Critiques/Kritiks

Baxter

MDAW 2012

“Strange things are afoot at the circle k…”

--Ted Theodore Logan

UniquenessLinks •Causality•ABImpacts

Kritiks vs. Disads

• Fiat• Permutations

Kritiks vs. Counterplans

• Value to Life• Why every kritik is the

same• Why should language

matter

Kritiks vs. Counterplans (2)

• Do we need an alt?Kritiks vs. Counterplans (3)

FrameworkBy Lav

Framework=filter

Dumb FrameworkAff: the Neg can only read a CP or advocate the status quoNeg: the judge should only listen to kritiks!

Why is this dumb?• No “best type” of argument

•Aff is whiny

•Is necessarily not “real world”

Smart framework!!Interpretation of knowledge vs interpretation of arguments

Smart framework examplesOnly evaluate impacts that have been justified[read cards why marxism is a way to justify impacts]

More Smart FrameworkAff: Only evaluate impacts that are justified[read cards about why social science is the best]

Framework Cheating!Allows you to not answer arguments on the aff and the neg and orBeat people JUST on framework

reifyelideconflateutopia/dystopiaDichotomy•us/them, self/other, inside/outside

General Vocab

otherizationnormalizationnormative v. descriptiveobjective v. subjectivesubjectcooptation

General Vocab(2)

enlightenmentrationalitymodernismOntologyEpistemologyEthics

Kritik/Philosophy Words

DeontologyUtilitarianismIdeologyDiscourse

Kritik/Philosophy Words

capitalismMarxismSocialismAnarchyCommodification/commodityFetishEmpire (Hardt/Negri)MultitudeProletariatBourgeoisObjectivism (Rand)Frankfurt School (Adorno, Marcuse)

Economics

RealismIdealismSecuritization/Environmental SecuritizationEurocentrismOccidentOrientalismSelf Fulfilling Prophecy/Error ReplicationNuclearismNuclear NumbingChaloupka/Love the Bomb DevelopmentGlobal/Local (Nayer)Human Rights K

International Relations

Identity PoliticsWaves of Feminism: 1st, 2nd, 3rd

Feminist International RelationsPublic/Private DichotomyPatriarchy3rd World FeminismEcofeminismPerformativity (Butler)Sex v. Gender Heteropatriarchy

Identity Politics

Heterosexism/HomophobiaPhallocentrismPhallogocentrismStandpoint EpistomologySubaltern (Spivak)EssentialismStrategic EssentialismIntersectionalityVictimologyNarratives (Delgado)Violence (Fanon)

Identity Politics (2)

Critical Race TheoryCritical Legal StudiesIndeterminacyMaskingTrashingNormativity (Schlag)Role PlayingRights Talk

Legal

powerdisciplinemicropoliticspanopticongeneaologydeath of the authorrepressive hypothesisconfessionalbare life Homo Sacer (Agamben)State of exceptionBiopower

Foucault

logocentrismtraceerasuredeconstructiondifferance

Derrida

psychoanalysisFreudLacanZizekMetaphoric condensationLetter of the lawSymptomLackFidelity to the Event (Badiou)JouissanceDesireObject A

Psychoanalysis