .FO5A iAP0 { fii* 01V z4'* # 9AAktT' V

tA7Stt3S I:ffigX$0

Page 79: World Bank Document€¦ · tIT 1997 L* t iflfO * Alex F. McCalla4gt 28X ~j, JfiNlit . Wendy Ayres, Hans Binswanger, Arturo Cornejo, Sanjiva Cooke, Douglas Forno, Dean Housden f David

%*NT$OAXMJJ 71

3Q;lM Jf k) VFf A tEM@tt1 ig. ifAtbMf iEI *o "-

Alkt$T-Klt,* amwgNr?-J, iM18W4 lf0ujwEs<tA 1950*U* +:l, tfid iE 310 4Z-

(l1991 T+ti) R f+ 7 -lj*3 MI SAk 530 Z< 4 4600 7Y

1- ffiP§ $t, VO -a Q sf tt YT V S ol AAZ

NM,j, i LwThThiPhO 1

3W RA;9 - t & , 4034eR 7J , AR 6.i 8b : - Y -' kL ,W ,it A 7Jc 5eur

f-L W ]T ff 149;bM a a; &<t tA-A1 h t t o

4, 0 1-7 f U- *i t a * 13 PiiF-14 MjelIJg'llati E *ttJl oE ip- ±A

t U7K tm7Y, jRfj ;S7JYjX d0- t Tk' V l tA t 9ffi j" 60 %, lAt15A;E#A. 1:*P X1mAV;jlX*O5Rf

tE 19 6 6 *i 19 9 +0 4JaEl tfl-Tr Vf§t T Ii 7AffL -/7311-;)R0 atfW, sll4t

-Tfii , A:+. *J4it WI eOW) ItAE 7§eMA t )R7JcW, it Y-TiX fit tj 1bM- X.fM) +,7.92%., iSt t JuE4 .Wlt#t

-it 6.8 IT *0 /4ilWeJ ' PAM & a

IV tPONE K- U1 t7k/1 k FtM vz ft']o -TAI k10% H.wkW E;Tt--

A@tX 4 m4 t4 it lt ,1| M-l!COt

*t- k--'f *RA1 tg e -/ Tl -ffi H k ,7(a I .- 1X- i t 7tl' llfl- tij+ 44

P q T, J f I §t t 1J 1'r f 4, SN 3flt : 8j2600)YA t 4 4 Eb-q }tF iA ; p 7JCv f L2 3u AE 1 &A r 4 i~ , 1N Al

Page 80: World Bank Document€¦ · tIT 1997 L* t iflfO * Alex F. McCalla4gt 28X ~j, JfiNlit . Wendy Ayres, Hans Binswanger, Arturo Cornejo, Sanjiva Cooke, Douglas Forno, Dean Housden f David

idThThrThTh, Ttf h1 11 ; 1 - YPh fl4N, 3 At Wt, 4¶t, * I Tb A; f) J fA1W A ffl t1 f4Kgf71Mt1I±R1tTf%t4W6iiQs

Th{ItTOw% hu,,# Ex Ht4iSJt0 Ai 4t t-i-Z AS

~, SMT t ~ Mji ~flIl #&~W,~t Ž

g tTThi.tlFtTh til HThAZ 'tR 1~RJF5tftTIfttjL{4, TWKM

A 4i 6.9 )X± *f A

$W%AtVI t #%B1, &4 K fA : a it tttfIE, (t WO, TI7tiiT 60-

v f-q0 7 ;-t I AX I fll A J A L 0£ tFg1t1 -ge f -fi Y 720 1 -KtE I IR-Aittl,10ll'tVAJ+4oTE

f & t*Wi(, A t4$,l tfl1mS4 180%p $Afl, * 80%-'teflE1 ' 992

AMZ0; 4mj( Itt1EKCn ARIiiE:; At44 601t

tt ffl. A'A , lgffA fe YT i] .it- tl9 kLE [AM7( 11 :t% * vA t-~1 fII~ - T4 2-3--fM

.O,SJKŽ 1Y{Ž R +, ttj8O % %i)57tk% f J. ft7ff Xt t~I it

F. P.J *J 6.9)oo 4-~, 4 -AiE MEfk WJ4 tf f Ii A A f n ff g tJPThnThri. g TX AU1' 5T)Ufl, ftwgkttH,*YM. taI< 5

h 4t 1993 *- Ml 1994 *, ttR #FW f, 60

M-A ff9 0 T M, - f Hk-b 'a *.tt iRitW /, t 1S A tJLn ''P ;n0 Fx7-,)j, Xt E@X0 TPQ ) r]

§E t 4'f H, 11,1, 0 eff4 tZ$t A -w, A t Of0 aaf -. 176 fftQllgULt P, t4 4@g92

T`JrfL2507 lI, t;4f*0E80%, 10 1994W-, ; 3E 12

9f, AWt t 3? 16 XIt o "f P 32t %k (ItWlPili Emiit tWT 5 2fi 11X ttvq iff rP

(tAk 4 *Zi t&S). J f N ;A LA t Rt t0X A o

)v;t T.t 193+z94p tftff!tt(2T A60,t l Z 3K1 i 17 w f] ~ 4 ARtulfq

Page 81: World Bank Document€¦ · tIT 1997 L* t iflfO * Alex F. McCalla4gt 28X ~j, JfiNlit . Wendy Ayres, Hans Binswanger, Arturo Cornejo, Sanjiva Cooke, Douglas Forno, Dean Housden f David

kk t f4'- i.rtfJ 73

t#t) ,Stt4 111ge, ?i*A tBt¶ , > StI#*ii--'4f" ". I1

'%4L7 1ii 4z *4t* ttLt3f k# It tYtt7tttflh±1•tttrPy: itoEX f kLtŽitt, Jtt# t tt tifkJp At-tftttI$ ir pfl

LT __r 0tGoe', MP N ttt, IQtt WU et) K A j z3A Fh tl' l-l A Oz i -

zt 1Wt4t5/XThaWIJ #J1; ± L t½ B It -LJ JKttu H•IWIfft

I ); -ILHI' mt itttQ; QJit t± RXtL MQ IK 1ttL

MYt aIV n )flf tJLg4T,R t , KAF,Fp R zhi-tflzK'$Aft r?' ft P tI¶Ex tJ rbg t tIQ TttJP WF%qtfi

4t 110k _ tiE 24i3 #htft2T±jffttfltLRWtttfWr -F iXt#¾S W4ittJ¶VtE.tA, S UM5YfkdRu

~~ ~~~trDi yq H ftij u;- hfr f ,4ulj)~tu

A ., t4AWFI, It0ItTWN W H 4-* tiavft ii it±Lb.ttpt

&utJ,>2 Tli@Rt _f)Wt IX t0f - II_: rra l- T M f fi R tiI fJ Ao ta 14 i V;g Af9/- a' f NatifffiftgtcfittlJ flat'1t%f

011t * SF',f PI ;, h f t J] Ain iPI At X,4 tNk4Q pt%jlt H Qlj lt:1Ejp

XtilIflKtMtYttttI±R0 ittttR49tXt4tJL htfIt-iGSi~fRh tTt ft ( ± t tt tl i UJ; FIT M i Qtdfl W f ŽL

Y3U2tiiktZLbiX) {ThS1kTe1' t1'i *6, {fl t Th; ThLfr%tljVlktYYhLjjtffltatF2tjliP>tt S FT ,i-.l:E U!s 1'P{ igt~tJ!J Hg'x HII t i H%Aiitnx

tltTh I Tt A:h1 ft4±REWI WtIflAt IK,.'t IiM$AtNL4&tnit<W, xfi

i X,80 11 IT 1 v i,3 r t -4 1 tX44tg K r, 9I , rlk Wr 'A a q- PT PA t LIJ JA! Jf Ifg7 S|tk3M7 EX49 4o f t an W#fItU Tt.It Xt«fith3;+e4;J ,~

T/6 T IRt- ') f1d- k M - t 0, ple :S T'FtIlI JKA AFt A lit-i fflX,

W iTT i RW j fff Ht in T)ff H ff- riSt<* tIT [itoh IP±Jl:w'4tta) 4H{tfgti2/t#tThiZ? Stl;fttu* ttt4iMteRThnt W&ttLR t4htAtdl? tW+tttThR ~tLt* f it 9 Mftf-Ttfi Uuh! Vi IL (H F -WtPtC tir±Itj F -i # ItiIH f!T ? O l 4 7i ;

t "jH

I P4I9tI- O hilJ1ifLLI, &+w7 )t .'i tMWt,A(,

Page 82: World Bank Document€¦ · tIT 1997 L* t iflfO * Alex F. McCalla4gt 28X ~j, JfiNlit . Wendy Ayres, Hans Binswanger, Arturo Cornejo, Sanjiva Cooke, Douglas Forno, Dean Housden f David

74 $kWŽ:UtTht

t* 6.10 tfli*44Q§fl

W DRIFsW'J (DRIF) imDRIF%*{1'kTh8

it tt. , 9~f_f AD IF t-a tv K WLI,p DRIF11 t$.ffAfnr * il4k ;J,t T *f

RI9,5#tZt,t {giyXt~ ag tit wi"tflio

Imm, 2O%a)pA9X tfIA %A- MRI FiLvIP$tt, DRIF tn /J)q tf A-

t*DtRtIOs b ttR Qit;$fl M 9k1 U A U $itA jTLj%k DRIF 45t#* 9 + ltt010P,[%9b<tHfiu Wb DRF EWjt)MA49t5ffl. AAliT-fo 4 %1XRf~fitofu

-StXRXtTh!U1~tfl, -p UK R4S4 AULLf, 3XfPSit

)7fTh AtO I RFt|l tffgXWU*tth*1 ~tG-Z£1AZOE it:bfktrd§$fi&{8l4'T,

TDIsWttl&3tQ Wt%$t DRIF ti4 3J1M, W&RFIFA, t7t- Nid. 60tHIitX 1%.8" DRIFE 1}it"3 o Y iiEiT W 0,aHT E A *IL O 4 f

t fc 4A;. fq 4*E;h0 Z t- Wg fle t TiTit ff E@H q to_W A9 . iTA~M9,H i . f*

HrX gS,Mt Yg+e2%tI g* 9i MDi fr NA L-I V H 0 I l'tP-aAT^t .

Xf., _EftS 30% NltR,it 1EXES§ gRXt M it

i~ t itt 5. Ars*ft> J0gR 19-WRA+ lfX rAl 3 Tk,

Ut ±# *4VA v, Ml tH 1T3 flTh I I 2 iff* Itkt tfA f ti A

tt otVttM4,A iEg¶t-Th90 S Ue eX $Ht#Ua44T'k,LJgT1fl

Page 83: World Bank Document€¦ · tIT 1997 L* t iflfO * Alex F. McCalla4gt 28X ~j, JfiNlit . Wendy Ayres, Hans Binswanger, Arturo Cornejo, Sanjiva Cooke, Douglas Forno, Dean Housden f David

75

i1ij7 ffIFR. 4j7SI MDA.1) "APXn44fiIAite ;AEt J

tit tIIJ'J f t-f 44 -*It. RI tAFE$ -+2A$HXEX T, oF ffiTtihtn nSi , Lt@ nh fPMg ]@, I!: i W iEt-4 -i-alW 1 1 {

Eti+tiJ,~tx 0 tS]RstXBtt iSt, *4i- tX it it A1

!RWlt lR- o4 f *(j fI N Af IR JEhtlFt,5M9 kX 5ttF 3'ittkk s±ttZt

1A9921994 15L i T h , %MI E r

1995*k, ±-#,T .

Nwt rT12 lA-k tni TWl:A f#IY rc *$i« tw4lton/'M%fi%a telpolM , it & Sie I w 4 I t, M1w mA 1'at W Ri,tS]pl.illtJf

iA A { Hf *E: -H 1000 I PI F TiS 5 A A L fi7e1A f

~t r o -7121, FHxhi£t7-sk5E~ et SI a itN rc0 *M,- nn-$Q+r.1 4 JL4-t f* fl j?t, ) _0Xie

Page 84: World Bank Document€¦ · tIT 1997 L* t iflfO * Alex F. McCalla4gt 28X ~j, JfiNlit . Wendy Ayres, Hans Binswanger, Arturo Cornejo, Sanjiva Cooke, Douglas Forno, Dean Housden f David

76 ttA,* Y ' J v -- f

ttftQh&zw, 3!~- a~ Y = QwhPB At x113tpJ* T $0itLt'!Pg XiTo EW 2 W0 tVW,tt, -t fit ttH ill WI, ;S(flj j:Ii it: ti H !ifiA, V T RKtPf1- t t f9 I* 6Vlot 34+

kLtA4{±{P, tIES}RhFtnLIt, Sin *J feLik wr t tT5i ll t:;sbitt. - @wk', EX '. -tf, 0t2

'sAf,!,- ttk'W&2 jW'M1JC½ t?t artS s] fH TF1hhiU*jnA 4H{ itt-r.

Lt / Tf Y ff ITli} -KSt4, m M l 'i 3lJFR Stit- %iu:,gAtbHtSf

g1'1 SCH'-'-'E IME4ti-# -'"Y RN#9 fW1

1TJ IF 4Ili Žf 'E F it Htk fi f, )itt j-r fjni trW

ZJ\?nt<-XvC,itRwf4FtlJrtb ajTnjIt it *l L K b a 4R:MMtt Ta A WThVV6i.12QNtIbJlLK K6.2< ElMeFMItl@

At ~~~~I~MtnWif-~9;>, ti+niuseiv ThtAA !kT rst. t4E•i ftXilgt:AYR

i m I IP m X q a L p it t mt> tA . P PI t .1 1iq I tj M t •L h;1, {2 R ft VJ!

b1;kkW Ai*:T4&A j'b Ii S-[ xJAT m f tL iit i II A>I. ±tFr

11,M/p-Mt 6.1 W frM, Tf Y'1Funkrol,

flZpdf~'' Q6T , .Hi'n ... S4±Rt~7 tft i

r t¾rII'WEtAR k ARo I tE3Bt iI, fjI f wiii-Wc F, W{SitTh ht _IA

/\fuaWtt5'vM ............ T.. tJ.1i4•i, {t 11' aiIii WX&ieAit#t o K 'StttbUflt

Iiwfi i''i'A'..tld, - i , ,, tx-rnIII *-''*0 A, tgpj4$ t't;-.-mgzpu fitR

YThT' Li). V ILII In - ri mtf a¶HIt .4M'A'S Ttr 'i

Nb /J-fis4ftbtt %$¢Jr11AVtF j,i 1L li_ -Mif 3: q :13 b fllt ffl, ff X

A; O A ft - X. Ax, ti1i ft E V : kX V-j In IJ Io<A if- [ i2l, 1' lVf t I M A/ r, TR ;| flY

'X:0'1_X fic 1.1FX4'At iE V-4ree 1Af p-tttqtzff4 3r ly Vt

;H 1R .q Ntt, E0 ,: f!* IlR t 1+; ddX{ > t.-

Page 85: World Bank Document€¦ · tIT 1997 L* t iflfO * Alex F. McCalla4gt 28X ~j, JfiNlit . Wendy Ayres, Hans Binswanger, Arturo Cornejo, Sanjiva Cooke, Douglas Forno, Dean Housden f David

t *P[ij'R ,qA 77

Ho g { 7f~'1f JftL @ 7il I j fi'It-, - @f~f i

,,J rt-I: t; ,:- hi 9S -:I,>+ t - A

7ftr-, 4I]i t-J 4 RV-t ffi4 tWjk

FXfi tf:gXl Ex, A r -V SI, t 11 t f' ft'- flf t , jZ -YI i ff X ¢ fl

A 1< tLitExf7Mu ffi 1f -. E, Rff) r

ii4iIXt't; g V0 lJ& itt'1 0 r1xo

A tiJ{ , m ;T{3ij4 i % t fA*l 34+;t: i+ if A A,e 01 191k 19

+:tt LK ff tf r11 lq- - t 9 X )X -r X-Ij(fi p f W#atg Xi l F ", t W TT Vf: %

Jcn1!x ) x 4 11 ' f{en-

2.t f,*AW -11uuJf,IIJ t I tJ 6~

LK 2't3c r)t -* IN g-Ft, 5 2. EX Vfttl R

J+q$.,S It JL 18; V'TttI/ ,-~ A tqs W -Tt

it 'p f4 N 1-- R4 1' t ff PI -- A;- , j w :. it2 .kWt At4iM

jIt - llPRq-rLit fl -f2lS tH :-LA Z%t W E biMUlA*A'l"u, a

;1I-l!9 iT 44j2 4 if,!a f 9 fF PM tAt4)(I tti t E )c 0,

ttfH Tt Jf 4 FPr"rf kN , M[ it(kJl ftE * qtt- PI

;hH t-%<tXiJttnZX@022t WTt9Vt6tEs Fffi0.t,g,5tI36%u44-t

Page 86: World Bank Document€¦ · tIT 1997 L* t iflfO * Alex F. McCalla4gt 28X ~j, JfiNlit . Wendy Ayres, Hans Binswanger, Arturo Cornejo, Sanjiva Cooke, Douglas Forno, Dean Housden f David

78 VVA t fIJiT

~ W~~{L L Thll XA

it&MA*O 69%, INE Ko

* MA (42%) fnPTRJLr (34%) BDO, * 5-7T-Jf4LThA&ThPI, '*i -T- IU4 t 0itIJIil, A' 1996 31 ffE

AKt. Jlfs TlT Qs 5 ? Lnutl filt 0,, UM-,, t~ i l tW fit h 4 ff , E tlf t Jt&

ft -1 K Pio tmT5: R) fttg et1m,wJ4-iiLa'S MOg

f, tf iJ WY f-l A f 11R.;6E, it 120 lZ ):T , t, t N W HA g @ fi<

Il- t) 4QP If §§t vI' 69 t- 4 , Z4EqfMj*W ig, YI] 1996 * 12 A 31 F,

t;Att3lrtt,iFi9t16% (Lz:*l*ff

xltAlf¢J TlAm'o wtttg N viqnt m Fh01/AXt;ttV 11ofZ

Ltiffl ], ! f i * bk1985 - 1986 47bd66 IZ (61 A-

t*,Y4i l. ) -56 F 1995-1996 t'Y J 27 3Z

f M 1; 0 0 Z -A -K X rRE ul ] o M ft! fl f IN 0, 3A i It 0, TO, t A T lR J, k 1985 1986 "F 6 * )t bt f-y, t t@ X eA ,\ttn,A Al 563 1-T YgIJ 1995-1996 tR te i 0 ,T1386

tA91.t:a', t-tl]b$ff71.Ml 0l8 4Z)E7G- -E6900)YA L YI 199ls6 TR

IRM I J1 , {f4 rl 5 t1986WMgf, "V1P 29%

gP, I/49 /3 N I If l V qlT fA61V-fH h< uMt ni tvt t j K 0fi: R AfIffilkA A ~I~ *TiffHA Lt if-A N MA Th0 44 M* -)R J _FJf tWapenhans b-i

Pi'A AiL¢ Mtt i i'r -t 3 ftf- vl A ITR -V SR * 3fl TN,-111- vri x't RWm1 ol% iZt f lt. Ph 1f it Tr VfeaH@X9t7 4i

0 vKf%tilz?tGt ItAN l ilk J' lrt, r-i -AT A h' ik MAMeY* rllft1996 T

R F ,jis'J'a-t 4 $tWit7i'J 0

* tpEt3St kt9gfiW ttlt2*-nmAEkZ*

±@ T h: 7' P5~ kIgAL; 1gtt«Xi<Xt $, -~Th 99

Page 87: World Bank Document€¦ · tIT 1997 L* t iflfO * Alex F. McCalla4gt 28X ~j, JfiNlit . Wendy Ayres, Hans Binswanger, Arturo Cornejo, Sanjiva Cooke, Douglas Forno, Dean Housden f David

79

U , I n, T-1 PW Pt, g o Tr ItR

UWM; ~#T, b U {#ltPAUhT 0;: tituIIl, Tt, it%flDTh A

3EVUR MTHIRit, fpbF-X,fiicMfl ,XXp rIK H,4 4~I PkR ixRKWA Vttt V

A,§pg 491200"OI MWibnOtl:fS

K "l RINAA FA#R $I f, i-^t lUtX 171ffl?: 9tA 9 af i Bqittlz:#tAFWAW

Wo1itPA 11! ) .;h%5 AL #,'R 5-6 -'I-.t Mi , 200ER t xh b

ifJ,KR Mh,*, i A, 1999 ti+b c tK *0m ar'# 0 T f 61 20

qlIQ K A *RtA 0--A:d -it iK'tW@ * RL0oxEx fflVffTMqk).&{v4

Mc'X z^ ft VR, A t T f', - fff -%t JR ) , tIt Ex R- o*,XRZAf S It} M

g4 11 t1ttIJ ; S;X itR ;ji t ( r f3iJX . EX) 1@ 14 Op 91 1*1 IrJ> Ts g t f- 1' l 1

rp+'s It*kkiTEiSffilS l"-ftEl4tr'I k1 1*4),AiM E@09otMit virk o

xlI : 3M Xr7,ld*pfffiKW-#3AAj f7 F LH -r IA5v 4h r ', 6, lit JBl -^ t f,mtR

Page 88: World Bank Document€¦ · tIT 1997 L* t iflfO * Alex F. McCalla4gt 28X ~j, JfiNlit . Wendy Ayres, Hans Binswanger, Arturo Cornejo, Sanjiva Cooke, Douglas Forno, Dean Housden f David

80 ktt&J< !&z2i<J

fit * -J ft Z' .& Jt1t4WVitt1ttA, tLIf1'WT

tRF fttRUKu- AThiAdt4t&l] SXtt±{'3tMt

tSAf±WftM1tYnY.ktPiV4&WkXt +@SfiEIMAtt1t Thi3itV2}JThttth

%1 JEt <ThTt ,iNL3t74M, '9Hi4.T 1X il 0 AN1 * j2

b4.tt 1 A frtCUk*et± t P'A4< K -

1.TA' - t , t4V!OThjcm, iJc AtY t ' ¶ H R SK f I tStLW4 P rt¼n

it T t tiLhJ1}t 0 n il i tA it t1 tf1

7. :J r-; IRRt'At2'; T), hirJVffJt t¶O 'rl'i!- L I 4 tiR f hi<Ak

WXtAZ,#tE ½X , -f4It4 CkL X{#A*$H, ±tTh ItIF TX:A A4 t5O LA ' 1 r -, i)11 , o tIti -TAtPfIf M P

tt$2 1 yJfKiBt#tI0 SIMLE Yit if fuTh&W<- u W L b[rThti~tti%,

U Ti~~~t1 fL i riut2: PthikM

3.I -fffffls ,I 1,2At;l ,*24*&rtiSJft8l%$

5. tittl f- aJ Pn 4-lY itJ t, 7J P0 it Sh' ft tt R ltXQ 1, Brit Atrt7 -, P7If AsX T rl vc rw_ ff vi Nttth

6. tP fEM4iid 'A t-I ff 9% 4- f,-AX -MEM,9'R1 A,O" 3S% t O- *o -Il)t It<Rjae dt 1'-] Aq

ffl T il ll, l-Y-! fWJ Df-*F it$tX ' ,t1' ;

Mi;olHlw 5 ' %1- It fI t'P,git# -VfriLS gX

Xtttttrm #ffi f,Tq-X X4V W-L S, Tkg +fEi' A Ht j

ilft h 501$I T I.,LVliL L A ff] WrlF- 1 -'Mi I M N i-r oh;Ag9+9% Af-)

*i i YX y8 U Pi bT f F ,fl l9A L t pTlfl;ll ;~A, it; IY*Lt£ Xt Y-qMt-

Page 89: World Bank Document€¦ · tIT 1997 L* t iflfO * Alex F. McCalla4gt 28X ~j, JfiNlit . Wendy Ayres, Hans Binswanger, Arturo Cornejo, Sanjiva Cooke, Douglas Forno, Dean Housden f David

tY@to~~~(f .) no'i',6 t4c 81t

% 4$ tItVP}4t t tt$ i tk W4 fA Ml ltK'tJ LltA_tt 2 a- ;ti44k a f 1 4 A 7 A Xf F] ff g f; 7; fl H 01 HOtt-''rUi A AJ11g111 f ilN f t6 ;,' it , ', -t A f i11/Rf ~rHR

R illi14 m tiirtvs lJ-5{%1 f 1AVJi At : IJ, , t rl ';j( f1UW*U%X

tifiu±L tt FWStI i'i it%R -MA It& ztt -, itU'jiI~~4BJt tAIKkJ-ttU I'fK1hKVIJt,

t4-I TtU, 1 t# 1 1 -KtL -f tl L * i Il m t i rn t gIIMi)MT- M-Ltt Y;id\ { § E4-] + (:tt%-Tr -- fi l

4HtAIJJ .t A fj I ;5I#iMs ?.1 rA'i-it ? 1 P IVAi 1211 ElktW

'1 E ' 1tt-$i'i~ % ttAk[+i- t ti MtP

R M tu .-- B'PfI Uht itntk' fbA I LItHhf:i' EPt. iU Pt -it

C ft it75 ±f1v J 4 K t0tt ATh 13 tt -t[W R-,T

Tb4Jr I'-J -'i-t ll (t 1996t 22* , f ti5 ]ttUN %Wyh#t R# ttnR? il tMT# tI T NdPT,EVJ 4 fS ff1½7{R ft0$½KtThTA0tif tk 7 K t v fitK% 1 i I {I. §tT f -1 f t 1 i I - A 1 rt - tft ; t -T)q :x«*t$;)1' X

toiT AJR ift ;,41111r1 irT-,+ (M ,E 16 t 1)I l A 4.NL@$8t.t>^u

Page 90: World Bank Document€¦ · tIT 1997 L* t iflfO * Alex F. McCalla4gt 28X ~j, JfiNlit . Wendy Ayres, Hans Binswanger, Arturo Cornejo, Sanjiva Cooke, Douglas Forno, Dean Housden f David

82

AA

. . .. . .. . . . . .

-(84)

MSg+I............... . . . .I. . . .. . . .................. .. . 9 2 -(8

,KW,i RM A i8X .............. .. ................... 9- --3- --- --

Jl, - --- - (87)

4R ;- --- - ----- (89)4g .. , :(90)

A+ .------ (91 )

.x A ---- ---- -. . -. '. - (94)

.. .... , . (94)

........ ( ) .... ,. 94.. . .. . .. . ... .. . .. . .. . .... .... .... . .. .. ( 9 8

Page 91: World Bank Document€¦ · tIT 1997 L* t iflfO * Alex F. McCalla4gt 28X ~j, JfiNlit . Wendy Ayres, Hans Binswanger, Arturo Cornejo, Sanjiva Cooke, Douglas Forno, Dean Housden f David

9 ...................... ( 99)

... .. ... .. .. ... .. ... ................. (9 9 )

Page 92: World Bank Document€¦ · tIT 1997 L* t iflfO * Alex F. McCalla4gt 28X ~j, JfiNlit . Wendy Ayres, Hans Binswanger, Arturo Cornejo, Sanjiva Cooke, Douglas Forno, Dean Housden f David

it ' ;I

tTttottR i3hti

ES.8Z<t3% A-Stt A t ~ENf ,T)'f k P f a~ rf* f Ao lt ,PF r'-2l-0, iS XK rA 0 MR- 2/3o8

* fi .484- IPatR 0,m 30 LA NnY g$ttjt J

ABlltAX MOetLa4-I'IrK iV>'X A&tQAti0

I,T, ThtlI i TXFhJi-H;

~)MTL,

fT P S t ktW,i Ex Uff) o A / Z T 3 i b l W itt 9 V IT lt it#XVt it ,NOV 1

At,> ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ i -E Si TS l-tll

17f iSat£@K J4 VbZ M,J * 57 4 si t! Nolf IptE

--j¢fii tX7iRt+ff W --f

30S3ATr3ifJW l0M o f 5 ffi4k 7l; AlilM3tf)tp

7? ft Ve L tx_ :lA JeIff Pl lE lS-

Page 93: World Bank Document€¦ · tIT 1997 L* t iflfO * Alex F. McCalla4gt 28X ~j, JfiNlit . Wendy Ayres, Hans Binswanger, Arturo Cornejo, Sanjiva Cooke, Douglas Forno, Dean Housden f David

I i J1 i 85

* tW1t, 1 tt i 19±LŽ,tQ: w qr -F KffkF, tktAtt

1, A I'l h; f, 'f yt)% H t ' t-+ If g1 -o k, S 4pX 4r i$,, ,1Pl jl-j lti

fitAW titoHYtg4 * KT_fltjt }i &PfAAiti#t i

* + S 1iLt1 1 1-1r21 .. M W 5 eO My, MMJR,%X I

'P,f lF13t[At'ttKLi4kiji K.T £ .f1--V IT1Kf -at W W ' 1 91

4 k i-IT 1- L .

I 's | ';ilt-I ti fit tl- - J t t T @- 4-1L

t< W 4 N'21',, ,-: JKr,

E LA,< 't gF] 4A 4k '^J tiSl jEhl 0- :g AafV Xfii lp ol It-A [A Wit t' i74-~j* tL ± g- R" kiJt?W F 1t

* 9W 193 7 A fin t N1Rtt *j iJ5 itR8, zilit#

PA Tit t 3c T9f Pt tk t T i7, t l ;1 -h !.i -it tiJ* .kA1 v -I- ?f t13 i-ff bM

* PE ALS FON A %t -PAZ 0T- t W]ff 4i AEXt".- f i)M H 5N

l~, i i ;t4 iA i h t ,- r ff w AK i f 7 A mF 6yI

Y)BI43tt, it4nIth i 1996 #9 tf t

"Ancianos" #12, 1.11 4Ži2 -'i1 1 f T

itLEx PA. [S-l it I1 j$ b litt i5t V#Em +nl V -fP f i W"4'l, t±TR-tVQLmfA-I;ft&tJf I: YI2ti Kh43ttiJAN, t tn R,T JIgf m4P X th, ±

-fd1tThktnQiQSitt Yll B, 44r

lift iAte--f'3l f $ 1 AI9itil TL o ikT!L- 20T

A 996 ftM4h, tIE PS+fliLt", 1996 * 4 A)o ttt:ttw, I ½± A deW AtVt 3TV * X Ik -t A-Ot (110Pft

S-, lit -A) Xg t tu fzL ), f n t f XT a W, Yr * Wu b TIE Filo +, l fE :L RP -if X~ W & AS f3 izAttdtkiK-tflWCXzKF¶; iMt:!c (1997W3 flt), tD+g-XTU¶ 4M

NT !, V Pt , ( ttt±1itR, $iIItTL{4NtM{ (11 WXI t

f-H K J<-btX '" ; vt Ar-Vt t i EXI tR itMA rfL t4S O. 1 A -E t )H,

Page 94: World Bank Document€¦ · tIT 1997 L* t iflfO * Alex F. McCalla4gt 28X ~j, JfiNlit . Wendy Ayres, Hans Binswanger, Arturo Cornejo, Sanjiva Cooke, Douglas Forno, Dean Housden f David

* Mf,gtM 3.5 ZA±R) RUT I.__ UA P9- T-M ;i1997-1998 #P*1# U, 4 tfOW i tU

1-6v 1,0b MWE+X f &LR-1-1tA f*N , RUTA rr -4W R)I, f~t t A k 1

Rt $ U§ T 1,411 ikI~~V at i4g-J MoT/ aS -t RUT 18ffI A

*3t9f4,'E- (97-t+Mftg ) I3r< [UA -tt4Tkt-h t RTAIOIt I J .t&

~ ~4~1ZRU-TA f~ 4H',4-4t #-M

H~i~Ef~;(2) ~jJ~t; (3) A 1I f Ut4ei-'~ , /~ ft -V f4T u 7 ItJV R U -

t«IV4tU{E, X'IJetY TA0 i MA RUTA MA. i_tF~~~ ~ RUT (± 1997 -L r1)x IPA IPtt ft UA t, Ll ) pX

HIR'4TWRJrpj-,f ITit~I9 1997 #f*n

*(RUTA) R M, k Z2, -4 R-

RUTA LtXtJLo

19 ; (~ll 3 a f X t tf 't nA fp ,f 'tt ff p tffit I HU VF 74tWlif _f I -Il Mt *U-f

Page 95: World Bank Document€¦ · tIT 1997 L* t iflfO * Alex F. McCalla4gt 28X ~j, JfiNlit . Wendy Ayres, Hans Binswanger, Arturo Cornejo, Sanjiva Cooke, Douglas Forno, Dean Housden f David

I'-' ttb 1 4t.11lt 1A if 87

RUTA S J OM7 VE 10 *t223%o, X7If ;V-95J Q @ pR 4 10 % -3J 18 fi4; l1

;tlLr Wg K b# it- t l ' fIJ J 24 % f170%

-it M;9

Vt ft- FX r± fE I t IM; IM w ofli VlJ I i- A h7

* 7fl, f f1 g {L, * fh! ti1X'J7, lA'TI 4

* ttIETtJ '11 *111M iet ?,S

)jX:, MWK oIi iT3

*rA IYt:it±Joz~t

* ~ IJt7j~ t fitJi'AeVfTI4Vffi3AEi^tJtvflifm ft*fQr S JL @2gF~ u_j~V1 ff f t its t ol A ; §

I'*i w 1'1, JF3Y2 1/19 tVlt 1

1998 UiRqF~).

* -Lt±iE,J )J iy4 k*T A 1i, t124k.fittftf u mlirQ

)hh1id@mtO 19941RtRE *MJLKP,

.A*AgADP j5%, * til 0i *t eU

5 ;V R i 5 -V N T L 0, E 7L N m, T It -lk Ik f I JIl)Iq

*,. 'U .±:55WR?gg+JLJCt EItf0tttWtE

Page 96: World Bank Document€¦ · tIT 1997 L* t iflfO * Alex F. McCalla4gt 28X ~j, JfiNlit . Wendy Ayres, Hans Binswanger, Arturo Cornejo, Sanjiva Cooke, Douglas Forno, Dean Housden f David

* ME T ~h'kfff %T o4vWr-

N-A,, RIt MJft itAkJ ,gm* tPIT7ALW

* 7 4% tŽ{ GDP iJ bnl14-@Tb I1JMOt rf

* Nif) 80%iNUL. fflixt

4i0t''J 0 tM 40% iRz

3 rr ft/ AO, tagl2l N * ,&qIN K0 l tol 14 40-FT Xtot0fi+ M

3 ) 6 't Lt ( )INI 1998 YI] ) o

fm:3's 104e X'/A 4- N N LIM)e 4 fLe Er0

ANIM401 ~ ~ ~ Hg- MA-1rlol l~#-lVf#Ffit 0R 3 0 - 6

go X%5ttM¢eh8 :1

X ith;i YlAJ o -]tAV X-is A4JA JU)3Zl &w (k v l tl@Jo

V I#E IAN4A 90ttNL Tt WHt P -- t it a 'k7RXa4t

* LAA -, Wl#-f

*l %T AA I<tbN StyH P l t 13 v4 AtYt ol n itjt A, a! 5 vl 1t f E t t iI o v, m TRtyAkiJ 33%Mk13 Q1l +%1h4t tJI4it , t-1

MIRA E v * T h'IAI t4 tiL

* kItJKZA ttS 1 t iFEtg SIIRtYJJ, t

+S 10 ±S'A§W45SXAt@tRMgKRoA

*e (gI+p "13 {Y IZJ), WAi $i'ti,tI$' 1

Page 97: World Bank Document€¦ · tIT 1997 L* t iflfO * Alex F. McCalla4gt 28X ~j, JfiNlit . Wendy Ayres, Hans Binswanger, Arturo Cornejo, Sanjiva Cooke, Douglas Forno, Dean Housden f David

Rt5ThThffiItAsit4t 89

-)i l v 0 j% fiw X tt~i lP 9R J lylJ t4 A lP JJ rf * b I'Antananarivo 1 JktS t LVtM T%, ;yrj J i. 4J i9H tT, t

* 4*tAtAt4if#kR6t4-4Ri{- ttW$P t;f]tTh'laj H" l KF

HJEXtfT¶4itTJt#; n14XttufcX

W09911 iWERŽ1U+i2k4 &Ri7MO itfJ

14tW l-l9;;IT. I-riAgg@

tfrltHBe1 (tfitLhtQPiSxl0lU# L¶t,r?ŽL@ff¶k 0 ~nf*hKtiaaMU; VM4nf$MK #tuWt TiYK i iAtT tttIrinTt W-

Mittti~ ~jM ttt4tQG Uktj@, W7-1httttik'itto M(7,Mi'-#R iTtPItt4flgXtLSkŽW* i9fti19g#tytRt&om J-.

Wttaff, tThiEf±ThKJt9 IT71Thi&S iY. itkitMj Afl#ttr; tQ f 2t r {EttlRhiS 9M f tk it t IT9, * a : 4 -ia Atit tF ? h -.

AI V Pit AJt@Ž iHA ltat to , kj&N-rytt f itft. iLI

tLROtRWWI iSE#R.SeEt t7thioX.t1t$t

IWtL, ItitAJ _ tIt WM t i ;-hSt it IttA iV-t tet,i41 * -kA+ t, - 4- it t- t o ol m fL %tnTF A

tAki-FlF ~ ~ itmmpR 4-m-&Miuft-X )} gfms;

;xiVJ LoJ it%'ttt > 0 t t '7- );je 19 96 V- 3 fl i l- fI Mt* i4tfl7kbHHt, )tu&Th kt A & , fDt, f$AtfltfL

A, P WE AK q &FP A -ir 1W3e ttk fA I', itkLtJfikS:AI$ 9 R

* 11 2ft4* M#, Vlttl4 Fltt P${L- , tIJWI ,n

* 4ith; -i1~±%~IJ (Uj4±ijM Th

* i5,u CPlfE Jl';3E" 27) tAEg'' t ffl -rL )-- f JTf, thu 7t ,; t E$t V-1

Page 98: World Bank Document€¦ · tIT 1997 L* t iflfO * Alex F. McCalla4gt 28X ~j, JfiNlit . Wendy Ayres, Hans Binswanger, Arturo Cornejo, Sanjiva Cooke, Douglas Forno, Dean Housden f David

90 vlf llTtJa

* K nTT *f i *F*Q ~i

*it _ t I a U FS f 1 # f f * o 1!

jiZ4t, IIt*tgOSit:)i,ilEt9Xl+ §3

* I1W i7±f3* , A jJI[U.

ir t 8 at ta t 4 -It A H 0 /\ p' t-3

* iii:Pi]IWP ti0 tAH - . P AArthVFVft t20) fii 44 f

* nj ~ tt (3-5 4

* ILf+ (Reft

* V IL, II., ±i3*WP

* n:tA*i< -tt55 WA WH itiJ

t A i ) $q 5t1 ';l A lJT l -i 1 f R bo o n W 1S 9R* U

RitEto ~ ~ ~~~W ljq x 11W>EfX $nk

1:;tSSttStXAW§wt ' t MWt§#1W13a:,EtFJI7kI......

Page 99: World Bank Document€¦ · tIT 1997 L* t iflfO * Alex F. McCalla4gt 28X ~j, JfiNlit . Wendy Ayres, Hans Binswanger, Arturo Cornejo, Sanjiva Cooke, Douglas Forno, Dean Housden f David

ttIit8'iw 91

-g'1M-t i: a pltŽIkbleitiJtXA,d if fti T -t A 4f A If I b E, O Rt .07 A A Mk -

* Mp,gl LLA (X WTF 0) f,*, t it I[ Iu iim i±At M.iRtSWSdRsR (tffAn)T~

* XitJ$ t,TB1fltE

* RIVIRaittd (1998"6*1), t!MV'IFIEC, 4tf- Aqv gRI 5

* vt1*dirk (1999 tMgO t4Iif . i

* e (1999 IR E) * i4 El 9 R aft* #LR {XitI{ (1997 tRt): i F#RE

* * & It-, T "E WI] * t

*Mffpi It AkVt$ E IEffIA *

{t, ]I*&*VMa, R* , iT5F J

Et*T r;ffkA/'J rSl*fglR-t4A

(i 51 %#8 Prx&61b9;t f tM r;XK) ti, l~

1-~~WA 071Lw 4A A( 99 A

t ~ ~ ~ ~ 3 f jEi,;)aSitis 6 § ;* tRII, a f iM Rl5 A&IZiI Ef-o i r I f@kI * ft:J@% @ I R W, it0-

Page 100: World Bank Document€¦ · tIT 1997 L* t iflfO * Alex F. McCalla4gt 28X ~j, JfiNlit . Wendy Ayres, Hans Binswanger, Arturo Cornejo, Sanjiva Cooke, Douglas Forno, Dean Housden f David

* WuaThtf),i-ntw$ ttX *-n2+

* tPXiwf/itt'b1¾tn; 4A /iTh1thu * RtT4tAtM4 * ir± * vTjtt&mWafittc3 (HIJt

* tuXtMR*JThiStn{tzE, )tWhuMTh t. MISff1Li2R. tMWii)

*& t±t twttt g't nt'k?#laXi9± t

Rtsk IA * S i)SIIitt! fi I , 4 , il <

* iUiEttz 11 :)t.tkF•iitWM-f #tM3 *f] 9 W1ito

* t1JUM l UWtL lkAttZttRk•fJ Ytt tW~

tqS r V e K QM

t* tefiAJIl-llE u

*o *~H±' t:IitWtH3I#1i;tiM@UtutUIttAXE,

AWAM19MA I f3fiW Ugt.@ttW7

* M5IJaHA'I AtfIfWt: A

FIJ2 Ei R tt-- tA, V -9 i i1 :f i k

* tU4i-:#- (iL T-10 fFf, J10'M}vJJ

* f18-11W07T, 4l9tI% t4~th0 tlgjJ5~tr{~,, fI W#H.f it bp n+ M i4t -]WaXft irL t"tM 1t , U 1*aty,fE t f WV ,

IZ A Z0, i.t R TT t tIJ, 21 a A k, Mtn ZT itkM. ff .k 91 R a RAt -fb

-f -t A'krW@'AI IF'A6 Qkf j i @, f£lt%X

.. it <gWtuAuW.em YX IJ I, i tf6i'0t A 4 Sti ~C, hgA

Li PA<0T. 0qzfH'S AX4Ao TiHtt It ' mMS 3:1 ~lAt

Page 101: World Bank Document€¦ · tIT 1997 L* t iflfO * Alex F. McCalla4gt 28X ~j, JfiNlit . Wendy Ayres, Hans Binswanger, Arturo Cornejo, Sanjiva Cooke, Douglas Forno, Dean Housden f David

pn N,'iAt fE T,wkoI cmk 1 i Iefi X t Vi , lj * iE Ht;T-

ol-ft'W th it o gow I q* t f),A )CTIftitill','9 (1998-1999 NfA+)U T i9 9 7 4E4$+)A ! 9- -l fi, IHIA ,. tZ f% %EidR

th 1998 M`ott KStt ffitt(

(ttPWR4&tq;Jl IPX 1 _ 3W #'rt

'H ~fF) Rit _4'J't /A U l*; TtW, n,Uf TIf,A

tbM$l ] frl tIt L l xIt PKlt EA itt

~IAW-STt,Jf3~ TffItljP(t); I#AlV4h±A#l#Bt4&IIkfdW7(±ilJ{ti AfW R ttFk l<gl9 V I; PkJ L bitu r t y W 1tN4 If Irl!- . t. W, I In . bt it x'n 4n m

PZ, RAx'k ig> EQ 1X4S ""

*t cSYtz tttI\Jt&tt (4n kWA, !2kiH A'gtU, tEi4t4tfi t.Bt:,fiP,tZ

P i -Li-t41)f d'K 7 ll itit (h -JRtAt- EtxnILJ$ji* t .A&&2VM, i 4c A, i ± -f • zK $l t 1f t l S t it4 Mt Ji uii elt t21;t ff, lMit-<;l VT OzH VtJk,ffl GJ iR T) A it i11 ;f VIV XE %~1i

iR I'l AW -r nlq MW A K3 I C, A a tih

qt itt44 1997-2000 i

Q - -5t 'i-t fi +t Ai ,&8 5N V- HgX#1r]i

* HtPtTAttIm½f&LuK*gtfP (tti &I,ittlM+ttAdM

* tt&cThtfWWStflfrmflTV EH t

1996 tQtŽ W* *2ttWrif T i- f fl R t t , Bli Z tlr Jr- o E1

F19 9 7 IFThf WO lft# -TrQ,I L1~N 1998 M tR }Jf4 (4P %Mffj~7K fQf 1I]

I/ttit t1J3 ( A;t7JM7q Nq*A (ZKVtqv7ii-'. -ag3$tW-iii -i fJct,R -,; < t 1Wtm5Xffi

la a99 9fgn 3HXRA198t t1tF gWlsJ%$e11

Page 102: World Bank Document€¦ · tIT 1997 L* t iflfO * Alex F. McCalla4gt 28X ~j, JfiNlit . Wendy Ayres, Hans Binswanger, Arturo Cornejo, Sanjiva Cooke, Douglas Forno, Dean Housden f David

94j~

~ ~K~5O 199 V 10 ,f.''l 4t?W Zt~zl

*44)itO 4lA, Ii4x 13t-t *;W EX * pgAi t b#~RaffiX t AX4t lW-AR M fiM *

ff-IpJ J;Kt M;.taa Ad IAT )i t-l, A' lo 'i3 A t

01 fiL $1J, YX f A ).9f iA AXlft Mo i-QA-4*fL 4* X X WT/f' di At

RXt7f Atlt2 H, Iit fl ' E 1f A)j'gtf

$rP tiR tX IV Pil -o , ol ft4lo-N1 Hf- I ft"b

~*+(NtN

1 0)44AX&*) Lwv-nO

VA Z*@ttE4t tAMtflwl k~Ct*lpM

fl~~EW~Pl R4W AbRA e¢1 H X-A xt l ft& 1trti- L f( A a i fi Ilt*-. % %a

tEtW 'II'liAtOi A itS All1 t>W 'l3k;8Ab 1;63 I

v 1X1 A1ZW4@ fl IN '11 Mlt 0-I iEP #Ek ; p i I

Page 103: World Bank Document€¦ · tIT 1997 L* t iflfO * Alex F. McCalla4gt 28X ~j, JfiNlit . Wendy Ayres, Hans Binswanger, Arturo Cornejo, Sanjiva Cooke, Douglas Forno, Dean Housden f David

ititlJ 95

ffi* t R o _t Lb o

.~O tt 8 7 % e'j )R Fl

I9 t.F At3 t±k o A1i N WiFh .S l'i tQ j 4

AtEgPL'£7t{L 1TIJE,

t-t fi -C Zh Sdit^- f VIT -A ;Xt 1X f PA tW Zffi~[EolAR~W

*AXlWi}ktttt t fJkiEuE

*Vkr±ttDl rt F6'+RtW4_V:F, -(E GDP

it &,jAW R #tt ;Rt t)9.niStlF k 1998at-f9i:t StU;J,~

{ rT-j%IPP1YIA h (18%) 1 (31% ) .

4tfitt ,t* m Kitat R. 28t'fitAJy-'M/\Tt- 25 -t

Hg3- t&T x R o ff 2*t ic _1 t' If i8 A A

if ill m 1998 "6*I R I ht7A AA S WjA-J*

i;\iftll .ftZa+ttgt lJ U4.itiJ,. X tl 198 R+tII<lf q,t i,; E

Page 104: World Bank Document€¦ · tIT 1997 L* t iflfO * Alex F. McCalla4gt 28X ~j, JfiNlit . Wendy Ayres, Hans Binswanger, Arturo Cornejo, Sanjiva Cooke, Douglas Forno, Dean Housden f David

it A'I, T f

it f f i - lf ' f5j ff J L ? t I L

SWj,lS1XRo fflJ SIrtIRx 'PO,i1 80%Gt¢X&!MFtZfff-4E

gEZAVklR 3P TV2K * ) T7 4 t iN 'J&1L tgIl}IMjt: l$tt 14tanK fi ff iStt th1S

0), Afiiilittt RidR/ * , iU4t -% -AA 9 t I, iFt -T0itt

{1']¢~~ kI1'1FWJt", '%aTQX

M*zt PJIt V itGll TJ3fi l$$trll * 4-tiiliX@ lSi7;Ut Ml N

AT Af f-1 0t'iI91ft 4 U p it wli A t i(M

RIM+, Nt * 1 M-I- tlRVk*~

ALkX1\t1W o&o o, 44 JR1tSbt^ ik ht 1g1 P EgSAtA YR.R-h'tRE) a MgUt it ki RRT 1997

b it VI- It; bAli { Kf 01 . i1),4 R L 1 31 1 .i t;

it]hXtt S tlti WI] Jk E t fbj*P * ~ 5-;S tR3XRX- t S tIt YNt RWI]

IE@gttA t{ tXt k 191 ) lX gtA0iS-0

Page 105: World Bank Document€¦ · tIT 1997 L* t iflfO * Alex F. McCalla4gt 28X ~j, JfiNlit . Wendy Ayres, Hans Binswanger, Arturo Cornejo, Sanjiva Cooke, Douglas Forno, Dean Housden f David

t'iSS @it: 97

it *t X'] IEThA, L n, -' ; P S* 5FS&tlX'lXIt" 1±gJp:

6-f if * i-f it , -i t V-t *)t 4

*tSt4liJ t (k'1ffititj4 HFtIM

*Ij yg qX T- 11 4A f flWS 8$+ AI $AtX, h&i t1ff,g?t " f AtWt 19 ;9 tat' 1ttt 8Q <<' s ik 9 flt- 1

7itt tIJ ,

' WAPTTQWtIQKW -V, ThtJltfJ, tI J l4 s au r V 5

9tlk I: -teJ4 @>0;t It tn btf lt @R E oiff L 'S 1: t I It * I' i iT U ,4 t i~F

o itA' M ft

r p-

LB1W4P f# 4Vitj UJTHL '1 1t 1f4

tM X,t-AUTU ft itPA fflii)-j FT, l iat @ 9 t M1 e t° . Ii,

3KltSk.~~~~-j~H A:q4X A o;llUt \IMa"Ea t w .9ll i IN vff I it) 1z1.j

MtRS, ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~~- l[AAttf% NPTkE (; IMA iJlSttJlW # 1.

Page 106: World Bank Document€¦ · tIT 1997 L* t iflfO * Alex F. McCalla4gt 28X ~j, JfiNlit . Wendy Ayres, Hans Binswanger, Arturo Cornejo, Sanjiva Cooke, Douglas Forno, Dean Housden f David

98 t": J

41 T _* pp f_t A X rp (q lk*) 21R&XEi (kef]jX

tff t -xqt@@/9 g 0 j @*

If' ft kTftft J), PIli 6 * I M irAE uI M

it&tJIA 0 t; ) Fi T (i 999, o

t tlQl2to* 7'gTttt Jf

*~4 Xt Wt letf A ( L (1998

* -t^@ERt (1998

it kiJ ,

Tt R tKiA A- 'Inr I TTolMi£ff t A n t)

T V-- tF T 15 it 1oll tf L Z-,-, PR M It L* *1 I rr v ff Nil)*tl E;q

W[J<rR7-ettAtM A t@fI JAX * A fXt et A4 xt itWe

XJJti;l4;I+At ((1998 "R*5-4lt)t8@J

a 4f ) t7 TX,lX tAEMX -a4XME *~u AAtA tYMt@7g@,T>e *T. 1- 3it b P=A 4M Aa44 M*Stt i, J tfim

Page 107: World Bank Document€¦ · tIT 1997 L* t iflfO * Alex F. McCalla4gt 28X ~j, JfiNlit . Wendy Ayres, Hans Binswanger, Arturo Cornejo, Sanjiva Cooke, Douglas Forno, Dean Housden f David

-4&'A A 3EK hARtWllR

S SSs tt-EWMe

A. 1# VT, 'tg i

t*it M Iit41 1o 1998-1999 5

*St ttittE KiR# zt4ŽXliY

LK i (6 IX + IK * ijg abemM t I- NAfp I StAtwA* xt itiI 4 , * fiZ ) t,

* 1998* *f14a A J*i At ?fA;W

mlolff I r , IVI- i k la t iK0 A *l -RitittlH ittg t -t4 Qi't i ,;

itA,if Hlt M At MJ HS w'g

* ~(1999#&Wjpt) it -M 1t f (2000 !4 e

*--) ts' Cg §f P" - lu0 T-NAI,

Art -tN99 58;$t EA M)Yffif iW V4,: IFMN '-jM q k

Page 108: World Bank Document€¦ · tIT 1997 L* t iflfO * Alex F. McCalla4gt 28X ~j, JfiNlit . Wendy Ayres, Hans Binswanger, Arturo Cornejo, Sanjiva Cooke, Douglas Forno, Dean Housden f David

M IL f J IJt t I-t 'U J F l f pry </ It v- IN V, n J. 4 n J~ ,, Wj I"P gtn t V J V , I J,

31A W~t AfTM -,a tA M-r± tZ Ah bU ml tt -gf 7tV! *Wo ~ d

wtWGIJIt@M4iit AVt3jE%$,#>WiLI 4tFX apAIVM tAga fij 'A.it

Page 109: World Bank Document€¦ · tIT 1997 L* t iflfO * Alex F. McCalla4gt 28X ~j, JfiNlit . Wendy Ayres, Hans Binswanger, Arturo Cornejo, Sanjiva Cooke, Douglas Forno, Dean Housden f David

101

PN B

3Ki, Ihf4- B.2 [tY T j NF X1tJt!1•'fAi5? ff/ h 'u(X i t

Aqz HA lg0t rE 14 M@ rA I1 Ri;;] H4 E)ItII RT1g \|*11 fft hQ 11-4A t WI] A t

''tJ111' $tJI #SYA 2000 't it~'tflJftkt

,i i A, rF it i ih l LA A ot -A 1t, i + 0 4- +$K

9';@ 4% M5titghti 9'tSSvthe t-N ffit 451

:. Iii :'JM {';LH*tti i-R FAfi

iA Tt;ilLoIt R Il5 I itX li)llt,LE :if 0,|-lv iEF3 I t t o Ai ffl 7P 5ff iz A1>o a )<pkfyU MU\10*Ax kJdYfiiF9iiJ'

bf1}O mi l o GNP J 35%, SJUlt 40%t naaU70%0 oPJI1

I-fJ;I¢ISW$%ii:Af 1tM t70 %tttSAt ' t V R t'<

MEMR{3wttW4tWO% fX121tkEl;aStt At11O-nX h,tJh k 25 *+4*jt4g 2%,

J1lXlUi1WifF13lSlil3 J1NhA im<fljt-f 2. 8 % AP31tIJL rW htJr V S[j:% < 7 1-8 n gr6,djfe Tt , 2 5 +ri g G f-n fiCgt 1 ft it it i

i It L & 4',1 iJ3±7 r, gp iv ')J3UH2f 0 1FWlitlit97W Ef:iI5* l@T hpAil FIN1, IM

.f OTM Ext*tiXtttiRW k4 T!A [B 0- t kE ffl tfK 15 :'Fr, ff A! Xt >t ot I A t, V r IT I I A Sitl AL I diT -* $, liEM ES klt io f<< r;v- ?-,

Page 110: World Bank Document€¦ · tIT 1997 L* t iflfO * Alex F. McCalla4gt 28X ~j, JfiNlit . Wendy Ayres, Hans Binswanger, Arturo Cornejo, Sanjiva Cooke, Douglas Forno, Dean Housden f David

1993 * GDP ft L 30' 17 10- 10' 20' 30 15

1980-1993$ -K8 1.7 4.0 -0.2 2.1 4.4 3.1 2.2

q 1993 $I-iAJ 1i#I tL 70 69 35 29 45 74 62

1980-1993 tWti 2.2 0.6 -0.7 0.7 2.0 1.7 1.0

1t AL ;j 4

A 1992 1IL F- ] 32 15 n.a. 30 5 21 18

& 1992 $* Uf*t 16 15 n.a. 16 21 21 17

S Lt: rx(1995 IFfit-YFkRE F,)- (tYeVY 995 Vb) fefkgtAt

a. OZittfVrii.a. Rgfi;*,

tfJ# B.2 2 AI39'J (T9Ht ti Y)

# 1992 $ GDPI It 10 5 4 25%

1980-19934ftk* (%) 2.1 4 t 6 3%

/i U7

i1993 + aV tf i L 29 6 ; 5P50%

1980-1993 Ft --z4 ( %) 0.7 5 5 2%

&-1992 tU*t 30' 2 411 h 50%

1992 El i t#L16 3

O-gfKP 1=1fiA; 6=*e.k

1hFfi7W 6%o

f-uMW4+b26 :1N,@lt *VAELWX *Ml1l -A@A9LA, *Iit>tfi4o

T, , 1 1~Nt R25

±AARVO 7RikPOsff, HX Al N *EAIE-1J091i i£ t 1iEb15E 2RtiH4 tp0031¢f8g t tf(X42nitfbtIVSaRp~~l tofW WIVMD 4AR

9f1f WA, AY*h1SMI *io WTowx otM&*" 4AA iffHiE

Page 111: World Bank Document€¦ · tIT 1997 L* t iflfO * Alex F. McCalla4gt 28X ~j, JfiNlit . Wendy Ayres, Hans Binswanger, Arturo Cornejo, Sanjiva Cooke, Douglas Forno, Dean Housden f David

itA4ii 103

g t $& tP , 2tM, 0 AIF k hij # 4%, MTkAt;EOM

e X fE * T4 , f k l n f r A S e Xf It a&1ff0 -w- tA fif-ItffiR* L =@A; .1

JT±ROfA, -5i4SIADLIkRtle fXtffi'i W@@ PK 9Ek A * 1t@41 tX4 l -- IF

At Il 10 F-T. 4if -i f ItV 1 Ifg-, X fl O E V *-rl fiJStu Ki tF

lklHliF9* lllV-mlv f t: t @ H4 tR* , b4iaa> t. r-11i-. "M )tilil (T&V) ttrXtX .WA lllhs' olem At/

R ffi it } tY: (

f%R-F02, BR+ -hf)Y A A H XiA 9 fi f b iFll ldlZ (4) PjE ¢;# IS01!(, LIXiJiWttoWYTW: f)"L N rX N rf o

HrI ij rTSVii t 27 -TJi,;-l±l7T9TH. 1 -ti

r-u-i t (tn f R lpmi, At 0.K 9 Al-ff,tR m+0l WIe I NtEGw,<M

I'1 )t -o ' S: h vR-1rl o

^.Mit IFiJSI@Qt#AS 47R V4;XA; A, JbVT, K IN4tAa W,i Ml> kleE5tt rL tn *9 XuteA 0Nk4MA J P l

Page 112: World Bank Document€¦ · tIT 1997 L* t iflfO * Alex F. McCalla4gt 28X ~j, JfiNlit . Wendy Ayres, Hans Binswanger, Arturo Cornejo, Sanjiva Cooke, Douglas Forno, Dean Housden f David

104 VtIt& :

* * St tVQT! Thi 7CA

g4ffiWAtgAtSThA*iiWzVJ* -aAUtWtgt@GT

n t&ittt°t#k,g1+f< #&Ž *~4 fP4FIi1tFhtttiZt, &4 A

1) _ -p l ~vff_ W.HŽ Wt

(YLWu, t3tVmtt- -Th4WTt EX ± 4 4WZhnRM 'tL Ak t okATtA±Th5tZS4%V+$tK<t *{~S ff t L P4flf, iIi

f tT t±4gt#tB$ Aitku, A

it tU0 t W,x l x0 H iI'tHfQ~Zfi/, rk IW fi1 3-A~1fNo t h

* H 9 r V-HA XM. -443ST-i Rt RStf tSPtAfi fiTW< f

3 la Th4t-t Aiiu*t *ix1 Th

4-~ALALDI, t4SThh4Iprh; * I (1) ±fkkk t2tfl4iY; (2 )T t*ttIt) M f d A M,,

*t#T hitQfltt l Al;; EtitrA#o m * tWfL ViAlkRA MA_ x N o

tE3 IF. fEi$EbMt: A4f Hfi1 i$797ift 14 f1 M 6 I to

fbMUMf;tJ;iit#t it ;1Ja -f R fO M vP, R lDln IN VT,Qg7W IYJUt la

It TttiC;'jt A RT jt NT4Jr Rt-.RW P B.

A3Tht o StflALtU9 @;'t, '@A4fi4iiT 11Q htŽlIt%

1fWRFT; (3)'tit 0 (4)F1 *tk {±*±$#X>ALtttR@ t

WM>QoJ ZAtttHfVXt'kR4tnt1h {ko A#tfhT{l~X

~tf4tA'thigtt4I&*& #WKSR tM IWttM4Qf] {U1dX4U'U*- W#fi

Page 113: World Bank Document€¦ · tIT 1997 L* t iflfO * Alex F. McCalla4gt 28X ~j, JfiNlit . Wendy Ayres, Hans Binswanger, Arturo Cornejo, Sanjiva Cooke, Douglas Forno, Dean Housden f David

(CASs)

tt'tiffO CAS 1 i: Wit #7' ItrnlrThp&, t ' '' t1 t 1998 NtR Mlif.M *i*ffihi$53#, t-ltt (Fi;: Th1±tt flit hum, iWE'liE 14"tir tl ft L'l 17';ytnQ, NiiW, TLr'tW. IL *it Aitr lX

ThfdAi3ri2tt W ILW)h. 'i I o tlItt2*ut-S 31k, AItF4 ¶1kti' K$tI4'fR As11 K.itW@-1n<fW31' Nrs-, ttH31)oijlp 4#4 SN-Mt1g ,,e -OTt I?AgRNI, +lfhA ff Vti I..1j LI (14o /=lGt 5&

T - -t W4 CASs CAs p M rX A I'] t & l , -Ak.-i 1998 I9t - [ / RttR;# t4M(if@)Lflk tum#hU. ThP1. Mn,I-fit +tJ Mi

Itt$ ALi [ ~Z~rit (j7It+@WJ5t 4jE L!, ± #If t1l ;lit u 1 -1M1 & .i,t LLAIL 1998 It M M- /ttMti i) lM * Uf kt1 iW ti tA ) i1 -tlv t ". jr 4t ttkt l]SiNtIt 'I , utt' ' li- *., Xi. Mit 4 Pi J

W ] ih-(5 i f]f] : 1996- ittl. Ittithuti.W [Ii, III "N f iiif{ jF HllflkMi2000 Wt fET hMittittIJ I 20%)O flWi t; i 'il I H jI!

Ii .' iSh/u-

11 L, Ii .ir+{-WII .f 7' I ll t&itt tL• uL {k 12ft7 ifLiA 1996l 11 9 F6 I I "i 1kt Mit te -R { ' . 1998 fiLtR It 7MixfL' I t, T f 3 t QI Ai Atkif. j-- tZ Mf- -x tt i t XtikfnitiŽ, 1996 9 1 |J1T if it

WXI -L SG2000 8) iF t Ži tFiit I A 1

(SSA) f U-

fLn..}!..{r 7 1),11 Mi .)tilL Ltfi1Jit%tU tŽlkALt t'Ls.'Q'-T'ir--. PPl ii J 7 ," 4,X r5,S .AriF AL 714

M M Pl lI IlI . r t< - r ir ;.:, tF & l FTt ' itL ti -.!1 Iti ffi1 NtiiM.l' IF V I _ 4 tin rI E- II tiF . I;tifF ALtiit ttET

.ttJ (Th t/WS /fl J1-1 :41)

LE 1996 7F- 10 fl f 1ThHI' : L, *Iittftft 11111 fr (Jf

- --- tkIStW ) (fiti. I- MijIV' ' c .IrJi ttfff '1-

Page 114: World Bank Document€¦ · tIT 1997 L* t iflfO * Alex F. McCalla4gt 28X ~j, JfiNlit . Wendy Ayres, Hans Binswanger, Arturo Cornejo, Sanjiva Cooke, Douglas Forno, Dean Housden f David

WAt B. 3 (tt)

4 Ii 'A kmi t i Z f ra4SM t j i T4U*toTh 199 8 = A*

i*UE 4r'ThIS. (±t)l. E fAT %. Mt 1f

15 tL: -AV A 4 m t; .- 1 'V A Ilij n T 1 ,7 tG 1

H ,',. IiF -t lrA rlEX Q H , S iT sit').,'Y]hti I Ir I 4 ff

MtROXAC ?%vt3t LtTi *0*t (AMJI%, LaJTf f 1995T 12 q 1998"tWT- 4I H+HMt-tŽ

lRA v1ffw f rX Aftj t Al 7z | U F iEf .RM | ;; L", i l.11,[| j : ' f n ff -It li | ,7,qtA, Vui-t6 it R. # l Lf i ',W t iff j

1996 # 10 fJi6 -- 4-- tl rf V tl WI#agl'DIHlI-T VN (fiAE

R0j]1/F}<M ) it1X4M ts itXk;4gIf' h!ljo19987it1 Xi tAl tV' 43 f' i'Jt

BR44I 1 1996- 2000 itit K 2 it itl Ti FU '/JAnRfisAtzTiA 1997 iR44IFtP 1998 51 J it 1998 WAF-- I Nli I /t A 11k

fWR@iMFf itSf, Win Xt8Th t W tu,ST2AW , fitt't 1998PWR ttM

fllpt#-4gtf VFiKf&WZ4 1997MR*jXt9Af&l, AttEoLA JLrHB. EH$I5E AZf 4t:GAf tEfl itrX}f

mm81FlE ib3t ~ ŽMt13:1995/1996W41 t k*4 ', t FSw1 *t5 fi, -4 P

f-UMPk&fTk &4IEfIi_ tr.P [ 1998144 FU /lM.

f~ R u 19im 4

Page 115: World Bank Document€¦ · tIT 1997 L* t iflfO * Alex F. McCalla4gt 28X ~j, JfiNlit . Wendy Ayres, Hans Binswanger, Arturo Cornejo, Sanjiva Cooke, Douglas Forno, Dean Housden f David

(3) t 7. v h. JtIE %th ih. vt 1998 't 'iT*tL3 . (4JBAE. ( jiTJAIh

A*wI,~ r&)fnti~1 tA~U~ fdhfls,tIfflWLTi AktŽtuwhu AP itXId:a-AkM bU:1 A41998i Vi#£s- fTOJ it

. N 1996t8- 1999 ttittitlPit- kStTJDtnIb. tAilAboM,TNiA-, A IA 4, rf V gt ½ir .A 4 $t (ut $l l, A 1998UR R$M.d4 A d, III ; Q A A I .1 <,&,rrl $ i; i( 1, 1?) ;. A I' fSA & S 0 1t A

3m iEr1 ~ 2 E T- X9A t ( H fT; 19 98 -ktX4 t£g9t§4e-|t;,- H2+1tM..r)a

I E"*i.bl98- 994I J 4{T tM. ir@tUE . B AS)l$iJYE;JLtI'fl flTt fA f xti/ bo - 4 M Z'IHAO t,tt no VA 1; f&,f mS4 E f 6MW 4W 1 .1 l l1- 1 4 1 -,1-B mSFs@; (fAXtE AWk hk --ft ff gM>zI *P W II - .- i! r.I li-~) gr, 1,7 1 ' a tg.1 SG2000 1998 Rt

dl fi -M, .,A1g uWjn* , -E J# E .j U 4m. AtM . g

M T ,n tq Aiu. -IV g LE l . , it- Es AFi ) f HY f o a ; 9 f 0 A Xi if

1996|8 A O 198 ',t ' 1t 1i

* 1996 F8fit J tVI a-;:ftI*fri4tY , ViB1(4.. I til

<Xi ^- ~t i. .' > + 18 W .fA,

Page 116: World Bank Document€¦ · tIT 1997 L* t iflfO * Alex F. McCalla4gt 28X ~j, JfiNlit . Wendy Ayres, Hans Binswanger, Arturo Cornejo, Sanjiva Cooke, Douglas Forno, Dean Housden f David

At B.3 (t)

A t: t fn it 111 T1 t .IJ, a' ,i, Al iu 45 1(9 ,1;ll -k , 'T

It -~

ZvfdiST'mtt JIZ' UJ 1 19 9 8'Hit P iZTitM 1 flpR

N 41 A if -1,1fiF1 }1ygL-tS9 J- C- nn Ei ,4

x~1998B4R]A7), F, it ITt mc

nil I J.t mRiti t&tTIitt J ut'i', A -j , f l?it&T Tn t llsLti),a'ItW.¶ rt 1998 lAtIIt# )#- t1 ITA/J

Lt'M tJ iJ'lOr i Ft ,it7GtVt-ftALI MtlIt9tt 1 AT l Mit:n M1997 TtI -kfnlfnl-tIWXM..... lin P t r1 ;t*&i ; 9{tL;tgJ3I- [Thi ...... 1998 8t'3iS{t~ Tfnflk'jx

tn W a --t . 1ti t% t 111 i. t *tS J1i n t it - - - it I ' 7 W.ti :"; i *,1- ? W itttt tittWpb 1 9 9 8 2 Y t f *t Y

tE : 11 1 ' V 4311 Rtl t V 1ktA> : 'tŽlfIn UT-! JF;i1Fr 4 1 'I t. 1t rItHI i.J W 1998 1 tA 1+ Fkf ,

tEAALrWR1tIt*fAZ$, 7tEX3ftfndti itn ]/jAfi[JIJ,, l it i

I T11 1

Page 117: World Bank Document€¦ · tIT 1997 L* t iflfO * Alex F. McCalla4gt 28X ~j, JfiNlit . Wendy Ayres, Hans Binswanger, Arturo Cornejo, Sanjiva Cooke, Douglas Forno, Dean Housden f David

Xh F 109

p A,u wlW AA -11K(n1 * ( -~it ii~ 79 f5M 0 Ti~iŽ3

4%),ffS+t) "fXt-*Ol *'Pl

01 fF t Et t V-fi JL-I I,-l TA iERX ()4 06 7 " i T 1 % f It . Ia

Hjo M4tU4t@oM¢

H H R{+T NAPOPt•,(~-T)O H iOI*rf~b At1

t;X.-X+ttSt$XXAX9,[email protected]£80 M 4JritAtagq-i 9

tF1pC t LfflHL ,.:irXtj ' I 97Ž WI-f J1t fd7C H A 'pc ra

+jT - j -T X W f , --t X I, V t t B I 4 I f 7 H t f r T . , A e f-r .

tt -MA7HII7 (2) 4L[RM'\t4r 1WP* M -l -, fU ES A E4X%77gff 11SXM

ii i tfi ol $p- A A 11 -: ~ ol;iX 7i X* ffef4 tEtAW ff- ttffi I

, tQt ttxj fa7W.7tga At71n 7t.AN (tn7$t A iX-q

-Pri Xf F i l 4Li hteltit tL7S1 I @ u Xgt 0t t 49

- f ,4) y w -1,Fl it x $ Mr19 z"I'Ef olt (0tE +|i7utE 7 tk) ttAt X it

SE% -LA Trj' ii ),ZIH jq Jtli - 17XEWiJ& RtJ b.7 Lx Z1glgp ! ffiqg<zt 7Ej,7 r± J7

iC, f R): ,- 3 A''!- R- -S,N7 'R ARIJ -,f# Af-I#t Ex J,-i ,jAit. fnfl-it -t4 (1 rf!ut@ fX4S

il N t 29 --- I kJ,W t h -ff talX i-7 , r~ t- Mit@ WE- 1H H- f L wh-f .k1R,i ~ 0, j y T-k f h

+"X17J4-lV ff- l 4-1Tf H WiV %]LPfTC'PW,247 (IC j5 0tp {H FJfW O X T X WiE it R

Page 118: World Bank Document€¦ · tIT 1997 L* t iflfO * Alex F. McCalla4gt 28X ~j, JfiNlit . Wendy Ayres, Hans Binswanger, Arturo Cornejo, Sanjiva Cooke, Douglas Forno, Dean Housden f David

lio B.4 Af*tf&*fl AThYlftbe

gT+X1&ft#-i t± W4 ifl&@tiP'flUEUTf Jtttth=r1996-1998W+ICfIUmxThA -ttt,I,J,X (I95)lt t tW 2001-20034 At7c)l

V4 (Vu [KRi) tt4l- ¢.LYAJ Wk -) ~ xfi5f A a 'H 4t "pqit " l990-1999 I** 9rT5WM (1 S E S J-; V:JrfntR IC Vi Jit 5ffib9U:%WtlU 2001-2003fU-tIS<RAJ8bt)C

ttll (1995f VIP TI l 1996T1 VIP 1 1fU 1)

I&A,i 4FOiit;l l X@t2lt±. gt*H*4-7- AAI*HfYkT (1998-1999!lI4-1)

* IJk*It*# (1998-1999!AtTk )

*L OI +1A - rNyt ,- ,- 1 rms(1998 -1999 #Wff)

* t* -1996 U T I t4 ft, 1997 9t i -Th1k*AW-'30%. 1998-1999 Rti

-Tft -JB A- -A$>

, (EAI)

W +. - Wti (i.tk±:t- * I * WStntP4truzttn - L '4

tt'+g)~~~i t"Ez fII-h Ti !l M ( FE el h s 1--

WLt i l (fn•L

-T)

tRtdkAt/tAXiR"FJ* bu+eR?-t¢flt"4* tYAtW/tMMP. htt¢lBl

t@e~ ~~~~~l ditg'o4e UlRW§-

* UNW@flWrt1tWThBI

UA%t4ILLJ/N*El tSo itAitff#tilM lIt 4tkA

U0 ;Ri9'tKt$#htt+5iE4*

Page 119: World Bank Document€¦ · tIT 1997 L* t iflfO * Alex F. McCalla4gt 28X ~j, JfiNlit . Wendy Ayres, Hans Binswanger, Arturo Cornejo, Sanjiva Cooke, Douglas Forno, Dean Housden f David

ifl;J 3e1MJ21 Z4Xio 11Affik 1El)otLK±~

M[1off1, tj

_@ttttttgt2% * i4+nH4$G I1 4tIL, II _X ( 4'1PI)o 't. fRti4Ž (JI, iTf, Aki 4zus,

AX-$tEllXi,~~~(lgtj, MARTM WmtESt@1 7A|J'R,

60 . it tr, I FWF l ,),-

*f 3ttZ,ffl0 *i) Ia L,

½ijiiyk, k'--4i' ittg~' ',' IL St 1ei'J1

A*ftl rP laZ5YKT , @O P t .1 r l A ,± O T1 X: t 4 JI i I l F , +L V f& eWq, O,J;.tL AZ $&p/ <Xi'Wff tttsp& PrE ;;1 HE t i 1 st lpt9

f[ -'Ib?;it5W 7trPi4 LE@ JL -t3 i R AM~ IkL a sLZ iJ

-ACCM3X- PE AF1 llE *h j(f 9 AT I l YtfbS ~ AAM~j AR g4 llil t-tQ ;at F ttfiff tLX ri'l'i X, tOA

i, 11 FP r3c m fil a f ll m R iJ-li fft

T t Ir t«gl -, A m I E k t , 1 a 4 11 H

1xi r3 A,:.% 19fii fi;1 14t.ESa

*~ itL)2i 2 3-k*t* )cgt@%1t I1p Mi atT,W M

M *htAtM-k4o S<XEdS&tMA-T:t3t

Page 120: World Bank Document€¦ · tIT 1997 L* t iflfO * Alex F. McCalla4gt 28X ~j, JfiNlit . Wendy Ayres, Hans Binswanger, Arturo Cornejo, Sanjiva Cooke, Douglas Forno, Dean Housden f David

112 tt94t* hk""

.)9I ;J+ I] & Pn t A1 ~~i1 ti; p§ .§ t IyJ f v . ) @ . i <T a

T* t P&IIABr'TIF kM4#flk4A-1'I' f A,* fg±tŽtIL $i-1&ji$tt, K'Th hl'&(Atl

it- 4tQP 1 1, kt TA (tLM $IfZtT A1 Mt t- MtuAM'1 t I) At #iAk

gJE-Kt Jj,SftWlt3fr tif ft0 M

qRf -ClA WVf )NiJ q 7-1thR4.Apq1 if f i )ff 191jv- O - fi4 f

IN *tt a T-)W,'fn-ArtE rr.ITAS, I,t A f {<, S%e tRXalt S V, rW, 1

M fft10t Mf,l I A fJ -i 1 f M 1t x p 1W WAS 1't41ti .Q~ t ,Il ;Rf, li#w l-~ 4nF

ji ji fl 4f JJo t T tRs At-.r f5t f4 1 bn Ntets

* - rl~ n V * t t 0-R I' I FrAt s ttI 0. J:)Nf-K I M VIW 1k;4RAWY#t

* t4r14t QSth M fA 4 A tAT'a/W0 X f "-'t-,IX_ w - (,ff~K-) tit,0 1- N* 4 -) w* lt§- l; Xi8 i.Xs lR toof u

t513P (It4zB;R*. >ZŽL 5tZIW B.1

±A. •hL (XiJ{R9 VIA)FM ,54 n t~Tt-EH'ThTUtU3TW

i4t6z TAt,t flk f R, ff k hq-lt t-f ± Aflt t+t)t@t o 1

i0 XTh0 jig mf O +tNfflV t Y

ftf -fL ?t f- l A- NEtlt0t nti 4 'i-L ) , n 4W f 5fl T Z',Z xt A/G* -)t f-t-t- i tt M 9t W TV

AQkX ZffllQkA MuEiEilTh) :htW (ffrMtf;@,JiltER) tiJt

*ThrJ If1lAM: t t$IftLt i Z*A gl,kltAitkt

hIf of nh fi tX ff {P1fR (f1) oT 4W i; j R it TX i t g

Tt tX iPJStt-'Th}Xit'lTii 7t{, (2) (ettLR) it

* VT S mttktftt IbT M f f n iii /{SThTF?k li J kMM-Mb-JX

Page 121: World Bank Document€¦ · tIT 1997 L* t iflfO * Alex F. McCalla4gt 28X ~j, JfiNlit . Wendy Ayres, Hans Binswanger, Arturo Cornejo, Sanjiva Cooke, Douglas Forno, Dean Housden f David

Mt X A 113

I

4'~1 l I"- lll ;l i-' ,' I l alI 15

B 5l' a, r,r T, it .v

'.1 .1 tl 'iJJ

I '. I I A r jF j

! 1stl4 8ffi,,I 1~7 il- r, t f

________________ . I .

* - .-1] A2 , lt] I±2i A * # - t Y, ,z / M

i6-- /~l ~S k t- k,*

j1 ,,, IE I ) W ff i ±

*, 'I L- 'i i a 4 i.

i - f - f ~~ - -~~ l t~f~ )

Page 122: World Bank Document€¦ · tIT 1997 L* t iflfO * Alex F. McCalla4gt 28X ~j, JfiNlit . Wendy Ayres, Hans Binswanger, Arturo Cornejo, Sanjiva Cooke, Douglas Forno, Dean Housden f David

W 3 B .5 # § t 6F R tttft"

- . A t!Y

- 1 111-,1i',.t;.1- ,.rr1,'11 1lsrt74 $4A 4* M 91t lfwrRfi1IttHX&m -4

Y7'tr' A-1. 44VAk 3-izkv Min,7Ks t. MA gmt3- v! jfl. l-!

nl Il I - t9

:2f-F1. rilk .ist, 0Eg tl *T) P£o *W5tRW T IR1-VN F

YX F-: i;t;"l twotgM-t r7-t7nt t o, f-£-1% -ET MPh --,fn h7 t' 41' *i4r_'Pl rKV rr) 'hf J: tg t$X .Et

bu FL.r9S L7 -1-0j -- F A ->tih;k i} _ i.g,) -EtS Jti m iJMitIH-RLx HuttV]lt-T) I; H I f4-Ji )fWj af q f r 11' A

Aq t.i I J06 H Mf tw T~ RU t Xst A A 0, fg ;@t '; i--- Ki 0 T _ UK ik:X TIa fft YiAJ,liB

-t- T I !:0 A ;,' --:ttl -I l :t]W-' gRT I H 4 O)ll f ht V 9 pHa m Tt,) S ty,fAP1 1if E

f-I k f 4 4vA l4qf * A R A,iEt I)ffi IJ ' k.tk t RX

(f,-UMLI-01JAtkl ritlJsg uVMf) *h doiXfiWlIT7Xt

T@L itit z .> Cl 7i AC ttE R A rf7W1 I-t-

RXRRi1JeL&ffim-M]FtiA b W$ESt -1-XNgE iTtEot

Page 123: World Bank Document€¦ · tIT 1997 L* t iflfO * Alex F. McCalla4gt 28X ~j, JfiNlit . Wendy Ayres, Hans Binswanger, Arturo Cornejo, Sanjiva Cooke, Douglas Forno, Dean Housden f David

itlf3-kwiE oF -t t * ff:iXA t 1iw t,et h IItt Xd4'AtM4pt JM miti4RAlJX t -R it:tLvwr i1rt5

* fEX 4 JR B iR R r-' 1

* > t EC, ffi EG. KIg3. i!hh

O We W LtW t-g '1f 4 ffi fiF/ i T , f,1 F. NuT

PI P~A V ig J1

* iq J y5fA ri0 +F * t 'A I' ' 1 -

HA 'N- 3 X it Y-Isf Pk

I A tt o T ll+X1;[lgstt 4II3 X2stAM11Sa Ri

Page 124: World Bank Document€¦ · tIT 1997 L* t iflfO * Alex F. McCalla4gt 28X ~j, JfiNlit . Wendy Ayres, Hans Binswanger, Arturo Cornejo, Sanjiva Cooke, Douglas Forno, Dean Housden f David

* fr1*aO RF*OtF112ht, -Wlt1ttk S RRA12'HA& £R

t4AAffiW10l-20% fiWftiM9t 0 tŽT#RJNtntn* #LttO SIEt Th-3A tO iLTh A80% ktt AAtIXu 0ff

tE V< f it 13 Wj IE T- Jl A -t F)j p f F,LI

* , VlA& * I- R A •h AA 3/a1tj A t, Q4*TitSLVkO NO),tqlTh

"#h" 'ffUVtfCi t-, EN7kThR. t* tk 0 d {t#W5(EX-M ft3 *fitttt-A S%PtAn

ff i,xt~-t x HDtxtkTtx9lH kSE fIQA M

* X1Ae MAtt~~ t t10t-X ¾Y7K"i ittn*tt fJttt-fLBo ltTh'lf/t t-A it& lW8,k HfE2 X, iA8;ttAniWlfM , 'So

it1i1 f flft {hT~4*g#nRt t4IktQktSAtt

f-t t- t f+W M tEPaIk t"Tt9 B: 11 7yXt -i I

SNtIttt~~tlt (1 1S1JMf~~AWk, ThSiA#&±tSK "Xb9

i-T W] ffiElfXfllt WiJ A {H s A bLKt [LIAE f LTftft %3o M1

{iTh ittTh{ tAis tt &, 4mAItfN bErl., AUX, S3&149#tZa l5 tttŽr FtTh , t-] o'TEl

x,3 t 11T X A itH * -A1; (2) Vk-O/0kb -i -tZ X PnikWATXlli%o*ttJI2tff -, j f 7g X A A 6fvl t t f q ta f t VE It, A *, iSt- illI 0, R P & f-xR T-

ThMhtSHO MThS, StŽTJHfW

ME tJ'. %

1 K Att¶t9. i F i, |'j t fLiftt#ttWtt|F ru1 f6 t

Zt Lt tiH1, $ flxTh&WVtf74tWW1Ii7E, tttt 1R1 A tJWIitA1lit , SifF

to '&IELFJD4, aUMtW;g;PX, ;kitt1$Jtfl TO :is;xwUaFsRI%X!ktStU#:3iPIg o W 1t tt T hSiI 3SPF lZ A AL ' ,:-@PAt~ Ft DX.t tf±h1 7c YtP2Et it R,

Page 125: World Bank Document€¦ · tIT 1997 L* t iflfO * Alex F. McCalla4gt 28X ~j, JfiNlit . Wendy Ayres, Hans Binswanger, Arturo Cornejo, Sanjiva Cooke, Douglas Forno, Dean Housden f David

A fx 117

tAT JI1-YiWtEtfr-4A^2 "It Fi it ;Ko''* tih0 it$ t

=, 4n7Tt'J 1 II4&*o ffiT% ktt& t II fuX htTh?fk 0 TIhThfXRf 4 Nq2m (k>tifl

WKf I j LT-hiAflttkRolTqi if * V -10ti,--t jtHtTh),0RkŽ1L, k'Y&htg l. ATf]X4zJ i- GULl ~lA *jtiALta * tnX ¢rt k±t rirA 8jtX

A#M TTht -"1ii~o 3Af flt )j ttu ' t&Žt?i Ijrj- ".r * tfltVkzJQ -lyfffiXZ$t~ikJ>tThtWg.IjTh 4th'l on :l t-si hi IijtiI "Iii- U,tl]nt)ALk:t4#fQ

1; fi- sl R X* .- Rf slXM$AW 10-n!>ll EX fu-:i- '1h Ip o~ ffviWAtTXighh7At

fXt ftTra - rT' LkIJf -'I'buWt aM FL S[XlA p xe Di;'t Il 97 iT 4i "l I)Q -IR t lp

(A.1: ftJ A rT, J<:' f 'it t f;1 M it l I

ILzht~tLT4h tStfHtltAfiXfu:i' t V*.TX Ri&LYW U{4kAtWhT H t,t

Uk EttI I ll w_ITt' tJ pi tI t- t o %

tv-J%m thz -01tn Tl) zyi lT- iL~ fWft M 4 hoth- )h$t- i q * li Mtl n T f IF IW lkH W

o EK MJ1 S3 -f iA4gtJ7r Ez if- .k 1 Stl eL 1ti bW A fk f+ 1TT WI]

18tWli'ffi 0 tAThi I]tfWbibRftRt, A Thfjv RiAiaitr4AXPEJ{v4tXUh-7-tb& 1iF5;Th.<t tt"tUT hL * ftnt t i T1 g ' bftL{. ft{K E 2 t

SXk4kttW A;9[mij,tiht

*l ±Atlf:W*8 MA5S@fiA .rTAXPllffifll-# X Wl1lR-4ul*t t ItTM fThf- A UV P T,tŽTtiI1tn f tu-

Ar4tzeQ At'bSR it RJil~ (3) g bltS.HtHX -

* -V&ttt±Rtn$iR'UttiiHf8 ittlr9'; -1AW#A, f+i JitrthIt4 1 oj

I,Itt t tfA t 1) AP PR |1 W a iktTit:t-

t Wtct3ibiQ+; i t*r jt' 6 L ATADF LATEN 4

ilt klvltr #tfilq A4~V, 51L~WVf65

. ih ( 4 ti j* tAKt. AtK tFEKV .fl+fV

* t tthi']x _mwott9t

Page 126: World Bank Document€¦ · tIT 1997 L* t iflfO * Alex F. McCalla4gt 28X ~j, JfiNlit . Wendy Ayres, Hans Binswanger, Arturo Cornejo, Sanjiva Cooke, Douglas Forno, Dean Housden f David

120 tMf&: U4Ti

* ; , R)PI T ifit¢la Ak/XtGDPA uqlA,

t+M ) t ml W-$ltsh YI 1 R A. Lt It YX i- g r . t tt,Ff vW2.5 i447A Z 14%-3.1% i 1R, {H.ItfP9b, ik b

* ' i * ,LLt ARWONreM* -t^IJ23iKR l t : 49m -iSt, tk AAYAll -EpIi%r-Wh o XIlst el/.@,fi

f a 1hX, W :ffiWwtpJs5 tEAtMt fitiA b9J1 440 *fXM.ttTEVAiNY -M,, $11 9l*a $ iEl gbt,Xt$tomf 11t1

W2etSE%, 4XTMAL

* tiXp1J±4j:t% lJN

e 13'1W- ri ;t IS v tA llXt te1

, i&4%, tW M (2) Xlt Ii)

it4% fJgff,' (2 VMVARXtiTt

Page 127: World Bank Document€¦ · tIT 1997 L* t iflfO * Alex F. McCalla4gt 28X ~j, JfiNlit . Wendy Ayres, Hans Binswanger, Arturo Cornejo, Sanjiva Cooke, Douglas Forno, Dean Housden f David

gP Z4 ;j 121

5Y4f(3) lAt54&f #JSt'P&I kTtfThtfTtfN v 4n.0 /'t/ k F-l* 9 T r $-l f;X h 1t1 r-itAr±Pt, R i-tA i f Et V , A E r Etff

Al Tjf IFaRQ it 5-C tL iI tEg 1 I T h

tittbgfl+f51ttIlt WNJ, tn M. J tt'OjItQ ttd I A 1998-1999 #jkt_T [ t It.,j [ fT } 2

* tfifntnt rnll , ?r'K o Z At ¶ I

* Th34-AtSX t 14*L VJtL% tIJkL-LtI I ti, N tI < f

* - Y f AF MN '11 /(,494 t) f% $ eS --P W 'fe A 1wt iA.m f f cI ,o t4F IT XT

. lMi ŽYT, tJ H -it A, ItIl~al A * TtJ

A th fl Vff"Ik- Rtli 1";T t11, Pfr 1h ' r± r-ItfE 5t 4 I 1)r 1M X ;fi 1¢1 0i f 9 I± 1~ 4, Ai 14 P' R ,S gli , t f1fih 1

* tkA#t1t {t5htAK ii ls AXMh0 dRti

± 2ViifUt' I .f tiP Lkf 4 13 ffkhtUVIt* kftn~~ffB(] i WOA-A fU4

* t-fMeliftJ /' kbJM,Jtf'Th u2 1iH@kt 13f]Bfl iAQ tt. WS

f* WhRniMt¼St{u i {tfl' o hALr miR0

FgAQ*-":~VDA' Pg- i ||it }0 t S i'TfVVttt bkP 4-t -9 YX f

* 19981999 4fl i iX S IN tXA M}W ittt -it53IIti1 ii0 tt .194 ttThRtt4Th@R 1±f* Et)dttfiUL -tThSI kiILWXtiffB43WtIn'k9$ 4*Thtni)JtSALiA+i&jShfI42f225tf& t WiFli9tiU;t Rtfii

A44tAtzrJ1? i#i'&, 4ztMl&:1? QbWlQ ½$2iii4t+Q-tQLrWk

ttI]&wi¾H5§,muim, 4{ kgPn tIg'tftiJ<t4ttiMt ThSTh'Xi@ThLALI tA m3LA-A, ThHW~ thtThltfl'4SfltI{kf#tS 4IMAhAtv &lLtui':ttX0 JXij'5J VIIq j'i W;O fn,¢ 1 jyxfkgtkqq'pff9 ttfi

M@Sit 1998-1999 #Rt ittiTh t§* t TY M^WkL{JUYO ffLIU

Page 128: World Bank Document€¦ · tIT 1997 L* t iflfO * Alex F. McCalla4gt 28X ~j, JfiNlit . Wendy Ayres, Hans Binswanger, Arturo Cornejo, Sanjiva Cooke, Douglas Forno, Dean Housden f David

122 VIRR: EG'

ZEABHo~~L t:wWaLI"'tXt$S W)n*Aa

tEt9-&tq*t'txttt2TPl ta#k, tStSteewt

ZEEt<Ng3RAAtE%hE8FAVTM@ tS444k- W] T-M 9A

fTo f[I' -5,itkltE iUi; At o @TM P 3 ' A, 1 NW ± h]M 121ftT3 ' t8K0 7JliJ t

r~~~k ENffT-' ~if I OEbS 4A tl, Vlf

t;ff]4g*t 1S121 ob'ttElMV 1W1 ASW ill'o*q J4A* 9 dNM Z 6tA7 T-

RE, -qM-L#T4klAIW aG AttRe*tIAlR oiF

Page 129: World Bank Document€¦ · tIT 1997 L* t iflfO * Alex F. McCalla4gt 28X ~j, JfiNlit . Wendy Ayres, Hans Binswanger, Arturo Cornejo, Sanjiva Cooke, Douglas Forno, Dean Housden f David

gugat n.o fljSdCF Il J I R EJ

* IntW -¾ f it-P U 0tIŽA.4flttk, fif( i * xvtw A#fPtILfit 1 * . l. I$*11±]tQ XDTI'

* 7J(~~4W~ go A T, -FO tk1tfd hk*k -P"0 Uitit1i* N W¢ 11' li- 1r] *:n% 3F 1iW iit Hfl o* t@ 7L,* m* ia--I H t.$M ifr>ll!ti ,;lt9t F7Rt£;

* NW'Wfl,wtt *i *-$ 7 t Si tt^

* Th3%A*, fiI O Matruh tW fl')f t*fRRP ia

* ~~~~~* _1' 7tgt*4: --Eht* ittttt-t&tf

M - fttAt 7Jc! 0 t *ttRt i * WR*49tB 1/ O a

. Atttj t z Htts M * IrTI.

M tffi+ fi E fi4 mR fi M iX go AN A i S$ St SS 8hX A Pi f At t2 3 Xkt; V A T K CA -t MMV i.iP4l fi RiA*Am,4i0 + $VW1R. I'tE l 'islMr*ull., ($tH7fXt)*"> j# <,A7)

* ±ttttt: , {HAtiY , R &$!i * jSl/l

* K, r f* RE 'h [i $ -W m zi Pl1* f7 ttj *1 fI l ' S r¶ Hdio * .5 ii $gl7 44#U +tfM 1 X t&i) (tHtc t* P4iAk 7 Srwl. E w t * 4 ml pi * fi 1 t*l 4I t t I

* f- W *op lh A A+ t , TAI t'I.A f#r T Pn A Lit $ r * A R g ' t i v t E itiJ a p- ( ;Xtr A* t4t4kt'tThiiPWt0 1 L,, i |. ThJfl. tt*9t 4g & t4* 48f Xt,'XW 9 tkt4i *n3t1ctiIil.4*{ Tr

fftS ,6 *t IIS ILA F~ I .L iR tuxt Xf>t ,,* 17t.~~~~~~~~~~~~~r -fij 1 io 115 ) S 1 7 g 2P"P ETe Xi)o

Page 130: World Bank Document€¦ · tIT 1997 L* t iflfO * Alex F. McCalla4gt 28X ~j, JfiNlit . Wendy Ayres, Hans Binswanger, Arturo Cornejo, Sanjiva Cooke, Douglas Forno, Dean Housden f David

IA) WT41rffw (*fSlkYTh4) :4W1*IW

oT wVpu4n .AT W iE X )W LIFUM

~'WSi-g+Th

oqW

tI'X?W§X@ '%.±4tT4-i4nL-

ogT§#t4r

%C 'RiunShw4i

r[ x +.En A4JI {22;;X21 h (W3 'R4- '£{* 'Gf4i) aUa3**WI{3*

(g) 9*fl$44

Page 131: World Bank Document€¦ · tIT 1997 L* t iflfO * Alex F. McCalla4gt 28X ~j, JfiNlit . Wendy Ayres, Hans Binswanger, Arturo Cornejo, Sanjiva Cooke, Douglas Forno, Dean Housden f David

(' tl: ILIh: Itf

. °kWLWWX4R4 F*TWVl~4W* W4W4J$T#W1*4 "i.i Y

r1'f'Wltb' 'W /ii I; nvtF * i!' lW* *l1 X X$

>Mta64B4g, . M}i[WtWF4kt -13 at9B4* '04QViBl+[

(E) 911fC4

Page 132: World Bank Document€¦ · tIT 1997 L* t iflfO * Alex F. McCalla4gt 28X ~j, JfiNlit . Wendy Ayres, Hans Binswanger, Arturo Cornejo, Sanjiva Cooke, Douglas Forno, Dean Housden f David

X$@S44N47. MR!VfiW?y (tj*'f YA*dif

(065) F:1 *

ik4 WJ*/d(UDF Tht *

4. (IuaWL$½AF 4 , -k (4Lwfl4) w 4ftt

(LI444) 1 *T 4:WL 1i*:Wf'i fr * h kM '31+J

Xi>wi!gW9)T XI w4i2$ 24 Sg§f- 4 i L1X * e20 N Id Dfl

INC

tllet> X 4824B-4} Y h h-llgtf 2zf '

Page 133: World Bank Document€¦ · tIT 1997 L* t iflfO * Alex F. McCalla4gt 28X ~j, JfiNlit . Wendy Ayres, Hans Binswanger, Arturo Cornejo, Sanjiva Cooke, Douglas Forno, Dean Housden f David

iOR t 1:t 127

K#t,tB.8 i t 'f bLI

' < m t t i'm g ti $ i44 s M 9 + tt -t * s

*l * 3f I n,4 TithfR ±t h-k jtO] E IJ kt#, F $w-4)

ft42~6- ;-I A ff Al.l.ttt

* W 4% 5At#T a -it fH 1Th~ xtm J~ ~~...rfi z{in a12t f 1~

*x f Jt YO; r TI n (-'jr, t$ tm st~ I PA l- L t i - T( * IL A 21 h Xlfi* r i ZE 'Jlr ttXbtITMA. * #t&k1ff§LThQY¶&X48]

*I' * f iiofiT My PM - ikJ '- m, YWiW f-t +

* tt1lmf~ jag $JM. 5AR#, &MŽk&fl 2. 4tptsM1±A Pet±1sFTh1F-i±i4-vv

9 *flitt'JjL , A2Rt~i,4h

* 4Xt wyf*n 4% &tt ntifRt4bit49 * *;hitftMWk tFL I4g±tiMi;i .tttXJi M±. @jR 4tW:* BffeXFl/-!{JtCR*X181S&FA I: , Pr #tt-1;-Iit Nb1Erl}it'2ti

ff ~* B.LW8I±TtR-MtkW

* tttsrrrbumsi (E bS W>W"TVL * tAtt 4Th:WEtThE1< TX*4i Tfh $kti5ii' 'W'ITht4

*k jtsfflaTTwfIsltwkE,Vr~ ntIt

T 0 *b fk , : I ffti r l T il * Jr., 'i T I

* ;l Et t'| 4- WtkA4f Mr] Tft2 Vg51tP§t m Oil T: 4O. * - xt t ||l. I 5 A1 I 1g- '81 A ..'li ,F xt -t-l !g 1 [ I 0 A *-g r

*~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~~~~iT A ipX tgfiL gi; eXX w it tJ it

Ae,;t~~~ I=} ,'1 1 ]

Page 134: World Bank Document€¦ · tIT 1997 L* t iflfO * Alex F. McCalla4gt 28X ~j, JfiNlit . Wendy Ayres, Hans Binswanger, Arturo Cornejo, Sanjiva Cooke, Douglas Forno, Dean Housden f David

144i 7 44-44444VP*44Y4

44W*wf4-5¾44�444iY444>W G'WWLq

-,V X H*ff I*4 14 JA T L1 tw4 Y*W749 SgVRW ** 4

^ 44Ž[4@-k)44W@A$TW *' *4-4f WXt t44w

0 *Mn:&4 Q1 '44f If-.t44

.' LW Hi IL$§ L$11tt(L4 g44j4$4JSl444Y4:4k44fIgjfL44442r '44 t)L,44444eH 'F44W4PI1;ir4ThIVX6*4uWT4N

4 e4 44

,W*ff IfY A- 70

W*W*:MW#2'f 44;@HigLe:# '#444 4(W44g 'sth4?UL4f$'h4Ifl6-XLJ44.WhWi4 'WY*NIla44Bf * XgWv9i XIS X-

IB N.'

4XIS\ i2R t4011fi '44yLB14u44E '(444$044i$4{4n4BW}WW4412Th44N 'w1;14$X1 4 I*W4444{ 0 4L4%444@fli't"B44f

C44ILii4WLf44k (2fiMw{14,) V44 -I{144

OUiallPdi' V S1-ye

°M?9 4- ?zT

4 '44XXS-SX$;W 4-,3F*

a.4 4fl4444*wB¢p (4@ (444Bflf4nL444) 'V4*9X*)4J14444ZS '4444414 '44444~4t4.4I4 '4II.XMWLJ1-2WW Wx,*S@X4 1 j3ulyR

44'" i4f Zt 4444 -9T

4/4444 ' B4W+44 4TW* [UbF* L44*fih 'W44f44 4$4 °4 '&@444#frmnk+£44 '44444444*444-

44'4444'44->R*$A#4'44 'fl*X4i444 fl44T*4 '4- 44*44 41T# f?^W444444iVf4* 'f'44

44 ' 44iS*4LiL44LJx44444444N ;44444}4 4LJ4+j1 '4 giL U.4444 '44444444I 1

'444+44+4 '41+44 '4434444*4444Fisi: .44444444-44* '4ha 4-2g4+ nLj4+M'*Y44 '4444444

(gj) 8-%1BBJd

zLf42"ftirBY~ :WJ44 8Zl

Page 135: World Bank Document€¦ · tIT 1997 L* t iflfO * Alex F. McCalla4gt 28X ~j, JfiNlit . Wendy Ayres, Hans Binswanger, Arturo Cornejo, Sanjiva Cooke, Douglas Forno, Dean Housden f David

*@43 129

ffi*B.8 (Z)

Ii i rI3 I'tL i &.I f/-i O f*fR=-&

* tAk11W A1'IM I Iii- i P] Wr' !M. AkiI r- Qki.T r Mt .RM4hu bo, bu M6ii4L*

iM s B<tli lhtZt WYA1gg Ik IR, T.),#-##tlt

r- tA Vtit At 4Tll¼ *At t vi ½I5Ig.* 4 -, L1I*O i- -)]i &a i? d r-iWfftt'i 21t4 .ttIW1li, ml

* tuuMXŽs*BII. Z±fiml/SMlittdJ. t< *½JitWit5g ithat]@tZIbTh*tTftittlBX. ThtIJmlml+. tik&a4Lk1.X .*eaR,M-ttnA-1t

* itfltIA AAkm-TW1N, hK$lt'tfflriXWI, tn*,/-A4tiWi ttt4irilEkwflgfi

* ttW&i ,tu Ml, 4ttKfP$-LtW ixx+Aik,VFRW]Tfa, J

. t+ i7T(.S. WAiiltKtMR<sit

* tu{FM*41* M tt . 4 v gtW U/ 1" %'I i I Z.] A M

JPaittUW. 1fwf W'ViflW,) MBa &%Jt-i#NffYif til w If rM A9txP 9M l .I ~a9 t1i

Page 136: World Bank Document€¦ · tIT 1997 L* t iflfO * Alex F. McCalla4gt 28X ~j, JfiNlit . Wendy Ayres, Hans Binswanger, Arturo Cornejo, Sanjiva Cooke, Douglas Forno, Dean Housden f David

130

W660k PA< XITAk6 g 4BJx' @

ItFSuS(IFC) iltJA R ml LA V)Y

An- its4 fi IFC- 42' $ I FCg4@t ilt 4f

IFC@ 944 9ot 6 IFC t +le4Xv4lXGEj

IFCt

1992 *J* 'v m 7 T kt- :

t0i;EvA lp-Lml,T A,otLk 9!Mt24tJ t a , 95 lk t T-S 0,WAW M9 ,6 ,-5 i-;t7g;lXtiPt

WRol T-MMJRiM, LL 1992 kit4± Mfl 5 ffi4

i AIf TLii k , 3 IFC *EV#t4l3Pn{3ff4

~ A #L~A~~1~1980Yl W-1 IN, A 43, A9'nAi]+t I A X6RZ (i

Yt 2tEi t B E1t&o A iV_ fp lPTff AL AI kl Tff fi A IVN 9[;) ft Eg T,R9 92A ++Jft V T -751Wo

ffio1 n1 i)l *4 aJtE 11 ; AaLk 1 bN 11 r S

* '1itiri{4F 1TA PI,11 Fi:311 T-½X44i¢9t@ x §tt UtSt X4LF' 98

Page 137: World Bank Document€¦ · tIT 1997 L* t iflfO * Alex F. McCalla4gt 28X ~j, JfiNlit . Wendy Ayres, Hans Binswanger, Arturo Cornejo, Sanjiva Cooke, Douglas Forno, Dean Housden f David

131

;h -~Tt~'1 -Rt trm kh%Iq ~ 44 A _ p" ft T ~ 4~) X'P T) H Hlf Jl, tt fJj

IFC° o IFC A -e f49. * Uit, IFC lFCttVIJe*_ IFC ilE I11 ' l

bZXiF Ci;h IFC 44L ry- .t If m xfWFf 9T4

-A1996 f 12 Ei3 IFCV , , IFC it-L -- T

IFC H~tIFC

I e5, FCcSeM94 ffl , (2) 44 'Jg I Ž1L0 tf fiS

I] igE 1996 tW- 12 A 4-41 -z

M,ig IFC 0, AR IFC

IFC R;hAAQA97iLN4f 1994uf I

g M k i(F40 it lW T l t W * K Jt a A@t,~~~~~~~~~~Il,fL *tSE:fi$1s@t Yix00 11/t9|;FFiXt1!w A+it t: fT A -

IFC *ft, ti:@AkX mtt' 9 T)q H li ~t t;T6hJ t

IFC~~~I CJAk;gf* n1 Tg f --b;16-

iWt, AfR2gT I;T,-Etl M: FCA bT-hgtigl T:A IF -W, A

IA.IFC 1 iVf w6trEWH gll[ tAV* -1

A A,1E f JWiET , T'lJA9~F IF UM EI t£ko i7e RI ;I (2 (1) /181 tv lJtAF

RStW ol *111Ffi; 42-4l tA -- t rm {EJ 0 3 A -1 214

Page 138: World Bank Document€¦ · tIT 1997 L* t iflfO * Alex F. McCalla4gt 28X ~j, JfiNlit . Wendy Ayres, Hans Binswanger, Arturo Cornejo, Sanjiva Cooke, Douglas Forno, Dean Housden f David

t 50-500 ThxtiJT H) H fl0hŽ4iYftfrjWiŽ&i JTh. f. fh -A -tt httlM HI, IF C 0,T-,' ll f A (--t ,it M'bP AI]f --qtJ2 a< W In, l r.fi M

, E IJFC'I'S 1 tt4P4AMThIi -f Vtitu *WMThtW O

* IE"-I 1tThAik%4iŽVi th W4 A7 J- Li

* U iR flt, Mi t-' , H; r, H -A

- itX- lPIAk6 H , U 7 - T ll FLLVktt%l 1Ti1ko*tDkTJfii1%t*VAJ?+4YttQ*S W, ftfl WtffiL- Htltl iWk fVPMA

t Z3 61*., iLX # kid -PT 1>1 5gi 97 T- PMq 1t f A: 3E1- A E I FCtEM JtUb. 1 swttiFE-A .n2,firm&

V± _i MI/str n J &I I vt- fri 6 ti Nt LA H~~ nP ft

-iYYE=tAe4i (IBRD) 41 X e , HT'I tXMiThI4ŽTIFC 4t -fl, JFCIUAg--ObU IHBRD h WiEi4

tnM1iJN J?, {tb IBRD M(I1TW# f T I r1

IBRD ¶ IFC ±At&k Ž AZ r I 0t M LR hAfOtH98RMJoIBRiAXttWt *Itt IFCiXStg %4tX

f4nlT: (1) ,t$i'Qt; (2) 0imtTh A½#kf3i] (tUQ tT1# tp) ttt4t;(3) Aibtfi (li ilg,irq iR,. f$;r%1j2 R-Ei:$J±-Jtt*MFk 5

tiQll (4) it-$#) f IBRD i-K 'iti ¾ t _kttPJVKUtf I LFC ATUb{TIkrff

iif-g10 S, Wit, t S U*:L 4$Ž , iA

4BJ#IF &tt t.f fWALAf,llE[llI Ž j± -Th M, I-l A)" 57 t. $t -it +Jl

tfi1d'.IFC.TVNrtt4EVItWP fit fMt Yi W M rlt IR /f fiWA,; t

WA~~~~~~tkf ~iH 1k J- pl i-tik t E NiWA#V+O,. r MN.......................'I4tQ4tt'

Page 139: World Bank Document€¦ · tIT 1997 L* t iflfO * Alex F. McCalla4gt 28X ~j, JfiNlit . Wendy Ayres, Hans Binswanger, Arturo Cornejo, Sanjiva Cooke, Douglas Forno, Dean Housden f David

133

WJ D

29~~~~~~~ iT i-t Eif9 S @ T

ffi 't t t * (EDI) Fs Xk U it

IFiM. EDI ±ATS iti PTX6A ffiW9t CVr±O

~1~fl1 ~ EDIEDI

EDI EDI EIj-ttI±l EiDT

Qitsthi)ls'SfsULmSt,it,TW

EDI'VT R ftH'*r' NPU 1 2. rT PIR ED I R j i-P1 ( ti'R ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ l-t- #1 s' N ?5W 4't ' 0 ), EDIfQ T ~j A It -

EDI H , tksffi f`±"Ms "0 i

R7 4 A (F R E ' W£ t I, H- I PI ,, I, L O

Ap,M lf~ +tLN ' EDTJ aF Tl -ij IM lAt'iIir' I ItAii kfiV t . . iJII-PoJ S fjiFr±F) EDI jx . U : ( ;rl D. 1): t v

EDI br t ±)jAA MFI, {TTM tJ-' 2 AlEJ 2. 9 } L ,I, ', O

illl,~~~~R --hmW 92f ItWi 4- 4E )XXt3 M T)q F] it ; -

it ldlg{kffi. 0;8< tA .I-' IJ[-,ii[ TI f Ifot@ t (5]T R 3D1

Page 140: World Bank Document€¦ · tIT 1997 L* t iflfO * Alex F. McCalla4gt 28X ~j, JfiNlit . Wendy Ayres, Hans Binswanger, Arturo Cornejo, Sanjiva Cooke, Douglas Forno, Dean Housden f David

134 tk&fl%Ji KJe1T'e

"fiD 00 "t 4 s

C -X (

t/iJ-

Page 141: World Bank Document€¦ · tIT 1997 L* t iflfO * Alex F. McCalla4gt 28X ~j, JfiNlit . Wendy Ayres, Hans Binswanger, Arturo Cornejo, Sanjiva Cooke, Douglas Forno, Dean Housden f David

iilW - 135

WAVV D.1 4 ittl

1994 * 10 iO, EDI AE EiffiX -tf TV3iNTI, I-XK?1&ffMig A4-T

M. rffo M+IA 819S1ffiI, tk f ieX i)ltq 4P.*TglotA:F199IF-2e f-iPff-Tffl)HThtM±~ih, Sitfiiit4, ThO 34IRU1t, X 4g«.f l95h 4U&It

1995T 10 qf ¶tJfkfTfV , t A±Tho] 4 , 4`tfXt { vi -- , 3t \L

~t 4, iflEt MT fit p Mk r4P

-- t EDI # 1995 * 2 l MW V E i4 {Tt ft4, ga1t h L tXa i#: M 4ME

tSfi It4c{,X, PlJStitlThs EDT AC.t&tlk*O iitJI&:

4. yxmn, -wL*wfr½

¢>*gSi)l, W|J\4tt"2° EDI t+§XQ

6. T4-,T1 wl6 t;R X t7 d-k Jt 1i, w' EDI !f'll tt QL (EDIEN) ffn

Mt, EIARThXŽiflAwthfri "t'r13$#h IA, EDIEN HM EDI iXtt

0 EDI 4 u-tM*, AliW1iltŽ1tn -AWttHtt1RV st, EDI V4-MPiflAVr EDIEN i4Th(UziI 0 tjVgzX,

tE,EDI A4iftt I EeJlttt4t 4t

tZ5, EDItIihk$±eiUI ak&VIIrX. 4tzttMMa bTtZ. WSt{BED! t{

EDI ttX'tbiTh RtiThTh*1FIWfl et 4tt$tE ,8S

n-zlJkiiIj'S ED! XTFfr±h` r#t&, EDIEN -, RIEN4EI-b.I II±,ZTL `WiW#iE * E WDI

IO

Page 142: World Bank Document€¦ · tIT 1997 L* t iflfO * Alex F. McCalla4gt 28X ~j, JfiNlit . Wendy Ayres, Hans Binswanger, Arturo Cornejo, Sanjiva Cooke, Douglas Forno, Dean Housden f David

136 Afttft,, k : 2i. i1 Ji

EDEEN t EDIENr (<<*txt¾i 1 2-ittNki&tffi7tV W

+,bOflt{T. IMf EDIEN iX

i 3AL#toU + A t+, i Si t MJ ii IIiA h ElEDIEN AN *efBt&rA -41Fa 3 ( fQT)0 tuof]kN '?lq-JV'i)EllT

itX;w tl ffitRtKTh0 hAAVIt, S 1fi,@ef; gt,tHl9E

EDJEN Ifl -LED#It E r±ttW U mm- P9-hfWHtnttt JFL kFiiI =lMht

g T$i#U -I'Mtt-ii t A U,X A tAm-fs l lW Uo 3tJt

'm+ttEThThTThgetItt4J0i ti+WthTh4tTt4Al1tQ

XWUO EiThA i t{tttitt#lIf II

EDIEN li EIN i:{ ~E

1tW ±Ai)XiTh, xtWlJAZTh± AEiltg+S FlA4St'

J< k t tS o- ATS 4iI .11A Q ljq f v Ex a it XE

EDIEN: &Ik* @5 ~ttfl g Vlltgj[LJjo tyXi£tetiIID UWA:

tAftk 7 4&4t&tJA EltTW T j

R-1 p i%'1Jt U& f 'gA VTIM1V_"l tT" , ii kTt e ;t R :fte

7ybiSTh--ttettThittiJlx U X@,aql U fi itt4tttto Jl~~ 4jU~¶~JIttXiit±m¶&3Thmtw7S:evtzALmk ±fffkThn1Tt

Page 143: World Bank Document€¦ · tIT 1997 L* t iflfO * Alex F. McCalla4gt 28X ~j, JfiNlit . Wendy Ayres, Hans Binswanger, Arturo Cornejo, Sanjiva Cooke, Douglas Forno, Dean Housden f David

I.!: IJ-iJ&WaTh 1.11 nWKI 0 JA4 4tflf 137

_-tSSl - ~SPtH>W &tit IL, k& J Ai)' I {A I

Pt, Pt.- I r& t -% f .SQ,t O~3/4. 3 i$ -P t* 5th±lJIIPT gS HttT h VtAg A .N.4I TeSt<tJttP o lA • ITi5; EWtThtIt,R

rdStJt, 4U14@I+/ | {T~5 #t3tttitT{TJfSttJl ItPtWdi-VH ;-42 4I.J4tuiTi jt, rn4f ]W ML,f R Wvi ¶l., ft0T ML Pt ¶k t19 bit ±iltJRI i t rQl 0) 1#:r-wSi- It&X,t#4 ¶fSaP4fl + Q tt# i ta XX t,fi H'i LIEtw&lBf A IR -k# ittP ' tS fWtttA, it-FIJMbZŽAM4ATX tfC MT,1 Qillf 91 I' SSt 0 K " 1-w44 ov Cy "Ir Af15if ftL Sf H7 f

tO r1 U i IA At * N-Rl i Ex 7 78 lf¶SY PItTh ZO E I11 1993 43Ž0 ft', 120 £ i'4t7't. A t'tf IJ i ' j',: ,. 4

rPti # EDI S It$E3 YtiJTI U i f H tT

*l tRi§P';t .Jrt3:XE J3Ž, $T {HI p t&iJ[l3t5 SF4Ž: t iiŽIAttWE*J~{i& ~kto~ AiI'Tt~~W 14Ž l;W3Ž#1ii tY -i-3ŽtŽo Stw11Wt4

A}Mt19to ff bt7iikStilMttR: EttVPcA7t til'k t±t# bŽtSB II !f'Vk4JIJltHXTh

fi1tDto tktt2tf i o] ',: & {47 3E14; t-T[ Y tPa 3'.j:-zr to

Wit&1t¶SttA$l I lMEJ t3Ž±i Y to$;#t Hi1Lj A-X4 4 H; HJH;#t-:l+TWTM7JhCŽ#tHitJ 0f3X it4Wti3ŽYYt7iiInt HiAHIf H1M@ i}XTh$i'Jtii)Att EDI~ QJ

-7 Hm Wj X rw-l Z 7 t 0 i 4 iI a t- rJ tlj 0, FAi i-It -meA ft 0 1 Wa h-- At- ~llt,- ,ilj Iti i f A] ff .,; lL l j!

A'HlŽ#tHittd~LJj 0 k7T4{±tSX, iV9MiW$, %:% #t5fioWtt6<Žt3 41kD¶Jiixl9i

-t . A f f I . i*- h. , Kg 0, #, !R r, -q" IA -'i 7,, eh Pt T j%4T14-f 1 r Tk

Mit Y*t-t hi 7 t4, W"t "fi EDJ9ThI'IiiIMHip-5w ir

~toTh4fRkThFt4ŽfnI1$gtM #Wtit-3Xtk Th#t4c0tt@0X llt4tt46

T- f$w H og A% -Al X Ma 5B1 1K T. it f ita t -a / r N |% A i;a f K ." "AaW .RJ t A

4ZtOlLtUktI#IPV jt+iji[0fi1Wgl tELl) ŽWSiiA Wit fiAt (4ftl3Ž1'k¼8Iit, tiJ^Ia I l- ^}7t A t tv i A v f fl 0, 6 4nt,tif&4tr4i)A 'i aTp±Q

tWiWOWalr Cl,Ti!,gsl t,#-WiS,- aSFN

~~ 1 t, 3~R , IJN A fI Iff. : I, E ; I ME DI TJ1 t i). I I TW IE :f t!5 q: O' li P

Kntl kLiRgf 11 5MIXI @$E

Page 144: World Bank Document€¦ · tIT 1997 L* t iflfO * Alex F. McCalla4gt 28X ~j, JfiNlit . Wendy Ayres, Hans Binswanger, Arturo Cornejo, Sanjiva Cooke, Douglas Forno, Dean Housden f David

138 A&9 T'J4

VIjU4, IM] it~'J I" A1 f J4- 4fI ~fw t TuJ f# H±wit/101MR, AMiXNl i(lft8I1/ Iz4Xi Viito i A!Eit A i,itE tZPCiEM tir 'fqlt oEi ffi WTitWiiFRI IA;lM3 ito rl9iM it$1 -1 xlJO t % fiip t it ol X

ThA±t43ttW1000-3000 )jW{#I t l,R lffi'I t i O, Oik # A1

tU+ ALV ir I; 10 % 4 fikg @f4 g ittJ4 a I ItI Jy I w 1* k*,HA:u

ta *W,fbi, iR4pfajL+9iSR"it$lleJb.%L$ExA# 14qvt#A tAtttAl

Page 145: World Bank Document€¦ · tIT 1997 L* t iflfO * Alex F. McCalla4gt 28X ~j, JfiNlit . Wendy Ayres, Hans Binswanger, Arturo Cornejo, Sanjiva Cooke, Douglas Forno, Dean Housden f David
Page 146: World Bank Document€¦ · tIT 1997 L* t iflfO * Alex F. McCalla4gt 28X ~j, JfiNlit . Wendy Ayres, Hans Binswanger, Arturo Cornejo, Sanjiva Cooke, Douglas Forno, Dean Housden f David

1818 H Street N WWashington 0 C 20433 USA

Te eprsne 202 477 1234

Facsn-e 202-477 6391

Te ex MCI 64145 WOPLOBANK

MCI 248423 WOPLDBANK

Cab e Aceress INTBAFRAD

WASHINGTONDC

Wor a W ce Web http www worldbank. org,

E -*a booksc worldbank org