54
Relativistic pseudospin symmetry, the nucleon-nucleon interaction, and effective field theory Joseph N. Ginocchio Theoretical Division, Los Alamos National Laboratory 1. Introduction 2. Symmetries of the Dirac Hamiltonian 3. Relation to QCD 3. Tests of pseudospin symmetry 4. Pseudospin symmetry for nuclei beyond the valley of stability 5. PS and the nucleon-nucleon interaction and EFT 6. Summary and Future Collaborators: A. Leviatan, D. Madland, P. von Neumann-Cosel JNG, Physics Reports 414, 165 (2005)

Relativistic pseudospin symmetry, the nucleon …...Relativistic pseudospin symmetry, the nucleon-nucleon interaction, and effective field theory Joseph N. Ginocchio Theoretical Division,

  • Upload
    others

  • View
    8

  • Download
    0

Embed Size (px)

Citation preview

Page 1: Relativistic pseudospin symmetry, the nucleon …...Relativistic pseudospin symmetry, the nucleon-nucleon interaction, and effective field theory Joseph N. Ginocchio Theoretical Division,

Relativistic pseudospin symmetry,the nucleon-nucleon interaction, and

effective field theoryJoseph N. Ginocchio

Theoretical Division, Los Alamos National Laboratory1. Introduction2. Symmetries of the Dirac Hamiltonian3. Relation to QCD3. Tests of pseudospin symmetry4. Pseudospin symmetry for nuclei beyond the valley of stability5. PS and the nucleon-nucleon interaction and EFT6. Summary and Future

Collaborators: A. Leviatan, D. Madland, P. von Neumann-Cosel

JNG, Physics Reports 414, 165 (2005)

Page 2: Relativistic pseudospin symmetry, the nucleon …...Relativistic pseudospin symmetry, the nucleon-nucleon interaction, and effective field theory Joseph N. Ginocchio Theoretical Division,
Page 3: Relativistic pseudospin symmetry, the nucleon …...Relativistic pseudospin symmetry, the nucleon-nucleon interaction, and effective field theory Joseph N. Ginocchio Theoretical Division,
Page 4: Relativistic pseudospin symmetry, the nucleon …...Relativistic pseudospin symmetry, the nucleon-nucleon interaction, and effective field theory Joseph N. Ginocchio Theoretical Division,

The Dirac Hamiltonian

Page 5: Relativistic pseudospin symmetry, the nucleon …...Relativistic pseudospin symmetry, the nucleon-nucleon interaction, and effective field theory Joseph N. Ginocchio Theoretical Division,

The Dirac Hamiltonian has an invariant SU(2) symmetry for two limits:

Spin Symmetry occurs in the spectrum of a:1) meson with one heavy quark (PRL 86, 204 (2001) )2) anti-nucleon bound in a nucleus (Phys. Rep. 315, 231 (1999) )

Pseudospin Symmetry occurs in the spectrum of nuclei PRL 78, 436 (1997)

Vs – Vv = Cs Spin Symmetry Vs + Vv = Cps P-Spin Symmetry

Page 6: Relativistic pseudospin symmetry, the nucleon …...Relativistic pseudospin symmetry, the nucleon-nucleon interaction, and effective field theory Joseph N. Ginocchio Theoretical Division,
Page 7: Relativistic pseudospin symmetry, the nucleon …...Relativistic pseudospin symmetry, the nucleon-nucleon interaction, and effective field theory Joseph N. Ginocchio Theoretical Division,
Page 8: Relativistic pseudospin symmetry, the nucleon …...Relativistic pseudospin symmetry, the nucleon-nucleon interaction, and effective field theory Joseph N. Ginocchio Theoretical Division,
Page 9: Relativistic pseudospin symmetry, the nucleon …...Relativistic pseudospin symmetry, the nucleon-nucleon interaction, and effective field theory Joseph N. Ginocchio Theoretical Division,

Realistic Relativistic Mean Fields

Page 10: Relativistic pseudospin symmetry, the nucleon …...Relativistic pseudospin symmetry, the nucleon-nucleon interaction, and effective field theory Joseph N. Ginocchio Theoretical Division,

10

QCD SUM RULES

is the chiral symmetry breaking nucleon sigma term

is the average quark mass

Uncannily close to the ratio of central values of mean field potentials

Page 11: Relativistic pseudospin symmetry, the nucleon …...Relativistic pseudospin symmetry, the nucleon-nucleon interaction, and effective field theory Joseph N. Ginocchio Theoretical Division,
Page 12: Relativistic pseudospin symmetry, the nucleon …...Relativistic pseudospin symmetry, the nucleon-nucleon interaction, and effective field theory Joseph N. Ginocchio Theoretical Division,
Page 13: Relativistic pseudospin symmetry, the nucleon …...Relativistic pseudospin symmetry, the nucleon-nucleon interaction, and effective field theory Joseph N. Ginocchio Theoretical Division,
Page 14: Relativistic pseudospin symmetry, the nucleon …...Relativistic pseudospin symmetry, the nucleon-nucleon interaction, and effective field theory Joseph N. Ginocchio Theoretical Division,
Page 15: Relativistic pseudospin symmetry, the nucleon …...Relativistic pseudospin symmetry, the nucleon-nucleon interaction, and effective field theory Joseph N. Ginocchio Theoretical Division,
Page 16: Relativistic pseudospin symmetry, the nucleon …...Relativistic pseudospin symmetry, the nucleon-nucleon interaction, and effective field theory Joseph N. Ginocchio Theoretical Division,
Page 17: Relativistic pseudospin symmetry, the nucleon …...Relativistic pseudospin symmetry, the nucleon-nucleon interaction, and effective field theory Joseph N. Ginocchio Theoretical Division,
Page 18: Relativistic pseudospin symmetry, the nucleon …...Relativistic pseudospin symmetry, the nucleon-nucleon interaction, and effective field theory Joseph N. Ginocchio Theoretical Division,
Page 19: Relativistic pseudospin symmetry, the nucleon …...Relativistic pseudospin symmetry, the nucleon-nucleon interaction, and effective field theory Joseph N. Ginocchio Theoretical Division,
Page 20: Relativistic pseudospin symmetry, the nucleon …...Relativistic pseudospin symmetry, the nucleon-nucleon interaction, and effective field theory Joseph N. Ginocchio Theoretical Division,
Page 21: Relativistic pseudospin symmetry, the nucleon …...Relativistic pseudospin symmetry, the nucleon-nucleon interaction, and effective field theory Joseph N. Ginocchio Theoretical Division,
Page 22: Relativistic pseudospin symmetry, the nucleon …...Relativistic pseudospin symmetry, the nucleon-nucleon interaction, and effective field theory Joseph N. Ginocchio Theoretical Division,
Page 23: Relativistic pseudospin symmetry, the nucleon …...Relativistic pseudospin symmetry, the nucleon-nucleon interaction, and effective field theory Joseph N. Ginocchio Theoretical Division,
Page 24: Relativistic pseudospin symmetry, the nucleon …...Relativistic pseudospin symmetry, the nucleon-nucleon interaction, and effective field theory Joseph N. Ginocchio Theoretical Division,
Page 25: Relativistic pseudospin symmetry, the nucleon …...Relativistic pseudospin symmetry, the nucleon-nucleon interaction, and effective field theory Joseph N. Ginocchio Theoretical Division,
Page 26: Relativistic pseudospin symmetry, the nucleon …...Relativistic pseudospin symmetry, the nucleon-nucleon interaction, and effective field theory Joseph N. Ginocchio Theoretical Division,
Page 27: Relativistic pseudospin symmetry, the nucleon …...Relativistic pseudospin symmetry, the nucleon-nucleon interaction, and effective field theory Joseph N. Ginocchio Theoretical Division,
Page 28: Relativistic pseudospin symmetry, the nucleon …...Relativistic pseudospin symmetry, the nucleon-nucleon interaction, and effective field theory Joseph N. Ginocchio Theoretical Division,
Page 29: Relativistic pseudospin symmetry, the nucleon …...Relativistic pseudospin symmetry, the nucleon-nucleon interaction, and effective field theory Joseph N. Ginocchio Theoretical Division,
Page 30: Relativistic pseudospin symmetry, the nucleon …...Relativistic pseudospin symmetry, the nucleon-nucleon interaction, and effective field theory Joseph N. Ginocchio Theoretical Division,
Page 31: Relativistic pseudospin symmetry, the nucleon …...Relativistic pseudospin symmetry, the nucleon-nucleon interaction, and effective field theory Joseph N. Ginocchio Theoretical Division,

Quadrupole Operator in Pseudospin Basis

˜ Q µ(r) = Σ i=1A ˜ Q µ (ri ) = Σ i=1

A σ i ⋅ ˆ p Qµ (ri )σ i ⋅ ˆ p =Σ i=1

A Qµ(ri )+ Σ i=1A [σ i ⋅ ˆ p ,Qµ (ri )]σ i ⋅ ˆ p

Σ i=1A [σ i ⋅ ˆ p ,Qµ(ri )]σ i ⋅ ˆ p = qµ

0 +Σ i=1A qµ ,i

1 σ i

The second term will be of order 1/A because

r σ i =

1AΣ i=1

A r σ i =

2A

r S i

˜ Q µ(r) ≈ Qµ(r)+ qµ0

Page 32: Relativistic pseudospin symmetry, the nucleon …...Relativistic pseudospin symmetry, the nucleon-nucleon interaction, and effective field theory Joseph N. Ginocchio Theoretical Division,
Page 33: Relativistic pseudospin symmetry, the nucleon …...Relativistic pseudospin symmetry, the nucleon-nucleon interaction, and effective field theory Joseph N. Ginocchio Theoretical Division,
Page 34: Relativistic pseudospin symmetry, the nucleon …...Relativistic pseudospin symmetry, the nucleon-nucleon interaction, and effective field theory Joseph N. Ginocchio Theoretical Division,
Page 35: Relativistic pseudospin symmetry, the nucleon …...Relativistic pseudospin symmetry, the nucleon-nucleon interaction, and effective field theory Joseph N. Ginocchio Theoretical Division,
Page 36: Relativistic pseudospin symmetry, the nucleon …...Relativistic pseudospin symmetry, the nucleon-nucleon interaction, and effective field theory Joseph N. Ginocchio Theoretical Division,
Page 37: Relativistic pseudospin symmetry, the nucleon …...Relativistic pseudospin symmetry, the nucleon-nucleon interaction, and effective field theory Joseph N. Ginocchio Theoretical Division,
Page 38: Relativistic pseudospin symmetry, the nucleon …...Relativistic pseudospin symmetry, the nucleon-nucleon interaction, and effective field theory Joseph N. Ginocchio Theoretical Division,
Page 39: Relativistic pseudospin symmetry, the nucleon …...Relativistic pseudospin symmetry, the nucleon-nucleon interaction, and effective field theory Joseph N. Ginocchio Theoretical Division,
Page 40: Relativistic pseudospin symmetry, the nucleon …...Relativistic pseudospin symmetry, the nucleon-nucleon interaction, and effective field theory Joseph N. Ginocchio Theoretical Division,
Page 41: Relativistic pseudospin symmetry, the nucleon …...Relativistic pseudospin symmetry, the nucleon-nucleon interaction, and effective field theory Joseph N. Ginocchio Theoretical Division,
Page 42: Relativistic pseudospin symmetry, the nucleon …...Relativistic pseudospin symmetry, the nucleon-nucleon interaction, and effective field theory Joseph N. Ginocchio Theoretical Division,
Page 43: Relativistic pseudospin symmetry, the nucleon …...Relativistic pseudospin symmetry, the nucleon-nucleon interaction, and effective field theory Joseph N. Ginocchio Theoretical Division,

43

Effective Field TheoryIn EFT expansion why aren’t pseudospin operatorson equal standing as spin operators?

For example

Page 44: Relativistic pseudospin symmetry, the nucleon …...Relativistic pseudospin symmetry, the nucleon-nucleon interaction, and effective field theory Joseph N. Ginocchio Theoretical Division,

44

Effective Field Theory

where p is the relative momentum

For two nucleons:

Page 45: Relativistic pseudospin symmetry, the nucleon …...Relativistic pseudospin symmetry, the nucleon-nucleon interaction, and effective field theory Joseph N. Ginocchio Theoretical Division,

45

Spin-Spin Interaction

This is consistent with the study of the nucleon-nucleoninteraction in which it is shown that the pseudospintransformation on two nucleons does not change the spin.However, this does not mean they are equivalent becausethe mixing angle between states of different pseudo-orbtialangular momentum is different than the mixing anglebetween states of different orbital angular momentum,which come about through other terms involving thepseudo-orbital angular momentum operator and the orbitalangular momentum operator.

Page 46: Relativistic pseudospin symmetry, the nucleon …...Relativistic pseudospin symmetry, the nucleon-nucleon interaction, and effective field theory Joseph N. Ginocchio Theoretical Division,

46

Tensor Interaction

That is, the tensor interaction is symmetrical in pseudospin and spinand it is an interaction between the spin and pseudospin, which is aninteresting insight.

Page 47: Relativistic pseudospin symmetry, the nucleon …...Relativistic pseudospin symmetry, the nucleon-nucleon interaction, and effective field theory Joseph N. Ginocchio Theoretical Division,

Spin - Orbit Interaction

(( T(TT

Page 48: Relativistic pseudospin symmetry, the nucleon …...Relativistic pseudospin symmetry, the nucleon-nucleon interaction, and effective field theory Joseph N. Ginocchio Theoretical Division,

Antinucleon Spectrum

Charge Conjugation

V S(r r ) = ′ C VS (r r )C = VS(r r )

V V (r r ) = ′ C V V (r r )C = −V V (r r )

∴V S(r r ) ≈ V V(r r )

⇒ Spin Symmetry for AntinucleonsSpin polarization in antiproton scattering from Carbon is almost zerosupporting this prediction, but data set is limited (PLB 151, 473 (1985)).

Perhaps additional antiproton scattering will be forthcoming at GSI

Page 49: Relativistic pseudospin symmetry, the nucleon …...Relativistic pseudospin symmetry, the nucleon-nucleon interaction, and effective field theory Joseph N. Ginocchio Theoretical Division,
Page 50: Relativistic pseudospin symmetry, the nucleon …...Relativistic pseudospin symmetry, the nucleon-nucleon interaction, and effective field theory Joseph N. Ginocchio Theoretical Division,
Page 51: Relativistic pseudospin symmetry, the nucleon …...Relativistic pseudospin symmetry, the nucleon-nucleon interaction, and effective field theory Joseph N. Ginocchio Theoretical Division,
Page 52: Relativistic pseudospin symmetry, the nucleon …...Relativistic pseudospin symmetry, the nucleon-nucleon interaction, and effective field theory Joseph N. Ginocchio Theoretical Division,

52

9) Spin and Tensor Interaction are equivalentto P-Spin and P-Tensor interactions.

10) Spin-Orbital and P-Spin-P-Orbital interactions are not equivalent. In fact P-Spin-P-Orbital interaction produces a P- spin dynamical symmetry but violatesspin symmetry.

Summary

Page 53: Relativistic pseudospin symmetry, the nucleon …...Relativistic pseudospin symmetry, the nucleon-nucleon interaction, and effective field theory Joseph N. Ginocchio Theoretical Division,
Page 54: Relativistic pseudospin symmetry, the nucleon …...Relativistic pseudospin symmetry, the nucleon-nucleon interaction, and effective field theory Joseph N. Ginocchio Theoretical Division,

54

4) Effective Field Theory expansions with spinand P-spin on same footing.

5) Rewriting the tensor interaction in terms ofthe two body spin-orbit interaction and the twobody pseudo spin-orbit interaction anddetermining the coefficients of each.

Future