43
Præsentation ved konferencen: Turisme som udviklingsstrategi, Aalborg d. 2. marts 2017. AAA’s projektteam: Mathias Meldgaard, Tom Nielsen og Jens Christian Pasgaard NYE FORTÆLLINGER FRA KYSTLANDSKABET - HVORDAN GENTÆNKER VI TURISMEN I DE DANSKE KYSTBYER? “RETHINKING TOURISM IN A COASTAL CITY – DESIGN FOR NEW ENGAGEMENTS”

“RETHINKING TOURISM IN A COASTAL CITY – … _Nye...Thermal baths in Vals (construction: 1990-1996) by Peter Zumthor (illustrations copy-pasted from tourist brochures) “[…]

Embed Size (px)

Citation preview

Page 1: “RETHINKING TOURISM IN A COASTAL CITY – … _Nye...Thermal baths in Vals (construction: 1990-1996) by Peter Zumthor (illustrations copy-pasted from tourist brochures) “[…]

Præsentation ved konferencen: Turisme som udviklingsstrategi, Aalborg d. 2. marts 2017. AAA’s projektteam: Mathias Meldgaard, Tom Nielsen og Jens Christian Pasgaard

NYE FORTÆLLINGER FRA KYSTLANDSKABET - HVORDAN GENTÆNKER VI TURISMEN I DE DANSKE KYSTBYER?

“RETHINKING TOURISM IN A COASTAL CITY – DESIGN FOR NEW ENGAGEMENTS”

Page 2: “RETHINKING TOURISM IN A COASTAL CITY – … _Nye...Thermal baths in Vals (construction: 1990-1996) by Peter Zumthor (illustrations copy-pasted from tourist brochures) “[…]

RETHINKING TOURISM IN A COASTAL CITY – DESIGN FOR NEW ENGAGEMENTS

Et tværinstitutionelt samarbejde mellem: Aarhus Universitet (AU)Arkitektskolen Aarhus (AAA)Ringkøbing-Skjern Kommune (RKSK) KRAFT (www.kraftnet.com)VisitAarhusDansk Kyst- og Naturturisme (DKNT)

Projektet er støttet af Innovationsfonden og afvikles i perioden fra marts 2016 til april 2019

Page 3: “RETHINKING TOURISM IN A COASTAL CITY – … _Nye...Thermal baths in Vals (construction: 1990-1996) by Peter Zumthor (illustrations copy-pasted from tourist brochures) “[…]

Todelt præsentation: 1 Den overordnede tilgang (JCP)2 Om Ringkøbing Skjern Kommune og aktuelle interventioner i Hvide Sande (TN)

Page 4: “RETHINKING TOURISM IN A COASTAL CITY – … _Nye...Thermal baths in Vals (construction: 1990-1996) by Peter Zumthor (illustrations copy-pasted from tourist brochures) “[…]

1 Den overordnede tilgang

RETHINKING TOURISM IN A COASTAL CITY – DESIGN FOR NEW ENGAGEMENTS

Page 5: “RETHINKING TOURISM IN A COASTAL CITY – … _Nye...Thermal baths in Vals (construction: 1990-1996) by Peter Zumthor (illustrations copy-pasted from tourist brochures) “[…]

1 Den overordnede tilgang

RETHINKING TOURISM IN A COASTAL CITY – DESIGN FOR NEW ENGAGEMENTS

Page 6: “RETHINKING TOURISM IN A COASTAL CITY – … _Nye...Thermal baths in Vals (construction: 1990-1996) by Peter Zumthor (illustrations copy-pasted from tourist brochures) “[…]

TURISMEFORSKNING PÅ ARKITEKTSKOLEN AARHUS

> En primær driver i rumlige transformationsprocesser

Page 7: “RETHINKING TOURISM IN A COASTAL CITY – … _Nye...Thermal baths in Vals (construction: 1990-1996) by Peter Zumthor (illustrations copy-pasted from tourist brochures) “[…]

Negativ diskussion - Fokusering på masseturismens ‘downsides’

Illustration from MVRDV (eds.) (2000): Costa Iberica - Upbeat To The Leisure City. Actar.

Page 8: “RETHINKING TOURISM IN A COASTAL CITY – … _Nye...Thermal baths in Vals (construction: 1990-1996) by Peter Zumthor (illustrations copy-pasted from tourist brochures) “[…]

Illustrations brought in the article “Nobody is innocent. Lloret de Mar: Sun and Beach Tourism” by M. Romaní (2004: 195 /201).

Page 9: “RETHINKING TOURISM IN A COASTAL CITY – … _Nye...Thermal baths in Vals (construction: 1990-1996) by Peter Zumthor (illustrations copy-pasted from tourist brochures) “[…]

Thermal baths in Vals (construction: 1990-1996) by Peter Zumthor (illustrations copy-pasted from tourist brochures)

Page 10: “RETHINKING TOURISM IN A COASTAL CITY – … _Nye...Thermal baths in Vals (construction: 1990-1996) by Peter Zumthor (illustrations copy-pasted from tourist brochures) “[…]

“[…] cities are clearly important to tourism, this does not automatically imply that tourism is important to cities.”

Ashworth, 2009: 208.

_ _ _ _

“Which Urban Problem are you Trying to Solve with Tourism?”

Ashworth, 2009: 215 (a subtitle).

Et strategisk værktøj (intelligent brug)

Page 11: “RETHINKING TOURISM IN A COASTAL CITY – … _Nye...Thermal baths in Vals (construction: 1990-1996) by Peter Zumthor (illustrations copy-pasted from tourist brochures) “[…]

“[...] from an urban planning perspective, it seems important to secure that tour-

ism-dominated spaces can accommodate very different modes of behaviour.”

POSITIV INTERFERENS

“[...] a potential desirable quality of the td-networks and td-spaces”

Coney Island, June 2008

Page 12: “RETHINKING TOURISM IN A COASTAL CITY – … _Nye...Thermal baths in Vals (construction: 1990-1996) by Peter Zumthor (illustrations copy-pasted from tourist brochures) “[…]

Blackpool, June 2009

Page 13: “RETHINKING TOURISM IN A COASTAL CITY – … _Nye...Thermal baths in Vals (construction: 1990-1996) by Peter Zumthor (illustrations copy-pasted from tourist brochures) “[…]

Blackpool, June 2009

Page 14: “RETHINKING TOURISM IN A COASTAL CITY – … _Nye...Thermal baths in Vals (construction: 1990-1996) by Peter Zumthor (illustrations copy-pasted from tourist brochures) “[…]

DEN AKTUELLE KYSTDEBAT

> Afgrundsdyb mistillid

> Søger en mere frugtbar diskussion

Page 15: “RETHINKING TOURISM IN A COASTAL CITY – … _Nye...Thermal baths in Vals (construction: 1990-1996) by Peter Zumthor (illustrations copy-pasted from tourist brochures) “[…]
Page 16: “RETHINKING TOURISM IN A COASTAL CITY – … _Nye...Thermal baths in Vals (construction: 1990-1996) by Peter Zumthor (illustrations copy-pasted from tourist brochures) “[…]
Page 17: “RETHINKING TOURISM IN A COASTAL CITY – … _Nye...Thermal baths in Vals (construction: 1990-1996) by Peter Zumthor (illustrations copy-pasted from tourist brochures) “[…]

En note i forhold til John Urry’s diskussion af ‘The Tourist Gaze’

“Collective” vs “Romatic”

Page 18: “RETHINKING TOURISM IN A COASTAL CITY – … _Nye...Thermal baths in Vals (construction: 1990-1996) by Peter Zumthor (illustrations copy-pasted from tourist brochures) “[…]

En note i forhold til John Urry’s diskussion af ‘The Tourist Gaze’

“Collective” vs “Romatic”

Source: http://www.aucklanddailyphoto.com/2008/07/28/winter-beach/

Page 19: “RETHINKING TOURISM IN A COASTAL CITY – … _Nye...Thermal baths in Vals (construction: 1990-1996) by Peter Zumthor (illustrations copy-pasted from tourist brochures) “[…]

Presented in Baud-Bovy and Lawson’s publication Tourism and Recreational Development: Handbook of Physical Planning (1976: 35).

Page 20: “RETHINKING TOURISM IN A COASTAL CITY – … _Nye...Thermal baths in Vals (construction: 1990-1996) by Peter Zumthor (illustrations copy-pasted from tourist brochures) “[…]
Page 21: “RETHINKING TOURISM IN A COASTAL CITY – … _Nye...Thermal baths in Vals (construction: 1990-1996) by Peter Zumthor (illustrations copy-pasted from tourist brochures) “[…]
Page 22: “RETHINKING TOURISM IN A COASTAL CITY – … _Nye...Thermal baths in Vals (construction: 1990-1996) by Peter Zumthor (illustrations copy-pasted from tourist brochures) “[…]
Page 23: “RETHINKING TOURISM IN A COASTAL CITY – … _Nye...Thermal baths in Vals (construction: 1990-1996) by Peter Zumthor (illustrations copy-pasted from tourist brochures) “[…]

KRITIK AF EN UNUANCERET DEBAT

Karakteriseret af en upræcis brug af referencer +

ureflekteret diskussion af ‘det autentiske’ (turistoplevelse / kystlandskab)

Page 24: “RETHINKING TOURISM IN A COASTAL CITY – … _Nye...Thermal baths in Vals (construction: 1990-1996) by Peter Zumthor (illustrations copy-pasted from tourist brochures) “[…]
Page 25: “RETHINKING TOURISM IN A COASTAL CITY – … _Nye...Thermal baths in Vals (construction: 1990-1996) by Peter Zumthor (illustrations copy-pasted from tourist brochures) “[…]
Page 26: “RETHINKING TOURISM IN A COASTAL CITY – … _Nye...Thermal baths in Vals (construction: 1990-1996) by Peter Zumthor (illustrations copy-pasted from tourist brochures) “[…]
Page 27: “RETHINKING TOURISM IN A COASTAL CITY – … _Nye...Thermal baths in Vals (construction: 1990-1996) by Peter Zumthor (illustrations copy-pasted from tourist brochures) “[…]
Page 28: “RETHINKING TOURISM IN A COASTAL CITY – … _Nye...Thermal baths in Vals (construction: 1990-1996) by Peter Zumthor (illustrations copy-pasted from tourist brochures) “[…]

Butler’s diagram from 1980 concerning the “Hypothetical evolution of a tourist area”. Butler is referring to the letters as ‘implications’. The direction of the curve, after consolidation and stagnation, is open to several interpretations. (Illustration reproduced from Butler, 1980: 7).

Page 29: “RETHINKING TOURISM IN A COASTAL CITY – … _Nye...Thermal baths in Vals (construction: 1990-1996) by Peter Zumthor (illustrations copy-pasted from tourist brochures) “[…]
Page 30: “RETHINKING TOURISM IN A COASTAL CITY – … _Nye...Thermal baths in Vals (construction: 1990-1996) by Peter Zumthor (illustrations copy-pasted from tourist brochures) “[…]

OPSUMMERING I FORHOLD TIL DEN OVERORDNEDE TILGANG: (AARCH’s Rolle & Bidrag)

- Et opgør med klassisk destinationsplanlægning (note forskel på specialiserede og ikke-specialiserede destinationer)

- Vi forsøger ikke at afkode et marked for derefter at svare på en given efterspørgsel

- En kvalitativ arkitektfaglig tilgang (hvor vi eksplicit fokuserer på udbudssiden)

- Vi søger at afkode situationer og adfærd (flydende definitioner - ‘liquid modernity’)

- Vi forsøger at supplere ’the reason to go’ – med en ’reason to stay’ (positiv udviklingsspiral)

- Vi forsøger at øge den programmatiske kompleksistet og at skabe flerdimensionelle lokaliteter

Page 31: “RETHINKING TOURISM IN A COASTAL CITY – … _Nye...Thermal baths in Vals (construction: 1990-1996) by Peter Zumthor (illustrations copy-pasted from tourist brochures) “[…]

EN INVESTERING I TURISME ER IKKE NØDVENDIGVIS EN INVESTERING I TURISME

Page 32: “RETHINKING TOURISM IN A COASTAL CITY – … _Nye...Thermal baths in Vals (construction: 1990-1996) by Peter Zumthor (illustrations copy-pasted from tourist brochures) “[…]
Page 33: “RETHINKING TOURISM IN A COASTAL CITY – … _Nye...Thermal baths in Vals (construction: 1990-1996) by Peter Zumthor (illustrations copy-pasted from tourist brochures) “[…]

Illustration: Mathias Meldgaard

Illustration: RKSK museum

Page 34: “RETHINKING TOURISM IN A COASTAL CITY – … _Nye...Thermal baths in Vals (construction: 1990-1996) by Peter Zumthor (illustrations copy-pasted from tourist brochures) “[…]
Page 35: “RETHINKING TOURISM IN A COASTAL CITY – … _Nye...Thermal baths in Vals (construction: 1990-1996) by Peter Zumthor (illustrations copy-pasted from tourist brochures) “[…]

En investering i turisme er ikke nødvendigvis en investering i turisme

Illustration: Mathias Meldgaard

Page 36: “RETHINKING TOURISM IN A COASTAL CITY – … _Nye...Thermal baths in Vals (construction: 1990-1996) by Peter Zumthor (illustrations copy-pasted from tourist brochures) “[…]
Page 37: “RETHINKING TOURISM IN A COASTAL CITY – … _Nye...Thermal baths in Vals (construction: 1990-1996) by Peter Zumthor (illustrations copy-pasted from tourist brochures) “[…]

Illustration: Mathias Meldgaard

Page 38: “RETHINKING TOURISM IN A COASTAL CITY – … _Nye...Thermal baths in Vals (construction: 1990-1996) by Peter Zumthor (illustrations copy-pasted from tourist brochures) “[…]

Illustrationer: Mathias Meldgaard

Page 39: “RETHINKING TOURISM IN A COASTAL CITY – … _Nye...Thermal baths in Vals (construction: 1990-1996) by Peter Zumthor (illustrations copy-pasted from tourist brochures) “[…]

Vindmøller i Ringkøbing Skjern kommune + planlagt Vesterhav Syd havvindmøllepark

Page 40: “RETHINKING TOURISM IN A COASTAL CITY – … _Nye...Thermal baths in Vals (construction: 1990-1996) by Peter Zumthor (illustrations copy-pasted from tourist brochures) “[…]
Page 41: “RETHINKING TOURISM IN A COASTAL CITY – … _Nye...Thermal baths in Vals (construction: 1990-1996) by Peter Zumthor (illustrations copy-pasted from tourist brochures) “[…]
Page 42: “RETHINKING TOURISM IN A COASTAL CITY – … _Nye...Thermal baths in Vals (construction: 1990-1996) by Peter Zumthor (illustrations copy-pasted from tourist brochures) “[…]

Illustration: Mathias Meldgaard

Page 43: “RETHINKING TOURISM IN A COASTAL CITY – … _Nye...Thermal baths in Vals (construction: 1990-1996) by Peter Zumthor (illustrations copy-pasted from tourist brochures) “[…]

Illustration: Mathias Meldgaard