67
PROJECT REPORT ON “PERFORMANCE AND RISK ANALYSIS OF MUTUAL FUND AND IT’S COMPARISON WITH THE STOCK MARKET” SUBMITTED IN PARTIAL FULFILLMENT OF PGDM COURSE. JRE SCHOOL OF MANAGEMENT Date: March 13 th , 2013 Student : Ankit Chandra Prakash PGDM 2012-14 Roll NO: 8 Page 1

Performance and Risk Analysis of Mutual Fund and It's Comparison With the Stock Market

Embed Size (px)

Citation preview

Page 1: Performance and Risk Analysis of Mutual Fund and It's Comparison With the Stock Market

PROJECT REPORT

ON

“PERFORMANCE AND RISK ANALYSIS OF MUTUAL FUND

AND

IT’S COMPARISON WITH THE STOCK MARKET”

SUBMITTED IN PARTIAL FULFILLMENT OF

PGDM COURSE.

JRE SCHOOL OF MANAGEMENT

Date: March 13th , 2013

Student : Ankit Chandra Prakash

PGDM 2012-14

Roll NO: 8

Page 1

Page 2: Performance and Risk Analysis of Mutual Fund and It's Comparison With the Stock Market

Acknowledgement

I wish to place on record my deep sense of gratitude to JRE School Of Management for

providing me an opportunity to take up this project and giving me a platform which is the first

step of my professional career..

A successful project can never be prepared by the single efforts of the person to whom

project is assigned, but it also demand the help and guardianship of some conversant person who

helped the undersigned actively or passively in the completion of successful project.

Page 2

Page 3: Performance and Risk Analysis of Mutual Fund and It's Comparison With the Stock Market

TABLE OF CONTENTS

EXECUTIVE SUMMARY 5CHAPTER 1: INTRODUCTION 6

1.1 Literature review 81.2 Problem of the Study 91.3 Objective 91.4 Definition of key term 101.5 Brief Outline of the Chapters 10

CHAPTER 2: METHODOLOGY 11 2.1 Universe of the study 11 2.2 Locale of the Study 12 2.3 Data Collection 12 2.4 Data Analysis 13CHAPTER 3: INDIAN MUTUAL FUND INDUSTRY 3.1 Classification of Mutual Fund 13 3.2 Risk Involved with Mutual Fund 13CHAPTER 4: EQUITY MARKET AND ITS COMPARISON WITH MUTUAL FUNDS 33 4.1 Equity Market in India 34 4.2 Equity Stock Selection Approaches

35 4.3 Comparison of Stock Market with Mutual Fund 39CHAPTER 5: CONCLUSION AND SUGGESTIONS

45 5.1 Findings 45 5.2 Suggestions 46 5.3 Limitations of the Study 46 5.4 Further Scope of the Study 47REFERENCE 47BIBLIOGRAPHY 48ANNEXURE 48

Page 3

Page 4: Performance and Risk Analysis of Mutual Fund and It's Comparison With the Stock Market

EXECUTIVE SUMMARY

The significant outcome of the government policy of liberalization in industrial and financial

sector has been the development of new financial instruments. These new instruments are

expected to impart greater competitiveness flexibility and efficiency to the financial sector.

Growth and development of various mutual fund products in Indian capital market has proved to

be one of the most catalytic instruments in generating momentous investment growth in the

capital market.

There is a substantial growth in the mutual fund market due to a high level of precision in the

design and marketing of variety of mutual fund products by banks and other financial institution

providing growth, liquidity and return. In this context, in this project has been done with an

Page 4

Page 5: Performance and Risk Analysis of Mutual Fund and It's Comparison With the Stock Market

objective to have an overall understanding of the different types mutual fund in various AMCs.

To conduct a detailed analysis of the stock market, and its relationship with mutual funds.

Mutual Fund is definitely growing at a high rate but the awareness of the benefits of investments in mutual funds among individual investors in India is still low. Among them those who are well aware of mutual fund investments are scared of the risk involved in it as they associate mutual funds with the stock market.

After getting thorough with the parameters required to measure the performance of Mutual

fund a comparative analysis of the stock market and mutual funds have been done. This analysis

revealed that the Mutual Funds have been able to perform better than the stock market and have

given good return considering the fact that it carries risk equivalent to the stock market.

Debt Funds and bond funds are preferred in low risk, low return scenario. For those willing to take high risks, equity and sector funds are the picks: Balance Funds are a good alternative for those who seek something between high risk sector funds and low risk bond funds.

CHAPTER 1: Introduction

The Mutual Funds originated in UK and thereafter they crossed the border to reach other

destinations. The concept of MF was Indianized only in the later part of the twentieth century in

the year 1964 with its roots embedded into Unit Trust of India (UTI). Now after 50 years,

booming stock markets & innovative marketing strategies of mutual fund companies in India are

influencing the retail investors to invest their surplus funds with different schemes of mutual

fund companies with or without complete understanding of Mutual Funds (MF).

There is a general notion that an investment in mutual fund is always risky. Investors should

always be conscious of the fact that Mutual Funds invest their funds in capital market

instruments such as shares, debentures, bonds etc and that all the capital market instruments have

risk. Risks can be Investor Psychology Risks, Prediction Risks, Choice Risks, and Cost Risks

etc.

Page 5

Page 6: Performance and Risk Analysis of Mutual Fund and It's Comparison With the Stock Market

Although there is no one mutual fund that will be suitable to all kinds of investors. Hence,

mutual fund investors need to identify a suitable fund for them. It will be the first step towards

making successful investments in mutual funds to make Mutual Funds their "CUP OF TEA".

Identifying a suitable fund can be done in a two-step manner as follows:

* Selecting a fund with investment objectives and preferences, return objectives, time horizon

and risk tolerances that meet the requirements of the investor.

* Selecting a fund that has a detailed asset allocation strategy by fund type category to reflect

the investment objectives of the fund.

Mutual funds can be win-win option available to the investors who are not willing to take any

exposure directly to the security markets as well as it helps the investors to build their wealth

over a period of time. But the thing which must be remembered by the investors is

"INVESTMENT IN MUTUAL FUND IS SUBJECT TO MARKET RISK".

The Indian Equity Market has grown significantly during the last three years; Mutual Funds are

not left far behind. Both the avenues have created wealth for the investors. But for the creation of

wealth through this avenue a proper understanding of the Mutual Funds is must.

Understanding Mutual Funds

A Mutual Fund is a trust that pools the savings of a number of investors who share a common

financial goal. The money thus collected is then invested in capital market instruments such as

shares, debentures and other securities. The income earned through these investments and capital

appreciation realized is shared by its unit holders in proportion to the number of units owned by them.

Page 6

Page 7: Performance and Risk Analysis of Mutual Fund and It's Comparison With the Stock Market

(Mutual Fund and Market Risks: Article By: Devindar Kaur Lecturer (Finance) Ludhiana

College of Engineering & Technology)

Thus a Mutual Fund is the most suitable investment for the common man as it offers an

opportunity to invest in a diversified, professionally managed basket of securities at a relatively

low cost.

When we talk about all these, one hard fact is about risks that are faced by the Mutual Fund

investors. Whenever we see any Mutual Fund offer, there are few statements inevitably found

along with that, which is commonly known as "Disclaimer Clause of the Mutual Fund".

1.1 LITERATURE REVIEW

Mutual funds industry is a growing at a very fast rate India. Various studies and research has

been on this industry by experts. Here are the list of few books that have been referred to for the

purpose of the study.

Mr M. Jaidev in his book has “Investment policy and performance of Mutual Fund”

has studied the Indian Public Sector Mutual Funds. In this book he has covered risk ,

rate of return. Investment policy and pricing of mutual funds. In this book he has

Page 7

Page 8: Performance and Risk Analysis of Mutual Fund and It's Comparison With the Stock Market

done an empirical study covering all aspects of mutual fund investment along with

the regulatory framework.

Nalini Prava Tripathy in her book “Mutual Funds in India. Emerging Issues” provides

a detailed evaluation of investment management which is not only helpful for

influencing marketing operations but also for securities selection, investment research

and timing and resource allocation.

Dr H. Sadak in his book “Mutual Funds in India” has highlighted the importance of

financials institutions in India. The basically focuses on the growth and development

of mutual funds in India. The entire gamut of the theoretical aspects of the fund

management has been critically examined in the context of the performance of mutual

funds and it provides an insight into fund management and the areas of weakness.

Mr. Sharad Panwar and Dr. R. Madhumathi in their journal “Characteristics and

Performance of selected mutual funds in India.”, have studied a sample of Public and

Private sector mutual funds of varied net assets to investigate the differences in

characteristics of assets held, portfolio diversification, and variable effects of

diversification on investment performance. The extent of diversification in the

portfolio of securities of public-sector sponsored and private-sector sponsored mutual

funds have been highlighted.

1.2 PROBLEM OF THE STUDY

Mutual Fund is definitely growing at a high rate but the awareness of the benefits of investments in mutual funds among individual investors in India is still low. Among them those who are well aware of mutual fund investments are scared of the risk involved in it as they associate mutual funds with the stock market . Through this project an attempt is made to increase the level of awareness of mutual funds, and to understand the risk involved in mutual fund investment, its performance and comparison with the stock market.

1.3 OBJECTIVES The present study has the following objectives:

Page 8

Page 9: Performance and Risk Analysis of Mutual Fund and It's Comparison With the Stock Market

1 To have an overall understanding of the different types mutual fund in various AMCs.

1 To conduct a detailed analysis of the stock market and its relationship with mutual funds.

2 To come up with viable suggestions for investors and mutual fund companies in India based

on the above study.

1.4 DEFINITION OF KEY TERMS :

1. AMC : An 'Asset Management Company' is a firm that invests the pooled funds of retail investors in securities in line with the stated investment

2. Asset Allocation: When you divide your money among various types of

investments, such as stocks, bonds, and short-term investments (also known as

"instruments"), you are allocating your assets.

3. NAV: The per-share value of a mutual fund, found by subtracting the fund’s

liabilities from its assets and dividing by the number of shares outstanding.

4. Entry/Exit load: The Fund charges some amount before buying the scheme. This is

usually some percentage of the amount invested and goes as the amount charged by

the Fund house to manage their money.

It is calculated as: Sales Purchase = Applicable NAV x ( 1 + Sales Charge )

Exit load is the charges you have to pay to the Fund house, if you wish to exit the

scheme. For most schemes the Exit load is nil. It is usually calculated as:

Repurchase Price = Application NAV x ( 1 - exit load)

5. Fund Factsheet: A newsletter sent by a mutual fund to its unit holders, either

quarterly or half yearly. The newsletter reviews performance of all its schemes

during the reference period, gives important schemes information such as portfolio

details, and offers pointers on what lies ahead.

Page 9

Page 10: Performance and Risk Analysis of Mutual Fund and It's Comparison With the Stock Market

CHAPTER 2: Methodology

In this chapter we aim to discuss the methodology that is being followed to achieve the stated

objectives. A lot of secondary research has been undertaken in order to ensure that

comprehensive understanding can be developed. The existent scenario in the mutual funds

industry and present statistical figures have been established on the basis of data collected

through secondary research. As far as the data collection from primary resources is concerned,

not much was revealed by the company so we had to rely on the data published by reliable

websites.

2.1 UNIVERSE OF THE STUDY

The entire Indian mutual fund industry and the Indian Financial Market is the universe of the

study. The scope of our universe further extends to all the investors who are an important part of

the financial markets.

2.2 LOCALE OF THE STUDY

Locale of the study are few of the Mutual Fund Houses in India namely Reliance Capital

AMC Ltd, DBS Cholamandalam AMC Ltd, Kotak Mahindra AMC Ltd, SBI Fund Management

Pvt Ltd, Birla Sun Life AMC Ltd HDFC AMC Ltd, Taurus AMC Ltd have been being analyzed

for the purpose of achieving the defined objectives.

2.3 DATA COLLECTION

Page 10

Page 11: Performance and Risk Analysis of Mutual Fund and It's Comparison With the Stock Market

Most of the data has been mainly collected from the secondary sources Primary sources for

data collection could not be used because of limited sources. Secondary Data has been collected

from

Capitaline Database

NSE Website

BSE Website

Mutualfundsindia.com

AMFI Module

2.5 DATA ANALYSIS

Datas that have been collected from secondary sources have been analyzed using statistical

tools. Statistical ratios like Treynor ratio, Sharpe ratio, standard deviation, beta, co variance etc.

of different schemes has been obtained from reliable sources on which the investors rely. For

statistical analysis, calculations wherever possible have been done to ensure that facts and

figures presented do not have any discrepancies.

CHAPTER 3: Indian Mutual Fund Industry

The Indian mutual fund industry is dominated by the Unit Trust of India, which has a total

corpus of Rs700bn collected from more than 20 million investors. The UTI has many

funds/schemes in all categories i.e. equity, balanced, income etc with some being open-ended

and some being closed-ended. The Unit Scheme 1964 commonly referred to as US 64, which is a

balanced fund, is the biggest scheme with a corpus of about Rs200bn. Most of its investors

believe that the UTI is government owned and controlled, which, while legally incorrect, is true

for all practical purposes.

Page 11

Page 12: Performance and Risk Analysis of Mutual Fund and It's Comparison With the Stock Market

The second largest category of mutual funds is the ones floated by nationalized banks. Can bank

Asset Management floated by Canara Bank and SBI Funds Management floated by the State

Bank of India are the largest of these. GIC AMC floated by General Insurance Corporation and

Jeevan Bima Sahayog AMC floated by the LIC are some of the other prominent ones.

3.1 MUTUAL FUND

The Assets under Management of UTI was Rs. 67bn. by the end of 1987. Let me concentrate

about the performance of mutual funds in India through figures. From Rs. 67bn. the Assets under

Management rose to Rs. 470 bn. in March 1993 and the figure had a three times higher

performance by April 2004. It rose as high as Rs. 1,540bn. The net asset value (NAV) of mutual

funds in India declined when stock prices started falling in the year 1992. Those days, the market

regulations did not allow portfolio shifts into alternative investments. There was rather no choice

apart from holding the cash or to further continue investing in shares. One more thing to be

noted, since only closed end funds were floated in the market the investors disinvested by selling

at loss in the secondary market.

3.2 CLASSIFICATION OF MUTUAL FUND

Mutual fund schemes may be classified on the basis of their structure and their investment

objective

By Structure

1) Open-ended Funds: An Open-ended Fund is one that is available for subscription all

through the year. These do not have a fixed maturity. Investors can conveniently buy and

sell units at Net Asset Value (NAV) related prices.

2) Close-ended Funds: A Close-ended Fund has a stipulated maturity period, which

generally ranges from 3 to 15 years. The fund is open for subscription only during a

Page 12

Page 13: Performance and Risk Analysis of Mutual Fund and It's Comparison With the Stock Market

specified period. Investors can invest in the scheme at the time of the initial public issue

and thereafter they can buy or sell the units of the scheme on the Stock Exchanges, if they

are listed. The market price at the stock exchange could vary from the scheme's NAV on

account of demand and supply situation, unit holders' expectations and other market

factors.

By Investment Objective

1) Growth Funds: The aim of growth funds is to provide capital appreciation over the

medium to long term. Such schemes normally invest a majority of their corpus in

equities. Growth schemes are ideal for investors who have a long-term outlook and are

seeking growth over a period of time.

2) Income Funds: The aim of Income Funds is to provide regular and steady income to

investors. Such schemes generally invest in fixed income securities such as bonds,

corporate debentures and Government securities. Income Funds are ideal for capital

stability and regular income. Capital appreciation in such funds may be limited, though

risks are typically lower than that in a growth fund.

3) Balanced Funds: The aim of Balanced Funds is to provide both growth and regular

income. Such schemes periodically distribute a part of their earning and invest both in

equities and fixed income securities in the proportion indicated in their offer documents.

This proportion affects the risks and the returns associated with the balanced fund - in

case equities are allocated a higher proportion, investors would be exposed to risks

similar to that of the equity market. Balanced funds with equal allocation to equities and

fixed income securities are ideal for investors looking for a combination of income and

moderate growth.

Page 13

Page 14: Performance and Risk Analysis of Mutual Fund and It's Comparison With the Stock Market

4) Money Market Funds: The aim of Money Market Funds is to provide easy liquidity,

preservation of capital and moderate income. These schemes generally invest in safer

short-term instruments such as Treasury Bills, Certificates of Deposit, Commercial Paper

and Inter-Bank Call Money. Returns on these schemes may fluctuate depending upon the

interest rates prevailing in the market. These are ideal for corporate and individual

investors as a means to park their surplus funds for short periods.

Other Equity Related Schemes

1) Tax Saving Schemes: These schemes offer tax rebates to the investors under specific

provisions of the Indian Income Tax laws, as the Government offers tax incentives for

investment in specified avenues. Investments made in Equity Linked Savings Schemes

(ELSS) and Pension Schemes are allowed as deduction under Section 88 of the Indian

Income Tax Act, 1961.

2) Index Schemes: Index Funds attempt to replicate the performance of a particular index

such as the BSE Sensex or the NSE S&P CNX 50.

3) Sectoral Schemes: Sectoral Funds are those which invest exclusively in specified

sector(s) such as FMCG, Information Technology, Pharmaceuticals, etc. These schemes

carry higher risk as compared to general equity schemes as the portfolio is less

diversified, i.e. restricted to specific sector(s) / industry (ies).

Different Mutual Fund plansTo cater to different investment needs, Mutual Funds offer various investment options. Some of

the important investment options include:

1) Growth Option: Dividend is not paid-out under a Growth Option and the investor

realizes only the capital appreciation on the investment (by an increase in NAV).

Page 14

Page 15: Performance and Risk Analysis of Mutual Fund and It's Comparison With the Stock Market

2) Dividend Payout Option: Dividends are paid-out to investors under the Dividend

Payout Option. However, the NAV of the mutual fund scheme falls to the extent of the

dividend payout.

3) Dividend Re-investment Option: Here the dividend accrued on mutual funds is

automatically re-invested in purchasing additional units in open-ended funds. In most

cases mutual funds offer the investor an option of collecting dividends or re-investing the

same.

4) Retirement Pension Option: Some schemes are linked with retirement pension.

Individuals participate in these options for themselves, and corporate participate for their

employees.

5) Insurance Option: Certain Mutual Funds offer schemes that provide insurance cover to

investors as an added benefit.

6) Systematic Investment Plan (SIP) : Here the investor is given the option of preparing a

pre-determined number of post-dated cheques in favour of the fund. The investor is

allotted units on a predetermined date specified in the offer document at the applicable

NAV.

7) Systematic Encashment Plan (SEP) : As opposed to the Systematic Investment Plan,

the Systematic Encashment Plan allows the investor the facility to withdraw a pre-

determined amount / units from his fund at a pre-determined interval. The investor's units

will be redeemed at the applicable NAV as on that day.

Page 15

Page 16: Performance and Risk Analysis of Mutual Fund and It's Comparison With the Stock Market

Mutual Fund Advantages

The benefits on offer are many with good post-tax returns and reasonable safety being the

hallmark that we normally associate with them. Some of the other major benefits of investing in

them are:

a) Number of available options: Mutual funds invest according to the underlying

investment objective as specified at the time of launching a scheme. So, we have equity

funds, debt funds, gilt funds and many others that cater to the different needs of the

investor. The availability of these options makes them a good option. While equity funds

can be as risky as the stock markets themselves, debt funds offer the kind of security that

Page 16

Page 17: Performance and Risk Analysis of Mutual Fund and It's Comparison With the Stock Market

aimed at the time of making investments. Money market funds offer the liquidity that

desired by big investors who wish to park surplus funds for very short-term periods.

b) Diversification: Investments spread across a wide cross-section of industries and

sectors and so the risk is reduced. Diversification reduces the risk because not all stocks

move in the same direction at the same time. One can achieve this diversification through

a Mutual Fund with far less money than one can on his own.

c) Professional Management: Mutual Funds employ the services of skilled

professionals who have years of experience to back them up. They use intensive research

techniques to analyze each investment option for the potential of returns along with their

risk levels to come up with the figures for performance that determine the suitability of

any potential investment.

d) Potential of Returns: Returns in the mutual funds are generally better than any

other option in any other avenue over a reasonable period. People can pick their

investment horizon and stay put in the chosen fund for the duration.

e) Get Focused: Investing in individual stocks can be fun because each company has

a unique story. However, it is important for people to focus on making money. Investing

is not a game. Your financial future depends on where you put you hard-earned dollars

and it should not take lightly.

f) Efficiency: By pooling investors' monies together, mutual fund companies can

take advantage of economies of scale. With large sums of money to invest, they often

trade commission-free and have personal contacts at the brokerage firms.

g) Ease of Use: Can you imagine keeping track of a portfolio consisting of hundreds

of stocks? The bookkeeping duties involved with stocks are much more complicated than

owning a mutual fund. If you are doing your own taxes, or are short on time, this can be a

Page 17

Page 18: Performance and Risk Analysis of Mutual Fund and It's Comparison With the Stock Market

big deal. Wealthy stock investors get special treatment from brokers and wealthy bank

account holders get special treatment from the banks, but mutual funds are non-

discriminatory. It doesn't matter whether you have Rs 1000 or Rs 10,00,000, you are

getting the exact same manager, the same account access and the same investment.

h) Risk: In general, mutual funds carry much lower risk than stocks. This is

primarily due to diversification (as mentioned above). Certain mutual funds can be riskier

than individual stocks, but you have to go out of your way to find them.

i) Transparent & well regulated: The Mutual Fund industry is well regulated both

by SEBI and AMFI. They have, over the years, introduced regulations, which ensure

smooth and transparent functioning of the mutual funds industry. This makes it safer and

convenient for investors to invest through the mutual funds.

j) Market timing becomes irrelevant: One of the biggest difficulties in equity

investing is WHEN to invest, apart from the other big question WHERE to invest. While,

investing in a mutual fund solves the issue of ‘where’ to invest, SIP helps us to overcome

the problem of ‘when’. SIP is a disciplined investing irrespective of the state of the

market. It thus makes the market timing totally irrelevant.

k) Does not strain our day-to-day finances: Mutual Funds allow us to invest very

small amounts (Rs 500 – Rs 1000) in SIP, as against larger one-time investment required,

if we were to buy directly from the market. This makes investing easier as it does not

strain our monthly finances. It, therefore, becomes an ideal investment option for a small-

time investor, who would otherwise not be able to enjoy the benefits of investing in the

equity market.

l) Reduces the average cost: In SIP fixed amount regularly is invested. Therefore,

you end up buying more number of units when the markets are down and NAV is low

Page 18

Page 19: Performance and Risk Analysis of Mutual Fund and It's Comparison With the Stock Market

and less number of units when the markets are up and the NAV is high. This is called

rupee-cost averaging. Generally, we would stay away from buying when the markets are

down. We generally tend to invest when the markets are rising. SIP works as a good

discipline as it forces us to buy even when the markets are low, which actually is the best

time to buy.

With stocks, one worry is that the company you are investing in goes bankrupt. With mutual

funds, that chance is next to nil. Since mutual funds, typically hold anywhere from 25-5000

companies, all of the companies that it holds would have to go bankrupt.

It cannot be argued on investing in individual stocks, but the advantages of using mutual funds

can help an investor earn good return with moderate risk.  

Drawbacks of Mutual Funds

Mutual funds have their drawbacks and may not be for everyone:

a) No Guarantees: No investment is risk free. If the entire stock market declines in value,

the value of mutual fund shares will go down as well, no matter how balanced the

portfolio.

b) Fees and commissions: All funds charge administrative fees to cover their day-to-day

expenses. Some funds also charge sales commissions or "loads" to compensate brokers,

financial consultants, or financial planners.

c) Taxes: During a typical year, most actively managed mutual funds sell anywhere from 20

to 70 percent of the securities in their portfolios.

d) Management risk: When you invest in a mutual fund, you depend on the fund's manager

to make the right decisions regarding the fund's portfolio.

Page 19

Page 20: Performance and Risk Analysis of Mutual Fund and It's Comparison With the Stock Market

3.3 TYPES OF RISK INVOLVED WITH MUTUAL FUNDSRisk is an inherent aspect of every form of investment. For mutual fund investments, risks would

include variability, or period-by-period fluctuations in total return.

Market Risk: At times, the prices or yields of all the securities in a particular market rises or

falls due to broad outside influences. When this happens, the stock prices of both an outstanding,

highly profitable company and a fledgling corporation may be affected. This change in price is

due to "market risk".

Inflation Risk: Sometimes referred to as "loss of purchasing power." Whenever the rate of

inflation exceeds the earnings on your investment, you run the risk that you'll actually be able to

buy less, not more.

Credit Risk: In short, how stable is the company or entity to which you lend your money when

you invest? How certain are you that it will be able to pay the interest you are promised, or repay

your principal when the investment matures?

Interest Rate Risk: Changing interest rates affect both equities and bonds in many ways. Bond

prices are influenced by movements in the interest rates in the financial system. Generally, when

interest rates rise, prices of the securities fall and when interest rates drop, the prices increase.

Investment Risks: In the sectoral fund schemes, investments will be predominantly in equities

of select companies in the particular sectors. Accordingly, the NAV of the schemes are linked to

the equity performance of such companies and may be more volatile than a more diversified

portfolio of equities.

Liquidity Risk: Thinly traded securities carry the danger of not being easily saleable at or near

their real values. The fund manager may therefore be unable to quickly sell an illiquid bond and

Page 20

Page 21: Performance and Risk Analysis of Mutual Fund and It's Comparison With the Stock Market

this might affect the price of the fund unfavorably. Liquidity risk is characteristic of the Indian

fixed income market.

Changes in the Government Policy: Changes in Government policy especially in regard to the

tax benefits may impact the business prospects of the companies leading to an impact on the

investments made by the fund.

Various Parameters to Measure Risk

1) BETA

A Beta is a measure of risk that when applied to investment portfolios, provides

useful statistical information. It indicates a fund’s past price volatility relative to a

particular stock market index.

High beta stocks react strongly to variations in the market, and low beta stocks are less

affected by market variations.

If Beta is 1, then an issue has the same volatility as the general market. It is either

growing at the same rate or declining at the same rate.

If Beta is greater than 1, then an issue is more volatile. At 1.25 it will probably

move 25% more than the market. If the market is in an up trend, then the security

will gain 25% more than the general market.

If Beta is less than 1, then an issue is less volatile. At 0.5 it probably will move

only 50% or a half of the market. If the market is In a downtrend, it will only lose

50% of what the general market loses.

If beta is less than 0, then the stock is moving in a reverse pattern to the index.

When the index moves up the stock declines and vice versa.

The formula for the Beta of an asset within a portfolio is

Page 21

Page 22: Performance and Risk Analysis of Mutual Fund and It's Comparison With the Stock Market

Where

ra measures the rate of return of an asset,

rp measures the rate of return of the portfolio of which the asset is a part

Cov(ra,rp) is the covariance between the rate of return.

2) STANDARD DEVIATION

It measures the risk of an asset from the mean/expected value of return. It represents

the square root of the average squared deviations of the individual returns from the

expected returns.

3) CORRELATION

It is a statistical measure of the degree to which security returns move together. In

order to diversify risk to have an efficient portfolio, i.e. maximum return for a given level

of risk or to minimize risk for a given level of return, the correlation between returns on

different securities is significant.

Positive correlation means that they move together,

Negative correlation suggests that they move in opposite direction

Zero correlation shows that they show no tendency to vary together in either

positive or negative.

4) SHARPE’S MEASURE

Sharpe’s measure evaluates the performance of the portfolio based on the total risk of

the portfolio, that is, standard deviation as a measure of risk. The Sharpe’s measure of

performance evaluation is given by:

Page 22

Page 23: Performance and Risk Analysis of Mutual Fund and It's Comparison With the Stock Market

S(x) = ( rx  -  Rf ) / StdDev(x)

Where,

x = some investment

rx = average annual rate of return of x

Rf = best available rate of return of a "risk-free" security (i.e. cash)

StdDev(x) = standard deviation of rx

5) TREYNOR’S MEASURE

Treynor’s measure relates the rate of return earned over and above the risk-free rate to

the portfolio beta during the time period under consideration.

Where

T = Treynor Ratio , = Portfolio Return , = Risk free return, = Portfolio Beta

6) SORTINO’S MEASURE

The Sortino ratio measures the risk-adjusted return of an investment asset, portfolio

or strategy. The Sortino ratio is a financial ratio, similar to the Sharpe ratio that measures

the risk-adjusted return of investments or portfolios. Unlike the Sharpe ratio, the Sortino

uses downside-volatility (sometimes referred to as semi-volatility) as the denominator

instead of standard deviation. The use of downside-volatility allows the Sortino ratio to

measure the return of "negative" volatility.

The ratio is calculated as

Where,

Page 23

Page 24: Performance and Risk Analysis of Mutual Fund and It's Comparison With the Stock Market

R = asset or portfolio realized return;

T = target or required rate of return for the investment strategy under consideration

DR = downside risk

7) P/E RATIO

The P/E ratio (price-to-earnings ratio) of a stock is a measure of the price paid for a

share relative to the annual income or profit earned by the firm per share.

The price per share (numerator) is the market price of a single share of the stock. The

earnings per share(denominator) is the net income of the company for the most recent 12

month period, divided by number of shares outstanding.

8) PORTFOLIO TURNOVER RATIO

The Portfolio Turnover ratio shows how actively a scheme has been managed in a

particular year. It is the aggregate value of purchases or sales of investments during the

year, expressed as a percentage of average weekly net assets.

9) EXPENSE RATIO

The Expense ratio helps to shed light on a fund’s efficiency and cost effectiveness. It

is the ratio of total recurring expenses to the average net assets.

10)DIVIDEND YIELD

The gross yield is a significant indicator of mutual fund investment characteristics.

11)TOTAL REURNS

The most common way to tell how well a fund performed is to check its total return,

which includes the impact of appreciation of its value and dividends, if any.

TR= Distributions + Change in NAV

Page 24

Page 25: Performance and Risk Analysis of Mutual Fund and It's Comparison With the Stock Market

NAV at the beginning of the period

(Graph taken from mutualfundsindia.com)

The risk return trade-off indicates that if investor is willing to take higher risk then

correspondingly he can expect higher returns and vise versa if he pertains to lower risk

instruments, which would be satisfied by lower returns. .

Thus investors choose mutual funds as their primary means of investing, as Mutual funds

provide professional management, diversification, convenience and liquidity. That doesn’t mean

mutual fund investments risk free. This is because the money that is pooled in are not invested

only in debts funds which are less riskier but are also invested in the stock markets which

involves a higher risk but can expect higher returns. Hedge fund involves a very high risk since it

is mostly traded in the derivatives market which is considered very volatile.

Page 25

Page 26: Performance and Risk Analysis of Mutual Fund and It's Comparison With the Stock Market

Relationship between Return and Risk:

(Figure taken from the website mutualfundsindia.com)

In the above graph it shows that as the standard deviation increases, the returns from the

particular type of fund increases.

3.4 MUTUAL FUND ANALYSIS

From the learning got from the fund houses as well as Mutual Fund distributors the selection

of funds is mainly based on the following criteria:

Funds Objective

Page 26

Page 27: Performance and Risk Analysis of Mutual Fund and It's Comparison With the Stock Market

Net Asset Value (NAV) Asset Under Management (AUM) Ratios

o Sharpe Ratio

o Standard Deviation

o Beta

o Alpha

o Treynor Ratio

o R-Squared

Returnso 1 Year

o 3 Year

o 5 Year

o Since Inception

o Fund Manager’s Performance.

Details of Mutual Funds and their constitution .

As on 31st march 2013 Ownership Foreign- Domestic - Sponsor

ABN AMRO Mutual Fund Private 75%, 25% ABN AMRO Asset

Management (Asia) Ltd.

Page 27

Page 28: Performance and Risk Analysis of Mutual Fund and It's Comparison With the Stock Market

Benchmark Mutual Fund Private 0%, 100% Niche Financial Services

Private Ltd

Birla Mutual Fund Foreign JV 50%, 50% Sun Life (India) AMC

Investments Inc., Birla

Global Finance Ltd

BOB Mutual Fund Public 0%, 100% Bank of Baroda

Canbank Mutual Fund Public 0%, 100% Canara Bank

DBS Chola Mutual Fund Private 37.48%, 62.52% Cholamandalam DBS

Finance Ltd.

Deutsche Mutual Fund Private 100%, 0% Deutsche Asset

Management (Asia) Limited

DSP Merrill Lynch Mutual Fund Foreign JV 40%, 60% DSP Merrill Lynch Ltd,

HMK Investment Pvt. Ltd.,

ADIKO Investment Pvt.

Ltd.

Escorts Mutual Fund Private 0%, 100% Escorts Finance Ltd

Fidelity Mutual Fund Private 100%, 0% Fidelity Internal Investment

Advisors

Franklin Foreign JV 75%, 25% Franklin Resources, Inc.

HDFC Mutual Fund Private 0%, 100% HDF Corporation Ltd

Page 28

Page 29: Performance and Risk Analysis of Mutual Fund and It's Comparison With the Stock Market

HSBC Mutual Fund Private -- 100% HSBC Securities and

Capital Markets (India)

Private Limited

ING Mutual Fund Foreign JV 85.68%, 14.32% National Nederlanden

Interfinance B.V (ING

Group),ING Vysya Bank

Ltd., Kirti Equities Pvt. Ltd.

(Mehta

JM Financial Mutual Fund Private 0%, 100% J.M Financial Consultancy

Services Private Ltd, J.M

Share & Stock Brokers Ltd.

Kotak Mutual Fund Private 0%, 100% Kotak Mahindra Finance

Ltd

LIC Mutual Fund Public 0%, 100% Life Insurance Corporation

of

      India

Morgan Stanley Mutual Fund Foreign JV 75%, 25% Morgan Stanley Dean Witter

& Company

Principal Mutual Fund Private 65%, 35% Principal Financial Services

Inc.

Prudential ICICI Mutual Fund Foreign JV 55%, 45% Prudential plc, ICICI Bank

Quantum Mutual Fund Private 0%, 100% Quantum Advisors Private

Limited

Reliance Mutual Fund Private 0%, 100% Reliance Capital Ltd

Page 29

Page 30: Performance and Risk Analysis of Mutual Fund and It's Comparison With the Stock Market

Sahara Mutual Fund Private 0% 100% Sahara Ind Fin. Corporation

Ltd

SBI Mutual Fund Public 37%, 63% SBI, Societe Generale AM

Stan Chartered MF Foreign JV 75%, 25% Standard Chartered Bank

Sundaram Mutual Fund Private 0%, 100% Sundaram Finance Ltd

Tata Mutual Fund Foreign JV 0%, 100% Tata InvestCorp Ltd, Tata

Sons Ltd

Taurus Mutual Fund Private 0%, 100% HB Portfolio Ltd

UTI Public 100% 0% UTI

UTI Mutual Fund Public 0%, 100% SBI, LIC, PNB, Bank of

Baroda

( Source: website mutualfundsindia.com)

(Source: website mutualfundsindia.com)

Recommendations regarding the fund selection depending upon the risk of the investor:

Debt Funds and bond funds are preferred in low risk, low return scenario: However, the bond funds faces interest rate risk .Income risk is the possibility that a fixed Income fund’s dividends will decline as a result of falling overall interest rates. There have been instances of investors locking in debt or income fund. They on seeing how returns pay up huge exit loads and get out of such schemes. Hence, it is very important that investors first measure their risk appetite. Once they understand their risk tolerance level they can choose the appropriate investment vehicle.

For those willing to take high risks, equity and sector funds are the picks: Sector funds limit their stock selection to the specific sectors and are not amply diversified. Since all the stocks are restricted to a particular sector like FMCG, pharma, or civil, if the sector takes a beating, the returns will be directly impacted. Equity Funds invest wholly in the stock markets. They have the same volatility as the investments in the stock market.

Balance Funds are a good alternative for those who seek something between high risk sector funds and low risk bond funds: balanced funds invest 80 to 90 percent of their money in equity instruments and generate decent returns. The

Page 30

Page 31: Performance and Risk Analysis of Mutual Fund and It's Comparison With the Stock Market

remaining money is locked in safe debt instruments. Investors should build a well diversified portfolio.

CHAPTER 4: Equity Market in Comparison with Mutual fund

Capital markets are the markets for the long term funds. It enhances capital formation, which

has a very significant role to play in the development of any economy.

Primary Market is a place where new offerings by Companies are made either as an

Initial Public Offering (IPO) or Rights Issue.

Secondary Market is a market where securities are traded after being initially offered to

the public in the Primary Market and/or listed on the Stock Exchange. Majority of trading

is done in this market which comprises of equity market and debt market. As the

secondary market is created for the securities raised in the primary markets, the depth of

the secondary market depends upon the primary markets.

India’s financial market began its transformation path in the early 1990s. The banking sector

witnessed sweeping changes, including the elimination of interest rate controls, reductions in

reserve and liquidity requirements and an overhaul in priority sector lending. Persistent efforts by

the Reserve Bank of India (RBI) to put in place effective supervision and prudential norms since

then have lifted the country closer to global standards.

Around the same time, India’s capital markets also began to stage extensive changes. The

Securities and Exchange Board of India (SEBI) was established in 1992 with a mandate to

protect investors and usher improvements into the microstructure of capital markets, while the

repeal of the Controller of Capital Issues (CCI) in the same year removed the administrative

controls over the pricing of new equity issues.

For over a century, India’s capital markets, which consist primarily of debt and equity

markets, have increasingly played a significant role in mobilizing funds to meet public and

Page 31

Page 32: Performance and Risk Analysis of Mutual Fund and It's Comparison With the Stock Market

private entities’ financing requirements. The advent of exchange-traded derivative instruments in

2000, such as options and futures, has enabled investors to better hedge their positions and

reduce risks. In total, India’s debt and equity markets were equivalent to 130% of GDP at the end

of 2005. This is an impressive stride, coming from just 75% in 1995, suggesting issuers’ growing

confidence in market based financing. However, the size of the country’s capital markets relative

to the United States’, Malaysia’s and South Korea’s remains low, implying a strong catch-up

process for India. India’s capital markets have experienced sweeping changes since the

beginning of the last decade. Its market infrastructure has advanced while corporate governance

has progressed faster than in many other emerging market economies. But still we can say there

is plenty of room for improvement and further reforms are needed to make India a world-class

financial centre.

4.1 EQUITY STOCK SELECTION APPROACHES

When the objective of the analysis is to determine what stock to buy and at what price, there

are two basic methodologies:

1. Fundamental Analysis

Fundamental Analysis is a technique that attempts to determine a security’s value by

focusing on underlying factors that affect a company's actual business and its future prospects.

As with most analysis, the goal is to derive a forecast and profit from future price movements.

To forecast future stock prices, fundamental analysis combines economic, industry, and company

analysis to derive a stock's current fair value and forecast future value. If fair value is not equal

to the current stock price, fundamental analysts believe that the stock is either over or under

valued and the market price will ultimately gravitate towards fair value.

2. Technical Analysis

Page 32

Page 33: Performance and Risk Analysis of Mutual Fund and It's Comparison With the Stock Market

Technical Analysis maintains that all information is reflected already in the stock price, so

fundamental analysis is a waste of time. Trends 'are your friend' and sentiment changes predate

and predict trend changes. Investors' emotional responses to price movements lead to

recognizable price chart patterns. Technical analysis does not care what the 'value' of a stock is.

Their price predictions are only extrapolations from historical price patterns.

In short, Fundamental Analysis tells us which stocks to buy, whereas the other Technical

Analysis gives us an indication as to when to buy the stocks. Investors use both these different

but somewhat complementary methods for stock picking. Many fundamental investors use

technical’s for deciding entry and exit points. Many technical investors use fundamentals to limit

their universe of possible stock to 'good' companies. In my project I have decided to limit my

study to only Fundamental Analysis.

Factors to be considered while selecting a Stock

The Selection of a stock is generally done from a three-dimensional perspective namely:

A. Qualitative Factors

The principal objective of qualitative analysis is to identify sustainable competitive

advantages of each company and to determine the level of confidence and conviction in

corporate management. The analysis includes evaluating both internal and external factors that

may have an impact on a company's ability to sell its product. It also involves having regular

open dialogue with management and regular conference calls to discuss recent developments.

The intent is to be long-term holders of the company one purchases. Strong belief in

management is required in order to maintain conviction during the short-term adversities that

virtually all companies experience.

Page 33

Page 34: Performance and Risk Analysis of Mutual Fund and It's Comparison With the Stock Market

The various qualitative factors to be considered are:

Industry

Industry is a grouping used to describe a company's main business activity. It is generally

determined by the major source of a company's income. A hot sector is a sector of the economy

experiencing a higher than regular growth rate. If companies across an industry show solid

earnings and revenue figures, that industry may be showing signs that it is in its growth phase.

Our goal is to select securities that area in a hot industry.

Scale of Opportunity: The trick lies in identifying Sectors which present huge scope of

opportunities. This involves finding sectors whose market cap are way beyond that of the total

industry.

For example when Mobile Telephony was in growing stage in India in 2004, Bharti Airtel

was trading at a market cap of $ US 1.5 billion against a total market size of US $ 100 billion.

Three years down the line and we can see the remarkable returns given by the stock.

Going forward we can estimate the case of the Indian Retail sector. The Indian Retail market

is presently worth US $ 300 billion and the collective market cap of the leaders in the listed

space was less than 1% in 2003 and is at a similar level currently. The total share of organized

retail has gone up from 2% in 2003 to 3% in 2006 and is estimated to hit 10% by 2010.

Company Market Capitalization

Pantaloon Retail US $ 1 billion

Titan US $ 756 million

Shopper Stop US $ 358 million

Trent US $ 263 million

Total market cap of listed Retail players US $ 2.37 billion

Total size of the Retail market US $ 300 billion

Percentage to the total Retail Market 0.79%

Page 34

Page 35: Performance and Risk Analysis of Mutual Fund and It's Comparison With the Stock Market

Industry Leader: The top two or three stocks in a strong industry group can have

incredible growth, while others in the group may barely move. One should buy the best

companies, the ones that lead their sectors and are number one in their particular field. The

number one market leader is not the biggest one. It is the one with the highest annual growth,

earning per share, and price relative strength. It’s a company that has competitive advantage over

its competitors. A company that is offering the best product

Management: Great management can make a difference between an average business and an

extraordinary one. Our goal as an investor is to find management teams that think like

shareholders; executives who treat the company as if they own a piece of it. One way to find out

about the management and how much they really care about share holders is to check the top

executive’s compensation plans.

Competitive Advantage: Generally, there are different ways that a company can create

sustainable competitive advantage:

1. Creating a real different product

2. Creating a strong brand

3. Keeping costs down

4. Locking in customers by creating high switching cost

5. Locking out competitors

Research and Development: One should consider the following questions in this respect

Page 35

Page 36: Performance and Risk Analysis of Mutual Fund and It's Comparison With the Stock Market

Does the Company have anything in the pipeline?

What are the Company’s technological capabilities?

Can the Company bring to market new products in a timely manner?

Shareholding Pattern: One should carefully analyze the Shareholding Pattern of the

Companies. If the institutional holding is very high on can say that the stock is fully researched

but at the same time its upside is also limited. One should also track Promoter holding to see

whether promoters involve in Insider Trading or not.

Analyst Coverage: Analysts issue their recommendations on individual companies. Analyst

coverage is useful to gauge market consensus on a stock price movement. A stock with no

analyst coverage could be a hidden value stock.

B. Quantitative Factors

These factors include analyzing the financial statements of a company through Ratio

Analysis. Ratio analysis includes calculating the various ratios and interpreting them in the

context of the company. The ratios help as to examine the critical parameters of a company like

Profitability, Liquidity, Valuation, Leverage and Price of the shares. The important ratios used

for the purpose of stock selection are:

Price-Book Value (P/BV) Enterprise Value (EV) EV/EBITDA Operating Profit Margin (OPM) Price/ Earnings Ratio (P/E) Beta Market Capitalization (MC) PEG Ratio Dividend payout ratio Dividend Yield ROCE ROE DEBT EQUITY

Page 36

Page 37: Performance and Risk Analysis of Mutual Fund and It's Comparison With the Stock Market

4.3 COMPARISON OF THE STOCK MARKET WITH MUTUAL FUND

It is a known fact that that mutual fund investments actually enter into the stock market. The

returns so particularly depend on the performance of the stock market. But then the question

arises whether mutual funds are actually capable of performing better than the stock market.

Comparison of stock market with mutual fund becomes an important issue and so here in this

section I have tried to compare few of the best mutual fund schemes with the stock market.

1) Comparison of S&p Bse 100 and UTI equity

Risk free return(assumed) 0.07

Covariance 0.004566

Variance 0.005645

Beta 0.83

Standard deviation 0.1562

Market Return 0.1025

Fund Return 0.1356

Expected Return using CAPM model 0.1203

Sharp ratio 0.24

Page 37

Page 38: Performance and Risk Analysis of Mutual Fund and It's Comparison With the Stock Market

Here, from the covariance and beta of BSE 100 and UTI Equity it’s pretty clear that gold

normally will provide return even if other market based assets do not.

ANALYSIS: After Covariance of this mutual fund with respect to the market is positive .

This tells that the movement of the NAV of this scheme depends on the movement of the market.

The covariance clears the point that the moves in the same direction and in parallel with the

stock market either upwards or downwards.

Beta of this particular scheme is very close to 1 which says that this fund has a average well

diversified portfolio. This means that the portfolio of this scheme is moderately aggressive. This

fund’s return moves in the same direction with respect to the market and with the same intensity

as the market.

If we look at the return of this fund it is clearly outperformed the market. The return of BSE

100 has for the period of 1st February 2013 to 7th March 2014 has been 10.25 %. The expected

return of this fund as per CAPM should have been 12.03%. But the funds performed and have

given an return of 13.56%.

The Sharpe ratio of the fund is 0.24 which is good. This means that for every single unit of

risk there is a probability of earning an extra return of 0.24 units.

2) NIFTY V/S ICICI Prudential Dynamic Fund

Risk free return(assumed) 0.07

Page 38

Page 39: Performance and Risk Analysis of Mutual Fund and It's Comparison With the Stock Market

Covariance 0.000391

Variance 0.000417

Beta 0.83

Standard deviation 0.1609

Market Return 0.1116

Fund Return 0.2006

Expected Return using CAPM model 0.1022

Sharp ratio 0.22

ANALYSIS : Covariance of this mutual fund with respect to the market is positive . This

tells that the movement of the NAV of this scheme depends on the movement of the market. The

covariance clears the point that the moves in the same direction and in parallel with the stock

market either upwards or downwards.

Beta of this particular scheme is very close to 1 which says that this fund has a average well

diversified portfolio. This means that the portfolio of this scheme is moderately aggressive. This

fund’s return moves in the same direction with respect to the market and with the same intensity

as the market.

If we look at the return of this fund it is clearly outperformed the market. The return of

NIFTY has for the period of 1st February 2013 to 7th March 2014 has been 11 %. The expected

return of this fund as per CAPM should have been 10.02%. But the funds outperformed and have

given an excellent return of 20.06%.

The Sharpe ratio of the fund is 0.22 which is good. This means that for every single unit of

risk there is a probability of earning an extra return of 0.22 units.

Page 39

Page 40: Performance and Risk Analysis of Mutual Fund and It's Comparison With the Stock Market

3) S&P BSE Sensex Vs Franklin India Bluechip

Covariance 0.000367

Market Variance 0.000523

Beta 0.86

ST. dev 0.1568

Risk free return(Assumed) 0.07

Market return 0.1246

Fund return 0.2237

Expected return using Capm Model 0.188546

Sharp ratio 2

ANALYSIS : Covariance of this mutual fund with respect to the market is positive . This

tells that the movement of the NAV of this scheme depends on the movement of the market. The

covariance clears the point that the moves in the same direction and in parallel with the stock

market either upwards or downwards.

Beta of this particular scheme is less than 1 which says that this fund has a below average

volatility. This means that the portfolio of this scheme is less aggressive. This fund’s return

moves in the same direction with respect to the market but not with the same intensity as the

market.

If we look at the return of this fund it is clearly outperformed the market. The return of BSE

Sensex has for the period of 1st February 2013 to 7th March 2014 has been 12.46 %. The

expected return of this fund as per CAPM should have been 18.85%. But the fund outperformed

and has given an excellent return of 22.37%.

Page 40

Page 41: Performance and Risk Analysis of Mutual Fund and It's Comparison With the Stock Market

The Sharpe ratio of the fund is high i.e. 2 which is excellent. This means that for every single

unit of risk there is a probability of earning an extra return of 2 units. Thus the risk return trade

off with this stock is satisfactory.

4) BSE 200 V/S SBI Magnum Comma Growth Fund

Covariance 0.000313

Variance 0.000523

Beta 0.90

Stdev 0.1892

Risk free Return( Assumed) 0.07

Market return 0.1008

Fund return 0.2012

Expected return using CAPM Model 0.1305

Sharpe ratio -0.72

ANALYSIS : Covariance of this mutual fund with respect to the market is positive . This

tells that the movement of the NAV of this scheme depends on the movement of the market. The

covariance clears the point that the moves in the same direction and in parallel with the stock

market either upwards or downwards.

Beta of this particular scheme is less than 1 which says that this fund has a below average

volatility. This means that the portfolio of this scheme is less aggressive. This fund’s return

moves in the same direction with respect to the market but not with the same intensity as the

market.

If we look at the return of this fund it is clearly outperformed the market. The return of

SENSEX has for the period of 1st February 2013 to 7th March 2014 has been 11 %. The expected

Page 41

Page 42: Performance and Risk Analysis of Mutual Fund and It's Comparison With the Stock Market

return of this fund as per CAPM should have been 13.05%. But the funds outperformed and have

given an excellent return of 20.12%.

The Sharpe ratio of the fund is high i.e. -0.72which is to be considered ok. This means that

for every single unit of risk there is a probability of earning an extra return of 0.72 units. Thus

the risk return trade off with this stock is satisfactory.

CHAPTER 5: Conclusion and Suggestions

From the above study it can be finally concluded that the mutual fund industry in India is

growing in India because to the brisk growth of the capital market. Most of the funds mobilized

by various AMCs are actually pumped into the capital market. The performance of mutual funds

actually depends in the performance of the stock market. We have seen in the recent past that the

the performance of the mutual fund have been impressive but the future growth will still depend

on the capital market behaves. Risk element always exists in mutual fund investment as they do

not guarantee any sure shot returns. But an investor can consider his risk being minimized as he

gets the expertise of fund managers and since the investments made by fund houses are in large

amounts the cost of investments also gets reduced. The top 10 % of the schemes that have

performed the best are mostly the equity diversified schemes. This explains the dependencies of

returns are on equities. There is no denying the fact that the returns have also gone down as and

when the stock markets have fell. Diversification of investments by AMCs has been the key of

their success in India.

5.2 FINDINGS

The key findings of the following study have been highlighted below:

Page 42

Page 43: Performance and Risk Analysis of Mutual Fund and It's Comparison With the Stock Market

1) Investments in equity diversified mutual funds are heavily depended on mutual and thus

the risk involved is very high.

2) The risk return trades off in mutual funds have been very satisfactory. Equity growth

schemes having high risk have generated a return in a range of 30% to 40%, whereas the

debt funds those have relatively low risk have given a moderate return of 6% to 8%.

3) Mutual Fund investments do not gurantee any fixed returns which might create fear in the

minds of risk free investors.

5.3 SUGGESTIONS

From the above study the following recommendations can be given to an investor.

1) For investors willing to take high risks, equity and sector funds are the picks: 2) Balance Funds are a good alternative for those who seek something between high risk

sector funds and low risk bond funds.3) Debt Funds and bond funds are preferred in low risk, low return scenario.4) Salaried persons earning a fixed salary can go for Systematic Investment Plan (SIP).5.4 LIMITATIONS OF THE STUDY

1) The time horizon is very short, so in depth analysis could be done only of few schemes.

2) The project is dependent on the relevance of the secondary data (eg, factsheets of various

schemes and investments vehicles of different companies) collected from the internet

which might not be correct.

3) The study has been done on only a handful of schemes so it cannot be generalized to the

entire industry.

4) The internal information about the creation of various asset classes and formation was not

revealed to the internees.

5.5 FURTHER SCOPE OF THE STUDY

Page 43

Page 44: Performance and Risk Analysis of Mutual Fund and It's Comparison With the Stock Market

There is lot of scope for improvement in the research for evaluating mutual fund

performances.

1) Various other multi-criteria decision models could be tested for evaluating mutual fund

performances.

2) Testing of fund performances in the long run can be done.

3) Extended sample of public-sector sponsored, private-sector Indian sponsored and

private-sector foreign sponsored mutual funds can be taken for generating results.

Portfolio risk through the measure of value at risk (VaR) can also be tested for

differences in mutual fund classes.

4) Mutual fund schemes used can be of varied class such as balanced fund , money market

fund , sectoral funds etc.

5) Hypothesis testing can also be done to predict the future performance of any scheme.

REFERENCES

1) Tripathy Nalini Prava “Mutual Funds in India. Emerging Issues” Vol – 1

( 2007) ,123-158

2) Riter,Jay,R1998, The buying and selling behavior of individual investors at the turn

of the year, journal of finance 43, 701-717.

3) Frazzini Andrea, “Dumb Money: Mutual Fund flows as the cross-section of stock

returns”, NCFM’s AMFI Material on mutual funds(workbook)

4) Nalini Prabha Tripathy , “Market Timing Abilities and Mutual Fund Performance-

An Empirical Investigation into Equity Linked Saving Schemes” (2006) XIMB

Journal of management ,Vilakshan, April 200 ,pp 6-8

5) Fact Sheets Of different AMCs.

Page 44

Page 45: Performance and Risk Analysis of Mutual Fund and It's Comparison With the Stock Market

BIBLIOGRAPHY

1) Jaidev M , “Investment policy and performance of Mutual Fund”

2) Sadak H. “Mutual Funds in India”

3) Pandey I.M , “Financial Management”

4) Damodaran Aswanth “Corporate Finance”

5) Tripathy Nalini Prava “Mutual Funds in India. Emerging Issues”

6) Panwar Sharad and Madhumathi R “Characterstics and Performance of selected

mutual funds in India.”

7) Frazzini Andrea, “Dumb Money: Mutual Fund flows as the cross-section of stock

returns”, NCFM’s AMFI Material on mutual funds(workbook)

8) Sankaran Sundar, “ Mutual fund Handbook ,A guide for distributors and

intelligent investors”

9) AMFI Module

10) Fund factsheet Of various Schemes

11) WEBSITES:

a. www.valueresearchonline.comb. www.moneycontrol.comc. www.amfiindia.comd. www.bseindia.come. www.indiainfoline.comf. www.myiris.comg. www.mutualfundindia.comh. www.nseindia.comi. www.capitaline.comj. www.capitalmarket.com

Page 45