13
I want a Boy’: the I want a Boy’: the preconception folklore preconception folklore By Langhit Kurar (March, 2011)

Maternal preconception and gender selection

Embed Size (px)

Citation preview

Page 1: Maternal preconception and gender selection

lsquolsquoI want a Boyrsquo the I want a Boyrsquo the preconception folklore preconception folklore

By Langhit Kurar (March 2011)

OUTLINEOUTLINE

Urban myths and preconceptionsDisadvantage and Diversity

- Religious and cultural implicationShettlesrsquo (theory)Evidence-based medicine

- lsquoYour child is what you eatrsquo- lsquoBe the bossrsquo

Urban Myths and Urban Myths and Preconceptions Preconceptions

ETC

MYTH BOY GIRLlsquoYour child is

what you eatrsquo - India

red meat salty food

soya

sweets fish vegetables

lsquoJoy of sexrsquo sleep on LHS love standing

up

missionary position woman orgasms

firstlsquoIts all in the

timingrsquo- China

womans head facing

north quarter

moon odd days

full moon even days

lsquoKeeping coolrsquo- India

high stress warmed testicles

relaxed cooled

testicleslsquoBe the bossrsquo

- Africa male-

dominated relationship

female-dominated relationship

lsquoHairstylersquo straight across

duck-tailed

Religious and Cultural Religious and Cultural ImplicationImplication

Sex selection big business In India abortion of girls on the rise Common amongst wealthy-access to USS 103 (BG) in some states (NBS)(1)

Land inheritance lsquodowryrsquo customs common themes

Illegal to disclose sex of unborn or abort based on gender-practice on increase

lsquoPay Rs 5000 today and save Rs 5 lakhs tomorrowrsquo

-Advertisement

Religious and Cultural Religious and Cultural ImplicationImplication

Missing women of China One-child policy (1979) correlates with gender-based birth rate

disparity 30 million more men than women (2020) predicted (NBS) Underreporting female live births diseases affecting female mortality

illegal sex-related abortion infanticide and child abandonment(2)

Shettlesrsquo (Theory)Shettlesrsquo (Theory)

First reputed child conception idea to determine babyrsquos sex

lsquoHow to Choose the Sex of Your Babyrsquo- publ1970 claims gt75 effectiveness (3)

Basic Concept (timing of intercourse) raquo X-bearing Sperm- Slower and larger than their Y-bearing counterparts- More resilient longer-lived

raquo Y-bearing Sperm- Faster and smaller than their X-bearing counterparts- More fragile short-lived

lsquolsquoYour child is what you eatrsquoYour child is what you eatrsquo

244 female mice fed high saturated fat content produced 60 male offspring vs 274 controls producing 48 male offspring (Plt00001)(5)+(6)

Trivers-Willard hypothesis (1973) (4) raquo Triversrsquo trivial assumptions1)Parental condition associated with offspring condition2)Differences in offspring condition will persist into adulthood3)Being in condition affects mating success of one sex more than the other

lsquoGood conditionrsquo hypothesis or lsquoAdaptiversquo theory

lsquolsquoBe the bossrsquoBe the bossrsquo

Maternal dominance hypothesis (1996) (7) Maternal dominance

serum testosteronechance of male fetus

lsquolsquoBe the bossrsquoBe the bossrsquo Faecal testosterone is elevated in

high-ranking female ibexes (lt005) and associated with more male offspring vs subordinate females (8M vs 5M)(8)

Ova development in follicular fluid high in testosterone is more likely to be fertilised by Y-chromosome-bearing spermatozoa(9)

Recent trial (2010) reported median testosterone levels higher in follicles that resulted in male embryos (3212 ngml) than female embryos (2398 ngml)(10)

Study

N (embryos)

Follicular testosteroneminndashmax (nM)

Median follicular testosteroneof subsequent embryos (nM)

Significance (P)

Male Female(9) 171 11-977 12260 9075 0032(10) 140 13ndash893 11136 8313 006

(11)

Conclusion Conclusion Controversial DebateSocial implications Little scientific evidenceShettles Theory Maternal Condition and

Dominance

REFERENCESREFERENCES1) Current status of abortion in India Consortium on National Consensus for Medical Abortion in India

httpwwwaiimsacinaiimseventsGynaewebsitema_finalsitereport1_1_1htm Retrieved 20111703 2) Johansson S Nygren O (1991) The missing girls of China a new demographic account Population and

Development Review (Population Council) 17 (1) 35ndash51 3) ldquoThe Shettles Method of Sex Selectionrdquo Robin Elise Weiss LCCE Aboutcom Guide

httppregnancyaboutcomodgenderselectionashettlesmethodhtm Retrieved 20111703 4) Trivers RLWillard D (1973) ldquoNatural selection of parental ability to vary the sex ratio of offspringrdquo Science

179 90ndash925) Alexenko APMao J Ellersieck MRDavis AMWhyte JJ (2007) ldquoThe contrasting effects of ad libitum and

restricted feeding of a diet very high in saturated fats on sex ratio and metabolic hormones in micerdquo Biology of Reproduction 77599ndash604

6) Cameron EZLemons PRBateman PWBennett NC (2008) ldquoExperimental alteration of litter sex ratios in a mammalrdquo Proc Royal Soc of London Series B 275 323ndash327

7) Grant VJIrwin RJ (2005) ldquoFollicular fluid steroid levels and subsequent sex of bovine embryosrdquo Journ of Experimental Zoology 303A1120ndash1125

8) Shargal DShore LRoteri NTerkel AZorovsky YShemesh MSteinberger Y (2008) ldquoFecal testosterone is elevated in high ranking female ibexes (Capra nubiana) and associated with increased aggression and a preponderance of male offspringrdquo Theriogenology 69 673ndash680

9) Grant VJIrwin RJStandley NTShelling ANChamley LW (2008) ldquoSex of bovine embryos may be related to mothersrsquo preovulatory follicular testosteronerdquo Biol of Reproduction 78 812ndash815

10) Garcia-Herreros MBermejo-Alvarez PRizos DGutierrez-Adan AFahey AGLonergan P (2010) ldquoIntrafollicular testosterone concentration and sex ratio in individually cultured bovine embryosrdquo Reproduction Fertility and Development 22 533ndash538

11) Dama MS Singh NM Rajender S (2011) ldquoHigh Fat Diet Prevents Over-Crowding Induced Decrease of Sex Ratio in Micerdquo PLoS ONE 6(1) e16296

ANY QUESTIONS ANY QUESTIONS

  • lsquoI want a Boyrsquo the preconception folklore
  • Outline
  • Urban Myths and Preconceptions
  • Religious and Cultural Implication
  • Slide 5
  • Shettlesrsquo (Theory)
  • lsquoYour child is what you eatrsquo
  • lsquoBe the bossrsquo
  • Slide 9
  • Slide 10
  • Conclusion
  • References
  • ANY Questions
Page 2: Maternal preconception and gender selection

OUTLINEOUTLINE

Urban myths and preconceptionsDisadvantage and Diversity

- Religious and cultural implicationShettlesrsquo (theory)Evidence-based medicine

- lsquoYour child is what you eatrsquo- lsquoBe the bossrsquo

Urban Myths and Urban Myths and Preconceptions Preconceptions

ETC

MYTH BOY GIRLlsquoYour child is

what you eatrsquo - India

red meat salty food

soya

sweets fish vegetables

lsquoJoy of sexrsquo sleep on LHS love standing

up

missionary position woman orgasms

firstlsquoIts all in the

timingrsquo- China

womans head facing

north quarter

moon odd days

full moon even days

lsquoKeeping coolrsquo- India

high stress warmed testicles

relaxed cooled

testicleslsquoBe the bossrsquo

- Africa male-

dominated relationship

female-dominated relationship

lsquoHairstylersquo straight across

duck-tailed

Religious and Cultural Religious and Cultural ImplicationImplication

Sex selection big business In India abortion of girls on the rise Common amongst wealthy-access to USS 103 (BG) in some states (NBS)(1)

Land inheritance lsquodowryrsquo customs common themes

Illegal to disclose sex of unborn or abort based on gender-practice on increase

lsquoPay Rs 5000 today and save Rs 5 lakhs tomorrowrsquo

-Advertisement

Religious and Cultural Religious and Cultural ImplicationImplication

Missing women of China One-child policy (1979) correlates with gender-based birth rate

disparity 30 million more men than women (2020) predicted (NBS) Underreporting female live births diseases affecting female mortality

illegal sex-related abortion infanticide and child abandonment(2)

Shettlesrsquo (Theory)Shettlesrsquo (Theory)

First reputed child conception idea to determine babyrsquos sex

lsquoHow to Choose the Sex of Your Babyrsquo- publ1970 claims gt75 effectiveness (3)

Basic Concept (timing of intercourse) raquo X-bearing Sperm- Slower and larger than their Y-bearing counterparts- More resilient longer-lived

raquo Y-bearing Sperm- Faster and smaller than their X-bearing counterparts- More fragile short-lived

lsquolsquoYour child is what you eatrsquoYour child is what you eatrsquo

244 female mice fed high saturated fat content produced 60 male offspring vs 274 controls producing 48 male offspring (Plt00001)(5)+(6)

Trivers-Willard hypothesis (1973) (4) raquo Triversrsquo trivial assumptions1)Parental condition associated with offspring condition2)Differences in offspring condition will persist into adulthood3)Being in condition affects mating success of one sex more than the other

lsquoGood conditionrsquo hypothesis or lsquoAdaptiversquo theory

lsquolsquoBe the bossrsquoBe the bossrsquo

Maternal dominance hypothesis (1996) (7) Maternal dominance

serum testosteronechance of male fetus

lsquolsquoBe the bossrsquoBe the bossrsquo Faecal testosterone is elevated in

high-ranking female ibexes (lt005) and associated with more male offspring vs subordinate females (8M vs 5M)(8)

Ova development in follicular fluid high in testosterone is more likely to be fertilised by Y-chromosome-bearing spermatozoa(9)

Recent trial (2010) reported median testosterone levels higher in follicles that resulted in male embryos (3212 ngml) than female embryos (2398 ngml)(10)

Study

N (embryos)

Follicular testosteroneminndashmax (nM)

Median follicular testosteroneof subsequent embryos (nM)

Significance (P)

Male Female(9) 171 11-977 12260 9075 0032(10) 140 13ndash893 11136 8313 006

(11)

Conclusion Conclusion Controversial DebateSocial implications Little scientific evidenceShettles Theory Maternal Condition and

Dominance

REFERENCESREFERENCES1) Current status of abortion in India Consortium on National Consensus for Medical Abortion in India

httpwwwaiimsacinaiimseventsGynaewebsitema_finalsitereport1_1_1htm Retrieved 20111703 2) Johansson S Nygren O (1991) The missing girls of China a new demographic account Population and

Development Review (Population Council) 17 (1) 35ndash51 3) ldquoThe Shettles Method of Sex Selectionrdquo Robin Elise Weiss LCCE Aboutcom Guide

httppregnancyaboutcomodgenderselectionashettlesmethodhtm Retrieved 20111703 4) Trivers RLWillard D (1973) ldquoNatural selection of parental ability to vary the sex ratio of offspringrdquo Science

179 90ndash925) Alexenko APMao J Ellersieck MRDavis AMWhyte JJ (2007) ldquoThe contrasting effects of ad libitum and

restricted feeding of a diet very high in saturated fats on sex ratio and metabolic hormones in micerdquo Biology of Reproduction 77599ndash604

6) Cameron EZLemons PRBateman PWBennett NC (2008) ldquoExperimental alteration of litter sex ratios in a mammalrdquo Proc Royal Soc of London Series B 275 323ndash327

7) Grant VJIrwin RJ (2005) ldquoFollicular fluid steroid levels and subsequent sex of bovine embryosrdquo Journ of Experimental Zoology 303A1120ndash1125

8) Shargal DShore LRoteri NTerkel AZorovsky YShemesh MSteinberger Y (2008) ldquoFecal testosterone is elevated in high ranking female ibexes (Capra nubiana) and associated with increased aggression and a preponderance of male offspringrdquo Theriogenology 69 673ndash680

9) Grant VJIrwin RJStandley NTShelling ANChamley LW (2008) ldquoSex of bovine embryos may be related to mothersrsquo preovulatory follicular testosteronerdquo Biol of Reproduction 78 812ndash815

10) Garcia-Herreros MBermejo-Alvarez PRizos DGutierrez-Adan AFahey AGLonergan P (2010) ldquoIntrafollicular testosterone concentration and sex ratio in individually cultured bovine embryosrdquo Reproduction Fertility and Development 22 533ndash538

11) Dama MS Singh NM Rajender S (2011) ldquoHigh Fat Diet Prevents Over-Crowding Induced Decrease of Sex Ratio in Micerdquo PLoS ONE 6(1) e16296

ANY QUESTIONS ANY QUESTIONS

  • lsquoI want a Boyrsquo the preconception folklore
  • Outline
  • Urban Myths and Preconceptions
  • Religious and Cultural Implication
  • Slide 5
  • Shettlesrsquo (Theory)
  • lsquoYour child is what you eatrsquo
  • lsquoBe the bossrsquo
  • Slide 9
  • Slide 10
  • Conclusion
  • References
  • ANY Questions
Page 3: Maternal preconception and gender selection

Urban Myths and Urban Myths and Preconceptions Preconceptions

ETC

MYTH BOY GIRLlsquoYour child is

what you eatrsquo - India

red meat salty food

soya

sweets fish vegetables

lsquoJoy of sexrsquo sleep on LHS love standing

up

missionary position woman orgasms

firstlsquoIts all in the

timingrsquo- China

womans head facing

north quarter

moon odd days

full moon even days

lsquoKeeping coolrsquo- India

high stress warmed testicles

relaxed cooled

testicleslsquoBe the bossrsquo

- Africa male-

dominated relationship

female-dominated relationship

lsquoHairstylersquo straight across

duck-tailed

Religious and Cultural Religious and Cultural ImplicationImplication

Sex selection big business In India abortion of girls on the rise Common amongst wealthy-access to USS 103 (BG) in some states (NBS)(1)

Land inheritance lsquodowryrsquo customs common themes

Illegal to disclose sex of unborn or abort based on gender-practice on increase

lsquoPay Rs 5000 today and save Rs 5 lakhs tomorrowrsquo

-Advertisement

Religious and Cultural Religious and Cultural ImplicationImplication

Missing women of China One-child policy (1979) correlates with gender-based birth rate

disparity 30 million more men than women (2020) predicted (NBS) Underreporting female live births diseases affecting female mortality

illegal sex-related abortion infanticide and child abandonment(2)

Shettlesrsquo (Theory)Shettlesrsquo (Theory)

First reputed child conception idea to determine babyrsquos sex

lsquoHow to Choose the Sex of Your Babyrsquo- publ1970 claims gt75 effectiveness (3)

Basic Concept (timing of intercourse) raquo X-bearing Sperm- Slower and larger than their Y-bearing counterparts- More resilient longer-lived

raquo Y-bearing Sperm- Faster and smaller than their X-bearing counterparts- More fragile short-lived

lsquolsquoYour child is what you eatrsquoYour child is what you eatrsquo

244 female mice fed high saturated fat content produced 60 male offspring vs 274 controls producing 48 male offspring (Plt00001)(5)+(6)

Trivers-Willard hypothesis (1973) (4) raquo Triversrsquo trivial assumptions1)Parental condition associated with offspring condition2)Differences in offspring condition will persist into adulthood3)Being in condition affects mating success of one sex more than the other

lsquoGood conditionrsquo hypothesis or lsquoAdaptiversquo theory

lsquolsquoBe the bossrsquoBe the bossrsquo

Maternal dominance hypothesis (1996) (7) Maternal dominance

serum testosteronechance of male fetus

lsquolsquoBe the bossrsquoBe the bossrsquo Faecal testosterone is elevated in

high-ranking female ibexes (lt005) and associated with more male offspring vs subordinate females (8M vs 5M)(8)

Ova development in follicular fluid high in testosterone is more likely to be fertilised by Y-chromosome-bearing spermatozoa(9)

Recent trial (2010) reported median testosterone levels higher in follicles that resulted in male embryos (3212 ngml) than female embryos (2398 ngml)(10)

Study

N (embryos)

Follicular testosteroneminndashmax (nM)

Median follicular testosteroneof subsequent embryos (nM)

Significance (P)

Male Female(9) 171 11-977 12260 9075 0032(10) 140 13ndash893 11136 8313 006

(11)

Conclusion Conclusion Controversial DebateSocial implications Little scientific evidenceShettles Theory Maternal Condition and

Dominance

REFERENCESREFERENCES1) Current status of abortion in India Consortium on National Consensus for Medical Abortion in India

httpwwwaiimsacinaiimseventsGynaewebsitema_finalsitereport1_1_1htm Retrieved 20111703 2) Johansson S Nygren O (1991) The missing girls of China a new demographic account Population and

Development Review (Population Council) 17 (1) 35ndash51 3) ldquoThe Shettles Method of Sex Selectionrdquo Robin Elise Weiss LCCE Aboutcom Guide

httppregnancyaboutcomodgenderselectionashettlesmethodhtm Retrieved 20111703 4) Trivers RLWillard D (1973) ldquoNatural selection of parental ability to vary the sex ratio of offspringrdquo Science

179 90ndash925) Alexenko APMao J Ellersieck MRDavis AMWhyte JJ (2007) ldquoThe contrasting effects of ad libitum and

restricted feeding of a diet very high in saturated fats on sex ratio and metabolic hormones in micerdquo Biology of Reproduction 77599ndash604

6) Cameron EZLemons PRBateman PWBennett NC (2008) ldquoExperimental alteration of litter sex ratios in a mammalrdquo Proc Royal Soc of London Series B 275 323ndash327

7) Grant VJIrwin RJ (2005) ldquoFollicular fluid steroid levels and subsequent sex of bovine embryosrdquo Journ of Experimental Zoology 303A1120ndash1125

8) Shargal DShore LRoteri NTerkel AZorovsky YShemesh MSteinberger Y (2008) ldquoFecal testosterone is elevated in high ranking female ibexes (Capra nubiana) and associated with increased aggression and a preponderance of male offspringrdquo Theriogenology 69 673ndash680

9) Grant VJIrwin RJStandley NTShelling ANChamley LW (2008) ldquoSex of bovine embryos may be related to mothersrsquo preovulatory follicular testosteronerdquo Biol of Reproduction 78 812ndash815

10) Garcia-Herreros MBermejo-Alvarez PRizos DGutierrez-Adan AFahey AGLonergan P (2010) ldquoIntrafollicular testosterone concentration and sex ratio in individually cultured bovine embryosrdquo Reproduction Fertility and Development 22 533ndash538

11) Dama MS Singh NM Rajender S (2011) ldquoHigh Fat Diet Prevents Over-Crowding Induced Decrease of Sex Ratio in Micerdquo PLoS ONE 6(1) e16296

ANY QUESTIONS ANY QUESTIONS

  • lsquoI want a Boyrsquo the preconception folklore
  • Outline
  • Urban Myths and Preconceptions
  • Religious and Cultural Implication
  • Slide 5
  • Shettlesrsquo (Theory)
  • lsquoYour child is what you eatrsquo
  • lsquoBe the bossrsquo
  • Slide 9
  • Slide 10
  • Conclusion
  • References
  • ANY Questions
Page 4: Maternal preconception and gender selection

Religious and Cultural Religious and Cultural ImplicationImplication

Sex selection big business In India abortion of girls on the rise Common amongst wealthy-access to USS 103 (BG) in some states (NBS)(1)

Land inheritance lsquodowryrsquo customs common themes

Illegal to disclose sex of unborn or abort based on gender-practice on increase

lsquoPay Rs 5000 today and save Rs 5 lakhs tomorrowrsquo

-Advertisement

Religious and Cultural Religious and Cultural ImplicationImplication

Missing women of China One-child policy (1979) correlates with gender-based birth rate

disparity 30 million more men than women (2020) predicted (NBS) Underreporting female live births diseases affecting female mortality

illegal sex-related abortion infanticide and child abandonment(2)

Shettlesrsquo (Theory)Shettlesrsquo (Theory)

First reputed child conception idea to determine babyrsquos sex

lsquoHow to Choose the Sex of Your Babyrsquo- publ1970 claims gt75 effectiveness (3)

Basic Concept (timing of intercourse) raquo X-bearing Sperm- Slower and larger than their Y-bearing counterparts- More resilient longer-lived

raquo Y-bearing Sperm- Faster and smaller than their X-bearing counterparts- More fragile short-lived

lsquolsquoYour child is what you eatrsquoYour child is what you eatrsquo

244 female mice fed high saturated fat content produced 60 male offspring vs 274 controls producing 48 male offspring (Plt00001)(5)+(6)

Trivers-Willard hypothesis (1973) (4) raquo Triversrsquo trivial assumptions1)Parental condition associated with offspring condition2)Differences in offspring condition will persist into adulthood3)Being in condition affects mating success of one sex more than the other

lsquoGood conditionrsquo hypothesis or lsquoAdaptiversquo theory

lsquolsquoBe the bossrsquoBe the bossrsquo

Maternal dominance hypothesis (1996) (7) Maternal dominance

serum testosteronechance of male fetus

lsquolsquoBe the bossrsquoBe the bossrsquo Faecal testosterone is elevated in

high-ranking female ibexes (lt005) and associated with more male offspring vs subordinate females (8M vs 5M)(8)

Ova development in follicular fluid high in testosterone is more likely to be fertilised by Y-chromosome-bearing spermatozoa(9)

Recent trial (2010) reported median testosterone levels higher in follicles that resulted in male embryos (3212 ngml) than female embryos (2398 ngml)(10)

Study

N (embryos)

Follicular testosteroneminndashmax (nM)

Median follicular testosteroneof subsequent embryos (nM)

Significance (P)

Male Female(9) 171 11-977 12260 9075 0032(10) 140 13ndash893 11136 8313 006

(11)

Conclusion Conclusion Controversial DebateSocial implications Little scientific evidenceShettles Theory Maternal Condition and

Dominance

REFERENCESREFERENCES1) Current status of abortion in India Consortium on National Consensus for Medical Abortion in India

httpwwwaiimsacinaiimseventsGynaewebsitema_finalsitereport1_1_1htm Retrieved 20111703 2) Johansson S Nygren O (1991) The missing girls of China a new demographic account Population and

Development Review (Population Council) 17 (1) 35ndash51 3) ldquoThe Shettles Method of Sex Selectionrdquo Robin Elise Weiss LCCE Aboutcom Guide

httppregnancyaboutcomodgenderselectionashettlesmethodhtm Retrieved 20111703 4) Trivers RLWillard D (1973) ldquoNatural selection of parental ability to vary the sex ratio of offspringrdquo Science

179 90ndash925) Alexenko APMao J Ellersieck MRDavis AMWhyte JJ (2007) ldquoThe contrasting effects of ad libitum and

restricted feeding of a diet very high in saturated fats on sex ratio and metabolic hormones in micerdquo Biology of Reproduction 77599ndash604

6) Cameron EZLemons PRBateman PWBennett NC (2008) ldquoExperimental alteration of litter sex ratios in a mammalrdquo Proc Royal Soc of London Series B 275 323ndash327

7) Grant VJIrwin RJ (2005) ldquoFollicular fluid steroid levels and subsequent sex of bovine embryosrdquo Journ of Experimental Zoology 303A1120ndash1125

8) Shargal DShore LRoteri NTerkel AZorovsky YShemesh MSteinberger Y (2008) ldquoFecal testosterone is elevated in high ranking female ibexes (Capra nubiana) and associated with increased aggression and a preponderance of male offspringrdquo Theriogenology 69 673ndash680

9) Grant VJIrwin RJStandley NTShelling ANChamley LW (2008) ldquoSex of bovine embryos may be related to mothersrsquo preovulatory follicular testosteronerdquo Biol of Reproduction 78 812ndash815

10) Garcia-Herreros MBermejo-Alvarez PRizos DGutierrez-Adan AFahey AGLonergan P (2010) ldquoIntrafollicular testosterone concentration and sex ratio in individually cultured bovine embryosrdquo Reproduction Fertility and Development 22 533ndash538

11) Dama MS Singh NM Rajender S (2011) ldquoHigh Fat Diet Prevents Over-Crowding Induced Decrease of Sex Ratio in Micerdquo PLoS ONE 6(1) e16296

ANY QUESTIONS ANY QUESTIONS

  • lsquoI want a Boyrsquo the preconception folklore
  • Outline
  • Urban Myths and Preconceptions
  • Religious and Cultural Implication
  • Slide 5
  • Shettlesrsquo (Theory)
  • lsquoYour child is what you eatrsquo
  • lsquoBe the bossrsquo
  • Slide 9
  • Slide 10
  • Conclusion
  • References
  • ANY Questions
Page 5: Maternal preconception and gender selection

Religious and Cultural Religious and Cultural ImplicationImplication

Missing women of China One-child policy (1979) correlates with gender-based birth rate

disparity 30 million more men than women (2020) predicted (NBS) Underreporting female live births diseases affecting female mortality

illegal sex-related abortion infanticide and child abandonment(2)

Shettlesrsquo (Theory)Shettlesrsquo (Theory)

First reputed child conception idea to determine babyrsquos sex

lsquoHow to Choose the Sex of Your Babyrsquo- publ1970 claims gt75 effectiveness (3)

Basic Concept (timing of intercourse) raquo X-bearing Sperm- Slower and larger than their Y-bearing counterparts- More resilient longer-lived

raquo Y-bearing Sperm- Faster and smaller than their X-bearing counterparts- More fragile short-lived

lsquolsquoYour child is what you eatrsquoYour child is what you eatrsquo

244 female mice fed high saturated fat content produced 60 male offspring vs 274 controls producing 48 male offspring (Plt00001)(5)+(6)

Trivers-Willard hypothesis (1973) (4) raquo Triversrsquo trivial assumptions1)Parental condition associated with offspring condition2)Differences in offspring condition will persist into adulthood3)Being in condition affects mating success of one sex more than the other

lsquoGood conditionrsquo hypothesis or lsquoAdaptiversquo theory

lsquolsquoBe the bossrsquoBe the bossrsquo

Maternal dominance hypothesis (1996) (7) Maternal dominance

serum testosteronechance of male fetus

lsquolsquoBe the bossrsquoBe the bossrsquo Faecal testosterone is elevated in

high-ranking female ibexes (lt005) and associated with more male offspring vs subordinate females (8M vs 5M)(8)

Ova development in follicular fluid high in testosterone is more likely to be fertilised by Y-chromosome-bearing spermatozoa(9)

Recent trial (2010) reported median testosterone levels higher in follicles that resulted in male embryos (3212 ngml) than female embryos (2398 ngml)(10)

Study

N (embryos)

Follicular testosteroneminndashmax (nM)

Median follicular testosteroneof subsequent embryos (nM)

Significance (P)

Male Female(9) 171 11-977 12260 9075 0032(10) 140 13ndash893 11136 8313 006

(11)

Conclusion Conclusion Controversial DebateSocial implications Little scientific evidenceShettles Theory Maternal Condition and

Dominance

REFERENCESREFERENCES1) Current status of abortion in India Consortium on National Consensus for Medical Abortion in India

httpwwwaiimsacinaiimseventsGynaewebsitema_finalsitereport1_1_1htm Retrieved 20111703 2) Johansson S Nygren O (1991) The missing girls of China a new demographic account Population and

Development Review (Population Council) 17 (1) 35ndash51 3) ldquoThe Shettles Method of Sex Selectionrdquo Robin Elise Weiss LCCE Aboutcom Guide

httppregnancyaboutcomodgenderselectionashettlesmethodhtm Retrieved 20111703 4) Trivers RLWillard D (1973) ldquoNatural selection of parental ability to vary the sex ratio of offspringrdquo Science

179 90ndash925) Alexenko APMao J Ellersieck MRDavis AMWhyte JJ (2007) ldquoThe contrasting effects of ad libitum and

restricted feeding of a diet very high in saturated fats on sex ratio and metabolic hormones in micerdquo Biology of Reproduction 77599ndash604

6) Cameron EZLemons PRBateman PWBennett NC (2008) ldquoExperimental alteration of litter sex ratios in a mammalrdquo Proc Royal Soc of London Series B 275 323ndash327

7) Grant VJIrwin RJ (2005) ldquoFollicular fluid steroid levels and subsequent sex of bovine embryosrdquo Journ of Experimental Zoology 303A1120ndash1125

8) Shargal DShore LRoteri NTerkel AZorovsky YShemesh MSteinberger Y (2008) ldquoFecal testosterone is elevated in high ranking female ibexes (Capra nubiana) and associated with increased aggression and a preponderance of male offspringrdquo Theriogenology 69 673ndash680

9) Grant VJIrwin RJStandley NTShelling ANChamley LW (2008) ldquoSex of bovine embryos may be related to mothersrsquo preovulatory follicular testosteronerdquo Biol of Reproduction 78 812ndash815

10) Garcia-Herreros MBermejo-Alvarez PRizos DGutierrez-Adan AFahey AGLonergan P (2010) ldquoIntrafollicular testosterone concentration and sex ratio in individually cultured bovine embryosrdquo Reproduction Fertility and Development 22 533ndash538

11) Dama MS Singh NM Rajender S (2011) ldquoHigh Fat Diet Prevents Over-Crowding Induced Decrease of Sex Ratio in Micerdquo PLoS ONE 6(1) e16296

ANY QUESTIONS ANY QUESTIONS

  • lsquoI want a Boyrsquo the preconception folklore
  • Outline
  • Urban Myths and Preconceptions
  • Religious and Cultural Implication
  • Slide 5
  • Shettlesrsquo (Theory)
  • lsquoYour child is what you eatrsquo
  • lsquoBe the bossrsquo
  • Slide 9
  • Slide 10
  • Conclusion
  • References
  • ANY Questions
Page 6: Maternal preconception and gender selection

Shettlesrsquo (Theory)Shettlesrsquo (Theory)

First reputed child conception idea to determine babyrsquos sex

lsquoHow to Choose the Sex of Your Babyrsquo- publ1970 claims gt75 effectiveness (3)

Basic Concept (timing of intercourse) raquo X-bearing Sperm- Slower and larger than their Y-bearing counterparts- More resilient longer-lived

raquo Y-bearing Sperm- Faster and smaller than their X-bearing counterparts- More fragile short-lived

lsquolsquoYour child is what you eatrsquoYour child is what you eatrsquo

244 female mice fed high saturated fat content produced 60 male offspring vs 274 controls producing 48 male offspring (Plt00001)(5)+(6)

Trivers-Willard hypothesis (1973) (4) raquo Triversrsquo trivial assumptions1)Parental condition associated with offspring condition2)Differences in offspring condition will persist into adulthood3)Being in condition affects mating success of one sex more than the other

lsquoGood conditionrsquo hypothesis or lsquoAdaptiversquo theory

lsquolsquoBe the bossrsquoBe the bossrsquo

Maternal dominance hypothesis (1996) (7) Maternal dominance

serum testosteronechance of male fetus

lsquolsquoBe the bossrsquoBe the bossrsquo Faecal testosterone is elevated in

high-ranking female ibexes (lt005) and associated with more male offspring vs subordinate females (8M vs 5M)(8)

Ova development in follicular fluid high in testosterone is more likely to be fertilised by Y-chromosome-bearing spermatozoa(9)

Recent trial (2010) reported median testosterone levels higher in follicles that resulted in male embryos (3212 ngml) than female embryos (2398 ngml)(10)

Study

N (embryos)

Follicular testosteroneminndashmax (nM)

Median follicular testosteroneof subsequent embryos (nM)

Significance (P)

Male Female(9) 171 11-977 12260 9075 0032(10) 140 13ndash893 11136 8313 006

(11)

Conclusion Conclusion Controversial DebateSocial implications Little scientific evidenceShettles Theory Maternal Condition and

Dominance

REFERENCESREFERENCES1) Current status of abortion in India Consortium on National Consensus for Medical Abortion in India

httpwwwaiimsacinaiimseventsGynaewebsitema_finalsitereport1_1_1htm Retrieved 20111703 2) Johansson S Nygren O (1991) The missing girls of China a new demographic account Population and

Development Review (Population Council) 17 (1) 35ndash51 3) ldquoThe Shettles Method of Sex Selectionrdquo Robin Elise Weiss LCCE Aboutcom Guide

httppregnancyaboutcomodgenderselectionashettlesmethodhtm Retrieved 20111703 4) Trivers RLWillard D (1973) ldquoNatural selection of parental ability to vary the sex ratio of offspringrdquo Science

179 90ndash925) Alexenko APMao J Ellersieck MRDavis AMWhyte JJ (2007) ldquoThe contrasting effects of ad libitum and

restricted feeding of a diet very high in saturated fats on sex ratio and metabolic hormones in micerdquo Biology of Reproduction 77599ndash604

6) Cameron EZLemons PRBateman PWBennett NC (2008) ldquoExperimental alteration of litter sex ratios in a mammalrdquo Proc Royal Soc of London Series B 275 323ndash327

7) Grant VJIrwin RJ (2005) ldquoFollicular fluid steroid levels and subsequent sex of bovine embryosrdquo Journ of Experimental Zoology 303A1120ndash1125

8) Shargal DShore LRoteri NTerkel AZorovsky YShemesh MSteinberger Y (2008) ldquoFecal testosterone is elevated in high ranking female ibexes (Capra nubiana) and associated with increased aggression and a preponderance of male offspringrdquo Theriogenology 69 673ndash680

9) Grant VJIrwin RJStandley NTShelling ANChamley LW (2008) ldquoSex of bovine embryos may be related to mothersrsquo preovulatory follicular testosteronerdquo Biol of Reproduction 78 812ndash815

10) Garcia-Herreros MBermejo-Alvarez PRizos DGutierrez-Adan AFahey AGLonergan P (2010) ldquoIntrafollicular testosterone concentration and sex ratio in individually cultured bovine embryosrdquo Reproduction Fertility and Development 22 533ndash538

11) Dama MS Singh NM Rajender S (2011) ldquoHigh Fat Diet Prevents Over-Crowding Induced Decrease of Sex Ratio in Micerdquo PLoS ONE 6(1) e16296

ANY QUESTIONS ANY QUESTIONS

  • lsquoI want a Boyrsquo the preconception folklore
  • Outline
  • Urban Myths and Preconceptions
  • Religious and Cultural Implication
  • Slide 5
  • Shettlesrsquo (Theory)
  • lsquoYour child is what you eatrsquo
  • lsquoBe the bossrsquo
  • Slide 9
  • Slide 10
  • Conclusion
  • References
  • ANY Questions
Page 7: Maternal preconception and gender selection

lsquolsquoYour child is what you eatrsquoYour child is what you eatrsquo

244 female mice fed high saturated fat content produced 60 male offspring vs 274 controls producing 48 male offspring (Plt00001)(5)+(6)

Trivers-Willard hypothesis (1973) (4) raquo Triversrsquo trivial assumptions1)Parental condition associated with offspring condition2)Differences in offspring condition will persist into adulthood3)Being in condition affects mating success of one sex more than the other

lsquoGood conditionrsquo hypothesis or lsquoAdaptiversquo theory

lsquolsquoBe the bossrsquoBe the bossrsquo

Maternal dominance hypothesis (1996) (7) Maternal dominance

serum testosteronechance of male fetus

lsquolsquoBe the bossrsquoBe the bossrsquo Faecal testosterone is elevated in

high-ranking female ibexes (lt005) and associated with more male offspring vs subordinate females (8M vs 5M)(8)

Ova development in follicular fluid high in testosterone is more likely to be fertilised by Y-chromosome-bearing spermatozoa(9)

Recent trial (2010) reported median testosterone levels higher in follicles that resulted in male embryos (3212 ngml) than female embryos (2398 ngml)(10)

Study

N (embryos)

Follicular testosteroneminndashmax (nM)

Median follicular testosteroneof subsequent embryos (nM)

Significance (P)

Male Female(9) 171 11-977 12260 9075 0032(10) 140 13ndash893 11136 8313 006

(11)

Conclusion Conclusion Controversial DebateSocial implications Little scientific evidenceShettles Theory Maternal Condition and

Dominance

REFERENCESREFERENCES1) Current status of abortion in India Consortium on National Consensus for Medical Abortion in India

httpwwwaiimsacinaiimseventsGynaewebsitema_finalsitereport1_1_1htm Retrieved 20111703 2) Johansson S Nygren O (1991) The missing girls of China a new demographic account Population and

Development Review (Population Council) 17 (1) 35ndash51 3) ldquoThe Shettles Method of Sex Selectionrdquo Robin Elise Weiss LCCE Aboutcom Guide

httppregnancyaboutcomodgenderselectionashettlesmethodhtm Retrieved 20111703 4) Trivers RLWillard D (1973) ldquoNatural selection of parental ability to vary the sex ratio of offspringrdquo Science

179 90ndash925) Alexenko APMao J Ellersieck MRDavis AMWhyte JJ (2007) ldquoThe contrasting effects of ad libitum and

restricted feeding of a diet very high in saturated fats on sex ratio and metabolic hormones in micerdquo Biology of Reproduction 77599ndash604

6) Cameron EZLemons PRBateman PWBennett NC (2008) ldquoExperimental alteration of litter sex ratios in a mammalrdquo Proc Royal Soc of London Series B 275 323ndash327

7) Grant VJIrwin RJ (2005) ldquoFollicular fluid steroid levels and subsequent sex of bovine embryosrdquo Journ of Experimental Zoology 303A1120ndash1125

8) Shargal DShore LRoteri NTerkel AZorovsky YShemesh MSteinberger Y (2008) ldquoFecal testosterone is elevated in high ranking female ibexes (Capra nubiana) and associated with increased aggression and a preponderance of male offspringrdquo Theriogenology 69 673ndash680

9) Grant VJIrwin RJStandley NTShelling ANChamley LW (2008) ldquoSex of bovine embryos may be related to mothersrsquo preovulatory follicular testosteronerdquo Biol of Reproduction 78 812ndash815

10) Garcia-Herreros MBermejo-Alvarez PRizos DGutierrez-Adan AFahey AGLonergan P (2010) ldquoIntrafollicular testosterone concentration and sex ratio in individually cultured bovine embryosrdquo Reproduction Fertility and Development 22 533ndash538

11) Dama MS Singh NM Rajender S (2011) ldquoHigh Fat Diet Prevents Over-Crowding Induced Decrease of Sex Ratio in Micerdquo PLoS ONE 6(1) e16296

ANY QUESTIONS ANY QUESTIONS

  • lsquoI want a Boyrsquo the preconception folklore
  • Outline
  • Urban Myths and Preconceptions
  • Religious and Cultural Implication
  • Slide 5
  • Shettlesrsquo (Theory)
  • lsquoYour child is what you eatrsquo
  • lsquoBe the bossrsquo
  • Slide 9
  • Slide 10
  • Conclusion
  • References
  • ANY Questions
Page 8: Maternal preconception and gender selection

lsquolsquoBe the bossrsquoBe the bossrsquo

Maternal dominance hypothesis (1996) (7) Maternal dominance

serum testosteronechance of male fetus

lsquolsquoBe the bossrsquoBe the bossrsquo Faecal testosterone is elevated in

high-ranking female ibexes (lt005) and associated with more male offspring vs subordinate females (8M vs 5M)(8)

Ova development in follicular fluid high in testosterone is more likely to be fertilised by Y-chromosome-bearing spermatozoa(9)

Recent trial (2010) reported median testosterone levels higher in follicles that resulted in male embryos (3212 ngml) than female embryos (2398 ngml)(10)

Study

N (embryos)

Follicular testosteroneminndashmax (nM)

Median follicular testosteroneof subsequent embryos (nM)

Significance (P)

Male Female(9) 171 11-977 12260 9075 0032(10) 140 13ndash893 11136 8313 006

(11)

Conclusion Conclusion Controversial DebateSocial implications Little scientific evidenceShettles Theory Maternal Condition and

Dominance

REFERENCESREFERENCES1) Current status of abortion in India Consortium on National Consensus for Medical Abortion in India

httpwwwaiimsacinaiimseventsGynaewebsitema_finalsitereport1_1_1htm Retrieved 20111703 2) Johansson S Nygren O (1991) The missing girls of China a new demographic account Population and

Development Review (Population Council) 17 (1) 35ndash51 3) ldquoThe Shettles Method of Sex Selectionrdquo Robin Elise Weiss LCCE Aboutcom Guide

httppregnancyaboutcomodgenderselectionashettlesmethodhtm Retrieved 20111703 4) Trivers RLWillard D (1973) ldquoNatural selection of parental ability to vary the sex ratio of offspringrdquo Science

179 90ndash925) Alexenko APMao J Ellersieck MRDavis AMWhyte JJ (2007) ldquoThe contrasting effects of ad libitum and

restricted feeding of a diet very high in saturated fats on sex ratio and metabolic hormones in micerdquo Biology of Reproduction 77599ndash604

6) Cameron EZLemons PRBateman PWBennett NC (2008) ldquoExperimental alteration of litter sex ratios in a mammalrdquo Proc Royal Soc of London Series B 275 323ndash327

7) Grant VJIrwin RJ (2005) ldquoFollicular fluid steroid levels and subsequent sex of bovine embryosrdquo Journ of Experimental Zoology 303A1120ndash1125

8) Shargal DShore LRoteri NTerkel AZorovsky YShemesh MSteinberger Y (2008) ldquoFecal testosterone is elevated in high ranking female ibexes (Capra nubiana) and associated with increased aggression and a preponderance of male offspringrdquo Theriogenology 69 673ndash680

9) Grant VJIrwin RJStandley NTShelling ANChamley LW (2008) ldquoSex of bovine embryos may be related to mothersrsquo preovulatory follicular testosteronerdquo Biol of Reproduction 78 812ndash815

10) Garcia-Herreros MBermejo-Alvarez PRizos DGutierrez-Adan AFahey AGLonergan P (2010) ldquoIntrafollicular testosterone concentration and sex ratio in individually cultured bovine embryosrdquo Reproduction Fertility and Development 22 533ndash538

11) Dama MS Singh NM Rajender S (2011) ldquoHigh Fat Diet Prevents Over-Crowding Induced Decrease of Sex Ratio in Micerdquo PLoS ONE 6(1) e16296

ANY QUESTIONS ANY QUESTIONS

  • lsquoI want a Boyrsquo the preconception folklore
  • Outline
  • Urban Myths and Preconceptions
  • Religious and Cultural Implication
  • Slide 5
  • Shettlesrsquo (Theory)
  • lsquoYour child is what you eatrsquo
  • lsquoBe the bossrsquo
  • Slide 9
  • Slide 10
  • Conclusion
  • References
  • ANY Questions
Page 9: Maternal preconception and gender selection

lsquolsquoBe the bossrsquoBe the bossrsquo Faecal testosterone is elevated in

high-ranking female ibexes (lt005) and associated with more male offspring vs subordinate females (8M vs 5M)(8)

Ova development in follicular fluid high in testosterone is more likely to be fertilised by Y-chromosome-bearing spermatozoa(9)

Recent trial (2010) reported median testosterone levels higher in follicles that resulted in male embryos (3212 ngml) than female embryos (2398 ngml)(10)

Study

N (embryos)

Follicular testosteroneminndashmax (nM)

Median follicular testosteroneof subsequent embryos (nM)

Significance (P)

Male Female(9) 171 11-977 12260 9075 0032(10) 140 13ndash893 11136 8313 006

(11)

Conclusion Conclusion Controversial DebateSocial implications Little scientific evidenceShettles Theory Maternal Condition and

Dominance

REFERENCESREFERENCES1) Current status of abortion in India Consortium on National Consensus for Medical Abortion in India

httpwwwaiimsacinaiimseventsGynaewebsitema_finalsitereport1_1_1htm Retrieved 20111703 2) Johansson S Nygren O (1991) The missing girls of China a new demographic account Population and

Development Review (Population Council) 17 (1) 35ndash51 3) ldquoThe Shettles Method of Sex Selectionrdquo Robin Elise Weiss LCCE Aboutcom Guide

httppregnancyaboutcomodgenderselectionashettlesmethodhtm Retrieved 20111703 4) Trivers RLWillard D (1973) ldquoNatural selection of parental ability to vary the sex ratio of offspringrdquo Science

179 90ndash925) Alexenko APMao J Ellersieck MRDavis AMWhyte JJ (2007) ldquoThe contrasting effects of ad libitum and

restricted feeding of a diet very high in saturated fats on sex ratio and metabolic hormones in micerdquo Biology of Reproduction 77599ndash604

6) Cameron EZLemons PRBateman PWBennett NC (2008) ldquoExperimental alteration of litter sex ratios in a mammalrdquo Proc Royal Soc of London Series B 275 323ndash327

7) Grant VJIrwin RJ (2005) ldquoFollicular fluid steroid levels and subsequent sex of bovine embryosrdquo Journ of Experimental Zoology 303A1120ndash1125

8) Shargal DShore LRoteri NTerkel AZorovsky YShemesh MSteinberger Y (2008) ldquoFecal testosterone is elevated in high ranking female ibexes (Capra nubiana) and associated with increased aggression and a preponderance of male offspringrdquo Theriogenology 69 673ndash680

9) Grant VJIrwin RJStandley NTShelling ANChamley LW (2008) ldquoSex of bovine embryos may be related to mothersrsquo preovulatory follicular testosteronerdquo Biol of Reproduction 78 812ndash815

10) Garcia-Herreros MBermejo-Alvarez PRizos DGutierrez-Adan AFahey AGLonergan P (2010) ldquoIntrafollicular testosterone concentration and sex ratio in individually cultured bovine embryosrdquo Reproduction Fertility and Development 22 533ndash538

11) Dama MS Singh NM Rajender S (2011) ldquoHigh Fat Diet Prevents Over-Crowding Induced Decrease of Sex Ratio in Micerdquo PLoS ONE 6(1) e16296

ANY QUESTIONS ANY QUESTIONS

  • lsquoI want a Boyrsquo the preconception folklore
  • Outline
  • Urban Myths and Preconceptions
  • Religious and Cultural Implication
  • Slide 5
  • Shettlesrsquo (Theory)
  • lsquoYour child is what you eatrsquo
  • lsquoBe the bossrsquo
  • Slide 9
  • Slide 10
  • Conclusion
  • References
  • ANY Questions
Page 10: Maternal preconception and gender selection

(11)

Conclusion Conclusion Controversial DebateSocial implications Little scientific evidenceShettles Theory Maternal Condition and

Dominance

REFERENCESREFERENCES1) Current status of abortion in India Consortium on National Consensus for Medical Abortion in India

httpwwwaiimsacinaiimseventsGynaewebsitema_finalsitereport1_1_1htm Retrieved 20111703 2) Johansson S Nygren O (1991) The missing girls of China a new demographic account Population and

Development Review (Population Council) 17 (1) 35ndash51 3) ldquoThe Shettles Method of Sex Selectionrdquo Robin Elise Weiss LCCE Aboutcom Guide

httppregnancyaboutcomodgenderselectionashettlesmethodhtm Retrieved 20111703 4) Trivers RLWillard D (1973) ldquoNatural selection of parental ability to vary the sex ratio of offspringrdquo Science

179 90ndash925) Alexenko APMao J Ellersieck MRDavis AMWhyte JJ (2007) ldquoThe contrasting effects of ad libitum and

restricted feeding of a diet very high in saturated fats on sex ratio and metabolic hormones in micerdquo Biology of Reproduction 77599ndash604

6) Cameron EZLemons PRBateman PWBennett NC (2008) ldquoExperimental alteration of litter sex ratios in a mammalrdquo Proc Royal Soc of London Series B 275 323ndash327

7) Grant VJIrwin RJ (2005) ldquoFollicular fluid steroid levels and subsequent sex of bovine embryosrdquo Journ of Experimental Zoology 303A1120ndash1125

8) Shargal DShore LRoteri NTerkel AZorovsky YShemesh MSteinberger Y (2008) ldquoFecal testosterone is elevated in high ranking female ibexes (Capra nubiana) and associated with increased aggression and a preponderance of male offspringrdquo Theriogenology 69 673ndash680

9) Grant VJIrwin RJStandley NTShelling ANChamley LW (2008) ldquoSex of bovine embryos may be related to mothersrsquo preovulatory follicular testosteronerdquo Biol of Reproduction 78 812ndash815

10) Garcia-Herreros MBermejo-Alvarez PRizos DGutierrez-Adan AFahey AGLonergan P (2010) ldquoIntrafollicular testosterone concentration and sex ratio in individually cultured bovine embryosrdquo Reproduction Fertility and Development 22 533ndash538

11) Dama MS Singh NM Rajender S (2011) ldquoHigh Fat Diet Prevents Over-Crowding Induced Decrease of Sex Ratio in Micerdquo PLoS ONE 6(1) e16296

ANY QUESTIONS ANY QUESTIONS

  • lsquoI want a Boyrsquo the preconception folklore
  • Outline
  • Urban Myths and Preconceptions
  • Religious and Cultural Implication
  • Slide 5
  • Shettlesrsquo (Theory)
  • lsquoYour child is what you eatrsquo
  • lsquoBe the bossrsquo
  • Slide 9
  • Slide 10
  • Conclusion
  • References
  • ANY Questions
Page 11: Maternal preconception and gender selection

Conclusion Conclusion Controversial DebateSocial implications Little scientific evidenceShettles Theory Maternal Condition and

Dominance

REFERENCESREFERENCES1) Current status of abortion in India Consortium on National Consensus for Medical Abortion in India

httpwwwaiimsacinaiimseventsGynaewebsitema_finalsitereport1_1_1htm Retrieved 20111703 2) Johansson S Nygren O (1991) The missing girls of China a new demographic account Population and

Development Review (Population Council) 17 (1) 35ndash51 3) ldquoThe Shettles Method of Sex Selectionrdquo Robin Elise Weiss LCCE Aboutcom Guide

httppregnancyaboutcomodgenderselectionashettlesmethodhtm Retrieved 20111703 4) Trivers RLWillard D (1973) ldquoNatural selection of parental ability to vary the sex ratio of offspringrdquo Science

179 90ndash925) Alexenko APMao J Ellersieck MRDavis AMWhyte JJ (2007) ldquoThe contrasting effects of ad libitum and

restricted feeding of a diet very high in saturated fats on sex ratio and metabolic hormones in micerdquo Biology of Reproduction 77599ndash604

6) Cameron EZLemons PRBateman PWBennett NC (2008) ldquoExperimental alteration of litter sex ratios in a mammalrdquo Proc Royal Soc of London Series B 275 323ndash327

7) Grant VJIrwin RJ (2005) ldquoFollicular fluid steroid levels and subsequent sex of bovine embryosrdquo Journ of Experimental Zoology 303A1120ndash1125

8) Shargal DShore LRoteri NTerkel AZorovsky YShemesh MSteinberger Y (2008) ldquoFecal testosterone is elevated in high ranking female ibexes (Capra nubiana) and associated with increased aggression and a preponderance of male offspringrdquo Theriogenology 69 673ndash680

9) Grant VJIrwin RJStandley NTShelling ANChamley LW (2008) ldquoSex of bovine embryos may be related to mothersrsquo preovulatory follicular testosteronerdquo Biol of Reproduction 78 812ndash815

10) Garcia-Herreros MBermejo-Alvarez PRizos DGutierrez-Adan AFahey AGLonergan P (2010) ldquoIntrafollicular testosterone concentration and sex ratio in individually cultured bovine embryosrdquo Reproduction Fertility and Development 22 533ndash538

11) Dama MS Singh NM Rajender S (2011) ldquoHigh Fat Diet Prevents Over-Crowding Induced Decrease of Sex Ratio in Micerdquo PLoS ONE 6(1) e16296

ANY QUESTIONS ANY QUESTIONS

  • lsquoI want a Boyrsquo the preconception folklore
  • Outline
  • Urban Myths and Preconceptions
  • Religious and Cultural Implication
  • Slide 5
  • Shettlesrsquo (Theory)
  • lsquoYour child is what you eatrsquo
  • lsquoBe the bossrsquo
  • Slide 9
  • Slide 10
  • Conclusion
  • References
  • ANY Questions
Page 12: Maternal preconception and gender selection

REFERENCESREFERENCES1) Current status of abortion in India Consortium on National Consensus for Medical Abortion in India

httpwwwaiimsacinaiimseventsGynaewebsitema_finalsitereport1_1_1htm Retrieved 20111703 2) Johansson S Nygren O (1991) The missing girls of China a new demographic account Population and

Development Review (Population Council) 17 (1) 35ndash51 3) ldquoThe Shettles Method of Sex Selectionrdquo Robin Elise Weiss LCCE Aboutcom Guide

httppregnancyaboutcomodgenderselectionashettlesmethodhtm Retrieved 20111703 4) Trivers RLWillard D (1973) ldquoNatural selection of parental ability to vary the sex ratio of offspringrdquo Science

179 90ndash925) Alexenko APMao J Ellersieck MRDavis AMWhyte JJ (2007) ldquoThe contrasting effects of ad libitum and

restricted feeding of a diet very high in saturated fats on sex ratio and metabolic hormones in micerdquo Biology of Reproduction 77599ndash604

6) Cameron EZLemons PRBateman PWBennett NC (2008) ldquoExperimental alteration of litter sex ratios in a mammalrdquo Proc Royal Soc of London Series B 275 323ndash327

7) Grant VJIrwin RJ (2005) ldquoFollicular fluid steroid levels and subsequent sex of bovine embryosrdquo Journ of Experimental Zoology 303A1120ndash1125

8) Shargal DShore LRoteri NTerkel AZorovsky YShemesh MSteinberger Y (2008) ldquoFecal testosterone is elevated in high ranking female ibexes (Capra nubiana) and associated with increased aggression and a preponderance of male offspringrdquo Theriogenology 69 673ndash680

9) Grant VJIrwin RJStandley NTShelling ANChamley LW (2008) ldquoSex of bovine embryos may be related to mothersrsquo preovulatory follicular testosteronerdquo Biol of Reproduction 78 812ndash815

10) Garcia-Herreros MBermejo-Alvarez PRizos DGutierrez-Adan AFahey AGLonergan P (2010) ldquoIntrafollicular testosterone concentration and sex ratio in individually cultured bovine embryosrdquo Reproduction Fertility and Development 22 533ndash538

11) Dama MS Singh NM Rajender S (2011) ldquoHigh Fat Diet Prevents Over-Crowding Induced Decrease of Sex Ratio in Micerdquo PLoS ONE 6(1) e16296

ANY QUESTIONS ANY QUESTIONS

  • lsquoI want a Boyrsquo the preconception folklore
  • Outline
  • Urban Myths and Preconceptions
  • Religious and Cultural Implication
  • Slide 5
  • Shettlesrsquo (Theory)
  • lsquoYour child is what you eatrsquo
  • lsquoBe the bossrsquo
  • Slide 9
  • Slide 10
  • Conclusion
  • References
  • ANY Questions
Page 13: Maternal preconception and gender selection

ANY QUESTIONS ANY QUESTIONS

  • lsquoI want a Boyrsquo the preconception folklore
  • Outline
  • Urban Myths and Preconceptions
  • Religious and Cultural Implication
  • Slide 5
  • Shettlesrsquo (Theory)
  • lsquoYour child is what you eatrsquo
  • lsquoBe the bossrsquo
  • Slide 9
  • Slide 10
  • Conclusion
  • References
  • ANY Questions