Upload
others
View
3
Download
0
Embed Size (px)
Citation preview
UNCLASSIFIED1 of 68 06 MAR 19Raymond E. Rainbolt / 315-772-9636 / [email protected]
TICKS & LYME DISEASEMANAGEMENT
AT FORT DRUM, NYRaymond E. Rainbolt
Natural Resources Branch Environmental Division Directorate of Public Works
UNCLASSIFIED2 of 68 06 MAR 19Raymond E. Rainbolt / 315-772-9636 / [email protected]
TICK MANAGEMENT ON FORT DRUM
A NR perspective on a pest control and public health issue…
UNCLASSIFIED3 of 68 06 MAR 19Raymond E. Rainbolt / 315-772-9636 / [email protected]
TICK MANAGEMENT ON FORT DRUMGoal: To Minimize Tick-Borne Diseases
UNCLASSIFIED4 of 68 06 MAR 19Raymond E. Rainbolt / 315-772-9636 / [email protected]
TICK MANAGEMENT ON FORT DRUMGoal: To Minimize Tick-Borne Diseases
UNCLASSIFIED5 of 68 06 MAR 19Raymond E. Rainbolt / 315-772-9636 / [email protected]
TICK MANAGEMENT ON FORT DRUM
UNCLASSIFIED6 of 68 06 MAR 19Raymond E. Rainbolt / 315-772-9636 / [email protected]
TICK MANAGEMENT ON FORT DRUM
Fort Drum is an active US Army installation and largest training area for Reserve and Guard units in the northeastern US.
UNCLASSIFIED7 of 68 06 MAR 19Raymond E. Rainbolt / 315-772-9636 / [email protected]
TICK MANAGEMENT ON FORT DRUM
“We’re thinking of moving to another part of the country—somewhere between Lyme disease and killer bees.”
UNCLASSIFIED8 of 68 06 MAR 19Raymond E. Rainbolt / 315-772-9636 / [email protected]
TICK MANAGEMENT ON FORT DRUM
1975: “Lyme Arthritis” first identified in Old Lyme, CT1981: Tick Ixodes scapularis (dammini) linked to Lyme Disease1988: In June, wildlife inspected for ticks on Fort Drum—none found
UNCLASSIFIED9 of 68 06 MAR 19Raymond E. Rainbolt / 315-772-9636 / [email protected]
TICK MANAGEMENT ON FORT DRUM
1988: In July, first Fort Drum Soldier diagnosed with Lyme Disease1989: In March, first I. scapularis documented in Schoharie Co.
(further north and inland—outside of Hudson Valley)
UNCLASSIFIED10 of 68 06 MAR 19Raymond E. Rainbolt / 315-772-9636 / [email protected]
TICK MANAGEMENT ON FORT DRUM
1989: In October, first I. scapularis documented in Jefferson Co.1991: In June, first I. scapularis documented on Fort Drum.
UNCLASSIFIED11 of 68 06 MAR 19Raymond E. Rainbolt / 315-772-9636 / [email protected]
TICK MANAGEMENT ON FORT DRUM
1988-1996
UNCLASSIFIED12 of 68 06 MAR 19Raymond E. Rainbolt / 315-772-9636 / [email protected]
TICK MANAGEMENT ON FORT DRUM
Lyme Disease Chronology1998: First person known to contract Lyme Disease in Jefferson Co.
from a local tick.2005: Veterinarians in area noted an increase in canine Lyme
Disease over the past few years.2006: 15 confirmed cases of Lyme Disease in Jefferson Co. –
14 were contracted in the county.
2007: First tick noticed by Cultural Resources staff on Fort Drum.2009: First Cultural Resources technician on Fort Drum treated
for Lyme disease.
2010: 115 confirmed cases of Lyme Disease in Jefferson Co.
2012: 39 embedded ticks on 10 people out of 11 Cultural Resourcesstaff—3 got Lyme disease and 1 hospitalized
UNCLASSIFIED13 of 68 06 MAR 19Raymond E. Rainbolt / 315-772-9636 / [email protected]
TICK MANAGEMENT ON FORT DRUM
UNCLASSIFIED14 of 68 06 MAR 19Raymond E. Rainbolt / 315-772-9636 / [email protected]
TICK MANAGEMENT ON FORT DRUM
Outreach
Small Mammal
Mgmt
Deer Mgmt
Vegetation/ Landscape
Mgmt
UNCLASSIFIED15 of 68 06 MAR 19Raymond E. Rainbolt / 315-772-9636 / [email protected]
TICK MANAGEMENT ON FORT DRUM
Small Mammal/Tick Pilot Project: 2014
1. Ticks?
2. Small mammals?
3. Indicator of small mammal populations as an indicator of Lyme disease?
Conventional Wisdom: Deer Mice & Deciduous Forests
UNCLASSIFIED16 of 68 06 MAR 19Raymond E. Rainbolt / 315-772-9636 / [email protected]
Lyme DiseaseAnaplasmosisRocky Mountain Spotted Fever
TICK MANAGEMENT ON FORT DRUMGoal: To Minimize Tick-Borne Diseases
BabesiosisEhrlichiosisPowassan
Bourbon VirusEtc.Etc.
UNCLASSIFIED17 of 68 06 MAR 19Raymond E. Rainbolt / 315-772-9636 / [email protected]
TICK MANAGEMENT ON FORT DRUMGoal: To Minimize Tick-Borne Diseases
20152010200520001995199019851980197519701905 1955
1975
Lym
e D
isea
se (L
D)
1986
Hum
an M
onoc
ytic
Ehr
lichi
osis
(HM
E)
1994
Hum
an G
ranu
locy
tic A
napl
asm
osis
(HG
A)
1999
Ew
ingi
i ehr
lichi
osis
(EE)
2005
Tid
ewat
er S
potte
d Fe
ver (
TWSF
)20
06 P
anol
a M
ount
ain
Ehrli
chio
sis
(PM
E)
1907
Roc
ky M
ount
ain
Spot
ted
Feve
r (R
MSF
)
1957
Bab
esio
sis
(BA
B)
2009
Ehr
lichi
asp
. Wis
cons
in (E
ML)
2012
Hea
rtla
nd v
irus
(HR
TV)
2013
Bor
relia
miy
amot
oi in
fect
ion
2015
Bor
relia
may
onii
infe
ctio
n 20
16 B
orre
lia b
isse
ttiii
nfec
tion
UNCLASSIFIED18 of 68 06 MAR 19Raymond E. Rainbolt / 315-772-9636 / [email protected]
TICK MANAGEMENT ON FORT DRUMGoal: To Minimize Tick-Borne Diseases
Longhorned TickHaemaphysalis longicornis
UNCLASSIFIED19 of 68 06 MAR 19Raymond E. Rainbolt / 315-772-9636 / [email protected]
UNCLASSIFIED20 of 68 06 MAR 19Raymond E. Rainbolt / 315-772-9636 / [email protected]
UNCLASSIFIED21 of 68 06 MAR 19Raymond E. Rainbolt / 315-772-9636 / [email protected]
FORT DRUM CANTONMENT AREA = SUBURBAN AREA ANYWHERE USA
UNCLASSIFIED22 of 68 06 MAR 19Raymond E. Rainbolt / 315-772-9636 / [email protected]
Small Mammal/Tick Project: 2015-2016
TICK MANAGEMENT ON FORT DRUM
1. Ticks?
2. Small mammals?
3. Mast as an indicator of small mammal populations as an indicator of Lyme disease?
UNCLASSIFIED23 of 68 06 MAR 19Raymond E. Rainbolt / 315-772-9636 / [email protected]
Small Mammal/Tick Project: 2015-2016
TICK MANAGEMENT ON FORT DRUM
UNCLASSIFIED24 of 68 06 MAR 19Raymond E. Rainbolt / 315-772-9636 / [email protected]
Small Mammal/Tick Project: 2015-2016
TICK MANAGEMENT ON FORT DRUM
UNCLASSIFIED25 of 68 06 MAR 19Raymond E. Rainbolt / 315-772-9636 / [email protected]
Small Mammal/Tick Project: 2015-2016
TICK MANAGEMENT ON FORT DRUM
DevelopmentStage
# Total Individuals
# Individualspositive for
B. burgdorferi
% Infection Rate
Adult 711 340 47.8%Nymph 535 97 17.6%
Army Public Health CommandFort Meade, MD
Ben PajacMelissa MillerMeagan Marshall
UNCLASSIFIED26 of 68 06 MAR 19Raymond E. Rainbolt / 315-772-9636 / [email protected]
Small Mammal/Tick Project: 2015-2016
TICK MANAGEMENT ON FORT DRUM
Developed
UNCLASSIFIED27 of 68 06 MAR 19Raymond E. Rainbolt / 315-772-9636 / [email protected]
Small Mammal/Tick Project: 2015-2016
TICK MANAGEMENT ON FORT DRUM
Grassland
UNCLASSIFIED28 of 68 06 MAR 19Raymond E. Rainbolt / 315-772-9636 / [email protected]
Small Mammal/Tick Project: 2015-2016
TICK MANAGEMENT ON FORT DRUM
Shrub
Shrub = Invasive (Buckthorn & Honeysuckle)
UNCLASSIFIED29 of 68 06 MAR 19Raymond E. Rainbolt / 315-772-9636 / [email protected]
Small Mammal/Tick Project: 2015-2016
TICK MANAGEMENT ON FORT DRUM
Deciduous Forest
UNCLASSIFIED30 of 68 06 MAR 19Raymond E. Rainbolt / 315-772-9636 / [email protected]
Small Mammal/Tick Project: 2015-2016
TICK MANAGEMENT ON FORT DRUM
Coniferous Forest
UNCLASSIFIED31 of 68 06 MAR 19Raymond E. Rainbolt / 315-772-9636 / [email protected]
Small Mammal/Tick Project: 2015-2016
TICK MANAGEMENT ON FORT DRUM
Mixed Forest
UNCLASSIFIED32 of 68 06 MAR 19Raymond E. Rainbolt / 315-772-9636 / [email protected]
Small Mammal/Tick Project: 2015-2016
TICK MANAGEMENT ON FORT DRUMLandcover Types
UNCLASSIFIED33 of 68 06 MAR 19Raymond E. Rainbolt / 315-772-9636 / [email protected]
Small Mammal/Tick Project: 2015-2016
TICK MANAGEMENT ON FORT DRUM
UNCLASSIFIED34 of 68 06 MAR 19Raymond E. Rainbolt / 315-772-9636 / [email protected]
Small Mammal/Tick Project: 2015-2016
TICK MANAGEMENT ON FORT DRUMLandcover Types
UNCLASSIFIED35 of 68 06 MAR 19Raymond E. Rainbolt / 315-772-9636 / [email protected]
Small Mammal/Tick Project: 2015-2016
TICK MANAGEMENT ON FORT DRUM
9 different species
UNCLASSIFIED36 of 68 06 MAR 19Raymond E. Rainbolt / 315-772-9636 / [email protected]
Small Mammal/Tick Project: 2015-2016
TICK MANAGEMENT ON FORT DRUM
Species # Total Individuals
% of mammals captured
# Individuals with tick burdens
Deer Mouse 80 38% 46 (58%)
E. Chipmunk 57 27% 19 (33%)
Red Squirrel 34 17% 17 (49%)
Gray Squirrel 20 9% 13 (65%)
TOTAL 191 90% 50%These were the 4 most abundant species and only species with ticks.
UNCLASSIFIED37 of 68 06 MAR 19Raymond E. Rainbolt / 315-772-9636 / [email protected]
Tick Management Project: 2018-2020
TICK MANAGEMENT ON FORT DRUM
?RESERVOIRS?
UNCLASSIFIED38 of 68 06 MAR 19Raymond E. Rainbolt / 315-772-9636 / [email protected]
Tick Management Project: 2018-2020
TICK MANAGEMENT ON FORT DRUM
?RESERVOIRS?
UNCLASSIFIED39 of 68 06 MAR 19Raymond E. Rainbolt / 315-772-9636 / [email protected]
Tick Management Project: 2018-2020
TICK MANAGEMENT ON FORT DRUM
RESERVOIRS?
UNCLASSIFIED40 of 68 06 MAR 19Raymond E. Rainbolt / 315-772-9636 / [email protected]
Tick Management Project: 2018-2020
TICK MANAGEMENT ON FORT DRUM
RESERVOIRS?
Determine species by assessing blood meals from tick stomach cells
UNCLASSIFIED41 of 68 06 MAR 19Raymond E. Rainbolt / 315-772-9636 / [email protected]
TICK MANAGEMENT ON FORT DRUM
Tick Management:
UNCLASSIFIED42 of 68 06 MAR 19Raymond E. Rainbolt / 315-772-9636 / [email protected]
TICK MANAGEMENT ON FORT DRUM
1 3
2 4Outreach
Small Mammal
Mgmt
Deer Mgmt
Vegetation/ Landscape
Mgmt
UNCLASSIFIED43 of 68 06 MAR 19Raymond E. Rainbolt / 315-772-9636 / [email protected]
TICK MANAGEMENT ON FORT DRUM
UNCLASSIFIED44 of 68 06 MAR 19Raymond E. Rainbolt / 315-772-9636 / [email protected]
Cantonment Area Deer Project: 2015-2018
TICK MANAGEMENT ON FORT DRUM
1. Fawn Survivorship?
2. Population?
3. Movement?
UNCLASSIFIED45 of 68 06 MAR 19Raymond E. Rainbolt / 315-772-9636 / [email protected]
TICK MANAGEMENT ON FORT DRUMA fawn from June 2016 was seen on a trail camera 121 miles from Fort Drum in Feb 2018.
UNCLASSIFIED46 of 68 06 MAR 19Raymond E. Rainbolt / 315-772-9636 / [email protected]
TICK MANAGEMENT ON FORT DRUMFort Drum is only 318 miles from Lyme, CT.
UNCLASSIFIED47 of 68 06 MAR 19Raymond E. Rainbolt / 315-772-9636 / [email protected]
Survival to 1 Year: 0.54
TICK MANAGEMENT ON FORT DRUM
Cantonment Area Deer Project: 2015-2018
UNCLASSIFIED48 of 68 06 MAR 19Raymond E. Rainbolt / 315-772-9636 / [email protected]
18 Mar – 01 Apr 201840 deer/mile2
TICK MANAGEMENT ON FORT DRUM
Cantonment Area Deer Project: 2015-2018
UNCLASSIFIED49 of 68 06 MAR 19Raymond E. Rainbolt / 315-772-9636 / [email protected]
18 Mar – 01 Apr 2018Up to 150 deer/mile2
UNCLASSIFIED50 of 68 06 MAR 19Raymond E. Rainbolt / 315-772-9636 / [email protected]
Cantonment Area Deer Management
DEER DENSITIESCurrent: 40 deer/mile2
Forest Regeneration: 17-20 deer/mile2
Tick Reduction: 7-9 deer/mile2 ?
TICK MANAGEMENT ON FORT DRUM
UNCLASSIFIED51 of 68 06 MAR 19Raymond E. Rainbolt / 315-772-9636 / [email protected]
Lethal control by
USDA-APHIS-WSØ Non-huntable/Residential/Administrative Areas (65%)
Continue camera surveys & tracking deer movements.
Cantonment Area Deer Management
Ø Huntable/Less Developed Areas (35%) Recreational Hunting
Ø Monitor Effectiveness
Methods
Nuisance Deer Permits
Deer Management Area
Program Permits (DMAPs)
Expanding # tick transects.
Fort Drum Natural Resources
Continue monitoring deer browse & exclosures.
TICK MANAGEMENT ON FORT DRUM
UNCLASSIFIED52 of 68 06 MAR 19Raymond E. Rainbolt / 315-772-9636 / [email protected]
September 2018 (3 nights): 87 deerFeb 2019 (3 nights): 73 deerMar-Apr 2019: TBD
Ø Non-huntable/Residential/Administrative Areas (65%)
Cantonment Area Deer Management
Ø Huntable/Less Developed Areas (35%)
Recreational HuntingMethods
TICK MANAGEMENT ON FORT DRUM
27 Sep – 09 Dec 2018 (74 days): 87 deer
Lethal control by USDA-APHIS-WS
UNCLASSIFIED53 of 68 06 MAR 19Raymond E. Rainbolt / 315-772-9636 / [email protected]
TICK MANAGEMENT ON FORT DRUM
QUESTIONS?