60
Policy Implementation Policy Implementation - How to develop LCS study How to develop LCS study - 脱温暖化 2050 http://2050.nies.go.jp Junichi Fujino[email protected]NIES 2008 AIM Training Workshop, Tsukuba 28 Oct, 2008

Policy Implementation -- How to develop LCS study How to ... filePolicy Implementation-- How to develop LCS study How to develop LCS study --脱温暖化 2050 httppgj://2050.nies.go.jpp

  • Upload
    hoangtu

  • View
    223

  • Download
    0

Embed Size (px)

Citation preview

Page 1: Policy Implementation -- How to develop LCS study How to ... filePolicy Implementation-- How to develop LCS study How to develop LCS study --脱温暖化 2050 httppgj://2050.nies.go.jpp

Policy ImplementationPolicy Implementation-- How to develop LCS study How to develop LCS study -- 脱温暖化

2050

http://2050.nies.go.jpp g jp

Junichi Fujino([email protected])NIES

2008 AIM Training Workshop, Tsukuba28 Oct, 2008

Page 2: Policy Implementation -- How to develop LCS study How to ... filePolicy Implementation-- How to develop LCS study How to develop LCS study --脱温暖化 2050 httppgj://2050.nies.go.jpp

What LCS model can offer?

What LCS model should answer?What LCS model should answer?

Page 3: Policy Implementation -- How to develop LCS study How to ... filePolicy Implementation-- How to develop LCS study How to develop LCS study --脱温暖化 2050 httppgj://2050.nies.go.jpp

Forecasting from now and Backcasting Forecasting from now and Backcasting from future prescribed/normative worldfrom future prescribed/normative world

Technology development,socio-economic change projected by historically

d

Forecasting Reference future

ldtrend worldMitigation

Technology developmentRequired

P li e ntion

3. We need

Service demand

Policy intervention and

Investment

pres

sur

int

erve

n

“Innovation”to realize visions

Long-terBack casting

changeby changing social

behavior, lifestyles and institutions

required intervention policy m

enta

l p

Requ

ired

2. We need“Vi i ”

rm target ye

ReleaseA

IM re

Back-casting

Normative target world

and measures

Envi

ronm

Checyear(2

Checyear(20

R “Visions”1.”Target” is tough

2020 20502000

ear

e of esult

gE cking015)

cking025)

is tough50% reductions

In the world

Page 4: Policy Implementation -- How to develop LCS study How to ... filePolicy Implementation-- How to develop LCS study How to develop LCS study --脱温暖化 2050 httppgj://2050.nies.go.jpp

Japan Low Carbon Society Scenarios toward 2050

[FY2004-2008, Global Environmental Research Program, MOE][FY2004 2008, Global Environmental Research Program, MOE]

Study environmental options toward low carbon society in Japand b d

Green buildingsSelf-sustained city

Decentralized services

Eco awarenessEffective communication

Dematerialization

Next generation vehiclesEfficient transportation system

Advanced logistics

Techno-Socio Innovation studyAdvisory board:advice to project

Decentralized services Dematerialization Advanced logistics

BaU scenarioE i h

Urban structure IT-society

Development of socio-economic scenarios io

nTransportation

system ReductionTarget study

BaU scenario

EE improvement

New energy

Energy saving

Structure change

Life-styleh

Tech. innovationeconomic scenarios, evaluating counter-measures with social-economic-technology models GH

G em

issi

-1135

Valid

EquityEffective

990

000

020

050

010

Interventionscenario

changeGHG reduction target(eg. 60-80% reduction by 1990 level)

Evaluate feasibility of GHG reduction target

Integration Team

Suitable

19 20 20 2020

Middle-termTarget year

Loge-termTarget year 5 teams

60 Researchers

4

60 ResearchersPropose options of long-term global warming policy

Page 5: Policy Implementation -- How to develop LCS study How to ... filePolicy Implementation-- How to develop LCS study How to develop LCS study --脱温暖化 2050 httppgj://2050.nies.go.jpp

GHG 70% reduction in 2050 Scenario A: Vivid Techno-driven SocietyDemand side energy -40% + Low carbonization of primary energy+CCSwith moderate cost of technological options as 0.3% of GDP in the year of 2050

Change of activityChange of activity

・High economic growth, Increase of service demand per household, Increase of office floor (increase)

・Servicizing of industry, Decline in number of households, Increase of public transportation (decrease)

with moderate cost of technological options as 0.3% of GDP in the year of 2050

621

6124

1013of

  y Re

duction 

of dem

and

ector Indu

stry

Reduction of service demandImprovement ofenergy intensityImprovement of

・Farm products produced and consumed in season 

on

90

13

38

97

Improvem

ent o

energy

intensit

of end

‐use

nergy de

mandse

dential &

 mmercial

Improvement ofcarbon intensity

Reduction of service demand

Improvement of

・Fuel switch from coal and oil to natural gas

・Insulation・Energy use management (HEMS/BEMS)

・Efficient heat pump air‐conditioner, Efficient water heater,

70%redu

ctio

36

7

28

17

Emission

Emission

Improvem

ent o

f carbon

intensity

 of end

‐use

Etor

ation

Resid

com Improvement of

energy intensityImprovement ofcarbon intensity

Efficient heat pump air conditioner, Efficient water heater,  Efficient lighting equipment

・Development and widespread use of fuel cell・All‐electric house・Photovoltaic

77

41

36CCS

1990

 CO

2 E

2000

 CO

2 E

mprovem

ent o

f arbo

nintensity

 f e

nergy supp

ly

nergy supp

ly sect

Transporta

Reduction of service demand

Improvement ofenergy intensity

・Advanced land use / Aggregation of urban function・Modal shift to public transportation service・Widespread use of motor‐driven vehicle such aselectric vehicle and fuel‐cell electric vehicle

CCS

2 Em

ission

Im ca ofE

nergy supp

ly

gy yImprovement ofcarbon intensity

Improvement of

・High efficiency freight vehicle・Improvement of energy efficiency (train/ship/airplane)

・Fuel mix change to low carbon energy sources such as natural gas, nuclear energy, and renewable energy

Carbon CaptureStorage

2050

 CO En Improvement of

carbon intensity

・Power generation without CO2 emission・Hydrogen production without CO2 emission

・Effective use of night power / Electricity storage・Hydrogen (derived from renewable energy) supply

Page 6: Policy Implementation -- How to develop LCS study How to ... filePolicy Implementation-- How to develop LCS study How to develop LCS study --脱温暖化 2050 httppgj://2050.nies.go.jpp

7. Pedestrian Friendly City Design

A Dozen Actions towards Low-Carbon SocietiesResidential/commercial sector actions

Press release on May 22, 2008

1. Comfortable and Green Built EnvironmentEfficiently use of sunlight and energy efficient built environment design. Intelligent buildings.

City design requiring short trips and pedestrian (and bicycle) friendly transport, augmented by efficient public transport

2. Anytime, Anywhere Appropriate AppliancesUse of Top-runner and Appropriate appliances. Initial cost reduction by rent and release system resulting in improved availability

8. Low-Carbon Electricity Supplying low carbon electricity by large-scale renewables, nuclear power and CCS equipped fossil (and biomass) fired plants

Energy supply sector actions

resulting in improved availability.

3. Promoting Seasonal Local FoodSupply of seasonal and safe low-carbon local

and CCS-equipped fossil (and biomass) fired plants9. Local Renewable Resources for Local DemandEnhancing local renewables use, such as solar, wind, biomass and others

Industrial sector actions

foods for local cuisine4. Sustainable Building Materials Using local and renewable buildings materials and products.

biomass and others.

10. Next Generation Fuels Development of carbon free hydrogen- and/or biomass-based energy supply system with required infrastructure5. Environmentally Enlightened Business and

Industry Businesses aiming at creating and operating in low carbon market. Supplying low carbon and high value added goods and services

system with required infrastructure

11. Labeling to Encourage Smart and Rational ChoicesVisualizing of energy use and CO2 costs information

Cross-sector actions

carbon and high value-added goods and services through energy efficient production systems.

6. Swift and Smooth Logistics

Visualizing of energy use and CO2 costs information for smart choices of low carbon goods and service by consumers, and public acknowledgement of such consumers

Transportation sector actions

12. Low-Carbon Society Leadership Human resource development for building “Low-Carbon Society” and recognizing extraordinary contributions.

6. Swift and Smooth LogisticsNetworking seamless logistics systems with supply chain management, using both transportation and ICT infrastructure

Page 7: Policy Implementation -- How to develop LCS study How to ... filePolicy Implementation-- How to develop LCS study How to develop LCS study --脱温暖化 2050 httppgj://2050.nies.go.jpp

http://www.kantei.go.jp/foreign/abespeech/2007/05/24speech_e.html

Page 8: Policy Implementation -- How to develop LCS study How to ... filePolicy Implementation-- How to develop LCS study How to develop LCS study --脱温暖化 2050 httppgj://2050.nies.go.jpp

Japanese PM outlines green

http://www.energysavingtrust.org.uk/resources/daily_news/climate_change/japanese_pm_outlines_green_fukuda_vision

Japanese PM outlines green 'Fukuda vision‘ on 9th June

• Japanese prime minister Yasuo Fukuda on Monday announced a new emissions trading trial set• Japanese prime minister Yasuo Fukuda on Monday announced a new emissions trading trial set for this autumn and pledged to cut of 60-80 per cent of greenhouse gas emissions based on current levels by 2050.

• Under the new ETS scheme, countries will be able to impose upper limits on greenhouse gas p pp g gemissions and issue credits to large firms.

• Japan will also set out a mid-term reduction target of a 14 per cent cut in emissions by 2020 based on of 2005 level, said Mr Fukuda.

• Japan will contribute up to $1.2 billion to a new multilateral fund with the US and Britain to help developing countries fight global warming, Mr Fukuda said in his speech.

• Analysts said Tokyo is aiming to boost the perception that it is playing a leading role in fighting• Analysts said Tokyo is aiming to boost the perception that it is playing a leading role in fighting climate change at the July G8 summit in Hokkaido, where world leaders will meet to discuss arrangements for the successor to the Kyoto protocol, which expires in 2012.

• Japan says it will use more clean energy such as wind and solar and cut overall output, consumption and waste.

• Speaking at the Japan National Press Club, the Japanese premier outlined the 'Fukuda Vision', saying: "We must see the transition to a low-carbon society as an opportunity for new economic growth "growth.

• Japan is currently the world's fifth largest carbon emitter.

Page 9: Policy Implementation -- How to develop LCS study How to ... filePolicy Implementation-- How to develop LCS study How to develop LCS study --脱温暖化 2050 httppgj://2050.nies.go.jpp

July 7-9 2008, Hokkaido, Japan

Page 10: Policy Implementation -- How to develop LCS study How to ... filePolicy Implementation-- How to develop LCS study How to develop LCS study --脱温暖化 2050 httppgj://2050.nies.go.jpp

Summary of the Hokkaido Toyako SummitJuly 9, 2008

(2) Environment and Climate Change(2) Environment and Climate Change

(a) Prime Minister Fukuda stated at the beginning that this was a very important summit, one that should determine whether humanity can move toward a low-carbon society, severing its dependence on fossil fuels and addressing challenges including globalsevering its dependence on fossil fuels and addressing challenges including global warming and resource depletion countries.

(b) Long-term GoalWith respect to the goal of achieving at least 50% reduction of global emissions by 2050 the G8 leaders agreed to seek to share and adopt it with all Parties to the2050, the G8 leaders agreed to seek to share and adopt it with all Parties to the United Nations Framework Convention on Climate Change.

(c) Mid-term GoalsIn order to achieve absolute emission reductions in all developed nations, G8 leaders agreed to implement ambitious economy-wide mid-term goalsagreed to implement ambitious economy-wide mid-term goals.

(d) Sectoral ApproachIt was recognized that sectoral approaches are useful tools for achieving national emission objectives and for reducing GHG emissions.

(e) Climate Investment Funds(e) Climate Investment FundsG8 leaders welcomed and supported the establishment of the Climate Investment Funds administered by the World Bank to support the efforts of developing countries, and welcomed commitments from other donors.

Page 11: Policy Implementation -- How to develop LCS study How to ... filePolicy Implementation-- How to develop LCS study How to develop LCS study --脱温暖化 2050 httppgj://2050.nies.go.jpp

Chair’s Summary yG8 Environment Ministers Meeting

Kobe, Japan, pMay 24-26, 2008

T iti i t l b i ti d t bli hiTransitioning to low-carbon societies and establishing an international research network on low-carbon societies5. To realize such long-term goals, it is necessary to change the g g , y gcurrentsocio-economic structures and transition to low-carbon societies. In so doing there was general recognition of the importance of all theso doing, there was general recognition of the importance of all the countries to have a clear vision of low-carbon societies. Strong support for establishing an international research network of i tit ti i l d i th h l b i tiinstitutions involved in the research on low-carbon societies was shown by a number of countries, and other countries also expressed their support for the consideration of its establishment.

http://www.env.go.jp/earth/g8/en/img/G8EMM%202008%20Chair'sSummary_Final_.pdf

Page 12: Policy Implementation -- How to develop LCS study How to ... filePolicy Implementation-- How to develop LCS study How to develop LCS study --脱温暖化 2050 httppgj://2050.nies.go.jpp

Chair’s Summary G8 Environment Ministers Meeting

Kobe, JapanMay 24-26, 2008

A ti t li l b i tiActions to realize low-carbon societies6. To achieve low-carbon societies, all countries need innovations in

their lifestyle, production and consumption patterns, and social y p p pinfrastructure in addition to technological innovations. It was recognized that technology transfer and capacity building are necessary to achieve low-carbon societies at the global scale. Thenecessary to achieve low carbon societies at the global scale. The importance of research and development, information infrastructures and institutional planning was also pointed out. It was highlighted that there is a need to promote further development of technologiesthat there is a need to promote further development of technologies such as carbon capture and storage and biofuels. Carbon offsetting was also recognized as an effective mechanism that provides a wide range of stakeholders such as citizens companies andrange of stakeholders such as citizens, companies, and governments with opportunities to contribute to mitigation actions. It was observed that in shifting toward low-carbon societies, international cooperation on carbon offsets will play an important role.

http://www.env.go.jp/earth/g8/en/img/G8EMM%202008%20Chair'sSummary_Final_.pdf

Page 13: Policy Implementation -- How to develop LCS study How to ... filePolicy Implementation-- How to develop LCS study How to develop LCS study --脱温暖化 2050 httppgj://2050.nies.go.jpp

Carbon Reduction in PortlandStrategies and SuccessStrategies and Success

Megan SteinCity of Portland Office of Sustainable Development

Page 14: Policy Implementation -- How to develop LCS study How to ... filePolicy Implementation-- How to develop LCS study How to develop LCS study --脱温暖化 2050 httppgj://2050.nies.go.jpp

Portland Profile

We are here!We are here!

Page 15: Policy Implementation -- How to develop LCS study How to ... filePolicy Implementation-- How to develop LCS study How to develop LCS study --脱温暖化 2050 httppgj://2050.nies.go.jpp

1993 Carbon Dioxide Reduction StrategyStrategy

Built on 1979Built on 1979 Local Energy Plan

Integrated Energy with:

Housing

Land Use

TransportationTransportation

Business

Page 16: Policy Implementation -- How to develop LCS study How to ... filePolicy Implementation-- How to develop LCS study How to develop LCS study --脱温暖化 2050 httppgj://2050.nies.go.jpp

2001 Local Action Plan on Global WarmingWarming

CO Reduction Goal:CO2 Reduction Goal:10% below 1990 levels by 2010by 2010

Over 100 government actions & community initiatives

PolicyR bl ERenewable Energy TransportationBuildingsBuildingsSolid WasteForestryForestry

Page 17: Policy Implementation -- How to develop LCS study How to ... filePolicy Implementation-- How to develop LCS study How to develop LCS study --脱温暖化 2050 httppgj://2050.nies.go.jpp

2001 Local Action Plan on Global WarmingWarming

Energy

Transportation

Green Building

R li dRecycling and Composting

Page 18: Policy Implementation -- How to develop LCS study How to ... filePolicy Implementation-- How to develop LCS study How to develop LCS study --脱温暖化 2050 httppgj://2050.nies.go.jpp

Energy

Internal energy efficiency and renewable energyefforts save the City over $2 7 million annuallyefforts save the City over $2.7 million annually

Biogas generation, representing $500,000 annual savingssavings

Solar panels, hydroelectric turbines and a small wind turbine

Page 19: Policy Implementation -- How to develop LCS study How to ... filePolicy Implementation-- How to develop LCS study How to develop LCS study --脱温暖化 2050 httppgj://2050.nies.go.jpp

Energy

Portland’s operations use p173 million kWh per year

$Roughly $13 million

100% renewable energy100% renewable energy for City operations by 20102010

Page 20: Policy Implementation -- How to develop LCS study How to ... filePolicy Implementation-- How to develop LCS study How to develop LCS study --脱温暖化 2050 httppgj://2050.nies.go.jpp

2001 Local Action Plan on Global WarmingWarming

Energy

Transportation

Green Building

Recycling and Composting

Page 21: Policy Implementation -- How to develop LCS study How to ... filePolicy Implementation-- How to develop LCS study How to develop LCS study --脱温暖化 2050 httppgj://2050.nies.go.jpp

Transportation

Urban Growth Boundary

Page 22: Policy Implementation -- How to develop LCS study How to ... filePolicy Implementation-- How to develop LCS study How to develop LCS study --脱温暖化 2050 httppgj://2050.nies.go.jpp
Page 23: Policy Implementation -- How to develop LCS study How to ... filePolicy Implementation-- How to develop LCS study How to develop LCS study --脱温暖化 2050 httppgj://2050.nies.go.jpp

Transportation

Renewable Fuels StandardAll Diesel = 5% BiodieselAll Gasoline = 10% EthanolAll Gasoline = 10% Ethanol2010 = 10% Biodiesel

Page 24: Policy Implementation -- How to develop LCS study How to ... filePolicy Implementation-- How to develop LCS study How to develop LCS study --脱温暖化 2050 httppgj://2050.nies.go.jpp

2001 Local Action Plan on Global WarmingWarming

Energy Use

T t tiTransportation

G B ildiGreen Building

Waste Reduction & Recycling

Page 25: Policy Implementation -- How to develop LCS study How to ... filePolicy Implementation-- How to develop LCS study How to develop LCS study --脱温暖化 2050 httppgj://2050.nies.go.jpp

Green Building

LEED Gold certification required for municipalLEED Gold certification required for municipalowned buildings:

New constructionExisting buildings and remodelsSpecial requirements for roofs and re-roof projects

LEED Silver certification for city funded, privateprojects

Page 26: Policy Implementation -- How to develop LCS study How to ... filePolicy Implementation-- How to develop LCS study How to develop LCS study --脱温暖化 2050 httppgj://2050.nies.go.jpp

2001 Local Action Plan on Global W iWarming

Energy

T t tiTransportation

Green BuildingGreen Building

Recycling andRecycling and Compostingg

Page 27: Policy Implementation -- How to develop LCS study How to ... filePolicy Implementation-- How to develop LCS study How to develop LCS study --脱温暖化 2050 httppgj://2050.nies.go.jpp

Recycling and Composting

63% Recovery Rate63% Recovery Rate

75% Recovery Goal

Mandatory recycling for businesses and construction sitesconstruction sites

Mandatory composting for food generators

Page 28: Policy Implementation -- How to develop LCS study How to ... filePolicy Implementation-- How to develop LCS study How to develop LCS study --脱温暖化 2050 httppgj://2050.nies.go.jpp

Accomplishments

Page 29: Policy Implementation -- How to develop LCS study How to ... filePolicy Implementation-- How to develop LCS study How to develop LCS study --脱温暖化 2050 httppgj://2050.nies.go.jpp

Achieving the New 2050 Goal

Portland 2010 Goal: 10% below 1990 levels10% below 1990 levels

Emissions level required to stabilize the climate

Page 30: Policy Implementation -- How to develop LCS study How to ... filePolicy Implementation-- How to develop LCS study How to develop LCS study --脱温暖化 2050 httppgj://2050.nies.go.jpp

Achieving the New 2050 Goal

18,000,000

14 000 000

16,000,000

8,000,000

Business as usual

12,000,000

14,000,000

O2e

Buildings/ electricity

8,000,000

10,000,000

met

ric to

ns C

O

Buildings/ natural gas

4,000,000

6,000,000

m

Passenger transportation

0

2,000,000Commercial transportationGoal

1990 2000 2010 2020 2030 2040 2050

Page 31: Policy Implementation -- How to develop LCS study How to ... filePolicy Implementation-- How to develop LCS study How to develop LCS study --脱温暖化 2050 httppgj://2050.nies.go.jpp

Achieving the New 2050 Goal: Possible StrategiesPossible Strategies

Establish an investment fund to leverage privateEstablish an investment fund to leverage private capital to finance comprehensive energy efficiency improvements and clean distributed

tigeneration

Require energy performance ratings forRequire energy performance ratings for residential and commercial buildings at time of sale

Require all evaluations of land use options to include forecasts of greenhouse gas impacts g g p

Make it possible for residents to access key community goods and services within walkingcommunity goods and services within walking distance

Page 32: Policy Implementation -- How to develop LCS study How to ... filePolicy Implementation-- How to develop LCS study How to develop LCS study --脱温暖化 2050 httppgj://2050.nies.go.jpp

www.PortlandOnline.com/OSD

[email protected]

Page 33: Policy Implementation -- How to develop LCS study How to ... filePolicy Implementation-- How to develop LCS study How to develop LCS study --脱温暖化 2050 httppgj://2050.nies.go.jpp

地方自治体の低炭素社会目標地方自治体の低炭素社会目標

目標値はそれぞれカリフォルニア州1 1

1.2

2050年 目標値はそれぞれの地域での基準年比排出量。

カリフォルニア州

カリフォルニア州ニューメキシコ州

ニューメキシコ州

コネッチカット州

コネッチカット州オレゴン州

オレゴン州ジュネーヴ

広島市柏0.9

1

1.1

基準年は地域によって異なるが、1990年が多い。

ロンドン

チェルトナム

ウォキング

オレゴン州ストックホルム

ベルリン

ミュンヘン 豊中

豊中

横浜柏

千代田区

東京都

ニューヨーク市

0 6

0.7

0.8

排出量

1990年が多い。

ロンドン ブリストル

チェルトナム

ウォキング

ウォキングレスター

ベルリン

ベルリン

ミュンヘン

豊中

横浜

横浜

広島市

0.4

0.5

0.6

基準年比

ロンドン ブリストル

カリフォルニア州ニューメキシコ州

オレゴン州豊中

0 1

0.2

0.3

60%~100%削減目標

ストックホルム

ジュネーヴ0

0.1

1990 2010 2030 2050 2070目標年目標年

Page 34: Policy Implementation -- How to develop LCS study How to ... filePolicy Implementation-- How to develop LCS study How to develop LCS study --脱温暖化 2050 httppgj://2050.nies.go.jpp

環境モデル都市プロジェクト(内閣官房地域活性化統合本部、2008)に提案された温室効果ガス排出削減目標

1.2

• 82件(89自治体)の

応募、

宇都宮市

堺市

高知市

釧路市

帯広市

宇都宮市

太田市

川口市松戸市

松戸市流山市

江戸川区

江戸川区福生市

相模原市大垣市

多治見市

刈谷市

後熊本市

1• 大幅な削減目標や実

現可能性、地域の特

色など、五つの選定宇都宮市

大阪市

富良野市

下川町

洞爺湖町

鹿追町

青森市

飯豊町

太田市

太田市川口市

柏市

流山市

千代田区豊島区

調布市

福生市

横浜市

相模原市上越市 富山市

金沢市

珠洲市

山梨市

各務原市豊田市東近江市

京丹後市

岸和田市

出雲市真庭市

上勝町

高松市

北九州市

長崎市

熊本市

水俣市

日田市

那覇市

うるま市

0.8

目標

出量

基準により、

• 環境モデル都市とし

て 6自治体(北海道

土浦市

北区

中津川市

札幌市 札幌市

下川町

つくば市

戸田&白河市

北本市福生市

横浜市相模原市

金沢市

山梨市 飯田市岐阜市 岐阜市

大垣市静岡市

名古屋市刈谷市

刈谷市

近江八幡市

高島市京都市

大阪市松山市

熊本市 水俣市鹿児島市

う 市

0.6

基準

年比

排出

基準

年比

排出 て、6自治体(北海道

帯広市、北海道下川

町、横浜市、富山市、

北九州市、熊本県水

俣市)中津川市

釧路市帯広市富良野市

下川町

洞爺湖町

飯豊町

土浦市

松戸市柏市

流山市千代田区

豊島区調布市川崎市

珠洲市

飯田市

各務原市御嵩町豊田市近江八幡市

京都市

吹田市

真庭市

広島市

高松市

松山市

高知市北九州市

長崎市熊本市

日田市

0.4

基 俣市)、

• 「環境モデル候補都

市」として、東京都千名古屋市

洞爺湖町鹿追町青森市宇都宮市太田市川口市

崎市上越市富山市山梨市

飯田市

岐阜市多治見市

中津川市静岡市

近江 幡市東近江市

京都市

京丹後市長岡京市

堺市岸和田市

吹田市

新宮市出雲市

広島市

上勝町

州市杵築市

鹿児島市

那覇市うるま市けいはんな

0.2 代田区、長野県飯田

市、愛知県豊田市、

京都市、大阪府堺市

高知県梼原町 沖静岡市 京都市 上勝町

0

2005 2010 2015 2020 2025 2030 2035 2040 2045 2050 2055

年目標年

、高知県梼原町、沖

縄県宮古島市を選ん

だ。

Page 35: Policy Implementation -- How to develop LCS study How to ... filePolicy Implementation-- How to develop LCS study How to develop LCS study --脱温暖化 2050 httppgj://2050.nies.go.jpp

Japan-UK Joint Research ProjectLCS through Sustainable DevelopmentLCS through Sustainable Development

for Global ParticipationTh Fi k h h ldThe First workshop was held

in Tokyo, June14-16, 2006. G8 Gleneagles 2005

Participants from 19 countries;

G8 Japan

Participants from 19 countries;Asia: Japan, China, India, Thailand, Taiwan (China)Africa: South Africa, NigeriaEurope: UK France Germany G8 Japan

July 2008Europe: UK, France, Germany, Denmark, Spain, Netherlands, RussiaLatin America: Brazil, Mexico, ChileNorth America: US, Canada

The Second workshop was held in London, June13-15, 2007.

The Third workshop was held in Japan, Feb13-15, 2008.

http://2050.nies.go.jphttp://2050.nies.go.jpDeveloping and Diffusing Innovations for our good life and LCS through SD

Page 36: Policy Implementation -- How to develop LCS study How to ... filePolicy Implementation-- How to develop LCS study How to develop LCS study --脱温暖化 2050 httppgj://2050.nies.go.jpp

JapanJapan‐‐UK Joint Research ProjectUK Joint Research ProjectSustainable LowSustainable Low‐‐Carbon Societies Carbon Societies ((LCSsLCSs))In 2006, the Governments of Japan and UK established an innovative joint research project with participation from a diverse group of some 20 countries. 

Launch of the Project : 16th Feb 2006 (Anniversary of Kyoto Protocol)

Former Japanese Environment Minister Yuriko Koike and UK Ambassador to Japan Sir. Graham Fry announced the launch of the joint research of theannounced the launch of the joint research of the Low‐Carbon Societies (LCSs) 

1 t W k h J 2006

A l t ti f i th d f

1st Workshop:  June 2006   Developing Visions for a LCS through Sustainable Development

A long‐term perspective focusing on the need for urgent action to reduce CO2 towards 2050.Achievement of LCS will involve the development d d l t f l b t h l iand deployment of low carbon technologies, 

changes to lifestyles and institution, and need to align with sustainable development.Tokyo

Page 37: Policy Implementation -- How to develop LCS study How to ... filePolicy Implementation-- How to develop LCS study How to develop LCS study --脱温暖化 2050 httppgj://2050.nies.go.jpp

JapanJapan‐‐UK Joint Research ProjectUK Joint Research ProjectSustainable LowSustainable Low‐‐Carbon Societies Carbon Societies ((LCSsLCSs))In 2006, the Governments of Japan and UK established an innovative joint research project with participation from a diverse group of some 20 countries. 

2nd Workshop: June 2007  Achieving a Sustainable LCSA wide range of stakeholders‐ from governmentA wide range of stakeholders‐ from government, business, and civil society need to be engaged in finding solutions. A significant share of GHG is due to cities Effective

3rd Workshop: Feb 2008 Roadmap to Low Carbon World

A significant share of GHG is due to cities. Effective Action can be and is being undertaken.London

Tokyo3rd Workshop: Feb 2008  Roadmap to Low Carbon World

Creation of appropriate incentives for business using long‐term policy signals to strengthen carbon pricing.Expanding financial flows, international cooperation inlow‐carbon approaches.Building trust between countries and stakeholders 

Co‐chairs: Shuzo Nishioka(NIES), Jim Skea(UKERC)

though enhancement of communications is important.

Page 38: Policy Implementation -- How to develop LCS study How to ... filePolicy Implementation-- How to develop LCS study How to develop LCS study --脱温暖化 2050 httppgj://2050.nies.go.jpp

Group 1Group 1Group1: Behavior change and its impact on delivering LCSsGroup1: Behavior change and its impact on delivering LCSsGroup chairs: Jeremy Watson (Arup, UK) and Yuichi Moriguchi (NIES, Japan)Rapporateur: Steve CorneliusRapporateur: Steve Cornelius

Key QuestionsWh t th i l i b h i h h t b iWhat are the main levers in behaviour change, what barriers need to be overcome?, and

• What roles exist for different actors i.e. individuals, businesses, Governments etc?Governments, etc?

• What are the roles of policy options, including regulations and setting standards, for behaviour change?

• In particular, how consumption patterns of the developed p , p p pcountries can be tackled in the context of behavior change?

Page 39: Policy Implementation -- How to develop LCS study How to ... filePolicy Implementation-- How to develop LCS study How to develop LCS study --脱温暖化 2050 httppgj://2050.nies.go.jpp

Group 2Group 2Group2: Delivering LCS through Sustainable DevelopmentGroup2: Delivering LCS through Sustainable DevelopmentGroup chairs: P.R.Shukla (IIM, India), Taka Hiraishi (IGES, Japan)Rapporateur: Sunil Malla (Technology Consultancy ServicesRapporateur: Sunil Malla (Technology Consultancy Services, Kathmandu), Tomoki Ehara (MHIR)

Key QuestionsKey QuestionsWhat are the differences among developing countries in terms of adapting to and mitigating the climate change?What are the differences between SDPAMs and LCSWhat are the differences between SDPAMs and LCS approaches and what advantages do LCS approaches provide to achieve SD?How approaches to LCS can be integrated into SDPAMs?How approaches to LCS can be integrated into SDPAMs?

Page 40: Policy Implementation -- How to develop LCS study How to ... filePolicy Implementation-- How to develop LCS study How to develop LCS study --脱温暖化 2050 httppgj://2050.nies.go.jpp

Group 3Group 3Group 3: Enabling LCSs: InvestmentGroup 3: Enabling LCSs: InvestmentHow to inspire innovation, driving force to make it happenGroup chairs: Jose Garibaldi (Enegeia Mexico), Takejiro Sueyoshi (UNDP)Sueyoshi (UNDP)Rapporateur: Andy Bolhito

K Q tiKey QuestionsWhat conditions (rules, institutions, price signals) will stimulate investment for LCSs? H d t th i ti t d i dHow do we create the necessary incentives to drive and enhance innovation?What are the roles of the governments to make necessary investments happen?investments happen?

Page 41: Policy Implementation -- How to develop LCS study How to ... filePolicy Implementation-- How to develop LCS study How to develop LCS study --脱温暖化 2050 httppgj://2050.nies.go.jpp

Group 4Group 4Group 4: Barriers and opportunities: approaches to sensitiveGroup 4: Barriers and opportunities: approaches to sensitive LCS sectorsWiping out concerns, bright futures, level playing fields, impacts to industry and other sectorsimpacts to industry and other sectorsGroup chairs: Jim Watson (SPRU, UK), Naoya Tsukamoto (MoEJ, Japan)Rapporateur: Jiang Kejun and Toshi ArimuraRapporateur: Jiang Kejun and Toshi Arimura

Key QuestionsWhat sectors are most sensitive and/or vulnerable in theWhat sectors are most sensitive and/or vulnerable in the transition to LCS?What kind of inertia hinders transition to LCSs (concepts, social systems economic systems infrastructure etc)?social systems, economic systems, infrastructure, etc)?What opportunities exist for such sectors in new “green” markets and what policy measures exist to achieve international level playing fields?p y g

Page 42: Policy Implementation -- How to develop LCS study How to ... filePolicy Implementation-- How to develop LCS study How to develop LCS study --脱温暖化 2050 httppgj://2050.nies.go.jpp

Behaviour Change and its impact onBehaviour Change and its impact on delivering a Low-Carbon Society

Co-chairs – Yuichi Moriguchi, Jeremy Watson

Rapporteur – Stephen CorneliusRapporteur – Stephen Cornelius

Page 43: Policy Implementation -- How to develop LCS study How to ... filePolicy Implementation-- How to develop LCS study How to develop LCS study --脱温暖化 2050 httppgj://2050.nies.go.jpp

Overview

• Leadership

• Instruments to drive Behaviour Change

• Tools for Behaviour Change• Tools for Behaviour Change

• Markets

• Psychology of Behaviour Change

• Timely and appropriate Behaviour ChangeTimely and appropriate Behaviour Change

• Engagement

Page 44: Policy Implementation -- How to develop LCS study How to ... filePolicy Implementation-- How to develop LCS study How to develop LCS study --脱温暖化 2050 httppgj://2050.nies.go.jpp

Leadership

• Governments are expected to play a leading role by creating enabling frameworks

• business want a framework with an appropriate balance of incentives and penalties and with long-term policy certaintyincentives and penalties and with long term policy certainty

• consumers welcome leadership and clear vision from governments rather government inaction

• Each group sees the onus to act first as being the responsibility of the others (government / business / i di id l )individuals)

Page 45: Policy Implementation -- How to develop LCS study How to ... filePolicy Implementation-- How to develop LCS study How to develop LCS study --脱温暖化 2050 httppgj://2050.nies.go.jpp

Instruments to drive Behaviour Change

• Regulationt d d t h i d l tt ti d• standards – e.g. worst choices made less attractive or removed

• obligations – e.g. mandatory emissions reduction targets

M t• Monetary• fiscal (taxes and incentives – e.g. London congestion charge)• procurement – e.g. C40 (energy efficiency purchases for publicprocurement e.g. C40 (energy efficiency purchases for public

buildings)• emissions trading

• Exemplar projects• low-carbon, low waste housing (e.g. BedZED)

Page 46: Policy Implementation -- How to develop LCS study How to ... filePolicy Implementation-- How to develop LCS study How to develop LCS study --脱温暖化 2050 httppgj://2050.nies.go.jpp

Tools for Behaviour Change

• Information / guidance• product labelling – e.g. life-cycle costs, energy ratings• household- and company-level emission inventory – e.g. energy

meters & accountingmeters & accounting• web resources – e.g. carbon calculator• support on how to change behaviour – e.g. advice helpline

l i t k• learning networks• mass media

A il bilit f it bl lt ti / h i• Availability of suitable alternatives / choices• product versus service choice• transport modal shifttransport modal shift

Page 47: Policy Implementation -- How to develop LCS study How to ... filePolicy Implementation-- How to develop LCS study How to develop LCS study --脱温暖化 2050 httppgj://2050.nies.go.jpp

Markets

• Recognise the value of market-based instruments to influence behaviours in the medium to long-term

• need a price on carbon (i.e. value on emission reduction) • power of informed consumer choice (e g consumer-durables)• power of informed consumer choice (e.g. consumer-durables)

• Supply (production) and Demand (consumption)• decarbonising energy supply (e g renewables CCS nuclear)• decarbonising energy supply (e.g. renewables, CCS, nuclear)• the benefit of incremental efficiency improvements may be offset

by increased consumption (rebound effect) and switching to more energy intensive alternatives

Page 48: Policy Implementation -- How to develop LCS study How to ... filePolicy Implementation-- How to develop LCS study How to develop LCS study --脱温暖化 2050 httppgj://2050.nies.go.jpp

Psychology of Behaviour Change

• Encourage positive attitude• not “don’t” but “let’s do”• small individual actions can be cumulatively powerful (e.g.

recycling)• turn aspirations to be greener into actions that matter• turn aspirations to be greener into actions that matter• Change should be desirable – fashionable and fun!

• Change mind set• Change mind-set • consumer items not as important as the service they provide• become aware that ownership carries responsibility• focus on quality-of-life rather than on mass-consumption and

disposal

• Social responsibility and peer pressure• family, neighbours, colleagues

Page 49: Policy Implementation -- How to develop LCS study How to ... filePolicy Implementation-- How to develop LCS study How to develop LCS study --脱温暖化 2050 httppgj://2050.nies.go.jpp

Timely and appropriate Behaviour Change

• Need more than incremental changes to rapidly transition to LCS

• move LCS philosophy from the periphery into the mainstream • likely to involve paradigm shifts• likely to involve paradigm shifts

• Recognising difference in circumstance• Recognising difference in circumstance• strategies for LCS will vary for different countries – depending

on national circumstance (resource endowment, development level etc)

• city-level action may also differ due to varying opportunity to act • leapfrogging – assistance to develop on a low-carbon pathway leapfrogging assistance to develop on a low carbon pathway

through appropriate technology transfer, financing and investment, joint venture exemplar projects etc

Page 50: Policy Implementation -- How to develop LCS study How to ... filePolicy Implementation-- How to develop LCS study How to develop LCS study --脱温暖化 2050 httppgj://2050.nies.go.jpp

Engagement

• Broad participation is needed to achieve a LCSp p• actions are required by all stakeholders – citizens, corporations

and government

• Government• city plans should be at least enabled and preferably supported

by national frameworksby national frameworks• advanced city-level action can be used as pilots for national

action

Page 51: Policy Implementation -- How to develop LCS study How to ... filePolicy Implementation-- How to develop LCS study How to develop LCS study --脱温暖化 2050 httppgj://2050.nies.go.jpp

Report fromReport fromGroup 2:G oup

“Delivering LCS through g gSustainable Development”

Page 52: Policy Implementation -- How to develop LCS study How to ... filePolicy Implementation-- How to develop LCS study How to develop LCS study --脱温暖化 2050 httppgj://2050.nies.go.jpp

Recognitionsg• “Developing countries” include a vast range of countries,

with differences in, for instance, population, natural , , p p ,resource endowment, stage of economic development, as well as political or geological conditions. Therefore, It is not proper to elaborate LCS questions monotonally onis not proper to elaborate LCS questions monotonally on “developing countries”.

• LCS actions and SD actions are required in both qdeveloped and developing countries, in line with their needs, priorities and within the available resources.Th G l b t d th LCS i ith b d ti• The Group elaborated the LCS issues with a broad time framework of “LCS by 2050”, while the Group was fully recognizant of the urgency of climate actions, in g g y ,particular, viz. extremely vulnerable countries. The Group also considered that actions towards “by 2050” would contain many early actions even in the near future term”contain many early actions even in the near future term .

Page 53: Policy Implementation -- How to develop LCS study How to ... filePolicy Implementation-- How to develop LCS study How to develop LCS study --脱温暖化 2050 httppgj://2050.nies.go.jpp

Recognition (2)g ( )• SD is meant to achieve sound development,

dd i i t t i haddressing many important issues such as; poverty, equity, health, technology, etc., which would not prevent development of futurewould not prevent development of future generations.

• SD concept has been with us for a couple of p pdecades (cf. Brundlunt Report (1987)), but there are numerous “definitions” reflecting the underlying background and the purpose of useunderlying background and the purpose of use. While essentially all the countries are committed to seek for its implementation, many countries p yare faced with a variety of difficulties.

Page 54: Policy Implementation -- How to develop LCS study How to ... filePolicy Implementation-- How to develop LCS study How to develop LCS study --脱温暖化 2050 httppgj://2050.nies.go.jpp

Major ConclusionsMajor Conclusions

Page 55: Policy Implementation -- How to develop LCS study How to ... filePolicy Implementation-- How to develop LCS study How to develop LCS study --脱温暖化 2050 httppgj://2050.nies.go.jpp

Relationship between LCS and SD• The Group believes that between LCS

and SD there are manyand SD, there are many commonalities and, possibly, many

t ll ti tmutually supportive components.• Detailed analysis of this aspect might y p g

be not only academically interesting, but it might accrue to valuable hints gfor future international actions on LCS/SD and on leap-frogging of p gg gdeveloping countries, though It would take significant time and resources.take significant time and resources.

Page 56: Policy Implementation -- How to develop LCS study How to ... filePolicy Implementation-- How to develop LCS study How to develop LCS study --脱温暖化 2050 httppgj://2050.nies.go.jpp

Provision of Visions on LCSProvision of Visions on LCS• Rather, the Group considered, as a matter

f i it di i ti d i i fof priority, dissemination and provision of “visions on LCS” to the world community is imperative so that governments andimperative, so that governments and relevant stakeholders can take well-informed and timely actions towards LCSinformed and timely actions towards LCS.

• For this purpose, the Group recommends that a detailed information/guidancethat a detailed information/guidance package on LCS should be prepared in the UK-Japan LCS scheme. [“Visions”]the UK Japan LCS scheme. [ Visions ]

Page 57: Policy Implementation -- How to develop LCS study How to ... filePolicy Implementation-- How to develop LCS study How to develop LCS study --脱温暖化 2050 httppgj://2050.nies.go.jpp

“Visions on LCS” (1)The “Visions on LCS” should address

issues such as: Principlesissues such as: Principles, Considerations, Means or Options. More specifically; The Visions should;specifically; The Visions should;– be clear that appropriate pathways to (certain types

f ) LCS ld t h i thof ) LCS, would not hamper economic growth.– state that LCS and SD should be synergistic.– be clear on societal benefits, expected from LCS.– propose a set of principles on Government’s

intervention.– allow dynamic and proactive changes in the

course of process towards LCS.

Page 58: Policy Implementation -- How to develop LCS study How to ... filePolicy Implementation-- How to develop LCS study How to develop LCS study --脱温暖化 2050 httppgj://2050.nies.go.jpp

“Visions on LCS” (2)( )The Visions should also;

ff ti ( f i di id l li i ) t l d– offer options (of individual policies), tools, and means (including international actions), possible

h d h d t llphased approaches and steps, as well as proposed timeline of actions.

– address requirements (especially, funds, technologies and human resources), and possible actions or means to obtain them.

– contain considerations on Implications on, and, p , ,by other policies, including fiscal policies (e.g., subsidies).)

Page 59: Policy Implementation -- How to develop LCS study How to ... filePolicy Implementation-- How to develop LCS study How to develop LCS study --脱温暖化 2050 httppgj://2050.nies.go.jpp

“Visions on LCS” (3):For the purpose of facilitation, the Visions

should also;should also;

– share good examples, or show cases.g p– contain discussions on cautions:

eventual problems in policyeventual problems in policy implementation (use of LCA?).

– consideration immediate (developmental) needs, of developing ( p ) , p gcountries.

Page 60: Policy Implementation -- How to develop LCS study How to ... filePolicy Implementation-- How to develop LCS study How to develop LCS study --脱温暖化 2050 httppgj://2050.nies.go.jpp

What LCS model can offer?

What LCS model should answer?What LCS model should answer?