28
Quark star RX J1856.5 Quark star RX J1856.5 - - 3754 and its mass 3754 and its mass Kazunori Kohri (郡 和範) RESCEU, Univ. of Tokyo K. Kohri, K. Iida and Katsuhiko Sato, Prog. Thor. Phys. 105 (2002) in press

Quark star RX J1856.5- 3754 and its mass - MPIA.de · 1 Quark star RX J1856.5-3754 and its mass Kazunori Kohri (郡 和範) RESCEU, Univ. of Tokyo K. Kohri, K. Iida and Katsuhiko

  • Upload
    others

  • View
    5

  • Download
    0

Embed Size (px)

Citation preview

Page 1: Quark star RX J1856.5- 3754 and its mass - MPIA.de · 1 Quark star RX J1856.5-3754 and its mass Kazunori Kohri (郡 和範) RESCEU, Univ. of Tokyo K. Kohri, K. Iida and Katsuhiko

1

Quark star RX J1856.5Quark star RX J1856.5--3754 and its mass3754 and its mass

Kazunori Kohri(郡 和範)

RESCEU, Univ. of Tokyo

K. Kohri, K. Iida and Katsuhiko Sato,

Prog. Thor. Phys. 105 (2002) in press

Page 2: Quark star RX J1856.5- 3754 and its mass - MPIA.de · 1 Quark star RX J1856.5-3754 and its mass Kazunori Kohri (郡 和範) RESCEU, Univ. of Tokyo K. Kohri, K. Iida and Katsuhiko

2

ContentsContents

・ Introduction

・ Observations of RX J1856.5-3754

・ Two-temperature model?

・ Quark matter in bag model

・ Quark star

・ Systematic study of mass of the star

in bag model

・ Other constraint on mass of the star

・ Other theoretical model of quark matter

・ Conclusion

Page 3: Quark star RX J1856.5- 3754 and its mass - MPIA.de · 1 Quark star RX J1856.5-3754 and its mass Kazunori Kohri (郡 和範) RESCEU, Univ. of Tokyo K. Kohri, K. Iida and Katsuhiko

3

IntroductionIntroduction

Recent deep Chandra LETG+HRC-S observations of RX J1856.5-3754reports,

Black body of Black body of

XX--ray luminosity,ray luminosity,

Drake et al., ApJ. 572 (2002) 996-1001

Radiation radiusRadiation radius

Page 4: Quark star RX J1856.5- 3754 and its mass - MPIA.de · 1 Quark star RX J1856.5-3754 and its mass Kazunori Kohri (郡 和範) RESCEU, Univ. of Tokyo K. Kohri, K. Iida and Katsuhiko

4

Distance toward RX Distance toward RX J1856.5J1856.5--37543754

Drake et al., ApJ. 572 (2002) 996-1001

Page 5: Quark star RX J1856.5- 3754 and its mass - MPIA.de · 1 Quark star RX J1856.5-3754 and its mass Kazunori Kohri (郡 和範) RESCEU, Univ. of Tokyo K. Kohri, K. Iida and Katsuhiko

5

Spectra of RX J1856.6Spectra of RX J1856.6--37543754

Drake et al., ApJ. 572 (2002) 996-1001

Page 6: Quark star RX J1856.5- 3754 and its mass - MPIA.de · 1 Quark star RX J1856.5-3754 and its mass Kazunori Kohri (郡 和範) RESCEU, Univ. of Tokyo K. Kohri, K. Iida and Katsuhiko

6

The 3The 3σσequivalent width equivalent width upper limit to line featuresupper limit to line features

Drake et al., ApJ. 572 (2002) 996-1001

Page 7: Quark star RX J1856.5- 3754 and its mass - MPIA.de · 1 Quark star RX J1856.5-3754 and its mass Kazunori Kohri (郡 和範) RESCEU, Univ. of Tokyo K. Kohri, K. Iida and Katsuhiko

7

XMMXMM--Newton observationNewton observationV. Burwitz et al, astro-ph/0211536

Page 8: Quark star RX J1856.5- 3754 and its mass - MPIA.de · 1 Quark star RX J1856.5-3754 and its mass Kazunori Kohri (郡 和範) RESCEU, Univ. of Tokyo K. Kohri, K. Iida and Katsuhiko

8

RX J1856.5RX J1856.5--3754 is 3754 is quark quark star?star?

i) No pulsation

ii) No spectral features

iii) Small radiation radius

Page 9: Quark star RX J1856.5- 3754 and its mass - MPIA.de · 1 Quark star RX J1856.5-3754 and its mass Kazunori Kohri (郡 和範) RESCEU, Univ. of Tokyo K. Kohri, K. Iida and Katsuhiko

9

MassMass--radius relation of radius relation of compact starcompact star

(Quark star)

(Neutron star)(White dwarf)

M

Courtesy of K. Iida

R

Page 10: Quark star RX J1856.5- 3754 and its mass - MPIA.de · 1 Quark star RX J1856.5-3754 and its mass Kazunori Kohri (郡 和範) RESCEU, Univ. of Tokyo K. Kohri, K. Iida and Katsuhiko

10

with heavy-element atmosphere

F.Walter and J.Lattimer, ApJ (2002)

T.M. Braje and R.W. Romani, ApJ (2002)

Two temperature modelTwo temperature model

Hot

Hot

Cold

X-ray

X-ray

UV/Optical

Page 11: Quark star RX J1856.5- 3754 and its mass - MPIA.de · 1 Quark star RX J1856.5-3754 and its mass Kazunori Kohri (郡 和範) RESCEU, Univ. of Tokyo K. Kohri, K. Iida and Katsuhiko

11

Broad band spectral fit Broad band spectral fit in twoin two--temperature temperature

blackbodyblackbody

T. Braje and R.W. Romani, ApJ (2002)

Page 12: Quark star RX J1856.5- 3754 and its mass - MPIA.de · 1 Quark star RX J1856.5-3754 and its mass Kazunori Kohri (郡 和範) RESCEU, Univ. of Tokyo K. Kohri, K. Iida and Katsuhiko

12

Thermodynamic potentialThermodynamic potential

Energy densityEnergy density

Quark matterQuark matter(zero-temperature uds quark matter)

where

QCD coupling constant

Strange quark mass

Bag constant

Page 13: Quark star RX J1856.5- 3754 and its mass - MPIA.de · 1 Quark star RX J1856.5-3754 and its mass Kazunori Kohri (郡 和範) RESCEU, Univ. of Tokyo K. Kohri, K. Iida and Katsuhiko

13

Quark matterQuark matter--22Number densityNumber density

PressurePressure

Baryon numberBaryon number

ConditionsConditionsIn equilibrium through weak interactions

Charge neutrality

Page 14: Quark star RX J1856.5- 3754 and its mass - MPIA.de · 1 Quark star RX J1856.5-3754 and its mass Kazunori Kohri (郡 和範) RESCEU, Univ. of Tokyo K. Kohri, K. Iida and Katsuhiko

14

Bag model parameters Bag model parameters fitted to fitted to hadronhadron mass mass

spectraspectra

Kohri, Iida and Sato, arXiv:astro-ph/0210259

Page 15: Quark star RX J1856.5- 3754 and its mass - MPIA.de · 1 Quark star RX J1856.5-3754 and its mass Kazunori Kohri (郡 和範) RESCEU, Univ. of Tokyo K. Kohri, K. Iida and Katsuhiko

15

Energy per baryonEnergy per baryon

((ααcc==00))

Page 16: Quark star RX J1856.5- 3754 and its mass - MPIA.de · 1 Quark star RX J1856.5-3754 and its mass Kazunori Kohri (郡 和範) RESCEU, Univ. of Tokyo K. Kohri, K. Iida and Katsuhiko

16

Energy per baryonEnergy per baryon((ααcc==0.60.6))

Page 17: Quark star RX J1856.5- 3754 and its mass - MPIA.de · 1 Quark star RX J1856.5-3754 and its mass Kazunori Kohri (郡 和範) RESCEU, Univ. of Tokyo K. Kohri, K. Iida and Katsuhiko

17

Equation of stateEquation of state

Page 18: Quark star RX J1856.5- 3754 and its mass - MPIA.de · 1 Quark star RX J1856.5-3754 and its mass Kazunori Kohri (郡 和範) RESCEU, Univ. of Tokyo K. Kohri, K. Iida and Katsuhiko

18

Quark starQuark starEquation of hydrostatic equilibrium

(Tolman-Oppenheimer-Volkoff (TOV) equation)

Equation of mass conservation

Then, the radius is determined by

The mass is

Page 19: Quark star RX J1856.5- 3754 and its mass - MPIA.de · 1 Quark star RX J1856.5-3754 and its mass Kazunori Kohri (郡 和範) RESCEU, Univ. of Tokyo K. Kohri, K. Iida and Katsuhiko

19

Mass of quark starMass of quark star

Page 20: Quark star RX J1856.5- 3754 and its mass - MPIA.de · 1 Quark star RX J1856.5-3754 and its mass Kazunori Kohri (郡 和範) RESCEU, Univ. of Tokyo K. Kohri, K. Iida and Katsuhiko

20

Radius of quark starRadius of quark star

Page 21: Quark star RX J1856.5- 3754 and its mass - MPIA.de · 1 Quark star RX J1856.5-3754 and its mass Kazunori Kohri (郡 和範) RESCEU, Univ. of Tokyo K. Kohri, K. Iida and Katsuhiko

21

MassMass--radius relationradius relation

Page 22: Quark star RX J1856.5- 3754 and its mass - MPIA.de · 1 Quark star RX J1856.5-3754 and its mass Kazunori Kohri (郡 和範) RESCEU, Univ. of Tokyo K. Kohri, K. Iida and Katsuhiko

22

MassMass--radius relationradius relation

Page 23: Quark star RX J1856.5- 3754 and its mass - MPIA.de · 1 Quark star RX J1856.5-3754 and its mass Kazunori Kohri (郡 和範) RESCEU, Univ. of Tokyo K. Kohri, K. Iida and Katsuhiko

23

Observed XObserved X--ray ray luminosityluminosity

Bondi accretion rate

where,

Then,

Page 24: Quark star RX J1856.5- 3754 and its mass - MPIA.de · 1 Quark star RX J1856.5-3754 and its mass Kazunori Kohri (郡 和範) RESCEU, Univ. of Tokyo K. Kohri, K. Iida and Katsuhiko

24

Contours of upper Contours of upper limit of masslimit of mass

Page 25: Quark star RX J1856.5- 3754 and its mass - MPIA.de · 1 Quark star RX J1856.5-3754 and its mass Kazunori Kohri (郡 和範) RESCEU, Univ. of Tokyo K. Kohri, K. Iida and Katsuhiko

25

Effects of the Effects of the pressurepressure--dependentdependent bag constantbag constant

Generally, we can parameterize the EOS as

Then, we transform it into

where

Namely, inside the star the bag Namely, inside the star the bag constant effectively becomes large!constant effectively becomes large!

A ~ 3 -- 4, for Lattice data , Peshier,Kampfer,Soff (2001).

A ~ 2, for Relativistic Mean Field, Dey et al. (1998) etc.

Page 26: Quark star RX J1856.5- 3754 and its mass - MPIA.de · 1 Quark star RX J1856.5-3754 and its mass Kazunori Kohri (郡 和範) RESCEU, Univ. of Tokyo K. Kohri, K. Iida and Katsuhiko

26

Contour of the effective Contour of the effective bag constant bag constant

Page 27: Quark star RX J1856.5- 3754 and its mass - MPIA.de · 1 Quark star RX J1856.5-3754 and its mass Kazunori Kohri (郡 和範) RESCEU, Univ. of Tokyo K. Kohri, K. Iida and Katsuhiko

27

Contours of the upper Contours of the upper limintlimint of the massof the mass

Page 28: Quark star RX J1856.5- 3754 and its mass - MPIA.de · 1 Quark star RX J1856.5-3754 and its mass Kazunori Kohri (郡 和範) RESCEU, Univ. of Tokyo K. Kohri, K. Iida and Katsuhiko

28

ConclusionConclusion

・ We have systematically computed mass-radius relation of quark star within the bag model.

・ Assuming that RX J1856.5--3754 is a pure quark star, we have derived an upper limit on its mass.

・ We find the upper limit can amount to 1 M around

B ~ (200MeV).4