* דוח מקינזי על הגורמים להצלחתן של מערכות החינוך הטובות בעולם ד**ֶ ר ומונה מורש ֵ מייקל ברב ומשרדיה1926- חברת מקינזי היא חברה בינלאומית לייעוץ ניהולי. היא נוסדה ב* מדינות בעולם. הסקר שלהלן עורר הד עולמי גדול ונחשב למקיף ביותר43-ים ב פרוש בתחומו. מטרתו הייתה לגלות מה יש לעשות כדי לשפר את מערכת החינוך המדינתית. כמומחה למגזר הציבורי. לפני כן היה יועצו של2005- הצטרף לחברת מקינזי ב)Barber( ** סיר ופרופ' מייקל ברבר)Mourshed( ראש ממשלת בריטניה לשעבר טוני בלייר לענייני חינוך ומרצה לחינוך באוניברסיטת לונדון. ד"ר מונה מורשאד בחינוך ובכלכלה.MIT- היא מייסדת סניף מקינזי במזרח התיכון. היא בוגרת סטנפורד ובעל תואר שלישי מ

McKinsey Report - Published Hebrew Translation

  • Upload
    yanivf

  • View
    34

  • Download
    5

Embed Size (px)

DESCRIPTION

דוח מקינזי: על הגורמים להצלחתן של מערכות החינוך הטובות בעולם

Citation preview

  • *

    **

    * . -6291 -34 .

    . .

    ** ' (rebraB) -5002 . . " (dehsruoM)

    . -TIM .

  • " 2

    9392296-30 li.gro.uti.www

  • " 3

    . .

    . 52 . -: " ".

    , , : : ;

    : ;

    : .

    , , ; ; ; ; ; ;

    ( ). .

    .

    , , , : , . . , . , , , , . , ,

    .

    " " "

  • " 4

    ( , -2 ) , .

    . , . . 72 03

    -DCEO. , . .

    .

    52 , 01 . . : 1) ;

    2) ; 3)

    . .

    . 6002 7002.

    .

  • " 5

    , . . .

    . "" ( rof emmargorP tnemssessA tnedutS lanoitanretnI), , , .

    , , 52 , ,

    .

    , . 01 : , , , , , , , , , ; : , , , , , .

    . , (, , , ). .

    .

    - .

  • " 6

    , . ( , , ) . . 52 01

    .

    , 0891 -5002 ( ) -%37. : -%81

    5002 -. , , -, , , , " -

    . , . ,

    9, 31 -71 -5002 -0891. . -DCEO , . . 1 .

    . , , . " , , , , , , , , , ".2 , -6991 -05 , -8491 6991,

    .3 . , , (sloohcS retrahC

  • " 7

    [ytilibatnuocca] ). . ; . (PEAN) , .4 , " " ( ) " ,

    ".5 , ( ),

    . . : "

    ".6 , " . , , , . : -

    ".7 . . 211

    , 9 . 301 .8 , . , -DCEO " ".9 , : , ( ).

    .01

    . 01

    : ,

  • " 8

    8

    -05 .11 , -32 -51 -8 .21 94 .31 , .41

    . , . , -. . 7 . 11 41; %6 41 .

    , .

    , . "" (SSMIT ), . 7 4 5 , 51 , , 05 . -%52 -%47 -%34 -%77 , 6

    . : , . : ; ; 000,32

    051 . . , , - .

    :

    ( ).

    (

    ). (

    ). , . , , , . , , , , . .

    .

  • " 9

    , . , .

    . . . : " ".51 " , , ".61

    " " (hcaeT aciremA roF ) , , (

    ).71 : %5 , %01 , -%03 . ycnediseR rehcaeT swolleF gnihcaeT ,

    . .

    " ... [ ]... ".81 : "

    ".91

    , ( -) : , . ,

    .

    1 "

    "

  • " 01

    , - . : ( ), , . : .02 , . 001 .

    ; .

    . . . .

    , . : .

    . .

    . -04 . : , - ,

    .12 . , . . , -7002 , .22 , , , , .

    . , . .

    , ,

    . ''

    . " "

  • " 11

    . : ;

    . , . - , . 02 001 . 57 001 . , , .

    . , . : , . , ,

    .

    . . , . .32 . .

    . ,

    . . , . , (ycnediseR rehcaeT -rehcaeT swolleF). . , .

    . . . , . : '; -%5 . , , .

    , .

    ,

  • " 21

    , . , 053 . 61 . : . , 11 ( 5002 090,95 -542,5 ). , ,

    . , , .

    .

    : ( ) . . -. . .

    .

    : ,

    ( ). . , , .

    .

    :

    . ycnediseR rehcaeT -swolleF gnihcaeT , , .

    . , . .

    * %02 .** %02 .

    : yesnikcM ,tnemeveihcA cimedacA tnedutS erutuF no stceffE laudiseR dna evitalumuC sreviR & srednaS.

    001

    05

    0 11 8

    *

    **

    09

    35

    73

  • " 31

    , , . , , . .

    . . -6002 23 ,

    . , . , .

    . , , . , %01 ,

    .

    . ( ) () -DCEO, " . : %59 -%99 " ( -DCEO

    -%44 %691 " ). . ,

    . , , , : " ".42

    . . , . , , (%01) (%03); , , (%611 " ), .52 , , (, ")

    ', , : " ' ' 3 4 - .

    , , "

  • " 41

    . , ,62

    . .

    :

    :

    '. : -%62 " -DCEO. -DCEO

    .

    : , , , : , -72.DCEO

    -%81 . . ; , , . : ;

    . , . . 0991 -7991 -084,1 -600,2 , .82 -62 -81 , -51. ,

    -%18 -%07 1002. (, , , , )

    ().

    :

    ; . , ( ). 03 -1, -71 -1 -92;DCEO -DCEO ( , %06%08 ). .

    .

    , .

  • " 51

    -DCEO , . , , . ,

    .

    . .

    . -. , , . , . , , .

    . ,

    . :

    : , tsriF hcaeT () -aciremA roF hcaeT ( ) . , tsriF hcaeT -aciremA roF hcaeT : " tsriF hcaeT

    ".03

    : , . . ,

    . (ADT) , . . : , , . : tsriF hcaeT , -kcarT tsaF

    . 13

    . , , . 001

    .

    . : ; -, , ; ; .

    . , "" : , . ,

    .

  • " 61

    , .

    , -.

  • " 71

    , : . , , - . .

    . " [ ] , ... ".23 . . , , -03

    . " 9 -5 ".33 , , . . , :

    . , , : ( ) , .

    . " , ... , , . %5 -%08 ... ".43 ; . : " , , ... 001 ...

    , ?"53 .

    2 "

    "

  • " 81

    , " 8891 -8991 , , . -8991 -8891... 8991 .

    ".63 . -%52 -%47 , -%34 -%77. , 05 , .

    -%36 -%57.

    . , , . .

    , : . ,

    . .

    . .

    . ,

    . . ,

    . , . , , , .73 : " ".83 ( , , , ), :

    .

    , ,

    .

    : . . ycnediseR rehcaeT , , . . ,

    .

    : , , , . , . . .

    : , . , .

  • " 91

    , . %08

    .

    :

    . , , , , . , .

    .

    . ;

    .

    .

    . .93 . ', , : " ' ' 3 4

    . , , ".04

    . , ,

    .

    : . , (). 6 . 4 . . ", , , ".14 , -41

    .

    : " " (ADT). -ADT , 42 24 ( ) . ; -ADT .

    .

    . 211

    , 9

  • " 02

    "" , ,

    .

    : . , .

    .

    : , . -9891 . , " ".

    .

    . (gniniart ecivres-ni). , , , , .

    , .

    . . " " . .

    . ,

    .

    - " - ".34 -%79 "" "" "" ""; %8 " " "" "".44 , . "

    ".54 - . , - . - . ,

    :

    : - , . " "

    .

    -%52 -%47 , -%34

    -%77

  • " 12

    " ".64 , . ( ) ( ).

    .

    : , . " " -. 6 . , . .

    .

    : -, . -. (

    ). .

    : , . , - " ".74

    ( ), -

    .

    : , , ,

    : - 003 , (

    7002; ).

    ()

    : , .

    02 .

    ()

    : , ,

    .

    ()

    : -.

    , .

    1 01

    * . : dnalniF rof troper dnuorgkcaB :srehcaeT gniniateR dna gnipoleveD ,gnitcarttA; , .

    :

  • " 22

    , .84 . : " . . ... , , ...

    ".94

    . , , . . , .

    .

    : " ". , .

    . : " , . ,

    ".05

    : . . . . : .

    .

    : . .

    .

    , .

    : " , ( ). , ...

    ". . . .

    , .

  • " 32

    . . , . -, . ,

    .

    :

    . ; . "" , , .

    . . , , : " , , . ".15 . ,

    : , . , , .25 , . , -%5 004,21 , -%5 -007,5 . . ( ) .35 -

    . .

    3

  • " 42

    , . . . , . :

    .

    . ' . "" "" : " '', ".45 2991

    : " ".55 . , , '

    : " ".65 -0991; . , , : " , ".75 , ;

    . , ; , . . , : , , 7 73 -.85 "" -DCEO . . . , ,

    .

    - . , . , . , , , '' , . , (, , ). , , ( ,

    , ).

    :

    : , . . : " ,

    ".95

  • " 52

    -: . , . -

    .

    , . , " ".06 , . , .

    . (

    ). ,

    , . , ,

    .

    : . , , , .

    .

    34 : , 34 . , . , , -5002, . , ,

    .

    : ; -5 . ; ,

    . . ,

    :

    : , ( ) , . : "[] ; ".16 , ,

    ,

    , .

  • " 62

    . " , , ".26 , , : " ; [ , , ]".36 . -

    .

    : , , . .

    : -5.1 .

    -: - . , , . , , , () - . %5 ,

    . , . . , ,

    . . 01 . ,

    .

    , . . , 3 001,1 711. , 525 , 46.97 - .

    .

    .

    . ,

  • " 72

    . 6 7 . 4 5 . 7 -41 -DCEO. , 51 , , -DCEO,

    . ( -%01 , ) ( , ). . . . . . -%03 . ,

    . , , .

    .

    . . . , , . '' . " "

    .

    . . . ,

    .

    : , 03

    . - .

    .

    : .

    , : .

    .

    , : .

    .

    1 6

    : : ().

    :

  • " 82

    . ( ; ).

    ( ) . : ; ; . .

    . , , , . ,

    . . , -. " ".56 . .

    , . , ,

    . . , , . ; .

    . ;

    :

  • " 92

    . , , , . , , : 1) ; 2) ; 3)

    .

    anoM & rebraB leahciM :ynapmoC & yesniKcM

    loohcS gnimrofreP-tseB s'dlrow eht woH ,dehsruoM

    .7002 ,rebmetpeS ,poT no tuO emoC smetsyS

    :

    . ?

    . ?

    : , ? .

    01 . ?

    ?

    - .

    02 . ?

    %01 . ?

    ?

    , - .

    -?

    , .

    , - . ?

    . - ?

    ?

    -05 , .

    , , ?

    .

    . ?

    ; -? .

    . ?

    :

  • 30 "

    Pritchett, Educational Quality and Costs: A Big 1Puzzle and Five Possible Pieces )2004(

    Barber, Journeys of Discovery )2005( 2 National Foundation for Education Research, 3

    Trends in Standards of Literacy and Numeracyin the United Kingdom )1997(

    NAEP, America's Charter Schools: Results from 4the NAEP Pilot Study )2003(

    Business Week, Bill Gates Gets Schooled 5)2006(

    .2006 , : 6 Cross City Campaign, A Delicate Balance: 7

    District policies and Classroom Practice )2005( Hanushek, The Evidence on Class Size )2003(. 8

    Shapson, An experimental study on the effects of class size. Akerhielm, Does class size

    ?matter . 9

    10 23-

    15- . 0.2

    Sanders & Rivers, Cumulative and Residual 11 Effects of Teachers on Future Student

    Academic Achievement )1996( Scientific American, Does Class Size Matter 12

    )2001( Teacher Effects on Student Achievement 13

    )1997( Kati Haycock, Achievement in America: Can we 14

    close the gaps )2006( .2007 , : 15

    NCTQ, Increasing the Odds: How good policies 16 can yield better teachers

    Decker, Mayer, Glazerman, The Effects of 17 Teach for America: Findings from a National

    Evaluation )2004( .NCEE, Tough Choices or Tough Times )2007( 18

    ," " [ .2007( ,

    : 19.2006 ,GCC((

    Training and Development Agency for Schools 20 )11 August 2005(

    Allington, Johnston, What do we know about 21 effective fourth grade teachers and their

    , ..classrooms )2000( .

    2007 22 .

    23 .

    . .2007 , : 24

    OECD, Attracting Developing and Retaining 25 Effective teachers, )from Dolton, Wolter,

    Denzler( p. 70 26

    , " 141%- ( " 389% ," 159%- 95% ,OECD-

    .( )2003( 27

    : 46% ; 45% ; 18% ( 47%- ;

    .( : .70% , ,OECD-

    OECD, Education at a Glance 2005

    Attracting Developing and Retaining Teachers: 28Country Report for the Netherlands, pp. 36-37

    OECD, Education at a Glance 2005(( 2003 29 IPSE, An evaluation of innovative approaches 30

    to teacher training on the Teach FirstProgramme )2006(

    Teach First 31 ,

    . .

    47%- .

    Barber, Journeys of Discovery )2005( 32Fullan, Hill, Crevola, Breakthrough )2006( 33

    .2007 , : 34 .2007 , : 35

    Barber, Journeys of Discovery )2005( 36 Harvey-Beavis, Performance Based Rewards 37

    for Teachers )2003(. CTAC, Catalyst for Change:Pay for Performance in Denver )2001(

    Elmore, School Reform from the Inside Out 38)2004(

    Chaney, Student outcomes and the 39 professional preparation of 8th grade

    teachers, Goldhaber and Brewer, Does?certification matter

    McBeath, Getting Districtwide Results )2006( 40 .2007 , : 41

    Barber, Journeys of Discovery )2005( 42 NCSL, Seven Strong Claims about Successful 43

    School Leadership )2006(Ofsted, School Inspection Data )2005/2006( 44

    National Audit Office, Improving Failing 45Schools )2006(

    NCSL, Seven Strong Claims about Successful 46School Leadership )2006(

    NCSL, Seven Strong Claims about Successful 47School Leadership )2006(

    DfES, Independent Study into School 48Leadership )2007(

    .2007 , : 49 Chenoweth, from Lewis, Does Lesson Study 50

    have a future in the United States )2002( .2007 , , 51

    RAND, The Economics of Investing in Universal 52Preschool Education in California )2005(

    Kati Haycock, Achievement in America: Can we 53close the gaps )2006(

    .2007 , : 54 .2007 , : 55

    .2007 , : 56 .2007 , : 57

    Currie, Thomas, Early Test Scores, 58 Socioeconomic Status and Future Outcomes

    )1998( .2006 : 59

    .2006 , : 60 . 61

    . , 62.2007 , : 63

    Hart and Risley, from New York Times "What it 64takes to Make a Student" )26 November 2006( NCSL, Seven Strong Claims about Successful 65

    School Leadership )2006(

  • " 13

  • :