The Plant Cell, Vol. 30: 1476–1495, July 2018, www.plantcell.org © 2018 ASPB.

INTRODUCTION

The plastid family of organelles develops primarily from proplas-tids in meristem cells (Waters and Langdale, 2009; Charuvi et al., 2012). Proplastids give rise to three subclasses of plastids: the pregranal plastids and etioplasts that serve as precursors forms of chloroplasts; the amyloplasts, elaioplasts, and leucoplasts that develop directly from proplastids; and the chromoplasts that can develop from either proplastids or chloroplasts (Jarvis and López-Juez, 2013; Staehelin, 2015). Each plastid type has unique structural and functional attributes with the chloroplasts being the most prominent due to their distinctive green color and their role in capturing sunlight to produce carbohydrates and molecular oxygen, upon which essentially all life depends.

Each chloroplast is delineated by two envelope membranes that surround an aqueous matrix, the stroma, and a complex 3D network of membranes termed thylakoids. The thylakoids form a continuous chamber, the thylakoid lumen, and are organized into two structural domains: the disc-shaped, stacked grana thyla-koids and the interconnecting, nonstacked stroma thylakoids (Austin and Staehelin, 2011). They harbor the functional com-plexes that trap and convert the sun’s energy into high-energy electrons and transmembrane proton gradients, which generate NADPH, ATP, and O2. The protein complexes that perform these functions are photosystems I and II (PSI and PSII), light-harvesting complex II (LHCII), cytochrome b6f (cyt b6f), and ATP synthase (Nevo et al., 2012; Garab, 2014). The structural differentiation of the thylakoids results from a nonuniform distribution of these complexes between grana and stroma thylakoids. Thus, most PSII and LHCII complexes are lo-cated in grana thylakoids and most PSI and all ATP synthases in stroma thylakoids. In contrast, the cyt b6f complexes are found in similar amounts in grana and stroma thylakoids (Staehelin, 2003; Pribil et al., 2014). The physical parameters of the complexes that lead to the formation of stacked grana membranes and to the confinement of other complexes to stroma membranes have

Thylakoid-Bound Polysomes and a Dynamin-Related Protein, FZL, Mediate Critical Stages of the Linear Chloroplast Biogenesis Program in Greening Arabidopsis Cotyledons[OPEN]

Zizhen Liang,a,1 Ning Zhu,a,1 Keith K. Mai,a Zhongyuna Liu,a David Tzeng,a Katherine W. Osteryoung,b Silin Zhong,a L. Andrew Staehelin,c and Byung-Ho Kanga,d,2

aCentre for Cell and Developmental Biology, State Key Laboratory for Agrobiotechnology, School of Life Sciences, The Chinese University of Hong Kong, Shatin, New Territories, Hong Kong, ChinabDepartment of Plant Biology, Michigan State University, East Lansing, Michigan 48824cMolecular Cellular and Developmental Biology, University of Colorado, Boulder, Colorado 80306dMicrobiology and Cell Science, University of Florida, Gainesville, Florida 32611

ORCID IDs: 0000-0002-8622-0674 (Z.L.); 0000-0003-3636-1150 (N.Z.); 0000-0002-0264-7807 (K.K.M.); 0000-0003-3679-3842 (Z.Y.L.); 0000-0001-7345-6533 (D.T.); 0000-0002-0028-2509 (K.W.O.); 0000-0002-0198-7383 (S.Z.); 0000-0002-0611-4346 (L.A.S.); 0000-0002-4299-2170 (B.-H.K.)

Biogenesis of the complex 3D architecture of plant thylakoids remains an unsolved problem. Here, we analyzed this process in chloroplasts of germinating Arabidopsis thaliana cotyledons using 3D electron microscopy and gene expression analyses of chloroplast proteins. Our study identified a linear developmental sequence with five assembly stages: tubulo-vesicular prothylakoids (24 h after imbibition [HAI]), sheet-like pregranal thylakoids that develop from the prothylakoids (36 HAI), pro-liferation of pro-grana stacks with wide tubular connections to the originating pregrana thylakoids (60 HAI), structural differ-entiation of pro-grana stacks and expanded stroma thylakoids (84 HAI), and conversion of the pro-grana stacks into mature grana stacks (120 HAI). Development of the planar pregranal thylakoids and the pro-grana membrane stacks coincides with the appearance of thylakoid-bound polysomes and photosystem II complex subunits at 36 HAI. ATP synthase, cytochrome b6f, and light-harvesting complex II proteins are detected at 60 HAI, while PSI proteins and the curvature-inducing CURT1A protein appear at 84 HAI. If stromal ribosome biogenesis is delayed, prothylakoids accumulate until stromal ribosomes are produced, and grana-forming thylakoids develop after polysomes bind to the thylakoid membranes. In fzo-like (fzl) mutants, in which thylakoid organization is perturbed, pro-grana stacks in cotyledons form discrete, spiral membrane compartments instead of organelle-wide membrane networks, suggesting that FZL is involved in fusing membrane compartments together. Our data demonstrate that the assembly of thylakoid protein complexes, CURT1 proteins, and FZL proteins mediate distinct and critical steps in thylakoid biogenesis.

1These authors contributed equally to this work.2Address correspondence to bkang@cuhk.edu.hk.The author responsible for distribution of materials integral to the findings presented in this article in accordance with the policy described in the Instructions for Authors (www.plantcell.org) is: Byung-Ho Kang (bkang@cuhk.edu.hk).[OPEN]Articles can be viewed without a subscription.www.plantcell.org/cgi/doi/10.1105/tpc.17.00972

CM

Electron Tomography of Thylakoid Assembly 1477

been the subject of many studies. They also play a major role in defining the process of chloroplast biogenesis and development from nonphotosynthetic plastids, the focus of this study (Daum and Kühlbrandt, 2011; Kouřil et al., 2011; Pogson et al., 2015; Rast et al., 2015). Virtually all recent advances in our understanding of thylakoid architecture and the structural basis of thylakoid dynamics have come from studies of cryofixed cells. The advantages of cry-ofixation methods such as high-pressure freezing over chemi-cal fixation methods have been known since the 1980s (Gilkey and Staehelin, 1986). Indeed, the use of cryofixation methods in membrane studies has been shown to be of critical importance because the quality of the initial specimen preservation deter-mines the quality of the final electron micrographic and elec-tron tomography data. For example, cryofixation immobilizes all cellular molecules, including proteins, lipids, salts, and water, simultaneously within ∼1 ms compared with the partial stabi-lization of only certain types of cellular molecules by chemical cross-linking agents that takes minutes and can trigger artifac-tual membrane vesiculation. In cells subsequently processed via freeze substitution, both dehydration-related structural chang-es and the extraction of lipids and solutes are greatly reduced (Shimoni et al., 2005; Austin et al., 2006; Staehelin and Kang, 2008; Charuvi et al., 2012). More recently developed cryo techniques involve direct visualization of the frozen samples in the electron microscope (Daum et al., 2010; Engel et al., 2015). Most notably, the images produced by Engel et al. (2015) using cryo-electron tomography imaging of cryo-focused ion beam milled, vitreous Chlamydomonas reinhardtii cells are trendsetting in the clarity with which the structural details of both chloroplast envelope and thylakoid membranes are seen.

Studies of the 3D architecture of thylakoids by means of se-rial section electron microscopy of chemically fixed cells in the 1960s culminated in the formulation of the “helical model” of thylakoid architecture as formulated by Paolillo (1970). In the helical model, the individual grana stacks are connected through evenly spaced stroma thylakoids that wind around the stacks as right-handed helices and connect to the individual grana cis-ternae via narrow, tubular membrane junctions (Mustárdy and Garab, 2003). This model has been validated by means of elec-tron tomography analysis of thylakoids preserved by cryofixation methods (Austin and Staehelin, 2011; Daum and Kühlbrandt, 2011). An important structural feature of thylakoids uncovered in specimens preserved by cryofixation methods includes the demonstration that plastoglobules contain biosynthetic enzymes and are attached to thylakoids through a half-bilayer that encom-passes the globule contents and is continuous with the thyla-koid membrane via blister-like outgrowths of the stroma-side leaflet of the membrane bilayer (Austin et al., 2006). Cryofixed specimens have also shown that exposure to light changes the volume of the thylakoid lumen (Kirchhoff et al., 2011). Most re-cently, studies of cryofixed cells have provided clear evidence for distinct contact sites between thylakoid margins and the in-ner chloroplast envelope membrane both in Arabidopsis thaliana shoot apical meristem and in Chlamydomonas cells (Charuvi et al., 2012; Engel et al., 2015). Although the above-mentioned studies have contributed much to our understanding of thylakoid architecture, they have provid-ed few insights into how the elaborate architecture of thylakoids arises during the transformation of proplastids into chloroplasts. Charuvi et al. (2012) examined plastid-to-chloroplast conversion in the shoot apical meristem with electron tomography to determine

1478 The Plant Cell

thylakoid structures of young leaf cells and to uncover that thyla-koids can either elaborate or degrade in differentiating leaf cells depending the origin of the cells. When a seed germinates un-derground, its proplastids first develop into etioplasts that con-tain prolamellar bodies (PLBs) and prothylakoid membranes that are continuous with and extend from marginal PLB tubules into the stroma (Weier et al., 1970). PLBs are paracrystalline bodies of chloroplast lipids (mostly mono- and digalactolipids), proto-chlorophyllide, and the light-dependent enzyme complex pro-tochlorophyllide oxidoreductase (Ryberg and Sundqvist, 1982; Selstam et al., 2007; Solymosi and Schoefs, 2010). Upon expo-sure to light and the resulting conversion of protochlorophyllide to chlorophyll, the prothylakoids become photosynthetically ac-tive thylakoids that grow and differentiate into grana and stroma thylakoids. Simultaneously, the PLBs shrink in size due to the transfer of lipids into the expanding thylakoid membranes (Hen-ningsen and Boynton, 1974; Adam et al., 2011). The physical continuity between prolamellar body tubules and forming thyla-koid membranes and the direct (without vesicle intermediate) transformation of PLB tubules into fenestrated thylakoids were documented with amazing clarity by early electron microsco-pists (Gunning, 1965). This physical relationship has been re-cently confirmed in an electron tomographic study of chemically fixed, greening bean chloroplasts (Kowalewska et al., 2016). How grana stacks are formed remains somewhat of a mys-tery. As shown by Brangeon and Mustardy (1979), grana stack formation originates with the formation of tongue-like membrane flaps that originate in the margins of membrane fenestrae and grow over the adjacent flat membrane surface to create stacked membrane domains. However, what triggers the formation of membrane flaps and how the initial ministacks become fully de-veloped grana stacks that are interconnected to each other by means of stroma thylakoids that form right-handed helices around the stacks and form bridges between the grana stacks remains to be determined (Austin and Staehelin, 2011). The recently dis-covered family of membrane curvature-inducing CURT1 proteins (Armbruster et al., 2013) demonstrates that thylakoid architecture is also dependent on membrane-shaping structural proteins. The goal of this study was to use electron tomography analysis to reexamine the process of thylakoid assembly in proplastids of high-pressure frozen cotyledon cells of germinating Arabidopsis seeds and to correlate these changes with the expression of the major protein complexes at the assembly stages of thylakoids. We also compare the assembly of thylakoids between wild-type chloroplasts, a mutant with impaired ribosome production, and a mutant deficient in the dynamin-like Fzo-like (FZL) membrane fu-sion protein. Thylakoid-inner envelope membrane contact sites are a typical feature of developing chloroplasts.

RESULTS

Chloroplast Development in Cotyledon Cells of Germinating Arabidopsis Seedlings Takes 120 h from the Onset of Illumination

To monitor the development of chloroplasts from proplastids in germinating Arabidopsis seeds, we examined cotyledon cells at 24, 36, 60, 84, and 120 h after imbibition (HAI) (Figures 1A to

1E) using confocal laser scanning microscopy (Figures 1F to 1J) and transmission electron microscopy (Figures 1K to 1O). The seedlings were grown under continuous light so that light-in-duced plastid-to-chloroplast conversion was not interrupted by periods of darkness. Autofluorescence from chlorophyll was rarely detected in cotyledon cells of seedlings at 24 HAI, but unambiguously observed in 36 HAI cotyledon cells (Figures 1F and 1G). Chloroplasts enlarged and their autofluorescence in-tensified gradually from 36 to 120 HAI (Figures 1G to 1J). In the 84 and 120 HAI cotyledon cells, individual chloroplasts could be identified in bright-field micrographs owing to their green color-ation (Figures 1I’ and 1J’). Transmission electron microscopy imaging of 24 HAI cotyle-don cells demonstrated that the bulk of their cytoplasm was filled with reserve organelles, protein storage vacuoles, and lipid bodies (Figure 1K). The large, darkly stained storage vacuoles together with the nucleus, mitochondria, and plastids occupied the central cytoplasm, whereas the tightly packed lipid bodies were located in the cell periphery (Supplemental Figure 1). In cry-ofixed/freeze-substituted cells, the darkly staining material in the storage vacuoles corresponds to the storage proteins and the bright spots to holes in the sections left behind by the shattered phytin globoids (Zheng and Staehelin, 2011). Between 24 and 36 HAI, the first significant changes in the architecture of the pregranal chloroplasts were seen, including a substantial increase in volume and expansion of the nonstacked thylakoids (Figures 1K, 1L, and 2). The cytoplasm of the 36 HAI cotyledon cells still contained large numbers of lipid bodies, and plastoglobules were present in the pregranal chloroplasts. The chloroplasts in the 60 HAI cotyledon cells possessed thylakoids that extended across their entire length and contained small pro-grana stacks embedded in a darkly stained stroma (Figures 1M and 3). At this stage, the number of cytoplasmic lipid bodies was decreased, and most storage vacuoles had merged into one large, central vacuole (Figure 1M; Supplemental Figures 1C to 1E). In the 84 HAI cotyledons, the swollen cells exhibited a rounded shape and were surrounded by large air spaces. Large vacuoles occupied the central regions of the cells and displaced all the other organelles, including the prominent chloroplasts, to the cell periphery (Figure 1N). The thylakoids displayed an increasingly elaborate architecture and alignment with the equatorial plane of the spheroidal chloroplasts (Figures 1N and 4). Cell enlarge-ment continued up to 120 HAI primarily due to an expansion of the central vacuole (Figures 1O and 1P; Supplemental Data Set 1). The chloroplasts in these cells appeared fully developed and possessed extensive grana and stroma thylakoid membrane systems with the margins of the end thylakoids anchored to the chloroplast envelope via contact sites (Figures 1 and 5).

The Assembly of Polysomes on the Thylakoid Membranes Correlates with the Transformation of the Tubulo-Vesicular Prothylakoids into Sheet-Like, Pregranal Thylakoids with Collapsed Lumina

Plastids in 24 HAI cotyledon cells had an ellipsoid shape with an average length of 0.488 μm (sd = 0.224 μm, n = 20) in electron

Electron Tomography of Thylakoid Assembly 1479

Figure 1. Arabidopsis Seedling Development.

(A) to (E) Stereomicroscope images of Arabidopsis seedlings at 24 (A), 36 (B), 60 (C), 84 (D), and 120 (E) HAI. Bars = 0.5 mm. (F) to (J) Confocal micrographs of cotyledon cells of seedlings at 24 (F), 36 (G), 60 (H), 84 (I), and 120 (J) HAI, showing chlorophyll autofluorescence. Bars = 10 μm. (I’) and (J’) are bright-field micrographs of the same are shown in (I) and (J), respectively. Chloroplasts (dark spheroids) are readily identified in (I’) and (J’). (K) to (O) Transmission electron micrographs of cotyledon cells at 24 (K), 36 (L), 60 (M), 84 (N), and 120 (O) HAI. Plastids/chloroplasts are marked with arrowheads. Bars = 5 μm. (P) Chloroplast lengths estimated from chloroplast autofluorescence. Confocal micrographs were captured from wild-type, rh3-4 mutant, and fzl mu-tant cotyledon cells (48 chloroplasts from three seedlings of the three genotypes were measured). Plastids at 24 HAI and rh3-4 plastids at 36 HAI were not examined because their chlorophyll autofluorescence was too weak for reliable measurements. (Q) The thickness of prothylakoids and pregranal thylakoids in 36 HAI plastids. Forty-one prothylakoids and 21 pregranal thylakoids were measured from tomographic slices of three plastids at 24 and 36 HAI, respectively. Error bars indicate sd in (P) and (O).

1480 The Plant Cell

micrographs. Their dense, opaque stroma contained tubulo- vesicular prothylakoids with wide lumina that were attached to the inner envelope membrane by means of membrane contact sites (Figures 2A and 2B, arrows). Some plastoglobules and inner envelope membrane infoldings were also seen (Supplemental Figure 1B). Between 24 and 36 HAI, the average length of the plastids increased significantly from 0.488 to 1.73 μm (sd = 0. 274 μm, n = 25). During this phase of development, the tubulo-vesicular prothylakoids were gradually converted into larger, nonstacked, and sheet-like pregranal thylakoids that displayed a narrow lu-men (Figure 1Q; Supplemental Data Set 2) and extended to-ward the central regions of the plastids (Figures 2C and 2D). This striking transformation of the thylakoid membranes was al-ways accompanied by the binding of polysomes to the pregranal thylakoids (Figures 2E and 2F), which also possessed contact sites with the inner envelope membrane. We compared ribo-some densities (ribosomes per µm3) in the bulk stroma and ad-jacent to the surfaces of prothylakoids and pregranal thylakoids in electron tomograms (Figure 2G; Supplemental Figure 2 and Supplemental Data Set 3). The ribosome densities in the vicinity of prothylakoids (12,047.2 per μm3, sd: 2888.1) were similar to those in the bulk stroma (10,438.0 per μm3, sd: 1623.9). By con-trast, planar pregranal thylakoids had significantly more closely associated ribosomes (22,051.9 per μm3, sd: 1360.1) compared with bulk stroma or tubular prothylakoids. These observations suggest that the flattening of the membranes and their increase in size are related to the insertion of plastid-encoded proteins into the thylakoid membranes and signal the beginning of the assembly of photosynthetic complexes.

Grana-Forming Thylakoid Buds Arise Adjacent to Thylakoid-Bound Polysomes and Become Coated with Additional Polysomes as They Produce More Stacked Membrane Regions

In the 60 HAI plastids, all of the thylakoids formed a single, coherent 3D network that extended along the entire length of the chloroplasts (Figures 3A and 3B). At this time point, the first small prograna stacks, which we define here as grana stacks with wide, slit-like connections between the grana and stroma membrane regions, began to form, giving rise to a variety of membrane shapes in cross-sectional views (Figures 3C to 3P). To understand how these membrane configurations are related

Figure 2. Arabidopsis Plastids at 24 and 36 HAI.

(A) and (B) Electron tomographic slice of a plastid in an Arabidopsis cotyledon cell at 24 HAI (A) and its 3D tomographic model (B). A con-tact site where the prothylakoid is continuous with the inner envelope is marked with an arrow in (B).

(C) to (F) Electron tomographic slice ([C], [E], and [F]) and 3D model (D) of an Arabidopsis plastid at 36 HAI. Tubulo-vesicular prothylakoids and plastoglobule-like compartments are colored in green and yellow, respectively. In (D) and (E), blue arrows, green arrows, and yellow arrow-heads mark rough prothylakoids, thick prothylakoids, and plastoglobule- like compartments, respectively. Membrane-bound ribosomes of a rough prothylakoid are indicated with purple brackets in (F). (G) Ribosome densities of bulk stroma (stroma), stroma within 20 nm from prothylakoid membranes (prothylakoids), and from pregranal thyla-koid membranes (pregranal thylakoids). *P < 0.01 (unpaired Student’s t test). Bars in (A), (C), and (E) = 500 nm.

Electron Tomography of Thylakoid Assembly 1481

to the de novo assembly of grana stacks, we examined the 3D organization of developing prograna in electron tomographic slices and models. The planar 60 HAI thylakoid domains were morphologically similar to the flat, polysome-bearing thylakoids of the 36 HAI chloroplasts. However, they also possessed prograna-forming, dome-shaped buds coated with polysomes (Figures 3C to 3F; Supplemental Movie 1). As these tongue-like membrane folds expanded over the membrane surfaces adjacent to the out-growth-forming sites, they developed contact zones that be-came the first stacked membrane domains (Figures 3G to 3J). The fact that the grana-forming thylakoid buds arose in associ-ation with membrane-bound polysomes is consistent with the hypothesis that localized cotranslational protein insertion is an integral part in the grana-forming, membrane outgrowth process (Figures 3F and 3I). The first polysome-associated stacked membrane domains subsequently seemed to serve as nucleation sites for additional grana-forming membrane folds. Formation of these folds, however, did not seem to follow a precise, 3D developmental program such as a helical pattern program. Instead, mem-brane sites closely associated with the newly formed adhering membranes appeared to develop buds that grew over the ex-isting grana-forming membrane regions from different direc-tions, thereby creating small membrane stacks that gave rise to a variety of different membrane configurations (Figures 3K to 3P; Supplemental Movies 2 and 3). These prograna stacks consisted of somewhat randomly interconnected membrane folds that had slanted or other noncanonical membrane config-urations. Furthermore, unlike in mature chloroplasts where the

Figure 3. Arabidopsis Plastids at 60 HAI.

(A) and (B) Electron tomographic slice of a plastid in an Arabidopsis cotyledon cell at 60 HAI (A) and its 3D model (B). (C) Three tomographic slices showing a bud on a rough thylakoid.

(D) 3D model of the bud (light blue) and the rough thylakoid (green) based on the tomogram in (C). Arrows in (C) and (D) point to the same position. (E) Side view of the model in (D). (F) Same 3D model in (E) but ribosomes (gold spheres) within 10 nm of the thylakoid membrane are shown. (G) Three tomographic slice images of a tongue-like thylakoid lying over a larger thylakoid. (H) 3D model of the thylakoids in (G). Arrows in (G) and (H) point to the same position as the arrowhead in (G). (I) Same 3D model in (H) but ribosomes (gold spheres) within 10 nm from the thylakoid membrane are shown. (J) View of the 3D model in (H) after rotating 90°. The membrane con-tact zone of a double-layered thylakoid is traced with a magenta dashed curve. (K) to (N) Thylakoid stacks consisting of three layers (red brackets). (N) and (M) show 3D models of the stacks in (K) and (L), respectively. The stack in (K) and (L) has folds on one side while the stack in (M) and (N) has folds on opposite sides constituting an S-shaped stack. (O) and (P) Tomographic slice images of a thylakoid stack and its 3D model. In (P), cross sections of the stack along the blue and yellow lines are shown ([P’] and [P’’]). (Q) Ribosome densities of bulk stroma (stroma), stroma within 20 nm from unstacked thylakoid membranes (unstacked thylakoids), and from grana-forming thylakoid membranes (grana-forming thylakoids). *P < 0.01 (unpaired Student’s t test). Three tomographic slice images from tomograms are shown in (C), (G), (K), (L), and (O). Their slice numbers are indicated in the panels (z). Bars = 500 nm in (A) and 100 nm in (C), (G), (K), (L), and (O).

1482 The Plant Cell

grana thylakoids can be linked to the stroma thylakoids either through narrow membrane tubules or through wider, sheet-like bridges (Austin and Staehelin, 2011), all of the initial membrane folds were connected to the adjacent membranes through wide, sheet-like membrane structures. The thylakoid-inner envelope membrane contact sites were dispersed around the envelope margins. Ribosome density in the bulk stroma was higher at 60 HAI (23,078.8 per μm3, sd: 6043.8) than at 36 HAI, indicating that ribosomes accumulated in the stroma during the 24-h period (compare Figures 2G and 3Q). As thylakoids expanded, ribo-somes were often concentrated to space between growing thylakoids and these clusters of ribosomes in the stroma con-tributed to the increase of stromal ribosome density (Sup-plemental Figures 2E and 2F). On the thylakoid membrane surfaces, ribosomes were more enriched at membrane buds and accessible membranes of thylakoid stacks (24,492.9 per μm3, sd: 3707.8, Supplemental Data Set 3) than at unstacked interconnecting thylakoids (11,722.6 per μm3, sd: 4654.6).

Between 60 and 84 HAI the Prograna Stacks Develop More Uniformly Organized Grana Stacks and Stroma Thylakoids, but Retain Wide, Grana-Stroma Membrane Connections

Defining structural features of mature thylakoids include grana stacks interconnected by stroma thylakoids and grana thyla-koids exhibiting uniform margins with small radii of curvature. All of these architectural elements began to emerge in the 84 HAI plastids as evidenced by the development of more regularly shaped grana stacks with larger diameters and more stacked membrane regions, and interconnected by increasing numbers of stroma thylakoids (Figures 4A and 4B). However, the grana stacks were still classified as prograna because the grana-stroma membrane connections were wide and slit-like as in the 60 HAI plastids (Figures 3 and 4L). Hints of a helical arrangement of the connecting stroma membranes around the grana were also seen (Figure 4L, yellow membrane ele-ments encircling the stack and having connections to disks in the stack). Contact sites between thylakoids and inner en-velope membranes were observed regularly (arrowheads in Figure 4A). The grana stack of the 84 HAI plastid depicted in the tomo-graphic slice images Figures 4C to 4H contained four stacked thylakoids connected to two stroma thylakoids that surrounded the stack (Figures 4I to 4K; Supplemental Movie 4). In addition, the adjacent thylakoids in the stack were connected to each other through membrane folds that appeared as U-shaped structures in the cross-sectional views (Figures 4D, 4F, and 4G). These wide connections suggest that the new pro-grana thylakoids continued to be formed as in the 60 HAI plastids (Figure 3).

Figure 4. Arabidopsis Plastids at 84 HAI.

(A) and (B) Electron tomographic slice of a plastid in an Arabidopsis cotyledon cell at 84 HAI (A) and its 3D model (B). Three stacks made of more than three layers and one of their unstacked stroma thylakoids are marked with yellow brackets and arrows, respectively, in (A) and (B). (C) to (H) Six tomographic slices from a grana stack consisting of four layers (L1–L4 in E) and two stroma thylakoids (STh1 in C and STh2 in [H]) surrounding the stack. Bends connecting adjacent layers are marked with brackets (red in [D], cyan in [F], magenta and dark in [G]). Slice numbers are indicated in the lower right corner of each panel. (I) 3D model of the grana stack in (C) to (H) showing the four layers (L1–L4). (J) The grana stack in (I) and its bent membranes between adjacent lay-ers (highlighted according to the colors used in [C] to [H]).

(K) Side views of the 3D model in (J) revealing the three links between adjacent layers. (L) The two stroma thylakoids around the grana stack (stippled) in (I). Bars 500 nm in (A) and 100 nm in (C).

Electron Tomography of Thylakoid Assembly 1483

Narrowing of the Grana to Stroma Membrane Connections in the 120 HAI Plastids Signals the Onset of the Final Phase of Chloroplast Development

The most notable structural difference between the 84 and 120 HAI chloroplasts was the huge increase in thylakoid membranes, which become the dominant structural feature of the latter chlo-roplasts (Figure 5A). In addition, the grana stacks possessed a greater width, an increased number of membranes per stack (Figures 5B to 5E; Supplemental Movie 5), and most impor-tantly, the transformation of the wide, slit-like grana-to-stroma membrane connections into narrow tubules (compare Figures 4I and 5G), a characteristic feature of mature chloroplasts (Austin and Staehelin, 2011). The sheet-like stroma thylakoids were also seen around the stack (Figure 5F and 5G). Prominent starch granules accumulated between the thylakoids (Figure 5A).

Transcriptomic Analysis Indicates That Transcripts Encoding Subunits for PSII Are Enriched When Polysomes Are Recruited to Pregranal and Grana-Forming Thylakoids

To determine what photosynthetic complexes assembled in the intermediates of thylakoid biogenesis that we observed with electron tomography, we performed transcriptomic analysis of RNA samples isolated from seedlings at the five stages. Total RNA samples were analyzed after degrading rRNA molecules to quantify transcripts from both plastid and nuclear genes encod-ing constituents of PSI, PSII, LHCs, cyt b6f, and ATP synthase complexes. We repeated the experiments twice, and in each independent experiment, we obtained 12 to 30 million high- quality reads that mapped to the Arabidopsis plastid genome or the five chromosomes (Supplemental Data Set 4). The heat maps (Figure 6; Supplemental Figure 3) illustrate transcrip-tional profiles of subunits that consist of the major protein com-plexes in thylakoid membranes during light-induced chloroplast development. PsbA (ATCG00020) was by far the most highly transcribed gene in the plastid at 24 HAI (fragments per kilobase of tran-script per million mapped reads [FPKM]: 10,325–13,840), and its FPKM values surpassed 20,000 at 36 HAI (Figure 6A; Supple-mental Data Set 5). FPKM values of some plastid genes encod-ing PSII proteins reached 10,000 at 36 HAI, while comparable upregulation was observed for plastid genes encoding PSI, cyt b6f, and ATP synthase subunits only after 60 and 84 HAI (Figures 6A; Supplemental Figure 3A). Transcripts for constructing PSII complexes were more abundant in the plastid at the early time points when polysomes concentrated to thylakoid membranes (36 and 60 HAI) than those for the other three complexes. These results suggest that transcripts of PSII subunits encoded by the plastid genome are translated by the polysomes associated with the flattening pregranal thylakoids at 36 HAI (Figure 2) and the grana-forming thylakoids at 60 HAI (Figure 3). The nuclear genes encoding proteins of the four thylakoid complexes exhibited similar expression patterns as the plastid genes (Figure 6B). PsbR, PsbS, PsbQ, and PsbP became acti-vated at 36 HAI, as some of their partner genes in the plastid did. Nuclear genes encoding PSI, cyt b6f, and ATP synthase sub-units were upregulated around 60 HAI. The early transcriptional

Figure 5. Arabidopsis Chloroplast at 120 HAI.

(A) Electron tomographic slice of a chloroplast in an Arabidopsis cotyle-don cell at 120 HAI (A). The grana stack in (B) to (G) is enclosed in the light-blue rectangle. Bars = 500 nm.(B) to (E) Four tomographic slices of a granum consisting of seven lay-ers (green brackets in [C]) and stroma thylakoids surrounding the stack (yellow brackets in [C]). Slice numbers are indicated in the lower right corner. (F) 3D model of the grana stack (green) and its stroma thylakoids (yellow) in (B) to (E). (G) Side views of the 3D model in (G). The convoluted stroma thylakoids consist of sheet-like (arrows in [F] and [G]) and tubular (arrowhead in [F] and [G]) components.

Figure 6. Transcriptomic Analysis of Genes Encoding Subunits of PSII, PSI, cyt b6f, and ATP Synthase Complexes in the Thylakoid Membrane during Chloroplast Biogenesis.

Electron Tomography of Thylakoid Assembly 1485

activation of PSII genes followed by genes for other complexes occurred in both plastid and nucleus. The correlative expres-sion profiles of plastid and nuclear genes encoding components of each complex reinforced the interorganelle communication. Transcript levels of the light-harvesting complex for PSII (Lhcb) increased significantly at 60 and 84 HAI (Figure 6C) when grana- forming thylakoids arose and layers in the prograna stacks in-creased (Figures 3 and 4). CURT1A is a thylakoid curvature-inducing membrane protein that localizes to grana margins, and the Arabidopsis genome encodes four CURT1 family proteins (Armbruster et al., 2013). Among the four members, transcripts from CURT1A (AT4G01150) and CURT1B (AT2G46820) accumulated more than CURT1C (AT1G52220) (Figure 6E). FPKM values of CURT1D (AT4G38100) were almost negligible at all the time points (1.3-29.0). CURT1 transcript levels increased sharply at 84 HAI (arrow, Figure 6D) when the distinction between grana stacks and intercon-necting thylakoids became more apparent (Figure 4) and CURT1A was readily detected by immunoblot analysis (Figures 7C and 7D). To substantiate the RNA-seq results, we selected genes ex-hibiting varying expression levels from the heat maps in Fig-ure 6 and quantified their transcripts using droplet digital PCR (ddPCR). This method is more reliable than quantitative RT-PCR because it does not require external reference genes for mea-suring amounts of target DNA templates in reaction mixes and has been shown to be more accurate and reproducible (Hindson et al., 2013; Taylor et al., 2017). We chose three PSII subunit genes, two PSI subunit genes, one ATP synthase subunit gene, and two cyt b6f subunit genes, one from the plastid genome and another from the nuclear genome (Figures 7A and 7B; Supple-mental Data Set 6). ddPCR analysis indicated that PsbA was most actively transcribed among the three plastid PSII subunit genes, followed by PsbB and PsbZ during the chloroplast bio-genesis (Figure 7A). The relative transcript abundances of the three genes agreed with transcriptional activities of the genes measured by RNA-seq in Figure 6A. We were able to observe similar matches between ddPCR and RNA-seq quantifications for plastid-encoded PSI subunit genes (PsaJ and PsaA), nucleus- encoded PSII subunit genes (PsbS, Lhcb-AT1G29930, and Lhcb-AT2G47450), and nucleus-encoded PSI subunit genes (PsaK and Lhca-AT3G54890). PsbA and PsbS were highly expressed genes of PSII com-ponents (Figures 6A and 6B) and their upregulation at 36 and 60 HAI was also observed in ddPCR readouts (Figures 7A and 7B). Transcript concentrations of PsbA (8.6 copies/pg) and PsbS (869 copies/ng) were higher than those of other com-plex subunits. Amounts of PsaJ, PsaK, and Lhca (AT3G54890) sharply increased 60 to 84 HAI, suggesting that PSI is primarily

produced after 60 HAI. These ddPCR results confirm the con-clusion from the RNA-seq analyses that transcripts for PSII as-sembly are more enriched at 36 and 60 HAI than those for other complexes (Figure 6).

PSII, PSI, LHCII, and CURT1 Proteins Appear at Different Times of Thylakoid Development, in Parallel with Changes in Their Transcript Levels

We performed immunoblot analyses for the major protein com-plexes of thylakoid membranes and CURT1 proteins to test whether accumulation of the transcripts at different times leads to their translation. To evaluate translation in the stroma and cy-tosol, we employed antibodies against subunits encoded by the nuclear genome and subunits encoded in the plastid genome for each complex. PBA, a subunit of the Arabidopsis protea-some complex β, was used as the loading control (Lee et al., 2013). The immunoblot data were confirmed in three separate experiments and quantified via polypeptide chemiluminescence as measured on film (Figure 7C) or with a digital imaging system (Figure 7D; Supplemental Data Set 7). PSII proteins were detected earlier in the immunoblots com-pared with other complex proteins during light-induced chlo-roplast development, in agreement with the RNA-seq analysis. PsbA, the stroma-translated D1 protein, was seen in the 24 HAI membranes and its amount increased in the 36 HAI thylakoids. PsbN, a chloroplast-encoded, low molecular weight, transmem-brane protein that localizes to stroma thylakoids and is needed for the efficient assembly of PSII reaction centers (Torabi et al., 2014), was first detected at 36 HAI and became more abundant at 60 HAI. PsbO, the cytosol-translated 33-kD oxygen-evolving protein, was also noticed in the 36 HAI samples and signals from the polypeptide intensified in later time points. Lhcb, the PSII light-harvesting and membrane adhesion-promoting pro-tein, became enriched from 60 HAI when their transcript levels increased (Figure 6C). Subunits of the PSI complex were detected only after 84 HAI by immunoblot analysis and ∼24 h after the cyt b6f and the ATP synthase complexes were discerned (Figures 7C and 7D). Both the stroma-translated PsaA (P700 core protein) and the cytosol-translated PsaD (ferredoxin-docking protein) subunits together with the PSI light harvesting antenna protein Lhca be-came significantly detectable in the 84 HAI samples. The late detection of PSI subunits in the immunoblot is consistent with their transcription profiles (Figures 6A and 6B). The stroma-translated proteins PetB and AtpB (CF1β) that are associated with the cyt b6f and the ATP synthase complexes, respectively, belonged to the second set of photosynthetic

(A) and (B) Heat maps illustrating changes in the transcript levels of the plastid and nuclear genes encoding complex subunits and Rubisco are shown in (A) and (B), respectively. Color-coding scales for the two heat maps are not equal. (C) Histogram showing total FPKM values of all Lhcb gene. The amount of Lhcb transcripts is increased steeply from 36 to 84 HAI. (D) and (E) Transcript levels of CURT1 family genes are depicted in (D) and of FZL in (E). Names of the subunits constituting the complexes in (A) and (B) followed the nomenclature by Race et al. (1999), and their gene IDs were obtained from www.arabidopsis.org. The charts in (C) to (F) were prepared with average FPKM values and their standard deviations of genes from the two sequencing experiments.

1486 The Plant Cell

Figure 7. Expression Analyses of Genes Encoding PSII, PSI, cyt b6f, and ATP Synthase Subunits in Thylakoid Membranes during Chloroplast Biogenesis.

(A) and (B) ddPCR quantification of transcript levels of genes selected from the RNA-seq data in Figure 6. Heat maps were drawn to illustrate tran-script concentrations at the five stages. Average copies per picogram (pg) of RNA sample (for plastid-encoded genes in [A]) and average copies per nanogram (ng) of RNA sample (for nucleus-encoded genes in [B]) from three replicate ddPCR experiments are given. Supplemental Data Set 3 has results from the three ddPCR experiments. (C) and (D) Immunoblot analysis showing time points when subunits of the four complexes are detected. Amounts of polypeptides were visualized on films (C) or quantified by their chemiluminescence (D). Proteins translated in the stroma are in green letters. For each complex, subunits encoded by the nuclear genome and the plastid genome are shown separately. CURT1A is a thylakoid membrane protein localizing to the grana margin. PBA, a subunit of the Arabidopsis proteasome complex b, was used as the loading control. For the histograms in (B), readouts from each polypeptide were normalized with those of PBA at the five time points and relative values were calcu-lated after the largest normalized intensity was set to be 1.0. The asterisk in each histogram of (D) indicates the time point when polypeptide readout significantly increased from readout of the previous time point (Student’s t test, one-tailed unpaired test, *P < 0.025).

Electron Tomography of Thylakoid Assembly 1487

electron transport chain complexes, which appeared ∼24 h after the PSII complex subunits in the greening thylakoids, i.e., at 60 HAI. The membrane curvature-inducing protein CURT1A was on the verge of detection in the 60 HAI membranes and became more abundant in the 84 HAI membranes at the time when dis-crete stacks were distinguished from stroma thylakoids and the PSI complexes appeared in the immunoblot.

Ribosome Biogenesis in the Stroma Is Required for Grana Formation

In wild-type plastids, the assembly of polysomes on the surface of the 36 HAI thylakoids correlated with the conversion of the tubulo-vesicular prothylakoids into sheet-like pregranal thyla-koids (Figures 2C to 2G). Membrane-bound polysomes also as-sembled close to the thylakoid surface sites where membrane buds gave rise to stacked prograna thylakoids (Figures 3C to 3J). These correlations suggest that protein synthesis by thylakoid-bound polysomes plays a critical role both in the for-mation of planar thylakoids and in the generation of stacked grana thylakoids. To test the hypothesis that protein synthesis by chloroplast ribosomes is critical for the assembly of planar thylakoids and of prograna stacks, we examined an Arabidopsis mutant in which ribosome biogenesis in plastids is delayed during germination. RH3 is a plastid-targeted RNA helicase that is required for chloroplast ribosome production. rh3-4 is a weak mutant allele of RH3 in which the density of plastid ribosomes is ∼80% lower than in wild-type plastids until 72 HAI but slowly recovers to the normal level by 2 weeks after germination (Lee et al., 2013). This property has enabled us to examine the effects of reduced and delayed plastid protein synthesis on thylakoid development. The rh3-4 mutant plastids were significantly smaller than the wild-type plastids at the same HAI times (Figure 1P). The 36 HAI plastids of the rh3-4 mutant cotyledons had tubulo-vesicular prothylakoid membrane compartments (Figures 8A and 8B) similar to those in the 24 HAI plastids of the wild-type cotyle-dons (Figures 2A and 2B). The 36 HAI rh3-4 mutant plastids also lacked the planar, pregranal-type thylakoids that were a characteristic feature of the 36 HAI wild-type plastids (Figures 2E and 2F). By 60 HAI tubulo-vesicular prothylakoids were no longer seen in the wild-type plastids, whereas in the 60 HAI mutant plastids, many prothylakoids were still present adjacent to rounded, lamellar membrane compartments (Figures 8C and 8D). These membrane lamellae, however, lacked the small pro-grana stacks seen in the 60 HAI wild-type plastids (Figure 3). Thylakoids coated with polysomes were seen in the rh3-4 plas-tids at 120 HAI, 84 h later than in the wild-type plastids (Figures 8E to 8H). The appearance of these thylakoid-associated poly-somes correlated with thylakoid flattening and stack formation, similar to the events in the 36 and 60 HAI wild-type plastids. Together, these results indicate that thylakoid assembly requires recruitment of polysomes to the thylakoid surface and suggests that the cotranslational insertion of chloroplast DNA-encoded thylakoid membrane proteins is required for the formation of flat thylakoids and prograna stacks.

FZL, a Chloroplast-Targeted, Dynamin-Like Protein, Is Required for Connecting the Individual Grana Stacks into a Coherent Thylakoid Membrane System

In 36 HAI wild-type cotyledons, the initially formed pregranal thylakoids were dispersed throughout the stroma (Figure 2), but by 60 HAI, all thylakoids had fused into large, plastid-spanning membrane sheets that were interconnected (Figure 3A). Thyla-koid connectivity continued to increase as thylakoid maturation

Figure 8. Plastids in rh3-4 Cotyledon Cells.

(A) to (F) Electron tomographic slice of plastids in rh3-4 cotyledon cells at 36 ([A] and [B]), 60 ([C] and [D]), and 120 HAI ([E] and [F]). High- magnification images of the mutant plastids at the three time points are shown in (B), (D), and (F), respectively. Convoluted tubular thylakoids of 36 and 60 HAI are marked with light-blue arrows ([A] to [D]). The round thylakoids of 60 HAI are indicated with dark blue ellipses in (C) and (D). Rough thylakoids (bracket in [F]) and grana stacks (arrowheads in [F]) are observed in 120 HAI plastids. (G) 3D model of the mutant plastid in (E). (H) 3D model of the primitive stack marked with three arrowheads in (F). The gold spheres represent ribosomes on the thylakoid membrane (brackets). Bars = 500 nm in (A), (C), and (E) and 150 nm in (B), (D), and (F).

1488 The Plant Cell

progressed (Figures 4 and 5), suggesting that membrane fusion may be involved in later stages of thylakoid development too. To investigate this possibility, we examined the role of a pro-tein hypothesized to promote membrane fusion in thylakoid de-velopment. Fzo1 is a dynamin-related protein required for fusion of mitochondrial outer membranes (Wang et al., 2016). Arabi-dopsis has a gene encoding an Fzo1 homolog, termed Fzo-like protein (FZL), that localizes to chloroplasts. In fzl mutant plants, the chloroplasts produce aberrant thylakoids (Gao et al., 2006). In 36 HAI fzl cotyledons, the plastids contained many vesicle-like compartments and short tubules (Figures 9A and 9B). They also displayed a few small flat thylakoids with ribosomes attached to their surfaces that appeared to be progranal thylakoids. By 60 HAI, most of these vesicles had disappeared and numerous individual, sheet-like pregranal thylakoids and small grana stacks were seen throughout the stroma (Figures 9C and 9D). The thylakoids of the 120 HAI fzl mutant plastids consisted of elongated spirals of large numbers of small diameter, prograna thylakoids (Figures 9E to 9G). However, these elongated, column- like pro-grana stacks were not interconnected by stroma thyla-koids. Despite the perturbed thylakoid architecture of their thylakoids, the fzl plastids were as big as the wild-type plastids of the same age (Figure 1P). In agreement with the defects in 36 and 60 HAI mutant chloroplasts, FZL transcript levels were higher at the early time points than at 84 and 120 HAI (Figure 6F). To determine where the FZL proteins function in developing chlo-roplasts, we performed immunogold labeling of fzl mutant plants that expressed FZL-GFP. Thylakoids in the transgenic plants ap-peared to be normal when compared with thylakoids of fzl mutant plants, indicating that the GFP fusion protein was functional (Sup-plemental Figure 4). In such plants, the immunogold particles were detected at the junctions between stroma thylakoids and grana stack margins (Figures 9I and 9J). Thus, the presence of elongated, free-standing and disorganized prograna stacks in the 120 HAI fzl plastids is consistent with the hypothesis that FZL is needed to connect the newly formed grana pro-stacks to each other via fusion of their marginal domains with stroma thylakoids.

DISCUSSION

The process of light-induced thylakoid biogenesis has attracted the interest of plant biologists for over 50 years. However, un-derstanding how the intricate 3D architecture of thylakoid mem-branes is generated, and how the assembly of the different com-plexes relates to the structural changes has remained an elusive goal. We investigated this process in Arabidopsis cotyledon chlo-roplasts using a combination of electron tomography of cryofixed cells, immunolabeling, correlative immunoblot, and transcriptomic analyses. The stages of thylakoid biogenesis in germinating cot-yledon cells and chloroplast proteins involved in the assembly activity at each stage are summarized in Figure 10.

Analysis of the Light-Induced Proplastid Developmental System in Cotyledons Has Uncovered a Remarkably Linear Developmental Program Starting with the Formation of Tubulo-Vesicular Prothylakoids

Proplastids, the colorless precursors of chloroplasts, were dis-covered in 1927 in a light microscopy study of maize (Zea mays),

Figure 9. Plastids in fzl Cotyledon Cells.

(A) to (F) Electron tomographic slice of fzl plastids at 36, 60, and 120 HAI ([A], [C], and [E]) and their 3D models ([B], [D], and [F]). Extended planar thylakoids and spiral thylakoids are marked with yellow and red brackets, respectively, in (E) and (F). (G) and (H) A spiral thylakoid in an fzl mutant chloroplast at 120 HAI. The long slanted stack consists of planar layers folded over each other. (I) to (K) Immunogold labeling of sections from cotyledon cells of fzl mu-tant seedlings expressing the FZL-GFP fusion protein with a GFP anti-body ([I] and [J]) or with an LHCB (light harvesting complex II) antibody (K). The LHCB-specific gold particles are associated with grana stacks where no GFP-specific gold particles are detected. The immunogold la-beling experiments were performed with 120 HAI old cotyledon samples. Bars = 500 nm in (A), (C), (E), and (I) and 200 nm in (J) and (K).

Electron Tomography of Thylakoid Assembly 1489

Figure 10. Schematic Diagram of Thylakoid Assembly in the Proplastid of Germinating Arabidopsis.

(A) Structural features and protein complexes associated with the thylakoid membrane noted at the five time points by electron tomography and immunoblot analysis. Black dots on the thylakoid surface represent ribosomes and small arrows point to thylakoid-inner envelope contact sites that become concentrated close to the plane defined by the major axis of the spheroidal chloroplasts during later stages of development. In addition to serving membrane lipid transport functions, these contact sites may help align the thylakoids within the spheroidal chloroplasts. (B) Cotranslational insertion of PSII by thylakoid-membrane bound polysomes enriches PSII-LHCII at 60 HAI and initiates stack formation. Because of their bulky stromal domains, PSI and ATP syntheses are excluded from the stacked region. Recruitment of CURT1 family proteins define the grana margins and grana become interconnected more extensively by FZL-mediated thylakoid membrane fusion at 84 HAI.

1490 The Plant Cell

pondweed (Elodea canadensis), and common toadflax (Lunularia vulgaris) seedlings (Zirkle, 1927). They were subsequently redis-covered by electron microscopists in the 1960s, who charac-terized them as small, undifferentiated plastids capable of dif-ferentiating into all types of plastids during plant development (reviewed in Gunning and Steer, 1975). Despite this long history, it is remarkable how little we know about proplastid structure, function, and differentiation. Typically, the prothylakoid membranes of proplastids are described as vesicles lacking chlorophyll and photosynthetic complexes (Rudowska et al., 2012; Pogson et al., 2015). As doc-umented in the electron tomography-based 3D reconstructions shown in Figures 2A and 2B, the vesicles seen in thin sections correspond to cross-sectional views of tubulo-vesicular proth-ylakoids. These membranes lack chlorophyll (Figure 1F) and have defined contact sites with the inner envelope membrane. The paucity of information about the light-induced greening of proplastids is most likely due to the absence of well-defined structural intermediates in electron micrographs of chemically fixed cells. Furthermore, the analysis of proplastid differentiation in shoot apical meristems is complicated by the fact that their developmental state varies with the specific region and/or layer of the shoot apical meristem in which they are formed (Charuvi et al., 2012). This contrasts with the sizeable literature on the process of photomorphogenesis of etioplasts, the chloroplast precursor-type of plastids of dark-grown seedlings that develop characteristic paracrystalline prolamellar bodies and radiating lamellar prothylakoids (Blomqvist et al., 2008; Solymosi and Schoefs, 2010; Adam et al., 2011). The lipidic prolamellar bod-ies contain protochlorophyllide molecules that upon exposure to light are rapidly converted to chlorophyll. This induces the transfer of the prolamellar lipids to the prothylakoids that are subsequently converted to pregranal thylakoids (Rudowska et al., 2012). The downside of the etioplast greening systems is their vari-ability, the result of different experimental growth conditions. This affects prolamellar body formation, growth, and compo-sition. However, prolamellar bodies enable the initial thylakoid assembly events to occur very rapidly and many processes to develop in parallel. This multitude of activities makes it difficult to decipher how each parameter contributes to thylakoid assembly and to compare the results of different studies. By contrast, the cotyledon proplastid developmental system we have investigated displays a remarkably linear and sequential developmental program that is spread out over a 5-d period. This temporal separation of the different assembly steps and the analysis of chloroplast development mutants has enabled us to untangle the process of thylakoid assembly in ways not previously possible. The developmental variations in the thylakoids of the shoot apical meristem resemble the sequence of thylakoid assembly events in the cotyledon (Charuvi et al., 2012). Proplastids in the L1 and L3 cell layers have extended thylakoids with simple stacks similar to the thylakoids in 60 HAI chloroplasts (Figure 3). Proplastids in the L2 layer contain discrete thylakoid mem-branes that are devoid of stacks as in the cotyledon proplastids at 36 HAI (Figure 2). In the leaf primordia, however, chloroplasts consist of grana stacks and interconnecting stroma thylakoids

that are easily differentiated. In cotyledons, we observed such partitioning in samples older than 84 HAI (Figure 4). This correla-tion suggests that cotyledon cells and shoot apical meristem cells operate similar gene expression programs for thylakoid biogenesis.

Thylakoid Biogenesis Starts between 24 and 36 HAI, as Evidenced by Thylakoid Expansion and Flattening, Polysome Binding, and PSII Assembly

The most striking structural change between the 24 and 36 HAI thylakoids is the transformation of the tubulo-vesicular prothylakoids into expanded, sheet-like pregranal thylakoids (Figures 2C to 2F). Additional characteristic features of the pre-granal thylakoids include a collapsed lumen, bound polysomes, and the accumulation of PSII subunits, but not other types of thylakoid proteins (Figures 6 and 7). The 36 HAI thylakoids also possess contact sites with the inner envelope membrane and many plastoglobules are seen (Figure 2D). As discussed below, these different structural and biochemical features provide new insights into how pregranal thylakoids are assembled during light-induced plastid development. Two activities coincide with the thylakoid flattening process: the binding of the polysomes that insert the chloroplast-encoded proteins into the membranes and the forces that drive the col-lapse of the thylakoid lumen. In our chloroplast greening sam-ples, membrane-bound polysomes were always present on the flattened thylakoids (Figures 2E and 2F), in agreement with the hypothesis that polysome binding to thylakoids is an essential factor in the flattening response. This hypothesis is supported by the fact that a slowdown in chloroplast ribosome assembly in the rh3-4 mutant causes a delay in thylakoid development and flattening (Figure 8). The reversible transformation of endoplas-mic reticulum (ER) membrane tubules into membrane sheets in mammalian cells has also been shown to involve polysome bind-ing to translocon proteins, the insertion of coiled-coil membrane proteins, and a reduction of the concentration of membrane curvature-inducing proteins (Shibata et al., 2010). Together, these findings are consistent with our proposal that polysome binding, probably for inserting integral membrane proteins, contributes to the conversion of the prothylakoids into sheet-like pregranal thylakoids. Assembly of PSII complexes involves both chloroplast-encoded and nuclear-encoded proteins (Nevo et al., 2012). We monitored synthesis of the proteins from the two sources in the early stages of thylakoid development by following the appearance of tran-scription and translation of PsbA, the stroma-translated D1 core protein, and PsbO and PsbP, the cytosol-translated peripheral 33- and 23-kD oxygen-evolving proteins (Figures 6 and 7). Both transcripts and proteins from the three genes are detected in the 36 HAI thylakoids, but the same samples contain significantly lower amounts of transcripts from genes encoding PSI, LHCII, cyt b

6f, and ATP synthase subunits (Figures 6 and 7). Polypeptides from some of their subunit genes were undetectable or barely detectable in the immunoblots (Figures 7C and 7D). Thus, PSII complexes appear to be inserted into the thylakoid membrane when polysomes attach to the flattening thylakoids at 36 HAI. PSII complex assembly starts with the formation of D1-D2 complexes

Electron Tomography of Thylakoid Assembly 1491

to which other proteins are bound in a precise sequential order (Heinz et al., 2016). Incorporation of the 33- and 23-kD OEC1 and OEC2 proteins is a late event, since their binding to newly formed core complexes occurs only after assembly of the Mn cluster and release of the Psb27 protein (Liu et al., 2011; Heinz et al., 2016). In agreement with these studies, PSII-encoding genes are upreg-ulated at 36 HAI, earlier than activation of the other complexes of the thylakoid (Figures 6 and 7). Together, these results suggest that the first phase of thylakoid biogenesis includes the assembly of PSII complexes. The large diameter and planar geometry of the intrinsic domain of these PSII complexes (Nevo et al., 2012) would be expected to facilitate the thylakoid-flattening process.

Thylakoid Expansion in the 36 HAI Chloroplasts Is Driven in Part by the Incorporation of Membrane Lipids

The thylakoids in the 36 HAI plastids exhibit a greatly expanded surface area and many plastoglobules (Figures 2C and 2D). Both of these changes reflect increased rates of lipid transfer to the thylakoids. Chloroplast membrane lipids are assembled primarily by enzymes in the envelope membranes (Wang and Benning, 2012). Two mechanisms have been proposed to explain how these lipids are transferred to the thylakoids: vesicular transport (Karim and Aronsson, 2014) and nonvesicular lipid transport (Lev, 2012). The vesicular transport hypothesis is supported by the identification of several chloroplast homologs of COPII proteins in bioinformatics studies and by the immunolocalization of CPSAR1 proteins in vesicular structures in chloroplasts of low-temperature- incubated Arabidopsis leaves. However, such vesicles are not typically seen in chloroplasts of room temperature-grown plants preserved by cryofixation methods, and it is often difficult to dis-tinguish plastoglobules from vesicles (Austin et al., 2006; Charuvi et al., 2012). In our opinion, vesicular transport in chloroplasts is at best a minor pathway for transferring chloroplasts lipids and imported chloroplast proteins to developing thylakoids. In contrast to the limited evidence supporting a vesicular transport mechanism, the evidence for nonvesicular transport mechanisms is substantial. For example, in seed plants the principal proteins involved in intraplastid protein trafficking are components of the Toc-Tic complex, whose functional proper-ties have been characterized in considerable detail (Celedon and Cline, 2013). Similarly, the importance of nonvesicular lipid transport mechanisms for transferring selected lipids between different membrane systems has attracted considerable interest in recent years. Seven types of contact sites (10–30 nm spac-ing) between ER membranes and other organelle membranes have been identified in plant cells (Staehelin, 2015), and several of those sites have been shown to be involved in lipid transfer activities. Indeed, nonvesicular lipid transport between mem-branes is most efficient when the membranes are closely linked by tethering molecules (Lebiedzinska et al., 2009; Lev, 2012). A well-characterized nonvesicular lipid transport system of plant cells involves the two-way lipid transport between closely as-sociated chloroplast and ER membranes (Wang and Benning, 2012). In yeast, the Nvj2 protein has been shown to serve as a tethering protein between ER and trans-Golgi membranes and to become activated for lipid transport when ceramides have to be transferred from the ER to the Golgi (Liu et al., 2017).

Contact sites between the inner chloroplast envelope mem-brane and thylakoids can be visualized in well preserved chem-ically fixed chloroplasts (see Figure 2 in Staehelin, 2003) but are more reliably seen in cryofixed samples (Figures 2C, 2D, 4A, and 4B; Supplemental Figures 1C to 1F; Charuvi et al., 2012). These contact sites are less frequent but more concentrated in mature chloroplasts than developing ones, suggesting that they may play a role in aligning the thylakoid membranes within the chloroplasts, in addition to lipid transfer (Figure 10).

Bound Polysomes Define the Sites of Grana Stack Assembly, and LHCII, cyt b6f, and ATP Synthase Create the Grana and Stroma Membrane Domains

The two defining structural changes of the 60 HAI plastids are the formation of grana stacks and the lateral differentiation of grana and stroma membrane domains. According to the clas-sical description of grana formation by Brangeon and Mustardy (1979), grana membrane buds originate at the margins of fenes-trae of lamellar thylakoids, and as these tongue-like structures expand, they overgrow the existing membranes and create the nascent grana stacks. New overgrowths subsequently expand the size of the stacks. Yet to be determined are the factors that define where a grana stack is formed and which protein com-plexes participate in this process. In the cotyledon chloroplast biogenesis system, we investigated, the grana-forming membrane sites are defined by membrane- bound polysomes (Figures 3C to 3J). However, unlike the sys-tem described by Brangeon and Mustardy (1979), the membrane bud-forming sites of developing cotyledon chloroplasts originate on the surface of planar membrane domains and not on the mar-gins of fenestrae. Polysomes are also seen attached to the later forming grana thylakoids. All of the newly formed grana folds pos-sess wide, slit-like connections to the originating membranes, a characteristic feature of immature prograna stacks (Figures 3K and 3O), but repeats of unit structures in grana discs (Arvidsson and Sundby, 1999; Shimoni et al., 2005) were not observed. Our RNA-seq and immunoblot analyses demonstrated that the formation of the grana stacks coincides with the appearance of membrane adhesion-promoting LHCII complexes (McDonnel and Staehelin, 1980). The incorporation of PSII complexes into the stacked membrane regions is likely driven by the tendency of PSII and LHCII to assemble into heteromeric supercomplexes (Dekker and Boekema, 2005). By contrast, the appearance of ATP synthase complexes that are confined to the nonstacked membrane domains (Miller and Staehelin, 1976) most likely helps stabilize the adjacent stroma thylakoid regions. Finally, the addition of cyt b6f complexes to the PSII and ATP synthase complexes may allow for the generation of ATP by the incom-plete electron transport chain.

Thylakoid Biosynthesis Appears to Conclude with the Assembly of PSI Complexes, the Incorporation of CURT1A Proteins, and the Narrowing of the Grana-Stroma Membrane Connecting Regions

Genes for PSI construction are upregulated later than those for PSII during thylakoid biogenesis (Figures 6 and 7). The simultaneous

1492 The Plant Cell

appearance of both stroma-translated PsaA and cytosol- translated PsaD subunits (Figures 7C and 7D) is likely indic-ative of the assembly of functional PSI complexes. The addi-tion of PSI complexes to the developing thylakoids together with the lateral fusion of the grana stacks, possibly mediated by the FZL protein, would be expected to expand the stroma membrane regions, thereby necessitating the addition of more CURT1A proteins to stabilize the boundary regions of the grana stacks. The final step of thylakoid biogenesis at 120 HAI involves the conversion of the wide grana-stroma membrane-connecting slits into much smaller and well-defined tubular connections. As documented previously (Austin and Staehelin, 2011), the size of these latter connections is highly variable, suggesting that control of their size might be part of a mechanism to regulate grana-to-stroma ion and protein movements. We postulate that this type of membrane structure regulation might be important for optimizing the functional activities of mature chloroplasts.

METHODS

Materials and Plant Growth Conditions

All the chemicals were from Sigma-Aldrich (http://www.sigmaaldrich.com) or Thermo-Fisher (https://www.thermofisher.com/) unless speci-fied. Seeds from wild type (Col-0), homozygous rh3-4 mutant (Lee et al., 2013), homozygous fzl mutant (Gao et al., 2006), and fzl mutant com-plemented by the FZL-GFP construct (Gao et al., 2006) plants were surface-sterilized and incubated in 4°C overnight. The seeds were ger-minated and grown on 0.75% phytoagar plates supplemented with half-strength Murashige-Skoog salt and MES buffer (0.5 g/L, pH 5.7) under continuous light (120 μE m−2 s−1, white fluorescent light bulb) in a growth chamber (22°C; Panasonic; catalog no. MLR-352H-PB) before their cot-yledons were dissected for high-pressure freezing, immunoblot analyses, and RNA-seq experiments. Some seedlings grew faster or slower than most of the seedlings in the same plates. Seedlings for which develop-mental stages deviated from the seedlings shown in Figures 1A to 1E were removed before sampling.

High-Pressure Freezing, Sample Processing, and Microscopy

High-pressure freezing, freeze substitution, resin embedding, and ultra-microtomy were performed as described (Kang, 2010). In brief, cotyledon tissues were dissected and rapidly frozen with an HPM100 high-pressure freezer (Leica Microsystems). Before freezing, the seedlings were imaged with a hand-held digital microscope (Dino-Lite; catalog no. AM4113TL), and their cotyledons were examined with a confocal laser scanning microscope (Zeiss) to assess their chlorophyll autofluorescence with the conditions de-scribed by Park et al. (2015). The samples were freeze-substituted at −80°C for 72 h, and excess OsO4 was removed by rinsing with precooled acetone. After being slowly warmed up to room temperature over 48 h, tissue sam-ples were separated from planchettes and embedded in Embed-812 resin (Electron Microscopy Sciences; catalog no. 14120). Thin sections (80 nm thick) prepared from sample blocks of each time point were examined with a Hitachi 7400 TEM (Hitachi-High Technologies) operated at 80 kV.

Dual-Axis Electron Tomography, Tomogram Reconstruction, Modeling, and Measuring Morphometric Parameters

Semithick sections (250 nm) were collected on formvar-coated copper slot grids (Electron Microscopy Sciences; catalog no. GS2010-Cu) and

stained with 2% uranyl acetate in 70% methanol followed by Reynold’s lead citrate. Tilt series were collected from 60° to −60° (1.5° intervals) with a 200-kV Tecnai F20 intermediate voltage electron microscopy (FEI). For dual-axis tomography analysis, tilt series around two orthogonal axes were acquired from each section using the tomography data acquisition program installed in the microscope by the manufacturer. Tomograms were reconstructed as described (Toyooka and Kang, 2014).

To generate models of complicated thylakoid membranes, we used the autocontour command (bio3d.colorado.edu/imod/doc/3dmodHelp/autox.html) of the 3dmod software package. Noise levels of tomographic slices were reduced by increasing their image thicknesses, and thylakoid membranes in the denoised slice images were traced with the autocon-tour under the high contrast mode with the threshold values between 140 and 160. The resulting contours were smoothened, and their excess points were deleted with the drawing tool plug-in (http://www.andrewn-oske.com/student/downloads/imod/drawingtools.html). This semiauto-matic modeling method is explained by Mai and Kang (2017). Thylakoid membranes were outlined in every 4th slice, and obvious errors in the outlines were corrected before the contours were meshed to generate 3D models with the imodmesh command. To compare luminal widths of 24 HAI prothylakoids and 36 HAI pregranal thylakoids, open contours spanning thylakoid lumens were drawn in the tomographic slices after loading in 3dmod and lengths of the contours were extracted with the imodinfo command (bio3d.colorado.edu/imod/doc/3dmodHelp/autox.html). Thirty-one sites in prothylakoids (three plastids) and 20 sites in pregranal thylakoids (three plastids) were measured.

Ribosome Density Measurements

Outlines of stroma space over thylakoid membranes were drawn with the sculpt tool of the Drawing tools (brush size = 18 nm) and the outlines were meshed to calculate the volume inside the mesh. Ribosomes within the meshed volume were identified, counted, and modeled as individual spheres (Supplemental Figures 2A and 2B). Ribosome densities were calculated as the values of ribosome numbers divided by volumes of the 18-nm thickness layer (Supplemental Figures 2C and 2D). Ribosome densities and their standard deviations were measured from three ran-domly chosen sites in the bulk stroma (36 and 60 HAI), prothylakoids (36 HAI), pregranal thylakoids (36 HAI), unstacked thylakoids (60 HAI), and grana-forming thylakoids (60 HAI). The bar charts and Student’s t tests for significant differences in ribosome densities (two tailed and unpaired tests) in Figures 2G and 3Q were prepared with Microsoft Excel for Mac (version 16.11.1). At each site, 31 to 50 ribosomes were counted.

Immunoblot Analysis and Immunogold Labeling

For immunoblot analysis, cotyledon tissues from seedlings at 24, 36, 60, 84, and 120 HAI were dissected and homogenized in 100 µL of 2× SDS-PAGE sample buffer (Sigma-Aldrich; catalog no. S3401-10VL) and incubated at 95°C for 5 min. The samples were cleared of insoluble debris by centrifugation at 16,100g for 5 min at room temperature. For each lane, 5 to 6 mg of cotyledon protein extract was resolved on a 15% (w/v) SDS-polyacrylamide minigel and analyzed by immunoblotting as described by Kang et al. (2001). After incubating with primary antibodies and horseradish peroxidase-conjugated secondary antibodies (Agrisera; catalog no. AS09 602), chemiluminescence from the blots was generated using the Clarity Max Western ECL Substrates (Bio-Rad, catalog no. 170-5060), and the blots were imaged with ChemiDoc Touch System (Bio-Rad; catalog no. 17001401). Immunoblot analyses were repeated three times with total protein extracts from three independent sets of cotyledon samples. We performed Student’s t test (one-tailed and unpaired test) with the triple replicate immunoblot data to determine when polypeptide quantities increase significantly using Microsoft Excel (version 16.11.1). The immunogold labeling experiments were performed according to the

Electron Tomography of Thylakoid Assembly 1493

protocol explained by Kang (2010). Antibodies for PsbA (AS10 704), PsbN (AS14 2786), PsaA (AS06 172), PsaD (AS09 461), Lhca (AS01 005), AtpB (AS05 085), 11) AtpC (AS08 312), PetB (AS03 034), 13) PetC (AS08 330), and CURT1A (AS08 316) were purchased from Agrisera. Anti-PBA1 an-tibody (ab98861) and anti-GFP antibody (ab6556) were purchased from Abcam. Antibodies against PsaA and PsbO were provided by Michael Seibert (National Renewable Energy Laboratory). Antibodies for PsbP (Henry et al., 1997) and Lhcb (Payan and Cline, 1991) were donated by Kenneth Cline (University of Florida)

Transcriptomic Analyses

Total RNA samples were isolated from seedlings at each time point using Qiagen Plant RNA extraction kit (Qiagen; catalog no. 74904) and rRNA in the samples was depleted with the Invitrogen Ribominus Plant Kit for RNA-seq (Thermo Fisher; catalog no. A1083808). cDNA libraries for Illumina sequencing were prepared according to the protocol for Illumi-na TruSeq RNA-seq library as described previously (https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/21807852). The libraries were sequenced on the Illumina Hi-Seq X10 platform using the PE150 run mode (Cloudhealth). After removing reads mapped to rRNA sequences from the RNA-seq data, we analyzed the remaining reads using TopHat and cufflinks as de-scribed previously (Trapnell et al., 2012; https://www.nature.com/nprot/journal/v7/n3/full/nprot.2012.016.html). The reads were mapped to the Arabidopsis TAIR10 reference genome. FPKM values for genes encoding proteins of the thylakoid membrane complexes, CURT1 family genes, and FZL were calculated to estimate their expression levels. The heat maps and the line charts were generated with R Studio (version 1.1.383) and Microsoft Excel (version 15.34), respectively. Two independent RNA-seq experiments were performed (from seedling harvest to preparation of cDNA library for Illumina sequencing). Heat maps and line charts in Figure 6 and Supplemental Figure 3 show results from the two RNA-seq analyses. FPKMs of CURT1 family genes and of FZL at the five time points illustrated in Figures 6E and 6F are their average values from the two data sets.

Gene Expression Analyses by Droplet Digital PCR

We selected several genes encoding subunits of thylakoid membrane complexes in Figure 6 and determined their transcript levels via ddPCR. Total RNA samples from Arabidopsis seedlings at 24, 36, 60, 84, and 120 HAI were isolated with the RNeasy Plant Mini Kit (Qiagen; catalog no. 74903), and equal amounts of RNA samples from each stage (600 ng) were reverse transcribed with a QuantiNova reverse transcription (RT) kit (Qiagen; catalog no. 205411). Three replicates of RT mixes were generat-ed for each stage. We had to dilute the RT mixes before ddPCR because cDNA concentrations of the genes in the mixes were too high and their ddPCR amplitudes surpassed dynamic ranges. To estimate amounts of cDNA templates of the selected genes, qRT-PCR assays were per-formed (denaturation at 98°C, annealing/extension at 60°C, 40 cycles) using a CFX96 real-time PCR detection system (Bio-Rad). qRT-PCR re-action mixes (20 µL) contained 4.5 ng of RT mix, 10 μL iTaq Universal SYBR Green Supermix (Bio-Rad; catalog no. 1725120), and 14 pmol of 5ʹ and 3ʹ primers. After diluting RT mixes according to qRT-PCR results, ddPCR assay was performed with a QX200 Droplet Digital PCR System (Bio-Rad). ddPCR reaction mixes (20 µL) contained diluted RT mixes, 2 pmol of 5ʹ primer, 2 pmol of 3ʹ primer, and 10 μL EvaGreen Digital PCR Supermix (Bio-Rad; catalog no. 1864034). After generating droplets (Bio-Rad; QX200 Droplet Generation Oil for EvaGreen; catalog no. 1864005), the reaction mixes were transferred to a 96-well plate and the plate was sealed with a PX1 PCR Plate Sealer (Bio-Rad). Fluorescent droplets were quantified with a QX200 Droplet Reader (Bio-Rad; catalog no. 1864003), and the results were analyzed using the QuantaSoft Analysis Pro soft-

ware package (Bio-Rad; bulletin no. 6827). Absolute amounts of DNA (copy numbers per picogram of cDNA sample for plastid-encoded genes and copy numbers for nanogram of cDNA sample for nucleus-encoded gens) were calculated with Microsoft Excel for Mac (version 16.11.1). Primers for ddPCR are listed in Supplemental Data Set 6. The same primer pairs were used for ddPCR and qRT-PCR.

Accession Numbers

The RNA-seq data have been deposited in NCBI Sequence Read Archive under accession number PRJNA418881.

Supplemental Data

Supplemental Figure 1. Electron micrographs of proplastids and vacuoles in developing cotyledon cells.

Supplemental Figure 2. Tomographic slice and ribosome models for calculating densities of ribosomes associated with thylakoid mem-branes.

Supplemental Figure 3. Heat maps and line chart showing transcript levels of the four electron transport complex subunits of the thylakoid and Rubisco from the duplicate RNA-seq experiment.

Supplemental Figure 4. Electron micrographs of 120 HAI chloro-plasts.

Supplemental Data Set 1. Measurements of chlorophyll autofluores-cence sizes.

Supplemental Data Set 2. Measurements of thylakoid thickness.

Supplemental Data Set 3. Ribosome density measurements.

Supplemental Data Set 4. Statistics of the two rounds of RNA-seq experiments.

Supplemental Data Set 5. Transcript levels of genes encoding sub-units of the electron transport chain complexes in the thylakoid mem-brane from the RNA-seq experiment used to prepare the heat maps and line charts in Figure 6 and Supplemental Figure 4.

Supplemental Data Set 6. ddPCR quantification (three replicates) and primers for the experiment

Supplemental Data Set 7. Quantification of polypeptide chemilumi-nescence with a digital imaging system.

Supplemental Movie 1. Tomographic volume containing the progranal thylakoid with the dome-shaped membrane outgrowth in Figure 3C.

Supplemental Movie 2. Tomographic volume containing the progranal stack in Figure 3K.

Supplemental Movie 3. Tomographic volume containing the progranal stack in Figure 3L.

Supplemental Movie 4. Tomographic volume containing the grana stack in Figures 4C to 4H (inside the dashed red oval).

Supplemental Movie 5. Tomographic volume containing the grana stack in Figures 5B to 5E (inside the dashed red oval).

ACKNOWLEDGMENTS

We thank Seibert (National Renewable Energy Laboratory, Golden, CO) and Kenneth Cline (University of Florida) for sharing their antibodies. We also thank Anton Titov, Mark McNeely, Dallas Khamiss, Robert Lloyd, and Kwanghee Lee (University of Florida) for their help in preparing preliminary thylakoid models and immunoblots not included here. The ddPCR exper-iments were assisted by Hong-Ming Lam and Yee-Shan Ku (Chinese Uni-versity of Hong Kong). This work was supported by the Research Grants

1494 The Plant Cell

Council of Hong Kong (GRF14126116, AoE/M-05/12, C4011-14R, and GRF14119814), by a USDA NIFA Award AFRI grant (2011-67013-30119), and by the Rural Development Administration, Republic of Korea, Cooper-ative Research Program for Agriculture Science and Technology Develop-ment Project PJ010953092018.

AUTHOR CONTRIBUTIONS

B.-H.K., L.A.S., and K.W.O. designed the research. B.-H.K. performed electron microscopy sample preparation, tomography data collection, and tomogram reconstruction. Z.L. and K.K.M. generated 3D models of thylakoids. Z.L. did immunoblot analysis, ECL quantification, immu-nogold labeling, and transmission electron microscopy imaging. N.Z. carried out RNA-seq experiments. K.K.M. calculated ribosome densities. Z.Y.L. performed ddPCR measurements of transcript concentrations. D.T. and S.Z. analyzed RNA-seq data. B.-H.K., L.A.S., and K.W.O. wrote the article.

Received January 16, 2018; revised May 2, 2018; accepted June 6, 2018; published June 7, 2018.

REFERENCES

Adam, Z., Charuvi, D., Tsabari, O., Knopf, R.R., and Reich, Z. (2011). Biogenesis of thylakoid networks in angiosperms: knowns and un-knowns. Plant Mol. Biol. 76: 221–234.

Armbruster, U., et al. (2013). Arabidopsis CURVATURE THYLAKOID1 proteins modify thylakoid architecture by inducing membrane curva-ture. Plant Cell 25: 2661–2678.

Arvidsson, P.-O., and Sundby, C. (1999). A model for the topolo-gy of the chloroplast thylakoid membrane. Funct. Plant Biol. 26: 687–694.

Austin II, J.R., and Staehelin, L.A. (2011). Three-dimensional architec-ture of grana and stroma thylakoids of higher plants as determined by electron tomography. Plant Physiol. 155: 1601–1611.

Austin II, J.R., Frost, E., Vidi, P.-A., Kessler, F., and Staehelin, L.A. (2006). Plastoglobules are lipoprotein subcompartments of the chlo-roplast that are permanently coupled to thylakoid membranes and contain biosynthetic enzymes. Plant Cell 18: 1693–1703.

Blomqvist, L.A., Ryberg, M., and Sundqvist, C. (2008). Proteomic anal-ysis of highly purified prolamellar bodies reveals their significance in chloroplast development. Photosynth. Res. 96: 37–50.

Brangeon, A., and Mustardy, L.A. (1979). The ontogenetic assembly of intra-chloroplastic lamellae viewed in 3-dimension. Biol. Cell. 36: 71–80.

Celedon, J.M., and Cline, K. (2013). Intra-plastid protein trafficking: how plant cells adapted prokaryotic mechanisms to the eukaryotic condition. Biochim. Biophys. Acta 1833: 341–351.

Charuvi, D., Kiss, V., Nevo, R., Shimoni, E., Adam, Z., and Reich, Z. (2012). Gain and loss of photosynthetic membranes during plastid dif-ferentiation in the shoot apex of Arabidopsis. Plant Cell 24: 1143–1157.

Daum, B., and Kühlbrandt, W. (2011). Electron tomography of plant thylakoid membranes. J. Exp. Bot. 62: 2393–2402.

Daum, B., Nicastro, D., Austin II, J., McIntosh, J.R., and Kühlbrandt, W. (2010). Arrangement of photosystem II and ATP synthase in chlo-roplast membranes of spinach and pea. Plant Cell 22: 1299–1312.

Dekker, J.P., and Boekema, E.J. (2005). Supramolecular organization of thylakoid membrane proteins in green plants. Biochim. Biophys. Acta 1706: 12–39.

Engel, B.D., Schaffer, M., Kuhn Cuellar, L., Villa, E., Plitzko, J.M., and Baumeister, W. (2015). Native architecture of the Chlamydomonas chlo-roplast revealed by in situ cryo-electron tomography. eLife 4: 3583–3529.

Gao, H., Sage, T.L., and Osteryoung, K.W. (2006). FZL, an FZO-like protein in plants, is a determinant of thylakoid and chloroplast mor-phology. Proc. Natl. Acad. Sci. USA 103: 6759–6764.

Garab, G. (2014). Hierarchical organization and structural flexibility of thylakoid membranes. Biochim. Biophys. Acta 1837: 481–494.

Gilkey, J.C., and Staehelin, L.A. (1986). Advances in ultrarapid freez-ing for the preservation of cellular ultrastructure. J. Electron Microsc. Tech. 3: 177–210.

Gunning, B.E.S. (1965). The greening process in plastids. Protoplasma 60: 111–130.

Gunning, B., and Steer, M.W. (1975). Plant Cell Biology. An Ultrastruc-tural Approach (Ultrastructure and Biology of Plant Cells). (New York: Jones & Bartlett Learning).

Heinz, S., Liauw, P., Nickelsen, J., and Nowaczyk, M. (2016). Analy-sis of photosystem II biogenesis in cyanobacteria. Biochim. Biophys. Acta 1857: 274–287.

Henningsen, K.W., and Boynton, J.E. (1974). Macromolecular physiol-ogy of plastids. IX. Development of plastid membranes during green-ing of dark-grown barley seedlings. J. Cell Sci. 15: 31–55.

Henry, R., Carrigan, M., McCaffrey, M., Ma, X., and Cline, K. (1997). Targeting determinants and proposed evolutionary basis for the Sec and the Delta pH protein transport systems in chloroplast thylakoid membranes. J. Cell Biol. 136: 823–832.

Hindson, C.M., Chevillet, J.R., Briggs, H.A., Gallichotte, E.N., Ruf, I.K., Hindson, B.J., Vessella, R.L., and Tewari, M. (2013). Absolute quantification by droplet digital PCR versus analog real-time PCR. Nat. Methods 10: 1003–1005.

Jarvis, P., and López-Juez, E. (2013). Biogenesis and homeostasis of chloroplasts and other plastids. Nat. Rev. Mol. Cell Biol. 14: 787–802.

Kang, B.-H. (2010). Electron microscopy and high-pressure freezing of Arabidopsis. Methods Cell Biol. 96: 259–283.

Kang, B.H., Busse, J.S., Dickey, C., Rancour, D.M., and Bednarek, S.Y. (2001). The arabidopsis cell plate-associated dynamin-like pro-tein, ADL1Ap, is required for multiple stages of plant growth and de-velopment. Plant Physiol. 126: 47–68.

Karim, S., and Aronsson, H. (2014). The puzzle of chloroplast vesicle transport - involvement of GTPases. Front. Plant Sci. 5: 472.

Kirchhoff, H., Hall, C., Wood, M., Herbstová, M., Tsabari, O., Nevo, R., Charuvi, D., Shimoni, E., and Reich, Z. (2011). Dynamic control of protein diffusion within the granal thylakoid lumen. Proc. Natl. Acad. Sci. USA 108: 20248–20253.

Kouřil, R., Oostergetel, G.T., and Boekema, E.J. (2011). Fine structure of granal thylakoid membrane organization using cryo electron to-mography. Biochim. Biophys. Acta 1807: 368–374.

Kowalewska, Ł.M., Mazur, R., Suski, S., Garstka, M., and Mostowska, A. (2016). Three-dimensional visualization of the internal plastid membrane network during runner bean chloroplast biogenesis. Plant Cell 28: 875–891.

Lebiedzinska, M., Szabadkai, G., Jones, A.W.E., Duszynski, J., and Wieckowski, M.R. (2009). Interactions between the endoplasmic reticulum, mitochondria, plasma membrane and other subcellular organelles. Int. J. Biochem. Cell Biol. 41: 1805–1816.

Lee, K.-H., Park, J., Williams, D.S., Xiong, Y., Hwang, I., and Kang, B.-H. (2013). Defective chloroplast development inhibits maintenance of normal levels of abscisic acid in a mutant of the Arabidopsis RH3 DEAD-box protein during early post-germination growth. Plant J. 73: 720–732.

Lev, S. (2012). Nonvesicular lipid transfer from the endoplasmic reticu-lum. Cold Spring Harb. Perspect. Biol. 4: a013300.

Liu, H., Roose, J.L., Cameron, J.C., and Pakrasi, H.B. (2011). A ge-netically tagged Psb27 protein allows purification of two consecutive photosystem II (PSII) assembly intermediates in Synechocystis 6803, a cyanobacterium. J. Biol. Chem. 286: 24865–24871.

Liu, L.-K., Choudhary, V., Toulmay, A., and Prinz, W.A. (2017). An in-ducible ER-Golgi tether facilitates ceramide transport to alleviate lipo-toxicity. J. Cell Biol. 216: 131–147.

Electron Tomography of Thylakoid Assembly 1495

Mai, K.K.K., and Kang, B.-H. (2017). Semiautomatic segmentation of plant Golgi stacks in electron tomograms using 3dmod. In Plant Cell Morphogenesis, Methods in Molecular Biology, L. Jiang, ed (New York: Springer), pp. 97–104.

McDonnel, A., and Staehelin, L.A. (1980). Adhesion between lipo-somes mediated by the chlorophyll a/b light-harvesting complex iso-lated from chloroplast membranes. J. Cell Biol. 84: 40–56.

Miller, K.R., and Staehelin, L.A. (1976). Analysis of the thylakoid outer surface. Coupling factor is limited to unstacked membrane regions. J. Cell Biol. 68: 30–47.

Mustárdy, L., and Garab, G. (2003). Granum revisited. A three- dimensional model--where things fall into place. Trends Plant Sci. 8: 117–122.

Nevo, R., Charuvi, D., Tsabari, O., and Reich, Z. (2012). Composition, architecture and dynamics of the photosynthetic apparatus in higher plants. Plant J. 70: 157–176.

Paolillo, D.J., Jr. (1970). The three-dimensional arrangement of inter-granal lamellae in chloroplasts. J. Cell Sci. 6: 243–255.

Park, J., Cui, Y., and Kang, B.-H. (2015). AtPGL3 is an Arabidopsis BURP domain protein that is localized to the cell wall and promotes cell enlargement. Front. Plant Sci. 6: 412.

Payan, L.A., and Cline, K. (1991). A stromal protein factor maintains the solubility and insertion competence of an imported thylakoid mem-brane protein. J. Cell Biol. 112: 603–613.

Pogson, B.J., Ganguly, D., and Albrecht-Borth, V. (2015). Insights into chloroplast biogenesis and development. Biochim. Biophy. Acta 1847: 1017–1024.

Pribil, M., Labs, M., and Leister, D. (2014). Structure and dynamics of thylakoids in land plants. J. Exp. Bot. 65: 1955–1972.

Race, H.L., Herrmann, R.G., and Martin, W. (1999). Why have organ-elles retained genomes?. Trends Genet. 15: 364–370.

Rast, A., Heinz, S., and Nickelsen, J. (2015). Biogenesis of thylakoid membranes. Biochim. Biophy. Acta 1847: 821–830.

Rudowska, L., Gieczewska, K., Mazur, R., Garstka, M., and Mostowska, A. (2012). Chloroplast biogenesis - correlation between structure and function. Biochim. Biophys. Acta 1817: 1380–1387.

Ryberg, M., and Sundqvist, C. (1982). Characterization of prolamellar bodies and prothylakoids fractionated from wheat etioplasts. Physiol. Plant. 56: 125–132.

Selstam, E., Schelin, J., Williams, W.P., and Brain, A.P.R. (2007). Structural organisation of prolamellar bodies (PLB) isolated from Zea mays. Parallel TEM, SAXS and absorption spectra measurements on samples subjected to freeze-thaw, reduced pH and high-salt pertur-bation. Biochim. Biophys. Acta 1768: 2235–2245.

Shibata, Y., Shemesh, T., Prinz, W.A., Palazzo, A.F., Kozlov, M.M., and Rapoport, T.A. (2010). Mechanisms determining the morphology of the peripheral ER. Cell 143: 774–788.

Shimoni, E., Rav-Hon, O., Ohad, I., Brumfeld, V., and Reich, Z. (2005). Three-dimensional organization of higher-plant chloroplast thylakoid membranes revealed by electron tomography. Plant Cell 17: 2580–2586.

Solymosi, K., and Schoefs, B. (2010). Etioplast and etio-chloroplast formation under natural conditions: the dark side of chlorophyll bio-synthesis in angiosperms. Photosynth. Res. 105: 143–166.

Staehelin, L.A. (2003). Chloroplast structure: from chlorophyll granules to supra-molecular architecture of thylakoid membranes. Photosynth. Res. 76: 185–196.

Staehelin, L.A. (2015). Membrane Structure and Membranous Organ-elles. In Biochemistry and Molecular Biology of Plants, B. Buchanan, W. Gruissem, and R. Jones, eds (West Sussex, UK: Wiley), pp. 2–44.

Staehelin, L.A., and Kang, B.-H. (2008). Nanoscale architecture of en-doplasmic reticulum export sites and of Golgi membranes as deter-mined by electron tomography. Plant Physiol. 147: 1454–1468.

Taylor, S.C., Laperriere, G., and Germain, H. (2017). Droplet Digital PCR versus qPCR for gene expression analysis with low abundant targets: from variable nonsense to publication quality data. Sci. Rep. 7: 2409.

Torabi, S., Umate, P., Manavski, N., Plöchinger, M., Kleinknecht, L., Bogireddi, H., Herrmann, R.G., Wanner, G., Schröder, W.P., and Meurer, J. (2014). PsbN is required for assembly of the photosystem II reaction center in Nicotiana tabacum. Plant Cell 26: 1183–1199.

Toyooka, K., and Kang, B.-H. (2014). Reconstructing plant cells in 3D by serial section electron tomography. Methods Mol. Biol. 1080: 159–170.

Trapnell, C., Roberts, A., Goff, L., Pertea, G., Kim, D., Kelley, D.R., Pimentel, H., Salzberg, S.L., Rinn, J.L., and Pachter, L. (2012). Dif-ferential gene and transcript expression analysis of RNA-seq experi-ments with TopHat and Cufflinks. Nat. Protoc. 7: 562–578.

Wang, Z., and Benning, C. (2012). Chloroplast lipid synthesis and lipid trafficking through ER-plastid membrane contact sites. Biochem. Soc. Trans. 40: 457–463.

Wang, Y., Zhang, Y., Chen, L., Liang, Q., Yin, X.-M., Miao, L., Kang, B.-H., and Xue, D. (2016). Kinetics and specificity of paternal mi-tochondrial elimination in Caenorhabditis elegans. Nat. Commun. 7: 12569.

Waters, M.T., and Langdale, J.A. (2009). The making of a chloroplast. EMBO J. 28: 2861–2873.

Weier, T.E., Sjoland, R.D., and Brown, D.L. (1970). Changes induced by low light intensities on the prolamellar body of 8-day, dark-grown seedlings. Am. J. Bot. 57: 276.

Zheng, H., and Staehelin, L.A. (2011). Protein storage vacuoles are transformed into lytic vacuoles in root meristematic cells of germi-nating seedlings by multiple, cell type-specific mechanisms. Plant Physiol. 155: 2023–2035.

Zirkle, C. (1927). The growth and development of plastids in Lunularia vulgaris, Elodea canadensis, and Zea mays. Am. J. Bot. 14: 429.

DOI 10.1105/tpc.17.00972; originally published online June 7, 2018; 2018;30;1476-1495Plant Cell

Zhong, L. Andrew Staehelin and Byung-Ho KangZizhen Liang, Ning Zhu, Keith K. Mai, Zhongyuna Liu, David Tzeng, Katherine W. Osteryoung, Silin

Linear Chloroplast Biogenesis Program in Greening Arabidopsis CotyledonsThylakoid-Bound Polysomes and a Dynamin-Related Protein, FZL, Mediate Critical Stages of the

 This information is current as of August 9, 2020

 

Supplemental Data /content/suppl/2018/06/07/tpc.17.00972.DC1.html

References /content/30/7/1476.full.html#ref-list-1

This article cites 62 articles, 24 of which can be accessed free at:

Permissions https://www.copyright.com/ccc/openurl.do?sid=pd_hw1532298X&issn=1532298X&WT.mc_id=pd_hw1532298X

eTOCs http://www.plantcell.org/cgi/alerts/ctmain

Sign up for eTOCs at:

CiteTrack Alerts http://www.plantcell.org/cgi/alerts/ctmain

Sign up for CiteTrack Alerts at:

Subscription Information http://www.aspb.org/publications/subscriptions.cfm

is available at:Plant Physiology and The Plant CellSubscription Information for

ADVANCING THE SCIENCE OF PLANT BIOLOGY © American Society of Plant Biologists