"Unsatisfactory" StudentsFirstNY

Embed Size (px)

Citation preview

  • 7/30/2019 "Unsatisfactory" StudentsFirstNY

    1/32

    O

    JACQG

    NOKK

    QCD[

    _HUC[FUDCE[NQV=

    [lo Kfu{qfa{fnh nd [oceloq Scbf{vfh How Vnq` Ef{v

    U{koh{uDfqu{HV

  • 7/30/2019 "Unsatisfactory" StudentsFirstNY

    2/32

    O

    JACQG

    NOKK

    QCD[

    fu How Vnq`u bockfhg tnfeo dnq u{koh{u

    wln koyohk nh yabfe okec{fnh dnq

    {lo u`fbbu {lov hook {n ueeook" a{ wlncqo {nn nd{oh dcfbok av c uvu{oj {lc{

    y{u uyoefcb fh{oqou{u" qc{loq {lch {lo

    fh {o qo u { u n d el f bk qoh " d f q u { ( Wo

    aobfoto {lc{ {lo u{koh{u nd How Vnq`

    U{c{o chk How Vnq` Ef{v echhn{ wcf{

    nho jfh{o jnqo dnq ch ohk {n aqn`oh

    ynbfefou {lc{ u{chk fh {lo wcv ndohuqfhg c scbf{v {oceloq fh otoqv

    ebcuuqnnj chk ch ohk {n {fqok qlo{nqfe

    {lc{ uoqtou nhbv {n kobcv jochfhgdb

    df|ou {n {lo yqnaboju fh nq uelnnbu(

    Bocqh jnqo c{=

    www(U{koh{uDfqu{HV(nqg

    U{koh{uDfqu{HV

  • 7/30/2019 "Unsatisfactory" StudentsFirstNY

    3/32

    O

    JACQG

    NOKK

    QCD[_HUC[FUDCE[NQV=

    [lo Kfu{qfa{fnh nd [oceloq Scbf{vfh How Vnq` Ef{v

    Mchcqv 1935

  • 7/30/2019 "Unsatisfactory" StudentsFirstNY

    4/32

    O

    JACQG

    NOKK

    QCD[

    Enyvqfgl{ 1935 U{koh{uDfqu{HV

  • 7/30/2019 "Unsatisfactory" StudentsFirstNY

    5/32

    O

    JACQG

    NOKK

    QCD[

    [lo fjynq{cheo n lfglbv ooe{fto {oceloqu {n {lo bfo n{enjou n {lofq u{koh{u wcu ecu{ fh u{cq` qobfo av c

    Koeojaoq 1933 u{kv" [lo Bnhg*[oqj Fjyce{u nd [oceloqu" av Qcm Elo{{v chk Mnlh H( Dqfokjch n Lcqtcqk

    _hftoquf{v chk Mnhcl O( Qne`n n Enbjafc _hftoquf{v( [lofq chcbvufu nhk {lc{ u{koh{u cuufghok

    enhufu{oh{bv {n lfgloq scbf{v {oceloqu cqo jnqo bf`obv {n gn {n enbbogo" gn {n ao{{oq enbbogou" ocqh lfgloq ucbcqfou

    chk bfto fh jnqo coh{ hofglanqlnnku chk cqo bouu bf`obv {n lcto elfbkqoh cu {oohcgoqu(

    Wlfbo {lo elcbbohgou {lc{ u{koh{u ceo n{ufko n uelnnb ech eqoc{o ynwoqb nau{cebou {n ceckojfe ueeouu"

    {louo dhkfhgu kojnhu{qc{o {lo fjynq{cheo n lfglbv ooe{fto {ocelfhg fh chv elfbku sou{ {n ntoqenjo {lnuo

    elcbbohgou( [lfu ulnbk uoqto cu c ebcqfnh ecbb nq uelnnbu {n yqntfko c scbf{v {oceloq {n otoqv u{koh{" chk gftou

    ycq{febcq qgohev {n {lo hook {n kn un fh {lo ebcuuqnnju n {lnuo u{koh{u nq wlnj c gqoc{ okec{fnh fu {lofq

    aou{ elcheo c{ {lo Cjoqfech kqocj(

    Lnw fu {oceloq scbf{v kfu{qfa{ok ceqnuu How Vnq` Ef{v yabfe uelnnbu> [lc{u {lo sou{fnh {lc{ U{koh{uDfqu{HV

    ungl{ {n chuwoq av chcbv}fhg {oceloq otcbc{fnh kc{c yqntfkok ,wf{ln{ fkoh{fvfhg fhnqjc{fnh& av {lo

    How Vnq` Ef{v Koycq{joh{ n Okec{fnh nq {lo 1933*1931 uelnnb vocq(3 Wo uo{ n{ {n ko{oqjfho wlo{loq

    {lo kfu{qfa{fnh n fhooe{fto {oceloqu" cu qoyqouoh{ok av {lo qobc{fto ow wln woqo qc{ok _huc{fuce{nqv"

    wcu qocunhcabv otoh ceqnuu cbb uelnnbu" nq wlo{loq f{ kfuyqnynq{fnhc{obv coe{ok eoq{cfh uelnnbu nq u{koh{

    ynybc{fnhu( ,Aobnw" wo tcqfnubv uo {lo {oqju _*qc{fhg chk _*qc{ok {oceloq nq ulnq{lchk(&

    _*qc{ok {oceloqu" mu{ 1(7

  • 7/30/2019 "Unsatisfactory" StudentsFirstNY

    6/32

    O

    JACQG

    NOKK

    QCD[

    Fh otoqv ecuo" nq dhkfhgu cbbnwok u {n qomoe{ c hbb lvyn{loufu {lc{ {loqo wcu hn kfoqoheo fh {lo yqotcboheo n

    _*qc{ok {oceloqu ao{wooh uelnnbu gqnyok ceenqkfhg {n yntoq{v" qceo nq u{koh{ celfotojoh{ botobu( Fhu{ock"

    wo nhk uyynq{ nq {lo hn{fnh {lc{ {oceloq {cboh{ fu kfu{qfa{ok fh c wcv {lc{ wo wnbk enhufkoq qogqouufto=

    YNTOQ[V= Uelnnbu wf{l {lo lfglou{ botobu n u{koh{ yntoq{v lck c kfuyqnynq{fnhc{obv lfgl

    hjaoq n _*qc{ok {oceloqu0

    QCEO= Uelnnbu wf{l {lo lfglou{ yoqeoh{cgou n u{koh{u n enbnq lck c kfuyqnynq{fnhc{obv

    lfgl hjaoq n _*qc{ok {oceloqu0

    OBOJOH[CQV CHK JFKKBO UELNNB U[_KOH[ CELFOTOJOH[= Obojoh{cqv uelnnbu

    chk jfkkbo uelnnbu wf{l {lo bnwou{ qc{ou n u{koh{ yqndefohev lck c kfuyqnynq{fnhc{obv lfgl

    hjaoq n _*qc{ok {oceloqu0 chk

    LFGL UELNNB U[_KOH[ CELFOTOJOH[= Lfgl uelnnbu wf{l {lo bnwou{ qc{ou n enbbogo

    qockfhouu lck c kfuyqnynq{fnhc{obv lfgl hjaoq n _*qc{ok {oceloqu(

    Fh n{loq wnqku= Ntoqcbb" u{koh{u wf{l {lo gqoc{ou{ hook nq nq aou{ okec{nqu cyyocq {n ao bocu{

    bf`obv {n lcto ceeouu {n {loj(

    Ch fhooe{fto {oceloq fh chv ebcuuqnnj fu c cfbqo n {lo uvu{oj c{ {lo o|yohuo n {lo elfbkqoh fh {lc{ ebcuuqnnj(

    Fhooe{fto {oceloqu fh jchv ebcuuqnnju fu c afg cfbqo( Chk enheoh{qc{fnhu n fhooe{fto {oceloqu uoqtfhg

    uyoefde u{koh{ ynybc{fnhu fu ch fhmu{feo( Wo lcto ch nabfgc{fnh {n u{koh{u {n uoo` qojokfou {n {louo

    yqnaboju" a{ How Vnq` Ef{v uelnnbu cqo tfq{cbbv ynwoqbouu {n kn un fh {lo eqqoh{ ynbfev ohtfqnhjoh{(

    [n elchgo {lfu ycqckfgj" wo qoenjjohk uotoqcb ynbfev ulf{u=

    Fjybojoh{ {lo U{c{ou jnqo qnau{ chk enjyqolohufto {oceloq otcbc{fnh uvu{oj0

    Jc`o f{ ocufoq nq {ny enbbogo gqckc{ou {n oh{oq {ocelfhg" chk yqntfko dhchefcb fheoh{ftou

    nq {loj {n kn un0

    Yqntfko ufghfdech{ ucbcqv fheqocuou {n lfglbv ooe{fto {oceloqu wln u{cv fh {lo ebcuuqnnju n

    lfgl*hooku uelnnbu0

    Ojynwoq yqfhefycbu cu jchcgoqu av qonqjfhg {lo n{jnkok U{c{o bcw {lc{ gqch{u {ohqo

    tfq{cbbv c{njc{fecbbv {n cbb {oceloqu c{oq {lqoo vocqu" wlfbo {lov cqo u{fbb bocqhfhg {lofq eqc{0

    Fjynuo c ecy nh lnw jchv fhooe{fto {oceloqu jcv ao cbbnwok {n qojcfh c{ chv nho uelnnb

    vocq c{oq vocq" qosfqo ycqoh{cb enhuoh{ nq c u{koh{ {n ao {cgl{ av ch fhooe{fto {oceloq" chk

    yqnlfaf{ uelnnbu qnj cuufghfhg {n {lo ebcuu n ch fhooe{fto {oceloq chv u{koh{ {cgl{ av ch

    fhooe{fto {oceloq fh {lo yqotfnu vocq0

    Qosfqo chhcb qoynq{fhg av {lo How Vnq` Ef{v Koycq{joh{ n Okec{fnh nh {lo kfu{qfa{fnh n

    {oceloq scbf{v ceqnuu uelnnbu chk u{koh{ ynybc{fnhu0

    Lnbk yqfhefycbu chk uelnnbu ceenh{cabo nq qfgnqnu fjybojoh{c{fnh n {lo how otcbc{fnh

    uvu{oj0 chk

    Enh{fho {n o|ychk lfgl*scbf{v uelnnb ny{fnhu nq cjfbfou" chk qojnto ckkqouu*kqftoh

    qou{qfe{fnhu {lc{ uogqogc{o chk enhufgh u{koh{u {n fhoqfnq uelnnbu(

    1 r _HUC[FUDCE[NQV= [LO KFU[QFA_[FNH ND [OCELOQ S_CBF[V FH HOW VNQ@ EF[V

  • 7/30/2019 "Unsatisfactory" StudentsFirstNY

    7/32

    O

    JACQG

    NOKK

    QCD[

    @OV DFHKFHGU

  • 7/30/2019 "Unsatisfactory" StudentsFirstNY

    8/32

    O

    JACQG

    NOKK

    QCD[

    Nq chcbvufu n uelnnbu acuok nh {lo yoqeoh{cgo n

    u{koh{u qoeoftfhg Dqoo chk Qokeok Yqfeo Bhel

    ,DQYB& nhk {lc{ Bnw Yntoq{v uelnnbu ,Joch DQYB

    Yoqeoh{cgo n 16(;?/& lck c Joch _*Qc{fhg Qc{o

    n 3(3;/0 Jokfj Yntoq{v uelnnbu ,Joch DQYB

    Yoqeoh{cgo n 4;(7

  • 7/30/2019 "Unsatisfactory" StudentsFirstNY

    9/32

    O

    JACQG

    NOKK

    QCD[

    BNWYNTOQ[VUELNNBU

    JOKF_JYNTOQ[VUELNNBU

    LFGLYNTOQ[VUELNNBU

    ;;(

  • 7/30/2019 "Unsatisfactory" StudentsFirstNY

    10/32

    O

    JACQG

    NOKK

    QCD[

    7;(;?/

    KOJNGQCYLFE CHCBVUFU= Gqnyfhgu nd Uelnnbu

    av Yoqeoh{cgo nd U{koh{u wln cqo Abce` nq Lfuychfe

    YOQEOH[ ND CBB [OCELOQU

    AV KOJNGQCYLFE GQN_Y

    YOQEOH[ ND _*QC[OK [OCELOQU

    AV KOJNGQCYLFE GQN_Y

    11(;

  • 7/30/2019 "Unsatisfactory" StudentsFirstNY

    11/32

    O

    JACQG

    NOKK

    QCD[

    BNWYOQEOH[CGOU[_KOH[UND ENBNQ

    JOKF_JYOQEOH[CGOU[_KOH[UND ENBNQ

    LFGLYOQEOH[CGOU[_KOH[UND ENBNQ

    ??(?3/

    Joch chk Gqny

    Yoqeoh{cgou nd _*Qc{ok

    [oceloqu fh Uelnnbu

    av Kojngqcylfe Gqny

    JOCH_*QC[FHG QC[O,Ctoqcgo nd ocel

    uelnnbu yoqeoh{cgo&

    GQN_Y_*QC[FHG QC[O,Cggqogc{o yoqeoh{cgond {lo gqny&

    3(94/

    3(66/

    ;(35/

    3(3?/

    1(97/

    5(75/

    BNW / U[_KOH[UND ENBNQ

    JOKF_J / U[_KOH[UND ENBNQ

    LFGL / U[_KOH[UND ENBNQ

    [lo qoub{u n {lo CHNTC {ou{" {lo Wobel {ou{ chk

    {lo Aqnwh*Dnquv{lo cbb ulnwok u{c{fu{fecbbv ufghfdech{

    qoub{u c{ {lo y:(9? botob( [lu" {lo hbb lvyn{loufu

    ech ao qomoe{ok( Jnqontoq" {lo Gcjou*Lnwobb ynu{

    lne {ou{ nhk c u{c{fu{fecbbv ufghfdech{ kfoqoheo

    ao{wooh ocel ycfq n gqnyu c{ {lo y:(9? botob(

    Fh qocb {oqju" {lo gqny n uelnnbu wf{l {lo bnwou{

    yoqeoh{cgo n abce` chk Lfuychfe u{koh{u"

    enjyqfufhg 11(

  • 7/30/2019 "Unsatisfactory" StudentsFirstNY

    12/32

    O

    JACQG

    NOKK

    QCD[

    CELFOTOJOH[ CHCBVUFU= Gqnyfhgu nd Obojoh{cqv

    Uelnnbu Av Yqndfefohev nh ;{l Gqcko Jc{l O|cj

    YOQEOH[ ND CBB [OCELOQU

    AV YQNDFEFOHEV GQN_Y

    YOQEOH[ ND _*QC[OK [OCELOQU

    AV YQNDFEFOHEV GQN_Y

    ;7(??/

    17(;7/ ?3(37/

    Obojoh{cqv Uelnnbu

    Lfgl Yqnfefohev obojoh{cqv uelnnbu ,Joch

    Yqnfefohev Yoqeoh{cgo n

  • 7/30/2019 "Unsatisfactory" StudentsFirstNY

    13/32

    O

    JACQG

    NOKK

    QCD[

    LFGLYQNDFEFOHEVUELNNBU

    JOKF_JYQNDFEFOHEVUELNNBU

    BNWYQNDFEFOHEVUELNNBU

    39(37/

    13(5?/

    ;1(1

  • 7/30/2019 "Unsatisfactory" StudentsFirstNY

    14/32

    O

    JACQG

    NOKK

    QCD[

    CELFOTOJOH[ CHCBVUFU= Gqnyfhgu nd Jfkkbo

    Uelnnbu Av Yqndfefohev nh

  • 7/30/2019 "Unsatisfactory" StudentsFirstNY

    15/32

    O

    JACQG

    NOKK

    QCD[

    LFGLYQNDFEFOHEVUELNNBU

    JOKF_JYQNDFEFOHEVUELNNBU

    BNWYQNDFEFOHEVUELNNBU

    3

  • 7/30/2019 "Unsatisfactory" StudentsFirstNY

    16/32

    O

    JACQG

    NOKK

    QCD[

    71(??/

    CELFOTOJOH[ CHCBVUFU= Gqnyfhgu

    nd Lfgl Uelnnbu Av Enbbogo Qockfhouu

    YOQEOH[ ND CBB [OCELOQU

    AV ENBBOGO QOCKFHOUU GQN_Y

    YOQEOH[ ND _*QC[OK [OCELOQU

    AV ENBBOGO QOCKFHOUU GQN_Y

    6(39/

    ;(66/

    51(9?/

    11(;4/

    Lfgl Uelnnbu

    Lfgl Enbbogo Qockfhouu uelnnbu ,Joch Enbbogo

    Qockfhouu Qc{o n

  • 7/30/2019 "Unsatisfactory" StudentsFirstNY

    17/32

    O

    JACQG

    NOKK

    QCD[

    LFGLENBBOGOQOCKFHOUUUELNNBU

    JOKF_JENBBOGOQOCKFHOUUUELNNBU

    BNWENBBOGOQOCKFHOUUUELNNBU

    ?

  • 7/30/2019 "Unsatisfactory" StudentsFirstNY

    18/32

    O

    JACQG

    NOKK

    QCD[

    ENHEB_UFNH CHKQOENJJOHKC[FNHU

    Acuok nh {lo dhkfhgu n {lfu u{kv" {lo kfu{qfa{fnh n {oceloqu wf{l _huc{fuce{nqv qc{fhgu fu" fh nq tfow"

    hkcjoh{cbbv qogqouufto( Uelnnbu wf{l {lo lfglou{ qc{ou n yntoq{v chk {lo bnwou{ qc{ou n u{koh{

    celfotojoh{ lcto uau{ch{fcbbv jnqo {lch {lofq cfq ulcqo n {oceloqu wf{l _huc{fuce{nqv qc{fhgu" cu kn

    uelnnbu wf{l lfgl enheoh{qc{fnhu n u{koh{u n enbnq( Enhtoquobv" wocb{lfoq" lfgloq*celfotfhg uelnnbu lcto

    owoq _*qc{ok {oceloqu(

    Wf{l mu{ 5/ n How Vnq` Ef{v {oceloqu qoeoftfhg _*qc{fhgu" {lo kfuycqf{fou fkoh{fdok fh {lfu qoynq{ {qchubc{o fh{nqobc{ftobv ujcbb kfoqoheou fh qcw hjaoqu( A{ f _*qc{fhgu cqo {lo {fy n {lo {oceloq scbf{v feoaoqg" {loh {lo

    fhefkoheo n _*qc{ok {oceloqu c{ lfgl*yntoq{v uelnnbu" nq o|cjybo" c{ c qc{o jnqo {lch {lqoo {fjou {lo qc{o c{

    bnw*yntoq{v uelnnbu jcv fhkfec{o c aqnckoq fhosf{v {lc{ lcqju jchv How Vnq` Ef{v uelnnbelfbkqoh ocel vocq(

    [lo uenyo n {lo yqnaboj fu fjynuufabo {n cuuouu wf{l {lo kc{c wo lcto" a{ {lc{ ulnbk hn{ ao hoeouucqv

    {n cgqoo ynh f{u hcfqhouu {n elfbkqoh chk fjybojoh{ unb{fnhu( Chk {n {lo o|{oh{ {lc{ tcqfc{fnh fh {lo

  • 7/30/2019 "Unsatisfactory" StudentsFirstNY

    19/32

    O

    JACQG

    NOKK

    QCD[

    Uelnnbu wf{l {lo Lfglou{ Yoqeoh{cgou

    nd _huc{fudce{nqv [oceloqu"

    Ceqnuu {lo Dfto Anqnglu

    %

    %

    %

    %

    %

    %

    %

    %

    %

    %

    %%

    %

    %%

    %%

    %

    %

    %

    %%

    %

    %

    %

    %

    %

    %

    %

    %

    %%

    %

    %%

    %%

    %

    %

    %%

    %%

    %

    %

    %

    %

    %

    %

    %

    %

    %

    %

    %%%

    %

    %

    %

    %

    %

    %

    %%

    %

    %

    %

    %%

    %

    %

    %

    %

    %

    %

    %

    %

    9*19/

    13*;9/

    ;3*49/

    43*

  • 7/30/2019 "Unsatisfactory" StudentsFirstNY

    20/32

    O

    JACQG

    NOKK

    QCD[

    Cbcqjfhgbv" {lo elcqce{oqfu{feu n {louo uelnnbu hkoquenqo {lo dhkfhgu n nq u{kv( Wlfbo abce` chk Lfuychfe

    u{koh{u jc`o y 4

  • 7/30/2019 "Unsatisfactory" StudentsFirstNY

    21/32

    O

    JACQG

    NOKK

    QCD[

    A{ hnho n {lfu lcu enjo {n ycuu0 n {lo bfu{ n ojybnvjoh{ koefufnhu" nhbv {oqjfhc{fnh wfbb ao coe{ok av

    fjybojoh{c{fnh n {lo how otcbc{fnh uvu{oj( How Vnq` Ef{v uelnnbu kn hn{ {cqgo{ qounqeou {n qoeqf{ lfglbv

    ooe{fto {oceloqu" {n qo{cfh {loj" nq {n kfu{qfa{o {loj fh c yqngqouufto wcv( Wlfbo {lo Ef{v yqnynuok uau{ch{fcb

    ucbcqv fheqocuou nq lfglbv ooe{fto {oceloqu" {lo fkoc wcu koebcqok kock nh cqqftcb av {lo {oceloqu hfnh" wlnuo

    cgqoojoh{ fu hoeouucqv hkoq {lo U{c{o bcw( [lo uelnnb uvu{oj n Howcq`" av enh{qcu{" mu{ cyyqntok c how

    enbboe{fto acqgcfhfhg cgqoojoh{ {lc{ neuou nh {louo fjyoqc{ftou av {vfhg cbb ucbcqv fheqocuou {n {oceloq scbf{v

    chk yqntfkfhg uau{ch{fcb anhuou {n lfglbv ooe{fto {oceloqu fh lfgl*hooku uelnnbu chk lcqk*{n*u{c uamoe{u(

    C{ {lo ucjo {fjo" {loqo cqo hc{qcb fheoh{ftou kqftfhg c qogqouufto kfu{qfa{fnh n {oceloq {cboh{= Coh{ uelnnbu

    wloqo u{koh{u oh{oq {lo ebcuuqnnj wf{l owoq o|{oqhcb elcbbohgou cqo cq jnqo c{{qce{fto ybceou {n wnq` nq

    jnu{ {oceloqu" chk wo uuyoe{ {lc{" cu c qoub{" {louo uelnnbu wfhk y wf{l c lfgloq scbf{v ynnb n cyybfech{u nq

    ocel {ocelfhg tcechev(5 U{qnhg fheoh{ftou" neuok nh nq aou{ okec{nqu" cqo hoeouucqv {n nuo{ {lfu ooe{(

    QOENJJOHKC[FNH %1= Yqntfko fhchefcb fheoh{ftou {n ohenqcgo

    {ny enbbogo gqckc{ou {n oh{oq {lo {ocelfhg yqnouufnh" chk ocuo {lo

    qogbc{nqv nau{cebou {lc{ u{chk fh {lofq wcv(

    QOENJJOHKC[FNH %5= Enhufu{oh{ wf{l U{c{o bcw" yqntfko ufghffech{

    ucbcqv fheqocuou {n lfglbv ooe{fto {oceloqu wln u{cv fh {lo ebcuuqnnju

    n lfgl*hooku uelnnbu(

    Cbun" How Vnq` Ef{v yqfhefycbu lcto ow {nnbu chk bf{{bo jchcgojoh{ c{lnqf{v {n ckkqouu {oceloq scbf{v

    kodefohefou nheo {lov lcto {c`oh qnn{ fh uelnnbu( Wlfbo {lo Ef{vu Koycq{joh{ n Okec{fnh lcu gnho {n gqoc{

    bohg{lu {n wnq` cqnhk c U{c{o bcw {lc{ cwcqku {ohqo tfq{cbbv c{njc{fecbbv ,{n cbb yoqunhu wln lcto aooh

    nhk enjyo{oh{" odefoh{ chk uc{fuce{nqv&" {lc{ bcw qojcfhu ch ohnqjnu lchkfecy {n {lo wnq` n yqfhefycbu

    cu jchcgoqu n {cboh{" uau{ch{fcbbv oqnkfhg c{lnqf{v {lc{ fu ch fh{qfhufe ycq{ n cbjnu{ cbb qobc{fnhulfyu ao{woohjchcgoqu chk {lofq u{cu fh yqnouufnhcb uo{{fhgu(

    Chk" n enquo" {lo kfdeb{v n qojntfhg fhooe{fto {oceloqu" nheo {lov cqo fh {lo ebcuuqnnj chk {ohqok" lcu

    aooh wobb ou{cabfulok( [loqo fu unjo lnyo {lc{ {lo how otcbc{fnh uvu{oj wfbb yqntfko qobfo {lqngl c bnwoq

    u{chkcqk nq {oqjfhc{fnh acuok nh fhenjyo{oheo" a{ {lc{ u{chkcqk cyybfou nhbv c{oq {oceloqu lcto uyoh{ {wn

    vocqu fhooe{ftobv okec{fhg elfbkqoh" chk uau{ch{fcb aqoceqc{fe an{{bohoe`u bnnj(

    QOENJJOHKC[FNH %;= Qoybceo {lo n{jnkok U{c{o bcw {lc{ gqch{u {ohqo

    tfq{cbbv c{njc{fecbbv c{oq mu{ {lqoo vocqu wf{l nho {lc{ ojylcuf}ou {lo

    qo{oh{fnh n lfglbv ooe{fto {oceloqu chk ojynwoqu yqfhefycbu {n jchcgochk fjyqnto {lo scbf{v n fhu{qe{fnh fh {lofq uelnnbu(

    QOENJJOHKC[FNH %?= Ohce{ ckkf{fnhcb qonqju fh U{c{o bcw chk

    enbboe{fto acqgcfhfhg cgqoojoh{u {n ohuqo {lc{ fhooe{fto {oceloqu kn

    hn{ qojcfh fh {lo ebcuuqnnj(

    C QOYN Q[ AV U[_KOH[ UDFQU [HV r 37

  • 7/30/2019 "Unsatisfactory" StudentsFirstNY

    22/32

    O

    JACQG

    NOKK

    QCD[

    [louo cqo {nnbu {lc{ wo aobfoto ech loby {lo uvu{oj chk fhkftfkcb yqfhefycbu jochfhgbbv ckkqouu {oceloq

    {cboh{ kodefohefou chk fhosf{fou( A{ jocuqou ulnbk cbun ao y{ fh ybceo cu ace`u{nyu {n yqn{oe{ u{koh{u

    chk ohuqo {lc{ {lo {nnbu ce{cbbv yqnkeo qoub{u(

    QOENJJOHKC[FNH %4= Qosfqo ycqoh{cb enhuoh{ nq chv elfbk {n aocuufghok {n {lo ebcuu n ch fhooe{fto {oceloq" chk yqnlfaf{ uelnnbu

    qnj cuufghfhg {n {lo ebcuu n ch fhooe{fto {oceloq chv u{koh{ {cgl{

    av ch fhooe{fto {oceloq {lo yqotfnu vocq(

    QOENJJOHKC[FNH %7= Qosfqo chhcb qoynq{fhg av {lo How Vnq` Ef{v

    Koycq{joh{ n Okec{fnh nh {lo kfu{qfa{fnh n {oceloq scbf{v ceqnuu

    uelnnbu chk u{koh{ ynybc{fnhu(

    QOENJJOHKC[FNH %

  • 7/30/2019 "Unsatisfactory" StudentsFirstNY

    23/32

    O

    JACQG

    NOKK

    QCD[

    CYYOHKF\

  • 7/30/2019 "Unsatisfactory" StudentsFirstNY

    24/32

    O

    JACQG

    NOKK

    QCD[

    Chv chcbvufu n _huc{fuce{nqv tu(

    Uc{fuce{nqv qc{fhgu {n cuuouu yc{{oqhu chk

    qobc{fnhulfyu ju{ enhqnh{ chk unbto nq

    ch ohnqjnu cjnh{ n uelnnb*{n*uelnnb tcqfc{fnh

    fh {lo cuufghjoh{ n _*qc{ok {oceloqu( Fhkook" 7;