25
THE INNOVATION CHALLENGES IN THE AVIATION ENVIRONMENT Aarti Panday

THE INNOVATION CHALLENGES IN THE AVIATION ENVIRONMENT ... · THE INNOVATION CHALLENGES IN THE AVIATION ENVIRONMENT ... Innovation Challenges High Barriers to Entry •First mover

Embed Size (px)

Citation preview

Page 1: THE INNOVATION CHALLENGES IN THE AVIATION ENVIRONMENT ... · THE INNOVATION CHALLENGES IN THE AVIATION ENVIRONMENT ... Innovation Challenges High Barriers to Entry •First mover

THE INNOVATION CHALLENGES IN

THE AVIATION ENVIRONMENTAarti Panday

Page 2: THE INNOVATION CHALLENGES IN THE AVIATION ENVIRONMENT ... · THE INNOVATION CHALLENGES IN THE AVIATION ENVIRONMENT ... Innovation Challenges High Barriers to Entry •First mover

2

Overview

National System of Innovation

TIA – Mandate, Role, Themes

The Aviation Landscape

Innovation Challenges

Where To From Here?

Page 3: THE INNOVATION CHALLENGES IN THE AVIATION ENVIRONMENT ... · THE INNOVATION CHALLENGES IN THE AVIATION ENVIRONMENT ... Innovation Challenges High Barriers to Entry •First mover

3

The National System of Innovation

(NSI)

New Technologies

Initiate

Import Modify

Diffuse

Increased Wealth

Improved Quality of Life

Private Sector

Universities

Science Councils

Government

NGO’s

International Funders

Page 4: THE INNOVATION CHALLENGES IN THE AVIATION ENVIRONMENT ... · THE INNOVATION CHALLENGES IN THE AVIATION ENVIRONMENT ... Innovation Challenges High Barriers to Entry •First mover

4

TIA Act No. 26 of 2008

“…stimulating and intensifying technological innovation in

order to improve economic growth and the quality of life of all

South Africans by supporting the development and exploitation

of technological innovations.”

“…the application in practice of creative new ideas, which includes

inventions, discoveries and processes by which new products and

services enter the market and the creation of new businesses.”

Technology

Ideas

Technology

Innovation

TIA Mandate

Page 5: THE INNOVATION CHALLENGES IN THE AVIATION ENVIRONMENT ... · THE INNOVATION CHALLENGES IN THE AVIATION ENVIRONMENT ... Innovation Challenges High Barriers to Entry •First mover

5

Basic Research Applied Research Tech Development Commercialisation

IP V

alu

e

Lowered Risk/

More certain Return

High Risk/

Uncertain Return

Partnerships

(e.g. IDC, NEF)

Partnerships

(e.g. NRF)

TIA’s Positioning Along

The Innovation Value Chain

Focused TIA Support

Technology Readiness Level (TRL)

Business Readiness Level

TRL 1-2 TRL 3-9

Page 6: THE INNOVATION CHALLENGES IN THE AVIATION ENVIRONMENT ... · THE INNOVATION CHALLENGES IN THE AVIATION ENVIRONMENT ... Innovation Challenges High Barriers to Entry •First mover

6

TIA’s Role

VALUE CHAIN AREA

TIA ROLE

ORGANIZATION CAPABILITY

DEPENDENCIES

Applied Research

Innovation Catalyst [Connector]

Technology Development

De-Risk Innovation- Technology Value- Market Acceptance

Commercialization

Venture Capital Catalyst

“Investor Spotting”Core Business:

Innovation Market-Readiness

“Innovation Spotting”

- Innovation Forum

- Top Tech 100- “Brokerage”

- Market Readiness skills and mindset

- Tech Transfer- Science Councils- Private Sector- “Outliers”

Technology Stations and Platforms

6

Page 7: THE INNOVATION CHALLENGES IN THE AVIATION ENVIRONMENT ... · THE INNOVATION CHALLENGES IN THE AVIATION ENVIRONMENT ... Innovation Challenges High Barriers to Entry •First mover

7

TIA’s Role + Other Funders in

the Value Chain

Page 8: THE INNOVATION CHALLENGES IN THE AVIATION ENVIRONMENT ... · THE INNOVATION CHALLENGES IN THE AVIATION ENVIRONMENT ... Innovation Challenges High Barriers to Entry •First mover

8

TIA’s Themes

Page 9: THE INNOVATION CHALLENGES IN THE AVIATION ENVIRONMENT ... · THE INNOVATION CHALLENGES IN THE AVIATION ENVIRONMENT ... Innovation Challenges High Barriers to Entry •First mover

9

The Aviation Landscape

Page 10: THE INNOVATION CHALLENGES IN THE AVIATION ENVIRONMENT ... · THE INNOVATION CHALLENGES IN THE AVIATION ENVIRONMENT ... Innovation Challenges High Barriers to Entry •First mover

10

The Aviation Landscape

Page 11: THE INNOVATION CHALLENGES IN THE AVIATION ENVIRONMENT ... · THE INNOVATION CHALLENGES IN THE AVIATION ENVIRONMENT ... Innovation Challenges High Barriers to Entry •First mover

11

The Aviation Landscape -

Value Chain

• South African Aviation Industry 2011 (IATA)

– 2% GDP, 300 000 jobs directly

– Catalytic : jobs & economic impact – millions & billions

• Broadest Context: Design Life Cycle

– Tier One (Complete System)

– Tier Two (Major Sub-Systems)

– Tier Three (Minor Sub-Systems)

– …

Page 12: THE INNOVATION CHALLENGES IN THE AVIATION ENVIRONMENT ... · THE INNOVATION CHALLENGES IN THE AVIATION ENVIRONMENT ... Innovation Challenges High Barriers to Entry •First mover

12

The Aviation Landscape -

Value Chain

• Broadest Context:

• Innovation Diversity Continuum:

Adapting/refining existing

products/systems/processes

Cumulative simple, small incremental

innovation on existing

products/systems

New, large-scale, complex systems

Page 13: THE INNOVATION CHALLENGES IN THE AVIATION ENVIRONMENT ... · THE INNOVATION CHALLENGES IN THE AVIATION ENVIRONMENT ... Innovation Challenges High Barriers to Entry •First mover

Innovation Challenges - Global

• Change of innovation paradigm

• Technological complexity vs. faster, cheaper, better

• Managing globalisation

• Offshore manufacturing

• A380, B787, …

High profile program execution “failures”

• Established industries have a different class of problems

Page 14: THE INNOVATION CHALLENGES IN THE AVIATION ENVIRONMENT ... · THE INNOVATION CHALLENGES IN THE AVIATION ENVIRONMENT ... Innovation Challenges High Barriers to Entry •First mover

14

Innovation Challenges: South

Africa

High Barriers to Entry

Compliance & Safety

Access to Finance/Funding

Narrow Focus in Aviation

Landscape

Fragmented Participation

Socio-political History

Page 15: THE INNOVATION CHALLENGES IN THE AVIATION ENVIRONMENT ... · THE INNOVATION CHALLENGES IN THE AVIATION ENVIRONMENT ... Innovation Challenges High Barriers to Entry •First mover

15

Innovation Challenges

High Barriers to Entry

• First mover status

• Product innovation

• Process innovation

• Disruptive technology• Product

differentiation

• Value proposition

Page 16: THE INNOVATION CHALLENGES IN THE AVIATION ENVIRONMENT ... · THE INNOVATION CHALLENGES IN THE AVIATION ENVIRONMENT ... Innovation Challenges High Barriers to Entry •First mover

Innovation Challenges

• Regulated industry

• Rigorous framework – across life cycle

• Country-specific regulations

• Licenses, Ratings, Competencies

• Common place vs. new players

Compliance & Safety

Socio-political History

• BBBEE

• Employment Equity/Affirmative Action

• Women

Page 17: THE INNOVATION CHALLENGES IN THE AVIATION ENVIRONMENT ... · THE INNOVATION CHALLENGES IN THE AVIATION ENVIRONMENT ... Innovation Challenges High Barriers to Entry •First mover

Innovation Challenges

• Industry, Academia, Science Councils, Service Providers, Policy-makers, Funders, Regulators, …

• Engineers, Artisans, Pilots, Technicians, Fire Personnel, Cabin Crew, Aeromedical, Dangerous Goods Inspectors, Air Traffic Controllers …

Fragmented Participation

• Customers?

Page 18: THE INNOVATION CHALLENGES IN THE AVIATION ENVIRONMENT ... · THE INNOVATION CHALLENGES IN THE AVIATION ENVIRONMENT ... Innovation Challenges High Barriers to Entry •First mover

18

• Clusters, Networks, Hubs, Aerotropolis

• Geography

Innovation Challenges

Fragmented Participation

Page 19: THE INNOVATION CHALLENGES IN THE AVIATION ENVIRONMENT ... · THE INNOVATION CHALLENGES IN THE AVIATION ENVIRONMENT ... Innovation Challenges High Barriers to Entry •First mover

Innovation Challenges

Access to Finance/Funding

• Generic Criteria

• Decision to invest?

– Market Opportunity

– Business Model

– Strong Management Team

• What investors want?

– Return on investment: 3 – 7 years

– Diverse management team: technical, business, … all the skills

• Risk averse vs. risk aware?

• Business models for commercialising innovative new technology

• Exit strategies

Page 20: THE INNOVATION CHALLENGES IN THE AVIATION ENVIRONMENT ... · THE INNOVATION CHALLENGES IN THE AVIATION ENVIRONMENT ... Innovation Challenges High Barriers to Entry •First mover

20

Innovation Challenges

• Some numbers:

– Development cost, Airbus A380 : R149 billion (€11 billion)

– Eurocopter Tiger: R13.8 billion (US $ 1.4 billion)

– Rooivalk: R1 billion (concept to first prototype flight)

– Rooivalk: R7 billion (total project cost)

Access to Finance/Funding

• Scale of funding required

• Years of investment

• Source: Government, Private Equity, Venture Capital

• Tangible milestones

• Disciplined project management

Page 21: THE INNOVATION CHALLENGES IN THE AVIATION ENVIRONMENT ... · THE INNOVATION CHALLENGES IN THE AVIATION ENVIRONMENT ... Innovation Challenges High Barriers to Entry •First mover

Innovation Challenges

• Aircraft design

• Major subsystem design

• OEM/System Integrator

Narrow Focus in Aviation Landscape

• Innovation diversity

• Innovation across aviation landscape – wide portfolio

• Organisational structure and culture

Page 22: THE INNOVATION CHALLENGES IN THE AVIATION ENVIRONMENT ... · THE INNOVATION CHALLENGES IN THE AVIATION ENVIRONMENT ... Innovation Challenges High Barriers to Entry •First mover

Innovation Challenges• Quest Kodiak

• FAR 23 Certification

• Private Investors – Mission Work

• ICON

• LSA Category

• Private investors – phased approach, final phase US $ 60 mill

Page 23: THE INNOVATION CHALLENGES IN THE AVIATION ENVIRONMENT ... · THE INNOVATION CHALLENGES IN THE AVIATION ENVIRONMENT ... Innovation Challenges High Barriers to Entry •First mover

23

Where To From Here?

• Let us work together: Collaborations, Networks

• Compliance is a non-negotiable

• Deep pockets required - Tier 1

• Boost business/commercial/finance skills

• Wide range of innovation sources

• Challenges are opportunities

• Joint Aerospace Steering Committee (JASC) –Industry Forum, R&D Forum

• Engage, debate, share, learn

Page 24: THE INNOVATION CHALLENGES IN THE AVIATION ENVIRONMENT ... · THE INNOVATION CHALLENGES IN THE AVIATION ENVIRONMENT ... Innovation Challenges High Barriers to Entry •First mover

24

A new dawn is inevitable …

Page 25: THE INNOVATION CHALLENGES IN THE AVIATION ENVIRONMENT ... · THE INNOVATION CHALLENGES IN THE AVIATION ENVIRONMENT ... Innovation Challenges High Barriers to Entry •First mover

25

[email protected]

Contact us at [email protected]

Download funding templates & guidelines at www.tia.org.za

Email proposals to [email protected]

Joint Aerospace Steering Committee: Ms. Yolandi Lombaard

[email protected]