Moeller Competitive Comp DILM Up to 170A

Schutzverm

erk ISO

16016 beachten04/18/23

Dateinam

e

Moeller GmbH / MD-PMM / EdelmannSeite - 1

Competitive comparison of contactor DILM up to 170A

Moeller GmbH / MD-PMM / EdelmannPage - 2

Observe protection m

ark to ISO

1601604/18/23

Dateinam

e

Usability of features argument for DILM up to 170A

Cage tension spring as connection method

for control current connections up to 150A

for main connections and control connections up to 12A

Same installation depth for

AC and DC actuated contactors

Double box terminal throughout

DC-actuated contactors 32A direct

controllable from PLC

Front control connections

Reliable connection of various

line cross-sections

Avoids costs for coupling relays/contactors Minimises planning

Faster wiring reduces assembly costs Maintenance-free High contact reliability even with vibrations

Same accessories for both types reduces type variety simpler planning

AC DC

SPS

DILM

Easier accessibility to the connections

ensures high rate of wiring safety



ark to ISO

1601604/18/23

Dateinam

e


Integrated protective circuit for

DC-actuated contactors

Very low standby power (DC)

Combined plug technique for contactors up to 15A

SmartWire control up to 32A

Contactors with integrated auxiliary switch up to 32A

DC

Reduces costs for protecting from voltage peaks Reduced assembly time

Minimises costs for switch-cabinet venting / - cooling Reduces costs because control transformer can be designed smaller

Faster and easier wiring when installing combination of contactor circuit and motor starter- saves assembly time

Reduces costs for additional auxiliary switches Reduces assembly time

Faster and safer wiring reduces assembly/test times Control and diagnostics of contactors and motor starter combination



ark to ISO

1601604/18/23

Dateinam

e


Wide control voltage range

(0.7…1.2 x Uc) for DC-actuated contactors

Extended voltage safety for

reliable contactor control in

unstable networks

DC



ark to ISO

1601604/18/23

Dateinam

e

Comparison 3RT10… and DILM

Mech. lifetime of smallest

size (30Mio.)

With lower frequency of switching and comparable elec. lifetime

Value only applies without auxiliary switch

Lower output power for DC-contactors up to 95A

With higher standby power

Actuation by PLC only ensured up to 25A

Lower DC standby power

Integrated protection circuitry for DC-actuated contactors

Normally, smaller or same installation depths

Higher AC-4 currents can be switched with same lifetime



ark to ISO

1601604/18/23

Dateinam

e

Comparison 3RT10… and DILM

From 115A Actuated by AS interface, Profibus DP and display of remaining lifetime

At cost of larger width and higher list price

Lower installation depths (AC)

At cost of higher width at which

most applications are critical Wide-frequency coils for AC- (40…60 Hz) or

DC- actuation for sizes from 115A

Higher list price

DILM is normally the cheaper contactors (AC and DC)



ark to ISO

1601604/18/23

Dateinam

e

Comparison of TeSys Model D and DILM

Up to 38A four connection possibilities (screw, spring-type, flat-cable and ring-cable ferrule connection)

Screw and spring-type connections sufficient for European market

2 auxiliary switches (NOC and NCC) in device up to 95A

After consultation with customers, one auxiliary switch is normally enough for most applications

Lower standby power for DC actuated contactors


Used at -25°C to 60°C

(at Schneider -5°C to 60°C)

Normally, smaller or same installation depths



ark to ISO

1601604/18/23

Dateinam

e


Additional contactor series with (GL) very low pull-in power and standby power

Only up to 38A

Only one auxiliary switch on front with 2 contacts can be used; no AS on side can be side

Auxiliary switches can be used for entire series

Additional washers required for AS from 40A

For DC, AS on side can only be used from 115A

DC-actuated contactor (DILM9, 12)

up to 50% lower list price

Higher AC-4 currents can be switched with same lifetime



ark to ISO

1601604/18/23

Dateinam

e


Lower installation depth for AC contactors

Higher installation depth DC contactors

installation width is critical in most applications; normally, this is lower for DILM

1000V from 40A switchable

High voltages only used at high powers; from DILM185, Moeller contactors also suitable for 1000V



ark to ISO

1601604/18/23

Dateinam

e

Comparison A9 to A185 and DILM


(for ABB only up to 37A (AL40))

Same or less installation widths

Lower pull-in power and standby power (AC and DC)

9 to 10 auxiliary switches can be installed on medium type series (37A to 110A)

9 to 10 auxiliary switches are irrelevant for most applications

1000V from 50A switchable

High voltages only used at high powers; from DILM185, Moeller contactors also suitable for 1000V



ark to ISO

1601604/18/23

Dateinam

e


Much better values for DC contactors from 50A

12 x higher mechanical switching frequency

½ pull-in power

double mech. lifetime

Electrical protection integrated throughput (for ABB only from 50A)

Wider working range of coil at 0.7…1,2x Uc

(for ABB 0.85…1.1x Uc)

Up to 37A (AL40) higher switching frequency (AC-3) and higher electrical lifetime

From 50A lower electrical lifetime

1.3 mio. switching cycles are sufficient for

machine lifetime Special series from 50 to 110A with very wide

actuation voltages for AC and DC

Higher list price

High radiation values (use in public low-voltage network requires additional measure)



ark to ISO

1601604/18/23

Dateinam

e


Use of -40°C to 70°C

Only without thermal overload relay

-25°C is suitable for use in switching-cabinet

At low working range of coil 0.85…1,1xUc | ≤55°C

1xUc | 55…70°C



ark to ISO

1601604/18/23

Dateinam

e

Comparison 100-C, 100-D and DILM


Lower values for pull-in power and standby power (AC & DC)


for Rockwell only from 60A

8 auxiliary switches can be installed throughout

From 95A 2, auxiliary switch in basic device

After consultation with customers, one auxiliary switch is normally enough for most applications

Up to 85A one accessory for all sizes



ark to ISO

1601604/18/23

Dateinam

e


Wider voltage range for DC contactors with 0.7…1.2 x Uc

for Rockwell 08/0.85…1.1 x Uc

Higher electrical lifetime for AC-3 applications

Lower installation depth up to 18.5 kW

Lower average prices

1000V from 95A switchable High voltages only used at high powers; from DILM185, Moeller contactors also suitable for 1000V



ark to ISO

1601604/18/23

Dateinam

e


Spring-type terminal and screw connection technology

Only screw connections for Rockwell


Simple box terminal or ring-cable ferrule connection for Rockwell



ark to ISO

1601604/18/23

Dateinam

e

Comparison CL00A to CK08 (GE/AEG) and DILM

From 22 kW AC/DC coils

Higher mech. lifetime (15… 20 mil.)

Higher elec. lifetime (1.5…2 Mil.)


The cheaper contactor

DC wide-range coils with

0.7…1.2 x Uc (at GE 0.8…1.1)



ark to ISO

1601604/18/23

Dateinam

e

Comparison CL00A to CK08 (GE/AEG) and DILM

From 22 kW actuated by AC/DC electronics

Due to low voltage tolerances, less reliability in unstable networks

Higher elec. lifetime (1.5…2 Mil.)

1,3 mio. switching cycles are sufficient for machine lifetime


Used at -25°C to 60°C

At GE -25…55°C


0.7…1.2 x Uc

At GE 0.8…1.1



ark to ISO

1601604/18/23

Dateinam

e

Comparison CWM9 to CWM180 (WEG) and DILM


For WEG, double box terminals for contactors for 32…105A



0.7…1.2 x Uc (for WEG 0.8…1.1)

1 auxiliary switch on side can be used for all sizes



ark to ISO

1601604/18/23

Dateinam

e

Comparison CWM9 to CWM180 (WEG) and DILM

Lower values for pull-in power and standby power for AC and DC actuated contactors




ark to ISO

1601604/18/23

Dateinam

e

Layout 1 DILM

Advantage of competitor

Counter-argument

Advantages of Moeller

Picture of competitor



ark to ISO

1601604/18/23

Dateinam

e

Layout 2 DILM


Counter-argument





ark to ISO

1601604/18/23

Dateinam

e

Layout 3 DILM


Counter-argument



Documents

Moeller Competitive Comp DILM Up to 170A