Embed Size (px)
Citation preview
Tennessee Board of Regents Office of Administration & Facilities Development 1 Bridgestone Park, Third Floor Nashville, TN 37214
(615) 366 – 4431 FAX (615) 365-1512
Designer Recommendations
Project: Statewide – TCAT Improvements (Morristown)
Category: Major
Total Budget: $ 15,270,000
MACC: $14,010,000
Designer Fee: $790,089
SBC Project No: 166/000-04-2013
Construct a new building on the TCAT-Morristown campus. Programs will include machine tool technology, HVAC, Welding, Computer Training, Classrooms, Offices, and support areas. 1) Proposers should submit their firm's direct project experience as the prime Designer for projects similar to the above description, 2) Proposers submitting projects completed by consultants must clearly identify the consultant and your firms past experience with that consultant, 3) Design will be accelerated and the proposal must include an anticipated schedule for design services.
1. Tuck-Hinton Architects PLC This firm’s submittal includes several higher education projects and a new TCAT building. Their experience includes high-tech labs, industry training spaces, multifunctional classrooms and related support spaces. The proposed project team has higher education experience and a history of working together.
2. Hefferlin + Kronenberg Architects PLLC This firm submitted a regional TCAT project which includes six new buildings. These sites include machine tool technology, HVAC, and welding programs along with classrooms and support spaces. Other submitted projects include a technical training center for welding and industrial training. The proposed team has experience on higher education projects and a history of working together.
3. Cope Associates, Inc. This firm’s submitted experience includes a large-scale renovation to repurpose an existing building to house several TCAT programs. This facility includes industrial maintenance, welding labs, advanced manufacturing, and industry training space. The proposed team has previous experience on some of the submitted projects and a history of working together.
A total of 15 firms submitted Letters of Interest for this project:
Firm Name Location Architects Weeks Ambrose McDonald, Inc. Knoxville BarberMcMurry Architects LLC Knoxville Blankenship & Partners, LLC Knoxville Cope Associates, Inc. Knoxville Design Innovation Architects, Inc. Knoxville Goodwyn, Mills & Cawood, Inc. Nashville Hefferlin + Kronenberg Architects PLLC Chattanooga Johnson Architecture, Inc. Knoxville Lose Design Nashville Michael Brady Inc. Knoxville Red Chair Architects, Inc. Knoxville Reedy & Sykes Architecture and Design Elizabethton Studio Four Design, Inc. Knoxville The Lewis Group Architects, Inc., P.C. Knoxville Tuck-Hinton Architects PLC Nashville
Tennessee Board of Regents Office of Administration & Facilities Development 1 Bridgestone Park, Third Floor Nashville, TN 37214
(615) 366 – 4431 FAX (615) 365-1512
Designer Recommendations
Project: TCAT Athens McMinn County Higher Education Training Facility
Category: Major
Total Budget: $17,750,000
MACC: $14,400,000
Designer Fee: $335,532
SBC Project No: 166/040-01-2018
Construct a facility to allow collaboration between TCAT Athens, ClSCC, UT Extension, Adult Education and local industry. Project will relocate current ClSCC leased space, expand TCAT programs for machine tool tech, mechanical maintenance electrical & instrumentation, relocate both UT Extension and Adult Education, and create a space for local industry training. 1) Proposers should submit their firm's direct project experience as the prime Designer for projects similar to the above description, 2) Proposers submitting projects completed by consultants must clearly identify the consultant and your firms past experience with that consultant, 3) Design will be accelerated and the proposal must include an anticipated schedule for design services.
1. Goodwyn, Mills & Cawood, Inc. This firm submitted higher education, industrial training and technical education projects. Programs in these buildings include flexible classrooms, training and education centers, flexible high bay space and advanced labs. The Robotics Technology park includes flexible spaces for a community college, private industry and military organizations. The proposed staff has experience working together, and on the reference projects.
2. Upland Design Group, Inc. This firm submitted higher education projects with flexible classrooms, flexible lab space, flexible high-bay spaces, industrial training space, mechanical maintenance programs, and other supporting spaces. One of their projects was a close match to this one, incorporating programs from a university, a community college, a technical college, and the city. The project team worked together on many of the reference projects.
3. Johnson Johnson Crabtree Architects, PC This firm submitted examples of previous higher education projects. Programs in these buildings included high bay training spaces with supporting classrooms, simulation labs, and public space to be shared with the larger community. They also submitted a renovation project completed on a fast track schedule. The project architect and consultants worked on all the reference projects.
A total of 13 firms submitted Letters of Interest for this project:
Firm Name Location Architects Weeks Ambrose McDonald, Inc. Knoxville Barber McMurry Architects LLC Knoxville Design Innovation Architects Knoxville Franklin Associates, Architects, Inc. Chattanooga Goodwyn, Mills & Cawood, Inc. Nashville Johnson Architecture, Inc. Knoxville Johnson Johnson Crabtree Architects, PC Nashville Lose & Associates Inc. Nashville Michael Brady Inc. Knoxville Red Chair Architects, Inc. Knoxville The Lewis Group Architects, Inc., P.C. Knoxville Tuck-Hinton Architects PLC Nashville Upland Design Group, Inc. Crossville
Tennessee Board of Regents Office of Administration & Facilities Development 1 Bridgestone Park, Third Floor Nashville, TN 37214
(615) 366 – 4431 FAX (615) 365-1512
Designer Recommendations
Project: TCAT - Knoxville (Blount County Campus) Training Facility
Category: Major
Total Budget: $14,850,000
MACC: $11,685,000
Designer Fee: $691,112
SBC Project No: 166/060-01-2017B
Construct a new building on the Pellissippi State campus in Blount County. Programs will include machine tool technology, pipe fitting, industrial maintenance, welding, nursing, EMT, advanced manuf., computer science, culinary science, plus corporate training and support areas. 1) Proposers should submit their firm's direct project experience as the prime Designer for projects similar to the above description. 2) Proposers submitting projects completed by consultants must clearly identify the consultant and your firms past experience with that consultant. 3) Design will be accelerated and the proposal must include an anticipated schedule for design services.
1. Johnson Johnson Crabtree Architects, PC This firm’s submitted experience lists several higher education projects, including two new TCAT building projects, and a community college renovation project completed on a tight schedule. Programs housed in these projects include nursing, culinary science, laboratory and computer classroom spaces. The proposed team, including consultants, worked on all the reference projects together.
2. BarberMcMurry Architects LLC This firm submitted previous higher education and manufacturing project experience. Their projects included lab, classroom, nursing, EMT, advanced technology, computer lab, and corporate training spaces. They included previous experience with a fast track schedule. The project team has experience on these projects and a history of working together.
3. Hefferlin + Kronenberg Architects PLLC
This firm’s submitted experience includes new TCAT buildings and TCAT renovations. Their projects include machine tool technology, pipe fitting, industrial maintenance, welding, nursing, EMT, and computer training spaces. The project team has experience on these projects and a history or working together.
A total of 17 firms submitted Letters of Interest for this project:
Firm Name Location Architects Weeks Ambrose McDonald, Inc. Knoxville BarberMcMurry Architects LLC Knoxville Blankenship & Partners, LLC Knoxville Community Tectonics Architects, Inc. Knoxville Cope Associates, Inc. Knoxville Design Innovation Architects, Inc. Knoxville Hefferlin + Kronenberg Architects PLLC Chattanooga Hurst-Rosche, Inc. Nashville Johnson Architecture, Inc. Knoxville Johnson Johnson Crabtree Architects, PC Nashville Lose Design Nashville Michael Brady, Inc. Knoxville Red Chair Architects, Inc. Knoxville Reedy & Sykes Architecture and Design Elizabethton Studio Four Design, Inc. Knoxville The Lewis Group Architects, Inc., P.C. Knoxville Tuck-Hinton Architects PLC Nashville
Designer Evaluation Summary
RANKING SCORE FIRM NAME
1) 98.33 I.C. Thomasson Associates, Inc. (Nashville) – Submittal showcased that firm has extensive experience completing similar scoped projects; proposed project team, including consultants, are very well qualified and have experience on similar projects and working at correctional facilities; project approach was detailed and included deliverables that aligned closely with agency needs.
2) 95.00 Edmonds Engineering, Inc. (Nashville) –Firm has good experience working on similar projects; submittal presented a very well qualified team that is all in-house; project approach is well thought out.
3) 83.33 Smith Seckman Reid, Inc. (Nashville) – Firm has experience working on similar projects; project team is well qualified; proposed project approach appeared a bit brief.
3) 83.33 Win Engineering, LLC (Nashville) – Firm has relevant project experience; proposed team is qualified and is all in-house; proposed approach appears to lack details.
No other firms submitted a Letter of Interest
Project: Various Facilities – Statewide Arc Flash Repairs
Agency: Correction
Category: Major
SBC Project No.: 140/001-02-2018
Project Approval Date: 09/13/2018
Maximum Liability: $950,000.00
Project Description: Identification and correction of arc flash in facilities statewide and all related work. Project includes training for employees on access and maintenance of the systems.
Revised: 2017-08-18 Page 1of 1 DSP-0602C
Dat
e: 1
2/11
/201
8D
esig
ner
Sele
cti
on
Evalu
ati
on
Sco
re S
um
mary
Matr
ix
Revi
sed:
201
7-09
-06
DSP
-050
1
Proj
ect N
ame:
Faci
lity:
D
epar
tmen
t:
Eval
uato
r1
Eval
uato
r2
Eval
uato
r3
Eval
uato
r1
Eval
uato
r2
Eval
uato
r3
Des
igne
rEd
mon
ds E
ngin
eerin
g50
.00
48.0
047
.00
48.3
343
.00
48.0
049
.00
46.6
795
.00
2Ed
mon
ds E
ngin
eerin
gI.C
. Tho
mas
son
50.0
050
.00
45.0
048
.33
49.9
850
.00
50.0
049
.99
98.3
31
I.C. T
hom
asso
nSm
ith S
eckm
an R
eid
38.0
042
.00
45.0
041
.67
40.0
040
.00
45.0
041
.67
83.3
33
Smith
Sec
kman
Rei
dW
in E
ngin
eerin
g50
.00
44.0
040
.00
44.6
738
.00
38.0
040
.00
38.6
783
.33
3W
in E
ngin
eerin
g
Grand Total
Eval
uati
on o
f Sub
mit
ted
Doc
umen
tsD
esig
ner
Requ
est F
or Q
ualif
icat
ions
Max
imum
100
Poi
nts
Rank
SBC
Num
ber:
Cate
gory
:M
ACC:
Arc
Flas
h Re
pairs
Var
ious
Fac
ilitie
sCo
rrec
tion
Maj
or
Sect
ion
B (M
ax =
60)
Sect
ion
C (M
ax =
40)
Section B Subtotal
Section C Subtotal
