Online discussion groups & forums in the classroom

Bianca Gray, Hannah Wilkinson & Michelle Harous

How can online discussion groups/forums be used effectively in the classroom?

Agenda Introduction Types of forums Advantages and disadvantages of forums MBED Facebook Forum Forums in schools Notion of virtual classrooms Role of the teacher Conclusion

Introduction

What is a online discussion/forum?

Discussion with peers Aids participation and deeper

learning – constructivist approach to learning

Top-down learning approach

Types of Forums

Available to everyone Do not need to sign up to the site in order to comment

on the forum http://

www.youth.gov.au/ayf/HaveASay/Pages/Default.aspx

Public Forums

Types of Forums

Only available to people who have signed up Can still be read by the general public, but in order to

access some threads and comment, you must be a member of the site

http://www.engquest.org.au/students-forum-up.cfm;jsessionid=ce30c3ab21cfa169de7e4b3d1f5e27c4a82e

Premium Forums

Types of Forums

You need to be invited to the forum in order to have access to it

Private forums cannot be found in forum directories “One Very Secret Forum” http

://www.facebook.com/home.php?sk=group_150779201653872

Private Forums

Types of Forums

Automatic messages are sent out every time someone adds something to the forum discussion, or creates a new thread.

These forums also give you the choice to change your settings so you no longer receive notice of movement within the forum.

Pushed Forums

Types of Forums

The only way to see if someone has added anything extra to this forum is to visit it

There is no option to change the settings to receive emails.

Because there is no need to sign up to write on a public forum, most public forums are optional forums, as are some premium forums.

Optional Forums

Threads within a forum

Threads are subtopics within a forum For example, if you were to set up a

forum for upper primary students for SOSE, the forum may have threads which discuss different topics within the subject, such as Australian history, rivers and lakes, geography etc.

AdvantageandDisadvantages

Advantages

Can be easily accessed by the internet Control over who has access Students use critical thinking as they

have time to reflect on discussion topics Students have time to research their input Everyone gets a chance to have their say Students can answer one another

questions Teachers can address the whole class and

the information is continuously accessible

Disadvantages Not everyone has continual access to the

internet and therefore the forum Some students can’t read and write adequately

to use an online forum Students may not be motivated to contribute to

the online forum Un monitored forums can lead to cyber bullying

or off track discussion Doesn’t encourage confidence for face to face

contact It may encourage students to use text talk

therefore effecting their writing skills.

MBED Facebook Forum

Advantages Easy access Premium forum, therefore it is accessible

to other uni students on facebook, but the admin can control who does and doesn’t have access

Quick response as most people log onto facebook at least once a day.

Very clear layout, with all information on one page.

MBED Facebook Forum

Disadvantages With so many people in the uni course, if

everyone adds one thing to the forum per day, you would get almost 150 emails notifying you that something has been added.

You MUST have Facebook to access the forum

At most schools, Facebook is blocked so it cannot be accessed, even for educational purposes.

Forums in Schools

Teachers can use forum sites such as Moodle to monitor their students understandings towards a certain topic.

Moodle could also be a great way for students to further explain the topic to one another, especially out of school hours where students may be working on assignments at home.

Forums could be threads which can be themed by subjects, such as English and SOSE, or by topic, WWI and Aboriginal Studies

Upper PrimaryAdvantages

Forums in Schools

Students are at school for around 6 hours a day, giving them plenty of time to discuss questions which may be raised around certain topics. There would only be limited things to discuss when they are home for the few hours before they go to sleep.

Upper PrimaryDisadvantages

Forums in Schools

Forums can be used as introductions to web-based learning by using simple topics that the children can relate to easily.

The teacher can post educational games which the children can play at home, and then discuss with their classmates, especially in long breaks such as school holidays, where they won’t be seeing their classmates every day.

Junior PrimaryAdvantages

Forums in Schools

Junior primary students are just learning how to read and write, therefore using an online forum would almost seem pointless, as many of them will struggle not only with writing their own posts, but with reading others and being able to reply to others. They are also very ego-centric in this age group, and will have difficulty seeing things from other points of view.

Junior PrimaryDisadvantages

Role of the Teacher

Set up the forum Teach the students how to use the

forum Teach the students about cyber safety Prompt discussion topics Motivate the students to contribute to

the forum Create forum rules Monitor the students discussion

Possible Forum Rules1. A post must be at least three sentences if its

going to be assessed and irrelevant posts or socialising do not count

2. Ask relevant question about the topic only.3. Respond constructively to what other students

are saying or asking, don’t rely on the teacher to answer all the questions.

4. Be helpful and friendly to each other to ensure cyber bullying doesn’t occur.

5. Remember you are on the internet and therefore should not mention any specific information about yourself of others.

Online Tutors

Online tutoring system http://www.homeworkhelp.com/

Activity – Visit this website What are the advantages/disadvantages of

this? Is this a good idea? What do you think?

Virtual Classrooms

Online classroom Discussion boards, forums, email, online assignments

Example of a virtual classroom: WizIQ http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=_Yty0cPzlcU&feature=rel

ated

The following website provides further information on how to set up a virtual classroom and the specific role of the teacher.

http://www.learnnc.org/lp/pages/665

Virtual Classrooms

Research has also investigated the notion of the virtual classroom and found that: Allow students to develop meaningful relationships There is a common purpose, interest, need and task. Shared policies and rules to guide interactions Sense of togetherness

(Ligorio & Van der Meijden, 2007)

How to create a forum http://docs.moodle.org/en/Adding/editing_

a_forum

Moodle Discussion

Do you feel that forums should be involved within a junior primary/primary

school setting? Why?

Conclusion

Forums can be used to support students during out of school hours

Provides them to ‘discuss’ school subjects with their peers in a non-confronting and comfortable environment

Although, we believe that forum use would be more successful in middle and upper primary classrooms.

References Australian Youth Forum. (n.d.). Department of Education,

Employment and Workplace Relations. Retrieved from http://www.youth.gov.au/ayf/HaveASay/Pages/Default.aspx

Comsoc Communities. (2011). IEEE Communications Society. Retrieved from http://community.comsoc.org/content/what-are-types-forums

Harris, N., & Sandor, M. (2007). School of Public Health http://www.ascilite.org.au/conferences/singapore07/procs/harris.pdf

Hobgood, B., (n.d.). Learn N C http://www.learnnc.org/lp/pages/665

Ligorio, M.B. & Van der Meikdent, H. (2007). Teacher guidelines for cross-national virtual communities in primary education. Journal of Computer Assisted Learning, 24 (1).

Ross, S. (n.d.). EngQuest. Retrieved from http://www.engquest.org.au/students-forum-up.cfm;jsessionid=ce30c3ab21cfa169de7e4b3d1f5e27c4a82e