Seed supply and breeding targets for Scots pine and Norway spruce in

Sweden

Dag Lindgren

at workshop

Delineation of Breeding Zones Hann Munden, March 23, 2009

http://www-genfys.slu.se/staff/dagl/TREEBREEDEX/

Levels of “targets”

1. An existing seed source (seed orchard) gets a delineated permitted or recommended area, but comparison with other seed sources makes the delineation less fixed.

2. Delineated areas are needed for estimates of needed seed orchards.

3. For long term breeding, “targets” are needed rather than zones.

4. For seed orchard composition, recruitment area around the main target.

Sweden is extremely simple!Sweden extends at northern latitudes, where latitude (light

climate) is more important.

Warming is welcome in Sweden!

Precipitation is rather uniform, drastic slopes and mountain forestry uncommon.

For choice of seed source, sites are characterized with:

heat sum and latitude.• Heat sum can be adjusted for e.g. exposure (or climate

change)• Latitude is more critical at more northern latitudes (thus

Sweden)• Latitude = light climate• For other factors, the consideration is species.

Existing seed source Västerhus seed orchard

Photo: Anders Fries

Plantation with Västerhus seedlings

Photo Dag Lindgren

Permitted seed sourcerather wide ranges

Tabell. För odling på viss latitud och höjd över havet anges i respektive ruta den sydligaste och den nordligaste tillåtna härkomstlatituden.

Altitude of planting site

PineAllowed seed source latitude

800-899 62-67

700-799 60-65 61-66 62-67 63-68 64-*

600-699 60-64 61-66 62-67 63-68 64-* 65-* 66-*

500-599 59-64 60-65 62-67 63-68 64-* 65-* 66-* 67-*

400-499 57-62 58-63 60-65 61-66 62-67 64-* 65-* 66-* 67-*

300-399 55-58 55-59 55-60 56-61 58-62 59-64 60-65 62-67 63-68 65-* 66-* 67-* 68-*

200-299 55-58 55-59 55-60 56-61 57-62 58-63 60-65 61-66 62-67 64-* 65-* 67-* 68-*

100-199 55-57 55-58 55-59 55-60 56-61 57-62 58-63 59-64 60-65 62-67 63-68 64-* 66-*

0- 99 55-57 55-58 55-59 55-60 56-61 57-62 58-63 59-64 60-65 61-66 62-68 64-*

Latitude of planting site

55 56 57 58 59 60 61 62 63 64 65 66 67 68

Västerhus permitted (enforced by the Forest Authority

Altitude of planting site

Pine

Västerhus lat=63.5 allowed800-899 62-67

700-799 60-65 61-66 62-67 63-68 64-*

600-699 60-64 61-66 62-67 63-68 64-* 65-* 66-*

500-599 59-64 60-65 62-67 63-68 64-* 65-* 66-* 67-*

400-499 57-62 58-63 60-65 61-66 62-67 64-* 65-* 66-* 67-*

300-399 55-58 55-59 55-60 56-61 58-62 59-64 60-65 62-67 63-68 65-* 66-* 67-* 68-*

200-299 55-58 55-59 55-60 56-61 57-62 58-63 60-65 61-66 62-67 64-* 65-* 67-* 68-*

100-199 55-57 55-58 55-59 55-60 56-61 57-62 58-63 59-64 60-65 62-67 63-68 64-* 66-*

0- 99 55-57 55-58 55-59 55-60 56-61 57-62 58-63 59-64 60-65 61-66 62-68 64-*

Latitude of planting site

55 56 57 58 59 60 61 62 63 64 65 66 67 68

A program (Planter’s guide by “Skogforsk”) exists assisting

decisions

• It is based on results from provenance trials

• It can compare different seed sources at a given location for relative performance

• It draws recommended areas for seed orchards

     

Recommended area

Västerhus seed orchard

Latitude for average plus tree origins 63°30‘

Area built on experience from progeny test adapted to Heat sum (=altitude) and latitude

     

Scots pine seed orchard performance at different plantation latitudes, alt =200m,

max=100, with Planter’s guide

Levels of “targets”

1. An existing seed source (seed orchard) gets a delineated permitted or recommended area.

2. Delineated areas are needed for estimates of needed seed orchards.

3. For long term breeding, “targets” are needed rather than zones.

4. For seed orchard composition, recruitment area around the main target.

Areas for estimates for current dimensioning of Swedish seed orchards

(each color an orchard supply area)Pine Spruce

• When seed orchards are mature, seed need have changed, recommendations will have changed, seed production projections has changed etc. Nothing is forever.

• The major uncertainty is projecting species need, not provenance need.

Levels of “targets”

1. An existing seed source (seed orchard) gets a delineated permitted or recommended area, but comparison with other seed sources makes the delineation less fixed.

2. Delineated areas are needed for estimates of needed seed orchards.

3. For long term breeding, “targets” are needed rather than zones.

4. For seed orchard composition, recruitment area around the main target.

Tree Breeding targets• Swedish long term tree breeding is structured in subpopulations,

each with 50 tested founders.• The populations are targeted based on heat sum and light climate

(altitude and latitude).• Figures show the targets of 24 pine (left) and 22 spruce (right)

subpopulations

“Map” of Sweden

Levels of “targets”

1. An existing seed source (seed orchard) gets a delineated permitted or recommended area, but comparison with other seed sources makes the delineation less fixed.

2. Delineated areas are needed for estimates of needed seed orchards.

3. For long term breeding, “targets” are needed rather than zones.

4. For seed orchard composition, recruitment area around the main target.

Origin of clones at Västerhus

0

100

200

300

400

500

600

61 62 63 64 65 66

Latitude

Alt

itu

de

Range of origins = v = 3 latitudes, but considering pollen, range of halfsibfamilies =v/2 = 1.5 latitude

Plust tree origins

Seed orchard location

A seed orchard recruits clones from

several breeding populations!

“Map” of Sweden

Recruitment area for the clones at

Västerhus

Inoptimality loss as function of zone size and origin range at the same

latitude according to a model I madeZone size Range of

originsLoss (%)

4 0 5.3

2 0 1.3

2 2 2.0

2 4 4.0

Conclusions:

• Zone size ranging over 2-3 latitudes for a seed orchard is OK

• Avoid larger range of origin for clones than 3 latitudes in seed orchards

Global warming and zones in Sweden

Dag Lindgren

at workshop

Delineation of Breeding Zones Hann Munden, March 24, 2009

http://www-genfys.slu.se/staff/dagl/TREEBREEDEX/

Environmental change

How has Swedish tree breeding prepared for an uncertain future?

• Structuring of long term breeding

• Increased use of seed orchards

• Seed orchards which produce robust and flexible seed

To prepare for an uncertain future, breeding effort are spread towards sea level and timber limit more than optimal today!

Timber lim

it

Sea level

Breeding materials are tested over a range of environments around the target environment! They will be more plastic and stable than Evolution made them!Evolution knows only now and here!!!!Tree breeders can do better than that!

Seed orchards produce seeds for variable conditions!!

• Seed orchards are predictable and reproducible.

• Clones selected from a wide range of stands and tested on several different sites.

• A sufficient number of clones (17-25).

• Some flexibility for immediate changes (roguing and selective harvest).

Global warming is here!!!• Now we are certain climate is warming!!

• Immediate action is justified!

• But as predictions vary very wildly, the uncertainty is larger than before!!

• Prepare for a more uncertain future!

• Response: wider range of testing!

Response to widened uncertainty!Breeding materials are tested over a wider range of environments!

Global warming is here!!!• Climate is warming!!• Immediate response justified! • Better guide lines will be formulated, till

then react now, logic, simple and moderate!

• Most certain change is temperature rise, other predictions are speculative and more difficult to manage.

How to mimic temperature change?• Pretend to change the elevation!• Logic. Physics says that air cools when lifted! And observations say

that it is colder at high altitudes! • Temperature in Swedish vegetation period rises around 0.6 degree

when elevation is reduced 100 m!• Thus, reduce elevation from 1990 to the actual year• Thus 3.33 meter/annually, 100 m in 33 years! • Or change heat sum correspondingly, but this is less transparent.• Equivalent to keeping the heatsum constant at a geographic location!

“Map” of Sweden

“Map” of Sweden

Response to warming:Move the map of Sweden!To keep to heat sum and latitude, the altitude of the breeding population target raises

Suitable climatic conditions

Modified fromGösta ErikssonForest genetics

How large temperature change?• Do something immediatly!• Do not overreact! Minimize reaction! Do not react so no

change becomes a disaster! There are still scientists doubting it will be warmer 2040 than it was 1990, the harm if they are right should be limited!

• Attention on first five years after plantation! Establishment important!

• Few scenarios predict less than 2 degrees rise in a century.

• Standard temperature period 1961-1990, it is most logic and simple to start from that!

• Our experience on transfers is mainly based on before 1990 events.

• A continuous change from 1990 to 2040, one degree in half a century.

• Make it simple!

Red arrow = ”Dag’s extrapolation” for Swedish global warming

First, I looked at the Swedish temp to 2001, “Dag’s extrapolation” looks

very reasonable

Red arrow = ”Dag’s extrapolation” for ”Swedish” global warming

When I found the Swedish temp to 2007, “Dag’s extrapolation”

looks unreasonable modest……

Two time horisons

• Planting a seed source (about 2013) – 83 m altitude change. Includes planting of tests of the long term breeding population.

• Planning seed orchards (planting about 2038) – 167 m altitude change

• Sweden covers larger altitude differences than 150 m, the change seems rather safe.

Scots pine seed orchard performance at different plantation latitudes, alt =200m,

1990, with Planter’s guide

2023, Planter’s guide alt 100 m

Comments

• Not much is lost if clima does not become warmer.

• If clima becomes warmer than predicted, the losses will be reduced.

• It is an immediate strategy, while thinking on a long term strategy.

• A bit conservative, but psychologically better that next change plans for a hotter future than to admit overreaction.

• For other changes than average temperature, the response is more in species than seed source.