10
Taller de Altas Energías 2013 Arely Cortes Gonzalez [email protected] Statistics Problems: Solutions

Taller de Altas Energías 2013 Statistics Problems: Solutionscowan/stat/benasque13/... · Taller de Altas Energías 2013 Arely Cortes Gonzalez [email protected] Statistics Problems:

  • Upload
    others

  • View
    1

  • Download
    0

Embed Size (px)

Citation preview

Page 1: Taller de Altas Energías 2013 Statistics Problems: Solutionscowan/stat/benasque13/... · Taller de Altas Energías 2013 Arely Cortes Gonzalez arelycg@ifae.es Statistics Problems:

Taller de Altas Energías 2013

Arely Cortes Gonzalez [email protected]

Statistics Problems: Solutions

Page 2: Taller de Altas Energías 2013 Statistics Problems: Solutionscowan/stat/benasque13/... · Taller de Altas Energías 2013 Arely Cortes Gonzalez arelycg@ifae.es Statistics Problems:

Problem 1: Discovering a small signal

where

2

Page 3: Taller de Altas Energías 2013 Statistics Problems: Solutionscowan/stat/benasque13/... · Taller de Altas Energías 2013 Arely Cortes Gonzalez arelycg@ifae.es Statistics Problems:

Size and Power of the test

1(a,b) Find the cumulative distribution…

3

Recall the definition of the size of the test: Rejecting the hypothesis H0 when it is true

Power of the test:

Page 4: Taller de Altas Energías 2013 Statistics Problems: Solutionscowan/stat/benasque13/... · Taller de Altas Energías 2013 Arely Cortes Gonzalez arelycg@ifae.es Statistics Problems:

Bayes’ theorem

1(c) we found the cumulative probabilities before:

4

1(d) Recall Bayes’ theorem

Signal purity

Page 5: Taller de Altas Energías 2013 Statistics Problems: Solutionscowan/stat/benasque13/... · Taller de Altas Energías 2013 Arely Cortes Gonzalez arelycg@ifae.es Statistics Problems:

p-value, significance 1(e) Experiment à observe nobs events, in the region x < xcut.

Poison distribution Expected bkg events p-value

5

Page 6: Taller de Altas Energías 2013 Statistics Problems: Solutionscowan/stat/benasque13/... · Taller de Altas Energías 2013 Arely Cortes Gonzalez arelycg@ifae.es Statistics Problems:

p-value, significance 1(e) Experiment à observe nobs events, in the region x < xcut.

Poison distribution Expected bkg events p-value

6

More events?! à Use identity from Sec. 10 of arXiv:1307.2487, relating the sum of Poisson probabilities to the cumulative χ2 distribution:

ß Function in ROOT

Significance:

Page 7: Taller de Altas Energías 2013 Statistics Problems: Solutionscowan/stat/benasque13/... · Taller de Altas Energías 2013 Arely Cortes Gonzalez arelycg@ifae.es Statistics Problems:

Expected (median) significance 1(f)

7

We computed s and b for xcut=0.1

Compare to:

Page 8: Taller de Altas Energías 2013 Statistics Problems: Solutionscowan/stat/benasque13/... · Taller de Altas Energías 2013 Arely Cortes Gonzalez arelycg@ifae.es Statistics Problems:

Expected (median) significance 1(f)

8

Compare to:

Write a program to compute the s and b at different xcut, and then compute the median significance as a function of xcut.

From the plot:

Page 9: Taller de Altas Energías 2013 Statistics Problems: Solutionscowan/stat/benasque13/... · Taller de Altas Energías 2013 Arely Cortes Gonzalez arelycg@ifae.es Statistics Problems:

Expected (median) significance 1(g) Design a test that exploits each measured value in the entire range of x. We define a test statistic to test the bkg-only hypothesis that is a monotonic function of the likelihood ratio

9

--- b hypothesis --- s+b hypothesis --- s+b median

The code generates 10M experiments. Count number of events found in the b-only test, below the s+b median

Page 10: Taller de Altas Energías 2013 Statistics Problems: Solutionscowan/stat/benasque13/... · Taller de Altas Energías 2013 Arely Cortes Gonzalez arelycg@ifae.es Statistics Problems:

Expected (median) significance 1(g) How to generate s+b hypothesis

10

For we find the cumulative distribution function and solve for r

ß Mixture model

NB We are generating two independent random numbers here…

Transformation method