The Future of Portugal's Colonies

Embed Size (px)

Text of The Future of Portugal's Colonies

  • The Future of Portugal's ColoniesAuthor(s): Robert Gale WoolbertSource: Foreign Affairs, Vol. 15, No. 2 (Jan., 1937), pp. 374-380Published by: Council on Foreign RelationsStable URL: .Accessed: 15/06/2014 20:21

    Your use of the JSTOR archive indicates your acceptance of the Terms & Conditions of Use, available at .

    .JSTOR is a not-for-profit service that helps scholars, researchers, and students discover, use, and build upon a wide range ofcontent in a trusted digital archive. We use information technology and tools to increase productivity and facilitate new formsof scholarship. For more information about JSTOR, please contact


    Council on Foreign Relations is collaborating with JSTOR to digitize, preserve and extend access to ForeignAffairs.

    This content downloaded from on Sun, 15 Jun 2014 20:21:26 PMAll use subject to JSTOR Terms and Conditions



    By Robert Gale Woolbert

    AS Chancellor Hitler, Dr. Schacht, General Goering and other high German

    jLJl officials have plainly stated in recent months, Germany is resolved to resume her r?le as a colonial power. The Nazis profess to prefer the return of

    Germany's prewar colonies: Togoland, Cameroons, Southwest Africa and German East Africa. These territories are now held as mandates by France and Britain, and the latter countries do not seem at all disposed to surrender them. However, speaking before the League Assembly in September 1935 concerning the possibility of making better use of the world's economic re

    sources, Sir Samuel Hoare stated that: "The view of His Majesty's Govern ment is that the problem is economic rather than political and territorial. It is the fear of monopoly

    ? of the withholding of essential colonial raw materials ? that is causing alarm. It is the desire for a guarantee that the distribution of raw materials will not be unfairly impeded that is stimulating -the demand for further inquiry. So far as His Majesty's Government is concerned, I feel sure

    that we should be ready to take our share in an investigation of these matters." Some Germans have expressed wonder that the possessor of the most exten

    sive colonial empire on earth does not lead the way in making some of her colonies available to nations less fortunately provided. They inquire, and others with them, what other colonial domains might be considered ripe for transfer. Among those which make the inquiry most anxiously are smaller

    Powers like the Netherlands, Belgium, Spain and Portugal. The acquisition of the colonial empires of either the Netherlands or Belgium would be satisfac

    tory, we may be sure, to the German imperialists. However, the line of least resistance does not lead to the Dutch or Belgian possessions but to those of

    Spain and Portugal. In the case of Spain, the few and unimportant areas still held by her would in no way satisfy Germany's colonial demands. On the other

    hand, the abundant natural resources of the Portuguese colonial domain offer a very real temptation.

    One of the anomalies of modern history is the survival of Portugal as an

    important colonial Power. True, her present overseas holdings are but a shadow of their former glory. Nevertheless, the possession of an empire containing over

    800,000 square miles and 9,000,000 inhabitants represents quite an achieve

    ment for a nation which is neither large nor rich. Of course, at the time she laid the foundation for her empire Portugal was not a poor nation, judged by the standards of the times; in the fifteenth century she was one of the leading

    maritime states in Europe. Inspired by such men as Henry the Navigator, Portuguese sailors in the latter part of that century gradually pushed south

    along the coast of Africa, until in i486 Bartolomeu Dias rounded the Cape of Good Hope and in 1498 Vasco da Gama reached Calicut in India. In 1500 King Emanuel assumed the title "Lord of the Conquest, Navigation and Commerce of India, Ethiopia, Arabia and Persia." Within the next few decades great ad venturers like Albuquerque had established Portuguese fortified settlements

    This content downloaded from on Sun, 15 Jun 2014 20:21:26 PMAll use subject to JSTOR Terms and Conditions


    as far east as China. By holding these key ports, the Portuguese gained control of the Indian Ocean and were thus free to monopolize the sea-borne trade between the Orient and Europe. So immensely lucrative was this commerce

    that other peoples naturally sought to intrude. Fortunately for Portugal, she had made an agreement in 1494 with her most dangerous rival, Spain. In their division of the new world between them, Portugal obtained everything east of the forty-sixth meridian of west longitude. This arrangement the other nations felt under no obligation to respect. The consequence was that when Portugal's power began to decay after her union with Spain in 1580, the Dutch conquered one after another of her colonies in Brazil, Africa, India and the East Indies.

    Whatever places the Dutch failed to take were soon captured by the Arabs, the Indian princes or the British, until by the middle of the eighteenth century little remained of Portugal's once magnificent empire. Except for a few unim

    portant stations in the East, all that she still held were certain undefined stretches of the east and west coasts of Africa, used chiefly as hunting grounds for slaves to be sent to Brazil.

    The mother country made no serious effort to develop these colonies until the scramble for a place in the sun that marked the last two decades of the nineteenth century obliged her to defend her centuries-old claims against the encroachments of the stronger Powers. In the end, Portugal managed to pre serve a considerable portion of her African patrimony. Even then, she would not have been able to retain her best colonies had the 1898 agreement between Britain and Germany for the eventual partition of Angola and Mozambique been put into effect. The British probably had no intention of carrying out this

    agreement, for in the very next year they signed a Secret Declaration with

    Portugal renewing the ancient treaty of 1661 by which England obligated her self "to protect the conquests and colonies ... of Portugal against all en

    emies, as well future as present." The outbreak of the World War found the Germans again seeking to enter an agreement with the British for the dismem berment of Portugal's African empire.

    No one can say whether Great Britain will ever be disposed to countenance the disappearance of Portugal as a colonial Power. Historians point out that the alliance between these two countries is the oldest in Europe, dating back to the fourteenth century. We may be sure, however, that more than mere sentiment holds the policies of these nations together. Portugal's colonies are

    valuable alike for their natural resources and for their location on Britain's oceanic route to the East, and it is to Britain's interest that they remain under the control of a friendly and dependent Power. Portugal's interest, naturally, is to cultivate this British solicitude, though her behavior in the present Spanish revolt leads one to wonder whether she is tied quite as closely to London's

    apron-strings as we have usually believed. In the World War, Portugal threw in her lot with the Entente Powers. Vic

    tory won, she was rewarded by being permitted to retain her colonies. The

    Portuguese Government was under no illusions, however, as to the fact that this might be merely a temporary reprieve. In view of the growing competition for colonial territories it behooved Portugal to do her utmost to demonstrate her capacity as a colonial administrator. The Carmona-Salazar dictatorship of recent years has been particularly energetic in this direction. It has extended

    This content downloaded from on Sun, 15 Jun 2014 20:21:26 PMAll use subject to JSTOR Terms and Conditions


    the principles of the corporative state (the Estado Nov?) as set up in the mother

    country to effect a thorough reorganization of the administrative machinery in the colonies. Laws have also been promulgated making the empire a closer economic unit by raising its tariff walls, by favoring Portuguese shipping, and

    by other neo-mercantilistic measures. Unfortunately, these attempts to create a Portuguese imperial autarchy have disrupted the economic life of the colo

    nies, with a consequent lowering of the standard of living. Portugal is not an

    industrial nation and can therefore absorb only a part of her colonies' raw

    materials and supply them with only a fraction of the manufactured goods they need. If there is indeed an incipient communist movement in the colonies, as reports indicate, this is not surprising in view of the repressive economic and social policies of the dictatorship.


    What are the constituent parts of the Portuguese colonial empire? The Azores and the Madeiras are not colonies but integral parts of Portugal. Their

    separation from that country would therefore represent not the redistribution of colonies, but the dismemberment