TNI 5 Spies

7/27/2019 TNI 5 Spies

1/127

7/27/2019 TNI 5 Spies

2/127

7/27/2019 TNI 5 Spies

3/127

7/27/2019 TNI 5 Spies

4/127

7/27/2019 TNI 5 Spies

5/127

7/27/2019 TNI 5 Spies

6/127

6

T Sc ShoppBy

Willie OSerWeil

inanv, ud, and dumb svc woksdamag h vau o h bosss poduc n

sub acs o psycho-soca saboag so pvasvha an n ndusy o mysy shopps

has spung up o comba

Whn w ak abou suvanc, w mak aconncon, amos auomacay, bwnsuvanc and cm, and anoh bwnsuvanc and chnoogy: T CCV cama

capung h maskd obb, h bank managmonong vy nch o hs vau o sgns o

, h NSA Uh, o so ndny a h daa ha avs acossAmcan ws and hough Amcan aspac.Whh J B 1984-,suvanc s hgh-ch and pocs h c.

7/27/2019 TNI 5 Spies

7/127

7

T v h ha, whn somon s o Jmy Bnhams, h h

h . A h F hv h Bh , h, h, ,hs a s oow a h om o h pson,

hh h h h .Wadns, howv, nd o wach psons muchss cosy han h capass ookng o squz

ou vy doa nd o wach hos a wok nh sos. As ong as woks a ocd o sm,poy g cusoms, and pon hm owad aspca da, capa w nd o snd ou mysyshopps o kp hm n n.

Mysy shopps spy n a sos, sauans,v h, , h, , ,

chuchs, docos ocs, pubc ans sysms,gas saons, mchancs shops, gyms, unahoms, unvss n sho, anywh hpubc s ad as a cusom. Makng msh mysy woshpps who pos as s-m conggans o vaua chuch cannss,ndnss, and godnss. Mnay hahy

h wh cauy compang h docos bhavoagans a chcks. las summ, a congssona

scuf ov h da govnmns pan o sndou dy mysy pans mad hadns, and

Willie osterWeil

7/27/2019 TNI 5 Spies

8/127

8

wh h masu umay ad, h U.S. hashpd Paksan dpoy mysy shopps n odo comba ax vason.

h v ,consum choc s had as cv by, and vysoca aonshp s undsood as a ansaconbwn povd and cusom, mysy shoppsa dpoyd bascay vywh. Ts a now-pad agns sakng casno oos o cmna

. M h ,moms cusng h ma wh an y o sh ogan-zaon and my wcom gngs. Ty a h- , h jv -vauaon and daa gahs o makng ms.

A , h $1.5 mpoyng 1.5 mon pop wodwd.

And y, h s amos no pubc knowdg oh mysy-shoppng ad. i you no on oh v

by conacos hd o cach you ou, o on oh mon and a ha dong h spyng, you coud

b ogvn o no knowng jus how sous abusnss mysy shoppng s. Wha acadmc h h b ndusy spcc, vauang s cacy ah

h . M h up om m o m n h nws, bu usuay n

the secret shopper

7/27/2019 TNI 5 Spies

9/127

9

--hh o ak mysy shoppng jobs ony a t mosophscad han h Ngan-pnc ma. Andh books abou mysy shoppng a amosxcusvy aspaona: Te Mysery ShoppersManual: How o Ge Paid o Shop in Your Favorie

Sores, Ea in Your Favorie Resaurans, and More!

T had wok o makng su vy chan so nh h

: M h hj hh -h (MSC), sang agncs ha copoaons ho povd a sps. T MSCs nams go omoay bana (Svc excnc Goup inc.; Cus- 1) h (S-; C) h M (ShCq ). h j, h,

a onm, on-ask conac bwn h mysyshopp and h MSC. Onc mysy shoppsag o do a shop, hy n h so and oowh h v ( h, , q, .), h h ( h ; h

down s a dad gvaway) and pndng o b a . T mpoys a h a s gu ou hy bngmysy-shoppd, h MSC can and w dny hmysy shopp paymn o ha shop.

Willie osterWeil

7/27/2019 TNI 5 Spies

10/127

10

Who hs mysy shopp svcs? evdncpovdd by mysy shopps has bn uphdas mpaa by judgs, so hy a somms

usd by copoa-aw ms o pov connouspons n ag cass. Makng ms aso usmysy shopps. ec, an accoun assocaha i nvwd, cuny manags a makngcampagn o a majo b dsbuo w ca Bzz B. H hno bas wh Buzz B ss a hgh voum o

ak nos on how pomnny dspayd Buzzadvsng s, how w h band pous, and

hh h Bzz v Bzz-. T h h hn a o hs nomaon n on a smaphon ( h q hpacua shop,) whch auomacay pocsss

h daa and uns no a Buzz Sco o ec.A a ound o shops s compd n a mak hswokng n, ec hn s h owns h BuzzScos and pomss ha h bas wh h hghs v q -vauaons w g nvd o Buzz pas and gos o bandd swag. is a wn-wn, ahough ocous h ba nv agd o pay hs gam.

Mysy shopps a pad a a , on a shop-by-

shop bass, quny $10 o $20. Usuay, bu no, h h h. h h

the secret shopper

7/27/2019 TNI 5 Spies

11/127

11

hav an y o da: h qusonnas hy mus vv z hh q. S h-

h h h hcohs n a so a h sz says on h hangs

h h, v -a xam whou gtng nocd. Mo on hy h vsb n nough pacs o monong h cash h h h , h h

h h o hav mmozd ha wk. Mysy shopps asauans on nd a hmom o s ood

mpaus, wh oh compans qu shop-ps o cay a sopwach so hy can masu h

m (o h scond!) aks hm o b gd.

As woks ou, amos no on can mak a vng

h. F h, h h h j: h MSC no sady wok o any shopps; nsad hy gvwoud-b shopps accss o wha s bascay anonn bun boad (on a a b anngand vtng pod). Jobs a posd and camdconsany, manng h shopp has o spnd a

, h h h, h . hshop usuay has a spcc day o wk whn nds o b compd o b vad, and pos h 24 h

Willie osterWeil

7/27/2019 TNI 5 Spies

12/127

12

o compon. Snc ach shop apps ony o a , hv zo v n a vy dns uban aa o do mo hanou o v shops n a day. Mysy shopps ano pad houy and a ay mbusd oav xpndus. And, o cous, h pos dmd nadqua hy bough h wong

h, , h mad by an mpoy no pay.

M h , z abo akn o an xm. As a su, mysyshopps nd o hav anoh om o ncom.Pdomnany mdd (o ow-mdd) casspop, mysy shopps a quny say-a-hom moms ookng o suppmn h spouss, - h j o h sma uxus, k ang ou, whou

woyng abou xpns. Many s do oan xa cash wh sayng busy and mnayshap, and, ss quny, so do young pop o

whom a t mony gos a ong way. Shoppson mssag boads and n nvws i conducddscb mysy shoppng as somhng bwna pa-m job and a hobby.

in sho, mysy shopps a mosy pop a-

donay consdd o b ousd h wokoc.M , h h -ns o do nna auds: o mono h acv

the secret shopper

7/27/2019 TNI 5 Spies

13/127

13

abo o mpoys n a way ha manags, whos v h h h hbhavo, canno. Wh h xsnc o h MSC

h h - h h h h h v h - h h h h v h hs ay wokng o. Dos you qusonna ask lv h h ,

h h comng ov o hp?

You aso nd up wh som pty nasy cass dy-

: -- h -s and moms o do nca suvanc on--- h doa. Bu jus k pop dong va mak-

ng n h soca nwoks o mnma pay b-caus s un, hs ja-k spyng on bha o hh h v choc, pasu, and dom ha a aways usdo jusy pcaous abo. You a o undown any job ha dosn ns you, pomssMShA.. Y

o ak o as much m as you wan whnvyou wan.

Willie osterWeil

7/27/2019 TNI 5 Spies

14/127

14

Wh hv h ? T , , o cash nansgnc: subug dsgnd o

coun h owns o h suy sock boy.Wnss -h v, h hs on om Cusom Fdback llC: 96% o 91% NVr ! 68% h

h q ! T

a qusonab, bu h da ha componbwn as sng h sam poducs a h h h o h sa sms commonpac, amos obvous.

S h h ?

Fs, w hp o undsand wha maks h so h . Sh h

acv abo s xpcd o h. is possb hah - , ? A M h M hv , don dv nnovaon and chnoogca chang- v-hmods o ssanc o xpoaon. on agus

ha wokng-cass dmands daw h pow nbng xpssd as usa, acs hough whch h s h poducon pocss. Mos obvousy,

the secret shopper

7/27/2019 TNI 5 Spies

15/127

15

bu aso appas as saboag, sow-downs, h, , ak ong, c., c.

Sh v, h by capa, ncssang nw oms o ssanc.in T Sagy o rusa on ws, Tpaoms o dmands whch woks hav o h hv h

hv h : h vo xpoaon. Bt condons o o h v . C wok dmands and amps o ansom hm h . W un dvop nw dmands, nw mods o usa.

in hs gh, much o h noba un oowngh uphavas o h 1960s and 70s can bundsood as a way o habang and co-opng wok dmands. Womn a bough noh and nomaz wo-ncom houshods. D jusggaon agans Acan Amcans s ndd,wh d aco sggaon mgs n h wa on h v poc vonc. Mo cav wok s odby h s o knowdg abo, bu a h xpnso gnazd pcay and h ansomaon

Willie osterWeil

7/27/2019 TNI 5 Spies

16/127

16

o a cavy no wok, va soca nwokng, , / -.indusa wags n h Goba Noh a kp a

mdd cass vs, bu mos ndusa jobs agobazd and shd o dvopng conoms,pacd by nonunon wag abo n svc anddsbuon. Cog ducaon s mad avaabo a and bcoms a om o db ponag.

B h h h h

usa. i much o h wokng cass n h Ws snow posond a h pons o consumpon anddsbuon as was, gas-saon atndans, ocashs, hn s h ha dmands-as-usas

. r ; -ak boycots; opang cash gss, scanns,and cd-cad machns ncny; akngncssany o cowoks; gnng gnoanc o

h so ayou; sagng hagc pc chcks ocanup and sockng go-sows; anng nwhs pooy; and, o cous, sang goods andmony om h so a a oms o usa and

cass sugg.

Bcaus hs oms o usa a pomd npubc ah han on h shopoo and a onagd a consums (hmsvs on wokng) h h h , hcan b ansoca and anang n h own gh.B h vz h h

the secret shopper

7/27/2019 TNI 5 Spies

17/127

17

, , z, hbhavos a oo wdspad o b xpand asa mat o bad apps. Anyon who has wokd

h h h h v v . yas n mov has, and h amoun o gabagpop av swn n h naow ows bwnsas (wh you nvaby bang you kns and h ) -

, . v

h j , h , , h,i woud, n wo hous, hav o pck h mand

o up o h oo a hy and humang askv (,n h paacha hom, womn).

H

ha oahng and sca o a cusom? On good h h v coud b a mysy shopp and ha a bad shopcoud g h d. MSCs nss ha h svcsshoud b usd ony o ncnv pogams andh h -shopp daa. in a bog pos d Msus o

M Sh S h M ShPovds Assocaon wbs, Chsoph

Wz h h . h qa ngh:

Willie osterWeil

7/27/2019 TNI 5 Spies

18/127

18

in som cass, poo pomanc ndcasa nd o coc h anng gmn haad o cvy convy managmns . B NO h h h . T h :masumn o nsu conssncy nachvng a spcc v o pomanc, v o h cusom, conssncy n companc

wh company pocs and pocdua

xpcaons. Conssncy.

i mosy ak Wazynsk a hs wod h, and iov ha shsc pon o conssncy. Hsms gnuny appad ha pop us hs n h . Hv, h h h h h h

whn you ook a h wbs o on o h MSPAs z, Nh l PvConsuans (NlPC). in bgh non-gn xh s dcas, Wha You Don Know CANHu You! Compans os bons o doas vyya smpy bcaus o: empoy bhavo, lousycusom svc, empoy h. T inn s

h ha pocy k Appbs, wh wo bad mysyshops w g you d. And whn NlPC os o h h hgh mpoys, hy pobaby no chckng o

the secret shopper

7/27/2019 TNI 5 Spies

19/127

19

hh h vz h .

Ts ambvanc uns hough mysy-shoppmssag boads as w. A commn om WndyM h h shopps gv:

Mysy shopps a and o bv hahy dong h so own a svc bypovdng an vauaon o h so, so ha

h v h v .Ty a hd by h sos hmsvs.

You os you job bcaus you pobabypovdd bad svc. So, h pson mos h h.Hv, j a ha wokng a sucks. Soy.

Mysy shopps know hy a gtng pop, h h v v ,h had wokd as on o ony a b m. Mo- h h . Ahhh da o gng woks n oub ups hm,hy ndd o jon Wazynsk n bamng somanags o msusng h wok. Mos mysy

shopps nd o b hons, vn ans, n hpos, whch, o a job paay akn up o hun o sah and dupcy, pons o h apvsy o h job.

Willie osterWeil

7/27/2019 TNI 5 Spies

20/127

20

Wha hs dvoon o h ask vas s hcouson wh h bosss. Mysy shopps amnau hough poc, acv pnkons,

h ousoucs h gwok o vyday psychccono. Ty a sn n o bak h avnus o v , h sandads damd up by maks, buaucas,and MBAs ha so dadn h xpnc ovyday und a capasm. And o op

a o, hy cass aos, dnyng wh and h h.A jus o a xa cash o h wknd.

P h h ; habo; and makng soday dcu hough , , aus o noba wokpac oganzaon. Bu

h v, , v.Jay Goud, nnh chs man n Amcan hsoy,aoad spcuao, and wdy dspsd obb

baon, amousy makd upon h hng oskbaks, i can h on-ha o h wokng h h h. N h un o h obb baons by poducng h

h hq G wh wach. Hghnd wokpac suvanc

hps bud a wokpac wh no m s wasd,wh a o s pu dcy no h poducon

the secret shopper

7/27/2019 TNI 5 Spies

21/127

21

h . B hjus h boom n.

T ha o h v-psn spy, h a ha h h h D h h18 , you us no on, xpcng hm a o b agans, h ,whch you now noc wh paanoac cncy.Sv, , .

is abou makng poc.

Willie osterWeil

7/27/2019 TNI 5 Spies

22/127

7/27/2019 TNI 5 Spies

23/127

23

Agns Whou AgncyBy

rOB HOrNiNG

T gam o bng an amau spy can b asasyng dvson om ou ova powssnss

Wh h ,i somms anasz abou bng a spy. i gvs

my suspcons a pupos. i sms o dgny myv, v v . rh h vpop, i can pnd i am kpng hm undobsvaon, and wha s a sak s no whhhy k m bu som ag quson o whhhy can b usd n h absac. i sms k a

way o da s-conscousnss, o dsappa noa msson. rah han powss, a cog n angung and ndn soca machn, i can unmy obsvaons no dscovs o oh pops hh h. sa o pnd ha mayb h a good asons

7/27/2019 TNI 5 Spies

24/127

24

i on im bng kp n h dak. is o my

own say.

T anasy mus b common. On o h sockchaacs o sponag hs s h odnaypson caugh n obscu bu pocha suggs, z .T v h h hz han ncomphnsb msh o sa-suvanc

v wod-hsoca mpoanc. lk h poagons,h ad has h chanc o b a h ha o an

mpoan gh whou h oub o havng osv n sa buaucacs o mas xnsv . Wh as, scapsm s pmsd paadoxcay on hanasy o knowng h a nscapab uh, h

, hh, , h han auhos aboay convd con.

Bsh auho ec Amb was a mas o hnav-spy-n-ov-hs-had op. H wo annuna sng o novs n h yas adng upo Wod Wa ii Uncommon Danger(1937),

Epiaph or a Spy (1938), Cause or Alarm (1938),Te Mask o Dimirios (1939), Journey Ino Fear(1940) ha hpd sabshd h no oh muky, modn sponag h. A o hmau odnay, sghy dspuab mn who

rob horning

7/27/2019 TNI 5 Spies

25/127

25

mo o ss nadvny nd up n h mdd onnaona conspacs, accusd o cms hyh h ,

ncompn poc, o wokng n coodnaonwh oh ogn agns whos uswohnss

mans undcdab.

lk Gog Ow, Amb wo om h p-

h h so humb o nsgncan ha hy coud man

. F z v socy o oa wa, whch dmandd an qua - . v , h - h . T 1930 hh h v h v. Twoud povok a cma o man pudnc and hh, , Bh z

hh oca sgnag o conus xpcd nvads.

Ambs novs c hs gowng anxy ov

pocng nomaon, bough on boh bychnoogca dvopmns ha mad aso dssmna nomaon and by h nangdcompxy ha dspsd van daa acossa boad popuac. in Epiaph or a Spy, h h v, h h h . Caus r

agents Without agency

7/27/2019 TNI 5 Spies

26/127

26

Aar h- h h h v .Gh, h h Jurn In Far,

assassnaon bcaus hs ngnng wok maksh h h . A h h hmpoan; h nws s gnay bokn o hm

hh v . T h hy hav bcom ngnc agns agans h

h hv h

va knowdg ha can b ansmtd houghhm whou h ncssay bng capab oundsandng s boad mpoanc.

B . Amaks a pon o conasng hs poagonss whh possona sps who com o h ad. Tsasond agns nss on h bundng, usss

gnoanc o h poagonss and h ugncy oh unshkab msson nonhss: You haveno idea wha you are doing, bu no one bu you can

do his. T poagonss a scambng oac n h absnc o h knowdg ha woudgv h acons manng. in hs hy smb

h v

n Fdch Hayks T Us o Knowdg nSocy. Ony oca abagus hav pnnknowdg, bu hs knowdg s aways paa h hmak, whch sps ou h uy aona anayss.

rob horning

7/27/2019 TNI 5 Spies

27/127

27

T v v h v . S h H h v v h

v v h h unqu nomaon o whch bnca us mgh

h h h h h wh whch opas, o how h ndvdua h gh acon.

Ambs chaacs a caugh n hs appan h h h h -. T h o an psmoogca sh ha accompans hgowng ogsca compxy o h conomy andh gobazd nconncon o sas and ms.T acons consu nomaon (knowng

h) h ( h h).Fo ndvduas, wha mans o know somhngh h h v h hwh ou masy o h acs. i may b pasano know hngs, bu ccuang h knowdgmaks a and cv. Ts condon unvs

h v ,

hh h socy. indvduas doogy dmands ha ouchocs consu oucoms, bu h compxyand nconncdnss o socy maks cacausay mpossb o sabsh.


7/27/2019 TNI 5 Spies

28/127

28

A , hv, h .Ty can njoy acon whou knowng h saks.T hv hh h -

v , -choogca n ha oshadows how h g-whzh h W h -v. Oh, na. I aiin sbd. I akina dead drop. My phone ells me where my iends are.

Soca mda has, a a, accmad us o h m-

u o vyday sponag ha has no appangoa. W a no dnyng and aggng pop nphoogaphs o gh h Nazs. W a no spad- h A. , A ,w a caugh up n a nzy o dscosus whhv hz h h synhss o c soca chang. insad o h

h h , h v v -

v, h hunahomab commca pocssng may nsu.

W hav com o ak o gand comphnsv v. W hv , h ;

rob horning

7/27/2019 TNI 5 Spies

29/127

29

hy a agns who a ab o dny us nhh, h, msnomaon o dsnomaon n pmann,

h ,who can b su? evn nmas can bcomnadvn doub o p agns n h nn

gss o sags and counsags n ou - -, hh v - .Why do pop sha wha hy sha? And snc

hy know i w b askng ha quson, how hash h h h hov ha Sany Cup payo gam, o Obamask s, o h ka hy had o dnn? How doi spond? evyhng s a mov n a compcadgam ha soca-mda suvanc maks suw a aways payng. Cono ov vn ou own

, h h n h mds o such cusv xvy. W snsou own ag aknss, whch can ony conm

ou suspcons o ohs.

D h C W, v h W S

and sun paanoa, wh pssv govnmnsocng ozd czns o pon ngs a onh. h F , hh, h h -chags o sa us spyng.


7/27/2019 TNI 5 Spies

30/127

30

Suvanc has bn sugacoad as consda

h, v . Wh , ,

o possb nsus on scsson oppounsbu budng communy and ong hop o hsmay afcd.

i nohng s, soca mda hav mad us acuy j h h ,how hs oom o h mos mundan mnua

hh v .Gv h v h , h h v h h h ,h appovng acons o ou oows, h hv h . W v q h

h h soca ncuson, aonazng h b ha bngncudd can smpy man bng wachd.

W h h payng du soca atnon o ou nds and h h h nuson: accdnay spyng on unnnddags. Snc w a hav a boadcas chann opogam and snc ou soca pacpaon (and,ncasngy, ou conomc woh) s masud

rob horning

7/27/2019 TNI 5 Spies

31/127

31

n ms o how w w , w bgn o sh pop aound us as psons o ns, no ough suspcous chaacs. W can b

sps obsvng oh sps whch s phapsss go busng han bng papaazz angmcocbs. (Tough gadng h dossscocd on us as cby gossp ah han h

nuson o pssv nsuona appaauss ss own doogca bam.)

T documnay possbs w a now posssshough soca mda hav sad o shap whaw s a phnomnon Nahan Jugnson hasdubbd h Facbook y. W gad hngsmo n ms o how hy may b ansmtdah han as hy a. Ts mod o sngmaks us knowng coaboaos n h cpngnomazaon o bank suvanc, und h

gus o ou cocng oca nomaon ncdwh ou unqu consaon o nss. Jusas Hayk damd, soca mda mak us aacks o nomaon, wh h soca-mdacompans jockyng o bcom poxs o hmas-pocssng mak n agggang ah daa and suppyng conomc agns wh

aona concusons.

T spyk pusu o nomaon ah hanknowdg maks us uncon ss as hnks han, ,


7/27/2019 TNI 5 Spies

32/127

32

ow-powd ons a ha. W a no h subjcswho know hngs o nnonay poduc know-; j

hough whch nomaon passs wh mo oss nos n h sgna. W bcom no ony pao a nwok bu pa o a ccu. W a pawns na ag gam, a y caugh n h cog-whs as

Vandassy, h naao o AmbsEpiaph or aSpy, pus .

Ambs poagonss a no h aona

agns h n h pos hs novs unod;

hy a subsumd no a ag sysm. Ty

v h h v hh ,

h h v h

assus ha hy can nv b can. T

acua aona subjc, h ny ha knows,

s a copoa o naona on byond h

comphnson o any ndvdua caugh n

h chaos o unodng vns. in ou cas, h

ny ha knows s a soca-mda company

o an agohm ha can pas a h daa

wv suppd. A passag omEpiaph or

a Spy usas Ambs gasp o sponag

no a mat o ngnous d agns bu

o a sysmc pocss nvovng a gon oundcab, unmakab mn scatd

hough vyday .

Bu hen you couldn xpc a spy o ook ka spy howv a spy was supposd o ook.

rob horning

7/27/2019 TNI 5 Spies

33/127

33

H v h . A v ,a ov h wod, mn w spyng, wh nv h h sus o h sps abos: hcknsss o , v , zzvocs, das o -cono mchansmsand angnds, uz cncs, das o, ,dsposon o ky acos, andmaks obombs. T wod was gtng ady o goo wa. Fo h sps, busnss was good.

A F, . Th

h h , h h h h v h h hv hv, j, h hsy md human aspaons. in Ambs wod,h qubum h ngnc-song machnsks und h gus o psvng s may svony o accommoda wa and xpd kng. in

ou wod, w sv h oushng o maks oh sak and h ncomphnsb nds.

i w accp h consoaons o h spy gam, andmbac h so o s-concpon sucus,

hn w aso concd ha w a whou agncy.W a conn o sv as a suboun n a muchag pogam ha w hav no aby o dc.

T ncnvs w xpnc sm no omsom nn yanng; hy don c h ugo xcs ou w. insad hy a h mansby whch w a pogammd o connu n ou

nomaon-ansmsson uncons. Any sns o


7/27/2019 TNI 5 Spies

34/127

34

h ou ngnc ppn owng. Snc w canundsand h pupos o a h nomaon w

can gah, h ony manngu mc s more. As h hw hav nohng o hd and no on o poc. ina buay compv, aomzng conomy whw pom ousvs o suvv and wh w aobgd o coc as much nomaon as w can h h

agans vyon, w sps n a wa o a agansa. W a whou vn a sd o choos.

rob horning

7/27/2019 TNI 5 Spies

35/127

7/27/2019 TNI 5 Spies

36/127

36

T Fuu is FmaBy

SAMANHA HiNDS

in h cn inker ailor Soldier Spy mak,womn a nowh and vywh

A a-soakd pat oods csson london. ininker ailor Soldier Spy, w s h khak sysand ng boxs o an mp packng s away.D A, h

v (L h Rih On In, 2008),says ohodox o nh John Cas x no

h sonoous uch o h ms V pdcsso.A v , wh a squnc o ofa jazz o undpnchan-smokng unconas. Wh s sngsongsuspns among h cassd sacks, inkerhas

a buaucac bbop. Adson, a Swd, n anadmtd scond-anguag vason, soyboadswh h comc-book cus o a kd who an saghpas h Oxod Casscs o in in.

7/27/2019 TNI 5 Spies

37/127

37

inkr, h C W h, h:mn, os, bown. l Cas Mi6, dubbd hC, v,

mad by dad avs. Cnmaogaph Hoyv H, 1971, 1973 hha dusky haz o cgat smok and ock-oomsam. Dsp a vy pac, way ons pvad.Wapps hudd und d-vnd cu maps.evn bak Sov ou s conducd n a pas h -h h

nwspap. As Vcav Hav sad whn askd oca h 1970s on h oh sd o h Cuan,

T h h , h .

inkers po uns on h sach o a KGB mo,

bu Cas soy ay nvoks dyng goy spccay, h duy and da o a Bz-badod guad und amoa nw managmn. Gay

Odmans Gog Smy, h cas-o spy boughback o nvsga a possb doub agn, saccodngy ducd and umnav. W s hm

don ovsz ams ha hghgh und-y bags j. H hv

h .

Compa hs o vsons Smy: an ach Ac

Gunnss, payng h n sca o upp-cusak wh a pcussv . Dcd by John ivn,

h 1979 BBC z inkr h. V h h

samantha hinds

7/27/2019 TNI 5 Spies

38/127

38

hous o cacuad od-man manuvs n hckywapapd ooms. T mayoshka do o h q, v,

: hxm. T a ian rchadson dd dandy n B H h: hh, v, . (C Fh v h ou o un.) BBC scnw Ahu Hopcansud h od Smy had a ns and nqusvagncy. Odman wokng wh h dacd

anguag o ws Bdg OConno and PSh , h . H h G ony whn dscbng an ncoun wh Sovach-nmss Kaa. Boh acos convy Smysdgny, bu ony Gunnss gav hm carriage.

T gnus o h Smy chaac s n hs

. Th , Ss no Condo on h un. No, hankuy, s h anavngng codg wh cudg, avodng spy acoMcha Cans aconay un o agng Harry

Brwn (2009). S h . Fv h v, Swoud b h wnss achyp a s moa bs.

A cusodan o unspokn cods ogd n wam,spn Smy wachs om Bsh knghs-an b bough o by h hghs bdd. inkerhus maks h pon whn h aona nobaappoach o ngnc cocon ousd h

the future is female

7/27/2019 TNI 5 Spies

39/127

39

h- h SWod Wa.

T manchoy o gnaona vanc spsn vywh n inker. H, w s hconmpav ho as ocd : bkp, , h h. Y ,

you gacy s h ony ca o acon o hsh- A -. T hav povn bua and nav, ccuang akd

Sov ngnc a h p o Bsh vs. AsHav nod, An a o apahy and wdspaddmoazaon bgan ... Socy was aomzd,sma sands o ssanc w dsoyd, and a h . A h h h B -W W.

Dsp h souc maas 1970s povnanc,Adsons npaon o inker nvabyh : h G W . Aa, knghs bg mcnas. No wond odays

v v inkr P A(oby Jons) k 24s Jack Bau, a phgmac

bond hug: h s h nw guad ncana, s-ghousy adng n as scs o gan. Hsugnss s appan bu aso mpc, sgnang a h h h B G. Sinkr v h

samantha hinds

7/27/2019 TNI 5 Spies

40/127

40

h. Th -CGi-ss such as 2007sBourne Ulimaum($270 mon n goss cps) s domna

h popua spy om, a nw bd has mgd o h v : 2005 Sriana an adapaon o See No Evil, h xposvydssnng mmo o CiA opaons cas oc

rob Ba and Cas Bg Phama hTe Consan Gardener.

Tough Ca, an xcuv poduc oinker,h , --wng by ow x-spy ru Mac Gch,ngnc vans gnay appaud Cascon o s hahy nsuona cyncsm. each

nw Ca adapaon mnds cvans o a v

and popua a. Ts mans mo han Sarmngon, om Mi5 had, bcomng cha oh 2011 M B Pz. T h S j h G Ah h h vrdich() h Nw Yrk Rviw Bks v T Livs Ohrs (2006). P

dscous nds s Gaham Gns, s Havsn vs. Mayb dsnchand scuy-suds h v H . T bank, a a, compad wh ps who pom


7/27/2019 TNI 5 Spies

41/127

41

dvnaoy anayss o langy: inkerhas aadypud n ov $10 mon.

A inkr T F F G, Th. (A , J Fo Focus Faus has sad ha h sagd inker - PG-13 T IrnLady.) Ts mag s a anasc submna jab, asA hh h h S

w Ann mans compy unsn.Unk spy cons ypca bang hah hapy

(s Angna Jo n 2006s Te Good Shepherd),

Ann s no a man chaac. Mo pvoa s ou M6 , Sv C Sh(Kahy Buk). H chaac s basd on a-

sach Mcn Bago, a Cassanda o sos

who ncsvy s spotd Bsh spook KmPhbys nooous dcon. in h 1979 ss,Conn s payd by an app-chkd By rd.Bu Adson maks hs sma Conn wasdand dowdy, h gam-changng nsgh ducd owd mammay paoxysms: A my boys. A myovy boys, sh mumus, vn whn sad boyshav cushd h vocaon. Manwh, S Pcy

mpassvy bus hs oas.

H . T hbn on o a acca sxuay ha s copoazdand waponzd. rah han gnmany, s

samantha hinds

7/27/2019 TNI 5 Spies

42/127

42

, h h h h N . P, v inkr

Haydon and hs many sxua conquss mappdono h uhss paybook o a ma spy. Ts ss spaang Vsp lynd om lynndengand han w hnk. As agns, womn a h Az h(N, Hh) (M,Massa). T ony cn dvaon om ads

h P Sa(2010), (h vh apoogc mana ac o aannos assassnnKill Bill).

inkern s nw aon can b ad as a amnov h dpon o acca sxuay. lbdo,havng bn abusd and coupd, s nay

. C h h --govnmn ca machn, Smy s cuckodd

by hs hom- bd, and Sov dco ina(Svana Khodchnkova) gs snud ou ocackng h Naasha achyp.

Ausy ks nay vyon n spy ms. Spy h S vh h, h h . rhBuon, as Ca chaac Ac lamas n Te

S Wh Ca in Fr h Cd (1965), h h , q


7/27/2019 TNI 5 Spies

43/127

43

: , q, h h. inkr, h h:S C Jh W

Chuch mn and sa mpassvy a nagsnay scwng on a naby couch. Young mn,oo, mak saccs o h maw o Saun andsa. easy h sadds scn n inkers asos qus: whn mod, boysh P Guam(B Ch) S h ,

h A h v

pcauon dsmss hs ov, whom h ds upom a dmy domsc kchn.

Ts a woman, pocams assumd uncoarck a (om Hady) n cassc spy op. rckv h h 1960 - (swchd om h ognas Hong Kong) o h

B, S & S Wh.

paaphas ec Amb, rck s h ap o Psvv. As wongd man, h shs, channngHchcocks vson o John Buchans 39 Seps(1935). Bu rck s mssy bdnous, h ssympahcay so, snakng no Smys dakhous n snaks and bu jans k a undpodga son. i wan a amy, hank you, a

dcas ghousy. i do nowan o nd up kyou o. Smy pocs hs ogu scaphuno uphodng good od engsh chvay owad a

boodd russan mo. Ts sa habo dsp v ,

samantha hinds

7/27/2019 TNI 5 Spies

44/127

44

h hp- and pos-copoazd spy.

inkers young s dba bua counn-gnc saagms aound a und ound ab,psnd n a gash oang sa oom nsad o

hushd pao o dusy oc. Ony a sng cysa h . O h C, h ngnc ocas a commandd by bad ah.

And h aomzd gd has a consquncs:W s a bochd opaon n a Budaps acadh h, v suckng s dad moh.

N, C v h h. h , Cspnd h yas on ascndng byond h

scaa poo. ion ads g no hoc dnou-. O , h h-cs and dscadd. Ausy ks: T nwinker

ons h spy-m gn o hos cassc pos v h :

v h v h. A h ,dsdanuy cu.


7/27/2019 TNI 5 Spies

45/127

7/27/2019 TNI 5 Spies

46/127

46

Shns lk God (xcps)By

iMP Kerr

From: ShUwHSubject: SHEx Initiation Ritual

Date: August 16, 2010 4:58:37 PM EDT

-000000

To: [email protected]

Message-ID: {unknown}

FILE C.

Recovered from Jerry Syrups computer:

Pmnay Nos on an inaon rua oxpd Atunmn o nw mmbs noS-Hex Wokng Goup (PowD.) o h Nw

Y Sh Bh h SH|| O; ShUH,.

{}

Q: T -, h j- .

7/27/2019 TNI 5 Spies

47/127

47

enans a ncouagd o xpmn wh hs ex malo bonum h h , h

xaodnay daym [ShUwH No: say-bhnd opaons].

end o h r o h SHex: T od was scad h Od o SHe, and was a ay sho-

vd and conovsa socy omd Oc. 15,2007, cca bca, n Soho, Manhatan, Nw

Yok, by imp K, add by Aoha Cov (anam: Aoysa Cov-Waugh) e alii (i. Wam,

Chq, -S), 2009, h 2010. sabshd hawas no pmay( ) vv h , hh v

imp K o any oh sma auhoy, hough pad and/o paaphasd h uas and aon m o anoh had a numb o pomnn h Mh[sic] banch. Soh has cvd many pubc om sva soucs by ason oh v Sh, hv, hncouagd h da ha Soh and sereohell

w h sam [s gossay nos, pp. 51-55].Fo das on h vs o K and Cov-Waugh, caons w mad [bd. iV, p. 70] n

h , SH h

7/27/2019 TNI 5 Spies

48/127

48

v h , h ,and w, b uh dscussd [nconcusv].

{}

Souc: COMiN (no vd, s p. 402(1010) 56; c. no 5). imp K concvd hda o oundng an od whch woud ncas, h NllGBl

AND iNeXPliCABle (so-cad) SYSeM,and by hs man, ca nw wods, dvs nw

spndos, oppos Wgnsn and Scnc ld,among ohs, and such, a o whch objcvs

h, , , , ,,and , whch w changd ouo SHex, whch was ansad as SoH easy com by h FBi Dcypon am,

and Soh o soh by h Sgnas Sv h US A. {} Sh oo shwd and sub o h own good, houghsuch quas gav h hadway o a m. {}O pacua ns s h amp by imp K( K) h h. K h h -S

v h h h ,bu daggd h down whou hpng SHexvy much, sachs say [vbam]. {}

[.1] T

7/27/2019 TNI 5 Spies

49/127

49

h h, hh v [v 2009, . 58] h v h h h h

aa [S-19 and S-75], whch s nod o a hghncdnc o unxpand sghngs, s ocad oh asn Aanc coas o h Und Sas.

[.1] W []. [] B-1po n [dacd] (h nam o hs ca a

) h [2008].Whn n acv duy h bough gs o h ABas om Nw Yok, ocay o oganznga hous pay, bu wo days a h avd, sadh, h h h jh andng, ung, boadng h gs h bough h . , h pods bwn h andng and h ak os ong, sad h. wo hous bo avng h

had a cha wh an A-2 po abou ha andh h, j, h h o S*He|| 1. H aughd bu a on h vsd a

S*H|| 1 S*H|| 2 h saw a pcu o a payma sma o on oh gs h w o Mam, Fl.

Noa Bn: S*He|| 1 was nay bs by bohnna and xna dsods, o

h wok and pmpoy odd o, h . va S*He|| asd opposon, so much ha

7/27/2019 TNI 5 Spies

50/127

50

[dacd] adcad [dacd] by dc, nd o

Oc. 2009.B2.A oo pan showng S-19 and S-75, boh

ocad whn S-19 and S-75.

Following page: Polaroids:

B1. T ava o rub Possopo a S-19.

B1. insd h d oom a S-19.

FILES B. (Mirror fles)

7/27/2019 TNI 5 Spies

51/127

7/27/2019 TNI 5 Spies

52/127

52

EEK!

2009, hh

atmp o k imp K nnsd. ingncocas wand ha had aangdh h Mh,and h massac o h mmoy, vbam andgs. Whn an apan cashd na h BuaoNagaa innaona Apo, kng a hpassngs, dcdd ha K

h h. A q h h v announcmns on oca wb ss and bogus

acs n nwspaps. Sh go a nw nam andnw auhnc documnaon wh h nw, v ,nv und o Nw Yok.

7/27/2019 TNI 5 Spies

53/127

53

T soh pooo was acqud by SvDP K h 2009.

T

w numbd om 1 o 115, ydng a oa o222 pags. T x was appoxmay 45,000

h. 23,046 .i was dvdd no scons, whch w bokn hh h.T numb o sgmns was changng a achnw adng om v o aound v hundd

h, h h n x.

Fuh xamnaon o h sucu o h xvad patns sma o ma homonacycs. wny-svn dn sys o wng

w dnd, and ach sgmn (o sag)

coud b dcomposd no sx dsjon vs (asnay sysm o wavs, o paa pans)handomnss a whch h vs w nacd ; , h dHOPE, poducd hn, on nacvv s andomy acvad wc, bo h h h v.

A agmnay and unauhozd pubcaon osereohell was mad by Ksopp Snak n 2010.i was a u-szd back and wh acsm o46 pags o h pooo, mad by dng bs

7/27/2019 TNI 5 Spies

54/127

54

. S hv hpooo, whch s s n h posssson o SvDPa.

Ts 46 pags concn pncpay S-52 and hv h W & B (WB) s vcns. Puncuaon and gamma os a. v h ga comphnson.

PROTOCOLS

Patern comparisons beween sereohell andemale hormonal cycles.

7/27/2019 TNI 5 Spies

55/127

55

T S-52 pooco has bn vsd o c hoowng cocon:

initiate contact on more than one occasion

contact you for no particular reason

ask your advice

apologize more than once

sew your mouth together at the inside of the lips

(h nd s bough ou hough on o younoss)

drain the contents of your abdominal and chest

cavs wh a oca and pac h movd

ma wh cavy ud

T S-52 hyppooco (n ms as):

torch your future

DISPATCH

in h a 90s, h oun dspachd gtyChq h MPD . Amany a summ and consdab buaons,sh sad h Wax & Bobs phas. in 2002 andonwad sh bough o h ad h asssanc

7/27/2019 TNI 5 Spies

56/127

56

o -Symmc, Mabu, and B, whos, , J.T gs w xmy scv, dnyng

hmsvs and h oun by assumd smpwods Chqua was You, h hadquas wasGn, Nw Yok Cy was T Angy Dagon,-S , . D v -, h q. T

1) Fv , 2)P. W & B v a dspopoona pcnag o mas. By Juy2007, had 158 nams on s os.

1. Chiquia pulls up hersrapless bra as she gesready or morning yoga,

ca. 2005.

2-3. wo dierenreadings.

7/27/2019 TNI 5 Spies

57/127

57

A h D,hough Cov, a hghy snsua and ncuayoung woman, and ingd Wam, daugh o r .Wam, and n 2008, Chqua was noducd oK, who cvd u accss o a o Chquasmaa n 2009.

S-52

A dozn o ma caaks w wokng a

S-52 ( S-56). T ,nanng paons, wokng up pavovanhos. Ty w od ha as s mad o a

housand dsass.

As h WB thad pu , h S-52 povddsysms and svcs n h MPD;

O, n h wods o,i was sma oa pva soh.

S-52 z-h h 19h C,aound a wos dn, ocad on lt Ws 12S. h h v. Ah . v 75,000 , h h v . Nv Hnch von Odngn was Hnch von

7/27/2019 TNI 5 Spies

58/127

58

S-52 and n 1848, Fyodo Dosoyvsky, hundgound man, sangd a aunchy skankwh a chokng sh n h kchn, sabbd hm

n h z and cookd hm, whoy, wh duckand putana sauc. T dsh was namd Sbarock. T cp s ound n Te Aspern

Pars. v 1975 J. F. Sh (H B G) hnam Foc 5 Nu Yok Fyodo.

4. (An xampo mmoy

manpuaon.)

Bo.

5. (An xampo mmoy

manpuaon.)A.

7/27/2019 TNI 5 Spies

59/127

59

S-52 a majo ncdn o subvson. T nspcon

, ,bodom, and dah. S*H//1 scuy unadd S-52 and ound BDSM say manuas,ops, dns unss, bokn bons and waxmaas nsd h zs, a machn wh an

X-ay mbm on , cassd documns sod v , hh

z h (h o bood vdncng mmoy manpuaon).

Chqua opnd S-52 n 2002. Fs sh hd-Symmc, a h m whn sh was bangngasss n vdo boohs o 50 bucks a pop. Sh

and bondag by dong and bo ongsh coud mak h Wamsbug Bdg ou oops. Sh cud Mabu n 2005. Mabu hadmkng npps. Sh was ncknamd mnaoa mdngh. Sh cud B n 2006,an xp n cuppng, vba abus, subvsvsxuay, jee kune do, and ha pung. Sxypcn o h body was atood. Ty w a

p-op and on homons o yas. Among hbg m guas was Jmmy Bodky, a on, a

d FBi po, an ou-o-cono. Tman was bang a pompadou, smng yow

7/27/2019 TNI 5 Spies

60/127

60

h, smng shmp. H was vng on hs FBipnson, up n h Upp Ws Sd. H was k,Honk honk! Mp mp! u u! H was cang

h h , , hagd sss daw us no : ov us dad hy

. H , , -,nncn. H was a bokn V scn, svngas a symbo o h unvs as a sugg bwnsnvsaon and goss. H was ha on bus

h , -

, - hs and you sad s. H was usng busy as anoun. H had a bank accoun a WaMu. And so

hy hough h was ngagd n h cocono nomaon o h pupos o subvson.H was codng hs voc, h was codng h

v. A h , M B

G, D V, Z B, FzFz F, h.How many yas hav you bn h, B?

B was vaan, o on hng. Sh had a busy, . Sh . Sh d. Sh had gn ys. Sh was dang ah . H j : T . A h , ,pung, nolo conendere, nolo conendere.

A B h . A h h

7/27/2019 TNI 5 Spies

61/127

61

h K , Dpubs, and napud, adan, sh daggd hmdown. So pty ubun a sag, n whch h

z , , v, . A h nv ansad no somhng nw.Dierenceand repeiion.

Know h kn! sh hud, Know h o!

Nolo conendere, nolo conendere

. T mak h gh dcson abou whn o sop. o

kp h cn av. i was no abou mos. iwas dg pay. Wh dos daknss a? Wha h ods? Wh dos cush h hozons?

H ? h hh v, S-52, h h h h . A hy had hah ssus, and hy sgnd a myown sk paps. And happ han h gs hy

. H h (), ha happy ndng? i k h sm o bas, ooSh ckn pussy bch! And sh augh hm, sh, G 70, h hom ouchng h, akng o h, ookng a h,ovng h. i was k ods. Nos a k ods.

7/27/2019 TNI 5 Spies

62/127

62

HOPE

B v lv, U K G B, B, N Y h USas, whn sh was 19. Sh had aways bn a

h vz h hh

h h h hwas ocd o uncon n squad condons, n

h an, h cobbsons, ads and gnmn,h boos o shny ah. Sh was hopu, bu

sh was akd ou. Sh ddn xcd abouh. , h . W, l B,

. Sh vcoud occu.

7/27/2019 TNI 5 Spies

63/127

7/27/2019 TNI 5 Spies

64/127

64

Und Ou SknBy

GiOVANNi iSO

Smaphons bng jus-n-m cncyand copoa dscpn o vyhng om

shoppng o sx savy

is wo yas ago, and im a a ba n Wngon.

A nd shows m on a map on h Phon haha s ndd wh w a. Fom whn h app

w coud pos hs nomaon on ou spcvFacbook was, o on w, FouSqua and sooh. Ts s h inn now, i az: no ong

j h v h CP/P -co, bu aso h GPS-nabd handss ha ackou ocaons n a m and nab us o upoadphoos o ousvs a bas n Wngon. And h

soca ds o sha ha nomaon: ha oo snow pa o h inn. W wan hs hngs o

v. W wd.

7/27/2019 TNI 5 Spies

65/127

65

is Fbuay 2012. A nws po coms ou oiay on h ac o womn sod no posuonom easn euop, Aca, and h Fa eas.LaRubbicaj Bv VPoch nd ony by mnon ha pmps usmcochp mpans and c phons o ack hs

h v h h. Wcan magn h s. A mcochp, o h knd youh . A h, h jo cay wh consquncs no doub mo

hoyng and bua bu ohws no ny h h h-ag chdn and mob woks, who woud asoac sancons hy bachd h aangmns

h, v, h , doppd o h gd whou adqua noc o avad xcus.

W know how gos. W a nmay amawh h hadwa and h sowa nvovd andhooughy habuad o how ou chnoogso communcaon can ossy doub no . T vas, angng om pacca convnnc apps ha hp you oca you phon n cas

s os o son, o ha accompany you chdousd h hom a h way down o nabngh hz v h . Th v h h

gioVanni tiso

7/27/2019 TNI 5 Spies

66/127

66

J h h hsam ha h maa uss o kp ack o Naaa,who sn much od.

A w, n ac, nud o hs? i suspc so. Soonw sha sop vn nocng such hngs. in hmanm, wh w a s magnay snszdo , wha a w o mak o hs conguy?Shoud boh us? Coud b ha pons oan acua connuy bwn consum bhavo

and cmna bhavo, bsds wha w mgh bncnd o consd an ncdna nk namyha h popuay o, n h cas a hand, ocaonv h hv -h-h h h,pvd puposs?

h q, v

h ypca spons o such ssus n mansam-mda commnay, whch s o mak h kydscmnan on o choc vsus mposon.Accodng o hs vw, h s nh conguyno connuy: jus good and bad, hons andh h h. hs s nua, and ou mod o ngagmn wh mans and aona. o w: ngagng nh mos makab acs o s-suvanc on h FSq h -. W h v

under our skin

7/27/2019 TNI 5 Spies

67/127

67

, , nacon, hamng nobody n h pocss. By, h h

h h h h h v F

h v v h h hs no subsana hs a (ghy) pcvd as . Wh h , z h h hnsd und h skn o ack h movmns

o womn sod no posuon as h hoyng h : q hxm nd o h spcum o nonchoc.

Ts anayss cs and nocs a undamnadoogca bas o ou ms, whch vauas nw

h q h consum xpnc ha s o say, hough

h . T h h j h v v. B h v h (now quas-myhca) ngn o Wsn aunc,h mod consum mus aso b a w-dsposday adop. Sh mus no b oo pcky, aon

q h h h v . h ddn duuy sand n n o ach nw aon h P, , h v n who w a, woud b cad no quson, wh

gioVanni tiso

7/27/2019 TNI 5 Spies

68/127

68

h q. S h consum mus adop mos nw poducs on hmak, and adop hm chuy. Wh mob

h v , h j h on mus ak a sp uh and gad hm no

jus as oos o busnss, bu as condons o u

pacpaon n socy.

h h q: C h? W ? W h h v ? T , a sma phon. O bng on Facbook. O gtng

P h h. N h aspaona. is abou kpng up, an mpavh h . S ,

h h. Ph

ou ss, o av ss. Bu h c phon whch h h . A hhng abou smaphons s ha n od o b uy h h h h , h w . T h.i s wha maks hm sma.

i you don own on o hs dvcs yous,you w phaps hav had h xpnc o bngh Ph. T h h h zms: S, hs s wh w a. i dosn ma

under our skin

7/27/2019 TNI 5 Spies

69/127

69

ha i hough ha i knew wh i was. My mnamap was no mach o h csp pcson o hPhons. Fom ha momn, bng n ha pac

h . T h . A hh , vsng m.

Wh mob inn and dynamc maps com ahos o ocaon svcs ha cocvy povd

v h h

h . h ags on ach oh and kp ack o ach ohs

. X h h . hshs okay.

On op o hs nwok o dsbud suvancmad up o smngy bngn sma bohs and

h (v) h h, h o hs chnoogs by compans, ams, andh h v h ,h, . h hs bcaus hy a paccay nchangab.C h ; hchdn concay o mak su ha hy a

v h h o; schoos ack h sudns concay ov . B h

Geoagging ones

wees seem o be

especially popular ahe momen. I wroe

his, and I wroe i here

I is no longer simply

an uterance, bu an

uterance wih longiud

and laiude. Tis will

enrich communicaion,

somehow.

gioVanni tiso

7/27/2019 TNI 5 Spies

70/127

70

an dn knds o suvanc. Ty a a

umay abou conong bods n spac. Tya abou nocng companc by makng h

subjcs consany vsb and awa ha hy abng wachd.

i dosn mat ha no a compans, no aams, and cany no a schoos do hs.T ac ha som o hm do, ha wha 15, 10,h v hv

us as dysopan anass hav bcom ounaangmns, s wha w mus accoun o.

And h a h cas o xnd hm uh, omak hm unvsa, ngad n h sysm by

dau. A coona nqus on h dah by sucd r, N Z, h h h

MF N Z h $200,000, h o and om h phon and povdng a ackngsvc so ha hy can nd ou wh h chds a any m. T coon hasn mad such a hh v MF v h abou h psn cuua momn.

W h , vvo som o h nsuons o h dscpnaysocy schoo, amy, wokpac ha w

under our skin

7/27/2019 TNI 5 Spies

71/127

71

judgd o b n mna css by Gs Duzwhn h skchd h ouns o h socy o. B h h , h ,

ud panopcsm n whch h subjcs undv v ho hmsvs and n aon o oh subjcs.in h manm, h physca conns o hoshsoca nsuons hav agy bokn down.T wokpac, mos o a, s whv and

whnv you happn o b, so ong as you

man vsb, psn, conncd o h nwok, h -v hch mod o cono.

T hh h , h h h , ,

h , h h dpoyd. T s mo vau n hos subjcv

uancs (i hav boadd h pan, im n hmng o vn im gong o bd) han n hjv - , h v sa o mnd as w as h wngnss o man

h h a codd ay o ma-suvanc ha s ssna

o h unconng o h sysm. W wan hshngs o b known abou ousvs. W wan ob oowd, boh maphocay o hs s hpmay manng ha h wod has on w and ay, whn w boadcas ou coodnas

gioVanni tiso

7/27/2019 TNI 5 Spies

72/127

72

o h wod o know. GPS s jus an nsumn,

an adjunc.

Y hv , j , h us o h ponoun we n hs ssay. Odnay iwoud agu ha pacpaon n h nwoks sanyhng bu qua, ha hy a basd owad

dscbng a can yp o subjc. Bu s z h h abou h adopon o inn chnoogs say, h numb o pop who hav a Facbookpo (900 mon pop, a as coun) o hnumb o Phons sod (h gu o 108 mon v ) h hhhs dsbud-suvanc nasucu has

ovad h od chnoogs and modas o z. T v h , -sn a manngu opon. Unss w acknowdgh z h h , h vh us o mcochps and c phons o ack hv v

as opposd o h samss xnson o h ogco h nwoks hmsvs and o h conomc

sysm ha unds hm.

under our skin

7/27/2019 TNI 5 Spies

73/127

73

B h h, , ,wh s goba ows o pogammab abo ands a-pvadng ccus o cono. T ackd

womn n h La Repubblica xpos w sand n Cypus and Sba bo dong annnshp n russa, dung whch h anngcapacy was sd and vauad. Tn hy wv h , , F,h Nh, h h h

. l

odnay, w-unconng modn wokpac,h h h and mak h sysm mo cn, ducng hags and h downm as much as h oss odspacmn o sa.

h . T h , h

us o quson h subbony popua myh hah inn s h pac o pusu ndvduaand cocv dom, o socaz, oganzand mobz, o b cav o acua a mov . h h, h . B , dpy mbddd, sucua ways, a chnoogy

o cono sud o h sag o capasm and h, , h . l , hcondons ha nabd o mg and oush.

gioVanni tiso

7/27/2019 TNI 5 Spies

74/127

74

Any cqu o hos condons ncudng ha gobazaon ha maks possb o souc,, v h h hh

h h hvo b nohng ss han a cqu o h innand s dsncv and mmnsy powu socaconguaons.

under our skin

7/27/2019 TNI 5 Spies

75/127

7/27/2019 TNI 5 Spies

76/127

76

Ou Man in Ga Nckby

DANNY PeNNY

An Amcan gandpan cas nang hSov Unon dsgusd as an odnay ous

om long isand

S h , v h KGB h. H h h , h, h, q h N h

a young man wa h day bo. T KGB agnnaowd hs ys and an hs ongu ov hs

h, h h h hsquaks o h suspcs cha h mpy oom.

Some o he names in his piece are real (hose o my

grandparens, a well-known acivis, and a celebriy).

Ohers have been changed o proec he privacy o

individuas wh wr invvd bu wh a n wan

o be named.

7/27/2019 TNI 5 Spies

77/127

77

Y q h , h . H h vs sng on hs dsk and adjusd h scn so

h h h . D h v ? h hV . S h h h .

A mdd-agd coup maazd on h scn.T h h h

no om h USSr. Do you cognz h wo h v? S h h h, . A h ?h man pssd. H spa hs wods ou as hy

h h h. T Mand Hn Cohn, known Zons sps, h sad.You hav bn codd assocang wh hm.

H pond o h V scn, hs ng appng

h h h. h abou hm and you mgh no go o pson.

M h h h . T h h boh o a usnk sh and my gandahhad m n h Sov Unon. Mo han 20 yas

a, hy ound hmsvs shang a ab whSg a h ba mzvah o som muua ndsgandchd. Tyd had a on hm and vyonh knw, a bnd o gany xoxs d wh h h h

danny penny

7/27/2019 TNI 5 Spies

78/127

78

whod bn usd x om h Sov Unonbcaus hy w Jwsh, o dssdns, o boh.Som had bn sn o pson camps n Sba;

h v, hh , h by a spawng, sa appaaus a dab, yowog stng ov h vs. Ts pop wdspa o av, bu w w v aowd. inJun 1982, my gandpans, Muay and Hn

Cohn, avd o h Sov Unon as pa o a

sc msson hadd by h Ga Nck chapo h long isand Comm o Sov Jwy n

our man in great neck

7/27/2019 TNI 5 Spies

79/127

79

Jws ampng o av russa.

A w yas ago, my gandmoh movd wh my h h h G N, hhom bas o h Sov opaons, o h oncswngng and now mosy wak-pushng Noh

Sh . Wh h , gandma mmday hands m a Gk yogu,

and wh a spoon n my mouh, w s hough

sacks o a mana nvops d wh bnds,h-, hp/msson.

My gandma xpans how sh s had on oh -, h l S, va spch dung a Shabba svc a h mp.T oganzaon atacd h bcaus whn sh

and my gandpa jond, hy w spcvy hscond and hd mmbs. i ddn wan o bpa o somhng wh h scay sood up h hn vybody vod on hs masu o ha,sh xpand. i w dcdd w wand o dosomhng, i wand o b ab o do , no spnda day dbang . My gandmoh ngcso mnon som o h oh psona asonsbhnd h p. A h m, sh and my moh h hh h, h h

danny penny

7/27/2019 TNI 5 Spies

80/127

7/27/2019 TNI 5 Spies

81/127

81

dscbd as sma o a homss Jsus. A h

sam m, my unc was jus sang o com ouo h cos, a pocss my gandah usd o

acknowdg, ay wakng ou o h oom oun an and whn my unc atmpd h ak.

T ns was no my mpy, was ban.Wh my gandmoh woud nv connc h

sand aonshps wh h chdn o h h Sv U, h h o h cahxs s woh mnonng. Who b

h h h h Jhpopuaon o h Sov Unon?

T pan was avy smp: my gandpanswoud go on a gua ou o h Sov Unon, v r U.Dung h day, hy woud pnd o b jus kv , h h

wh pop who h oganzaon had aadyconacd n od o dsbu h ms hydh. , o an a w ky phass n russan, whch mygandmoh conssny d o as hcyc anguag whn i akd o h. Howv,hs ppaaon und ou o b py basc, and

o much o h p, hy d upon usnkansaos and h handu o snncs hydmmozd. Ty w no CiA maa.

danny penny

7/27/2019 TNI 5 Spies

82/127

82

Unamiliar Customs

We were requesed o bring in quie a ew hings ino

h Svi Unin: n an wand a shrwav radi,one man waned a book by Henry Kissinger, anoher

wand a hrah bk. As ca u, h

brough he requess o reuseniks who were sill here,

and we ried o ollow hrough.

So when we arrived a cusoms o leave he U.S., we

decided ha your grandaher and I would go on

dieren lines. My valise was packed so ha i lookedcasua, bu crain hins wr hiddn i cuss sard

o open i up. Well, I go hrough my line and I me

our group a he oher end. And Grandpa, hey open

his valise and he rs hing hey see is a big book by

Kissinger and hey didn undersand, so hey said,

Wh d u hav his bk? I ik rad, h sas.

And wh d u hav a shrwav radi? Bcaus Iwan o hear he news om he Unied Saes.

Bu he crme de resisance was when hey opened

hrah bk and saw icurs nud wn

ha was i. So hey kep him here, quesioning him

a good 10 or 15 minues, while I was already on he

oher side. And my group leader said o me, Who is

ha person? and I said, I have no idea.

Moscow Mule

Dung h wks o oow, my gandpans sawh h A


7/27/2019 TNI 5 Spies

83/127

83

coup on vacaon, akng snapshos o Moscowou h wndow o h ou bus. o ngaahmsvs o h ou guds and ho cks,

hy usd h Poaod cama, a novy manyo h russans had nv sn. is nsan magcsond vn h sons acs. Ty wn o hmaks, admd h vws, and d o a hood k vyon s, bu n h vnng, hyvd anoh .

I had n hs L Sac bas which xandd, and in

ha ba, I carrid bu jans, wns anhs, and

oher hings o sell on he black marke. A pair o blue

jans cud k a ai in, I hink, r six nhs

a ha ime. And so when we le he room, we ook

wih us hese bags we acually looked like hobos.

We didn alk in he rooms abou anyhing ha was

paricularly dangerous because all he rooms werebugged. In ac, here were ligh swiches ha didn

urn on lighs. We knew somehing was wrong. And

we would no make any ouside calls while we were in

he room.

W had av ur assrs a h n dsk, huh

we carried xeroxes wed made in he U.S. and when

we le he hoel, we would give he key lady our key . . .Te key ladies were he mos suspicious people o all

because we never wen ou wih he oher people in

he group in he evening. Bu because he bureaucracy

was so awul in each area, nobody bohered o alk o

danny penny

7/27/2019 TNI 5 Spies

84/127

84

ic in h win ara. W wr incn, and

so were hey. When we go ou o he room, we walked

dwn w bcks r s, and w usd a ubic hn

and called somebody and old hem we were coming.

I remember we used a dime, which was equivalen o

he size o a kopeck.

o hail a cab, your grandaher held up eiher a pack

o Camels or Philip Morris cigaretes because his wasa very desirable hing o have. And all o a sudden,

cabs zoomed in om all over, when you jus held up

somehing like ha. We would wrie he addresses on

litle bis o paper hey were really less han he


7/27/2019 TNI 5 Spies

85/127

85

wrain a ciar and w wud hid i in h

h ur chs. W in h cab and r h ar

in hal and gave he driver he cyrillic insrucions.

Whn w arrivd a h addrss, ur randahr wud

si in h cab, and I wud u hs buidins and

I would have o ask somebody in he cyrillic language,

Where is so and so? I only knew a ew senences. Soha was par o our raining, which was really inep;

we bungled along like Peer Sellers, bu we wen. We

danny penny

7/27/2019 TNI 5 Spies

86/127

86

also developed codes or everybody ha we saw, and I

developed so many codes ha I orgo wha he codes

sood or.

Ida and the Orange

On n ur frs nihs, w wr a Lv Bchshins

aarn wih a , and w wr ivin awa

whavr w had in ur knasack. W av anhs,

ea, coee coee was very difcul o ge in hose

das. Evn in h h, u n n i di-cu

o coee no rells.

And while we were here, Ida Nudel arrived. She was

really he vanguard or people who waned o ge ou

o he Sovie Union. She had hung up a banner on her

windw ha rad Let my people go! and bcaus

ha, she was sen o a Siberian prison camp or years.

She slep wih an ax under her pillow because here

wr wid ds, hivs, raiss, and cu hras. Bu sh

knw ha w wr cin, s sh anad shw

arrange o ge o Levs place.

A h bgnnng o h p, my gandpans hada ayov n Fnand, wh my gandmoh had

cvd a nav oang om h an. Sh had

sowd n h knapsack o a and ogotnabou , ony mmbng whn sh saw lvpac. Sh shd h oang ou and ossd oida Nud wh t cmony. ida handd h


7/27/2019 TNI 5 Spies

87/127

7/27/2019 TNI 5 Spies

88/127

88

, v h, skn, squzng n h pam. Sh cackd h sa h h h h

h. Ao my gandmoh, Sh hadn sn an oang n

yas, so hy ook a Poaod o ida Nud usng

a kn o p h oang, ph ha-xposd and achdk gn cpng acoss h nomay socac. My gandpans amd an nagd copy oh phoo and kp pomnny posond on

h bookcas o yas.

Tis was a ruar uris ri in h Svi Unin and

we were old o ry and make iends wih somebody

who didn know wha we were doing. And we made

iends wih his couple who held up he our one

rnin bcaus h wr arrsd. T ic huh

hey were rying o buy icons, which was very illegal.

When we were wih Lev, we ook he rain o visi

sbd, and h KGB was win us a ha i. A

an ca u us and askd us in h criic anua

which sccr a w rrrd bcaus h Wrd Cu

was in n a ha i. And Lv knw w wr bin

inrviwd and h said, Lav h an; h dn

like soccer.

I know ha when we wen ou early in he morning

once, we were ollowed. We sopped a a sore window

and he person who was ollowing he was maybe

30 ee away sopped a a sore window and he


7/27/2019 TNI 5 Spies

89/127

89

looked in. I happened a ew imes, we would o look

in a window, and hen hed have o sop, oo. I said o

your grandaher, Were being ollowed.

White Nights

Te las place we wen o was Leningrad, which was

never dark. I was ligh pracically 23 hours a day.

And your grandaher was very happy; he sared o

ear up all he papers o people we me and fush hem

down he oile.

My gandmoh says vy happy h, bu sh

h j .Th h , h v , v h . Hv, h vxpncd wha hs docos a dagnosd as a , h h hz h h h h USSr.

I helped him acually. He was absoluely earless. He

was he impeus ha propelled us on because I was a

i bi cncrnd. And h said Dn wrr, and wr

going o go here, and were going o go here, and he

ore his [piece o paper] up ... He had an enormous

aun nr. T n cncrn I did hav was hasomeimes, he was a very alkaive. Ta was par o

he illness.

danny penny

7/27/2019 TNI 5 Spies

90/127

7/27/2019 TNI 5 Spies

91/127

91

My gandmoh ddn go no any da, bu mymoh a cound a soy my gandpansod h whn hy und. in lnngad, my

h h , , anon. Sandng n a cowdd vao wh mygandmoh, my gandah bgan o ak abouh pans o m somon a ha ngh. Myh h h h h h , h

woudn b dd. in a as dch o, mygandmoh yd ov hm, Muay, a youhirsy? Do you wan a dnk?! Ts phas wassupposd o b cod o Sop akng abou scspy su! whch mus hav smd somwhaobvous o h many oh pop packd no hsway vao compamn. Wh woud h

dnk my gandma od com om?Exodus

When we came back, he phoographers were here,

and I was very inexperienced and naive. And Lee [he

rsidn h Ln Isand Ci n Svi Jwr]

whisrd in ar, Yur i wi c, and ushd

me ou o he way and le he phoographers ake her

picure. So I learned a lo on my rip, and I learned a

lo coming back, oo.

danny penny

7/27/2019 TNI 5 Spies

92/127

7/27/2019 TNI 5 Spies

93/127

7/27/2019 TNI 5 Spies

94/127

94

Te Guardian Angel

My gandmoh and i wap up ou nvw,

chatng abou h amy and ang hough hsacks o maas sh and my gandah sm-

achvd a h p. Ts s how i com acossh an od abd, Muays Assgnmnn whch i nd a xox o an ac cppd oma nwspap. T s n ads, Sov Jwshv N h 53 h

h Mv hrussa and acss Jan Fonda was h sups h. M h hh 1984. way hough h documns: vaous cops andognas and o ts and acs on h long C Sv J, vo h po my gandpans wo up dang

h v, h o Fonda a adng abou h advocacy o idaNud. H opns wh a w paagaphs abou mygandpans m n h USSr and h ownmng wh Nud. Tn n h hd paagaphh ws, Wd umos w bng ccuadha you pannd o mak a mov, Te Guardian

An, h v h dung h Sban x. O cous, w xpcd

h , h h gan wod wd atnon. H nds h t by

h h l.A. ,


7/27/2019 TNI 5 Spies

95/127

7/27/2019 TNI 5 Spies

96/127

96

ha h woud k o m somwh and dscussh muua ns n Sov Jwy and ponam possbs.

No on v mad a mov wh Jan Fonda as idaNud, no hav my gandpans xpos bnopond o a uu bockbus, hough myh h

hv h Ga Nck.


7/27/2019 TNI 5 Spies

97/127

7/27/2019 TNI 5 Spies

98/127

98

excp om Te ZoneBy

MAHiAS NArD

Translated by

CHArlOte MANDell

i saw my savaon n h bauu cysah h Q O, h vo pnponas, n h dak bu o dpomac, h -h h , h h v h A ChB S, hh va o m, vn aacv, spakng, n ac, n hha o h wod, wh h hghs saas n a

h cv svc, wh chauus, cpons, and

h v hv hh ,Mauana, Guna-Bssau, Congo, Bhuan, so iocd mys o an, o an o hs absusss, aw, synhss, hsoy, God knows wha s,

h , v h

Cousy o Opn l Books

7/27/2019 TNI 5 Spies

99/127

99

dubous sodng pas, o smpy bcaus my ssus wn up o ha psgous mnsy h

, , h h a, an hons oa psnaon, and my hugdsapponmn sms o m oday, n yas a,n mans sa, n hs an o h Vacan, had oundsand: i coudn s wha hundng Zus

was savng o m, a a n a much mo obscuadmnsaon han Fogn Aas, on h

Bv M, M h h suvvo o a h Napoonc campagns whhy mpoyd m, agans a xpcaons, as , h h vxam dcay wodd , and i suppos hhundd canddas psn n ha absouycommonpac xam oom a knw wha dns

dga man, o a as hy hough hy dd,nomaon agn, mo o ss sc agn, anagn mo o ss om ousd, o acon wasn v ,an xam pty much dnca o h on o h, S Sv, h Nv C,and as Pama sds by h wndow i s agan my h Bv, h , h ,h sang ua-scu budng, whou a comachn so as no o ncouag d convsaon h , , ,ndss s, dozns o s o go hough on by

mathias enard

7/27/2019 TNI 5 Spies

100/127

100

, hz, , h h , o anoh, und such-o-such a sunam spodn pos comng om saons o h , , h , , h o h naon, n h shadows, n h shadow o a

sack o mana ods, and my ony gogaphcxps had obvousy bn gnod n pusmay ogc, no Bakans o m, no Savs: i was

h h A hh h, Gh , h q B hv h , h A h Ch C hh , h-h mass-muds wh nams ha w a ak om, n h madnss o h 1990s h snch o

mdva wa, dsmbowmns, ampuaons, vh, h , , v , hbands, and God, God vywh o cono h h, h h cs and hams, Bda, Mda, vcousy, ibgan wh svn dcapad monks hads svnd oss h ys ha-opn ono h advancd h h M 21, 1996 hh h bgnnng o my wo Agan yas a hBouvad Mo, h masha wh h ong h h J r,

the zone

7/27/2019 TNI 5 Spies

101/127

101

mayb h had dcapad obd monks, womn,

chdn, n h mpa som, vy monng ihough o hm, o hs unom, hs pauts as i

wn o my ua-scu hdaway o da wh mys, n h havy gy amosph o ha wod osccy wh i ad my pos o hoa-sngsand may opaons whou undsandng a, h , no h Zon whou passon bu aso whoudsgus, wh an ncasng cuosy abou h

dangs o h wahu gods, pany n myamod n i guadd h hoow vsss, idndd Aga om s n h daknss, and

jus awads, as i ook h mo, whn i wn

h r C, Mon h bouvad paqu, my guadan ang,knowng ha i was vy ky bng oowd and

obsvd by my own coagus who had o mak , hh vsvan an, bgnnng spy ha i was no nh pay o ogn naons o God knows whaxms movmn, i coud vy hs cny

h , , h h v , mo, a dd-ou , a a n an nomaonhbaum, das pacs nams suspconspsychoogca ouns aonshps guy o noamy assssmn o h cas oc and so on upo cods ncs addons casscaons

mathias enard

7/27/2019 TNI 5 Spies

102/127

102

assgnmns vaous nos absncs quss oav k hos ha d m o Ahns passnghh P h A

hoo and h dad monks hy had dumpd onm so i coud achv h massac ou o sgh soi coud gv a pausb vson o h ncdb h A , P i had dnn h no a om h bapsy andh cahda, hnkng abou h Fans amyduks o Pama and Pacnza, abou Ma lous

h , v A Co anyhng havng o do wh wa, xcp o h

py o a sang monk, Ghado Sga bun h q 1300, h vpovy o whom wasn a sn o down nakdnx o a woman whou bng mad, and oh, S v h

aposoc ov, povy gnosy and h casss , h P hh h q ho hm haud hm n o qusonng and dcddo condmn hm o h sak, Sga dd no ah, h hh h h h Chhwas on o h sgns o h nd o days, ha hy

w a gong o d, a h pas h bshopsh h, h h hSga scamd, o h ga dgh o hspcaos, hs had ono hs chs, hs body

bund o a ong m, atachd o h pos, hn

the zone

7/27/2019 TNI 5 Spies

103/127

103

h wo xcuons bok hs bons n h s-

smokng ogs, hw hs ha-cabonzd mbs onop o ach oh n a p and covd hm whanoh bach o wood, akng ca o savag h h h v h h h bun compy, hn h nx monng, onc hman was compy ducd o ashs, onc hy

w su ha Ghado Sga coud no ong h h h D

o Judgmn, h wo sns vgs scad hs h P rv, h q hh na Chuch had oud h monk whoh h h , , h v h

a y n Ba o s h Acopos bo osngmys n h sands, ang squd saad and ambkbabs, n h ha o h vnng, h cons

o h shng amps on h Agan and id happygo and og mys n h wndy wn o hCycads now chang ans n Boogna go back oBa cus o Abana o go o Scy sand o hnd o h wod s down n h Gk ha n

aomna and wach h bay o Naxos bah hhsds, bu i hav o nsh h sa hand ov hsucas say n rom o Sashka wh h angcsm mak my as hy say wh h pc o

mathias enard

7/27/2019 TNI 5 Spies

104/127

104

ason whch sn much h mony accumuad , vh o my mans nsh my sha o xsnc av

ans jounys movmn n gna sn o h h, h o advnu whou advnu s soucs v h h ha connuay m and m agan, an acks,ascs o spas, s wh bayons jond, ascs

, h h h

whos axs dcapad hm, hos sam ascsom whch Musson woud mak hs and hsmps mbm, h wod suoundd by spks , vh: Mo n Pama, i chck up on mys k my soucson h Bouvad Mo, and ysday, dyng

h

hh P h , v v h h, h h o pap cps i hough o a h nams i had h h h s o aboad h ong s o hos i had obsvd h j v h n hs oppssvy ho an ca, h cosswodnhusas and hs w, i coud o hm mydconay o h puzzs hy wn iaan,

my nghbo h Pono ad, n on o m hh , , , h

the zone

7/27/2019 TNI 5 Spies

105/127

105

on boy scous o somhng sma wh scavs h h, h h ys cosd, a possona hab mayb, whn h

s hng hy ach you, n a spys anng, s h v h h

you, h hoy o h buty n, sad mynsuco, you hav o b anspan nvsb h , a sabshmns o gh-had and usuay

bucoc buty huns, whch gay amusd

Sashka h s m sh askd m my posson,im an nomoogs, a naua hsoan, a huno nscs i sad, sh pd aughng ha i ddn

hav h bud

mathias enard

7/27/2019 TNI 5 Spies

106/127

7/27/2019 TNI 5 Spies

107/127

107

engma Dvaonsby

MAX FOX

Codbak and ponng compuscns Aan ungs and dah usa

how sps on h nd o ncyp hpsona vs

wo yas ago, Gah Wams was ound nakdand dcomposng, padockd nsd a du

bag n h bahoom o hs london apamn.H had bn mpoyd as a codbak o hGovnmn Communcaons Hadquas(B NSA ), h h h Singnc Svc m wh h commsson

o h Mopoan Poc bo nvsgaonsno hs dah bgan o nsu ha any o hsnsv maas hd had accss o woudn bcompomsd. T nvsgaon was nsad.

7/27/2019 TNI 5 Spies

108/127

108

Myss mgd and mand myss. Who h h ? Wh h hh h h? Wh -h

womans wg was ha? Why was hs apamnunusuay can o ngpns? Why was hs haon n Augus? Why dd hs ow spooks a Mi5

h h ? A -v h h h hand oh qusons.

T dcv assgnd o Wamss cas wasbad om dcy qusonng hs co-woksas wnsss o suspcs. Sh nsad had o yon scuy-cad counosm ocs oquson hm o h. T Guardian pos ha

SO15 [-] , h homcd command, nvwd SiS wnsss,n h psnc o h n manags and ga

v, ,swon, vbam samns, SO15 poducdanonymzd nos, dawn up a h nvw.

T h h a ow oc, dnd n cou ony as F, who

nay nod h poc ha Wams had bn . A h : q h , [F] h h j h h o do, and was uncan abou how h had aknh , N W h rah. T

max fox

7/27/2019 TNI 5 Spies

109/127

109

mpcaon was obvous. Wams was supposdo hav kd hms.

T scond n o spcuaon, ncopoang h , h , W h, h : subspy snuffed out in sick sex game gone wong.T W h vconmd by hs andady, whod had o un hm h . C

bough n o suppo hs on. Who was h gongo gv h 20,000 o womns dsgn cohsn hs apamn o, anyway, sng as h had nonds a wok and no known omanc nss,ma o ma?

Wamss amy, o h pa, suspcs h dak h , v

hav com oh o assu h gvng Wamssh h r h hv a cyph such as h son o hs pocvs and

backmad, hn mnad hm. Ta, o hsv , hSiS woud hav had o do hmsvs.

Whav h dc caus o Wamss dah, h

h wh h as o wo oh qus wh hgh-v

scuy caancs, and y on cognzab and

-. T h q h

enigma deViations

7/27/2019 TNI 5 Spies

110/127

110

pojc s, occupd as s wh maon and

h nma das o oh mns vs. Bu has h h h h -

ps s-knowdg and s-dscosu. is h n- inn a honypo ap, wh h machnshmsvs a spyng on us n od o an ousoca mos and umay pass hmsvs o asus? T as o vaous qu nods n h suv- h h v

way, byond ha o h shad ogn.

A h h h hwh hs moh n 1954. Foh aound hs mouh,a bn app by hs bd and jas o cyand n hh v , hh h h,h h h , hav bn an accdn: H was aways so cass.B h , h v v Snw Whiand h Svn Dwarvs h , h had jus os hs pos dong sach wh hGovnmn Communcaons Hadquas,

Gah Wamss pac o mpoy 60 yas a.Fnds bough h soy.

h h h GCHQdung Wod Wa ii, dvsng among oh hngs

max fox

7/27/2019 TNI 5 Spies

111/127

111

h mhod qud o dcyp Gman may

communcaon, and conbung sgncanyo h dvopmn o h dga compu

aong h way. emgng om h opn, jocuahomosxuay o Cambdg Unvsy, ung . A h

, hv, h v h r h h Cambdg Cc, a hgh-cass goup o KGB

agns whn Bans , and h a o Kaus

Fuchs, a nuca scns who passd Manhatan

Pj r, h pcous ngnc a paamoun concn, so hBh v h U.S. scons on mpoyng homosxuas.

Tus whn ung bough a youh back o hshom and ha youh a bough a nd whobugd hm, pong h das o h ncdn

d o a a o goss ndcncy ha was akn - h. Cv

, njcons o wo yas, whch mad hm buxom

and mpon. Mos who knw hm sumsd hahs was a humaon ha umay causd hs. Oh h

h v h h h h h h and a py o som comy young spy.

enigma deViations

7/27/2019 TNI 5 Spies

112/127

112

Th , h h ha h coud compoms snsv ngnc.

B v h. H ho s-dscosu h vound o h pocv h h h h h hom o sx woud hav mad hm a bon. Ts unocd consson maks a b mosns w ak a mak h maks n hs 1950pap Compung Machny and ingnc

as ndcav o hs atud owad subugn gna.

T h v h h , hh

v q h h. vhough on o hs as ncua umphswas a poo o Gds incompnss Tom,

whch coud asy hav d hm o bv n h h, h hAndw Hodgs ws ha ung

had povd ha h was no macuousmachn ha coud sov a mahmaca, h h h vh q , h o h unvsa machn ha coud ak ov

h wok oany machn. And h had agudh h h coud b don by a machn. So h coud

b a sng machn whch, by adng hdscpons o oh machns pacd upon , h qv h

max fox

7/27/2019 TNI 5 Spies

113/127

113

v. A h, hhuman compu. An cc ban!

T amcaons o hs dscovy w wd-h h h . T dc payd a sgncan o n hozng wha

woud b h mod o h dga compu and , h paagaph.

T q, C h h?i bv o b oo manngss o dsvdscusson. Nvhss i bv ha a h h h hv h h h hh . vuh ha no usu pupos s svd byconcang hs bs.

H a wo hngs. Fs, h bvs ha humanbhavo s umay gua nough ha asucny powu compu coud conca sdny as a machn om a human nocuo.Scond, h s unconcnd wh hs guahv h h h h ss no pon n concang . Ts wo posons

h hh hhhas com o guad h bod bwn machnand human ngnc, an ncasngy conodposon wh h dp ngaon o soca mdano how w subjcva ousvs.

enigma deViations

7/27/2019 TNI 5 Spies

114/127

114

T h h h s o dmn whh o no woud b uo say ha machns a capab o ngnc

o hough. T way h dos hs s by unngh quson sghy, so ha hnkng can bascand by h machn payng a vson oa gam as w as a human coud. Ts gam, h , o whch o wo oh pays n a oom apa

om hm o h s a man and whch s a woman by

q hh .On o h wo oh pays s yng o hp h

nogao pck cocy, and h oh s yngo usa h dncaon.

v h , h and ma pays bcom a sng on, assumd

o b human bu ponay machn, whch s

conond by h nogao, unsu whho no sh s addssng an hons o dcuhuman o a machn pogammd o b dcu.ung assums ha h nogao w ask h

possb machn qusons ony a human coudansw (a sma compu woud know no oansw a quson ony a compu woud know),

h pausby bg ncapacy on human-k gounds.

Tus an xchang k h oowng s pu oh.

max fox

7/27/2019 TNI 5 Spies

115/127

115

Q: Pas w m a sonn on h subjc o hFoh Bdg.

A: Coun m ou on hs on. i nv coud wpoy.

Q: Add 34957 o 70764.

A: (P 30 h v )105621.

Q: Do you pay chss?

A: Ys.

Q: hv K K1, h . Y hv K K6 r r1. v. Wh you pay?

A: (A a paus o 15 sconds) r-r8 ma.

T buk o h s o h pap s ddcad o h v o why a machn coud nv pass o a human.T xpanaons vay, bu h oc o hobjcons coms om h ac ha s dpydsabzng o nd ons on qua dscusvoong wh a machn.

O cous, w now do so guay. Spam ma asw as spambos on w accoun o a massvmajoy o mssags sn on h inn. Andwh mos o hs machns vy qucky a h

enigma deViations

7/27/2019 TNI 5 Spies

116/127

116

, @h_ wdspad ascnaon o h poc quay oh amps.

A pobm wh ungs concp o machnngnc, hough, s h so o subjc mgh

. W h v h ? T dpnd on whh o no such xv acvy

s common among humans. Dupcous o pa-hddn subjcs, such as sps o qus, hav onghad o know a hng o wo abou h ngncq h h, hh h by h nd o such cov.

T h

s-dscosu, a ec Schmds i you havsomhng ha you don wan anyon o know,mayb you shoudn b dong n h s pac, h h hhanonymy s umay possb s unsovdoday. Tnk o h dcv nvsgang Gah

Wamss dah, who had o noga hwnsss hough h nmday o coun-osm ocs and cvd ony anonymzd

summas o h sponss n un. Machns h,

max fox

7/27/2019 TNI 5 Spies

117/127

117

h h ha woud s qu humans o ac on .

A agc nsanc o hs yp o daogu mgdwhn Wired magazn pubshd h cha og oh convsaons bwn B. Mannng, h Amypva accusd o passng may and dpomacscs o Wkaks, and Adan lamo, h hack h h h. h h,Mannng as lamo as h nogao, and sh

w b h assumd dcv.(1:40:51 PM) bradass87 has not

been authenticated yet. You should

authenticate this buddy.

(1:40:51 PM) Unveried conversation with

bradass87 started.

(1:41:12 PM) bradass87: hi

(1:44:04 PM) bradass87: how are you?

(1:47:01 PM) bradass87: im an army

intelligence analyst, deployed to

eastern baghdad, pending discharge for

adjustment disorder in lieu of gender

identity disorder

(1:56:24 PM) bradass87: im sure youre

pretty busy

(1:58:31 PM) bradass87: if you had

unprecedented access to classiednetworks 14 hours a day 7 days a week

for 8+ months, what would you do?

(1:58:31 PM) [email protected] : Tired of being tired

enigma deViations

7/27/2019 TNI 5 Spies

118/127

118

(2:17:29 PM) bradass87: ?

(6:07:29 PM) [email protected]: Whats

your MOS?

(3:16:24 AM) bradass87: re: Whats your

MOS? Intelligence Analyst (35F)

(3:16:24 AM) [email protected] : Tired of being tired

easy nough o h machn ns omh human. Bu w know lamos conduc sunuswohy hs h FBi noman who

und Mannng n and Mannngs nd o acondan s pcsy h ason h ngncsvcs d o dsk hmsvs by xpngpvs n ungs m.

A Foucaudan soy coud b od abou h v h s-anspan subjcs o on ha assumdmupy ayd ons, wh nough condnc ns own ongvy o aow o nonsmuanousdscosu o subjcs vy ac. T ong gam, hh h h h , h v h h h h , hh h

unvsa o s capacy o pom any possb v. T gvn pocdu quvan n ms o compungpow.

max fox

And physical, in a coroll

added by David Deut

in 1985

7/27/2019 TNI 5 Spies

119/127

119

T h , hh h vz

a onc poaby consung h soca and . v a ayd and paay dupcous dny o bconnuay xposd and managd.

Mupy ayd and pa-hddn subjcs and anacd nauanss und acu knowdg o

suvanc a h as ha mus b masd , q j, h . h h hv z

hh h v,whn hs hsoy bnds a h ogh?

D h jv mahmacs, ung was nvhss vauang

s uss basd on wha h hough wha on coud h h h . A h h, h hv h Gncompnss homs o manan a vw oh v h by agohm. H ddn, hough, and now humanacvy has bn vasy dgzd.

T v o anonymy a compu aods o hdny o s us s now known o b hadba,gvn ha h ad-basd inn s pdcad pncs no mcs. Bu ay hacks ook

enigma deViations

7/27/2019 TNI 5 Spies

120/127

120

h inn sousy as a so o pos-aca, pos-, v - h h h h . Th h

hv , h h h h . h pac human compus wh dga compus,and ma human compus a ha: compuer

h .

i s Aan ungs cnnay hs monh, and hv h ChD h 10 . H h ho compung and aca ngnc s scu. 2009, G B , h h

h h h h hh hh v hv v. B h and may ngnc whch ungs sxuaypayd spo o s uncons h sam way and

s cachs ohs k hm n s n dsp hpa o aws. ungs conbuons o h wo

ds ncud an umnaon o h own aws, asw as h sang nxus.

max fox

7/27/2019 TNI 5 Spies

121/127

7/27/2019 TNI 5 Spies

122/127

h h h h . has sombody ss pobm. im akng h nd oms. Bu im no akng abou h nd o ms as w

h. T . T h nd, h bg nsh. T as b o h who nchadaa h nd o h day, has wha h sad. i guss im a bwod ha pop mgh ak hs nws as a sgna o

un amuck, and amuck s h as way you wan o un.espcay whn m s s unnng ou.

S , .J , h z .

A sysm s ndd. A s o us sounds a b sn a

h .i coud b jus wha h doom-and-goom docoodd. T hng s hs nw soca sucus, hs

nw moas hav o b cusom-dsgnd. i can hpyou wh ha. Youv go o ca by you onsom, v you nw phosophy. (Fu dscosu: i coud hp you

wh ha, bu h a so many o you and ha woudpu a cmp n my own oun, whch s m o makmo m o mys.)

7/27/2019 TNI 5 Spies

123/127

7/27/2019 TNI 5 Spies

124/127

T z . hv v h. vn Facbook: is aady gvn you whav can gv

; j v h . . A , h v . r. T h N -

v . hv cnus, bu hs go o b a mo m-cn wayo bng good uck o you vag han wakng hough n a coud o vmon powd wh a 13-nch maskw hough you ongu.

S . G hh . T 60 h. D

you own hng, Kp on uckn. evn h Amy hada ga on: B a ha you can b. Pck on ou, us ,you can vn abus has on o h pks o hnd ms.

Hads up o nx monh: As m gs sho and h

wod gs wd, h s no m o pop o havh . Y h . B

. l ! S Cw o cous b gandahd n.

7/27/2019 TNI 5 Spies

125/127

7/27/2019 TNI 5 Spies

126/127

7/27/2019 TNI 5 Spies

127/127

Documents

TNI 5 Spies