31

uwv[xzy|{F} ~py - Columbia Universityww2040/full.pdf · uwv[xzy|{F} ~py Q ` G N N ` 8 C | U C ` \ j = U ' \ = z \ p z N - \ z ¢¡G F£6 ¥¤ ¥ -¦ p Y = § N ` Q p \

  • Upload
    others

  • View
    0

  • Download
    0

Embed Size (px)

Citation preview

Page 1: uwv[xzy|{F} ~py - Columbia Universityww2040/full.pdf · uwv[xzy|{F} ~py Q ` G N N ` 8 C | U C ` \ j = U ' \ = z \ p z N - \ z ¢¡G F£6 ¥¤ ¥ -¦ p Y = § N ` Q p \

��������������� � � ��������������� ����� ������� ��� ����� � ����� �!�� ��� �#"���$��� ��� ������% �#� ���!��������'&

�(�)� � �*�����+ �,�#� ���-�*���.�/� �)�0�

1-2

3�46587�3 9;:=<8<>@?BA;465C<8D%?FEG<IHKJMLNE;7 O;PC<858:Q4KRTSUE VW:XE;?F?B5C:XE;VY46E;7!Z@A[?F5\4K<8:XHWE P^]�?FP8?B4658_`9

a H6RXO;D 1 :Q4cb�E;:ed6?B58PC:e< 26f[g ?Fh�ijHW58k flg inmpo6o-qWr

s!4658_`9!t f qKoWo-q

m

Page 2: uwv[xzy|{F} ~py - Columbia Universityww2040/full.pdf · uwv[xzy|{F} ~py Q ` G N N ` 8 C | U C ` \ j = U ' \ = z \ p z N - \ z ¢¡G F£6 ¥¤ ¥ -¦ p Y = § N ` Q p \

uwv[xzy|{F}�~py��Q�`�G�N�N�����`�8���C���������|�U�C�`�����\�j�=�U�'�\���=���z�\���������p��� �z�N���-� �\�z�¢¡G���F£6�¥¤��¥�-¦��p�Y�=�§�N�`���Q�p�\�

¨ �`��©M�`�z�����N�`��£W�¥�\�c¡G���|£W�¥¤-�`�(�p�G¤+�����(�`���N�N���(�`� �`ª�«U¬-�­�`�¥�p�����=�`�p�M�\���K���p�\�®�\�z�K�N�`�'�¥�@�� ��¯X¯j�C�`�����\�8°±�\���§���p�¥���¥�-¦��²�\���¥���z�\���¥���+�p�³�N�`� £6�¥�\�­� �`¡G���z�N�z�K��������£p�z�%�X� �`¡��C��©j¬-�����p��´!�N��`�G�N�N���(�`�C�®�F£p�`�w��¬G�Y�N�z���`¡�¬G���-�pª.µ¶���·�`�p�=�j�\�z�K�N�`�z°U��¬-���N�`��£W�¥�\�����`¡¸�'�����¹���-¡G¡;�p���N�z¤¨Kº¹» �����N���z�=� ¨ �p�C���N�@�=�-�e�p�C�����������W¼��p�G¤-¼��\���������G�¥�`���������W¼��N�z�C¬G�-�����p¦ º �XµN½±«³�U� » �G��¡¸�(�z�§�`°���G�C¬¾�p�®�²¡G� ��£����N� ¨ � �p��� ¬¿�\À-� ¬G�p�G¦p�!�QÁÃÂMÄI�C°M�p�/�¥�K�N�`� �p�\����£p�Y£p���=�\�����z�N¡;���G�N�·�Xµ¶ÅÇƳ��G�G���`°p�p���p�G�N���������¥�U�`�p�¥�-¤��¥�N�N� � ¨ �-�N�p�±�Q�j½ÉÈ^�C°K�Ç¡ �`�C�N���G�p�W�\���(¡��-�N�`�³�QÁM½U�Ê�p�G¤(�p� �N�p���N�z¤¤G����� ¨ �p�N�z�zª�Ë#����¬¿��¬G�Y� ��¡��=¤+¦p���|©U��¬/�p�®�\ÌN� ��Í@Í®�\�N�C�`°U�\���§���p�\� ¨ �`��©M�`�z�/��¬-�Y�N�`��£W�¥�\�¡G���F£6�¥¤G�`�³�p�G¤¹�����³�`�G�N�N���(�`�C�^�����p�e�N�z�����p¤G��£W�¥�'�\¼����p�¥�[�p�³��¬G��µÎ�§�N�`�C�-�`�^�¥�G�N�N�z�p¤%�p� ¨6º�N�z���`¡�¬-���G�pªÊ«U¬6�G�Ï��¬-�±¦p�z�-�`�C�p�G�¥�K�N�`���X�p�\� ¨ �`��©M�`�z���^�N�`� £6�¥�\�±¡G� �|£W�¥¤-�`���p�G¤(�������`�G���N���(�`� ��¥�É�-�F©$�p�X�N�z���`�p�¥���z¤��®�\���§���p�\�Ç�\�z�§�N�`�|ª«U¬-�c¤-�z���¥¦����p�G¤+���p����¦p�z�(�z�§�@�p�³�\���§���p�\���\�z�K�N�`� ���¥�Ð�¥�(¡;�p�����p�K�`°T�p�G¤�©Ñ�p� ��¬ º �p�

���z�N�z��� �C¬Ò° ¨ �z�`�p�G�N���\���K���p�\���\�z�K�N�`� ���\����¡G� �¥�N�@�­�¥����¦p�p°Ó¦p���|©j�=�-¦c¡������Ç�p�Ñ��¬G�(�z�\���-��� º�p�G¤ ¨ �z�`�p���N����¬G� º ����� » �����N�Ð�\����¡��¥�¥�`���N�z¤ÒªI½±�¥�p� ���¥���`�p�=�[�\�z�K�N�`� �^�����(�\���(¡��=�¥�`���N�z¤ ¨ �\¼�`�p�G�N�w��¬-�`���c�����®�p�X�N�z�+���p� º � º ¡;�z���p�j�`�p�=�¥�`°Ê��� » ����� �¥�-¦�¤��ÕÔ �`� �z�§�Ð�N�`��£W�¥�\�w��´6�¥�=�¥�`°Ó����� ¬�p�T´W�-�|©¢���z¤-¦p�j�p�Ò¤G��Ô �`���z�K�Ã�¥�p�G¦��G��¦p�z�Ñ�p��¤(´6�G�|©j���z¤G¦p�j�p�Ò¤G�ÕÔ;�`���z�K�Ã�N¡;�z�`�¥�p�-¡G� ���(�p�������G�`ª«U¬-�­�j½±ÈÖ�¥�(� ¨ �¥�w�N�·���z�N¡;���G¤!��¬-�����-¦�¬+�N´W�¥�¥��¼ ¨ �p�N�z¤!�����-���¥�G¦-° ¨ �-�@��¬-�`���­� �z���p�¥�G�@�p��p¡G¡;�p�����G�G�¥� º �N�¹¤G�`�N�`� ���¥�-� ¨ �`�N�N�`�@�����G���¥�-¦Y�p��¦p�p�C����¬G�����p�G¤����p���'�\Ô;�z�\����£p�­�(�`��¬-�W¤G��e�p�É�N���B×w�-¦-ªÃ«U¬-�ǤG�Õ×w�`�G�������z�Ñ�����³�=����¦p�z� º ¤G�G�¢�N�(�G�G�\�`� ���p�¥�§� º � ¨ ���-�M�X�G���-���Ç����� ��£��p�¥�Ñ�p��N�`��£W�¥�\�^��� » �-�z�N���j�p�[£���� �����G�U´6�¥��¤G�É�p�G¤c��¬-�I���=�(�I�p�G¤­���z�����-� �\�z�U��¬����U©j�¥�¥� ¨ �^��� » �G�����z¤�N�����z�N¡;���G¤c�N�®��¬-���N�I��� » �-�z�N���zªØ ��£p�z�w��¬G���±�\���K���p�\�É©j����¬w�`�G�N�N���(�`� �±�-�Ð�����-¦p�`�É�-�`�z¤ ¨ � ¨6º �N�z���`¡�¬-���G�p°6���M�¥�M�-�z�\�z�μ

����� º �N�I�\���G���¥¤G�`����¬-�É�p��¬-�`�Ã�(�z¤��¥�W°��pªÙ¦-ª�°6�\¼����p�¥�Ú°p�Q�BÀ °Kµ¶�K�N�`� �-�`�`°§�`����ª�Ë�¬-�z�®�N�`��£W�¥�\�É���`¡��¡;�`���e�p�C�Û�N�`£p�`� �p�±¤G��Ô �`���z�K��´W�¥�G¤��I�p�É©M�p��´¸°���¬G�`���w�=���%�-�`�z¤!�N�¹�p�¥�¥�6�`���N�w�\Ô �p� �Ð�N�¹��¬-�¤G�ÕÔ;�`���z�K�Ñ���p�N´W�`°W©j¬G�=� ¬'¡G���z�N�z�K���M�p¡G¡;�p�����G�G�����¥�z�T�X�p�±�=�(¡G���F£p�z¤'�\×w�`���z�G� º ���[�N���(�³�p�Ó��¬-�©Ñ�p� ´Ð�`�p� ¨ �É¡;���N�N¡;���-�z¤ÒªÊÜ%�������¥�(�z¤G�=�¢�p�¥���I���z�p¤(�N���(�p� �U�\���(¡��¥�¥�`���N�z¤®�\���§���p�\�Ñ�\À6¡;�`� �Õ¼�z�G�\�z�`ª�Ý-�p���\À-�p�(¡����p°��`���N�N���(�`� �����¥¦�¬§�Ï�p���N�`� �G���N� ¨ �`��©M�`�z�@¡;�`� ���W¤G�l�p� �¥�K�N�`� �p�\�������Щj����¬�N�`��£W�¥�\�Ç���`¡��É�p�G¤c¡;�`� �¥�6¤G�M�p� ¨ ���|©¢���¥�-¦@���c��¬-�^µÎ�§�N�`�C�-�`�`ªÃ«U¬6�G�`°W��¬-�^�Q�G�¥� �\���§���p�\�¢�\À6¡;�\¼� ���z�G�\���®��¦�¬§������´p�®¡��¥�p�\�®�|£p�`�@�N�`£p�`� �p�ä��¥�XÞN���¥�§�^��� ¨ �¥�K�N�`��£B�p�=�Ç�p�M���=�(�pªw½M���G��� » �-�z�K��� º °�N�`��£W�¥�\�^���`¡��j����¦�¬K�É�\Ô �z�\����£p�z� ºw¨ �I�N�`� £6�¥�G¦@���`£p�`� �p�Ó¤G��Ô �`���z�K�U�`�G�N�N�����`� �U���U���G�\�pª«U¬G�=�j¡���¡;�`�^¤-�z���\�C� ¨ �z�³�����(�@���z�N�z��� �C¬²¤G�����z�\���¥���G�³���z�¥���N�z¤¹�N���N�N�W� ¬G�p�N���=�(�(�6¤G�z�¥�³�p�

�\���§���p�\�w�\�z�§�N�`�C�`°É�p�¥���¥�-¦¹�N�²���z��¡ ����¤��N����¬G�z�N�Y� ¬��p�¥���z�-¦p�z�`ª¿«U¬G�w¦p���p�¢�¥�@�N�²�G�G�\�F£p�`��X���G¤G�p�(�z�K���p�Ê¡G� �¥�G�`�¥¡����z�j�p��¤²¤-�`£p�z���p¡�¡;�`���X�p� ���p�G�\�(�p�G�p� º ���=�¢�N�6���¥�^��¬����^©j�¥�¥�Ê����´p�®���¡;������� ¨ �¥���N�²�¥�(¡G� �|£p�w��¬-�­¤-�z����¦��+�p�G¤+���p�G��¦p�z���z�§�(�p�³�\���§���p�\�®�\�z�K�N�`� �`ª·Ë�����¬-���G�¥¤�N�`�`´·�\���G¤����������G���e�p�w�N�\ß\��àW�N�C�@áW�z��¯ãâX�Kä��¥���\���§���p�\���\�z�K�N�`� �`°�©¢¬-�`���w��¬-�®�\×'�`�¥�z�G� º �p�j��¥����¦p�±���¥�-¦��¥�\¼��N´6�=�¥�p�\�z�§�N�`�T�=�[�p�C¬G���`£p�z¤@�¥�Ð�¢�Ð�G�����Õ¼���´6�¥�=���z¤^�\�z�§�N�`��©¢����¬����=�G�¥���p��å¸�\ÀW� ¨ �¥�¥��� º ªæ ���B×'�-¦���¬-���G�¥¤ ¨ �j�����G¤G���z¤��=�@�z�p� ¬w�p�;��¬-���`�¢�=�(¡;�p�����p�§�����=�(�j���`�p���z�zçÊ� �z�p�Õ¼����¥�(�p°6��¬-�p���μ�N�`� ���p��¤������-¦�¼��N�`� ��ª�èTÔ �p���'��¬-���G�¥¤ ¨ �����p¤G���N���G��¤-�`� �N���p�G¤+��¬G�Y�\���§�N�C� ¨ �-���������p�¤G�ÕÔ;�`���z�K�®�N���-� �\�z�®�p�I�G�G�\�`�����p�=�§� º ç��(�W¤-�z�j�G���\�`�����p�¥�K� º °É¡���� �p���`�N�`�w�G���\�`�����p�¥�K� º �p�G¤¡G���W�\�z�����G�G�\�`� ���p�¥�§� º ª æ �¥�Ð�G�¥���������Ð��¬-���G�=¤ ¨ �É�G�N�z¤(�p���Ç�N�6���-�p�G¤(��¬-�����¥¤ ¨ �±��¬-�É��� ¨ ÞÎ�z�\��p�T�N���G¤ º çÑèTÔ �p� �¢��¬-�����¥¤ ¨ �����p¤-���N�'¤-�`�N�`�C���¥�-�I��¬G����� » �G�����z¤­� �¥�����¥���������­� ���G���z�-¦p��¬G��e�p�³�`�p�¥�Õ¼��\�z�K�N�`�¢���=���G�=���������G�`ªÃèTÔ �p� �j��¬-���G�=¤ ¨ �����p¤-�I�N�w�¥�§£p�z������¦����N���p¡;�`� �����������p�Ò���z�p�Õ¼���¥�(�(���¥�Ð�G�¥�����¥���G� ¨Kº �\���G¤G�G�\���=�-¦­���¥�Ð�G�¥���������G�³©j�¥��¬��-�z�N�N�z¤����¥�Ð�G�¥�����¥���G�`ª@ÝÊ�=�G�p�¥� º °Ò�p��\Ô �p� �Y��¬-���G�=¤ ¨ �²���p¤G���N�¾�¥�K�N�`¦p� ���N�·���z���z��� � ¬��p�G¤.�z¤G�G�`�����¥��� ¨Kº ����´W�¥�-¦��\���K���p�\��\�z�§�N�`�C�j���\���K�N�\À6�¢�e�W�`�G�U�=�­�\���-� �N�z�É���%�N�N�W� ¬G�p�N���=�I�(�W¤-�z�¥�É�p�G¤�� �¥�����¥���������Òª

Page 3: uwv[xzy|{F} ~py - Columbia Universityww2040/full.pdf · uwv[xzy|{F} ~py Q ` G N N ` 8 C | U C ` \ j = U ' \ = z \ p z N - \ z ¢¡G F£6 ¥¤ ¥ -¦ p Y = § N ` Q p \

éÒêìëBíÓîpï�ð�ñÑòÃó6î�ô�ðÓí

éÒê�élêöõwòÃ÷FîpðÓø�ùGï·õ'ðÓí[îpú;ó6î²õ'ù�í[îpùGï§÷­úÒ÷�ëBí[î�ù�ï�ûÎú;óWù¸÷�ûÎðlï�ü³ù�ý�ù�÷BùGï�þ�ôÿóWù�÷

s!46E 2 PC?B5 d¸:e_B?FP��±J�5CHWD ?BDY?B58V6?BE;_ 2 <8Hc58?|<`46:eR��É4658?�RQ465CVW?BR 2����������� ���������|f :XEY<\9Ò4K<³_BO;P <\HWDY?B5CP46E;7)P8?B5 d�:X_B?¿A 58Hpd�:X7;?F58P�4K58?+5C?BDYH6<\?²J�58HWD ?B46_`9 H6<\9;?F5 f 4K<¹RX?B46PC<%hI9;?BE*PC?B5Cd�:e_B?+:eP¹:XE :e<\:X4K<\?F7���ÒHW5j?�� 46DYA;RX? f ?FD%?F58VW?FE;_ 2 D%?F7;:X_B46RÓP8?B5 d�:X_B?Ð:XPjH6JÚ<\?FE�A;58Hpd�:X7 ?B7 1-2 ?FD%?F58VW?FE;_ 2 �ÎD%?F7;:X_B46R��ÎP8?B5 d�:X_B?� Sjs�����AÓ?B5CP8HWE E;?BRWhI9;H�465C58:=dW?É:XE�4KE�46D 1 O;RX46E;_F? f�1 O <�<89;?ÉD%?F7;:X_B46R6PC?B5 d¸:e_B?U:XP�O P8OÒ46ReR 2 58?���O ?BPC<8?B71-2 D¹46kG:eE;V!4 � mWm�<\?BRe?BA;9 HWE;?¹_B46RXR!��3 :e<89�58?|<`46:eR f <\9 ?¹_BO PC<\H6D%?F5w:XP®RX:ek6?FR 2 <8H!58?FD¹4K:XE¾58?BDYH6<8?J�58H6Dö<\9;?�PC?B5Cd�:e_B?®A;58Hpd�:X7;?F5I?FdW?FE�hI9;?FE�<89;?'PC?B5 d¸:e_B?�:XPIAÓ?B5 J�HW58DY?B7��"�ÒHW5^?��;4KD%A;Re? f 4�_BO PC<\H6D%?F5D%4 2 HW5C7;?B5�4+_FH-4K<cJ�5CHWD 4+_B4K<`4KRXHWV 1-2 D¹46kG:eE;V¿4!<\?FRX?FA;9;HWE;?�_B46RXRjHW5wJ�5CHWD <89;?�LNE-<\?F58E;?|< 1G2d�:X?|hI:XE;V·46E¾HWE;Re:XE;?­_B4K<`46ReHWV²46E;7¾?BE-<8?B58:eE;V�46A;A;5CHWA;58:X4K<\?­_F58?F7;:e<#�N_�4K587¾:XE J�HW5CD¹4§<\:XH6E��%$^9;?FE�<\9 ?_BHW4K<ÉD%4 2®1 ?Ç7;?FRX:ed6?B5C?B7c<\H�<\9;?Ç_FO;PC<8HWDY?B5 1-2 4@PC9;:XA A[?F5MP8O _`9¹46PMb�E;:=<\?F7'&M465C_B?BR��¸?B5 d¸:e_B? � b(&"�)���3 :e<89�4Ð<\?BRe?BPC?B5Cd�:e_B? f <89;?^7;?BRe:ed6?B5 2 H6JÓP8?F5Cd�:X_F?^:XP±A;5CHpd¸:e7;?B7�HW5M?BEÒ4 1 RX?B7 1-2 4 � _BO;P <\HWDY?B5*�Ñ_BHWE+�

<`4K_F<�_B?FEG<8?B5��-, ��.0/��21+���3����/��4�� :XPI4�_BHWReRX?F_F<\:eHWE�H6JÑ58?FP8HWO;5C_B?FPÐA;5CH�d�:e7;:XE;VY46E·:XE-<8?B5CJ�4K_B? 1 ?|<Nh³?F?BE<\9 ?�PC?B5 d¸:e_B?IA;5CH�d�:e7;?B5U46E 7Y:=<\PÉ5C?BDYH6<\?^_FO;PC<8HWD%?F58P��5�ÒHW5±<\9;?^?FD%?F58VW?FE;_ 2 �ÎD%?F7;:X_B46R��ÎP8?B5 d�:X_B?^?�� 46D'�A;Re?^4 1 H�d6? f <89;?^_BHWE-<\46_F<É_F?BE-<\?F5UD¹4 2'1 ?^4@V658HWO;A­HKJÊSjs��c7;:eP8AÒ4§<\_`9;?F58P6�7�lH65M<\9;?³58?F<\46:XR�?�� 46DYA;Re?4 1 HpdW? f <\9;?U_FHWE-<`46_|<Ñ_F?BE-<\?F5Ñ_B46E 1 ?É?F:e<\9 ?B5Ã4Ç<\?BRe?BA;9 HWE;?U_�46ReRW_B?FE-<\?B5 f 5C?B_B?F:ed�:XE VI<8?BRe?BA;9;H6E;?UHW587;?F58P fHW5U4(DYHW58?^VW?FE;?B5846R;_FHWE-<`46_|<¢_F?BE-<\?F5 f hI:e<89Y?��GO;:XA;DY?BE-<¢46E;7�PC?B5Cd�:e_B?I58?FA;58?FP8?BE-<\4K<\:=dW?BP¢58?FP8AÓHWE;7;:eE;V<\H�LNE-<\?F58E;?|<ÐH6587;?F58P6�

éÒê98�êöõwý�úÒ÷�÷�ô�óWúÒý¢ü³ù�ý�ù;:=<ÃðÓíTù/õ'úÒýÿý^õ'ù¸íÓîpùGïK÷

$^9;?!_FRQ46PCP8:e_�46RI_BH6EG<\46_F<¹_B?FEG<8?B5%:XP�<\9;? � <\?FRX?FA;9;HWE;?>� �?1@�A�(����/��4�� zf _BH6EG<\46:XE :XE;V/4/_FHWRXRe?B_F<8:XHWEH6J�_FO;PC<8HWD%?F5¹PC?B5Cd�:e_B?+5C?BA;5C?BP8?FE-<`4K<8:edW?FP � P8?F5Cd�:X_F?+58?FA;P f :!� ?B� f AÓ?BHWA RX?��­hI9;H�<\46RXk#<8H#_BO;P <\HWDY?B5CPHpdW?F5®<89;?c<\?FRX?BA 9;HWE;?B�YLNE/4�_�46ReR±_B?FE-<\?B5 f <89;?�P8?F5Cd�:X_F?Y5C?BA;P®465C?�P8O;A;AÓHW5 <\?B7 1-2 �GO;:e<8?­?BRQ4 1 HW584K<\?:XE¸J�HW58D%4K<\:eHWEC�N46E;7C�Î_BHWDYDcO;E;:e_�4K<8:XHWE+�¶<8?B_`9;E;H6RXHWV 2 � L a $D�^?6�GO;:XA D%?FEG< f P8O;_`9¿4KPÐ4�A;58:=dK4K<\? 1 5846E;_`9?��¸_`9Ò4KE;VW? � &FE�GH� f 4KE/4KO <\HWD%4K<8:X_®_�46ReRÑ7;:ePC<858: 1 O <\HW5 � , a >I� f 4�AÓ?B58PCHWEÒ46RM_BHWDYA;O <8?B5 � & a �@4KE;746PCP8HW5 <\?B7·7Ò4K<\4 1 46PC?BP��$^9;?�?FE-d¸:e58HWE D%?FEG<�H6Jc4�< 2 A;:e_�46R�_�4KRXR(_B?FE-<\?B5�:XP·4�RX4658V6?¿58H�HWD JÒReRX?B7 hI:e<89�_FO 1 :e_BRX?FP f :eE

hI9;:e_`9cP8?F5Cd�:X_F?³58?FA;PMh¢?�465C:XE;V�<\?FRX?BA 9;HWE;?¢9;?�467 P8?F<8P±P8:=< 1 ?FJ�H658?j_BHWDYA;O <8?B5MPC_B5C?B?BE P f hI9;:e_`9cA;58Hpd�:X7 ?P8O A;A[H65C<\:eE;V�:XE J�H658D%4K<\:eHWE��TLÎJÊh¢?�:eVWE;HW5C?Ç<\9;?IL a $,PCO;A;AÓHW5C< f 4®_B46RXRK�N_B?FE-<\?B5ÉPC?B5 d¸:e_B?�58?FA%:ePÉP8:XDY:XRX465<\H$46E�HWRe7C�Î<8:XDY?�<\?FRX?FA;9;HWE;?�HWAÓ?B584K<\H656�L$ÃH¸7Ò4 26f h³?¾9Ò4�dW?¾58?FRQ4K<8:ed6?BR 2 RX:=<8<8RX?!?��¸A[?F58:X?FE;_B?�hI:e<89

m

Page 4: uwv[xzy|{F} ~py - Columbia Universityww2040/full.pdf · uwv[xzy|{F} ~py Q ` G N N ` 8 C | U C ` \ j = U ' \ = z \ p z N - \ z ¢¡G F£6 ¥¤ ¥ -¦ p Y = § N ` Q p \

<\?FRX?FA;9;HWE;?wHWA[?F5\4K<8HW58P fÏ1 O <(J�H65C< 2·2 ?�4K58P�46VWH�<8?BRe?BA;9;H6E;?cHWAÓ?B584K<\HW5CPÐh¢?B58?�4KP(A;58?|d64KRX?BE-<�4KP@_�46ReR��_B?FE-<\?B5²PC?B5Cd�:e_B?�58?FA;P²4658?+<8H¸7;4 2 �MEÇ4K_`k)<\9;?FE f :=<¹h³46P²A;58HONC?B_F<8?B7 <\9Ò4§<�?Fd6?B5 2 Re:ed�:XE V�AÓ?B58PCHWEh¢HWO;RX7�P8H�HWE 1 ?�4�<8?BRX?FA;9;HWE ?!HWAÓ?B584K<\HW5 f :=JÐ<\9 ?�EGO;D 1 ?B5YH6J(AÓ?BH6A;RX?²?BDYA;ReH 2 ?B7)46P%<8?BRX?FA;9;HWE ?HWAÓ?B584K<\HW5CP²k6?BA¸<!VW5CHphI:XE;V$4K<�<89;?/A 58?FdK46:eRX:eE;V#5\4§<\?@�P$^9;?�P8A :X58:=<²H6J®<\9;?�<\?FRX?BA 9;HWE;?��NHWAÓ?B584K<\HW5_BO Re<\O 58?�:XP�h¢?BRXR(_B46A <8O;58?F7 1-2RQ :XR 2 $ÑH6D%Re:XE�S P�O;E J�H658VW?|<8<`4 1 RX?¿_`9Ò4K5\46_|<\?B5 f SÉ58E;?FPC<\:eE;?@�T�ÒHW5²458?FA;RQ4 2 H6J[<89;?^d�:X7;?FH UCSU5CE;?BP <\:eE;?�s�?B?|<\P³s�56�=VU?B?B7 RX?6W(J�5CHWD <89;?^<\?BRe?Fd�:XPC:XHWE­A 58HWVW5846DPX 1@Y@Z0[+\^]�/ÒfP8?F?'9-<C<\A�_a`b`§h^h^hI� RX:eR 2 <\HWDYRX:eE�� _BHWDc�$^9;?B5C?c465C?'7 :9d[?B58?FE-<ÐkG:XE 7;P�HKJÉ_�46ReR�_B?FEG<8?B5CP6_ a 46ReRT_B?BE-<8?B58P�D¹4 2 9Ò4�d6?wHWE;R 2 :XE 1 HWO;E;7·<\584BeY_

� _FO;PC<8HWDY?B5#�ÎVW?BE ?B5\4§<\?B7!_�46ReRXP�� f HWE;R 2 H6O < 1 HWO;E;7·<\584BeY_ � 5C?BAC�ÎVW?BE ?B5\4§<\?B7!_�46ReRXP f ?B� V)� f <8?BRe?BD%4658kK?F<f�:XE V;�ÑHW5U4(_BH6D 1 :XE;4K<\:eHWEcH6Jl<\9 ?BP8?B�ÉLNE 1 HWO E;7%_B46RXR¸_B?FEG<8?B5CP³465C?IO;P8OÒ4KRXR 2 P8O A;A[H65C<\?F7 1-2 :eE-<\?B5846_F<8:ed6?dWH6:X_B?%58?FP8AÓHWE;P8? � L2V(]g�(O;E;:e<8P f hI9;:X_`9#PC?B5 dW?²46P'?BRQ4 1 HW584K<\?Y46E PCh¢?B58:eE;V+D%46_`9;:eE;?BP��h$^9 58HWO;V69.4P8?FRX?F_F<\:eHWE�H6JÃDY?BEGO;P f L2V(]IS PI4K<C<\?FD%A <³<\H­58?FP8AÓHWE;7�<\H­<89;?@_BO PC<\H6D%?F56S P�E ?B?B7 P�4KE;7 f :=JÃE;?B_F?BP8P8465 26f9;?FRXA²58HWO¸<\?(<\9;?�_B46RXRÊ<8HY46E!4KA;A;58H6A;58:X4K<\?@PC?B5 d¸:e_B?®58?FA��Z@O < 1 HWO;E;7®_�4KRXRW_F?BE-<\?F58PÃD¹4 2 9;4pd6?¢A 58?B7 :X_F<8:ed6?j7 :Q46Re?B58P f hI9;:X_`9®7;:X46R 1 ?FJ�HW5C?U4�5C?BA�:XPT4�dK46:XRX4 1 Re? f

4K<C<\?BDYA <8:XE;V·<\H¿46E-<8:X_B:eAÒ4K<8?%hI9;?FE.HWE;?¹hI:eRXR 1 ?�4pdK46:eRQ4 1 RX? f <\9GO;P­5C?B7;O _B:XE V+58?FA.:X7;Re?Y<8:XDY? f±1 O¸<O;E J�H65C<\O EÒ4K<\?FR 2 RX?�4K7;:XE;V�<\H�P8HWDY?�_B46RXRePwhI:e<89;HWO <Y4+_B46RXRe:XE;V�AÒ465C< 26f <89GO;PY46E;E;H 2 :XE;V¿<89;?�_�46ReRX?F7AÒ465 <\:e?BPji t@kBl!� � LÎ<�h¢HWO;RX7 1 ?+E;:e_B?!<8H.58?F7;O;_B?¿<89Ò4K<²46E E;H 2 46E;_F? f 46E;7*<\9GO;P�:eD%A;5CHpdW?+P 2 P <\?FDAÓ?B5CJ�H658D%46E;_B?@J�5CHWDö<89;?�_BO;P <\HWDY?B5�S PIAÓ?B58PCA[?F_F<8:edW?B�m�a 46RXRÑ_B?FEG<8?B5CP�4658?cAÓ?B5 dK46P8:=dW?�46E;7¿V658HphI:XE;V¹5\46A;:e7;R 2 �In�?FE;_B? f NCO;PC<�4KPÐhI:e<89¿HWA[?F5\4K<8HW58P�J�HW5C< 2

2 ?B4658Pc46VWH f h¢?�_FHWO;RX7�A;58H0NC?F_F<c<89Ò4K<w?FdW?F5 2 RX:ed�:eE;V�AÓ?B5CP8HWE/h³HWO RX7.P8H�HWE 1 ?B_FHWDY?�4!_B46RXRK�N_B?FE-<\?B5P8?F5Cd�:X_F?¹5C?BA f :=J³<89;?%EGO;D 1 ?F5wH6J^AÓ?BH6A;RX?Y?BDYA;RXH 2 ?B7#4KPwP8?F5Cd�:X_F?¹5C?BA;P'k6?BA¸<cVW5CH�hI:eE;V+4§<w_FO;585C?BE-<5\4§<\?BP��o�Ò58HWD <\9;?�AÓ?B5CP8AÓ?B_F<8:ed6?¾HKJpNCH 1 P84K<\:ePCJ�46_|<\:XH6E f <\9Ò4K<�h¢HWO;Re7 E;H6< 1 ?¿P8H 1 467 f�1 ?F_�46O;PC?<\9 ?­P8?B5 d�:X_B?­5C?BA�S P�NCH 1 _B46E 1 ?cDwO;_`9�D%HW5C?c?��¸_F:e<\:eE;V¹<89Ò46E+<\9 ?gNCH 1 H6J¢46E¿HWRe7C�Î<8:XDY?®<8?BRX?FA;9;HWE ?HWAÓ?B584K<\HW5 � ?Fd6?BE¿46ReRXHphI:XE Vw<\9Ò4§<ÐSÉ5CE;?BP <\:XE ?'PC?B?BDY?B7·<\H 1 ?®9;4pd�:eE;V¹4�A;5C?F<8< 2 V6H¸H�7�<\:eD%?>���É3 :e<8946ReR³<\9;?²PCO;A;AÓHW5C<8:XE;V�L a $ ?���O :XA;DY?BE-<%4K<�<\9;?F:X5qJÒE VW?B5 <\:XA P f <\9;?·P8?F5Cd�:X_F?�5C?BA;P�9Ò4�dW?�4�VW58?B4K<\?F5HWA;AÓHW5 <\O;E;:=< 2 <\HrU 1 O PC<�HWO <�hI:e<\9·D%467�PCkG:XRXReP6�sW#LNE�<89;?®D%HW5C?(_`9Ò46ReRX?BE VW:XE;V�PC?F<8<8:XE;V6P f <\9;?tNCH 1 H6J4­P8?F5Cd�:X_F?'5C?BA·_�46E�46A;A;5CH-46_`9²<\9Ò4§<IH6J±4KE!46:e58A;RX46E;?@A :XRXHK<ÇHW5I46E�46:e5#�Î<85\4BeY_@_FHWE-<\5CHWRXRe?B56�

éÒê9u�ê üv<Ãù wgxFõ'ðÓø#ø�ùGï§óWùhy�ù-þ[ðÓý�òTîpô�ðÓí

n�Hph¢?FdW?F5 f :=<@:XP�?Fd�:e7;?BE-<@<89Ò4K< f NCO;PC<@46PÐhI:=<\9�<8?BRe?BA;9;H6E;?cHWAÓ?B584K<\HW5CP 1 ?FJ�HW5C? f 7;5\46D%4K<8:X_(<\?F_`9C�E;HWReHWVW:e_�46R�_`9Ò46E;V6?BPj4658?³_BO;5C58?BE-<8R 2 O;E 7;?B5 hÇ4 2Wf hI9;:e_`9�hI:eRXR�58?F7;O;_B?^<89;?^E;?B?F7YJ�H65±P8H�D%46E 2 P8?F5Cd�:X_F?

q

Page 5: uwv[xzy|{F} ~py - Columbia Universityww2040/full.pdf · uwv[xzy|{F} ~py Q ` G N N ` 8 C | U C ` \ j = U ' \ = z \ p z N - \ z ¢¡G F£6 ¥¤ ¥ -¦ p Y = § N ` Q p \

58?FA;P6�z$^9;?�<\?BRe?BA;9 HWE;?Y:XP�E;H·RXHWE;V6?B5@<\9 ?YH6E;R 2 DY?�4KE;P�H6JÇ_FHWD%DwO;E;:X_B4K<\:eHWE��{$^9;?�<\?FRX?FA;9;HWE;?�:eP5\4KA;:X7;R 2�1 ?F:XE;V�58?FA;RQ46_F?B7 1-2 ?BRX?F_F<858HWE;:e_³D%46:XRG4KE;7w<\9 ?ÇLNE-<\?B5CE;?F<6�±LNE;7;?F?B7 f h¢?^465C?³:XE'<\9;?¢D%:e7;PC<ÑH6J4%_FHWDYDcO;E;:e_�4K<8:XHWE·58?|dWHWReO <\:eHWE f hI:e<89!P8?F5Cd�:X_F? 1 ?B:XE V¹A;5CH�d�:e7;?B7+DYHW5C?w46E 7+D%H658?�d¸:X4%?FRX?B_|<\5CHWE;:X_D%46:XRT46E 7�<\9 ?cLNE-<\?B5CE;?F<6��3/?c4K58?w?��¸A[?F58:X?FE;_B:eE;V�4Y5\46A;:e7!VW5CHph^<\9+H6J � ?BRe?B_|<\58H6E;:X_>� ��\?��.0|{|}�� *��� �,ÐPÐ46E!:eRXReO;PC<85\4K<8:XHWE f 3�?F:XE 1 ?F58Vji r6oOlM7;?FP8_F58: 1 ?BP�<\9;?�~ÒO;5C5 2 H6JÉHWE RX:XE ?'PCA[?FE;7;:XE V%J�HW5pVj46RX?FE-<\:XE ?@S P>(4 2 46PI46E�U8S�� a H6D%DY?B5C_B? Q HpdW? Q ?F<8<8?B5�_�W

S±dW?FEc:XE'4IP89Ò46k 2 ?B_FHWE;HWD 2Wf ,�D%?F58:e_�46E;PTP <\:XReRW9Ò467®<\:eD%?U46E 7wDYHWE;? 2 <8H�PC?BE;7'd¸:e5C<8OÒ46RReH�d6?%H6E�Vj46Re?BE-<\:eE;?@S P®>(4 2 ��Vj46RX?FE-<\:XE ?@S P'>(4 2 q6o6o-q²5C?BPCO;Re<8P'9Ò4�d6?�HWE;Re:XE;?­5C?F<`4K:XRX?F58PhI9;:ePC<8RX:XE V�RXHpdW?wP8HWE;V6P@<\H�<\9 ?c<\O;E;?­HKJt�B� 1 :XReRX:XH6E���,ÐDY?B5C:X_B46E;P@PCA[?FEG<�E ?�465CR 2 t6o��DYHW58?®HWE;Re:XE;?(<89Ò46E!RX46PC< 2 ?B465Ð:eE�<89;?­q6oY7Ò4 2 P 1 ?|J�HW58?IVj46Re?BE-<\:eE;?@S P@>(4 2Wf 46_F_BHW5C7;:XE;V<8H/?��N_BH6D%DY?B5C_B?�<\5846_`k6?F5�E³:9�B584K<\?B� _FHWD���s�H658?·46E;7$D%H658?²_BO;P <\HWDY?B5CP¹4K58?²P8?F?B:XE V<89;?�LNEG<8?B5CE;?F<@46P�4�A 58:XD%465 2 P89 HWA;A;:eE;V%5C?BPCHWO;58_F? f E;H6<7NCO;P <�46P�4YA;RX46_B?(<8HY_FHWDYAÒ4658?A;5C:X_F?BP6�

�¸:XE _B?²<\9;?�:XE-<\?F5CJ�46_F? 1 ?F<Nh¢?B?FE*P8?B5 d�:X_B?�A;58Hpd�:X7 ?B58P%46E;7�<\9;?F:X5�_BO;P <\HWDY?B5CP¹:ePYRe?BPCP%Re:Xk6?FR 2 <8H:XE-d6HWRed6?+<\?BRe?BA;9 HWE;?¿_�4KRXRXP f <\9;?¿:eEG<8?B5 J�46_B?¿:eP�E;Hph H6JÚ<8?BE*5C?FJ�?B5C58?F7�<8H�46P²4#_BO;P <\HWDY?B5�_FHWE-<`46_|<_B?FE-<\?B5^H65�NCO;P <^4w_FHWE-<`46_|<^_B?FEG<8?B5��U3/?Ðh³46E-<Ç<\H 1 ?|<8<\?F5³O;E 7;?B5CPC<`4KE;7�<\5\4K7;:e<8:XHWEÒ4KR;<\?BRe?BA;9 HWE;?@_B46RXR_B?FE-<\?B5CP¹4KE;7�58?BPCA[H6E;7.<\H�E;?Fhö_`9Ò46ReRX?BE VW?BP­AÓHWP8?F7 1G2 <\9;?�?FD%?F58VW:eE;V f DYHW58?�VW?FE;?B5846R f _FHWE-<`46_|<_B?FE-<\?B5CP6�

éÒêK�ÃêLw@óWð[íTðÓø#ô�ó²ëFør:ÉðlïpîpúÒíÃóWù!ðlû@õ'ð[íÓîpúÒó6î�õ'ù¸íÓîpùGïK÷

$^9;?­:XE-<858H�7;O;_F<8:XHWE·<\H¹<89;?{&É58H6VW5\46Dc,�E;E;HWO;E _BDY?BE-<(J�HW5@S��¸A;ReHW5\4K<8HW5 2 ]I?BPC?�465C_`9¾H6E¿SÉE;VW:��E;?F?B58:eE;V�<\9;?%�¸?B5 d�:X_B?%�¸?F_F<\H65 fÓg ����o-qO�No-q@� f d�:=d¸:e7;R 2 7;?BPC_B5C: 1 ?BPI<\9;?®:XDYA[H65C<`4KE;_B?(H6JÑ<\9;?®P8?F5Cd�:X_F?P8?F_F<8HW5(:XE!<89;?­?B_FHWE;HWD 2 46E 7+<\9;?­E;?F?B7¿J�HW5�A;58H�7;O;_|<\:ed�:=< 2 VW5CHph^<\9¿:XE�<\9Ò4K<@P8?B_|<\HW5��q��:XE;_F?c_BHWE+�<`4K_F<@_F?BE-<\?F58P®465C?wO;PC?B7¿<\9;H6O;VW9;HWO¸<@<\9;?wP8?B5 d�:X_B?wP8?B_|<\HW5 f <\9 HWP8?­VW?FE;?B5846RMH 1 P8?F5CdK4K<\:eHWE;PÐ46A;A;R 2 <8H_BH6EG<\46_F<�_F?BE-<\?F58P@4KPÇh³?FRXR��,ÐP^:eE;7;:X_B4K<\?F7²4 1 H�d6? f <89;?(_BHWE-<\46_F<#�N_B?FE-<\?B5I:eE;7;O;P <\5 2 :e<8P8?BR=JT:XP³dK46P <�46E;7�5846A;:X7 R 2 ?��¸AÒ46E;7 :XE;V)�

LÎ<j:XPU?BP <\:eD¹4K<8?B7�<\9Ò4§<³4 1 HWO¸<jJ�H6O;5UD%:eRXRX:eHWEwAÓ?BH6A;RX?I:XE�<\9 ?Ðb�E;:e<8?B7}��<`4K<8?BP5����� H6J[<\9;?Ih³H658k-J�HW58_F?�ch¢HW5Ck�:eE)_BH6EG<\46_F<�_B?BE-<8?B58P f hI:=<\9)<89;?+EGO;D 1 ?B5%VW58HphI:eE;V 1-2 4 1 HWO¸<�q6ob� AÓ?B5 2 ?�4K56�s!4KE 2PC<\4K<\:ePC<8:X_BPÑ9Ò4�dW? 1 ?B?FE­_BHWReRX?B_|<\?F7c7;?BDYHWE;P <\584K<\:eE;V�<89;?Ç?B_FHWE;HWDY:X_¢:XDYA[H65C<`4KE;_B?jH6Jl_BH6EG<\46_F<±_B?BE-<8?B58P��J�HW5I4­P\4KD%A;Re? f PC?B?®9-<8<\A�_m`b`�h^h^hI� _B46RXRe_B?BE-<8?B58E ?FhIP6� _BH6D�`K5C?BPCHWO;58_F?BP*`KP89-<\DYR-�

Page 6: uwv[xzy|{F} ~py - Columbia Universityww2040/full.pdf · uwv[xzy|{F} ~py Q ` G N N ` 8 C | U C ` \ j = U ' \ = z \ p z N - \ z ¢¡G F£6 ¥¤ ¥ -¦ p Y = § N ` Q p \

éÒê9��êo��ôÿ÷|îpðlïO��ðlûDy�ù�÷BùGú;ï§óB<,ðÓí,ü¢ù¸ý�ù;:�<TðÓíÃù¾õwú;ýÿý^õwù�í[î�ù�ï§÷

éÒê9��ê�éÒêÛü%<Tù��UðÓí��.ü¢ï§ú;ñÑôÚî�ô�ð[í$ú îz��üq�²ü

$^9;?B5C?�:XP®4·RXHWE;V�<85\467;:=<\:eHWE�H6J^58?FP8?B4658_`9#H6E/<\?FRX?FA;9;HWE;?%_�46ReRÉ_B?FEG<8?B5CP f DcO _`9#_BHWE 7;O;_F<8?B7.4§<,5$p�H$ f hI9;?F58?+<89;?+46O¸<\9;HW5Yh³H658k6?F7*J�HW5%<89;?+RQ4KPC<Y<Nh³?FEG< 2 ��J;dW? 2 ?B4658P����6O;PC<²4KP%h¢?¿A;58HWAÓHWPC?<\H²7;H f D%HWP <(A;5C?Fd�:XHWO P®5C?BPC?�465C_`9;?B5CP'9Ò4�d6?Y?��¸A;RXHW:=<\?F7¾P <\H�_`9Ò46P <\:X_ � HW5@A;5CH 1 4 1 :XRX:ePC<8:X_��^DYH¸7;?FRXPÐ<8H9;?FRXA�:XDYA;5CH�d6?Ð<\9 ?(7;?BPC:XVWE·46E;7�D%46EÒ4KVW?BDY?BE-<^H6JÃ_B46RXR[_B?BE-<8?B58P��-�ÒHW5³4­P\46DYA;RX?�H6JT<\9;?(A O 1 RX:eP89;?F758?FP8?B4658_`9�HWE�_B46RXRÊ_B?BE-<8?B58P�J�58HWD�,5$p�H$ f PC?B?vE³58:eV-46E;7 :Ï?F<�46R!�Di¥m>�Bl f >@O;5C:XE;Hpd�:X_��#�6HW9 58:Ï4KE;7 Q ?|d 2i�m��Bl f�� HWV-46E²?F<�46R!�pi��b�Bl f Q ?|d 2 ?F<�46R!�Di��-oOl f s·:XRX:=<\Hc?|<�46R��pi tWq0l f �¸?FV-46R"i t@�BlT4KE;7��+�B?zis�B�@l��n�Hph¢?FdW?F5 f <\9;?(A O 1 RX:eP89;?F7²58?BPC?�465C_`9�:ePÇHWE;R 2 <89;?@<\:eA�H6JT<\9;?(:e_B? 1 ?B5CV)� <89;?B5C?�h³46P^DcO _`9�DYHW58?

O;E;A O 1 RX:eP89;?F7#58?FP8?B4658_`9�HWE#_B46RXRU_F?BE-<\?F58P�4K<%,5$p�I$H�=,öP <\58H6E;V+AÓHW:XE-<'H6JI:XE-<\?F58EÒ4KR¢5C?BP8?B4658_`9�4§<,5$p�H$�HpdW?F5�<89;? 2 ?B4658P�9Ò46P 1 ?B?BE²<\9 ?®?���<\?BE P8:ed6?wO;PC?�H6JM_B46RXRK�N7;?|<`46:eR[7;4K<`4��

éÒê9��ê98Ïêow(ør:Ñô�ï§ô�óWúÒý-¡ÊîpòÑñÃô�ù�÷{w(¢£:Ñý�ð[ôÚî�ô�í��#õ'úÒý�ýAx*¤�ù-îpúÒô�ý"¤�ú î�ú

,Ç<5,5$p�H$�:e<Ñ9Ò46P±ReHWE;V 1 ?B?FE­58?F_BHWVWE :�B?F7c<\9Ò4§<±:e<M:XPÃE;?B_F?BPCP\465 2 <\H@?��¸A;RXHW:=<Ñ<89;?³J�O;ReR¸_B46RXRK�N7;?|<`46:eR7Ò4K<\4�:XE+H6587;?F5Ð<\H�A 58HWAÓ?B5CR 2 O;E;7;?F58PC<\46E;7�_�4KRXR��Î_B?FEG<8?B5�A[?F5CJ�HW5CD¹46E _B?@�I�ÒHW5 <\O;E;4K<\?FR 2Wf ,5$p�H$ 9Ò4KP9Ò467c46_B_F?BP8PÑ<\H@4KRXRW<\9 ?³E;?F_B?BPCP\465 2 _B46RXRK�N7;?|<`46:eR67Ò4K<\4��Ñ<89;?³_B46RXRK�N7;?|<`46:eR67Ò4§<`4�_B46Ec_FHWD%?UJ�58H6D�P8?Fd6?B5846RP8H6O;58_F?BP6_±<89;?Ð_FO;PC<8HWDY?B5 1 :XRXRe:XE;V(P 2 PC<\?FD f <\9;?�E;?F<Nh¢HW5Ck¹PChI:=<\_`9;?FP f <\9;?(&"E"G f 46E;7¹<89;?Ð_FHWD%A O <\?F57Ò4K<\4­E;?F<Nh¢HW58k�PCO;A;AÓHW5C<8:XE;V­<89;?�& a S P�H6JÑ<89;?�P8?F5Cd�:X_F?'5C?BA;P��$^9;?(_�4KRXR��Î7;?F<\46:XR 7Ò4K<`4®h³?F58?(O;PC?B7�<\H­9 ?BRXA¹D¹46E;46VW?I<\9;?�,5$p�H$ _BO PC<\H6D%?F5#�N_B4658?Ð_B?BE-<8?B58PI4KE;7

<\H¾467¸d¸:eP8?²_BO PC<\H6D%?F58P­hI:e<89$_B46RXR³_B?BE-<8?B58PY_BH6E;E;?B_|<\?F7 1-2 <\H6RXR��¶J�58?F? � m���kWoWo+PC?B5 d¸:e_B?>�­<8?BRX?FA;9;HWE ?RX:eE;?BP�4 1 HWO¸<'P 2 PC<\?FD A[?F5CJ�HW5CD¹4KE;_B?B�z$^9Ò4§<w4K7 d�:X_B?­h¢HWO;Re7/H6JÚ<8?BE�NCO;PC<8:eJ 2 P8?BReRX:eE;V�<\9;?Y_BO PC<\H6D%?F5DYHW58?@Re:XE;?FP f;1 O <ID%H658?(:XDYAÓHW5C<\46E-<\R 2 <89;?�467 d�:X_F?�_BHWE;P <\:=<\O <8?B7·4­P8:XV6E;:9JÒ_B46E-<I_BHWDYAÓHWE;?BE-<IH6JÃ<\9 ?m��4kWoWoÐPC?B5Cd�:e_B?IA;58Hpd�:X7 ?B7 1-2 ,5$p�H$�<\H(:=<\P±_FO;PC<8HWDY?B58P f ?BEÒ4 1 RX:XE VÐ<\9;?p,5$p�H$$_BO;P <\HWDY?B5CPj:eEc<\O;5CE<\H�A;5CHpd¸:e7;? 1 ?|<8<8?B5IP8?F5Cd�:X_F?®<8H�<89;?B:e5^_BO;P <\HWDY?B5CP6�b�E J�H65C<\O EÒ4K<\?FR 26f <\9 ?B58?·:XP�5C?BRQ4§<\:ed6?BR 2 RX:=<8<8RX?¹:eE$<89;?·HWA[?FE�Re:e<8?B5\4§<\O;5C?�HWE�?FD%A :X58:e_�46R¢PC<8O;7;:X?FP

H6Jj_�4KRXRM_F?BE-<\?F58P���b�P8O;46RXR 2Wf <89;?­7Ò4K<\4¹h³?F58?Y58?BVW46587;?F7¾46P(A;58H6A;58:e?F<`4K5 2 :XE J�HW5CD¹4§<\:XH6E��(LNE;7;?F?B7 f :e<:XP®7;:�e%_FO;Re<�<8H!H 1 <\46:XE/_�46ReR��Î7;?F<\46:XRÑ7Ò4K<`4²J�58HWD H6A[?F5\4K<8:XE;V·_�46ReRU_B?BE-<8?B58P f ?Fd6?BE#<\9 HWO;VW9/DcO;_`9#:eP4�dK46:XRX4 1 RX?�J�58HWDÛ<\9;?I, a >q�ZÐJc_BH6O;58PC? f _�46ReR(_B?FEG<8?B5CP!7;H$A[?F5CJ�HW5CD 7Ò4K<\4�46E;46R 2 P8:eP²46E;7�D¹46kK?/AÓ?B5 J�HW58D%46E;_F?�58?BAÓHW5 <\P6�

n�Hph¢?Fd6?B5 f <89;?+hI:X7 ?BR 2 4�dK46:XRX4 1 RX?·58?FA[H65C<\P�A 58H�7;O;_B?F7*J�HW5�_�4KRXRÐ_F?BE-<\?F5²D¹46E;46VW?B5CP�465C?¿P\46DYA;RX?

Page 7: uwv[xzy|{F} ~py - Columbia Universityww2040/full.pdf · uwv[xzy|{F} ~py Q ` G N N ` 8 C | U C ` \ j = U ' \ = z \ p z N - \ z ¢¡G F£6 ¥¤ ¥ -¦ p Y = § N ` Q p \

4�dW?F5\46VW?FP^HpdW?B5³:XE-<\?F5CdK46RXP f O P8OÒ46ReR 2 5846E;VW:eE;V'J�5CHWDMJ;dW?@<8Hw<\9 :X5C< 2 DY:XEGO <8?BP��ÉLÎ<Ç?Fd�:e7;?BE-<\R 2 9;46P³E;HK<1 ?B?BE·7;?F?BDY?B7�h¢HW5 <\9-hI9;:XRe?@<\H�_BH6RXRX?F_F<�46E 7�D%46:XE-<\46:XE¹J�O RXRÊ_B46RXRK�N7;?|<`46:eR[7;4K<`4��LÎ<Ð:eP^<\9GO;P�d6?B5 2 9 ?BRXA¸J�O;R�<\9Ò4K<�P8:eVWE;:�JÒ_�46E-<�?BDYA;:e58:X_B46RÏP <\O;7;:e?BP�H6J±_B46RXR�_F?BE-<\?F58P@9;4pd6?w5C?B_B?FE-<\R 2

1 ?B?BE._FHWE;7;O _F<\?F7$46E;7#5C?BAÓHW5C<8?B7 1-2 s!46E;7;?FR 1 4KO;D ?|<­46R!�¥i¦�Gr0l³46E;7¨§ÊHW9Ò465'?F<­4KR��riskb�0l���$^9;?46EÒ4KR 2 P8:ePj:eE�i¦�Gr�l[:eP 1 46P8?F7¹HWEY<\9;?^J�O;ReRÒ_�46ReR��Î7;?F<\46:XR¸58?B_FHW587%H6J��@�b� f oWoWo@<\?FRX?BA 9;HWE;?�_�46ReRXP±<8Hw4 1 46E;kHpdW?F5(4%<Nh¢?BRed6?��ÎD%HWE-<89+A[?F58:eH¸7��D$^9;?c?FD%A :X58:e_�46R�P <\O;7 :X?BP@4658?'_BRX?B4658R 2 _B5C:e<\:e_�46R!�3$^9;?B5C?­:XP�4¹E;?F?B7J�HW5^DYHW58?(?FD%A :X58:e_�46RÓh³H658k �

éÒê9��ê9uÏêÛü%<Tù+ü³ï�úÒñTù©�jô�î�ù�ï�ú îpòÃï�ù

$^9;?B5C?@:XP¢46ReP8H'4®dK46PC<¢A;5CH6J�?BPCP8:XH6EÒ46RÒ<\58467;?ÐRe:e<8?B5\4§<\O;5C?^HWE¹_B46RXRl_B?FE-<\?B5CP^46E;7Y<\9;?�D%H658?�VW?BE;?F5\46R_BH6EG<\46_F< _F?BE-<\?F58P f hI9;:e_`9 _�46E 1 ? 46_B_F?BPCP8?B7 ?�4KP8:XR 2 J�5CHWD <\9;? LNE-<\?F58E;?|< f ?@� V)� f J�58HWD9-<8<8A�_m`@`§h^h^hI� A :XA;kG:XE P6� _BHWD}`K58?FP8HWO 58_B?FP6� 46P8A 4KE;7n9-<C<\A�_a`b`§h^h^hI� _�46ReRX_F?BE-<\?F58E;?|hIP6� _BHWD � ª�H�H�7HpdW?F5Cd�:X?|hIP%H6J�_FO;585C?BE-<%46A;A;5CH-46_`9;?FP�<8H�_BHWE-<`4K_F<f�Î_B?FEG<8?B5�D%46EÒ46VW?FD%?FE-<�_�46E 1 ?�H 1 <`4K:XE;?F7#J�58HWD,ÐE-<8HWE¥i¦�@l f EÇ465 1 ?F5^?F<�46R��3i r0lÃ4KE;7 a RX?Fd6?BRX46E;7�46E;7!s!4 2¸1 ?BE¥i¥mprOl!�

éÒê9��êK�Tê«¡Êî�ð�óB<TúÒ÷Fîpôÿó�¬�ð�ñTù¸ý�÷

,ÐP¢AÒ465C<jH6J[<\9;?�RXH6E;V'5C?BPC?�465C_`9¹<\58467;:e<8:XHWE f :e<U9Ò46P 1 ?B?BE¹PC<`4KE;7Ò465C7%<\H®O;PC?ÐPC<8H¸_`9;46PC<8:X_�D%H�7;?BReP f?BPCA[?F_B:X46RXR 2 ��O ?BO;?F:XE;V¿DYH¸7 ?BRXP���$^9 ?¹h³H658kG9;HW5CP8?��GO;?FO;?B:eE;V¿D%H�7;?FRXP®9Ò4�dW? 1 ?B?FE#<\9;?�SÉ5CRQ46E;V E� ReHWP8P*�Ç46E;7 a � 7;?BRX4 2 �³DYH¸7 ?BRXP f kGE;HphIE!4KP(­�®>­¯®b°�:XE�<\9;?�P <`46E;7;46587 � ?BE;7Ò4KRXR��GO;?FO;?B:eE;V%E H6<`40�<\:eHWE��H$^9;?­DYHWP <(_BHWDYDYHWE!?��¸<8?BE;PC:XHWE P®_FHWE;PC:X7;?F58?B7¾4K<C<\?FD%A <�<\H²46_F_BHWO EG<(J�H65Ð_BO PC<\H6D%?F5�4 1 46EC�7;HWE D%?FEG< f _FO;PC<8HWDY?B5­58?|<\5C:Q46ReP f E;HWE+�N?��¸AÓHWE;?FEG<8:Q46R³_�46ReR��N9 HWRX7;:eE;VB�¶<\:XDY?c7;:ePC<858: 1 O <\:eHWE;P­46E 7�<8:XDY?��dK465 2 :eE;V@465C58:=d64KR-5\4K<8?BP f61 O <±?|dW?FEc<\9;?FP8?³J�46DY:XRe:Q465[A;9;?FE;HWDY?BEÒ4ÐAÓHWPC?³P8?F58:eHWO;P±4KEÒ46R 2 PC:XPÃ_`9Ò46RXRe?BE;V6?BP6�Q 4658VW?FR 2 P <\:XDwO;RQ4K<8?B7 1-2 <\9;?®5\46A :X7·VW58Hph^<\9�H6JÉ_FHWE-<`46_|<Ð_F?BE-<\?F58P f <\9;?'D%H658?®46_�4K7;?BDY:X_�A;O 1 �

RX:eP89;?F7�58?FP8?B4658_`9²RX:=<\?F5\4K<8O;58?�HWE�_FHWE-<`46_|<^_B?FEG<8?B5CP^:XP³E H�h�VW5CHphI:XE;V'5\46A;:e7;R 26f 4KP³_�4KE 1 ?@PC?B?FE�J�58HWD<\9 ?�5C?B_F?BE-<jP8O;5 dW? 2 H6E±�GO;?FO;?B:eE;V®D%H�7;?BReP±H6J[_�46ReR _F?BE-<\?F58P 1G2{� H�HWRe?^46E;7%s!46E 7;?BR 1 46O;Dci��-r�l f <\9 ?RXH6E;VW?B5�<\O <8HW58:X46RMAÒ4KA[?F5 1G2 ª®46E P f�� H¸H6RX?c4KE;7/s!46E;7;?FR 1 4KO;D i qWqOlU4KE;7�58?BPC?�465C_`9 1 : 1 RX:eHWVW5846A;9 21-2 s!46E 7;?BR 1 46O;D²i¦�;m6l!� g ?|dW?B5 <\9;?FRX?FP8P f DcO;_`9·58?FD¹4K:XE;P³<8H 1 ?(7;HWE ?@�

éÒê9³�êLy¹ù¸÷Fù�ú ïKó0<´¤²ô�ï�ù�ó6î�ô�ðÓíÑ÷

3�?U7;?FP8_F58: 1 ?É58?FP8?B4658_`9'7;:X5C?B_F<8:XHWE PÏ58?FRQ4K<8?B7@<\HIP <\H�_`9Ò46PC<8:X_ÉDYH¸7 ?BRXPÊH6J�_BHWE-<`4K_F<Ã_B?FEG<8?B5CP f 4K:XDY:XE;V<\H�O;E;_FH�d6?B5MJ�O E;7Ò46DY?BE-<`4KR�A 58:XE _B:XA RX?BPÃ46E 7w7;?|dW?BReHWAcAÓ?B5 J�HW58D%46E;_F?���4KEÒ46R 2 PC:XP�<\H�HWRXP�<89Ò4K<ÃhI:XRXR-D%46kK?

t

Page 8: uwv[xzy|{F} ~py - Columbia Universityww2040/full.pdf · uwv[xzy|{F} ~py Q ` G N N ` 8 C | U C ` \ j = U ' \ = z \ p z N - \ z ¢¡G F£6 ¥¤ ¥ -¦ p Y = § N ` Q p \

:e<'AÓHWP8PC: 1 Re?%<\H!:XDYA;58HpdW?Y<\9;?¹7;?BPC:XVWE.4KE;7.D¹4KEÒ46VW?FD%?FEG<'H6JI_FHWE-<`46_|<­_B?FEG<8?B5CP6�©$^9;?�VWHW46RU:XP'<8H:XDYA;5CH�d6?'<89;?%�GOÒ46Re:e< 2 46E 7!<\9;?w?�eY_B:e?BE;_ 2 H6JUPC?B5 d¸:e_B?wd�:X4%_BH6EG<\46_F<Ð_B?FEG<8?B5CP6�(LNE;7;?F?B7 f h³?wh¢HWO;Re7RX:ek6?Y<\H+PC:XDcO;R=<`46E ?BHWO;PCR 2 46_`9;:e?Fd6? 1 HK<\9.H 1 NC?F_F<8:edW?FP6_Y3�?¹h¢HWO;Re7.RX:ek6?%<8H+D%46k6?�:=<wAÓHWPCP8: 1 RX?%J�H65P8?F5Cd�:X_F?^A;58Hpd�:X7 ?B58PÑ<\H@A;5CHpd¸:e7;?Ç9;:eVW9;?F57�GOÒ46RX:=< 2 P8?B5 d�:X_B?³D%HW5C?³?�e%_F?BE-<\R 2 �Fn�H�h¢?Fd6?B5 f h¢?^58?F_BHWV6E;:�F?<\9;4K<±:=<M:ePÑH6JÚ<8?BEcE ?B_B?FP8P8465 2 <8H 1 4KRQ46E;_F?¢<89;?BPC?Ç_BHWDYAÓ?F<\:eE;VÐH 1 NC?B_|<\:ed6?BP��M3�?¢h³HWO RX7cRe:Xk6?U<\H 1 ?Ç4 1 RX?<\HÐ_BHWE;PCO;Re<±46E;7­4K7 d�:XP8?³_BHWE-<`4K_F<f�Î_B?FEG<8?B5±D%46EÒ4KVW?B5CPÑ<\H�7Ò4 2WfK1 O <ÉH6O;5MD%46:XE'46:eD�:XPÑ<8H@O;E;_FHpdW?B5U4KE;7467;7 58?BPCP'J�O;E 7Ò46DY?BE-<`46RUA;5CH 1 Re?BDYP®<89Ò4K<'D%?F?F<'RXHWE;V0�Î<\?F58D E;?B?F7;P6�²3�?YP89 HWO;RX7/P8?F?Bk/467;7;:=<\:XH6EÒ46R?��¸AÓHWP8O 58?c<\H¹HWA[?F5\4K<8:XE;V%_BHWE-<\46_F<Ð_B?BE-<8?B58P f�1 O <(A 58:XD%465C:XR 2 <\H�VW46:XE!4 1 ?|<8<8?B5@O;E 7;?B5CPC<`4KE;7;:XE V�H6J<\9 ?Ð:XDYAÓHW5C<\46E-<jJ�O E;7Ò46DY?BE-<`4KR[:eP8P8O ?BP6�É3/?�h³46E-<Ç<\HwP8:XV6E;:9JÒ_B46E-<\R 2 467 dK46E;_F?Ð<\9 ?ÐPC<\4K<\?ÐH6JÏ<\9 ?@465 <H6JÑPC<8H¸_`9Ò4KPC<\:e_�D%H�7;?BReRX:eE;Vw:eE²<89;?®4658?B4­H6JM_FO;PC<8HWDY?B5I_BHWE-<\46_F<�_B?FE-<\?B5CP6�

8ÏêLy�ù�÷BùGú;ï§óB<�õ%<TúÒý�ý�ù�í��Óù�÷

LNE�<\9 :XP³PC?B_|<\:XH6E�h³?@7 ?BP8_F58: 1 ?@PCHWDY?@H6J�<\9 ?@?��¸_B:=<\:eE;Vc58?FP8?B4658_`9²_`9Ò46ReRX?FE;VW?BPjh³?(PC?B?@:eE�7;?|dW?BReHWA;:eE;V46E;7�46EÒ4KR 2 �B:eE;V­:XE;PC:XVW9-<CJ�O;RÏPC<8H¸_`9;46PC<8:X_�D%H�7;?FRXPÇH6JÑ_BH6EG<\46_F<�_F?BE-<\?F58P6�

8Ïê�élêT¡�µ�ô�ýÿý¶x*·cúÒ÷Bù�ñ�y�ðÓò�î�ôÿí��

8Ïê�élê�éÒêP¬òÑýÚî�ô¸:Mý�ù·ü(�£:Éù�÷

LNE)DYH¸7 ?B58E$_�4KRXR^_B?FE-<\?B5CP¹:=<�:XP�_BHWDYDYHWE.<\H¾9Ò4�dW?!DwO;Re<8:XA;Re?¹< 2 A[?FP¹H6JÐ_�46ReRXP�46E;7$DcO;R=<\:eA;RX?< 2 A[?FP�H6JjP8?B5 d�:X_B?�5C?BA;P���Z@E;?­hÇ4 2 <8H�_BRQ4KP8P8:=J 2 _B46RXReP@:XP 1G2 RQ46E;V6OÒ46VW?B_�3 :e<89+<\9;?­V6RXH 1 4KRX:�B4K<\:eHWEH6J^D%46E 2�1 O;PC:XE;?FP8PC?BP f _B46RXRÉ_F?BE-<\?F58PcHKJÚ<\?BE/58?F_B?B:=dW?%_�46ReRXP�:XE/P8?Fd6?B5846R¢7 :9d[?B58?FE-<cRQ4KE;VWOÒ46V6?BP6�}$^9;?_�4KRXRX?F58P(4KE;7¿<\9;?­PC?B5Cd�:e_B?­58?FA;P�?�46_`9¾D%4 2 P8AÓ?�4Kk+HWE;?­HW5ÐD%HW5C?cH6JjP8?|dW?F5\46RÉAÓHWP8PC: 1 Re?cRQ4KE;VWOÒ46V6?BP f1 O <ÇE;H6<^E;?F_B?FP8P\4K58:XR 2 4KRXRÓH6J�<\9;?FD��5,�E;7 f HKJT_BHWO;5CP8? f :e<³:XP³E H6<^A;5846_F<8:X_�4KRÓJ�HW5¢<\9;?@PC?B5 d¸:e_B?(5C?BA;P³<8HRX?B4658E¹46RXRÒ<89;?@RQ4KE;VWOÒ46V6?BP6� � �ÒHW5j58?BPC?�465C_`9²HWE�DY?F<\9 H¸7;Pj<\H­4KEÒ46R 2 �F?ÐDcO;R=<\:eRX:XE VWOÒ46R�<\?BRe?BA;9 HWE;?@_B46RXR_B?FE-<\?B5CP f P8?F?%�G<`46E J�H6587�46E;7�ª�5846P8PCD¹4KE;E�is�b�0l��a�,ÐE;HK<\9;?F5�_FRQ46PCP8:9J;_�4K<8:XHWE :XE-d6HWRed6?BP·P8AÓ?B_B:X46R(A;5CHWD%HK<\:XH6E;P6�o$^9;?/_�46ReRX?B5CP�D¹4 2*1 ?¾_�46ReRX:XE V.4

P8AÓ?B_F:Q46R�kWoWo¹EGO;D 1 ?F5@7;?BPC:XVWE;4K<\?F7+J�HW5�<89;?cP8AÓ?B_F:Q46RÃA;5CHWD%HK<\:XH6E�� a HW5C58?FP8AÓHWE;7;:eE;VWR 26f <89;?cP8?F5Cd�:X_F?58?FA;P±< 2 A;:X_B46RXR 2 4658?¢<\5\4K:XE;?F7w<\H@5C?BPCA[HWE 7�<8H@:XE���O :X58:e?BPÑ4 1 HWO <ÉPCHWD%?¢H6JÒ<\9 ?^4�d64K:XRQ4 1 RX?UA;5CHWD%HK<\:XH6E;P f1 O <'E;H6<'46ReR±H6Jj<\9;?FD�� Q ?�465CE;:XE;V·4 1 HWO <®PCA[?F_B:Q4KRÉA;58HWDYH6<8:XHWE;P(:eP�_B?B5 <`46:eE;R 2 RX?FP8P®7;:9eY_BO Re<(<\9;46ERX?B4658E :XE;VY?BE-<\:e58?cRX46E;VWO;46VW?BP f[1 O <@:=<�<8?BE;7;P�<\H 1 ?wA;5CHW9;: 1 :e<8:edW?�<\H%<\?�4K_`9¿46RXRTPC?B5Cd�:e_B?c5C?BA;P(4 1 HWO¸<46ReRMP8AÓ?B_F:Q46RMA;58HWDYH6<8:XHWE;P��v�¸:XDY:XRX4658R 2Wf :XE+<8?B_`9;E;:e_�46R � ?@� V)� f _BHWDYA;O <8?B5��Ð9 ?BRXA¿7 ?BP8kGP f PC?B5Cd�:e_B?�58?FA;PD%4 2 HWE;R 2�1 ?'4 1 RX?@<8HY9 ?BRXA·_BO PC<\H6D%?F58P^hI:e<89·PCHWDY?®HKJÑ<89;?B:e5Ç<\?B_`9 E;:X_B46R�A;58H 1 RX?FD%P��

Page 9: uwv[xzy|{F} ~py - Columbia Universityww2040/full.pdf · uwv[xzy|{F} ~py Q ` G N N ` 8 C | U C ` \ j = U ' \ = z \ p z N - \ z ¢¡G F£6 ¥¤ ¥ -¦ p Y = § N ` Q p \

$^9GO;P f J�5C?6�GO;?BE-<8R 2Wf <\9;?�_�4KRXRXP¹9Ò4�dW?¾7;:9d[?B5C?BE-<²58?���O :X58?FD%?FE-<\P�46E;7*<\9;?�PC?B5Cd�:e_B?�58?FA;P�9;4pd6?7;:�dÊ?F58?BE-<'P8kG:XReRXP����ÒHW5C<8O;EÒ4K<8?BR 2Wf D%H�7;?B5CE#46O¸<\HWD%4K<\:e_­_�46ReRÉ7;:XP <\5C: 1 O <8HW58P � , a >qS P*�®9Ò4�dW?Y<\9;?Y_�4O�AÒ4 1 :XRX:=< 2 HKJM5CHWO <\:eE;V�_�46ReRXP³<8H�P8?B5 d�:X_B?®58?FA;PIhI:e<\9�<89;?®46A;A;5CHWA;58:X4K<\?(PCkG:XRXReP6�7$^9GO;P�<\9;?�_B46RXRK�N_B?FE-<\?B5L a $ì?6�GO;:eA;DY?BE-<c_B46E#46ReRXHph0J�H65®<89;?¹VW?FE;?B5846RX:9��4K<8:XHWE¿<8H!DcO;R=<\:eA;RX?w< 2 AÓ?BP���$^9Ò4§<c_�4KAÒ4 1 :eRX:e< 2 H6J, a >qS P�:ePI_�46ReRX?B7 �¹0�A�A�º\#»�10��?¼' *.0YC�^�A/+Z � ��EÇ]g���LNE�J�46_|< f <\9 ?B58?'D¹4 2�1 ?'467;7;:=<\:XH6EÒ46R�~Ò?��¸: 1 :eRX:e< 2 �-�Ñ:X58P < f <\9 ?B58?®D%4 2²1 ?®DcO;Re<8:XA;Re?@P8kG:eRXR�RX?|dW?FRXP6_

�¸HWDY?­P8kG:eRXRXP�4K58?­A;5C:XD%465 2 P8kG:XReRXP f hI9 :XRX?wH6<\9;?F5�P8kG:XReRXP�465C?­P8?B_FHWE;7Ò4K5 2 P8kG:XReRXP��q$^9;?Y:X7;?B4²:eP@<\9Ò4§<_�4KRXRXP®58?��GO;:X5C:XE;V!4�AÒ465 <\:e_BO;RX465�P8kG:XReRjPC9;HWO;Re7rJÒ5CPC< 1 ?¹5CHWO <\?F7�<\H+4�P8?F5Cd�:X_F?�58?FA#hI:e<89/<\9;4K<cPCk�:eRXR46P�4�A;58:eD¹4K5 2 P8kG:XReR��#Z(E R 2 :=J�46RXRÇPC?B5 d¸:e_B?²58?FA;P­hI:e<89�<89;?²P8kG:XReRÇ46PY4¿A;5C:XD%465 2 P8kG:XReRÇ465C? 1 O;P 2P89 HWO;RX7�P8?B5 d�:X_B?�5C?BA;P'hI:e<\9#<89Ò4K<wP8kG:XReR³46Pw4+P8?F_BHWE;7;465 2 P8kG:XReR 1 ?�_FHWE;P8:e7;?B5C?B7��j$^9GO;P f <89;?�PCk�:eRXRRX?|dW?FR�A;58Hpd�:X7;?FPÐ4­PC?B5Cd�:e_B?�A;58:eHW58:=< 2 J�HW5I4KP8P8:eVWE;:eE;V­_�46ReRXP³<8H%PC?B5 d¸:e_B?�58?FA;P6��¸?B_FHWE;7 f P8?|dW?F5\46R@7 :9d[?B58?FE-<�_�4KRXRI_B?FEG<8?B5CP f ?B46_`9,hI:e<89�<89;?B:e5¹HphIE´, a > f DY:XV69G< 1 ?!RX:eE;k6?F7

<\H6VW?F<89;?B5c<8H�J�H658D 4�E ?F<Nh¢HW58k#HKJÐ_B46RXR¢_B?BE-<8?B58P��¨$^9;?B5C?²:XPw<89�O P�<89;?²A[H6P8P8: 1 :XRe:e< 2 H6J�58?F58HWO¸<\:XE V<\584BeY_(J�58HWDnHWE;?�H6JÃ<\9;?FP8?®_�46ReRÏ_B?FEG<8?B5CP�<8H%4KE;H6<\9 ?B5I:XE²HW5C7;?B5^<\H 1 ?F<C<\?B5 1 4KRQ46E;_F?@<\9;?�ReH-467;P��

8Ïê�élê98ÏêÛü%<Tù¾õ%<TúÒýÿý�ù�í��lù ½®ü³ð¥¤�ð¾¡�µ�ô�ý�ýAx*·cúÒ÷Bù�ñ¿y¹ð[ò�î�ô�í��ÁÀ0ù�ý�ý

n�Hph¢?FdW?F5 f :e<':XP®7;:�e%_FO;Re<®<\H!D¹46E;46VW?�<\9;?%DcO;Re<8:��¶< 2 AÓ?�P 2 PC<8?BD ?�d[?B_F<8:ed6?BR 2 � �Ñ:X58P < f J�HW5w4KE 2VW:=dW?BEw_BHWReRX?B_|<\:eHWE'HKJÒP8?F5Cd�:X_F?Ç58?FA;P f :=<M:ePÑ7;:�eY_BO;R=<Ñ<8H@7;H�<89;?Ç5CHWO <\:eE;VÐHKJÒ_�46ReRXPT<\H�P8?B5 d�:X_B?³58?BA P±:XEw46E?�d[?B_|<\:=dW?wD%46E;E ?B5 f Re?F<Ð46RXHWE ?'4KE!HWA <8:XD%46RÏD%46E;E;?F56�³3 :=<\9·<\9;?®L a $�?6�GO;:eA;D%?FE-< f :e<�:XP�A[H6P8P8: 1 RX?<\H¿H 1 <`46:eE.58?FRX?FdK46E-<­7;4K<`4+J�HW5cD%46kG:XE V!<\9;?�5CHWO <8:XE;V¿7;?F_B:eP8:XH6E fÉ1 O <�PCH�J�4K5cHWE;R 2 5CO;7;:XDY?BE-<\465 246ReVWHW58:=<\9;DYPY4658?!O;P8?F7���3 9;:XRe?�<89;?B5C?¿4658?!P8kG:XReR�� 1 46P8?F7C�N5CHWO <\:eE;V � ��EÇ]g�%4KRXVWHW5C:e<89;D%P�:eE,A;RQ4K_B? f<\9 ?B58?�5C?BD%46:XE;PI4­VW5C?�4K<�HWA A[HW5 <\O;E :e< 2 J�H65^7;?Fd�:XPC:XE;V 1 ?F<C<\?B5I5CHWO <\:eE;V�46ReVWHW58:=<\9;DYP6��¸?B_FHWE;7 f :e<w58?BD%46:eE;Pw<\H�7;?|<\?F58DY:XE;?�9 H�höD¹4KE 2 P8?F5Cd�:X_F?·5C?BA;PchI:=<\9�P8AÓ?B_F:Q46R³P8kG:XReR³P8?|<\PY465C?

E;?F?B7;?F7��':!� ?B� f <89;?B5C?¿:XP�4#DYHW58?�_BHWDYA;Re:X_�4§<\?B7)PC<`40e%E V.A;58H 1 RX?BD :XE,<89;?¿DcO;R=<\:K�Î< 2 A[?·P8?|<8<8:XE;V)�$^9;?·A;58H 1 RX?FD H6JÐJ�H658?B_B46PC<8:XE;V¾:XP�DcO _`9�DYHW58?²7;:�eY_BO;R=<>��3 :e<\9�DcO Re<\:eA;RX?%< 2 AÓ?BP f h³?·E;?F?B7�<8HA;5C?B7;:e_F< f E;H6<'HWE;R 2 <89;?¹<8H6<`46RU_B46RXRj465C58:edK46RÉ584K<\? f±1 O <c46RXPCH�<89;?¹_B46RXRj465C58:edK46RÉ584K<\?YJ�HW5®?�46_`9._B46RXR< 2 A[?B�Çs·HW58?FH�d6?B5 f hI:=<\9�<\9;?�A;5CHWDYH6<\:eHWE;P f <\9;?®7;?FD¹46E 7·D%4 2�1 ?�<85\46E P8:X?FE-< f P8H�<\9;4K<I<\9;?F58?�D¹4 21 ?®Re:e<C<\RX?�9;:XP <\HW5 2 <8HY5C?BR 2 O;AÓHWE��S±dW?BE�4KJÚ<\?F5j?FPC<8:XD%4K<\:eE;V@<\9;?I_B46RXRl465C58:=d64KR 5\4§<\?BP 1-2 < 2 A[? f <89;?B5C?�5C?BD%46:XE­7;:�eY_BO;R=<\:X?FPÉ:XEY7;?F<8?B5��

DY:XE;:eE;V¹<\9 ?%4KA;A;58H6A;58:X4K<\?­P <`4BeYE;V·RX?|dW?BReP�:XE�7;:9d[?B5C?BE-<®_�4K<8?BVWH658:X?FP6�%ZÐJ³_FHWO;5CP8? f <\9 ?YReHWE;VB�¶<\?F58DPC<\4BeYE;V¹A 58H 1 Re?BDn:XPI_BHWE E;?B_|<\?B7�<\H�<\9;?�P89 HW5C<#�Î<\?F58D 5CHWO <\:eE;V�A;58H 1 RX?FD f PCHY<89Ò4K<�4­J�O;RXRÏPCHWRXO¸<\:XH6E

r

Page 10: uwv[xzy|{F} ~py - Columbia Universityww2040/full.pdf · uwv[xzy|{F} ~py Q ` G N N ` 8 C | U C ` \ j = U ' \ = z \ p z N - \ z ¢¡G F£6 ¥¤ ¥ -¦ p Y = § N ` Q p \

58?��GO;:X5C?BPIP8HWR=d�:XE;V 1 H6<\9²A;5CH 1 RX?FD%P f E;H6<�NCO PC<�HWE;?B�ª®4K58E;?|<8<�46E 7$s!46E;7;?FR 1 4KO;D i qB�@l³_BHWE 7;O;_F<8?B7$4+P8:eDcO;RX4K<\:eHWE/P <\O;7 2 <\H!P89;HphnP8HWDY?�H6JI<\9 ?

HWAÓ?B584K<\:eHWEÒ46RI_BH6D%A;Re?��¸:e<8:X?FP%H6J�PCkG:XRXRK� 1 4KP8?B7)58HWO <8:XE;V���]I?BP8?B4658_`9 HWE�<\9;?+7 :9eY_BO;R=<�A;5CH 1 Re?BD H6JP8kG:eRXR�� 1 46PC?B7!5CHWO <8:XE;VY9Ò46P 1 ?B?FE+7;HWE ? 1-2 &Ã?B585 2 4KE;7 g :eRXPCP8HWE¥i t@�0l fÂ� H¸HWRe?w4KE;7�$Ñ46RX:eD²is�@kBl±4KE;7E³HW5CPC<�46E;7��¸?F58:�i�m��0l!�F$^9;?B5C?':eP^_BRX?B4658R 2 5CH¸H6DnJ�HW5^DcO _`9�DYHW58?(5C?BPC?�465C_`9��

8Ïê98�êLy¹ù¸÷Fð[òTï§óWù�Ã@ðÏðÓý�ôÿí��

8Ïê98�ê�éÒêÛü%<TùÁÄ�ðÓú;ý#½Iw(Å#ó-ô�ù�íÃó@�ÇÆ%ôÚîO<�¬òÃý�îpô^:Ñý�ù·ü(�£:Éù�÷

,ÐE%?���<\5C?BDY?Ð_B46P8?�hI:e<\9Y7;:�dÊ?F58?BE-<¢P8kG:XReRXPU:XPÉ<8Hw9Ò4�dW?�P8?FAÒ465\4§<\?ÐV658HWO;A P¢H6JÏP8?B5 d�:X_B?�58?FA;P³7;?F7;:X_B4K<\?F7<\H¾?�4K_`9,7;:9d[?B5C?BE-<%P8kG:XReR^P8?F<6�´$^9;?BE f :XE;P <\?�4K7�H6J@HWE;? 1 :XV¾_�46ReR^_B?FEG<8?B5 f h³?·h³HWO RX7$?�d[?B_F<8:ed6?BR 29Ò4�dW?�4�RX4658V6?wEGO;D 1 ?B5@HKJUDcO;_`9�P8D%46RXRe?B5�:XE;7 ?BAÓ?BE;7;?FE-<�_�46ReRÑ_F?BE-<\?F58P6�'b�AÓHWE¿?B46_`9�_�46ReRM465C58:=d64KR f<\9 ?w_�4KRXRT_�46E 1 ?'58HWO¸<\?B7�<\H%<89;?'46A;A;5CHWA;58:X4K<\?®VW5CHWO;A!HKJÉP8?F5Cd�:X_F?c58?FA;P6�I3 :e<89!4z&ÑHW:eP8P8H6E¿46585C:edK46RA;5CH¸_F?BP8Pj<\H®<\9;?�J�O;RXRÒ_B46RXRÒ_F?BE-<\?F5 f 4KE;7¹hI:e<89%:eE;7;?FA[?FE;7;?BE-<pE¢?B58E HWO;RXRe:;58H6O <\:eE;V®<8H'<89;?ÐPCO 1 VW5CHWO;A;P f<\9 ?%PC?BAÒ46584K<\?%465C58:edK46RÑA;58H�_B?FP8PC?BPw<8H²<89;?YP8O 1 V658HWO;A P 1 ?B_FHWD%?YDcO <8OÒ46ReR 2 :XE;7;?FA[?FE;7;?FEG<q&ÑHW:eP8PCHWEA;5CH¸_F?BP8PC?BP��3�¸H f :XE;7;?F?B7 f <89;?�P8D%46RXRe?B5ÇV658HWO;A P�7 H%4K_F<�46P^P8?FAÒ46584K<\?®:XE;7 ?BAÓ?BE;7;?FE-<Ð_B46RXR[_B?BE-<8?B58P��$^9;?Y7;:9eY_BO Re< 2 hI:=<\9¿<\9 :XP(AÒ465 <\:=<\:XH6E;:XE;V%H6Jj<\9;?�_B?FE-<\?B5�:eEG<8H²P8D%46RXRe?B5ÐPCO 1 _B?BE-<8?B58P':XP@<89Ò4K<�:e<

<\?FE;7;P�<\H 1 ?�DcO;_`9$RX?BPCP�?�eY_B:e?BE-<>��LNE$HWA[?F5\4K<8:XHWE f PCHWDY?�H6J�<89;?²P8D%46RXRe?B5cPC?B5 d¸:e_B?²VW5CHWO;A;PY465C?RX:ek6?FR 2 <\H 1 ?�HpdW?F58RXHW467;?B7 f hI9 :XRX?¹H6<\9;?F58P­4K58?�O;E;7 ?B58O¸<\:XRe:�F?B7��¿LNE;7 ?B?B7 f :=<c:XP'h³?FRXRÇkGE;HphIE.<\9Ò4§<RQ4K58VW?F5cP8?F5Cd�:X_F?·V658HWO;A P�4658?�DYHW58?¹?�eY_B:e?BE-<>�¾�ÒHW5cPCHWDY?�P8O;A;AÓHW5 <\:XE V+<\9;?FHW5 2 ?FPC<\4 1 RX:eP89;:eE;V+<\9 ??�eY_F:X?BE _ 2 H6JIRX4658V6?B5cPC?B5Cd�:e_B?�VW5CHWO;A;P � O;E;7;?F5­58?FVWO;RQ4K58:e< 2 _FHWE;7;:=<\:XH6E;P�� f P8?B?h��D%:=<\9.46E 7�3 9 :e<8<i��WoBlÐ46E;7)3 9;:=<8<�i r0�@l��R$^9;?+A;46A[?F5©i��WoBl�?��¸A;ReHW:e<8P%P <\H�_`9Ò46PC<8:X_��NHW5C7;?B5%58?BRX4K<\:eHWE;P�<\H/P89;Hph <\9Ò4§<AÓ?B5CJ�H658D%46E;_B?M:XDYA;58HpdW?FPÏhI:e<89®PC_�46Re? f ?@� V)� f hI9;?BE�<Nh³HIP 2 P <\?FD%P�hI:e<89�_BHWDYD%H6E@_BO;P <\HWDY?B5�9 HWRX7;:eE;VB�<\:eD%?j7;:ePC<\5C: 1 O¸<\:XH6E;P±465C?Ç_BH6D 1 :XE ?B7��Ã3 9;?BEc<89;?^_BO;P <\HWDY?B5M9;HWRX7 :XE;VB�¶<\:eD%?É7;:ePC<858: 1 O <\:eHWE;P±4K58?¢d6?B5 27;:�dÊ?F58?BE-< f AÒ465C<8:e<8:XHWE;P�_�4KE 1 ?­467¸d64KEG<\46VW?FHWO;P f 4KP@hI:e<\9¿PCO;AÓ?B58D%465Ck6?F<�?��¸A;58?FP8P�_`9;?B_`kKHWO <'RQ46E ?BP6��ÒHW5²4�PC<\O 7 2 :XE-dW?FPC<8:XV-4K<8:XE;V�9;Hph <\H$7;?F<8?B58DY:XE ?¾V6H¸H�7*AÒ465 <\:e<8:XHWE P f hI9 ?BE�A;465C<8:e<\:eHWE;P�HKJw<\9 ?P8?F5Cd6?B58PÐ4658?�4KA;A;58H6A;58:X4K<\? f P8?F?®3 9;:=<8<vi�kWo0l!�E 2 9Ò4�d�:XE;V²DYHW58?{~Ò?��¸: 1 Re?­P8?B5 d�:X_B?Y58?FA;P�hI:e<\9�DcO Re<\:eA;RX?wP8kG:XReRXP f :=<�:XP(AÓHWP8PC: 1 Re?c<\H·D%?F?F<�<\9 ?

P8AÓ?B_F:Q46R�E ?B?B7 PÐH6JM_BO;P <\HWDY?B5CP�4KE;7 2 ?F<�PC<\:eRXRÏ9;4pd6?'PCHWDY?®HKJM<\9 ?®?�eY_B:X?FE;_ 2 H6J±4YPC:XE;V6RX?(RQ4K58VW?(_B46RXR_B?FE-<\?B5��@LNE+J�46_|< f 4¹P8D%46RXRÃ46DYHWO;E-<�H6J5~Ò?�� : 1 :XRe:e< 2 D%4 2 VWH�4¹ReHWE;VYhÇ4 2 �ÐLÎ<@D%4 2·1 ?wAÓHWP8PC: 1 Re?®<8H46_`9;:e?Fd6?¹46ReD%H6PC<(<\9 ?�J�O RXRÉ?�eY_F:X?BE _ 2 H6JÇ4·PC:XE;VWRe?­P8?F5Cd�:X_F?%VW5CHWO;A 1-2 A;58Hpd�:X7;:eE;V·HWE;R 2 4·DYH�7;?BP <46DYHWO;E-<IH6JÑHpdW?B5CRQ46A��"$^9;4K<�VW?BE;?F5\46R�?�eY_B:X?FE;_ 2 A 9;?BE;H6D%?FE;HWE·:XP^_�4KRXRX?F7 *���.0YC *���3È�.�.0�º�A/+Z �

k

Page 11: uwv[xzy|{F} ~py - Columbia Universityww2040/full.pdf · uwv[xzy|{F} ~py Q ` G N N ` 8 C | U C ` \ j = U ' \ = z \ p z N - \ z ¢¡G F£6 ¥¤ ¥ -¦ p Y = § N ` Q p \

8Ïê98�ê98Ïê ëBíÃ÷�ô¸�É<[î�÷cûÎï�ðÓø ¡ÊîpðÏóB<TúÒ÷Fî�ô�óBx?Ã'ï�ð�óWù�÷�÷'�jôÿø#ôÚî�÷

�¸:XV6E;:9JÒ_B46E-<¹?B4658R 2 <\9;?FHW58?|<\:X_B46RIh³HW5Ck�?��¸A[HWPC:XE;V/<\9;?�58?BPCHWO;5C_B?+AÓH¸H6RX:XE V/A;9 ?BE;HWDY?BE HWE)h³46P7;HWE ? 1-2 ,g��465¢?F<Ç46R��tis�Bl f VÐdW?F7;?BE P8k§4 2 4�?F<^4KR��3i��bkBl f $ÑO;5CE;?B5His�-tOlÊ4KE;7²s�:=<*�B?FE;D%46_`9;?B5�i tB�Bl��5,�E4 1 P <\5846_F<(A 58H 1 Re?BD _BH6E;P8:e7;?B5C?B7�:XE¾i��bkOl±:XE-d6HWRed6?BP(46PCP8:eVWE;:XE V�46585C:ed�:XE V¹_BO PC<\H6D%?F58P f :XDYD%?F7;:Q4K<8?BR 2O;AÓHWE²465C58:edK46R f <8H­HWE;?(H6JÃPC?FdW?F5\46R�:e7;?BE-<8:X_�4KR��GO;?BO ?BP6�jLNE�<\9;?(DYH�7;?BRl<\9;?F58?�:XPÇ4cP8:XE VWRX?�PC<\5C?�46DnH6J_BO PC<\H6D%?F58P(465C58:=d¸:eE;V¹:eE¿4�&ÃHW:XPCP8HWE¿A;5CH¸_F?BPCP6�®b�AÓHWE¿465C58:=d64KR f ?�46_`9�_FO;PC<8HWD%?F5@DcO;P <"NCHW:eE+HWE;?'H6J4²RQ465CVW?­EGO;D 1 ?B5®H6JÇ:eE;7;?BAÓ?BE 7;?BE-< f :X7;?FE-<\:X_B46RÉP8:eE;VWRe?��NPC?B5 dW?B5��GO;?BO ?BP'hI:=<\9¾?��¸AÓHWE;?BE-<8:Q46RUP8?F5Cd�:X_F?<\:eD%?FP�46E 7*O;E;RX:eD%:=<\?F7$h³46:e<8:XE;V�P8AÒ46_F?@�Ê$^9;?¿P <`46E;7;46587�46A;A 58H-46_`9*:eP%<8H.?�� 46DY:XE;?·<\9;?¿P <`4K<8?H6JÐ46RXR¢<\9;?��GO;?BO ?BP%46E;7�NCHW:XE.HWE ?·HKJ�<89;?���O ?BO;?FP%hI:e<89.<\9;?�J�?Fh¢?BP <�_FO;PC<8HWD%?F58P��$LNE 7;?B?F7 f <\9 ?NCHW:eEC�Î<89;?��ÎP89;HW5 <\?FPC<f�ÎRX:eE;?Ð5CO;RX?@:eP^HWA <8:XD%46R7i�k-t0l!� � n�Hph³?|dW?B5 f H6A <\:eD¹46Re:e< 2 _B46E²_B?�4KP8?�:eJÃP8H6D%?(H6JÃ<\9 ?46PCP8O;DYA <\:eHWE;P(4K58?c_`9Ò4KE;VW?B7 f ?@� V)� f :eJÉ<\9 ?­P8?B5 d�:X_B?��Î<8:XDY?w7;:ePC<\5C: 1 O¸<\:XH6E!E;?F?B7�E;H6< 1 ?­?��¸AÓHWE;?FEG<8:Q46Ri rWq0l!�m�z,7;:�eY_BO;R=< 2 hI:e<89·<89;?3NCH6:XEC�¶<\9;?��NP89 HW5C<8?BPC<#�4�GO;?FO;?'5CO;RX? f 9;Hph³?|dW?F5 f :eP^<\9Ò4K<�:=<ID¹4 2 58?��GO;:X5C?H 1 <\46:XE :XE;V.4#RX4658V6?¿46DYHWO;E-<�H6J®PC<\4K<\?¿:eE J�HW5CD¹4K<8:XHWE���LNE�A;465C<8:X_BO RQ465 f h¢?¿E;?F?B7 <\H�kGE;Hph <\9 ?EGO;D 1 ?B5cHKJ�_FO;PC<8HWDY?B58Pw:XE#?B46_`9�H6J^<\9;?}��O ?BO;?FP f hI9;:X_`9�D%4 2¾1 ?�7;:�e%_FO;Re<w:eJ^<89;?B5C?�4658?¹D¹46E 2hI:X7 ?BR 2 �Î7;:XP <\58: 1 O <8?B7Ë�GO;?BO ?BP6��¸H²:e<Ð:XP@EÒ4§<\O;5846RÑ<8H�_BHWE;PC:X7;?F5�46Re<8?B5CEÒ4K<\:=dW?­4KA;A;58HW46_`9;?BP@<89Ò4K<�5C?6�GO;:X5C?cRX?FP8P(:eE J�HW58D%4K<8:XHWE��(,

P8:eD%A RX?É46R=<\?F58EÒ4K<8:ed6?±:XPÏ<8H�4KP8P8:eVWE�?�46_`9'465C58:edK46RK5\46E 7;HWDYR 2 <\HIHWE;?ÉH6J�<\9 ?"�GO;?FO;?BP f hI:=<\9�?�46_`9®P8?F5Cd6?B51 ?B:XE V¾PC?BRe?B_F<8?B7,9;4pd�:eE;V/?��GOÒ46RI_`9Ò46E;_F?@�´n�Hph³?|dW?B5 f 46P�E;H6<8?B7,4 1 HpdW? f 4�5\46E;7 HWD 46PCP8:XV6E;D%?FE-<D%46k6?FP�<89;?²:XE;7 :ed�:X7;O;46R¢PC?B5 dW?B5CP�46_|<Y46P�P8?FAÒ465\4§<\?�­¯®>­¯®�mh�GO;?FO;?BP���LÎJÐh¢?�4KP8P8:eVWE�P8O;_F_B?FP8P8:=dW?465C58:edK46ReP¢5846E;7;H6D%R 2 <8H­HWE;?(H6JT<89;?@P8?F5Cd6?B58P f <\9;?FE²h¢?(RXH6P8?(46ReRÓ<89;?(?�eY_F:X?BE _ 2 H6JT<89;?@DcO;R=<\:eP8?B5 dW?F5P 2 P <\?BDh�$^9;?·k6? 2 :e7;?�4¿:eERis�Blvi��bkOl f is�-t�lvi tB�0lI:XPc<8H¾46RXReH�hÌNCO;P <%4�Re:e<C<\RX?%_`9;HW:e_B?@��LNE$AÒ465 <\:X_FO;RQ4K5 f :e<

P8OCe%_F?BPc<8H!_BH6D%AÒ4K58?�NCO;PC<'<Nh³H©�GO;?FO;?BP�_±,�E.46R=<\?B5CEÒ4K<8:edW?rUCRe:XVW9-<Nh¢?B:XV69G<?W!4KA;A;58HW46_`9#:XP�<\H!A;:X_`k<Nh¢H�H6J±<89;?%�GO;?FO;?BP(4§<Ð5846E;7;HWD�46E 7'NCHW:eE·<89;?wPC9;HW5C<8?B5�H6J±<\9 HWP8?®<Nh³H)�D$^9;?'58?BD%465CkK4 1 RX?(J�46_|<Ð:eP<\9;4K<Ç<\9 :XPÇRe:XVW9-<Nh¢?B:XV69G<'UCRXHpht�N:eE J�HW5CD¹4K<8:XHWE�W(7;?B_F:XP8:eHWE�58O RX?@7;H�?BPI4KRXDYHWPC<Ç46P³h¢?BRXRÏ46P³<\9 ?�NCHW:XEC�¶<\9;?P89 HW5C<8?BPC<#�4�GO;?FO;?w5CO;RX? f 5C?6�GO;:e58:XE V�J�O RXRÏ:eE J�HW58D%4K<8:XHWE f hI9;:X_`9�:XE�<\O 58E!7 H¸?FP�E;?B4658R 2 46P^h¢?BRXRÃ46PI<\9 ?RQ4K58VW?Y_BHWD 1 :XE;?F7#VW5CHWO;A�HKJIP8?B5 dW?F58PchI:e<89.4�PC:XE;V6RX?±��O ?BO;? f PC?B5 d¸:eE;V+:eE�JÒ5CPC<f�Î_BHWDY?zJ;58PC<#�NPC?B5Cd6?B7HW5C7;?B5���$^9Ò4K<'_BHWE _BRXO P8:XH6E/h³46P®J�H658D%46RX:9�B?B7 1-2 _BHWE P8:X7 ?B58:eE;V²<\9;?%46P 2 DYA <\HK<\:X_ 1 ?B9Ò4�d�:XH65w46P�<\9 ?EGO;D 1 ?B5IH6JÑP8?F5CdW?F58P�VW?F<8P�RX4658V6? � hI:=<\9²<\9;?®465C58:edK46R[5\4K<8?(k6?FA <ÐA 58HWAÓHW5C<8:XHWE;46RA���$^9GO;P f D¹4K<89;?BD%4K<8:X_�4KRI46EÒ46R 2 PC:XP%58?Fd6?�46ReP¹<\9 ?+A[H6P8P8: 1 :XRe:XR=< 2 J�HW5¹?�dÊ?F_F<8:edW?¿5C?BPCHWO;58_F?¿A[H�HWRe:XE;V

Page 12: uwv[xzy|{F} ~py - Columbia Universityww2040/full.pdf · uwv[xzy|{F} ~py Q ` G N N ` 8 C | U C ` \ j = U ' \ = z \ p z N - \ z ¢¡G F£6 ¥¤ ¥ -¦ p Y = § N ` Q p \

hI:e<89�5C?BRQ4§<\:ed6?BR 2 RX:=<8<\Re?q~Ò?��¸: 1 :XRe:e< 2 ���lO 5C<\9 ?B5w5C?BRX4K<\?F7�58?FP8?B4658_`9.HWE/58?FP8HWO;5C_B?�AÓH�HWRX:eE;V�9Ò46P 1 ?F?BE7;HWE ? 1G2 s!46E;7 ?BR 1 46O;D 4KE;7·]�?F:XD%46Eji¦���Bl f s�:e<?�B?FE;D¹4K_`9;?B5�i tB�Bl f s�:=<*�F?BE;D%46_`9;?F5I46E;7ËV'ÍHW_`kG:eE;Vi tWt0l f $ÑO 58E;?F5qi��b�0l�i��-r0l�46E;7²3 :XRXRe:Q46DYP(isk@�0l��LÎ<�58?FD¹46:eE;PÐ<8H�?BPC<\4 1 Re:XP89¿_FHWDYAÒ465\4 1 RX?®<\9;?FHW58?|<\:X_B46R±5C?BP8O Re<\P@J�H65@P8kG:XReR�� 1 46P8?F7+58H6O <\:eE;V�:XE¿_B46RXR

_B?FE-<\?B5CP6�ULNE�<\9;?I_BH6EG<8?���<jH6JÏPCkG:XRXRK� 1 4KP8?B7­5CHWO <8:XE;V(:eEY_B46RXR _B?BE-<8?B58P f :=<É58?FD¹46:eE;P±<\H�7;?|<\?F58DY:XE;?^9;HphDcO;_`9·?�eY_F:X?BE _ 2 _�4KE 1 ?®46_`9;:X?|dW?F7 1-2 dK4658:eHWO;PI46DYHWO;E-<8P�HKJ=~Ò?��¸: 1 :eRX:e< 2 � P8?B5 d�:X_B?®P8kG:eRXRÏHpdW?F58RX46A ���E³H6<89�D%4K<89;?BD%4K<\:e_�46R[46EÒ4KR 2 P8?FP�4KE;7�PC:XDcO RQ4K<8:XHWE%PC<\O 7;:X?FP�h¢HWO;Re7 1 ?�:XE-<\?F58?FPC<\:eE;V)�

8Ïê9u�êo¬�ðlï�ù+ëFíÑ÷�ô¸�É<[î�÷­ûÎï�ðÓø ¡ÊîpðÏóB<TúÒ÷Fî�ô�óBx?Ã'ï�ð�óWù�÷�÷{�jôÿø�ô�î�÷

,ÐP­:eE;7;:X_B4K<\?F7�4 1 H�d6? f <\9 ?�D¹4K<89;?BD%4K<8:X_�4KRj5C?BPCO;Re<8PcP8O;A A[HW5 <\:eE;V¿58?FP8HWO;5C_B?²AÓH¸HWRe:XE;V·:XE.DwO;R��<\:eP8?F5CdW?F5@P8?F5Cd�:X_F?­P 2 PC<8?BDYP(A;58:eD¹4K58:XR 2 9Ò4�d6? 1 ?F?BE�?BP <`4 1 Re:XPC9;?B7 1-2 _BHWE;PC:X7;?F58:eE;V¹<\9 ?­46P 2 DYA <\HK<\:X_58?FVW:XDY?w:eE!hI9;:e_`9�<89;?­EGO;D 1 ?B5@HKJ¢PC?B5 dW?B5CP':eP@46ReRXHph¢?B7+<\H²4KA;A;58HW46_`9�:XE�JÒE :e< 2 �®s·HW58?­VW?FE;?B5846RXR 2Wfh¢? 1 ?BRX:e?Fd6?·<89Ò4K<%:XDYA[HW5 <`46E-<�:eE;P8:eVW9-<\PY4 1 HWO <z��O ?BO;?F:XE;V/P 2 PC<8?BDYP�_�46E 1 ?·V-46:eE;?B7$J�58HWD P8O;_`9��4.���[�10��!����\ÈÉ *.������z�º�A|{�A�¸ i�kb�Bl!�©�ÒHW5'O;E;7;?F58PC<\46E;7;:eE;V+<\9 ?�A[?F5CJ�HW5CD¹4KE;_B?%H6JI_�46ReR¢_F?BE-<\?F58P f :=<w:ePEÒ4K<8O;5\4KRT<8HYJ�H�_BO P�HWE²<\9 ? 1 ?B9Ò4�d�:XH65�H6JMDcO;R=<\:XPC?B5 dW?B5IPC?B5Cd�:e_B?wP 2 PC<\?FD%P�:XE²hI9;:X_`9·<\9;?®EGO;D 1 ?B5�H6JP8?F5Cd6?B58P�:XPI46ReRXHph¢?B7�<\H�VW5CH�hI��ÒHW5w<\9 ?�PC<`4KE;7Ò465C7)SÉ58RX46E;V a � ­¯®6­¯®b°�7;?BRX4 2 �wDYH¸7 ?BRÇ4KE;7�:e<\PqÎ�ÏC®>­¯®@°²VW?FE;?B5846RX:9��4K<8:XHWE

9Ò4�d�:XE;V�4¿VW?FE;?B5846RÇ5C?BE;?|hÇ46RÇ46585C:edK46R³A 58H�_B?BPCP f P8O;_`9�46P 2 DYA <8H6<\:e_�58?FP8O;R=<\Pch¢?B58?�?FPC<\4 1 RX:eP89;?F7 1G2nÐ4KR9JÒE�46E;7/3 9 :e<8<�i��WoBl!�h$^9 ? 2 H 1 <\46:XE;?F7#4·O;P8?|J�O;R³Re:XDY:e<\:eE;V�5C?BVW:eD%? 1-2 RX?F<C<\:eE;V·<89;?¹EGO;D 1 ?F5H6JIPC?B5Cd6?B5CP f ° f 4KA;A;58HW46_`9#:XECJÒE;:e< 26f hI9;:eRX?¹Re?F<C<\:XE V�<\9 ?�A;58H 1 4 1 :eRe< 2 H6J�7;?FRQ4 2 46A;A;5CH-46_`9�4!Re:XDY:e<PC<858:e_F<\R 2+1 ?F<Nh¢?B?FE.o²46E;7$mb�{$^9;? 2 PC9;Hph³?F7�<\9;4K<(<\9;H6P8?Y_BHWE;7 :e<\:eHWE;P(4K58?�?6�GO;:=d64KRX?BE-<(<8H�Re?F<8<8:XE;V<\9 ?Ç<\5\40e%_^:eE-<\?BE P8:e< 26f�ÐÒf 46A;A;5CH-46_`9²mÇhI9;:eRX?3°(Ñ Ò f PCH@<\9Ò4K< � m�Ó Ð ��Ô °�Ñ Õ²J�HW5±PCHWDY?^A[HWPC:e<8:edW?_BH6E;PC<\46E-<tÕF��$^9Ò4§<³Re:XDY:e<É:eEY<8O;58Ez��O;46E-<\:9J;?BPU<\9;?�?B_FHWE;HWDY:X?FP¢H6JÊP8_B46RX?�:XE%46EY:XDYA[HW5 <`46E-<Éh³4 2 �ULNE<\9;4K<IRX:eD%:=<\:XE V®5C?BVW:eD%? f 4­A;5CHWA[?F58R 2 P8_B46RX?F7�dW?B5CP8:eHWE�HKJÃ<89;?I�GO;?BO;?��NRe?BE;V6<89�A 58H�_B?BPCPI_BHWE-dW?F58VW?FP�<8H4@<\5846_F<\4 1 RX?³7;:9d[O;P8:eHWEcA;5CH¸_F?BPCP f 46E;7­<\9;?I4KP8P8H�_B:X4K<\?F7­P8?���O ?BE;_F?ÐH6JÓA;5CHWA[?F58R 2 P8_B46RX?F7�PC<\?B467 2 �NP <`4K<8?7;:ePC<\5C: 1 O¸<\:XH6E;PÉ_BHWE-d6?B58V6?BP³<8Hw4(<\5846_F<\4 1 RX?IE;H6E;7;?BV6?BE;?F5\4K<8?ÐRX:eD%:=<\:eE;VÐ7;:ePC<858: 1 O <\:eHWE f A;5CH�d�:e7;:XE;V�<\9 ?1 46PC:XP^J�HW5^O;PC?FJ�O;RT4KA;A;58H>�¸:XD%4K<8:XHWE;P�� PC?B? a 9Ò46A <8?B5�mpo­H6JÃ3 9;:e<C<viskb�0l�J�HW5I4­58?Fd�:e?FhI�s�HW5C?�5C?B_B?FE-<\R 26f H6<\9;?F58Pj9Ò4�dW?�H 1 <\46:XE;?F7¹4K7;7;:e<8:XHWE;46R Re:XDY:e<\:eE;V�58?BPCO;Re<8P¢:eE­<\9;?zU?n�46R9JÒE+�Î3 9;:=<8<*W

RX:eD%:=<\:eE;V¿58?FVW:XDY?@�Ö$^9;?+VW?FE;?B5846RX:9��4K<8:XHWE�<\H�<89;?©ÎIÏC®@×vØ}®b°!DYH¸7;?FR f 9;4pd�:eE;V�4�DYHW58?�VW?BE;?F5\46RA;9Ò4KP8?��¶< 2 A[?#PC?B5 d¸:e_B?��Î<\:eD%?�7;:ePC<858: 1 O <\:eHWE f h³46P�?BPC<\4 1 Re:XP89 ?B7 1-2 &ÉO;9Ò46ReP8kG:X:�46E 7�]�?F:XD%46EÙi t6r0l��ª(?BE;?F5\46Re:��4§<\:XH6E;P�46_B_FHWO;E-<\:eE;V�J�HW5Y_BH6PC<\P¹46E;7�_BO;P <\HWDY?B5¹4 1 46E;7 HWE;DY?BE-<¹h¢?B5C?!?BP <`4 1 RX:XPC9;?B7 1G2

mpo

Page 13: uwv[xzy|{F} ~py - Columbia Universityww2040/full.pdf · uwv[xzy|{F} ~py Q ` G N N ` 8 C | U C ` \ j = U ' \ = z \ p z N - \ z ¢¡G F£6 ¥¤ ¥ -¦ p Y = § N ` Q p \

E³HW5CPC<�?F<�46R!�pi�m�q0lT46E 7�ª�4658E ?F<8<I?|<�46R��pi qWt0l!�a HW585C?BPCA[HWE 7;:XE;VI5C?BP8O Re<\PÏJ�H65�SÉ58RQ4KE;V^RXHWPCP�P 2 PC<8?BDYP�h³?F58?UH 1 <\46:XE;?F7 1-2 �W46VW?F58D%46E±is�@�0l f E¢HW58Hpd�k6Hpd

i�mpoBl�i¥mWm�lÇ46E 7¾�¸58:ek§46E-<­46E;7#3 9 :e<8<�i�� m6l f 46Pc7;:eP8_FO;P8PC?B7�:XEÚi r¸m�l^46E;7´is� m�l��!]�?FRQ4K<8?B7#Re:XDY:e<\P@J�H65�GO;?BO ?B:XE V®E ?F<Nh¢HW58kGP f PC<\4K<\?��N7;?FA[?FE;7;?FEG<��GO;?BO ?BPj46E;7­<\:eD%?��N7;?FA[?FE;7;?FEG<7��O ?BO;?FPjh¢?B5C?�?FPC<\4 1 RX:eP89;?F71-2 ,�58DYHWE 2 46E 7¾s!46VWRX465\46Pqi tOl f E¢HW58P <(?F<®46R!�'i�m�q0l f s!46E;7 ?BR 1 46O;D�?F<®46R!�±i��Gq�lpi¦���Bl±46E;7¾s!46E+�7;?FR 1 46O D 46E;7h&M4§<\P%i��Gt�l��S±dW?BE¿<89;HWO;VW9 fÏ1-2 E;Hph f <89;?B5C?c:XPÐ4¹P8O 1 PC<\46E-<\:Q4KRMRX:=<\?F5\4K<8O;58?®HWE+D%46E 2 �NP8?F5Cd6?B5�46P 2 DYA <8H6<\:e_BP f

:e<�5C?BD%46:XE;PI4�J�58O;:=<8J�O;R�7 :X58?F_F<8:XHWE�J�HW5I58?FP8?B4658_`9��p$^9;?F58?'D¹4 2 ?|dW?BE 1 ?�:XE-<\?F58?FPC<\:eE;V¹E ?Fh�Re:XDY:e<\:eE;V58?FVW:XDY?BP�Û

8ÏêK�ÃêMÀ ðlïOµÏûÎðlï§óWù�¬�úÒíTú)�lù¸ø/ù¸íÓî�½'¡[îpú�Å#í��

S±dW?BE%:XE­<\9 ?�5C?BRX4K<\:=dW?BR 2 PC:XDYA;RX?³_�46PC?�:eE­hI9;:X_`9Y?�46_`9YP8?F5Cd�:X_F?I58?BAY_�4KE%9Ò4KE;7;RX?I4KRXR _B46RXReP f <89;?B5C?465C?Ð_`9Ò46ReRX?FE;VW?BPj:XE%PC<\4BeYE;Vc_�4KRXRl_B?FEG<8?B5CP6�F$ÑH'O;E;7;?F58P <`46E;7�<89;?ÐP <`4BeYE;Vw_`9Ò46RXRe?BE;V6?BP f :e<¢:XPj9;?FRXA J�O;R<\H�:e7;?BE-<\:=J 2��A[+ *���%¼@� Ü��� ���/��F�^�A|}�H��?1@���5Ý>.0 ���21fÞÇ/+Z _É5C?�46RK�Î<\:eD%? f PC9;HW5 <f�Î<8?B5CD 46E;7²RXH6E;VB�Î<8?B5CD��

8ÏêK�Ãê�éÒêoy�ùGúÒý¶x`ü'ôÿø�ù�¡[îpú�Å#í��

E 2� ��?1@�º\4�^�A|}�I��21fÞÇ/+Z6f h³?wD%?B46E!7 2 EÒ4KD%:e_'P <`4BeYE;V�:eE�<89;?'<8:XDY?'PC_�46Re?'H6JÉ<89;?wRe?BE;VK<\9!HKJU4P8:eE;VWRe?'_B46RXR f 7;HWE;?':XE!5C?BPCA[HWE P8?w<8H¹H 1 PC?B5 dW?B7�P 2 P <\?FD PC<\4K<\? f :eE;_BReO;7;:eE;V%:eE J�HW5CD¹4K<8:XHWE²4 1 HWO¸<Ð<\9 ?9;:ePC<\H65 2 H6J±<89;?c_�4KRXRT_B?FEG<8?B5@H6E!<\9Ò4§<Ð7Ò4 2 46E;7+:eE J�HW5CD¹4K<8:XHWE·4 1 HWO <�_�4KRXRXP�_BO 5858?FE-<\R 2 :eE+A;58H�_B?FP8P��$^9;?�:e7;?�4!:ePw<\H¿9;4pd6?�P8O�eY_F:X?BE-<{~Ò?��¸: 1 :eRX:e< 2 <8H 1 ?²4 1 RX?Y<\H�467;7.PC?B5 d¸:e_B?�5C?BA;PchI9;?FE.<\9;? 2 465C?E;?F?B7;?F7�46E 7 <8H�A;O;RXR�<\9;?FD H@d�<8H.7;H$46Re<8?B5CEÒ4K<\:=dW?!h¢HW5Ck)hI9;?BE <\9 ? 2 465C?¿E;H6<�E ?B?B7 ?B7��ÛZÐJ_BH6O;58PC? f _�46ReR��N_F?BE-<\?F5ÉD¹4KEÒ46VW?F58PÉ58H6O <\:eE;?BR 2 7;H®P8H6D%?ÇJ�HW5CDÖH6J[58?B46R��¶<\:XDY?³P <`4BeYE;V f�1 O <jP 2 PC<8?BD%4K<\:e_58?B46R��¶<\:eD%?�PC<`40e%E V 1 4KP8?B7·HWE·P8O 1 PC<`4KEG<8:Q46R�7;4K<`4�46E;7�46EÒ4KR 2 P8:eP^P8H­J�465^:XP^H6E;R 2 4­7;5C?�46Dh�3 9;:e<C<gi rBk0ll7;:eP8_BO P8P8?FP¢9 H�h)58?B46R��¶<\:XDY?jPC<`40e%E V'DY:XVW9-< 1 ?I7;HWE ?@�Fª(:ed6?BE­<\9Ò4§<É<\9;?F58?I:XPÉ:eE;7;?B?F7

<\9 ?¹E;?F_B?BPCP\465 2 ~;?��¸: 1 :eRX:=< 2 :XE/PC<\4BeYE;V f <89;?Y:X7;?B4�:XP�<\H·?��¸A;ReHW:e<'4�dK46:XRX4 1 Re?­:XE J�HW5CD¹4§<\:XH6E��}�Ñ:X58P < f<\9 ?­L a $ ?���O :XA;DY?BE-<�D%46k6?FP(:e<@AÓHWPCP8: 1 RX?w<8H�H 1 <`4K:XE!<89;?­:XE J�H658D%4K<\:eHWE��H�ÒHW5�?�46_`9¾_�46ReR f h³?�_B46EkGE;Hph <89;?c_B46RXRe:XE;V%46E;7+_B46RXRe?B7+A;465C<8:X?BP f h¢?­kGE;Hph <89;?cP8?F5Cd�:X_F?c58?FA¿9Ò46E;7 RX:XE V%<\9 ?c_�46ReR f 46E;7+h¢?_�4KE�kGE;Hph�DcO _`9!4 1 HWO <^<89;?�A;O;5CA[HWPC?�H6JÑ<89;?�_�46ReR��7$^9GO;PIh¢?'_B46E�HKJÚ<\?BE²_FRQ46PCP8:eJ 2 <\9;?�_B46RXR!�E 2 _�465C?FJ�O;ReR 2 _FRQ46PCP8:eJ 2 :eE;V�<89;?¹_B46RXRU:XE/A;58H�_B?FP8P­4KE;7 1-2 O P8:XE V�<\9 ?�kGE;HphIE.RX?BE V6<\9/H6JÇ<\:eD%?

<\9;4K<³_B46RXRl9Ò4KPÇ46Re58?�4K7 2Y1 ?F?BE�:eE¹P8?F5Cd�:X_F? f :e<¢D¹4 2Y1 ?�AÓHWP8PC: 1 Re?�<8HcA;58?F7;:X_|<³9 H�h�ReHWE;V�<\9;?�_�46ReRlhI:eRXR58?FD¹4K:XE¿:XE¿PC?B5 d¸:e_B? 1 ?FJ�HW5C?­P8?B5 d�:X_B?�:eP(_BHWDYA;RX?|<\?B��Z@5 f DYHW58?cA 58?B_F:XPC?BR 26f :e<(D%4 2+1 ?­A[HWPCP8: 1 RX?w<8H

mWm

Page 14: uwv[xzy|{F} ~py - Columbia Universityww2040/full.pdf · uwv[xzy|{F} ~py Q ` G N N ` 8 C | U C ` \ j = U ' \ = z \ p z N - \ z ¢¡G F£6 ¥¤ ¥ -¦ p Y = § N ` Q p \

A;5C?B7;:e_F<U<\9;?�_BH6E;7;:e<8:XHWE;46R;A;5CH 1 4 1 :eRX:=< 2 7;:ePC<\5C: 1 O¸<\:XH6E­H6JÊ<89;?�5C?BD%46:XE :XE;V(_B46RXRÒ9;H6RX7;:eE;V(<\:XDY? f V6:edW?FE<\9 ?w:XE¸J�HW58D%4K<\:eHWE��3,�E;7+<\9Ò4§<Ð_FHWE;7;:=<\:XH6EÒ46RT7;:XP <\5C: 1 O <8:XHWE·D%4 2·1 ?wDcO _`9+D%H658?wA 58?B7 :X_F<8:ed6?'<\9;46E<\9 ?®O E;_BHWE 7;:e<8:XHWEÒ4KRÊ_�4KRXRÏ9;H6RX7;:eE;VB�Î<8:XDY?�7 :XPC<858: 1 O <\:eHWE��E 2 _FHWD 1 :eE;:XE;VwP8O;_`9�:XE J�HW5CD¹4§<\:XH6E¹HpdW?F5�D%46E 2 _B46RXReP^46E;7·P8?F5Cd�:X_F?�58?BA P f :e<ÇD¹4 2�1 ?�A[H6P8P8: 1 RX?

<\H!46_B_FO;5\4§<\?BR 2 A;58?F7;:X_|<'<89;?¹PC?B5Cd�:e_B?¹7 ?BD%46E;7#:eE¾<89;?¹E;?B465'J�O¸<\O;5C? f ?B� V�� f �O���Wo²D%:eEGO <\?FP':eE/<\9 ?J�O <8O;58? f <89GO;PUA;58Hpd�:X7;:eE;V�4 1 46PC:XP±J�HW5É5C?�46RK�Î<8:XDY?¢P <`4BeYE;V)��$^9;?IAÒ46AÓ?B5gi rBk0lÒPC9;HphIP¢9;Hph)PC<\H�_`9Ò46P <\:e_DYH¸7;?FRXPU_�4KE 1 ?�?��¸A;RXHW:=<\?F7Y<8H'J�46_F:XRX:=<`4K<8?³<\9 ?�A;5CH¸_F?BPCP6�5$^9;?�:X7;?B4®7;?FP8?F5CdW?FP³<\H 1 ?�?��¸A;ReHW58?F7¹DYHW58?J�O;ReR 2 �]�?B46R��¶<\:eD%?(P <`4BeYE;V%A;RQ46_F?BP�VW58?B4K<Ð_`9;46RXRe?BE;VW?FP�O A[HWE��GO;?BO;?F:XE;V%<\9;?FHW5 26f[1 ?B_B46O;P8?w:e<�58?���O :X58?FP

<\9;4K<­h³?·_BH6E;P8:e7;?B5­<\9 ?²<8:XDY?��Î7;?BAÓ?BE;7 ?BE-< 1 ?F9Ò4�d¸:eHW5­H6J�<\9;?��GO;?FO;?B:eE;V/P 2 PC<\?FD���b�PCOÒ46ReR 2Wf AÓ?B5��J�HW5CD¹46E _B?�4KEÒ46R 2 PC:XPw:ePw_FHWE�JÒE;?F7#<\H¿4�7;?BPC_B58:eA <\:eHWE#H6J^<89;?�P <\?�4K7 2 �NPC<\4K<\? 1 ?B9;4pd�:eHW56�©n�Hph³?|dW?B5 f58?F_B?FEG<®5C?BP8?B4658_`9/9Ò46P 1 ?BVWO E¾PC?B?Fk�:eE;V�46RXVWH658:e<89;DYP�<8H�7;?BPC_B58: 1 ?­<89;?c<\:eD%?��N7;?FA[?FE;7;?BE-< 1 ?B9Ò4�d�:XH65H6J��GO;?FO;?B:eE;VcP 2 P <\?BDYP6�"&Ñ465C<8:X_BO RQ465CR 2 A;5CHWDY:XP8:eE;V®:XE%<89;:XP¢58?FV-46587�4658?Ð46A;A;Re:X_�4§<\:XH6E;PUH6J�EGO;DY?B58:e_�46R<\5846E;P J�HW58D :XE-d6?B58PC:XHWE�� ?@� V)� f PC?B?�, 1 4K<\? f a 9;H6O;7;9GO;5 2 46E;7¹3 9 :e<8<�i�m6l f , 1 4K<\?(4KE;7¹3 9;:=<8<�i q0l7i��Bl fa 9;HWO 7;9GO;5 2 ?F<±46R���i�m��Bl¸46E;7®3 9;:e<C<3i r@�Bl!���ÒO;5 <\9;?F5M?�� A RXHW584K<\:eHWE'HKJ <\9;4K<±4KA;A;58HW46_`9c:XPTh³46585846E-<\?B7��

8ÏêK�Ãê98Ïê«¡£<Tðlïpî6x`ü¢ù�ï§ø ¡[îpú�Å#í��

E 2Ö�[�.0 ��^\4���� �| ��21fÞÇ/+Z6f h³?¿DY?�46E,<89;?¿7Ò46:eR 2 PC<\4BeYE;V.7;HWE;?�:eE,58?FA[HWE P8?¿<\H#J�HW5C?B_B46PC<8?B77;?FD¹46E 7,46E;7)k�E H�hIRe?B7;V6?+H6J@<89;?+4�dK46:XRX4 1 Re?²46VW?BE-<8P6�ÖE 2R�.0/+Z@\4���� �|ß���1fÞ¿/+Z6f h³?�D%?B46E)<\9 ?PC<\4BeYE;V·7;HWE;?Y:XE¿<\9 ?Y<8:XDY?cP8_B46RX?�H6J¢<\9;?�RX?FE;V6<89/H6Jj<\:eD%?­5C?6�GO;:e58?B7¾<\H²9;:e58?Y46E;7�<\5846:XE�P8?F5Cd�:X_F?58?FA;P6�{$^9 ?�<8:XDY?c58?��GO;:X5C?B7¿<\H²9;:e58?�4�E;?|hÖP8?F5Cd�:X_F?�58?BA¾:XP�J;RXRX?F7!hI:e<89�O;E;_B?F5C<\46:XE-< 2 46E 7¾DY:XV69G<E;?F?B7�<\H 1 ?�4KEÒ46R 2 �F?B7�A;58H 1 4 1 :eRX:XP <\:e_�46ReR 2 �@b�E;7;?F5@J�4�dWHW584 1 RX?­_F:X5C_BO;DYPC<\46E;_B?FP f <\9 ?c<\:XDY?w<8H�9;:X5C?D%4 2¾1 ?¹5C?BRQ4§<\:ed6?BR 2 P89;HW5 <>��n�Hph¢?FdW?F5 f ?Fd6?BE.:eJ³<\9;?Y<\:XDY?�<\H+9;:e58?Y:XP®P89;H65C< f <89;?%<8:XDY?­<\H!<85\46:eEH6JÚ<8?BE+:eP@4%PC:XVWE :9JÒ_B46E-< 1 H6<8<8RX?BE ?B_`k f A;5C?Fd6?BE-<\:eE;V�<\9;?w_�46ReRÃ_F?BE-<\?F5@J�58HWD 5C?BPCA[HWE 7;:XE;V}��O :X_`kGR 2 � :eE<\9 ?�<8:XDY?@P8_B46RX?�H6JÑ7Ò4 2 P�H65Çh³?F?BkGP��^<\HY4­A[?F58_B?F:ed6?B7!:eE;_B5C?�46PC?�:XE²7;?BD%46E;7��, P8:XV6E;:9JÒ_B46E-<(_`9Ò46ReRX?FE;VW?­:XE�PC9;HW5C<#�Î<8?B58D PC<\4BeYE;V�:eP@<\9Ò4§<(<\9;?­_B46RXRÉ4K5858:=dK46RM584K<\?cdK465C:X?BP(PC:XVB�

E;:�JÒ_�46E-<8R 2 HpdW?F5�<\9 ?w7Ò4 2 ��LNE!PCHWDY?'_B46P8?FP f <89;?'_B46RXRT9;H6RX7;:eE;VY<8:XDY?BP�465C?'PCO�eY_B:X?FE-<\R 2 P89 HW5C<�<\9Ò4§<<\9 ?%<\:eD%?��N7;?FA[?FE;7;?FE;_B?%_�46E 1 ?¹P84KJ�?BR 2 :XVWE HW58?F7���$^9;?BE f :e<':XP'46A;A;5CHWA;58:X4K<\?�<\H�O;P8?¹4!7 2 EÒ46DY:X_PC<8?�467 2 P <`4K<8? f O P8:XE V�<\9 ?³AÒ465846DY?F<\?F58PÃ<\9Ò4K<M465C?³46A A;58HWA 58:Q4§<\?¢4K<±4KE 2 <8:XDY?j:eE;PC<\46E-< � 4�P89 HW5C<#�Î<\?F58D4�dW?F5\46VW?>� f 5\4§<\9;?F5�<89Ò46E²<\9;?®RXHWE VB�N5CO;E·4pd6?B5846VW?®AÒ465\4KD%?|<\?B5CPIH�d6?B5�46E!?FE-<\:X5C?�7Ò4 2 �tn�Hph³?|dW?B5 f h¢?46_|<\OÒ46ReR 2 7 H¹E;H6<ÐO;E;7;?F58P <`46E;7�h³?FRXRÃ?BE;HWO VW9!hI9;?FE+?�46_`9¿kG:eE;7!H6JÉ46EÒ46R 2 PC:XP�:XP�46A;A 58HWA;5C:Q4K<8?@�^3/?

m�q

Page 15: uwv[xzy|{F} ~py - Columbia Universityww2040/full.pdf · uwv[xzy|{F} ~py Q ` G N N ` 8 C | U C ` \ j = U ' \ = z \ p z N - \ z ¢¡G F£6 ¥¤ ¥ -¦ p Y = § N ` Q p \

h¢HWO;RX7·A;5CH0NC?B_|<�<89Ò4K<I5C?BP8?B4658_`9�:XE�<\9 :XPI465C?�4�:XP^E;Hph�H6E;R 2 :XE²:e<8P^:XE J�46E _ 2 �LNE�PCHWD%?�:eE;PC<\46E;_B?FP�H6JÇPC9;HW5C<#�Î<8?B58D PC<`40e%E V f :=<�:XP�_BRe?�465CR 2 :XDYA[HW5 <`46E-<@<8H�7 :X58?F_F<8R 2 4KEÒ46R 2 �F?

<\9 ?­P 2 PC<8?BD hI:=<\9�4¹<\:eD%?��ÎdK465 2 :eE;V�4K5858:=dK46RÑ584K<\?B�v,�E;7 f :eE;7;?B?F7 f 4�P8:eVWE;:�JÒ_�46E-<(?�dÊH65C<(9Ò4KP 1 ?F?BED%467;?c<\H·7;H·P8H)�Ñ?@� V)� f PC?B?z, 1 4K<8?Y46E;7�3 9;:e<C<zi q0l f ª�5C?B?FE�?F<'46R!�hi q6r0lgi qBk0l f ª(58:e?B5(?F<'46R!�hi qB�Bl f�6?BE E;:XE;V6P@?F<®46R!�±is�B�@l f s!46E;7;?FR 1 4KO;D ?|<®46R��±i¦�Gq�lDi��@�BlDi¦�GtOl f s!4KP8P8? 2 46E;7¿3 9;:=<8<{i t6o0lpi t¸m6lÉ4KE;73 9;:=<8<vi r@�Bl!�5,ÐV-46:eE f J�O;5 <\9;?F5I58?BPC?�465C_`9!:eE²<89Ò4K<I7;:e58?F_F<\:eHWE�:XPÇh³465C5\46E-<\?F7��,ÖP8:eVWE;:�JÒ_�46E-<�_BHWDYAÓHWE;?BE-<ÐH6JUP89;H65C<f�¶<\?F58D PC<\4BeYE;V�:XP�P8_`9;?F7;O;Re:XE;V�h¢HW58k·P89 :eJÚ<\P�J�HW5I<\9;?cPC?B5��

d�:X_F?­58?BA P f :XE;_FRXO;7 :XE;V 1 58?�4Kk�P(J�HW5(_FH@d[?B?�46E;7�ReO;E;_`9���s�4K<\9;?FD¹4§<\:X_B46RMA 58HWVW5846DYD%:eE;V¹9Ò4KP 1 ?F?BEP8O _B_B?FP8P J�O;RXR 2 46A;A;Re:X?B7�<8H%PC9;:eJÚ<IPC_`9;?B7 O;RX:eE;V­J�HW5^P8HWDY?(<\:eD%?B� ?@� V)� f P8?F?q�¸?FV-46RFi t@�Bl!�

8ÏêK�Ãê9uÏêP�jðÓí��)x`ü³ùGï§ø ¡Êî�ú�Å.í��

$^9;?B5C?²4658?¹7;:9d[?B5C?BE-<­_`9Ò46ReRX?FE;VW?BPw:XE#ReHWE;VB�¶<\?B5CD PC<\4BeYE;V+hI9;?BE�:=<w<`4Kk6?BP�4+5C?BRX4K<\:=dW?BR 2 RXHWE V<\:eD%?I<\H®<\5846:XE%E;?Fh�P8?F5Cd�:X_F?@58?FA;P6�5$^9;?FE�<\5846:XE;:eE;V®H6JTE;?Fh�PC?B5Cd�:e_B?@5C?BA;P 1 ?B_FHWDY?BP^46E¹:XDYA[HW5 <`46E-<7;?F_B:XPC:XHWE%d64K58:Q4 1 RX? f hI9 :X_`9²D%:eVW9-< 1 ?@?�� A RXHW:=<\?B7¹:XE�4c7 2 E;46D%:e_ÐA;5CHWVW5846D%DY:XE V'4KA;A;58HW46_`9��É3 :e<894­RQ465CVW?@dK4658:e?F< 2 H6JMPCkG:XRXReP f <89;?B5C?®4658?�_BH65858?FP8AÓHWE;7;:eE;VWR 2 4­RQ465CVW?@EGO;D 1 ?B5IH6JÃ<\5846:XE :XE;Vc<\4658VW?|<\P��ZÐdW?B5@<89;?cReHWE;VW?F5�<8:XDY?wP8_B46RX? f :=<@:XPÐ46RXPCH¹:eD%AÓHW5C<\46E-<�<8H�467;7 58?BPCP(P8?F5Cd�:X_F?��N5C?BA¾4K<C<\58:=<\:eHWE!4KE;7

P8?F5Cd�:X_F?��Î58?BA._B4658?F?B5'AÒ4K<\9 P6�h$^9;?�:X7 ?�46RU:XP�<\H�9Ò4�dW? 1 H6<89#P\4K<8:XP#JÒ?B7#PC?B5 d¸:e_B?%58?BA P­46E;7/P\4K<8:XPfJ;?B7_BO PC<\H6D%?F58P6�7ª®4KE;PM4KE;7'§Ê9;HWO}i q@�Bl�9Ò4�dW?Ç5C?B_F?BE-<\R 2 7 ?FdW?FRXHWAÓ?B7c4Ðs!4K58k6Hpd'7;?B_F:XPC:XHWE®A;58H�_B?FP8P±DYH�7;?BRJ�HW5Ñ_�46ReR��N_F?BE-<\?F5ÑP <`4BeYE;VÐ:XEwhI9;:e_`9w<\9 ? 2 467;7;5C?BP8PÉRe?�465CE;:XE VÐ46E 7c<\O;5CE;HpdW?B5��7$^9;? 2 46ReP8H@_F:e<8?¢?B4658Re:X?B558?FRQ4K<8?B7²RX:=<\?F5\4K<8O;58?ÐJ�H65Ç<\9;?�RXH6E;VB�Î<8?B5CDöPC<\4BeYE;VYA;58H 1 RX?BDh�

8Ïê9��êo¤²ôAàUùGï§ù�í[îË¡ÊðÓòÃï§óWù�÷YðlûDá²íÑóWùGïpîpúÒô�í[î��

LNE²46E 2 PC?F<C<\:XE VwhI9;?B5C?@PC<8H¸_`9;46PC<8:X_ÐDYH�7;?BReP³465C? 1 ?B:XE Vc46A;A RX:X?F7 f :e<¢:XP³:eD%AÓHW5 <`46E-<U<\Hc_FHWE;PC:X7;?F5hI9Ò4K<%465C?�<\9;?²DYHWPC<�:eD%AÓHW5 <`46E-<cPCHWO;5C_B?BPYH6J�O;E;_F?B5C<\46:XE-< 2 �Ç$^9;4K<YP8?B?FD%P­d6?B5 2 :eD%AÓHW5 <`46E-<wJ�H65_BH6EG<\46_F<�_F?BE-<\?F58P6�

8Ïê9��ê�éÒê«¡ÏðÓòTï§óWù¸÷­ðlûgá·íÃóWùGïpîpúÒô�í[î���û¶ðÓïYîO<Tù���ï�ï§ô�þ úÒý�îï�ð�óWù�÷�÷

�ÒHW5¢?�� 46D%A RX? f :e<¢:XP¢EÒ4K<8O;5\46Rl<\H'D%H�7;?FRl<89;?(465C58:=d64KRÒH6JT:XE;:=<\:X46R;P8?F5Cd�:X_F?@58?��GO;?BP <\PI46P³4q&ÑHW:eP8PCHWEA;5CH¸_F?BP8P f AÓHWP8PC: 1 R 2 hI:=<\9�4w<8:XDY?��¶d64K5 2 :XE;V'465C58:edK46Rl584K<\?B�±3 9Ò4K<^4K58?Ð<89;?@P8H6O;58_F?BP^H6JTO;E _B?B5 <`46:eE-< 2)â�M:e58PC< f <89;?B5C?®:eP |}.6¼+����Y+/����� ��21@�A/��^ãKfÒ1 ?B_B46O;PC?�<89;?�465C58:edK46R[A;58H�_B?FP8PIDY:XVW9-<I46_|<\OÒ4KRXR 2 E;H6< 1 ?(h¢?BRXRDYH¸7;?FRX?F7 1-2 4Ë&ÑH6:XP8PCHWE�A;58H�_B?FP8P��Ã?B� V�� f PC?B?±�6HWE;V 1 RXH�?B7�46E 7 � H�HWRe?Ëi��-tOl!�'LÎ<@:XP(46A A;58HWA 58:Q4§<\?'<8H

m��

Page 16: uwv[xzy|{F} ~py - Columbia Universityww2040/full.pdf · uwv[xzy|{F} ~py Q ` G N N ` 8 C | U C ` \ j = U ' \ = z \ p z N - \ z ¢¡G F£6 ¥¤ ¥ -¦ p Y = § N ` Q p \

:XE-d6?BPC<8:XV-4§<\?�9;Hph�h¢?BReRÏ<\9;?�DYH¸7;?FR�J;<8P6�ª�:=dW?FE�<\9Ò4K<Ç4q&ÑH6:XP8PCHWE�A;5CH¸_F?BP8P^DYH�7;?BRÓ:XP¢7;?B?FD%?F7²46A;A;5CHWA;58:X4K<\? f <89;?B5C?@58?FD¹4K:XE;P È�1@ ?1@|}���4��

Y+/����� ���1@�A/��^ã �/LNE$A 5\46_|<\:X_F?¹h¢?·7 H¿E;H6<�kGE;Hphö<89;?²46585C:edK46RK�N5\4§<\?­J�O;E;_|<\:XH6E�46E;7�DcO;P <�?BPC<8:XD%4K<\?:e<6�I$^9;?­AÒ465846D%?|<\?F5@O;E;_F?B5C<\46:XE-< 2 :XP(467 7;58?FP8P8?F7 1-2 7 HW:XE;V%J�HW58?F_�46P <\:XE V)�®3 :=<\9¿4¹<8:XDY?��¶d64K5 2 :XE;V465C58:edK46RI584K<\? f <\9;?+?FPC<8:XD%4K<\:eHWE�A 58H 1 Re?BD :XP%D%H658?!_FHWDYA;RX:e_�4K<8?B7 f¢1 ?F_�46O;PC?+h³?!DcO;PC<�?BPC<8:XD%4K<\?<\9 ?w?BE-<8:X58?w46585C:edK46RK�N5\4§<\?@J�O;E;_|<\:eHWE f E;H6<FNCO;PC<ÐHWE;?wH65�<Nh¢H�AÒ465846DY?F<\?F58P��@Z@E;?'_�46E+5C?F<8O;58E!<8H¹<\9 ?AÒ465846DY?F<\5C:X_@PC?F<C<\:XE V 1-2 46PCP8O;DY:XE V%4�AÒ465846DY?F<\5C:X_ÐJ�H658DöJ�HW5Ç<89;?®46585C:edK46RK�N5\4§<\?�J�O E;_F<8:XHWE f PCO;_`9+4KPRX:eE;?�4K5(HW5I��O;467;5\4§<\:X_B��s�46P8PC? 2 ?F<'46R!��i¦���0lj:eEGd6?BP <\:XVW4K<\?­h³4 2 P®<\H·?BPC<8:XD%4K<\?c<89;?Y_BH�?�eY_B:e?BE-<\P®H6JRX:eE;?�4K5Ç465C58:edK46RK�N584K<\?IJ�O;E;_|<\:XH6E;PÇJ�58HWDnE;HWE;9 HWD%H6VW?BE;?FHWO;P���&ÑH6:XP8PCHWEC�ÎA;58H�_B?FP8PI7Ò4K<\4��F�ÒO;5C<89;?B5^P <\O;7 2:XPÇh³465C5\46E-<\?F7��LNEc<\9;?³_�46ReR��N_F?BE-<\?F5ÑPC?F<C<\:XE V f <89;?B5C?^4658?Ç4�dK4658:e?F< 2 H6JÒ7Ò4§<`4ÐPCHWO;58_F?BP±<8H@O;P8?¢J�HW5Ñ<89;?¢J�HW5C?B_B46PC<8:XE;V f

P8H+<89;?¹J�HW5C?B_B46PC<8:XE;V+:ePwDYHW58?Y_BH6D%A;Re:X_B4K<\?F7��!LÎ<­:ePwEÒ4§<\O;5846Rj<8H+:XE-d6?BPC<8:XV-4§<\?¹<89;?��GOÒ46Re:e< 2 H6JI<\9 ?J�HW5C?B_�4KPC<\:eE;V)�Ã3�?�P89;H6O;RX7%46:XD <\H��GOÒ46E-<\:=J 2 <\9;?I?F5858H65j5C?BPCO;Re<8:XE;V(J�58H6D0J�HW58?F_�46P <\:eE;V)�5�ÒHW5ÉPC?F<8<8:XE;V6P:XE,hI9 :X_`9,<\9 ?¿?B585CHW5�:eP�P8:eVWE;:9J;_�46E-< f :=<�D¹4 2�1 ?+46A;A;5CHWA;58:X4K<\?�<\H.:XE _BRXO 7;?!<\9;4K<�?B5C58HW5¹:XE,<\9 ?46EÒ4KR 2 P8:eP6�F�6HWE V 1 RXH�?B7%46E;7 � H�HWRe?%i��-t0lÓPC9;Hph�9 H�h _FHWE;VW?FPC<8:XHWE�_B46E 1 ?Ð7 ?BP8_F58: 1 ?F7¹hI9;?BE�<89;?B5C?Ð:ePO;E;_F?B5 <`46:eEG< 2 4 1 HWO¸<^<\9;?®465C58:edK46R[5\4K<8?(:XE�<\9 ?'SÉ5CRQ46E;V a D%H�7;?BR!�ª�:=dW?FE¹<\9Ò4§<Ç4v&ÑHW:eP8P8H6E�A;58H�_B?FP8PÇDYH�7;?BRÒ:eP¢7;?F?BDY?B7�4KA;A;58H6A;58:X4K<\?�46E;7Y<\9;?Ð46585C:edK46R��Î5\4K<8?ÇJ�O;E;_��

<\:eHWE#9Ò4KP 1 ?F?BE$?BPC<8:XD%4K<\?F7 1-2 J�HW5C?B_�4KPC<\:eE;V � 4KE;7.:XPw<89GO;P�A;58?FP8O;DY?B7$kGE;HphIE � f <\9;?F58?�5C?BD%46:XE;P<\9 ? ÈÉ *.�������Y+/����� ��21@�A/��^ãKf :�� ?@� f <89;?@:XE 9;?B5C?BE-<^5\4KE;7;HWDYE;?BPCP^46PCP8H�_B:Q4§<\?B7�hI:=<\9¹<89;?ÐJ�O;ReR 2 PCA[?F_B:9J;?B7&ÑH6:XP8PCHWEC�ÎA;58H�_B?FP8P(DYH¸7;?FR��(�lH65�?��;4KD%A;Re? f <\9;?cEGO;D 1 ?F5@H6J¢46585C:edK46ReP�:eE¿46E 2 VW:ed6?BE+<\:eD%?®:XE-<8?B5CdK46R:XPwE;H6<�kGE;HphIE�:eE.467 dK46E _B? fj1 O <�:eE;PC<8?�467�:ePc5\46E 7;HWD f 9Ò4�d¸:eE;V�4j&ÑHW:eP8PCHWE�7;:XP <\58: 1 O <8:XHWE � hI:e<894¿d64K58:Q4KE;_B?�46Reh³4 2 P%?���O;46R�<8H/:=<\P�DY?�46E f hI9;:X_`9)_�46E�P8?B5 dW?!46PY<89;?·P8:XE VWRX?²AÒ465846DY?F<\?F5�H6J@<\9 ?&ÑH6:XP8PCHWE+7;:ePC<858: 1 O <\:eHWE ���p$^9;?wA;58H�_B?FP8P@O;E _B?B5 <`46:eE-< 2 VW:=dW?FP@O;PÐ<89;?w5846E;7;HWD dK465C:Q4 1 Re?�:XE;P <\?�4K7+H6J:e<8P^58?B46RX:9��4K<8:XHWE f hI9;:e_`9�:eP^O;E;kGE;HphIE!hI9;?FE·h¢?w4K58?(AÓ?B5CJ�H658DY:XE;Vc<89;?®46EÒ46R 2 PC:XP��,ÐE,:eE-<\?B5C?BP <\:XE V�58?FP8?B4658_`9*A;5CH 1 Re?BD :XP�<\H¾_BH6D%AÒ4K58?²<\9;?FP8?!<89;58?F?�J�HW5CD%P�H6J(O E;_B?F5C<`4K:XE-< 2 �

DYH¸7;?FRGO;E;_B?F5C<\46:XE-< 2Wf AÒ465\4KD%?|<\?B5ÃO;E;_F?B5 <`46:eEG< 2 46E 7cA;58H�_B?FP8PÑO;E;_B?F5C<\46:XE-< 2 �Ê:eEc46_|<\OÒ4KR 46A A;RX:e_�4K<8:XHWEP8?|<8<8:XE;VWP��F�M:X5CPC< f h¢?�h³46E-<^<\H­kGE;Hph�:eJÃHWE;?ÐJ�H658DöHKJÑO E;_B?F5C<`4K:XE-< 2 :ePÇ7;HWDY:XEÒ4KEG<6�¸<89;?BE²:e<ÇAÒ4 2 PÇ<8HAÒ4 2 DYHWPC<(4K<8<8?BE-<\:eHWE¿<\H�:e<6�­s�H658?­VW?FE;?B5846RXR 2Wf h¢?�h³46E-<�<\HË�GOÒ46E-<8:eJ 2 <89;?�_BHWE-<858: 1 O <\:eHWE+<\H�<\9 ?<\HK<`46RUO;E;_F?B5 <`46:eEG< 2 7;O;?Y<\H�?�46_`9._FHWD%AÓHWE;?FE-<>�h$^9Ò4K<c5C?6�GO;:e58?BPw4�d�:X?|h H6JÇ<\9 ?¹?BE-<8:X58?%A;58H�_B?FP8P f5\4§<\9;?F5'<\9;46EhNCO;P <cHWE;?%_BHWDYAÓHWE;?BE-<6��$^9Ò4§<cD%4 2 5C?6�GO;:e58?¹7 ?FdW?FRXHWA :XE;V+PCHWDY?%E;?|hÛD%?|<\9;H�7;Pc4KPh¢?BRXR!�

m>�

Page 17: uwv[xzy|{F} ~py - Columbia Universityww2040/full.pdf · uwv[xzy|{F} ~py Q ` G N N ` 8 C | U C ` \ j = U ' \ = z \ p z N - \ z ¢¡G F£6 ¥¤ ¥ -¦ p Y = § N ` Q p \

8Ïê9��ê98Ïê«¡ÏðÓòTï§óWù¸÷­ðlûgá·íÃóWùGïpîpúÒô�í[î���û¶ðÓïYîO<TùÁ¡Êù�ïpþTô�óWù îï�ð�óWù�÷�÷

LNE²467;7;:=<\:eHWE%<8HcO;E;_F?B5C<\46:XE-< 2 4 1 H6O <^465C58:=d64KRXP f <89;?B5C?@:XP¢O;E;_B?F5C<\46:XE-< 2 4 1 HWO¸<³<\9 ?@P8?F5Cd�:X_F?(A;58HB�_B?FP8P��3$^9;? 1 46P8:e_'DYH¸7 ?BRÏJ�HW5I_BO PC<\H6D%?F5I<8?BRe?BA;9;H6E;?'_B46RXR�9 HWRX7;:eE;V � PC?B5Cd�:e_B?��Ç<\:eD%?FPI:XP�4YPC?6�GO;?FE;_B?H6Jj:XE 7;?BAÓ?BE;7 ?BE-<®46E;7¿:e7;?BE-<\:e_�46ReR 2 7;:ePC<858: 1 O <\?F7 � L8L�>I��5\46E;7 HWD�dK465C:Q4 1 RX?BP f ?B46_`9¿hI:e<\9�4KE¿?��¸A[H0�E;?FEG<8:Q46R^7 :XPC<858: 1 O <\:eHWE fÉ1 O¸<�46P­hI:=<\9.<\9;?�465C58:edK46R¢A;58H�_B?FP8P f <\9;?F58?·:XP­DYH¸7 ?BRÇO;E _B?B5 <`46:eE-< 2 �¯�ÒHW5?�� 46DYA;Re? f <\9;?�46_|<\OÒ46RlPC?B5Cd�:e_B?��¶<\:eD%?^7;:ePC<858: 1 O <\:eHWE�D%:eVW9-<UE;H6< 1 ?I?��¸AÓHWE;?FEG<8:Q46R!�±LNE%dK465C:XHWO PjP <\O;7+�:X?FP f E³HWReH6<\:eEÚi��Bl^D%467;?²4¿_�46PC?�J�HW5­4¿RXHWV6E;HW58D%46RU7;:ePC<\5C: 1 O¸<\:XH6E�46E;7$4+D%:K��<\O;5C?�H6J�RXHWVWE HW58D%46R7;:ePC<\5C: 1 O¸<\:XH6E;P6�Ðs�HW5C?BHpdW?F5 f <89;?w9;H6RX7;:eE;VB�Î<8:XDY?(7;:XP <\5C: 1 O <8:XHWE·D%4 2 7;?FA[?FE;7¿O;AÓHWE!<89;?c_�4KRXR�< 2 A[? f<\9 ?®PC?B5 d¸:e_B?®58?FA!46E 7²<89;?(<\:eD%?@HKJ±7Ò4 2 ��6O;PC<Ñ46PÏhI:=<\9@<89;?j46585C:edK46R§A;58H�_B?FP8P f <\9 ?B58?U:ePÏAÒ465846D%?|<\?F5�O;E;_B?F5C<\46:XE-< 2 4 1 HWO <Ê<\9;?É_B46RXRK�N9;HWRe7;:XE VB�

<\:eD%?�7;:XP <\5C: 1 O <8:XHWE��5ª(:edW?FE�<\9Ò4§<I46E²?��¸AÓHWE;?BE-<8:Q46R[7;:XP <\58: 1 O <8:XHWE�:eP³7;?F?BDY?B7·46A;A 58HWA;5C:Q4K<8? � AÓHWPCP8:��1 R 2 4KJÚ<8?B5±_FHWE;7;:=<\:eHWE;:XE VÐO;AÓHWE­<\9;?^_B46RXRG< 2 A[? f <\9;?^PC?B5Cd�:e_B?^58?FAY46E;7c<\9 ?Ç<\:XDY?³HKJ[7;4 2 � f :e<É5C?BD%46:XE;P<\H%?BP <\:XD%4K<8?�<89;?®P8:XE VWRX?�AÒ465846DY?F<\?F5IH6JM<89;?w?�� AÓHWE;?FE-<\:Q4KRÃ7 :XPC<858: 1 O <\:eHWE f hI9 :X_`9+_B46E 1 ?'7 HWE;? 1G246EÒ4KR 2 �B:eE;V�9 :XPC<8HW58:e_�46RM7Ò4K<`4C��LNE#_�4KP8?BP'H6JÇPCA[?F_B:X46RUA;58HWDYH6<8:XHWE;P f 9;Hph³?|dW?B5 f <\9;?F58?%D¹4 2¿1 ?Yd6?B5 2RX:=<8<8RX?­9;:ePC<\H658:X_B46RU7Ò4K<\4���$^9�O P f AÒ465846D%?|<\?F5'O;E _B?B5 <`46:eE-< 2 D%4 2�1 ?%P8:XV6E;:9JÒ_B46E-<'J�H65w_�4KRXRU9;HWRe7;:XE;V<\:eD%?FPÇ<\H�H)��M:XE;46RXR 2Wf <89;?B5C?�:XP­A;5CH¸_F?BP8P�O;E _B?B5 <`46:eE-< 2 J�HW5w<89;?�9;HWRe7;:XE;V�<\:XDY?BPc46Pch³?FRXR!�¨ª(:edW?FE#<\9Ò4§<Y46E

?��¸AÓHWE;?FEG<8:Q46RÊ7;:XP <\58: 1 O <8:XHWE�:ePÇ7;?F?BDY?B7·46A;A;5CHWA;5C:Q4K<8?ÐJ�HW5³<89;?(_�46ReRÊ9;H6RX7;:eE;Vw<\:eD%?FP^46E;7�<89;?(P8:eE;VWRX??��¸AÓHWE;?FEG<8:Q46R AÒ465\4KD%?|<\?B5É:eP±kGE;HphIE f <\9;?F58?I58?FD¹4K:XE;PM<89;?^:XE 9;?B5C?BE-<U5\46E 7;HWDYE;?BPCPjHKJÓ<89;?^?��¸AÓHWE;?FEC�<\:X46RÊ7 :XPC<858: 1 O <\:eHWE�_7$^9 ?'PC?B5Cd�:e_B?(<\:eD%?FPI4658?(5C?�46Re:��4§<\:XH6E;P³J�58H6Dn<\9 ?®?��¸A[HWE ?BE-<\:X46R�7;:XP <\5C: 1 O <8:XHWE��

8Ïê9��ê9uÏê«¡ÏðÓòTï§óWù¸÷­ðlûgá·íÃóWùGïpîpúÒô�í[î���û¶ðÓïYîO<Tù�Àä<ÃðÓý�ù�¬�ð�ñTù�ý

3 9;?BE+h¢?cA;O¸<@<\9;?'D%H�7;?FRÃA 58:XDY:e<8:ed6?BPI<\HWVW?|<\9;?F5�<8H¹H 1 <\46:XE!4¹DYH¸7;?FR�J�HW5�<89;?wAÓ?B5 J�HW58D%46E;_F?H6J±<89;?w?FE-<\:X5C?'_B46RXRT_F?BE-<\?F5 f h¢?c4KV-46:XE·9Ò4�dW?'<\9;?®<\9;5C?B?'J�H658DYP�H6JMO;E;_F?B5C<\46:XE-< 2 7;?BPC_B5C: 1 ?B7¿4 1 HpdW? fEÒ46DY?BR 2Wf DYH¸7;?FR^O;E;_F?B5C<\46:XE-< 26f AÒ465846DY?F<\?F5­O;E;_F?B5C<\46:XE-< 2 46E 7�A;5CH¸_F?BPCP%O;E _B?B5 <`46:eE-< 2 ��b�E J�HW5 <\OC�EÒ4K<8?BR 2Wf <\9;?®58?FRQ4K<8:ed6?(:XDYA[HW5 <`46E _B?�H6JM<89;?BPC?'7 :9d[?B58?FE-<ÐPCHWO;58_F?BP�H6J±O;E _B?B5 <`46:eE-< 2 :ePIE;H6<�E;?�4K58R 2 4KPh¢?BRXRÃO;E;7 ?B58P <\H�H¸7+46PÐ:=<�PC9;HWO;Re7 1 ?@�ILÎ<@:eP�EÒ4§<\O;5846RÃ<8H�46PCk�hI9;:X_`9!J�H658D H6JÉO;E _B?B5 <`46:eE-< 2 :ePÐDYHWPC<_B5C:e<8:X_�4KRÊ:XE·46E 2 4KA;A;RX:e_�4K<8:XHWE��,ÐE;7®<\9;?F58?¢4658?UP <\:XReRWH6<89;?B5TJ�HW58DYP�H6J O;E;_B?F5C<\46:XE-< 2 <\9;4K<ÃP89;HWO RX7 1 ?j_BHWE P8:X7 ?B58?F7��7�ÒHW5�?�� 46D%A RX? f

AÓH¸HW5ÃAÓ?B5CJ�H658D%46E;_B?jDY:XVW9-<ÑH¸_F_BO;5 1 ?F_�46O;PC?ÇH6JÒP 2 PC<\?FD J�46:eRXO;5C?BP��MS5�GO;:XA D%?FEG<MD%:eVW9-< 1 58?B46k'7 H�hIE��P8?F5Cd�:X_F?�58?BA P�DY:XV69G<³VW?F<IPC:X_`k �"�ÒHW5Ç?�� 46DYA;Re? f HWE�<89;?(LNE-<\?B5CE;?F<�:e<Ç:XPÇE;HK< 2 ?F<�_FRX?�4K5³hI9;?F<89;?B5I<\9 ?

m�t

Page 18: uwv[xzy|{F} ~py - Columbia Universityww2040/full.pdf · uwv[xzy|{F} ~py Q ` G N N ` 8 C | U C ` \ j = U ' \ = z \ p z N - \ z ¢¡G F£6 ¥¤ ¥ -¦ p Y = § N ` Q p \

A;5C:XD%465 2 _�46O;PC?wH6J±_BHWE;V6?BPC<8:XHWE·:XPI<\9 ?'H�_B_FO;585C?BE;_F?wH6JÉH�_B_B46P8:eHWEÒ46R 1 O;58P <\PÐHKJ±_BO PC<\H6D%?F5�7;?FD¹4KE;7HW5Ç<89;?�H¸_F_BO;5C58?BE _B?®H6JMH�_B_B46P8:eHWEÒ46RÊP 2 PC<8?BD J�46:XReO;58?FP6�LNE$<89;?²_BHWE-<8?���<¹HKJÐ_FHWE-<`46_|<%_F?BE-<\?F58P f <\9;?²VWH-4KRÇ:XPc<8H 1 ?F<C<\?F5YO E;7;?B5CPC<\46E;7�<89;?BPC?�7 :9d[?B58?FE-<

P8H6O;58_F?BP�H6JMO E;_B?F5C<`4K:XE-< 2 46E;7�<\HY7;?|<\?B5CD%:eE;?@<\9 ?®:eD%AÓHW5 <`46E;_F?@H6JÑ?�46_`9��

8Ïê9³�êT¡Ïô�ø¾òÃý�ú î�ô�ð[í

8Ïê9³�ê�éÒêP��í)ëFør:Éðlï�î�úÒí[î'Ã@ùGï�ûÎðlï§ø�úÒíÃóWù���íTúÒý¸��÷�ôÿ÷�ü³ðÊð[ý

�¸:XE _B?j_BHWE-<`4K_F<Ñ_B?BE-<8?B58P±4658?U_BH6D%A;Re:X_B4K<\?F7 f ?BP8AÓ?B_F:Q46ReR 2 hI:=<\9®P8kG:XReR�� 1 46P8?F7�58HWO <8:XE;V f :=<Ã:XPTEÒ4K<8O;5\46R<\HÐ58?BR 2 H6EcP8:eDcO;RQ4§<\:XH6E®<8H(46EÒ46R 2 �B?¢<89;?Ç5C?BP8O Re<\:eE;V@P <\H�_`9Ò46PC<8:X_ÇDYH�7;?BReP6��,ÐE;7 f :XE;7;?F?B7 f PC:XDcO RQ4K<8:XHWE9Ò46P�H6JÚ<\?FE 1 ?B?FE¿46A;A;Re:X?F7�<\H¹46EÒ46R 2 �B?®_�46ReR��N_F?BE-<\?F5�DYH�7;?BReP6�3, P8:XDwO;RQ4K<8:XHWE�<8H¸HWR�_B46RXRe?B7·<\9;? a 46RXR&É58H�_B?FP8P8:eE;V}�¸:XDcO RQ4K<8HW5 � a ,�&"�)�ÇhÇ46PI_F58?�4§<\?B7!46E;7²?���<8?BE;PC:edW?FR 2 46A A;RX:e?B7·4K<p,5$p�H$Li�m>�@l!��¸:XDwO;RQ4K<8:XHWE)58?BD%46:eE;P²46E�4K<8<85\46_|<\:=dW?¾46A;A;5CH-46_`9 <\H�A;5C?B7;:e_F<�46E;7 _BH6EG<858HWR(_FHWE-<`46_|<!_F?BE-<\?F5

AÓ?B5CJ�H658D%46E;_B? f¢1 O <%<89;?B5C?!4K58?²_`9Ò46ReRX?BE VW?BP­<\H�D%46k6?·P8:eDcO;RX4K<\:eHWE#DYHW58?�?�dÊ?F_F<\:=dW?B��$^9;?F58?!:eP�4E;?F?B7,J�HW5YE;?Fh�?�e%_F?BE;_ 2 �N:XDYA;5CH�d6?BDY?BE-<�<8?B_`9;E;:9�GO;?BP f PCH�<\9Ò4§<¹<\9 ?!_BH6D%A;Re?��$P 2 P <\?FD%P�_B46E 1 ?46EÒ4KR 2 �B?F7+?�d[?B_|<\:ed6?BR 2 ��$^9;?F58?­:ePÐ4¹E ?B?B7¿J�HW5�DYHW58?'P8HWA;9 :XPC<8:X_B4K<\?F7+P8:eDcO;RQ4§<\:XH6E·H6O <\A;O¸<�46EÒ46R 2 P8:XP:XE�HW587;?F5c<\H+O E;7;?B5CPC<\46E;7�<\9;?�P <`4K<8:XP <\:X_B46RjA;58?F_B:XPC:XHWE.HKJ�?FPC<8:XD%4K<\?FP6�©,ÐE 7�<89;?B5C?�:XPw4+E;?B?F7�J�H6546EÒ4KR 2 P8:ePÇ<\H�HWRXP³<8H�9;?BReA�PC:XDcO;RX4K<\H658PÇA;RX46E�<\9 ?B:X5^PC:XDcO RQ4K<8:XHWE�?��¸A[?F58:XDY?BE-<8P6�

8Ïê9³�ê98ÏêoÃwý�úÒíÃíÑô�í���õ'ðÓí[îpúÒó6î�xFõ'ù�í[îpùGïh¡Ïô�ø¾òÃý�ú î�ô�ð[íÃ÷

�¸:XE _B?!_FHWE-<`46_|<f�Î_B?BE-<8?B5�P8:eDcO;RX4K<\:eHWE;P�D¹4 2 E;?F?B7*<\H 1 ?�7;HWE;? ��O :e<\?·J�58?���O ?BE-<\R 2Wf :e<%:XP%EÒ4K<f�O;5846R�<8H/<85 2 <\H/7;?F<8?B58DY:XE ?!9;Hph 1 ?BPC<%<\H#_B46585 2 HWO <Y<\9;?FP8?+PC:XDcO;RX4K<\:eHWE;P��Ú�lH65 1 H6<\9�EÒ4K<8O;5\46RDY?F<\9 H¸7;P�4KE;7�_FRX?|dW?B5�:eE;7;:X5C?B_|<�D%?|<\9;H�7;P f :e<c:XP­EÒ4K<8O;5\4KRÇ<\H¿<\5 2 <\H�7;?|<\?B5CD%:eE;?�9;Hph ReHWE;V¿<\9 ?P8:eDcO;RX4K<\:eHWE�58O;E;PwE;?B?F7#<\H 1 ?¹:eE�HW5C7;?B5®<\H+?FPC<\:eD¹4§<\?�<\9;?%A[?F5CJ�HW5CD¹46E _B?¹DY?�4KP8O;5C?BPcH6JÇ:XE-<\?F58?BP <hI:e<89²46E 2 7;?FP8:e58?B7²P <`4K<8:XPC<8:X_B46R[A 58?B_F:XPC:XHWE��js·HW58?FH�d6?B5 f :e<^:ePÇEÒ4K<8O;5\46RÓ<\H­PC?B?Bk%d64K58:Q4KE;_B?��N58?F7;O;_|<\:XH6EHW5�?�eY_F:X?BE _ 2 �N:eD%A;5CHpdW?BDY?BE-<'<\?B_`9 E;:�GO;?FPw<\H·58?F7;O;_B?Y<\9;?%58?���O :X58?F7�5CO;E�Re?BE;V6<89;P�J�HW5®46E 2 V6:edW?FE7;?FP8:X5C?B7·PC<\4K<\:ePC<\:e_�46RÊA;58?F_B:XPC:XHWE��3 9;:e<C<Ëi r@�Bl¢46A A;RX:e?B7�7 :9d[O;P8:eHWE�4KA;A;58H>�¸:XD%4K<8:XHWE;P(<8H!H 1 <\46:XE/P8:eD%A;Re?�9;?BO;5C:XP <\:X_�J�HW5CDcO;RQ4KP�<8H

?BP <\:eD¹4K<8?­<\9;?YP8:eDcO;RQ4§<\:XH6E¿58O;E#Re?BE;VK<\9¾58?6�GO;:e58?F7/<\H�H 1 <\46:XE/46E 2 7;?BPC:X5C?B7#P <`4K<8:XPC<8:X_B46RÉA;58?F_B:eP8:XH6EhI9;?FE�P8:XDwO;RQ4K<8:XE;V'4wPC:XE;VWRe?��ÎP8?B5 dW?F5-�GO;?BO ?@�"$^9Ò4K<^4KEÒ46R 2 PC:XPÇ4KRXP8H'_�46E 1 ?@4KA;A;RX:e?B7Y<\HcE;?|<Nh³H658kGP^H6JP8:eE;VWRe?��NPC?B5 dW?B5g�GO;?BO;?FP�46E;7�DcO;Re<8:XPC?B5Cd6?B5g��O ?BO;?FPÐhI:e<89!58?FRQ4K<8:ed6?BR 2 J�?|hP8?F5CdW?F58P f�1 O <�:e<�7;H¸?FPÐE;HK<46A;A R 2 <8H'��O ?BO;?FP�hI:e<89·4YRX4658VW?ÐE�O D 1 ?F5IH6JMPC?B5 dW?B5CP f 46E;7²<\9GO;PIE;H6<I<8HYDYHWP <I_BHWE-<`4K_F<�_B?FEG<8?B5CP6�

m��

Page 19: uwv[xzy|{F} ~py - Columbia Universityww2040/full.pdf · uwv[xzy|{F} ~py Q ` G N N ` 8 C | U C ` \ j = U ' \ = z \ p z N - \ z ¢¡G F£6 ¥¤ ¥ -¦ p Y = § N ` Q p \

�¸58:ek§46E-<^46E;7%3 9;:e<C<Ii�� m�lÊ_�465C58:X?F7¹HWO¸<^4wPC:XDY:XRQ4K5ÉA;58HWV65\46DìJ�HW5j?BP <\:XD%4K<8:XE;V®<\9;?�RXHWE;V0�N58O E�4�d��?B5846VW? 1 ReH¸_`kG:XE V(A;58H 1 4 1 :XRe:e< 2 :XEY4(DcO;R=<\:XPC?B5 dW?B5UReHWP8PÉDYH¸7 ?BR��=�M:e58PC<É<89;? 2 :e7;?BE-<8:9JÒ?F7�<Nh¢Hw7 :9d[?B58?FE-<DY?F<\9 H¸7;PÑ<\9Ò4K<É4658?ÇDYHW5C?Ç?�eY_B:e?BE-<U:XEw7;:9d[?B5C?BE-<U58?FVW:XHWE P6��$^9;?I7;:X5C?B_F<±D%?|<\9;H�7 f hI9;:e_`9­:XPÉNCO PC<É<\9 ?5\4§<\:XH%H6JU<\9;?wH 1 P8?F5Cd6?B7¾RXHWPCP8?BP�<\H�<\9 ?cH 1 PC?B5Cd6?B7/46585C:edK46ReP f :XP@DcO _`9¿D%HW5C?w?�e%_F:X?FEG<�O E;7;?B5(Re:XVW9-<RXHW467 f hI9;:eRX?®46E·:XE;7;:e58?F_F<�D%?|<\9;H�7 1 46P8?F7+HWE�?BPC<8:XD%4K<\:eE;Vc<\9 ?wDY?�46E·H¸_F_BO;A;46E;_ 26f 4KE;7+46A A;R 2 :XE VQ :e<C<\RX?BS PI_FHWE;P8?F5CdK4K<8:XHWE�RQ4�h fÉå¿æÊçÉèÖf :ePIDcO;_`9+DYHW58?�?�e%_F:X?FEG<ÐO;E;7;?F5Ð9;?B4�d 2 ReH-467;P��3�ÒHW5 1 H6<89DY?F<\9 H¸7;P f 5C?BRX4K<\:=dW?BR 2 PC:XDYA;RX?^J�HW5CDcO;RQ4KP±h³?F58?@7;?|<\?F58DY:XE;?F7YJ�HW5U<\9 ?Ð46P 2 D%A <8H6<\:e_^d64K58:Q4KE;_B? f hI9 :X_`9:XE�<\O 58E�Re?�467 P�<8H�PC:XDYA;RX?cJ�H658DcO;RX46P@J�HW5(<\9 ?%5C?6�GO;:X5C?B7/P8:XDwO;RQ4K<8:XHWE¿5CO;E�Re?BE;VK<\9��%LNEG<8?B5C?BPC<8:XE;V6R 2Wf<\9 ?®J�HW5CDcO;RX46P³J�HW5^<\9 ?'DcO Re<\:eP8?F5CdW?F5IRXHWPCP�DYH�7;?BReP^7;:9d[?B5^7;5846D%4K<\:e_�46ReR 2 J�58HWDn<\9;?®_BHW5C58?FP8AÓHWE;7;:eE;VJ�HW5CDcO;RQ4KP³J�HW5Ç<\9 ?®PC:XE;V6RX?��ÎP8?F5CdW?F5ID%H�7;?BReP6��¸58:ek§46E-<³4KE;7Y3 9 :e<8<(i��-q0lÓ46ReP8H�_BH6EG<8:XEGO;?F7¹<\H�RXH�HWkwJ�H65É?FdW?FE 1 ?F<8<8?B5jD%?|<\9;H�7;PÉ<\9;4K<jA;58H�7;O;_F?B7

VW5C?�4K<8?B5ÇdK4658:X46E;_F?@58?F7;O;_F<8:XHWE��ÉLNEri��-q�lÏ<\9;? 2 PC9;Hph³?F7�<\9;4K<I4­_BHWD 1 :XE;?F7�?BP <\:XD%4K<8HW5 f _BHWE PC<\5CO;_F<8?B71-2 <\46kG:XE;V�4!h¢?B:eVW9-<\?B7$_BH6D 1 :XE;4K<\:eHWE�H6JI<89;?�7;:X5C?B_|<­?BP <\:XD%4K<8HW5c46E 7�<89;?�:XE 7;:X5C?B_F<w?BP <\:XD%4K<8HW5 fA;5CH�d�:e7;?B7�467;7;:=<\:eHWEÒ46RÓd64K58:Q4KE;_B?(5C?B7;O;_|<\:eHWE��LÎ<Ç:ePjE;4K<\O;5846RÒ<\H':XE-dW?FPC<\:eV-4K<8?�<89;?ÐP846D%?D�GO;?BP <\:eHWE;P¢J�H65jDwO;Re<8:XP8?F5Cd6?B5j7;?BRX4 2 DYH�7;?BReP¢4KE;7%<89;?B:e5

DYHW58?Ç_FHWDYA;RX:e_�4K<8?B7­_BH6EG<\46_F<#�N_F?BE-<\?F5¢5C?BRQ4§<\:ed6?BP��MLNE-<\O;:=<\:=dW?BR 2Wf :=<±h³H6O;RX7Y46A;AÓ?�4K5±<\9Ò4K<É<89;?^58?��GO;:X5C?B7P8:eDcO;RX4K<\:eHWEc58O E%Re?BE;V6<89;PÉJ�HW5ÉDcO;R=<\:eP8?B5 dW?F5É7;?BRX4 2 D%H�7;?BReP±h³H6O;RX7 1 ?�PC:XDY:XRX465Ñ<8H�<89;?I58?���O :X58?F7¹5CO;ERX?FE;V6<89;PÉJ�HW5É<\9;?I_BH65858?FP8AÓHWE;7;:eE;V®DcO;Re<8:XPC?B5Cd6?B5URXH6P8PUD%H�7;?FRXP f-1 O <U<\9;?�46EÒ4KR 2 P8:ePj:eP 2 ?|<¢<8H 1 ?I7;HWE;?B�s�HW5C?BHpdW?F5 f :=<j:XPjEÒ4K<\O 5\46Rl<\H'_BHWE0NC?F_F<8O;58?�<\9Ò4K<¢<\9;?�58?���O :X58?F7�58O E¹RX?FE;V6<89;P¢J�HW5jDYHW58?�_BHWDYA;Re:X_�4§<\?B7_BH6EG<\46_F<#�N_F?BE-<\?F5®DYH�7;?BReP�h¢HWO;RX7 1 ?cPC:XDY:XRQ4K5I<8H�<\9;?­5C?6�GO;:e58?B7¿5CO;E�RX?FE;V6<\9 PÐJ�HW5Ð<89;?cDcO;R=<\:eP8?B5 dW?F57;?FRQ4 2 D%H�7;?BReP fÓ1 O <@46V-46:eE·<89;?­46EÒ4KR 2 P8:eP�:eP 2 ?|<@<\H 1 ?'7;HWE;?B��$^9;HWPC?­465C?wA;5CHWD%:eP8:eE;V%7 :X58?F_F<8:XHWE;PH6JÑ58?FP8?�4K58_`9��

8Ïê9³�ê9uÏê«é':ÉùGï�ú î�ô�ð[íTúÒý-y¹ù�ú;ýAx\üwô�ø�ù�¡�ô�ø�òÑý�ú î�ô�ðÓí

�¸:XDwO;RQ4K<8:XHWE�:ePÐ4KRXDYHWPC<�46R=hÇ4 2 PÐ4KA;A;RX:e?B7·H@d¾RX:eE;?(<\H¹D%46kK?'P 2 P <\?FD P <\O;7;:e?BP��gn�Hph³?|dW?B5 f hI:e<89<\9 ?­PC<\?B467 2 :eE;_B5C?�46PC?�H6Jj_BHWDYA;O <8?B5(AÓH�h¢?B5 f :e<(:eP 1 ?F_BHWDY:XE V�A[HWPCP8: 1 RX?w<8H�A[?F5CJ�HW5CD PC:XDcO;RX4K<\:eHWE;P7 2 EÒ46DY:X_B46RXR 2 :eE%5C?�46R;<8:XDY?Ç<\H®A;58?F7;:X_|<¢46E;7¹_FHWE-<\5CHWRÒ_BHWE VW?BP <\:XH6E��5�ÒHW5U_BHWE-<\46_F<¢_B?FEG<8?B5CP f <89;?�:X7;?B4:XP�<\H²?��¸A;ReHW:e<�<\9;?�L a $ ?6�GO;:XA D%?FEG<(<8H²H 1 <`4K:XE+<\9 ?­_BO;5C58?BE-<®P 2 P <\?BD PC<`4§<\? f 46E 7�<89;?BE�AÓ?B5 J�HW58DDcO;R=<\:eA;RX?%58?BA RX:X_B4K<\:eHWE;PcHKJÐPC:XDcO;RX4K<\:eHWE;P'H�d6?B5%4¿P89;HW5 <f�¶<\?B5CD 9;HW5C:�FHWE.:XE�HW5C7;?B5­<\H�A;5C?B7;:e_F<�<\9 ?<\5846E;PC:X?BE-< 1 ?B9Ò4�d�:XHW5ÇJ�H65Çd64K58:XH6O;P^P8_F?BEÒ465C:XHWPIH6JÑ:XE-<8?B58?FPC<6�$ÑH�?FdK46ReOÒ4K<\?É<89;?¢AÓ?B5 J�HW58D%46E;_F?UH6JÒ58?B46R��¶<\:eD%?±PC:XDcO RQ4K<8:XHWE f h³?¢_�46E'A[?F5CJ�HW5CD�4�P 2 P <\?FD PC:XDcO RQ40�

m�r

Page 20: uwv[xzy|{F} ~py - Columbia Universityww2040/full.pdf · uwv[xzy|{F} ~py Q ` G N N ` 8 C | U C ` \ j = U ' \ = z \ p z N - \ z ¢¡G F£6 ¥¤ ¥ -¦ p Y = § N ` Q p \

<\:eHWE�46_F_BHWDYAÒ46E :X?B7 1G2 467;7;:=<\:eHWEÒ46RÓ58?FA;RX:e_�4K<8:XHWE;PjH6J�<85\46E;PC:X?FEG<IPC:XDcO RQ4K<8:XHWE;PUAÓ?B5 J�HW58DY?B7�<89;58HWO VW9P8:eDcO;RX4K<\:eHWE­<\:XDY?�:XE%<89;?ÐD%46:eE%5CO;E��±3/?Ð9;HWAÓ?�<8Hc:XE-d6?BPC<8:XV-4§<\?�<89;?BPC?�UCPC:XDcO;RX4K<\:eHWE;P±hI:=<\9¹E ?BPC<8?B7P8:eDcO;RX4K<\:eHWE;P6�sW

8Ïê¶êÊêo¬òÃý�îpôÿø�ù�ñÃô�ú

ª�:=dW?FE%<\9;4K<³_FHWE-<`46_|<³hI:=<\9¹_FO;PC<8HWDY?B58P¢E;HwReHWE;VW?F5UE;?B?F7 1 ? 1-2 <8?BRe?BA;9;H6E;? f :e<j:XPjE;?F_B?BPCP\465 2 <8H_BH6E;P8:e7;?B5j<\9;?@HK<\9;?F5³DY?B7;:X4I�É?FD¹4K:XR f J�4O� f LNE-<\?B5CE;?F< f ?F<8_@�5$^9;?ÐE;?Fh�DY?B7;:X4'AÓ?B5CJ�H658D :XE�7 :9d[?B58?FE-<h³4 2 P f 5C?6�GO;:e58:XE VYE ?Fh�P <\H�_`9Ò46P <\:X_�DYH¸7 ?BRXP��

8Ïê¶êÊê�éÒêLÀ0ðlïOµ#îO<Tú î¹óWúÒí¯ëÉù Ã@ðÓ÷Fî>:Éð[íTù�ñ

3 9;?BE·<\9;?(E ?Fh�DY?B7 :Q4­465C?®:eE-<\58H�7;O;_F?B7 f :e<^D%4 2 9Ò46A;AÓ?BE�<89Ò4K<^<\9 ?®PC?B5 d¸:e_B?�58?FA;PI<\9Ò4K<^h¢?B5C?HWE;R 2 4KE;PCh¢?B5C:XE;V+<89;?�<\?FRX?BA 9;HWE;?�4K58?�E;HphÛ58?���O :X58?F7.<\H¿58?FA[H6E;7#<\H¿PC?B5Cd�:e_B?�58?��GO;?BP <\P%46585C:ed�:XE;V1-2 <89;?­H6<\9 ?B5@DY?B7;:X4�46P@h¢?BReR��(3 :e<89+?��ÎD¹46:eRM4KE;7¿LNE-<\?B5CE;?F< f <\9;?c5C?6�GO;:e58?B7�5C?BP8AÓHWE;PC?�D%:eVW9-< 1 ?58?FV-465C7;?B7¾46P@:eE;PC<\46E-<`46E ?BHWO;P f P8H�<\9;4K<@<\9 ?cE;?FhÚNCH 1 _�4KE 1 ?�46PCP8:eVWE;?B7+<8H²46E�4�dK46:XRX4 1 RX?®P8?F5Cd�:X_F?58?FA f NCO PC<^4KP¢:=J�:e<Uh¢?B58?@4®<\?FRX?FA;9;HWE;?�_�46ReR f hI:e<89%<89;?ÐPC?B5Cd�:e_B?Ð5C?BA�5C?6�GO;:e58?B7%<\Hc7;H'HWE;R 2 HWE;?�<89;:XE V4K<Ð4%<\:eD%?B�Dn�Hph³?|dW?F5 f :XE�P8HWDY?®_�46PC?BP f ?@� V)� f hI:e<89!J�40� f <89;?w5C?BPCA[HWE P8?­D%4 2 E H6< 1 ?w5C?6�GO;:X5C?B7!<8H1 ?':eE;PC<\46E-<`46E;?FHWO;P��^LNE;7;?B?F7 f J�HW5�PCHWDY?®HKJ±<\9;?®DY?B7;:X4­<89;?B5C?wD%4 2�1 ?®DcO;_`9!D%HW5C?H~Ò?��¸: 1 :XRX:=< 2 :eE<\9 ?®5C?6�GO;:e58?B7·58?FP8AÓHWE;PC?®<8:XDY?@�LNE¿J�46_F< f P8?F5Cd�:X_F?­58?FA;P(:XE!<85\467 :e<\:eHWEÒ46R�_B46RXRÑ_B?FEG<8?B5CP(9Ò4�dW?�46Re58?�4K7 2!1 ?B?FE+J�46_B?F7¿hI:e<\9!P8?Fd6?B5846R

kG:XE;7 P@H6J¢46Re<8?B5CEÒ4K<\:=dW?®h³HW5Ck f P8HWDY?cH6JÉhI9;:e_`9�:XP(�GO;:=<\?cE HWEC�Î<8:XDY?��Î_B58:=<\:e_�46R!�g�Ñ:X58P < f :XE¿D%46E 2 _B46RXR_B?FE-<\?B5CPÉ<\9;?^PC?B5Cd�:e_B?^58?FA;Pj4658?³58?6�GO;:e58?F7�<8H(A[?F5CJ�HW5CDìUC4KJÚ<\?F5#�N_B46RXRGh¢HW58k f WwP8O _`9¹46PM_BHWDYA;RX?|<\:eE;VÐ<\9 ??BE-<85 2 H6JÃ_FO;PC<8HWD%?F5^HW587 ?B58P����¸?B_FHWE;7 f 7;:�dÊ?F58?FEG<^J�H658DYPÇH6JTh³H658k�?�� :ePC<I:eE�_�46ReRÊ_B?FE-<\?B5CP^<\9Ò4K<I9;4pd6?1 H6<\9¿:eE 1 HWO;E 7/4KE;7�HWO < 1 HWO;E 7¿_�46ReRXP6��$^9;?�:XE 1 HWO;E;7¿_B46RXRePÐ5C?6�GO;:X5C?­:XDYD%?F7;:Q4§<\?®58?BPCA[H6E;P8? fÑ1 O¸<<\9 ?@<\:XDY:XE V'H6JT<89;?(HWO < 1 HWO E;7�_�46ReRXP¢:XPÇDcO _`9·DYHW5C?(~Ò?��¸: 1 RX?B�7$^9;?I�GO;?BP <\:XH6E�H6JÃ9;Hph�<8H�46RXReH¸_B4K<\?P8?F5Cd�:X_F?�5C?BA�<\:eD%? 1 ?F<Nh¢?B?FE,:XE 1 HWO;E;7�46E;7�HWO¸< 1 HWO;E;7$_�46ReRXP­:eP­k�E H�hIE)46P­<\9;?¿UC_B46RXRK� 1 Re?BE;7 :XE;VA;5CH 1 RX?FD��sW­?@� V)� f P8?F?%E³9GO;RX46:�46E 7 � H�HWRX?'i�kBl!�3 9;?BE'<\9;?F58?Ç4K58?jP8?Fd6?B5846R¸J�HW5CD%PTH6J h³HW5Ck�46585C:ed�:XE V f P8HWDY?¢HKJ;hI9;:X_`9'_�46E 1 ?jA[H6PC<\AÓHWE;?F7 f <89;?B5C?

:XP@46E�HWA;AÓHW5C<8O;E;:e< 2 <\H²P8DYH�H6<\9+<89;?ch³H658kGRXH-4K7 1-2 AÓHWP <\AÓHWE;:XE V�h³HW5Ck�<89Ò4K<�_�4KE 1 ?­AÓHWPC<8A[HWE ?B7hI9;?FE'<\9 ?jh¢HW58kGReH-467®:XP�58?FRQ4K<8:ed6?BR 2 9;:XV69��Ã3 9 :e<8<�i�k m6lGPC9;Hph³?F7c9;Hph.5C?BRQ4§<\:ed6?BR 2 P8:eD%A RX?ÉDYH¸7;?FRXP�_B46E1 ?³O;PC?B7c<\H�?BP <\:XD%4K<8?j<89;?³5C?B7;O;_F?B7­HpdW?F5\46ReR¸5C?6�GO;:e58?B7w_�46AÒ4K_B:e< 2 <89Ò4K<±:ePÑE ?B?B7 ?B7c<\H�D%?F?F<M7;?BD%46E;7 fhI9;?FE/PCHWD%?­HKJ¢<89;?�RX?BPCP#�¶<\:XDY?��Î_B5C:e<\:e_�46R�h¢HW58k!_�46E 1 ?YAÓHWP <\AÓHWE;?B7��q,Ð5CD%HWE 2 4KE;7/s!46VWRX465\46P{i t0l

m�k

Page 21: uwv[xzy|{F} ~py - Columbia Universityww2040/full.pdf · uwv[xzy|{F} ~py Q ` G N N ` 8 C | U C ` \ j = U ' \ = z \ p z N - \ z ¢¡G F£6 ¥¤ ¥ -¦ p Y = § N ` Q p \

_BH6E;P8:e7;?B5j<\9;?�A[HWPCP8: 1 :XRe:e< 2 H6J�4'_�4KRXR�� 1 46_`k­HWA¸<\:XH6E��M3 :e<89%<89;?ÐE;?|h DcO;R=<\:XDY?B7 :Q4(_BHWE-<\46_F<³_B?BE-<8?B58P f<\9 ?®AÓHWPCP8: 1 :XRX:=< 2 H6J±AÓHWPC<8A[H6E;:XE;V­PCHWDY?�h¢HW5Ck�:XPÇh¢HW5C<89�DYHW5C?(_�465C?FJ�O;R�P <\O;7 2 �

8Ïê¶êÊê98ÏêP¬�ðÓï�ù�õwðÓør:Ñý�ôÿóWú î�ù¸ñ*õ'ð[íÓîpúÒó6î±w(¢£:ÉùGï§ô�ù�íÃóWù�÷

b�E-<\:eRl58?B_F?BE-<\R 2Wf <\9;?�_BO PC<\H6D%?F5jh¢HWO;Re7¹D%46k6?^<\9 ?B:X5UPC?B5Cd�:e_B?Ð5C?6�GO;?FPC<\P³H�d6?B5³4®PC:XE;VWRe?^D%?F7;:XO D��$^9;?®_BO;P <\HWDY?B5IDY:XVW9-<^_B46RXRÊHWE·<89;?(<\?FRX?BA 9;HWE;?®HW5^D%46k6?®46E·LNE-<\?B5CE;?F<�HW5C7;?B5 fÒ1 O <I<\9;?®_BO PC<\H6D%?F5h¢HWO;RX7)O;P8?+H6E 2 4�PC:XE;V6RX?²D%?F7;:XO D 4K<�46E 2 HWE;?·<\:eD%?²<\H/_�465C5 2 HWO <Y<\9;?·<\5\4KE;P\46_|<\:eHWE���LNE*4DcO;R=<\:eD%?F7;:Q4�_FHWE-<`46_|<!_F?BE-<\?F5 f <\9 ?/PC?B5Cd�:e_B?�5C?BA;P·DY:XVW9-< 1 ?¾h¢HW58kG:eE;V$hI:=<\9�P8?|dW?B5846Rw7 :9d[?B58?FE-<DY?B7;:X4 f;1 O <I<89;? 2 h¢HWO;Re7 1 ?'O P8:XE VY?B46_`9!H6E;R 2 H6E;?®4K<�4�<8:XDY? f;1 ?B_B46O;P8?®_BO PC<\H6D%?F58PIh³?F58?®O;P8:eE;VHWE;R 2 4­P8:eE;VWRe?(D%?F7;:XO;Dh�n�Hph¢?FdW?F5 f <\9;4K<²:XP�5846A;:X7 R 2 _`9;46E;VW:eE;V)�Ûs�O;R=<\:eD%?F7;:Q4/46A;A;Re:X_�4§<\:XH6E;P¹hI9;?F58?/46O;7;:eH f d�:e7;?BH f

VW5846A;9;:e_BP�46E;7#<8?���<%4658?�P 2 E;_`9;58H6E;:�F?B7�4658? 1 ?B_FHWD%:eE;V+dW?F5 2 :eD%AÓHW5 <`46E-<>�j$^9;?²DYHWPC<wJ�46D%:eRX:X465?�� 46DYA;Re?%:ePws�46_B5CHWD%?F7;:Q4h�MRX46P89�&ÉRQ4 2 ?F5 f ?|d�:X7;?FEG<8R 2 A;5C?BP8?FE-<­:XE��-rb� H6JÇ46RXR 1 58HphIP8?F58P6�²3/HW58k:XPÐO;E;7;?F5Ch³4 2 <8H²58?BA RQ46_F?'ng$�s Q 4KE;7©G�s Q hI:e<\9¿<89;?­A;58H6VW5\46DYDY:XE;V%:XE J�5846PC<858O;_|<\O;5C?c<\H²P8O;A+�AÓHW5C<YDcO;R=<\:eD%?F7;:Q4+4KA;A;RX:e_�4K<8:XHWE P6�¿&U5CHWDY:XE;?FEG<%46A A;58H-4K_`9;?BP¹4658?²<\9;? � 2 E;_`9;5CHWE;:9�B?B7*s�O;Re<8:XDY?��7;:X4�LNEG<8?BVW584K<\:eHWE Q 46E;V6OÒ46VW? � �;s�L Q �@46E;7Á�¸AÓ?B?F_`9�,�A;A;Re:X_�4§<\:XH6E Q 46E;VWOÒ4KVW?q$Ñ46VWP � �+, Q $D���ÏP8?F?9-<8<8A�_m`@`§h^h^hI� hD�C� HW5CV;`B,�O;7;:XHBV@:X7 ?BH%46E;7²9-<8<\A�_m`b`�h^h^hI� P846Re<CJ�HW58O;Dh� HW58V��$^9GO;P f PCH¸H6E f <89;?Ð_FO;PC<8HWDY?B5Ç4KE;7%<89;?ÐPC?B5Cd�:e_B?@5C?BA¹hI:eRXR 1 ?Ð4 1 RX?I<\HwPC:XDcO Re<`4KE;?BHWO P8R 2�1 ?�O;P8:eE;V

DcO;R=<\:eA;RX?ÑD%?F7;:Q4Ç<\HI_B46585 2 HWO <T<\9 ?U<85\46E P\46_|<\:XH6E���,$_FO;PC<8HWDY?B5TD%:eVW9-< 1 ?jH6E®<89;?ULNEG<8?B5CE;?F<ÑRXH�HWkG:XE;V4K<�4KE¾H6E;RX:eE;?c_�4§<`46ReHWV�46E;7¿<89;?BE f hI9;:eRX?c_FHWE;E;?F_F<8?B7�<\H�<\9;?­LNE-<8?B58E ?F< f A;RX46_B?�4¹<8?BRe?BA;9;H6E;?�_�46ReR f46E;7�PCH 1 ?@:eE�_BHWE-<\46_F<ÇhI:=<\9�<89;?(P8?F5Cd�:X_F?(58?BA²PC:XDcO;R=<`46E ?BHWO;PCR 2Y1-2 <8?BRX?FA;9;HWE ?�46E;7�<\9 ?(LNEG<8?B5CE;?F<6�,ÐR=<\?F58EÒ4K<8:ed6?BR 26f <89;?­P8?FP8P8:eHWE�D%:eVW9-<ÐP <`465 <(HWE+<89;?­LNE-<\?B5CE;?F<®4KE;7¿<\9;?FE�4¹<\?BRe?BA;9 HWE;?­_BH6E;E;?B_|<\:eHWEDY:XVW9-< 1 ?®467;7;?F7��3 9;?BE 1 HK<\9�<\9;?�_FO;PC<8HWD%?F5�46E;7²<\9;?�P8?F5Cd�:X_F?�58?BA�465C?®PC:XDcO Re<`4KE;?BHWO P8R 2 :XE²DcO Re<\:eD%?F7;:Q4®_BHWE+�

<`4K_F< f <\9;?�_BO PC<\H6D%?F5^_BHWE-<`4K_F<�?��¸AÓ?B58:e?BE;_F?'_B46E²VW?F<IDwO;_`9�DYHW5C?(_BHWDYA;RX:e_�4K<8?B7��ÑLÎ<�E;Hph 1 ?B_FHWD%?FPAÓHWP8PC: 1 Re?'J�HW5�P8?B5 d�:X_B?w58?BA P@<\H¹<8:XDY?��NPC9Ò465C?'HpdW?F5(P8?|dW?B5846R±7;:�dÊ?F58?FEG<@_BO;P <\HWDY?B5CPÐ<\9Ò4§<@<\9;? 2 4K58?c:eE_BH6EG<\46_F<�hI:e<89��($^9;?'_BO;P <\HWDY?B5ÐD%:eVW9-<Ð4KRe<\?F58EÒ4§<\? 1 ?|<Nh³?F?BE�:XE-<\?F5\46_|<\:eHWE;P�hI:=<\9·<\9;?'P8?B5 d�:X_B?w58?BA f?B:=<\9;?F5(HWE¿<\9;?c<8?BRe?BA;9;H6E;?­HW5@d�:Q4�HWE ?YHKJj<89;?�H6<\9 ?B5(DY?B7;:X4 f 46E;7�AÓ?B5C:XH�7;P@H6J 1 5CH�hIPC:XE;V·HWE¿<\9 ?LNE-<\?F58E;?|< f NCO;PC<�46PI_FO;PC<8HWD%?F58PI7;HY:XE�RX4658VW?(7 ?BAÒ465 <\DY?BE-<�PC<8HW58?FP6�LNE�RQ465CVW?'7 ?BAÒ465 <\DY?BE-<�PC<8HW58?FP f <89;?cP\4KRX?BPCA[?F58PCHWE�E;Hph < 2 A;:e_�46ReR 2 E;?F?B7;P(<\H 1 ?­:eE+_BHWE-<\46_F<�4§<

<\9 ?vJÒEÒ4KRÃP <\?FA¿:XE!H6587;?F5�<8H¹_BH6D%A;Re?F<8?®<89;?wP846RX?'4K<�<\9;?'_�46PC9+58?FVW:XP <\?B5 f[1 O <�<89Ò4K<gJÒEÒ46RTPC<8?BA¿_B46E

m��

Page 22: uwv[xzy|{F} ~py - Columbia Universityww2040/full.pdf · uwv[xzy|{F} ~py Q ` G N N ` 8 C | U C ` \ j = U ' \ = z \ p z N - \ z ¢¡G F£6 ¥¤ ¥ -¦ p Y = § N ` Q p \

1 ?�4�d6HW:X7;?F7YhI:=<\9%4®5C?BDYH6<\?^_FHWE-<`46_|<³_F?BE-<\?F5 f�1 ?F_�46O P8?I<\9;?IP\4KRX?I_�46E 1 ?�_FHWDYA;RX?|<\?B7 1-2 PC<\46E;7Ò465C7A;5CH¸_F?B7;O;5C?²H�d6?B5­<\9 ?�LNEG<8?B5CE;?F<6�¨$^9;?�J�O;E;_F<8:XHWE.HKJ�<89;?�P8?F5Cd�:X_F?·5C?BA$:XPc?FP8_B46RQ4K<8?B7.<\H¾4+9;:eVW9;?F5RX?|dW?FR f hI:=<\9�<\9;?�5CHWO <\:eE;?(RXHpht�¶d64KRXO;?���467;7 ?B7�<`4KP8kGP 1 ?F:XE;V�?BRe:XDY:XEÒ4§<\?B7 � 7;HWE ? 1G2 _FHWDYA;O <\?F58P*���ULNE<\9 ?­?BDY?B58V6:XE;V�DcO Re<\:eD%?F7;:Q4�_BH6EG<\46_F<®_F?BE-<\?F5 f P8?F5Cd�:X_F?Y5C?BA;P(hI:eRXR 1 ?­HWE;R 2 A 58Hpd�:X7;:eE;V�_BO;P <\HWDY?B5CP:XDYAÓHW5C<\46E-<^:XE J�H658D%4K<\:eHWE f 9;?BReA;:XE V�<89;?BD 46_`9;:X?|dW?�<\9;?F:X5^H 1 NC?B_F<8:ed6?BP6�LÎ<jP89;HWO RX7 1 ?I?Fd�:e7;?BE-<U<\9Ò4§<¢:=<É:XPUDcO _`9%DYHW58?^_`9;46RXRe?BE;VW:eE;V@<\H�_FHWE;PC<858O;_|<³PCO;:e<\4 1 Re?^PC<\H�_`9Ò46P <\:e_

DYH¸7;?FRXP¹<8H�9;?BReA�7 ?BP8:eVWE�46E;7 D%46EÒ46VW?¿_FHWE-<`46_|<²_B?FEG<8?B5CP·hI9;?FE�_FO;PC<8HWD%?F58P²9Ò4�dW?�PCO;_`9�DYHW58??BRX4 1 HW5\4K<8?^_BHWE-<\46_F<¢?��¸AÓ?B58:e?BE;_F?BP����ÒHW5ÉH6E;?^<\9;:eE;V f <\9;?I_FO;PC<8HWD%?F5¢_FHWE-<`46_|<U<\:XDY?I46PCP8H�_B:Q4§<\?B7�hI:e<89HWE;?I_FHWE-<`46_|<¢?��¸A[?F58:X?FE;_B?ID%4 2 E;H6< 1 ?I4(P8:XDYA;Re?Ç:XE-<\?F5CdK46R!�MLÎ<ÉhI:XReR 1 ?I:XE-<\?F58?BP <\:eE;V(<\H�D%H�7;?FR ?Fd6?BE4­P8:eE;VWRX?(_FHWE-<`46_|<�?��¸A[?F58:e?BE;_F?@Û

8Ïê9í�êoî·ðÓí£x\ü³ù�ør:Éðlï�úÒý#ï�î�ðÓí�xFõ'ðÓí��lù�÷Fî�ô�ðÓí¯¬�ùGúÒ÷�òTï§ù�÷YðÓûHðYòTúÒý�ô�î��

a 46RXRK�N_F?BE-<\?F5ÐAÓ?B5CJ�H658D%46E;_B?®:XP�58HWO¸<\:XE ?BR 2 _`9;465\46_|<\?F58:�F?B7 1-2 <\9;?cEGO;D 1 ?F58PÐHKJU_�46ReRXP�9Ò46E;7;Re?B7 f1 ReH¸_`kK?B7¿46E 7+4 1 4KE;7;HWE;?F7 f 46E;7 1G2 46PCP8H�_B:X4K<\?F7+4�dW?F5\46VW?FPD�¢<\9;?®AÓ?B58_F?BE-<`4KVW?wH6JM_�46ReRXP�46E;P h³?F58?F7 f4�dW?F5\46VW?­PCA[?F?B7�<\H²46E PCh¢?B5 � ,��C,H�@4KE;7�4�dW?B5846VW?�4KJÚ<8?B5@_B46RXRÑ9Ò46E;7 RX:XE V%<\:eD%?B�I$^9;?�4K<8<8?BE-<\:eHWE+:ePJ�H�_BO;PC?B7�H6E¾<89;58HWO VW9;A;O <w46E;7¾_BH6E;VW?BP <\:eHWE��±,Û_FHWDYD%HWE�7;?FRQ4 2 <`4K58VW?|<':eP@<\9;?zkWo�`6q6o�58O;Re?{�I<8H9Ò4�dW?vkWo�� H6JÃ<\9;?�_�4KRXRXPI4KE;PCh¢?B5C?B7�hI:=<\9;:eE�q6o­P8?B_FHWE;7;P��n�Hph¢?FdW?F5 f J�HW5®?�d[?B_F<8:ed6?�D¹46E;46VW?BDY?BE-< f :e<':XP':XDYA[H65C<`4KEG<�<8H¿46RXPCH!_FHWE;P8:e7;?B5'E;HWEC�¶<\?FD%AÓHW5\4KR f

E;HWE+�N_BH6E;VW?BP <\:eHWE!DY?�46PCO;58?FP@H6JUPC?B5Cd�:e_B?%�GOÒ4KRX:e< 2 �g$^9 ?cH 1 d�:XHWO;P�HWE;?��N7;:eD%?FE;P8:eHWEÒ46RT46R=<\?F58EÒ4K<8:ed6?':eP_BH6PC< � 46_|<\OÒ46ReR 2 58?|dW?BEGO;?!D%:eE�O PY_FHWPC<������¸:XV6E;:9JÒ_B46E-<YPC<\?FA;PY:XE�<\9Ò4K<Y7;:e58?F_F<\:eHWE.h³?F58?·D¹4K7;? 1G2E³HW5CPC<U?|<³4KR��-i¥m�qOll46E;7}ª®4K58E;?|<8<U?F<j4KR��3i qWt�l��G<\9;? 2 :XE _BRXO 7;?B7�_BH6PC<\PU:eE­D¹46E 2 �NPC?B5 dW?B5¢46P 2 DYA <8H6<\:e_BP6��Ò58HWD <89;?Y_BO;P <\HWDY?B5�S P®A[?F58PCA[?F_F<\:=dW? f <\9 ?B58?Y:XP�DYHW58?B_I$^9;?B5C?¹:XP(<89;?'��O;46RX:=< 2 H6JÇPC?B5 d¸:e_B?Y58?��

_B?F:ed6?B7���n�Hphn7;H+h³?�584K<\?%<\9;?��GOÒ4KRX:e< 2 H6JI<89;?�P8?F5Cd�:X_F?�?��¸A[?F58:e?BE;_F?�58?B_F?B:=dW?B7Öi��b�Bl â LÎ<­P8?F?BDYP46A;A 58HWA;5C:Q4K<8?w<\H�V6H 1 ? 2 HWE;7�_FHWE;VW?FPC<\:eHWE¾46E;7¿_FHWPC<6�­Z@E;?­_�4KE;7;:X7;4K<\? fÏ1 O <�?FRXO;PC:edW? f D%?B46P8O 58?c:eP1 5846E;7$RXH 2 46R=< 2Wf hI9;:X_`9�D%:eVW9-<­:XE _B58?B46P8?�hI:=<\9$VWH¸H�7�P8?F5Cd�:X_F?�?�� AÓ?B5C:X?FE;_B?FP�46E;7$7;?F_B58?B46P8?²hI:e<891 467%HWE;?FP6�FE³5846E;7�ReH 2 46Re< 2 P89;HWO RX7¹_`9;46E;VW?@:eE¹4®P8ReH�h¢?B5j<\:eD%?^PC_�46Re?@46E;7%P8:eVWE;:9J;_�46E-<\R 2 4Bd[?B_|<³<\9 ?_BO PC<\H6D%?F5ÇP8?F5Cd�:X_F?��N5C?6�GO;?FPC<�5\4K<8?BP��F�lH�_BO P8:XE VwHWE 1 5846E;7�ReH 2 46Re< 2 _FHWO;RX7¹_�46A <8O;58?Ð?�d[?B_F<8PÇ<\9Ò4§<^465C?:XDYAÓHW5C<\46E-<^HpdW?B5IReHWE;VW?F5Ç<\:XDY?@PC_�46Re?BP6�

q6o

Page 23: uwv[xzy|{F} ~py - Columbia Universityww2040/full.pdf · uwv[xzy|{F} ~py Q ` G N N ` 8 C | U C ` \ j = U ' \ = z \ p z N - \ z ¢¡G F£6 ¥¤ ¥ -¦ p Y = § N ` Q p \

8Ïê9ñ�ê üv<Ãù��!òÃø�úÒí¯w(ý�ù�ø�ù�í[î

&Ñ?F589Ò46A P®<89;?­D%H6PC<®4K<C<\5\4K_F<\:=dW?wJ�?B4K<\O 58?�H6Jj_BHWE-<\46_F<®_B?FE-<\?B5CP f D¹4Kk�:eE;V¹<89;?BD PCH²:XE-<\?F58?BP <\:eE;V<\H­P <\O;7 2Wf :XPj<\9;?(_F?BE-<\5846RÏ5CHWRX?�A;RQ4 2 ?F7 1G2 A[?FHWA;Re?@�5$^9;?(_FO;PC<8HWD%?F58PI465C?@AÓ?BHWA;Re?(46E;7�<89;?(P8?F5Cd�:X_F?58?FA;P(465C?'AÓ?BH6A;RX?B��3/?w_B46E+?�4KP8:XR 2 58?FRQ4K<8?®<8H¹_BH6EG<\46_F<@_B?BE-<8?B58P 1 ?F_�46O;PC?wh¢?cHWO;5CP8?BR=dW?FP@H6JÚ<\?FE¿465C?_BO PC<\H6D%?F58PIH6JÑ_BHWE-<`4K_F<�_B?BE-<8?B58P��ª�:=dW?FE�<89;?^:XDYAÓHW5C<\46E-<±9GO;D%46E�?BRX?FD%?FE-< f :e<±:XP±EÒ4§<\O;5846R <\H(<85 2 <8H 1 ?|<8<8?B5UO;E;7;?F58P <`46E;7Y9GO;D%46E

1 ?B9Ò4�d�:XHW5T:eE'_FHWE-<`46_|<M_F?BE-<\?F58P6�MLÎ<M:eP�:XE-<\?F58?BP <\:eE;V�<8H�P <\O;7 2 <89;?jA;P 2 _`9;HWReHWV 2 H6J��GO;?BO;?F:XE;Vqis�@�BlÂi q�m6l��LÎ<I:XP^:eE-<\?B5C?BP <\:XE V�<8H�_BHWE;PC:X7;?F5^hI9 2 PC?B5 d¸:e_B?�58?FA;P�D%:eVW9-<^P8ReH�h�7;HphIE·:XE²_B?F5C<`4K:XE²_B:e58_BO D%P <`46E;_F?BP f46P��C�B?cH 1 P8?F5CdW?F7¯i��@�0l��@LÎ<Ð:XP�:XE-<\?F58?BP <\:eE;V%<8H�:XE-dW?FPC<8:XV-4K<8?'hI9 2 _FO;PC<8HWDY?B58P@4 1 46E;7 HWE¿46E;7!58?F<85 2 ��¸O;_`9�P <\O;7;:e?BPÉ9Ò4�d6? 1 ?F?BE�D¹4K7;?^4K<5,5$p�H$ fW1 O <ÉRX:=<8<8RX?U:eJÓ46E 2 4658?ÇA O 1 RX:eP89;?F7��É]I?B_F?BE-<\R 2Wf ,�d�:eP89Ò46:s!46E 7;?BR 1 46O;D 46E;7/9;:XP®_BH6RXRX?B46VWO;?FP�9Ò4�dW?¹D%467;?%4�PC?B5C:XHWO;P®PC<8O;7 2 H6JÇ_FO;PC<8HWDY?B5c4 1 46E;7;H6E;D%?FE-<i¦��kBl"i�kb�Bl�i¦�GrOl!�

uÏêìëBíÓîpù;�Óï�ú îpô�ðÓí)ðlûpy�ù�÷BùGú;ï§óB<,ú;íÑñ¯w(ñÃòÃóWú î�ô�ð[í

LÎ<�:XP(7;?FP8:e5\4 1 Re?w<\H²9Ò4�d6?%4�5C?BP8?B4658_`9¾A;5CHWVW5\4KD <\9;4K<�9;?BReA;P(A;5CH�d�:e7;?cdK46RXOÒ4 1 RX?­4KE;7�?��¸_B:=<\:XE V?B7 O;_�4K<8:XHWE;46R�?��¸A[?F58:X?FE;_B?FP�J�HW5YPC<\O 7;?BE-<\P fÐ1 H6<\9�VW5\4K7;OÒ4K<8?+46E;7*O E;7;?B5CVW5\4K7;OÒ4K<8?@�Ì$^9;:eP¹AÒ4KA[?F57;?FP8_B5C: 1 ?BP�D¹46E 2 AÓHWPCP8: 1 RX?�58?FP8?�4K58_`9+7;:e58?F_F<\:eHWE;P f hI9;:X_`9�P89;HWO RX7 1 ?�P8O;:=<`4 1 RX?(J�HW5IPC<8O;7;?BE-<8P�hI:e<89dK465 2 :eE;V 1 46_`kGVW58H6O;E;7;P��a HWE-<`46_|<­_B?FE-<\?B5CP�_�46E 1 ?�D%467;?¹4!_BHWE-<8?���<cJ�H�_BO;Pc:eE#_BH6O;58PC?BP­HWE#P <\H�_`9Ò46P <\:X_¹D%H�7;?BRePw4KE;7

P8:eDcO;RX4K<\:eHWE f <8H�A 58Hpd�:X7;?U467 7;:e<8:XHWEÒ4KR6DYH6<\:=d64§<\:XH6E�J�HW5�Re?�465CE;:XE;VÇ<89;?±<\?F_`9;E;:e_�46R-D%4K<\?F58:X46R�� a HWE-<\46_F<#�_B?FE-<\?B5ÐP8:XDwO;RQ4K<8:XHWE PÇ_�46E!D¹46kK?'V6H¸H�7�PC:XDcO RQ4K<8:XHWE²_BH6O;58PC?wA;5CH0NC?B_|<\P6�gE 2 9Ò4�d�:XE;V%PC<8O;7;?BE-<8P@58?B467<\9 ?I<85\467 ?^RX:e<8?B584K<\O;5C? f d�:eP8:e<±HWA[?F5\4K<8:XHWE;46R _FHWE-<`46_|<U_B?BE-<8?B58P¢46E;7�h¢HW58kwhI:=<\9�_BH6EG<\46_F<#�N_F?BE-<\?F5j7;4K<`4 fh¢?Ð_�4KE 1 ?F<C<\?B5jA;5C?BAÒ465C?ÐP <\O;7;?FE-<\P¢J�H65UJ�O¸<\O;5C?�h¢HW58kY46E 7¹DYH6<\:=d64§<\?³<89;?�dK46ReO;?IH6JÊ<89;?�O;E;7;?F58R 2 :eE;V<\9 ?BHW5 2 <\9Ò4§<�h¢?(J�H¸_FO;PIHWE��

q¸m

Page 24: uwv[xzy|{F} ~py - Columbia Universityww2040/full.pdf · uwv[xzy|{F} ~py Q ` G N N ` 8 C | U C ` \ j = U ' \ = z \ p z N - \ z ¢¡G F£6 ¥¤ ¥ -¦ p Y = § N ` Q p \

y�ùGûÎùGï�ù�íÑóWù�÷

i�m6l�, 1 4§<\? f ��� f ª{� Q � a 9;H6O;7;9GO;5 2 46E;7#3Ê�Ñ3 9 :e<8< � m��@�b����,�E.:XE-<\5CH¸7 O;_F<8:XHWE�<8H+EGO;DY?B58:e_�46R<\5846E;PCJ�H658DÖ:eEGd6?B5CP8:XH6E�46E;7%:e<\Pj46A A;RX:e_�4K<8:XHWEc<8HwA;5CH 1 4 1 :eRX:=< 2 DYH¸7;?FRXP���ò .0|(ÈÉYC��1@�!��.0/É1@��ó� *.@»6\1�»6�A�º�A�!ã§f 3Ê�ɪ(5\46PCP8D%46E � ?F7��m� f � RXO-h³?F5 f E³H6PC<\H6E f qWtWrO�4�-q@���

i q0l�, 1 4§<\? f ���Ó46E;7!3Ê�Ò3 9;:=<8< � m��@�bk�� a 46RX_FO;RQ4§<\:XE V�<85\46E P8:X?FE-<@_`9Ò465846_F<8?B5C:XPC<8:X_FP�H6JM<\9;?wSU5CRQ46E VRXHWPCP^D%H�7;?FR 1-2 EGO;D%?F58:e_�46RÊ<85\46E PCJ�HW5CD :XE-dW?F58PC:XHWE���ô �4.���[�10��^����õ�.6¼+���a m>� f �b�b�0�4�bkWo��

i��Bl�, 1 4§<\? f ���G46E 7Y3Ê�W3 9;:=<8< � m��b�b��� a H6D%A;O¸<\:XE V Q 46A RQ46_F?Ç<\5\4KE;PCJ�HW5CD%P±J�H65jEGO;DY?B5C:X_B46R <\5846E;P��J�HW58D :eE-dW?B5CP8:eHWE+d�:Q4%_FHWE-<\:eE�O ?B7+J�5\4K_F<\:eHWE;P�� ]*ög÷tø�ùpõ ôÁú .0YC �/É1@�5.0/ ò .0|(ÈÉY+�^�A/+Z mWm f �b�@�B��-o-tC�

i¦�@l�,ÐE-<\H6E f ��� � qKoWoWo��-$^9;?�AÒ4KPC< f A 58?BPC?BE-<(4KE;7�J�O <\O;5C?�H6JM_FO;PC<8HWDY?B5�46_B_F?BPCP�_F?BE-<\?F58P6� ]�/��4�� �/É1@\�!��.0/É1@� ú .0Y+ �/É1@��.�Ý ô �� ��������g]�/ɼ@Y���^ �ã{õ©1@/É1�Z+��|}��/�� mWm f mpq6o0�`m>�Wo��

i t0l�,Ð5CD%HWE 26f sÁ�Ê46E 7 a �Ïs�46VWRQ4K5\46P��Óq6oWo mb�[Z@E!_FO;PC<8HWDY?B5Ð_FHWE-<`46_|<@_F?BE-<\?F58PÐhI:=<\9+4Y_�46ReR�� 1 46_`kHWA <8:XHWE�_Ã_BO PC<\H6D%?F5¢7;?F_B:eP8:XH6E;P f P8?��GO;?BE;_F:XE;Vw58O;Re?BP f 46E 7¹P 2 P <\?BD 7;?FP8:eVWE�� g ?|h)ijHW58k�b�E;:ed6?B5��P8:=< 2 �

i��Bl�,(�B465 f iq� f ,v� E³58H�7;?B5 f ,%� � 465CRX:XE²4KE;7!S3�lb�A J�46R � m>�b�@�;�tEÇ4KRQ46E;_F?B7�46RXReH¸_B4K<\:eHWE;P�� ó� *.������?¼@\�A/+Z0q.�ÝH�A[���û�ü0�¸[}ý ò õ ô ã0|(È�.���AYC|ä.0/ �¸[���þ�[���.0 �ãË.�Ý ò .0|(ÈÉYC�^�A/+Z ÿ ô þ"ø ò��(t@�b�0�4�Wo-qC�

i r0lvEÇ465 1 ?F5 f ª'� f E(� a RX?Fd6?BRX46E;7 f nv�Ã>@HW5 <\D%46E;P f ª{� Q ?Fd�:XE f ª{�Ms�46_>&É9;?F58P8H6E.46E;7�,%���¸DY:e<89� q6o6oWo��'ò 1@�A� ò ��/��4�� �÷�.0 *���?10��!�A/+Z�1@/ɼ ô ��[��?¼@YC�º�A/+Z���þ�[���������g.�Ý ò 1@�A� ò ��/��4�� võ©1@/É1�Z+��\|}��/��7ùD���������Éf a 46RXR a ?FE-<\?B5g&É58?FP8P f ,�E;EÒ46AÓHWRX:eP f s!>q�

i�kBlvE³9GO;RQ4K: f �Â��46E;7qª'�§sÁ� � H�HWRX? � q6oWoWob�£,Ç�GO;?BO ?B:XE VÐDYH¸7;?FRWJ�HW5T_�46ReR 1 RX?FE;7;:eE;VI:XE®_�46ReR-_B?BE-<8?B58P��ó� �.������?¼@�A/+Z0v.�ÝI�¸[����@�A[z] ����� ò��±ò�m>�Gq¸m��`m>�GqB���

i��BlvE³HWReH6<\:eE f V%��,%� � m��b�@���g$Ñ?FRX?FA;9;HWE;?­_F:X5C_BO;:=<(9;HWRe7;:XE;V%<\:XDY?c7;:ePC<858: 1 O <\:eHWE;P6� ó� �.������?¼@�A/+Z0±.�Ý�¸[��������¸[}]�/����� �/É1@�^��.0/É1@����������^ f1fÞ´� ò .0/+Z@ �������];þ ò \����Òf m�qWtO�\m��@�)�

i�mpoBlvE³HW5CH�d�kKH�d f ,%�=,%� � m��-r@�b�{ô �4.���[�10��!���±ó� *.�����������A/��tY ��Y����A/+ZÚþ�[���.0 �ã§f �¸A;5C:XE;V6?B5 fUg ?FhijHW58k �

qWq

Page 25: uwv[xzy|{F} ~py - Columbia Universityww2040/full.pdf · uwv[xzy|{F} ~py Q ` G N N ` 8 C | U C ` \ j = U ' \ = z \ p z N - \ z ¢¡G F£6 ¥¤ ¥ -¦ p Y = § N ` Q p \

i�mWm6lvE³HW5CH�d�kKH�d f ,%�B,%� � m��bkB�;� ý(�ãB|(ÈÉ�4.0�^���tõ����A[�.6¼0p�A/��tY ��Y����A/+Z�þ�[���.0 �ã§f 3 :XRe? 2WfWg ?Fh�ijHW5CkÉ�

i�m�q0lvE³HW5CPC< f �Â� a � f ,v�³s�46E;7;?FR 1 46O D 46E;7*sÁ�¢L��j]I?B:XD%46E � q6o6oWo��­>@:XDY?BE;PC:XHWE :XE;V¿RX4658VW?²_B46RXR_B?FEG<8?B5CP6�ÉE³?BReR Q 4 1 HW5\4K<8HW58:e?BP f)Q O;_B?FE-<($Ã?B_`9;E HWRXHWV6:X?BP f s�O;5C5\4 2 n�:eRXR f;g ���

i�m��BlvE³HW5CPC< f �Â� a �l46E;7h&�� �¸?B5C: � q6o6oWo��³]IH 1 O;P <�46RXV6HW58:=<\9;DYPjJ�H65^P89Ò465C:XE;V�4KVW?BE-<\P^hI:=<\9�DcO;R=<\:eA;RX?P8kG:XReRXP��)E³?FRXR Q 4 1 HW5\4§<\HW5C:X?BP f s�O 585\4 2 n�:XRXR f g ���

i�m>�@lvE³58:eV-46E;7 : f ,%�Â��� f >q�Ó]I�Ó>(4658VWH6E f s������Â�¸9 ?B?B9;46E�46E;7�$H���¸AÓ?BE _B?B5 � m��b�B�;�t,5$p�I$HS P@_B46RXRA;58H�_B?FP8PC:XE;V�P8:eDcO;RQ4§<\:XH65 � a ,(&"�)��_KZ@A[?F5\4K<8:XHWE;46R67;?FP8:eVWEwH6J¸:XE 1 HWO;E;7®_�4KRXRW_F?BE-<\?F58P6� ]�/��4�� AÝ�1+����qB� f �O� q@k��

i�m�t0l a 9Ò46DYA 2Wf ���b,v�-46E;7%s���n�46DYD%?F5 � qKoWo mO� ùp���A/+Z@�A/����� ��A/+Z��A[�� ò .0 2È�.0 f1@�!��.0/��Fý õj1@/�� Ý>����4.Ý>.0 ��pY���A/����I *���@.0�ºYC�^��.0/Òf P8?F_BHWE 7!?B7 :e<\:eHWE f nÐ465CA[?F5gE¢O;P8:eE;?BPCP(E³H�HWkGP flg ?Fh�ijHW58k �

i�m��Bl a 9;HWO;7 9�O 5 2Wf ª{� Q � f >q�És�� Q O _�46E-<\H6E;:^46E;7#3Ê�Ã3 9;:e<C< � m>�b�-rb� g O;DY?B5C:X_�4KR¢PCHWRXO <8:XHWE/H6J­��!®@Î��^®¸mI�GO;?BO ?BP6� ø=È��� f1@�!��.0/�(ùD����?1@ *��[ �Gt f �Gt¸m��2���b���

i�m�r0l a RX?|dW?BRX46E;7 f E(�±46E;7¿���Us!4 2�1 ?FE � m��b�-r@� ò 1@�A� ò ��/��4�� zõ©1@/É1�Z+��|}��/��%.0/Ç÷£10��g÷�.0 ��"1@ f¼6fa 46RXR a ?BE-<\?F5(&É5C?BP8P f ,�E;EÒ46AÓHWRe:XP f s!>q�

i�m�kBl'>@O�eY?BRe7 fUg �7ª'�M46E;7.3Ê�M3 9;:=<8< � m��b�-r@� a HWE-<\5CHWRÇ46E 7$5C?B_FH�d6?B5 2 J�58HWD 5\465C?�_BH6E;VW?BP <\:eHWE?Fd6?BE-<\P�:XE·4�RQ465CVW?@DcO;R=<\:K�NP8?F5Cd6?B5^P 2 P <\?BDh� �tY���Y ���A/+Z ô ã������|% q@� f �b�0�`m�o@�)�

i�m��Bl'>@O;58:eE;Hpd�:X_����6HW9;5C: f �Â�-46E;7ciq� Q ?Fd 2 � m>�b�-rb��,Ð7 dK46E;_F?B7Y58HWO¸<\:XE V(P8HWReO <\:eHWE;PMJ�HW5Ñ<\HWReR��ÎJ�5C?B?j_BO;P��<\HWDY?B5CP6_(4KRXVWHW5C:e<89;D 7;?BPC:XVWE¾46E 7/AÓ?B5 J�HW58D%46E;_F?@� ó� *.������?¼@�A/+Z0}.�Ýq�¸[��v]�/����� �/É1@�^��.0/É1@�DþÉ�����\�! f1fÞ´� ò .0/+Z@ *�����=]�þ ò \��� 6f SÉRXPC?Fd�:X?F5 f ,ÐDYPC<8?B5C7Ò46D f m�tWrO�\m��-rC�

i q6oBlv�l46RX:eE f ª{�Ò46E 7���� ª{��$Ã?BDYA;RX?|<\HWE � m>�b�-rb� ùp���^ ��^1@���tY ��Y���|f a 9Ò46A D¹46E�46E;7hn�46RXR!�

i q¸m6l%ª®4K:XR f $H��4KE;7 Q ���¸_BHK<8< � m��b�-rb�D, JÒ?BRe7¿PC<8O;7 2 :eEGd6?BP <\:XVW4K<\:eE;V¹<\9 ?c?�d[?B_|<'HKJÉhÇ46:=<\:eE;V¹<\:eD%?HWE²_BO;P <\HWDY?B5IP84K<\:ePCJ�46_|<\:XH6E��Âú .0Y+ �/É1@��.�Ýgó"�ã���[�.0�.?Z@ã§flg HpdW?FD 1 ?F5�m��b�-r f �-tWtO�4�b�Wo��

i qWq0l%ª®4KE;P fÓg � f ª'� � H�HWRX?®46E;7�,%�[s!46E 7;?BR 1 46O;D � q6oWo-qb�t$Ã?BRe?BA;9;H6E;?w_B46RXR�_F?BE-<\?F58P6_3,<\O¸<\HW5C:Q46R46E;7�Re:e<\?F5\4K<8O;58?�58?|d¸:e?FhI�C$^9;?(3 9Ò465C<8HWEh�¸_`9;H�HWR f b�E :edW?F58PC:e< 2 HKJ�&Ñ?BE E;P 2 RedK46E :Q4��)$ÃH�46A;AÓ?�4K5

i q@�Bl%ª®4KE;P f�g ��46E 7Yi{�C§Ê9;H6O � m��b�b���Us!4KEÒ46VW:eE;V�RX?�4K58E;:eE;V®46E;7%<8O;58E H�d6?B5¢:XEY?BDYA;RXH 2 ?F?�P <`4BeYE;V��$^9;?(3 9Ò465 <\HWE �¸_`9;H�HWR f b�E;:=dW?B5CP8:=< 2 H6J�&Ñ?BE E;P 2 RedK46E :Q4��

q@�

Page 26: uwv[xzy|{F} ~py - Columbia Universityww2040/full.pdf · uwv[xzy|{F} ~py Q ` G N N ` 8 C | U C ` \ j = U ' \ = z \ p z N - \ z ¢¡G F£6 ¥¤ ¥ -¦ p Y = § N ` Q p \

i qB�@l%ª®4K58E;?|<8< f Zq�W46E;7%,%�-s�46E;7;?FR 1 46O D � q6oWoWo��£,ÐE­:eE-<\58H�7;O;_|<\:eHWE'<8H(P8kG:XReRXP#� 1 46PC?B7w5CHWO <8:XE;V(4KE;7:e<8P^HWA[?F5\4K<8:XHWE;46RÊ_FHWD%A RX?��¸:=<\:X?FP6�C$Ñ?F_`9;E;:XH6E f LNP85846?BR!�

i qWt0l%ª®4K58E;?|<8< f Zq� f ,v� s�46E;7;?FR 1 46O D 46E;7�sÁ�¸L���]I?B:XD%46E � q6o6oWo��±>@?BPC:XVWE :XE;V'4'_B46RXRÒ_F?BE-<\?F5¢hI:e<89:XDYAÒ4K<8:X?BE-<³_BO;P <\HWDY?B5CP6�ÉE³?BReR Q 4 1 HW5\4K<8HW58:e?BP f s�O;5C5\4 2 n�:eRXR f g � ���

i q@�Bl%ª�5C?B?FE f Q �l46E;7�&�� � HWRX?FP\465 � m>�bkb���-$Ã?BP <\:XE VY<89;?®dK46Re:X7;:=< 2 HKJ±4'�GO;?BO;?F:XE;V%D%H�7;?FR�H6JMAÓHWRe:X_B?AÒ4K<858HWR!� õ©1@/É1�Z+��|}��/�� ô ������/���� �-t f m�qWrO�\m>��k��

i qWr0l%ª�5C?B?FE f Q �)Vq� f &��Â��� � H6RX?BP8465I46E;7����É�¸H-465C?BP � q6o6o mO�³LNDYA;58Hpd�:XE;V­<89;?q��L�&"&*4KA;A;58HW46_`9·J�H65PC<\4BeYE;V'PC?B5 d¸:e_B?�P 2 PC<8?BDYPj<89Ò4K<j9Ò4�dW?�_ 2 _FRX:X_^7 ?BD%46E;7;P�� ø=È��� f1@�^��.0/�tùp����?1@ *��[ ��� f t0���0� tB�@�)�

i q@kBl%ª�5C?B?FE f�Q �)Vq� f &=�É��� � H6RX?BP8465I46E;7����É�¸HW4658?FP � q6oWo m���,ÐE·:XDYA;58Hpd6?B7²9;?BO 58:XP <\:e_@J�HW5^PC<\4BeYE;V<\?FRX?BA 9;HWE;?­_B46RXR±_F?BE-<\?F58P�hI:e<89¿RX:XDY:e<8?B7+H6A[?F5\4K<8:XE;V�9;H6O;58P���ª�58467;OÒ4§<\?±�¸_`9;H�HWRÉH6J-E³O;PC:XE;?FP8P fa HWRXO D 1 :Q4wb�E;:=dW?B5CP8:=< 2 �

i q@�Bl%ª�5C:X?F5 fÇg � f 3Ê��,v�³s�46P8PC? 2Wf $H�³s�_ � H 2 46E;7�3Ê�U3 9;:=<8< � m��@�-rb�{$^9;?�<8:XDY?��N7 ?BAÓ?BE;7;?FE-<SÉ58RQ4KE;V­RXHWPCPID%H�7;?BRÓhI:e<89�5C?F<\5C:Q46ReP6� þÂ�������.0|{|{Y+/����?1@�!��.0/ ô ãO��4��|% r f qWt@�0��q@�-tC�

i��WoBlvnÐ46R�JÒE f �Â�¸46E;7�3Ê�-3 9;:e<C< � m��bk m��7n�?�4�d 2 �Î<85\4BeY_ÐRe:XDY:e<8PMJ�HW5F�GO;?BO;?FP³hI:e<89%D%46E 2 ?��¸AÓHWE;?FEC�<\:X46RÊPC?B5Cd6?B5CP6� ø=È��� ?1@�^��.0/��ùp���! q@� f t@�WrO� t@k@k��

i�� m6lvnÐ465C58:eP f a �Ws�� f a � Q �Bn�H@d[D¹46Ew46E;7%&=�BE(�b�¸46O;E;7;?F58P � m��bk-r@�Ãs·H¸7;?FRX:eE;V�<89;?³L�]g�®<8?BRX?FA;9;HWE ?<\?�� A;4 2 ?B5�:XE J�H658D%4K<\:eHWE�P 2 P <\?BDh� ø=È��� f1@�!��.0/�(ùD����?1@ *��[ �-t f tKo@�B� t6q@���

i��-q0lvnÐ46PCP8:eE f ]��646E;7%s���n�4�d¸:=dÉ�;m��b�-t+�WS5�GO;:XRe: 1 5C:XO;D�<\9 58?BPC9;HWRe7­PC<\584K<\?FVW:X?FP6_Ã<\9;?^_B46P8?IH6JÉ�GO;?BO ?BPhI:e<89·A 58:XH658:e<8:X?FP6� ø=È��� ?1@�^��.0/��ùp����?1@ *��[ �-t f �b�b�O���-r@�C�

i��b�Bl%�W46VW?F58D%46E f >q� Q � � m��-rB�;�I�¸H6D%?YA;58H6A[?F5C<\:e?BP®H6J³<89;?�SÉ5CRQ46E;V·RXH6P8P(J�O;E;_|<\:XH6E�� �����A� ô ãO��4��|þÂ����[+/����?1@� ú .0YC �/É1@� tB� f tWqWt�� tWt¸m@�

i��@�@l%�6?BE;E :XE;VWP f Zq�gEg� f ,v�Ðs�46E;7;?FR 1 46O D f 3Ê�p,v�Ðs�46P8PC? 2 46E;7�3Ê�^3 9;:=<8< � m>�b�b���Ë�¸?F5Cd6?B5PC<\4BeYE;V­<\HYD%?F?F<^<\:eD%?��ÎdK465 2 :eE;Vc7;?FD¹4KE;7�� õ©1@/É1�Z+��|}��/�� ô ������/���� �Gq f m��bkb�O�`m��b�B�)�

i��-t0l%�6HWE;V 1 RXH�?B7 f ª{�Ó46E;7jª{�Ós�� � H�HWRe? � q6oWoWob��s�46EÒ46VW:eE;VYO;E;_B?F5C<\46:XE-< 2 :XE�_�46ReR�_B?BE-<8?B58PÐO;P8:eE;V&ÑHW:eP8PCHWE²D%:K�¸<8O;58?FP6� �Ò58?F?®b�E;:=dW?B5CP8:=< 2Wf ,ÐDYPC<8?B5C7Ò46Dh�

qB�

Page 27: uwv[xzy|{F} ~py - Columbia Universityww2040/full.pdf · uwv[xzy|{F} ~py Q ` G N N ` 8 C | U C ` \ j = U ' \ = z \ p z N - \ z ¢¡G F£6 ¥¤ ¥ -¦ p Y = § N ` Q p \

i��b�Bl � HWV-46E f i{� f iq� Q ?Fd 2 46E;7!]���,v�Ós�:XRe:e<\H � m��b�-r@� a 46RXRÏ5CHWO <8:XE;V­<\HY7;:ePC<\5C: 1 O¸<\?B7h�GO;?BO ?BP6_¢LNP�ML��ÃZ 5C?�46ReR 2%1 ?|<8<\?F5^<\9Ò46E!s!SU> âjþÉ�������.0|{|{YC/����?1@�^��.0/ ô ã���4��|% r f q@�b�0�4� m�qC�

i��-r0l � H¸HWRe? f ª{��46E;7�,%�Ãs!4KE;7;?BR 1 46O;D � q6oWo¸mO�#"(O ?BO;?F:XE;V·D%H�7;?FRXP(H6J¢_�46ReRÉ_B?FEG<8?B5CP6_c4KE/:eEG<858HB�7;O;_|<\:XH6E����Ò58?F?'b�E;:ed6?B5CP8:e< 26f ,ÐDYPC<8?B587;46D��

i��bkBl � H¸HWRe? f ª'�¢s��¢46E;7¯���F$M46Re:XD � q6oWoWob��S��¸AÓHWE;?BE-<8:Q46R�46A;A;5CH>� :eD¹4§<\:XH6E$HKJ(DcO;R=<\:��ÎP8kG:XReR³_B46RXR_B?FEG<8?B5CPÐ465C_`9;:e<8?B_|<\O;5C?@� ó� *.������?¼@�A/+Z0q.�Ý$��ö%�vþ��û'&�&�&§f LNRXkGRX? 2Wf b ��f qB� f m��\mpo��

i��b�Bl Q 4658PCHWE f ]I� a � � m��bk-r@�(&Ñ?F58P8AÓ?B_|<\:=dW?BP®HWE©�GO;?FO;?BP�_(P8H�_B:Q4KR NCO;P <\:X_F?�46E;7+<89;?­A;P 2 _`9;H6RXHWV 2 H6J�GO;?BO;?F:XE;V�� ø=È��� ?1@�^��.0/�I *����?1@ *��[ kb�-tO�4�Wo-tC�

i¦�-oBl Q ?Fd 2Wf iq� f �Â�W>@O;5C:XE;Hpd�:X_��#�6HW9 58:G46E;7�]I�O,%�Ws�:XRe:e<\H � m��b�@�;�T> 2 EÒ46DY:X_jE;?F<Nh¢HW5Ckw_�4KRXRG7;:XP <\5C: 1 OC�<\:eHWE�hI:=<\9+AÓ?B5C:XH�7;:X_®O;AÓ7Ò4K<\?FP6� ó� *.������?¼@�A/+Z0'.�Ýq�A[��v÷�.0Y+ ��4����/��A[h]�/��4�� �/É1@�!��.0/É1@�3þÉ������! f1fÞ´�ò .0/+Z@ *������];þ ò \����Òf SÉRXP8?|d�:X?B5 f ,ÐDYPC<8?B587;46D f k-tO���B�)�

i¦�;m6lws!46E;7 ?BR 1 46O;D f ,v� � q6o6o mO� a 46ReR a ?BE-<\?F58P � a ?BE-<858?BP*��_!]�?FP8?�4K58_`9 1 : 1 Re:XHWVW5846A;9 2 hI:e<\9�4 1 �PC<85\46_|<\P6� �l46_FO;Re< 2 H6JÑLNE;7;O;P <\58:X46RTSÉE;VW:eE;?B?F58:XE V%4KE;7�s!46EÒ46V6?BDY?BE-< f $^9;?�$Ã?B_`9;E;:eHWE f n�46:eJ�4��

i¦�Gq0lws!46E;7 ?BR 1 46O;D f ,%� f 3Ê��,v�Ts!46PCP8? 2 46E;7¾s��ÊL���]�?F:XD%46E � m��b�bkb����<\5CHWE;V²46A A;58H>�¸:XD%4K<\:eHWE;PJ�HW5�s!465Ck6Hpd�:Q46E·P8?F5Cd�:X_F?�E;?F<Nh¢HW58kGP�� �tY���Y ���A/+Z ô ãO��4��|% �Wo f m>���0��q6o mb�

i¦���Blws!46E;7 ?BR 1 46O;D f ,v� f 3Ê�7,v�js!46P8PC? 26f s��ÉL��É]I?B:eD¹4KE f E(�É]I:X7;?F5�46E;7¾,%�F�G<\HWR 2 465 � q6oWoWo��"@O;?BO;?�RX?FE;V6<\9)46E;7)h³46:=<\:XE V/<\:eD%?FPYJ�H65%DcO Re<\:eP8?F5CdW?F5z�GO;?FO;?BP�hI:=<\9)4 1 46E;7 HWE;DY?BE-<\P�4KE;758?|<\58:X46RXP�� ó� *.������?¼@�A/+Z0h.�Ý��A[��( @�¸[j]�öD÷3ø�ùpõ ô þÉ�������.0|{|{YC/����?1@�^��.0/� ò .0/>Ý>�� ���/����|f E³H¸_B4]�4§<\HWE f � Q �

i¦�b�@lws!46E;7 ?BR 1 46O;D f ,v� f 3Ê�Â,v�Ïs�46P8PC? 2Wf s��[L��[]I?B:XD%46E�46E;7©Eg�Ê]I:X7;?F5 � m��b�b�b�p$^:eD%?�dK465 2 :XE VDcO;R=<\:XPC?B5 dW?B5D�GO;?BO ?BPÐhI:=<\9+4 1 46E;7;H6E;D%?FE-<\P@4KE;7!5C?F<\5C:Q46ReP6� ó� *.������?¼@�A/+Z0{.�Ý%�A[��)�+ü0�¸[�]�/����� �\/É1@�!��.0/É1@��þÂ������^ ?1fÞ´� ò .0/+Z@ ����|f &=� � ? 2 4KE;7!>q���¸D%:=<\9 � ?B7;P��m���

i¦�Gt0lws!46E;7 ?BR 1 46O;D f ,%�;46E;7�ª'��&M4K<8P � m��b�Wtb�-��<\4K<\?��N7;?FA[?FE;7;?FEG<g�GO;?BO ?BP6_¢46A;A 58H>�¸:XD%4K<\:eHWE;PÇ4KE;746A;A;Re:X_B4K<\:eHWE;P6�£ô �4.���[�10��!���vöv���*�-.0 *¹�|f L s�,LVUHWRXO D%?FPÐ:XE¾s�4K<\9;?FD¹4§<\:X_FP�46E;7¿:=<\PH,ÐA A;RX:e_�40�<\:eHWE;P f �-��&=� � ?FRXR 2 46E;7�]I� ���;3 :XReRX:Q4KD%P f ?F7;P6� f �¸A;5C:XE;V6?B5 flg ?Fh�ijHW58k f q@�b�O� q@k-q+�

i¦���Blws!46E;7 ?BR 1 46O;D f ,v�;46E;7·sÁ� L��Ò]I?B:eD¹46E � m��@�bk��³Z@E�AÓH�HWRX:eE;Vw:eE��GO;?BO;?F:XE;V­E ?F<Nh¢HW58kGP6� õ©1@/�\1�Z+��|}��/�� ô ������/���� �@� f �-r¸m����bk m@�

qWt

Page 28: uwv[xzy|{F} ~py - Columbia Universityww2040/full.pdf · uwv[xzy|{F} ~py Q ` G N N ` 8 C | U C ` \ j = U ' \ = z \ p z N - \ z ¢¡G F£6 ¥¤ ¥ -¦ p Y = § N ` Q p \

i¦�Gr0lws!46E;7 ?BR 1 46O;D f ,%� f � 46kKH�d f ,%�646E;7z�Â�;§Ê?FRe< 2 E � qKoWo mO�ÃSUDYA;:e58:X_B46R¸46EÒ46R 2 PC:XP±HKJÊ4@_B46RXR�_B?FE-<\?B5��$^9;?I$Ñ?F_`9;E;:eHWE f nÐ4K:eJ�4 f LNPC5\46?FR��

i¦��kBlws!46E;7 ?BR 1 46O;D f ,%�l46E;7 g �Â�¸9;:eD%kG:eE � q6oWo6o��t, DYH�7;?BRÏJ�HW5I584K<\:eHWEÒ46R�4 1 46E;7;H6E;D%?FE-<\PIJ�58HWD:XE-d�:XPC: 1 Re?(�GO;?BO ?BP6� �tY���Y ���A/+Z ô ã���4��|% �b� f m>�;m��\m�r@���

i¦���Blws!46PCP8? 26f 3Ê��,v� f ª{��,v�)&Ñ4658kK?B5�46E;7�3Ê��3 9;:e<C< � m��@�b���¢SÉP <\:XD%4K<8:XE;V®<\9;?@A;465\46DY?F<8?B5CP^H6JÃ4E;HWE;9 HWD%H6VW?BE;?FHWO;P-&ÑHW:eP8P8H6E�A;58H�_B?FP8P³hI:=<\9¹4wRX:eE;?�465U584K<\?B� þÉ�������.0|{|{YC/����?1@�^��.0/ ô ãO��4��|% t f�b� m��4�bkbk��

i t6oBlws!46PCP8? 26f 3Ê��,v�Ï46E;7+3Ê�Ó3 9;:e<C< � m>�b�b��� g ?|<Nh³HW5CkGP®HKJ¢:eE�JÒE;:=<\?��NP8?F5Cd6?B5��GO;?FO;?BP(hI:e<89+E;HWE+�PC<\4K<\:eHWEÒ465 2 &ÃHW:XPCP8HWE·:XE;A O <>� �tY���Y ���A/+Z ô ãO��4��|% m>� f m�kb�O� qWt6oC�

i t¸m6lws!46PCP8? 26f 3Ê�0,%�K46E;7w3Ê�p3 9;:=<8< � m��b�Wrb�£&Ñ?�4Kk'_FHWE;VW?FPC<\:eHWEc:eE'DcO Re<\:K�NPC?B5Cd6?B5ÃP8?F5Cd�:X_F?³P 2 P <\?BDYPhI:e<89·PCRXHphIR 2 dK465 2 :XE V%4K5858:=dK46RÊ584K<\?FP6� �tY���Y ���A/+Z ô ã���4��|% qWt f m�tWrO�\m�rWqC�

i tWq0lws�:XRe:e<8H f ]I�5,%� f iq� Q ?|d 2 46E;7.i{�5,Ð5C:Q46E � m��b� mO�c> 2 EÒ4KD%:e_�46RXV6HW58:=<\9;DYP'J�HW5­7 :XPC<858: 1 O <\?F7�GO;?BO;?FP�hI:=<\9+4 1 46E;7;H6E;D%?FE-<\P6� ó� *.������?¼@�A/+Z0q.�Ý��¸[��hþ�[+�A �������/��A[�]�/��4�� �/É1@�!��.0/É1@�tþÉ������! f1fÞ´�ò .0/+Z@ *���|f;g H65C<\9+��n�H6RXRQ4KE;7 f ,ÐDYPC<\?F587Ò4KD f �Wq@�0���@�@�)�

i t@�Blws�:e<?�B?FE;D¹4K_`9;?B5 f s�� � m��@�b��� þ�[��vóp.+�-�� {.�Ý�þ,�-. ò [�.0������v�A/�ùt1@/ɼ+.0| X .61�¼-�g1@��1@/����A/+Z6f&É9��l>q�;7;:eP8P8?F5C<\4K<\:eHWE f b�E;:ed6?B58PC:e< 2 HKJ a 46Re:eJ�HW5CE;:Q4w4K<DE³?B5Ck6?FRX? 2 �

i tB�@lws�:e<?�B?FE;D¹4K_`9;?B5 f s�� � m��b�-rb�Hn�H�hÖO;P8?|J�O;R¢:eP�HWRX7¾:XE J�H658D%4K<\:eHWE âÊó� *.������?¼@�A/+Z0Ë.�Ý'�¸[��-�+ü0�A[ý ò õ ô ãB|(È�.���AY+|ä.0/ ó� ��A/����aÈÉ���q.�Ý � ���^ ��^»6YC�4�?¼ ò .0|(ÈÉYC�^�A/+Z6f kb�O��� mb�

i tWt0lws�:e<?�B?FE;D¹4K_`9;?B5 f s���46E 7}E(��V{ÍHW_`kG:XE;V � m��b�@����$^9;?@4KP 2 D%A¸<\H6<8:X_BPUH6JÏP8?BRe?B_|<\:XE V®<89;?�PC9;HW5 <\?BP <H6J�<Nh¢H f :XDYA;5CH�d6?B7�� ó� �.������?¼@�A/+Z0�.�Ý��A[�������vý(�A��� ���.0/ ò .0/>Ý>�� ���/�����.0/ ò .0|{|{Y+/����?1@�^��.0/'�ò .0/��! *.0��1@/ɼ ò .0|(ÈÉYC�^�A/+Z6f b�E :edW?F58PC:e< 2 H6JMLNRXRe:XE;HW:eP6�

i t@�Blv&Ñ?F585 26f s��Ã46E;7�,%� g :eRXP8PCHWE � m��b�Wqb�H&Ñ?B5 J�HW58D%46E;_F?¹DYH¸7 ?BRX:eE;V�H6JI4KO <\HWD%4K<8:X_­_�4KRXRU7;:XP <\5C: 1 �O <\H658P6_¾46PCP8:eVWEÒ4 1 Re?�V65\467;?!H6J(P8?F5Cd�:X_F?¿PC<\4BeYE;V)� ó� *.������?¼@�A/+Z0©.�Ýh�¸[��.�����A[¨]�/����� �/É1@�^��.0/É1@�ô �5�A����[+�A/+Z ô ãB|(È�.���AY+|­f q@�B�B� q@�@k��

i tWr0lv&ÉO;9Ò46ReP8kG:X: f ,%�¢46E;7 sÁ�³L��¢]�?F:XD%46E � q6oWoWob�'$^9;?!DcO;Re<8:X_FRQ46PCP}ÎIÏC®@×vØ}®�/ ��O ?BO;?+:eE)<\9 ?nÐ46R�JÒEC�¶3 9;:e<C<Ç58?FVW:XDY?@� ýg¼@�01@/�����I�A/ËýtÈ�ÈÉ�º���?¼±ó� *.@»�1�»6�A�º�A�!ã �-q f t@�B�B� t@�WtC�

q@�

Page 29: uwv[xzy|{F} ~py - Columbia Universityww2040/full.pdf · uwv[xzy|{F} ~py Q ` G N N ` 8 C | U C ` \ j = U ' \ = z \ p z N - \ z ¢¡G F£6 ¥¤ ¥ -¦ p Y = § N ` Q p \

i t@kBl%� 46DcO ?BRXPCHWE f >q�",%� � m>�b�b���'&É58?B7 :X_F<8:ed6?+7;:Q4KRX:XE V�J�H65¹HWO < 1 H6O;E;7)<8?BRX?FA;9;HWE ?+_�46ReRI_B?BE-<8?B58P��]�/��4�� AÝ�1+���� qB� f �b�0�4k mb�

i t@�Bl%�¸?BVW46R f s�� � m>�-rB�;�p$^9;?­HWAÓ?B5\4§<\HW5��NP8_`9 ?B7;O;Re:XE;V¹A;58H 1 RX?BDh_�4�E;?F<Nh¢HW58kb��~ÒHphì46A;A 58H-46_`9�� ø=ÈÉ\�� f1@�!��.0/��ùp����?1@ *��[ qWq f kWo@k0��k-qB���

i��WoBl%�¸DY:e<\9 f >q�W]I�W4KE;7c3Ê�63 9;:=<8< � m��bk m��M]�?FP8HWO 58_B?^PC9Ò465C:XE;V@J�HW5M?�eY_B:e?BE;_ 2 :XEc<85\4BeY_ÇP 2 PC<\?FD%P�������A� ô ã������| þÂ����[+/����?1@� ú .0Y+ �/É1@� �Wo f �b�0� t6tC�

i�� m6l%�¸58:ek§46E-< f ]I�¸4KE;7Y3Ê�-3 9;:=<8< � m>�b�b���5�¸:eDcO;RX4K<\:eHWEc58O E¹RX?FE;V6<89;PÉ<\H®?BPC<8:XD%4K<\? 1 ReH¸_`kG:eE;V�A;58H 1 �4 1 :eRX:e<8:X?FP6� ý ò õ þ� f1@/�61+���!��.0/�v.0/ õ�.6¼+���º�A/+Z�1@/ɼ ò .0|(ÈÉYC�4�� ô �A|{YC��1@�^��.0/ � f rO� t6qC�

i��-q0l%�¸58:ek§46E-< f ]I�Ò46E;7²3Ê�;3 9;:=<8< � m>�b�b���"Vj4K58:Q4KE;_B?�58?F7;O;_|<\:XH6E·:eE²P8:XDwO;RQ4K<8:XHWE P³H6JMRXHWPCP^D%H�7;?BReP6�ø=È��� f1@�!��.0/�gùD����?1@ *��[ �Gr f tKob�0� t6q@���

i��b�Bl%��<`4KE J�HW587 f >q��,%�T46E 7¾3Ê� � ��ª(5\46PCP8D%46E;E � qKoWoWo��(E¢:XRX:eE;VWOÒ4KRÑPC?B5Cd6?B5®_�46ReR±_B?FE-<\58?FP6� ý(/É1@�º\ãO���.�Ý ò .0|{|{Y+/����?1@�!��.0/¾öv���*�-.0 *¹��� ò 1@�A� ò ��/��^ *����hþ) f1fÞ´�h1@/ɼ©óp�� AÝ>.0 �|±1@/����|f >q�É]��s�_�>@H6EÒ46RX7�4KE;7¿�Â�É]I�ÉS3�7$ÑO 58E;?F5 � ?B7;P��m� f �M:e?BRe7;PcLNE;P <\:e<8O <\? a H6D%DcO E;:X_B4K<\:eHWE;P­qBk f $^9;?,ÐDY?B5C:X_�4KE·s!4K<\9��É�¸H¸_F:X?|< 2Wf &É58Hpd�:X7;?FE;_B? f ]�L f �¸m��4��kC�

i��@�@l%�C�B? f >q�Uiq� � m��bkB�;�',ä�GO;?BO;?F:XE;V�D%H�7;?BR^J�HW5Y<\?FRX?BA 9;HWE;?�HWA[?F5\4K<8HW5YPC<`40e%E V)� ø=È��� f1@�^��.0/�ùp����?1@ ���[ �-q f qWq@�0��qB�����

i��-t0l�$ÑO 58E;?F5 f �É��]��§S3� � m��b�@��� ùp���.0YC *���Fóp.�.0�º�A/+ZH�A/ ô �4.���[�10��!���Fö����0�-.0 *¹�|f &É9��ã>q��7;:eP8PC?B5C<\4K<\:eHWE fb�E;:=dW?F58P8:=< 2 H6J a 46D 1 5C:X7;V6?@�

i��b�Bl�$ÑO 58E;?F5 f �Â�Ó]��ÓS3� � m��@�bk��t$^9;?®?�d[?B_F<ÐH6J±:eE;_B5C?�46PC?B7�58HWO <8:XE;VY_`9;HW:e_B?®HWE!5C?BPCHWO;58_F?wAÓH¸H6RX:XE V)�ó� �.@»�1�»6�A�º�A�^ã'�A/©�¸[�����/+Z@�A/����� ��A/+Z}1@/ɼ{]�/>Ý>.0 �|±1@�!��.0/É1@� ô ������/����� mpq f mpob�O�`m�qB���

i��-r0l�$ÑO 58E;?F5 f �Â��]I��S3� � q6o6oWo��g,ÖNCHW:eE+<\9;?­PC9;HW5 <\?BP <���O ?BO;?YD%H�7;?FR±:XE¿9;?B4�d 2 <85\4BeY_B��ú .0YC �/É1@�.�ÝDý-È�ÈÉ�º���?¼'ó� �.@»�1�»6�A�º�A�^ã �-r f q¸m�qO��qWq@���

i��bkBlIVÐd6?B7;?FE;P8k§4 2 4 fWg �p>q� f ]�� Q ��>@H 1 58O P89;:eE'4KE;7��-�BL�� � 465CA[?FRXHpd�:X_`9 � m>�b�b���1"@O;?FO;?B:eE;V^P 2 P <\?BDYPhI:e<89�PC?BRX?F_F<8:XHWE·H6JM<89;?®P89;HW5 <\?FPC<�H6JM<Nh¢H}�GO;?FO;?BP�_^46E+4KP 2 D%A¸<\H6<8:X_�46A;A 58H-46_`9�� ó� *.@»6���|%��A/]�/>Ý>.0 �|±1@�^��.0/¿þ) f1@/��|{�����.0/ �-q f m�tO��qWrC�

qWr

Page 30: uwv[xzy|{F} ~py - Columbia Universityww2040/full.pdf · uwv[xzy|{F} ~py Q ` G N N ` 8 C | U C ` \ j = U ' \ = z \ p z N - \ z ¢¡G F£6 ¥¤ ¥ -¦ p Y = § N ` Q p \

i��b�Bl�3#4K:e<\? f ,%�Â��� � m>�b�b���{ò Y����.0|}�� *�ý( � ��A���A/+Z-�5�A�A[�132����4.0 �ã�1@/ɼ X �?1@���A/+Z-�5�A�¸[�1@/4�65�È���\ �����/����|f $Ã?BRX?F_BHWD«E³H¸H6k�P flg ?|h�ijHW58k �

i r6oBl�3�?F:XE 1 ?B58V f ,%� � q6oWo-qb�¢S7�Î_BHWDYDY?B58_F?(RXHpdW?�Re?F<8<8?B5��9-<8<\A�_m`b`�h^h^hI�a�ÒHW5 1 ?FP6� _BHWD}`§<\?F_`9;E;HWReHWV 2 `K?F_BHWDYD%?F58_F?�`Wq6o6o-qb`6o-q@`Wq6o�`6oWqWq6oKdK46Re?BE-<\:eE;?@� 9-<\DYR

i r¸m6l�3 9;:e<C< f 3Ê� � m��bkB�;�gn�?�4�d 2 �¶<\584BeY_%4KA;A;58H>�¸:XD%4K<8:XHWE;P�J�HW5@PC?B5Cd�:e_B?�P 2 PC<8?BDYP(hI:e<\9 1 RXH�_`k�:eE;V)�ývþ87{þ9�����A� X 1�»�.0 f1@�4.0 ������þÂ����[+/����?1@� ú .0Y+ �/É1@� �b� f �bkb�0��r6obk��

i rWq0l�3 9;:e<C< f 3Ê� � m>�bkb���±>@?F_B:X7 :XE;V(hI9;:e_`9z�GO;?FO;?�<8H3NCHW:eE�_ÃP8HWDY?�_FHWO;E-<\?F58?��;4KD%A;Re?BP�� ø=È��� f1@�^��.0/�ùp����?1@ ���[ �@� f tWtO�4�-qC�

i r@�Bl�3 9;:e<C< f 3Ê� � m��bkb�b��&ÉRQ4KE;E;:XE V��GO;?FO;?B:eE;V¿P8:eDcO;RQ4§<\:XH6E;P6� õ©1@/É1�Z+��|}��/�� ô ������/���� �-t f m��@�;m��m��b�b�C�

i rB�@l�3 9;:e<C< f 3Ê� � m>�b�-qb�Ïb�E;7;?B5CPC<\46E;7;:eE;V�<89;?¢?�eY_B:X?FE;_ 2 HKJ;DcO;R=<\:K�NP8?F5Cd6?B5�P8?F5Cd�:X_F?¢P 2 PC<\?FD%P�� õ©1@/�\1�Z+��|}��/�� ô ������/���� �@k f r6obkO� rWq@�C�

i rWt0l�3 9;:e<C< f 3Ê� � m>�b�b���t,ÐA A;58H>�¸:XD%4K<\:eHWE;PÇJ�HW5^<89;?qÎIÏC®@Î%®+: �GO;?BO ?@� ó� *.6¼@Y����!��.0/Á1@/ɼ©ø=È��� f1@\�!��.0/�(õj1@/É1�Z+��|}��/�� q f mWm>�B�\m�� mb�

i r@�Bl�3 9;:e<C< f 3Ê� � m��b�b�b�³LND%A;5CHpd¸:eE;V�P8?F5Cd�:X_F? 1-2 :XE¸J�HW58DY:XE;Vw_BO;P <\HWDY?B5CP�4 1 HWO¸<Ð4KEG<8:X_F:XAÒ4K<8?B7²7;?��RQ4 2 P6� õ©1@/É1�Z+��|}��/�� ô ������/���� �-t f m��-q�� q6o-r+�

i rWr0l�3 9;:e<C< f 3Ê� � m��b�@���t&É58?B7 :X_F<8:XE;V'�GO;?FO;?B:eE;V%7 ?BRQ4 2 P6� õ©1@/É1�Z+��|}��/�� ô ������/���� �Gt f k-r6oO��kbkbkC�

i r@kBl�3 9;:e<C< f 3Ê� � m>�b�b���Ã> 2 E;46D%:e_¢P <`4BeYE;V(:eE­4Ð<\?FRX?FA;9;HWE;?³_�46ReR¸_F?BE-<\?F5U46:XDY:XE;VI<\HÐ:XDYD%?F7;:Q4K<8?BR 246E;P h³?F5Ð46ReRÊ_B46RXReP6� ø=È��� f1@�^��.0/��ùp����?1@ *��[ X ���!�4�� * qB� f qKo-tO� q�m�qC�

i r@�Bl�3 9;:e<C< f 3Ê� � m��@�b����>@?B_BH6D%AÓHWP8:=<\:eHWE)4KA;A;58H>�¸:XD%4K<8:XHWE;P­J�HW5Y<\:eD%?��N7;?FA[?FE;7;?BE-<·s�4658kKH�d�:X46E�GO;?BO;?F:XE;VYE;?|<Nh³HW5CkGP6� ø=È��� f1@�!��.0/��ùp����?1@ *��[ X ���^���� * q0� f �-rO�\mpob���

i�kWoBl�3 9;:e<C< f 3Ê� � m>�b�b���"&M465 <\:e<8:XHWE :XE;V®_BO;P <\HWDY?B5CP^:XE-<\H­PC?B5 d¸:e_B?(VW5CHWO;A;P�� õ©1@/É1�Z+��|}��/�� ô ������/�����Gt f mptWr@�0�\m�t@�-qC�

i�k m6l�3 9;:e<C< f 3Ê� � m>�b�b���¿b�PC:XE;V�7;:9d[?B5C?BE-</58?BPCA[H6E;P8?��Î<\:eD%?�5C?6�GO;:X5C?BDY?BE-<\P¾<\H�P8DYH¸H6<89 <8:XDY?��dK465 2 :XE V­7;?BD%46E;7²J�HW5^P8?F5Cd�:X_F?@� ø=È��� f1@�!��.0/�(ùD����?1@ *��[ X ���^���� * qB� f m��\mpo��

q@k

Page 31: uwv[xzy|{F} ~py - Columbia Universityww2040/full.pdf · uwv[xzy|{F} ~py Q ` G N N ` 8 C | U C ` \ j = U ' \ = z \ p z N - \ z ¢¡G F£6 ¥¤ ¥ -¦ p Y = § N ` Q p \

i�k-q0l�3 9;:e<C< f 3Ê� � q6oWo m���n�Hph,DwO;Re<8:XP8?F5Cd6?B55�GO;?BO ?BP³PC_�46Re?ÇhI:e<89YV658HphI:XE;V�_FHWE;VW?FPC<\:eHWEC�Î7;?BAÓ?BE;7 ?BE-<7;?BD%46E;7�� ø=È��� f1@�!��.0/��ùp����?1@ *��[�f <8H%4KA;A[?B4656�� 9-<8<8A�_a`b`§h^h^hI� 58?BPC?�465C_`9�� 4K<8<6� _FHWD�`<;(h¢Hphg`K7;?BD%46E;7)�6E;H)� A[7¸J��

i�kb�Bl�3 9;:e<C< f 3Ê� � q6oWoWqb�gô ��.���[�10��^����\�ó� *.������ X �A|{�A�¸|f ��A;58:eE;VW?B5 fÒg ?|h�ijHW5CkÉ�

i�k@�@l�3 :XReRX:Q4KD%P f ]I�;��� � q6oWoWo��MZ(EY7 2 EÒ46DY:X_^PC_`9;?B7 O;RX:eE;V�H6JÏ4�AÒ465846RXRe?BR�P8?F5CdW?F5³P 2 P <\?FDÖhI:e<\9�_FHWD'�A;RX?|<\?�58?FP8HWO;5C_B?�A[H�HWRX:eE;V)� ý(/É1@�ºã���I.�Ý ò .0|{|{Y+/����?1@�^��.0/}öv���*�-.0 *¹��� ò 1@�A� ò ��/��! *����gþ) f1fÞ´�1@/ɼÁóp�� ¸Ý>.0 �|±1@/����|f >q�¢]I�Çs�_B>@HWEÒ46Re7,46E 7R�Â�³]I�¢Sp�"$ÃO;58E;?F5 � ?F7;P6�a� f �M:e?BRX7 P%LNE;P <\:=<\O <8?a HWDYDcO;E;:e_�4K<8:XHWE;PÇq@k f $^9 ?v,�D%?F58:X_B46E�s!4K<89�� �¸H�_B:e?F< 2Wf &É5CH�d�:e7;?BE;_F? f ]IL f ���0� r6qC�

i�k-t0l�3 :XE;P <\HWE f 3Ê� � m��-rWr@�(Z(A¸<\:XD%46Re:e< 2 H6J¢<\9;?�P89 HW5C<8?BPC<'RX:eE;?c7;:eP8_F:XA;Re:XE;?B�=ú .0YC �/É1@�-.�Ý�ý-È�ÈÉ�º���?¼ó� �.@»�1�»6�A�º�A�^ã m>� f m�k m��\m�kb���

i�kb�Bl%§ÊHW9Ò465 f S3� f ,%�ls�46E;7;?FR 1 46O D 46E;7 g ���¸9;:eD%kG:eE � q6oWo6o��",�7Ò46A <8:edW? 1 ?B9;4pd�:eHW5^H6JÃ:XDYAÒ4K<8:X?BE-<_BO;P <\HWDY?B5CPT:XE�<\?BRe?��2��O ?BO;?FP6_�<\9;?FHW5 2 4KE;7'?FD%A :X58:e_�46RKP8O;A A[HW5 <>�O$^9;?"$Ñ?F_`9;E;:eHWE f n�46:eJ�4 f LNP85\4K?BR��

q@�