VBI 2007 Top Lab Theory File.doc

8/10/2019 VBI 2007 Top Lab Theory File.doc

1/68

VBI@LMU 2007Top Lab Theory File

THEORY I NDEX

TO I!"LITY 2# RITI# OF TO I!"LITY $

%L"N&U"&E ' # RITI# OF TO I!"LITY (")T # RITI# OF TO I!"LITY *

! ONDITION"LITY B"D ++")T ! ONDITION"LITY &OOD +,")T ! ONDITION"LITY B"D +$! ONDITION"LITY &OOD +(")T "R"METRI!- &OOD +*

"R"METRI!- B"D 2+"R"METRI!- &OOD 2,

# RITI#- B"D 27# RITI#- .ITHOUT " LTERN"TIVE- B"D 2(

")T # RITI#- B"D 2*# RITI#- &OOD ,+")T # RITI#- &OOD ,/

# RITI# ERM ,$M I!RO OLITI!- B"D ,7

N"RR"TIVE- B"D /0")T N "RR"TIVE- B"D /+

IRONY B"D //F"IRNE-- I- " VOTER /

F"IRNE-- I- NOT " VOTER /7F"IRNE-- TRUM - EDU!"TION /*TEXT TRUM - EDU!"TION )F"IRNE-- $0I N1R OUND " BU-E I- NE!E--"RY $+

OTENTI"L " BU-E I- " VOTER $2EDU!"TION I- " VOTER $,")T %R E E!T THE " R&UMENT 3 NOT THE DEB"TER ' $/

! ONTR"DI!TION- B"D $$MULTI LE ! ONDITION"L ! OUNTER L"N- B"D $7

MULTI LE A P RIORIS B"D $*


2/68


3/68


Topicality

I45erpre5a5io46ro i8e 9o:45er 8e;i4i5io4 a48 i5


4/68


i45o a99o:45 5he 9o45eC5 o; 5he re=ol:5io4 a= Aell a= 5he 4:a49e= o; 5he 5er


5/68


15hi=


6/68


Kritik of Topicality

+? Topi9ali5y i= a 4o41;al=i;iable 9lai< i4=o;ar a= i5>= i


7/68


9o44e95io4 Ai5h =o


8/68


are 5Ao i


9/68


Language Kritik of Topicality

KDo 4o5 r:4 5hi= i4 9o4 :495io4 Ai5h a4y o; 5he o5her iola5io4=?

The 4o5io4 o; 5opi9ali5y i= i4here45ly ;laAe83 be9a:=e 5he i8ea 5ha5 5here i= o4e Aor8 or


10/68


A/T Kritik of Topicality

Ma e =:re 5o pro i8e 9o45eC5:al re=po4=e= i4 a88i5io4 5o 5he=e li5


11/68


8oe=4Q5 re :ire a bri5eli4e? I4=o;ar a= a a=5


12/68


Conditionality Bad

K5hi= i= i; 5hey are4>5 a99ep5i4 5he har


13/68


a;;ir


14/68


A/T Conditionality Good

"T6 Dep5h i=


15/68


"T6 I


16/68


A/T Conditionality Bad

"T6 re8i95able 8i i=io4 o; ro:48

+? No Li4 6 5hi= ar :


17/68


be5Aee4 5 i


18/68


8? Re9ipro9al b:r8e4=? The 4e a5i e 9a4 8i=pro e 5he a;;ir


19/68


Conditionality Good

I? 8e;i4i5io4II? iola5io4III? =5a48ar8=

a? !o48i5io4ali5y alloA= := 5o 8i=9:== a4 i==:e


20/68


A/T Parametrics Good

"T6 ara5


21/68


be9a:=e i5= i


22/68


Parametrics Bad

I? I45erpre5a5io46a? The re=ol:5io4 i= a 9a5e ori9al 5r:5h =5a5e


23/68


ii? Di=9:==io4 o; hoA para


24/68


Parametrics Good

I? 8e;i4i5io4II? iola5io4III? =5a48ar8=

a? I45er4a5io4ally !o4=i=5e45 &ro:486 ara


25/68


=:9h a= ;ra


26/68


"T6 "88i4 Aor8= 5o re=ol:5io43 =o har


27/68


pre8o


28/68


Kritiks Bad

+? I45erpre5a5io46 5he 8eba5e =ho:l8 be pre8i9a5e8 o4 a 9la=h o; i8ea=?2? Viola5io46 The ri5i 8e=5roy= 9la=h i4 5he 8eba5e ro:48

+? Ti


29/68


Kritiks wit out Alternati!es Bad

+? I45erpre5a5io46 5he 8eba5e =ho:l8 be pre8i9a5e8 o4 a 9la=h o; i8ea=?2? Viola5io46 The ri5i 8oe=4>5 o;;er a4 al5er4a5i e3 =o 5here i= 4o 4e Aorl8

+? Ti


30/68


A/T Kritiks Bad

+? Ti< 4o5 = eAi4 5i


31/68


/? Re=ear9h b:r8e4=+J E erybo8y ha= 5he =a5 = 4o rea=o4 Ahy re=ear9h i= 4e9e==ary 5o e4 a e 5he ar :


32/68


Kritiks Good

+? #ri5i = ;or9e := 5o 8eal Ai5h 5he a95:al i


33/68


4+ HoAe er3 i


34/68


9a4 4o5 be pro e8 5r:e? re8i95abili5y i= ey 5o ;air4e== be9a:=e i; ar :5 pre8i95able i5 =e erely h:r5=


35/68


A/T Kritiks Good

+? ")T #ri5i = pro i8e := Ai5h a 4eA 9ri5i9al 5ype o; ar :


36/68


Kritik Perm

By


37/68


"icropolitics Bad

+? Deba5e i= 5he Aro4


38/68


i4 200/ Ari5e=6


39/68


7? -i49e 9o45eC5 8oe=4>5


40/68


#arrati!es Bad

+?1arratives fail to make e*plicit claims. "5


41/68


li#its to .hat interpretations can say% criti,"e beco#es $ac"o"s and resistance beco#esdirectionless*

*? -5ory5elli4 ill= p:bli9 8i=9o:r=e?Da4iel Farber a48 -: a44a -herry3 ro;e==or= o; LaA3 +**73 Beyo48 "ll Rea=o43 ++

-e9o483 ra8i9al


42/68


i; 5hi= Aere4>5 5r:e3 5he ;a95 5ha5 5he 4e a5i e 8i84>5 r:4 a 4arra5i e i4 ro:48 i4 5he =a


43/68


eli5 a8 o9a5e 9o4;la5i4 5he =i5:a5io4 o; 5he a:5hor Ai5h 5he a:5hor 5he< r:44i4 5hi= 4arra5i e i4 a 8eba5e ro:48 i


44/68


$rony Bad

1* Iro4y a= a4 e;;e95i e poli5i9al 5ool Ao:l8 re :ire 5he :8 e 5o =hare 5he 8eba5er>= pre8i=po=i5io4= abo:5 5he 4a5:re o; 9er5ai4 i8eolo ie=? Thi= i= 5r:e be9a:=e ar :5 a95:ally =:b er=i e?* -5a5i4 5ha5 o4e>= po=i5io4 i= iro4i9 eli


45/68


2? .ro4 ;or:


46/68


%airness is a &oter

+? Fair4e== :ara45ee= 5ha5 e ery 8eba5er 9o


47/68


%airness is not a &oter

+J Fair4e== a= a =5a48ar8 8e5ra95= ;ro< 5r:5h1=ee i4 a= 5heory a= = := 5o re e95 9er5ai4ar :


48/68


e8:9a5io4 i= a99ep5able i4 a ro:48 5here i= 4o Aay ;or 5he :8 e 5o arbi5rarily o5e o4 =o


49/68


%airness Trumps 'ducation

+J Fair4e== i= 4e9e==ary ;or e8:9a5io4 i4=o;ar a= ea9h =i8e


50/68


Te(t Trumps 'ducation/%airness

+J The o4ly =5a5i9 r:le i4 8eba5e i= 5ha5 Ae


51/68


$n)*ound A+use is #ecessary

+? Vo5i4 o4 po5e45ial ab:=e p:4i=he=


52/68


Potential A+use is a &oter

F:5:re ro:48=

+? Vo5i4 8oA4 a 8eba5er ;or a po5e45ially ab:=i e po=i5io4 =e5= a pre9e8e45 o; a99ep5ablear :


53/68


'ducation is a &oter

+? The o4ly 5hi4 o; la=5i4 e48:ra49e ;ro< a ro:48 i= 5he e8:9a5io4 Ae re9ei e? Thi=


54/68


A/T *e,ect t e Argument- not t e .e+ater

+? Deba5er= are 5ie8 5o 5heir a8 o9a9ie= be9a:=e i5 i= :4;air ;or 5he< 5o i9 5heir ar :


55/68


Contradictions Bad

INTER RET"TION6!o45ra8i95ory ar :


56/68


9o45ra8i95io4?

$? By re=po48i4 5o ar :


57/68


"ultiple Conditional Counterplans Bad

INTER RET"TION6The 4e a5i e =ho:l8 4o5 be alloAe8 5o r:4


58/68


all o; 5he< be9a:=e aJ i5 i= 5he e45ire5y o; 5he 9o:45erpla4= a= a Ahole 5ha5 pro e= :4;aira48 bJ re e95i4 o4ly o4e ar :5 ;i h5 5he ab:=e be9a:=e 5he 8eba5er 9a4 =5ill o;or o5her=?


59/68


"ultiple A Prioris Bad

INTER RET"TION6M:l5iple a priori ar :


60/68


peed Good +ecause of 'ducation

INTER RET"TION6-pee8 i= oo8 ;or 8eba5e be9a:=e i5 i= e8:9a5io4al?

VIOL"TION6I a< oi4 ;a=5?

-T"ND"RD-6

+? The abili5y 5o 5al ;a=5 e


61/68


'tine 3 Eli abe5h L?3)ingfield 3 "r5h:r3 : 4oon 3 Leo4ar8? +*;< J? HoA


62/68


per;or


63/68


yo: pre;er


64/68


peed Good +ecause of %airness

INTER RET"TION6-pee8 i= oo8 ;or 8eba5e be9a:=e i5


65/68


peed Bad

"? I45erpre5a5io46 -pee8 i= ba8?B? Oppo4e45 i= :=i4 eC9e==i e =pee8!? Vo5i4 I==:e i= ;air4e==D? -5a48ar8=6

i? The =5a48ar8 i= a99e==ibili5y? U=i4 eC9e==i e =pee8 i= :4;air be9a:=e 4o5all 8eba5er= 9a4 :48er=5a48 eC9e==i e =pee8 a48 =o are p:5 a5 a4 i


66/68


i? The =5a48ar8 i= a99e==ibili5y? -pee8 i= 4o5 e8:9a5io4al be9a:=e i; I 9a4>5:48er=5a48 yo:r ar :5 re=po48 5o 5he< a48 4ei5her o; := 9a4lear4 ;ro< 5he 8eba5e be9a:=e 5here i= 4o 9la=h?

ii? The =5a48ar8 i= 8ep5h3 brea85h3 e59? -pee8 i= 4o5 e8:9a5io4al be9a:=e i5e49o:ra e= a ;o9:= o4 =pee8 a= a = ill i4=5ea8 o; =:b=5a45i ear :


67/68


A/T peed Bad

"? "T -pee8 i= Ba8B? Vo5i4 I==:e=

a? Fair4e==i? Tha5 i=4>5 a ;air4e== iola5io4 be9a:=e 8eba5e 4e9e==arily i= a


68/68


yo: a95:ally ha e 5o pro e 5ha5 I>< ab:=i4 yo" 4o5 5ha5 I>< ab:=i4 yo:i; yo: happe4e8 5o be =o

Documents

VBI 2007 Top Lab Theory File.doc