- 1. Workplace Employee Wellness
-
- Budgeting, Banking, Reconciliation, Checking, Saving, Financial
Goals, Understanding credit cards, Importance of Credit
Scores,
-
- Down payment, Prepay penalties, Loan programs, Cash Flow,
Equity management Good debt vs. Bad Debt
- Financial, College & Retirement Planning
-
- 401(K), 403(b), Pension, 529 plans, stocks, bonds, Utilizing a
financial planner
-
- Health insurance, exercise, diet, nutrition, (these topics
addressed in later session)
2. Benefits of Workplace Financial Education and Home Equity
Management Planning
- Attract, retain, reward and motivate the right employees to
achieve a committed and productive workforce!
- Improve productivity and reduce costs by addressing the
work-life issues your employees face everyday.
- Educate employees about cash flow, debt reduction, savings,
retirement planning, their mortgage structure and how it affects
wealth enhancement.
3. State of the Employee Financial Wellness
- In December 2005, consumer debt in the U.S. reached $2.2
trillion. Credit cards account for almost 40% of that debt. 1
- The average household has a combined balance of over $8,400 on
credit cards and the average interest rate is just under 13%.
2
- The U.S. Personal Savings Rate dippedbelow0% during 2005 and is
now at -0.7%, which means personal outlays are exceeding personal
disposable income. 3
- 46.6 million American workers have no health insurance
- 1.Federal Reserve Board, December2005, Consumer Credit
Statistical Releasewww.federalreserve.gov
- 2.Money Magazine, March 2006.
- 3.Bureau of Economic Analysis, January 2006 www.bea.gov
Approximately 30% of workers report high work stress and among
the five major risk stressors (relationships, work, health,
crime/violence, and personal finance), workers rate personal
finance the number one source of stress! 4. REAL WORLD EXAMPLE Jim
& Sue Smith, 3 children
- $135,000 house,15 yr., monthly pmt = $2,300
- 1 st& 2 ndmortgage,$105,000 annual income
- Monthly $825 2 car pmts, $1,300 credit cards
- Credit scores are low, but not damaged
- 5 hrs phone calls & meetings
- Countless hours / days spent under stress
- Solution:125% Loan to value refinance
- Payoff all debts except mortgage & car loans
- 8 months of saving, $2,000 cash flow monthly
5. Relationship between personal financial wellness and worker
productivity!
- Improving employee financial wellness can result in a 40% boost
in your company's financial performance. Employees with money and
credit card issues are more likely to be unhappy with their salary
levels and/or change employers. Source: National Report on Work
& Family, 2001
-
- Financial Stress negative impact to the employer
-
-
- Primary cause of divorce and family breakdown
-
- Work time used for personal financial matters Average employee
with financial problems spends 27 hours a month worrying about
financial issues.
-
-
- Talk with coworkers about money related matters
-
-
- Talked with a lender about refinancing home or car
-
-
- Make calls regarding an overdue credit payment
-
-
- Make calls to friends or relatives about financial matters
-
-
- Talked with a financial planner
-
-
- Make calls to a credit or budget counselor
6. Reduce HR Administrative Costs
-
- Financial education helps defray the costs of wage garnishment
and payroll advances for employees in financial trouble.
-
- Reduces the burden on internal HR staff from answering
questions on financial benefits, communication and marketing around
financial benefits.
-
- Especially effective for companies with multiple sites and
remote workforces
- Increase participation in employee financial benefits
programs
- Only half of all workers who retire have any kind of private
pension plan.And over half of 401(K) participants age 51-60 have
$10,000 or less in their retirement account!
-
- Knowledge is power! Employees who understand their benefits are
more likely to participate in them.
-
- Financial education can help your company pass discrimination
testing by increasing participation.
7. U.S. Household Wealth Home Equityaccounts for almost
one-third of all U.S. household financial wealth, yet it is the
onlyunmanagedfinancial asset! 8. Incorporating Home Equity
Management Planning into Workplace Financial Education
- How employees handle issues of home ownership may well
determine whether they achieve financial wellness.
-
- Rent vs. Own Owning a home is the American dream
-
- Credit Scores more powerful than money
-
-
- Understanding credit scores
- Mortgage Structure and Wealth Enhancement
-
- Equity management - Cash Flow
-
- Debt Reduction Good Debt vs. Bad Debt
9. Best Practices
- #1: Unbiased programs, designed to educate, not sell.
-
- Clearly separate employee financial education plan from normal
Retirement Plan Mtgs
- #2: Incorporate multiple learning channels to accommodate
different learning styles Enable employees to access the
information in the way that is most helpful and convenient for
them.
-
- Offering multiple learning channels will result in a high
percentage of employees utilizing the service.
- #3: Personalize the financial counseling and coaching so that
employees can get specific guidance on their own financial
situations.
- #4: Education should be on-going not just a one time event and
by offering unlimited access, employees can use the service as
often as their personal needs dictate.
-
- Studies show that on average information has to be repeated
seven times before people act upon it, reinforcement is a
must.
- #5: Market the programs as a new employee benefit,Personalized
Financial Coaching Benefit.
-
- Employees perceive greater value in an employee benefit than
they do in an individual service. Employees will be more
engaged.
10.
- Do you have time to manage your portfolio?
- Are you an expert in investing and market trends?
- Do you enjoy making investment decisions?
Considering Professional Advice 11. If you save $250 each month,
how much could you have in your account after 30 years* ($90,000
total investment)? 6% - $251,128.76 8% - $372,589.86 10% -
$565,121.98 12% - $873,741.03
*http://www.fandktitle.com/calcs/allcalcs/invest_return_calculator.htm.Sample
shown for illustrative purposes only.Assumes that Interest is
compounded monthly.Does not include the effect of any fees,
reinvestment of dividends or additional contributions or
withdrawals. Investing involves market risk, including possible
loss of principal, and there is no guarantee that investment
objectives will be achieved. Investment Performance 12. S&P 500
Index 11.9% Average Equity MutualFund Investor 3.9% Source:
Quantitative Analysis of Investor Behavior 2006, Dalbar Inc. Equity
performance is represented by the Standard & Poors 500
Composite Index, an unmanaged index of 500 common stocks generally
representative of the U.S. stock market.The average investor refers
to the universe of all mutual fund investors whose actions and
financial results are restated to represent a single investor. This
approach allows the entire universe of mutual fund investors to be
used as the statistical sample, ensuring ultimate reliability. QAIB
calculates investor return as the change in assets, after excluding
sales, redemptions and exchanges. This method of calculation
captures realized and unrealized capital gains, dividends,
interest, trading costs, sales charges, fees, expenses and any
other costs. You cannot invest directly in an index.Past
Performance is not necessarily indicative of future results.
Average Annual Returns 1986-2005 13. Influences on Participation
Rates
Source: Whats New From the Ivory Tower, Dr. Julie Agnew, William
and Mary College Plan Design and 401(k) SavingsOutcomes, National
Tax Journal on Pensions, James C. Choi, Brigitte C. Madrin, David
Laibson, June 2004
-
- Number of investment options
14. Participation Source: Annual Survey of Profit Sharing and
401(k) Plans, Profit Sharing Council of America Is it acceptable
that 1 out of 5 eligible employees does not participate? RATES: 78%
77% 76% 80% 2005 2004 2003 2002 15. Savings Levels
- Behavioral reasons for undersaving
-
- Determining appropriate savings rate is difficult
-
- Procrastination and inertia
- Individuals want to save more but procrastinate
-
- 28% planned on increasing their savings rate after attending
afinancial seminar
-
- Only 8% actually did increase their savings
- Majority have not tried to estimate how much money they will
needfor retirement
- Many underestimate how much money they will need
Source: Defined Contribution Pensions: Plan Rules, Participant
Choices, and the Path of Least Resistance, Choi, Laibson, Madrain,
Metrick, Nov. 2001, Updated July 2004Employee Benefit Research
Institute, 2005 Retirement Confidence Survey 16. Save More Tomorrow
Results Average Savings Rate Source: Save More Tomorrow: Using
Behavioral Economics to Increase Employee Saving, Richard H. Thaler
and Schlomo Benartzi, 2004 13.6% 11.6% 9.4% 6.5% 3.5% 162 Chose
Auto Increase 8.8% 8.2% 8.9% 9.1% 4.4% 79 Accepted Consultants
Advice 6.2% 6.6% 6.8% 6.5% 6.6% 29 No Consultation 4 thpay raise 3
rdpay raise 2 ndpay raise 1 stpay raise Pre-advice Initial
participants 5.9% 6.1% 6.2% 6.3% 6.1% 45 Declined Auto Increase 17.
Increasing Number of Investments Source: PSCAs Annual Survey of
Profit Sharing and 401(k) Plans 18. Do Participants Take Advantage?
Source: 2006 Fidelity Investments Building Futures % of Total
Participants Number of Options Utilized by Participants 11 15
Options 16 30 Options 19. Participant Rebalancing is Market
Driven
- 88% of all participants made no trades (April 1994 August
1998).In 2003, 87% made no trades.
- On average, one trade is made every 3.85 years
-
- driven by a polarity factor.rebalancing between equities and
fixed income investments
-
- motivated by the contemporary performance of the market, rather
than a long-term strategy
Source: DC Plan Investing December 2004, 20. Are Asset
Allocation/Lifestyle Funds the Solution? Source:Hewitt Trends and
Experience in 401(k) Plans, plansponsor.com, Iomas Annual Defined
Contribution Survey 2005
-
- 58% of plans offered this option in 2004
Plans Offering Asset Allocation/Lifestyle funds Percent of Plan
Assets 55% 2003 63% 35% 30% 19% % of Plans 2005 2001 1999 1997 Year
10% 2003 10% 10% 8% 10% % of Total Balance 2005 2001 1999 1997 Year
21. Are Lifestyle Funds Utilized Properly? Source: Hewitt
Associates, 2003 Benchmarks20-29 Lifestyle Fund Utilization By Age
40-49 50-59 60+ 30-39 3 3.5 4 5.5 4.5 5 6 Percent of Participants
Avg. Number of Funds 4.5 5.6 5.5 5.2 4.6 22. Managed Accounts
Source: PSCAs 49 thAnnual Survey of Profit Sharing Plans Savings
Rate Doubles for Those Who Use Advice and Managed Accounts,
Managing 401(k) Plans, May 2005 NOTE: Results are based on an
internal analysis by Charles Schwab.Schwab does not charge
participants or the plan sponsor a fee for the advice
service.Percentage of Plans Offering a Professionally Managed
Alternative
- More likely to sign up for advice (54%) when the service is
presented in face-to-face educational sessions
- 401(k) savings rate rose from 4.57% to 9.57% (2004)
23. Summary
-
- 1 in 4 do not participate for various reasons
-
- Automatic enrollment increases participation and gets
participants in the plan sooner
-
- Low savings rates are an epidemic
-
- Automatic escalation is effective in increasing savings
rates
-
- Most are overwhelmed and need help