8/10/2019 Verdict of Abdul Quader Molla, A Travesty of Justice in Bangladesh _ Radiance Viewsweekly

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/verdict-of-abdul-quader-molla-a-travesty-of-justice-in-bangladesh-radiance 1/9

02/11/2014 Verdict of Abdul Quader Mol la, A Travesty of Justi ce in Bangladesh | Radiance Viewsweekly

http://radianceweekly.in/portal/issue/radiance-is-50-now-scholars-recognise-its-contributions/article/verdict-of-abdul-quader-molla-a-travesty-of-justice-in-bangladesh/ 1/9

COVER-STORY EDITORIAL GUIDANCE-I GUIDANCE-II INSIDE INDIA MUSLIM WORLD BOOK REVIEW HEALTHCARE AUTHORS

 

Search Radiance Viewsweekly  ABOUT US SUBSCRIBE NOW GIFT A SUBSCRIPTION ADVERTISEMENT TARRIF CONTACT

01-11-2014 | 11:42pm IST

 

Abdul Quader Molla

You are here: Home / Vol. LI No.27 / Verdict of Abdul Quader Molla, A Travesty of Justice in Bangladesh

Verdict of Abdul Quader Molla, A Travesty of Justice inBangladesh

6 Oct 2013 0 comments

By MOHAMMAD HOSSAIN

It was an unheard of feat in the history of judiciary in Bangladesh that a prisoner was

sentenced to death in an appeal to the highest court and then stripped of his right to appeal

the very same sentence. Defying logic and all manner of common sense, the Supreme Court

on 18 September sentenced Abdul Quader Molla, a senior member of the biggest Islamic party

in the country, the Bangladesh Jamaat-e-Islami, to death for allegedly committing crimes

against humanity during the nation’s 1971 independence war against Pakistan.

It is worth mentioning here that the veteran politician was earlier sentenced to life

imprisonment for crimes against humanity by the Bangladeshi International Crimes Tribunal

(ICT) on 5 February 2013. Following due course of law, both the defence and prosecution

challenged the sentence to the Supreme Court. The appellate division dismissed the appeal

made by Molla’s lawyers against his conviction on five counts of crimes against humanity while

positively focusing the prosecution appeal for a death penalty. The appellate division, in an

unusual move, ramped up his punishment and changed it from life imprisonment to a death

penalty.

The reactions to the appeal verdict have been mixed, but they showcase a widening rift in the

country between supporters of the incumbent Awami League government led by Prime

Minister Sheikh Hasina and those of the opposition led by ex-Prime Minister Khaleda Zia. This

Share |

B'DESH SCENARIO

8/10/2019 Verdict of Abdul Quader Molla, A Travesty of Justice in Bangladesh _ Radiance Viewsweekly

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/verdict-of-abdul-quader-molla-a-travesty-of-justice-in-bangladesh-radiance 2/9

02/11/2014 Verdict of Abdul Quader Mol la, A Travesty of Justi ce in Bangladesh | Radiance Viewsweekly

http://radianceweekly.in/portal/issue/radiance-is-50-now-scholars-recognise-its-contributions/article/verdict-of-abdul-quader-molla-a-travesty-of-justice-in-bangladesh/ 2/9

comes at a time when both camps gear up for facing each other over the issue of national

elections which the present government says will be held by the beginning of next year.

It is worth mentioning that the issue of elections has been a subject of controversy since the present government abolished the caretaker system

through a comfortable majority in the Parliament back in June 2011. Since then, the opposition has regularly taken to the streets in a bid to put

forward their demands for the reinstatement of the caretaker system, arguing against the neutrality of any polls that may be held under a

partisan government. Many in the opposition see the war crimes trials as being a tool used to divert the public attention from the above issue.

Coupled with the glaring flaws on the trial of Abdul Quader Molla and the other accused at the ICT trials, and the fact that the almost all

defendants are members of the opposition parties Jamaat and BNP, the conviction that the trials are politically motivated is only bound to getstronger.

 

BACKDROP OF CONTROVERSIES

Controversy at the International Crimes Tribunal, a domestic court set up to try the war criminals of 1971 started as early back in mid-December

last year, when the disgraced Chairman of the tribunal resigned in lieu of his connection with the “Skypegate” scandal that was exposed by the

Economist  in detail in “The trial of a Birth of a Nation”. The defence was prevented from calling more than 6 witnesses and the case was promptly

rushed towards judgment in February this year.

The verdict of life imprisonment for Abdul Quader Molla resulted in an uproar of public sentiment, a result of a barrage of the emotional hypethat had been fuelled by the government and media since the incumbent government had come to power. Emotion prevailed over reason, as

thousands came out onto the streets of Dhaka, particularly at Shahbag, enraged at what they perceived to be a compromise on rightful justice,

oblivious to the merit or lack thereof of a trial that was more than 40 years behind schedule.

The law as it stood at the time of conviction did not permit any prosecution appeal for a higher sentence. In an unprecedented move, the ruling

party made the move to amend the associated law to allow the prosecution to appeal. The amendment was passed following Prime Minister

Sheikh Hasina’s remarkable statement in parliament, as a result of mass demonstrations on the streets of Dhaka that the tribunal judges should

listen to ‘the sentiment of the people.’

 

THE FINAL JUDGEMENT

As experts noted, the appellate division focused on building on previous convictions, as the court upheld unanimously that his acquittal on

charge no. 4 should be reversed and should stand as a conviction, and most significantly that, by a majority, the sentence on charge no. 6 (the

murder of a family), should be changed from life imprisonment to a death penalty.

The case as it stood before the appellate division was an extremely weak one. Three of the five charges against Mr. Molla relied totally on

hearsay evidence. The charge for which Mr. Molla was sentenced by the appellate division to hang was based on the testimony of a single

witness, who was a 13-year-old at the time, and against whose testimony there was no corroborating evidence whatsoever. At the end of the day,

it stood out that those who had labelled Abdul Quader Molla the ‘Butcher of Mirpur’ all these years simply had a lone hearsay account to prove it.

 

8/10/2019 Verdict of Abdul Quader Molla, A Travesty of Justice in Bangladesh _ Radiance Viewsweekly

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/verdict-of-abdul-quader-molla-a-travesty-of-justice-in-bangladesh-radiance 3/9

02/11/2014 Verdict of Abdul Quader Mol la, A Travesty of Justi ce in Bangladesh | Radiance Viewsweekly

http://radianceweekly.in/portal/issue/radiance-is-50-now-scholars-recognise-its-contributions/article/verdict-of-abdul-quader-molla-a-travesty-of-justice-in-bangladesh/ 3/9

FINAL NAIL IN COFFIN OF JUSTICE

Abbas Faiz, Amnesty International’s Bangladesh Researcher was expressing his concern when he said, “This is the first known case of a prisoner

sentenced to death directly by the highest court in Bangladesh. It is also the first known death sentence in Bangladesh with no right of appeal.”

The concerns of Amnesty are genuine. The imposition of the death sentence without the possibility of appeal is incompatible with Bangladesh’s

obligations under international human rights law. Not only does such a sentence defy human rights laws, but it also needs to be taken into

cognizance that one human rights violation does not cancel out another.

The grounds for conviction of such nature were weak from the very moment clear evidence emerged of the government meddling in the mattersof the tribunal back in 2012. In retrospect, few can turn back and say they witnessed a fair trial. Few can say that they witnessed something more

than a show of political vendetta.

[Mohammad Hossain is a Bangladesh based blogger and commentator on social and political affairs of Bangladesh.] 

Leave A Reply

Name

E-mail

comment

Submit

Also See

TOWARDS REALISING SIR

SYED’S DREAM

CRICKET HOW CROOKED? ILM AND AALIM ISLAMIC FINANCE A

SUCCESS STORY FROM

MEW...

You Are Reading

Vol. LI No.27, 06 Oct 2013

8/10/2019 Verdict of Abdul Quader Molla, A Travesty of Justice in Bangladesh _ Radiance Viewsweekly

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/verdict-of-abdul-quader-molla-a-travesty-of-justice-in-bangladesh-radiance 4/9

02/11/2014 Verdict of Abdul Quader Molla, A Travesty of Justice in Bangladesh | Radiance Viewsweekly

http://radianceweekly.in/portal/issue/radiance-is-50-now-scholars-recognise-its-contributions/article/verdict-of-abdul-quader-molla-a-travesty-of-justice-in-bangladesh/ 4/9

More in the issue

Go To Current Issue

Radiance is 50 Now,

Scholars Recognise

Its Contributions

0

 

0

8/10/2019 Verdict of Abdul Quader Molla, A Travesty of Justice in Bangladesh _ Radiance Viewsweekly

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/verdict-of-abdul-quader-molla-a-travesty-of-justice-in-bangladesh-radiance 5/9

02/11/2014 Verdict of Abdul Quader Molla, A Travesty of Justice in Bangladesh | Radiance Viewsweekly

http://radianceweekly.in/portal/issue/radiance-is-50-now-scholars-recognise-its-contributions/article/verdict-of-abdul-quader-molla-a-travesty-of-justice-in-bangladesh/ 5/9

What Ails National

Integration

Council?

Spectrum of 

Humanity

0

PLAYING THE REPO

CARD Growth or

Inflation control

0

M for Muzaffarnagar 1

The Ashes 2013 0

Shun Doubtful Things 0

The Ultimate Success 0

ASEEMANAD, OTHERS FOUND

GUILTY UNDER DIFFERENT

SECTIONS OF IPC

0

 JIH FLAYS SHIELDING OF TAINTED 0

8/10/2019 Verdict of Abdul Quader Molla, A Travesty of Justice in Bangladesh _ Radiance Viewsweekly

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/verdict-of-abdul-quader-molla-a-travesty-of-justice-in-bangladesh-radiance 6/9

02/11/2014 Verdict of Abdul Quader Molla, A Travesty of Justice in Bangladesh | Radiance Viewsweekly

http://radianceweekly.in/portal/issue/radiance-is-50-now-scholars-recognise- its-contributions/article/verdict-of-abdul-quader-molla-a-travesty-of-justice-in-bangladesh/ 6/9

POLITICIANS, HAILS SC RULING

ANCESTORS SLAUGHTERED COW ON

EVERY FESTIVE OCCASION:

ANANTHAMURTHY

0

‘HIBA AN ACCURATE WAY TO

TRANSFER PROPERTIES’

0

WHY NOT DELIMITATION

COMMITTEE: ASK MUSLIM LEADERS

0

WILL EXTEND SUPPORT TO GROUPS

WORKING FOR MINORITY STATUS;

AMU-VC

0

HM WRITES TO CMS OVER ILLEGAL

ARRESTS

0

MAHARASHTRA TO SHAME

UNCARING CHILDREN

0

SUDANESE PREZ DENIED US VISA;

KHARTOUM SUMMONED US

CHARGE D’AFFAIRES

0

SHOE THROWN AS ROUHANI

RETURNS AFTER OBAMA CALL

0

EGYPT’S CENTRAL BANK CONFIRMS

ECONOMIC ACHIEVEMENTS UNDER

MORSI

0

EU CALLS ON EGYPT TO CLARIFY

COURT ORDER BANNING IKHWAN

0

GERMANY CALLS ON EGYPT TO

REINTEGRATE BROTHERHOOD

0

RELIGIOUS PARTY BAN SHOWS 0

8/10/2019 Verdict of Abdul Quader Molla, A Travesty of Justice in Bangladesh _ Radiance Viewsweekly

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/verdict-of-abdul-quader-molla-a-travesty-of-justice-in-bangladesh-radiance 7/9

02/11/2014 Verdict of Abdul Quader Mol la, A Travesty of Justi ce in Bangladesh | Radiance Viewsweekly

http://radianceweekly.in/portal/issue/radiance-is-50-now-scholars-recognise- its-contributions/article/verdict-of-abdul-quader-molla-a-travesty-of-justice-in-bangladesh/ 7/9

PANEL’S ‘SECULARIST FACE’

SALAFIST LEADERS BLAST CALLS

FOR NEW EGYPT CONSTITUTION

0

ETHICA LAUNCHES ISLAMIC

FINANCE CERTIFICATION IN OMAN

0

Iqbal’s Message to

Muslim Youth

0

Shinde’s letter reflective of 

Congress’ dirty tricks

0

Involve great minds for Muslimcause

0

Unforgettable lesson for Islamic

movements

0

Blessings 0

 JIH to Adopt 1000

Mazaffarnagar Riot-

hit Families

0

Let’s Say No to

Dowry

0

8/10/2019 Verdict of Abdul Quader Molla, A Travesty of Justice in Bangladesh _ Radiance Viewsweekly

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/verdict-of-abdul-quader-molla-a-travesty-of-justice-in-bangladesh-radiance 8/9

02/11/2014 Verdict of Abdul Quader Mol la, A Travesty of Justi ce in Bangladesh | Radiance Viewsweekly

http://radianceweekly.in/portal/issue/radiance-is-50-now-scholars-recognise-its-contributions/article/verdict-of-abdul-quader-molla-a-travesty-of-justice-in-bangladesh/ 8/9

Most Popular Latest Comments

COVER STORY EDITORIAL GUIDANCE-I GUIDANCE-II INSIDE INDIA MUSLIM WORLD

Regional

Implications of US-

Iranian

Rapprochement

0

New York Times

Fiction On Obama’sLetter to Rouhani

0

Personal Laws are Identity of 

Muslims: SQR Ilyas

3

Anti-Communal Forum Need of the

Hour

2

Rogue Elements Dangerous for

Unity and Prosperity: Advocate

Paracha

1

Expanding Shadows of Hate1

Don’t Let Leaders Spoil Independent

Identity of SC: Fali Nariman

1

8/10/2019 Verdict of Abdul Quader Molla, A Travesty of Justice in Bangladesh _ Radiance Viewsweekly

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/verdict-of-abdul-quader-molla-a-travesty-of-justice-in-bangladesh-radiance 9/9

02/11/2014 Verdict of Abdul Quader Mol la, A Travesty of Justi ce in Bangladesh | Radiance Viewsweekly

http://radianceweekly.in/portal/issue/radiance-is-50-now-scholars-recognise-its-contributions/article/verdict-of-abdul-quader-molla-a-travesty-of-justice-in-bangladesh/ 9/9

© 2014 Radiance Viewsweekly Powered by: imagine360