42

The First Billion Years of History - seeing Galaxies Close to the Dawn of Time Andrew Bunker, Andrew Bunker, Anglo-Australian Observatory & University

Embed Size (px)

Citation preview

Page 1: The First Billion Years of History - seeing Galaxies Close to the Dawn of Time Andrew Bunker, Andrew Bunker, Anglo-Australian Observatory & University
Page 2: The First Billion Years of History - seeing Galaxies Close to the Dawn of Time Andrew Bunker, Andrew Bunker, Anglo-Australian Observatory & University

The First Billion Years of The First Billion Years of

History - seeing Galaxies History - seeing Galaxies

Close to the Dawn of TimeClose to the Dawn of Time

Andrew Bunker,Andrew Bunker,

Anglo-Australian Anglo-Australian

ObservatoryObservatory

& University of Oxford& University of Oxford

KIAA/PKU WorkshopKIAA/PKU Workshop

Page 3: The First Billion Years of History - seeing Galaxies Close to the Dawn of Time Andrew Bunker, Andrew Bunker, Anglo-Australian Observatory & University
Page 4: The First Billion Years of History - seeing Galaxies Close to the Dawn of Time Andrew Bunker, Andrew Bunker, Anglo-Australian Observatory & University

"Lyman break technique" - sharp drop in flux at

below Ly-. Steidel et al. have >1000 z~3

objects, "drop" in U-band.

Page 5: The First Billion Years of History - seeing Galaxies Close to the Dawn of Time Andrew Bunker, Andrew Bunker, Anglo-Australian Observatory & University

HUBBLE SPACE HUBBLE SPACE

TELESCOPETELESCOPE

Page 6: The First Billion Years of History - seeing Galaxies Close to the Dawn of Time Andrew Bunker, Andrew Bunker, Anglo-Australian Observatory & University

"Lyman break

technique" - sharp

drop in flux at

below Ly-.

Steidel et al. have

>1000 z~3 objects,

"drop" in U-band.

Pushing to higher

redshift- Finding

Lyman break

galaxies at z~6 :

using i-drops.

Page 7: The First Billion Years of History - seeing Galaxies Close to the Dawn of Time Andrew Bunker, Andrew Bunker, Anglo-Australian Observatory & University

Using HST/ACS GOODS data - CDFS &

HDFN, 5 epochs B,v,i',z'

Page 8: The First Billion Years of History - seeing Galaxies Close to the Dawn of Time Andrew Bunker, Andrew Bunker, Anglo-Australian Observatory & University

By selecting on rest-

frame UV, get

inventory of ionizing

photons from star

formation. Stanway,

Bunker & McMahon

(2003 MNRAS)

selected z-drops

5.6<z<7 - but large

luminosity bias to

lower z.

Contamination by

stars and low-z

ellipticals.

Page 9: The First Billion Years of History - seeing Galaxies Close to the Dawn of Time Andrew Bunker, Andrew Bunker, Anglo-Australian Observatory & University

10-m Kecks10-m Kecks

8-m Gemini8-m Gemini

ESO VLTsESO VLTs

Page 10: The First Billion Years of History - seeing Galaxies Close to the Dawn of Time Andrew Bunker, Andrew Bunker, Anglo-Australian Observatory & University

The Star Formation

History of the Univese Bunker, Stanway, z=5.8

Ellis, McMahon

& McCarthy (2003)

Keck/DEIMOS

spectral follow-up

& confirmation

I-drops in the Chandra Deep

Field South with HST/ACS

Elizabeth Stanway, Andrew

Bunker, Richard McMahon

2003 (MNRAS)

Page 11: The First Billion Years of History - seeing Galaxies Close to the Dawn of Time Andrew Bunker, Andrew Bunker, Anglo-Australian Observatory & University

GLARE I: Stanway, Glazebrook, Bunker et al.

2004 ApJ 604, L13

Page 12: The First Billion Years of History - seeing Galaxies Close to the Dawn of Time Andrew Bunker, Andrew Bunker, Anglo-Australian Observatory & University
Page 13: The First Billion Years of History - seeing Galaxies Close to the Dawn of Time Andrew Bunker, Andrew Bunker, Anglo-Australian Observatory & University

GLARE II: Stanway, Bunker, Glazebrook et al.

2007 MNRAS 376, 272

Page 14: The First Billion Years of History - seeing Galaxies Close to the Dawn of Time Andrew Bunker, Andrew Bunker, Anglo-Australian Observatory & University
Page 15: The First Billion Years of History - seeing Galaxies Close to the Dawn of Time Andrew Bunker, Andrew Bunker, Anglo-Australian Observatory & University
Page 16: The First Billion Years of History - seeing Galaxies Close to the Dawn of Time Andrew Bunker, Andrew Bunker, Anglo-Australian Observatory & University
Page 17: The First Billion Years of History - seeing Galaxies Close to the Dawn of Time Andrew Bunker, Andrew Bunker, Anglo-Australian Observatory & University
Page 18: The First Billion Years of History - seeing Galaxies Close to the Dawn of Time Andrew Bunker, Andrew Bunker, Anglo-Australian Observatory & University

For I-drops (z~6) would only get ~1 per NIRSpec field bright enough for S/N~3-10 in continuum in 1000sec for

abs line studies

Page 19: The First Billion Years of History - seeing Galaxies Close to the Dawn of Time Andrew Bunker, Andrew Bunker, Anglo-Australian Observatory & University

Looking at the UDF (going 10x deeper, z'=26 28.5 mag)

Bunker, Stanway, Ellis

&McMahon 2004

Page 20: The First Billion Years of History - seeing Galaxies Close to the Dawn of Time Andrew Bunker, Andrew Bunker, Anglo-Australian Observatory & University

After era probed

by CMBR the

Universe enters

the so-called

“dark ages” prior

to formation of

first stars

Hydrogen is then

re-ionized by the

newly-formed

stars

When did this

happen?

What did it?

DARK AGES

Redshift z

5

10

1100

2

0

Page 21: The First Billion Years of History - seeing Galaxies Close to the Dawn of Time Andrew Bunker, Andrew Bunker, Anglo-Australian Observatory & University
Page 22: The First Billion Years of History - seeing Galaxies Close to the Dawn of Time Andrew Bunker, Andrew Bunker, Anglo-Australian Observatory & University

Implications for Reionization

From Madau, Haardt & Rees (1999) -amount

of star formation required to ionize Universe

(C30

is a clumping factor).

This assumes escape fraction=1 (i.e. all ionzing photons make

it out of the galaxies)

Our UDF data has star formation at z=6 which is 3x less than

that required! AGN cannot do the job.

We go down to 1M_sun/yr - but might be steep (lots of low

luminosity sources - forming globulars?)

Page 23: The First Billion Years of History - seeing Galaxies Close to the Dawn of Time Andrew Bunker, Andrew Bunker, Anglo-Australian Observatory & University

Ways out of the Puzzle

- Cosmic variance

- Star formation at even earlier epochs to reionize

Universe (z>>6)?

- Change the physics: different recipe for star

formation (Initial mass function)?

- Even fainter galaxies than we can reach with the

UDF?

Page 24: The First Billion Years of History - seeing Galaxies Close to the Dawn of Time Andrew Bunker, Andrew Bunker, Anglo-Australian Observatory & University

Spitzer – IRAC (3.6-8.0 microns)

Page 25: The First Billion Years of History - seeing Galaxies Close to the Dawn of Time Andrew Bunker, Andrew Bunker, Anglo-Australian Observatory & University

- z=5.83 galaxy

#1 from

Stanway, Bunker

& McMahon

2003 (spec conf

from Stanway et

al. 2004,

Dickinson et al.

2004). Detected

in GOODS

IRAC 3-4m:

Eyles, Bunker,

Stanway et al.

Page 26: The First Billion Years of History - seeing Galaxies Close to the Dawn of Time Andrew Bunker, Andrew Bunker, Anglo-Australian Observatory & University
Page 27: The First Billion Years of History - seeing Galaxies Close to the Dawn of Time Andrew Bunker, Andrew Bunker, Anglo-Australian Observatory & University

Other Population Synthesis Models

Maraston vs. Bruzual & Charlot

B&C =500Myr,

0.7Gyr, 2.4x1010MsunMaraston =500Myr,

0.6Gyr, 1.9x1010Msun

Page 28: The First Billion Years of History - seeing Galaxies Close to the Dawn of Time Andrew Bunker, Andrew Bunker, Anglo-Australian Observatory & University

●30Myr const SFR

with E(B-V)=0.1

●No reddening

●0.2solar

metallicity

Page 29: The First Billion Years of History - seeing Galaxies Close to the Dawn of Time Andrew Bunker, Andrew Bunker, Anglo-Australian Observatory & University
Page 30: The First Billion Years of History - seeing Galaxies Close to the Dawn of Time Andrew Bunker, Andrew Bunker, Anglo-Australian Observatory & University

-Have shown that some z=6 I-drops have old stars and

large masses (subsequently confirmed by H. Yan et al)

-Hints that there may be z>6 galaxies similar (Egami

lens). Mobasher source - z=6.5??? (probably lower-z) -Turn now to larger samples, to provide stellar mass

density in first Gyr with Spitzer-- In Stark, Bunker, Ellis et al. (2006) we look at v-

drops (z~5) in the GOODS-South-21 have spectroscopic redshifts, 2/3rds unconfused at

Spitzer resolution-- Also use 200 photometric redshifts (going fainter),

>50 unconfused

Page 31: The First Billion Years of History - seeing Galaxies Close to the Dawn of Time Andrew Bunker, Andrew Bunker, Anglo-Australian Observatory & University

Eyles, Bunker, Ellis et al. astro-ph/0607306

Page 32: The First Billion Years of History - seeing Galaxies Close to the Dawn of Time Andrew Bunker, Andrew Bunker, Anglo-Australian Observatory & University

Eyles, Bunker, Ellis et al. astro-ph/0607306

Page 33: The First Billion Years of History - seeing Galaxies Close to the Dawn of Time Andrew Bunker, Andrew Bunker, Anglo-Australian Observatory & University
Page 34: The First Billion Years of History - seeing Galaxies Close to the Dawn of Time Andrew Bunker, Andrew Bunker, Anglo-Australian Observatory & University

Eyles, Bunker, Ellis et al. astro-ph/0607306

Page 35: The First Billion Years of History - seeing Galaxies Close to the Dawn of Time Andrew Bunker, Andrew Bunker, Anglo-Australian Observatory & University

Eyles, Bunker, Ellis et al. astro-ph/0607306

Page 36: The First Billion Years of History - seeing Galaxies Close to the Dawn of Time Andrew Bunker, Andrew Bunker, Anglo-Australian Observatory & University

DAZLE - Dark Ages 'z' Lyman-alpha Explorer

IoA - Richard McMahon, Ian Parry; AAO - Joss Bland-Hawthorne

Page 37: The First Billion Years of History - seeing Galaxies Close to the Dawn of Time Andrew Bunker, Andrew Bunker, Anglo-Australian Observatory & University

JAMES WEBB SPACE TELESCOPE – JAMES WEBB SPACE TELESCOPE –

successor to Hubble (2013+)successor to Hubble (2013+)

Page 38: The First Billion Years of History - seeing Galaxies Close to the Dawn of Time Andrew Bunker, Andrew Bunker, Anglo-Australian Observatory & University

What is JWST?● 6.55 m deployable primary

● Diffraction-limited at 2 µm

● Wavelength range 0.6-28 µm

● Passively cooled to <50 K

● Zodiacal-limited below 10 µm

● Sun-Earth L2 orbit

● 4 instruments

– 0.6-5 µm wide field camera (NIRCam)

– 1-5 µm multiobject spectrometer (NIRSpec)

– 5-28 µm camera/spectrometer (MIRI)

– 0.8-5 µm guider camera (FGS/TF)

● 5 year lifetime, 10 year goal

● 2014 launch

QuickTime™ and aTIFF (Uncompressed) decompressor

are needed to see this picture.

Page 39: The First Billion Years of History - seeing Galaxies Close to the Dawn of Time Andrew Bunker, Andrew Bunker, Anglo-Australian Observatory & University
Page 40: The First Billion Years of History - seeing Galaxies Close to the Dawn of Time Andrew Bunker, Andrew Bunker, Anglo-Australian Observatory & University

ESA Contributions to JWST● NIRSpec

– ESA Provided– Detector & MEMS Arrays from NASA

● MIRI Optics Module– ESA Member State Consortium– Detector & Cooler/Cryostat from NASA

● Ariane V Launcher (ECA)

QuickTime™ and aTIFF (LZW) decompressor

are needed to see this picture.

(closely similar to HST model…)

Page 41: The First Billion Years of History - seeing Galaxies Close to the Dawn of Time Andrew Bunker, Andrew Bunker, Anglo-Australian Observatory & University

NIRSpec IST

Page 42: The First Billion Years of History - seeing Galaxies Close to the Dawn of Time Andrew Bunker, Andrew Bunker, Anglo-Australian Observatory & University

Absorption lines at z>5 - a single v.

bright Lyman break z=5.5 galaxy, Dow-

Hygelund et al (2005), AB=23-24, VLT

spectrum (22 hours), R~3000; S/N=3-10

at R=1000,2700 in 1000sec NIRSpec