valdebulebiTi samarTali (zogadi nawili) · valdebulebiTi samarTali (zogadi nawili) krebulSi gamoqveynebulia erTgvarovani sasamarTlo praqti-kis Camoyalibebisa da samarTlis ganviTarebisaTvis

1

valdebulebiTi samarTalivaldebulebiTi samarTalivaldebulebiTi samarTalivaldebulebiTi samarTalivaldebulebiTi samarTali

(zogadi nawili)(zogadi nawili)(zogadi nawili)(zogadi nawili)(zogadi nawili)

krebulSi gamoqveynebulia erTgvarovani sasamarTlo praqti-kis Camoyalibebisa da samarTlis ganviTarebisaTvis mniSvne-lovani gadawyvetilebebi. am da sxva saqmeTa moZebna SesaZle-belia saqarTvelos uzenaesi sasamarTlos veb-gverdze:http://www.supremecourt.ge/default.aspx?sec_id=133&lang=1

2

saqarTvelos uzenaesi sasamarTlos gadawyvetilebanisamoqalaqo saqmeebze2018, #9

Decisions of the Supreme Court of Georgiaon Civil Cases(in Georgian)2018, #9

Entscheidungen des Obersten Gerichts von Georgienin Zivilsachen(in der georgischen Sprache)2018, #9

Htitybz Dth[jdyjuj Celf Uhepbbgj uhf;lfycrbv ltkfv

(yf uhepbycrjv zpsrt)2018, #9

gadawyvetilebebis SerCevasada damuSavebaze pasuxismgebeli giorgi WyoiZe

teqnikuri redaqtori marika maRalaSvili

redaqciis misamarTi: 0110, Tbilisi, Zmebi zubalaSvilebisq. #32, tel: 299 04 18; www.supremecourt.ge

Jurnali gamodis saqarTvelos uzenaesi sasamarTlosa dasaqarTvelos iusticiis umaRlesi sabWos saerTosasamarTloebis departamentis mxardaWeriT

3

1. xelSekrulebis dadeba

winare xelSekruleba

gadawyvetilebasaqarTvelos saxeliT

#as-202-191-2017 27 seqtemberi, 2017 w., q. Tbilisi

saqarTvelos uzenaesi sasamarTlos samoqalaqosaqmeTa palataSemadgenloba: m. Todua (Tavmjdomare),

e. gasitaSvili (momxsenebeli),p. qaTamaZe

davis sagani: zianis anazRaureba, xelSekrulebebis ba-Tilad cnoba (sarCeli); Tanxis dakisreba (Segebebuli sar-Celi)

aRwerilobiTi nawili:1. r. b-sa (SemdegSi: pirveli gamyidveli) da b. p-s (Sem-

degSi: pirveli myidveli an pirveli mopasuxe, SegebebulimosarCele) Soris 2011 wlis 1 dekembers gaformda samar-Tlebrivi urTierTobis sasamarTlosgareSe mowesrigebisxelSekruleba, romlis safuZvelze pirvel mopasuxes gam-yidveli sakuTrebis uflebiT gadascemda uZrav qonebas,mdebares q. TbilisSi, W-is q. #6, me-9 sarTuli, bina #22,farTi 100 kv.m. (s/k 0..), statusi _ mSenebare.

2. uZravi nivTis Rirebuleba ganisazRvra 50 000 aSS do-lariT, romelic amave xelSekrulebis Tanaxmad, myidvels(anu pirvel mopasuxes) unda gadaeca g. m-isaTvis (SemdegSi:Tavdapirveli an ZiriTadi mosarCele).

3. amave xelSekrulebis me-7 muxlis me-8 punqtis Ta-naxmad, pirveli gamyidveli valdebulia winamdebare ga-dawyvetilebis me-2 punqtSi dasaxelebul pirs mianiWoswarmomadgenlobiTi uflebamosileba, romlis safuZ-velzec igi, marwmuneblis saxeliT, xels moawers am mux-liT dadgenil aqtebs da nebismier aqtebs sxva samar-Tlebriv urTierTobebSi.

4. 2011 wlis 3 dekembers v. J-asa (SemdegSi: meore gam-yidveli) da pirvel myidvels (pirvel mopasuxes) Sorisgaformda samarTlebrivi urTierTobis sasamarTlosgare-

4

Se mowesrigebis xelSekruleba, romlis safuZvelze, amukanasknels meore gamyidveli sakuTrebis uflebiT ga-dascemda ramdenime uZrav qonebas mdebares, q. TbilisSi,W-is q. #6, kerZod:

4.1. sarTuli 1, bina 2, farTi 300 kv.m. da avtosadgomi#1 farTi 18 kv.m. (s/k 0...) statusi _ mSenebare;

4.2. sarTuli 5, bina #16, farTi 125 kv.m. (s/k 0...) statu-si _ mSenebare;

4.3. sarTuli 6, bina 18, farTi 300 kv.m. avtosadgomi #14,farTi 18 kv.m. da avtosadgomi #15, farTi 18 kv.m. (s/k 0...)statusi _ mSenebare;

4.4. sarTuli 8, bina 21, farTi 250 kv.m. da avtosadgomi#18 farTi 18 kv.m. (s/k 0...) statusi _ mSenebare;

4.5. avtosadgomi #12, farTi #18 kv.m (s/k 0...)4.6. avtosadgomi #13, farTi #18 kv.m (s/k 0...)4.7. sarTuli 5, bina #16, farTi 125 kv.m. (s/k 0...) statu-

si _ mSenebare;5. 2011 wlis 23 dekembers am gadawyvetilebis me-2 pun-

qtSi miTiTebul pirveli gamyidvelis warmomadgenelsa(anu Tavdapirvel mosarCeles), rogorc myidvels, da pir-vel myidvels (pirvel mopasuxes), rogorc gamyidvels So-ris gaformda `Sesyidvis ofciis winare xelSekruleba~,romlis me-2 muxlis pirveli punqti gansazRvravs: gam-yidveli (am SemTxvevaSi pirveli mopasuxe) da myidveli(am SemTxvevaSi Tavdapirveli mosarCele) SeTanxmdnen,rom mxareebi dadeben Sesyidvis ofciis ZiriTad xel-Sekrulebas, romlis safuZvelze myidvels (TavdapirvelmosarCeles) ufleba eqneba iyidos q. TbilisSi, T. W-is q.#6-Si, mSenebare farTis merve da mecxre sarTulebzemdebare farTebi, winamdebare xelSekrulebis me-4 mux-lSi miTiTebuli odenobiTa da wesiT:

5.1. 2011 wlis 23 dekembris xelSekrulebis gaformebismomentisaTvis:

1) q. Tbilisi, W-is q. #6, me-9 sarTuli, bina #22, (s/k 0...),statusi _ mSenebare, farTi Seadgens 100 kv.m. da regis-trirebulia pirveli gamyidvelis (ix. am gadawyvetilebispirveli punqti) sakuTrebis uflebiT; 2) imave misamarTze,sarTuli 8, bina 21, (s/k 0...) statusi _ mSenebare, romlisfarTi Seadgens 250 kv.m., saidanac xelSekrulebis saganswarmoadgens 125 kv.m. sakuTrebis uflebiT registrire-bulia meore gamyidvelis (ix. am gadawyvetilebis me-4 pun-

5

qti) saxelze;5.2. 2011 wlis 23 dekembris xelSekrulebis me-3 muxlis

me-4 punqtis Tanaxmad, am muxlis wina punqtebidan gamom-dinare, Sesyidvis ofciis ZiriTadi xelSekruleba undadaidos nasyidobis sagnebis gamyidvelis (anu pirveli mo-pasuxis) sakuTrebaSi gadasvlisTanave;

5.3. amave xelSekrulebis me-4 muxlis pirveli punqtisTanaxmad, gamyidveli (pirveli mopasuxe) valdebulia, uz-runvelyos Senoba-nagebobis proeqtis koreqtireba daamis Sesaxeb miiRos mSeneblobis nebarTva. amasTanave, ga-mosyidvis pirobebi damokidebulia imaze, moxdeba Tu aramecxre sarTulis proeqtis koreqtireba _ farTis dama-teba, Tu arsebuli farTis (100 kv.m.) SenarCuneba. oriveSemTxvevaSi, gamyidveli (pirveli mopasuxe) valdebuliafarTebi _ nasyidobis orive sagani miiyvanos Savi karkasismdgomareobamde. Sesabamisad, gamyidveli (romelic am Sem-TxvevaSi pirveli mopasuxea) valdebulia, myidvels (Tav-dapirvel mosarCeles) mSeneblobis nebarTvisa da mecxresarTulis proeqtis koreqtirebis, an ucvlelad datove-bis Sesaxeb informacia werilobiT miawodos mSeneblobisnebarTvis miRebidan 7 kalendarul dReSi;

5.4. xelSekrulebis me-4 muxlis pirveli punqtis à~ qve-punqtis Tanaxmad, im SemTxvevaSi, Tu mecxre sarTulisproeqti darCeba ucvleli _ im saxiT, ra saxiTac arsebobswinamdebare xelSekrulebis dadebis momentisaTvis (Se-noba-nagebobis koreqtirebamde), myidveli (Tavdapirve-li mosarCele) valdebulia gamoisyidos nasyidobis ori-ve sagani (orive farTi, mdebare W-is quCis mxares) _ me-8sarTulis farTi, garda 125 kv.m-isa, da me-9 sarTuli sru-lad, kerZod, bina #22, farTi 100 kv.m. gamosyidvis fasiSeadgens 110 000 aSS dolars, xolo gamosyidvis vada Se-adgens farTis `Savi karkasis~ mdgomareobamde miyvanis Se-saxeb myidvelisaTvis werilobiTi Setyobinebis gadace-midan 45 kalendarul dRes;

5.5. amave muxlis pirveli punqtis `b~ qvepunqtis Ta-naxmad, im SemTxvevaSi, Tu me-9 sarTulis proeqti Seic-vleba da daemateba farTi, myidveli valdebulia gamois-yidos nasyidobis orive sagani (orive farTi, mdebare W-isquCis mxares) _ me-8 sarTulis farTi, garda 132 kv.m-isa,da me-9 sarTulze arsebuli koreqtirebuli farTi, gar-da 113 kv.m-isa, gamosyidvis fasi Seadgens 110 000 aSS do-

6

lars, xolo gamosyidvis vada Seadgens farTis `Savi kar-kasis~ mdgomareobamde miyvanis Sesaxeb myidvelisaTviswerilobiTi Setyobinebis gadacemidan 45 kalendaruldRes;

5.6. xelSekrulebis me-3 muxlis me-5 punqtis Tanaxmad,gamyidvelis (anu pirveli mopasuxis) mier winamdebarexelSekrulebis me-2 muxlis pirveli punqtis à~ qvepun-qtSi miTiTebuli farTis myidvelisaTvis miyidvis val-debulebis Sesruleba damokidebulia am gadawyvetile-bis pirvel punqtSi dasaxelebuli pirveli gamyidvelismier amave gadawyvetilebis me-2 punqtSi dasaxelebuliwarmomadgenlisaTvis (romelic gansaxilvel davaSi Ziri-Tadi mosarCelea) mindobilobis uflebamosilebis sru-lad da jerovnad Sesrulebaze _ pirveli gamyidveliskuTvnili farTis yadaRisagan gaTavisuflebaze.

6. q. Tbilisi, W-is q. #6-Si uZravi qonebis RirebulebaSeadgens 1 kv.m-sTvis 1600 aSS dolaris Sesabamis ekviva-lents larSi.

7. saqarTvelos iusticiis saministros aRsrulebiserovnuli biuros #NA11063362-014/001 gankargulebis sa-fuZvelze, q. Tbilisi, W-is q. #6, me-9 sarTuli, bina #22(uZravi qonebis s/k 0...) amJamad registrirebulia am gadaw-yvetilebis me-2 punqtSi dasaxelebuli piris (ZiriTadimosarCelis anu pirveli gamyidvelis warmomadgenlis) sa-kuTrebis uflebiT.

8. 2013 wlis 23 maiss am gadawyvetilebis pirvel pun-qtSi miTiTebulma pirvelma mopasuxem ramdenime nas-yidobis xelSekruleba gaaforma sxvadasxva pirTan,kerZod:

8.1. g. g-s (SemdegSi: meore myidveli, meore mopasuxe)mihyida da am ukanasknelis sakuTrebis uflebiT aRiric-xa q. TbilisSi, W-is q. #6, pirvel sarTulze mdebare ko-merciuli farTi #2, 80 kv.m (uZravi qonebis s/k 0...).

8.2. zemoTxsnebul meore myidvels mihyida da am uka-nasknelis sakuTrebis uflebiT aRiricxa q. TbilisSi, W-isq. #6, mesame sarTulze bina #10, 104,20 kv.m (uZravi qone-bis s/k 0...);

8.3. meore myidvels mihyida da am ukanasknelis sakuT-rebis uflebiT aRiricxa q. TbilisSi, W-is q. #6, meeqvsesarTulze bina #18a, 141,20 kv.m (uZravi qonebis s/k 0...);

8.4. meore myidvels mihyida da am ukanasknelis sakuT-

7

rebis uflebiT aRiricxa q. TbilisSi, W-is q. #8, meeqvsesarTulze bina #20, 132,60 kv.m (uZravi qonebis s/k 0...);

8.5. m. k-es (SemdegSi: mesame myidveli, mesame mopasuxe)mihyida da am ukanasknelis sakuTrebis uflebiT aRiric-xa q. TbilisSi, W-is q. #6, meeqvse sarTulze bina #18 b,104,70 kv.m (uZravi qonebis s/k 0...);

8.6. i. m-es (SemdegSi: meoTxe myidveli, meoTxe mopasu-xe) mihyida da am ukanasknelis sakuTrebis uflebiT aRi-ricxa q. TbilisSi, W-is q. #6, mexuTe sarTulze bina #15,120,50 kv.m (uZravi qonebis s/k 0...).

9. sarCelis moTxovna da safuZvlebi9.1. winamdebare gadawyvetilebis me-2 punqtSi dasaxe-

lebulma pirma 2013 wlis 23 maiss sarCeli aRZra pirveli,meore, mesame da meoTxe mopasuxeebis winaaRmdeg da mo-iTxova (ix. sarCeli TandarTuli dokumentaciiT; aseve da-zustebuli sarCeli):

9.1.1. mosarCelis sasargeblod pirveli mopasuxisaTviszianis anazRaurebis mizniT 462 480 (oTxas samocdaoriaTas oTxas oTxmoci) aSS dolaris dakisreba saqarTvelossamoqalaqo kodeqsis (SemdegSi: ssk) 361-e, 412-e da 394-emuxlebis safuZvelze;

9.1.2. pirvel mopasuxesa da meore myidvels Soris amgadawyvetilebis 8.1-8.4 qvepunqtebSi miTiTebuli23.05.2013 w. nasyidobis xelSekrulebebis baTilad cnoba,romelTa safuZvelze myidvelis sakuTrebad aRiricxa #2komerciuli farTi; 104,20 kv.m uZravi qoneba; 141,20 kv.muZravi qoneba; 132,60 kv.m uZravi qoneba;

9.1.3. pirvel mopasuxesa da mesame myidvels (mesame mo-pasuxes) Soris am gadawyvetilebis 8.5 qvepunqtSi miTiTe-buli 23.05.2013 w. nasyidobis xelSekrulebis baTilad cno-ba, romlis safuZvelze myidvelis sakuTrebad aRiricxa104,70 kv.m uZravi qoneba;

9.1.4. pirvel mopasuxesa da meoTxe myidvels (meoTxemopasuxes) Soris am gadawyvetilebis 8.6 qvepunqtSi miTi-Tebuli 23.05.2013 w. nasyidobis xelSekrulebis baTiladcnoba, romlis safuZvelze myidvelis sakuTrebad aRiric-xa 120,50 kv.m uZravi qoneba.

9.2. sarCeli efuZneba Semdeg faqtobriv garemoebebs:9.2.1. winamdebare gadawyvetilebis me-2 punqtSi dasa-

xelebulma mosarCelem pirvel mopasuxesTan 2011 wlis 23dekembers sanotaro wesiT gaaforma winare xelSekrule-

8

ba, romelsac, Tavis mxriv, safuZvlad daedo ori xel-Sekruleba, kerZod: 1. pirvel mopasuxesa da am gadawyve-tilebis pirvel punqtSi miTiTebul pirvel gamyidvelsSoris 2011 wlis 1 dekembers dadebuli `samarTlebriviurTierTobis sasamarTlosgareSe mowesrigebis xel-Sekruleba~ da 2. pirvel mopasuxesa da am gadawyvetile-bis meoTxe punqtSi miTiTebul meore gamyidvels Soris2011 wlis 3 dekembers dadebuli `samarTlebrivi urTier-Tobis sasamarTlosgareSe mowesrigebis xelSekruleba~,romelTa safuZvelze mosarCelisaTvis pirvel mopasuxesunda gadaeformebina am ukanasknelis saxelze registri-rebuli farTebi, mdebare q. TbilisSi, T. W-is q. # 6-Si, ker-Zod, Senobis merve da mecxre sarTulebze ganTavsebuliuZravi qoneba 110 000 aSS dolaris Rirebulebis farTebi;

9.2.2. mosarCele uTiTebs 2011 wlis 23 dekembris xel-Sekrulebis me-4 muxlis pirvel punqtze (ix. am gadawyve-tilebis 5.3. qvepunqti) da ganmartavs, rom pirvelma mopa-suxem daarRvia da ganzrax gadaaforma sxva pirebze uZra-vi qoneba, kerZod, q. TbilisSi, W-is q. #6-Si mdebare me-8sarTulis 178 kv.m gaasxvisa m. o.-eze, xolo darCenili132,60 kv.m gaaforma sakuTar saxelze; aseve, me-9 sarTu-lis 192,20 kv.m gaaforma jer r. j-ze, Semdeg _ 2013 wlis 2maiss, es farTi gadaaforma z. j-ze. am faqtTan dakavSire-biT mosarCelem 2013 wlis 11 maiss werili miswera pirvelmopasuxes da mosTxova xelSekrulebiT gaTvaliswinebu-li valdebulebis Sesruleba da ganusazRvra damatebiTivada, romelic uSedegod gavida. imave wlis 23 maisis saja-ro reestris amonaweriT pirveli mopasuxis sakuTrebadiricxeboda rva erTeuli bina. mas Semdeg, rac pirveli mo-pasuxisaTvis cnobili gaxda, rom mis saxelze ricxuli uZ-ravi qonebis Sesaxeb mosarCelem Seityo, pirvelma mopa-suxem imave dResve gadaaforma masze aRricxuli binebisxva pirebze. amasTan, sakuTrebaSi arsebuli uZravi qone-ba gadamala materialuri pasuxismgeblobis Tavidan aci-lebis mizniT. sadavo farTis me-8 da me-9 sarTulebis 1kv.m-is sabazro Rirebuleba Seadgens 1 600 (aTas eqvsasi)aSS dolaris ekvivalent lars, rac dadgenilia saqarTve-los iusticiis saministros mier. aRniSnulidan gamomdi-nare mosarCelisaTvis miyenebuli ziani 462 480 aSS dola-ris ekvivalent lars Seadgens.

9.2.3. mosarCelem moiTxova am gadawyvetilebis 8.1-8.6

9

qvepunqtebSi miTiTebuli garigebebis baTilad cnoba ma-Ti moCvenebiTi xasiaTis gamo. mosarCele uTiTebs, rom aR-niSnuli sasarCelo moTxovnis dakmayofilebis SemTxve-vaSi, rogorc Tanamdevi Sedegi, gauqmdeba sadavo uZravqonebebze registracia da maTze aRdgeba pirveli mopa-suxis sakuTrebis ufleba sajaro reestrSi `sajaro rees-tris Sesaxeb~ saqarTvelos kanonis 26-e muxlis `b~ qve-punqtis Sesabamisad.

10. mopasuxeTa Sesagebeli10.1. pirvelma da meore mopasuxeebma werilobiT war-

dgenili SesagebliT sarCeli ar cnes da miuTiTes Semdegfaqtobriv garemoebebze:

10.1.1. am gadawyvetilebis pirvel punqtSi miTiTebulipirveli gamyidvelis sakuTrebaSi arsebuli uZravi nivTi2012 wlis TebervalSi valdebulebisgan gamoaTavisuflamosarCelem, magram es moxda pirveli mopasuxis mier ga-dacemuli TanxiT, rac warmoadgenda S. b-Tan dadebuligarigebis Rirebulebas. garda amisa, 2012 wlis 29 Teber-vals mosarCelem Tavis sakuTrebad aRricxa aRniSnuli uZ-ravi qoneba, ris Sesaxebac ar acnoba pirvel mopasuxes.amasTan, am gadawyvetilebis pirvel punqtSi miTiTebuligamyidvelis sakuTrebad ricxuli uZravi nivTi s/k: 0..., 2012wlis 24 Tebervlis gancxadebis safuZvelze, imave wlis29 Tebervals sajaro reestrSi mosarCelem aRricxa saku-Tar saxelze, anu pirvelma mopasuxem gadaixada Tanxa, xo-lo sakuTrebis ufleba uZrav nivTze miiRo mosarCelem,romelic pirveli mopasuxis fuliT SeZenili qonebis me-sakuTrec gaxda da masve darCa nasyidobis Tanxa, riTacusafuZvlod gamdidrda;

10.1.2. meore mopasuxesTan gaformebuli garigebebis ba-Tilad cnobis moTxovnis nawilSi (ix. am gadawyvetilebis8.1-8.4 qvepunqtebi), SesagebelSi aRniSnulia, rom pirve-li mopasuxe iyo investori, misi interesebi mxolod Se-sasrulebeli valdebulebiT ar Semoifargleboda. mas Ta-visTavad hqonda komerciuli interesi, daekmayofilebi-na binebiT adamianebi, romlebic amas wlebis ganmavlobaSielodnen. amdenad, pirvelma mopasuxem sadavo garigebe-biT mesame da meoTxe mopasuxeebisadmi (ix. am gadawyveti-lebis 8.5-8.6 qvepunqtebi) Seasrula nakisri valdebule-bebi, xolo pirvel mopasuxes, rogorc investors, meoremopasuxesTan dadebuli garigebebiT surda aenazRaure-

10

bina komerciuli interesi. ar arsebobs sadavo garigebaTabaTilad cnobis safuZveli, rasac unda mohyves sarCelisuaryofa;

10.2. mesame mopasuxem, wardgenili werilobiTi Sesageb-liT aseve ar cno mis winaaRmdeg aRZruli sarCeli da miu-TiTa:

10.2.1. 2011 wlis 3 dekembers samarTlebrivi urTier-Tobis sasamarTlosgareSe mowesrigebis xelSekruleba(ix. xelSekruleba) daido meore gamyidvelTan, am ukanas-knels ki warmoadgenda ZiriTadi mosarCele da xelSekru-lebis 5.1 punqtiT mxareebi SeTanxmdenen, rom meore gam-yidveli sakuTrebaSi gadascemda, xolo pirveli mopasu-xe sakuTrebaSi miiRebda 250.00 kv.m mSenebare farTs me-8sarTulze, bina 21 (s/k 0...- ix. xelSekrulebis 5.1.4 qvepun-qti), ris sanacvlodac es ukanaskneli kisrulobda val-debulebas meore gamyidvelis Svilis _ l. J-asTvis Seuz-Rudav sakuTrebaSi gadaeca Turquli masalebiT garemon-tebuli 80.00 kv.m amave korpusSi an remontis Tanxa _ 15000 aSS dolari, aseve, 130 000 aSS dolari gadaakisra kre-ditor g. k-isadmi Sesasrulebeli valdebuleba 47 000 aSSdolaris odenobiT.

10.2.2. xelSekrulebis me-6 muxliT pirvel mopasuxesgadaekisra valdebulebebi mesame mopasuxis (T. m-is mem-kvidris) mimarTac;

10.3. meoTxe mopasuxem wardgenili werilobiTi Sesageb-liT sarCeli ar cno da miuTiTa Semdeg faqtobriv gare-moebebze:

10.3.1. 2011 wlis 13 dekembers dadasturebuli samar-Tlebrivi urTierTobebis morigebiT dasrulebis Sesaxeb#111358848 sanotaro aqtiT mowesrigda dava rig pirebsSoris, romelTa Sorisac iyo mesame mopasuxec. morigebisaqtis me-15 punqtiT ganisazRvra mesame mopasuxis ufle-bebi, rom igi q. TbilisSi, W-is quCa #6-Si miiRebda binas#16, mexuTe sarTulze s/k #0..- da #12 avtosadgoms s/k#.....; mesame mopasuxes, zemoaRniSnuli farTebis garda,imave misamarTze unda mieRo 65 kv.m.

10.3.2. orive sadavo garigeba mesame da meoTxe mopasu-xeebTan dadebulia am ukanasknelTan, romelic 2013 wlis8 aprils notarius o.- z-is mier damowmebuli mindobilo-bis safuZvelze, mesame mopasuxis warmomadgenelia;

10.3.3. 2013 wlis 22 maiss meoTxe mopasuxem, rogorc me-

11

same mopasuxis dedam, marwmuneblis (anu Svilis _ mesamemopasuxis) saxeliT SeiZina uZravi nivTi s/k 0..., farTi104,70 kv.m. nacvlad 123 kv.m-isa, xolo 2011 wlis 28 dekem-bris xelSekrulebis safuZvelze _ nacvlad 65 kv.m-isa Se-iZina da Tavis saxelze aRricxa 120 kv.m uZravi qoneba. Se-sabamisad, Tavdapirveli mosarCelis mier sadavod qceu-li garigeba pirvelsa da meoTxe mopasuxeebs Soris arcmoCvenebiTia da arc TvalTmaqcuri. pirvelma mopasuxemSeasrula xelSekrulebiT nakisri valdebulebebi, sarCe-li usafuZvloa.

11. pirveli mopasuxis Segebebuli sarCeli11.1. pirvelma mopasuxem 2013 wlis 1 ivliss Segebebu-

li sarCeli aRZra Tavdapirveli mosarCelis winaaRmdegTanxis dabrunebis moTxovniT da miuTiTa (ix. SegebebulisarCeli):

11.1.1. am gadawyvetilebis 1-3 punqtebSi miTiTebulixelSekrulebis pirobebze, romelic pirvelma mopasuxem(Segebebuli sarCelis avtorma) pirvel gamyidvelTan da-do 2011 wlis 1 dekembers, romlis Tanaxmad pirveli mopa-suxe, rogorc myidveli sakuTrebaSi miiRebda uZrav qo-nebas 50 000 aSS dolarad. am xelSekrulebiT myidvels (Se-gebebuli sarCelis avtors) pirvelma gamyidvelma daava-la, rom nasyidobis Tanxa srulad gadaeca misi warmomad-genlisaTvis (Tavdapirveli mosarCelisaTvis _ ix. am ga-dawyvetilebis me-2 punqti);

11.1.2. 2011 wlis 3 dekembers analogiuri Sinaarsis xel-Sekruleba gaformda meore gamyidvelTanac (ix. am gadaw-yvetilebis me-4 punqti), romlis safuZvelze, mxareebi Se-Tanxmdnen, rom pirveli mopasuxe sakuTrebaSi miiRebdame-8 sarTulze mSenebare 250 kv.m farTs, binas #21, s/k 0...,ris sanacvlodac pirveli mopasuxe kisrulobda valde-bulebas, l. J-asaTvis (meore gamyidvelis SvilisaTvis) Se-uzRudav sakuTrebaSi gadaeca Turquli masalebiT gare-montebuli 80 kv.m amave korpusSi, an remontis Tanxa _ 15000 aSS dolari, aseve, 130 000 aSS dolari da gadakisre-bul iqna kreditor g. k-isadmi Sesasrulebeli valdebu-leba 47 000 aSS dolaris odenobiT. amave xelSekrulebisTanaxmad, meore gamyidvelis davalebiT pirvelma mopa-suxem (Segebebuli sarCelis avtorma) aRniSnuli Tanxasrulad gadasca Tavdapirvel mosarCeles, rac iTvlebo-da meore gamyidvelisaTvis (ix. am gadawyvetilebis me-4

12

punqti) Tanxis gadaxdad da pirveli mopasuxis mier val-debulebis Sesrulebad;

11.1.3. Segebebulma mosarCelem (pirvelma mopasuxem) daZiriTadma (Tavdapirvelma) mosarCelem 2011 wlis 23 de-kembers dades sanotaro wesiT damowmebuli `Sesyidvisofciis winare xelSekruleba~ (ix. am gadawyvetilebis me-5 punqti), rasac safuZvlad daedo zemoaRniSnuli orixelSekruleba _ 2011 wlis 1 dekembrisa da 3 dekembris,riTac Tavdapirvel mosarCeles mieniWa ufleba, eyida q.TbilisSi, W-is q. 6-Si mdebare Senobis merve da mecxre sar-Tulebze ganTavsebuli farTebi. amave garigebis Sinaar-sidan gamomdinare, Sesyidvis ofciis ZiriTadi xelSekru-leba unda dadebuliyo nasyidobis sagnebis gamyidvelis(am SemTxvevaSi pirveli mopasuxis) sakuTrebaSi gadas-vlisTanave. S. b-is kuTvnili uZravi qonebis valdebule-bebisagan gamosaTavisufleblad, Tavdapirvelma mosarCe-lem pirvel mopasuxes (Segebebuli sarCelis avtors) wi-naswar gamoarTva nasyidobis fasi 50 000 (ormocdaaTi aTa-si) aSS dolari, magram aRniSnuli Tanxa aRiricxa Tavis sa-kuTrebad da amiT usafuZvlod miiTvisa Segebebuli mo-sarCelis mier winaswar gadaxdili nasyidobis Tanxa _ 50000 aSS dolari. aqedan gamomdinare, Segebebuli sarCelisavtorma moiTxova Tavdapirveli mosarCelisaTvis 50 000aSS dolaris ekvivalenti laris dakisreba da 2011 wlis 23dekembers dadebuli xelSekrulebis (ix. am gadawyveti-lebis me-5 punqti) baTilad cnoba (ix. saqalaqo sasamar-Tlos gadawyvetileba).

12. Segebebeuli sarCelis mopasuxis pozicia12.1. Segebebuli sarCelis mopasuxem (Tavdapirvelma

mosarCelem) ar cno mis winaaRmdeg aRZruli sarCeli dawerilobiT wardgenil SesagebelSi Semdeg faqtobriv ga-remoebeze miuTiTa:

12.1.1. 2011 wlis 23 dekembers dadebuli Sesyidvis of-ciis winare xelSekrulebis safuZvelze Tavdapirvel mo-sarCeles evaleboda ZiriTadi xelSekrulebis dasadebadpirveli gamyidvelis (ix. am gadawyvetilebis pirveli pun-qti) sakuTrebad ricxuli farTis yadaRisgan gaTavisuf-leba, rac Segebebuli sarCelis mopasuxem Seasrula, ra-sac pirveli mopasuxe (romelic Segebebuli mosarCelea)TviTonac aRiarebs;

12.1.2. pirvel mopasuxes Tavdapirveli mosarCelisaT-

13

vis ar gadauxdia 50 000 aSS dolari am gadawyvetilebispirvel punqtSi dasaxelebuli pirveli gamyidvelis sa-xelze ricxuli farTis yadaRisgan gaTavisuflebis miz-niT da gamosasyidad. es garemoeba sasamarTlom morige-bis aqtSi mxolod formalurad aRniSna, sinamdvileSipirvel mopasuxes (Segebebuli sarCelis avtors) Tanxa argadauxdia da ZiriTadma mosarCelem sakuTari saxsrebiTuzrunvelyo am farTis gamosyidva auqcionze. amasTan, amukanasknelma valdebulebis SesrulebisTanave acnobapirvel mopasuxes (Segebebul mosarCeles) da gamoxatamzadyofna, rom misTvis gadaeformebina aRniSnuli uZra-vi qoneba. Tumca, pirvelma mopasuxem ganacxada, rom esfarTi isedac misi iyo da amas mogvianebiT gaakeTebda. mi-uxedavad amisa, pirveli mopasuxe am farTis faqtobrivflobas Seudga, kerZod, man daangria aRniSnuli bina, mox-sna gadaxurva da 100 kv.m-is nacvlad gazarda 292.20 kv.m-mde. aqedan gamomdinare, usafuZvloa pirveli mopasuxismtkiceba, rom ZiriTadma mosarCelem ar Seasrula nakisrivaldebulebebi, radgan es ukanaskneli pirveli mopasu-xis gareSe ver SeZlebda binis gadaformebas. amisaTvis sa-Wiro iyo ormxrivi garigebis registracia sajaro rees-trSi. amdenad, sasarCelo gancxadebaSi miTiTebuli gare-moeba usafuZvlo gamdidrebis Taobaze dausabuTebeliada Segebebuli sarCeli ar unda dakmayofildes (ix. saqa-laqo sasamarTlos gadawyvetileba).

13. Tbilisis saqalaqo sasamarTlos samoqalaqo saq-meTa kolegiis 2014 wlis 9 seqtembris gadawyvetilebada daskvnebi:

13.1. Tbilisis saqalaqo sasamarTlos samoqalaqo saq-meTa kolegiis 2014 wlis 9 seqtembris gadawyvetilebiTsarCeli pirveli, meore, mesame da meoTxe mopasuxeebiswinaaRmdeg ar dakmayofilda, aseve, ar dakmayofilda pir-veli mopasuxis Segebebuli sarCeli Tavdapirveli mosar-Celis winaaRmdeg;

13.1.1. gauqmda Tbilisis saqalaqo sasamarTlos samoqa-laqo saqmeTa kolegiis 2013 wlis 24 maisis ganCineba dayadaRa moexsna pirveli mopasuxis sakuTrebaSi arsebuluZrav qonebas, mdebare: a) Tbilisi, W-is (yof. b-is) #6, ko-merciuli farTi #2, sarTuli 1, 80.40 kv.m, s/k 0...—; b) Tbi-lisi, W-is (yof. b-is) #6, sarTuli 2, bina #6, 80.00 kv.m, s/k0...—; g) Tbilisi, W-is (yof. b-is) #6, sarTuli 3, bina #10,

14

104.20 kv.m, s/k 0...—; d) Tbilisi, W-is (yof. b-is) #6, sarTu-li 5, bina #15, 120.50 kv.m, s/k 0...—; e) Tbilisi, W-is (yof. b-is) #6, sarTuli 6, bina #18a, 141.20 kv.m, s/k 0...—a; v) Tbili-si, W-is (yof. b-is) #6, sarTuli 6, bina #18b, 104.70 kv.m, s/k 0...—; z) Tbilisi, W-is (yof. b-.is) #6, sarTuli 8, bina #20,132.60 kv.m, s/k 0...—;

13.1.2. gauqmda Tbilisis saqalaqo sasamarTlos samoqa-laqo saqmeTa kolegiis 2013 wlis 28 maisis ganCineba dayadaRa moexsna meore mopasuxis (ix. am gadawyvetilebis8.1. qvepunqti) sakuTrebaSi arsebul uZrav qonebas, mde-bare: a) Tbilisi, W-is (yof. b-.is) #6, komerciuli farTi#2, sarTuli 1, 80.40 kv.m, s/k 0...—; b) Tbilisi, W-is (yof. b-.is) #6, sarTuli 3, bina #10, 104.20 kv.m, s/k 0...—; g) mesamemopasuxis sakuTrebaSi arsebul uZrav qonebas, mdebareTbilisi, W-is (yof. b-.is) #6, sarTuli 6, bina #18b, 104.70kv.m, s/k 0...—b; d) Tbilisi, W-is (yof. b-.is) #6, sarTuli 8,bina #20, 132.60 kv.m, s/k 0...—; e) meoTxe mopasuxis sakuT-rebaSi arsebuli uZravi qoneba, Tbilisi, W-is (yof. b-.is)#6, sarTuli 5, bina #15, 120.50 kv.m, s/k 0...—; d) Tbilisi, W-is s/k kodi: 0...—a;

13.1.3. gauqmda Tbilisis saqalaqo sasamarTlos samoqa-laqo saqmeTa kolegiis 2013 wlis 31 maisis ganCineba dayadaRa moexsna ZiriTadi mosarCelis (Segebebuli sarCe-lis mopasuxis) sakuTrebaSi arsebul uZrav qonebas, mde-bare: q. Tbilisi, W-is q. #4 / q. Tbilisi, W-is q. (yof b-.is)#6, me-9 sarTuli, bina 22, farTi _ 100 kv.m, s/k 0...—;

13.1.4. Segebebuli mosarCelis moTxovna iuridiulimomsaxurebisaTvis gaRebuli xarjebis anazRaurebis Ta-obaze ar dakmayofilda;

13.2. saqalaqo sasamarTlom dadgenilad miiCnia pirve-li mopasuxis mier Tavdapirveli mosarCelisaTvis 50 000aSS dolaris gadaxdis faqti, rac sadavo iyo mxareTa So-ris.

13.2.1. saqarTvelos samoqalaqo saproceso kodeqsis(SemdegSi: sssk) 105-e muxlis me-2 nawilis Tanaxmad, sasa-marTlo afasebs mtkicebulebebs Tavisi Sinagani rwmeniT,romelic unda emyarebodes maT yovelmxriv, srul da obi-eqtur ganxilvas, ris Sedegadac mas gamoaqvs daskvna saq-misaTvis mniSvnelobis mqone garemoebebis arsebobis anararsebobis Taobaze. saproceso kodeqsi awesebs mtkice-bis tvirTis ganawilebis standarts, Tumca, TiToeuli

15

mtkicebulebis Sefasebas sasamarTlos Sinagan rwmenasukavSirebs. mtkicebulebaTa Sinagani rwmeniT Sefasebi-sas, rogorc samoqalaqo procesis mTavari principi cxad-yofs, araviTar mtkicebulebas ar gaaCnia winaswar dadge-nili Zala.

13.2.2. miuxedavad imisa, rom sasamarTlos Sinagani rwme-na ganpirobebulia subieqturi kriteriumiT, aRniSnuliprincipi ar aris SeuzRudavad uzrunvelyofili da undaefuZnebodes mtkicebulebaTa yovelmxriv gamokvlevas.sasamarTlos Sinagani rwmenis Camosayalibeblad mxedve-lobaSi unda iqnes miRebuli da Sefasebuli TiToeuli de-tali, romelic arsebobs am garemoebis irgvliv. amdenad,Sinagani rwmeniT mtkicebulebaTa Sefasebis meTodi moi-cavs TiToeuli mtkicebulebis mniSvnelobis gansazRvrasdamoukideblad.

13.2.3. sasamarTlom imsjela saqmeSi wardgenili 2011wlis 1 dekemberis nasyidobis xelSekrulebaze (ix. am ga-dawyvetilebis pirveli punqti), sadac asaxulia, rom pir-vel mopasuxes, rogorc uZravi qonebis myidvels, am gari-gebis safuZvelze warmoSobili valdebuleba unda Sees-rulebina ZiriTadi mosarCelis mimarT da aseT SemTxve-vaSi valdebuleba CaiTvleboda Sesrulebulad.

13.2.4. Tbilisis saqalaqo sasamarTlos samoqalaqo saq-meTa kolegiis 2012 wlis 10 Tebervlis ganCinebiT dam-tkicda morigeba, romlis me-13 muxlis Sinaarsi Camoyali-bebulia Semdegnairad: vinaidan pirvelma mopasuxem pir-vel gamyidvels (ix. am gadawyvetilebis pirveli punqti)gadauxada 50 000 aSS dolari, am ukanasknelis mier misaRe-bi farTi q. TbilisSi, W-is q. #6, me-9 sarTuli, bina #22, (s/k 0...) aRiricxos pirveli mopasuxis (anu Segebebuli mo-sarCelis) sakuTrebis uflebiT;

13.2.5. sasamarTlom ganmarta, rom ssk-is 373-e muxlisme-2 nawili gansazRvravs kreditoris TanxmobiT Sesru-lebis ganxorcielebas mesame piris sasargeblod. aseT Sem-TxvevaSi, rogorc kreditori, ise movale inarCuneben sa-marTlebriv poziciebs, xolo valdebuleba miiCneva Ses-rulebulad. amdenad, aRniSnuli saxelSekrulebo urTi-erTobidan gamomdinare, uflebamosil pirs warmoadgenskreditori da ara mesame piri. samoqalaqo samarTalwar-moebis procesSi mxareTa morigeba, Tavisi samarTlebriviSinaarsiT, garigebas warmoadgens, sadac TiToeuli mxa-

16

re, sakuTari SexedulebiT gankargavs misTvis miniWebulmaterialur uflebebs;

13.2.6. sasamarTlos SefasebiT, 2011 wlis 1 dekembrisgarigebis Sinaarsi moicavda pirveli gamyidvelis valde-bulebas misTvis 50 000 aSS dolaris gadaxdis sanacvlod,gadaeca uZravi qoneba pirveli mopasuxisaTvis, xel-Semkvreli myidveli mxarisaTvis. saqalaqo sasamarTlosSefasebiT, miuxedavad imisa, rom aRniSnuli xelSekrule-ba iTvaliswinebs nasyidobis safasuris nawilSi valdebu-lebis Sesrulebas Tavdapirveli mosarCelis sasar-geblod, am Tanxaze uflebamosil pirs warmoadgenda pir-veli gamyidveli. 2012 wlis 10 Tebervals, morigebisas pir-velma gamyidvelma daadastura Tanxis miRebis faqti daufro metic, amis sanacvlod gankarga sadavo uZravi qo-neba. Sesabamisad, sasamarTlom daaskvna, rom ZiriTadi mo-sarCele ver iqneboda am faqtobrivi garemoebis Secile-baze uflebamosili piri.

13.3. saqalaqo sasamarTlom aRniSna, rom saqmisaTvismniSvnelobis mqone sxva faqtobrivi garemoebebi mxare-ebs sadavod ar gauxdiaT.

13.4. sasamarTlom miiCnia, rom mxareTa Soris 2011 wlis23 dekembers gaformebuli xelSekruleba ar Seesabame-boda ofciis winare xelSekrulebis Sinaarss da ganmarta,rom samoqalaqo brunvis ganviTarebam ganapiroba garige-bebis mravalferovani xasiaTi. samoqalaqo kodeqsi, saxel-Sekrulebo urTierTobis Tavisuflebis principidan ga-momdinare, SesaZleblobas aniWebs mxareebs, sakanon-mdeblo regulirebis farglebSi sakuTari SexedulebiTmoawesrigon maT Soris arsebuli ekonomikuri urTierTo-bebi. Sesabamisad, amgvari xelSekrulebebi SesaZloa, zog-jer ar Tavsdebodes samoqalaqo kodeqsSi mza saxiT mo-cemuli saxelSekrulebo modelis CarCoebSi, Sesabamisad,sadavoobisas samarTlebrivi Sedegebis mowesrigeba saWi-roebs sasamarTlos mier xelSekrulebis Sinaarsis gan-martebas. TiToeuli xelSekrulebis Sinaarsi unda gani-martos ara misi saxelwodebidan gamomdinare, aramed imufleba-movaleobaTa sistemis gaTvaliswinebiT, romel-sac Seicavs konkretuli garigebis Sinaarsi;

13.5. sasamarTlos SefasebiT, 2011 wlis 23 dekembrisxelSekrulebaSi mxareTa neba mimarTulia ori samoqala-qosamarTlebrivi institutis warmoSobisaken, kerZod, mas

17

gaaCnia winare xelSekrulebis iuridiuli datvirTulo-ba, xolo garigebis Sinaarsi moicavs ofciis xelSekrule-bis formulirebas.

13.6. ofciis xelSekrulebis samarTlebrivi regulaciaasaxulia ssk-is 515-e muxlSi, romlis Tanaxmad, mxareebiSeiZleba SeTanxmdnen, rom myidvels calmxrivad aqvs uf-leba, esa Tu is sagani SeiZinos gansazRvrul dromde angansazRvrul movlenamde (Sesyidvis ofcia), anda, imavepirobebSi gamyidvels ufleba aqvs, sagani myidvels mih-yidos (gayidvis ofcia). ofciis xelSekrulebis mimarT ga-moiyeneba nasyidobis xelSekrulebis normebi, Tuki mxa-reebi sxva rameze ar SeTanxmebulan.

13.7. ofciis xelSekruleba damoukidebel samar-Tlebriv urTierTobas warmoadgens, romelsac specifi-kuri ufleba-movaleobebi da regulirebis sagani gaaCnia.ofciis xelSekruleba ormxrivi garigebaa, romlis saga-nia myidvelisaTvis an gamyidvelisaTvis uflebis/valde-bulebis dadgena, SeiZinos an gaasxvisos konkretuli aq-tivi, winaswar gansazRvrul dros an SeTanxmebuli droismonakveTSi, anda gansazRvruli movlenis arsebobisas.amasTan, sasamarTlom yuradReba gaamaxvila im garemoe-baze, rom ssk-is 515-e muxlSi asaxuli termini `calmxri-vad~ ar gulisxmobs xelSekrulebis calmxriv bunebas, ara-med _ ofcionis mflobelis SesaZleblobas, ofciis xel-SekrulebiT dadgenili pirobebis arsebobisas, calmxri-vad ganaxorcielos uflebebis realizacia. ofcionis Sem-Zens eniWeba ufleba, sakuTari SexedulebiT gadawyvitos,SeiZinos Tu ara SeTanxmebuli sagani.

13.8. ssk-is 515-e muxlic ofciis xelSekrulebis or sa-xes ganasxvavebs. kerZod, Sesyidvis ofcia, romelic gan-sazRvravs myidvelis uflebas, da ara valdebulebas, Sei-Zinos SeTanxmebuli sikeTe (call option). rac Seexeba gam-yidvels, misi samarTlebrivi mdgomareoba boWavs mas val-debulebiT, nebis calmxrivi gamovlinebisas, gaaformosmyidvelTan misTvis sasurveli garigeba. ofciis xel-Sekrulebis meore formaa gayidvis ofcia, romelic gu-lisxmobs myidvelis valdebulebas, SeiZinos aqtivebi (putoption). ofcionis mflobeli ar aris SeboWili aranairi val-debulebiT da ofciis xelSekrulebiT miniWebuli ufle-bis realizacia calmxrivad mis neba-survilzea damoki-debuli. gansxvavebul samarTlebriv reJimSi imyofeba kon-

18

traqtis meore mxare, romelic valdebulia, SeiZinos angaasxvisos aqtivi, Tu ofciis mflobeli gadawyvets Tavi-si uflebis realizacias.

13.9. ofciis xelSekrulebas, garda imisa, rom erT-er-Ti mxarisaTvis samomavlod xelSekrulebis gansazRvru-li pirobebiT dadebis garantias qmnis, damoukidebeliekonomikuri Sinaarsic gaaCnia: ofcia, rogorc wesi, sas-yidliania, sadac ofciis SemZeni valdebulia, miniWebuliuflebis sanacvlod gadauxados meore mxares SeTanxme-buli premia. im SemTxvevaSi, Tu beneficiari ofciis xel-Sekrulebis winapirobebis dadgomisas ar gamoiyenebs amuflebas, gadaxdili sazRauri dabrunebas ar eqvemdeba-reba.

13.10. amdenad, marTalia ofcia damoukidebeli xel-Sekrulebis statusiT arsebobs, Tumca mis obieqts war-moadgens ufleba da ara konkretuli materializirebu-li qonebrivi sikeTe an momsaxurebis sfero. miuxedavadimisa, rom ssk-is 515-e muxli ofciis xelSekrulebis mi-marT nasyidobis xelSekrulebis regulaciebis gamoyene-bis SesaZleblobas gansazRvravs, misi Sinaarsi ar gulis-xmobs qonebis uflebriv gadanacvlebas, rac mxareTa sa-boloo mizans da garigebis materialur interess warmo-adgens, aramed uflebis miniWebiT uzrunvelyofs Sem-dgomSi nasyidobis xelSekrulebis dadebas.

13.11. ssk-is 327-e muxlis me-3 nawilis Tanaxmad, xel-SekrulebiT SeiZleba warmoiSvas momavali xelSekrule-bis dadebis valdebuleba. xelSekrulebiT gaTvaliswine-buli forma vrceldeba aseve winare xelSekrulebazedac.erTi SexedviT, ofciis xelSekrulebis samarTlebrivifunqcia emsgavseba winare xelSekrulebas, romlis miza-nic aris ZiriTadi xelSekrulebis dadeba. Tumca, maT So-ris gansxvaveba isaa, rom marTalia, winare xelSekrule-bac samarTlebrivad damoukidebel xelSekrulebas war-moadgens, magram mxareTa interesi mxolod samomavloxelSekrulebis dadebiskenaa mimarTuli da mas damouki-debeli ekonomikuri Sinaarsi ar gaaCnia. ofciis xelSekru-leba ki, rogorc zemoT aRiniSna, damoukidebladac war-moSobs ekonomikur Sedegebs.

13.12. vinaidan, ofciis xelSekruleba da winare xel-Sekruleba or damoukidebel garigebas warmoadgens, ka-noni dasaSvebad miiCnevs ofciisaTvis, rogorc ZiriTadi

19

garigebisaTvis winare xelSekrulebis arsebobas. Tumca,am ori samarTlebrivi institutis analizis safuZvelzesasamarTlom daaskvna, rom ZiriTad mosarCelsa da pir-vel mopasuxes Soris 2011 wlis 23 dekembers dadebuliSesyidvis ofciis winare xelSekruleba ar Seicavda aR-niSnuli xelSekrulebisaTvis damaxasiaTebel winapiro-bebs.

13.13. TiToeuli xelSekrulebis Sinaarsi unda ganimar-tos masSi asaxuli ufleba-movaleobebis Sesabamisad. mxa-reTa Soris 23.12.2011w. xelmowerili xelSekrulebis me-2punqti gansazRvravs garigebis sagans, romlis Tanaxmad,gamyidveli da myidveli SeTanxmdnen, rom mxareebi dade-ben Sesyidvis ofciis ZiriTad xelSekrulebas; am xel-Sekrulebis safuZvelze myidvels ufleba eqneba iyidos,q. TbilisSi, T. W-is q. #6-Si me-8 da me-9 sarTulebze mde-bare farTebi, xelSekrulebis me-4 punqtSi miTiTebuliodenobiTa da wesiT. sasamarTlom ganmarta: imis gaTvalis-winebiT, rom winare xelSekrulebis dadebis mizans war-moadgens ZiriTadi xelSekrulebis dadeba, ofciis wina-re xelSekrulebis samarTlebrivi funqcia samomavlodofciis xelSekrulebis gaformebaa. 2011 wlis 23 dekem-bris xelSekrulebis Sinaarsi avaldebulebs mxareebs sa-momavlod xelSekrulebis gaformebas, Tumca, is ufleba-movaleobebi, romelic momavali garigebis SinaarsiT arisgansazRvruli, sasamarTlos SefasebiT, ar Seesabameba of-ciis xelSekrulebas.

13.14. zemoaRniSnulidan gamomdinare, saqalaqo sasa-marTlom daaskvna, rom ofciis xelSekrulebis sagans arwarmoadgens uZrav qonebaze kreditoris uflebrivi mdgo-mareobis dadgena. misi Sinaarsi gulisxmobs, uflebis Se-Zenas, romelic momavalSi garantirebulad uzrunvel-yofs, ofciis mflobelis centraluri interesis dakma-yofilebas sxva garigebis pirobebSi. amitom, im SemTxve-vaSic ki Tu 2011 wlis 23 dekembris xelSekruleba moicavswinare xelSekrulebis saxes, momavali xelSekruleba,romlis dasadebadac aris igi mimarTuli ar Seesabameba of-ciis kontraqts.

13.15. imis gaTvaliswinebiT, rom winare xelSekrule-bis mimarT moqmedebs saxelSekrulebo samarTlis Ziri-Tadi principebi, misTvisac damaxasiaTebelia SeTanxmebayvela arsebiT pirobaze. savaldebulo wesiT unda aisa-

20

xos ZiriTadi xelSekrulebis gaformebis dro da pirobe-bi. ssk-is 327-e muxlis me-3 nawili ar gansazRvravs winarexelSekrulebis motivebs. Tu mxareebs surT nasyidobisxelSekrulebis dadeba, xolo nasyidobis sagani, jer ki-dev ar warmoadgens gamyidvelis sakuTrebas, Tumca, gam-yidveli darwmunebulia, rom axlo momavalSi gasasxvise-beli aqtivi moeqceva misi sakuTrebis sferoSi, maT gaaC-niaT winare xelSekrulebis gaformebis legitimuri uf-leba. myidvels, romelic dainteresebulia am konkretu-li nivTis SeZeniT, surs miiRos garantiebi. amitom, moma-vali garigebis mxareebi Tanxmdebian, rom rogorc ki nas-yidobis sagani moeqceva gamyidvelis sakuTrebis sfero-Si, igi valdebuli iqneba ukve nasyidobis xelSekrulebisgaformebis gziT, gadasces myidvels sasurveli qoneba.sasamarTlos SefasebiT, 2011 wlis 23 dekembris xelSekru-leba (ix. am gadawyvetilebis me-5 punqti) am Sinaarsis ma-tarebelia. rogorc saqmis masalebiT aris dadgenili, aR-niSnuli xelSekrulebis gaformebisas, nasyidobis sagani,mdebare q. TbilisSi, W-is q. #6-Si, me-9 sarTulis bina # 22(s/k 0...), registrirebuli iyo pirveli gamyidvelis sakuT-rebis uflebiT, xolo imave misamarTze, me-8 sarTulis bi-na # 21 (s/k 0...) _ meore gamyidvelis sakuTrebis uflebiT(ix. winamdebare gadawyvetilebis pirveli da meoTxe pun-qtebi). aseve, mosalodneli iyo me-9 sarTulze mdebarebina #22-is proeqtis koreqtireba.

13.16. saqalaqo sasamarTlos SefasebiT, zemoxseneulpirobebSi, SeuZlebeli iqneboda nasyidobis xelSekrule-bis gaformeba srulyofili formiT, ris gamoc 2011 wlis23 dekembris xelSekruleba warmoadgens winare nasyido-bis xelSekrulebas.

13.17. sasamarTlom aseve mniSvnelovnad miiCnia mova-lis pasuxismgebloba winare xelSekrulebiT nakisri val-debulebebis darRvevis SemTxvevaSi da ganmarta, rom aR-niSnuli garigebis specifika gamoricxavda xelSekrule-bidan gasvlis samarTlebrivi institutis gamoyenebas,radgan misi Sinaarsi ar xasiaTdeba naturaluri Sesrule-biT. Tumca, vinaidan winare xelSekruleba valdebulebiT-samarTlebriv kategorias warmoadgens, kanonmdebeli da-saSvebad miiCnevs, msgavs SemTxvevaSi, ssk-is 394-e muxlisgamoyenebis SesaZleblobas, zogad safuZvlebze.

13.18. ssk-is 394-e muxlis pirveli nawilis mixedviT, mo-

21

valis mier valdebulebis darRvevisas kreditors SeuZ-lia moiTxovos amiT gamowveuli zianis anazRaureba. mi-TiTebuli norma gansazRvravs im aucilebel winapirobebs,romlebic unda arsebobdes xelSekrulebis darRveviT ga-mowveuli zianis moTxovnis uflebis warmoSobisaTvis;kerZod, unda arsebobdes ziani, braleuli qmedeba da mi-zezobrivi kavSiri darRvevasa da damdgar Sedegs Soris.

13.19. sasamarTlom ganmarta, rom saqmeze dadgenilifaqtobrivi garemoebebi unda Seesabamebodes aRniSnulnormaSi miTiTebul konstruqcias, amasTan, zianis anaz-Raurebis instituti emsaxureba ara zianis mimyeneblisdasjas, aramed im danaklisis Sevsebas, romelic valde-bulebis darRvevis Sedegad ganicada kreditorma. ssk-is394-e muxli adgens princips, romlis mixedviT, ziani un-da anazRaurdes sruli moculobiT. ZiriTadi mosarCelismier moTxovnili zianis moculobiTi nawili daangariSe-bulia im uZravi nivTebis sabazro RirebulebiT, romelickreditors unda mieRo nasyidobis xelSekrulebis gafor-mebis SemTxvevaSi. aRniSnuli norma gansazRvravs zianisanazRaurebis samarTlebriv winapirobebs, Tumca, zianisiuridiuli Sedegi mocemulia amave kodeqsis 408-e mux-lis arsebul nawilSi, romlis Tanaxmad, im pirma, romelicvaldebulia aanazRauros ziani, unda aRadginos is mdgo-mareoba, romelic iarsebebda, rom ar damdgariyo anazRa-urebis mavaldebulebeli garemoeba. saqarTvelos uzena-esi sasamarTlos 2013 wlis 1 ivlisis # as-1607-1509-2012gadawyvetilebaSi zianis anazRaurebis formebis dadge-nisas ganmartebulia: `...sakasacio palata aRniSnavs, romdauSvebelia kreditors mieces rogorc naturiT, asevefuladi TanxiT anazRaurebis ufleba~. amdenad, zianisanazRaurebis Sinaarsi gamoricxavs dublirebuli aRsru-lebis SesaZleblobas, rodesac kreditori arsebuli da-naklisis Sevsebas cdilobs, rogorc naturiT restitu-ciiT, ise _ sanacvlo ekvivalenturi kompensirebiT.

13.20. sasamarTlos SefasebiT, saqmis masalebiT dad-genilia, rom q. TbilisSi, W-is q. #6, me-9 sarTulze mdeba-re bina #22 amJamad registrirebulia ZiriTadi mosarCe-lis sakuTrebad. aRniSnuli uZravi qoneba warmoadgendasamomavlo nasyidobis xelSekrulebis sagans. ZiriTadi mo-sarCelis mier zianis saxiT moTxovnili odenoba, Seicavsaseve am qonebis ekvivalentur Rirebulebas, Tumca, am

22

ukanasknelis (mosarCelis) sakuTrebaSi naturaluri for-miT ukve arsebobs. amdenad, mosarCelis ekonomikuri in-teresi, romlis miRwevac mas surda nasyidobis xelSekru-lebis gaformebiT am nawilSi dakmayofilebuli iyo da ararsebobda danaklisi.

13.21. garda amisa, saqalaqo sasamarTlom miiCnia, romZiriTadi mosarCelis mier zianis saxiT moTxovnili 462480 aSS dolaris ekvivalenti larSi, romelic gaangariSe-bulia misaRebi uZravi qonebis ekvivalenturi Rirebule-biT, ar Seesabameboda zianis anazRaurebis samarTlebrivfunqcias. sasamarTlom ganmarta, rom valdebulebis Se-usrulebloba, TavisTavad zianis momtania mxarisTvis,radgan kreditors yovelTvis aqvs Sesrulebis molodinida Sesruleba misTvis yovelTvis garkveul Rirebulebaswarmoadgens, magram zianis anazRaurebis moTxovna war-moiSoba valdebulebis darRvevis SemTxvevaSi mxolod ma-Sin, Tu darRvevam damatebiT ziani miayena kreditors. zi-ani dgeba, rodesac valdebulebis SesrulebiT kreditorsgarkveuli Semosavlis wyaro gauCndeboda, damatebiT ma-terialur sikeTes SeiZenda, rac ver ganxorcielda val-debulebis Seusruleblobis gamo. sasamarTlos Sefase-biT, amgvari garemoeba saqmeSi wardgenili masalebis mi-xedviT ar ikveTeboda. mxolod is faqti, rom SesaZloa,xelSekrulebis pirobebi mosarCelisTvis momgebiani iyo,ar warmoadgenda zianis moTxovnis winapirobas. mosarCe-lis moTxovna gamomdinareobda ara valdebulebis dar-Rvevis Sedegad damatebiTi danaklisis Sevsebidan, ara-med _ mxareTa mier Sesasrulebeli valdebulebebis ekvi-valenturi Rirebulebidan. am SemTxvevaSi, msgavsi Sina-arsis uflebis realizacia gulisxmobda darRveuli val-debulebis Sesrulebas da scdeboda zianis iuridiuldatvirTulobas. amdenad, sasamarTlom usafuZvlod mi-iCnia ZiriTadi mosarCelis moTxovnis es nawili.

13.22. sasamarTlom aseve ar gaiziara mosarCelis moT-xovna 2013 wlis 23 maiss pirvel da meore mopasuxeebs So-ris gaformebuli oTxi nasyidobis xelSekrulebis, imaveTariRiT pirvel da mesame, aseve _ pirvel da meoTxe mopa-suxeebs Soris gaformebuli nasyidobis xelSekrulebebis(ix. am gadawyvetilebis 8.1-8.6. qvepunqtebi) baTilad cno-bis nawilSi.

13.23. sasamarTlom ganmarta, rom xelSekrulebis baTi-

23

loba Tavisi samarTlebrivi bunebiT aRiarebiT sarCelswarmoadgens, Sesabamisad, misTvis damaxasiaTebelia iu-ridiuli interesis arseboba. samoqalaqo saproceso ko-deqsi samarTlebrivi urTierTobis arseboba-ararsebobisdadgenis samarTlebriv saSualebad aRiarebiT sarCelsiTvaliswinebs, Tumca, am saxis sarCelebi, rogorc aRiniS-na, yovelTvis SezRudulia iuridiuli interesiT, anusarCelis dakmayofilebis aucilebel winapirobas warmo-adgens im iuridiuli Sedegebis miRwevadoba, risi dadgo-mac surs sarCelis avtors amgvari aRiarebiT.

13.24. samoqalaqo saproceso kanonmdeblobiT gaTva-liswinebuli iuridiuli interesi mniSvnelovani samar-Tlebrivi kategoriaa. aseTi interesis arseboba yovel-Tvis gulisxmobs, rom mxare garkveul mniSvnelobas ani-Webs interesis obieqts. Tumca, gasaTvaliswinebelia, romiuridiuli interesi ar ganisazRvreba mxolod piris su-bieqturi damokidebulebiT, anu mxolod misi surviliT,aramed, aucilebelia misi obieqturi mxarec. obieqturiTvalsazrisiT, interesi moicavs Sedegebs, romelic sa-zogadoebrivi cxovrebis sxvadasxva sferoSi arsebobs. aR-niSnuli Sedegebi aucileblad gansazRvruli unda iyossamarTlis normebiT. swored Sedegebis amgvari samar-Tlebrivi dacva ganapirobebs interesebis iuridiul bu-nebas. amdenad, iuridiuli interesebis miRwevadobis au-cilebel winapirobas warmoadgens is garemoeba, Tu samar-Tlebrivad ramdenad daculia Sedegebi, romelTa dadgo-mac surs mosarCeles.

13.25. sasamarTlom ganmarta, rom gansaxilveli davisfarglebSi, Tavdapirveli mosarCelis samarTlebriv in-teress xelSekrulebebis baTilobis mimarT warmoad-genda, moTxovnili zianis anazRaurebis SemTxvevaSi, aR-srulebisaTvis xelsayreli pirobebis Seqmna. vinaidan sa-samarTlom ar daakmayofila mosarCelis moTxovna zianisanazRaurebis Taobaze, Sesabamisad, aRniSnulis gaTvalis-winebiT, daaskvna, rom ar arsebobda dasaxelebuli xel-Sekrulebebis baTilobis mimarT mxaris iuridiuli inte-resi.

13.26. pirveli mopasuxis Segebebuli sarCelis uaryo-fisas, saqalaqo sasamarTlom aRniSna, rom Segebebuli sar-CeliT pirveli mopasuxis moTxovnis samarTlebriv safuZ-vels warmoadgenda ssk-is 986-e muxli, romlis Tanaxmad:

24

`pirs, romelic Segnebulad an SecdomiT sxvis valebs is-tumrebs, SeuZlia am pirs mosTxovos xarjebis anazRau-reba~. kerZo samarTalSi damkvidrebuli principis Tanax-mad, aravin ar SeiZleba gamdidrdes Sesabamisi safuZvlisgareSe. zemoxsenebuli norma, usafuZvlo gamdidrebiserT-erTi gamovlinebaa, romelic aregulirebs sami pirisurTierTobas. aRniSnuli normis samarTlebrivi specifi-ka imaSi mdgomareobs, rom mesame piri ar aris SeboWilikreditoris mimarT aranairi valdebulebiT. Sesabamisad,misi Sesruleba ar efuZneba samarTlebriv safuZvels. ka-nonmdebeli ukumoTxovnis uflebas aniWebs valdebule-bis Semsrulebels, am SesrulebiT gamdidrebuli pirisa-gan.

13.27. sasamarTlom aRniSna, rom safuZvlis gareSe gam-didreba moicavs, rogorc viTom-kreditoris qonebriviaqtivis gazrdas, ise _ mis mier sxva piris xarjze qonebisdazogvas. Sesabamisad, ssk-is 986-e muxlis Sinaarsi Sei-cavs zogadad usafuZvlo gamdidrebis institutisaTvisdamaxasiaTebel konstruqcias, sadac mesame piris moqme-deba iwvevs sxva piris gamdidrebas, yovelgvari samar-Tlebrivi safuZvlis gareSe. amgvar viTarebaSi, SemZenivaldebulia daabrunos mis mier miRebuli sikeTe, miuxe-davad imisa, Tu visma qmedebam gamoiwvia misi gamdidreba.

13.28. sasamarTlom dadgenilad miiCnia, rom pirvelmamopasuxem (Segebebulma mosarCelem) ZiriTad mosarCelesgadasca 50 000 aSS dolari. im sakiTxis Sesafaseblad, ar-sebobda Tu ara kondiqciuri valdebulebis winapirobe-bi, sasamarTlom imsjela faqtobrivi monacemebis Tan-mimdevrulobaze, miuTiTa winamdebare gadawyvetilebis1-3 punqtebSi asaxuli xelSekrulebis pirobebze da ssk-is 373-e muxlis me-2 nawilze, romlis Tanaxmad, Tu valde-bulebis Sesruleba miiRo im pirma, romelic ar iyo ufle-bamosili, valdebuleba CaiTvleba Sesrulebulad maSin,roca kreditorma misca amis Tanxmoba, an am Sesrulebisa-gan miiRo sargebeli. zogadi principis Tanaxmad, valde-bulebis Sesrulebis adresats warmoadgens samarTlebri-vi urTierTobis subieqti, Tumca, samoqalaqo kodeqsi da-saSvebad miiCnevs Sesrulebis realizacias mesame pirissasargeblod, mxolod kreditoris TanxmobiT; amasTan, sa-xelSekrulebo urTierTobis uSualo mxareebi inarCune-ben samarTlebriv mdgomareobas da mesame piris mimarT

25

ganxorcielebuli Sesruleba, gulisxmobs valdebulebisSesrulebas kreditoris mimarT; Sesabamisad, rogorc ga-rigebis Sinaarsi, ise misi subieqturi Semadgenloba rCebaucvleli.

13.29. sasamarTlos SefasebiT, pirveli mopasuxis miermosarCelisaTvis gadaxdili 50 000 aSS dolaris samar-Tlebriv safuZvels warmoadgenda 2011 wlis 1 dekembrisxelSekruleba. Sesrulebis samarTlebrivi safuZvlis ar-seboba, TavisTavad, gamoricxavda usafuZvlo gamdidre-bis gamoyenebis SesaZleblobas.

14. mosarCelisa da Segebebuli mosarCelis (pirve-li mopasuxis) saapelacio saCivrebi

14.1. saqalaqo sasamarTlos gadawyvetileba saapelaciowesiT gaasaCivres Tavdapirvelma mosarCelem da pirvelmamopasuxem, romelTac gasaCivrebuli gadawyvetilebis ga-uqmeba da, axali gadawyvetilebiT, Tav-TavianTi sasarCe-lo moTxovnebis dakmayofileba moiTxoves.

15. Tbilisis saapelacio sasamarTlos samoqalaqosaqmeTa palatis 2016 wlis 25 oqtombris gadawyveti-leba da daskvnebi

15.1. Tbilisis saapelacio sasamarTlos samoqalaqo saq-meTa palatis 2016 wlis 25 oqtombris gadawyvetilebiTnawilobriv dakmayofilda Tavdapirveli mosarCelisa dapirveli mopasuxis saapelacio saCivrebi;

15.1.1. am saqmeze Tbilisis saqalaqo sasamarTlos samo-qalaqo saqmeTa kolegiis 2014 wlis 9 seqtembris gadaw-yvetilebis SecvliT miRebul iqna axali gadawyvetileba;

15.1.2. nawilobriv dakmayofilda Tavdapirveli mosar-Celis moTxovna;

15.1.3. Tavdapirveli mosarCelis sasargeblod pirvelmopasuxes daekisra 302 480 (samas ori aTas oTxas oTxmo-ci) aSS dolaris gadaxda;

15.2. baTilad iqna cnobili pirvel mopasuxesa da meo-re mopasuxes Soris dadebuli garigebebi, romlebic wi-namdebare gadawyvetilebis 8.1-8.4 qvepunqtebSia miTiTe-buli;

15.3. ar dakmayofilda sarCeli ZiriTadi mosarCelis sa-sargeblod pirveli mopasuxisaTvis zianis asanazRaureb-lad 160 000 (as samoci aTasi) aSS dolaris dakisrebis na-wilSi;

15.4. ar dakmayofilda Tavdapirveli mosarCelis moT-

26

xovna pirvel mopasuxesa da mesame mopasuxes Soris, ase-ve, pirvel mopasuxesa da meoTxe mopasuxes Soris 2013 wlis23 maiss uZrav qonebaze dadebuli nasyidobis xelSekru-lebebis baTilad cnobis nawilSi (ix. am gadawyvetilebis8.5- 8.6 qvepunqtebi);

15.5. ar dakmayofilda pirveli mopasuxis SegebebulisarCeli.

15.6. saapelacio sasamarTlom am gadawyvetilebis me-5punqtSi asaxul 2011 wlis 23 dekembris `Sesyidvis ofciiswinare xelSekrulebis Sesaxeb~ pirobebze miuTiTa, ker-Zod:

15.6.1. farTi (mSenebare), me-9 sarTulze mdebare bina#22, farTiT 100,00 kv.m (uZravi qonebis s/k 0...), registri-rebuli iyo pirveli gamyidvelis saxelze (ix. am gadawyve-tilebis pirveli punqti);

15.6.2. farTi (mSenebare), me-8 sarTulze mdebare bina#21-dan (farTi 250,00 kv.m.-dan) 125 kv.m (uZravi qonebis s/k 0...), registrirebuli iyo meore gamyidvelis sakuTre-bad (ix. am gadawyvetilebis meoTxe punqti).

15.7. sasamarTlom aRniSna: rom zemoaRniSnuli farTe-bi dayadaRebuli iyo amxanagoba `v-s~ wevrebis nawilis mi-er aRZruli sarCelis safuZvelze da maTTan dakavSire-biT mimdinareobda sasamarTlo dava. pirvelma mopasuxem,massa da Tavdapirvel mosarCeles Soris 2011 wlis 23 de-kembris xelSekrulebis dadebamde, dasaxelebuli farTe-bis mesakuTreebTan _ pirvel da meore gamyidvelebTandado xelSekrulebebi da am garigebebiT moipova uflebamiTiTebuli farTebis mis sakuTrebaSi miRebis Sesaxeb.

15.8. 2011 wlis 23 dekembris xelSekrulebiT mxareebi _pirveli mopasuxe da ZiriTadi mosarCele, SeTanxmdnen,rom am ganCinebis pirvel da meoTxe punqtebSi miTiTebu-li pirveli da meore gamyidvelebis sakuTrebad registri-rebuli zemoaRniSnuli farTebis pirveli mopasuxis sa-kuTrebaSi gadasvlisTanave, am ukanasknelsa da ZiriTadmosarCeles Soris daideboda nasyidobis xelSekruleba2011 wlis 23 dekembris xelSekrulebiT dadgenili wesiTda pirobebiT, q. TbilisSi, W-is q.#6-Si mdebare uZravi qo-nebidan mosarCelisaTvis farTis miyidvis Taobaze.

15.9. zemoxsenebuli xelSekrulebis me-4 muxliT gan-sazRvrulia am garigebiT gaTvaliswinebuli uZravi qone-bis (xelSekrulebis 3.1 muxli) Sesyidvis pirobebi; ker-

27

Zod, pirveli mopasuxis valdebulebas warmoadgenda, uz-runveleyo Senoba-nagebobis (romlis nawilicaa nasyido-bis sagani) proeqtis koreqtireba da amis Sesaxeb mieRomSeneblobis nebarTva; amasTan, gamosyidvis pirobebi da-mokidebuli iyo imaze, moxdeboda Tu ara Senobis me-9 sar-Tulis koreqtireba _ farTis damateba Tu arsebuli far-Tis (100,00 kv.m.) SenarCuneba. orive SemTxvevaSi gamyidve-li (am SemTxvevaSi pirveli mopasuxe) valdebuli iyo, nas-yidobis sagani mieyvana `Savi karkasis~ mdgomareobamde;Sesabamisad, igi valdebuli iyo, ecnobebina myidvelisaT-vis _ ZiriTadi mosarCelisaTvis, mSeneblobis nebarTvisada me-9 sarTulis proeqtis koreqtirebis, an ucvleladdatovebis Sesaxeb informacia werilobiT, mSeneblobisnebarTvis miRebidan 7 kalendarul dReSi (ix. am gadaw-yvetilebis 5.3 qvepunqti).

15.10. Setyobinebis miRebis Semdeg: a) im SemTxvevaSi,Tu me-9 sarTulis proeqti darCeboda ucvleli saxiT, imsaxiTac rogorc igi arsebobda 2011 wlis 23 dekembris xel-Sekrulebis dadebis momentisaTvis (Senoba-nagebobisproeqtis koreqtirebamde), myidveli _ ZiriTadi mosar-Cele, valdebulebas iRebda, gamoesyida orive sagani (ori-ve farTi mdebare W-is quCis mxares) _ me-8 sarTulis far-Ti, garda 125,00 kv.m-isa da me-9 sarTuli srulad; kerZod,bina #22, farTi 100,00 kv.m; mxareTa mier uZravi qonebisgamosyidvis fasi gansazRvrulia da igi Seadgens 110 000aSS dolars (ekvivalent lars), xolo gamosyidvis vada Se-adgens farTis `Savi karkasis~ mdgomareobamde miyvanis Se-saxeb myidvelisaTvis werilobiTi Setyobinebis gadace-midan 45 kalendarul dRes; b) im SemTxvevaSi, Tu me-9 sar-Tulis proeqti Seicvleboda da me-9 sarTuls daemate-boda farTi, myidveli _ mosarCele iRebda valdebule-bas, gamoesyida nasyidobis orive sagani (orive farTi mde-bare W-is quCis mxares) _ me-8 sarTulis farTi, garda 132,00kv.m-isa da me-9 sarTulze arsebuli koreqtirebuli far-Ti, garda 113,00 kv.m-isa; orive sagnis nasyidobis fasikvlav rCeboda 110 000 aSS dolari (ekvivalenti lari);

15.10.1. igive wesi iyo gansazRvruli uZravi qonebis ga-mosyidvis vadis Taobazec (farTis `Savi karkasis~ mdgo-mareobamde miyvanis Sesaxeb myidvelisaTvis werilobiTiSetyobinebis gadacemidan 45 kalendaruli dRe);

15.10.2. xelSekrulebis mixedviT, pirveli mopasuxis,

28

rogorc gamyidvelis, valdebulebas warmoadgenda myid-velis mier nasyidobis orive sagnis gamosyidvis fasis ga-daxdis Semdeg, mieyvana igi `TeTri karkasis~ mdgomareo-bamde; gamosyidvis momentisaTvis nasyidobis orive saga-ni unda yofiliyo uflebrivad unaklo (ix. xelSekrule-bis me-4 muxlis me-4 punqti).

15.11. sasamarTlom aRniSna, rom dadgenili da udavoais garemoeba, rom pirveli gamyidvelis saxelze ricxuluZrav qonebaze (ix. am gadawyvetilebis pirveli punqti)registrirebuli iyo uflebrivi SezRudva _ pirveli dameore rigis yadaRebi (saaRsrulebo biuros 03.10.2003 01/09 momarTva; sajaro reestris erovnuli saagentos Tbi-lisis saregistracio samsaxuris gadawyvetileba#102011079987/3; 20 aprili, 2011 weli) yadaRis registra-ciis Sesaxeb; sajaro reestris erovnuli saagentos Tbi-lisis saregistracio samsaxuris gadawyvetileba#102011208580/3; 8 noemberi, 2011 weli); pirveli gamyidve-li registrirebuli iyo movaleTa reestrSi.

15.12. Tavdapirvel mosarCeles pirveli gamyidvelisa-gan miniWebuli (mindobili) hqonda yvela im valdebule-bis Sesrulebis uflebamosileba, rac gamomdinareobda amukanasknelsa da pirvel mopasuxes Soris dadebuli `sa-marTlebrivi urTierTobebis sasamarTlosgareSe mowes-rigebis~ 2011 wlis 1 dekembris sanotaro aqtidan;

15.13. 2011 wlis 23 dekembris xelSekrulebis mixedviT,pirveli mopasuxis mxridan ZiriTadi mosarCelis mimarTnakisri valdebulebis (pirveli mopasuxis sakuTrebaSi uZ-ravi qonebis gadasvlisTanave, am qonebis mosarCelisaT-vis SeTanxmebuli pirobebis da wesis dacviT miyidvis Ta-obaze garigebis dadebis) Sesruleba, amave xelSekrule-bis me-3 muxlis me-5 punqtis Sesabamisad, damokidebuliiyo mosarCelis mier am ukanasknelisaTvis pirveli gam-yidvelisagan miniWebuli uflebamosilebis srulad dajerovnad Sesrulebaze _ am gadawyvetilebis pirvel pun-qtSi miTiTebuli pirveli gamyidvelis kuTvnili farTisuflebrivi SezRudvisagan (yadaRebisagan) gaTavisufle-baze.

15.14. saqmis masalebiT dadgenilia, rom Tbilisis saqa-laqo sasamarTlos warmoebaSi imyofeboda samoqalaqo saq-me #2/6464-06 (mosarCeleebi: d. J-a, n. a-i, T. x-i, Sps ì~, l.g-i, l. C-e, g. C-a, j. g-a; mopasuxeebi: b. p-i, v. J-a, r. b-i, x. g-

29

i, z. l-i, m. f-a, n. l-i, s. k-e; mesame pirebi damoukidebelisasarCelo moTxovniT: m. o-e, m. k-e, r. q-a, e. e-i, r. j-i, g. k-i; mesame pirebi damoukidebeli sasarCelo moTxovnis ga-reSe: sajaro reestris erovnuli saagento, notariusi m.f-a; davis sagani _ mesakuTred cnoba); mxareTa Soris da-vis sagans warmoadgenda q. TbilisSi, W-is q. #6-Si mdebarebinaTmSeneblobidan gamomdinare ufleba-movaleobebi;

15.15. dadgenilia, rom mosarCeleebi, mopasuxeebi dadamoukidebeli sasarCelo moTxovnis mqone mesame pirebiSeTanxmdnen maTi monawileobiT Tbilisis saqalaqo sasa-marTlos samoqalaqo saqmeTa kolegiaSi mimdinare #2/6464-06 samoqalaqo saqmis morigebiT dasrulebis Taoba-ze da am mizniT mimarTes notariuss (ix. 2011 wlis 28 de-kembris `samarTlebrivi urTierTobis morigebiT dasru-lebis Sesaxeb~ xelSekruleba, romelic Semdeg mxareTa mi-er wardgenili iqna Tbilisis saqalaqo sasamarTloSi mim-dinare #2/6464-06 samoqalaqo saqmis ganxilvisas);

15.15.1. Tbilisis saqalaqo sasamarTlos samoqalaqo saq-meTa kolegiis 2012 wlis 10 Tebervlis ganCinebiT mxareTaSoris damtkicda morigeba maT mier SeTanxmebuli piro-bebiT da Sesabamisad, #2/6464-06 samoqalaqo saqmis war-moeba Sewyda. sasamarTlos aRniSnuli ganCineba Sevida ka-nonier ZalaSi;

15.15.2. mxareTa morigebis damtkicebis Taobaze miRe-buli sasamarTlos ganCinebiT (mraval sxva sakiTxTan er-Tad) ganisazRvra da gadawyda pirveli da meore gamyidve-lebis sakuTrebis uflebis gauqmeba Semdeg farTebze: Tbi-lisSi, W-is q. #6-Si, me-8 sarTulis bina #21-ze (s/k #0...),me-9 sarTulis bina #22-ze (s/k #0...) da aRniSnuli farTe-bis aRricxva pirveli mopasuxis sakuTrebad (ganCinebissarezolucio nawilis me-12 muxlis 4.4. punqti da me-13muxli).

15.16. zemoaRniSnulidan gamomdinare, saapelacio sa-samarTlos SefasebiT, pirvel mopasuxes sajaro reestrSiTbilisis saqalaqo sasamarTlos samoqalaqo saqmeTa ko-legiis 2012 wlis 10 Tebervlis ganCinebis wardgenis gziT,yovelgvari dabrkolebis gareSe mieca Tavdapirveli mo-sarCelis mier Sesasyidi 2011 wlis 23 dekembris xelSekru-lebiT gaTvaliswinebuli farTebis Tavis saxelze aR-ricxvis SesaZlebloba.

15.16.1. dadgenilia, rom pirvel mopasuxes Tbilisis sa-

30

qalaqo sasamarTlos samoqalaqo saqmeTa kolegiis 2012wlis 10 Tebervlis ganCinebis aRsasruleblad _ mis saxel-ze uZravi qonebis (mdebare TbilisSi, W-is q. #6-Si, me-8sarTulze bina #21-ze, s/k #0..., me-9 sarTulze bina #22-ze s/k #0...) sakuTrebis uflebiT dasaregistrirebelad,SemdgomSi ZiriTad mosarCelesTan garigebis dadebis miz-niT, sajaro reestrisaTvis ar miumarTavs.

15.16.2. dadgenilia is garemoebac, rom pirvel mopasu-xes, massa da ZiriTad mosarCeles Soris dadebuli 2011wlis 23 dekembris xelSekrulebis me-4 muxliT gaTvalis-winebuli valdebuleba ar Seusrulebia da am ukanaskne-lisaTvis ar ucnobebia uZravi qonebis Sesyidvis TaobazexelSekrulebiT gansazRvruli misi uflebis dadgomis Se-saxeb; kerZod, rogorc ukve aRiniSna, pirveli mopasuxisvaldebulebas warmoadgenda mSeneblobis nebarTvis (ase-ve me-9 sarTulis proeqtis koreqtirebis, an misi ucvle-lad datovebis Sesaxeb) miRebidan, aRniSnulis TaobazeSvidi dRis vadaSi mosarCelis werilobiTi saxiT informi-reba.

15.16.3. saqmis masalebiT aseve dadgenilia, rom pir-velma mopasuxem, nacvlad sasamarTlos 2012 wlis 10 Te-bervlis ganCinebis aRsasruleblad sajaro reestrisTvismimarTvis da mis saxelze zemoaRniSnuli qonebis dare-gistrirebisa, 2011 wlis 23 dekembris xelSekrulebiT Zi-riTadi mosarCelisadmi nakisri valdebulebis (xelSekru-lebiT gaTvaliswinebuli pirobebis dacviT misTvis qone-bis miyidvis Taobaze) Sesrulebis mizniT, am garigebiTgansazRvruli mosarCelis mier Sesasyidi qoneba, indivi-dualuri binaTmSeneblobis amxanagoba `v-s~ saerTo kre-bis oqmis safuZvelze gadasca sxva pirebs (kerZod, q. Tbi-lisSi, W-is q. #6-Si me-8 sarTulze 178,00 kv.m. farTi aRi-ricxa m. o.-is saxelze, amave sarTulze darCenili 132,60kv.m. farTi Tavis saxelze aRricxa pirvelma mopasuxem,xolo me-9 sarTulze mdebare 192,20 farTi aRiricxa r. j.-ze; SemdgomSi aRniSnuli qoneba 2013 wlis 02 maisis Cuqe-bis xelSekrulebis safuZvelze aRiricxa z. j-is sakuT-rebad; amonawerebi sajaro reestridan);

15.17. rogorc aRiniSna, pirveli mopasuxis mier 2011wlis 23 dekembris xelSekrulebiT ZiriTadi mosarCelismimarT nakisri valdebulebis Sesruleba, damokidebuliiyo am ukanasknelis mier, misTvis pirveli gamyidvelisa-

31

gan miniWebuli uflebamosilebis, srulad da jerovnadSesrulebaze _ pirveli gamyidvelis kuTvnili farTis uf-lebrivi SezRudvisagan (yadaRebisagan) gaTavisuflebaze(xelSekrulebis me-3 muxlis me-5 punqti); Sesabamisad, sa-apelacio sasamarTlom imsjela mosarCelis mier xel-SekrulebiT nakisri valdebulebis Sesrulebis Sesaxeb daaqedan gamomdinare, warmoeSva Tu ara mosarCeles garige-bis mxaris _ pirveli mopasuxisadmi sapasuxo SesrulebismoTxovnis ufleba.

15.17.1. sasamarTlos SefasebiT, Tavdapirvelma mosar-Celem aRniSnuli valdebuleba Seasrula, kerZod, man sa-qarTvelos iusticiis saministros aRsrulebis erovnu-li biuros mier gamarTul auqcionze SeiZina pirveli gam-yidvelis kuTvnili uZravi qoneba da aRmasruleblis#A11063362_014/001 gankargulebis safuZvelze (damow-mebis TariRi 23/02/2012) aRiricxa am qonebis mesakuTred(amonaweri sajaro reestridan);

15.17.2. amasTan, aRniSnulis Taobaze mosarCelem acno-ba garigebis mxares _ pirvel mopasuxes, mzadyofna ganac-xada xelSekrulebiT gaTvaliswinebuli Tanxis gadaxdisda SeTanxmebuli pirobebis dacviT farTis miRebis Tao-baze; pirobis darRvevis da nakisri valdebulebis Seus-ruleblobis gamo mxarem werilobiTac mimarTa pirvel mo-pasuxes;

15.17.3. sasamarTlom usafuZvlod miiCnia da, Sesabami-sad, ar gaiziara pirveli mopasuxis is argumenti, rom mo-sarCelem mis mier nakisri valdebuleba ar Seasrula je-rovnad da SeTanxmebuli pirobis dacviT; kerZod, pirve-li mopasuxe miuTiTebda, rom mosarCelem qoneba auqci-onze SeiZina da Tavis saxelze aRricxa, rasac ar iTvalis-winebda mxareTa SeTanxmeba; saapelacio sasamarTlom yu-radReba gaamaxvila mxareebs Soris dadebuli 2011 wlis23 dekembris xelSekrulebis me-5 muxlis pirobaze, rom-lis mixedviT, mosarCelis valdebulebas warmoadgendapirveli gamyidvelis saxelze ricxuli uZravi qoneba (mde-bare q. TbilisSi, W-is q.#6, me-9 sarTuli, bina #22, farTi100,00 kv.m. sakadastro kodi #0...), romelzec registri-rebuli iyo pirveli da meore rigis yadaRebi, gaeTavisuf-lebina uflebrivi SezRudvisagan; swored aRniSnuli val-debuleba Seasrula man da is garemoeba, rom es qmedebaganxorcielda nivTis auqcionze SeZenis Sedegad, sruli-

32

ad ar ewinaaRmdegeboda garigebis mizans;15.17.4. saapelacio sasamarTlos SefasebiT mTavari da

arsebiTi mniSvnelobis iyo is garemoeba, rom dasaxelebu-li qoneba mosarCelis qmedebis Sedegad uflebrivad unak-lo gaxda (arsebuli yadaRebisagan gaTavisuflda); rac Se-exeba im garemoebas, rom nivTi aRiricxa Tavdapirveli mo-sarCelis sakuTrebad, aRniSnuli ganpirobebuli iyo auq-cionze qonebis SeZenis Tanmdevi SedegiT.

15.18. saapelacio sasamarTlom imsjela mxareTa gan-martebebze, romlebiTac calsaxad dasturdeboda, rommosarCele qonebis mis saxelze aRricxvis Semdeg, yovel-Tvis, maT Soris, saapelacio sasamarTloSi davis ganxilvisetapzec, mudmivad mzadyofnas gamoxatavda am saxiT (uf-lebrivad unaklo) dasaxelebuli nivTis mxarisaTvis (pir-veli mopasuxisaTvis) gadacemaze; mxare, romelsac saku-Tari valdebulebis Sesruleba ar surda, ar eTanxmebodaaRniSnul SeTavazebas; Sesabamisad, mxolod mosarCelisnebiT ver miiRweoda Sedegi, ra mizniTac am ukanasknelmagamoisyida da valdebulebebisagan gamoaTavisufla pir-veli gamyidvelis kuTvnili uZravi qoneba.

15.19. zemoaRniSnulidan gamomdinare, saapelacio sa-samarTlom dadgenilad miiCnia davis gadawyvetisaTvisarsebiTi mniSvnelobis mqone garemoebebi imis Taobaze,rom mosarCelem Seasrula 2011 wlis 23 dekembris xel-SekrulebiT nakisri valdebuleba, xolo pirvelma mopa-suxem ar Seasrula mosarCelis winaSe nakisri valdebule-ba, rasac ukavSirdeba valdebulebis damrRvevi piris mxri-dan, amave xelSekrulebiT gaTvaliswinebuli pirobebisdacviT garigebis mxaris sasargeblod zianis anazRaure-bis wesi. kerZod, mxareebs Soris 2011 wlis 23 dekembersdadebuli xelSekrulebis me-6 punqti gansazRvravs pir-veli mopasuxis, rogorc gamyidvelis, mxridan am xel-SekrulebiT mosarCelis, rogorc myidvelis, mimarT na-kisri valdebulebis Seusruleblobis SemTxvevaSi zianisanazRaurebis wess; zianis odenoba gamoiTvleba nasyido-bis saganTa sabazro fasis gaTvaliswinebiT. mxedveloba-Si miiReba sabazro fasi im momentisaTvis, roca unda da-debuliyo gamosyidvis xelSekruleba.

15.20. saapelacio sasamarTlom ganmarta, rom nasyido-bis saganTa sabazro fasis gansazRvris Taobaze, mosarCe-lis mier saqmis masalebSi wardgenili iyo saqarTvelos

33

iusticiis saministros aRsrulebis erovnuli biuros Se-fasebis samsaxuris Semfaseblis, p. b-s 2013 wlis 22 maisis#01/02_0926 daskvna, romlis mixedviT, Sesafasebeli obi-eqtis _ q. TbilisSi, W-is q.#6-Si mdebare sacxovrebel kor-pusSi me-8 da me-9 sarTulebze (e.w. `TeTri karkasis~ mdgo-mareobiT) 1 kv.m-s Rirebuleba Seadgens 1600 aSS dolars;amasTan, ZiriTadi mosarCelis sarCelSi asaxulia, Tu rasSeadgens nasyidobis farTis odenoba; kerZod, mxare uTi-Tebs, rom vinaidan Seicvala me-9 sarTulis proeqti, mas2011 wlis 23 dekembris xelSekrulebis me-4 muxlis pirve-li nawilis `b~ punqtis Sesabamisad, unda mieRo q. Tbilis-Si, W-is q.#6-Si mdebare sacxovrebel korpusSi me-8 sar-Tulze 178,6 kv.m farTi (saerTo farTs 360,60 kv.m-s _ 132kv.m) da me-9 sarTulze 179,2 kv.m (saerTo farTs 292,20 kv.m-s _ 113,00 kv.m); e.i. jamSi _ 357,80 kv.m farTi; imis gaTvalis-winebiT, rom 1 kv.m farTis Rirebuleba Seadgens 1600 aSSdolars, amasTan, aRniSnul qonebaze nasyidobis xel-Sekrulebis dadebis SemTxvevaSi, mosarCelis mier gada-saxdeli Tanxis odenoba xelSekrulebiT gansazRvrulia110 000 aSS dolariT, Sesabamisad, am Tanxis gamoklebiT,mxare misTvis miyenebuli zianis odenobas gansazRvravs462 480 aSS dolariT (357,80 X 1600 - 110 000 = 462 480);

15.21. saapelacio sasamarTlom aRniSna, rom q. Tbilis-Si, W-is q.#6-Si mdebare nagebobis proeqtis koreqtire-bis gamo misi calkeuli sacxovrebeli da arasacxovrebe-li farTebis zomis, konfiguraciis, mdebareobisa da fun-qciuri daniSnulebis cvlilebaze, miuTiTebda saqmis ma-salebSi wardgenili amxanagobis krebis oqmic.

15.22. sasamarTlom aRniSna, rom mosarCelis mier miTi-Tebuli garemoebebis, saqmeze darTuli da dasaxelebu-li mtkicebulebebis sawinaaRmdegod, mopasuxes sxva mtki-cebulebebi ar warudgenia da Tavisi poziciis Camoyali-bebisas sasamarTloSi wardgenili SesagebliT pirveli mo-pasuxe Semoifargla mxolod im garemoebaze miTiTebiT,rom mxareebs Soris 2011 wlis 23 dekembers dadebuli ga-rigeba baTilia; amasTan, igi imasac aRniSnavda, rom mosar-Celes ar Seusrulebia garigebiT nakisri valdebuleba;

15.22.1. sasamarTlos SefasebiT, pirveli mopasuxis ze-moxsenebuli msjeloba urTierTgamomricxavi da winaaR-mdegobrivi iyo (erTi mxriv, mxare miuTiTebda garigebisbaTilobaze, xolo meore mxriv, afasebda am garigebiT na-

34

kisri valdebulebis Sesrulebis sakiTxs); rac Seexeba zi-anis odenobis nawilSi pirveli mopasuxis pretenzias damiTiTebas im garemoebaze, rom qonebis sabazro Rirebu-lebas gansazRvravda mis mier sasamarTloSi wardgenilinasyidobis xelSekrulebebi, saapelacio sasamarTlom aR-niSna, rom mxaris mier wardgenili garigebebiT ar SeiZle-boda dadgeniliyo (miT ufro dasaxelebuli garigebebissadavoobis pirobebSi) uZravi qonebis sabazro Rirebule-ba; saTanado codnis da kompetenciis mqone piris daskvnaam qonebis sabazro Rirebulebis gansazRvris Taobaze, mo-pasuxes ar warudgenia.

15.22.2. keTilsindisierebis instituti gansakuTrebiTmniSvnelovania samoqalaqo samarTlisaTvis da igi mTlia-nad kerZo samarTlis umTavres princips warmoadgens. ssk-is me-8 muxlis mesame nawilis danawesis Sesabamisad, sa-marTlebrivi urTierTobis monawileni valdebuli ariankeTilsindisierad ganaxorcielon TavianTi uflebebi damovaleobebi. kodeqsis es danawesi, romelsac avsebs ssk-is 361-e muxlis meore nawili, moicavs mTel kerZo samar-Tals. aRniSnuli muxlebis moqmedeba calsaxa da impera-tiulia, amitomac mxareebs ar aqvT ufleba xelSekrule-biT an SeTanxmebiT gamoricxon maTi moqmedeba. ssk-is me-8 muxlis mesame nawili gansazRvravs keTilsindisierebas,rogorc valdebulebis ZiriTad da aucilebel komponentsda mxolod valdebulebaTa SesrulebiT ar Semoifargle-ba, xolo ssk-is 361-e muxlis meore nawilis danawesi imisSesaxeb, rom valdebuleba unda Sesruldes keTilsindi-sierad, warmoadgens kanonismier moTxovnas da gulis-xmobs, zogadad, samoqalaqosamarTlebrivi urTierTobismonawileTa mier urTierTobis sxva monawilis interese-bis pativiscemas, sakuTari rolisa da pasuxismgeblobisgaTavisebas, Tundac im SemTxvevaSi, rodesac mas konkre-tuli pirdapiri valdebuleba ar ekisreba. zemoaRniSnu-li normebi mTeli samoqalaqo brunvis qvakuTxedia da sa-Sualebas iZleva nebismieri urTierToba samarTlebriviTvalsazrisiT Sefasdes.

15.22.3. sasamarTlom aRniSna: dadgenili iyo, rom Tav-dapirvelma mosarCelem 2013 wlis 11 maiss werili miswerapirvel mopasuxes da mosTxova xelSekrulebiT nakisrivaldebulebis Sesruleba; man amave weriliT damatebiTxuTi dRis vada ganusazRvra mxares SeTanxmebiT nakisri

35

valdebulebis Sesasruleblad da acnoba, rom winaaRmdegSemTxvevaSi ganaxorcilebda samarTlebriv reagirebas;

15.22.4. garigebis mxaris _ pirveli mopasuxis qcevis ke-Tilsindisierebis Sesafaseblad, sasamarTlom mniSvne-lovnad miiCnia, rogorc manamde (misTvis zemoaRniSnuliweriliT mimarTvamde), aseve SemdgomSi ganviTarebulimovlenebis aRwera da maTi gaanalizeba; kerZod, dginde-boda, rom mosarCelis mier pirveli mopasuxisadmi dasa-xelebuli werilis gagzavnis Semdeg, 2013 wlis 23 maiss,mosarCelem mimarTa sajaro reestrs da moiTxova amona-werebi pirveli mopasuxis saxelze q. TbilisSi, W-is q.#6-Si mdebare uZravi qonebis Sesaxeb; amave dRes mosarCelemsarCeliT mimarTa sasamarTlos pirveli mopasuxis wina-aRmdeg zianis anazRaurebis moTxovniT da aseve waradgi-na gancxadeba sarCelis uzrunvelyofis RonisZiebis ga-tarebis mizniT, pirveli mopasuxis saxelze sakuTrebisuflebiT ricxul zemoaRniSnul misamarTze mdebare SviduZrav nivTze yadaRis dadebis Sesaxeb; ganmcxadeblismoTxovna dakmayofilda da Tbilisis saqalaqo sasamar-Tlos samoqalaqo saqmeTa kolegiis 2013 wlis 24 maisis gan-CinebiT yadaRa daedo pirveli mopasuxis saxelze ricxuluZrav qonebas _ Svid nivTs _ mdebares, TbilisSi, W-is q.#6-Si;

15.22.5. sasamarTlos zemoaRniSnuli ganCinebis aRsru-leba ver ganxorcielda, radgan 2013 wlis 22-23 maiss, pir-velma mopasuxem, mis saxelze ricxuli qoneba sajaro re-estris erovnul saagentoSi nasyidobis xelSekrulebebisdadebis gziT (maT Soris ori sxva uZravi qonebac /s.k. 0...—da s.k.0../, romlebzedac ar iyo gamoyenebuli sarCelis uz-runvelyofis RonisZieba) sxva pirebze gadaaforma (ix. amgadawyvetilebis 8.1-8.6 qvepunqtebi); aseve, 2013 wlis 23maiss pirvel mopasuxesa da m. p-s Soris daido uZravi qo-nebis Cuqebis xelSekruleba uZrav nivTze, mdebare q. Tbi-lisSi, isanSi s.k. 0...— da aRniSnuli qoneba aRiricxa am uka-nasknelis saxelze; imave dRes pirvel mopasuxesa da n. j-s Soris daido nasyidobis xelSekruleba uZrav nivTze mde-bare baTumSi, s.k. 0.. da qoneba am ukanasknelis saxelzeaRiricxa.

15.23. saapelacio sasamarTlos SefasebiT, pirvel mo-pasuxesa da meore mopasuxes Soris 2013 wlis 23 maiss ga-formebuli uZravi qonebis nasyidobis Sesaxeb winamdeba-

36

re gadawyvetilebis 8.1-8.4 qvepunqtebSi miTiTebuli oT-xi xelSekrulebis dadeba miznad ar isaxavda am garigebe-bis Sesabamisi iuridiuli Sedegis dadgomas; pirveli mo-pasuxis, rogorc gamyidvelis, mxridan am garigebebis da-debis mizans warmoadgenda materialuri pasuxismgeblo-bis _ mosarCelisaTvis zianis anazRaurebisagan Tavidanarideba; dasaxelebuli ZviradRirebuli oTxi uZravi niv-Tis SemZenis Sesatyvisi qceva da am mizniT garigebebis da-deba ver daadastura verc meore mopasuxem; miT ufro,imis gaTvaliswinebiT, rom uZravi nivTebis Taobaze nasyi-dobis oTxive garigeba sajaro reestrSi daido erTsa daimave dRes da mxarec daCqarebuli wesiT daregistrirdaam qonebis mesakuTred; igi (meore mopasuxe) sxdomaze argamocxadebula da Sesabamisad, uSualod misi axsna-gan-marteba saqmis masalebSi ar moipoveboda; sasamarTlomarainformaciulad da mwirad miiCnia meore mopasuxis mi-er wardgenili Sesagebeli, romelSic mxare mxolod im ga-remoebaze miuTiTebda, rom pirvel mopasuxes gaaCnda uZ-rav qonebaTa gasxvisebis uflebamosileba da komerciu-li interesi, xolo mas ki _ am qonebaTa SeZenis interesi.

15.24. saapelacio sasamarTlos SefasebiT, 2013 wlis 23maiss pirvel mopasuxesa da mesame mopasuxes Soris, imavedRes, pirvel mopasuxesa da meoTxe mopasuxes Soris da-debuli uZravi qonebis nasyidobis xelSekrulebebi (ix. amgadawyvetilebis 8.5-8.6 qvepunqtebi) namdvilia da gari-gebis monawileTa neba Seesabameba garigebis Sinaarss; amdaskvnis safuZvels iZleoda saqmis masalebi, kerZod, mxa-reTa ganmartebebi imis Taobaze, rom dasaxelebuli gari-gebebiT uZravi qonebis SemZenebi floben maT mier SeZe-nil qonebas (aRniSnuli garemoeba daadastura Tbilisissaapelacio sasamarTlos samoqalaqo saqmeTa palatis 2015wlis 22 maisis sxdomaze mxarem _ meoTxe mopasuxem); sasa-marTlom aRniSna, rom mniSvnelovani iyo is garemoebac,rom mesame mopasuxes (ix. 8.5. qvepunqti) gaaCnda pirvelimopasuxisagan TbilisSi, W-is q.#6-Si mdebare korpusSifarTis miRebis ufleba, razedac mxareebi SeTanxmdnenda es SeTanxmeba damtkicebuli iyo kanonier ZalaSi Sesu-li Tbilisis saqalaqo sasamarTlos 2012 wlis 10 Teber-vlis ganCinebiT (aRniSnulis Taobaze miTiTebulia nasyi-dobis xelSekrulebaSic; kerZod, me-4 muxlSi aRniSnulia,rom mesame mopasuxes 104,70 kv.m. dan 65,00 kv.m. usasyidlod

37

gadaeca Tbilisis saqalaqo sasamarTlos samoqalaqo saq-meTa kolegiis 2012 wlis 10 Tebervlis ganCinebis safuZ-velze, romliTac damtkicda mxareTa Soris miRweuli mo-rigeba (saqme #2/6464-06), xolo danarCeni farTi _ 39,70kv.m. xelSekrulebis mixedviT gaiyida 44 000 larad);

15.25. sssk-is me-4 muxlis pirveli nawilis Tanaxmad, sa-marTalwarmoeba mimdinareobs SejibrebiTobis safuZ-velze. mxareebi sargebloben Tanabari uflebebiTa da Se-saZleblobebiT, daasabuTon TavianTi moTxovnebi, uaryonan gaaqarwylon meore mxaris mier wamoyenebuli moTxovne-bi, mosazrebebi Tu mtkicebulebebi. mxareebi TviTonvegansazRvraven, Tu romeli faqtebi unda daedos safuZ-vlad maT moTxovnebs, an romeli mtkicebulebebiT undaiqnes dadasturebuli es faqtebi. amave kodeqsis 102-e mux-lis pirveli nawilis Tanaxmad, TiToeulma mxarem unda da-amtkicos garemoebebi, romlebzedac igi amyarebs TavismoTxovnas da Sesagebels. amave muxlis me-3 nawilis Ta-naxmad, saqmis garemoebebi, romlebic kanonis Tanaxmad un-da dadasturdes garkveuli saxis mtkicebulebebiT, ar Se-iZleba dadasturdes sxva saxis mtkicebulebebiT. Sejib-rebiTobis principidan gamomdinare, mxare TviTon gan-sazRvravs, Tu romel faqtebze miTiTebiT uaryos an gaa-qarwylos meore mxaris mier wamoyenebuli moTxovnebi, mo-sazrebebi Tu mtkicebulebi.

15.25.1. saapelacio sasamarTlom yuradReba gaamaxvilasaxelSekrulebo valdebulebidan gamomdinare samoqala-qosamarTlebrivi pasuxismgeblobis dakisrebasTan dakav-SirebiT mxareTa mtkicebis tvirTze da ganmarta, rom mtki-cebulebaTa wardgenis movaleobas mtkicebis saganSi Se-mavali faqtis dasadgenad, kanonmdebeli akisrebs im mxa-res, romlisTvisac es ufro advili da mosaxerxebelia. sa-xelSekrulebo urTierTobebidan warmoSobili valdebu-lebis Seusruleblobis gamo zianis anazRaurebis Taoba-ze aRZrul sarCelebSi, mosarCeles ekisreba im faqtebismtkicebis tvirTi, rom aseTi urTierToba arsebobs, manSeasrula xelSekrulebiT nakisri valdebuleba da, Sesa-bamisad, dadga mopasuxis mxridan am xelSekrulebidan ga-momdinare valdebulebis Sesrulebis dro, mopasuxem da-arRvia nakisri valdebuleba; mopasuxem unda amtkicosfaqtebi, romlebic kanonis Tanaxmad abrkoleben (gamoric-xaven) am urTierTobis warmoSobas, mosarCelis mier val-

38

debulebis Sesrulebas da Sesabamisad, amarTleben misimxridan valdebulebis Seusruleblobas.

15.25.2. sasamarTlom ssk-is 361.2 muxlze miuTiTa, rom-lis Tanaxmad, mxareTa Soris warmoSobili saxelSekrule-bo urTierTobidan gamomdinare valdebuleba unda Ses-ruldes jerovnad, keTilsindisierad, daTqmul drosa daadgilas; pasuxismgeblobis safuZvlis gansazRvrisaTvis,gamoyenebul unda iqnes valdebulebis darRveviT gamow-veuli zianis maregulirebeli zogadi normebi. ssk-is 394-e muxli gansazRvravs zianis anazRaurebis moTxovnas val-debulebis darRvevisas da normis pirveli nawiliT dad-genilia, rom movalis mier valdebulebis darRvevisas kre-ditors SeuZlia moiTxovos amiT gamowveuli zianis anaz-Raureba. es wesi ar moqmedebs maSin, roca movales ar ekis-reba pasuxismgebloba valdebulebis darRvevisaTvis. da-saxelebuli norma adgens braleuli pasuxismgeblobisprincips valdebulebiT urTierTobaSi da movales akis-rebs pasuxismgeblobas, Tuki dadginda, rom misi qmedebabraleuli/marTlsawinaaRmdego iyo, mas mohyva ziani daarsebobs mizezobrivi kavSiri qmedebasa da damdgar Se-degs Soris.

15.25.3. ssk-is 412-e muxlis Tanaxmad, anazRaurebas eq-vemdebareba mxolod is ziani, romelic movalisaTvis wi-naswar iyo savaraudo da warmoadgens zianis gamomwvevimoqmedebis uSualo Sedegs. zemoaRniSnulidan gamomdi-nare, gansaxilvel SemTxvevaSi, saapelacio sasamarTlosdaskvniT, mosarCelem daadastura mis mier mxareTa So-ris 2011 wlis 23 dekembris xelSekrulebiT nakisri val-debulebis Sesruleba da aseve daadastura pirveli mopa-suxis mxridan mis winaSe amave garigebiT nakisri valdebu-lebis Seusrulebloba; Tavis mxriv, Segebebulma mosar-Celem (pirvelma mopasuxem) ver daamtkica garemoebebi,romlebic gamoricxavda mis mier Tavdapirveli mosarCe-lis winaSe valdebulebis Sesrulebas. aRniSnulis gaTva-liswinebiT, saapelacio sasamarTlom daaskvna, rom gamov-linda mxareebs Soris dadebuli 2011 wlis 23 dekembrisxelSekrulebis me-6 punqtiT gansazRvruli zianis pirve-li mopasuxisaTvis dakisrebis faqtobrivsamarTlebrivisafuZveli ZiriTadi mosarCelis sasargeblod.

15.25.4. sasamarTlom is garemoebac gaiTvaliswina, romZiriTadi mosarCelis saxelze sajaro reestris monace-

39

mebiT sakuTrebis uflebiT aRricxulia TbilisSi, W-isq.#6, me-9 sarTulze mdebare bina #22, farTi 100,00 kv.m(s/k #0...); Sesabamisad, zianis moculobis gansazRvrisassasamarTlom mxedvelobaSi miiRo aRniSnuli garemoeba daam farTis sabazro Rirebuleba (100X1600=160 000) _ 160000 aSS dolari, gamoaklo mosarCelis mier sarCeliT moT-xovnil Tanxas _ 462 480 aSS dolars da sabolood, mosar-CelisaTvis zianis asanazRaurebeli Tanxa gansazRvra 302480 aSS dolariT, rac pirvel mopasuxes (Segebebul mo-sarCeles) daakisra.

15.26. ssk-is 56-e muxlis pirveli nawilis Tanaxmad, ba-Tilia garigeba, romelic dadebulia mxolod mosaCveneb-lad, im ganzraxvis gareSe, rom mas Sesabamisi iuridiuliSedegi mohyves (moCvenebiTi garigeba). amrigad, gansaxil-veli normiT igulisxmeba is SemTxveva, rodesac, rogorcnebis gamomvleni, aseve, misi mimRebi moqmedeben im gan-zraxvis gareSe, rom am garigebas Sesabamisi iuridiuli Se-degi mohyves. kerZod, moCvenebiTi garigebis dros mosaC-veneblad iqceva am garigebis monawile nebis gamovlenisyvela subieqti. amdenad, moCvenebiTad CaiTvleba gari-geba, Tuki nebis gamomvleni da nebis mimRebi Tanxmdebianimaze, rom maT mier gamovlenil nebas ar mieces msvlelo-ba, e.i. garigebis monawile mxareebi unda acnobierebdnen,rom maT Soris dadebul garigebas samarTlebrivi Sedege-bi ar mohyveba da igi dadebulia mxolod mosaCveneblad.amasTan, igi, rogorc wesi, kanonsawinaaRmdego miznebismisaRwevad an dasafarad gamoiyeneba. moCvenebiTi gari-gebis SemTxvevaSi, SeiZleba daisvas mesame pirTa intere-sebis dacvis sakiTxi.

15.26.1. saapelacio sasamarTlom aRniSna, rom gansaxil-vel SemTxvevaSi, 2013 wlis 23 maiss pirvel da meore mopa-suxeeebs Soris gaformebuli uZravi qonebis oTxi nasyi-dobis xelSekruleba (ix. am gadawyvetilebis 8.1-8.4 qve-punqtebi) warmoadgenda moCvenebiT garigebebs; am Sem-TxvevaSi, gamovlenili iyo garigebis monawileTa ganzraxqmedeba, ra drosac, maT ar surdaT samarTlebrivi Sede-gis dadgoma da misi dadebis mizans warmoadgenda im fi-nansuri pasuxismgeblobisagan Tavis arideba, rac ekisre-boda pirvel mopasuxes mosarCelis winaSe, xelSekrule-biT nakisri valdebulebis Seusruleblobis gamo zianisasanazRaureblad. aRniSnulidan gamomdinare, sasamar-

40

Tlom daaskvna, rom gamoikveTa miTiTebuli garigebebisbaTilobis samarTlebrivi safuZveli.

15.27. sasamarTlom usafuZvlod miiCnia pirveli mopa-suxis Segebebuli sarCelis moTxovna Tavdapirveli mo-sarCelisaTvis 50 000 aSS dolaris dakisrebisa da mxare-ebs Soris dadebuli 2011 wlis 23 dekembris garigebis ba-Tilad cnobis Taobaze.

15.27.1. sasamarTlom miuTiTa ssk-is 986-e muxlze `pirs,romelic Segnebulad an SecdomiT sxvis valebs istumrebs,SeuZlia am pirs mosTxovos Tavisi xarjebis anazRaure-ba~, rac Segebebuli sarCelis moTxovnis samarTlebriv sa-fuZvels warmoadgenda da ganmarta, am nawilSi gasaziare-beli iyo pirveli instanciis sasamarTlos Sefaseba, romsafuZvlis gareSe gamdidreba moicavs, rogorc viTom-kreditoris qonebrivi aqtivis gazrdas, ise mis mier sxvapiris xarjze qonebis dazogvas; Sesabamisad, ssk-is 986-emuxlis Sinaarsi Seicavs zogadad usafuZvlo gamdidre-bis institutisaTvis damaxasiaTebel konstruqcias, sa-dac mesame piris moqmedeba iwvevs sxva piris gamdidre-bas, yovelgvari samarTlebrivi safuZvlis gareSe. amgvarviTarebaSi SemZeni valdebulia, daabrunos mis mier miRe-buli sikeTe, miuxedavad imisa, Tu visma moqmedebam gamo-iwvia misi gamdidreba.

15.27.2. dadgenili iyo, am gadawyvetilebis 1-3 pun-qtebSi miTiTebuli pirobebiT xelSekrulebis gaformebapirvel gamyidvelsa da pirvel mopasuxes Soris. pirveliinstanciis sasamarTlo miuTiTebda ssk-is 373-e muxlisme-2 nawilze, romlis Tanaxmad, Tu valdebulebis Sesru-leba miiRo im pirma, romelic ar iyo uflebamosili, val-debuleba CaiTvleba Sesrulebulad maSin, roca kredi-torma misca amis Tanxmoba an am Sesrulebisagan miiRo sar-gebeli.

15.27.3. zogadi principis Tanaxmad, valdebulebis Ses-rulebis adresats warmoadgens samarTlebrivi urTier-Tobis subieqti, Tumca, samoqalaqo kodeqsi dasaSvebadmiiCnevs Sesrulebis realizacias mesame piris sasar-geblod, mxolod kreditoris TanxmobiT; amasTan, saxel-Sekrulebo urTierTobis uSualo mxareebi inarCuneben sa-marTlebriv mdgomareobas da mesame piris mimarT gan-xorcielebuli Sesruleba gulisxmobs valdebulebis Ses-rulebas kreditoris mimarT; Sesabamisad, rogorc gari-

41

gebis Sinaarsi, ise misi subieqturi Semadgenloba rCebaucvleli.

15.27.4. dadgenili iyo is garemoebac, rom am urTier-Tobidan gamomdinare, pirvel gamyidvels pretenzia ar ga-aCnda Tavdapirveli mosarCelis mimarT;

15.28. zemoaRniSnulidan gamomdinare, saapelacio sa-samarTlom gaiziara qvemdgomi sasamarTlos daskvna, romgansaxilvel SemTxvevaSi ar arsebobda ssk-is 986-e mux-liT gaTvaliswinebuli safuZvliT Segebebuli sarCelis(Tavdapirveli mosarCelisaTvis 50 000 aSS dolaris, ro-gorc usafuZvlod miRebuli Tanxis, pirveli mopasuxisaT-vis dabrunebis) dakmayofilebis pirobebi.

15.29. saapelacio sasamarTlom aseve usafuZvlod mi-iCnia pirveli mopasuxis Segebebuli sarCelis moTxovnamassa da Tavdapirvel mosarCeles Soris 2011 wlis 23 de-kembers dadebuli xelSekrulebis (ix. am gadawyvetile-bis me-5 punqti) baTilad cnobis Taobaze; mxare moTxovnissamarTlebriv safuZvlad miuTiTebda ssk-is 320-e muxls;am normis Tanaxmad, baTilia xelSekruleba, romliTac er-Ti mxare kisrulobs valdebulebas, mTeli Tavisi momava-li qoneba an qonebis nawili gadasces sxvas anda uzuf-ruqtiT datvirTos igi, garda im SemTxvevebisa, roca xel-Sekruleba dadebulia momavali qonebis calkeul niv-Tebze.

15.29.1. sasamarTlos SefasebiT, gansaxilvel SemTxve-vaSi, rogorc ukve aRiniSna, mxareebs Soris dadebuli ze-moaRniSnuli garigebiT gansazRvruli iyo ZiriTadi mo-sarCelis mxridan am xelSekrulebiT nakisri valdebule-bis Sesrulebis SemTxvevaSi (garigebis me-5 muxli), pirve-li mopasuxis mier, mis sakuTrebaSi xelSekrulebiT gaT-valiswinebuli qonebis gadasvlisTanave, SeTanxmebuliwesiT da pirobebis dacviT mosarCelisaTvis qonebis mi-yidva, rac ar ewinaaRmdegeba zemoaRniSnuli normis moT-xovnas; miT umetes im garemoebis gaTvaliswinebiT, rompirveli mopasuxe, romelic misive ganmartebiT, warmoad-genda investors (amgvaradaa igi moxseniebuli am gadaw-yvetilebis pirvel da meoTxe punqtebSi miTiTebul xel-SekrulebebSi), misive komerciuli interesebidan gamom-dinare, dainteresebuli iyo mxareTa Soris sadavo urTi-erTobebis mowesrigebiT sasamarTlo davis gareSe, obieq-tis mSeneblobis droulad dasrulebiT da Sesabamisad,

42

am mizniT debda sxvadasxva garigebebs; zemoaRniSnuli ga-rigeba ar ewinaaRmdgeba kanoniT gaTvaliswinebul moT-xovnebs da am garigebis dadebiT pirvel mopasuxes ar ukis-ria mTeli misi momavali qonebis ZiriTadi mosarCelisaT-vis gadacema.

16. pirveli da meore mopasuxeebis sakasacio saCivari16.1. pirvelma da meore mopasuxeebma saksacio wesiT

gaasaCivres saapelacio sasamarTlos gadawyvetileba, mo-iTxoves misi gauqmeba ZiriTadi mosarCelis dakmayofile-buli moTxovnis nawilSi (ix. am gadawyvetilebis 15.1.2-15.1.3. da 15.2 qvepunqtebi) da, axali gadawyvetilebis mi-RebiT, ZiriTadi sarCelis uaryofa, pirveli mopasuxis Se-gebebuli sarCelis dakmayofileba da, aseve, mosarCeli-saTvis sasamarTlo xarjebis dakisreba Semdeg pretenzi-ebze dayrdnobiT (ix. sakasacio saCivari da dazustebulisakasacio saCivari):

16.1.1. sssk-is 391-e muxlis mexuTe nawilis danawesismixedviT qonebriv da sxva araqonebriv davebze sakasaciosaCivari uzenaesi sasamarTlos mier daiSveba, Tu: a) saqmemniSvnelovania samarTlis ganviTarebisa da erTgvarova-ni sasamarTlo praqtikis CamoyalibebisaTvis; (am SemTxve-vaSi kanonmdebels mxedvelobaSi aqvs samarTlis konkre-tuli normis erTgvarovani ganmartebisa da gagebis sazo-gado (sayovelTao) interesis arseboba, romelic xels uw-yobs, rogorc samarTlebrivi usafrTxoebis ganmtkicebas,ise marTlmsajulebis calkeuli sakiTxebis ganviTarebas).b) saapelacio sasamarTlos gadawyvetileba gansvavdebaam kategoriis saqmeebze saqarTvelos uzenaesi sasamar-Tlos samoqalaqo saqmeTa palatis mier dadgenili praq-tikisgan (ix. saqarTvelos uzenaesi sasamarTlos saqmee-bi: #as-661-628-2014, #as-459-438-2015); g) saapelacio sa-samarTlos mier saqme ganxilulia sssk-is 105-e muxlismoTxovnaTa uxeSi darRveviT: saqmis faqtobrivi garemo-ebebi arasworad aris dadgenili, arsebuli mtkicebule-bebi ar aris Sefasebuli maT erTobliobaSi, ar aris miTi-Teba im garemoebebze, romlis gamoc sasamarTlom zogi-erTi mtkicebuleba cno utyuarad, xolo sxvebi _ arasar-wmunod. Sesabamisad, mniSvnelovanma procesualurma dar-Rvevebma, gamoiwvia araswori gadawyvetilebis miReba;

16.1.2. saapelacio sasamarTlom gadawyvetilebis miRe-bisas gamoiyena ssk-is me-8, 56-e, 361-e da 986-e muxlebi,

43

aseve 412-e aseve 394-e muxlis pirveli nawili da 373-e mux-lis meore nawili da miiCnia, rom arsebobda TavdapirvelimosarCelis saapelacio saCivris nawilobriv dakmayofi-lebis faqtobrivi da samarTlebrivi safuZveli, ris Se-degadac gaauqma Tbilisis saqalaqo sasamarTlos samoqa-laqo saqmeTa kolegiis gadawyvetileba. sasamarTlos mi-er gamoyenebul normaTagan, kasatoris mosazrebiT mxo-lod ori, ssk-is 394-e muxlis pirveli nawili da 986-e mux-li, warmoadgens moTxovnis safuZvels. ssk-s 394-e muxlispirveli nawilis Tanaxmad, `movalis mier valdebulebisdarRvevisas kreditors SeuZlia moiTxovos amiT gamow-veuli zianis anazRaureba. es wesi ar moqmedebs maSin, ro-ca movales ar ekisreba pasuxismgebloba valdebulebisdarRvevisaTvis~, 986-e muxlis Tanaxmad ki, `pirs, rome-lic Segnebulad an SecdomiT sxvis valebs istumrebs, Se-uZlia am pirs mosTxovos Tavisi xarjebis anazRaureba~.

16.1.3. sasamarTlom ise miiRo gadawyvetileba, rom ardaudgenia, ra urTierToba arsebobda mxareTa Soris, ro-mel mxares ra evaleboda da saidan warmoiSva moTxovna.

16.2. kasatori uTiTebs am gadawyvetilebis 1-3 pun-qtebSi asaxuli pirobebiT gaformebul xelSekrulebazepirvel gamyidvelsa da pirvel mopasuxes (romelic kasa-toria) Soris. nasyidobis safasuris _ 50 000 aSS dolarismiRebaze uflebamosil pirs warmoadgenda pirveli gam-yidveli, romlis warmomadgenelma _ Tavdapirvelma mo-sarCelem 2012 wlis 10 Tebervals morigebisas daadastu-ra Tanxis miRebis faqti, magram uZravi qoneba ar gadauciapirveli mopasuxisaTvis sakuTrebaSi. aqedan gamomdina-re, 2011 wlis 1 dekembris xelSekruleba ar Sesrulebu-la;

16.3. am gadawyvetilebis me-4 punqtSi miTiTebul xel-SekrulebasTan dakavSirebiT kasatori aRniSnavs, rom 2011wlis 3 dekembers meore gamyidvelsa da pirvel mopasuxesSoris daido samarTlebrivi urTierTobis morigebiT das-rulebis xelSekruleba (#111324013 sanotaro aqti), rom-lis safuZvelze, meore gamyidvelma sakuTrebis uflebiTgadasca pirvel mopasuxes araerTi uZravi qoneba (ix. amgadawyvetilebis 4.1-4.7 qvepunqtebi).

16.3.1. zemoxsenebuli qonebis sakuTrebaSi miRebis sa-nacvlod pirvelma mopasuxem Seasrula Semdegi valdebu-lebebi:

44

_ meore gamyidvelis Svils _ e. J-as sakuTrebaSi gadas-ca 80 kv.m. sacxovrebeli farTi 15 000 aSS dolaris Rire-bulebis remontiT;

_ meore gamyidvels gadauxada 130 000 aSS dolari, racam ukanasknelis davalebiT gadasca ZiriTad mosarCeles(anu am ukanasknelma pirveli mopasuxisagan naRdi fulissaxiT miiRo 180 000 aSS dolari, am gadawyvetilebis 16.2.qvepunqtSi miTiTebuli miRebuli Tanxis _ 50 000 aSS do-laris CaTvliT);

_ g. k-s gadauxada 47 000 aSS dolari;_ Seasrula amxanagobis wevrebis: m. o-is, T.. m-is mem-

kvidris m. k-isa da e. e-is mimarT aRebuli valdebulebebi.16.3.2. kasatori uTiTebs am gadawyvetilebis me-5 pun-

qtSi asaxuli 2011 wlis 23 dekembris xelSekrulebis pi-robebze da ofciis xelSekrulebis samarTlebriv mowes-rigebaze, romelic asaxulia ssk-is 515-e muxlSi, romlisTanaxmad, mxareebi SeiZleba SeTanxmdnen, rom myidvelscalmxrivad aqvs ufleba, esa Tu is sagani SeiZinos gan-sazRvrul dromde an gansazRvrul movlenamde (Sesyidvisofcia), anda, imave pirobebSi gamyidvels ufleba aqvs sa-gani myidvels mihyidos (gayidvis ofcia). ofciis xel-Sekrulebis mimarT gamoiyeneba nasyidobis xelSekrule-bis normebi, Tuki mxareebi sxva rameze ar SeTanxmebulanda imeorebs pirveli instanciis sasamarTlos mier am kon-teqstSi ganviTarebul msjelobasa da daskvnebs (ix. am ga-dawyvetilebis 13.4.-13.10 qvepunqtebi);

16.3.3. kasatoris mtkicebiT, mxareTa Soris ofciis Zi-riTadi xelSekruleba ar dadebula, vinaidan pirvelma mo-pasuxem, misgan damoukidebeli mizezebis gamo, ver miiRosakuTrebaSi ZiriTadi mosarCelisaTvis gadasacemi qone-bebi. mxareebs arc imis mcdeloba hqoniaT, rom moeTxovaTxelSekrulebis misadageba Secvlili garemoebebisadmi.ssk-s 398-e muxlis Tanaxmad, `1. Tu is garemoebebi, romle-bic xelSekrulebis dadebis safuZveli gaxda, xelSekru-lebis dadebis Semdeg aSkarad Seicvala da mxareebi ar da-debdnen am xelSekrulebas an dadebdnen sxva SinaarsiT,es cvlilebebi, rom gaeTvaliswinebinaT, maSin SeiZlebamoTxovnil iqnes xelSekrulebis misadageba Secvlili ga-remoebebisadmi. winaaRmdeg SemTxvevaSi, calkeul gare-moebaTa gaTvaliswinebiT, xelSekrulebis mxares ar SeiZ-leba moeTxovos Seucvleli xelSekrulebis mkacrad dac-

45

va... 3. mxareebi jer unda Seecadon, rom xelSekruleba mi-usadagon Secvlil garemoebebs, Tuki SeuZlebelia xel-Sekrulebis misadageba Secvlili garemoebebisadmi, an me-ore mxare amas ar eTanxmeba, maSin im mxares, romlis inte-resebic dairRva, SeuZlia uari Tqvas xelSekrulebaze~.

16.3.4. kasatoris mtkicebiT, imis gaTvaliswinebiT, rommxareTa Soris ar arsebobs namdvili xelSekruleba, racgamoricxavs pirveladi moTxovnis dakmayofilebas (of-ciis xelSekrulebis dadeba), Sesabamisad, ver dadgeba amurTierTobidan gamomdinare meoradi moTxovnis _ zianisanazRaurebis valdebuleba. miuxedavad amisa, saapelaciosasamarTlos daskvniT, Tavdapirvelma mosarCelem daa-dastura mis mier mxareTa Soris 2011 wlis 23 dekembrisxelSekrulebiT nakisri valdebulebis Sesruleba da ase-ve daadastura pirveli mopasuxis mxridan mis winaSe amavegarigebiT nakisri valdebulebebis Seusrulebloba; Ta-vis mxriv, pirvelma mopasuxem ver daamtkica garemoebe-bi, romlebic gamoricxavda mis mier mosarCelis winaSevaldebulebis Sesrulebas. aRniSnulis gaTvaliswinebiT,sasamarTlom daaskvna, rom arsebobda mosarCelis sasar-geblod pirveli mopasuxisaTvis (b. p-isaTvis) mxareebs So-ris dadebuli 2011 wlis 23 dekembris xelSekrulebis me-6punqtiT gansazRvruli zianis dakisrebis safuZveli.

16.3.5. saapelacio sasamarTlom ar gaiTvaliswina, romZiriTadma mosarCelem, rogorc pirveli gamyidvelis war-momadgenelma, ar Seasrula 2011 wlis 1 dekembris xel-Sekrulebis pirobebi. Sesabamisad, uZravi qonebis sakuT-rebaSi miRebis gareSe ver Seasrulebda 2011 wlis 23 de-kembris xelSekrulebiT nakisr valdebulebas, aRniSnu-li xelSekrulebis pirobebi arc erT mxares ar Seusrule-bia, mxareebma uari Tqves xelSekrulebaze. ssk-is 394-emuxlis pirveli nawilis mixedviT, movalis mier valdebu-lebis darRvevisas kreditors SeuZlia moiTxovos amiTgamowveuli zianis anazRaureba. miTiTebuli norma gan-sazRvravs im aucilebel winapirobebs, romlebic unda ar-sebobdes xelSekrulebis darRveviT gamowveuli zianismoTxovnis uflebis warmoSobisaTvis; kerZod, unda arse-bobdes ziani, braleuli qmedeba da mizezobrivi kavSiridarRvevasa da damdgar Sedegs Soris. amdenad, saqmezedadgenili faqtobrivi garemoebebi unda SeesabamebodesaRniSnul normaSi miTiTebuli konstruqcias.

46

16.3.6. ssk-is 394-e muxli adgens princips, romlis mi-xedviT, ziani unda anazRaurdes sruli moculobiT. mo-sarCelis mier moTxovnili zianis moculoba daangariSe-bulia im uZravi nivTebis sabazro RirebulebiT, romelickreditors unda mieRo ofciis xelSekrulebis gaforme-bisas. aRniSnuli norma gansazRvravs zianis anazRaure-bis samarTlebriv winapirobebs, Tumca, zianis iuridiuliSedegi mocemulia amave kodeqsis 408-e muxlSi, romlisTanaxmad, im pirma, romelic valdebulia aanazRauros zi-ani, unda aRadginos is mdgomareoba, romelic iarsebob-da, rom ar damdgariyo anazRaurebis mavaldebulebeli ga-remoeba. imis gaTvaliswinebiT, rom kasators (pirvel mo-pasuxes da imavdroulad Segebebuli sarCelis avtors) ardaurRvevia raime valdebuleba, mas ar unda daekisros zi-anis anazRaurebis valdebuleba;

16.3.7. kasatori uTiTebs saqarTvelos uzenaesi sasa-marTlos samoqalaqo saqmeTa palatis 2015 wlis mniSvne-lovan ganmartebaze, romelic exeba xelSekrulebidan gas-vlis SemTxvevaSi, miuRebeli Semosavlis saxiT, damdgarizianis anazRaurebis dakisrebisTvis aucilebel samar-Tlebriv aspeqts (saqme #as-459-438-2015). xelSekrule-biT gaTvaliswinebuli valdebulebis darRveviT miyene-buli zianis anazRaurebis moTxovnasTan mimarTebaSi, sa-kasacio sasamarTlom, upirvelesad, Seafasa zianis, ro-gorc meoradi moTxovnis, warmoSobis samarTlebrivi sa-fuZvlebis arseboba. sasamarTlos ganmartebiT, ziani ariskanoniT gaTvaliswinebuli anazRaurebadi sxvaoba ùndayofiliyo~ da àris mdgomareobas~ Soris (sxvaobis hipo-Teza) da am TvalsazrisiT, sakasacio palatis ganmartebissagani gaxda ssk-is 394-e muxlis pirveli nawili, aseve 408-e muxlis pirveli nawili.

16.3.8. kasatori zemoxsenebul mniSvnelovan ganmarte-baze dayrdnobiT aRniSnavs, rom sakasacio sasamarTlosmosazrebiT, normiT dadgenili zianis anazRaurebis, ro-gorc pirvandeli mdgomareobis aRdgenis valdebuleba-Si, swored im faqtobrivi mdgomareobis aRdgena igulis-xmeba, romelic iarsebebda, rom ara valdebulebis dar-Rveva (totalreparation-is principi). amasTanave, mniSvnelobaar aqvs, Tu ramdenad maRalia movalis braleulobis (gan-zraxva Tu gaufrTxilebloba) xarisxi zianis dadgomaSi.Tumca, es wesi izRudeba, Tu kreditori Tanabraleulia.

47

sakasacio sasamarTlos ganmartebiT, sruli anazRaurebaexeba ara saerTod zians, romelic SeiZleba vinmem ganica-dos, aramed im zians, romelic samoqalaqo pasuxismgeblo-bis saerTo safuZvlidan gamomdinare anazRaurebadia.anazRaurebas eqvemdebareba is ziani, romelic movalisaT-vis winaswar iyo savaraudo da warmoadgens zianis gamom-wvevi moqmedebis uSualo Sedegs. rodesac xelSekrule-bis mxare kisrulobs valdebulebas, mas mxedvelobaSi aqvsmxolod im riskis aReba, romelic kanonzomierad aris da-kavSirebuli xelSekrulebis SesrulebasTan. aRniSnuli-dan gamomdinare, misgan SeiZleba moTxovnil iqnes mxo-lod im zianis anazRaureba, romelic xelSekrulebis dar-Rvevis normalur Sedegad aRiqmeba. ssk-is 412-e muxli mo-vales aTavisuflebs iseTi riskebisagan, rac miuRebeliaqonebrivi pasuxismgeblobis Cveulebrivi principebisaT-vis. mosarCelem unda daamtkicos, rom mis mier gancdiliziani aris xelSekrulebis darRvevis Cveulebrivi da nor-maluri Sedegi. zianis savaraudoba dgindeba gonivrulo-bis TvalsazrisiT da ar ganisazRvreba konkretuli xel-Sekrulebis damrRvevis subieqturi SesaZleblobebiT.

16.3.9. movalem ziani yovelTvis unda aanazRauros, mag-ram xelSekrulebiT nakisri riskis farglebSi. kasatorismtkicebiT, mas ar daurRvevia arc erTi xelSekrulebispiroba, amdenad, mas ar unda daekisros ziani, miT umetesim pirobebSi, roca valdebulebebi mosarCelem ar Seas-rula.

16.3.10. kasatoris pretenzia imasac ukavSirdeba, romsasamarTlos ar unda ecno baTilad pirvel da meore mo-pasuxeebs (romlebic sakasacio saCivris avtorebi arian)Soris 2011 wlis 23 maiss gaformebuli oTxi nasyidobisxelSekruleba (ix. am gadawyvetilebis 8.1-8.4 qvepunqte-bi). xelSekrulebis baTiloba Tavisi samarTlebrivi bune-biT aRiarebiT sarCels warmoadgens. Sesabamisad, misTvisdamaxasiaTebelia iuridiuli interesis arseboba. saqar-Tvelos samoqalaqo saproceso kodeqsi samarTlebriviurTierTobis arseboba-ararsebobis dadgenis samar-Tlebriv saSualebad aRiarebiT sarCels iTvaliswinebs.Tumca, am saxis sarCelebi, rogorc aRiniSna, yovelTvisSezRudulia iuridiuli interesiT, anu sarCelis dakma-yofilebis aucilebel winapirobas warmoadgens im iuri-diuli Sedegebis miRwevadoba, risi dadgomac surs sarCe-

48

lis avtors amgvari aRiarebiT. samoqalaqo saproceso ka-nonmdeblobiT gaTvaliswinebuli iuridiuli interesimniSvnelovani samarTlebrivi movlenaa. aseTi interesisarseboba yovelTvis gulisxmobs, rom mxare garkveul mniS-vnelobas aniWebs interesis obieqts. Tumca, gasaTvalis-winebelia, rom iuridiuli interesi ar ganisazRvreba mxo-lod piris subieqturi damokidebulebiT, anu mxolod mi-si surviliT, aramed aucilebelia misi obieqturi mxarec.obieqturi TvalsazrisiT, interesi moicavs Sedegebs, ro-melic sazogadoebrivi cxovrebis sxvadasxva sferoSi ar-sebobs. aRniSnuli Sedegebi aucileblad unda iyos gan-sazRvruli samarTlis normebiT. swored Sedegebis amgva-ri samarTlebrivi dacva ganapirobebs interesebis iuri-diul bunebas. amdenad iuridiuli interesebis miRweva-dobis aucilebel winapirobas warmoadgens is garemoeba,Tu samarTlebrivad ramdenad daculia Sedegebi, romel-Ta dadgomac surs mosarCeles.

16.3.11. gansaxilveli davis farglebSi, mosarCelis sa-marTlebriv interess xelSekrulebis baTilobis mimarT,warmoadgens moTxovnili zianis anazRaurebis SemTxveva-Si, aRsrulebisaTvis xelsayreli pirobebis Seqmna. gamom-dinare iqidan, rom sasamarTlos ar unda daekmayofile-bina mosarCelis moTxovna zianis anazRaurebis Taobaze,ar arsebobs mosarCelis iuridiuli interesi dasaxele-buli xelSekrulebebis baTilobis mimarT.

16.4. sasamarTlom aseve usafuZvlod ar daakmayofilapirveli mopasuxis Segebebuli sarCelis moTxovna mosar-CelisaTvis 50 000 aSS dolaris dakisrebis nawilSi.

16.4.1. kasatori uTiTebs 2011 wlis 1 dekembers pirvelgamyidvelsa da pirvel mopasuxes (kasators) Soris dade-buli samarTlebrivi urTierTobis sasamarTlosgareSe mo-wesrigebis xelSekrulebis pirobebze (ix. am gadawyveti-lebis 1-3 punqtebi) da aRniSnavs, rom mas gadaxdili aqvs50 000 aSS dolari, rac dasturdeba Tbilisis saqalaqo sa-samarTlos 2012 wlis 10 Tebervlis ganCinebiT saqmeze #2/6464-06 mxareTa morigebis gamo saqmiswarmoebis SewyvetisSesaxeb (muxli 13, 2011 wlis 13 dekembris #111358848, sa-marTlebrivi urTierTobis morigebiT dasrulebis Sesa-xeb muxli 24, pirveli gamyidvelis uflebebis Sesaxeb da2011 wlis 28 dekembris xelSekrulebiT samarTlebrivi ur-TierTobis morigebiT dasrulebis Sesaxeb, muxli 13 _ pir-

49

veli gamyidvelis uflebebis Sesaxeb). amasTan, pirvelmagamyidvelma Tanxis gadacema daavala mosarCeles (am uka-nasknels Tanxa miRebuli aqvs, aRniSnuli faqti dadas-turebulia mravali dokumentiT);

16.4.2. kasatori ssk-is 986-e muxlze dayrdnobiT aR-niSnavs, rom safuZvlis gareSe gamdidreba moicavs, ro-gorc viTom-kreditoris qonebrivi interesis gazrdas, ise_ mis mier sxva piris xarjze qonebis dazogvas, Sesabami-sad, ssk-is 986-e muxlis Sinaarsi Seicavs zogadad usafuZ-vlo gamdidrebis institutisaTvis damaxasiaTebel kon-struqcias, sadac mesame piris moqmedeba iwvevs sxva pi-ris gamdidrebas, yovelgvari samarTlebrivi safuZvlisgareSe. amgvar viTarebaSi, Tanxis mimRebi valdebulia da-abrunos mis mier miRebuli sikeTe, miuxedavad imisa, Tuvisma moqmedebam gamoiwvia misi gamdidreba.

17. sakasacio samarTalwarmoebis etapi17.1. saqarTvelos uzenaesi sasamarTlos samoqalaqo

saqmeTa palatis 2017 wlis 16 Tebervlis ganCinebiT saka-sacio ganacxadi warmoebaSia miRebuli sssk-is 391-e mux-lis safuZvelze dasaSvebobis winapirobebis Sesamow-meblad, xolo amave wlis 5 maisis ganCinebiT cnobili iqnadasaSvebad arsebiTad gansaxilvelad, dasaxelebuli mux-lis me-5 nawilis à~ da è~ qvepunqtebis safuZvelze.

samotivacio nawili:sakasacio sasamarTlo saqmis arsebiTad ganxilvis, mxa-

reTa ganmartebebis Seswavlisa da mtkicebulebaTa er-Toblivad gaanalizebis Sedegad mivida daskvnamde, romnawilobriv unda dakmayofildes pirveli da meore mopa-suxeebis mier warmodgenili sakasacio saCivari da saape-lacio sasamarTlos samoqalaqo saqmeTa palatis gasaCiv-rebuli gadawyvetileba nawilobriv unda Seicvalos. sa-kasacio sasamarTlos mier miRebuli axali gadawyvetile-biT, Tavdapirveli mosarCelis sasarCelo moTxovna ar dak-mayofilda, Sesabamisad, gauqmda sarCelis uzrunvelyo-fis mizniT gamoyenebuli RonisZiebebi (ix. am gadawyveti-lebis sarezolucio nawili) xolo pirveli mopasuxis Se-gebebuli sarCelis uaryofis nawilSi, saapelacio sasamar-Tlos gasaCivrebuli gadawyvetileba ucvlelad darCa.

18. sssk-is 404-e muxlis pirveli nawiliT, sakasacio sa-samarTlo gadawyvetilebas amowmebs sakasacio saCivris

50

farglebSi, amave kodeqsis 407-e muxlis pirveli nawiliT,sakasacio sasamarTlo imsjelebs mxaris mxolod im axsna-ganmartebaze, romelic asaxulia sasamarTlo gadawyveti-lebebSi da sxdomis oqmebSi. garda amisa, SeiZleba mxedve-lobaSi iqnes miRebuli am kodeqsis 396-e muxlis pirvelinawilis `v~ qvepunqtSi miTiTebuli faqtebi; amave muxlisme-2 nawilis Tanaxmad, saapelacio sasamarTlos mier dam-tkicebulad cnobili faqtobrivi garemoebebi savalde-buloa sakasacio sasamarTlosaTvis, Tu wamoyenebuli araris dasaSvebi da dasabuTebuli pretenzia (Sedaveba). sa-kasacio sasamarTlos miaCnia, rom kasatoris (pirveli dameore mopasuxeebis) pretenziaTa nawili dasabuTebulia.

19. sakasacio sasamarTlo aRniSnavs, rom adamianis uf-lebaTa evropuli konvenciis me-6 muxlis pirveli parag-rafi avaldebulebs sasamarTlos, daasabuTos Tavisi ga-dawyvetileba, rac ar unda iqnes gagebuli TiToeul ar-gumentze detaluri pasuxis gacemad (ix. jRarkava saqar-Tvelos winaaRmdeg, # 7932/03; Van de Hurk v. Netherlands, par.61,Garcia Ruiz v. Spain [GC] par.26; Jahnke and Lenoble v France (dec.);Perez v France [GC], par. 81; Hirvisaari v. Finland, §32)

20. uwinaresad, sakasacio sasamarTlo yuradRebas gaa-maxvilebs gansaxilveli davis mxareebze da maT Soris ar-sebuli saxelSekrulebo urTierTobis faqtobriv safuZ-vlebze, raTa moZiebuli iqnes sasarCelo moTxovnis dam-fuZnebeli norma, anu materialuri kanonis imgvari dis-pozicia, romelic mosarCelis mier wardgenili sarCeliTmoTxovnili iuridiuli Sedegis Semcvelia.

21. `sakasacio sasamarTlom araerT saqmeSi ganmarta,rom sasamarTlos upirvelesi amocanaa, daadginos, Tu rasiTxovs mosarCele mopasuxisagan da ris safuZvelze, anuromel faqtobriv garemoebebze amyarebs Tavis moTxovnas.sasamarTlom mxaris mier miTiTebuli moTxovnis far-glebSi unda moZebnos is samarTlebrivi norma (normebi),romelic im Sedegs iTvaliswinebs, risi miRwevac mxaressurs. amasTan, moTxovnis samarTlebriv safuZvlad ganxi-luli norma (an normebi) Seicavs im aRwerilobas (faq-tobriv Semadgenlobas), romlis Semowmebac sasamarTlosprerogativaa da romelic unda ganxorcieldes logiku-ri meTodebis gamoyenebis gziT, anu sasamarTlom unda da-adginos, normaSi moyvanili abstraqtuli aRweriloba ram-denad Seesabameba konkretul cxovrebiseul situacias

51

da gamoitanos Sesabamisi daskvnebi. is mxare, romelsacaqvs moTxovna meore mxarisadmi, sul mcire, unda uTiTeb-des im faqtobriv Semadgenlobaze, romelsac samarTlisnorma gvTavazobs. aqedan gamomdinare, SegviZlia davas-kvnaT, rom moTxovnis samarTlebrivi safuZvlis romeli-me faqtobrivi wanamZRvris (samarTlebrivi winapirobis)ararseboba gamoricxavs mxarisaTvis sasurveli samar-Tlebrivi Sedegis dadgomas (ix. susg #as-15-29-1443-2012,09.12.2013w.; Sdr. susg saqme #as-973-1208-04) _ ix. saqar-Tvelos uzenaesi sasamarTlos 2017 wlis 2 martis didipalatis gadawyvetileba saqmeze #664-635-2016, 187-e pun-qti.

22. gansaxilvel saqmeSi sakasacio sasamarTlo qrono-logiuri TanmimdevrobiT gaamaxvilebs yuradRebas ram-denime konkretul xelSekrulebaze da mis mxareebze, ra-Ta davis farglebSi swori samarTlebrivi kvalifikacia mi-aniWos mxareTa Soris arsebul urTierTobas.

23. saqmis masalebSia 2011 wlis 1 dekembris sanotarowesiT dadasturebuli xelSekruleba samarTlebrivi ur-TierTobebis sasamarTlosgareSe mowesrigebis Sesaxeb(sssk-is 37.1 muxli), romelic xelmowerilia am gadawyve-tilebis pirvel punqtSi miTiTebuli pirveli gamyidve-lisa da pirveli mopasuxis, rogorc myidvelis, mier. xel-Sekrulebis me-2 muxlis me-2 punqtis Tanaxmad, pirveligamyidveli aris individualuri binaTmSeneblobis amxa-nagobis `v-s~ saqmianobis farglebSi warmoSobil samoqa-laqo davaze TanamosarCele; me-5 muxlis safuZvelze, pir-veli gamyidveli (r. b.-i) sakuTrebaSi gadascems pirvelmyidvels (b. p-s), xolo es ukanaskneli miiRebs mSenebarefarTs (me-9 sarTuli, bina 22, 100 kvm, s/k 0...), risTvisacmyidvelma unda gadaixados 50 000 (ormocdaaTi aTasi) aSSdolaris ekvivalenti larSi; amave xelSekrulebis me-2muxlis me-6 punqtis Tanaxmad, myidveli (b. p-i) ar aris gam-yidvelisa (anu am gadawyvetilebis pirvel punqtSi miTi-Tebuli pirveli gamyidvelis) da mosarCeleebis urTier-Tobebis/davis monawile, magram igi, rogorc investori,Tavisi komerciuli interesebidan gamomdinare, monawile-obs mxareTa Soris sadavo urTierTobebis mowesrigebaSida dainteresebulia davis sasamarTlosgareSe gadawyve-taSi.

24. zemoxsenebuli xelSekrulebis me-5 muxlis me-3

52

punqtiT am gadawyvetilebis pirvel punqtSi miTiTebulipirveli gamyidveli avalebs myidvels (anu am davaSi pir-vel mopasuxes), rom mSenebare farTis SesaZenad gadasax-deli Tanxa _ 50 000 aSS dolari srulad gadasces Tavda-pirvel mosarCeles (ix. am gadawyvetilebis me-2 punqti).amave xelSekrulebis me-5 muxlis me-5 punqtis Tanaxmad,Tanxis miRebis aucilebeli pirobaa uflebrivad unaklo(yovelgvari valdebulebisagan Tavisufali) farTis gada-cema myidvelisaTvis (anu pirveli mopasuxisaTvis) da amukanasknelisaTvis gadacemuli farTis SeuzRudav (pir-veli gamyidvelis valdebulebebisagan Tavisufal) sakuT-rebad registracia. Tavdapirveli mosarCelisaTvis (g. m-isaTvis) am Tanxis gadacema CaiTvleba pirveli gamyidve-lis (r. b.-is) mimarT pirveli mopasuxis, romelic am Sem-TxvevaSi myidvelia (b. p-is, romelmac 50 000 aSS dolariunda gadauxados), mier valdebulebis Sesrulebad;

25. farTis gadacema moxdeba mas Semdeg, rac farTi ga-Tavisufldeba yvela yadaRisa da valdebulebisagan dafarTis gadacemis Sesaxeb Sedgeba Sesabamisi aqti (ix.01.12.2011 w. xelSekrulebis me-5 muxlis 5-6 punqtebi).

26. saqmis masalebSia 2011 wlis 3 dekembris sanotarowesiT dadasturebuli xelSekruleba samarTlebrivi ur-TierTobebis sasamarTlosgareSe mowesrigebis Sesaxeb,romelic xelmowerilia am gadawyvetilebis me-4 punqtSimiTiTebuli meore gamyidvelisa da pirveli mopasuxis,rogorc myidvelis, mier. xelSekrulebis me-2 muxlis me-2punqtis Tanaxmad, meore gamyidveli aris individualuribinaTmSeneblobis amxanagobis `v-s~ saqmianobis farglebSiwarmoSobil samoqalaqo davaze TanamosarCele; me-5 mux-lis safuZvelze, meore gamyidveli (v. J-a) sakuTrebaSi ga-dascems pirvel mopasuxes, romelic am xelSekrulebiTmyidvelia (b. p-s), xolo es ukanaskneli miiRebs winamdeba-re gadawyvetilebis 4.1-4.7 qvepunqtebSi miTiTebul far-Tebs. aRniSnuli farTebis sanacvlod myidvelma (anu pir-velma mopasuxem) ikisra am gadawyvetilebis 10.2.1 qvepun-qtSi miTiTebuli valdebuleba.

27. sakasacio sasamarTlo ganmartavs, rom 2011 wlis 1da 3 dekembris xelSekrulebebSi pirveli mopasuxis (b. p-is) monawileoba myidvelis statusiT ganpirobebulia araimiT, rom igi individualuri binaTmSeneblobis amxanago-bis `v-s~ saqmianobidan warmoSobili urTierTobis monawi-

53

lea da pirveli da meore gamyidvelebis (r. b.-isa da v. J-as_ ix. am gadawyvetilebis pirveli da meoTxe punqtebi), ro-gorc TanamosarCeleebis mxarezea an maTi procesualurimowinaaRmdegea anu mopasuxea, aramed, igi, rogorc in-vestori, monawileobs mxareTa Soris sadavo urTierTo-bebis mowesrigebaSi da dainteresebulia urTierTobebismowesrigebiT sasamarTlo davis gareSe (ix. samarTlebri-vi urTierTobebis sasamarTlosgareSe mowesrigebis Sesa-xeb 01.12.2011w. da 03.12.2011w. xelSekrulebebis, me-2 mux-lis me-6 punqti), Sesabamisad, am ormxriv xelSekrulebebsxels aweren mxolod gamyidveli (01.12.2011w. xelSekru-lebaSi _ v. b.-i [pirveli gamyidveli] _ ix. am gadawyvetile-bis pirveli punqti; 03.12.2011w. xelSekrulebaSi _ v. J-a[meore gamyidveli ] _ ix. am gadawyvetilebis meoTxe pun-qti] da myidveli [orive miTiTebul xelSekrulebaSi _ b.p-i]. 01.12.2011w. da 03.12.2011w. xelSekrulebebs xels araweren sasamarTloSi mimdinare samarTalwarmoebis mxa-reebi _ pirvel da meore gamyidvelebTan (r. b.-Tan da v. J-asTan) erTad saqmiswarmoebis monawile sxva mosarCelee-bi da maTi mopasuxeebi.

28. sakasacio sasamarTlo 01.12.2011w. da 03.12.2011w. xel-Sekrulebebs, maTi Sinaarsis gaTvaliswinebiT, ar ganixi-lavs nasyidobis winare xelSekrulebebad, isini miCneulunda iqnes myidvelTan (pirvel mopasuxesTan) gaforme-bul CarCo-SeTanxmebebad, romlebic asaxaven momavalSigasatarebel RonisZiebaTa, garkveul qmedebaTa ganxorci-elebis Sesaxeb mxareTa SeTanxmebas, rac SesaZloa moma-valSi dasadebi xelSekrulebis momzadebad miviCnioT.2011 wlis 1 da 3 dekembris CarCo-SeTanxmebebi ar warmo-adgenen ssk-is 327-e muxlis me-3 nawiliT dadgenil wina-re, am SemTxvevaSi nasyidobis, xelSekrulebebs, radganmaTSi asaxuli qmedebebi ar aris dakavSirebuli uSualodmxolod gamyidvelisa da myidvelis (anu pirveli mopasu-xis) mier ormxrivad gansaxorcielebel RonisZiebebTan dasxva pirTa uflebebs, maT Soris am ukanasknelebis nebisgamovlenaze damokidebul sakiTxebsac, ukavSirdeba, ra-sac ara ormxrivi, aramed mravalmxrivi SeTanxmeba sWir-deba (ix. am gadawyvetilebis 22-e, 25-e, 26-e qvepunqtebida qvemoT 29-e qvepunqti).

29. 2011 wlis 1 dekembrisa da 3 dekembris xelSekrule-bebis safuZvelze myidvelisaTvis (pirveli mopasuxisaT-

54

vis) sakuTrebaSi gadasacemi uZravi qoneba, orive SemTxve-vaSi, sasamarTlo davis sagania. amave xelSekrulebebzegamyidvelis saxeliT xelmomweri pirebis, (romlebic sxvapirebTan erTad, TanamosarCeleebi arian individualuribinaTmSeneblobis amxanagobis `v-s~ saqmianobidan gamom-dinare urTierTobebSi) sakuTrebad ricxul uZrav qone-baze ramdenjerme aris registrirebuli yadaRa, xolo pir-veli gamyidveli iricxeba movaleTa reestrSi (ix.01.12.2011w. xelSekrulebis me-3 muxli [davis sagani];03.12.2011w. xelSekrulebis me-3 muxli [davis sagani]]. ama-ve xelSekrulebebis me-5 muxlebiT dadgenilia, rom pir-veli da meore gamyidvelebi davis sagans gankuTvnil uZ-rav qonebas gadascemen myidvels (pirvel mopasuxes), ro-melic, am xelSekrulebebSi monawileobs, rogorc in-vestori, sakuTari komerciuli interesis gaTvaliswine-biT. zemoxsenebuli orive xelSekrulebiT gansazRvru-lia, rom `winamdebare xelSekrulebis realizaciis miz-niT mxareebisa da sxva dainteresebuli pirebis monawile-obiT daideba SeTanxmeba samarTlebrivi urTierTobebismorigebiT dasrulebis Sesaxeb, romelic damtkicdeba sa-samarTlo wesiT da savaldebulo iqneba mxareebisaTvis~(ix. 01.12.2011w. xelSekrulebebis me-7 muxlis me-2 nawilida 03.12.2011w. xelSekrulebis me-8 muxlis me-2 nawili). da-saxelebuli xelSekrulebebis konkretuli debulebebisSinaarsis samarTlebrivi Sefaseba mniSvnelovania ara mxo-lod im daskvnis gamosatanad, rom 2011 wlis 1 dekembrisada 3 dekembris xelSekrulebebi gamyidvelsa (pirveli dameore gamyidvelebi) da myidvels (pirveli mopasuxe) So-ris ormxrivad gaformebuli CarCo-SeTanxmebebia da aranasyidobis winare xelSekrulebebi, aramed im mizniTac,rom es CarCo-SeTanxmebebi (romlebSic asaxulia mxareTaSoris momavalSi gansaxorcielebeli araerTi qmedeba damaTi realizaciisaTvis saWiroa axali SeTanxmebis _ mori-gebis miRweva ara mxolod SeTanxmebis monawile pirebs So-ris, aramed sxva dainteresebul pirebTanac, rac ara or-mxrivi, aramed mravalmxrivi SeTanxmebis saxea, radgan or-ze met pirs Soris unda gadanawildes ufleba-movaleo-bebi da aRniSnuli gadanawileba SesaZloa simetriuladarc ki moxdes /rogorc ormxriv xelSekrulebebSia/, rad-gan mxareTa Soris gansxvavebuli urTierTvaldebulebe-bi arsebobs, rac Semdeg sasamarTlos mier damtkicdeba)

55

safuZvlad udevs Tavdapirvel mosarCeles, rogorc myid-velsa, da pirvel mopasuxes, rogorc gamyidvels, Soris2011 wlis 23 dekembers gaformebul xelSekrulebasac, ro-melic saxeldebulia Sesyidvis ofciis winare xelSekru-lebad. Sesabamisad, samarTlebrivad unda Sefasdes23.12.2011w. xelSekruleba, rac misi Sinaarsis gaanalize-bisa da mis safuZvlad gamoyenebuli faqtobrivi Tu sxvasaxelSekrulebo garemoebebis mixedviTaa SesaZlebeli.

30. ZiriTadi mosarCelis moTxovna (ix. am gadawyveti-lebis me-9 punqti) efuZneba 2011 wlis 23 dekembers pir-vel mopasuxesTan xelmowerili xelSekrulebis me-4 pun-qtiT nakisri valdebulebis Seusruleblobis gamo miye-nebuli zianis am ukanasknelisaTvis dakisrebas.

30.1. saapelacio sasamarTlos mier dadgenili faq-tobrivi garemoebis mixedviT, 23.12.2011 wlis xelSekru-lebis dadebis dros q. TbilisSi, W-is q. #6-Si, me-9 sar-Tulze mdebare mSenebare bina # 22, 100 kv.m farTiT [s/k0...] registrirebulia am gadawyvetilebis pirvel punqtSimiTiTebuli pirveli gamyidvelis sakuTrebad, romelic01.12.2011w. xelSekrulebis gamyidveli mxarea pirvel mo-pasuxesTan, xolo W-is q. #6-Si, me-8 sarTulze mSenebarebinis #21, 250 kv.m farTidan [s/k 0...], 125 kv.m registrire-bulia am gadawyvetilebis me-4 punqtSi dasaxelebul meo-re gamyidvelze sakuTrebis uflebiT. es ukanaskneli, Ta-vis mxriv, 03.12.2011w. xelSekrulebaSi gamyidveli mxareapirvel mopasuxesTan, rogorc myidvelTan. Sesabamisad,23.12.2011 wels mxareTa Soris xelmowerili da Sesyidvisofciis winare xelSekrulebad saxeldebuli SeTanxmebapirvelma mopasuxem, rogorc gamyidvelma, gaaforma Tav-dapirvel mosarCelesTan, rogorc myidvelTan da am xel-Sekrulebis me-3 muxlis me-4 punqtiT gansazRvrulia, romSesyidvis ofciis ZiriTadi xelSekruleba unda daidosnasyidobis sagnebis gamyidvelis sakuTrebaSi gadas-vlisTanave anu pirveli mopasuxe jer kidev ar gamxdaraim uZravi qonebis mesakuTre, romelTa nasyidobazec e.w.ofciis winare xelSekruleba gaaforma Tavdapirvel mo-sarCelesTan (myidvelTan).

30.2. sakasacio sasamarTlo iziarebs pirvelis instanci-is sasamarTlos msjelobasa da daskvnas, rom 23.12.2011w.xelSekruleba ar Seesabameba ofciis winare xelSekrule-bis Sinaarss (ix. am gadawyvetilebis 13.4-13.14 qvepunqte-

56

bi) da igi ar iyo mimarTuli ofciis xelSekrulebis dade-bisaken.

31. ssk-is 327.3 muxliT dadgenilia, rom `xelSekrule-biT SeiZleba warmoiSvas momavali xelSekrulebis dade-bis valdebuleba. xelSekrulebisaTvis gaTvaliswinebu-li forma vrceldeba aseve winare xelSekrulebazedac~.amave kodeqsis 323-e muxli adgens uZravi nivTis gasxvise-bis wess `xelSekruleba, romliTac erTi mxare iRebs val-debulebas, uZrav nivTze sakuTreba gadasces sxvas an Se-iZinos igi, moiTxovs werilobiT formas~, xolo 183-e mux-li gansazRvravs: ùZravi nivTis SesaZenad aucilebeliagarigebis werilobiTi formiT dadeba da SemZenze am ga-rigebiT gansazRvruli sakuTrebis uflebis registraciasajaro reestrSi~. sakasacio sasamarTlo ganmartavs, rommoxmobili normebiT dadgenilia uZrav nivTze garigebiswerilobiTi formiT dadeba, xolo rac Seexeba ssk-is 183-e muxlSi asaxul miTiTebas werilobiTi garigebis safuZ-velze sakuTrebis uflebis sajaro reestrSi registra-ciasTan dakavSirebiT, aRniSnuli ar ukavSirdeba garige-bis formas, aramed mxolod imas gansazRvravs, rom uZra-vi qonebis nasyidobis Sesaxeb xelSekrulebis kanoniTdadgenili wesiT werilobiT gaformebis Semdeg, mopove-buli sakuTrebis uflebis aRricxva publicirebul uf-lebaTa anu sajaro reestrSi unda moxdes.

32. 2011 wlis 1 da 3 dekembris samarTlebrivi urTier-Tobebis sasamarTlosgareSe mowesrigebis Sesaxeb xel-Sekrulebebis Taobaze winamdebare gadawyvetilebis 29-epunqtSi ganviTarebuli msjelobis gaTvaliswinebiT,23.12.2011w. xelSekrulebis Sinaarsis gasaanalizeblad un-da aRiniSnos, rom is gaformda momavalSi iseTi uZravi qo-nebis gasxvisebaze, romlis mesakuTrec jer kidev ar iyogamyidveli (pirveli mopasuxe). saapelacio sasamarTlosmsjeloba (ix. saapelacio sasamarTlos gadawyvetileba),rom Tavdapirvel mosarCelesa da pirvel mopasuxes So-ris 2011 wlis 23 dekembris xelSekrulebis dadebamde,masSi miTiTebuli uZravi qonebis (farTebis) pirveli mo-pasuxis sakuTrebaSi miRebis ufleba am ukanasknelma moi-pova pirvel gamyidvelTan da meore gamyidvelTan dade-buli 2011 wlis 1 da 3 dekembris garigebebis safuZvelze,iuridiulad dausabuTebelia, pirvel rigSi imitom, romgasaCivrebul gadawyvetilebaSi samarTlebrivad araa Se-

57

fasebuli, Tu ras warmoadgens Tavisi arsiT 2011 wlis 1dekembrisa da 3 dekembris xelSekrulebebi; xolo meoresmxriv, gaugebaria uZrav qonebaze momavalSi mosapovebe-li sakuTrebis uflebaze msjeloba ra samarTlebriv sa-fuZvels emyareba da ra daskvnamde mivida saapelacio sa-samarTlo. aRniSnuli ki sssk-is 394-e muxlis è~ qvepun-tis safuZvelze gasaCivrebuli gadawyvetilebis gauqme-bis absoluturi safuZvelia, misi arasakmarisi iuridiu-li dasabuTebulobis gamo.

33. `sakuTreba kanonieria da saqarTvelos konstitu-ciis 21-e muxliT dacul sferoSi Sedis, Tu misi SeZenamoxda kanonis moTxovnaTa dacviT. sakuTrebis gankargvisTavisuflebasTan gvaqvs saqme, roca es gankargva mesakuT-ris Tavisufali nebis Sedegad xdeba da igi warmoadgenssuverenuli uflebis realizaciis gamovlinebas~ _ ix. sa-qarTvelos sakonstitucio sasamarTlos 2007 wlis 2 iv-lisis #1/2/384 gadawyvetileba, saqarTvelos sakonsti-tucio sasamarTlos 2008 wlis 19 dekembris #1/2/411 ga-dawyvetileba.

34. uZrav qonebaze momavalSi misaRebi sakuTrebis uf-leba, cxadia, ar warmoadgens samarTlebriv safuZvels imdaskvnis gamosatanad, rom Tavdapirvel mosarCelesa(myidvelis statusiT) da pirvel mopasuxes (gamyidvelisstatusiT) Soris 2011 wlis 23 dekembers nasyidobis wina-re xelSekruleba daido, radgan mis dadebas win uswrebda2011 wlis 1 da 3 dekembers ara raime saxis winare xelSekru-lebebis gaformeba, aramed _ mxareTa Soris mimdinare mo-laparakebebi da swored am CarCo-SeTanxmebis pirobebi ai-saxa 2011 wlis 1 da 3 dekembris xelSekrulebebSi, rac Ta-visi arsiT, ar qmnis SeTanxmebis kontrahentTa imgvar sa-marTlebriv boWvas, romelic damaxasiaTebelia winarexelSekrulebisaTvis (ssk-is 327.3 muxli).

34.1. ssk-is 327-e muxlis me-2 nawilis Tanaxmad: àrsebi-Tad CaiTvleba xelSekrulebis is pirobebi, romlebzedacerT-erTi mxaris moTxovniT miRweul unda iqnes SeTan-xmeba, anda romlebic aseTad miCneulia kanonis mier~. sa-kasacio sasamarTlo yuradRebas gaamaxvilebs 23.12.2011w.xelmowerili xelSekrulebis saganze, romlis me-2 da me-3 punqtebis Sinaarsi asaxulia winamdebare gadawyvetile-bis me-5 punqtSi, 5.1-5.6 qvepunqtebSi da ganmartavs, romTavdapirvel mosarCelesa da pirvel mopasuxes Soris

58

xelmowerili da Sesyidvis ofciis winare xelSekrulebadsaxeldebuli SeTanxmeba, mxareebs Soris SeTanxmebulmxolod im SesaZleblobas gulisxmobs, rom myidvels (pir-vel mopasuxes) momavalSi, am ukanasknelisaTvis pirvelida meore gamyidvelebis mier uZrav qonebaze (konkretulfarTebze) sakuTrebis uflebis gadacemis SemTxvevaSi, Se-eZleba gaasxvisos uZravi qoneba;

34.2. sakasacio sasamarTlos SefasebiT zemoxsenebuliSinaarsis ormxrivi SeTanxmebis gaformebis iuridiuli da-sabuTebuloba bundovani da kanonSeusabamoa imis gaTva-liswinebiT, rom uZravi qonebis mesakuTred miiCneva sa-jaro reestrSi registrirebuli mesakuTre, romelsac mi-si sakuTrebis gankargvis ufleba kanoniT dadgenili we-siT aqvs miniWebuli. amdenad, kerZosamarTlebriv urTi-erTobebSi sajaro reestrSi registrirebuli mesakuTre(misi warmomadgeneli) gamodis uZravi qonebis gamsxviseb-lad da am urTierTobis sajarosamarTlebrivi mowesri-gebis nawilia `sajaro reestris Sesaxeb~ saqarTvelos ka-nonis 11.2 muxli ùZrav nivTebze uflebaTa reestrSi, re-gistrirebuli uflebis Sesaxeb monacemebis garda, aseveSeitaneba uflebis subieqtisa da obieqtis saidentifika-cio monacemebi, maT Soris, uZravi nivTis sakadastro mo-nacemebi~.

34.3. saqalaqo sasamarTlom nasyidobis winare xelSkru-lebad miiCnia Tavdapirvel mosarCelesa (myidvelis sta-tusiT) da pirvel mopasuxes (gamyidvelis statusiT) So-ris xelmowerili 23.12.2011w. xelSekruleba, romliTacmxareebma ivaldebules momavalSi nasyidobis ZiriTadixelSekrulebis dadeba (ix. am gadawyvetilebis 13.13-13.16qvepunqtebi), rac mocemul SemTxvevaSi SeuZlebelia Se-fasdes ssk-is 327-e muxlis me-3 nawilis mixedviT, misi ar-sebiTi pirobis ararsebobis gamo, radgan sadavo araa, romormxrivi SeTanxmebis gaformebis droisaTvis nasyidobissagani ar ekuTvnoda gamyidvels;

34.4. sakasacio sasamarTlo aRniSnavs, rom erTmaneTi-sagan unda gaimijnos 2011 wlis 23 dekembris xelSekru-leba (romelic Tavis mxriv imave wlis 1 da 3 dekembrismravalmxriv CarCo-SeTanxmebebs efuZneba) da 2011 wlis28 dekembris `samarTlebrivi urTierTobebis morigebiTdasrulebis Sesaxeb~ xelSekruleba, romelic Semdeg mxa-reebma waradgines Tbilisis saqalaqo sasamarTloSi mim-

59

dinare # 2/6464-06 samoqalaqo saqmis ganxilvisas da ama-ve sasamarTlos 2012 wlis 10 Tebervlis ganCinebiT mxare-Ta Soris damtkicda morigeba maT Soris SeTanxmebuli pi-robebiT, rac saqmiswarmoebis Sewyvetas daedo safuZvladda gadawyvetileba Sevida kanonier ZalaSi (sssk-is 272-emuxlis `d~ qvepunqti; ix. sasamarTlos 10.02.2012w. ganCi-neba; aseve _ am gadawyvetilebis 15.14-15.15.2 qvepunqte-bi).

34.5. Tavdapirvel mosarCelesa da pirvel mopasuxes So-ris xelmowerili, sanotaro wesiT damowmebuli 2011 wlis23 dekembris xelSekruleba ar warmoadgens nasyidobis wi-nare xelSekrulebas, radgan igi asaxavs or mxares Sorismimdinare molaparakebis process, momzadebas momaval-Si, garkveuli pirobebis Sesrulebis SemTxvevaSi SesaZloxelSekrulebis gaformebaze da, rogorc zemoT ukve aRi-niSna, ver miiCneva nasyidobis winare xelSekrulebad, nas-yidobis sagnis, rogorc xelSekrulebis arsebiTi pirobis,gamyidvelis sakuTrebaSi ararsebobis gamo da aqedan ga-momdinare ar warmoSobs valdebulebas.

34.6. sakasacio sasamarTlo imasac aRniSnavs, rom samar-Tlebrivad ar aris Sefasebuli saqmeSi moTavsebuli 2011wlis 28 dekembris mravalmxrivi SeTanxmeba, romelic 21pirs Soris sasamarTlo wesiT morigebas daedo safuZvlad;aRniSnuli morigeba gaformebulia sul sxva pirebs Soris:mosarCeleebs, mopasuxeebs (romelTa Soris arian pirve-li mopasuxe _ b. p-i; pirveli gamyidveli _ r. b-i, romelsacwarmoadgens g. m-e anu gansaxilveli davis TavdapirvelimosarCele; meore gamyidveli _ v. J-a, romelsac warmoad-gens b. p-i, anu gansaxilveli davis pirveli mopasuxe /ix. amgadawyvetilebis pirveli da meoTxe punqtebi/) da damou-kidebeli sasarCelo moTxovnis mqone mesame pirebs So-ris, romelTa Sorisaa am gadawyvetilebis 8.5 qvepunqtSidasaxelebuli mesame myidveli da mopasuxe _ m. k-e;

35. sanotaro wesiT damowmebuli 2011 wlis 28 dekem-bris xelSekrulebis me-12 muxli adgens pirveli mopasu-xisa (b. p-is) da meore gamyidvelis (v. J-as) uflebebis Sesa-xeb mxareTa SeTanxmebas, xolo me-13 muxlSi, romelic pir-veli gamyidvelis (r. b-is) uflebas exeba, aRniSnulia, rom`vinaidan b. p-ma r. b-s gadauxada 50 000, 00 (ormocdaaTiaTasi) aSS dolaris ekvivalenti lari, r. b-is mier misaRe-bi farTi: 100,00 kvm uZravi qonebis sakadastro kodi: #

60

0...) aRiricxeba b. p-is sakuTrebad~.36. sakasacio sasamarTlo aRniSnavs, rom saapelacio sa-

samarTlo ise msjelobs 2011 wlis 28 dekembris mraval-mxriv SeTanxmebaze da mis samarTlebriv Sedegebze (ix. amgadawyvetilebis 15.16, 15.16.1, 15.16.2, 15.16.3, 15.17, 15.17.1qvepunqtebi), rom samarTlebrivad ar afasebs am mraval-mxrivi SeTanxmebis Sinaarss, kerZod, im garemoebas, Turamdenad aris SesaZlebeli nasyidobis winare xelSekru-lebad iqnes miCneuli Tavdapirveli mosarCelesa da pir-vel mopasuxes Soris 23.12.2011 wels xelmowerili ormxri-vi SeTanxmeba im faqtobrivi winapirobebiT, rac misi xel-moweris droisaTvis ar damdgara da realurad xuTi dRisSemdeg (28.12.2011w.) moewera xeli sxva mravalmxriv SeTan-xmebas, sadac pirveli mopasuxe (b. p-i) sasamarTloSi mim-dinare samoqalaqo samarTalwarmoebaSi mopasuxe mxarea,xolo Tavdapirveli mosarCele (g. m-e) pirveli gamyidve-lis (r. b-is) warmomadgenelia, romelic meore gamyidvel-Tan (v. J-asTan) erTad mopasuxea im davaSi, romelzedacmorigeba Sedga; Tavdapirvelma mosarCelem, rogorc pir-veli gamyidvelis (r. b-is warmomadgenelma) b. p-isagan (pir-veli mopasuxisagan), miiRo 50 000 aSS dolaris ekvivalen-ti lari (ix. am gadawyvetilebis 39-e muxli).

37. sakasacio sasamarTlo ganmartavs, rom winare xel-Sekrulebis samarTlebrivi bunebidan gamomdinare, Tav-dapirvel mosarCelesa da pirvel mopasuxes Soris 2011wlis 23 dekembers xelmowerili da Sesyidvis ofciis wi-nare xelSekrulebad saxeldebuli SeTanxmeba ar aris nas-yidobis winare xelSekruleba da, Sesabamisad, igi ver war-moSobda pirveli mopasuxis, rogorc gamyidvelis valde-bulebas, daedo ZiriTadi nasyidobis xelSekruleba Tav-dapirveli mosarCelisaTvis, rogorc myidvelisaTvis. sa-kasacio sasamarTlos ganmartebiT: `winare xelSekrule-ba, samoqalaqo kodeqsis 327-e muxlis me-3 nawilis Sesaba-misad, warmoSobs ZiriTadi xelSekrulebis dadebis da araZiriTadi xelSekrulebiT gansazRvruli Sesrulebis val-debulebas~ (ix. susg #as-376-360-2016, 17.02.2017).

38. Tavdapirvelma mosarCelem pirveli mopasuxis wi-naaRmdeg aRZruli sarCeliT moiTxova zianis anazRaure-bis saxiT 462 480 aSS dolaris dakisreba im faqtobriv ga-remoebaze dayrdnobiT, rom am ukanasknelma 23.12.2011w.xelmowerili Sesyidvis ofciis winare xelSekrulebis me-

61

4 muxlis pirveli punqti daarRvia (ix. am gadawyvetile-bis 9.1.1-9.2.2 qvepunqtebi) da ganzrax gadaaforma uZraviqoneba sxva pirebze.

39. imis gaTvaliswinebiT, rom mxareTa Soris 2011 wlis23 dekembers dadebuli xelSekruleba warmoadgens aranasyidobis winare xelSekrulebas, aramed _ xelSekrule-bis momzadebas, romelic SesaZlebelia ramdenime etapi-saganac ki Sedgebodes da araerTxel dazustdes misi daT-qmebi da pirobebi, mxareTa Soris ar warmoSobila raimesaxis valdebulebiTsamarTlebrivi urTierToba, romlisSeusruleblobamac ziani miayena Tavdapirvel mosarCe-les. amasTan, sakasacio sasamarTlo ganmartavs, rom xel-Sekrulebis momzadebis stadiaze warmoSobili pasuxis-mgebloba SeiZleba gamoixatos mxolod zianis (gaweulixarjebis) anazRaurebis davaldebulebaSi, rac Sesabami-si mtkicebulebebiT dadasturebas saWiroebs.

40. aseve dausabuTebelia saapelacio sasamarTlos ga-dawyvetilebis is nawili, romliTac baTilad iqna cnobi-li pirvel da meore mopasuxeebs Soris gaformebuli xel-Sekrulebebi uZravi qonebis nasyidobis Sesaxeb (ix. am ga-dawyvetilebis 8.1-8.4 qvepunqtebi). sakasacio sasamarTloaraerT gadawyvetilebaSi/ganCinebaSi ganmartavs: `pala-ta ganmartavs, rom aRiarebiTi sarCelis dasaSvebobis, ise-ve, rogorc misi dasabuTebulobis sakiTxis Semowmeba sa-marTlis sakiTxia da aqedan gamomdinare, sasamarTlomprocesis monawile mxaris pretenziis ararsebobis piro-bebSic, sakuTari iniciativiT unda Seamowmos sarCelisdasaSveboba saqmiswarmoebis nebismier etapze. kanonis da-nawesidan gamomdinare, aRiarebiTi moTxovna dasaSvebia,Tu ikveTeba mosarCelis iuridiuli interesi, rom aseTiaRiareba sasamarTlos gadawyvetilebiT moxdes, magali-Tad, mamad cnoba, mamobis dadgena, qorwinebis baTiladcnoba, literaturuli nawarmoebis avtorad aRiareba daa.S. am saxis sarCelebis mizania ara subieqturi uflebismikuTvneba, aramed uflebis sadavoobis aRmofxvra. amdros sulac ar aris aucilebeli, rom piris ufleba dar-Rveuli iyos, magram varaudi imisa, rom momavalSi SeiZle-ba dairRves, warmoadgens piris iuridiul interess. ami-tomac, am tipis sarCelebs ùflebis damdgen~ sarCeleb-sac uwodeben. mikuTvnebiTi sarCelebisgan gansxvavebiT,aRiarebiTi sarCelis davis sagania TviT materialursamar-

62

Tlebrivi urTierToba, romelic subsidiuria da iuridi-uli interesis arseboba gamoricxulia, Tu SesaZlebeliamopasuxis mimarT mikuTvnebiTi moTxovnis wardgena (ix.saqarTvelos uzenaesi sasamarTlos didi palatis gadaw-yvetileba saqmeze # as-664-635-2016, 02.03.2017w; Seada-reT aseve, susg-ebs: #as 916-857-2017, 12.09.2017w; #as-302-285-17, 16.06.2017w; #as-244-232-2017, 19.05.2017w; #as-937-887-2015, 10.11.2015w; #as-17-14-2015, 01.07.2015w; #as-1069-1008-2015, 16.12.2015w; #as-869-819-2015, 11.12.2015w; #as-773-730-2015, 08.09.2005w; #as-181-174-2016, 06.05.2016w;#as-1025-967-2015, 23.12.2015w; #as-323-308, 2016,03.06.2016w; #as-407-390-2016, 10.06.2016w; #as-375-359-2016, 17.06.2016w.).

40.1. sakasacio sasamarTlo ganmartavs, rom sarCelissaxeebad dayofas (mikuTvnebiTi, gardaqmniTi da aRiare-biTi) praqtikuli mniSvneloba gaaCnia da uzrunvelyofspiris kanoniT daculi uflebisa da interesebis sasamar-Tlo wesiT dacvas. rogorc wesi, mosarCelis interesi gan-sazRvruli samarTlebrivi Sedegis miRwevas ukavSirdeba(mag. xelSekrulebiT nakisri valdebulebis Sesruleba,qonebis dabruneba, pirvandeli mdgomareobis aRdgena, zi-anis anazRaureba da a.S), romelic mxolod mikuTvnebiTisarCeliT miiRweva da aseT SemTxvevaSi, aRiarebiTi sar-Celis aRZvra dauSvebelia, radganac, marTlmsajulebisganxorcielebisas saproceso ekonomiis principidan ga-momdinare, darRveuli uflebis aRdgenasa da samarT-lebrivi mdgomareobis gaumjobesebas pirma erTi da araramdenime sarCelis aRZvris gziT unda miaRwios, sxva sit-yvebiT rom vTqvaT, aRiarebiTi sarCelis dakmayofilebasmosarCelisaTvis misTvis sasargeblo Sedegi unda moh-qondes da mikuTvnebiTi sarCelis aRZvris saWiroeba aRarunda arsebobdes. sssk-is 180-e muxlis Sinaarsidan gamom-dinareobs aRiarebiTi sarCelis iuridiuli interesis gan-msazRvreli Semdegi kriteriumebi: a) mosarCeles undaedavebodnen uflebaSi; b) davis arseboba unda qmnides mo-sarCelis uflebis momavalSi darRvevis realur saSiSro-ebas; g) aRiarebiTi sarCelis gadawyveta davis gadawyve-tis saukeTeso saSualeba unda iyos, kerZod, gadawyveti-lebiT srulad garkveuli Sedegi unda miiRebodes mxari-saTvis, aRiarebiTi sarCelis dakmayofileba unda qmnidesim uflebisa Tu urTierTobis gansazRvrulobas, rac mo-

63

sarCelesa da mopasuxes Soris warmoSobili davis gamo ir-Rveva (Sdr. susg #as-838-802-2014, 19.03.2015w.).

41. sakasacio sasamarTlo ar iziarebs pirveli mopasu-xis sakasacio pretenziebs mis sasargeblod Tavdapirve-li mosarCelisaTvis 50 000 aSS dolaris ekvivalenti la-ris dakisrebis Taobaze da winamdebare gadawyvetilebis34-e punqtsa da saapelacio sasamarTlos gadawyvetile-bis motivaciaze miuTiTebs (ix. 15.27-15.28 qvepunqtebi),Sesabamisad, am nawilSi ucvlelad rCeba saapelacio sasa-marTlos samoqalaqo saqmeTa palatis gasaCivrebuli ga-dawyvetileba.

42. mxareTa Soris saxelmwifo baJis ganawilebis sakiT-xi asaxulia winamdebare gadawyvetilebis sarezolucionawilSi.

sarezolucio nawili:sakasacio sasamarTlom ixelmZRvanela saqarTvelos

samoqalaqo saproceso kodeqsis 411-e da 1991-e muxlebiTda

g a d a w y v i t a:

1. b. p-isa da g. g-is sakasacio saCivari dakmayofildesnawilobriv;

2. nawilobriv gauqmdes Tbilisis saapelacio sasamar-Tlos samoqalaqo saqmeTa palatis 2016 wlis 25 oqtombrisgadawyvetileba, kerZod, misi sarezolucio nawilis me-3,me-4, me-6 (romelic rigiTobiT gasaCivrebuli gadawyveti-lebis sarezolucio nawilis me-5 punqtia) punqtebi, me-10punqtis `b~ qvepunqti (usworobis gasworebis Sesaxeb Tbi-lisis saapelacio sasamarTlos samoqalaqo saqmeTa pala-tis 2016 wlis 10 ianvris ganCinebis gaTvaliswinebiT), me-12, me-14, me-15, me-16 punqtebi da am nawilSi miRebuli iq-nes axali gadawyvetileba:

2.1. g. m-is sarCeli ar dakmayofildes;2.2. gauqmdes Tbilisis saqalaqo sasamarTlos samoqa-

laqo saqmeTa kolegiis 2013 wlis 24 maisis ganCineba, rom-liTac yadaRa daedo b. p-is (p/n ...) sakuTrebaSi arsebuluZrav qonebas: Tbilisi, W-is (yof. b-is) # 6, sarTuli 2,bina #6, 80.00 kvm, sakadastro kodi 0....;

2.3. gauqmdes Tbilisis saqalaqo sasamarTlos samoqa-

64

laqo saqmeTa kolegiis 2013 wlis 28 maisis ganCineba, rom-liTac yadaRa daedo g. g-is (p/n 0..—) sakuTrebaSi arsebuluZrav qonebas: a) Tbilisi, W-is (yofili b-is) #6, komerci-uli farTi #2, sarTuli 1, 80.40 kv.m sakadastro kodi: 0...—.; b) Tbilisi, W-is (yofili b-is) #6, sarTuli 3, bina #10,104.20 kv.m. sakadastro kodi: 0...—.; g) Tbilisi, W-is (yofilib-is) #6, sarTuli #6, bina #18a, 141.20 kv.m., sakadastrokodi 0...—a; d) Tbilisi, W-is (yofili b-is) #6, sarTuli #8,bina #20, 132.60 kv.m., sakadasatro kodi: 0...—.;

3. danarCen nawilSi Tbilisis saapelacio sasamarTlossamoqalaqo saqmeTa palatis 2016 wlis 25 oqtombris ga-dawyvetileba, darCes ucvlelad;

4. g. m-es saxelmwifo biujetis sasargeblod daekisros,Tbilisis saapelacio sasamarTlos samoqalaqo saqmeTa pa-latis 2014 wlis 3 noembris ganCinebiT, gadavadebuli sa-xelmwifo baJis _ 5 000 laris gadaxda;

5. g. m-es b. p-isa da g. g-is sasargeblod daekisros sa-xelmwifo baJis _ 6 000 laris gadaxda;

6. sakasacio sasamarTlos gadawyvetileba sabolooa daar gasaCivrdeba.

valis arsebobis aRiareba


#as-938-900-2014 30 oqtomberi, 2015 w., q. Tbilisi

saqarTvelos uzenaesi sasamarTlos samoqalaqosaqmeTa palataSemadgenloba: p. qaTamaZe (Tavmjdomare, momxsenebeli),

b. alaviZe,z. ZlieriSvili

davis sagani: Cuqebis xelSekrulebis baTilad cnoba,mesakuTred cnoba, Tanxis dakisreba

aRwerilobiTi nawili:1. q. TbilisSi, s-Si, d-is q.#...-Si mdebare Senoba-nage-

boba (SemdegSi uZravi qoneba) 1995-2003 wlebSi Tanabari

65

wilobrivi monawileobiT aaSenes r. g-em (SemdegSi mosar-Celem an kreditorma) da misma Zmam _ v. i-ma (SemdegSi pir-velma mopasuxem an pirvelma kasatorma).

2. ojaxis wevrTa urTierTSeTanxmebiT, uZravi qonebasajaro reestrSi aRiricxa i. g-isa (SemdegSi mosarCelisdedis, meore mopasuxis, meore kasatoris an movalisa) dal. g-is (SemdegSi mosarCelis dis) TanasakuTrebaSi.

3. 25.10.2007 wels, erTi mxriv, mosarCelesa da, meoremxriv, mosarCelis dedasa da das Soris daido `xelSekru-leba valis aRiarebisa da valdebulebis arsebobis Sesa-xeb~. aRniSnuli xelSekrulebis Tanaxmad, mosarCelis de-dam da dam aRiares, rom maT saxelze sajaro reestrSi aR-ricxuli uZravi qonebis faqtobrivi mesakuTreebi iyvnenmosarCele da pirveli mopasuxe, kerZod, mosarCelis de-dis saxelze sajaro reestrSi aRricxuli uZravi qonebis1/2 nawilis faqtobrivi mesakuTre iyo mosarCele, xolomosarCelis dis saxelze sajaro reestrSi aRricxuli uZ-ravi qonebis 1/2 nawilis mesakuTre ki _ pirveli mopasuxe.amave xelSekrulebiT, mosarCelis dedam ikisra valdebu-leba, rom mosarCelis pirveli moTxovnisTanave, am uka-nasknelis saxelze aRricxavda uZravi qonebis 1/2 nawils(50%-s) an, am qonebis sanacvlod, mosarCeles gadauxdidamis sabazro Rirebulebas.

4. 17.03.2010 wlis nasyidobis xelSekrulebis safuZ-velze mosarCelis dam Tavis saxelze aRricxuli uZraviqonebis 1/2 nawili sakuTrebaSi gadasca pirvel mopasu-xes.

5. 27.04.2010 wlis Cuqebis xelSekrulebis safuZvelzemosarCelis dedam mis saxelze aRricxuli uZravi qonebis1/2 nawili aCuqa pirvel mopasuxes.

6. zemoxsenebuli nasyidobisa da Cuqebis xelSekrule-bebis safuZvelze pirveli mopasuxe sajaro reestrSi aRi-ricxa mTliani uZravi qonebis mesakuTred.

7. damoukidebeli eqspertis sainJinro-teqnikuri dasasaqonlo eqspertizis 2010 wlis 18 noembris daskvnis mi-xedviT, uZravi qonebis sabazro Rirebuleba Seadgens 980000 aSS dolars.

8. mosarCelem sarCeliT mimarTa sasamarTlos da moiT-xova: pirveli da meore mopasuxisaTvis, mosarCelis sasar-geblod, 490 000 aSS dolaris solidarulad dakisreba, ase-ve, 27.04.2010 wlis Cuqebis xelSekrulebis baTilad cnoba

66

da am xelSekrulebiT gaCuqebuli qonebis meore mopasu-xis saxelze aRricxva.

9. mosarCelis ganmartebiT, meore mopasuxem ar Seas-rula 27.10.2010 wlis xelSekrulebiT gaTvaliswinebulivaldebuleba, kerZod, mosarCeles sakuTrebaSi ar gadas-ca uZravi qonebis 1/2 nawili, amitom, amave xelSekrule-bis mixedviT, igi valdebuli iyo, mosarCelisaTvis gadae-xada uZravi qonebis 1/2 nawilis sabazro Rirebuleba, rac,damoukidebeli eqspertis daskvnis mixedviT, Seadgenda490 000 aSS dolars. mosarCelis ganmartebiT, 27.04.2010wlis Cuqebis xelSekruleba dadebuli iyo mosaCveneblad,im ganzraxvis gareSe, rom mas Sesabamisi iuridiuli Sede-gebi mohyoloda, kerZod, miTiTebuli xelSekruleba dai-do im mizniT, rom meore mopasuxes Tavi aeridebina27.10.2010 wlis xelSekrulebiT gaTvaliswinebuli valde-bulebis Sesrulebisagan, Sesabamisad, sadavo garigeba ba-Tili iyo da gaCuqebuli qoneba kvlav meore mopasuxis sa-xelze unda aRricxuliyo, vinaidan es qoneba meore mopa-suxis valdebulebis Sesrulebis erTaderT saSualebaswarmoadgenda.

10. mopasuxeebma sarCeli ar cnes da ganmartes, rom maTmosarCelisaTvis ziani ar miuyenebiaT, Sesabamisad, usa-fuZvlo iyo am ukanasknelis moTxovna mopasuxeebisaTvis490 000 aSS dolaris solidarulad dakisrebis Taobaze.mopasuxeebis ganmartebiT, usafuZvlo iyo, aseve, Cuqe-bis xelSekrulebis baTilad cnobis moTxovnac, vinaidanes xelSekruleba ar dadebula mosaCveneblad da, amasTan,mosarCeles sadavo xelSekrulebis baTilad cnobis mimarTar gaaCnda iuridiuli interesi.

11. Tbilisis saqalaqo sasamarTlos samoqalaqo saqme-Ta kolegiis 2012 wlis 21 Tebervlis gadawyvetilebiT:

_ sarCeli nawilobriv dakmayofilda;_ baTilad iqna cnobili 27.04.2010 wlis Cuqebis xel-

Sekruleba da meore mopasuxis sakuTrebaSi aRiricxa sa-davo qoneba;

_ meore mopasuxes, mosarCelis sasargeblod, daekisra490 000 aSS dolaris gadaxda;

_ sarCeli pirveli mopasuxisaTvis, meore mopasuxes-Tan erTad, solidarulad 490 000 aSS dolaris dakisrebisTaobaze ar dakmayofilda.

12. pirveli instanciis sasamarTlom daadgina winamde-

67

bare ganCinebis 1-7 punqtebSi miTiTebuli faqtobrivi ga-remoebebi da miiCnia, rom sarCeli nawilobriv unda dak-mayofilebuliyo, kerZod, sasamarTlom aRniSna, rom meo-re mopasuxem ar Seasrula 27.10.2010 wlis xelSekrulebiTgaTvaliswinebuli valdebuleba, kerZod, mosarCeles sa-kuTrebaSi ar gadasca uZravi qonebis 1/2 nawili, amitom,amave xelSekrulebis mixedviT, igi valdebuli iyo, mosar-CelisaTvis gadaexada uZravi qonebis 1/2 nawilis sabazroRirebuleba, rac, damoukidebeli eqspertis daskvnis mi-xedviT, Seadgenda 490 000 aSS dolars. sasamarTlom miiC-nia, aseve, rom sadavo Cuqebis xelSekruleba mosaCveneb-lad dadebul garigebas warmoadgenda da, Sesabamisad, ba-Tili iyo saqarTvelos samoqalaqo kodeqsis (SemdegSi ssk-is) 56.1 muxlis safuZvelze. sasamarTlos mosazrebiT, sa-davo garigebis dadebiT meore mopasuxes surda, Tavi ae-ridebina valis aRiarebis xelSekrulebidan gamomdinaremosalodneli pasuxismgeblobisagan, Sesabamisad, es gari-geba daido im ganzraxvis gareSe, rom mas Sesabamisi iuri-diuli Sedegebi mohyoloda. pirveli instanciis sasamar-Tlom Tavisi gadawyvetilebis samarTlebrivi dasabuTe-bisas, ixelmZRvanela ssk-is 56.1, 976-e, 316.1, 317-e, 361.2,992-e, 412-e, 463-e-464-e muxlebiT.

13. pirveli instanciis sasamarTlos gadawyvetilebasaapelacio wesiT gaasaCivra orive mxarem. mosarCelem mo-iTxova gasaCivrebuli gadawyvetilebis gauqmeba sarCelisdakmayofilebaze uaris Tqmis nawilSi da axali gadawyve-tilebiT sarCelis dakmayofileba, xolo mopasuxeebma mo-iTxoves gasaCivrebuli gadawyvetilebis gauqmeba sarCe-lis dakmayofilebis nawilSi da axali gadawyvetilebiTsarCelis dakmayofilebaze uaris Tqma.

14. Tbilisis saapelacio sasamarTlos samoqalaqo saq-meTa palatis 2014 wlis 9 ivlisis gadayvetilebiT:

_ mopasuxeebis saapelacio saCivari ar dakmayofilda;_ mosarCelis saapelacio saCivari dakmayofilda;_ gauqmda gasaCivrebuli gadawyvetileba sarCelis

dakmayofilebaze uaris Tqmisa da saxelmwifo baJis gana-wilebis nawilSi (gasaCivrebuli gadawyvetilebis sarezo-lucio nawilis pirveli, meoTxe da mexuTe punqtebi) da amnawilSi miRebul iqna axali gadawyvetileba;

_ pirvel mopasuxes, meore mopasuxesTan erTad, soli-darulad daekisra 490 000 aSS dolaris gadaxda mosarCe-

68

lis sasargeblod;_ danarCen nawilSi gasaCivrebuli gadawyvetileba dar-

Ca ucvlelad.15. saapelacio sasamarTlo daeTanxma pirveli in-

stanciis sasamarTlos mier dadgenil faqtobriv garemo-ebebsa da samarTlebriv daskvnebs im nawilSi, romelSicsarCeli dakmayofilda, kerZod, palatis mosazrebiT, sar-Celi efuZneboda 25.10.2007 wlis xelSekrulebiT nakisrivaldebulebis darRvevis gamo miyenebuli zianis anazRa-urebas. saapelacio sasamarTlom miiCnia, rom meore mopa-suxem ar Seasrula 25.10.2007 wlis xelSekrulebiT nakis-ri valdebuleba, riTac ziani miadga mosarCeles, kerZod,am ukanasknelma sakuTrebaSi ver miiRo sadavo uZravi qo-neba. rac Seexeboda zianis odenobas, palatis miTiTebiT,igi mxareebma TviTon gansazRvres zemoxsenebuli xel-SekrulebiT, kerZod, ziani Seadgenda davis warmoSobisdroisaTvis sadavo farTis sabazro Rirebulebas. saape-lacio sasamarTlom miiCnia, rom zianis odenobis gan-sazRvris nawilSi mosarCelem SeZlo misi wili mtkicebistvirTis realizeba, kerZod, sasamarTlos warudgina da-moukidebeli eqspertis 18.11.2010 wlis daskvna, romlismixedviT, sadavo uZravi qonebis sabazro Rirebuleba Se-adgenda 980 000 aSS dolars. palatis mosazrebiT, sworedam Tanxis naxevari _ 490 000 aSS dolari meore mopasuxes,mosarCelis sasargeblod, ssk-is 394-e muxlis safuZvelzeunda dahkisreboda.

16. saapelacio sasamarTlom miuTiTa saqarTvelos sa-moqalaqo saproceso kodeqsis (SemdegSi sssk-is) 180-e mux-lze da miiCnia, rom aRiarebiTi sarCelis mimarT mosarCe-les gaaCnda namdvili iuridiuli interesi, kerZod, es in-teresi ukavSirdeboda sadavo uZrav qonebaze meore mo-pasuxis sakuTrebis uflebis aRdgenas, ris Sedegadac amukanasknels sasamarTlos gadawyvetilebiT dakisrebulifuladi valdebulebis Sesrulebis saSualeba miecemoda.saapelacio sasamarTlos mosazrebiT, sadavo Cuqebis xel-Sekruleba ssk-is 56.1 muxliT gaTvaliswinebul moCvene-biT garigebas warmoadgenda, vinaidan igi dadebuli iyo immizniT, rom meore mopasuxes Tavi aeridebina mosarCelismimarT nakisri valdebulebis SesrulebisaTvis. es das-kvna saapelacio sasamarTlom Semdegi faqtobrivi gare-moebebis Sefasebis Sedegad gamoitana: sadavo garigebis

69

mxareebi iyvnen deda-Svili; pirveli mopasuxe mosarCeles-Tan erTad monawileobda uZravi qonebis mSeneblobaSi; mo-sarCeles dedasTan hqonda daZabuli urTierToba; mosar-Celis dedas ekisra valdebuleba mosarCelis mimarT uZ-ravi qonebis 1/2 nawilis sakuTrebaSi gadacemis Taobaze;pirveli mopasuxisaTvis, sadavo Cuqebis xelSekrulebisdadebisas, cnobili iyo zemoxsenebuli valdebulebis Se-saxeb. zemoaRniSnulis gaTvaliswinebiT, saapelacio sa-samarTlom gaiziara saqalaqo sasamarTlos msjeloba damiiCnia, rom arsebobda sadavo Cuqebis xelSekrulebis ba-Tilad cnobisa da am xelSekrulebiT gaCuqebuli qonebismeore mopasuxis sakuTrebaSi dabrunebis safuZveli.

17. saapelacio palatis mosazrebiT, gasaCivrebuli ga-dawyvetileba dausabuTebeli iyo pirveli mopasuxisaT-vis mosarCelis mier moTxovnili Tanxis solidarulad da-kisrebaze uaris Tqmis nawilSi, kerZod, palatam miiCnia,rom ssk-is 998-e muxlis safuZvelze, 490 000 aSS dolarisgadaxda unda dahkisreboda pirvel mopasuxes, meore mo-pasuxesTan erTad, solidarulad, vinaidan pirvelma mo-pasuxem, sadavo Cuqebis xelSekrulebis dadebisas, ico-da gaCuqebul qonebaze meore mopasuxis valdebulebis ar-sebobis Sesaxeb da, miuxedavad amisa, mainc miiRo saCuqa-ri (uZravi qoneba), riTac xeli Seuwyo mosarCeles zianismiyenebaSi.

18. saapelacio sasamarTlos gadawyvetileba sakasaciowesiT gaasaCivres mopasuxeebma. sakasacio saCivris safuZ-vlebi:

_ saapelacio sasamarTlom arasworad Seafasa 25.10.2007wlis xelSekruleba da arasworad daadgina faqtobrivigaremoeba imis Sesaxeb, rom meore mopasuxem daarRvia25.10.2007 wlis xelSekrulebiT nakisri valdebuleba daamiT mosarCeles ziani miayena. xelSekrulebis mixedviT,meore mopasuxes mosarCelisaTvis sakuTrebaSi unda ga-daeca uZravi qonebis 1/2 nawili an am qonebis sabazro Ri-rebuleba gadaexada misTvis. aqedan gamomdinare, arsebob-da alternatiuli valdebulebebi da, vinaidan movalemerT-erTi valdebuleba ar Seasrula, mosarCeles warmo-eSva meore valdebulebis (uZravi nivTis sabazro Rirebu-lebis gadaxdis valdebulebis) Sesrulebis moTxovnis uf-leba. kasatoris mosazrebiT, 25.10.2007 wlis valis aRia-rebis xelSekrulebis sxvagvari interpretacia SeuZle-

70

belia;_ saapelacio sasamarTlom arasworad daadgina faq-

tobrivi garemoeba imis Sesaxeb, rom mosarCelisaTvis zi-anis miyenebaSi meore mopasuxes pirvelma mopasuxemac Suw-yo xeli. mocemul SemTxvevaSi, zianis arsebobaze saubariSeuZlebelia, vinaidan, rodesac arsebobs alternatiulivaldebulebani, movales SeuZlia erT-erTi valdebule-bis SesrulebiT daakmayofilos kreditori;

_ saapelacio sasamarTlom ar daasabuTa, Tu ratom ga-moiyena ssk-is 998-e muxli im pirobebSi, rodesac mosar-Celis moTxovna pirveli mopasuxis mimarT SesaZlebeliagamomdinareobdes deliqturi urTierTobidan, xolo me-ore mopasuxis mimarT ki, saxelSekrulebo urTierTobi-dan;

_ sasamarTlos ar unda gaeziarebina eqspertizis das-kvna masSi gadmocemuli winaaRmdegobrivi msjelobebis ga-mo;

_ saapelacio sasamarTlom arasworad daadgina faq-tobrivi garemoeba imis Sesaxeb, rom sadavo Cuqebis xel-Sekruleba dadebulia mosaCveneblad.

19. saqarTvelos uzenaesi sasamarTlos samoqalaqo saq-meTa palatis 2014 wlis 8 oqtombris ganCinebiT warmoeba-Si iqna miRebuli mopasuxeTa sakasacio saCivari, sssk-is391-e muxlis mixedviT, dasaSvebobis Sesamowmeblad, xo-lo amave sasamarTlos 2015 wlis 4 maisis ganCinebiT dasaS-vebad iqna cnobili mopasuxeTa sakasacio saCivari sssk-is391-e muxlis me-5 nawilis à~ da `g~ qvepunqtebis safuZ-velze.

samotivacio nawili:20. sakasacio sasamarTlo saqmis Seswavlis, sakasacio

saCivris safuZvlebis Semowmebis Sedegad miiCnevs, romsakasacio saCivari nawilobriv unda dakmayofildes Sem-deg garemoebaTa gamo:

21. sssk-is 404-e muxlis pirveli nawilis Tanaxmad, sa-kasacio sasamarTlo amowmebs gadawyvetilebas sakasaciosaCivris farglebSi. amave kodeqsis 407-e muxlis Tanax-mad, saapelacio sasamarTlos mier damtkicebulad cno-bili faqtobrivi garemoebebi savaldebuloa sakasacio sa-samarTlosaTvis, Tu wamoyenebuli ar aris dasaSvebi dadasabuTebuli pretenzia (Sedaveba).

71

22. mocemul SemTxvevaSi, sakasacio palata miiCnevs,rom saapelacio sasamarTlom sworad daadgina saqmisaT-vis arsebiTi mniSvnelobis mqone faqtobrivi garemoebebi(ix. winamdebare ganCinebis 1-7 punqtebi), romelTa mimarTkasators dasabuTebuli pretenzia ar warmoudgenia.

23. mosarCele Tavis moTxovnas afuZnebs 25.10.2007wlis xelSekrulebaze, Sesabamisad, upirvelesad, unda Se-fasdes, Tu ra samarTlebrivi urTierToba warmoiSva mxa-reTa Soris miTiTebuli xelSekrulebiT.

24. sakasacio palatis mosazrebiT, 25.10.2007 wlis xel-Sekruleba, misi Sinaarsis gaTvaliswinebiT, ssk-is 341-emuxliT gaTvaliswinebul valis arsebobis aRiarebis xel-Sekrulebad unda miviCnioT. miTiTebuli normis mixed-viT, im xelSekrulebis namdvilobisaTvis, romliTac aRi-arebul iqna valdebulebiTi urTierTobis arseboba (va-lis arsebobis aRiareba) aucilebelia werilobiTi aRia-reba. Tu sxva formaa gaTvaliswinebuli im valdebulebi-Ti urTierTobis warmoSobisaTvis, romlis arsebobac aRi-arebul iqna, maSin aRiarebac moiTxovs am formas.

25. sakasacio sasamarTlom sxvadasxva saqmeSi araer-Txel ganmarta, rom zemoxsenebuli normiT gaTvaliswi-nebuli valis arsebobis aRiareba axal moTxovnas qmnis Zi-riTadi valdebulebiTi urTierTobisagan damoukideb-lad. valis arsebobis aRiareba, ZiriTadi valdebulebiTiurTierTobis sadavoobis SemTxvevaSic, Sesrulebis val-debulebas warmoSobs da kreditors moTxovnis uflebasaniWebs. amasTan, valis aRiareba imiT gansxvavdeba nebis-mieri sxva formiT gaTvaliswinebuli moTxovnis aRiare-bisagan, rom igi axali xelSekrulebaa da ara sxva saxel-Sekrulebo urTierTobis farglebSi nebis gamovlena. va-lis arsebobis aRiareba aris calmxrivi da abstraqtulixelSekruleba, romlis Tanaxmad, erTi mxare meore mxa-ris sasargeblod, damoukideblad kisrulobs garkveulimoqmedebebis Sesrulebas. valis arsebobis aRiareba mxo-lod maSin arsebobs, Tu igi damoukidebelia ZiriTadi val-debulebiTi urTierTobisagan da axal, damoukidebelmoTxovnas warmoSobs (ix. susg #as-839-890-2011,08.11.2011w.; susg #as-413-391-2012, 25.09.2012w.).

26. gansaxilvel SemTxvevaSi, 25.10.2007 wlis `valis aRi-arebisa da valdebulebis arsebobis Sesaxeb~ xelSekru-lebiT, meore mopasuxem ikisra valdebuleba, rom mosar-

72

Celis pirveli moTxovnisTanave am ukanasknelis saxelzeaRricxavda Tavis sakuTrebaSi arsebul uZrav qonebas (q.TbilisSi, s-Si, d-is q.#...-Si mdebare uZravi qonebis 1/2nawils (50%-s)) an, am qonebis sanacvlod, mosarCeles ga-dauxdida sabazro Rirebulebas. sakasacio palatis mosaz-rebiT, miTiTebuli xelSekruleba aris axali, abstraqtu-li xelSekruleba, romelic warmoSobs Sesrulebis val-debulebas da mosarCeles (kreditors) aniWebs moTxovnisuflebas. sakasacio palata miiCnevs, aseve, rom 25.10.2007wlis xelSekruleba pasuxobs uZravi nivTis gasxvisebisaT-vis kanoniT dadgenil werilobiT formas (ssk-is 323-e mux-li).

27. ssk-is 374-e muxlis mixedviT, Tu ramdenime valde-bulebidan unda Sesruldes erT-erTi (alternatiulivaldebulebani), arCevis ufleba aqvs movales, Tuki xel-Sekrulebidan, kanonidan an valdebulebis arsidan sxvaram ar gamomdinareobs.

28. am normis Sinaarsidan gamomdinare, alternatiulvaldebulebebSi erTi Sesrulebis gverdiT arsebobs me-ore alternatiuli Sesruleba, romelTagan realurad Se-iZleba ganxorcieldes mxolod erT-erTi. is Tu, romelisagniT Sesruldeba valdebuleba, damokidebulia xel-Sekrulebis mxaris (movalis an kreditoris) arCevanze. ze-moxsenebuli normis mixedviT, movales arCevis uflebamxolod maSin aqvs, Tu xelSekrulebidan, kanonidan anvaldebulebis arsidan sxva ram ar gamomdinareobs. amde-nad, arCevanis ufleba an movales ekuTvnis, anda kredi-tors.

29. gansaxilvel SemTxvevaSi, 25.10.2007 wlis xelSekru-lebiT gaTvaliswinebulia alternatiuli valdebuleba-ni, kerZod, meore mopasuxe (movale) valdebulia, mosar-Celes (kreditors) sakuTrebaSi gadasces uZravi qonebaan gadauxados am qonebis sabazro Rirebuleba. amasTan,mocemul SemTxvevaSi, xelSekrulebis Sinaarsidan gamom-dinareobs, rom alternatiuli valdebulebebidan Sesru-lebis arCevis ufleba ekuTvnis kreditors, vinaidan swo-red misi pirveli moTxovnis SemTxvevaSi warmoeSobodamovales erT-erTis Sesrulebis valdebuleba. Tundac mi-viCnioT, rom, gansaxilvel SemTxvevaSi, arCevis uflebaekuTvnis movales, am ukanasknelma faqtobrivad airCiavaldebulebis Sesruleba uZravi qonebis sabazro Rire-

73

bulebis gadaxdiT, vinaidan Tavad uZravi qoneba gaasxvi-sa mesame pirze. im SemTxvevaSic ki, Tu miviCnevT, rom Ses-rulebis (uZravi nivTis kreditoris sakuTrebaSi gadace-mis) SeuZlebloba dadga movalis braliT, am ukanasknelmavaldebuleba unda Seasrulos darCenili sagniT _ uZraviqonebis sabazro Rirebulebis gadaxdiT (ssk-is 375-e mux-li). da bolos, Tu movale, romelsac aqvs arCevis ufleba,ar iyenebs mas, maSin kreditori uflebamosilia, Tavad ga-moiyenos es ufleba da moiTxovos ama Tu im moqmedebisSesruleba.

30. mocemul SemTxvevaSi, kreditori moiTxovs25.10.2007 wlis xelSekrulebiT gaTvaliswinebuli al-ternatiuli valdebulebebidan erT-erTis Sesrulebas,kerZod, uZravi qonebis sabazro Rirebulebis gadaxdas.aRsaniSnavia, rom kasatori (movale) Tavadac miiCnevs, rommis mier uZravi qonebis mesame pirze gasxvisebis gamo, kre-ditors swored alternatiuli valdebulebis Sesrule-bis moTxovnis ufleba warmoeSva da ara xelSekrulebisdarRveviT gamowveuli zianisa, rogorc es gasaCivrebulgadawyvetilebaSia miTiTebuli.

31. sakasacio palata ar iziarebs kasatoris pretenzi-as imis Sesaxeb, rom, uZravi qonebis sabazro RirebulebisSefasebisas, saapelacio sasamarTlos ar unda gaeziare-bina mosarCelis mier warmodgenili eqspertizis daskvna.sakasacio palata, upirvelesad, yuradRebas miaqcevs imgaremoebas, rom sssk-is 102.1 da 103.1 muxlebis Sesabami-sad, mosarCele valdebuli iyo, daemtkicebina, Tu ras Se-adgenda uZravi qonebis sabazro Rirebuleba. sadavo ga-remoebis dasadastureblad, mosarCelem sasamarTloswarmoudgina dasaSvebi mtkicebuleba _ damoukidebeli eq-spertis sainJinro-teqnikuri da sasaqonlo eqspertizis2010 wlis 18 noembris daskvna, romliTac irkveva uZraviqonebis sabazro Rirebuleba. mopasuxe ar eTanxmeba ra eq-spertis daskvnaSi miTiTebul fass, mxolod Tavisi axsna-ganmartebiT cdilobs gaaqarwylos daskvnaSi miTiTebu-li garemoebebi, rac, sakasacio palatis mosazrebiT, Se-saZlebelia, ganxorcieldes sxva eqspertis daskvniT daara am daskvnis sityvieri gakritikebiT.

32. zemoaRniSnulidan gamomdinare, sakasacio palatamiiCnevs, rom saapelacio sasamarTlom marTebulad dato-va ucvlelad pirveli instanciis sasamarTlos gadawyve-

74

tileba im nawilSi, romliTac meore mopasuxes, mosarCe-lis sasargeblod, daekisra 490 000 aSS dolaris gadaxda(pirveli instanciis sasamarTlos gadawyvetilebis sare-zolucio nawilis mexuTe punqti). marTalia, sakasacio pa-lata ar iziarebs saapelacio sasamarTlos samarTlebrivdasabuTebas, magram, palata miiCnevs, rom gadawyvetile-ba am nawilSi arsebiTad sworia da mxolod is garemoeba,rom gadawyvetilebis samotivacio nawili ar Seicavs Sesa-bamis dasabuTebas, ver gaxdeba am gadawyvetilebis gauq-mebis safuZveli (sssk-is 410-e muxlis `g~ qvepunqti).

33. sakasacio palata ar iziarebs kasatorebis preten-zias gasaCivrebuli gadawyvetilebis im nawilis dausabu-Teblobis Taobaze, romliTac, ssk-is 56.1 muxlis safuZ-velze, baTilad iqna cnobili sadavo Cuqebis xelSekru-leba da gaCuqebuli qoneba daubrunda Tavdapirvel mesa-kuTres. palata eTanxmeba saapelacio sasamarTlos mierganviTarebul msjelobas, rac mocemulia winamdebare gan-Cinebis me-16 punqtSi da miiCnevs, rom saapelacio pala-tis daskvnebi am nawilSi ar ewinaaRmdegeba sakasacio sa-samarTlos mier dadgenil praqtikas (ix. susg #as-643-611-2013, 19.06.2015w.; susg #as-490-464-2015, 27.10.2015 ).

34. sakasacio palatis mosazrebiT, dausabuTebelia dagauqmebas eqvemdebareba gasaCivrebuli gadawyvetilebaim nawilSi, romliTac kreditoris sarCeli dakmayofil-da da pirvel mopasuxes, meore mopasuxesTan erTad, so-lidarulad daekisra 490 000 aSS dolaris gadaxda mosar-Celis sasargeblod. saapelacio sasamarTlom miiCnia, rommosarCelis mier moTxovnili Tanxa pirvel mopasuxes me-ore mopasuxesTan erTad, ssk-is 998-e muxlis safuZvelze,solidarulad unda dahkisreboda, rasac sakasacio pala-ta ver gaiziarebs. palatis mosazrebiT, upirvelesad, yu-radReba unda mieqces im garemoebas, rom meore mopasuxismimarT mosarCelis moTxovnis samarTlebrivi safuZveliassk-is 341-e muxli da ara amave kodeqsis 992-e muxli, Sesa-bamisad, vinaidan meore mopasuxis samoqalaqosamar-Tlebrivi pasuxismgeblobis safuZvelia saxelSekrule-bo da ara deliqturi valdebuleba, SeuZlebelia pirvelmopasuxes, ssk-is 998-e muxlis safuZvelze, meore mopa-suxesTan erTad, solidarulad daekisros sarCeliT moT-xovnili Tanxis gadaxda. miTiTebuli norma adgens im pir-Ta solidarul pasuxismgeblobas, romlebic arasaxel-

75

Sekrulebo zianis miyenebaSi erTad monawileobdnen. mo-cemul SemTxvevaSi, meore mopasuxes pasuxismgebloba da-ekisra ara imis gamo, rom man arasaxelSekrulebo ziani mi-ayena mosarCeles, aramed imis gamo, rom 25.10.2007 wlisxelSekruleba mas avaldebulebda, Seesrulebina am xel-SekrulebiT gaTvaliswinebuli alternatiuli valdebu-lebebidan erT-erTi, Sesabamisad, sarCeliTac zemoxse-nebuli xelSekrulebidan gamomdinare pirveladi moT-xovnaa wamoyenebuli. cxadia, Tu meore mopasuxis pasuxis-mgebloba mosarCelisaTvis arasaxelSekrulebo zianis mi-yenebas ar ukavSirdeba, verc pirveli mopasuxe iqnebaararsebuli zianis miyenebaSi Tanamonawile piri da, ssk-is 998-e muxlis safuZvelze, pasuxismgeblobac ver dae-kisreba.

35. zemoaRniSnulidan gamomdinare, sakasacio sasamar-Tlo miiCnevs, rom gasaCivrebuli gadawyvetileba pirve-li mopasuxisaTvis, meore mopasuxesTan erTad, solida-rulad 490 000 aSS dolaris dakisrebis nawilSi iuridiu-lad dausabuTebelia, rac am nawilSi gadawyvetilebis ga-uqmebis absoluturi safuZvelia (sssk-is 394-e muxlis è~qvepunqti).

36. sssk-is 411-e muxlis Tanaxmad, sakasacio sasamar-Tlo TviTon miiRebs gadawyvetilebas saqmeze, Tu ar ar-sebobs am kodeqsis 412-e muxliT gaTvaliswinebuli gadaw-yvetilebis gauqmebisa da saqmis saapelacio sasamarTlo-Si xelaxla gansaxilvelad dabrunebis safuZvlebi.

37. sakasacio sasamarTlo miiCnevs, rom, mocemul Sem-TxvevaSi, ar arsebobs saqmis saapelacio sasamarTloSi xe-laxla gansaxilvelad dabrunebis kanoniT gaTvaliswine-buli romelime safuZveli, Sesabamisad, sakasacio sasamar-Tlo uflebamosilia, TviTon miiRos gadawyvetileba saq-meze, kerZod, palatas miaCnia, rom mopasuxeTa sakasaciosaCivari nawilobriv unda dakmayofildes, unda gauqmdessaapelacio sasamarTlos gasaCivrebuli gadawyvetilebissarezolucio nawilis me-2, me-3 (garda im nawilisa, rom-liTac gasaCivrebuli gadawyvetileba darCa ucvlelad),me-4, me-5, me-6 da me-7 punqtebi da am nawilSi miRebul iq-nes axali gadawyvetileba, romliTac ar dakmayofildebasarCeli pirveli mopasuxisaTvis, meore mopasuxesTan er-Tad, solidarulad 490 000 aSS dolaris dakisrebis Tao-baze. amasTan, ucvlelad unda darCes saapelacio sasamar-

76

Tlos gasaCivrebuli gadawyvetilebis sarezolucio na-wilis pirveli punqti, me-3 punqti im nawilSi, romliTacdanarCen nawilSi gasaCivrebuli gadawyvetileba darCaucvlelad da me-8 punqti.

38. sssk-is 53-e muxlis pirveli nawilis Tanaxmad, im mxa-ris mier gaRebuli xarjebis gadaxda, romlis sasargeblo-dac iqna gamotanili gadawyvetileba, ekisreba meore mxa-res, Tundac es mxare gaTavisuflebuli iyos saxelmwifobiujetSi sasamarTlo xarjebis gadaxdisagan. Tu sarCelidakmayofilebulia nawilobriv, maSin mosarCeles am mux-lSi aRniSnuli Tanxa miekuTvneba sarCelis im moTxovnisproporciulad, rac sasamarTlos gadawyvetilebiT iqnadakmayofilebuli, xolo mopasuxes _ sarCelis im moT-xovnaTa proporciulad, romelzedac mosarCeles uari eT-qva. amave muxlis me-2 nawilis Tanaxmad, am muxlSi aRniSnu-li wesebi Seexeba, agreTve, sasamarTlo xarjebis ganawi-lebas, romlebic gaswies mxareebma saqmis saapelacio da sa-kasacio instanciebSi warmoebisas, xolo, me-3 nawilis Ta-naxmad, Tu saapelacio an sakasacio sasamarTlo Secvlisgadawyvetilebas, an gamoitans axal gadawyvetilebas, Se-sabamisad, Secvlis sasamarTlo xarjebis ganawilebasac.

39. gansaxilvel SemTxvevaSi, sasamarTlos saboloo ga-dawyvetilebiT mosarCelis moTxovna dakmayofilebulianawilobriv, amitom mopasuxeebs, mosarCelis sasar-geblod, sarCelis dakmayofilebuli nawilis proporci-ulad, unda daekisroT 2000 laris gadaxda, mosarCelismier sarCelze gadaxdili saxelmwifo baJis asanazRaureb-lad. rac Seexeba kasatorebs, maTi sakasacio saCivari, ase-ve, nawilobriv dakmayofilda. imis gaTvaliswinebiT, romsakasacio sasamarTlos 08.10.2014 wlis ganCinebiT, sssk-is 47-e muxlis safuZvelze, kasatorebi gaTavisufldnensakasacio saCivarze saxelmwifo baJis gadaxdisagan, saka-sacio palata miiCnevs, rom sssk-is 55-e muxlis mixedviT,sakasacio saCivarze kasatorebis mier gadasaxdeli saxel-mwifo baJis nawilis _ 2000 laris (kasatorebis moTxovnisim nawilis proporciulad, romelic dakmayofilda) gadax-da biujetis Semosavlis sasargeblod unda daekisros ka-satorebis mowinaaRmdege mxares (mosarCeles).


77

samoqalaqo saproceso kodeqsis 408.3, 410-e, 411-e muxle-biT da

g a d a w y v i t a :

1. v. i-isa da i. g-is sakasacio saCivari nawilobriv dakma-yofildes;

2. gauqmdes Tbilisis saapelacio sasamarTlos samoqa-laqo saqmeTa palatis 2014 wlis 9 ivlisis gadawyvetile-bis sarezolucio nawilis me-2, me-3 (garda im nawilisa,romliTac gasaCivrebuli gadawyvetileba darCa ucvle-lad), me-4, me-5, me-6 da me-7 punqtebi da am nawilSi miRe-bul iqnas axali gadawyvetileba;

3. r. g-is sarCeli v. i-isaTvis, i. g-esTan erTad, solida-rulad 490 000 aSS dolaris dakisrebis Taobaze ar dakma-yofildes;

4. saapelacio sasamarTlos gasaCivrebuli gadawyveti-lebis sarezolucio nawilis pirveli punqti, me-3 punqtiim nawilSi, romliTac danarCen nawilSi gasaCivrebuli ga-dawyvetileba darCa ucvlelad da me-8 punqti darCes uc-vlelad.

5. v. i-sa da i. g-es r. g-is sasargeblod daekisroT 2000laris gadaxda, mosarCelis mier sarCelze gadaxdili sa-xelmwifo baJis asanazRaureblad.

6. r. g-es saxelmwifo biujetis sasargeblod daekisros2000 laris gadaxda. saxelmwifo baJi ganTavsebul iqnesSemdeg angariSze: q. Tbilisi, `saxelmwifo xazina~ bankiskodi TRESGE22, mimRebis angariSis #..., saxazino kodi ...;

7. sakasacio sasamarTlos gadawyvetileba sabolooa daar gasaCivrdeba.

78

valis arsebobis aRiareba


#as-383-364-2015 27 maisi, 2016 w., q. Tbilisi

saqarTvelos uzenaesi sasamarTlos samoqalaqosaqmeTa palataSemadgenloba: b. alaviZe (Tavmjdomare, momxsenebeli),

z. ZlieriSvili,p. qaTamaZe

davis sagani: fuladi valdebulebis Sesruleba

aRwerilobiTi nawili:1. mosarCelis moTxovna da sarCelis faqtobrivi sa-

fuZvlebi:1.1. saqarTvelos ekonomikisa da mdgradi ganviTarebis

saministrom (SemdgomSi _ mosarCele, mowinaaRmdege mxa-re an kreditori) sarCeli aRZra sasamarTloSi ss `s-is~(SemdgomSi _ mopasuxe, apelanti, kasatori an movale) mi-marT eleqtroenergiis Rirebulebis _ 2 238,99 laris da-kisrebis moTxovniT.

1.2. sarCeli emyareba Semdeg garemoebebs: 2010 wlis 11marts saqarTvelos finansTa saministros Semosavlebissamsaxurs, saqarTvelos ekonomikisa da mdgradi ganvi-Tarebis saministrosa da da ss è. XXI-s~ gakotrebis mmar-Tvels Soris `gadaxdisuunarobis saqmis warmoebis Sesa-xeb~ saqarTvelos kanonis 38-e muxlis 121 punqtis Sesa-bamisad, gaformda SeTanxmeba, romlis safuZvelzec sa-qarTvelos ekonomikisa da mdgradi ganviTarebis saminis-tros naturiT gadaeca auqcionze gausxvisebeli sameur-veo qoneba, maT Soris, 2010 wlis 11 martis debitorulimoTxovna komerciul subieqtebTan 207 382 136 lari. mo-sarCelem 2013 wlis 5 aprils mopasuxes mimarTa weriliT,romliTac moiTxova ss è. XXI-is~ mimarT arsebuli dava-lianebis _ 2 238,99 laris dafarva (romelic warmoSobi-lia ss `s-niis~ mier ss `s-is~ wyaltubos filialisaTvismiwodebuli eleqtroenergiis safasuris gadauxdelobisSedegad). werilis pasuxad movalem kreditors mosTxo-

79

va arsebuli davalianebis gaqviTva, romelic gamomdina-reobda 2008 wels ss è. XXI-isaTvis~ mopasuxis sasar-geblod dakisrebuli Tanxidan, rac arasworia, radganacmosarCele ar warmoadgens ss è. XXI-is~ uflebamonac-vles (ix. sarCeli).

2. mopasuxis pozicia:mopasuxem moTxovnis gamomricxavi/Semaferxebeli Se-

sagebliT ar cno sarCeli da ganmarta, rom kreditoriswerilis pasuxad, miuxedavad moTxovnis xandazmulobi-sa, mopasuxem mosarCeles, samoqalaqo kodeqsis 442-e-443-e muxlebis Sesabamisad, acnoba, rom sasamarTlos 2007 wlis17 dekembris kanonier ZalaSi Sesuli gadawyvetilebis sa-fuZvelze ss è. XXI-isaTvis~ mopasuxis sasargeblod da-kisrebul davalianebaSi gaqviTa moTxovna. sarCelis aR-Zvramde mosarCeles pretenzia ar ganucxadebia, xolomoTxovnaTa gaqviTvis Sedegad valdebuleba Sewyda da ararsebobs davis sagani. garda aRniSnulisa, mopasuxem miu-TiTa im garemoebaze, rom davalianeba 2007 wlamdea war-moSobili, xolo sarCeli 2014 welsaa aRZruli, rac, samo-qalaqo kodeqsis 129-e muxlis pirveli nawilis Sesabami-sad, mis xandazmulobas adasturebs (ix. Sesagebeli).

3. pirveli instanciis sasamarTlos gadawyvetile-bis sarezolucio nawili:

Tbilisis saqalaqo sasamarTlos samoqalaqo saqmeTakolegiis 2014 wlis 2 maisis gadawyvetilebiT sarCeli dak-mayofilda, mopasuxes mosarCelis sasargeblod daekisra2 238,99 laris gadaxda.

4. apelantis moTxovna:saqalaqo sasamarTlos gadawyvetileba saapelacio we-

siT gaasaCivra mopasuxem, moiTxova misi gauqmeba da sar-Celis dakmayofilebaze uaris Tqma.

5. gasaCivrebuli ganCinebis sarezolucio nawili:Tbilisis saapelacio sasamarTlos samoqalaqo saqme-

Ta palatis 2015 wlis 16 Tebervlis ganCinebiT saapela-cio saCivari ar dakmayofilda, xolo gasaCivrebuli ga-dawyvetileba darCa ucvlelad.

6. kasatoris moTxovna:saapelacio sasamarTlos ganCineba sakasacio wesiT ga-

asaCivra mopasuxem, moiTxova misi gauqmeba da axali ga-dawyvetilebiT sarCelis dakmayofilebaze uaris Tqma (ix.sakasacio saCivari).

80

samotivacio nawili:sakasacio sasamarTlom Seiswavla saqmis masalebi, ga-

saCivrebuli ganCinebis dasabuTebuloba, sakasacio saCiv-ris safuZvlebi da miiCnevs, rom kasatoris moTxovna sa-fuZvliania da unda dakmayofildes Semdeg garemoebaTagamo:

1. gasaCivrebuli ganCinebis Secvlis faqtobrivi dasamarTlebrivi dasabuTeba:

1.1. sakasacio sasamarTlos Sefasebis sagans miRebulimomsaxurebis (moxmarebuli eleqtroenergiis) Rirebule-bis anazRaurebis kanoniereba warmoadgens, romelsac mo-pasuxe gamoricxavs urTierTmoTxovnaTa gaqviTvis gziTvaldebulebis SewyvetiT, aseve, sarCelis xandazmulo-bis gamo. saapelacio palatam moTxovnis gaqviTvis Sesa-xeb mopasuxis werilobiTi mimarTva fuladi valdebule-bis arsebobis damadasturebel dokumentad miiCnia daswored masze dayrdnobiT ar gaiziara mopasuxis mosaz-reba sarCelis xandazmulobasTan dakavSirebiT.

1.2. gasaCivrebuli ganCinebiT dadgenilia davis gadaw-yvetisaTvis mniSvnelobis mqone Semdegi faqtobrivi ga-remoebebi:

1.2.1. 2010 wlis 11 martis xelSekrulebisa da miReba-Cabarebis aqtis safuZvelze mosarCeles gadaeca ss è. XXI-is~ debitoruli moTxovna 207 382 136 laris odenobiT.

1.2.2. 2013 wlis 5 aprils mosarCelem movales mimarTa 2238,99 laris davalianebis anazRaurebis moTxovniT, da-saxelebul dokuments Tan erTvis abonentis baraTi, ro-melic Seicavs mopasuxe sazogadoebis wyaltubos filia-lisTvis miwodebuli eleqtroenergiis safasuris am-saxvel monacems.

1.2.3. mosarCelis mxridan movalis mimarT wardgenilimoTxovna Sedis ss è. XXI-is~ mier saministrosaTvis daT-mobil moTxovnebSi.

1.2.4. 2013 wlis 25 aprilis weriliT movalem mosarCe-les acnoba, rom igi iyenebda gaqviTvis uflebas da ss è.XXI-is~ mimarT arsebul eleqtroenergiis davalianebisTanxas gaqviTavda Tbilisis saqalaqo sasamarTlos samo-qalaqo saqmeTa kolegiis 2007 wlis 17 dekembris kanonierZalaSi Sesuli gadawyvetilebiT ss è. XXI-isaTvis~ ss `s-is~ sasargeblod dakisrebuli 425 795,03 laris angariSSi.miTiTebuli gadawyvetilebis Tanaxmad, ss è. XXI-s~ Sps

81

`s-is~ sasargeblod daekisra 413 393,03 larisa da saxel-mwifo baJis _ 12 402 laris gadaxda. gadawyvetilebis aR-srulebis mizniT gacemulia saaRsrulebo furceli.

1.2.5. mosarCele ar warmoadgens ss ̀ e. XXI-is~ imgvar uf-lebamonacvles, rodesac uflebamonacvleze gadadis mi-si winamorbedis yvela ufleba-movaleoba (zogadi ufle-bamonacvleoba), kerZod, mosarCeles aRniSnuli xel-Sekrulebidan gamomdinare arc raime valdebuleba gadas-cemia da arc araviTari valdebuleba mopasuxis mimarT argaaCnia.

1.3. samoqalaqo saproceso kodeqsis 407-e muxlis me-2nawilis Tanaxmad, saapelacio sasamarTlos mier damtki-cebulad cnobili faqtobrivi garemoebebi savaldebuloasakasacio sasamarTlosaTvis, Tu wamoyenebuli ar aris da-saSvebi da dasabuTebuli pretenzia (Sedaveba). dasabuTe-bul pretenziaSi igulisxmeba miTiTeba im procesualurdarRvevebze, romlebic daSvebuli iyo saapelacio sasa-marTlos mier saqmis ganxilvis dros da ramac ganapirobafaqtobrivi garemoebebis arasworad Sefaseba-dadgena, ma-terialursamarTlebrivi normis arasworad gamoyeneba an/da ganmarteba (sssk-is 393-e muxli).

1.4. kasatori ar eTanxmeba saapelacio sasamarTlos Se-fasebebsa da daskvnebs moTxovnis gaqviTvis Taobaze 2013wlis 25 aprilis werilis fuladi valdebulebis arsebo-bis damadasturebel mtkicebulebad miCnevis Taobaze, imsafuZvliT, rom sadavo dokumentSi gamovlenili neba war-moadgenda ss è. XXI-is~ davalianebaSi mopasuxis davalia-nebis gaqviTvas da ara samoqalaqo kodeqsis 341-e muxliTgaTvaliswinebul valis aRiarebas. sakasacio saCivris Ta-naxmad, marTalia, mosarCele ar warmoadgenda ss è. XXI-is~ uflebamonacvles, ris Taobazec man sarCelSi miuTi-Ta da mopasuxis werili am safuZvliT ar iqna gaziarebu-li, Tumca, Tavad am werilis Sinaarsidan ar dgindeba va-lis aRiarebisaTvis mniSvnelobis mqone garemoeba imis To-baze, rom movale kreditoris winaSe faqtobrivi Tu sa-marTlebrivi moqmedebiT gacnobierebulad aRiarebdamoTxovnas.

1.5. sakasacio sasamarTlo srulad iziarebs kasatorisargumentebs da sadavo mtkicebulebis swori samar-Tlebrivi kvalifikaciis mizniT yuradRebas gaamaxvilebsvaldebulebis arsebobis aRiarebis sakiTxze samoqalaqo

82

kodeqsis 137-e, 144-e da 341-e muxlebis konteqstSi:1.5.1. samoqalaqo kodeqsis 137-e muxliT gaTvaliswine-

bul SemTxvevaTa ricxvs miekuTvneba movalis imgvari qme-deba, rodesac igi (valdebuli piri) uflebamosili piriswinaSe avansis, procentis gadaxdiT, garantiis micemiT ansxvagvarad aRiarebs moTxovnis arsebobas. normis winapi-robaTagan pirvelze (garkveuli Sesrulebis ganxorcie-lebis gziT xandazmulobis vadis denis Sewyveta) sakasa-cio palata ar SeCerdeba, radganac, misi ararseboba sada-vo ar aris, rac Seexeba valdebulebis sxvagvarad aRiare-bis sakiTxs, igi SefasebiTi kategoriaa da konkretul Sem-TxvevaSi garemoebaTa sruli analiziT unda dadgindes.movalis aseT qmedebad _ sxvagvar aRiarebad unda CaiTva-los movalis iseTi qmedeba, romelSic aSkarad gamokveTi-lia piris neba valdebulebis arsebobasTan mimarTebiT (ix.susg #as-330-733-06, 19 dekemberi, 2006 weli). samarTlisTeoriaSi gabatonebuli Sexedulebis Tanaxmad, erTmane-Tisagan gansxvavdeba martivi, kauzaluri da abstraqtu-li aRiareba. maTi saerTo niSani isaa, rom isini adasture-ben/warmoSoben moTxovnis arsebobas, Tumca, iuridiuliTvalsazrisiT gaaCniaT ganmasxvavebeli niSan-Tvisebebi.martivi aRiareba saxezea maSin, rodesac movale calmxri-vad adasturebs arsebul valdebulebiT urTierTobas dagacnobierebulad gamoTqvams mzaobas, Seasrulos igi (da-pireba). kauzaluri valis aRiareba aseve mimarTulia ar-sebuli samarTlebrivi urTierTobis dadasturebisakenda bunebrivia unda Seicavdes dapirebis elements, amas-Tan igi SeiZleba ar iyos calmxrivi (mxareTa ormxrivi Se-Tanxmeba arsebuli valdebulebis Sesrulebis damatebiTvadaze, sxva Sesrulebis miRebaze da sxva). rogorc mar-tivi, ise _ kauzaluri aRiareba xandazmulobis vadis de-nis Sewyvetis kerZo SemTxvevas warmoadgens da Sedegad,amave kodeqsis 141-e muxlis ZaliT, Sewyvetamde ganvli-li dro mxedvelobaSi ar miiReba, aramed, vada daiwyebaTavidan. samoqalaqo kodeqsis 137-e muxlis miznebisaT-vis movalis aRiareba samarTlebrivi Zalis matarebelimxolod im SemTxvevaSia, Tuki aRiareba xandazmulobis va-daSi ganxorcielda, radganac safuZvels moklebuli iq-neba msjeloba imaze, rom movalis iuridiuli mniSvnelo-bis mqone moqmedebas Sedegad mohyves ukve gasuli xan-dazmulobis vadis denis Sewyveta. sainteresoa xandazmu-

83

lobis vadis gasvlis Semdgom valis martiv an kauzaluraRiarebas gaaCnia Tu ara iuridiuli Zala. sakasacio pala-tis mosazrebiT, am sakiTxis regulirebisaTvis gamoyene-bul unda iqnas samoqalaqo kodeqsis 144-e muxlis me-3 na-wili, romelic amave muxlis me-2 nawilTan erTobliobaSiganimarteba, kerZod, 144.2 muxlis Tanaxmad, Tuki movalexandazmulobis vadis gasvlis Semdgom Seasrulebs val-debulebas, igi Sesrulebis dabrunebis moTxovnis ufle-bas kargavs, aseT SemTxvevaSi misi Sesagebeli ar SeiZlebaiyos maT Soris imaze miTiTeba, rom Sesrulebis momentSiar icoda xandazmulobis vadis gasvlis faqti, analogiu-ri Zalis matarebelia movalis mier valdebulebis aRia-reba moTxovnis iZulebiTi ganxorcielebis vadis gasvlisSemdeg, Tuki es aRiareba Seicavs piris gacnobierebul ne-bas, rom igi valdebulebas Seasrulebs. es regulaciavrceldeba valis rogorc martiv, ise _ kauzalur aRiare-baze.

1.5.2. rac Seexeba samoqalaqo kodeqsis 341-e muxls,upirvelesad unda aRiniSnos is, rom Tavad am normiT mo-wesrigebuli valis arsebobis aRiareba 137-e da 144.3 mux-lebiT gaTvaliswinebuli aRiarebisgan abstraqtuli bu-nebiT gansxvavdeba, igi Tavad warmoadgens calmxriv ga-rigebas da damoukidebel valdebulebas warmoSobs. valisaRiarebis xelSekruleba, ZiriTadi valdebulebiTi urTi-erTobis arsebobis sadavoobis SemTxvevaSic Sesrulebisvaldebulebas warmoSobs da kreditors moTxovnis uf-lebas aniWebs. sakasacio sasamarTlos mier damkvidrebu-li praqtikis Tanaxmad, samoqalaqo kodeqsis 341-e mux-lis gagebiT valis arsebobis aRiarebasTan ar gvaqvs saq-me, rodesac mxareebi ukve arsebuli valdebulebis Sina-arsidan gamodian an adastureben mas, an mxareebi arsebu-li valdebulebis Sesasruleblad axali valdebulebisSesrulebas kisruloben. amdenad, igi ar unda ukavSirde-bodes ZiriTadi valdebulebidan gamomdinare Sesrule-bis moTxovnas (ix. susg #as-392-371-2013, 8 noemberi, 2013weli). valis aRiarebis xelSekrulebis damoukidebuli bu-neba im kuTxiTac gansxvavdeba valdebuli piris sxvagva-ri aRiarebisagan, rom samoqalaqo kodeqsis 341-e muxliTgaTvaliswinebuli xelSekruleba moTxovnis xandazmulo-bis vadis gasvlis Semdegac namdvilia, radganac, rogorczemoT aRiniSna, igi axal, damoukidebel moTxovnas war-

84

moSobs da am xelSekrulebiT gaTvaliswinebuli valde-bulebis mimarT damoukideblad aiTvleba xandazmulobisvadis dena.

1.5.3. saqmeSi warmodgenili sadavo mtkicebulebis Ses-wavliT irkveva, rom kreditoris moTxovnis pasuxad mo-valem werilobiT gamoxata neba, samoqalaqo kodeqsis 442-e muxlis Sesabamisad, wardgenili moTxovnis ss è. XXI-is~mimarT (sasamarTlos kanonier ZalaSi Sesuli gadawyveti-lebiT dadasturebuli) arsebul moTxovnaSi gaqviTvis Ta-obaze. werilSi ar aris imgvari miTiTeba, romelic raimeformiT daadasturebda movalis mzaobas mosarCelis wi-naSe ganexorcielebina Sesruleba, es garemoeba adastu-rebs gasaCivrebuli ganCinebis umarTebulobas am mtkice-bulebis valdebulebis aRiarebad miCnevis Taobaze.

1.6. sakasacio palata mxedvelobaSi iRebs mopasuxis mi-er SesagebelSi gamoTqmul Sedavebas, romelic imdenadarsebiTi xasiaTisaa, rom moTxovnis ganxorcielebas afer-xebs, kerZod, Sesageblis Tanaxmad, moTxovna (davaliane-ba) warmoSobilia 2007 wlamde, sarCeli ki sasamarTloSiaRZrulia 2014 wels. davalianebis warmoSobis TariRi mo-sarCeles sadavo ar gauxdia, ufro metic, movalisaTvisgagzavnil werils erTvis abonentis baraTi, romlis Ta-naxmadac, weriliTa da winamdebare sarCeliT moTxovni-li davalianeba _ 2 238,99 lari mopasuxe sawarmos wyaltu-bos filials warmoeSva 2007 wlis 7 ivniss, xolo sasamar-Tlos saregistracio Stampze sarCelis wardgenis Tari-Rad miTiTebulia 2014 wlis 3 aprili.

1.7. sasamarTlo yuradRebas gaamaxvilebs winamdebaregadawyvetilebis samotivacio nawilis 1.2.1. punqtSi miTi-Tebul garemoebaze da aRniSnavs, rom samoqalaqo kodeq-sis 198-e muxlis pirveli nawilis Tanaxmad, moTxovna anufleba, romelTa daTmoba da dagiravebac SesaZlebelia,maTma mflobelma SeiZleba sakuTrebad gadasces sxva pirs.moTxovnebi da uflebebi axal pirze gadadis iseTsavemdgomareobaSi, rogorSic isini Zveli mflobelis xelSiiyvnen. moxmobili normidan gamomdinare, SeiZleba iTqvas,rom mosarCelem valdebulebiTsamarTlebriv urTierTo-baSi Caanacvla movalis Zveli kreditori da Tavad valde-bulebas sxva raime cvlileba ar mohyolia. es garemoebaSeexeba moTxovnis warmoSobisa da mis ganxorcielebisfarglebsac. im udavo garemoebis gaTvaliswinebiT, rom

85

davalianeba nardobis xelSekrulebis farglebSia warmo-Sobili, Tanxis anazRaurebis moTxovnis uflebis xan-dazmulobis sakiTxis gadawyvetisas gamoyenebuli undaiqnas samoqalaqo kodeqsis 129-e muxlis pirveli nawiliTdadgenili 3-wliani vada. rogorc saqmis masalebiT das-turdeba, Tavdapirveli kreditoris moTxovna (sk-is 130-e muxli) warmoiSva 2007 wlis 7 ivniss da amoiwura 2010 wlis7 ivniss. udavoa isic, rom sarCeli sasamarTloSi war-modgenilia 2014 wlis 3 aprils.

1.8. samoqalaqo saproceso kodeqsis 411-e muxlis Ta-naxmad, sakasacio sasamarTlo TviTon miiRebs gadawyve-tilebas saqmeze, Tu ar arsebobs am kodeqsis 412-e mux-liT gaTvaliswinebuli gadawyvetilebis gauqmebisa dasaqmis saapelacio sasamarTloSi xelaxla gansaxilveladdabrunebis safuZvlebi. gansaxilvel SemTxvevaSi, pala-ta miiCnevs, rom uflebamosilia, Tavad gadawyvitos da-va, ramdenadac udavoa moTxovnis warmoSobis momenti, xo-lo sarCeli wardgenilia am droidan 3-wliani vadis gas-vlis Semdeg, ris Taobazec pretenzia sarCelis winaaRmdegwardgenil SesagebelSive ganacxada valdebulebma pirma.samoqalaqo kodeqsis 144-e muxlis pirveli nawilis Tanax-mad, xandazmulobis vadis gasvlis Semdeg valdebuli pi-ri uflebamosilia uari Tqvas moqmedebis Sesrulebaze.amdenad, sakasacio palata miiCnevs, rom xandazmulobisvadis gasvlis gamo ar arsebobs samoqalaqo kodeqsis 629-e muxlidan gamomdinare kreditoris moTxovnis dakmayo-filebis safuZveli.

2. sasamarTlo xarjebi:2.1. samoqalaqo saproceso kodeqsis 53-e muxlis pirve-

li-mesame nawilebis Tanaxmad, im mxaris mier gaRebulixarjebis gadaxda, romlis sasargeblodac iqna gamotani-li gadawyvetileba, ekisreba meore mxares, Tundac es mxa-re ganTavisuflebuli iyos saxelmwifo biujetSi sasamar-Tlo xarjebis gadaxdisagan. Tu sarCeli nawilobriv dak-mayofilda, maSin am muxlSi aRniSnuli Tanxa mosarCelesmiekuTvneba sarCelis im moTxovnis proporciulad, ro-melic sasamarTlos gadawyvetilebiT iqna dakmayofile-buli, xolo mopasuxes _ sarCelis moTxovnis im nawilisproporciulad, romelzedac mosarCeles uari eTqva. ammuxlSi aRniSnuli wesebi Seexeba agreTve sasamarTlo xar-jebis ganawilebas, romlebic gaswies mxareebma saqmis saa-

86

pelacio da sakasacio instanciebSi warmoebisas. Tu saape-lacio an sakasacio sasamarTlo Secvlis gadawyvetilebasan gamoitans axal gadawyvetilebas, igi Sesabamisad Sec-vlis sasamarTlo xarjebis ganawilebasac.

2.2. sakasacio sasamarTlos winamdebare gadawyvetile-bis Sesabamisad, dakmayofilda ra mopasuxis mier war-modgenili sakasacio saCivari srulad, palata Tvlis, rommosarCeles kasatoris sasargeblod unda daekisros amukanasknelis mier saapelacio da sakasacio saCivrebis ga-mo gaweuli saproceso xarjis _ 450 (150+300) laris anaz-Raureba.


samoqalaqo saproceso kodeqsis 53-e, 411-e muxlebiT da


1. ss `s-is~ sakasacio saCivari dakmayofildes.2. gauqmdes Tbilisis saapelacio sasamarTlos samoqa-

laqo saqmeTa palatis 2015 wlis 16 Tebervlis ganCinebada miRebul iqnas axali gadawyvetileba.

3. saqarTvelos ekonomikisa da mdgradi ganviTarebissaministros sarCeli ss `s-is~ mimarT eleqtroenergiisRirebulebis _ 2 238,99 laris anazRaurebis Taobaze ardakmayofildes.

4. saqarTvelos ekonomikisa da mdgradi ganviTarebissaministros ss `s-is~ sasargeblod daekisros am ukanas-knelis mier saapelacio da sakasacio saCivrebis gamo ga-daxdili saxelmwifo baJis _ 450 (150+300) laris anazRau-reba.

5. sakasacio saCivarze saxelmwifo baJi gadaxdilia.6. sakasacio sasamarTlos gadawyvetileba sabolooa da

ar gasaCivrdeba.

87

2. xelSekrulebidan gasvla davaldebulebis darRveva

xelSekrulebaze uaris Tqmis Sedegebi

ganCinebasaqarTvelos saxeliT

#as-938-903-2016 5 maisi, 2017 w., q. Tbilisi

saqarTvelos uzenaesi sasamarTlos samoqalaqosaqmeTa palataSemadgenloba: b. alaviZe (Tavmjdomare, momxsenebeli),

z. ZlieriSvili,p. qaTamaZe

davis sagani: Tanxis dakisreba (ZiriTad sarCelSi), xel-Sekrulebis nawilobriv baTilad cnoba, Tanxis dakisreba(Segebebul sarCelSi)

aRwerilobiTi nawili:1. mosarCelis/Segebebuli sarCelis avtoris moT-

xovna da sarCelis/Segebebuli sarCelis faqtobrivisafuZvlebi:

1.1. q. Tbilisis municipalitetis meriam (SemdgomSi _mosarCele, mopasuxe Segebebul sarCelze, apelanti, ka-satori, meijare an mesakuTre) sarCeli aRZra sasamarTlo-Si ss `m-as~ (kreditoruli moTxovnis nawilSi uflebamo-nacvle j. x-i, ix. Tbilisis saqalaqo sasamarTlos samoqa-laqo saqmeTa kolegiis 22.12.2015w. da 29.12.2015w. ganCine-bebi, SemdgomSi _ mopasuxe, Segebebuli mosarCele, mowi-naaRmdege mxare, moijare an moaRnage) mimarT da moiTxo-va misTvis 2011 wlis 20 seqtembris ijaris xelSekrulebi-dan gamomdinare saijaro qiris davalianebis _ 88 687,61laris, amave xelSekrulebidan gamomdinare saijaro qi-ris gadaxdis vadis gadacilebis gamo, pirgasamtexlos _16 519,66 laris, 2013 wlis 25 noembridan qiris gadaxdisvaldebulebis srulad Sesrulebamde yoveldRiurad sa-ijaro qiris 0,1 %-is, amave xelSekrulebis 2.1. punqtisdarRvevisaTvis pirgasamtexlos _ 14 800 laris, aseve, 2011wlis 20 seqtembris aRnagobis xelSekrulebidan gamomdi-nare, aRnagobis gadauxdeli sazRauris _ 56 977,4 laris,

88

am Tanxis gadaxdis vadis gadacilebis gamo, pirgasam-texlos _ 16 479,45 laris, 2013 wlis 25 noembridan sazRa-uris srulad dafarvamde yoveldRiurad gadauxdeliTanxis 0,1%-isa da xelSekrulebis 2.1. punqtis darRvevi-saTvis pirgasamtexlos _ 14 800 laris dakisreba.

1.1.1. sarCeli emyareba Semdeg faqtobriv garemoebebs:q. Tbilisis meriis ssip qonebis marTvis saagentos 2011wlis 20 seqtembris #01-4/419 brZanebiT dakmayofilda mo-pasuxis gancxadeba da pirdapiri gankargvis wesiT, ijarisuflebiT, 49 wlis vadiT gadaeca 2457 kv.m (s/k #...) da 1300kv.m (0.1.14.005.157) miwis nakveTebi. brZanebis Tanaxmad, ija-ris wliuri Tanxa pirvel qonebaze ganisazRvra 41 769 la-riT, xolo meore qonebaze _ 35 100 lariT. moijares qiraunda gadaexada weliwadSi orjer (eqvs TveSi erTxel) Ta-nabarwilad. moijares aseve daevala konkretul miwis nak-veTze, SeTanxmebuli proeqtis Sesabamisad, moewyo Ria dadaxuruli auzi Sesabamisi infrastruqturiT (2012 wlis 1seqtembramde, Tumca, es vada Seicvala da sabolood val-debuleba unda Sesrulebuliyo 2012 wlis 31 dekembramde).xelSekrulebis 12.2 punqtiT, saijaro qiris gadauxdelo-bis an gadaxdis vadis darRvevis SemTxvevaSi, pirgasam-texlos odenoba ganisazRvra qiris 0,1%-iT, magram, ara-nakleb 1 larisa darRvevis dRidan yovel vadagadacile-bul dReze, amasTanave, saijaro xelSekrulebis 2.1. da 2.2.punqtebis darRvevis gamo, mopasuxes ekisreboda pirga-samtexlo 100 laris odenobiT valdebulebis darRvevi-dan mis gamosworebamde. xelSekrulebis 10.4. punqtiT, sa-ijaro pirobebis Seusruleblobis ganmeorebiT gamovle-nis an/da dawesebul vadaSi pirgasamtexlos gadauxdelo-ba meijaris mier miiCneva saijaro urTierTobis calmxri-vad Sewyvetis safuZvlad. qonebis mimReb pirs ar ubrunde-ba gadaxdili Tanxa da ar aunazRaurdeba gaweuli nebismi-eri sxva xarji. meijare uflebamosilia, aseve, moiTxovosqonebisaTvis miyenebuli da sxva saxis zianis an/da zara-lis anazRaureba. moijarem daarRvia xelSekrulebiT na-kisri valdebuleba da mas ericxeba rogorc qiris/sas-yidlis, ise _ pirgasamtexlos davalianeba. swored am sa-fuZvliT Sewyda mxareTa Soris dadebuli xelSekruleba.moaRnagem aseve daarRvia #... miwis nakveTze aRnagobisxelSekrulebiT nakisri valdebulebebi, ramac gamoiwviasaxelSekrulebo urTierTobis Sewyveta. amasTan, mas

89

ericxeba aRnagobis sazRauri xelSekrulebis Sewyvetam-de periodisaTvis da pirgasamtexlo aRnagobis uflebiTsargeblobisaTvis.

1.2. mopasuxem Segebebuli sarCeliT mimarTa sasamar-Tlos Tavdapirveli mosarCelis mimarT da moiTxova q. Tbi-lisis meriis ssip qonebis marTvis saagentos 2011 wlis 20seqtembris #01-4/419 brZanebaze TandarTuli ijarisxelSekrulebis 10.4 da 10.5 punqtebis, 2011 wlis 20 seq-tembris #01-4/420 brZanebaze TandarTuli aRnagobisxelSekrulebis 8.4 da 8.5 punqtebis baTilad cnoba, Sege-bebul sarCelze mopasuxisaTvis sadavo xelSekrulebe-bis farglebSi usasyidlod gadacemuli sabagiros Rire-bulebis _ 200 422,5 evros ekvivalenti larisa da sazoga-doebrivi kvebis obieqtis mSeneblobisaTvis gaweuli xar-jis _ 152 020,73 laris dakisreba, aseve, zianis (miuRebeliSemosavlis) anazRaureba (sarCelis aRZvris momentisaT-vis 50 128,74 laris, xolo gadawyvetilebis aRsrulebam-de yovelTviurad 4 177,39 laris odenobiT).

1.2.1. Segebebuli sarCeli emyareba Semdeg faqtobrivgaremoebebs: q. Tbilisis mTavrobis 2011 wlis 15 agvistosdadgenilebiT Segebebuli mosarCelis mier moTxovnilimiwis nakveTis koreqtirebis mizniT am ukanasknels dae-vala ss `m-as~ sakuTrebaSi darCenil miwis nakveTze Ria dadaxuruli auzis mowyoba; ss `T-isaTvis~ 22 kv.m miwis sa-kuTrebaSi gadacema; ijarisa da aRnagobis uflebiT Sege-bebul mosarCeles gadaeca ori miwis nakveTi (s/k#... da s/k#...) da daevala sazogadoebrivi kvebis obieqtis mowyo-ba; aseve daevala 250 000 aSS dolaris Rirebulebis sabagi-ros SeZena da q. Tbilisis TviTmmarTveli erTeulisaTvissakuTrebaSi usasyidlod gadacema; ss `m-as~ sakuTrebaSiunda gadascemoda gudauris sarekreacio teritoriazesimbolur fasad _ 1 larad miwis nakveTi, romelzec undaaSenebuliyo 100-120 nomriani sastumro. xsenebuli dad-genilebis safuZvelze mopasuxem 2011 wlis 20 seqtembersgamosca ori brZaneba 2457 da 1300 kv.m miwis nakveTebis ss`m-asaTvis~ pirdapiri gankargvis wesiT ijarisa da aRna-gobis uflebebiT gadacemis Taobaze. q. Tbilisis mTavro-bis 2012 wlis 30 oqtombris gankargulebiT Zaladakargu-lad gamocxadda 2011 wlis 15 agvistos dadgenileba gu-dauris teritoriaze miwis simbolur fasad gadacemisa dasastumros mSeneblobis nawilSi. Segebebulma mosarCelem

90

amave dadgenilebiT gaTvaliswinebuli valdebulebebisZiriTadi nawili Seasrula, kerZod: avstriuli kompania`s-isagan~ 200 422,50 evrod SeiZina sabagiro da sakuTreba-Si gadasca saxelmwifos; ss `T-s~ aseve sakuTrebaSi gadas-ca 22 kv.m miwis nakveTi, aRnagobisa da ijaris uflebiTgadacemul miwis nakveTebze moawyo sazogadoebrivi kve-bis obieqti da investirebul iqna 152 020,73 lari; mSeneb-lobis nebarTvis Sesabamisad, daiwyo Ria da daxuruli sa-curao auzis mSenebloba. 2013 wlis 25 noembris brZanebe-biT ssip qonebis marTvis saagentom Sewyvita ijarisa daaRnagobis xelSekrulebebi da masve sakuTrebaSi darCa,rogorc sabagiro mowyobiloba, ise _ sazogadoebrivi kve-bis obieqti. Segebebuli sarCelis Tanaxmad, mxareTa So-ris gaformebuli xelSekrulebebis sadavo punqtebi ewi-naaRmdegeba xelSekrulebidan gasvlis maregulirebelnormebs, aseve, keTilsindisierebis princips, ris gamocsasamarTlos mxridan baTilad unda iqnas cnobili.

2. mopasuxeebis pozicia:2.1. Tavdapirvelma mopasuxem sarCeli nawilobriv, aR-

nagobis sazRaurisa da saijaro qiris davalianebis nawil-Si cno, rac Seexeba pirgasamtexlos, igi miiCnia Seusaba-mod valdebulebis darRvevasTan da moiTxova misi ode-nobis Semcireba.

2.2. Tavdapirvelma mosarCelem Segebebuli sarCeliswinaaRmdeg samarTlebrivi Sedaveba waradgina da gan-marta, rom ijarisa da aRnagobis xelSekrulebebis piro-bebi xelSekrulebis Tavisuflebis principis farglebSimiRweul SeTanxmebas warmoadgens da ar arsebobs sadavodebulebebis baTilad cnobis safuZveli, Sesabamisad, arcmoTxovnili Tanxis dakisrebis winapirobaa saxeze.

3. pirveli instanciis sasamarTlos gadawyvetile-bis sarezolucio nawili:

Tbilisis saqalaqo sasamarTlos samoqalaqo saqmeTakolegiis 2015 wlis 30 seqtembris gadawyvetilebiT Tav-dapirveli sarCeli nawilobriv dakmayofilda, mopasuxes2011 wlis 20 seqtembris xelSekrulebidan gamomdinaresaijaro qiris davalianebis saxiT, mosarCelis sasar-geblod, daekisra 88 687,61 laris gadaxda, masve, amavexelSekrulebiT gaTvaliswinebuli saijaro qiris gadax-dis vadagadacilebis gamo daekisra pirgasamtexlos _ 1652 laris, xolo 2013 wlis 25 noembridan valdebulebis

91

Sesrulebamde gadauxdeli saijaro qiris 0,01 procentisgadaxda, amave gadawyvetilebiT moaRnages, 2011 wlis 20seqtembris xelSekrulebidan gamomdinare, aRnagobis sa-fasuris saxiT daekisra 56 977,4 laris gadaxda, xolo, amTanxis gadaxdis vadagadacilebis gamo pirgasamtexlos _1 647,9 laris, xolo, 2013 wlis 25 noembridan aRnagobisgadauxdeli safasuris 0,01 procentis gadaxda valdebu-lebis Sesrulebamde. danarCen nawilSi Tbilisis meriissarCeli ar dakmayofilda. nawilobriv dakmayofilda Se-gebebuli sarCeli: baTilad iqna cnobili Tbilisis meriisssip qonebis marTvis saagentos 2011 wlis 20 seqtembris#01-4/419 brZanebaze TandarTuli da mxareebs Soris ga-formebuli ijaris xelSekrulebis 10.4 da 10.5 punqtebi,aseve, ssip qonebis marTvis saagentos 2011 wlis 20 seq-tembris #01-4/420 brZanebaze TandarTuli da mxareebsSoris gaformebuli aRnagobis xelSekrulebis 8.4 da 8.5punqtebi, q. Tbilisis merias Segebebuli mosarCelis sa-sargeblod daekisra sabagiros Rirebulebis _ 200 422,5evros ekvivalenti larisa da sazogadoebrivi kvebis obi-eqtis mSeneblobisaTvis gaweuli xarjis _ 152 020,73 la-ris gadaxda. amave gadawyvetilebiT ganawilda procesisxarjebi.

4. apelantis moTxovna:saqalaqo sasamarTlos gadawyvetileba saapelacio we-

siT gaasaCivra q. Tbilisis municipalitetis meriam, moiT-xova sarCelis dakmayofilebaze uaris Tqmis, aseve, Sege-bebuli sarCelis dakmayofilebis nawilSi misi gauqmeba daaxali gadawyvetilebiT sarCelis srulad dakmayofileba,xolo Segebebuli sarCelis dakmayofilebaze uaris Tqma.

5. gasaCivrebuli ganCinebis/damatebiTi ganCinebissarezolucio nawili:

5.1. Tbilisis saapelacio sasamarTlos samoqalaqo saq-meTa palatis 2016 wlis 14 ivnisis ganCinebiT saapelaciosaCivari ar dakmayofilda, xolo, gasaCivrebuli gadawyve-tileba darCa ucvlelad.

5.2. amave sasamarTlos 2016 wlis 21 ivnisis damatebiTiganCinebiT apelants mowinaaRmdege mxaris sasargebloddaekisra iuridiuli momsaxurebis xarjis _ 2 500 larisanazRaureba.

6. kasatoris moTxovna:saapelacio sasamarTlos ganCineba/damatebiTi ganCi-

92

neba sakasacio wesiT gaasaCivra apelantma, moiTxova gan-Cinebis/damatebiTi ganCinebis gauqmeba da axali gadawyve-tilebiT ZiriTadi sarCelis dakmayofileba, xolo Sege-bebuli sarCelis dakmayofilebaze uaris Tqma.

samotivacio nawili:sakasacio sasamarTlom Seiswavla saqmis masalebi, ga-

saCivrebuli ganCinebis dasabuTebuloba, sakasacio saCiv-ris safuZvlebi da miiCnevs, rom kasatoris moTxovna usa-fuZvloa da ar unda dakmayofildes Semdeg garemoebaTagamo:

1. sakasacio ganacxadi da sakasacio ganxilvis pro-cesualuri farglebi:

1.1. Tbilisis saqalaqo sasamarTlos samoqalaqo saqme-Ta kolegiis 2015 wlis 30 seqtembris gadawyvetilebiTTavdapirveli sarCeli saijaro qirisa da aRnagobis saz-Rauris moTxovnis nawilSi dakmayofilda srulad, xolo,pirgasamtexlos nawilSi _ nawilobriv. amave gadawyveti-lebiT Segebebuli sarCeli miCneul iqna safuZvlianadxelSekrulebaze uaris Tqmis samarTlebrivi Sedegebidangamomdinare, restituciis gamomricxav debulebebTan mi-marTebaSi, Sesabamisad, sasamarTlom q. Tbilisis merias,rogorc saxelSekrulebo urTierTobis calmxrivad Sew-yvetis iniciators pirvandeli mdgomareobis aRdgena fu-ladi kompensaciis anazRaurebis saxiT daakisra, rac See-xeba miuRebel Semosavals, Segebebul mosarCeles uari eT-qva mis anazRaurebaze.

1.2. saqalaqo sasamarTlos gadawyvetileba Tavdapir-veli sarCelis dakmayofilebis, aseve, Segebebuli sarCe-lis dakmayofilebaze uaris Tqmis nawilSi mxareTa mierar gasaCivrebula, Sesabamisad, igi samoqalaqo saprocesokodeqsis 264-e (1) muxlis `b~ qvepunqtis Tanaxmad, Sesu-lia kanonier ZalaSi da Sefasebas aRar eqvemdebareba.

1.3. Tavis mxriv, saapelacio palatam ar gaiziara ra Tav-dapirveli mosarCelis saapelacio pretenziebi, ucvle-lad datova gasaCivrebuli gadawyvetileba. amave mocu-lobiTaa warmodgenili sakasacio saCivari, ris gamoc, sa-kasacio palatis msjelobis sagania, rogorc pirgasam-texlos Semcirebis kanoniereba, ise _ xelSekrulebaze ua-ris Tqmis SemTxvevaSi, restituciis gamomricxav piroba-ze mxareTa SeTanxmebis marTlzomiereba (sssk-is 409-e mux-

93

lis Tanaxmad, sakasacio sasamarTlo uflebamosilia Sec-valos saapelacio sasamarTlos gadawyvetileba mxolodim farglebSi, rasac mxareebi moiTxoven).

1.4. 2016 wlis 9 dekembris ganCinebis Tanaxmad, sakasa-cio saCivris gansaxilvelad daSvebis safuZvels warmo-adgens samoqalaqo saproceso kodeqsis 391-e (5) muxlisà~ qvepunqti (dava mniSvnelovania samarTlis ganviTare-bisa da erTgvarovani sasamarTlo praqtikis Camoyalibe-bis TvalsazrisiT), Sesabamisad, erTgvarovani sasamarTlopraqtikis CamoyalibebisaTvis sainteresoa msjelobaiseT sakiTxebze, rogoricaa: xelSekrulebidan gasvlis(xelSekrulebaze uaris Tqmis) winapirobebi da misi samar-Tlebrivi Sedegebi; moTxovnis uzrunvelyofis valdebu-lebiT-samarTlebrivi saSualebis gamoyeneba da uz-runvelyofis saSualebis samarTliani odenobiT gan-sazRvra.

2. saapelacio sasamarTlos mier dadgenili faqte-bi da maTi savaldebuloba winamdebare ganCinebis mi-marT:

2.1. q. Tbilisis mTavrobis 2011 wlis 15 agvistos#22.24.914 dadgenilebiT miRebul iqna Semdegi gadawyve-tileba:

a) ganxorcieldes q. Tbilisis TviTmmarTveli erTeu-lis sakuTrebaSi arsebuli uZravi qonebis: q. TbilisSi,parki `m-is~ mier dakavebuli 129057 kv.m miwis nakveTis (s/k #...) sazRvrebis cvlileba da koreqtirebuli sazRvre-biT q. Tbilisis TviTmmarTveli erTeulis sakuTrebad re-gistracia, danarTi 1-iT warmodgenili koreqtirebuli sa-kadastro azomviTi naxazis mixedviT, Semdegi pirobebiT:ss `m-am~ sakuTrebaSi arsebul miwis nakveTze (s/k #...) Se-Tanxmebuli proeqtis Sesabamisad, uzrunvelyos 2012 wlis1 seqtembramde Ria da daxuruli auzis mowyoba, Sesabami-si infrastruqturiT;

b) miwis nakveTebis koreqtirebuli sazRvrebiT dare-gistrirebidan 1 kviris vadaSi ss `m-am~ warmoadginos ss`T-Tan~ gaformebuli xelSekruleba, ss `T-isaTvis~ 22 kv.mmiwis nakveTis sakuTrebaSi gadacemis Sesaxeb, SemdgomSitransformatoris ganTavsebis mizniT;

g) gadaeces ss `m-as~ ijariTa da aRnagobis uflebiT,pirdapiri gankargvis formiT, `m-is~ teritoriaze arse-buli, danarTi 2-Si da danarTi 3-Si aRniSnuli miwis nakve-

94

Tebi 49 wlis vadiT, im pirobiT, rom gadacemul terito-riaze parki `m-is~ rekonstruqciis Sesabamisad, moawyobssaz.kvebis centrs (food court), 2012 wlis 4 agvistomde;

d) ss `m-am~ SeiZinos 250 000 aSS dolaris Rirebulebis`moving carpet~ q. Tbilisis TviTmmarTveli erTeulisaTvis2011 wlis 25 dekembramde, usasyidlod sakuTrebaSi gada-cemis mizniT;

e) am dadgenilebis safuZvelze, gudauris sarekreacioteritoriaze SeirCes da ss `m-as~ gadaeces miwis nakveTisimbolur fasad _ 1 larad;

v) saprivatizacio pirobebad ganisazRvros: saprivati-zacio safasuris gadaxda nasyidobis xelSekrulebis sa-qarTvelos prezidentTan SeTanxmebidan 1 Tvis vadaSi;saprivatizacio teritoriaze aranakleb 100-120 nomrianisastumros mSenebloba da dasruleba (eqspluataciaSi mi-Reba) 2012 wlis dekembris bolomde.

2.2. 2011 wlis 20 seqtembers q. Tbilisis meriis sajarosamarTlis iuridiuli piris qonebis marTvis saagentos mi-er gamoica #01-4/419 brZaneba q. TbilisSi, `m-is~ parkSiarsebuli 2457 kv.m miwis nakveTis (s/k #...) ss `m-asaTvis~pirdapiri gankargvis wesiT ijariT gadacemis Sesaxeb. mi-TiTebuli brZanebis danarTs warmoadgens q. Tbilisis me-riasa da ss `m-as~ Soris dadebuli ijaris xelSekrulebispirobebi, romlebic xelmowerilia orive mxaris mier. ama-ve brZanebis safuZvelze q. Tbilisis meriasa da ss `m-as~Soris daido ijaris xelSekruleba Semdegi pirobebiT:

a) ijaris vada ganisazRvra 49 wliT da ss `m-as~ ijariTgadaeca q. TbilisSi, `m-is~ parkSi arsebuli 2457 kv.m miwisnakveTi;

b) ijaris yovelwliuri Rirebuleba Seadgenda 41 769lars, rac gadaxdili unda yofiliyo Tanabarwilad yovel6 TveSi erTxel ara ugvianes yoveli eqvsTviani periodisgasvlis ukanaskneli dRisa. vadis aTvla iwyeboda ssip qo-nebis marTvis saagentos Sesabamisi brZanebis gamocemisdRidan;

g) xelSekrulebis 12.2 muxlis Sesabamisad, saijaro qi-ris gadauxdelobis an gadaxdis vadis darRvevis SemTxve-vaSi, pirgasamtexlo gansazRvrul iqna qiris 0.1%-iT, mag-ram aranakleb 1 larisa, valdebulebis darRvevis dRidan,yovel vadagadacilebul dReze;

d) 2.1. muxliT ganisazRvra, rom ss `m-a~ valdebuli iyo,

95

#... sakadastro kodiT registrirebul miwis nakveTze, Se-Tanxmebuli proeqtis Sesabamisad, 2012 wlis 1 seqtembram-de moewyo Ria da daxuruli tipis sacurao auzi, Sesabami-si infrastruqturiT (q. Tbilisis meriis sajaro samar-Tlis iuridiuli piris qonebis marTvis saagentos 2012wlis 6 agvistos #01-4/86 brZanebiT cvlileba iqna Seta-nili ijaris xelSekrulebaSi da es vada ganisazRvra 2012wlis 31 dekembramde, xolo 2012 wlis 31 dekembris #01-4/133 brZanebiT, Ria da daxuruli tipis auzebis mSeneblo-bis vada gagrZelda 2013 wlis 30 ivnisamde);

e) ijaris xelSekrulebis 2.2. muxlis Sesabamisad, ss `m-as~ q. Tbilisis TviTmmarTveli erTeulisaTvis 2011 wlis25 dekembramde usasyidlod sakuTrebaSi unda gadaeca 250000 aSS dolaris Rirebulebis `moving carpet~;

v) saijaro pirobebis 2.1. da 2.2. muxlebiT gaTvaliswi-nebuli valdebulebis Seusruleblobis SemTxvevaSi, mo-ijares ekisreboda pirgasamtexlos saxiT 100 laris gadax-dis valdebuleba yovel vadagadacilebul dReze;

z) 10.4 muxlis Tanaxmad, saijaro pirobebis Seusruleb-lobis (darRvevis) ganmeorebiT gamovlenis SemTxveva da/an dawesebul vadaSi pirgasamtexlos gadauxdeloba mei-jaris mier miiCneoda saijaro urTierTobis calmxrivadSewyvetis safuZvlad. qonebis mimReb pirs ukan ar ub-rundeboda gadaxdili Tanxa da ar aunazRaurdeboda ga-weuli nebismieri xarji. meijares aseve gaaCnda ufleba,moeTxova qonebisTvis miyenebuli da sxva saxis zianis da/an zaralis anazRaureba;

T) xelSekrulebis 10.5 muxlis Sesabamisad, saijaro ur-TierTobis calmxrivad Sewyvetis SemTxvevaSi sargeblo-bis uflebis mimReb pirs ar ubrundeboda Setanili Tanxada ar aunazRaurdeboda gaweuli xarjebi.

2.3. 2011 wlis 20 seqtembers q.Tbilisis meriis ssip qo-nebis marTvis saagentom gamosca #01-4/420 brZaneba q.Tbi-lisSi, `m-is~ parkSi arsebuli 1300 kv.m miwis nakveTis (ss/k#...) ss `m-asaTvis~ pirdapiri gankargvis wesiT aRnagobisuflebiT gadacemis Sesaxeb. miTiTebuli brZanebis da-narTs warmoadgens q. Tbilisis meriasa da ss `m-as~ Sorisdadebuli aRnagobis xelSekruleba Semdegi pirobebiT:

a) aRnagobis vada ganisazRvra 49 wliT da ss `m-as~ aRna-gobis uflebiT gadaeca q. TbilisSi, `m-is~ parkSi arsebu-li 1300 kv.m miwis nakveTi;

96

b) aRnagobis yovelwliuri Rirebuleba Seadgenda 35 100lars, rac gadaxdili unda yofiliyo Tanabarwilad yovel6 TveSi erTxel, ara ugvianes yoveli eqvsTviani periodisgasvlis ukanaskneli dRisa. vadis aTvla iwyeboda ssip qo-nebis marTvis saagentos Sesabamisi brZanebis gamocemisdRidan;

g) aRnagobis xelSekrulebis 10.2 muxlis Sesabamisad,qiris gadauxdelobis an gadaxdis vadis darRvevis Sem-TxvevaSi, pirgasamtexlo gansazRvrul iqna qiris 0.1%-iT,magram aranakleb 1 larisa, valdebulebis darRvevis dRi-dan, yovel vadagadacilebul dReze;

d) 2.1. muxliT ganisazRvra ss `m-as~ valdebuleba #...sakadastro kodiT registrirebul miwis nakveTze, SeTan-xmebuli proeqtis Sesabamisad, 2012 wlis 1 seqtembramdemoewyo Ria da daxuruli tipis sacurao auzi, SesabamisiinfrastruqturiT (ssip qonebis marTvis saagentos 2012wlis 6 agvistos #01-4/87 brZanebiT cvlileba iqna Seta-nili xelSekrulebaSi da es vada ganisazRvra 2012 wlis 31dekembramde, xolo, 2012 wlis 31 dekembris #01-4/132brZanebiT, Ria da daxuruli tipis auzebis mSeneblobisvada gagrZelda 2013 wlis 30 ivnisamde);

e) xelSekrulebis 2.2. muxlis Sesabamisad, ss `m-as~ sar-geblobis uflebiT gadacemul teritoriaze parki `m-is~rekonstruqciis gegmis Sesabamisad, 2012 wlis 1 seq-tembramde unda ganexorcielebina saz.sakvebis centris(food court) mowyoba;

v) 2.3. muxlis Sesabamisad, ss `m-as~ q. Tbilisis TviT-mmarTveli erTeulisaTvis 2011 wlis 25 dekembramde usas-yidlod sakuTrebaSi unda gadaeca 250 000 aSS dolarisRirebulebis `moving carpet~;

z) xelSekrulebis pirobebis 2.1. 2.2. da 2.3. muxlebiTgaTvaliswinebuli valdebulebis Seusruleblobis Sem-TxvevaSi, ss `m-as~ daekisreboda pirgasamtexlo 100 la-ris odenobiT yovel vadagadacilebul dReze;

T) 8.4 muxlis Tanaxmad, aRnagobis pirobebis Seusru-leblobis (darRvevis) ganmeorebiT gamovlenis SemTxve-va da/an dawesebul vadaSi pirgasamtexlos gadauxdelo-ba mesakuTris mier miiCneoda saijaro urTierTobis cal-mxrivad Sewyvetis safuZvlad. qonebis mimReb pirs ukanar ubrundeboda gadaxdili Tanxa da ar aunazRaurdebo-da gaweuli nebismieri sxva xarji. mesakuTre aseve ufle-

97

bamosili iyo, moeTxova qonebisTvis miyenebuli da sxvasaxis zianis da/an zaralis anazRaureba;

i) aRnagobis pirobebis 8.5 muxlis Sesabamisad, aRnago-bis urTierTobis calmxrivad Sewyvetis SemTxvevaSi, sar-geblobis uflebis mimReb pirs ar daubrundeboda Seta-nili Tanxa da ar aunazRaurdeboda gaweuli xarjebi.

2.4. #... miwis nakveTi, romelzec unda aSenebuliyo Riada daxuruli auzebi warmoadgenda ss `m-as~ sakuTrebas.

2.5. ss `m-as~ srulad ar gadauxdia ijarisa da aRnagobisxelSekrulebebiT gansazRvruli sazRauri. ijaris xel-Sekrulebidan gamomdinare davalianeba Seadgens 88 687,61lars, xolo, aRnagobis xelSekrulebidan gamomdinare da-valianeba _ 56 977,4 lars.

2.6. ss `m-as~ davalebis safuZvelze ss `b-am~ SeiZina e.w`moving carpet~ (sabagiro mowyobiloba) da gadasca q. Tbili-sis merias. ssip qonebis marTvis saagentos 2012 wlis 22ivnisis weriliT q. Tbilisis meriam miiRo Sesruleba. saba-giro mowyobilobis Rirebulebam Seadgina 200 422,5 evro.

2.7. q. Tbilisis mTavrobis 2011 wlis 15 agvistos#22.24.914 dadgenilebiT gaTvaliswinebuli 22 kv.m miwisnakveTi sakuTrebaSi gadaeca ss `T-s~.

2.8. 2012 wlis 30 oqtombers q. Tbilisis mTavrobis#29.36.1085 dadgenilebiT Zaladakargulad gamocxaddaq. Tbilisis TviTmmarTveli erTeulis qonebis koreqti-rebisa da garkveuli nakveTebis ss `m-asaTvis~ sakuTreba-sa da sargeblobaSi gadacemis Sesaxeb q. Tbilisis mTavro-bis 2011 wlis 15 agvistos #22.24.914 dadgenilebis me-5 dame-6 punqtebi (romelic Seexeboda gudauris sarekreaciozonaSi ss `m-asaTvis~ miwis nakveTis simbolur fasad ga-dacemis sakiTxs), dadgenilebaSi miTiTebulia, rom ver mo-xerxda gudauris sarekreacio teritoriaze miwis nakve-Tis gadacema kompaniisaTvis, azrs kargavs miwis nakveTisSerCeva, radgan saprivatizacio pirobebiT gansazRvrulvadaSi ver moxdeba sastumros mSenebloba da misi eqsplu-ataciaSi miReba.

2.9. q. Tbilisis meriis ssip qonebis marTvis saagentos2013 wlis 25 noembris #01-4/143 da #01-4/144 brZanebe-biT valdebulebebis darRvevis motiviT Sewyda q. Tbili-sis meriasa da ss `m-as~ Soris gaformebuli ijarisa da aR-nagobis xelSekrulebebi, ris Sesaxebac eleqtronulifostiT ss `m-as~ gaegzavna Setyobineba 5 dRis vadaSi mi-

98

wis nakveTebis pirvandel mdgomareobaSi moyvanisa da me-sakuTrisaTvis dabrunebis Sesaxeb.

2.10. aRnagobis xelSekrulebiT gaTvaliswinebuli val-debulebis _ sazogadoebrivi kvebis obieqtis mosawyobadss `m-am~ gaaforma sxvadasxva xelSekruleba, maT Soris,miwis nakveTis dakvalvis, saproeqto da nardobis xel-Sekrulebebi, romelTa saerTo Rirebulebam Seadgina 152020,73 lari. kasatoris mowinaaRmdege mxarem am mizniTaseve SeiZina sxvadasxva masala, romelTa saerTo Rirebu-lebam Seadgina 13 902,57 lari.

2.11. saapelacio palatis mier dadgenilad miCneuli ze-moxsenebuli garemoebebi savaldebuloa sakasacio sasa-marTlos winamdebare ganCinebis mimarT, radganac maT wi-naaRmdeg kasators dasabuTebuli Sedaveba ar warmoud-genia sakasacio sasamarTlosaTvis (sssk-is 407-e muxlisme-2 nawilis Tanaxmad, saapelacio sasamarTlos mier dam-tkicebulad cnobili faqtobrivi garemoebebi savalde-buloa sakasacio sasamarTlosaTvis, Tu wamoyenebuli araris dasaSvebi da dasabuTebuli pretenzia (Sedaveba)).

3. sakasacio Sedavebis safuZvlebi:3.1. kasatori sadavod xdis sasamarTlos mxridan ija-

risa da aRnagobis xelSekrulebaTa im debulebebis baTi-lad cnobas, romelTa Tanaxmadac, mowinaaRmdege mxarismxridan valdebulebis ganmeorebiT darRvevis motiviTq. Tbilisis meriis mier xelSekrulebis Sewyvetis SemTxve-vaSi, ss `m-as~ qonebrivi restitucia ar daiSveboda. Sesa-bamisad, mxare miiCnevs, rom sasamarTlos ar unda gamoe-yenebina samoqalaqo kodeqsis 54-e muxli. misi mosazre-biT, sadavo daTqmebi xelSekrulebis Tavisuflebis prin-cipis (sk-is 319.1 muxli) farglebSi SeTanxmebul pirobebswarmoadgenda, romelTa mimarTac moqmedebda standartu-li xelSekrulebebis maregulirebeli wesebi (sk-is 342.1muxli). Tavad SeTanxmeba srulad Seesabameboda samoqa-laqo kodeqsis 359-e muxlis debulebas, am TvalsazrisiTki qvemdgomma sasamarTloebma arasworad gamoiyenes/gan-martes samoqalaqo kodeqsis 352-e muxli.

3.2. kasatoris azriT, swored im safuZvlidan gamomdi-nare, rom movalis restituciis amkrZalavi saxelSekru-lebo daTqmebi namdvilia, ar arsebobda q. Tbilisis meri-isaTvis gadacemuli sabagiro mowyobilobis Rirebulebis,aseve, saz.kvebis obieqtis mSeneblobaze gaweuli xarje-

99

bis anazRaurebis winapirobebi, amasTanave, sasamarTlommSeneblobis xarjebis odenobis gansazRvrisas arasworadgaanawila mtkicebis tvirTi. kasators ar ekisreboda amkuTxiT dokumentebis wardgenis valdebuleba, aramed,moTxovnili odenobiT xarjis miznobriobis mtkicebisvaldebuleba ss `m-as~ mxares iyo, radganac miznobriobissakiTxs Seedava kasatori.

3.3. kasatori acxadebs, rom sasamarTlom samoqalaqokodeqsis 420-e muxlis moTxovnaTa darRveviT, arasworadSeamcira xelSekrulebis Tavisuflebis principis dacviTSeTanxmebuli pirgasamtexlo, kerZod, sasamarTlos ar da-usabuTebia Semcirebis aucileblobis winapirobebi, amas-Tanave, sarCeliT moTxovnili pirgasamtexlos nawilis da-kisrebaze qvemdgom sasamarTloebs saerTod ar umsjeli-aT.

4. sakasacio sasamarTlos Sefasebebi da samar-Tlebrivi daskvnebi:

4.1. sakasacio palata nawilobriv iziarebs kasatorispretenzias samoqalaqo kodeqsis 352-e muxlis gamoyene-basTan dakavSirebiT, Tumca, ar iziarebs pretenziebs,romlebic exeba saproceso samarTlis normebis darRve-vas.

4.2. saqmis masalebiT dadgenilia, rom mxareebi erTma-neTTan imyofebodnen saxelSekrulebo urTierTobaSi,kerZod, erT SemTxvevaSi maT Soris daido sanivTosamar-Tlebrivi garigeba (aRnagoba), xolo meore SemTxvevaSi _valdebulebiTsamarTlebrivi garigeba (ijara). sakasaciopalata ganmartavs, rom sanivTo samarTlis regulaciissferos mikuTvnebuli ufleba-movaleobebi, sanivTo sa-marTlis absoluturi bunebidan gamomdinare, imperatiu-li danawesebiT xasiaTdeba da kanoniT pirdapir gauTva-liswinebeli Carevebi am regulaciaSi yovelTvis ar daiS-veba. sanivTo samarTlis imperatiul bunebas ganapirobebsis, rom am wesebiT daregulirebelia pirTa `qonebaze ba-tonobiT~ ganpirobebuli SemTxvevebi, ris gamoc igi abso-luturi xasiaTiT gamoirCeva (am ganmartebis farglebSieqceva maT Soris sanivTo garigebebiT mopovebuli ufle-bebi, rameTu samoqalaqo kodeqsis 147-e muxlis Tanaxmad,qoneba, am kodeqsis mixedviT, aris yvela nivTi da arama-terialuri qonebrivi sikeTe, romelTa flobac, sar-gebloba da gankargva SeuZliaT fizikur da iuridiul pi-

100

rebs da romelTa SeZenac SeiZleba SeuzRudavad, Tuki esakrZaluli ar aris kanoniT an ar ewinaaRmdegeba zneobrivnormebs). rac Seexeba valdebulebiTi samarTlidan gamom-dinare uflebebsa da movaleobebs, isini relatiuri xasi-aTiT gamoirCevian, rameTu regulirebis obieqti e.w `pi-radi uflebebia~, romlebic SeZenilia xelSekrulebiT,deliqtiT, usafuZvlo gamdidrebiT an kanoniT gaTvalis-winebuli sxva saSualebiT, Sesabamisad, fardobiTobis me-ti elementis arsebobac am niSnebiTaa ganpirobebuli.

4.3. samoqalaqo kodeqsis 233-e (1) muxlis Tanaxmad, mi-wis nakveTi SeiZleba sxva pirs gadaeces vadian sargeblo-baSi ise, rom mas hqondes am nakveTze an mis qveS raime na-gebobis aRmarTvis ufleba, aseve, am uflebis gasxvisebis,memkvidreobiT gadacemis, Txovebis, gaqiravebis ufleba(aRnagobis ufleba). dasaxelebuli normidan gamomdina-re, debuleba _ `pirs SesaZloa hqondes~, ar unda iqnas ga-gebuli sityvasityviTi mniSvnelobiT, ramdenadac igi aR-nagobis instituts daakargvinebda arss. normis namdviliarsis dasadgenad, sakasacio palata Tvlis, rom ganmarte-ba unda ganxorcieldes teleologiuri meTodiT. samoqa-laqo kodeqsis 233-e-241-e muxlebis Sinaarsidan gamomdi-nare, SeiZleba iTqvas, rom aRnagoba warmoadgens sanivTogarigebis specialur saxes, romlis mizani miwaze an misqveS nagebobis aRmarTvaa. amgvari SeTanxmebisas mesakuT-risa da moaRnagis mizani Semdegia: moaRnages, romelsacar gaaCnia uZravi qoneba sakuTrebaSi, surs miwis nakveTiSenobis asaSeneblad, raTa garkveuli drois ganmavloba-Si sakuTari SexedulebiT isargeblos misiT, xolo miwismesakuTris interesi am sargeblobis Sedegad garkveulisazRauris miReba/armiReba da vadis amowurvis SemdgomSenobis sakuTrebaSi datovebaa (sk-is 234-e (2) (3), 236-e (1)da 239-e muxlebis Tanaxmad, aRnagobis uflebis safuZ-velze aSenebuli nageboba iTvleba aRnagobis uflebis ar-sebiT Semadgenel nawilad da registrirdeba aRnagobisuflebis mqone piris sakuTrebad. aRnagobis uflebis Sew-yvetisas aRnagobis uflebis safuZvelze aSenebuli nage-boba xdeba miwis nakveTis arsebiTi Semadgeneli nawili.aRnagobis uflebis mqones SeiZleba xelSekrulebiT dae-kisros sazRauris gadaxda. miwis nakveTis mesakuTris esufleba ganuyofelia nakveTze sakuTrebis uflebisagan.sasyidliani aRnagobis uflebis vadis gasvlis SemTxveva-

101

Si, Tu mxareTa SeTanxmebiT sxva ram ar aris gaTvaliswine-buli, miwis nakveTis mesakuTrem aRnagobis uflebis mqo-nes unda misces anazRaureba am nakveTze aRmarTuli na-gebobis Rirebulebis ori mesamedis odenobiT. miwis nak-veTis mesakuTres SeuZlia, aRnagobis uflebis mqones,anazRaurebis gadaxdis sanacvlod, gaugrZelos aRnago-bis ufleba am nakveTze aRmarTuli nagebobis arsebobissavaraudo vadiT, Tu mxareTa SeTanxmebiT sxva ram ar arisgaTvaliswinebuli. Tu aRnagobis uflebis mqone uars it-yvis aRnagobis uflebis vadis gagrZelebaze, igi kargavsanazRaurebis moTxovnis uflebasac. aRnagobis uflebisSewyvetisas aRnagobis uflebis mqones ara aqvs uflebawaiRos nageboba an misi Semadgeneli nawilebi). amdenad,SeiZleba davaskvnaT, rom aRnagobis uflebis arsebiT pi-robas warmoadgens miwis zedapirze an mis qveS Senobis aSe-neba, rac aRnagobis ganmavlobaSi am uflebis, xolo aRna-gobis uflebis Sewyvetis Semdgom _ miwis nakveTis arse-biT Semadgenels warmoadgens.

4.4. mocemul SemTxvevaSi, sakasacio sasamarTlos Se-fasebis sagania aRnagobidan, rogorc sanivTosamar-Tlebrivi garigebidan gasvlis SesaZlebloba moaRnagismxridan valdebulebis darRvevisas (rogorc saqmis masa-lebidan irkveva, mesakuTre q. Tbilisis meriam xelSekru-lebaze uaris Tqmas safuZvlad daudo moaRnagis mxridanSenoba-nagebobis aSenebis vadis darRveva, aseve aRnago-bis sazRauris gadauxdeloba) da gasvlis samarTlebriviSedegebis gamoyeneba (sk-is 352-e muxli) aRnagobis samar-Tlebrivi institutis mimarT. aRnagobis maregulirebe-li normebi ar iZleva pasuxs kiTxvaze, SeuZlia Tu ara me-sakuTres samoqalaqo kodeqsis 236-e muxliT gaTvaliswi-nebuli SemTxvevis garda, sxva viTarebaSi gavides xel-Sekrulebidan an am urTierTobis mimarT gamoiyeneba Tuara garigebis Sewyvetis zogadi wesebi, aseve, ra uflebagaaCnia mesakuTres, Tu moaRnage arRvevs magaliTad nage-bobis aSenebis pirobas. sakasacio palatis mosazrebiT, mi-uxedavad imisa, rom aRnagobis momwesrigebeli normebi iT-valiswineben aRnagobis xelSekrulebidan gasvlis speci-alur wesebs, es ar unda iqnas gagebuli imgvarad, rom aR-nagoba, rogorc garigeba ar eqvemdebareba garigebis Sew-yvetis maregulirebeli im normebiT mowesrigebas, rom-lebic valdebulebiTi samarTlis zogad nawilSia moce-

102

muli, radganac aRnagobis sanivTo xasiaTis miuxedavad,masze, rogorc garigebaze, vrceldeba valdebulebiTi sa-marTlis is danawesebi, romlebic absoluturi mowesri-gebis (sanivTo) imperatiul debulebebs ar ewinaaRmdege-bian. Sesabamisad, aRnagobis uflebasTan mimarTebaSi sa-moqalaqo kodeqsiT gansazRvruli, xelSekrulebidan gas-vlis (xelSekrulebaze uaris Tqmis) momwesrigebeli ge-neraluri normebis (sk-is 352-e da 405-e muxlebi) gamoye-neba dasaSvebia, Tuki saxezea iseTi winapirobebi, rogo-ricaa valdebulebis darRveva da gasvlis nebis namdvi-loba, Tumca, mxedvelobaSi unda iqnes miRebuli specia-luri normebi, romlebic aRnagobis TavSia mocemuli (saz-Rauris gadauxdelobis gamo aRnagobis ufleba mesakuT-ris mxridan SeiZleba calmxrivad Sewydes am valdebule-bis 2 wlis ganmavlobaSi Seusruleblobis SemTxvevaSi, TumxareTa SeTanxmebiT sxva ram ar aris gaTvaliswinebuli(sk-is 236.2 muxli)).

4.5. mxareTa Soris sadavo ar aris ss `m-as~ mxridan val-debulebis darRveva, aseve q. Tbilisis municipalitetismeriis mxridan xelSekrulebaze uaris Tqmis nebis namdvi-loba, ufro metic, rogorc saqmis masalebidan irkveva,moaRnagem mesakuTres daubruna aRnagobis sagani Senoba-nagebobasTan erTad, anu samoqalaqo kodeqsis 352.1 mux-lis safuZvelze, mesakuTris sasargeblod ganxorciel-da restitucia naturiT, magram Segebebuli sarCelis pi-robebSi, dRis wesrigSi dgas sazogadoebrivi kvebis obi-eqtis mSeneblobisaTvis gaweuli xarjebis anazRaurebissafuZvlianobis sakiTxi, aseve is, Tu moTxovnis dasakma-yofileblad romeli norma unda iqnes gamoyenebuli. sa-kasacio palatis mosazrebiT, am SemTxvevaSi samoqalaqokodeqsis 352-e muxlis gamoyeneba ararelevanturia, vina-idan dasaxelebuli norma vrceldeba miRebul Sesrule-basa da sargebelze. amave kodeqsis 353.2 muxlis mixedviT,Tu movale sagans ukan abrunebs, anazRaurebs fuliT an,Tu 352-e muxlis me-4 nawilis à~ da `b~ qvepunqtebis mi-xedviT dauSvebelia zianis anazRaurebis moTxovna, maSinmas unda aunazRaurdes aucilebeli danaxarjebi. sxva da-naxarjebi unda anazRaurdes mxolod maSin, Tu kreditor-ma maT safuZvelze sargebeli miiRo. sakasacio sasamarTloTvlis, rom moxmobili norma yvelaze metad miesadagebaSegebebuli mosarCelis moTxovnas, amasTan, saxezea nor-

103

miT gaTvaliswinebuli elementebis faqtobrivi Semad-genloba _ movalis (moaRnagis) mier miwis nakveTis q. Tbi-lisis meriisaTvis ukan dabruneba; movalis mier xarjebisgaweva; kreditoris mier sargeblis miReba (am garemoebas-Tan dakavSirebiT kasators dasabuTebuli Sedaveba arwarmoudgenia).

4.6. palata ar iziarebs kasatoris pretenzias mtkice-bis tvirTis ganawilebis wesis darRvevasTan dakavSire-biT da yuradRebas miaqcevs im garemoebas, rom Segebebul-ma mosarCelem, samoqalaqo saproceso kodeqsis 102-e mux-lis Sesabamisad, warmoadgina gankuTvnadi mtkicebule-bebi _ xelSekrulebebi samuSaoebis Sesrulebis, qvekon-traqtorebis daqiravebisa da masalebis Sesyidvis Taoba-ze, aseve, xarjebis gawevis damadasturebeli Sesabamisizednadebebi, romelTa yovelmxrivi Sefasebis Sedegad(sssk-is 105-e muxli) sasamarTlos marTebulad Camouya-libda Sinagani rwmena Segebebuli mosarCelis mier moT-xovnili odenobiT Tanxis gawevis Taobaze. am garemoebisgaqarwyleba bunebrivia, daekisra mopasuxe mxares, romel-sac wonadi argumentebi da utyuari mtkicebulebebi arwarmoudgenia (sssk-is me-4 da 102-e muxlebis Sesabamisad),amgvar viTarebaSi xarjebis gaweva dadasturebulad miiC-neva.

4.7. sakasacio palata aseve ar iziarebs kasatoris sa-marTlebriv Sedavebas imasTan dakavSirebiT, rom mxare-Ta Soris dadebuli ijarisa da aRnagobis xelSekrulebe-bi unda ganvixiloT samoqalaqo kodeqsis 342-e muxliT gan-sazRvrul standartuli pirobebiT dadebul xelSekru-lebebad, ramdenadac q. Tbilisis municipalitetis meriaam normis subieqts ar warmoadgens. ar SeiZleba misi yo-veldRiuri saqmianobis sagnad iqnas miCneuli ijarisa daaRnagobis xelSekrulebebis dadeba, radganac stan-dartuli pirobebi gamoiyeneba yvelgan, sadac arsebobsmravalricxovan momxmarebelTan saqmiani urTierToba daxelSekrulebis standartul pirobebs erTi mxare (SemTa-vazebeli) udgens meore mxares. normis subieqtunariano-bidan gamomdinare, kasatoris poziciis gamarTlebad veriqneba miCneuli is garemoeba, rom garigebis meore mxarewarmoadgenda mewarme subieqts. sakasacio palata aseve,usafuZvlod miiCnevs mxaris pozicias, romlis Tanaxma-dac, xelSekrulebaTa sadavod qceuli debulebebi See-

104

sabameba samoqalaqo kodeqsis 359-e muxlis danawess, racTavis mxriv, gamoricxavs amave kodeqsis 352-e muxlis ga-moyenebis SesaZleblobas da ganmartavs, rom samoqalaqokodeqsis 359-e muxli (Tu xelSekruleba dadebulia im daT-qmiT, rom movalem, xelSekrulebidan gamomdinare, undadakargos Tavisi uflebebi, Tuki igi Tavis valdebulebebsar Seasrulebs, maSin kreditors am SemTxvevis dadgomi-sas SeuZlia gavides xelSekrulebidan) ar warmoadgensmoTxovnis uflebis SeTanxmebas gauqmebis pirobiT (sk-is97-e muxli), aramed, warmoadgens gasvlis daTqmas _ xel-SekrulebiT SeTanxmebul gasvlis uflebas, romelic ime-orebs kanonismieri gasvlis uflebis winapirobas (valde-bulebis darRvevas), magram uflebas aZlevs mxares, gavi-des xelSekrulebidan damatebiTi vadis dawesebis an gaf-rTxilebis gareSe. es danawesi iTvaliswinebs orive mxa-ris interesebs. kreditorisaTvis is xelsayrelia imde-nad, ramdenadac mas eZleva arCevani xelSekrulebis Se-narCunebasa da gasvlas Soris. gauqmebis pirobis SemTxve-vaSi xelSekrulebis SenarCuneba mis nebaze aRar iqnebo-da damokidebuli da movales SeeZleboda, valdebulebisSeusruleblobiT uari eTqva samarTlebriv urTierToba-ze. movalisaTvis es danawesi xelsayrelia imdenad, ram-denadac gasvlis SemTxvevaSi is inarCunebs sapirispiromoTxovnis uflebebs samoqalaqo kodeqsis 352-e da 353-emuxlebis Sesabamisad. 359-e muxli warmoadgens mxolodganmartebis wess, romelic moqmedebs saeWvoobisas, is aruzRudavs mxareebs Tavisuflebas, SeaTanxmon pirgasam-texlo an calsaxad dadon xelSekruleba gauqmebis piro-biT.

4.8. zemoT ganviTarebuli msjelobidan gamomdinare,sakasacio palata iziarebs gasaCivrebuli ganCinebis das-kvnas, rom Segebebuli mosarCelis mier sadavod gamxdarixelSekrulebebis debulebebi samoqalaqo kodeqsis 54-emuxlis Tanaxmad, ucilod baTilia (baTilia garigeba, ro-melic arRvevs kanoniT dadgenil wessa da akrZalvebs),amasTanave, romc gaviziaroT kanonis imgvari ganmarteba(sk-is 359-e muxli), rogorc amas kasatori miiCnevs, gasaT-valiswinebelia, rom am pirobiT mxolod kasatori naxu-lobs sargebels da igi movalis uflebebis, aseve, qoneb-rivi mdgomareobis arsebiTad gauaresebas iwvevs. samoqa-laqo kodeqsis 325-e muxlis pirveli nawilis Sinaarsidan

105

gamomdinare ki, Tu valdebulebis Sesrulebis pirobebiunda ganisazRvros xelSekrulebis erT-erTi mxaris an me-same piris mier, maSin saeWvoobisas ivaraudeba, rom amgva-ri gansazRvra unda moxdes samarTlianobis safuZvelze.samarTlianobis koncefcia, samoqalaqo kodeqsis um-Tavresi qvakuTxedia, rameTu aqsiomaturi debuleba ker-Zo samarTlisaTvis aris is, rom samarTlebrivi urTier-Tobis monawileni valdebulni arian keTilsindisierad ga-naxorcielon TavianTi uflebebi da movaleobani (sk-is 8.3.muxli). palata damatebiT ganmartavs, rom nebis kanonSe-sabamisobis sakiTxi warmoadgens sasamarTlos mxridan Se-mowmebis aucileblobas, gansxvavebiT sacilo garigebebi-sagan, romelTa vadaSi Seucilebloba garigebis namdvilo-bas da Sesabamisad, valdebulebis warmoSobas iwvevs (ix.sk-is 72-e-89-e muxlebi), ucilod baTili garigeba arwarmo-Sobilad miiCneva da mas samarTlebrivi Sedegi ar mosdevs.im pirobebSic ki, Tu ss `m-a~ Segebebuli sarCeliT qoneb-riv restituciasaTan erTad ar moiTxovda am restituci-is sawinaaRmdego SeTanxmebis baTilobas, sasamarTlo ma-inc Seamowmebda restituciis samarTlebriv winapirobebs.

4.9. 4.8. punqtSi SemoTavazebuli Sefasebebi relevan-turia aseve Segebebuli mosarCelis im moTxovnasTan mi-marTebaSi, romelic exeba q. Tbilisis meriisaTvis sadavoxelSekrulebebis farglebSi usasyidlod gadacemuli sa-bagiros Rirebulebis _ 200 422,5 evros ekvivalenti la-ris dakisrebas. sakasacio sasamarTlo ganmartavs, rom qo-nebis sakuTrebaSi usasyidlod gadacema samoqalaqosamar-Tlebrivi TvalsazrisiT warmoadgens samoqalaqo kodeq-sis 524-e muxliT gaTvaliswinebul Cuqebis xelSekrule-bas (Cuqebis xelSekrulebiT mCuqebeli usasyidlod ga-dascems dasaCuqrebuls qonebas sakuTrebad misi Tanxmo-biT), romelic calmxrivi xaiaTisaa da neba swored mCu-qeblisagan unda momdinareobdes. samoqalaqo kanon-mdebloba ar icnobs Cuqebis imgvar formas, rodesac da-saCuqrebuli winswrebiT gamoTqvams nebas usasyidlod ga-daeces sakuTrebaSi konkretuli Rirebulebis qoneba, Se-sabamisad, amgvari piroba, rogorc marTlsawinaaRmdego,aseve baTilad miiCneva (sk-is 54-e muxli), xolo kondiqci-uri valdebulebidan gamomdinare, viTom kreditorma sa-moqalaqo kodeqsis 976-e (1) muxlis à~ qvepunqtisa da 979-e (2) muxlis safuZvelze unda daabrunos usafuZvlod mi-

106

Rebuli sikeTe an misi Rirebuleba am sikeTis dabrunebisfaqtobrivi SeuZleblobis SemTxvevaSi (pirs, romelmacsxvas valdebulebis Sesasruleblad raime gadasca, SeuZ-lia mosTxovos viTom-kreditors (mimRebs) misi ukan dab-runeba, Tu valdebuleba garigebis baTilobis an sxva sa-fuZvlis gamo ar arsebobs, ar warmoiSoba. Tu ukan dabru-neba SeuZlebelia gadacemuli sagnis mdgomareobis gamoan, Tu mimRebs raime mizeziT ar SeuZlia sagnis ukan dab-runeba, maSin man unda aanazRauros misi saerTo Rirebu-leba. Rirebuleba ganisazRvreba anazRaurebis moTxovnisuflebis warmoSobis drois mixedviT). amdenad, im piro-bebSi, rodesac Sedavebuli ar aris sabagiro mowyobilo-bis Rirebuleba, aseve is, rom es mowyobiloba damontaJe-bulia da misi dabruneba SeuZlebelia, qvemdgomi sasamar-Tloebis daskvna am qonebis Rirebulebis anazRaurebis Ta-obaze dasabuTebulia.

4.10. bolos sakasacio sasamarTlo Seexeba pirgasam-texlos sakiTxs, sasamarTlo ganmartavs, rom samoqalaqokodeqsi icnobs moTxovnis uzrunvelyofis sanivTo davaldebulebiT saSualebebs, romelTagan pirvels girav-noba (sk-is 254-e muxli) da ipoTeka (sk-is 286-e muxli), xo-lo meores _ pirgasamtexlo, be da movalis garantia (sk-is416-e muxli) ganekuTvneba. miTiTebulTagan erT-erT yve-laze gavrcelebul saSualebas swored pirgasamtexlowarmoadgens da igi mxareTa SeTanxmebiT gansazRvrulifuladi Tanxaa, romelic movalem unda gadaixados val-debulebis Seusruleblobis an arajerovnad Sesrulebi-saTvis (sk-is 417-e muxli). Tavis mxriv, rogorc praqtikaaCvenebs, pigasamtexloze SeTanxmeba xSirad relatiuriurTierTobisas gvxvdeba saxeze, Tumca, misi gamoyenebadasaSvebia sanivTo garigebiT nakisri valdebulebis mi-marTac. samoqalaqo kodeqsis 419-e muxlis pirveli nawi-lidan gamomdinare, pirgasamtexlos daniSnuleba valde-bulebis darRvevis minimaluri zianis angariSSi am TanxisCaTvlaa. funqciuri daniSnulebiT, minimaluri ziani arwarmoadgens faqtobrivad miRebuli zianis srul anazRa-urebas, aramed esaa Tanxa, romelic uzrunvelyofs kre-ditoris moTxovnis minimalur dakmayofilebas, sworedamiTaa gamarTlebuli pirgasamtexlos saxelSekrulebobuneba, anu pirgasamtexlos dakisrebisaTvis savaldebu-loa mxareTa mier Sesabamisi formiT SeTanxmebis miRweva,

107

rac regulirebulia samoqalaqo kodeqsis 418-e muxlis me-2 nawiliT. gansxvavebiT zianis anazRaurebis valdebule-bisagan, romelic, samoqalaqo kodeqsis 317-e muxlis pir-veli nawilis Tanaxmad, ar saWiroebs mxareTa winaswari Se-Tanxmebis arsebobas, pirgasamtexlo yovelTvis saxel-Sekrulebo pirobad gvevlineba. zianis anazRaurebis sa-xelSekrulebo pirobis erTaderTi gamonaklisia fuladivaldebulebis Sesrulebis vadis gadacilebisas procen-tze SeTanxmeba (sk-is 403-e muxli), Tumca, es SemTxvevasaxeze ar gvaqvs. marTalia, samoqalaqo kanonmdeblobapirgasamtexlos namdvilobas mxareTa mier nebis Tavisu-fali gamovlenis gziT miRweul SeTanxmebas ukavSirebs,Tumca, igi ar warmoadgens absolutur daTqmas da mova-lis Sesageblis arsebobis pirobebSi, sasamarTlo ufle-bamosilia, Seafasos kreditoris mier moTxovnili ode-nobis Tanxis Tanazomiereba valdebulebis darRvevasTan,kerZod, samoqalaqo kodeqsis 420-e muxlis Tanaxmad, sa-samarTlos SeuZlia, saqmis garemoebaTa gaTvaliswinebiTSeamciros Seusabamod maRali pirgasamtexlo. normis da-saxelebuli danawesi sasamarTlos mxridan mxareTa Tavi-sufali nebis gamovleniT miRweul SeTanxmebaSi Carevislegitimur safuZvels warmoadgens da aseT SemTxvevaSi,konkretuli saqmis Taviseburebis gaTvaliswinebiT, un-da Sefasdes is subieqturi da obieqturi faqtorebi, ro-goricaa: mxareTa qonebrivi mdgomareoba, valdebulebisdarRvevis xarisxi, kreditoris molodini valdebulebisjerovani Sesrulebis mimarT da sxva. mocemul SemTxveva-Si, sakasacio palata eTanxmeba qvemdgomi sasamarTloe-bis miTiTebas imaze, rom aRnagobisa da ijaris xelSekru-lebebTan erTad mowinaaRmdege mxaris molodini iyo gu-dauris sakurorto zonaSi ekonomikuri saqmianobis miz-niT, kasators simbolur fasad misTvis sakuTrebaSi gada-eca miwis nakveTi. es valdebuleba ar Sesrulebula da Sew-yda q. Tbilisis mTavrobis Sesabamisi dadgenilebiT. Sew-yvetis safuZvlad ki, miTiTebulia is, rom valdebulmapirma ver SeZlo miwis droulad gadacema kompaniisaTvisda radganac saprivatizacio pirobebiT gansazRvrul va-daSi ver aSendeboda am teritoriaze sastumro, calmxri-vad nakisri valdebulebis Sesruleba (miwis gadacema) ga-umarTleblad iqna miCneuli. garda amisa, sruliad samar-Tliania saapelacio palatis pozicia, romelic pirgasam-

108

texlosagan movalis gaTavisuflebas iTvaliswinebs saku-Tar miwaze Ria da daxuruli auzis mSeneblobis valdebu-lebis darRvevisaTvis. xelSekrulebaTa Sewyvetis gamosasamarTlom sworad miiCnia, rom am valdebulebis mimarTTbilisis merias aRar gaaCnda interesi da am nawilSi ararsebobda sarCelis dakmayofilebis safuZveli. garda ami-sa, gasaCivrebuli ganCinebiT daaxloebiT aTjeraa Semci-rebuli pirgasamtexlo, rac Tanazomieria valdebulebisdarRvevisa. sakasacio palata miiCnevs, rom am SemTxveva-Si daculia rogorc mxareebis interesTa balansi, ise _pirgasamtexlos funqcia da kasatoris, rogorc kredito-ris uflebebi. rac Seexeba mis pozicias, rom sasamarTlospirgasamtexlos nawilze saerTod ar umsjelia, sasamar-Tlo am sakiTxs gadawyvetilebis gauqmebis winapirobadver miiCnevs da ganmartavs, rom adamianis uflebaTa ev-ropuli konvenciis me-6 muxlis pirveli paragrafi aval-debulebs sasamarTlos, daasabuTos Tavisi gadawyveti-leba, rac ar unda iqnes gagebuli TiToeul argumentzedetaluri pasuxis gacemad (ix. jRarkava saqarTvelos wi-naaRmdeg, # 7932/03; Van de Hurk v. Netherlands, par.61, Garcia Ruizv. Spain [GC] par.26; Jahnke and Lenoble v. France (dec.); Perez v France[GC], par. 81); Boldea v. Romania, par. 30). Sesabamisad, kasatorisarc aRniSnuli msjeloba SeiZleba daedos safuZvlad ga-saCivrebuli ganCinebis gauqmebas, ramdenadac pirgasam-texlos samarTliani odenobis gansazRvris, aseve, misi da-kisrebis winapirobebze namsjelia, rogorc pirveli in-stanciis, ise _ saapelacio sasamarTlos mxridan.

5. gasaCivrebuli ganCinebis ucvlelad datovebissamarTlebrivi dasabuTeba:

sakasacio palata miiCnevs, rom gasaCivrebuli ganCine-biT saproceso wesebis dacviT sworad iqna dadgenili da-vis gadawyvetisaTvis mniSvnelobis mqone faqtobrivi ga-remoebebi, aseve, nawilobriv marTebulad ganxorcieldamaTi subsumireba materialuri samarTlis normebTan, xo-lo kasators ar warmoudgenia samoqalaqo saproceso ko-deqsis 393-e-394-e muxlebiT gaTvaliswinebuli dasabuTe-buli Sedaveba, ris gamoc, amave kodeqsis 410-e muxlis Se-sabamisad (sakasacio sasamarTlo ar daakmayofilebs saka-sacio saCivars, Tu: kanonis miTiTebul darRvevas ara aqvsadgili; saapelacio sasamarTlos gadawyvetilebas safuZ-vlad ar udevs kanonis darRveva; saapelacio sasamarTlos

109

gadawyvetileba arsebiTad sworia, miuxedavad imisa, romgadawyvetilebis samotivacio nawili ar Seicavs SesabamisdasabuTebas) sakasacio palata ucvlelad tovebs mas.

6. saqmis warmoebis Sewyvetaze uaris Tqmis dasabu-Teba:

6.1. kasatoris mowinaaRmdege mxarem gancxadebiT mo-marTa sasamarTlos da ganmarta, rom q. Tbilisis meria arwarmoadgens sabiujeto organizacias, Sesabamisad, igi sa-moqalaqo saproceso kodeqsis 2591-e muxlis pirveli na-wilis subieqtia, romelic valdebuli iyo 30-dRian vada-Si gamocxadebuliyo sasamarTloSi da Caebarebina gadaw-yvetileba. am valdebulebis darRvevis gamo, mxare Tvlis,rom gasaCivrebuli ganCineba Sesulia kanonier ZalaSi, risgamoc sakasacio samarTalwarmoeba unda Sewydes.

6.2. sakasacio palata ar iziarebs mowinaaRmdege mxarisam pozicias da ganmartavs Semdegs: TviTmmarTvelobis ko-deqsis me-2 muxlis me-2 nawilis debuleba, rom TviT-mmarTvelobas aqvs sakuTari qoneba da biujeti, aseve, sa-biujeto kodeqsis me-6 muxlis `T~ qvepunqti, romlis Ta-naxmadac adgilobrivi TviTmmarTveli erTeulis biuje-ti aris adgilobrivi TviTmmarTvelobis warmomadgenlo-biTi organos (sakrebulos) mier damtkicebuli, adgilob-rivi xelisuflebis funqciebisa da valdebulebebis Ses-rulebis mizniT misaRebi Semosulobebis, gasawevi gada-saxdelebisa da naSTis cvlilebis erToblioba ar adas-turebs imas, rom q. Tbilisis municipalitetis meria arwarmoadgens sabiujeto organizacias.

6.3. samoqalaqo saproceso kodeqsis 46-e muxlis me-2nawilisa da `saxelmwifo baJis Sesaxeb~ saqarTvelos ka-nonis 5.1. muxlis ù~ qvepunqtis dispoziciidan gamomdi-nare, kasatori ganixileba amave kodeqsis 2591-e muxlis me-2 nawilis subieqtad da mis mimarT amave normis pirvelinawilis debulebebi ar moqmedebs. sakasacio saCivris gan-saxilvelad miRebis etapze gasaCivrebis saproceso vada,bunebrivia, Semowmda palatis mier da ar arsebobs mowina-aRmdege mxaris Suamdgomlobis gaiziarebis winapiroba.

7. sasamarTlo xarjebi:7.1. samoqalaqo saproceso kodeqsis 53-e muxlis pirve-

li nawilis Tanaxmad, im mxaris mier gaRebuli xarjebisgadaxda, romlis sasargeblodac iqna gamotanili gadaw-yvetileba, ekisreba meore mxares, Tundac es mxare ganTa-

110

visuflebuli iyos saxelmwifo biujetSi sasamarTlo xar-jebis gadaxdisagan. Tu sarCeli nawilobriv dakmayofil-da, maSin am muxlSi aRniSnuli Tanxa mosarCeles miekuT-vneba sarCelis im moTxovnis proporciulad, romelic sa-samarTlos gadawyvetilebiT iqna dakmayofilebuli, xo-lo mopasuxes _ sarCelis moTxovnis im nawilis proporci-ulad, romelzedac mosarCeles uari eTqva. im mxaris war-momadgenlis daxmarebisaTvis gaweul xarjebs, romlis sa-sargeblodac iqna gamotanili gadawyvetileba, sasamar-Tlo daakisrebs meore mxares gonivrul farglebSi, mag-ram araumetes davis sagnis Rirebulebis 4 procentisa, xo-lo araqonebrivi davis SemTxvevaSi _ gansaxilveli saqmismniSvnelobisa da sirTulis gaTvaliswinebiT, 2 000 laram-de odenobiT.

7.2. sakasacio palata miiCnevs, rom davis sagnis Rire-bulebisa da zemoxsenebuli normiT gansazRvruli cen-zis Sesabamisad, saapelacio sasamarTlom sworad daakis-ra damatebiTi ganCinebiT q. Tbilisis merias mogebulimxris sasargeblod iuridiuli momsaxurebis xarjis gadax-da, Sesabamisad, misi zogadi pretenzia, rom ar arsebobdaam xarjis dakisrebis winapirobebi, ver iqneba gaziarebu-li palatis mier (sssk-is 393.3 muxli), amasTanave, vinaidansakasacio samarTalwarmoeba aseve q. Tbilisis meriis wa-rumateblobiT dasrulda, palata safuZvlianad miiCnevsmowinaaRmdege mxaris Suamdgomlobas sakasacio etapze iu-ridiuli momsaxurebis xarjis saxiT 800 laris dakisrebisTaobaze (am sakiTxTan dakavSirebiT ix. saqmis masalebi,aseve, adamianis uflebaTa evropuli sasamarTlos gadaw-yvetilebebi: `pinkova da pinki CexeTis respublikis wina-aRmdeg~; àsaniZe saqarTvelos winaaRmdeg~).

7.3. `saxelmwifo baJis Sesaxeb~ saqarTvelos kanonis 5.1.muxlis ù~ qvepunqtis Tanaxmad, radganac kasatori biu-jetis mimarT angariSsworebisgan gaTavisuflebulia, saq-mis ganxilvasTan dakavSirebul xarjs, samoqalaqo sapro-ceso kodeqsis 55-e muxlis Sesabamisad, gaiRebs saxelmwi-fo.


samoqalaqo saproceso kodeqsis 53-e, 55-e, 410-e muxle-biT da

111

d a a d g i n a:

1. q. Tbilisis municipalitetis meriis sakasacio saCi-vari ar dakmayofildes.

2. ucvlelad darCes Tbilisis saapelacio sasamarTlossamoqalaqo saqmeTa palatis 2016 wlis 14 ivnisis ganCine-ba da amave sasamarTlos 2016 wlis 21 ivnisis damatebiTiganCineba.

3. j. x-is Suamdgomloba iuridiuli momsaxurebis xar-jis anazRaurebis Taobaze dakmayofildes.

4. q. Tbilisis municipalitetis merias (s/k #...) j. x-is(p/n ...) sasargeblod daekisros sakasacio samarTalwarmo-ebis gamo iuridiul momsaxurebaze gaweuli xarjis _ 800laris anazRaureba.

5. kasatori saxelmwifo baJis gadaxdisagan gaTavisuf-lebulia.

6. sakasacio sasamarTlos ganCineba sabolooa da ar ga-saCivrdeba.



#as-1069-1028-2016 7 ivlisi, 2017 w., q. Tbilisi



davis sagani: zianis anazRaureba

aRwerilobiTi nawili:1. T. k-sa (SemdegSi: gamyidveli, mopasuxe, apelanti an

kasatori) da n. C-s (SemdegSi: myidveli an mosarCele) So-ris, am ukanasknelis warmomadgenlis i. x-as (SemdegSi: mo-sarCelis warmomadgeneli) meSveobiT 2013 wlis oqtomber-Si daido elene axvledianis ferweruli naxatis `zamTa-

112

ri~ nasyidobis xelSekruleba (saqarTvelos samoqalaqokodeqsis, SemdegSi ssk, 477-e muxli), romlis safuZvelzegamyidvelma mosarCelis warmomadgenels gadasca naxatida miiRo misgan SeTanxmebuli sazRauri 13 000 (cameti aTa-si) aSS dolari.

2. mogvianebiT dadginda, rom mosarCelisaTvis gadace-muli ferweruli naxati `zamTari~ ar iyo Sesrulebulielene axvledianis mier (ix. eqspertizis uzrunvelsayo-fad Seqmnili komisiis krebis oqmi #34).

3. sarCelis safuZvlebi3.1. myidvelma 2014 wlis 11 aprils sarCeli aRZra mopa-

suxis winaaRmdeg 13 000 aSS dolaris dakisrebis moT-xovniT.

3.2. myidvelis ganmartebiT, naxatis SeZenidan moklevadaSi, mosarCelis ojaxis axlobelma gamoTqva eWvi naxa-tis namdvilobasTan dakavSirebiT, ris gamoc naxats Cau-tarda eqspertiza saqarTvelos erovnul muzeumSi dadadginda, rom naxati ar Seesabameboda elene axvledia-nis Sesrulebis mxatvrul dones.

4. mopasuxis Sesagebeli4.1. mopasuxem ar cno sarCeli im dasabuTebiT, rom igi

ar warmoadgenda xelSekrulebis mxares da mxolod dax-mareba gauwia naxatis mesakuTres g. i-s. Sesabamisad, xel-Sekruleba daido mosarCelesa da g. i-s Soris.

4.2. mopasuxis ganmartebiT, eweoda ra suraTebiTa dasxva nivTebiT vaWrobas maRazia-salonis meSveobiT, mas g.i-is meuRlem mimarTa da acnoba rom surda elene axvle-dianis ferweruli tilos gayidva, aseve, miawoda naxatisfoto. mopasuxem ganmarta, rom naxati salonSi ar hqonda,radgan Zvirfas nivTebs, rogorc wesi, ar itovebda. 2013wlis oqtomberSi mas daukavSirda mosarCelis warmomad-geneli, romelmac ganumarta, rom surda elene axvledia-nis naxatis SeZena, ris Semdegac, mopasuxe daukavSirda g.i-s, romelmac gadasca mas naxati, mopasuxem ki naxati ga-dasca mosarCelis warmomadgenels, 2-3 dRis Semdeg ki mi-iRo nasyidobis safasuri, saidanac g. i-s gadasca 9 500 aSSdolari.

5. Tbilisis saqalaqo sasamarTlos gadawyvetilebada daskvnebi

5.1. Tbilisis saqalaqo sasamarTlos samoqalaqo saqme-Ta kolegiis 2015 wlis 10 ivnisis gadawyvetilebiT myid-

113

velis sarCeli dakmayofilda da mis sasargeblod mopasu-xes 13 000 aSS dolaris gadaxda daekisra.

5.2. saqalaqo sasamarTlom davis gadawyvetisas ixel-mZRvanela ssk-is 327-e, 477-e, 487-e, 488-e, 491-e, 352-e mux-lebiT, saqarTvelos samoqalaqo saproceso kodeqsis (Sem-degSi sssk) me-4, 102-e muxlebiT da ganmarta, rom gansa-xilvel SemTxvevaSi mxareebs Soris urTierTobis warmo-Sobis safuZveli iyo nasyidobis xelSekruleba.

5.3. mxareebs Soris sadavo ar iyo is garemoeba, mxareTaSeTanxmebiT nasyidobis sagans warmoadgenda elene axvle-dianis mier Sesrulebuli ferweruli tilo. specialis-tTa komisiam daadgina, rom mosarCelisaTvis gadacemuliferweruli tilo ar iyo Sesrulebuli elene axvledianismier, e.i. ar Seesabameboda mxareebis mier gansazRvrul xa-risxs.

5.4. am ganCinebis 5.2 da 5.3 qvepunqtebSi miTiTebuligaremoebebis safuZvelze, sasamarTlom daaskvna, rom ssk-is 491-e muxlisa da 352-e muxlis pirveli nawilis Tanax-mad, mosarCele uflebamosilia nivTis naklis gamo moSa-los xelSekruleba, rac mopasuxes akisrebs xelSekrule-bis safuZvelze miRebuli Sesrulebis dabrunebis valde-bulebas.

6. saapelacio saCivris safuZvlebi6.1. mopasuxem saapelacio wesiT gaasaCivra saqalaqo sa-

samarTlos gadawyvetileba, misi gauqmeba da, axali gadaw-yvetilebis miRebiT, sarCelis uaryofa moiTxova Semdegpretenziebze dayrdnobiT:

6.1.1. sasamarTlom arasworad miiCnia udavod dadgeni-lad is faqtobrivi garemoebebi, rom nasyidobis xelSekru-leba daido mosarCelesa da mopasuxes Soris; mosarCeli-saTvis gadacemuli ferweruli naxati `zamTari~ ar iyoelene axvledianis mier Sesrulebuli. sasamarTlo daey-rdno eqspertizis daskvnas, Tumca, ar umsjelia im sakiT-xze, rom mosarCeles SeeZlo eqspertiza Caetarebina aramisTvis gadacemul naxatze, aramed mis aslze, romlis Seq-mna an mopoveba arcTu ise rTulia;

6.1.2. mosarCelis safuZvliani pretenziis arsebobis pi-robebSi sasamarTlos unda gamoeyenebina xelSekrulebisromelime safuZvliT baTilad cnobis momwesrigebelinormebi. apelantis mosazrebiT, nasyidobis obieqtis ga-dacemiT da Tanxis miRebiT xelSekruleba Sesrulda. amas-

114

Tan, ssk-is 405-e muxliT gaTvaliswinebuli SemTxvevebisdros aucilebelia mxareTa Soris arsebuli xelSekrule-ba ZalaSi iyos.

7. saapelacio sasamarTlos ganCineba da daskvnebi7.1. Tbilisis saapelacio sasamarTlos samoqalaqo saq-

meTa palatis 2016 wlis 29 seqtembris ganCinebiT ar dak-mayofilda saapelacio saCivari da gasaCivrebuli gadaw-yvetileba darCa ucvlelad.

7.2. saapelacio sasamarTlom ar gaiziara apelantismtkiceba, rom is ar warmoadgenda xelSekrulebis mxares,radgan nasyidobis sagani mosarCelis warmomadgenels ga-dasca mopasuxem da nasyidobis fasic am ukanasknelma mii-Ro. sasamarTlom miuTiTa ssk-is 158-e muxlze, romlis Ta-naxmad ivaraudeba, rom moZravi nivTis mflobeli aris mi-si mesakuTre.

7.3. imis gaTvaliswinebiT, rom sadavo ferwerul tilosflobda mopasuxe da swored am ukanasknelma gadasca ismosarCelis warmomadgenels, im garemoebis mtkicebistvirTi, rom ferweruli naxati `zamTari~ ekuTvnoda sxvapirs da gamyidveli moqmedebda mxolod rogorc Suamava-li, apelants ekisreboda, romelmac Sesabamis mtkicebu-lebebze miTiTebiT ver uzrunvelhyo misi mtkicebis sa-ganSi Semavali garemoebebis saTanadod dadastureba.

7.4. saqmeSi wardgenili saqarTvelos erovnuli muzeu-mis xelovnebaTmcodneebisa da restavratorebis eq-spertizis uzrunvelsayofad Seqmnili komisiis #34 oq-miT dasturdeba, rom mopasuxis kuTvnili ferweruli na-xati `zamTari~ 1971 weli, tilo, zeTi, 80X60, ar Seesabame-ba elene axvledianis Sesrulebis mxatvrul dones.

7.5. saapelacio sasamarTlom ar gaiziara apelantis va-raudi, rom SesaZloa mosarCelem eqspertizaze waradgi-na sxva, yalbi namuSevari da ara misi meSveobiT SeZeniliferweruli suraTi ̀ zamTari~. pirveli instanciis sasamar-TloSi mosamzadebel etapze mopasuxes sakuTari varau-dis dasamtkiceblad gaaCnda SesaZlebloba, Tavad Caeta-rebina eqspertiza sadavo ferwerul namuSevarze, rac manar ganaxorciela. amasTan, saqmeSi arsebuli mtkicebule-bebiT ar dasturdeboda mosarCelis mflobelobaSi, gar-da mopasuxisgan SeZenili naxatisa, sxva identuri, yalbiferweruli suraTis arsebobis faqti. aRniSnulidan, ga-momdinare, sasamarTlom ar gaiziara apelantis mosazre-

115

ba, rom eqspertiza Cautarda ara nasyidobis sagans, ara-med sxva ferwerul namuSevars.

7.6. gansaxilvel SemTxvevaSi mxareebs Soris sadavo ariyo is garemoeba, rom mxareTa SeTanxmebiT nasyidobis sa-gans warmoadgenda elene axvledianis mier Sesrulebuliferweruli tilo. dadginda, rom mosarCelisaTvis gada-cemuli suraTi ar iyo Sesrulebuli elene axvledianismier, e.i. ar Seesabameboda mxareebis mier gansazRvrul xa-risxs.

7.7. ssk-is 491-e da 352-e muxlebze dayrdnobiT, sasa-marTlom daaskvna, rom mosarCele uflebamosili iyo, niv-Tis naklis gamo moeSala nasyidobis xelSekruleba, racmopasuxes xelSekrulebis safuZvelze miRebuli Sesru-lebis _ 13 000 aSS dolaris dabrunebis valdebulebas akis-rebda, Sesabamisad ar arsebobda saapelacio saCivris dak-mayofilebisa da gasaCivrebuli gadawyvetilebis gauqme-bis safuZveli.

8. sakasacio saCivris safuZvlebi8.1. saapelacio sasamarTlos ganCineba sakasacio wesiT

gaasaCivra mopasuxem, misi gauqmeba da, axali gadawyveti-lebis miRebiT, sarCelis uaryofa moiTxova.

8.2. kasatori ar eTanxmeba saapelacio sasamarTlos das-kvnas, romelic am ganCinebis 7.2 qvepunqtSia miTiTebulida ganmartavs, rom ssk-is 158-e muxlis Tanaxmad, naxatismesakuTred g. i-i unda miCneuliyo;

8.3. myidvelma nasyidobis safasuri nivTis miRebidan2-3 dReSi gadaixada, es dro sakmarisi iyo naxatis av-Tenturobis dasadgenad;

8.4. saqmis masalebiT ar dasturdeba, Tu romeli naxatiwaredgina eqspertizas;

8.5. sasamarTlom arasworad gaanawila mtkicebis tvir-Ti. kasatoris ganmartebiT, mopasuxe ver SeZlebda emtki-cebina, Tu romeli naxati waredgina eqspertizas, radganmyidveli, Tu mas elene axvledianis sxva naxatic eqnebo-da, damalavda mas da ar warudgenda eqspertizas. amasTan,naxatis gadacemidan mxolod 5 Tvis Semdeg wamoayena pre-tenzia myidvelma;

8.6. kasatoris mtkicebiT, myidvels gadaeca namuSev-ris originali, xolo sasamarTlom usafuZvlod miiCnia,rom ferweruli tilo ar Seesabameboda elene axvledia-nis mxatvrul dones. sasamarTlom aseTi gadawyvetile-

116

biT safrTxe Seuqmna samoqalaqo brunvis mdgradobas.9. sakasacio samarTalwarmoebis etapi:9.1. mopasuxis sakasacio saCivari warmoebaSia miRebu-

li saqarTvelos uzenaesi sasamarTlos samoqalaqo saqme-Ta palatis 2017 wlis 11 ianvris ganCinebiT sssk-is 391-emuxlis safuZvelze dasaSvebobis winapirobebis Sesamow-meblad.

9.2. saqarTvelos uzenaesi sasamarTlos samoqalaqo saq-meTa palatis 2017 wlis 17 martis ganCinebiT mopasuxissakasacio saCivari, sssk-is 391-e muxlis me-5 nawilis à~da è~ qvepunqtebis safuZvelze, dasaSvebad iqna cnobi-li da miRebul iqna arsebiTad gansaxilvelad.

samotivacio nawili:sakasacio sasamarTlo sakasacio saCivris iuridiuli

dasabuTebulobis Semowmebisa da saqmis masalebis arse-biTad ganxilvis Sedegad miiCnevs, sakasacio saCivari sa-fuZvliania da igi nawilobriv unda dakmayofildes Sem-degi argumentaciiT:

10. sssk-is 404-e muxlis pirveli nawiliT, sakasacio sa-samarTlo gadawyvetilebas amowmebs sakasacio saCivrisfarglebSi, amave kodeqsis 407-e muxlis pirveli nawiliT,sakasacio sasamarTlo imsjelebs mxaris mxolod im axsna-ganmartebaze, romelic asaxulia sasamarTlo gadawyveti-lebebSi da sxdomis oqmebSi. garda amisa, SeiZleba mxedve-lobaSi iqnes miRebuli am kodeqsis 396-e muxlis pirvelinawilis `v~ qvepunqtSi miTiTebuli faqtebi; amave muxlisme-2 nawilis Tanaxmad, saapelacio sasamarTlos mier dam-tkicebulad cnobili faqtobrivi garemoebebi savalde-buloa sakasacio sasamarTlosaTvis, Tu wamoyenebuli araris dasaSvebi da dasabuTebuli pretenzia (Sedaveba). sa-kasacio sasamarTlos miaCnia, rom kasatoris pretenziaTanawili dasabuTebulia, ris gamoc arsebobs sakasacio ga-nacxadis nawilobriv dakmayofilebis safuZveli.

11. sakasacio sasamarTlo yuradRebas gaamaxvilebs,rom mxareTa Soris daido nasyidobis xelSekruleba. ssk-is 477-e muxlis Tanaxmad gamyidveli movalea gadascesmyidvels nasyidobis sagani, xolo myidveli movalea ga-daixados SeTanxmebuli fasi. ssk-is 487-e da 488-e muxle-bis Tanaxmad nivTi unda iyos uflebrivad da nivTobri-vad unaklo. gansaxilvel SemTxvevaSi sakasacio sasamar-

117

Tlo yuradRebas gaamaxvilebs nivTobriv naklze, radgansaqmis masalebiT dadgenilia, rom nasyidobis sagani _ na-xati ar aRmoCnda elene axvledianis mier Sesrulebuli,rogorc es nasyidobis xelSekrulebiT iyo SeTanxmebuli.

12. saqmis masalebidan gamomdinare udavoa, rom gam-yidvelma isargebla ssk-is 405.1 muxliT gaTvaliswinebu-li uflebiT da uari Tqva xelSekrulebaze (xelSekrule-bidan gavida). Sesabamisad, ssk-is 352.1 muxliT gaTvalis-winebuli winapiroba _ naturiT dabrunebis valdebulebawarmoiSva. mxareebi valdebuli arian, erTmaneTs daubru-non miRebuli Sesruleba. sakasacio sasamarTlo gan-martavs, rom ssk-is 352-e muxli, romelic xelSekruleba-ze uaris Tqmas, anu urTierTobidan gasvlas exeba, samar-Tlebrivi Sedegis saxiT iwvevs ormxriv restitucias. amis-gan gansxvavebiT, xelSekrulebis Sewyveta samarTlebri-vad ar warmoSobs mxareTa restitucias. sagulisxmoa, romxelSekrulebidan gasvlis Semdeg, mxareebi Tavisuflde-bian xelSekrulebiT nakisri pirveladi valdebulebisSesrulebisagan da gardaiqmnebian restituciis kredito-rad, romelic am SemTxvevaSi, mosarCelea, da restituci-is movaled (mopasuxe).

13. sakasacio sasamarTlos ganmartebiT: `mxaris ufle-bas, gavides xelSekrulebidan adgens samoqalaqo kodeq-sis 352-e muxli, romlis pirveli nawilis Tanaxmad, TuxelSekrulebis erT-erTi mxare 405-e muxliT gaTvalis-winebuli pirobebis arsebobisas uars ityvis xelSekru-lebaze, maSin miRebuli Sesruleba da sargebeli mxareebsubrundebaT (naturiT dabruneba). amave normis meore na-wili ki iTvaliswinebs dabrunebas fuladi saxiTac. xel-Sekrulebidan gasvlis uflebis ganxorcielebis SemTxve-vaSi, orive mxare Tavisufldeba xelSekrulebiT nakisrimovaleobebis Sesrulebisagan da ekisrebaT ormxrivi res-titucia. am SemTxvevaSi mxareebi valdebuli arian daub-rundnen im mdgomareobas, romelic arsebobda xelSekru-lebis dadebamde~ (ix. susg as-837-788-2015, 11.11.2015 w.).

14. sakasacio sasamarTlo yuradRebas gaamaxvilebs ssk-is 354-e muxlze /xelSekrulebidan gasvlis Sedegad war-moSobili valdebulebebi mxareebma unda Seasrulon er-Tdroulad/ da aRniSnavs, rom gamyidvelis valdebule-baa daabrunos nasyidobis safasuri _ 13 000 aSS dolari,xolo myidvelis valdebulebaa daabrunos nasyidobis sa-

118

gani _ naxati.15. sakasacio sasamarTlo ganmartavs, rom mocemul Sem-

TxvevaSi ormxrivi restitucia unda ganxorcieldes Sem-degnairad: mopasuxem/gamyidvelma mosarCeles/myidvelsunda gauxados nasyidobis safasuri _ 13 000 (cameti aTa-si) aSS dolari mas Semdeg, rac myidveli/mosarCele gam-yidvels/mopasuxes daubrunebs nasyidobis sagans _ na-xats.

16. sakasacio sasamarTlo ganmartavs, rom im SemTxve-vaSi Tu gamyidveli ar miiRebs Sesrulebas _ ar daibru-nebs naxats, mosarCeles SeuZlia ixelmZRvanelos ssk-is434-e muxlis danawesiT da Sesrulebis sagani Seinaxos sa-samarTlosa an notariatSi/deponireba. deponirebiT mo-vale Tavisufldeba kreditoris winaSe valdebulebisa-gan (ssk-is 434.2 muxli).

17. mas Semdeg, rac mosarCele mopasuxes gadascems na-xats an moaxdens mis deponirebas da amis damadasture-bel mtkicebulebas moipovebs, mas SeeZleba mopasuxesmosTxovos nasyidobis safasuris _ 13 000 aSS dolaris ukandabruneba. im SemTxvevaSi Tu mopasuxe nebayoflobiT arSeasrulebs masze dakisrebul valdebulebas, mosarCelesSeeZleba ixelmZRvanelos `saaRsrulebo warmoebaTa Se-saxeb~ saqarTvelos kanoniT dadgenili wesiT iZulebiTiaRsrulebis Sesaxeb.

18. sssk-is 53-e muxlis pirveli nawilis Tanaxmad im mxa-ris mier gaRebuli xarjebis gadaxda, romlis sasargeblo-dac iqna gamotanili gadawyvetileba, ekisreba meore mxa-res sarCelis im moTxovnis proporciulad, romelic sa-samarTlos gadawyvetilebiT iqna dakmayofilebuli. aR-niSnuli muxlis danawesis Sesabamisad mopasuxes mosar-Celis sasargeblod daekisreba sarCelis dakmayofilebu-li nawilis proporciuli saxelmwifo baJis gadaxda (ix. ga-dawyvetilebis sarezolucio nawili).


samoqalaqo saproceso kodeqsis 411-e muxliT da


1. T. k-is sakasacio saCivari dakmayofildes nawilob-

119

riv;2. gauqmdes Tbilisis saapelacio sasamarTlos samoqa-

laqo saqmeTa palatis 2016 wlis 29 seqtembris ganCinebada miRebul iqnes axali gadawyvetileba;

3. n. C-is sarCeli dakmayofildes nawilobriv;4. n. C-is sasargeblod 13 000 (cameti aTasi) aSS dolaris

gadaxda daekisros T. k-s, am ukanasknelisaTvis mosarCe-lis mier sapasuxo Sesrulebis ganxorcielebis, kerZod,mosarCelisaTvis mopasuxis mier gadacemuli ferwerulinaxatis `zamTari~ 1971 weli, tilo, zeTi, 80X60, dabrune-bis Semdeg;

5. T. k-s n. C-is sasargeblod daekisros, pirveli in-stanciis sasamarTloSi gadaxdili saxelmwifo baJis _ 683laris gadaxda;

6. gadawyvetileba sabolooa da ar saCivrdeba.


ganCinebasaqarTvelos saxeliT

#as-1209-1169-2016 12 ivlisi, 2017 w., q. Tbilisi



davis sagani: zianis anazRaureba

aRwerilobiTi nawili:1. T. l-s (SemdegSi: mosarCele, gamyidveli, apelanti an

kasatoris mowinaaRmdege) da e. r. n-is, o. r-is, i. s. n-i S-isda i. n-i r-is (SemdegSi: mopasuxeebi, myidvelebi, kasato-rebi) warmomadgenels m. z. n-is (SemdegSi: mopasuxeTa,myidvelTa an kasatorTa warmomadgeneli) Soris 2008 wlis6 marts daido xelSekruleba, romelic saxeldebulia uZ-ravi qonebis nasyidobad (ix. xelSekruleba).

2. uZravi qoneba warmoadgens arasasoflo-sameurneo

120

miwis nakveTebs da mdebareobs q. TbilisSi, sofeli l-i,erTi miwis farTobia 5600 kv.m, sakadastro kodiT 7.. dameore nakveTis farTobia _ 347 kv.m sakadastro kodiT 7..;xelSekrulebis fasi ganisazRvra 1 070 872 (erTi milionsamocdaaTi aTas rvaas samocdaTormeti) aSS dolariT.

3. xelSekrulebis me-4 muxlis Tanaxmad, myidvelebs un-da gadaexadaT 1 070 872 (erTi milion samocdaaTi aTas rva-as samocdaTormeti) aSS dolaris ekvivalenti erovnulvalutaSi, xelSekrulebis xelmoweridan 3 dRis gan-mavlobaSi. im SemTxvevaSi, Tu myidveli ar gadaixdida ze-moxsenebul Tanxas miTiTebuli xelSekrulebis mixedviTda dadgenil vadaSi, uZravi qonebis nasyidobis xelSekru-leba gauqmebulad CaiTvleboda da mdgomareoba daub-rundeboda mis pirvandel saxes.

4. uZravi qoneba nasyidobis xelSekrulebis safuZ-velze sajaro reestrSi aRiricxa winamdebare ganCinebispirvel punqtSi miTiTebul mopasuxeTa sakuTrebad (saqar-Tvelos samoqalaqo kodeqsis, SemdegSi ssk, 477-e, 183-e,311-e, 312-e muxlebi). uZravi qoneba gaerTianebulia sxvasakadastro kodebiT mdebare miwis nakveTebTan, dat-virTulia ipoTekiT da masze registrirebulia nasyido-bis winare xelSekruleba (ix. amonawerebi sajaro reestri-dan; sesxisa da ipoTekis xelSekruleba).

5. sarCelis moTxovna da safuZvlebi5.1. gamyidvelma 2014 wlis 30 ianvars sasamarTlos mi-

marTa da moiTxova sarCelis aRZvramde, uzrunvelyofisRonisZiebis saxiT, mopasuxeTa uZrav qonebaze yadaRis da-deba, rac Tbilisis saqalaqo sasamarTlos samoqalaqo saq-meTa kolegiis 2014 wlis 17 Tebervlis ganCinebiT dakma-yofilda (ix. gancxadeba da sasamarTlos ganCineba). imavewlis 14 Tebervals gamyidvelma sarCeli aRZra am ganCine-bis pirvel punqtSi miTiTebuli mopasuxeebis winaaRmdeg(ix. sarCeli) da moiTxova mosarCelis sasargeblod myid-velebs solidarulad dahkisrebodaT:

5.1.1. 1 070 872 aSS dolaris ekvivalentis erovnul va-lutaSi gadaxda;

5.1.2. 909 091 aSS dolaris ekvivalentis erovnul valu-taSi gadaxda;

5.1.3. 909 091 aSS dolaris ekvivalentis erovnul valu-taSi wliuri 12%-is anazRaureba 2008 wlis 10 martidangadawyvetilebis aRsrulebamde;

121

5.1.4. sarCelze gadaxdili saxelmwifo baJisa da advo-katis momsaxurebaze gaweuli xarjebis anazRaureba.

5.2. moTxovnis faqtobriv safuZvlad mosarCelem miu-TiTa am ganCinebis 1-3 punqtebSi miTiTebul garemoebeb-ze da ganmarta, rom nasyidobis xelSekrulebis dadebisdResve, anu 2008 wlis 6 marts sajaro reestrSi uZraviqoneba aRiricxa SemZenTa sakuTrebad, romelTac myidve-lisaTvis gadaxdili aqvT mxolod 161 781 aSS dolari, xo-lo xelSekrulebiT SeTanxmebuli nasyidobis safasurisdanarCeni nawili ar gadauxdiaT;

5.3. miwis nakveTebze 2014 wlis 31 ianvris axali amona-weris aRebis Semdeg, mosarCelem Seityo, rom erT-erTimiwis nakveTis sakadastro kodi 7.., romelic nakveTis wi-na nomerSi sxva nomrebTan erTadaa miTiTebuli, Secvli-lia da amJamad sakadastro kodia 7.. meore nakveTze ki,romlis sakadastro kodi iyo 7.. imave 2014 wlis 31 ianvrisamonawerSi, erT-erT sakadastro nomrad miTiTebulia 7..;

5.4. yovelgvari gonivruli vada gavida xelSekrulebisnebayoflobiT SesrulebisaTvis, ar aqvs azri damatebiTivadis dawesebas, vinaidan gamyidvels aRar aqvs nasyido-bis darCenili Tanxis miRebis interesi, igi uars ambobsxelSekrulebaze, gadis xelSekrulebidan da iTxovs zia-nis anazRaurebas;

5.5. sarCelis aRZvris stadiaze, gamyidvelma aRmoaCi-na, rom naturiT dabrunebis moTxovna SeuZlebelia da ssk-is 352-e muxlis meore nawilis `b~ qvepunqtis safuZvelze,mopasuxeebi valdebuli arian, fuladi anazRaureba moax-dinon naturiT dabrunebis sanacvlod. qonebis Rirebu-leba miTiTebulia nasyidobis xelSekrulebaSi da igi Se-adgens 1 070 872 aSS dolars;

5.6. xelSekrulebidan gamyidvelis gasvla xdeba mova-lis (mopasuxeTa) braliT, amdenad, es ukanasknelebi val-debuli arian, aanazRauron valdebulebis Seusruleblo-biT miyenebuli ziani ssk-is 394-e muxlis safuZvelze `mo-valis mier valdebulebis darRvevisas kreditors SeuZ-lia moiTxovos amiT gamowveuli zianis anazRaureba~. mo-sarCelisaTvis miyenebuli pirdapiri ziani aris is gada-uxdeli Tanxa, rac myidvelebma ar gadauxades gamyidvels2008 wlis 6 martis nasyidobis xelSekrulebidan gamomdi-nare;

5.7. ssk-is 411-e muxlis safuZvelze, mosarCele iTxovs

122

miuRebeli Semosavlis saxiT miyenebuli zianis anazRau-rebas. amasTan, radgan mopasuxeebi 5 welze metia ukano-nod sargebloben mosarCelisaTvis gadasaxdeli TanxiT,gamyidvelis mtkicebiT, ssk-is 981-e muxlis me-2 nawilissafuZvelze, gamokveTilia usafuZvlo gamdidrebis nair-saxeoba da myidvelebma unda gadaixadon procenti. fu-lis unikaluri Tvisebidan gamomdinare, ivaraudeba, rommisi gacvla SesaZlebelia qonebrivi urTierTobis TiT-qmis nebismier obieqtze, amdenad, mas yovelTvis moaqvssargebeli mesakuTrisaTvis. saqarTvelos samoqalaqo sap-roceso kodeqsis (SemdegSi: sssk) 102-e muxlis safuZvelzemopasuxeebma unda daamtkicon, rom SeZenilma qonebam maTsargebeli ar moutana.

6. mopasuxeTa Sesagebeli6.1. mopasuxeebma ar cnes maT winaaRmdeg aRZruli sar-

Celi im dasabuTebiT, rom myidvelTa warmomadgenelma (ix.am ganCinebis pirveli punqti) xelSekrulebis dadebisdResve _ 2008 wlis 6 marts gadauxada nasyidobis sruliTanxa 1 070 872 aSS dolari gamyidvels, saidanac 161 781aSS dolari gadaxdilia sabanko gadaricxviT uSualod mo-sarCelis (gamyidvelis) saxelze, xolo danarCeni Tanxa,am ukanasknelisave miTiTebiT, gadaxdilia sxva pirebis sa-banko angariSebze, rac dasturdeba myidvelTa warmomad-genlis 2008 wlis amonaweriT da a. b-is, i. n-isa da d. d-issanotaro wesiT damowmebuli gancxadebebiT (ix. Sesage-beli);

6.2. mosarCeles mTeli 6 wlis ganmavlobaSi ar warudge-nia, Tundac zepiri formiT, pretenzia myidvelebisaTvisTanxis gadaxdis Taobaze 06.03.2008 w. xelSekrulebis sa-fuZvelze, man mxolod 5 wlisa da 11 Tvis Semdeg waradgi-na sarCeli (ix.Sesagebeli).

7. Tbilisis saqalaqo sasamarTlos samoqalaqo saq-meTa kolegiis 2015 wlis 28 ivlisis gadawyvetileba dadaskvnebi

7.1. Tbilisis saqalaqo sasamarTlos samoqalaqo saqme-Ta kolegiis 2015 wlis 28 ivlisis gadawyvetilebiT myid-velis sarCeli ar dakmayofilda;

7.2. sasamarTlom dadgenil sadavo faqtobriv garemo-ebaTa Soris miuTiTa winamdebare ganCinebis 1-3 punqtebSimiTiTebul garemoebebze.

7.3. am ganCinebis me-4 punqtSi miTiTebuli garemoebis

123

dadgenisas sasamarTlo daeyrdno Semdeg mtkicebulebebs:7.3.1. nasyidobis xelSekrulebis gaformebis dRes, anu

2008 wlis 6 marts, myidvelTa warmomadgenelma (m. z. n-im)ss `s-idan~ uZravi qonebis gamyidvels pirad angariSze Ca-uricxa 161 781 aSS dolari;

7.3.2. imave dRes myidvelTa warmomadgenlis angariSi-dan i. n-is angariSze gadairicxa 137.605 aSS dolari, a. b-isangariSze _ 391.704 aSS dolari, d. d-is angariSze _ 404.782aSS dolari. 2008 wlis 6 marts myidvelTa warmomadgenlisangariSidan sxvadasxva pirebisaTvis sul gadaricxulia2.270 030 aSS dolari;

7.3.3. a. b-is mier 2014 wlis 16 aprils xelmowerili do-kumentiT dasturdeba, rom 2008 wlis 6 marts, mis piradangariSze ss `s-Si~ miRebuli Tanxa _ 391 704 aSS dolari _gadmoricxulia myidvelTa warmomadgenlis mier 2008wlis 6 marts gaformebuli nasyidobis xelSekrulebis Se-sabamisad, myidvelTa mier gamyidvelis (mosarCelis) mi-marT nakisri valdebulebis Sesrulebis mizniT da aR-niSnuli Tanxa myidvelis mier am ganCinebis meore punqtSimiTiTebuli uZravi qonebis SeZenis sanacvlod gamyidve-lisaTvis gadaxdili nasyidobis safasurs warmoadgens.amasTan, a. b-i adasturebs, rom 2008 wlis 6 marts myid-velma zemoaRniSnuli Tanxa _ 391 704 aSS dolari xelzemiiRo srulad _ sanotaro aqti damowmebulia notariusisT. p-is mier, reestris #140374436.

7.3.4. d. d-is mier 2014 wlis 25 aprils xelmowerili do-kumentiT dasturdeba, rom 2008 wlis 6 marts mis piradangariSze ss `s-Si~ 404 782 aSS dolaris odenobiT miRebu-li Tanxidan 379 782 aSS dolari gadmoricxulia myidvelTawarmomadgenlis mier, 2008 wlis 6 marts gaformebuli nas-yidobis xelSekrulebis Sesabamisad, myidvelTa mier gam-yidvels (mosarCelis) mimarT nakisri valdebulebis Ses-rulebis mizniT da aRniSnuli Tanxa warmoadgens myidve-lebis mier am ganCinebis meore punqtSi miTiTebuli uZra-vi qonebis SeZenis sanacvlod gamyidvelisaTvis gadaxdilnasyidobis safasurs, Tanaxmad zemoxsenebuli xelSekru-lebisa. amasTanave d. d-e adasturebs, rom myidvelma ze-moaRniSnuli Tanxa _ 379 782 aSS dolari _ xelze miiRosrulad _ sanotaro aqti damowmebulia notarius b. S-asmier, reestris #140402864.

7.3.5. i. n-is mier 2014 wlis 23 aprils xelmowerili do-

124

kumentiT dasturdeba, rom 2008 wlis 6 marts mis piradangariSze ss `s-Si~ miRebuli Tanxa _ 137 605 aSS dolari _gadmoricxulia myidvelTa warmomadgenlis mier 2008wlis 6 marts gaformebuli nasyidobis xelSekrulebis Se-sabamisad, myidvelTa mier gamyidvelis (mosarCelis) mi-marT nakisri valdebulebis Sesrulebis mizniT da aR-niSnuli Tanxa warmoadgens myidvelis mier am ganCinebismeore punqtSi miTiTebuli uZravi qonebis SeZenis sanac-vlod gamyidvelisaTvis gadaxdil nasyidobis safasurs, Ta-naxmad zemoaRniSnuli xelSekrulebisa. amasTanave i. n-eadasturebs, rom 2008 wlis 6 marts mosarCelem (gamyidvel-ma) zemoaRniSnuli Tanxa _ 137 605 aSS dolari xelze mii-Ro srulad _ sanotaro aqti damowmebulia notarius T. p-is mier, reestris #140387713.

7.3.6. mosarCele mcxeTis municipalitetis l-is teri-toriuli organos gamgeobis specialistad muSaobda 2007wlis 12 ivnisidan 27 dekembramde da 2008 wlis 8 ianvridan16 martis CaTvliT. 2008 wlis 17 martidan igi gadaiyvanesmcxeTis municipalitetis gamgeobis m-is teritoriuliorganos xelmZRvanelad, xolo 2008 wlis 1 dekembers _piradi gancxadebis safuZvelze gaTavisuflda dakavebu-li Tanamdebobidan. 2010 wlis 17 ivnisidan iyo mcxeTis mu-nicipalitetis sakrebulos wevri (cnobis gacemamde pe-riodi 2014 wlis 9 ivnisi). 2014 wlis 24 ivnisidan iyo fraq-cia è. n. m-s~ Tavmjdomaris moadgile da agrarul sakiT-xTa, bunebrivi resursebisa da garemos dacvis komisiiswevri, fraqcia maJoritaris Tavmjdomare.

7.4. saqalaqo sasamarTlom samarTlebriv garemoebeb-Tan dakavSirebiT Semdeg daskvnebze miuTiTa:

7.4.1. ssk-is 317-e muxlis Tanaxmad, valdebulebis war-moSobisaTvis aucilebelia monawileTa Soris xelSekru-leba, garda im SemTxvevebisa, roca valdebuleba warmoi-Soba zianis miyenebis (deliqtis), usafuZvlo gamdidre-bis an kanoniT gaTvaliswinebuli sxva safuZvlebidan. mo-cemuli davis sagania xelSekrulebis SeusruleblobiT mi-yenebuli zianis anazRaureba. samoqalaqo samarTalSi zi-anis anazRaureba niSnavs piris mimarT warmoSobili zia-nis kompensacias sxva piris mier. zianis anazRaurebis val-debuleba SesaZloa gamomdinareobdes xelSekrulebidan,sxva SemTxvevaSi samarTlebrivi mowesrigebiT. gansakuT-rebiT mniSvnelovania, erTi mxriv, xelSekrulebiT gan-

125

sazRvruli valdebulebis da, meore mxriv, deliqturivaldebulebis Sedegad warmoSobili zianis anazRaureba,rac gaTvaliswinebulia ssk-is 992-e muxliT. kanoniT gan-sazRvruli yoveli zianis anazRaurebis valdebulebiswinapiroba aris, rom igi gamowveulia mavaldebulebeligaremoebis Sedegad. zianis anazRaurebis mavaldebule-bel garemoebasa da zians Soris, ese igi, arsebul mdgoma-reobasa da im mdgomareobas Soris, romelic iarsebebda,rom ar ganxorcielebuliyo zianis anazRaurebis maval-debulebeli garemoeba, unda arsebobdes mizezobrivi kav-Siri. es niSnavs, rom nebismieri piroba mizezobriv kav-SirSia SedegTan da am SedegisaTvis TanabarmniSvnelovanswarmoadgens, Tu dadgindeba, rom am pirobis gareSe Sede-gi am konkretuli formiT ar dadgeboda. amdenad, samoqa-laqo kanonmdeblobis Tanaxmad, zianis anazRaurebis Se-saxeb pirs pasuxismgebloba daekisreba mxolod kanoniTgaTvaliswinebuli pirobebis erToblivad arsebobisas,kerZod: dadasturebuli unda iyos zianis faqti; ziani mi-yenebuli unda iyos marTlsawinaaRmdego qmedebiT; mar-TlsawinaaRmdego qmedebasa da damdgar zians Soris undaarsebobdes mizezobrivi kavSiri da zianis mimyenebels un-da miuZRodes brali zianis dadgomaSi. bralis gareSe pa-suxismgeblobis dadgomisaTvis ki aucilebelia pasuxis-mgebeli piris marTlsawinaaRmdego qmedebis arseboba. TuaseTi qmedeba ar arsebobs, cxadia, bralze saubari Sina-arss moklebulia.

7.4.2. saqalaqo sasamarTlom ssk-is 477-e muxlis pirvelpunqtze dayrdnobiT, aRniSna, rom nasyidobis xelSekru-lebiT gamyidveli movalea gadasces myidvels sakuTre-bis ufleba qonebaze, miawodos masTan dakavSirebuli sa-buTebi da saqoneli. myidveli movalea gadauxados gam-yidvels SeTanxmebuli fasi da miiRos nayidi qoneba. nas-yidobis xelSekruleba warmoadgens konsesualur da or-mxriv xelSekrulebas. kanonmdebeli nasyidobisaTvisdadgenili zogadi wesiT gansazRvravs valdebulebebispirobebs da emyareba xelSekrulebis Tavisuflebis prin-cips, garigebis Sesrulebulad misaCnevad savaldebuloamxareTa mier ufleba-movaleobebis jerovnad da srul-yofilad Sesruleba, Tanaxmad ssk-is 361-e muxlisa.

7.4.3. sasamarTlom imsjela, rom gansaxilvel SemTxve-vaSi sasarCelo moTxovnis safuZveli iyo nasyidobis xel-

126

Sekrulebidan gamomdinare valdebulebaTa Sesruleba,romlis safuZvelze gamyidvelma myidvels (maTi warmo-madgenlis m. z. n-is saxiT), gadasca sakuTrebaSi uZravi qo-neba, Tumca, rogorc mosarCele miuTiTebda, mopasuxeTawarmomadgenelma nasyidobis Rirebuleba ar gadaixada, ararsebobda mopasuxis mier Tanxis gadaxdis neba, ris gamocgamyidveli wyvetda xelSekrulebas da moiTxovda zianisanazRaurebas. xelSekrulebis Sewyvetis safuZvlebi dawesi gaTvaliswinebulia ssk-is 405-e muxliT. xelSekru-leba SeiZleba Sewydes SesrulebiT, amasTan, xelSekru-lebis mxareebi, aseve, uflebamosili arian, daadginonxelSekrulebis Sewyvetis sxva safuZvlebi da wesi. amde-nad, mocemul SemTxvevaSi, sasamarTlom aRniSna, rom da-sadgen faqtobriv garemoebas warmoadgenda myidvelTawarmomadgenlis mier valdebulebis Sesruleba-arSesru-lebis sakiTxis gadawyveta.

7.4.4. sasamarTlom aRniSna, rom sadavo faqtobriv ga-remoebas ar warmoadgenda, rom 2008 wlis 6 marts mosar-Celesa da mopasuxeebs Soris daido nasyidobis xelSekru-leba uZrav qonebaze, ganisazRvra nasyidobis fasi, misigadaxdis wesi da pirobebi (ix. am ganCinebis 1-3 punqtebi).

7.4.5. sasamarTlom ganmarta, rom ssk-is 183-e-185-e mux-lebis Sesabamisad, uZrav qonebaze ganxorcielebuli sa-marTlebrivi qmedebebi saWiroebda savaldebulo regis-tracias da amave kodeqsis 312-e muxlis Tanaxmad, regis-trirebuli monacemebi namdvilad iTvleba, sanam sawina-aRmdego ar dadasturdeba. sasamarTlos SefasebiT, dad-genilia, rom nasyidobis xelSekruleba damowmebulia sa-notaro wesiT da uZravi qoneba aRricxulia sajaro rees-trSi mopasuxeTa sakuTrebad. arc xelSekruleba da arcsajaro reestrSi xelSekrulebis registracia mosarCe-les sadavod ar gauxdia. nasyidobis xelSekrulebis me-4muxliT mxareebi SeTanxmdnen, rom myidvelis mier nasyi-dobis fasis gadaxda ganxorcieldeboda xelSekruleba-ze xelmoweridan sami dRis ganmavlobaSi. valdebulebisdarRvevis SemTxvevaSi ki xelSekruleba gauqmdeboda daaRdgeboda pirvandeli mdgomareoba.

7.4.6. mosarCeles (gamyidvels) ar gamouyenebia xel-Sekrulebis zemoxsenebuli me-4 muxliT miniWebuli uf-leba pirvandeli mdgomareobis aRdgenis Sesaxeb.

7.4.7. xelSekrulebis Rirebuleba gansazRvrulia 1 070

127

872 aSS dolariT. mosarCele sadavod ar xdis da dadgeni-lia, rom xelSekrulebis farglebSi, xelSekrulebis ga-formebis dResve, mas miRebuli aqvs 161 781 aSS dolari.

7.4.8. Sps ì-is~ saeqsperto daskvniT l-s mimdebare te-ritoriaze mdebare 1 kv.m miwis Rirebuleba 2008 wlisaT-vis Seadgenda 10-dan 15 aSS dolars.

7.4.9. mxareTa ganmartebebiT, mowmeebis _ a. b-is, i. n-is,d. d-is, notarius l. r-is ganmartebebiT irkveva, rom mo-pasuxe (warmomadgeneli _ m. z. n-i) miwebis Sesyidvas awar-moebda misTvis sando pirebis SuamavlobiT da meSveobiT.sadavo SemTxvevaSic miwebis Sesyidva moxda mopasuxeTawarmomadgenelTan mosarCelis SeTanxmebis Sedegad. Se-Tanxmebis sagans warmoadgenda sofel l-s teritoriaze,erTmaneTis momijnaved mdebare, ramdenime mesakuTris mi-wis nakveTi. miwis yoveli kvadratuli metrisaTvis SeTan-xmebuli fasi ganisazRvra 40 aSS dolariT.

7.4.10. sasamarTlom aRniSna: dadgenilia, rom 2008 wlis6 marts, nasyidobis xelSekrulebebi gaformda mosarCe-lis kuTvnil 5947 kv.m miwis nakveTze da am miwis nakveTismomijnave miwis nakveTebze, sul 56 749 kv.m farTis 11 mi-wis nakveTze. auditoruli daskvnisa da teqnikuri naxa-zebis Sesabamisad, gayiduli miwebi erTmaneTis gver-digverd mdebareobs. miwebi ganlagebulia or xazad, er-TmaneTis mimdebared; qveda xazi emijneba trasas (saka-dastro kodebi: 7..., 7..., 7..., 7..., 7..., 7... da 7...), xolo meorexazi mdebareobs mis zeviT (sakadastro kodebi: 7..., 7..., 7...da 7...).

7.4.11. Sesyiduli miwis farTis da Rirebulebis gaanga-riSebiT mTlianad gadasaxdeli Tanxa ganisazRvra 2 259960 aSS dolariT.

7.4.12. dadgenilia, rom aRniSnuli Tanxa mopasuxeTawarmomadgenelma gadaricxa sxvadasxva pirebis angariSeb-ze (ix. am ganCinebis 7.3.2 qvepunqti).

7.4.13. mopasuxe yuradRebas amaxvilebs imaze, rom nas-yidobis xelSekrulebaSi miTiTebuli miwis nakveTebis Ri-rebuleba aragonivrulad didia da ganmartavs, rom xel-Sekrulebis gaformebis dros lisis teritoriaze miwis ga-sayidi fasi Seadgenda 16-26 aSS dolars kvadratul met-rze; xelSekrulebaSi ki miwis farTTan misi fasis Tana-fardobam Seadgina 180 aSS dolari, rac aragonivrulia dagamowveulia sxvadasxva mizeziT. gamyidvelis angariSze

128

Caricxuli 161 781 aSS dolari sworedac savaraudod misimiwis Rirebulebas warmoadgens. mosarCelis miwis mdeba-reoba ar iyo sakvanZo an didi mniSvnelobis, misi miwa gana-pirasaa da am miwis yidva ar warmoadgenda im saWiroebas,rom mopasuxeebs mis TiToeul kvadratul metrSi 180 aSSdolari gadaexadaT.

7.4.14. mopasuxeTa warmomadgenlis mtkicebiT, gam-yidveli (mosarCele) iyo mTeli am miwis nakveTebis Ses-yidvis operaciis organizatori da misive miTiTebiT Ta-vissave miwebze nasyidobis xelSekrulebaSi gaiwera misa-Rebi gansxvaveba myidvelebsa da gamyidvelebs Soris Se-Tanxmebuli fasisa. yvela xelSekruleba gaformda nota-rius l. r-esTan erTsa da imave dRes. xelSekrulebebi er-TmaneTis identuria da gansxvavdeba mxolod gamyidvel-Ta saidentifikacio monacemebiT, fasiTa da qonebis aR-werilobiT. yvela xelSekrulebis meoTxe muxli moicavsSemdeg daTqmas: `mxareTa Soris SeTanxmebulia, rom myid-veli kisrulobs valdebulebas gadauxados gamyidvelsnasyidobis fasi winamdebare xelSekrulebaze xelmowe-ris dRidan sami dRis ganmavlobaSi. im SemTxvevaSi, Tumyidveli ar gadaixdis zemoxsenebul Tanxas, Tanaxmad wi-namdebare xelSekrulebisa, masSi miTiTebul vadaSi, uZ-ravi qonebis nasyidobis winamdebare xelSekruleba gauq-mebulad CaiTvleba da mdgomareoba daubrundeba pir-vandel saxes~.

7.4.15. saqalaqo sasamarTlom aRniSna, rom saqmeze mow-mis saxiT daikiTxa notariusi l. r-e, romelmac ganmarta,rom mopasuxeTa warmomadgeneli m. z. n-i iyo misi klientida misi monawileobiT gaformebul arc erT garigebaSi ro-melime mxares pretenzia ar hqonia. notariusis praqtiki-dan gamomdinare, Tuki nasyidobis sagnis Rirebuleba ga-daxdili ar iqneboda, is myidvelTa warmomadgenels xel-Sekrulebas ar gadascemda sajaro reestrSi registraci-isaTvis. notariusma ganmarta, rom xelSekrulebis me-4punqtis Sesabamisad, mosarCeles (gamyidvels), romelTa-nac axlo urTierToba akavSirebs, arc xelSekrulebis ga-formebidan 3 dRis Semdeg da arc am dromde, Tanxis gada-uxdelobis Sesaxeb raime pretenziiT ar miumarTavs.

7.4.16. sasamarTlom aRniSna, rom saqmeSi aseve wardge-nilia 2014 wlis 1 dekembers israelis saxelmwifo nota-riusis mier damowmebuli z. T-is ficiT micemuli werilo-

129

biTi Cveneba, sadac is adasturebs 2008 wlis 6 martis xel-Sekrulebidan gamomdinare m. z. n-is mier valdebulebisSesrulebis faqts. kerZod, z. T-i uTiTebs, rom 2007-2008wlebSi muSaobda m. z. n-is pirad TanaSemwed da Tarjimnad.n-im xeli moawera 10 xelSekrulebas 15-ze met sxvadasxvagamyidvelTan, l-s mimdebared miwis nakveTebis SeZenismizniT. 2008 wlis 6 marts m. z. n-is mier gaformebuli xel-SekrulebebiT arsebuli valdebuleba n-im Seasrula _ yve-la gamyidvelma miiRo Tanxa, rac Seexeba mosarCeles (gam-yidvels), z. T-i eswreboda piradad, rodesac myidvelsgadaeca naRdi fulis didi Sekvra piradad. igive mowme we-rilobiTi ficiT adasturebs, rom es Tanxa iyo nasyidobissafasuris nawilobrivi gadasaxadi, romelic misTvis argadauxdiaT sabanko gadaricxviT, xolo mopasuxeTa war-momadgenelma mxolod mas Semdeg miiRo xelSekrulebebidasaregistrireblad, rac yvela gamyidvels gadauxadanasyidobis Tanxa. yvela xelSekruleba notariusTan dar-Ca, sanam myidvelTa warmomadgenelma ar gadauxada yvelagamyidvels Tanxa da Semdeg yvela gamyidvelma neba dar-To notariuss, batoni n-isaTvis (mopasuxeTa warmomad-genlisaTvis) gadaeca yvela kontraqti. mowme uSualodeswreboda, rodesac naRdi fulis didi Sekvra piradadgadaeca erT-erT gamyidvels _ T. l-s, am ukanasknels Tan-xa gadaeca, rogorc nasyidobis safasuris nawilobrivi ga-dasaxadi, romelic misTvis ar gadauxdiaT sabanko gada-ricxviT, Tumca, gadaericxaT sxva pirebs sabanko angariS-ze da gamyidvels gadaeca naRdi fuli. mopasuxeTa warmo-madgenelma nasyidobis xelSekrulebebi miiRo mxolod masSemdeg, rac notariuss yvela gamyidvelma daudastura,rom n-im (myidvelTa warmomadgenelma) srulad gadauxa-da Tanxa Sesabamis gamyidvelebs da rom maT ar aqvT sxvamoTxovnebi.

7.4.17. mosarCelem sadavo gaxada mowme a. b-is, i. n-is dad. d-is Cvenebebi da Tanxis gadacemis Sesaxeb Sesrulebu-li sanotaro wesiT dadasturebuli gancxadebebi (ix. amganCinebis 7.3.3 _ 7.3.5 qvepunqtebi). sasamarTlom ar gaizi-ara am Cvenebebis Sesaxeb mowmeTa arasandooba, radgan isi-ni sasamarTlom gaafrTxila cru Cvenebis micemis SemTxve-vaSi mosalodneli pasuxismgeblobis Taobaze.

7.5. sasamarTlom imsjela saqmeSi wardgenil mtkice-bulebebze _ sanotaro wesiT dadasturebul gancxadebeb-

130

ze da aRniSna, rom i. n-e uaryofda da ar adasturebda gam-yidvelis mier mis angariSze Caricxuli Tanxis miRebisfaqts.

7.6. sasamarTlom ganmarta, rom sssk-is 105-e muxlis pir-veli nawilis Tanaxmad, sasamarTlosaTvis araviTar mtki-cebulebas ara aqvs winaswar dadgenili Zala. xolo amavemuxlis me-2 nawilis Sesabamisad, sasamarTlo afasebs mtki-cebulebebs Tavisi Sinagani rwmeniT, romelic unda emya-rebodes maT yovelmxriv, srul da obieqtur ganxilvas,ris Sedegadac mas gamoaqvs daskvna saqmisaTvis mniSvne-lobis mqone garemoebebis arsebobis an ararsebobis Sesa-xeb. sasamarTlom ar gaiziara i. n-is mier Sesrulebuli 2014wlis 24 ivnisiT daTariRebuli gancxadebis Sinaarsi, ram-denadac misi gaqarwyleba Sesabamisi mtkicebulebebiT ariyo gamyarebuli. amasTan, nawilobriv ewinaaRmdegebodaimave piris mierve sasamarTlo sxdomaze, mowmis saxiT, mi-cemul Cvenebebs da saqmeSi arsebul sxva mtkicebulebebs.

7.7. sasamarTlom aseve miuTiTa, rom 2008 wlis 6 martissadavo nasyidobis xelSekrulebiT gaTvaliswinebuli uZ-ravi qoneba, amave xelSekrulebis safuZvelze, sajaro re-estrSi mopasuxeTa sakuTrebad aRiricxa. registracia sa-davod ar gamxdara. uZravi qoneba gaerTianebulia sxva sa-kadastro kodebiT mdebare miwis nakveTebTan, datvirTu-lia ipoTekiT da masze registrirebulia nasyidobis wina-re xelSekruleba. amasTan, xelSekrulebis gaformebidansarCelis aRZvramde gasulia 5 weli da 11 Tve, Tumca, mo-sarCeles am xelSekrulebidan gamomdinare, mopasuxeTamimarT, raime pretenzia ar hqonia. Sesabamisad, sasamar-Tlos daskvniT, pretenziis ararseboba gamowveulia mo-pasuxis mier valdebulebis Sesrulebis faqtiT.

7.8. sasamarTlom aRniSna, rom mosarCele (gamyidveli)pretenziis ufro adre ganucxadeblobis safuZvlad miu-TiTebda, rom mas problemebi hqonda wina xelisuflebas-Tan, sdevnidnen da iZulebuli iyo, Tavi Seekavebina moT-xovnis wardgenisagan.

7.9. sasamarTlom imsjela saqmeSi moTavsebul mtkice-bulebebze, romlebiTac dasturdeboda, rom mosarCele2007 wlidan sajaro dawesebulebaSi muSaobda sxvadasxvaTanamdebobaze, 2010 wlis 17 ivnisidan dRemde ki aris mcxe-Tis municipalitetis sakrebulos wevri, aseve, 2010 wlis24 ivnisidan iyo fraqcia è. n. m-s~ Tavmjdomaris moadgi-

131

le. amavdroulad, 2010 wlis 24 ivnisidan mosarCele arismcxeTis municipalitetis sakrebulos agrarul sakiTxTa,bunebrivi resursebisa da garemos dacvis komisiis wevri.amasTan, 2012 wlis 5 noembridan dRemde aris fraqcia `m~-s Tavmjdomare. Sesabamisad, sasamarTlom dausabuTebladmiiCnia mosarCelis mtkiceba yofili xelisuflebis mxri-dan misi devnisa da Seviwroebis gamo, mopasuxeTa winaaR-mdeg am pretenziis ufro adre wardgenaze Tavis Sekave-basTan dakavSirebiT. mxares amis damadasturebeli raimemtkicebuleba ar warudgenia sasamarTlosaTvis, xolo mo-sarCelis SromiTi biografiis Sesaxeb cnobebi ki sawina-aRmdegos adasturebdnen (ix. 7.3.6 qvepunqti).

7.10. sasamarTlom sssk-is 102-e muxlis mowesrigebazedayrdnobiT, gansaxilvel SemTxvevaSi miTiTebuli sada-vo faqtobrivi garemoebis dadgenisas, mxedvelobaSi mii-Ro, rogorc saqmeSi wardgenili werilobiTi mtkicebule-bebi, ise _ mxareTa axsna-ganmartebebi da daaskvna, rommosarCelem ver daadastura is faqtobrivi garemoebebi,romelzedac amyarebda sasarCelo moTxovnas.

7.11. ssk-is 352-e muxlis pirveli punqtis Tanaxmad, TuxelSekrulebis erT-erTi mxare 405-e muxliT gaTvalis-winebuli pirobebis arsebobisas uars ityvis xelSekru-lebaze, maSin miRebuli Sesruleba da sargebeli mxareebsubrundebaT. naturiT dabrunebis nacvlad movales ekis-reba fuladi anazRaureba, Tu: a. SeZenilis xasiaTidan ga-momdinare, gamoricxulia misi dabruneba; b. miRebul sa-gans mxare gamoiyenebs, gaasxvisebs, uflebrivad dat-virTavs, gadaamuSavebs an gadaakeTebs; g. miRebuli saganigafuWda an daiRupa; saTanado gamoyenebiT gamowveulicveTa mxedvelobaSi ar miiReba. ssk-is 405-e muxlis Ta-naxmad, Tu xelSekrulebis erTi mxare arRvevs ormxrivixelSekrulebidan gamomdinare valdebulebas, maSin xel-Sekrulebis meore mxares SeuZlia uari Tqvas xelSekru-lebaze valdebulebis SesrulebisaTvis mis mier damate-biT gansazRvruli vadis uSedegod gasvlis Semdeg. Tuvaldebulebis darRvevis xasiaTidan gamomdinare, ar ga-moiyeneba damatebiTi vada, maSin damatebiTi vadis gan-sazRvras uTanabrdeba gafrTxileba. Tuki valdebulebamxolod nawilobriv dairRva, maSin kreditors SeuZliauari Tqvas xelSekrulebaze mxolod im SemTxvevaSi, Tuvaldebulebis darCenili nawilis Sesrulebam misTvis da-

132

karga interesi. ssk-is 427-e muxlis Sesabamisad, valdebu-lebiTi urTierToba wydeba kreditoris sasargeblod val-debulebis SesrulebiT (Sesruleba).

7.12. zemoxsenebul normaTa gaanalizebisa da saqmisfaqtobrivi garemoebebis urTierTSejerebis safuZ-velze, sasamarTlom dadgenilad miiCnia, rom ssk-is 427-emuxlis [valdebulebiTi urTierToba wydeba kreditorissasargeblod valdebulebis SesrulebiT (Sesruleba)] Se-sabamisad, mocemul SemTxvevaSi mxareTa Soris arsebuli,nasyidobis, xelSekrulebidan gamomdinare valdebulebe-bi Sewyvetilia Sesrulebis gamo, Sesabamisad, ar arsebob-da ssk-is 405-e muxliT gaTvaliswinebuli xelSekrulebi-dan gasvlis da 394-e muxlis safuZvelze _ zianis anazRa-urebis dakisrebis safuZveli.

8. mosarCelis saapelacio saCivris faqtobrivi dasamarTlebrivi safuZvlebi

8.1. gamyidvelma saapelacio wesiT gaasaCivra saqalaqosasamarTlos gadawyvetileba, misi gauqmeba da, axali ga-dawyvetilebis miRebiT, sarCelis dakmayofileba moiT-xova Semdegi garemoebebis gamo:

8.1.1. sasamarTlom gasaCivrebuli gadawyvetilebis3.2.6, 3.2.7, 3.2.8 punqtebiT arasworad miiCnia dadgenilad,rom a. b-s, d. d-es da i. n-es gamyidvelTan dadebuli xel-Sekrulebis Sesrulebis mizniT Caericxa Tanxa jamSi 909091 aSS dolari da es Tanxebi gadaeca apelants (mosarCe-les);

8.1.2. mopasuxeTa mtkiceba, rom gamyidvelis miTiTebiTmoxda darCenili Tanxebis gadaricxva a. b-is, d. d-is da i.n-is angariSebze, ar dasturdeba Tavad mopasuxeTa war-momadgenlis axsna-ganmartebiT, romelmac 20.05.2015w.sxdomaze miuTiTa, rom gamyidveli (apelanti) cxovreba-Si ar unaxavs da rom miwa Suamaval a-s SuamavlobiT (sauba-ria b-ze) SeiZina. misive ganmartebiT, man bankis TanamSro-mels ganucxada, rom a. gadascemda angariSis nomrebs, sa-dac unda Caricxuliyo Tanxa. SekiTxvaze, miuTiTa Tu araapelantma misTvis gadasaricxi Tanxa ra wesiT da visTvisunda Caricxuliyo, mopasuxeTa warmomadgenelma ganmarta,rom mas mosarCelesTan am sakiTxze ar usaubria;

8.1.3. mopasuxeTa versia, rom gamyidvelma miTiTeba mis-ca mopasuxeTa warmomadgenels (n-is), Tanxa Caricxuliyosxva pirebis angariSze, elementarul kritikas ver uZlebs.

133

mosarCelis axsna-ganmartebiT da i. n-is CvenebiT das-turdeba, rom isini 2014 wlamde ar icnobdnen da arc Sex-vedrian erTmaneTs. utyuarad dasturdeba aseve, rom gam-yidveli da d. d-ec ar icnobdnen erTmaneTs. gamyidveli(apelanti) icnobda da endoboda mxolod a. b-s da gaugeba-ria, Tu raSi dasWirdeboda mas misTvis ucnobi pirebis an-gariSze Tanxebis gadaricxva. Tavisuflad iyo SesaZlebe-li mTeli es Tanxa Caricxuliyo a. b-is angariSze;

8.1.4 gasaTvaliswinebelia isic, rom mopasuxeTa mierwardgenilia mxolod amonaweri maTi warmomadgenlis an-gariSidan da saqmeSi ar moipoveba amonaweri uSualod ze-moaRniSnuli pirebis sabanko angariSidan, romliTac da-dasturdeboda, marTla Caricxa Tu ara SesagebelSi miTi-Tebuli Tanxebi am pirTa angariSze da gamoCndeboda isic,Tu rodis gaitanes am pirebma Tanxa angariSidan an gaita-nes Tu ara saerTod;

8.1.5. apelantis miTiTebiT, Tanxis a. b-is, d. d-is da i. n-is angariSebze Caricxvis gaziarebis SemTxvevaSi, gasaT-valiswinebelia is garemoeba, rom Caricxuli Tanxa Sead-gens 934 091 aSS dolars, anu 25 000 aSS dolariT mets, vid-re ekuTvnoda gamyidvels. gaugebaria, ra mizeziT undagadaericxa mopasuxes 25 000 aSS dolariT meti Tanxa mo-sarCelisaTvis; saqmeSi ar moipoveba met-naklebad dama-jerebeli mtkicebuleba, romliTac dadasturdeboda,rom a. b-ma, d. d-em da i. n-em maT angariSze Caricxuli Tan-xebi gadasces apelants (gamyidvels). am ukanasknelis gan-martebiT, d-is da b-is Cvenebebis kritikulad gaanalize-bis SemTxvevaSi sasamarTlo darwmundeba, rom isini war-moadgenen cru mowmeebs, romelTa mimarTac apelantsprokuraturaSi saCivari ukve wardgenili aqvs. rac Seexe-ba i. n-es, man 20.05.2015w. sxdomaze daadastura, rom23.04.2014w. notariulad damowmebul gancxadebaSi miTi-Tebuli faqti Tanxis gadacemis Sesaxeb, simarTles ar Se-esabameboda da mas motyuebiT moawerines xeli werilo-biT dasturze;

8.1.6. gaugebaria sasamarTlo ra saxis mtkicebulebadmiiCnevs z. T-is werilobiT ganmartebas, radgan aRniSnu-li piri sxdomaze mowmed ar dakiTxula da ar yofila gaf-rTxilebuli cru Cvenebis Sedegebze;

8.1.7. mcdaria sasamarTlos msjeloba, rom gamyidvelismier 2014 wlis TebervalSi sarCelis aRZvra adasturebs

134

mopasuxis mier valdebulebis Sesrulebis faqts. apelan-tis miTiTebiT, garigebaTa organizatori da Suamavali iyoa. b-i, romelsac apelanti araerTxel Sexvda da mosTxova,uzrunveleyo mopasuxeTa mier Tanxis gadaxda. 2008-2013wlebSi a. b-i imyofeboda patimrobaSi da am periodSi mo-sarCelisTvis (gamyidvelisaTvis) SeuZlebeli iyo misi meS-veobiT pretenziis wardgena. amasTan, uZravi qonebis gam-yidveli am periodSi ganicdida zewolas da erideboda yo-velgvar aqtivobas, maT Soris sasamarTlosTvis an/da pro-kuraturisTvis mimarTvas, misTvis mopasuxeTa mier Tan-xis gadauxdelobis gamo. mxedvelobaSia misaRebi is faq-tic, rom pirdapiri kavSiri mopasuxeebTan ar arsebobdada apelants gaumarTla im TvalsazrisiT, rom man sabo-lood SeZlo mopasuxeebs dakavSireboda da sarCeli Cae-barebina maSindeli qarTveli advokatebis meSveobiT. gar-da amisa, apelantis ganmartebiT, igi imedovnebda, rom sa-sarCelo xandazmulobis vadebis gasvlamde moaxerxebdapretenziebis wardgenas mopasuxeebisaTvis;

8.1.8. b-is patimrobidan gaTavisuflebis Semdeg, am uka-nasknels maSinve daukavSirda apelanti da mosTxova, uz-runveleyo mopasuxeebisagan Tanxis darCenili nawilis ga-daxda, Tumca, b-ma mas ganucxada, rom kavSiri aRar hqondamopasuxeebTan da umjobesi iyo, miemarTa sasamarTlosT-vis. sasamarTloSi sarCeli Sevida 2014 wlis TebervalSi,xandazmulobis vada ar darRveula da dausabuTebelia sa-samarTlos msjeloba, rom mopasuxeebma Seasrules val-debuleba, rac imiT dasturdeboda, rom gamyidvels didixnis manZilze ar wauyenebia maTTvis pretenzia;

8.1.9. gamyidveli (apelanti) uars ambobs xelSekrule-baze (gadis xelSekrulebidan) da mopasuxeebi valdebuliarian, daubrunon miwis nakveTebi, Tumca, ssk-is 352-e mux-lis me-2 nawilis `b~ qvepunqtis Tanaxmad, naturiT dab-runebis nacvlad movales ekisreba fuladi anazRaureba,Tu: miRebul sagans mxare gamoiyenebs, gaasxvisebs, uf-lebrivad datvirTavs, gadaamuSavebs an gadaakeTebs. mo-cemul SemTxvevaSi miwis nakveTebi mopasuxeebma gamoiye-nes, uflebrivad datvirTes. kerZod, sadavo ar aris isgaremoebac, rom gamyidvelis mier gayiduli miwis nakve-Tebis gaerTianeba moxda sxva miwis nakveTebTan, dait-virTa ipoTekiT da gaformda winare nasyidobis xelSekru-leba. amdenad, SeuZlebelia uZravi qonebis naturiT dab-

135

runebis moTxovna da mopasuxeebs, sssk-is 352-e muxlis me-2 nawilis `b~ qvepunqtis Sesabamisad, unda daekisroT fu-ladi anazRaureba, rac 1 070 872 aSS dolars Seadgens;

8.1.10. ssk-is 352-e muxlis me-5 nawilis Tanaxmad, am mux-lis pirveli nawilidan gamomdinare valdebulebaTa dar-RvevisaTvis, 394-e muxlis mixedviT, kreditors SeuZliamoiTxovos zianis anazRaureba. amave muxlis Sesabamisad,movalis mier valdebulebis darRvevisas kreditors Se-uZlia moiTxovos amiT gamowveuli zianis anazRaureba. vi-naidan xelSekrulebidan mosarCelis gasvla xdeba mopa-suxeebis braliT, isini valdebuli arian, aanazRauronvaldebulebis SeusruleblobiT gamyidvelisaTvis (ape-lantisaTvis) miyenebuli ziani. pirdapiri ziani, rac uZ-ravi qonebis gamyidvels miadga xelSekrulebis Seusru-leblobiT aris gadauxdeli Tanxa _ 909 091 aSS dolari;

8.1.11. ssk-is 404-e muxlis Sesabamisad, kreditors uf-leba aqvs, moiTxovos vadis gadacilebiT gamowveuli zia-nis anazRaureba. amave kodeqsis 411-e muxlis Tanaxmad,ziani unda anazRaurdes ara mxolod faqtobrivad dam-dgari qonebrivi danaklisisTvis, aramed _ miuRebeli Se-mosavlisTvisac. miuReblad iTvleba Semosavali, romelicar miuRia pirs da romelsac igi miiRebda, valdebulebajerovnad rom Sesrulebuliyo. vinaidan mopasuxeebi 5welze metia ukanonod sargebloben misTvis gadasaxdeliTanxebiT, aRniSnuli ganxiluli unda iqnes, rogorc usa-fuZvlo gamdidrebis nairsaxeoba da mopasuxeebs, ssk-is981-e muxlis Sesabamisad, unda daekisroT procentis ga-daxda wliuri 12%-is odenobiT 2008 wlis 10 martidan ga-dawyvetilebis aRsrulebamde.

9. Tbilisis saapelacio sasamarTlos samoqalaqo saq-meTa palatis 2016 wlis 20 oqtombris ganCineba saqmis xe-laxla gansaxilvelad saqalaqo sasamarTloSi dabrunebisSesaxeb

9.1. Tbilisis saapelacio sasamarTlos samoqalaqo saq-meTa palatis 2016 wlis 20 oqtombris ganCinebiT gamyidve-lis saapelacio saCivari nawilobriv dakmayofilda, gauq-mda saqalaqo sasamarTlos gasaCivrebuli gadawyvetile-ba da saqme xelaxla gansaxilvelad daubrunda imave sasa-marTlos.

9.2. saapelacio sasamarTlom sssk-is 377-e muxlis sa-fuZvelze Seamowma gasaCivrebuli gadawyvetileba saape-

136

lacio saCivris farglebSi faqtobrivi da samarTlebriviTvalsazrisiT. samarTlebrivi TvalsazrisiT Semowmebi-sas ki ixelmZRvanela amave kodeqsis 393-e da 394-e muxle-bis moTxovnebiT. sssk-is 385-e muxlis pirveli nawilis à~qvepunqtis Tanaxmad, saapelacio sasamarTlo auqmebs ga-dawyvetilebas da saqmes ubrunebs pirveli instanciis sa-samarTlos xelaxla gansaxilvelad, Tu adgili aqvs amavekodeqsis 394-e muxliT gaTvaliswinebul SemTxvevebs. ssk-is 394-e muxlis è1~ punqti adgens, rom gadawyvetilebayovelTvis CaiTvleba kanonis darRveviT miRebulad, Tugadawyvetilebis dasabuTeba imdenad arasrulia, rom mi-si samarTlebrivi safuZvlianobis Semowmeba SeuZlebelia.

9.3. sasamarTlom sssk-is me-4 muxlze miuTiTa da gan-marta, rom saqmis ganmxilveli sasamarTlo SezRuduliamxaris mier miTiTebuli faqtobrivi garemoebebiT, rac Se-exeba samarTlis normebis gamoyenebas, sasamarTlo saqme-ze dadgenili faqtobrivi garemoebebis SefasebiT adgens,Tu ra samarTlebrivi urTierToba arsebobs mxareTa So-ris da am urTierTobis maregulirebeli samarTlebrivinormebis safuZvelze akmayofilebs an ar akmayofilebssarCels;

9.4. mxareTa Soris arsebuli urTierTobis Sefaseba sa-samarTlos kompetencias ganekuTvneba da mxaris mier aras-wori normatiuli safuZvlis miTiTeba ar SeiZleba gaxdessarCelis uaryofis safuZveli, Tumca, sasamarTlos dis-krecia imgvarad unda ganxorcieldes, rom mopasuxes arSeezRudos konkretul sakiTxze Sesageblis wardgenisuflebamosileba, raTa saqmeze gadawyvetileba miRebuliqnes SejibrebiTobis principis sruli realizaciis piro-bebSi.

9.5. SejibrebiTobis principi moicavs mxareTa saqmia-nobas saqmis faqtobrivi garemoebebisa da mtkicebulebe-bis sferoSi. moTxovnebis Tu Sesageblis faqtobrivi da-sabuTeba ekisrebaT Tavad mxareebs. mxareebma TviTon un-da gansazRvron, Tu romeli faqtebi unda daedos safuZ-vlad maT moTxovnebs da ra konkretul garemoebebs daem-yareba maTi Sesagebeli. mopasuxis Sesagebeli warmoadgenssarCelisgan Tavis dacvis saSualebas, romliTac mopasu-xe unda Seedavos mosarCelis moTxovnas, winaaRmdeg Sem-TxvevaSi, igi waagebs samarTlebriv davas. mopasuxis Sesa-gebeli unda iyos imdenad konkretuli, ramdenadac kon-

137

kretulia mosarCelis moxseneba. es niSnavs, rom mopasu-xem Tavisi Sesagebeli unda moargos da Seusabamos mosar-Celis moxsenebis abstraqciis xarisxsa da dones, xolo Se-sagebelSi mocemuli ganmartebebi sasamarTlom unda Sea-fasos sarCelTan da masSi miTiTebul faqtobriv garemo-ebebTan mimarTebiT. Tu mopasuxe daeTanxmeba mosarCelismier wardgenil faqtobriv garemoebebs, an Tu man aR-niSnulTan dakavSirebiT aranairi azri ar gamoTqva (racfaqtobrivad niSnavs, rom igi am garemoebebs ar xdis sada-vod), maSin sasamarTlos am garemoebebTan dakavSirebiTaRar sWirdeba mtkicebulebaTa Segroveba. udavo faq-tobrivi garemoebebi miiCneva namdvilad. im SemTxveveb-Si, rodesac mopasuxe arc edaveba da arc aRiarebs mosar-Celis ganmartebebs, sasamarTlos SeuZlia gamoiyenossssk-is 222-e muxliT gaTvaliswinebuli kiTxvis dasmis uf-leba. mas SeuZlia, hkiTxos mopasuxes misi poziciis Sesa-xeb ama Tu im garemoebis Taobaze. Tu mopasuxe ar reagi-rebs mosamarTlis SekiTxvebze, maSin misi dumili unda Ca-iTvalos aRniSnuli garemoebebis aRiarebad, vinaidan mxa-reebs evalebaT, srulad moaxsenon sasamarTlos saqmesTandakavSirebuli faqtobrivi garemoebebi da gamoxaton mo-sazreba procesualuri mowinaaRmdegis ganmartebebis Ta-obaze.

9.6. gansaxilvel SemTxvevaSi saapelacio sasamarTlommiiCnia, rom gasaCivrebuli gadawyvetilebiT davis gadaw-yvetisTvis mniSvnelobis mqone garemoebebi dadgeniliiyo sarCelSi miTiTebuli, SesagebliT dadasturebuli,Tu sadavod gamxdari faqtobrivi garemoebebisagan gan-sxvavebulad, rac SejibrebiTobisa da dispoziciurobisprincipis darRvevad unda Sefasebuliyo. amasTan, gasa-Civrebuli gadawyvetileba Seicavda winaaRmdegobrivmsjelobebs davis gadawyvetisTvis mniSvnelobis mqone ga-remoebebTan mimarTebaSi, kerZod:

9.6.1. mosarCelis ganmartebiT, 2008 wlis 6 marts massada mopasuxeTa warmomadgenels Soris daido uZravi qone-bis nasyidobis xelSekruleba, romliTac gamyidvelmamyidvelebs mihyida TbilisSi, sofel l-Si mdebare ori mi-wis nakveTi 1 070 872 aSS dolarad. xelSekrulebis gafor-mebis dRes, anu 2008 wlis 6 marts myidvelTa warmomadge-nelma mosarCeles Cauricxa Tanxis nawili, kerZod 161 781aSS dolari, xolo darCenili Tanxa 909 091 aSS dolari

138

dRemde gadaxdili ar aris (ix. sarCeli);9.6.2. sarCelisagan Tavis dasacavad wardgenil Sesage-

belSi mopasuxeebma miuTiTes, rom maTi warmomadgenlismier xelSekrulebis dadebis dResve gamyidvelisaTvis ga-daxdil iqna sruli Tanxa _ 1.070,872 aSS dolari, saidanac161 781 aSS dolari gadaxdilia sabanko gadaricxviT uSu-alod mosarCelis saxelze, xolo danarCeni Tanxa _ mo-sarCelis miTiTebiT a. b-is, i. n-isa da d. d-is sabanko anga-riSebze. Sesageblis Tanaxmad, gamyidvelis davalebiT mo-pasuxeTa warmomadgenelma sxva pirebis Cauricxa 934 091aSS dolari, saidanac 25 000 aSS dolari ekuTvnoda vinmev. g-s, xolo am Tanxidan darCenili Tanxa 909 091 aSS dola-ri, mosarCeles (apelants) ekuTvnoda, rac am ukanas-knelma miiRo kidec zemoxsenebuli pirebisgan. amasTan,amave SesagebelSi mopasuxeebi ganmartaven, rom gamyidve-lis (mosarCelis) mier xelSekrulebaSi miTiTebuli miwisRirebuleba aragonivrulad didia, vinaidan xelSekrule-bis gaformebis dros l-is teritoriaze miwis gasayidi fa-si Seadgenda 16-26 aSS dolars kvadratul metrze. mopa-suxeTa ganmartebiT, nasyidobis xelSekrulebaSi miwisfarTTan misi fasis Tanafardobam Seadgina 180 aSS dola-ri, rac aragonivrulia da gamowveulia sxvadasxva mize-ziT da apelantis angariSze Caricxuli Tanxa 161 781 aSSdolari sworedac savaraudod misi miwis Rirebulebas war-moadgens;

9.6.3. mopasuxeTa miTiTebiT, uZravi qonebis gamyidve-lis miwis mdebareoba ar iyo sakvanZo an didi mniSvnelo-bis, misi miwa ganapirasaa da am miwis yidva ar warmoadgendaimgvar saWiroebas, rom mopasuxeTa warmomadgenels mis Ti-Toeul kvadratul metrSi gadaexada 180 aSS dolari. mo-pasuxis mtkicebiT, Tavad gamyidveli iyo mTeli am miwisnakveTebis Sesyidvis operaciis organizatori da Tavisi-ve miTiTebiT Tavis miwebze nasyidobis xelSekrulebaSigaiwera myidvelebsa da gamyidvelebs Soris SeTanxmebu-li fasis misaRebi gansxvaveba (ix. Sesagebeli);

9.7. zemoxsenebuli garemoebebis Sefasebisas, saapela-cio sasamarTlom ganmarta, rom mopasuxe, erTi mxriv, mi-uTiTebda mosarCelis mier piradad da sxva pirebis meSve-obiT xelSekrulebaSi miTiTebuli nasyidobis Tanxis 1 070872 aSS dolaris srulad miRebaze, xolo meore mxriv, gan-martavda, rom nasyidobis xelSekrulebaSi miTiTebuli

139

Tanxa aragonivruli iyo da gamyidvelis angariSze Caric-xuli Tanxa 161 781 aSS dolari sworedac savaraudod misimiwis Rirebulebas warmoadgenda.

9.8. saapelacio sasamarTlom aRniSna: gasaTvaliswine-belia is garemoeba, rom mopasuxis mier SesagebelSi miTi-Tebuli zemoaRniSnuli winaaRmdegobrivi garemoebebiamave saxiTaa asaxuli gasaCivrebul gadawyvetilebaSi,kerZod, sasamarTlo dadgenilad miiCnevs, rom nasyido-bis xelSekrulebis Rirebuleba gansazRvrulia 1 070 872aSS dolariT, saidanac mosarCeles xelSekrulebis gafor-mebis dResve miRebuli aqvs 161 781 aSS dolari. aRniSnu-lis Semdgom saqalaqo sasamarTlo, erTi mxriv, msjelobsmopasuxeTa warmomadgenlis mier a. b-is, i. n-isa da d. d-isaTvis Caricxuli Tanxebis T. l-isaTvis gadacemis dama-dasturebel mtkicebulebebze, xolo meore mxriv, sasa-marTlo miuTiTebs l-is mimdebare teritoriaze mdebaremiwebis Rirebulebaze 2008 wlisaTvis da yuradRebas amax-vilebs mopasuxis mier SesagebelSi mocemul ganmarteba-ze imis Sesaxeb, rom xelSekrulebaSi miTiTebuli fasi ara-gonivrulia da gamyidvelis angariSze Caricxuli Tanxa _161 781 aSS dolari, sworedac savaraudod misi miwis Ri-rebulebas warmoadgenda. pirveli instanciis sasamarTlosabolood adgens, rom mxareTa Soris arsebuli nasyido-bis xelSekrulebidan gamomdinare valdebulebebi Sewyve-tilia Sesrulebis gamo, Tumca, gasaCivrebuli gadawyve-tilebidan calsaxad ar irkveva, ra moculobis saxel-Sekrulebo valdebulebis Sesruleba ekisrebodaT mopa-suxeebs mosarCelis (apelantis) mimarT; ra formiT da viswinaSe Sesrulda aRniSnuli valdebuleba da warmoad-gendnen Tu ara Sesrulebis mimRebi pirebi uflebamosilpirebs.

9.9. saapelacio sasamarTlom àdamianis uflebaTa daZiriTad TavisuflebaTa dacvis~ evropuli konvenciis me-6 muxlis pirveli punqtiT ganmtkicebuli samarTliani sa-samarTlos uflebaze miuTiTa, rac gulisxmobs sasamar-Tlos valdebulebas, daasabuTos mis mier miRebuli ga-dawyvetileba. procesis monawileebisaTvis, iseve, ro-gorc sazogadoebisaTvis, naTeli unda iyos gansjis is pro-cesi, romelic sasamarTlom gaiara konkretuli gadawyve-tilebis miRebamde. gadawyvetilebaSi asaxuli unda iyossasamarTlos mosazrebebi da samarTlebrivi daskvnebi,

140

romlebmac davis swored amgvari gadawyveta gamoiwvia. sa-samarTlo dacvis uflebis ganxorcieleba unda iyos sru-li, rac gulisxmobs ara mxolod yvelas SesaZleblobas,mimarTos sasamarTlos, aramed sasamarTlos valdebule-bas, gamoitanos samarTliani da dasabuTebuli gadawyve-tileba. es moTxovna miznad isaxavs mxaris mier gasaCivre-bis uflebis ganxorcielebis SesaZleblobis uzrunvel-yofasac, xolo dasaxuli miznis miRweva SesaZlebelia mxo-lod imgvarad, rom sasamarTlom swored mxaris SedavebissafuZvlianobis kvleviT, motivirebuli msjelobiT, da-arwmunos mxare misi poziciis marTebuloba-umarTebulo-baSi.

9.10. saapelacio sasamarTlos SefasebiT, gansaxilvelSemTxvevaSi gasaCivrebuli gadawyvetilebis dasabuTebaimdenad arasruli iyo, rom SeuZlebeli iyo misi samar-Tlebrivi safuZvlianobis Semowmeba. Sesabamisad, sasamar-Tlom daaskvna, rom gasaCivrebuli gadawyvetileba undagauqmebuliyo da saqme xelaxla gansaxilvelad unda dab-runeboda Tbilisis saqalaqo sasamarTlos samoqalaqo saq-meTa kolegias. saapelacio sasamarTlo amowmebs pirveliinstanciis sasamarTlos gadawyvetilebas faqtobrivi daiuridiuli TvalsazrisiT (sssk-is 377-e muxlis pirvelinawili). amdenad, gansaxilvel SemTxvevaSi saapelacio sa-samarTlos msjelobis sagans warmoadgenda pirveli in-stanciis sasamarTlos mier dadgenili is faqtobrivi ga-remoebebi, romlebzedac damyarebuli iyo gasaCivrebu-li gadawyvetileba, am garemoebebis damadasturebelimtkicebulebebi da maTi samarTlebrivi TvalsazrisiT Se-fasebis siswore. aRniSnuliT ki saapelacio sasamarTlomdaaskvna, rom misi uflebamosilebis farglebi ar moicav-da gadawyvetili davis xelaxali ganxilvis SesaZleblo-bas.

10. mopasuxeTa sakasacio saCivari10.1. saapelacio sasamarTlos ganCineba, romlis safuZ-

velzec saqme xelaxla gansaxilvelad daubrunda saqala-qo sasamarTlos, sakasacio wesiT gaasaCivres mopasuxeeb-ma, moiTxoves misi gauqmeba, mosarCelis saapelacio saCiv-ris uaryofa da saqalaqo sasamarTlos samoqalaqo saqme-Ta kolegiis 2015 wlis 28 ivlisis gadawyvetilebis ucvle-lad datoveba Semdeg pretenziebze dayrdnobiT:

10.1.1. saapelacio sasamarTlos ganCinebaSi miTiTebu-

141

li saproceso garemoebebi ar warmoadgens saqmis pirveliinstanciis sasamarTloSi xelaxla gansaxilvelad dabru-nebis safuZvels, radgan sssk-is 394-e muxlis pirveli na-wilis à~ qvepunqtis safuZvelze, aRniSnuli saapelaciosasamarTlos uflebaa da ara valdebuleba. amgvari mid-goma ewinaaRmdegeba racionaluri marTlmsajulebisa daprocesualuri ekonomiis principebs, ewinaaRmdegeba ssk-is 385-e muxlis me-2 nawiliT dadgenil kanonmdeblis ne-bas; am konteqstSi kasatori uTiTebs susg-ebze: #as-402-764-06, 23.06.2005w; #as-657-618-2012, 10.12.2012w; #as-1308-1234-2012, 04.02.2013w;

10.1.2. imis gaTvaliswinebiT, rom saqalaqo sasamarTlossafuZvlianad aqvs dadgenili (saqalaqo sasamarTlos ga-dawyvetilebis 3.2.6, 3.2.7 da 3.2.8 qvepunqtebi) da dasabu-Tebuli, rom mopasuxeebma valdebuleba Seasrules, erTimxriv, myidvelis angariSze da, meore mxriv, misive orga-nizebuli jgufis wevrTaTvis (a. b-i, d. d-e da i. n-e) anga-riSebze Tanxis daricxviT, dausabuTebelia gasaCivrebu-li ganCinebis msjeloba, rom pirveli instanciis sasamar-Tlos gadawyvetilebidan ar irkveoda, ra formiT da viswinaSe Sesrulda valdebuleba;

10.1.3. kasatori uTiTebs, rom daikiTxnen mowmeebi daxelSekrulebis dammowmebeli notariusi, romelTac daa-dastures, rom Tanxis mimRebi pirebi moqmedebdnen mo-sarCelesTan (gamyidvelTan) winaswari SeTanxmebis safuZ-velze da amisTvis gasamrjeloc miiRo TiToeulma maT-ganma mosarCelisagan. amitom, calsaxaa, rom gamyidvelmaxelSekrulebiT gaTvaliswinebuli Tanxa miiRo rogorcpiradad, ise _ sxva pirebis meSveobiT.

10.2. kasatori iTxovs axali gadawyvetilebis miRebiTsaapelacio sasamarTlos gasaCivrebuli ganCinebis gauq-mebas da pirveli instanciis sasamarTlos gadawyvetile-bis ucvlelad datovebas.

11. sakasacio samarTalwarmoebis etapi11.1. sakasacio sasamarTlos samoqalaqo saqmeTa pala-

tis 2017 wlis 5 maisis ganCinebiT sakasacio ganacxadi da-saSvebad iqna cnobili sssk-is 391-e muxlis me-5 nawilisà~ da è~ qvepunqtebis safuZvelze da imave ganCinebiTganisazRvra saqmis zepiri mosmena, mxareTa monawileobiT2017 wlis 12 ivliss.

11.2. sakasacio sasamarTloSi 2017 wlis 12 ivliss gamar-

142

Tul sxdomaze gamocxadebulma kasatorma (mopasuxem) mxa-ri dauWira mis mier warmodgenil sakasacio saCivars dayuradReba gaamaxvila Semdeg garemoebebze (ix. t.3, saka-sacio saCivari, damatebiTi mosazrebebi, kasatoris weri-lobiTi mosazreba uzenaes sasamarTlos da sakasacio sa-samarTlos 12.07.2017 sxdomis oqmi 12:33:20-dan 13:29:57-mde):

11.2.1. nasyidobis xelSekruleba dadebulia da myidve-lebma srulad gadauxades SeZenili uZravi qonebis Rire-buleba gamyidvels (mosarCeles), anu Seasrules xel-SekrulebiT nakisri valdebuleba nasyidobis xelSekru-lebis dadebis dResve. amas isic adasturebs, rom gam-yidvels ar usargeblia xelSekrulebis me-4 muxliT mini-Webuli uflebiT (ix. am ganCinebis me-3 punqti) da xel-Sekrulebis xelmoweridan samdRian vadaSi, Tanxis gada-uxdelobis motiviT, ar gasula xelSekrulebidan;

11.2.2. mosarCeles aRZruli aqvs ara pirveladi moT-xovna, anu igi ar iTxovs xelSekrulebiT nakisri valde-bulebis Sesrulebas _ Tanxis gadaxdas, aramed _ iTxovsxelSekrulebidan gasvlas ssk-is 352-e muxliT da miwisdabrunebas;

11.2.3 zemoxsenebul konteqstSi unda ganimartos 352-e muxlis me-3 nawili. rogorc doqtrina, ise germanuli sa-samarTlo praqtika calsaxad miuTiTebs, rom ssk-is 352.3muxlSi ar SeiZleba moiazrebodes mxolod saxelSekru-lebo fasi, Tu es fasi araadekvaturia nivTis realur Ri-rebulebasTan SedarebiT. amis Taobaze sakasacio saCivar-ze mxarem damatebiTi mosazrebebi werilobiT warmoadgi-na, sadac miuTiTa, rom mosarCele xelSekrulebidan gas-vlisa da naturiT dabrunebis sanacvlod fuladi anazRa-urebis moTxovnas afuZnebs ssk-is 352-e da 405-e muxlebze,kerZod, radgan gamyidveli gadis xelSekrulebidan, ssk-is 352-e muxlis meore nawilis `b~ qvepunqtis /2. naturiTdabrunebis nacvlad movales ekisreba fuladi anazRau-reba, Tu: ... b. miRebul sagans mxare gamoiyenebs, gaasxvi-sebs, uflebrivad datvirTavs, gadaamuSavebs an gadaake-Tebs/ dayrdnobiT ayenebs moTxovnas, xolo xelSekrule-baSi miTiTebuli (gayiduli) miwis nakveTebi gaerTianebu-lia sxva miwebTan da ipoTekiT aris datvirTuli, mopasu-xeebi (myidvelebi) valdebuli arian, fuladi anazRaure-ba gadauxadon mosarCeles (gamyidvels), rac 1 070 872 aSS

143

dolars Seadgens (ix. sarCelis me-5 gverdi da saapelaciosaCivris me-13 gverdi);

11.2.4 kasatorma gaimeora moTxovnis xandazmulobis na-wilSi SesagebelSi miTiTebuli pozicia (ix. am ganCinebis6.2 qvepunqti);

11.2.5. ssk-is 352-e muxlis me-2 nawilis `b~ qvepunqtisgamoyenebis SemTxvevaSi gaumarTlebelia, rom fuladianazRaureba saxelSekrulebo fasis mixedviT moxdes, TuaRniSnuli araTanazomieria nivTis realur Rirebulebas-Tan mimarTebiT. xelSekrulebidan gasvlis dros, Rire-bulebis anazRaurebis mizania ara piris dasja nivTis ga-dakeTebis/ipoTekiT datvirTvis gamo, aramed _ uflebri-vad datvirTuli nivTis Rirebulebis anazRaurebiT immdgomareobasTan miaxloeba, romelic iarsebebda mxare-ebs Sesrulebebi saerTod rom ar gaecvalaT _ am dros gam-yidvels (mosarCeles) eqneboda 89 205 aSS dolaris Rire-bulebis miwa (ix. Munchener Kommentar zum BGB Rn, 45 7, Auflage2016) da swored es Rirebuleba unda aunazRaurdes mosar-Celes. ssk-is 352-e muxlis Sesabamisi punqtebis danawese-bis Teleologiuri daviwroeba (reduqcia) unda moxdes dagadaxdili safasuris nacvlad, nivTis obieqtur Rirebu-lebaze orientireba (ix. ssk-is komentari 351-e muxlze,gverdi 9, veli 17 _ www.gccc.ge, aseve _ Faust JuS 2009, 271 [273f.]; Staudinger/Kaiser Rn. 160 ff.; aA Gsell LMK 2009, 276149; zu, par.346S.2 aF ferner Larenz 1 par 26 a; aA Leser S. 170);

11.2.6. gansaxilvel SemTxvevaSi nasyidobis sagnis Ri-rebuleba, romelic srulad gadaixada mopasuxem oTxi pi-risaTvis gadaxdis gziT da saqmeSi wardgenili eqspertisdaskvna miwebis RirebulebasTan dakavSirebiT, rac mosar-Celes sadavod ar gauxdia, adasturebs, rom gamyidvelismier gasxvisebuli miwis Rirebuleba ar aRemateboda 15aSS dolars erT kv.m-ze (ix. eqspertis daskvna, romelicsaqalaqo sasamarTloSia wardgenili 2015 wlis 3 aprils);

11.2.7. imis gaTvaliswinebiT, rom mosarCele iTxovsxelSekrulebidan gasvlas da radganac mas surs fuladianazRaurebis miReba naturiT anazRaurebis (miwis nakve-Tebis dabrunebis) sanacvlod, mas unda aunazRaurdes isRirebuleba, rac warmoadgens/warmoadgenda am nivTis obi-eqtur Rirebulebas anu gamyidvelis miwis Rirebulebaa89 205 aSS dolari, xolo piradad mis angariSze mopasuxe-Ta warmomadgenlis mier gadaricxuli 161 781 aSS dolari

144

ukve aRemateba miwis nakveTebis realur Rirebulebas.11.2.8 zemoxsenebuli sakiTxebi unda Seefasebina saa-

pelacio sasamarTlos, rac ar momxdara da aRniSnuliTdasturdeba, rom gasaCivrebuli ganCineba dausabuTebe-li da usafuZvloa. saapelacio sasamarTlos romc daed-gina, rom pirveli instanciis sasamarTlom imsjela araxelSekrulebidan gasvlis Sedegad Sesabamisi samar-Tlebrivi Sedegebis dadgomaze, aramed yuradReba gaamax-vila saxelSekrulebo pirvelad moTxovnaze (rac prin-cipSi mxares ar mouTxovia), saapelacio sasamarTlos au-cileblad unda ganexila sakiTxi, rom Tu qvemdgomi in-stanciis sasamarTlo imsjelebda mosarCelis meoradimoTxovnis dakmayofilebis Sedegebze, eqneboda Tu aramas sarCelis dakmayofilebis SesaZlebloba.

11.3. mosarCelis meore moTxovna miuRebeli Semosav-lis gamo zianis anazRaurebis Taobaze samarTlebrivaddausabuTebelia, radgan ssk-is 352-e muxlis me-3 nawilispecialuri da gancalkevebuli mowesrigebaa, romelicpirdapir miuTiTebs, Tu ra Sedegebi dgeba im SemTxveva-Si, Tuki naturiT dabruneba SeuZlebelia. amdenad, ssk-is411-e muxlis gamoyeneba miuRebeli Semosavlis saxiT zia-nis anazRaurebisaTvis 352.3 muxlTan mimarTebiT dauSve-belia.

11.3.1. mocemul SemTxvevaSi ar arsebobs sssk-is 412-emuxliT dadgenili safuZvlebi saqmis xelaxla gansaxil-velad dasabruneblad saapelacio sasamarTloSi da saka-sacio sasamarTlo TviTonvea uflebamosili, miiRos ga-dawyvetileba.

12. kasatoris mowinaaRmdegem (mosarCelem) sakasaciosasamarTlos zepir sxdomaze ganmarta, rom sakasacio moT-xovna iyo dausabuTebeli da ar unda dakmayofilebuliyoSemdegi garemoebebis gamo (ix. sakasacio Sesagebeli, mxa-ris ganmarteba sakasacio sasamarTloSi _ 12.07.2017w sxdo-mis oqmi _ 14:04:34-dan 14:40:02-mde);

12.1. cxadia, sabolood uzenaesma sasamarTlom unda ga-dawyvitos, Tumca, kasatoris moTxovna am saxiT dausabu-Tebelia, amasTan, imis gaTvaliswinebiT, rom pirveli in-stanciis sasamarTlom arasworad daadgina faqtebi, kasa-toris procesualuri mowinaaRmdegisaTvis arsebiTi mniS-vneloba ar aqvs, Tu vin daadgens faqtebs _ pirveli Tumeore instanciis sasamarTlo; Tumca, eTanxmeba saapela-

145

cio sasamarTlos ganCinebas, romliTac saqme daubrundapirveli instanciis sasamarTlos xelaxla gansaxilvelad;

12.2. mopasuxem araerTxel aRniSna, rom mis mimarT mo-sarCeles amdeni xnis manZilze ar gamouTqvams pretenzia.realurad SeuZlebeli iyo am pirebTan kontaqtze gasvla,n-is mxaresTan erTaderTi sakontaqo piri _ a. b-i dapatim-rebuli iyo 2013 wlamde. Tavis mxriv, b-i xelSekrulebisxelmoweramde erTi Tvis gacnobili hyavda TviTon mosar-Celes. rac Seexeba sakiTxs, iyo Tu ara SesaZlebeli sarCe-lis aRZvra, saqmeSia mtkicebulebebebi, rom 2014 wels mo-sarCelem orjer `di-eiC-elis~ /DHL/ meSveobiT gaugzavnasarCeli mopasuxeebs, Tumca, erTxel dabrunda gzavniliimis gamo, rom miTiTebuli misamarTebi ar arsebobda, xo-lo meored marTalia Cabarda, magram mokle xanSi israe-lidan miiRes Setyobineba, rom is pirebi, visac CabardaTkorespondencia, ar iyvnen mopasuxeebi, Semdeg, SemTxve-viT moxerxda saqarTveloSi mopasuxeTa yofil advokat-Tan dakavSireba;

12.3. mosarCele mopasuxeebs a. b-is meSveobiT sTxovdaTanxis gadaxdas. b-i, romelic faqtiurad mopasuxeebTansakontaqto piri iyo, acxadebda, rom Tanxas gadaixdidamopasuxe, radgan is sxva miwebsac yidulobda da ara mxo-lod im nakveTebs, razedac mosarCelesTan gaaforma xel-Sekruleba;

12.4. kasatoris mowinaaRmdege mxarem miuTiTa pirveliinstanciis sasamarTlos sxdomis oqmebze da gaakritikarogorc mopasuxeTa pozicia, ise _ sasamarTlos daskvne-bi, romelsac ar daudgenia xelSekrulebis safuZvelzera iyo Sesasrulebeli da ra Sesrulda;

12.5. sakasacio sasamarTlos SekiTxvis pasuxad, kasato-ris mowinaaRmdegem ganmarta, rom SeuZlebeli iyo mosar-Celis mier pirveladi moTxovnis wardgena, radgan nasyi-dobis xelSekrulebiT gayiduli miwis nakveTebi gaerTia-nebulia sxva nakveTebTan da masze registrirebulia nas-yidobis winare xelSekruleba sajaro reestrSi (ix. aseve,am ganCinebis 5.5 qvepunqti);

12.6. kasatoris mowinaaRmdegem dausabuTeblad miiC-nia mopasuxeTa pozicia, rom sasamarTlom ixelmZRvane-los ara saxelSekrulebo fasiT, aramed _ nivTis realuriRirebulebiT, rogorc es ì-is~ daskvnaSia asaxuli, rome-lic mopasuxem sasamarTloSi mimdinare samarTalwarmoe-

146

bisaTvis moamzadebina. mosarCeles miaCnia, rom mopasu-xeebs Sesasrulebeli aqvT valdebuleba da unda gadaixa-don 1 070 872 aSS dolari, xolo mopasuxeebs ra miaCniaT,anu ramdeni aqvT gadasaxdeli, gaugebaria, es ar daudge-nia pirveli instanciis sasamarTlos da nebismier SemTxve-vaSi gamosakvlevia, pirveli an meore instanciis sasamar-TloSi samarTalwarmoebis etapze;

12.7. sasarCelo moTxovnis (ix. am ganCinebis 5.1.1-5.1.3qvepunqtebi) samarTlebriv safuZvlebTan dakavSirebiT,mxaris warmomadgenelma ganmarta, rom man 5.1.1 qvepunqtSimiTiTebuli moTxovna daafuZna ssk-is 352-e, 405-e mux-lebs, imis gaTvaliswinebiT, rom gamyidveli (mosarCele)gadis xelSekrulebidan, xolo mopasuxeebi valdebuliarian, daabrunon miwis nakveTebi, Tumca, am ukanaskneleb-ma nivTi gamoiyenes, sxva nakveTebTan gaaerTianes, uf-lebrivad datvirTes da nasyidobac dades masze, rac sa-davo ar aris; ssk-is 352.2 muxlis `b~ qvepunqtis safuZ-velze gadacemulis naturiT dabruneba SeuZlebelia, Se-sabamisad, Sesruleba unda moxdes xelSekrulebaSi miTi-Tebuli Tanxis _ 1 070 872 aSS dolaris odenobiT; 5.1.2 qve-punqtSi miTiTebul sasarCelo moTxovnasTan dakavSire-biT mxarem ganmarta, rom moTxovnilia 909 091 aSS dola-ris ekvivalentis gadaxda erovnul valutaSi, rac realu-rad aris saxelSekrulebo fassa da mopasuxeTa mier mo-sarCelis pirad angariSze Caricxul Tanxebs Soris sxvao-ba (1 070 872 _ 161 781) da emyareba ssk-is 352.5 nawils àmmuxlis pirveli nawilidan gamomdinare valdebulebaTadarRvevisaTvis 394-e muxlis mixedviT kreditors SeuZ-lia moiTxovos zianis anazRaureba~; am ganCinebis 5.1.3 qve-punqtSi miTiTebuli sasarCelo moTxovnis samarTlebrivsafuZvlad mosarCele uTiTebs 404-e `kreditors ufle-ba aqvs moiTxovos vadis gadacilebiT gamowveuli zianisanazRaureba~ da 414-e muxlebze `zianis odenobis gan-sazRvrisas mxedvelobaSia misaRebi is interesi, romelickreditors hqonda valdebulebis jerovani SesrulebismimarT. zianis odenobis dasadgenad gaTvaliswinebul un-da iqnes xelSekrulebis Sesrulebis dro da adgili~.

12.8. kasatoris mowinaaRmdege (mosarCele) yuradRebasamaxvilebs Sesageblis saprocesosamarTlebriv mniSvne-lobaze, radgan konkretul saproceso etapze, mopasuxe-ebs eZlevaT sakuTari poziciis wardgenis SesaZlebloba.

147

mocemul SemTxvevaSi mopasuxeTa SesagebelSi miTiTebu-lia (me-4 faqtobrivi garemoeba), rom mopasuxeebma mosar-Celis miTiTebiT gadauricxes sxva pirebs sabanko angari-Sebze xelSekrulebiT gaTvaliswinebuli Tanxebi, xolosasamarTlo sxdomaze m. z. n-im, romelic iyo erTaderTisakontaqto piri mopasuxeebTan komunikaciis dros, ara-erTxel aRniSna, rom mas mosarCele cxovrebaSi TvaliTar unaxavs; am viTarebaSi gaugebaria, rogor miscemda mi-TiTebas gamyidveli myidvelebis warmomadgenels saxel-Sekrulebo Tanxis konkretuli pirebis sabanko angariSeb-ze gadaricxvis Taobaze; dakonkretebis mizniT, mosarCe-lis warmomadgenlis mier dasmuli araerTi kiTxvis miu-xedavad, myidvelTa warmomadgenelma (n-im) samjer miu-TiTa swored im faqtze, rom igi ar icnobda gamyidvels darogor eqneboda masTan kontaqti. mxaris winaaRmdegob-riv poziciaze sasamarTlo sxdomis wuTebis moniSvniT aqvsmiTiTebuli mosarCeles saapelacio saCivarSi (ix. saape-lacio saCivari);

12.9. mopasuxeTa warmomadgeneli _ n-i sxva garigebebi-Tac iyo dakavSirebuli b-Tan, aseve _ n-esTan da d-esTa-nac. gamyidveli arc erT pirs ar icnobs, garda b-isa, rome-lic xelSekrulebis xelmoweramde erTi TviT adre gaic-no. gamosakvlevi da Sesajerebelia saqmeSi arsebuli e.w.gadaricxvebi da mowmeTa ganmartebebi. saqmis masalebSiamxolod n-is mier gadaricxuli Tanxebis Sesaxeb gadaxde-bi, xolo mosarCelis garda, sami sxva pirisaTvis _ b-is, d-isa da n-isaTvis Tanxebis Caricxvis Sesaxeb am ukanas-knelTa sabanko angariSebidan amonaweri saqmeSi ar ariswardgenili, rac mopasuxeTa mtkicebis tvirTia. is sakiT-xi, rom am sami pirisaTvis maRali albaTobiT CaricxuliTanxa (rac vin daavala gaugebaria) mosarCelem miiRo, armtkicdeba, amasTan, mopasuxeTa mier gadaricxuli Tanxe-bi Tu dajamdeba, mainc 25 000 aSS dolariT metia gadaxdi-li, rac damatebiT amtkicebs mosarCelis pozicias, rommisi miTiTeba ar yofila myidvelebisadmi (mopasuxeebi-sadmi) Tanxebis sxvadasxva pirebisaTvis Caricxvaze;

12.10. qvemdgom sasamarTloSi mosarCelis warmomad-genlis araerTi kiTxvis pasuxad mopasuxeTa warmomadge-nelma _ n-im ganmarta, rom rasac a. (b-i) metyoda, imas vric-xavdio; gaurkvevelia, ratom gaanawila myidvelis warmo-madgenelma _ n-im Tanxebi sxvadasxva pirebze da Cauricxa

148

ramdenime pirs, aqedan _ 404 000 aSS dolari _ sakuTarmZRols d-es, Tu mas endoboda, mTliani Tanxa masve ra-tom ar Cauricxa;

12.11. mopasuxeTa mtkicebis sawinaaRmdegod, mosarCe-lis warmomadgenelma ganmarta, rom yvela xelSekrule-bas erTvoda ivriTze naTargmni xelSekrulebebi, sadacweria, rom 516 000 aSS dolari unda gadauxados gam-yidvels, Tumca, unda Sefasdes, ratom gadauricxa myid-velma amxela Tanxa sxvadasxva pirebs, romelic aRemate-boda 516 000 aSS dolars, eWvi ratom ar gauCnda. savarau-dod, b-i, d-e da n-e dakavSirebuli pirebi iyvnen, ris ga-moc mosarCelem crumowmeobazec aRZra saCivari proku-raturaSi 2015 wels da savaraudod TaRliTobis faqtzemimdinareobs mokvleva, Tumca, es mtkicebuleba ar aqvskasatoris mowinaaRmdeges, radgan saapelacio sasamar-Tlom ar daakmayofila mosarCelis Suamdgomloba sisxlissamarTlis saqmis masalebis gamoTxovis Taobaze;

12.12. mosarCelis warmomadgenlis ganmartebiT, mem-kvidreobiT miRebuli qoneba gayida gamyidvelma, orwli-ani vadac iyo gasuli da sagadasaxado dabegvris reJimicar exeboda, amitom gaugebaria mopasuxeTa mtkiceba, romTanxis piradad miReba ar surda gamyidvels, amasTan, xel-Sekruleba sajaro reestrSi iyo daregistrirebuli daxelmisawvdomi nebismieri pirisaTvis, amitom dausabuTe-belia mopasuxeTa mosazreba da gaurkvevelia, risTvis un-da aeridebina Tavi mosarCeles;

12.13. kasatoris mowinaaRmdegis (mosarCelis) ganmarte-bis sapasuxod, kasatoris (mopasuxis) warmomadgenelebmaganmartes, rom mosarCeles (gamyidvels) b-Tan kavSirihqonda (am ukanasknelis sapatimro dawesebulebaSi yof-nis periodSic ki, radgan sxdomaze b-ma ganmarta, rom mascixeSi daukavSirda gamyidveli, xolo am ukanasknels esar uaruyvia); b-i daaxloebuli iyo gamyidvelTan da arawerilobiTi mindobilobiT, aramed, faqtobrivad warmo-adgenda mas. mopasuxeTa warmomadgenelma _ n-im gamyidve-lis miTiTebiT gadaixada Tanxebi, gadauricxa ramdenimepirs, garda uSualod gamyidvelisaTvis gadaricxuli Tan-xisa, riTac srulad Seasrula nasyidobis xelSekrulebiTnakisri valdebuleba;

12.13.1. mosarCele zianis anazRaurebis saxiT iTxovs 909091 aSS dolars; xelSekrulebidan gasvla romc daud-

149

gindes mosarCeles, man kargad icis, rom miiRebs ara sa-xelSekrulebo, aramed _ nivTis Sesabamis Rirebulebas,rac dRes gacilebiT naklebia; sakasacio sasamarTlos gan-marteba mniSvnelovani iqneba ssk-is 411-e muxlis Taoba-ze, romelic SeuZlebeli da dauSvebelia gamoyenebuliiqnes 352.3 muxlTan mimarTebiT. mosarCelis ziani ver iq-neba saxelSekrulebo fasi, radgan 352.3 muxlis mizani arispiris dacva da ara dasja (ix. zemoT 11.3 qvepunqti).

samotivacio nawili:sakasacio sasamarTlo saqmis Seswavlis, mxareTa gan-

martebebis zepir sxdomaze mosmenis, saqmeSi ganTavsebu-li mtkicebulebebis gaanalizebisa da sakasacio saCivrisiuridiuli dasabuTebulobis arsebiTad ganxilvis gziTSemowmebis Sedegad miiCnevs, rom sakasacio ganacxadi na-wilobriv unda dakmayofildes da saqme saapelacio saCiv-ris ganxilvis etapidan unda daubrundes saapelacio sa-samarTlos Semdegi motivaciiT:

13. sssk-is 404-e muxlis pirveli nawiliT, sakasacio sa-samarTlo gadawyvetilebas amowmebs sakasacio saCivrisfarglebSi, amave kodeqsis 407-e muxlis pirveli nawiliT,sakasacio sasamarTlo imsjelebs mxaris mxolod im axsna-ganmartebaze, romelic asaxulia sasamarTlo gadawyveti-lebebSi da sxdomis oqmebSi. garda amisa, SeiZleba mxedve-lobaSi iqnes miRebuli am kodeqsis 396-e muxlis pirvelinawilis `v~ qvepunqtSi miTiTebuli faqtebi; amave muxlisme-2 nawilis Tanaxmad, saapelacio sasamarTlos mier dam-tkicebulad cnobili faqtobrivi garemoebebi savalde-buloa sakasacio sasamarTlosaTvis, Tu wamoyenebuli araris dasaSvebi da dasabuTebuli pretenzia (Sedaveba); sa-samarTlos miaCnia, rom kasatoris mier wamoyenebul pre-tenziaTa nawili dasabuTebulia.

14. sakasacio sasamarTlo, uwinaresad, yuradRebas ga-amaxvilebs, rom kasatoris moTxovna, rom sakasacio samar-Talwarmoebis etapzeve iqnes miRebuli gadawyvetileba,romliTac gauqmdeba saapelacio sasamarTlos gasaCivre-buli ganCineba pirveli instanciis sasamarTlosaTvis saq-mis dabrunebis Sesaxeb da ZalaSi darCeba saqalaqo sasa-marTlos gadawyvetileba, procesualurad dausabuTebe-lia. sakasacio sasamarTlos saproceso kanonmdeblobiTminiWebuli uflebamosilebis farglebSi ar aqvs SesaZ-

150

lebloba imsjelos, daadginos da Seafasos axali garemo-ebebi da faqtebi. saapelacio sasamarTlos mier dadgeni-li faqtebi savaldebuloa sakasacio sasamarTlosaTvis sa-boloo instanciis sasamarTloSi samarTalwarmoebis etap-ze (sssk-is 404-e da 407-e muxlebi), romelic uflebamosi-lia, ukve dadgenil faqtebs misces samarTlebrivi Sefa-seba, maT Soris, ar gaiziaros qvemdgomi sasamarTlos iu-ridiuli dasabuTeba da gansxvavebul samarTlebriv mo-tivacias daafuZnos gadawyvetileba. sakasacio sasamar-Tlo araerT gadawyvetilebaSi/ganCinebaSi uTiTebs, rom`sasamarTlos upirvelesi amocanaa, daadginos, Tu ras iT-xovs mosarCele mopasuxisagan da ris safuZvelze, anu ro-mel faqtobriv garemoebebze amyarebs Tavis moTxovnas.sasamarTlom mxaris mier miTiTebuli moTxovnis far-glebSi unda moZebnos is samarTlebrivi norma (normebi),romelic im Sedegs iTvaliswinebs, risi miRwevac mxaressurs. amasTan, moTxovnis samarTlebriv safuZvlad ganxi-luli norma (an normebi) Seicavs im aRwerilobas (faq-tobriv Semadgenlobas), romlis Semowmebac sasamarTlosprerogativaa da romelic unda ganxorcieldes logiku-ri meTodebis gamoyenebis gziT, anu sasamarTlom unda da-adginos, normaSi moyvanili abstraqtuli aRweriloba ram-denad Seesabameba konkretul cxovrebiseul situaciasda gamoitanos Sesabamisi daskvnebi. is mxare, romelsacaqvs moTxovna meore mxarisadmi, sul mcire, unda uTiTeb-des im faqtobriv Semadgenlobaze, romelsac samarTlisnorma gvTavazobs. aqedan gamomdinare, SegviZlia davas-kvnaT, rom moTxovnis samarTlebrivi safuZvlis romeli-me faqtobrivi wanamZRvris (samarTlebrivi winapirobis)ararseboba gamoricxavs mxarisaTvis sasurveli samar-Tlebrivi Sedegis dadgomas (ix. saqarTvelos uzenaesi sa-samarTlos didi palatis 2017 wlis 2 martis gadawyveti-leba, saqme #as-664-635-2016, punqti 187).

15. gansaxilvel SemTxvevaSi saapelacio sasamarTlomgamoiyena sssk-is 385-e muxliT miniWebuli ufleba da saq-me xelaxla gansaxilvelad daubruna qvemdgom sasamar-Tlos im dasabuTebiT, rom gasaCivrebuli gadawyvetile-biT davis gadasawyvetad mniSvnelobis mqone garemoebebidadgenilia sarCelSi miTiTebuli, SesagebliT dadastu-rebuli, Tu sadavod gamxdari faqtobrivi garemoebebisa-gan gansxvavebulad, rac SejibrebiTobisa da dispozici-

151

urobis principebis darRvevad Seafasa da am konteqstSiadamianis uflebaTa da ZiriTad TavisuflebaTa dacvis ev-ropuli konvenciis me-6 muxliT dadgenil samarTliani sa-samarTlos uflebaze miuTiTa.

16. mopasuxeTa sakasacio moTxovna imgvarad aris Camo-yalibebuli, rom meore instanciis samarTalwarmoebis ga-motovebiT, moTxovnilia saqalaqo sasamarTlos gadawyve-tilebis ZalaSi datoveba, amasTan, kasatori TviTonveuTiTebs, rom ar aris gamokvleuli saqmisaTvis mniSvne-lobis mqone faqtobrivi garemoebebi.

17. sakasacio sasamarTloSi saqmis zepiri mosmenisdros mxareTa mier gamoTqmuli poziciebi da argumente-bi asaxulia winamdebare ganCinebaSi (ix.11.2-12.13 qvepun-qtebi). saapelacio sasamarTlos, romelsac sssk-is 385-emuxlis pirvel nawilSi miTiTebuli safuZvlebis arsebo-bis SemTxvevaSi SeuZlia saqme xelaxla gansaxilvelad da-ubrunos qvemdgomi instanciis sasamarTlos, amave nor-mis meore nawiliT SeuZlia ar gadaagzavnos saqme da Tvi-Tonve miiRos gadawyvetileba. sssk-is 385.1 muxlis safuZ-velze `saqmis pirveli instanciis sasamarTlosaTvis ukandabruneba, iseve, rogorc saqmeze axali gadawyvetilebismiReba, saapelacio sasamarTlos uflebaa da ara valde-buleba. miuxedavad amisa, aRniSnuli ar gulisxmobs saa-pelacio sasamarTlos SeuzRudaobas, nebismieri dausa-buTebeli gadawyvetilebis SemTxvevaSi, qvemdgomi in-stanciis sasamarTlos xelaxla gansaxilvelad daubru-nos saqme. aseTi midgoma ewinaaRmdegeba racionaluri mar-Tlmsajulebisa da procesualuri ekonomiis principebs,samoqalaqo saproceso kodeqsis 385-e muxlis me-2 nawi-lis namdvil azrs, riTac mocemul SemTxvevaSi SeboWiliasaapelacio sasamarTlo, amitom, saapelacio sasamarTlom,romelic samoqalaqo saproceso kodeqsis Tanaxmad, ase-ve, saqmis arsebiTad ganmxilveli sasamarTloa, pirveliinstanciis sasamarTlos saqme ukan unda daubrunos mxo-lod gamonaklis SemTxvevebSi, rodesac mas Tavad realu-rad gauWirdeba faqtobrivi garemoebebis dadgena an kon-kretuli saqmis garemoebebis gaTvaliswinebiT, marTlacmizanSewonilia saqmis ukan dabruneba~... (ix. susg #-as-471-450-2015, 30.10.2015w; Sdr. susg-ebs: #as-973-922-2015,16.02.2016w; #as-151-147-2016, 19.04.2016w; #as-1132-1088-2016, 17.02.2017w.).

152

18. gansaxilvel SemTxvevaSi imis gaTvaliswinebiT, romsakasacio sasamarTlos gadawyvetilebiT saqme saapela-cio saCivris ganxilvis etapidan unda daubrundes saape-lacio sasamarTlos, sakasacio sasamarTlos samarTlebri-vi Sefasebebi, romlis farglebSic unda moxdes saapela-cio saCivris xelaxla ganxilva (sssk-is 412-e muxli) ram-denime ZiriTad aspeqts Seexeba, radgan saapelacio sasa-marTlo, rogorc zemoT ukve aRiniSna, pirveli instanci-is sasamarTlos msgavsad, saqmis arsebiTad ganxilveli,anu faqtebis damdgeni sasamarTloa, rac imas niSnavs, romsaapelacio samarTalwarmoebis etapze, sarCelsa da mispasuxad wardgenil SesagebelSi miTiTebuli faqtobrivigaremoebebis safuZvelze da maT dasadastureblad sasa-marTlosaTvis wardgenili mtkicebulebebis mixedviT, Se-saZlebelia damatebiT iqnes gamokvleuli da dadgeniliiseTi faqtebi, rac gasaCivrebul gadawyvetilebaSi wina-aRmdegobrivad da urTierTgamomricxavad miiCnia saape-lacio sasamarTlom. amasTan, saapelacio samarTalwarmo-ebis etapze saproceso kanonmdeblobiT dadgenili uf-lebamosileba axali garemoebebis gamokvlevisa da dad-genis Taobaze saqmis droul da efeqtian ganxilvasac ukav-Sirdeba, marTlmsajulebis ganxorcielebisas saprocesoekonomiis standartis dacviT.

19. sakasacio sasamarTlom zemoxsenebul punqtSi sssk-is 187-e da 201-e muxlebis safuZvelze wardgenil sarCelsada Sesagebelze yuradReba gaamaxvila imis gamosakveTad,rom daculia mxareTa SejibrebiTobisa da dispoziciuro-bis principebi da isini kanonis winaSe araTanaswori mop-yrobis safrTxis winaSe ar aRmoCndebian saapelacio sasa-marTlos mier saqmis saapelacio saCivris xelaxla gan-xilvis etapidan, radgan TiToeul maTgans Sesrulebuliaqvs kuTvnili saproceso valdebuleba sarCelisa da Se-sageblis (TandarTuli mtkicebulebebiT) wardgenis gziT,gavlili aqvs saqmis mosamzadebeli saproceso etapi, ro-melic aseve mniSvnelovania mxareTaTvis sakuTari pozi-ciis dasamtkiceblad axali, damatebiTi mtkicebulebe-bis wardgenis konteqstSi, rac samarTlian sasamarTlozeTiToeuli mxaris uflebis ganuyofeli Semadgenelia. Se-sabamisad, samarTalwarmoebis pirvel etapze wardgeniliganmartebebisa da mtkicebulebebis Semdeg, Tuki aR-moCndeba iseTi garemoebebi da mtkicebulebebi, romel-

153

Ta miTiTeba an mopoveba mxareebs manamde ar SeeZloT sa-patio mizeziT, sssk-is 380-e muxli, saapelacio samar-Talwarmoebis etapze, aseTi axali faqtebisa da mtkice-bulebebis wardgenis SesaZleblobasac Tanabrad aniWebsmxareebs.

20. saapelacio saCivris xelaxla ganxilvis etapidan sa-apelacio sasamarTlom yuradReba unda gaamaxvilos, Tura saxis samarTlebrivi urTierTobaa mxareTa Soris, ra-Ta Semowmdes sarCelis stadia, anu sarCelSi miTiTebulifaqtebis mixedviT, ra moTxovnas ayenebs mosarCele mo-pasuxeTa winaaRmdeg. imis gaTvaliswinebiT, Tu mosarCe-lis moTxovnas gaaCnia samarTlebrivi safuZveli da igiganxorcielebadi iqneba, mopasuxis stadiaze SemowmdebaSesagebeli sssk-is 201-e muxlis Sesabamisad.

20.1. saqmeSi wardgenilia 2008 wlis 6 martis xelSekru-leba (ix. am ganCinebis pirveli punqti), romelic uZraviqonebis nasyidobis xelSekrulebad Seafasa saqalaqo sa-samarTlom, xolo mosarCele Tavis moTxovnas afuZnebsssk-is 352-e muxlis meore nawilis `b~ qvepunqts da misimosazrebiT, imis gaTvaliswinebiT, rom SeuZlebelia gas-xvisebuli uZravi qonebis naturiT dabruneba, gamyidve-li myidvelTa braliT gadis xelSekrulebidan, xolo amukanasknelebs warmoeSobaT valdebulebis Seusruleblo-biT gamyidvelisaTvis (mosarCelisaTvis) miyenebuli zia-nis anazRaurebis valdebuleba ssk-is 394-e, aseve, 411-emuxlebis safuZvelze (ix. am ganCinebis 5.1-5.7 qvepunqte-bi).

20.1.1. sakasacio sasamarTlo, upirvelesad, Seamowmebsganxorcielebulia Tu ara ssk-is 477-e muxliT dadgeniliwinapirobebi: `1. nasyidobis xelSekrulebiT gamyidvelimovalea gadasces myidvels sakuTrebis ufleba qoneba-ze, masTan dakavSirebuli sabuTebi da miawodos saqone-li. 2. myidveli movalea gadauxados gamyidvels SeTanxme-buli fasi da miiRos nayidi qoneba~. xelSekrulebis me-4muxliT dadgenilia nasyidobis sruli safasuris _ 1 070872 aSS dolaris gadaxda xelSekrulebis xelmoweris dRi-dan 3 dRis vadaSi, amasTan, am vadis uSedegod gasvlis(myidvelis mier nasyidobis safasuris gadauxdelobis)SemTxvevaSi, xelSekruleba CaiTvleboda gauqmebulad damdgomareoba daubrundeboda pirvandel saxes (ix. am gan-Cinebis me-3 punqti).

154

20.1.2. uwinaresad dasadgenia, Tu raze SeTanxmdnen gam-yidveli da myidveli, radgan 20.1.1 qvepunqtSi miTiTebu-li ssk-is 477.1 muxlis definiciidan gamomdinare Sesamow-mebelia, miTiTebuli saxelSekrulebo piroba ramdenadgamoricxavs ssk-is 477.2 muxliT dadgenil mowesrigebas`myidveli movalea gadauxados gamyidvels SeTanxmebulifasi da miiRos nayidi qoneba~; amdenad, Sesafasebelia mxa-reTa neba rogor gamovlinda da aisaxa maT Soris 2008 wlis6 marts xelmoweril xelSekrulebaSi, kerZod, gamyidvelsxelSekrulebis xelmoweridan sam dReSi unda mieRo nas-yidobis Tanxa srulad da mxolod amis Semdeg unda gadae-ca myidvelisaTvis sakuTrebis ufleba, Tu piriqiT, es uka-naskneli xelSekrulebis xelmowerisTanave miiRebda sa-kuTrebis uflebas uZrav qonebaze da sam dReSi gadaixdi-da nasyidobis safasurs;

20.1.3. ssk-is 477-e muxliT nasyidobis xelSekrulebisdadebisas mxareebi, amave kodeqsis 319-e muxliT dadge-nili saxelSekrulebo Tavisuflebis farglebSi Tanxmde-bian xelSekrulebis arsebiT pirobebze, rac mocemuliassk-is 327-e muxlSi, Sesabamisad, nasyidobis safasuris ga-daxda da myidvelisaTvis sakuTrebis uflebis gadacemanasyidobis saganze swored is arsebiTi pirobaa, romelicaisaxa 2008 wlis 6 martis xelSekrulebis me-4 muxlSi. mxa-reTa nebis dasadgenad, sakasacio sasamarTlo yuradRe-bas gaamaxvilebs sarCelSi miTiTebul me-2, me-3 da me-4faqtobriv garemoebebze, romelTa Tanaxmad, rogorc gam-yidveli aRniSnavs, `06.03.2008w. xelSekrulebis me-4 pun-qtis Tanaxmad, myidvelebs unda gadaexadaT 1 070 872 aSSdolaris ekvivalenti erovnul valutaSi, xelSekrule-bis xelmoweridan 3 dRis ganmavlobaSi, xelSekruleba da-debis dResve waredgina sajaro reestrs da ramdenimedReSi miwa daregistrirda myidvelebze (mopasuxeebze);xelSekrulebis gaformebis dRes, anu 2008 wlis 6 martsmyidvelTa warmomadgenelma m. z. n-im gamyidvels Cauric-xa Tanxis nawili 161 781 aSS dolari, Semdeg arc erTi TeT-ri mopasuxeTa mxridan ar gadaxdila~ (ix. sarCeli). sakasa-cio sasamarTlo yuradRebas gaamaxvilebs saCelze Tan-darTul amonawerebze sajaro reestridan, romelTa mi-xedviT, gamyidvelsa da myidvels Soris xelmowerili 2008wlis 6 martis nasyidobis xelSekrulebis safuZvelze: a)sajaro reestrma 2008 wlis 6 marts miiRo ganacxadi sa-

155

kuTrebis uflebis registraciaze arasasoflo-sameurneomiwis nakveTze s/k 7.., 0.56 ha dazustebul farTze da mopa-suxeTagan e. r. n-is sakuTrebis ufleba daaregistrira 2008wlis 12 marts; b) sajaro reestrma 2008 wlis 19 marts mii-Ro ganacxadi sakuTrebis uflebis registraciaze arasa-soflo-sameurneo miwis nakveTze s/k 7.., 0.0347 ha dazus-tebul farTze da mopasuxeTagan e. r. n-is sakuTrebis uf-leba daaregistrira 2008 wlis 25 marts (ix. amonawerebisajaro reestridan _ t.1, s.f. 62-63, aseve, am ganCinebispirveli da meore punqtebi). sakasacio sasamarTlom ima-sac miaqcia yuradReba, rom 2008 wlis 6 martis nasyidobisxelSekrulebis safuZvelze am ganCinebis pirvel punqtSimiTiTebuli oTxive myidvelis sakuTrebad miwis nakveTis/k 7... aRiricxa 2008 wlis 4 ivliss, xolo miwis nakveTi s/k7... _ imave wlis 3 ivliss.

20.2. mopasuxeebma SesagebelSi sarCelis me-3 da me-4faqtobrivi garemoebebis pasuxad aRniSnes, rom uZrav qo-nebaze s/k 7.. sakuTrebis uflebis registraciis mizniTmopasuxeebma ara xelSekrulebis gaformebis dRes, ara-med 2008 wlis 19 marts mimarTes sajaro reestrs, rac Tvi-Ton mosarCelis mierve wardgenili amonaweriT dginde-boda, xolo xelSekrulebis xelmoweris dRes, anu 2008wlis 6 marts mopasuxeebma TavianTi warmomadgenlis meS-veobiT srulad gadauxades 1 070 872 aSS dolari gam-yidvels (mosarCeles), saidanac 161 781 aSS dolari uSua-lod am ukanasknels Caericxa, xolo danarCeni Tanxa gam-yidvelisave miTiTebiT sxva pirTa anagariSebze iqna ga-daricxuli (ix. Sesagebeli, aseve, am ganCinebis me-6 pun-qti).

20.3. sakasacio sasamarTlo saapelacio sasamarTlos yu-radRebas gaamaxvilebs, rom ssk-is 477-e muxlis safuZ-velze mxareTa Soris 2008 wlis 6 marts xelmowerili nas-yidobis xelSekrulebis me-4 muxli, rogorc xelSekrule-bis arsebiTi piroba, SeTanxmebuli mxareTa nebis gamov-lenis Sedegad, nasyidobis saganze sakuTrebis uflebisgadacemis, nasyidobis safasuris odenobasa da misi gadax-dis wesze, imgvarad unda ganimartos, rom gamyidvelma nas-yidobis saganTan dakavSirebuli sabuTebi gadasca myid-velebs, romelTac werilobiT gaformebuli garigebis sa-fuZvelze gansazRvruli sakuTrebis ufleba, ssk-is 183-emuxlis Tanaxmad, aRricxes sajaro reestrSi da erT miwis

156

nakveTze myidvelis sakuTrebis ufleba daregistrirda2008 wlis 12 marts, xolo meoreze _ imave wlis 25 marts.xelSekrulebis xelmoweridan sam dReSi myidvels nasyi-dobis safasuri unda gadaexada gamyidvelisaTvis, xoloam vadis gasvlis Semdeg, anu 2008 wlis 10 marts, Tuki gam-yidveli ver miiRebda nasyidobis safasurs srulad, maSinnasyidobis xelSekruleba gauqmebulad CaiTvleboda damxareebi daubrundebodnen pirvandel mdgomareobas, racimgvarad unda ganimartos, rom uZrav nivTze sakuTrebasver dairegistrirebda myidveli, xolo Tuki am ukanas-knels nasyidobis safasuridan raime nawili eqneboda ga-daxdili gamyidvelisaTvis, maSin mas es Tanxa unda daeb-runebina myidvelisaTvis.

20.3.1. sakasacio sasamarTlom zemoT ukve aRniSna, rom2008 wlis 6 martis xelSekrulebis me-4 muxlis Tanaxmad,gamyidvels myidvelisagan uZrav qonebaze gadacemuli sa-buTebis dabrunebis moTxovnis ufleba warmoeSva 2008wlis 10 marts, Tumca, mas es ufleba ar gamouyenebia, myid-velze sakuTrebis ufleba aRiricxa 2008 wlis 12 da 25marts, xolo gamyidvelma 2014 wlis 14 Tebervals aRZrasarCeli myidvelTa winaaRmdeg. sasamarTloSi saqmeze ga-remoebebis gamokvleva da dadgena mtkicebulebaTa er-TobliobiT xdeba sssk-is 102-e da 105-e muxlebis safuZ-velze, Sesabamisad, sarCelisa da Sesageblis stadiebzemxareTa mier miTiTebul poziciebze sakasacio sasamar-Tlom zemoxsenebul punqtebSi ukve imsjela da, nasyido-bis safasuris gadaxdis konteqstSi, saapelacio sasamar-Tlos yuradRebas gaamaxvilebs 2008 wlis 6 martis gari-gebis dammowmebeli notariusis ganmartebaze, romelicmowmis saxiT daikiTxa pirveli instanciis sasamarTloSi(sssk-is 140-e, 145-e muxlebi) da romelmac ganmarta, mopa-suxeTa warmomadgeneli _ z. m. n-i misi klientia da araer-Ti garigeba daumowmebia; notariusi Tavisi praqtikiT, mxa-res mxolod mas Semdeg atanda xelSekrulebas sajaro re-estrSi dasaregistrireblad, rac myidveli gadauxdidagamyidvels Tanxas. mosarCeles (gamyidvels) arc xel-Sekrulebis gaformebidan 3 dRis Semdeg da arc Semdeg,Tanxis gadauxdelobis Sesaxeb raime pretenziiT ar miu-marTavs notariusisaTvis (ix. am ganCinebis 7.4.15 qvepun-qti);

20.3.2. sadavo samarTalurTierToba ssk-is 477-e muxli-

157

dan gamomdinareobs, Tumca, am SemTxvevaSi ar aris gamov-lenili amave kodeqsis 491-e muxlis (myidvelis mier xel-Sekrulebis moSlis ufleba) winapirobebis Semowmebis sa-Wiroeba, radgan mocemul SemTxvevaSi uZravi qonebis myid-vels ar dauyenebia xelSekrulebidan gasvlis sakiTxi. ro-gorc zemoT aRiniSna, mosarCele (gamyidveli) iTxovs zi-anis anazraurebas ssk-is 352-e, 405-e, 411-e muxlebze day-rdnobiT. nasyidobis samarTlebriv urTierTobaSi ssk-is494.1 muxli adgens nasyidobidan gamomdinare zianis anaz-Raurebis zogad wess, kerZod, moxmobili norma gan-sazRvravs: `nivTis nakliT an xelSekrulebiT gansazRvru-li sxva pirobebis darRveviT miyenebuli ziani anazRaur-deba zogadi wesebis mixedviT~.

20.3.3. sakasacio sasamarTlos miTiTebiT, saapelaciosaCivris ganxilvis etapze saapelacio sasamarTlos kvle-vis sagania ssk-is 352-e da, Sesabamisad, 405-e muxlebis wi-napirobebi sasarCelo moTxovnis safuZvlianobis dasad-genad. rogorc zemoT ukve aRiniSna, sayuradReboa mxare-Ta Soris xelmowerili xelSekrulebis me-4 muxlis Sina-arsi da myidvelTa sakuTrebad uZravi qonebis registra-ciis TariRi (ix. am ganCinebis 20.1.3, 20.3 da 20.3.1. qvepun-qtebi), rac mniSvnelovania saapelacio samarTalwarmoe-bis etapze mxareTa SeTanxmebis im nawilis gamosakvlevad,rom Tu myidvelebi ar gadauxdidnen gamyidvels 1 070 872aSS dolars xelSekrulebis xelmoweridan sami dRis va-daSi, uZravi qonebis nasyidobis 06.03.2008w. xelSekrule-ba gauqmdeboda da mdgomareoba daubrundeboda pir-vandel saxes (ix. xelSekruleba). sadavo araa, rom gam-yidvelma mis sakuTrebad ricxuli ori miwis nakveTi gayi-da, Tumca, arasakmarisia pirveli instanciis sasamarTlosmier dadgenili sadavo faqtebi (ix. am ganCinebis me-4 pun-qti, aseve, pirveli instanciis sasamarTlos gadawyveti-leba, 3.2.3 qvepunqti), radgan mniSvnelovania saqmis masa-lebSi wardgenili sajaro reestris amonawerebi SefasdesmaTSi miTiTebuli TariRebis mixedviT, rogorc mopasu-xeTa sakuTrebad uZravi qonebis aRricxvis, aseve, Semdeg,mopasuxeTa mier mosarCelisagan SeZenili uZravi qonebissxva miwis nakveTebTan gaerTianebis mdgomareobiT.

20.4. imis gaTvaliswinebiT, rom mxareTa Soris 2008 wlis6 marts daido uZravi qonebis nasyidobis xelSekruleba(ssk-is 477-e muxli), saapelacio sasamarTlom unda daad-

158

ginos ganxorcielebulia Tu ara gansaxilvel SemTxvevaSissk-is 352-e muxlis (normis definicia ix. zemoT 20.3.1 qve-punqtSi) winapirobebi, anu gamyidvelsa da myidvelebs So-ris xelmowerili xelSekrulebis me-4 muxli (ix. am ganCi-nebis me-3 punqti), romelic myidvelis mier nasyidobissagnis Rirebulebis gadauxdelobis SemTxvevaSi, gam-yidvels xelSekrulebidan gasvlis uflebas aniWebda, ro-melma mxarem Seasrula, ra moculobiT da TiToeul mxa-res ra ufleba warmoeSva. xelSekrulebidan gasvla TiTo-eul mxares miRebulis dabrunebis (ukuqcevis) valdebu-lebas warmouSobs, swored amiT gansxvavdeba xelSekru-lebis moSlisagan xelSekrulebidan gasvla, radgan es uka-naskneli restitucias ukavSirdeba.

20.5. zemoxsenebul konteqstSi sakasacio sasamarTloyuradRebas gaamaxvilebs sarCelis aRZvramde, uzrunvel-yofis RonisZiebis gamoyenebis Sesaxeb gancxadebaSi dasarCelSi miTiTebul faqtze, rom gamyidvelma myidvelTa-gan xelSekrulebis xelmoweris dRes, anu 2008 wlis 6marts nasyidobis safasuris nawili _ 161 781 aSS dolarimiiRo, xolo darCenili 909 091 aSS dolaris gadaxdaze mi-uxedavad araerTgzisi dapirebisa, myidvelebs es Tanxa argadauxdiaT (ix. gancxadeba da sarCeli). amave konteqstSisaapelacio sasamarTlom unda Seafasos mopasuxeTa Sesa-gebelSi miTiTeba, rom mosarCelis mxridan arc werilo-biTi da arc zepiri moTxovna fuladi valdebulebis Ses-rulebaze arasodes yofila, radgan mopasuxeebma xel-Sekrulebis xelmoweris dResve gadaixades nasyidobissruli safasuri, Sesabamisad, mosarCelis moTxovnas xel-Sekrulebidan gasvlisa da zianis anazRaurebis Sesaxeb sa-marTlebrivi safuZveli ar gaaCnia (ix. Sesagebeli).

20.5.1. am ganCinebis 12.2.-12.3 qvepunqtebSi asaxuli mo-sarCelis warmomadgenlis ganmartebis Sesafaseblad saa-pelacio sasamarTlom yuradReba unda gaamaxvilos saq-meSi moTavsebul mtkicebulebebze, romelTa mixedviT mo-sarCelis warmomadgeneli 2014 wlis 21 Tebervlidan cdi-lobda mopasuxisaTvis Tbilisis saqalaqo sasamarTlos2014 wlis 17 Tebervlis ganCinebis Cabarebas. sakasacio sa-samarTlos miaCnia, rom aRniSnuli mtkicebulebebi mosar-Celis mier miTiTebul garemoebas, rom igi 2008 wlis 6 mar-tis xelSekrulebis xelmoweris Semdeg araerTxel iT-xovda nasyidobis safasuris daCenili Tanxis 909 091 aSS

159

dolaris gadaxdas mopasuxeTagan, ver adasturebs.20.6. mxareTa Soris 06.03.2008w. xelmowerili xelSekru-

lebis me-4 muxlidan gamomdinare, gamyidvels xelSekru-lebidan gasvlis ufleba eqneboda ssk-is 405.1 muxlis wi-napirobebis: `Tu xelSekrulebis erTi mxare arRvevs or-mxrivi xelSekrulebidan gamomdinare valdebulebas, ma-Sin xelSekrulebis meore mxares SeuZlia uari Tqvas xel-Sekrulebaze valdebulebis SesrulebisaTvis mis mier da-matebiT gansazRvruli vadis uSedegod gasvlis Semdeg.Tu valdebulebis darRvevis xasiaTidan gamomdinare, argamoiyeneba damatebiTi vada, maSin damatebiTi vadis gan-sazRvras uTanabrdeba gafrTxileba. Tuki valdebulebamxolod nawilobriv dairRva, maSin kreditors SeuZliauari Tqvas xelSekrulebaze mxolod im SemTxvevaSi, Tuvaldebulebis darCenili nawilis Sesrulebam misTvis da-karga interesi~ ganxorcielebis SemTxvevaSi. ssk-is 352-emuxlis pirveli nawili, romelic blanketuri Sinaarsisaada Seicavs daTqmas amave kodeqsis 405-e muxliT gaTvalis-winebul pirobebze awesebs qcevis imgvar wess, romlis Ta-naxmad, Tu xelSekrulebis erT-erTi mxare uars ityvisxelSekrulebaze, maSin miRebuli Sesruleba da sargebe-li mxareebs ubrundebaT (naturiT dabruneba) _ ix. susg#as-708-674-2014, 28.09.2015w.

20.6.1. sagulisxmoa, rom samoqalaqo kodeqsis me-5 Tav-Si, romelic xelSekrulebidan gasvlas exeba, moTavsebu-li 355-e muxliT dadgenilia, rom `xelSekrulebidan gas-vla xdeba xelSekrulebis meore mxarisaTvis Setyobine-biT~, xolo 356-e muxlis mixedviT: `Tu xelSekrulebidangasvlis vada ar aris dadgenili, maSin SeiZleba gamsvlelpirs xelSekrulebis meore mxarisagan ganesazRvros ase-Ti vada. vada unda iyos gonivruli. xelSekrulebidan gas-vlis ufleba qarwyldeba, Tu uari vadis gasvlamde ar iq-neba gacxadebuli~.

20.6.2. ssk-is 352-e muxli aris germaniis samoqalaqo ko-deqsis (gsk) 346-e paragrafis analogi, romelic adgensxelSekrulebidan gasvlis (xelSekrulebaze uaris Tqmis)winapirobebs, rac moicavs xelSekrulebidan gasvlis ro-gorc kanonismier, ise _ saxelSekrulebo daTqmis safuZ-vels da ganimarteba, rogorc calmxrivi miRebasavalde-bulo nebis gamovleniT valdebulebiTi urTierTobisukuqceva (ix. ian kropholeri, gsk-is komentari, 2014 w. ga-

160

mocema). doqtrinaSi araerTi mosazrebaa gamoTqmuli ssk-is 352-e muxlSi miTiTebul xelSekrulebaze uaris Tqmisa(gasvlis) da xelSekrulebis moSlis terminologiuriuzustobis Sesaxeb (ix. www.gccc.ge _ 352-e muxlis komen-tari) da daskvnis saxiT SesaZlebelia aRiniSnos, rom xel-Sekrulebaze uaris Tqmas, rasac gadacemulisa da miRe-bulis ormxrivi restitucia mosdevs, xelSekrulebidangasvla ewodeba. gansaxilvel SemTxvevaSi, mxareTa Sorisxelmowerili 06.03.2008w. xelSekrulebis me-4 muxlis daT-qma Sinaarsobrivad asaxavs mxareTa nebas restituciulurTierTobaze. sagulisxmoa isic, rom zogadad xelSekru-lebidan gasvlis Semdeg, mxareebi Tavisufldebian xel-SekrulebiT nakisri pirveladi valdebulebis Sesrule-bisagan da gardaiqmnebian restituciis kreditorad, ro-melic am SemTxvevaSi, mosarCelea, da restituciis mova-led (mopasuxeebi). gasaTvaliswinebelia isic, rom natu-riT dabrunebis SemTxvevaSi, aRniSnuli sargeblis dab-runebasac moicavs (ssk-is 154-e muxli). Tuki SeuZlebelianaturiT restitucia, maSin restituciis movales ssk-is352.2 muxlis à-g~ qvepunqtebis safuZvelze daekisrebanivTis sruli Rirebulebis an misi nawilis (damokidebu-lia konkretul faqtobriv winapirobaze) anazRaureba fu-ladi saxiT;

20.6.3. mosarCele uTiTebs, rom miwis nakveTebis sxvanakveTebTan gaerTianebis gamo, SeuZlebelia naturiT dab-runebis moTxovna da amitom sakuTar moTxovnas ssk-is 352-e muxlis meore nawilis `b~ qvepunqtze [2. naturiT dabru-nebis nacvlad movales ekisreba fuladi anazRaureba, Tu:b. miRebul sagans mxare gamoiyenebs, gaasxvisebs, uflebri-vad datvirTavs, gadaamuSavebs an gadaakeTebs] afuZnebs(ix. am ganCinebis 5.5 qvepunqti); moxmobili norma SesaZ-loa analogiiT iqnes gamoyenebuli restituciis movalismier dasabrunebeli nivTis 193-e muxlis safuZvelze mi-wis nakveTis arsebiT Semadgenel nawilad qcevis an 194-emuxlis Sesabamisad _ Serwymis SemTxvevaSi (ix. www.gccc.ge_ 352-e muxlis komentari veli 12).

20.7. saapelacio sasamarTlom unda Seamowmos aseve,ramdenad aris SesaZlebeli, rom mosarCelis moTxovna ssk-is 352-e muxlis safuZvelze, mis mier miTiTebuli faqte-bidan gamomdinare, pirvelad moTxovnad iqnes Sefasebu-li da SesaZlebeli iyo Tu ara pirveladi moTxovnis daye-

161

neba mxaris mier, winaaRmdeg SemTxvevaSi, SesrulebuliaTu ara yvela winapiroba mosarCelis mier meoradi moT-xovnis dasayeneblad. amasTan, saxelSekrulebo moTxovne-bi upiratesia kanonismierTan SedarebiT, isini swored amTanmimdevrobiT unda Semowmdes da dadgindes pirvela-di moTxovnis aRZvris SeuZlebloba.

20.8. saapelacio sasamarTlos mier ssk-is 405-e da 352-emuxlebis Sesabamisad, sarCelis samarTlebrivi winapiro-bis dadgenis SemTxvevaSi, rom mosarCelem mopasuxes val-debulebis Sesasruleblad damatebiTi vada ganusazRvra(gaafrTxila an valdebulebis darCenili nawilis Sesru-lebam azri dakarga, ramac gamyidvels mianiWa xelSekru-lebidan gasvlis ufleba), sarCeli miiCneva dasabuTebu-lad, anu moTxovna _ warmoSobilad, Sesabamisad, Tuki isar Sewyvetila, Semowmdeba moTxovnis ganxorcielebado-ba. mopasuxem SesagebelSi miuTiTa mis winaaRmdeg sarCe-lis aRZvramde, rac 5 wlisa da 11 Tvis Semdeg moxda, gam-yidvelis mxridan pretenziis ararsebobaze (ix. am ganCi-nebis 6.2. qvepunqti; mopasuxeTa Sesagebeli). sakasacio sa-samarTlo yuradRebas gaamaxvilebs, rom moTxovnis gan-xorcielebadoba (xandazmuloba), moTxovnis warmoSobis,misi gamomricxavi da Semwyveti garemoebebis SemowmebisSemdeg unda iqnes ganxiluli. Sesabamisad, Tu moTxovnaar warmoSobila, an SemdgomSi Sewyda, swored am safuZ-vliT, da ara xandazmulobiT, unda iqnes uaryofili sar-Celi (ix. susg #as-1063-1023-2016, 17.02.2017w; Sdr. #as-197-187-2016, 12.07.2016w.). sakasacio sasamarTlo araerTgadawyvetilebaSi/ganCinebaSi ganmartavs, rom xandazmu-loba faqtia da [am faqtis miTiTebis Semdeg, sasamarTlovaldebulia yovelmxriv, srulad da obieqturad gamoik-vlios sasarCelo moTxovnis ganxorcielebis xelis-SemSleli garemoebebi, rac dadgenili sasamarTlo praq-tikis safuZvelze, ar gulisxmobs xandazmulobis miTi-Tebisas konkretuli TariRis zustad dasaxelebas, rad-gan sakmarisia movale Seedavos kreditors, rom misi moT-xovna dagvianebulia, rac SesaZloa ar iyos konkretulisamarTlebrivi cnebiT `xandazmuli~ gamoxatuli, aramed_ aseTi saxiTac ki Camoyalibdes àmden xans ar mouTxoviavaldebulebis Sesruleba~ _ ix. susg #as-1063-1023-2016,17.02.2017w.]. gansaxilvel SemTxvevaSi, Tuki dadgindeba,rom moTxovna warmoiSva da ar Sewyvetila, saapelacio sa-

162

samarTlom unda gamoiyenos xandazmulobis zogadi 10-wliani vada.

20.9. mopasuxis stadiaze saapelacio sasamarTlos miergamosakvlevi iqneba, Seasrula Tu ara mopasuxem 2008 wlis6 martis xelSkrulebis me-4 muxliT dadgenili valdebu-leba da srulad gadaixada Tu ara uZravi qonebis nasyido-bis safasuri. Tuki dadgindeba, rom mopasuxes srulad arSeusrulebia valdebuleba, maSin dadgeba ssk-is 352-e mux-lis gamoyenebis sakiTxi (winamdebare ganCinebis 20.4-20.8qvepunqtebSi asaxuli msjelobisa da daskvnis gaTvalis-winebiT), romelic xelSekrulebaze uaris Tqmas, anu ur-TierTobidan gasvlis winapirobebs (am SemTxvevaSi gam-yidvelis mxridan) exeba da samarTlebrivi Sedegis saxiTiwvevs ormxriv restitucias.

20.9.1. mopasuxis poziciasTan dakavSirebiT ssk-is 352.3muxlisa da 411-e muxlis urTierTmimarTebis Sesaxeb (ix.am ganCinebis 11.3 qvepunqti), sakasacio sasamarTlo ssk-is 352.3 muxlis definiciaze `Tu xelSekrulebaSi gaTva-liswinebuli iyo samagiero Sesruleba, maSin fuladi anaz-Raureba Seicvleba am SesrulebiT~ da gsk-is 346 II 2 parag-rafis Sinaarsze `Tu xelSekrulebaSi gaTvaliswinebuliasapasuxo Sesruleba, maSin es ukanaskneli gamoiyeneba saz-Rauris Tanxis gamongariSebis safuZvlad~ gaamaxvilebsyuradRebas, raTa naTeli moefinos qarTuli normis Sina-arss. amdenad, am konteqstSi Sesafasebelia mopasuxismsjeloba da pozicia, romelic asaxulia am ganCinebis 11.3qvepunqtSi (ix. www.gccc.ge _ 352.3 muxlis komentari, ve-lebi 15-17), Tumca, mxareTa Soris 06.03.2008w. xelmoweri-li xelSekrulebis me-4 muxlis Sinaarsidan gamomdinare,jer unda gamoiricxos 352-e muxlis me-4 nawiliT dadge-nili winapirobebi. amdenad, SesaZlebelia davaskvnaT, romssk-is 411-e muxlis gamoyenebis saWiroeba ar dgeba ssk-is352.3 muxlis mowesrigebis Sinaarsis gaTvaliswinebiT.

20.10. sarCelisa da Sesageblis erToblivad gaanalize-bisas, saapelacio sasamarTlom damatebiT unda gamoikvli-os mxareTa Soris xelmowerili sadavo xelSekrulebis pi-robebidan gamomdinare mopasuxis mtkiceba, rom nasyido-bis safasuri gamyidvelis davalebiT (miTiTebiT) sruladgadauxada oTx pirs, romelTagan erTi Tavad mosarCelea,Tanxebis sabanko angariSebze gadaricxvis gziT. gamyidve-lis (mosarCelis) miTiTebiT sxva pirTa angariSebze myid-

163

velTa (mopasuxeTa) mier nasyidobis safasuris gadaxdazewerilobiTi SeTanxmebis (rac ssk-is 709-e muxlis safuZ-velze davalebis wesebis mixedviT, savaldebulo ar aris)ararsebobis pirobebSi, erToblivad unda Sefasdes mow-meebis (b-i, d-e, n-e) ganmartebebi. gansakuTrebuli yurad-RebiT aris gamosakvlevi mowme b-is ganmarteba, raTa dad-gindes, Tu ra roli hqonda mas am urTierTobaSi, vis war-moadgenda, visi davalebiT moqmedebda da ra evaleboda(ssk-is 709-e-710-e muxlebi). amave konteqstSi sakasaciosasamarTlo yuradRebas amaxvilebs mopasuxeTa mowmis _z. T-is werilobiTi ganmartebis (ix. am ganCinebis 7.4.16 qve-punqti) mtkicebulebiT Rirebulebaze, radgan igi, kano-niT dadgenili wesiT, ar dakiTxula sasamarTlos mier,rac imas niSnavs, rom mowme ar gaufrTxilebiaT ganzraxaraswori Cvenebis micemis SemTxvevaSi mosalodneli sis-xlis samarTlis pasuxismgeblobis Sesaxeb (sssk-is 145-emuxli).

20.11. sakasacio sasamarTlo aqve imasac ganmartavs, rommxareTa Soris dadebuli xelSekruleba ar warmoadgensnasyidobas gadaxdis ganvadebiT. saqarTvelos uzenaesisasamarTlos praqtikis safuZvelze, nasyidoba gadaxdisganvadebiT SesaZlebelia daidos, rogorc moZrav, ise uZ-rav nivTebze (ix. susg-ebi _ #as-691-1021-07, 12.02.2008w;#as-9691-2013, 15.04.2013w.). saqarTvelos uzenaesi sasa-marTlos ganmartebiT, ssk-is 477-e muxliT `mxareebi mxo-lod kisruloben garkveuli moqmedebis Sesrulebis val-debulebas. Sesabamisad, rogorc erTi mxriv Tanxis, ise,meore mxriv, nasyidobis sagnis gadacema, ara xelSekru-lebis dadebis winapiroba, aramed misi Sesrulebaa. saqar-Tvelos samoqalaqo kodeqsis 505-e muxlis mixedviT ki,ganvadebiT nasyidobisas gamyidveli valdebulia gadas-ces nivTi myidvels fasis gadaxdamde. nivTis fasis gadax-da myidvelis mier xdeba nawil-nawil drois gansazRvrulSualedebSi. Sesabamisad, ganvadebiT nasyidobisas gam-yidvels nivTis gadacemis valdebuleba warmoeSveba myid-velis mier fasis srulad gadaxdamde, nivTis gadacemiTki myidvelze gadadis sakuTrebis ufleba da mesame pi-rebTan urTierTobaSi nasyidobis sagnis mesakuTred gvev-lineba ukve myidveli~ (ix. susg #as-666-627-2012,12.07.2012w.).

20.11.1. mxareTa Soris werilobiT dadebuli 2008 wlis

164

6 martis xelSekruleba ar Seicavs ssk-is 506-e muxliTdadgenili mowesrigebis elementebs: a) naRdi gadaxdisodenoba; b) nawil-nawil gadasaxadi Tanxis odenoba dadro; g) wliuri procentis odenoba. Tumca, aqve isic undaaRiniSnos, rom dadgenili sasamarTlo praqtikis safuZ-velze, `gadaxdis ganvadebiT nasyidobis xelSekrulebisarsebiT pirobas warmoadgens nawil-nawil gadasaxadi Tan-xis odenoba da gadaxdis dro~ (ix. susg # as-944-906-2014,27.01.2015w. Sdr. #as-874-832-2013 17.02.2014w.). am SemTxve-vaSi, mxareTa Soris Tanxis gadaxda, rogorc xelSekrule-bis arsebiTi piroba, SeTanxmda ara nawil-nawil, aramed _srulad, amasTan, swored am pirobas _ xelSekrulebis xel-moweridan sam dReSi nasyidobis safasuris srulad gada-uxdelobis SemTxvevas _ daukavSires mxareebma xelSekru-lebidan gasvlis ufleba restituciiT;

20.11.2. Tu xelSekruleba dadebulia 506-e muxlis moT-xovnaTa darRveviT, maSin ssk-is 507-e muxlis safuZvelze`xelSekruleba CaiTvleba dadebulad nivTis gadacemismomentidan. am SemTxvevaSi myidveli valdebulia gadai-xados mxolod nivTis fasi procentebis gareSe~ (ix. susg#as-397-713-2009, 20.10.2009w.). gadaxdis ganvadebiT nas-yidobaze yuradRebis gamaxvileba sakasacio sasamarTlommizanSewonilad miiCnia ssk-is 508-e muxlis `valdebule-bis Seusruleblobisas Tu gamyidveli itovebs uflebas,uari Tqvas xelSekrulebaze im SemTxvevisaTvis, roca myid-veli ar asrulebs dakisrebul valdebulebebs, uaris Tqmi-sas yoveli mxare valdebulia daubrunos erTmaneTs is,rac xelSekrulebiT miiRes. amis sawinaaRmdego SeTanxme-ba baTilia~ ganmartebis konteqstSi, radgan moxmobilinorma valdebulebis Seusruleblobisas ormxriv resti-tucias adgens, kerZod: àRniSnuli normis me-2 winadade-ba xelSekrulebidan gasvlis samarTlebriv Sedegs iTva-liswinebs, xolo pirveli _ xelSekrulebidan gasvlis wi-napirobas. saapelacio sasamarTlos ganmartebiT, xel-Sekrulebidan gasvla aRmWurveli uflebaa, rac imas niS-navs, rom gansazRvruli winapirobebis arsebobisas mxaresaqvs SesaZlebloba, miaRwios garkveul samarTlebriv Se-degs _ daasrulos saxelSekrulebo urTierToba konkre-tuli uflebebiTa da movaleobebiT da gansxvavebul sa-marTlebriv reJimSi gadaiyvanos igi. pirveladi moTxovnis,anu xelSekrulebiT nakisri valdebulebebisa da Sesaba-

165

misad, xelSekrulebis Seusrulebloba xelSekrulebidangasvlis meoradi moTxovnis uflebis aRmocenebis samar-Tlebrivi safuZvelia. amdenad, dauSvebelia erTdrou-lad moTxovnil iqnes xelSekrulebis Sesrulebaca daxelSekrulebidan gasvlis meoradi uflebis gamoyenebac.amgvar moTxovnaTa kumulaciurad ganxorcieleba daar-Rvevda xelSekrulebis mxareebis interesTa balanss, swo-red rasac uzrunvelyofs meoradi moTxovnis, xelSekru-lebidan gasvlis uflebis gamoyeneba (#as-12-12-2012,04.06.2012w.)~. sakasacio sasamarTlos miTiTebuli gan-marteba gasaTvaliswinebelia zogadad xelSekrulebidangasvlis uflebis gamoyenebisas mxareTa mier restituci-idan gamomdinare moTxovnis aRZvrisas, Sesabamisad, gan-saxilveli sarCelis moTxovnidan gamomdinare sakasaciosasamarTlos mier ganviTarebuli msjeloba asaxulia amganCinebis 20.6.2-20.6.3 da 20.7 qvepunqtebSi.

20.12. zemoxsenebuli motiviT gauqmda saapelacio sa-samarTlos samoqalaqo saqmeTa palatis gasaCivrebuliganCineba da, mopasuxis sakasacio ganacxadis nawilobrivdakmayofilebiT, sakasacio sasamarTlos mier miTiTebu-li samarTlebrivi safuZvlebiT saqme saapelacio saCiv-ris ganxilvis etapidan ubrundeba saapelacio sasamar-Tlos sssk-is 412-e muxlis Tanaxmad.

sarezolucio nawili:sakasacio palatam ixelmZRvanela saqarTvelos samo-

qalaqo saproceso kodeqsis me-8 muxliT, 257-e muxlis pir-veli nawiliT, 372-e, 399-e muxlebiT, 408-e muxlis pirve-li da meore nawilebiT, 412-e muxliT da

d a a d g i n a:

1. i. n-i r-is, e. r. n-is, o. r-isa da i. s. n-i S-is sakasaciosaCivari dakmayofildes nawilobriv;

2. gauqmdes Tbilisis saapelacio sasamarTlos samoqa-laqo saqmeTa palatis 2016 wlis 20 oqtombris ganCinebada saqme daubrundes imave sasamarTlos saapelacio sa-Civris ganxilvis etapidan;

3. kasatorebs saxelmwifo baJi gadaxdili aqvT;4. ganCineba sabolooa da ar saCivrdeba.

166



#as-38-38-2018 8 ivnisi, 2018 w., q. Tbilisi

saqarTvelos uzenaesi sasamarTlos samoqalaqosaqmeTa palataSemadgenloba: z. ZlieriSvili (Tavmjdomare, momxsenebeli),

e. gasitaSvili,b. alaviZe

davis sagani: xelSekrulebidan gasvla da zianis anaz-Raureba

aRwerilobiTi nawili:1. 2011 wlis 23 marts ss `saqarTvelos s-is m-is k-iasa~

(SemdegSi: gamyidveli an mopasuxe an apelanti an kasato-ri) da m. m-s (SemdegSi: myidveli an mosarCele an mowinaaR-mdege mxare) Soris daido nasyidobis xelSekruleba P. HiB-is mier miwodebuli xarisxobrivi maCveneblebis dama-dasturebeli sertifikatis mqone simindis saTesle masa-laze. myidvelma Seisyida: 168 tomara PR38R92 saxeobis sa-Tesle masala 16000 marcvliani SefuTviT (70 lari) da 131tomara PR35F38 saxeobis saTesle masala 65000 marcvlianiSefuTviT (240 lari). saqonlis fasi ganisazRvra 43 200 la-riT. nasyidobis safasuris anazRaureba unda ganxorcie-lebuliyo xelSekrulebis gaformebidan ara ugvianes 7Tvis ganmavlobaSi.

2. 2011 wlis 28 marts gamyidvels da p. d-s (SemdegSi:meore mosarCele an meore myidveli) Soris daido nasyi-dobis xelSekruleba P. Hi B-is mier miwodebuli xaris-xobrivi maCveneblebis damadasturebeli sertifikatismqone simindis saTesle masalaze. myidvelma Seisyida: 75tomara PR35P12 saxeobis saTesle masala 65000 marcvlianiSefuTviT (240 lari) saqonlis fasi ganisazRvra 18 000 la-ris odenobiT. nasyidobis safasuris anazRaureba undaganxorcielebuliyo xelSekrulebis gaformebidan araug-vianes 7 Tvis ganmavlobaSi.

3. 2011 wlis 8 aprils gamyidvelsa da b. a-s (SemdegSi:mesame mosarCele an mesame myidveli) Soris daido nasyi-

167

dobis xelSekruleba P. Hi B-is mier miwodebuli xaris-xobrivi maCveneblebis damadasturebeli sertifikatismqone simindis saTesle masalaze. myidvelma Seisyida: 70tomara PR35F38 saxeobis saTesle masala 65000 marcvlianiSefuTviT (240 lari). saqonlis fasi ganisazRvra 16800 la-ris odenobiT. nasyidobis safasuris anazRaureba undaganxorcielebuliyo xelSekrulebis gaformebidan ara ug-vianes 7 Tvis ganmavlobaSi.

4. 2011 wlis 6 aprils gamyidvelsa da l. g-as (SemdegSi:meoTxe mosarCele an meoTxe myidveli) Soris daido nas-yidobis xelSekruleba P. Hi B-is mier miwodebuli xaris-xobrivi maCveneblebis damadasturebeli sertifikatismqone simindis saTesle masalaze. myidvelma Seisyida: 36tomara PR35F12 saxeobis saTesle masala 65000 marcvlianiSefuTviT (240 lari). saqonlis fasi ganisazRvra 8 640 la-ris odenobiT. nasyidobis safasuris anazRaureba undaganxorcielebuliyo xelSekrulebis gaformebidan ara ug-vianes 7 Tvis ganmavlobaSi.

5. myidvelebma miiRes saqoneli.6. myidvelebma nasyidobis safasuris gadaxdis valde-

bulebis Sesruleba uzrunvelyves ss `j-s~ (SemdegSi: ga-rantori) mier gacemuli sabanko garantiebiT. garantormasagarantio Tanxa gadauxada gamyidvels 2013 wlis 25 no-embris moTxovnis Sesabamisad.

7. Tavis mxriv, myidvelebma aunazRaures garantors ga-daxdili sagarantio Tanxa.

8. mosarCeleebma sarCeli aRZres gamyidvelis winaaR-mdeg xelSekrulebidan gasulad aRiarebis da gamyidve-lis mier usafuZvlod miRebuli Tanxis dabrunebis moT-xovniT, saidanac pirveli myidvilisTvis gadasaxdeli Tan-xis odenoba Seadgens 43 200 lars, meore myidvelisTvis _18 000 lars, mesame myidvelisTvis _ 16 800 lars da meoTxemyidvelisTvis _ 8 640 lars [saqarTvelos samoqalaqo ko-deqsis (SemdegSi: ssk-is) 405-e da 352-e muxlebi].

9. garda amisa, mosarCeleTa moTxovna miuRebeli Semo-savlis saxiT damdgari zianis anazRaurebaSi mdgomareob-da, saidanac pirveli myidvelisaTvis asanazRaurebeliTanxis odenoba Seadgens 7000 lars, meore myidvelisaT-vis _ 12000 lars, mesame myidvelisaTvis _ 1200 lars, me-oTxe myidvelisaTvis _ 25 000 lars [ssk-is 394-e da 411-emuxlebi].

168

10. xelSekrulebidan gasvlis safuZvlad mosarCele-ebma miuTiTes, rom myidvelis mier miwodebuli produq-cia gamodga uxarisxo da Seusabamo simindis Teslis mo-savlianobis Sesaxeb gavrcelebul informaciasTan. am sa-fuZvliT myidvelebma uari ganacxades nasyidobis safa-suris gadaxdaze. gamyidvelma ki, moTxovna garantorismeSveobiT daikmayofila.

11. mopasuxem waradgina moTxovnis gamomricxavi da gan-xorcielebis Semaferxebeli (xandazmuloba) Sedaveba, racxelSekrulebidan gasvlis winapirobebis ararsebobaSi,kerZod, nasyidobis sagnis uxarisxobis daudastureblo-basa da Tavis mxriv, myidvelTa mxridan Tesvis Semdgometapze rekomendaciebis daucveblobaSi mdgomareobda.

12. Tbilisis saqalaqo sasamarTlos samoqalaqo saqme-Ta kolegiis 2016 wlis 13 oqtombris gadawyvetilebiT moT-xovna nasyidobis xelSekrulebidan gasulad aRiarebisada gamyidvelisaTvis pirveli myidvelis sasargeblod nas-yidobis xelSekrulebis safasuris angariSSi 43 200 larisanazRaurebis nawilSi dakmayofilda, xolo moTxovna zi-anis _ 7000 laris dakisrebis nawilSi, uaryofili iqna.

13. meore myidvelis moTxovna nasyidobis xelSekru-lebidan gasulad aRiarebisa da gamyidvelisaTvis meoremyidvelis sasargeblod nasyidobis xelSekrulebis safa-suris angariSSi 18 000 laris anazRaurebis nawilSi dakma-yofilda, xolo moTxovna zianis _ 12 000 laris dakisre-bis nawilSi, uaryofili iqna.

14. mesame myidvelis moTxovna nasyidobis xelSekru-lebidan gasulad aRiarebisa da gamyidvelisaTvis meoremyidvelis sasargeblod nasyidobis xelSekrulebis safa-suris angariSSi 16 800 laris anazRaurebis nawilSi dakma-yofilda, xolo moTxovna zianis _ 1200 laris dakisrebisnawilSi, uaryofili iqna.

15. meoTxe myidvelis moTxovna nasyidobis xelSekru-lebidan gasulad aRiarebisa da gamyidvelisaTvis meoTxemyidvelis sasargeblod nasyidobis xelSekrulebis safa-suris angariSSi 8640 laris anazRaurebis nawilSi dakma-yofilda, xolo moTxovna zianis _ 25 000 laris dakisre-bis nawilSi, uaryofili iqna.

16. saqalaqo sasamarTlom dadgenilad miiCnia am ganCi-nebis pp: 1-7-Si miTiTebuli faqtobrivi garemoebebi.

17. mosarCeleTa pozicia imasTan dakavSirebiT, rom

169

maTTvis gadacemuli nasyidobis sagani _ simindis saTes-le masala, ar iyo SeTanxmebuli Tvisebebis da mosarCele-ebis SemTxvevaSi 1 ha miwis nakveTze movida saSualod mxo-lod 1 tona simindi, saqalaqo sasamarTlom dadasture-bulad miiCnia Semdegi garemoebebis gaTvaliswinebiT:

18. nasyidobis xelSekruleba iTvaliswinebda iseT ar-sebiT pirobebze SeTanxmebas, rogoric iyo simindis maRa-li mosavlianoba (mosavlianobis saSualo maCvenebeli iyoheqtarze 10-12 tona. PR38R92 saxeobis saTesle masalis mo-savlianobis saSualo maCvenebeli _ 8-10 tona heqtarze),gamZleoba Cawolaze, gvalvagamZleoba da daavadebebisad-mi mdgradoba. Tesvis rekomendirebuli norma iyo 60 000 _65 000 marcvali erT heqtarze, saTesle masalis Rirebu-leba 65 000 marcvali _ 240 lari (1 heqtarze samyofi sa-Tesle masala), 16 000 marcvali _ 70 lari (0,25 heqtarzesamyofi saTesle masala). daculi unda yofiliyo mwkriv-TaSorisi da rigTaSorisi Sesabamisi manZilebi, maRali mo-savlis misaRebad aucilebeli iyo agro kalendris mixed-viT gansazRvruli sasuqebis Setana da daTesili farTo-bis morwyva (mtkicebulebebi: sareklamo _ sainformaciomasala).

19. gamyidveli simindis Teslis realizacias axorcie-lebda simindis warmoebis xelSewyobis programis far-glebSi, romelic Tavis mxriv warmoadgenda s-is m-is sami-nistros iniciativas da misi mizani iyo simindis mosavli-anobis donisa da xarisxis zrda. mopasuxe sajarod sTava-zobda (sainformacio broSurebSi) dainteresebul pirebssaTesle masalis Sesyidvas da acnobda pirobebs, Sesaba-misad mosarCeleebsa da mopasuxes Soris swored zemoaR-niSnuli Tvisebebis mqone saTesle masala iyo SeTanxme-bis sagani.

20. Sps `m-ma~ 2013 wlis 15 Tebervals Caatara saTeslesimindis `p-is~ PR35F38 _ hibridis nimuSze kvleva. daskvnismixedviT, Teslis gaRvivebis energia Seadgens 22-25%-s,xolo gaRvivebis unari 23-25%-s da ar Seesabameba stan-dartiT gaTvaliswinebul moTxovnebs. laboratoriul pi-robebSi warmodgenili Teslis garkveuli nawili CaiTesasavegetacio qoTnebSi momzadebul niadagSi. am SemTxve-vaSi, niadagSi CaTesili marcvlis 8% aRmocenda.

21. sasamarTlom miiCnia, rom marTalia ar dgindebodaSemowmebul simindsa da uSualod mosarCeleebis sasaqon-

170

lo partias mikuTvnebul siminds Soris uSualo kavSiri,magram kvleva erTmniSvnelovnad Cautarda gamyidvelissiminds, romlis realizaciasac gamyidveli axorcieleb-da simindis warmoebis xelSewyobis programis farglebSi.

22. Sps `m-is~ 2014 wlis 2 maisis werilSi miTiTebulia,rom mas monawileoba ar miuRia simindis sinjis aRebis pro-ceduraSi, aRniSnuli sinjis romelime sasaqonlo parti-asTan identobis dadgenis mizniT, Sps `m-s~ ar daudgeniasakvlevad wardgenili simindis sinji miekuTvneboda Tuara gamyidvelis mier realizebul produqts _ kompania`p-is~ hibrids.

23. zemoaRniSnulis miuxedavad, sasamarTlom aRiSna,rom mopasuxis mier proeqtis farglebSi realizebul si-mindsa da gamokvleul saTesle masalas Soris kavSirisdadgena SesaZlebeli iqna saqmeSi warmodgenili sxva mtki-cebulebebiTac, kerZod, mxedvelobaSi iqna miRebuli, romSps `m-s~ simindis Tesli Sesamowmeblad gadasca arasame-warmeo iuridiuli piris _ simindis warmoebis xelSewyo-bis programiT dazaralebulTa kavSirma. kvleva Cautar-da swored saqarTveloSi Semotanil Teslis nimuSs.

24. marTalia, mopasuxis mier warmodgenil iqna rumine-Tis s-is m-is, metyeveobis da s-is ganviTarebis saminis-tros da saTesi da sargavi masalis xarisxis centralurilaboratoriis mier gacemuli sertifikatebi saTes masa-laze, magram aRniSnuli sertifikatebi gaica rumineTisrespublikaSi arsebul masalaze da maTi kavSiri uSualodsaqarTveloSi Semosul da uSualod mosarCeleebze rea-lizebul saTesle masalis partiaze utyuarad ar das-turdeboda.

25. sasamarTlos miTiTebiT, ar dadasturda isic, TuSps ̀ m-is~ mier Semowmebuli saTesle masala 2013 wlis mdgo-mareobiT ra pirobebSi inaxeboda, magram arc Sps `m-is~kvleva da arc saqmeSi warmodgenili sxva raime mtkicebu-leba ar adasturebda sapirispiros, kerZod, imas rom, sa-Tesle masala uvargisi gaxda swored gamyidvelis mier mi-si realizaciis Semdgom periodSi Senaxvis pirobebis da-ucvelobis Sedegad.

26. garda zemoaRniSnulisa, mosarCeleebis iniciativiTdakiTxulma mowmeebma: n. t-ma, i. C-em, i. k-em, a. m-ma, rom-lebic zedamxedvelobas axocielebdnen mosarCeleebi-saTvis gadacemuli simindis daTesva da movlis procesze

171

saqarTvelos sxvadasxva administraciul erTeulSi, daa-dastures rom saTesle masalas ar aRmoaCnda gaRvivebisda aRmocenebis saTanado unari.

27. sasamarTlom aRniSna, rom marTalia, mopasuxis ini-ciativiT daikiTxa mowme z. k-aZe, romelsac aseve hqondaSeZenili simindis marcvali da pretenzia ar gaaCnda sa-Tesle masalasTan dakavSirebiT, magram aRniSnuli warmo-adgenda erTeul SemTxvevas da ufro xSir SemTxvevebSi,saqarTvelos sxvadasxva administraciul erTeulebSi sa-Tesle masalis gamoyenebam daTqmuli Tvisebebi ar gamo-avlina. garda amisa, mosarCeleebma daaxloebiT erTsa daimave periodSi SeiZines simindis saTesle masala da maRa-li albaTobiT masala erTsa da imave sasaqonlo partiasmikuTvnebuli iqneboda gansxvavebiT mowme z. k-aZis mierSeZenili masalisa. saTesle masalis uxarisxoba garda mxa-reTa axsna-ganmartebis, mowmeTa Cvenebis da specialis-tis daskvnisa, dgindeboda aseve masobrivi informaciissaSualebebiT sxvadasxva dros gavrcelebuli masalebiT,romliTac dasturdeboda momxmareblebis pretenzia Se-Zenil saTesle masalasTan mimarTebaSi,

28. aseve, erT-erT saqmeze saqarTvelos uzenaesi sasa-marTlos mier 2016 wlis 23 marts miRebuli ganCinebiT da-dasturda saTesle masalis uxarisxoba, aRniSnul davaSipirveli da meore mosarCele monawileobdnen mesame pi-rebad damoukidebeli moTxovnis gareSe.

29. sasamarTlom uaryo mopasuxis ganmarteba, rom Se-saZlebeli iyo mosarCeleebs daculi ar hqonodaT simin-dis moyvanisaTvis saWiro yvela agroprocesi, maT Soris:agro kalendris mixedviT gansazRvruli sasuqebis Seta-nasa da daTesili farTobis morwyvasTan mimarTebaSi sa-Wiro wesi. sasamarTlom aRniSna, rom mopasuxis amgvarimtkiceba eyrdnoba mxolod zepir mosazrebas, rasac Ta-vis mxriv, uaryofdnen mosarCeleebi, aseve mowmeebi, ro-melTa mtkicebiT isini uSualod monawileobdnen yvelaagroprocesis sworad warmarTvaSi. sasamarTlom ar gai-ziara mopasuxis miTiTeba rom saqmeSi warmodgenili 2011wlis 15 noembris xelSekruleba k-iis sakuTrebaSi arse-bul Sesanax centrebSi simindis gaSroba _ Senaxvis momsa-xurebis Sesaxeb da miReba-Cabarebis aqtebi abaTilebda mo-sarCeleebis arguments mosavlis miuReblobasTan dakav-SirebiT da rom aRniSnuli mtkicebulebebiT dasturde-

172

boda, rom pirvelma mosarCelem miiRo mosavali da igi Se-sanax punqtebSi miabara mopasuxes.

30. sasamarTlom aRniSna, rom saqmeSi warmodgenili mi-Reba-Cabarebis aqtebis umravlesoba Sedgenili iyo ara si-mindis gaSroba-Senaxvis momsaxurebis Sesaxeb 2011 wlis15 noembris xelSekrulebis safuZvelze, aramed safuZ-vlad miTiTebuli iyo sxva xelSekrulebebi (2011 wlis 21dekembris da 2011 wlis 18 dekembris, 2011 wlis 19 noem-bris) da arc miReba-Cabarebis aqtebiT ar irkveoda Tu kon-kretulad romeli marcvlovani kultura Cabarda Sesana-xad. saqmeSi warmodgenili iyo mxolod 6 miReba-Cabarebisaqti, Sedgenili 2011 wlis 15 noembris xelSekrulebis sa-fuZvelze, miReba-Cabareba ganxorcielda 2011 wlis 15 no-embers saerTo jamSi, 65 400 (65 tona) kilogram simindismarcvleulze. amasTan, miTiTebuli ar iyo Tu konkretu-lad romeli jiSis simindis marcvali iqna mibarebuli. imav-droulad, aRniSnuli ar abaTilebda mosarCelis argu-ments, rom heqtarze dapirebuli 10 tonis nacvlad movi-da mxolod 1 tona.

31. saqmis masalebiT ar dadasturda, rom mosarCele-ebma mopasuxesTan xelSekruleba dades rogorc mewarmesubieqtebma. xelSekruleba ar Seicavda miTiTebas mosar-Celeebis rogorc mewarme subieqtebis Sesaxeb.

32. sasamarTlom mxolod mosarCeleebis axsna-gan-martebasa da mowmeTa Cvenebebze dayrdnobiT ar CaTvaladadasturebulad, Tu konkretulad romel mosarCelesra konkretul farTobze hqonda daTesili mopasuxisaganSeZenili simindis marcvali da rom maT Sesabamisad Semo-savlis saxiT unda mieRoT: pirvel mosarCeles 7000 la-ris, meore mosarCeles 12000 laris, mesame mosarCeles 12000 laris, meoTxe mosarCeles _ 25000 laris simindi. meo-re mosarCelem ganmarta, rom mas daTesili hqonda ramde-nime saxeobis simindi da aseve sxva marcvlovani kultu-ra. amdenad, mxolod mosarCelis axsna-ganmarteba da mow-mis Cveneba ver gaxda sakmarisi mtkicebuleba aRniSnulisadavo garemoebis dasadgenad.

33. saqalaqo sasamarTlom dava moawesriga ssk-is 991-e,491-e, 352-e, 405-e, 488-e, 412-e, 129-e 130-e muxlebiT.

34. ganCinebis gauqmebis moTxovniT wardgenili gam-yidvelis saapelacio saCivari uaryofilia gasaCivrebu-li ganCinebiT.

173

35. saapelacio palatam gaiziara pirveli instanciis sa-samarTlos mier dadgenili faqtobrivi garemoebebi (ix.,am ganCinebis pp-1-7). imavdroulad, uaryo apelantis po-zicia ssk-is 495-e muxlis winapirobebis daucvelobasTandakavSirebiT [normis pirveli nawilis dispozicia: Tumyidveli mewarmea, is valdebulia dauyovnebliv Seamow-mos nivTi; Tuki igi naklis aRmoCenidan Sesabamis vadaSian im vadaSi, romlis ganmavlobaSic cnobili unda yofi-liyo misTvis naklis arseboba, ar warudgens gamyidvelspretenzias, mas erTmeva nivTis naklis gamo moTxovnis uf-leba].

36. saapelacio sasamarTlom aRniSna, rom normis dana-wesi myidvels ar avaldebulebda nivTis yidvisas dauyov-nebliv Seemowmebina nivTis xarisxi. am mxriv, gamonaklisiiyo dawesebuli im myidvelisTvis, romelic eweoda same-warmeo saqmianobas. kanonmdebloba mewarmes avaldebu-lebs nivTis yidvisas dauyovnebliv Seamowmos igi. mewar-me valdebulia an TviTon Seamowmos nivTi, an uzrunvel-yos misi Semowmeba situaciis Sesabamisad maqsimaluradmokle droSi. Tu myidveli nakls aRmoaCens Sesabamis va-daSi an im vadaSi, romlis ganmavlobaSic cnobili unda yo-filiyo misTvis naklis arseboba, ar warudgens gamyidvelspretenzias (reklamacias) mas erTmeva nivTis naklis gamo,moTxovnis ufleba. naklTan mimarTebiT Semowmebis val-debuleba mxolod im viTarebaSi unda moxdes, rodesacsaxelSekrulebo urTierTobis monawile mewarme subieq-tia an/da nasyidobis sagani misi samewarmeo saqmianobissferos ukavSirdeba da Sesabamisad, misi kompetencia, ga-mocdileba am sferoSi sxva rigiTi fizikuri pirisagan gan-sxvavebulia.

37. gansaxilvel SemTxvevaSi, saapelacio palatam mo-sarCeleebi ar miiCnia mewarme subieqtebad miuxedavad imi-sa, rom isini registrirebulni arian da warmoadgenen in-dividualur mewarmeebs.

38. saqmeSi warmodgenili nasyidobis xelSekrulebebi-sa da miReba-Cabarebis aqtebiT dadgenili iqna, rom oTxi-ve mosarCele mocemul samarTlebriv urTierTobaSi mo-nawileobdnen rogorc fizikuri pirebi da arc xelSekru-lebebSi da arc sxva dokumentaciaSi ar fiqsirdeboda ma-Ti mewarmis statusi. ar dasturdeboda arc maTi samewar-meo saqmianobis Semxebloba nasyidobis xelSekrulebidan

174

gamomdinare sagnis mimarT da Sesabamisad, mosarCeleebismimarT ver gavrceldeboda ssk-is 495-e muxlis moTxovna.amasTan, imis gaTvaliswinebiTac, rom simindis Tesli ga-nekuTvneboda iseTi kategoriis nivTs, romlis naklis aR-mosaCenadac saWiroa misi gardaqmna mcenared.

39. uaryofili iqna Sedaveba moTxovnis mudmivad Sema-ferxebel (xandazmuloba) SedavebasTan mimarTebiTac, imsafuZvliT, rom ssk-is 128-e muxlis me-3 nawilis mixed-viT, xandazmulobis saerTo vada Seadgens aT wels. ssk-is130-e muxlis Sesabamisad, xandazmuloba iwyeba moTxovniswarmoSobis momentidan. moTxovnis warmoSobis momentadCaiTvleba dro, roca pirma Seityo an unda Seetyo ufle-bis darRvevis Sesaxeb. moTxovnebi gamomdinareobda usa-fuZvlo gamdidrebis normebidan, Sesabamisad, maTzevrceldeboda saerTo xandazmulobis 10-wliani vada, xo-lo moTxovnis uflebebi warmoSobili iyo im dros, rode-sac gamyidvelma garantorisagan gaiTxova sagarantio Tan-xa (ix., am ganCinebis p-6), saidanac ar iyo gasuli sasarCe-lo xandazmulobis vada.

40. saapelacio sasamarTlos ganCinebis gauqmebis dasarCelis uaryofis moTxovniT apelantma warmoadgina sa-kasacio saCivari, romelic efuZneba Semdeg mosazrebebsda daskvnebs:

41. kasatoris mosazrebiT, sasamarTlom yovelgvarimsjelobis da mtkicebulebebis gareSe miiCnia, rom 100%-iani saxelmwifo wilobrivi monawileobiT dafuZnebuliiuridiuli piri, romelic axorcielebda saxelwifo prog-ramas, kerZod, axorcielebda saxelwifo biujetiT Sesyi-duli simindis Teslis realizacias, gamdidrda usafuZ-vlod.

42. gadawyvetileba ar Seicavs dasabuTebas imis Taoba-ze Tu raSi gamoixata mopasuxis gamdidreba. imavdroulad,sasamarTlo gascda sasarCelo moTxovnas da miiCnia, romsaxelmwifo kompania gamdidrda usafuZvlod, maSin ro-desac mosarCeleebi ar moiTxovdnen usafuZvlo gam-didrebis Sedegad miRebuli sargeblis dabrunebas.

43. kasatoris mosazrebiT, uznaesma sasamarTlom undaimsjelos Tu rogor SeiZleba saxelmwifo kompania gam-didrdes usafuZvlod saxelmwifo programis ganxorcie-lebis dros, saxelmwifo saxsrebiT Sesyiduli nivTis re-alizaciiT.

175

44. amasTan, mniSvnelovania, im safuZvlebis gamokvle-vac, rac gaxda Tbilisis saapelacio sasamarTlos mier am-gvari gadawyvetilebis miRebis safuZveli, radgan gadaw-yvetilebaSi Tbilisis saapelacio sasamarTlo Semoifar-gla mxolod samarTlebriv normaTa interpretaciiT, saq-meSi arsebuli mtkicebulebebis sapirispirod.

45. kasatorisTvis gaugebaria, ris safuZvelze daadgi-na sasamarTlom is faqti, rom mowinaaRmdege mxareebs arhqondaT movaleoba gadaexadaT nasyidobis safasuris Tan-xa, an ratom ar unda gamoeTxova kasators garantorisganaRniSnuli Tanxa.

46. kasatoris mosazrebiT, mosarCeleebis mier saqmisganxilvisas ar iqna warmodgenili arcerTi nasyidobis anmsgavsi urTierTobis damadasturebeli dokumenti, rom-liTac dadasturdeboda, rom maT Seisyides aTeulobiTheqtarze darguli simindisTvis saWiro sasoflo-sameur-neo saSualebebi (herbicidebi da sxv) an/da sxvadasxva mom-saxurebebi.

47. kasatori ar uaryofs meoTxe mosarCelis mier saga-rantio Tanxis garantisTvis gadaxdis faqts, Tumca miiC-nevs, rom danarCeni mosarCeleebis mier garantorisaTvisTanxis gadaxdis faqti ar aris dadasturebuli. amasTan,kasatori aRniSnavs, rom mesame mosarCelesTan dakavSi-rebiT gacemuli cnobis Tanaxmad, am ukanasknels aqvs ga-cilebiT naklebi Tanxa gadaxdili vidre SeTanxmebuli iyo.

48. kasatori aRniSnavs, rom uzenaesi sasamarTlos mi-er winamdebare sakasacio saCivarze msjelobiT unda ga-nimartos ssk-is 880-e muxlis pirveli nawili, kerZod, Turis safuZvelze ekrZaleba kreditors sagarantio TanxismiReba garantori kompaniisagan da SesaZlebelia Tu aragarantoris mier gacemuli cnoba, romelic SeusabamobaSimodis dasaxelebul faqtebTan, CaiTvalos principalismier nakisri valdebulebis Sesrulebad.

49. kasatori aRniSnavs, rom simindis saTesle masalaar ganekuTvneba im kategoriis produqcias, romlis nak-lis aRmosaCenad saWiroa misi gardaqmna an gadamuSaveba.winamdebare garemoebas aseve adasturebs mowinaaRmdegemxaris mier warmodgenili laboratoriis daskvna da amavelaboratoriis werili, sadac fiqsirdeba rom dakveTa gan-xorcielda 29 ianvars, xolo daskvna daiwera 15 Teber-vals. kasatoris mosazrebiT, im faqts, rom nivTi daTqmu-

176

li xarisxis iyo adasturebs mxareTa Soris gaformebulinasyidobis xelSekrulebebi, riTac mxareebi SeTanxmdnennivTis maxasiaTeblebze. kasatori aqve aRniSnavs, rom mog-vianebiT Sesabamisi miReba-Cabarebis aqtebiT moxda am niv-Tis gadacema mowinaaRmdege mxareebisaTvis. sasamarTlosgadawyvetilebis 2.2 punqtis Tanaxmad, mosarCeleebma mi-iRes xelSekrulebiT gaTvaliswinebuli saqoneli, kasato-ris mosazrebiT ki, es garemoeba adasturebs im faqts, romssk-is 488-e muxlis Sesabamisad nasyidobis sagani iyo niv-Tobrivad unaklo.

50. kasatori ar eTanxmeba dadgenil faqtobriv gare-moebas imasTan dakavSirebiT, rom myidvelebs gadaecaTSeuTanxmebeli Tvisebebis mqone produqcia da maT 1 ha-ze miiRes saSualod 1 tona simindi. piriqiT, kasatori aR-niSnavs, rom saqmeSi warmodgenili mtkicebulebebiT das-turdeba, rom mowinaaRmdege mxareebs gadaecaT SeTanxme-buli Tvisebebis mqone nivTi, xolo is, rom myidvelebmaver miiRes mosavali dasturdeba mxolod maTi axsna-gan-martebebis safuZvelze. rac Seexeba mowmeTa Cvenebebs,kasatori ganmartavs, rom mowmeTa mier ar dadasturebu-la konkretuli garemoeba. piriqiT, maT ar axsovdaT weliTu rodis daiTesa simindi, ramden heqtarze iyo daTesi-li simindi, maT ar dausaxelebiaT is agroprocesebi, ro-melic ganxorcielda mowinaaRmdege mxareTa mier da sxva.kasatori aRniSnavs, rom mowme z. k-aZis Cveneba sasamar-Tlom ar gaiTvaliswina usafuZvlod, vinaidan am ukanas-knelma imave periodSi miiRo kasatorisgan igive saxeobissimindi, ganaxorciela yvela agroprocesi da Sedegad mi-iRo mosavali.

51. kasatori sadavod xis mxareTa Soris mtkicebis tvir-Tis gadanawilebasac da aRniSnavs, rom mopasuxes daevalaim garemoebebis damtkiceba, rom mosarCeleebma ver mii-Res mosavali da ar ganaxorcieles saTanado agroproce-sebi. swored mosarCeleebs unda warmoedginaT sarCelisaRZvris etapze mtkicebulebebi, romelTa meSveobiTacdadasturdeboda, rom maT ver miiRes mosavali, Tumca ga-naxorcieles yvela dadgenili agroprocesi.

52. rac Seexeba simindis Teslis xarisxis dokumenta-cias, kasatori aRniSnavs, rom sasamarTlom ixelmZRvane-la erT-erTi laboratoriis mier garkveuli simindis Tes-lze Catarebuli laboratoriuli analizebiT da daadgi-

177

na, rom albaTobis meti xarisxiT is warmoadgenda saqar-Tvelos teritoriaze arsebuli Teslis vargisianobis Ta-obaze miRebul pasuxs.

53. kasatori miiCnevs, rom sasamarTlom yuradRebismiRma datova mopasuxis mier warmodgenili xarisxis ser-Tifikatebi da ver daadgina kavSiri Semosul TeslTan. ze-moaRniSnulTan mimarTebiT kasatori ganmartavs, rom sa-qarTvelos mcenareTa da cxovelTa axali jiSebis SesaxebsaqarTvelos kanonis mixedviT, xarisxis serTifikatebiwarmoadgenda aucilebel dokumentacias, imisaTvis, romsimindi saqarTvelos teritoriaze Semosuliyo. amgvaridokumentaciis gareSe ki simindis Tesli saqarTvelos saz-Rvars ver gadmokveTda.

54. kasatoris mosazrebiT, sasamarTlom ar gamoikvliais detalebi, rac arsebiTi iyo mtkicebulebaTa Sesafa-seblad. kerZod mesame piris mier meoTxe pirTan (labora-toriaSi) wardgenil iqna simindis Tesli, romelic saidaniqna mopovebuli, ra pirobebSi da ra vadiT inaxeboda ardgindeba. aseve, sasamarTlom ar imsjela im garemoebaze,rom Tuki mesame pirma aRniSnuli simindis Tesli miiRokasatorisgan, maSin misi Senaxvidan gasuli 2 wlis gan-mavlobaSi ra pirobebSi inaxeboda es ukanaskneli da kon-kretulad ra simindi iqna gadacemuli laboratoriisTvismesame piris mier.

55. kasatori ar eTanxmeba saapelacio sasamarTlos Se-fasebas myidvelebis mewarme subiqtebad miCnevis uaryo-fis nawilSi da aRniSnavs, rom myidvelebi registrire-bulni arian samewarmeo reestrSi rogorc ind. mewarmee-bi. maTi ganmartebiT xelSekrulebis gaformebamde da ad-rec am sferoSi eweodnen samewarmeo saqmianobas. marTa-lia, mewarmeTa Sesaxeb saqarTvelos kanoni sasoflo-sa-meurneo saqmianobas ar miiCnevs samewarmeo saqmianobad,Tumca kasatoris ganmartebiT, mocemul SemTxvevaSi, re-alurad saxezea is xuTi arsebiTi komponenti, rac same-warmeo saqmianobas axasiaTebs. aseve saxezea mosarCelee-bis mier SeZenili im raodenobis simindi, romelic ar Se-iZleba miCneul iqnas mxolod sasoflo-sameurneo saqmia-nobis gansaxorcieleblad SeZenilad. kasatori aRniSnavs,rom marTalia mosarCeleebma xelSekruleba gaaformesrogorc fizikurma pirebma, Tumca, isini moqmedebdnen sa-mewarmeo miznebisaTvis, kerZod rodesac mxare aseulo-

178

biT heqtarze sasoflo-sameurneo procesebis Sedegadelodeba kolosalur Tanxebs, is aucileblad warmoadgensmewarme subieqts.

samotivacio nawili:56. saqarTvelos uzenaesi sasamarTlos samoqalaqo saq-

meTa palatis 2018 wlis 29 ianvris ganCinebiT sakasaciosaCivari miRebul iqna warmoebaSi, samoqalaqo saprocesokodeqsis 391-e muxlis Sesabamisad, dasaSvebobis Sesamow-meblad. mogvianebiT, sakasacio saCivris dasaSvebobis sa-kiTxis gansaxilvelad dainiSna zepiri mosmena 2018 wlis23 marts mxareTa daswrebiT, romel sxdomazec sakasaciosaCivari dasaSvebad iqna cnobili. saqmeze 2018 wlis 18 ma-iss saqmis arsebiTi ganxilvis mizniT Catarda zepiri mos-mena.

57. sakasacio sasamarTlom Seiswavla saqmis masalebi,gasaCivrebuli ganCinebis samarTlebrivi dasabuTeba, sa-kasacio saCivris safuZvlebi da miiCnevs, rom sakasaciosaCivari nawilobriv unda dakmayofildes Semdegi gare-moebebis gamo:

58. sakasacio saCivriT moTxovnilia _ Tbilisis saape-lacio sasamarTlos samoqalaqo saqmeTa palatis 2017 wlis24 noembris ganCinebis kanonierebis Semowmeba, romliTacucvlelad iqna datovebuli pirveli instanciis sasamar-Tlos gadawyvetileba oTxive mosarCelis nawilSi xel-Sekrulebidan gasvlisa da nasyidobis safasuris ukan dab-runebis dakmayofilebis Sesaxeb.

59. sakasacio palata aRniSnavs, rom vinaidan, sasarCe-lo moTxovnebi miuRebeli Semosavlis saxiT damdgari zi-anis [ssk-is 394-e da 411-e muxlebi] anazRaurebis nawilSiuaryofili da gasaCivrebuli ar yofila, gadawyvetile-bis es nawili Sesulia kanonoer ZalaSi da amdenad, maszemsjeloba sakasacio palatas ar eqneba.

60. amdenad, gansaxilevl SemTxvevaSi, sakasacio pala-tis kvlevisa da msjelobis sagania oTxive mosarCelismxridan xelSekrulebidan gasvlis uflebis gamoyenebismarTlzomiereba [ssk-is 405-e da 352-e muxlebi], xolo vi-naidan xelSekrulebidan gasvla gamsvlel mxares imav-droulad, warmouSobs garkveul uflebebsac (xelSekru-lebis farglebSi gadaxdili Tanxis ukan dabrunebis da a.S),sakasacio palatis msjeloba aRniSnul sakiTxsac daeT-

179

moba.61. aRsaniSnavia, rom gansaxilveli dava warmoSobilia

nasyidobis samarTlebrivi urTierTobidan, romlis far-glebSic myidvelebs gamyidvelma miawoda dadgenili ode-nobiT produqcia (nasyidobis sagani), romelsac myidve-lebis mosazrebiT, gaaCnda imgvari nakli/wuni, rac maTwarmouSobda xelSekrulebidan gasvlis uflebas, kon-krtulad ki, nasyidobis sagans (miwodebul produqcias)ar aRmoaCnda is Tvisebebi, rac xelSekrulebis dadebismiznebisTvis iyo ganmsazRvreli myidvelebisaTvis.

62. kasators ki, piriqiT, miaCnia, rom jer erTi, dau-dasturebelia myidvelebis mier miTiTebuli garemoebe-bi nasyidobis sagnis pirobebTan Seusabamobis Tvalsazri-siT da meorec, myidvelebis miznis miuRwevloba ganapi-roba ara produqciis (nasyidobis sagani) SeTanxmebulisa-gan gansxvavebulma xarisxma, aramed myidvelebis mxridannasyidobis sagnis gamoyenebisTvis aucilebeli wesebis da-ucvelobam.

63. sakasacio saCivris safuZvlebis (kasaciis mizeze-bis) Semowmebis mizniT, sakasacio palata miuTiTebs mo-cemul saqmeze saapelacio sasamarTlos mier dadgenilfaqtobriv garemoebebze, romlebic sakasacio saCivriTSedavebuli ar yofila da amdenad, am garemoebebs sakasa-cio saCivris ganxilvisas aqvT savaldebulo Zala (sssk-is407.2 muxli):

64. dadgenilia, rom 2011 wlis 23 gamyidvelsa da pir-vel myidvels Soris daido nasyidobis xelSekruleba P. HiB-is mier miwodebuli xarisxobrivi maCveneblebis dama-dasturebeli sertifikatis mqone simindis saTesle masa-laze. pirvelma myidvelma Seisyida: 168 tomara PR38R92 sa-xeobis saTesle masala 16000 marcvliani SefuTviT (70 la-ri) da 131 tomara PR35F38 saxeobis saTesle masala 65000marcvliani SefuTviT (240 lari). saqonlis fasi ganisaz-Rvra 43 200 lariT. nasyidobis safasuris anazRaureba un-da ganxorcielebuliyo xelSekrulebis gaformebidan araugvianes 7 Tvis ganmavlobaSi.

65. 2011 wlis 28 marts gamyidvels da meore myidvelsSoris daido nasyidobis xelSekruleba P. Hi B-is mier mi-wodebuli xarisxobrivi maCveneblebis damadasturebelisertifikatis mqone simindis saTesle masalaze. myid-velma Seisyida: 75 tomara PR35P12 saxeobis saTesle masa-

180

la 65000 marcvliani SefuTviT (240 lari) saqonlis fasiganisazRvra 18 000 laris odenobiT. nasyidobis safasu-ris anazRaureba unda ganxorcielebuliyo xelSekrule-bis gaformebidan ara ugvianes 7 Tvis ganmavlobaSi.

66. 2011 wlis 8 aprils gamyidvelsa da mesame myidvelsSoris daido nasyidobis xelSekruleba P. Hi B-is mier mi-wodebuli xarisxobrivi maCveneblebis damadasturebelisertifikatis mqone simindis saTesle masalaze. myid-velma Seisyida: 70 tomara PR35F38 saxeobis saTesle masa-la 65000 marcvliani SefuTviT (240 lari). saqonlis fasiganisazRvra 16800 laris odenobiT. nasyidobis safasurisanazRaureba unda ganxorcielebuliyo xelSekrulebis ga-formebidan ara ugvianes 7 Tvis ganmavlobaSi.

67. 2011 wlis 6 aprils gamyidvelsa da meoTxe myidvelsSoris daido nasyidobis xelSekruleba P. Hi B-is mier mi-wodebuli xarisxobrivi maCveneblebis damadasturebelisertifikatis mqone simindis saTesle masalaze. myid-velma Seisyida: 36 tomara PR35F12 saxeobis saTesle masa-la 65000 marcvliani SefuTviT (240 lari). saqonlis fasiganisazRvra 8 640 laris odenobiT. nasyidobis safasurisanazRaureba unda ganxorcielebuliyo xelSekrulebis ga-formebidan ara ugvianes 7 Tvis ganmavlobaSi.

68. myidvelebma miiRes saqoneli (nasyidobis sagni) dasafasuris gadaxdis valdebulebis Sesruleba uzrunvel-yves sabanko garantiebiT. garantorma sagarantio Tanxagadauxada gamyidvels 2013 wlis 25 noembris moTxovnisSesabamisad.

69. mosarCeleebma moTxovna xelSekrulebidan gasuladaRiarebis da gamyidvelis mier usafuZvlod miRebuliTanxis dabrunebis Taobaze daafuZnes miwodebuli pro-duqciis uxarisxobas, agreTve, Seusabamobaze simindisTeslis mosavlianobis Sesaxeb gavrcelebul informaci-as.

70. myidvelTa zemoaRniSnuli pretenziis safuZvlia-nobis Sesaswavlad, Tavdapirvelad, yuradReba unda mi-eqces nasyidobis xelSekrulebis im debulebebs, romle-bic xelSekrulebis dadebis ganmapirobebel arsebiT faq-tors warmoadgenda.

71. dadgenilia, rom gamyidvelis mier myidvelisaTvisSeTavazebuli produqciis upiratesobad dasaxelebuliiyo simindis maRali mosavlianoba (mosavlianobis saSua-

181

lo maCvenebeli iyo heqtarze 10-12 tona. PR38R92 saxeobissaTesle masalis mosavlianobis saSualo maCvenebli _ 8-10 tona heqtarze), gamZleoba Cawolaze, gvalvagamZleobada daavadebebisadmi mdgradoba. Tesvis rekomendirebu-li norma iyo 60 000 _ 65 000 marcvali erT heqtarze, sa-Tesle masalis Rirebuleba 65 000 marcvali _ 240 lari (1heqtarze samyofi saTesle masala), 16 000 marcvali _ 70lari (0,25 heqtarze samyofi saTesle masala). daculi un-da yofiliyo mwkrivTaSorisi da rigTaSorisi SesabamisimanZilebi, maRali mosavlis misaRebad aucilebeli iyo ag-ro kalendris mixedviT gansazRvruli sasuqebis Setanada daTesili farTobis morwyva.

72. sagulisxmoa, rom mopasuxe sajarod sTavazobda (sa-informacio broSurebSi) dainteresebul pirebs saTeslemasalis Sesyidvas da acnobda zemoTdasaxelebul piro-bebs.

73. amdenad, sakasacio palatas miaCnia, rom mosarCele-ebsa da mopasuxes Soris swored zemoaRniSnuli Tvisebe-bis mqone saTesle masala iyo SeTanxmebis sagani [ssk-is327-e muxli]. xolo im garemoebis dasadatureblad, rommiwodebuli produqcia SeTanxmebulisagan gansxvavebu-li iyo, saqmeSi warmodgenili iqna Sps `m-is~ 2013 wlis 15Tebervlis kvlevis Sedegebi saTesle simindis `p-is~PR35F38-hibridis nimuSze (SemdegSi: daskvna).

74. daskvnis mixedviT, Teslis gaRvivebis energia Se-adgens 22-25%-s, xolo gaRvivebis unari 23-25%-s da arSeesabameba standartiT gaTvaliswinebul moTxovnebs. la-boratoriul pirobebSi warmodgenili Teslis garkveulinawili CaiTesa savegetacio qoTnebSi momzadebul niadag-Si. am SemTxvevaSi, niadagSi CaTesili marcvlis 8% aRmo-cenda.

75. sakasacio palata aRniSnavs, rom ssk-is 105-e muxlismixedviT arcerT mtkicebulebas ar gaaCnia winawar dad-genili Zala. yvela mtkicebuleba, saqmeSi warmodgenilsxva mtkicebulebebTan erTobliobaSi unda Sefasdes ma-Ti dasaSvebobis, gankuTvnadobis, iuridiuli Zalisa daSinaarsis mixedviT. mtkicebulebaTa Sefasebis miznebi-saTvis, rodesac sakiTxi Seexeba saeqsperto daskvnas, au-ditis daskvnas, Tu specialistis kvlevis Sedegebs, mniS-vnelovania yuradReba mieqces swored im garemoebas, Tura nimuSebi waredgina uflebamosil pirs gamosakvlevad,

182

iyo Tu ara gamosakvlevad wardgenili nimuSebi sworadSerCeuli da aRebuli, sakmarisi raodenobis da a.S. gardaamisa, kvlevis romeli meTodi iqna gamoyenebuli da sxva.

76. gansaxilvel SemTxvevaSi, daskvnis iuridiuli ZalaerTdroulad Sedavebulia ramdenime safuZvliT. kasato-ris mosazrebiT, sasamarTlom ar gamoikvlia is detalebi,rac arsebiTi iyo mtkicebulebaTa Sesafaseblad. kerZod,laboratoriaSi wardgenili iqna simindis Tesli, romelicsaidan iqna mopovebuli, ra pirobebSi da ra vadiT inaxe-boda ar dgindeba (kasaciis safuZvlebi p _ 54).

77. kasaciis zemoTdasaxelebul safuZvels sakasaciopalata ar iziarebs da ganmartavs, rom saTesle simindis`p-is~ PR35F38-hibridis nimuSze laboratoriis mier Cata-rebuli kvlevis Sedegebis uarsayofad kasators dasabu-Tebuli Sedaveba ar warmoudgenia.

78. rac Seexeba kasatoris pretenzias laboratoriaSigagzavnil sakvlev masalasTan da nimuSis aRebis wesTandakavSirebiT, marTalia Sps `m-is~ 2014 wlis 2 maisis we-rilSi miTiTebulia, rom laboratorias monawileoba ar mi-uRia simindis sinjis aRebis proceduraSi da sinjis ro-melime sasaqonlo partiasTan identobis dadgenis mizniTar daudgenia sakvlevad wardgenili simindis sinji mie-kuTvneboda Tu ara gamyidvelis mier realizebul pro-duqts _ kompania `p-is~ hibrids, Tumca aRsaniSnavia, romsimindis mosavlianobis gazrdis proeqtis farglebSi re-alizebul simindsa da gamokvleul saTesle masalas So-ris kavSiris dadgena SesaZlebeli iqna saqmeSi warmodge-nili sxva mtkicebulebebiTac, kerZod, mxedvelobaSi iq-na miRebuli, rom Sps `m-s~ simindis Tesli Sesamowmebladgadasca arasamewarmeo iurdiuli piris _ simindis warmo-ebis xelSewyobis programiT dazaralebulTa kavSirma.kvleva Cautarda swored saqarTveloSi Semotanil Tes-lis nimuSs. sxva mtkicebuleba ki, romelic gaaqarwylebdagamosakvlevi masalisa (PR35F38) da laboratoriaSi Semow-mebuli nimuSis avTenturobas, kasators ar warmoudge-nia.

79. amasTan, kasatori marTalia sadavod xdis imasac, Tura pirobebSi inaxeboda Sps `m-is~ mier Semowmebuli saTes-le masala 2013 wlis mdgomareobiT, magram arc Sps `m-is~kvleva da arc saqmeSi warmodgenili sxva raime mtkicebu-leba ar adasturebs sapirispiros, kerZod, imas rom, sa-

183

Tesle masala uvargisi gaxda swored gamyidvelis mier mi-si realizaciis Semdgom periodSi Senaxvis pirobebis da-ucvelobis Sedegad. amdenad, arc am kuTxiTaa kasatorisSedaveba gasaziarebeli.

80. sakasacio palatas miaCnia, rom saTesle simindis `p-is~ PR35F38-hibridis nimuSze laboratoriis mier Catare-buli kvlevis Sedegebis uarsayofad kasators damajere-beli Sedaveba ar warmoudgenia, Tumca, sakasacio saCiva-ri nawilobriv gasaziarebelia mtkicebulebaTa gan-kuTvnadobis kuTxiT [sssk-is 393.2 muxli].

81. am TvalsazrisiT, sakasacio palata mxedvelobaSiiRebs im garemoebas, rom gansaxilvel saqmeSi miwodebu-li produqciis uxarisxobasa da xelSekrulebisagan gan-sxvavebulobis dasadastureblad mosarCeleTa mier war-modgenili laboratoriuli daskvna Seexeba mxolod sa-Tesle simindis ̀ p-is~ PR35F38-hibridis nimuSze Catarebulkvlevas. saqmis masalebiT ki, dadgenilia, rom saTesle si-mindis ̀ p-is~ PR35F38-hibridis Sesyidva ganxorcielebuliamxolod mesame mosarCelis (mesame myidveli) mier srulad(am ganCinebis p-1) da pirveli mosarCelis (pirveli myid-veli) mier nawilobriv _ 131 tomris odenobiT (am ganCine-bis p-3). gasaCivrebuli ganCinebiT ki, romliTac ucvle-lad iqna datovebuli pirveli instanciis sasamarTlos ga-dawyvetileba, xelSekrulebidan gasvlis winapirobebiganxorcilebulad iqna miCneuli erTdroulad oTxive mo-sarCelis nawilSi [ssk-is 394-e, 405-e, 352-e muxlebi], maSinrodesac am nawilSi, simindis Teslis uxarisxobis dasa-dastureblad meore da meoTxe mosarCeleebis mxridan sa-Tanado mtkicebulebebi warmodgenili ar yofila.

82. aqedan gamomdinare, sakasacio palatas miaCnia, romgasvlis ufleba warmoSobilia mxolod saTesle simindis`p-is~ PR35F38-hibridze gaformebuli xelSekrulebis far-glebSi. am farglebSi ki xelSekrulebis mxares mxolodpirveli da mesame myidveli warmoadgens. sakasacio pala-ta xelSekrulebidan nawilobriv gasvlis dauSveblobazemiuTiTebs susg-ze #as-793-742-2017. p-14.5.

83. amdenad, saTesle simindis `p-is~ hibridis PR38R92da PR35P12 gaformebuli xelSekrulebebis nawilSi kasa-torma warmoadgina dasaSvebi da dasabuTebuli sakasaciopretenzia (Sedaveba).

84. zemoaRniSnulidan gamomdinare, iuridiulad nawi-

184

lobriv dausabuTebelia gasaCivrebuli ganCineba (ssk-is393-e muxli). aRniSnuli garemoeba, samoqalaqo saproce-so kodeqsis 394-e muxlis è~ qvepunqtis Tanaxmad ki, gasa-Civrebuli ganCinebis gauqmebis absoluturi safuZvelia.

85. samoqalaqo saproceso kodeqsis 411-e muxlis mixed-viT, sakasacio sasamarTlo TviTon miiRebs gadawyvetile-bas saqmeze, Tu ar arsebobs am kodeqsis 412-e muxliT gaT-valiswinebuli gadawyvetilebis gauqmebisa da saqmis saa-pelacio sasamarTloSi xelaxla gansaxilvelad dabrune-bis safuZvlebi.

86. mocemul SemTxvevaSi, sakasacio sasamarTlo miiC-nevs, rom ar arsebobs saqmis saapelacio sasamarTloSi xe-laxla gansaxilvelad dabrunebis safuZveli, vinaidan sa-Wiro araa mtkicebulebaTa damatebiTi gamokvleva, Sesa-bamisad, sakasacio sasamarTlo uflebamosilia, TviTon mi-iRos gadawyvetileba saqmeze.

87. saqmeze dadgenilia, rom laboratoriam Seamowma si-mindis mxolod erTi konkretuli jiSi (PR35F38), nasyido-bis xelSekrulebis safuZvelze ki, miwodebuli iqna si-mindis sxva jiSebic, rogoricaa PR38R92; PR35P12; PR35F12,romlebzedac laboratoriul kvlevebSi araferia aR-niSnuli, agreTve, arc sxva dasaSvebi da sakmarisi mtkice-bulebebia warmodgenili mosarCeleebis mier simindis da-narCeni jiSebis naklis dasadastureblad.

88. Sesabamisad, sakasacio palatas miaCnia, rom vinai-dan miwodebuli produqciis uxarisxobasa da xelSekru-lebisagan gansxvavebulobis dasadastureblad mosarCe-leTa mier warmodgenili daskvna Seexeba mxolod saTes-le simindis `p-is~ PR35F38-hibridis nimuSze Catarebulkvlevas, mxolod am xelSekrulebis nawilSia gamyidvel-Ta pretenzia miwodebuli produqciis naklze samar-Tlebrivad vargisi da argumentirebuli.

89. rac Seexeba kasatoris Sedavebas mtkicebulebaTaSefasebis nawilSi, romelic Seexeba saqmeze mowmis saxiTdakiTxul pirTa axsna-ganmartebebs, romliTac gamyardaargumenti simindis saTesle masalis dapirebuli gaRvi-vebis unaris, mdgradobisa da mosavlianobis Sesaxeb. sa-kasacio palata aRniSnavs, rom vinaidan simindis danarCe-ni jiSebis uxarisxobasTan mimarTebiT sxva raime mtkice-buleba, rogoric iqneboda laboratoriuli kvleva an sxvadakvirveba, warmodgenili ar yofila, mxolod mowmeTa Cve-

185

nebebi am garemoebis dasadastureblad sakmarisi ar aris.amdenad, am nawilSic sakasacio pretenzia nawilobriv ga-saziarebelia.

90. amdenad, dadgenilia, rom saTesle simindi `p-is~PR35F38-hibridis 70 tomara 65000 marcvliani SefuTviT(240 lari) miewoda mesame myidvels da saqonlis fasi gani-sazRvra 16800 lariT, xolo 131 tomara saTesle masala65000 marcvliani SefuTviT (240 lari) miewoda pirvelmyidvels da miwodebuli simindis jiSis nawilSi saqonlisfasi ganisazRvra 31440 lariT. sakasacio palatas miaCnia,rom swored am nawilSi warmoeSoba xelSekrulebidan gas-vlis ufleba pirvel mosarCeles nawilobriv, xolo mesa-me mosarCeles _ srulad.

91. sakasacio palatas miaCnia, rom pirvelma da mesamemosarCeleebma SeZles miwodebuli nasyidobis sagnis na-wilSi saxelSekrulebo interesis ganuxorcieleblobisdadastureba. am daskvnis safuZvels iZleva dadgenili ga-remoebebi imis Sesaxeb, rom gamyidvelis mier myidveli-saTvis SeTavazebuli produqciis (nasyidobis sagani) upi-ratesobad dasaxelebuli iyo simindis maRali mosavlia-noba (mosavlianobis saSualo maCvenebeli iyo heqtarze10-12 tona. gamZleoba Cawolaze, gvalvagamZleoba da daa-vadebebisadmi mdgradoba. myidvelebis daintereseba damiwodebul produqciaze nasyidobis xelSekrulebis ga-formeba swored siminidis dasaxelebuli _ SeTavazebuliTvisebebiT iyo ganpirobebuli. Tumca, dadasturebulia,rom produqciis erT nawils (PR35F38 saxeobis saTesle ma-sala) gaaCnda imgvari nakli/wuni, rac produqciis am na-wilSi, myidvelebs warmouSobda xelSekrulebidan gas-vlis uflebas. ufro konkrtulad, ki, nasyidobis sagans(miwodebul produqcias) ar aRmoaCnda is Tvisebebi (niv-Tobrivi nakli), rac xelSekrulebis dadebis miznebisTvisiyo ganmsazRvreli myidvelisaTvis.

92. sakasacio palata aRniSnavs, rom xelSekrulebis da-debis momentidan mxareebi valdebulni arian SeudgnenxelSekrulebiT nakisri valdebulebebis Sesrulebas. maTar SeuZliaT calmxrivad Tqvan uari nakisri valdebule-bis Sesrulebaze. magram kanoniT gaTvaliswinebul Sem-TxvevaSi xelSekrulebis mxares ufleba aqvs gavides xel-Sekrulebidan da uari Tqvas nakisri valdebulebis Ses-rulebaze. xelSekrulebis erT-erTi monawilis SesaZ-

186

leblobas kanoniT gaTvaliswinebul SemTxvevebSi uariTqvas xelSekrulebis gagrZelebaze, xelSekrulebidangasvla ewodeba. igi saqarTvelos samoqalaqo kodeqsSigermaniis samoqalaqo kodeqsidanaa gadmoRebuli da bev-rad exmaureba evrogaerTianebis samarTals. xelSekrule-bidan gasvlis ufleba aRmWurveli uflebaa da gansxvave-biT moTxovnis uflebisagan, masze ar vrceldeba xan-dazmuloba. samoqalaqo kodeqsi da sxva kerZosamar-Tlebrivi kanonmdebloba Seicavs agreTve iseT normebs,romlebic gamoiyeneba moTxovnis safuZvliT gaTvalis-winebuli winapirobebis Semowmebisas da amdenad, asru-lebs damxmare funqcias. damxmare xasiaTis normebs gane-kuTvneba aseve uSualod samarTlebrivi Sedegis dam-fuZnebeli uflebis momwesrigebeli normebi, isini pirssamarTlebrivi Sedegis modificirebis uflebas aniWebsxelSekrulebis meore mxaris Tanxmobis arsebobis miuxe-davad. damfuZnebelia uSualo samarTlebrivi SedegiswarmomSobi ufleba, romelic pirs aniWebs uflebamosi-lebas, calmxrivi nebis gamovleniT warmoSvas, Secvalosan gaauqmos samarTlebrivi Sedegi. damfuZnebeli ufle-bis maregulirebeli normebis ZiriTadi Tavisebureba isaa,rom uflebamosili piris mier ufleba xorcieldeba nam-dvili, miRebasavaldebulo nebis gamovleniT. aseT dam-fuZnebel uflebaTa ricxvs miekuTvneba xelSekrulebi-dan gasvla, romelic sk-is 355-e muxlis Tanaxmad, xdebaxelSekrulebis meore mxarisaTvis SetyobinebiT. dam-fuZnebeli ufleba ganxorcielebulia anu Sesabamisi ne-bis gamovlena namdvilia im momentidan, rodesac igi xel-Sekrulebis meore mxares miuva, kerZod, moxvdeba mimRe-bis Zalauflebis sferoSi da am ukanasknels eqneba misiSinaarsis realurad ganxorcielebis SesaZlebloba. am uf-lebaTa gansxvavebuli statusi, cxadia, ar gamoricxavs maTganxorcielebas sasamarTlosaTvis mimarTvis gziT.

93. sakasacio palata aRniSnavs, rom xelSekrulebiTgaTvaliswinebuli valdebulebis Sesrulebis moTxovnamxareebis mxridan pirveladi moTxovnis xasiaTs atarebs,romlis Seusruleblobac iwvevs meoradi moTxovnis uf-lebis warmoSobas. am ukanasknels ki miekuTvneba xel-Sekrulebidan gasvlis moTxovna. xelSekrulebidan gas-vla gamoiyeneba mxolod kanoniT an mxareTa SeTanxmebiTzustad gansazRvrul SemTxvevebSi. amitom kanoni amom-

187

wuravad gansazRvravs xelSekrulebidan gasvlis safuZ-vlebsa da wess, kerZod, imas, Tu rodis SeuZlia xelSekru-lebis mxares moiTxovos xelSekrulebidan gasvla (ssk-is405-e, 352-e-359-e muxlebi). Tumca, es ar gamoricxavs, rommxareebi SeTanxmdnen xelSekrulebidan gasvlis damate-biT pirobebze. Tu mxareebi am uflebiT ar isargebleben,gamoiyeneba kanonis dispoziciuri normebi. xelSekrule-bidan gasvlis, rogorc meoradi moTxovnis uflebis sa-fuZvlebi SeiZleba daiyos materialur da formalur na-wilebad. materialurSi SeiZleba vigulisxmoT saxel-Sekrulebo valdebulebis Seusrulebloba, xolo forma-lurSi _ damatebiTi vadis daweseba da xelSekrulebazeuaris Tqmis Sesaxeb Setyobineba.

94. xelSekrulebidan gasvlis moTxovnis kanonismieriwinapirobebia: a) xelSekrulebis namdviloba (unda akma-yofilebdes garigebis namdvilobis zogad pirobebs); b)zogadi wesis mixedviT, movalis mxridan xelSekrulebismniSvnelovani (arsebiTi) darRveva (darRveva arsebiTi xa-siaTisaa, Tu movalis mxridan ZiriTadi valdebulebis dar-Rvevis gamo, faqtobrivi Sesrulebis daniSnulebisamebrgamoyeneba SeuZlebeli xdeba an ikargeba momavalSi misiSesrulebis imedi anda kreditors ekargeba Sesrulebi-sadmi interesi); g) xelSekrulebidan gasvlis Sesaxeb gan-cxadebis gakeTebiT monawile mTlianad gadis xelSekru-lebidan, radganac kanoniT dauSvebelia xelSekrulebi-dan nawilobrivi gasvla; d) miuxedavad valdebulebis mniS-vnelovani darRvevisa, movales ar SeuZlia kreditorsmosTxovos xelSekrulebis ZalaSi datoveba; e) valdebu-lebis darRvevisaTvis kreditori mTlianad an umTavre-sad ar aris pasuxismgebeli; v) moTxovnas ar upirispirde-ba Sesagebeli, romelic ukve warmodgenilia an wardgeni-li iqneba dauyovnebliv movalis mier, Tuki kreditoriuars ityvis xelSekrulebaze (magaliTad, Sesagebeli val-debulebis gaqviTvaze); z) saxezea kreditoris mier Sesa-gebeli iuridiuli moqmedeba _ xelSekrulebidan gasvli-saTvis mocemuli gonivruli vada, Tu xelSekrulebiT ase-Ti vada ar yofila dadgenili _ anda, Tu valdebulebisdarRvevis xasiaTidan gamomdinare, ar gamoiyeneba dama-tebiTi vada _ gafrTxileba.

95. saxelSekrulebo valdebulebis SeusruleblobaTavisTavad ar afuZnebs xelSekrulebidan gasvlis ufle-

188

bas. Seusrulebloba garkveuli obieqturi masStabiT un-da gaizomos. zogadad, xelSekrulebidan gasvlis uflebawarmoiSoba, miuxedavad imisa, Tu ra tipis valdebulebadairRva. valdebuleba, romlis darRvevac xelSekrule-bidan gasvlis safuZvels warmoadgens, unda iyos namdvi-li, vadamosuli da upretenzio. Tu valdebulebebi jerkidev ar aris Sesasrulebeli, mxare ver gava xelSekru-lebidan, radgan mas ar eqneba amis safuZveli. Tumca, sk-is 405-e muxlis me-4 nawiliT gaTvaliswinebul SemTxve-vebSi, mxares SeuZlia Sesrulebis vadis dadgomamde ga-nacxados uari xelSekrulebaze. xelSekrulebidan gas-vlis piroba valdebulebis Seusrulebloba an arajero-vani Sesrulebaa. Tu movalem valdebuleba Seasrula ankreditorma SeTanxmebulis nacvlad sxva Sesruleba mii-Ro (datio pro solutio), kreditori xelSekrulebidan ver gava.kreditors aseve ezRudeba xelSekrulebidan gasvlis uf-leba, Tu movalem waradgina an dauyovnebliv warmoadgenspretenzias (Sesagebels). analogiuri wesi gamoiyeneba ma-Sinac, rodesac movales SeuZlia valdebulebis gaqviTvada igi am uflebas kreditoris mxridan xelSekrulebidangasvlis moTxovnis dayenebisTanave gamoiyenebs (dolo agit,qui petit, quod statim redditurus est). xelSekrulebidan gasvlawarmoSobs monawileTa Soris axal valdebulebas: miRebu-li Sesruleba da sargebeli mxareebma erTmaneTs unda da-ubrunon.

96. ssk-is 405-e muxlis pirveli da me-2 nawilebi ganam-tkiceben xelSekrulebis erT-erTi mxaris uflebas uariTqvas xelSekrulebaze, Tu meore mxare arRvevs xelSekru-lebiT nakisr valdebulebas. valdebulebis darRvevis Sem-TxvevaSi kreditors SeuZlia movales dauwesos damatebi-Ti vada xelSekrulebiT gaTvaliswinebuli pirobebis Se-sasruleblad. rac ganamtkicebs faqts, rom misTvis mTava-ria valdebulebis Sesruleba da ara pasuxismgebloba Se-usruleblobisaTvis. xelSekrulebidan gasvla, romeliciwvevs valdebulebiTsamarTlebrivi urTierTobis anuli-rebas, ar SeiZleba ganxorcieldes movalisaTvis valebu-lebis Sesasruleblad xelmeore SesaZleblobis micemis ga-reSe, raTa amiT Tavidan iqnes acilebuli xelSekrulebisanulireba. swored amitom, kanoni iTvaliswinebs SemTxve-vebs, rodesac valdebulebis Sesasruleblad movales mie-cema damatebiTi vada, am dros kreditori sargeblobs Sez-

189

Ruduli uflebiT gavides xelSekrulebidan, xolo mova-lis interesebi ki garkveulwilad daculia (analogiura-daa sakiTxi gadawyvetili germaniis samoqalaqo kodeqsis323-e paragrafiT). valdebulebis xasiaTidan gamomdinare,SesaZlebelia, rom damatebiTi vadis gansazRvras gauTa-nabrdes gafrTxileba, romliTac kreditori avaldebu-lebs movales Seasrulos xelSekrulebiT nakisri valde-buleba. gafrTxileba erTgvari Sexsenebaa vadamosuli val-debulebis Sesasruleblad. ssk-is 405-e muxlis me-2 nawi-li iTvaliswinebs gamonaklis SemTxvevebs, rodesac ar arissaWiro valdebuli pirisaTvis arc damatebiTi vadis dawe-seba da arc gafrTxileba. saxelSekrulebo urTierTobeb-Si xelSekrulebidan gasvlis formis gansazRvra mniSvne-lovania mxareTa Semdgomi samarTlebrivi urTierTobebi-saTvis da gansazRvravs am uflebis ganxorcielebis samar-Tlebriv marTebulebas. ssk-is mixedviT, xelSekrulebidangasvla xorcieldeba meore mxarisaTvis Setyobinebis gziT.xelSekrulebidan gasvlis Sesaxeb Setyobineba ZalaSia masSemdeg, rac gansazRvruli winapirobebi iqneba dakmayofi-lebuli. ssk-is 405-e muxli detalurad awesrigebs xel-Sekrulebidan gasvlis moTxovnis uflebis warmoSobis wi-napirobebsa da gamonaklisebs, iseve, rogorc aRniSnuliuflebis warmoSobis damabrkolebel garemoebebs (xel-Sekrulebidan gasvlis safuZvlebze sakasacio palatis ze-moaRniSnuli msjeloba mocemulia saqmeSi #as-1003-924-2017, 01 dekemberi, 2017 weli).

97. ZiriTadi saxelSekrulebo miznis ganuxorcieleb-lobisa da xelSekrulebidan gasvlis uflebis gamoyene-bis miznebisaTvis ixileT agreTeve, susg #as-459-438-2015,07 oqtomberi, 2015 weli.

98. rac Seexeba mopasuxis Sedavebas xandazmulobis sa-kiTxsa da agreTve, im sakiTxTan mimarTebiT, rom myidve-lebi warmoadgendnen mewarme subieqtebs (am ganCinebis p-11, 55), sakasacio palatas miaCnia, rom am nawilSi, kasator-ma ver warmoadgina dasabuTebuli sakasacio pretenzia,Sdr: susg-ebi #as-1189-1119-2015, 23 marti, 2016 weli; #as-146-142-2016 23 marti, 2016 weli.

99. amdenad, sakasacio palatas miaCnia, rom saqmezedadgenili faqtobrivi garemoebebi iZleoda mxolodPR35F38-hibridis nimuSze warmoSobili xelSekrulebidangasvlis uflebas, xolo danarCeni hibridis nimuSebze,

190

xelSekrulebidan gasvlis ufleba warmoSobilad ar miiC-neva saTanado mtkicebulebebis ararsebobis gamo.

100. Sesabamisad, sakasacio palatas miaCnia, rom moT-xovna sworad dakmayofilda nasyidobis xelSekrulebdangasvlisa da gamyidvelisaTvis pirveli myidvelis sasar-geblod nasyidobis xelSekrulebis safasuris angariSSigadasaxdeli 31440 laris, xolo mesame myidvelisaTvis 16800 laris anazRaurebis nawilSi. amdenad, am nawilSi, sa-kasacio saCivris dakmayofilebis winapirobebi ar arse-bobs, xolo vinaidan sakasacio palatis mosazrebiT, hib-ridis danarCen nimuSebze: PR38R92 da PR35P12 ar iyo war-moSobili xelSekrulebidan gasvlis ufleba, amitom un-da gauqmdes Tbilisis saapelacio sasamarTlos samoqala-qo saqmeTa palatis 2017 wlis 24 noembris ganCineba, rom-liTac ucvlelad iqna datovebuli Tbilisis saqalaqo sa-samarTlos samoqalaqo saqmeTa kolegiis 2016 wlis 13 oq-tombris gadawyvetileba nasyidobis xelSekrulebidangasvlisa da gamyidvelisaTvis pirveli myidvelis sasar-geblod nasyidobis xelSekrulebis safasuris angariSSi11 760 laris anazRaurebis, aseve, dasaxelebuli safuZ-vliT meore myidvelis sasargeblod 18 000 laris anazRa-urebisa da meoTxe myidvelis sasargeblod 8 640 larisanazRaurebis nawilSi.

101. sssk-is 53-e muxlis safuZvelze ki, sasamarTlo xar-jebi mxareTa Soris Semdegnaiarad unda ganawildes: kasa-tors unda aunazRaurdes sarCelis uaryofili nawilisproporciulad p. d-is mier 1620 lari da l. g-as mier 777lari. xolo imis gaTvaliswinebiT, rom m. m-is sarCeli dak-mayofilebulia nawilobriv, am nawilSi, mis mier pirveliinstanciis sasamarTloSi gadaxdili saxelmwifo baJi un-da gamoakldes sarCelis uaryofis nawilSi kasatoris mi-er gaRebul xarjebs da sabolood, mis mier kasatorisaT-vis gadasaxdeli Tanxa unda ganisazRvros 115 lariT.




1. ss `saqarTvelos s-is m-is k-iis~ sakasacio saCivari

191

dakmayofildes nawilobriv;2. nawilobriv gauqmdes Tbilisis saapelacio sasamar-

Tlos samoqalaqo saqmeTa palatis 2017 wlis 06 ivnisis gan-Cineba Tbilisis saqalaqo sasamarTlos samoqalaqo saqme-Ta kolegiis 2016 wlis 13 oqtombris gadawyvetilebis uc-vlelad datovebis Sesaxeb da miRebul iqnes axali gadaw-yvetileba;

3. m. m-is sarCeli xelSekrulebidan gasvlisa da ss `sa-qarTvelos s-is m-is k-iisaTvis~ 31440 laris dakisrebisSesaxeb dakmayofildes, xolo sarCeli xelSekrulebidangasvlisa da ss `saqarTvelos s-is m-is k-iisaTvis~ 11 760laris dakisrebis nawilSi ar dakmayofildes;

4. b. a-is sarCeli xelSekrulebidan gasvlisa da ss `sa-qarTvelos s-is m-is k-iisaTvis~ 16 800 laris dakisrebisSesaxeb dakmayofildes;

5. p. d-is sarCeli xelSekrulebidan gasvlisa da ss `sa-qarTvelos s-is m-is k-iisaTvis~ 18 000 laris dakisrebisSesaxeb ar dakmayofildes;

6. l. g-as sarCeli xelSekrulebidan gasvlisa da ss `sa-qarTvelos s-is m-is k-iisaTvis~ 8640 laris dakisrebis Se-saxeb ar dakmayofildes;

7. ucvlelad darCes Tbilisis saapelacio sasamarTlossamoqalaqo saqmeTa palatis 2017 wlis 06 ivnisis ganCine-ba Tbilisis saqalaqo sasamarTlos samoqalaqo saqmeTa ko-legiis 2016 wlis 13 oqtombris gadawyvetilebis sarezo-lucio nawilis me-2, me-4, me-6, me-8 da me-11 punqtebis Za-laSi datovebis Sesaxeb;

8. m. m-s ss `saqarTvelos s-is m-is k-iis~ sasargebloddaekisros saxelmwifo baJis anazRaureba 115 laris ode-nobiT;

9. p. d-s ss `saqarTvelos s-is m-is k-iis~ sasargebloddaekisros saxelmwifo baJis anazRaureba 1620 laris ode-nobiT;

10. l. g-as ss `saqarTvelos s-is m-is k-iis~ sasargebloddaekisros saxelmwifo baJis anazRaureba 777 laris ode-nobiT;

11. sakasacio sasamarTlos gadawyvetileba sabolooada ar gasaCivrdeba.

192



#as-945-895-2015 14 marti, 2016 w., q. Tbilisi

saqarTvelos uzenaesi sasamarTlos samoqalaqosaqmeTa palataSemadgenloba: n. baqaquri (Tavmjdomare, momxsenebeli),

z. ZlieriSvili,b. alaviZe

davis sagani: xelSekrulebidan gasvla, Tanxis dakis-reba, zianis anazRaureba

aRwerilobiTi nawili:1. c. s-em sarCeli aRZra sasamarTloSi Sps `s-os~ mimarT

da moiTxova 2008 wlis 16 maisis uZravi qonebis nasyido-bis winare da 2010 wlis 23 Tebervlis uZravi qonebis nas-yidobis xelSekrulebebis Sewyveta, sacxovrebeli far-Tis SesaZenad gadaxdili Tanxis _ 38 416 aSS dolaris dab-runeba da miyenebuli zianis anazRaureba 46 193 aSS dola-ris odenobiT Semdegi dasabuTebiT:

2. mosarCelis ganmartebiT, mxareTa Soris 2008 wlis 16maiss daido uZravi qonebis nasyidobis winare xelSekru-leba, romliTac mopasuxe kisrulobda valdebulebas 2008wlis dekembrisaTvis daesrulebina da mosarCelisaTvisgadaeca q. TbilisSi, o-is quCa #..-Si mdebare 68.6 kv.m sac-xovrebeli farTi, xelSekrulebiT SeTanxmebuli pirobe-biT, TeTri karkasi. erTi kv.m farTis Rirebuleba ganisaz-Rvra 560 aSS dolariT, sul mosarCeles unda gadaexada 38416 aSS dolari.

3. mosarCelem Tanxis gadaxdis valdebuleba Seasrula2008 wlis 16 maiss da Tanxa srulad gadaixada.

4. 2010 wlis 23 Tebervals mxareTa Soris daido nasyi-dobis xelSekruleba imave qonebaze. sacxovrebeli biniseqspluataciaSi Sesvlis vada ganisazRvra 2010 wlis de-kembriT. mosarCelis ganmartebiT, amJamad mSeneblobadasrulebuli ar aris da arc raime samuSaoebi mimdinare-obs. mopasuxem xelSekrulebiT nakisri valdebuleba arSeasrula, ris gamoc masTan samarTlebrivi urTierTobis

193

gagrZelebam azri dakarga.5. mosarCeles farTis SesaZenad ss `s-dan~ aRebuli aqvs

miznobrivi sesxi 38 500 aSS dolari 14%-iani wliuri sap-rocento ganakveTiT, 15 wlis vadiT. amJamad dafaruliasesxis ZiriTadi Tanxis nawili _ 20 642.46 aSS dolari dagadaxdilia Sesabamisi sargebeli _ 21 190.42 aSS dolari.sesxis ZiriTadi Tanxidan gadasaxdeli darCa 17 857.54 aSSdolari da sargebeli _ 11 643.48 aSS dolari, sul 29 549.40aSS dolari.

6. sesxis uzrunvelsayofad ipoTekiT daitvirTa mo-sarCelis axloblis uZravi qoneba mdebare, q. Tbilisi, k-is ..... uZravi qoneba savaldebulo wesiT dazRveulia sa-dazRvevo kompania à-Si~ da wliuri sadazRvevo premia Se-adgens 124 aSS dolars, sul 15 wlis ganmavlobaSi sadaz-Rvevo premiis saxiT mosarCeles gadasaxdeli aqvs 1860 do-lari. amJamad gadaxdili aqvs 6 wlis dazRvevis Tanxa, 740aSS dolari, gadasaxdeli aqvs 1120 aSS dolari.

7. mosarCelis gancxadebiT, mSeneblobis dausruleb-lobis gamo man ver miiRo Semosavali 11 500 aSS dolari,rasac igi miiRebda im SemTxvevaSi, Tu 2008 wlis dekem-berSi dasrulebul binas gaaqiravebda 2012 wlis oq-tombris Tvemde, TveSi saSualod 250 aSS dolarad.

8. mosarCelis ganmartebiT, mopasuxe Sps `s-o~ regis-trirebulia movaleTa reestrSi, dayadaRebuli aqvs uZ-ravi qoneba da angariSebi, ar mimdinareobs samSeneblo sa-muSaoebi. Sesabamisad, arsebobs safuZvliani varaudi, rommopasuxis mimarT daiwyeba gakotrebis saqmis warmoeba,rac kidev ufro met zians miayenebs mosarCeles.

9. mopasuxem sarCeli ar cno da ganmarta, rom ar arse-bobda mosarCelis mier xelSekrulebaze uaris Tqmis sa-fuZveli, radgan mosarCelesTan arsebuli xelSekrule-bebiT gaTvaliswinebuli sacxovrebeli bina aSenebulia,miyvanilia garigebiT gaTvaliswinebul mdgomareobamdeda SesaZlebeli iyo misiT sargebloba.

10. Tbilisis saqalaqo sasamarTlos 2014 wlis 11 dekem-bris sasamarTlo sxdomaze mosarCelem daazusta sarCe-li da zianisa da miuRebeli Semosavlis saxiT nacvlad 46193 aSS dolarisa moiTxova mopasuxisaTvis 39 424.59 aSSdolaris dakisreba, saidanac zianis Tanxa gansazRvra 27924.59 aSS dolariT, xolo miuRebeli Semosavlis _ 11 500aSS dolariT (ix. 11.12.2014 wlis sasamarTlo sxdomis oqmi

194

15:06:29sT-16:08:42sT.).11. Tbilisis saqalaqo sasamarTlos samoqalaqo saqme-

Ta kolegiis 2015 wlis 16 ianvris gadawyvetilebiT c. s-issarCeli dakmayofilda: Sewyda c. s-esa da Sps `s-os~ Soris2008 wlis 16 maiss gaformebuli winare xelSekruleba; Sew-yda mxareTa Soris 2010 wlis 23 Tebervals gaformebulinasyidobis xelSekruleba; Sps `s-os~ c. s-is sasargebloddaekisra sacxovrebeli farTis SesaZenad gadaxdili 38 416aSS dolaris ukan dabruneba; Sps ̀ s-os~ c. s-is sasargebloddaekisra zianis anazRaureba 27 924.59 aSS dolaris ode-nobiT; Sps `s-os~ c. s-is sasargeblod daekisra 11 500 aSSdolaris gadaxda miuRebeli Semosavlis asanazRaureb-lad.

12. saqalaqo sasamarTlos gadawyvetileba saapelaciowesiT gaasaCivra Sps `s-om~.

13. Tbilisis saapelacio sasamarTlos samoqalaqo saq-meTa palatis 2015 wlis 31 ivlisis gadawyvetilebiT Sps`s-os~ saapelacio saCivari nawilobriv dakmayofilda: Tbi-lisis saqalaqo sasamarTlos samoqalaqo saqmeTa kolegi-is 2015 wlis 16 ianvris gadawyvetileba nawilobriv Seic-vala; Tbilisis saqalaqo sasamarTlos samoqalaqo saqme-Ta kolegiis 2015 wlis 16 ianvris gadawyvetilebis me-2,me-3, me-4 da me-6 punqtebi darCa ucvleli; Tbilisis saqa-laqo sasamarTlos samoqalaqo saqmeTa kolegiis 2015 wlis16 ianvris gadawyvetilebis pirveli da me-5 punqtebis Sec-vliT miRebul iqna axali gadawyvetileba; Sps `s-os~ c. s-is sasargeblod daekisra 2013 wlis 17 ivnisidan 38 416 aSSdolaris anazRaurebamde 38 416 aSS dolaris yovelwliu-ri 14%-is anazRaureba; Sps `s-os~ c. s-is sasargeblod da-ekisra 2013 wlis 17 ivnisidan 11 500 aSS dolaris anazRau-rebamde 11 500 aSS dolaris yovelwliuri 10%-is anazRa-ureba; gadawyvetilebis 4.1.1 da 4.1.2 qvepunqtebiT gan-sazRvruli sargeblis jamuri odenobis maqsimaluri zRva-ri ganisazRvra 27 924 aSS dolariT.

14. saapelacio sasamarTlom dadgenilad miiCnia Sem-degi faqtobrivi garemoebebi:

15. 2008 wlis 16 maiss c. s-esa da Sps `s-os~ Soris daidouZravi qonebis nasyidobis winare xelSekruleba, romlissafuZvelzec, samomavlod unda gaformebuliyo binis nas-yidobis xelSekruleba uZrav qonebaze, mdebare q. Tbili-si, me-.... l-is dasaxleba, o-is quCa #..., bina ..., farTi _ 68,6

195

kv.m, sarTuli _ ....16. c. s-em Sps `s-os~ gadauxada nasyidobis fasi, 38 416

dolari.17. 2010 wlis 23 Tebervals aRniSnul binaze mxareTa

Soris daido nasyidobis xelSekruleba, romlis Tanxmad,saxli eqspluataciaSi unda miRebuliyo 2010 wlis dekem-berSi. mosarCeles unda gadascemoda bina Semdeg mdgoma-reobaSi: gare fasadi SeRebili, Selesili, metaloplastma-sis kar-fanjriT, sadarbazo keTilmowyobili, lifti da-montaJebuli, centraluri komunikacia adgilamde miyva-nili, Sida tixrebi, liTonis Sesasvleli kari, Sida eleq-trogayvaniloba, kedlebi Selesili gajiT, ezo keTil-mowyobili.

18. 2008 wlis 15 maiss, ss `saqarTvelos banksa~ da c. s-esSoris daido sabanko momsaxurebis xelSekruleba, romli-Tac mosarCeles gaexsna sakredito xazi 40 000 aSS dola-ris farglebSi da uzrunvelyofis saxiT ipoTekiT dait-virTa z. a-is kuTvnili uZravi qoneba. am xelSekrulebisfarglebSi c. s-em, sacxovrebeli binis SesaZenad miiRosesxad 38 500 aSS dolari, 180 Tvis vadiT, wliuri 14%-ianisargeblis daricxviT. jamSi sargeblis saxiT c. s-es gada-saxdeli aqvs 26 064 aSS dolari. ipoTekis sagnis dazRve-visTvis mosarCeles gadasaxdili aqvs jamSi 1 840 aSS do-lari kompania à-s~ sasargeblod.

19. saapelacio sasamarTlom gaiziara Tbilisis saqala-qo sasamarTlos mier dadgenili faqtobrivi garemoebaimis Taobaze, rom mosarCeles bina gadaeca ara im saxiT,rac mxareTa Soris xelSekrulebiT iyo gansazRvruli. pa-latam aRniSna, rom miTiTebuli faqtis dasadgenad, sasa-marTlom swori Sefaseba misca saqmeSi warmodgenil eq-spertizis daskvnas, romlis mixedviTac, obieqtze ar arisSesrulebuli gare metaloplastmasis kar-fanjris mow-yobis, Sesasvleli liTonis karis montaJis, Sida eleqtro-gayvanilobisa da gajiT lesvis samuSaoebi, ar aris dasru-lebuli korpusis Sida kibe da korpuss ara aqvs lifti.

20. saapelacio palatam ar gaiziara apelantis mosaz-reba imis Taobaze, rom ar arsebobs xelSekrulebidan gas-vlis safuZveli, vinaidan araarsebiTi nawili darCa Sesas-rulebeli, xolo ZiriTadi samuSaoebi Sesrulebulia. pa-latis azriT, sapatiod ver iqneba miCneuli is garemoe-bac, rom mSeneblobis gaWianureba gamowveuli iyo 2008

196

wlis saomari movlenebis negatiuri SedegebiT, rac mZi-med aisaxa samSeneblo seqtorze. sasamarTlos ganmarte-biT, miuxedavad imisa, rom saxelmwifos mxridan garkveu-li SeRavaTebi gakeTda samSeneblo seqtoris mimarT, amanar SeiZleba gamoiwvios kompaniis kontrahentebis mxri-dan garkveul moTxovnebze uaris Tqmis valdebuleba. pa-latam yuradReba miaqcia im garemoebas, rom 2010 wlis 23Tebervals, rodesac mxareebma dades ZiriTadi xelSekru-leba, SesaZlebeli iyo gaeTvaliswinebinaT garemoebebi,romlebic 2008 wlis Semdgom warmoiSva, magram maT gaime-ores winare xelSekrulebaSi aRniSnuli pirobebi da ikis-res igive valdebulebebi, rac 2008 wlis maisSi. amasTan,sasamarTlom usafuZvlobis gamo ar gaiziara apelantisargumenti im TvalsazrisiTac, rom igi konkretulad verasaxelebda raime axal pirobas, an vadas, romlis gaTva-liswinebiTac SesaZlebeli iqneboda saxelSekrulebo ur-TierTobis SenarCuneba. xelSekrulebiT nakisri valde-buleba apelants unda Seesrulebina 2010 wlis dekemberSida samuSaoebi davis ganxilvis drosac (2015w.) ar iyo das-rulebuli. mxolod is faqti, rom SenobaSi lifti ar arisdamontaJebuli palatam xelSekrulebidan gasvlisTvissakmaris winapirobad miiCnia imis gaTvaliswinebiT, rom ga-dasacemi bina me-13 sarTulze mdebareobs. amasTan, aR-niSna, rom saxelSekrulebo urTierTobis gagrZelebis da-mabrkolebel garemoebas Sps-s ekonomikuri mdgomareo-bac warmoadgenda. saapelacio sasamarTloSi warmodgeni-li mtkicebulebebiT sasamarTlom dadasturebulad mi-iCnia, rom kompanias aqvs davalianeba da aRricxulia mo-valeTa reestrSi. aRniSnuli garemoebebi ki sakmaris sa-fuZvels warmoadgenda samoqalaqo kodeqsis 405-e muxlisTanaxmad, xelSekrulebidan gasvlisaTvis. aqedan gamom-dinare, palatam samoqalaqo kodeqsis 352-e da 405-e mux-lebis Sesabamisad, safuZvlianad miiCnia mosarCelis moT-xovna xelSekrulebidan gasvlis Sedegad gadacemuli Tan-xis, 38 416 aSS dolaris dakisrebis Sesaxeb.

21. sasamarTlom ixelmZRvanela samoqalaqo kodeqsis407-e, 408-e muxlebiT da ar gaiziara Tbilisis saqalaqosasamarTlos mosazreba zianis odenobis gaangariSebis na-wilSi. saapelacio palatis ganmartebiT, zianis anazRau-rebiT aRdgenil unda iqnas is viTareba, rac iarsebebdaxelSekrulebiT nakisri valdebulebis jerovani Sesru-

197

lebis (anu xelSekrulebidan gasvlis winapirobebis arar-sebobis) SemTxvevaSi. zianis odenobis aRniSnuli princi-piT daTvlas palatam safuZvlad daudo Semdegi garemoe-bebi:

22. dadgenilia, rom c. s-em 2013 wlis 22 aprils mimarTakompanias da dainteresda mSeneblobis mimdinareobiT dadasrulebis perspeqtiviT, xolo 2013 wlis 17 ivniss sar-Celis wardgeniT gamoxata neba xelSekrulebidan damate-biTi vadis dawesebis gareSe gasvlis Sesaxeb, rac zemoaR-niSnuli msjelobis Tanaxmad, marTlzomier qmedebad Se-fasda sasamarTlos mier.

23. saapelacio sasamarTlos azriT, samoqalaqo kodeq-sis 408-e muxlis pirveli nawiliT gansazRvruli zianisanazRaurebis mavaldebulebel garemoebad miCneul un-da iqnas mosarCelisTvis xelSekrulebiT gansazRvrulimdgomareobiT da vadaSi sagnis gadaucemloba. xelSekru-lebis mixedviT, mosarCeles bina unda mieRo 2010 wlis de-kemberSi. Sesabamisad, palata daeTanxma Tbilisis saqala-qo sasamarTlos daskvnas imis Taobaze, rom 2013 wlis 17ivnisamde binis gaqiravebis Sedegad mosarCele miiRebda11 500 aSS dolars qiris saxiT, rac samoqalaqo kodeqsissafuZvelze unda dakisreboda mopasuxes.

24. saapelacio sasamarTlom ar gaiziara apelantis pre-tenzia qiris odenobasTan dakavSirebiT da ganmarta, romkonkretuli faqtobrivi garemoebis dasadgenad sasamar-Tlos specialuri codna ar gaaCnia, ris gamoc igi xel-mZRvanelobs specialistis daskvniT. saqmeze warmodge-nili auditoruli daskvniT sasamarTlom daadgina mSene-bare da ara dasrulebuli saxis binis qiris odenoba. sxvamtkicebuleba, rac gaabaTilebda auditorul daskvnas, pa-latis ganmartebiT, mopasuxes ar warmoudgenia. amdenad,saapelacio sasamarTlom miiCnia, rom samoqalaqo kodeq-sis 411-e muxlis safuZvelze, pirveli instanciis sasamar-Tlom marTebulad daakisra mopasuxes miuRebeli Semo-savlis saxiT 11500 aSS dolari.

25. palatam aRniSna, rom 2013 wlis 17 ivniss, xelSekru-lebidan gasvlisas mxareebs valdebuleba gaaCndaT erTma-neTisTvis daebrunebinaT xelSekrulebis safuZvelze mi-Rebuli Sesruleba da sargebeli. Sesabamisad, mopasuxesc. s-isTvis 38 416 aSS dolaris dabrunebis valdebulebaam dros warmoeSva. aRniSnuli Tanxis droulad daubru-

198

neblobiT mosarCeles miadga ziani, rac am periodidan ses-xis sargeblis odenobiT unda ganisazRvros. saapelaciopalatam Tbilisis saqalaqo sasamarTlos msgavsad yurad-Reba gaamaxvila im garemoebaze, rom 38416 aSS dolarzeSps `s-om~ gasca invoisi ss `s-ze~, c. s-is binis safasurismisaRebad. aRniSnuli garemoeba, sasamarTlos azriT, iZ-leva imis varaudis safuZvels, rom kompaniisTvis cnobi-li unda yofiliyo binis kreditiT SeZenis Sesaxeb, amde-nad ziani, romelic miadga c. s-es gadaxdili Tanxis drou-li daubruneblobiT, Sps `s-osTvis~ savaraudo zians war-moadgens da ar arsebobs am pasuxismgeblobisgan mopasu-xis gaTavisuflebis winapiroba im motiviT rom ziani kom-paniisTvis ar iyo mosalodneli da savaraudo (samoqala-qo kodeqsis 412-e muxli).

26. saapelacio sasamarTlom miiCnia, rom 2013 wlis 17ivniss, rodesac mosarCelem mopasuxis mier valdebule-bis darRvevis gamo xelSekrulebidan gasvlis neba gamo-xata, mas gauCnda gadaxdili Tanxis dabrunebis ufleba,xolo Sps-s misi gadaxdis valdebuleba. am valdebulebisSesruleba mosarCeles Tavidan aacilebda im zians, rome-lic mas miadga 2013 wlis 17 ivnisidan sabanko procentissaxiT. Sesabamisad, xelSekrulebis safuZvelze gadaxdi-li 38416 aSS dolaris dabrunebamde, mopasuxes unda da-kisreboda mosarCelis sasargeblod am Tanxis wliuri 14%-is anazRaureba.

27. palatis mosazrebiT, zianis saxiT mopasuxes aseveunda dakisreboda 2010 wlis dekembridan 2013 wlis 17 iv-nisamde miuRebeli qiris 11 500 aSS dolaris wliuri 10%(anabris daaxloebiTi saprocento odenoba). aRniSnuliTanxis dabrunebis valdebuleba unda dakisreboda mopa-suxes xelSekrulebidan gasvlisas gadasaxdeli Tanxis _miuRebeli qiris odenobis droulad (2013 wlis 17 ivniss)daubruneblobis gamo da igi unda gagrZelebuliyo 11 500aSS dolaris dabrunebamde.

28. saapelacio sasamarTlom ixelmZRvanela samoqala-qo saproceso kodeqsis 248-e muxliT da miiCnia, rom mo-sarCelis moTxovna 38 416 aSS dolarisa da 11 500 aSS do-laris anazRaurebis Taobaze unda dakmayofildes sru-lad, xolo yovelwliuri sargeblis dakisrebis nawilSimoTxovnis zeda zRvari unda ganisazRvros araumetes 27924 aSS dolariT.

199

29. saapelacio sasamarTlos gadawyvetilebaze Sps `s-om~ Seitana sakasacio saCivari da moiTxova gasaCivrebu-li gadawyvetilebis gauqmeba da axali gadawyvetilebismiRebiT sarCelis dakmayofilebaze uaris Tqma SemdegidasabuTebiT:

30. sasamarTlom arasworad daadgina faqtobrivi gare-moeba imis Sesaxeb, rom TiTqos s-osTvis cnobili iyo c. s-is mier aRebuli sesxebis Sesaxeb.

31. kasatoris gancxadebiT, samSeneblo kompanias hyav-da asobiT klienti aTobiT obieqtze, qalbatoni c. s-ismsgavsad Zalian bevr maTgans (maT Soris potenciursac)invoisi gahqonda kompaniidan, saidanac mxolod 3%-s Tuumtkicdeboda sesxi, isic mSenebare farTebis uzrunvel-yofis xarjze. SesaZloa, mosarCelem marTlac aRebulisesxiT iyida mSenebare bina, Tumca zianis anazRaurebisdros aRniSnuli garemoeba ar SeiZleba iqnas gamoyenebu-li, vinaidan kompaniisaTvis ar iyo mosalodneli. igi ewi-naaRmdegeba samarTliani sasamarTlos erTgvarovan prin-cipebs. saxelmwifos midgoma 2008 wlamde dawyebuli mSe-neblobebis mimarT naTelia, Tumca sasamarTlo cdilobsmxolod samSeneblo kompanias ahkidos sruli pasuxis-mgebloba, vinaidan erTi mxare mosamarTlea.

32. sakasacio saCivris avtoris gancxadebiT, sasamar-Tlom saTanadod ar gamoikvlia faqtobrivi garemoebebida Sesabamisad, araswori samarTlebrivi Sefaseba miscamaT.

33. kasatoris ganmartebiT, xelSekrulebis arsebiTipirobebis darRvevas adgili ar hqonia. mSenebloba daas-rula kompaniam droulad, gadaxura igi da yvela Sida ko-munikacia moawyo. rac Seexeba mopirkeTebis samuSaoebs,sxdomaze naTlad gacxadda, rom erT TveSi SesaZlebeliamisi gakeTeba, Tu mxares xelSekrulebidan gasvla ar surs.mosaxleobis didi nawili ukve cxovrobs korpusSi. lif-tis damontaJebis sakiTxi ki unda gadawydes uaxloes mo-mavalSi q. Tbilisis meriasTan erTad.

34. sakasacio saCivris avtoris gancxadebiT, kompaniammSeneblobisTvis daxarja 9 milioni aSS dolaramde dadarCenili mosapirkeTebeli samuSaoebisTvis saWiroa sul350 000 aSS dolari. am fonze mosarCelis pretenzia, romTiTqos man dakarga valdebulebis darCenili nawilis Ses-rulebisadmi interesi, absurdulia. sasamarTlom moce-

200

mul SemTxvevaSi arasworad gamoiyena samoqalaqo kodeq-sis 405-e muxli. sasamarTlos aRniSnuli logikiT saqar-TveloSi vercerTi samSeneblo kompania ver daasruleb-da mSneblobas, Tuki yvela klientis sasargeblod daekis-reboda ormagi xarjebis gadaxda. amrigad, c. s-is mier aRe-buli sesxi da sxva qonebiT uzrunvelyofa ver gaxdebodakompaniis mier anazRaurebis sagani. sasamarTlos unda em-sjela `Savi karkasis~ Caubareblobis SemTxvevaSi ra zianimiadga mxares.

35. sasamarTlom arasworad Seafasa samoqalaqo kodeq-sis 411-e muxli da arasworad gamoiangariSa miuRebeli Se-mosavlis odenoba. Tuki s-e gadis xelSekrulebidan, ga-urkvevelia ra sargebelzea saubari. Tuki kompanias ekis-reba miuRebeli Semosavali, raSic s-em Tanxa gadaixada daunda gadaexada kidec, ratom ekisreba Sps-s es Tanxebi.sasamarTlos gadawyvetileba mTlianad arRvevs aqamde ar-sebul praqtikas.

36. mosarCelem warmoadgina eqspertis daskvna dasru-lebuli da garemontebuli (sacxovreblad vargisi) binisgaqiravebasTan dakavSirebiT, maSin rodesac s-es unda ga-dascemoda `Savi karkasi~ da TiTqmis binis naxevarze metifasi unda daexarja mis sacxovrebel doneze gasaremon-teblad. sasamarTlom ki qiris odenoba gansazRvra sulsxva mdgomareobaSi myof binaze. amasTan, aRsaniSnavia, romeqspertizis mier binis Sefasebis Semdgom dolaris kur-sma moimata 30 %-iT, rac sayovelTaod cnobilia (1 aSS do-lari 1.65-dan 2.40-mde gaizarda). sasamarTlom sayovel-Taod cnobili movlenac mosamarTlis sasargeblod Sefa-sebis miRma datova da gaiziara saqmesTan kavSiris ar mqo-ne eqspertis daskvna. mocemul SemTxvevaSi mtkicebistvirTi mosarCeles ekuTvnis da mas unda warmoedgina imqonebis Sefaseba, rac unda mieRo da ara gaberili da mot-yuebiT saqmeSi Cadebuli dokumentebi.

37. saqarTvelos uzenaesi sasamarTlos 2015 wlis 12 oq-tombris ganCinebiT Sps `s-os~ sakasacio saCivari miRebuliqna, warmoebaSi, samoqalaqo saproceso kodeqsis 391-emuxlis mixedviT, dasaSvebobis Sesamowmeblad.

38. 2016 wlis 18 ianvars saqarTvelos uzenaesi sasamar-Tlos samoqalaqo saqmeTa palatas gancxadebiT momarTakasatorma da ganmarta, rom igi amcirebs moTxovnas 38 416aSS dolariT. Sesabamisad, Tuki c. s-es ar surs masze re-

201

gistrirebuli binis datoveba, aRniSnuli bina unda gada-vides Sps `s-os~ sakuTrebaSi, xolo Sps `s-o~ Tanaxmaa da-ubrunos c. s-es mis mier Setanili Tanxa (38 416 aSS dola-ri).

39. saqarTvelos uzenaesi sasamarTlos samoqalaqo saq-meTa palatis 2016 wlis 8 Tebervlis ganCinebiT Sps `s-os~gancxadeba dakmayofilda; Sps `s-os~ sakasacio saCivarzeSps `s-osTvis~ c. s-is sasargeblod sacxovrebeli farTisSesaZenad gadaxdili 38 416 aSS dolaris ukan dabrunebisdakisrebis Sesaxeb Tbilisis saapelacio sasamarTlos sa-moqalaqo saqmeTa palatis 2015 wlis 31 ivlisis gadawyve-tilebis gauqmebis nawilSi Sewyda saqmiswarmoeba; ZalaSidarCa Tbilisis saapelacio sasamarTlos samoqalaqo saq-meTa palatis 2015 wlis 31 ivlisis gadawyvetilebis sare-zolucio nawilis me-3 punqti Tbilisis saqalaqo sasamar-Tlos 2015 wlis 16 ianvris gadawyvetilebis me-2, me-3 dame-4 punqtebis ucvlelad datovebis nawilSi; ganemartaTmxareebs, rom saqmiswarmoebis Sewyvetis SemTxvevaSi sa-samarTlosaTvis xelmeored mimarTva davaze imave mxare-ebs Soris, imave saganze da imave safuZvliT ar SeiZleba;danarCen nawilSi Sps `s-os~ sakasacio saCivari Tbilisissaapelacio sasamarTlos samoqalaqo saqmeTa palatis 2015wlis 31 ivlisis gadawyvetilebaze dasaSvebad iqna cnobi-li.

samotivacio nawili:40. sakasacio sasamarTlom Seiswavla saqmis masalebi,

gasaCivrebuli gadawyvetilebis samarTlebrivi dasabu-Teba, sakasacio saCivris safuZvlebi da miiCnevs, rom sa-kasacio saCivari unda dakmayofildes nawilobriv.

41. upirveles yovlisa, unda aRiniSnos, rom radgan ka-satorma (mopasuxem) uari Tqva sakasacio saCivarze im na-wilSi, romliTac gasaCivrebuli iyo xelSekrulebidan mo-sarCelis gasvlis gamo misTvis sacxovrebeli farTis Se-saZenad gadaxdili 38 416 aSS dolaris ukan dabruneba, ami-tom sakasacio sasamarTlo ar msjelobs nasyidobis xel-Sekrulebidan gasvlisa da nasyidobis Tanxis ukan dabru-nebis marTebulebaze. Sesabamisad, sakasacio sasamarTlosSemowmebis sagans warmoadgens mxolod is sakasacio pre-tenziebi, romlebic exeba sasamarTlos mier mopasuxezemosarCelis sasargeblod zianis anazRaurebis dakisrebis

202

marTebulobas.42. sakasacio sasamarTlo pirvelad imsjelebs zianis

anazRaurebis saxiT miuRebeli Semosavlis dakisrebis mar-Tebulobaze.

43. kasatoris miTiTebiT, saapelacio sasamarTlom mo-pasuxeze miuRebeli Semosavlis anazRaurebis dakisrebi-sas arasworad gamoiyena da ganmarta samoqalaqo kodeq-sis 411-e muxli da aseve, arasworad gaiziara mosarCelismier wardgenili eqspertis daskvna binis qiris savarau-do odenobasTan dakavSirebiT. kerZod, kasatoris miTi-TebiT, saapelacio sasamarTlom ar Seafasa is garemoeba,rom mosarCelem warmoadgina eqspertis daskvna dasrule-buli da garemontebuli (sacxovreblad vargisi) binis ga-qiravebasTan dakavSirebiT, maSin, rodesac xelSekrule-bis Sesabamisad, mosarCeles unda gadascemoda ara das-rulebuli bina, aramed e.w. `Savi karkasi~.

44. sakasacio sasamarTlo ver gaiziarebs kasatoris aR-niSnul pretenzias, radgan sasamarTlos mier dadgenilia,rom mxareTa Soris 2010 wlis 23 Tebervals dadebuli nas-yidobis xelSekrulebis Tanaxmad, mosarCeles nasyido-bis sagani unda gadascemoda Semdeg mdgomareobaSi: `garefasadi SeRebili, Selesili, metaloplastmasis kar-fan-jriT, sadarbazo keTilmowyobili, lifti damontaJebu-li, centraluri komunikacia adgilamde miyvanili, Sidatixrebi, liTonis Sesasvleli kari, Sida eleqtrogayvani-loba, kedlebi Selesili gajiT, ezo keTilmowyobili~.xelSekrulebaSi ar gvxvdeba termini `Savi karkasi~ da arckasatori akonkretebs, igulisxmeba Tu ara `Sav karkasSi~swored zemoaRniSnul mdgomareobaSi myofi bina. Sesaba-misad, usafuZvloa kasatoris miTiTeba e.w. `Savi karkasis~Sesaxeb SeTanxmebasTan dakavSirebiT. amave dros, dausa-buTebelia da aranair arguments emyareba kasatoris msje-loba, rom xelSekrulebiT gaTvaliswinebul mdgomareo-baSi mosarCelisaTvis Cabarebis SemTxvevaSi, sadavo binagasaqiraveblad uvargisi iqneboda.

45. rogorc saapelacio sasamarTlos gadawyvetilebi-dan irkveva, saapelacio sasamarTlom gamoikvlia kasato-ris mier miTiTebuli mtkicebuleba _ auditis daskvna uZ-ravi qonebis saijaro qiris sabazro Rirebulebis gan-sazRvris Sesaxeb, romlis Tanaxmad, Sesafasebeli qone-bis saijaro Rirebuleba dadgenilia gayidvebis Sedare-

203

bis meTodiT, analizisaTvis gamoyenebulia Sedarebis sa-mi obieqti da dadgenilia, rom Sesafasebeli obieqtis 1kv. m-is gaSenebis saijaro qiris sabazro Rirebuleba aris4.42 aSS dolari, rac mTliani farTis mixedviT Seadgens300 aSS dolars. daskvnaSi arsad aris miTiTebuli, rom Se-fasebulia nasyidobis xelSekrulebiT gaTvaliswinebu-lisagan gansxvavebul mdgomareobaSi myofi binis qiris Ri-rebuleba (188-212). Sesabamisad, dausabuTebelia kasato-ris miTiTeba, rom auditorma `dasrulebuli da garemon-tebuli~ binis qiris Rirebuleba Seafasa. amitom sakasa-cio sasamarTlo ver gaiziarebs kasatoris pretenzias sa-apelacio sasamarTlos mier aRniSnuli auditis daskvnis,rogorc mtkicebulebis, araswor gamoyenebasTan dakavSi-rebiT.

46. sakasacio sasamarTlo damatebiT aRniSnavs, rom impirobebSi, roca mosarCelis miTiTeba binis qiris savara-udo Rirebulebaze gamyarebulia specialistis daskvniT,mopasuxis mxolod miTiTeba am Rirebulebis arasworadgansazRvrasTan dakavSirebiT, arasakmarisia. sxva mtkice-buleba, rac gaabaTilebda specialistis daskvnas, mopa-suxes sasamarTlosTvis ar warmoudgenia. zemoaRniSnuli-dan gamomdinare, dausabuTebelia kasatoris pretenzia,rom sasamarTlom binis qiris savaraudo odenoba araswo-rad daadgina.

47. dausabuTebelia, aseve, kasatoris pretenzia, romsasamarTlos mopasuxisaTvis zianis anazRaurebis saxiTsaerTod ar unda daekisrebina mosarCelis mier binis ga-qiravebis SemTxvevaSi misaRebi Semosavali.

48. sasamarTlos mier dadgenilia, rom mxareTa Soris2010 wlis 23 Tebervlis nasyidobis xelSekrulebis Sesa-bamisad, saxli eqspluataciaSi unda yofiliyo miRebuli2010 wlis dekemberSi. sasamarTlos mier dadgenilia, rom2013 wlis 17 ivniss, rodesac mosarCelem sasamarTloSisarCeli aRZra da moiTxova xelSekrulebidan gasvla, sax-lis mSenebloba jer kidev dasrulebuli ar iyo.

49. samoqalaqo kodeqsis 411-e muxlis Sesabamisad, zia-ni unda anazRaurdes ara mxolod faqtobrivad damdgariqonebrivi danaklisisaTvis, aramed miuRebeli Semosav-lisTvisac. miuReblad iTvleba Semosavali, romelic armiuRia pirs da romelsac igi miiRebda, valdebuleba romjerovnad Sesrulebuliyo. miuRebeli Semosavali savara-

204

udo Semosavalia. yuradReba unda mieqces imas, ramdenadmosalodneli iyo misi miReba.

50. uzenaesma sasamarTlom araerT saqmeSi ganmarta,rom `miuRebeli Semosavali Tavisi bunebiT gulisxmobs`wminda ekonomikur danakargs~ (pure economic loss), rome-lic xelSekrulebis mxarem ganicada da romelsac adgiliar eqneboda, xelSekruleba jerovnad rom Sesrulebuli-yo. imisaTvis, rom Semosavali miuReblad CaiTvalos, maspirdapiri da uSualo kavSiri unda hqondes movalis miervaldebulebis darRvevasTan. pirdapir kavSirSi igulis-xmeba movlenebis, moqmedebisa da damdgari Sedegis is lo-gikuri bma, romelic ar tovebs Semosavlis miRebis rea-lur SesaZleblobasTan dakavSirebuli eWvis safuZvels.miuRebeli Semosavlis anazRaurebis sakiTxis gadawyve-tisas, zianis anazRaureba unda ganisazRvros mxolod obi-eqturi kriteriumebiT, ise, rom amas ar mohyves dazara-lebulis usafuZvlo gamdidreba~ (ix., susg #as-307-291-2011, 24 oqtomberi, 2011 weli; susg #as-899-845-2012, 22noemberi, 2012 weli).

51. mocemul saqmeSi, mosarCele miuTiTebs, rom mopa-suxis mier xelSekrulebiT gaTvaliswinebuli valdebu-lebebis droulad Sesrulebis SemTxvevaSi mas unda ga-dascemoda bina 2010 wlis dekemberSi. amitom, 411-e mux-lis Sinaarsis gaTvaliswinebiT, mniSvneloba eniWeba im ga-remoebebs, romlebic miuTiTeben mopasuxis mier zemoaR-niSnuli binis gadacemasTan dakavSirebiT nakisri valde-bulebebis jerovnad Sesrulebis SemTxvevaSi ra Semosa-vals miiRebda da valdebulebis darRvevis Sedegad ar mi-iRo mosarCelem. mosarCele miuTiTebs, rom xelSekrule-biT gaTvaliswinebul mdgomareobaSi binis gadacemis Sem-TxvevaSi, igi 2011 wlis ianvridan am binas gaaqiravebda,rac savsebiT SesaZleblad miaCnia sasamarTlos, radganTu pirs bina sacxovreblad ar sWirdeba, misi gaqiravebawarmoadgens uZravi qonebiT Semosavlis miRebis yvelazefarTod damkvidrebul da aprobirebul formas. mosar-Cele mopasuxesTan saxelSekrulebo urTierTobaSi imyo-feboda 2013 wlis 17 ivnisamde, Tumca aRniSnuli perio-dis ganmavlobaSi mopasuxem sakuTari valdebulebebi verSeasrula. Sesabamisad, 2011 wlis ianvridan 2013 wlis 17ivnisamde, mosarCeles SeuZlia moiTxovos is miuRebeliSemosavali, romelic mas am periodSi (anu xelSekrulebi-

205

dan gasvlamde) binis gaqiravebis SemTxvevaSi eqneboda.52. aRniSnulidan gamomdinare, sasamarTlo kasatoris

pretenzias iziarebs mxolod im nawilSi, romliTac zemo-aRniSnul periodSi miuRebeli Semosavlis odenobad ga-nisazRvra 11 500 aSS dolari, radgan auditis daskvnaSimiTiTebuli binis yovelTviuri qiris odenobis Sesabami-sad 2011 wlis ianvridan 2013 wlis 17 ivnisamde periodSibinis gaqiravebiT miuRebeli Semosavlis odenoba 11 500aSS dolaris nacvlad iqneboda 9000 aSS dolari(300*30=9000). amrigad, 9000 aSS dolaris nawilSi sasamar-Tlom marTebulad daakmayofila mosarCelis moTxovna.

53. sakasacio sasamarTlo miiCnevs, rom saapelacio sa-samarTlom mopasuxes marTebulad daakisra mosarCelissasargeblod zianis anazRaurebis saxiT 2013 wlis 17 ivni-sidan binis nasyidobis Tanxis dabrunebamde aRniSnuliTanxis wliuri 14% gadaxda (magram ara umetes 11 643.48aSS dolarisa).

54. samoqalaqo kodeqsis 405-e muxlis pirveli nawilisTanaxmad, Tu xelSekrulebis erTi mxare arRvevs ormxri-vi xelSekrulebidan gamomdinare valdebulebas, maSinxelSekrulebis meore mxares SeuZlia uari Tqvas xel-Sekrulebaze.

55. Tu xelSekrulebis erT-erTi mxare 405-e muxliTgaTvaliswinebuli pirobebis arsebobisas uars ityvis xel-Sekrulebaze, maSin miRebuli Sesruleba da sargebeli mxa-reebs ubrundebaT (naturiT dabruneba) (samoqalaqo ko-deqsi, muxli 352.1) da ramdenadac valdebulebis darRve-va SesaZlebelia SesrulebaTa ukuqcevis urTierTobaSicwarmoiSvas, aRniSnuli darRvevisaTvis, samoqalaqo ko-deqsis 394-e muxlis Sesabamisad, kreditors aseve SeuZ-lia moiTxovos zianis anazRaureba (samoqalaqo kodeqsi,muxli 352.5).

56. mocemul SemTxvevaSi, zianis anazRaurebis saxiT mo-sarCele iTxovda, rogorc xelSekrulebidan gasvlamdebankisaTvis ukve gadaxdil, ise xelSekrulebidan gasvlisdRidan gadasaxdelad darCenil procents. sasamarTlosmier dadgenilia, rom binis Sesasyidad mosarCelem aiRokrediti bankidan, romlis winaSec misi davalianeba xel-Sekrulebidan gasvlis dRisaTvis Seadgenda ZiriTadi da-valianebis saxiT 17 857.54 aSS dolars, xolo gadasaxdeliprocentis saxiT _ 11 643.48 aSS dolars.

206

57. 2013 wlis 17 ivniss, xelSekrulebidan mosarCelisgasvlis Sedegad, mopasuxes warmoeSva misTvis Sesrule-bis _ binis Rirebulebis _ dabrunebis valdebuleba, racmopasuxes ar ganuxorcielebia.

58. sakasacio sasamarTlo miuTiTebs, rom binis Ses-yidvis mizniT bankidan aRebuli krediti da am kreditiTsargeblobisaTvis gadasaxdeli procenti saapelacio sa-samarTlom marTebulad ar miiCnia im zianad, romelic ga-mowveulia xelSekrulebis SeusruleblobiT, radgan xel-Sekrulebis Sesrulebis SemTxvevaSi, mosarCele miiReb-da binas da ara Tanxas (ix. susg #as-899-845-2012, 22 noem-beri, 2012 weli). Tumca im dRidan, roca mosarCele gavidaxelSekrulebidan, mopasuxes warmoeSva mis mimarT ukveara binis saTanado mdgomareobaSi gadacemis, aramed misiRirebulebis dabrunebis valdebuleba, romlis Sesrule-bis SemTxvevaSi, mosarCeles, Tavis mxriv, miecemoda ban-kisaTvis darCenili sakredito davalianebis dabrunebisSesaZlebloba. aRniSnuli SesaZlebloba mosarCeles ar eZ-leva. Sesabamisad, binis Rirebulebis dabrunebamde, aR-niSnuli Tanxis 38 416 aSS dolaris wliuri 14% warmoad-gens mosarCelis zians, Tumca ara umetes 11 643.48 aSS do-larisa, romelic xelSekrulebidan gasvlis droisaTvisgadasaxdeli hqonda mas procentis saxiT.

59. zemoaRniSnuli msjelobidan gamomdinare, dausa-buTebelia kasatoris miTiTeba, rom Sesrulebis drouladdaubruneblobiT gamowveuli ziani, samoqalaqo kodeqsis412-e muxlis Sesabamisad, misTvis ar iyo winaswar savara-udo da ar warmoadgens misi moqmedebis uSualo Sedegs.

60. sakasacio sasamarTlo iziarebs kasatoris preten-zias, rom mas ar unda daekisros zianis anazRaurebis sa-xiT 2013 wlis 17 ivnisidan miuRebeli Semosavlis Tanxis11 500 aSS dolaris wliuri 10%-is gadaxda.

61. sakasacio sasamarTlo aRniSnavs, rom binis gaqira-vebiT mosarCelis mier miuRebeli Semosavlis odenobawarmoadgens 9000 da ara 11 500 aSS dolars (ix. winamdeba-re gadawyvetilebis 51-e da 52-e paragrafebi), amasTan, sa-moqalaqo kodeqsis 352-e muxlis pirveli nawilis Sesaba-misad, xelSekrulebidan gasvlis dros warmoiSoba miRe-buli Sesrulebisa da sargeblis dabrunebis valdebule-ba. zemoaRniSnuli Tanxa ki warmoadgens miuRebel Semo-savals, romlis anazRaurebac mopasuxes daekisra, xel-

207

Sekrulebebis pirobebis darRvevis gamo, xelSekrulebi-dan mosarCelis gasvlamde periodisaTvis. igi ar eqceva352-e muxlis regulirebis sferoSi. Sesabamisad, am nawil-Si saapelacio sasamarTlom arasworad gamoiyena da gan-marta samoqalaqo kodeqsis 352-e da 394-e muxlebi, ami-tom aRniSnul nawilSi, gasaCivrebuli gadawyvetileba iu-ridiulad dausabuTebelia, rac samoqalaqo saprocesokodeqsis 394-e muxlis è~ punqtis Sesabamisad, misi gauq-mebis safuZvelia.

62. samoqalaqo saproceso kodeqsis 411-e muxlis mixed-viT, sakasacio sasamarTlo TviTon miiRebs gadawyvetile-bas saqmeze, Tu ar arsebobs am kodeqsis 412-e muxliT gaT-valiswinebuli gadawyvetilebis gauqmebisa da saqmis saa-pelacio instanciaSi xelaxla gansaxilvelad dabrunebissafuZvlebi. mocemul SemTxvevaSi, sakasacio sasamarTlomiiCnevs, rom aseTi safuZvlebi ar arsebobs da igi ufle-bamosilia TviTon miiRos gadawyvetileba.

63. gadawyvetilebis aRsrulebis wesi: sakasacio sasa-marTlo damatebiT aRniSnavs, rom samoqalaqo kodeqsis352-e muxli iTvaliswinebs xelSekrulebidan gasvlis Sem-TxvevaSi ormxriv restitucias, anu orive mxaris valde-bulebas erTmaneTs daubrunon miRebuli Sesruleba dasargebeli. Sesabamisad, radgan mocemul saqmeSi kasato-ri aRar asaCivrebs mosarCelisaTvis binis sazRauris dab-runebis marTebulobas, xolo sasamarTlos mier dadgeni-lia, rom bina imyofeba mosarCelis sakuTrebaSi, unda ga-nisazRvros winamdebare gadawyvetilebis aRsrulebis we-si, kerZod, unda dadgindes, rom mopasuxis mier mosarCe-lisaTvis binis Rirebulebis gadaxda da mosarCelis miermopasuxisTvis sadavo qonebaze sakuTrebis uflebis dab-runeba sajaro reestrSi registraciis gziT unda moxdeserTdroulad.

64. saproceso xarjebi: samoqalaqo saproceso kodeq-sis 53-e muxlis pirveli nawilis Sesabamisad, im mxaris mi-er gaRebuli xarjebis gadaxda, romlis sasargeblodac iq-na gamotanili gadawyvetileba, ekisreba meore mxares,Tundac es mxare gaTavisuflebuli iyos saxelmwifo biu-jetSi sasamarTlo xarjebis gadaxdisagan. amave muxlis me-2 nawilis Sesabamisad, am muxlSi aRniSnuli wesebi Seexe-ba, agreTve, sasamarTlo xarjebis ganawilebas, romlebicgaswies mxareebma saqmis saapelacio da sakasacio instanci-

208

ebSi saqmis warmoebisas, xolo me-3 nawilis Tanaxmad, Tusaapelacio an sakasacio sasamarTlo Secvlis gadawyveti-lebas an gamoitans axal gadawyvetilebas, igi SesabamisadSecvlis xarjebis ganawilebasac.

65. mocemul SemTxvevaSi, sakasacio sasamarTlos 2015wlis 12 oqtombris ganCinebiT, kasators gadauvadda sa-xelmwifo baJis saxiT 8000 laris gadaxdis valdebuleba.2016 wlis 18 ianvars kasatorma uzenaes sasamarTloSi Se-amcira moTxovna 38 416 aSS dolaris nawilSi, xolo danar-Cen nawilSi misi moTxovna nawilobriv dakmayofilda. ze-moaRniSnulis gaTvaliswinebiT, agreTve, saapelacio sa-samarTloSi kasatoris mier ukve gadaxdili saxelmwifobaJis odenobis gaTvaliswinebiT, mis mier gadasaxdeli sa-xelmwifo baJi samive instanciis sasamarTloSi Seadgens 6562. 89 lars.

66. sasarCelo moTxovnebis dakmayofilebis Sesabami-sad da mis mier ukve gadaxdili saxelmwifo baJis gaTva-liswinebiT, mosarCelis mier samive instanciaSi gadasax-deli saxelmwifo baJi Seadgens 2 717.74 lars. amave dros,mopasuxes mosarCelis sasargeblod unda daekisros mo-sarCelis mier ukve gadaxdili saxelmwifo baJis nawilis,723.43 laris anazRaureba.




1. Sps `s-os~ sakasacio saCivari dakmayofildes nawi-lobriv;

2. Tbilisis saapelacio sasamarTlos samoqalaqo saq-meTa palatis 2015 wlis 31 ivlisis gadawyvetileba nawi-lobriv Seicvalos;

3. Tbilisis saqalaqo sasamarTlos 2015 wlis 16 ianvrisgadawyvetilebis sarezolucio nawilis me-6 punqtis uc-vlelad datovebis nawilSi Tbilisis saapelacio sasamar-Tlos samoqalaqo saqmeTa palatis 2015 wlis 31 ivlisisgadawyvetilebis sarezolucio nawilis me-3 punqtis, ase-ve amave gadawyvetilebis sarezolucio nawilis me-4 dame-5 punqtebis SecvliT miRebuli iqnas axali gadawyve-

209

tileba;4. Sps `s-os~ c. s-is sasargeblod daekisros zianis anaz-

Raurebis saxiT 2013 wlis 17 ivnisidan 38 416 aSS dolarisanazRaurebamde 38 416 aSS dolaris yovelwliuri 14%-isanazRaureba, araumetes 11 643.48 aSS dolarisa;

5. Sps `s-os~ c. s-is sasargeblod daekisros 2011 wlisianvridan 2013 wlis 17 ivnisamde miuRebeli SemosavlissaxiT 9000 aSS dolaris anazRaureba;

6. ganisazRvros gadawyvetilebis aRsrulebis wesi: Sps`s-os~ mier c. s-isaTvis sasamarTlos gadawyvetilebiT mi-kuTvnebuli 38 416 aSS dolaris dabruneba da c. s-is mierSps `s-osTvis~ binaze, mdebare, q. Tbilisi, g-is q. #9, sar-Tuli me-13, b. #175, sakuTrebis uflebis dabruneba saja-ro reestrSi registraciis gziT moxdes erTdroulad;

7. Sps `s-os~ daekisros saxelmwifo baJis, 6562,89 larisgadaxda saxelmwifo biujetis sasargeblod;

8. c. s-es daekisros saxelmwifo baJis, 2717,74 laris ga-daxda saxelmwifo biujetis sasargeblod;

9. Sps `s-os~ c. s-is sasargeblod daekisros 723,43 la-ris gadaxda;

10. sakasacio sasamarTlos gadawyvetileba sabolooada ar gasaCivrdeba.

210

saZiebeli

1. xelSekrulebis dadeba

winare xelSekruleba ................................................................... 3

valis arsebobis aRiareba .................................................... 64; 78

2. xelSekrulebidan gasvla da valdebulebis darRveva

xelSekrulebazeuaris Tqmis Sedegebi .................................... 87; 111; 119; 166; 192

Documents

valdebulebiTi samarTali (zogadi nawili) · valdebulebiTi samarTali (zogadi nawili) krebulSi gamoqveynebulia erTgvarovani sasamarTlo praqti-kis Camoyalibebisa da samarTlis ganviTarebisaTvis