130
Musculoskeletal disorders, disability and work People and Work Research Reports 89 Kari-Pekka Martimo

Kari-Pekka Martimo - UEF · Kari-Pekka Martimo Musculoskeletal disorders, disability and work Kari-Pekka Martimo Musculoskeletal disorders (MSD) are the most important causes of temporary

  • Upload
    others

  • View
    15

  • Download
    0

Embed Size (px)

Citation preview

Page 1: Kari-Pekka Martimo - UEF · Kari-Pekka Martimo Musculoskeletal disorders, disability and work Kari-Pekka Martimo Musculoskeletal disorders (MSD) are the most important causes of temporary

Orders:Finnish Institute of Occupational HealthTopeliuksenkatu 41 a AFI-00250 HelsinkiFinland

Fax +358-9 477 5071E-mail [email protected]/bookstore

ISBN 978-951-802-987-1 (paperback) 978-951-802-988-8 (PDF)ISSN-L 1237-6183ISSN 1237-6183

Cover picture: Sami Rantanen

Musculoskeletal disorders, disability and work

People and WorkResearch Reports 89

Kari-Pekka Martimo

Musculoskeletal disorders, disability and w

orkK

ari-Pekka Martim

oMusculoskeletal disorders (MSD) are the most important causes of temporary and permanent work disability. The aim of this thesis was to examine the role of work in the disability caused by MSD from various perspectives: primary prevention using lifting advice and devices, perception of work-relatedness, measurement of productivity loss, and secondary/tertiary prevention through ergonomic intervention or part-time sick leave. The original articles include a systematic review, two surveys, a randomised controlled trial, and a study protocol. The results support the early use of a biopsychosocial model for effective management of disability.

89

Page 2: Kari-Pekka Martimo - UEF · Kari-Pekka Martimo Musculoskeletal disorders, disability and work Kari-Pekka Martimo Musculoskeletal disorders (MSD) are the most important causes of temporary

People and Work

Editor in chief Harri Vainio

Scientific editors Raoul Grönqvist Irja Kandolin Timo Kauppinen Kari Kurppa Anneli Leppänen Hannu Rintamäki Riitta Sauni

Editor Virve Mertanen

Address Finnish Institute of Occupational Health Topeliuksenkatu 41 a A FI-00250 Helsinki Tel. +358- 30 4741 Fax +358-9 477 5071 www.ttl.fi

Layout Juvenes Print / Katja Hakala Cover Picture Sami Rantanen ISBN 978-951-802-987-1 (paperback) 978-951-802-988-8 (PDF) ISSN-L 1237-6183 ISSN 1237-6183 Press Tampereen Yliopistopaino Oy – Juvenes Print, Tampere 2010

Page 3: Kari-Pekka Martimo - UEF · Kari-Pekka Martimo Musculoskeletal disorders, disability and work Kari-Pekka Martimo Musculoskeletal disorders (MSD) are the most important causes of temporary

MUSCULOSKELETAL DISORDERS, DISABILITY AND WORK

Kari-Pekka Martimo

People and Work Research Reports 89

Finnish Institute of Occupational Health, Helsinki, Finland

Page 4: Kari-Pekka Martimo - UEF · Kari-Pekka Martimo Musculoskeletal disorders, disability and work Kari-Pekka Martimo Musculoskeletal disorders (MSD) are the most important causes of temporary

DOCTORAL DISSERTATION

Supervisors: ProfessorEiraViikari-Juntura FinnishInstituteofOccupationalHealth Helsinki,Finland

DocentMariAntti-Poika UniversityofHelsinki Helsinki,Finland ProfessorKajHusman FinnishInstituteofOccupationalHealth Helsinki,Finland

Reviewers: DocentMarjaMikkelsson UniversityofTurkuand Päijät-HämeSocialandHealthCareGroup Lahti,Finland

ProfessorHannuVirokannas UniversityofOulu Oulu,Finland

Opponent: ProfessorSakariTola MutualPensionInsuranceCompanyVarma Helsinki,Finland

Page 5: Kari-Pekka Martimo - UEF · Kari-Pekka Martimo Musculoskeletal disorders, disability and work Kari-Pekka Martimo Musculoskeletal disorders (MSD) are the most important causes of temporary

3

ABSTRACT

Musculoskeletaldisorders(MSD)arethemostimportantcauseoftem-poraryworkdisabilityinFinland,andtogetherwithmentaldisorders,theyaccountforthemajorityofpermanentdisabilitypensions.Themostcommonmusculoskeletalproblemintheworkingpopulationislowbackpain(LBP),whichtogetherwithsomeupperextremitydisorders(UED)hasthestrongestscientificevidenceofallMSD,thatworkingconditionshavearoleintheaetiology.

Thisthesisconsistsoffivestudiesrepresentingthreepossibleap-proachestoreducingdisabilityduetoMSDatwork;preventionofthedisordersbyreducingtheirwork-relatedriskfactors(primarypreven-tion),preventionofdisabilityasaconsequenceoftheexistingMSD(secondaryprevention),andpreventionoftheexacerbationofdisability(secondaryandtertiaryprevention).Thestudiesexamineworkactivityasariskfactor,butalsoasanindicatorofthelevelofdisabilityandasanopportunityforrehabilitation.

Themethodsusedinprimarypreventiontochangeworkingroutinesarenotsupportedbyevidencegatheredinasystematicreviewshow-ingthatwidelyadaptedtraininginliftingtechniquesdoesnothelptopreventLBP.Earlierstudiesingeneralhaveshownonlymodesteffectsofwork-relatedinterventionsintheprimarypreventionofMSD.Intermsofsecondaryprevention,thecross-sectionalsurveyrevealedthatmanyworkerswithMSDconsiderthemselvesaspartiallyabletoworkinsteadofeithertotallyableorunable.Theyalsofrequentlyperceivetheirmusculoskeletalhealthproblemsasbeingrelatedtowork,andthebeliefwasshowntocorrelatewithself-assesseddisability.Manyworkers,however,considerthattherearepossiblechangesthatcouldbeinitiatedintheworkplacetogivethemsupportinworkingdespitetheirMSD.

Page 6: Kari-Pekka Martimo - UEF · Kari-Pekka Martimo Musculoskeletal disorders, disability and work Kari-Pekka Martimo Musculoskeletal disorders (MSD) are the most important causes of temporary

4

ABSTRACT

Accordingtoanothersurvey,medicallyverifiedUEDcausesignificantproductivitylossatwork,evenwhentheemployeesdonotneedsickleavebecauseofthesymptoms.ThislostproductivityisusuallynotincludedineconomicevaluationsoftheconsequencesofMSDatwork.IntheassessmentofemployeeswithMSD,productivitylossshouldbetakenintoconsiderationinadditiontocollectingdataonself-assessedwork-relatednessofthedisorder.Ifthedisordercannotbemedicallycured,thenthechallengeforallparties,i.e.theemployee,employerandhealthserviceprovider,istoaccommodateworkinordertoavoiddeteriorationofthesymptomsduetowork,and,ontheotherhand,impairmentofworkoutputbecauseofthesymptoms.

Earlyergonomicinterventiontogetherwithadequatemedicalcarerestoreddecreasedon-the-jobproductivityassociatedwithUEDbetterthanmedicalcarealone.Thisrandomisedcontrolledtrialaddstotherelativelyscarcebodyofworkontheeffectivenessofergonomicinterven-tions.TheresultsalsoencourageoccupationalhealthpersonneltotryforanearlyinteractionwiththesupervisorandtoanergonomicworksitevisitifUEDisthemaincomplaintoftheemployee.Comparedtoregularhealthcarepractices,thestudyinterventionwasinitiatedatanearlierstage.MostoftenintheacutephaseofMSD,apurelybiomedicalmodelofdisabilityisapplied.Onlywhenthedisabilitybecomesprolonged,aremorework-orientedactionstaken.Accordingtothepresentresults,however,ergonomicinterventionislesseffectivewhenappliedatamoreseverestageofUED.

BasedonthefindingthatpartialworkabilityiscommonamongemployeeswithMSD,thebeneficialeffectsofmodifiedworkonreturntoworkinearlierstudies,andthepositiveattitudestopart-timesickleavereportedinotherNordiccountries,arandomisedcontrolledtrialwasdesignedandinitiatedtocomparepart-timesickleaveandconven-tionalsicknessabsenceinthemanagementofMSD.Duringpart-timesickleave,theemployeeisadvisedandsupportedtocontinueworkingsothattherecoveryprocessisnotendangered,andbothworkingtimeandworktasksaremodifiedincollaborationwiththesupervisor.Theresultsofthistrialcanbeexpectedin2011.

ThisthesisshowsthatdisabilitycausedbyMSDcanbemanagedeffectively,especiallyintheoccupationalhealthservices.Despitetheevidencethatliftingadvicehasnoeffectivenessinprimaryprevention,

Page 7: Kari-Pekka Martimo - UEF · Kari-Pekka Martimo Musculoskeletal disorders, disability and work Kari-Pekka Martimo Musculoskeletal disorders (MSD) are the most important causes of temporary

5

ABSTRACT

thesecondstudydiddetectencouragingresultsatthelevelofsecondaryprevention.ThisapproachchallengesthemanagementofworkerswithMSDutilisingonlythebiomedicalmodel.Theresultsencouragetheadaptationofabiopsychosocialmodel,wherethemainfocusisshiftedfrompossibleanatomiccausestowardsmorecomplexsystemsofworkdisability.Inthismodel,theimportanceofstakeholderinteractions(forexample,family,supervisor,co-workers,employer,andinsurancecompany)isstressedtogetherwiththecrucialroleoftheindividual.

ThemajorityofbarriersandfacilitatorsofstayingatworkdespiteMSDarerelatedmoretopsychosocial,workplaceandmanagementissuesratherthantothephysicaldisorderitself.Therefore,thediseasediagnosisperspectiveinthemanagementofMSDhastobesupplementedbyadisabilitydiagnosis,byinvestigatingitscausalpsychosocialandenviron-mentalfactors.Theapproachsupportseffectivedisabilitymanagementstrategies,whichpreventunnecessarysicknessabsenteeismandallowemployeestoremainproductiveatworkdespiteMSD.

Page 8: Kari-Pekka Martimo - UEF · Kari-Pekka Martimo Musculoskeletal disorders, disability and work Kari-Pekka Martimo Musculoskeletal disorders (MSD) are the most important causes of temporary

6

YhTEENvETO

OhimeneväätyökyvyttömyyttäaiheuttavatSuomessaenitentuki-jaliikuntaelinsairaudet.Yhdessämielenterveyshäiriöidenkanssaneovatyleisinsyypysyviintyökyvyttömyyseläkkeisiin.Tavallisinliikuntaelinvai-vatyöikäisilläonalaselkäkipu.Kaikistaliikuntaelinvaivoistaselkäkivunjajoidenkinyläraajasairauksiensuhteenonenitennäyttöä,ettätyölläjatyöolosuhteillaonmerkitystänäidenvaivojensynnyssä.

Tämäväitöskirjakoostuuviidestäosatutkimuksesta,jotkaedustavatkolmeamahdollisuuttavähentääliikuntaelinsairauksistaaiheutuvaatyökyvynlaskua;ennaltaehkäisemällävaivojavähentämälläniidentyö-peräisiäriskitekijöitä(primaaripreventio),vähentämälläolemassaolevistavaivoistaaiheutuvaatyökyvynlaskua(sekundaaripreventio)sekäestä-mällätyökyvynlaskunpaheneminen(sekundaari-jatertiaaripreventio).Väitöskirjakäsitteleetyötoimintaariskitekijänä,muttamyöstyökyvynmittarinajakuntoutumismahdollisuutena.

Primaaripreventiossakäytetyttyöskentelytapoihinkohdistuneetmenetelmättulevatkyseenalaistetuiksitässätutkimuksessa.Järjestel-mällisessäkirjallisuuskatsauksessaosoitetaan,ettälaajaltikäytössäolevanostotekniikoidenopettamineneiautakaanehkäisemäänalaselkäkipuataakankäsittelyssä.Aikaisemmatkintutkimuksetovatyleensäosoitta-neet,ettätyöperäisilläinterventioillaonvainvaatimattomiavaikutuksialiikuntaelinvaivojenprimaaripreventiossa.Sekundaaripreventionosaltapoikittaistutkimuksessaosoitetaan,ettämonettyöntekijätovatmieles-täänliikuntaelinvaivastahuolimattaosittaintyökykyisiäsensijaan,ettäpitäisivätitseäänjokotäysintyökykyisinätaityökyvyttöminä.Heidänmielestäänliikuntaelinvaivatovatuseinmyöstyöperäisiä,millätutki-muksessaosoitetaanolevanyhteyttäitsearvioituuntyökyvynlaskuun.

Page 9: Kari-Pekka Martimo - UEF · Kari-Pekka Martimo Musculoskeletal disorders, disability and work Kari-Pekka Martimo Musculoskeletal disorders (MSD) are the most important causes of temporary

7

YHTEENVETO

Monientyöntekijöidenmielestätyöpaikallaonkuitenkinmahdolli-suuksiasellaisiinmuutoksiin,jotkaauttavatheitäselviytymääntyössäänliikuntaelinvaivastahuolimatta.

Toisenpoikkileikkaustutkimuksenmukaanlääkärintoteamaylä-raajavaivaaiheuttaamerkittäväätuottavuudenalenemaatyössämyössilloin,kuntyöntekijäeioleoireidenvuoksisairauslomantarpeessa.Tätätuottavuudenalenemaaeiyleensähuomioida,kunarvioidaanliikuntaelinvaivojenaiheuttamiataloudellisiaseurauksiatyössä.Lii-kuntaelinoireisentyöntekijäntutkimisessatulisihuomioidasairaudestaaiheutuvatuottavuudenlaskusamoinkuintyöntekijänomaarviovaivantyöperäisyydestä.Vaikkasairauttaeivoilääketieteellisestiparantaa,työn-tekijän,työnantajanjaterveydenhuollonyhteinenhaasteonmukauttaatyötäniin,ettävältetäänsekätyöstäaiheutuvaoireidenpaheneminenettäoireistajohtuvatyöntuloksenheikkeneminen.

Yhdistämällävarhaisiaergonomisiatoimenpiteitäasianmukaiseenlääketieteellisenhoitoonvoidaanpalauttaayläraajavaivoihinliittyväalen-tunuttyötuottavuusparemminkuinpelkällälääketieteellisellähoidolla.Tämäsatunnaistettukontrolloitututkimustukeetähänmennessävä-häistänäyttöäergonomistentoimenpiteidenvaikuttavuudesta.Tuloksetmyöskannustavattyöterveyshenkilöstöäolemaanvarhaisessavaiheessayhteydessäesimieheenjakäymääntyöpaikalla,mikälityöntekijänpää-ongelmaonyläraajavaiva.Verrattunaterveydenhuollontavanomaiseentoimintaantutkimuksentoimenpiteetaloitettiinvarhaisemmassavaihees-sa.Useimmitenliikuntaelinvaivanakuutinvaiheenhoidossasovelletaanvainpuhtaastilääketieteellistämallia.Vastakuntyökyvynlaskupitkittyy,ryhdytääntyöhönliittyviintoimenpiteisiin.Tulostenmukaanergono-misettoimenpiteetovatkuitenkinvähemmänvaikuttavia,josniihinryhdytäänvastayläraajavaivanmuututtuavakavammaksi.

Osittainentyökykyonyleistäliikuntaelinvaivoistakärsivillätyönteki-jöillä.Lisäksiaikaisemmintutkimuksissaonosoitettu,ettämukautetullatyöllävoidaannopeuttaatyöhönpaluutasairauslomanjälkeen.KunvielämuissaPohjoismaissaonkuvattumyönteistäsuhtautumistaosa-aikaiseensairauspoissaoloon,viidesosajulkaisukuvaasatunnaistetunkontrolloiduntutkimuksen,jossaverrataanosa-aikaistajaperinteistäsairauspoissaoloaliikuntaelinsairauksienhoidossa."Osasairausvapaan"aikanatyöntekijääohjataanjatuetaanjatkamaantyössääntoipumistavaarantamatta,kun

Page 10: Kari-Pekka Martimo - UEF · Kari-Pekka Martimo Musculoskeletal disorders, disability and work Kari-Pekka Martimo Musculoskeletal disorders (MSD) are the most important causes of temporary

8

YHTEENVETO

sekätyöaikaaettätyötehtäviämuokataanyhteistyössäesimiehenkanssa.Tämäntutkimuksentuloksetovatkäytettävissävuonna2011.

Tämäväitöskirjaosoittaa,ettäliikuntaelinvaivoistaaiheutuvaatyö-kyvynlaskuavoidaanhoitaatehokkaastierityisestityöterveyshuollossa.Vaikkatutkimustenmukaannosto-opetusprimaaripreventionaeiolevaikuttavaa,toinenosajulkaisuosoittaa,ettäsekundaaripreventiossasaadaankannustaviatuloksia.Tämähaastaapelkänlääketieteellisenmallinkäytönjakannustaabiopsykososiaalisenmallinhyödyntämiseenliikuntaelinvaivoistakärsivientyöntekijöidenhoidossa.Päähuomiosiirretäänmahdollisistarakenteellisistasyistäkohtityökyvyttömyyteenliittyviämonimutkaisempiajärjestelmiä,joissapainotetaansekäsosiaa-lisiavuorovaikutussuhteita(esim.perhe,esimies,työkaverit,työnantajajavakuutusyhtiö)ettäyksilönkeskeistäasemaa.

Suurinosaliikuntaelinvaivankanssatyössäjatkamisenesteistäjamahdollistajistaliittyyenemmänpsykososiaalisiintekijöihinsekätyöhönjajohtamiseenkuinfyysiseenvaivaansinänsä.Siksidiagnoosinlisäksiliikuntaelinvaivojenhoidossaontutkittavatyökyvyttömyyttäaiheuttaviajaylläpitäviäpsykososiaalisiajaympäristöönliittyviätekijöitä.Tämälähestymistapaluomahdollisuuksiatukeatyökykyä,välttäätarpeetonsairauspoissaolojaedesauttaatyöntekijöidentyössäjatkamistatuottavastiliikuntaelinvaivastahuolimatta.

Page 11: Kari-Pekka Martimo - UEF · Kari-Pekka Martimo Musculoskeletal disorders, disability and work Kari-Pekka Martimo Musculoskeletal disorders (MSD) are the most important causes of temporary

9

ACKNOWLEDgEMENTS

ThisthesisistheresultofmyworkconductedintheFinnishInstituteofOccupationalHealthstartingatthebeginningof2005.TheCentreofExpertise"HealthandWorkAbility"anditsteamof"Work-relatedDiseases"havebeenmybestpossibleschoolandsupportinmyaspira-tiontohigheracademiclevel.IamforevergratefultoDocentHelenaLiira,whoinitiallysuggestedthatIwouldcombineresearchandpracticalwork.IamalsothankfultotheFinnishInstituteofOccupationalHealththatmadeitpossibletotakethiscrucialstepintotheintriguingworldofmusculoskeletalresearch.

Themainprerequisitesforadoctoralstudenttosucceedarethesupervisors.IcouldneverhavemadethisstepwithoutProfessorEiraViikari-Juntura,whoalwayswasavailablewhenIneededher.Iadmirethepositiveenergyshecantransmiteveninsituationswhenherappro-priatecorrectionswerefollowedbyhoursofextrawork.Theeffortwasalwaysworthdoing,becausetheresultwasbothapersonallygratifyinglearningexperienceandamuchbetteroutcome.

Ialsooweverymuchtomyothersupervisors,DocentMariAntti-PoikaandProfessorKajHusman.Theybothhavebeenpersonallyveryimportanttome,notonlyduringthepresentendeavour.Bothcolleagueshavebeenmytutorsfromthebeginningofmycareerinthefieldofoc-cupationalhealth,andthereforewithoutthemIcouldnothavebecometheoccupationalhealthprofessionalthatIam.

WhatIappreciatemostinmycolleaguesandco-authorsistheteamspiritthatwehavesharedduringthepreparationoftheoriginalarticles.IamespeciallygratefultoJosVerbeek,MD,PhD,whotaughtmethefinessesoftheCochranemethodology,aswellastoProfessor

Page 12: Kari-Pekka Martimo - UEF · Kari-Pekka Martimo Musculoskeletal disorders, disability and work Kari-Pekka Martimo Musculoskeletal disorders (MSD) are the most important causes of temporary

10

ACKNOWLEDGEMENTS

JaroKarppinenandDocentEsa-PekkaTakala,fortheinspiringdiscus-sionsaroundmusculoskeletalresearch.IwanttothankalsoRahmanShiri,MD,PhD,forbeingalwaysreadytosharehisexpertiseinthestatisticalanalyses.IhavealsobeenveryluckytoworktogetherwithHelenaMiranda,MD,PhD,whoseideasaboutmusculoskeletalpainanditsmanagementhaveinspiredmenotonlytoincludetheminthescientificworks,butalsotoimplementtheminpracticeasanoc-cupationalphysician.

Icouldnothavedoneallthiswithoutmycolleaguesandco-authorsLeenaKaila-Kangas,JohannaKausto,RitvaKetola,MarttiRechardt,RitvaLuukkonen,MerjaJauhiainen,AndreaFurlan,andPaulKuijer.Iwanttoexpressmywarmestthankstothem,aswellastoProfessorHilkkaRiihimäki,whoneverfailedtogiveherpositiveencouragementtomeasajuniorresearcher.Another"seniorcitizen",whomIwishtothank,isDocentKirstiLaunis.Fromher,Ilearntthatsometimestheresultsarelimitedbythechosenmethod,and,therefore,researchisnotsimplylookingforthetruth,butrathertryingtofindthepathtothetruth.

Iamalsogratefultotheofficialreviewers,DocentMarjaMikkels-sonandProfessorHannuVirokannas,fortheirvaluablecommentsforimprovingthemanuscript,aswellastoEwenMacDonaldforrevisingthelanguage.

IthasbeenimportantthatIhavebeenabletosharemyworktimebe-tweenresearchandpracticalworkasanoccupationalphysician.Withoutthepositiveattitudeofmysupervisorsandemployers,firstAriHimmaatM-realCorp.andsubsequentlyTapioVirtaatMehiläinen,Icouldnothavehadtheopportunitytoconductthisacademicwork.Therefore,Iwanttoexpressmygratitudetobothofthem,withoutforgettingallthesupportthatIhavereceivedfrommycolleaguesatMehiläinenOc-cupationalHealthCare.

Sometimestheboundarybetweenworkandleisureisveryvague.Ihaveenjoyedenormouslythescientificdiscussions(andalsothelessscientificones)withJormaMäkitalo,MD,PhD,JuhaLiira,MD,PhD,andProfessorPeterWesterholm.Inaddition,SirkkuVuorma,MD,PhD,andDocentMattiHöyhtyäaremyoldestfriends,whosestepsIhavefollowedfirstinfolkdancingandtheninPhDstudies.Fortunately

Page 13: Kari-Pekka Martimo - UEF · Kari-Pekka Martimo Musculoskeletal disorders, disability and work Kari-Pekka Martimo Musculoskeletal disorders (MSD) are the most important causes of temporary

11

ACKNOWLEDGEMENTS

Ihavebeenblessedwithmanydearfriends,whohavesupportedmeinalltheirownways.Thankyouforthat!

Finally,thereasonforeverythingismyfamily,mymotherToini,fatherJaakko,andbrotherArto.IamalsothankfulformyextendedfamilyinVaasafortheirfriendship.Thelastandthewarmestthanksgotomypartner,Sami.YourloveandcareistheairthatIbreathe.Thisworkisdedicatedtoyou.

Helsinki, May 3, 2010

Kari-Pekka Martimo

Page 14: Kari-Pekka Martimo - UEF · Kari-Pekka Martimo Musculoskeletal disorders, disability and work Kari-Pekka Martimo Musculoskeletal disorders (MSD) are the most important causes of temporary

12

ABBREvIATIONS

CCT controlledclinicaltrial(nonrandomised)CI confidenceintervalCTS carpaltunnelsyndromeFIOH FinnishInstituteofOccupationalHealthGEE generalizedestimatingequationICF InternationalClassificationofDisability, FunctioningandHealthLBP lowbackpainMSD musculoskeletaldisordersOH(S) occupationalhealth(services)OR oddsratioQQ QuantityandQualitymethodRTW returntoworkRCT randomisedcontrolledtrialUED upperextremitydisordersWHO WorldHealthOrganisation

Page 15: Kari-Pekka Martimo - UEF · Kari-Pekka Martimo Musculoskeletal disorders, disability and work Kari-Pekka Martimo Musculoskeletal disorders (MSD) are the most important causes of temporary

13

LIST Of ORIgINAL PUBLICATIONS

I MartimoKP,VerbeekJ,KarppinenJ,FurlanAD,TakalaEP,KuijerPPFM,JauhiainenM,Viikari-JunturaE(2008).Effectoftrainingandliftingequipmentforpreventingbackpaininliftingandhandling:systematicreview.BMJ336(7641):429–31

II MartimoKP,VaronenH,HusmanK,Viikari-JunturaE(2007).Factorsassociatedwithself-assessedworkability.OccupMed(Lond)57(5):380–2.

III MartimoKP,ShiriR,MirandaH,KetolaR,VaronenH,Viikari-JunturaE(2009).Self-reportedproductivitylossamongworkerswithupperextremitydisorders.ScandJWorkEnvironHealth35(4):301–8.

IV MartimoKP,ShiriR,MirandaH,KetolaR,VaronenH,Viikari-JunturaE(2010).Effectivenessofanergonomicinterventiononproductivityofworkerswithupperextremitydisorders:–arandomisedcontrolledtrial.ScandJWorkEnvironHealth36(1):25–33.

V MartimoKP,Kaila-KangasL,KaustoJ,TakalaEP,KetolaR,RiihimakiH,LuukkonenR,KarppinenJ,MirandaH,Viikari-JunturaE(2008).Effectivenessofearlypart-timesickleaveinmusculoskeletaldisorders(Studyprotocol).BMCMusculoskel-etalDisorders9:23doi:10.1186/1471-2474-9-23

Page 16: Kari-Pekka Martimo - UEF · Kari-Pekka Martimo Musculoskeletal disorders, disability and work Kari-Pekka Martimo Musculoskeletal disorders (MSD) are the most important causes of temporary

14

CONTENTS

1.INTRODuCTION........................................................ 16

2.REVIEWOfCONCEpTS............................................... 19 2.1.Musculoskeletaldisorders........................................ 19 2.1.1.General...................................................... 19 2.1.2.Lowbackpain............................................. 19 2.1.3.upperextremitydisorders............................ 20 2.1.4.Work–relatedmusculoskeletaldisorders......... 21 2.2.Disability............................................................... 22 2.2.1.Biomedicalmodel........................................ 23 2.2.2.Biopsychosocialmodel................................. 24 2.2.3.Othermodels.............................................. 25 2.3.Disabilityandwork................................................. 26 2.3.1.Sicknessabsenteeism................................. 27 2.3.2.Sicknesspresenteeism (productivitylossatwork)............................ 29 2.3.3.Returntowork............................................ 31 2.3.4.Work–relatedinterventions........................... 31

3.pREVIOuSSTuDIESONMuSCuLOSKELETAL DISORDERS,DISABILITYANDWORK........................... 34 3.1.Work–relatedriskfactorsof musculoskeletaldisorders........................................ 34 3.1.1.Background................................................ 34 3.1.2.Lowbackpain............................................. 38 3.1.3.upperextremitydisorders............................ 41 3.1.4.Work–relatedinterventionsin preventingmusculoskeletaldisorders............. 44 3.2.Work–relatedriskfactorsofsicknessabsence............ 46 3.2.1.General...................................................... 46 3.2.2.Lowbackpain............................................. 47 3.2.3.upperextremitydisorders............................ 51 3.2.4.preventionofsicknessabsence causedbymusculoskeletaldisorders.............. 51 3.3.Work–relateddeterminantsofsicknesspresenteeism... 54 3.3.1.preventionofsicknesspresenteeism associatedwithmusculoskeletaldisorders...... 58 3.4.Determinantsofreturntowork................................ 59 3.4.1.Workerperceptionsandexpectations............. 60 3.4.2.Workenvironmentandworkorganisation....... 61 3.4.3.Roleofthemedicalprovider........................ 64

Page 17: Kari-Pekka Martimo - UEF · Kari-Pekka Martimo Musculoskeletal disorders, disability and work Kari-Pekka Martimo Musculoskeletal disorders (MSD) are the most important causes of temporary

15

CONTENTS

4.CONCEpTuALfRAMEWORKOfTHESTuDY................... 67

5.STuDYquESTIONSANDHYpOTHESES......................... 71

6.MATERIALANDMETHODS........................................... 73 6.1.Studypopulations.................................................. 73 6.2.Methods................................................................ 74 6.2.1.Systematicreview(StudyI)......................... 74 6.2.2.Surveys(StudiesII–III)............................... 75 6.2.3.Randomisedcontrolledtrials(StudiesIV–V)..... 77 6.3.Statisticalanalyses................................................. 79 6.3.1.Systematicreview(StudyI)......................... 79 6.3.2.Surveys(StudyII–III)................................. 79 6.3.3.Randomisedcontrolledtrials(StudiesIV–V).... 80

7.RESuLTS.................................................................. 82 7.1.Trainingandliftingdevicesforpreventing backpain(StudyI)................................................ 82 7.2.factorsassociatedwithself–assessed workability(StudyII)............................................. 86 7.3.Self–assessedproductivitylosscaused byupperextremitydisorders(StudyIII)................... 89 7.4.Effectivenessofanergonomicintervention onproductivityloss(StudyIV)................................. 92 7.5.Earlypart–timesickleavein musculoskeletaldisorders(StudyV)......................... 96

8.DISCuSSION............................................................ 97 8.1.Mainfindings......................................................... 97 8.1.1.primarypreventionoflowbackpain andrelateddisability................................... 97 8.1.2.factorsassociatedwithperceiveddisability...... 98 8.1.3.productivitylossasanindicatorofdisability..... 100 8.1.4.Secondarypreventionofdisability................. 101 8.1.5.Comparisonoftwodisability managementmethods................................. 102 8.2.Methodologicalconsiderations.................................. 103 8.2.1.Studydesigns............................................. 103 8.2.2.Studypopulations....................................... 106 8.3.Implicationsforfutureresearch............................... 108 8.4.policyimplicationsandrecommendations.................. 109 8.5.Conclusions........................................................... 111

REfERENCES...............................................................113

Page 18: Kari-Pekka Martimo - UEF · Kari-Pekka Martimo Musculoskeletal disorders, disability and work Kari-Pekka Martimo Musculoskeletal disorders (MSD) are the most important causes of temporary

16

1. INTRODUCTION

Oneofthemostcrucialaspectsoflifeishealth.Thisdoesnotmeanonlytheabsenceofsymptoms,illnessandmorbidity(WHO2001).Healthalsomaintainscapacitytoattainone’sowngoalsthroughtarget-orientedactions,i.e.,paidorunpaidwork.TheWorldHealthOrganisation(WHO)hasclassifiedhealthandfunctioningusingthreedifferentdo-mains:bodyfunctionsandstructures,activity(levelofcapacity;whatapersoncandoinastandardenvironment),andparticipation(levelofperformance;whatapersoncandointheirusualenvironment)(WHO2001).IntheInternationalClassificationofFunctioning,DisabilityandHealth(ICF),theterm“functioning”isusedtorefertoallbodyfunc-tions,activitiesandparticipation.Similarly,theterm“disability”referstoallimpairments,activitylimitationsandparticipationrestrictions.

Disabilityisexplainedas“somethingthatrestrictsorlimits”.There-fore,theFinnishtranslation“työkyvyttömyys”(workincapacity)fortheterm“workdisability”canbeconsideredasmisleading.Itreinforcesthefalseunderstandingthatworkdisabilityisadichotomousfactor,i.e.youhaveeitherfullcapacity(“työkykyinen”)oryouareentirelyincapacitated(“työkyvytön”).ThisisnotsupportedbyICF,whichviewsdisabilityandfunctioningasinteractionsbetweenhealthconditions(diseases,disor-dersandinjuries)andcontextualfactors(externalenvironmentalandinternalpersonalfactors)(figure1).Disabilityinvolvesdysfunctioningatoneormoreofthethreedomains(impairments,activitylimitations,andrestrictedparticipation).Restrictionsandbarrierstoperformanceoffunctionalactivitiesorrolesinwhichapersonengagesinthecontextofhisorherlifearealsoconsideredtohaveaninfluenceuponhealthoutcomesandthehealthrecoveryprocess.ICFhasutilizedabiopsycho-socialmodelofdisability(explainedinmoredetailsinchapter2.2.2.).

Page 19: Kari-Pekka Martimo - UEF · Kari-Pekka Martimo Musculoskeletal disorders, disability and work Kari-Pekka Martimo Musculoskeletal disorders (MSD) are the most important causes of temporary

17

1INTRODuCTION

Health condition

(disorder or disease)

Personal Factors

EnvironmentalFactors

Body Functions& Structure

ParticipationActivity

FigurE 1. interactions between the components of iCF (WHO 2001)

AccordingtoICF,thedisabilityprocessinitiatedbyahealthconditionisinfluencedbybothenvironmentalandpersonalfactors.Environmentalfactorscanincludesocialattitudes,architecturalcharacteristics,legalandsocialstructure,aswellasclimateandterrain.Thepersonalfactorsaregender,age,copingstyles,socialbackground,education,profession,pastandcurrentexperienceofhealthconditions,overallbehaviourpattern,personality,andotherfactorsthatinfluencetheperceptionofdisabilitybytheindividual.

Disabilitydoesnotmeantotallossoffunctioninginanyofthethreedomains.Despiteofamedicalcondition(forexample,seropositivityforHumanImmunodeficiencyvirus),apersonmaybefullyfunctionalinboththeactivityandparticipationdomains.Inaddition,andparticularlywithparticipation,restrictions(problemsanindividualmayexperienceininvolvementinlifesituations)canbeconsideredasproblemscreatedbyanunaccommodatingphysicalenvironmentasaresultofattitudesandotherfeaturesofthesocialenvironment.

Latelythepositiveeffectsofworkhavegainedincreasingattention(Waddelletal.2006).Workoftenplaysaroleinpromotingbothphysicalandmentalhealth:physicalactivity(forexample,work)isusuallyas-sociatedwithimprovementinphysicalcapacity,whilegoalachievement,

Page 20: Kari-Pekka Martimo - UEF · Kari-Pekka Martimo Musculoskeletal disorders, disability and work Kari-Pekka Martimo Musculoskeletal disorders (MSD) are the most important causes of temporary

18

1INTRODuCTION

socialinteractions,andself-realisationinworkaresourcesofsatisfactionandenhancedself-esteem(WHO1985).Therefore,insteadofleavingworklife,peoplewithdisabilitiesshouldbeencouragedtocontinueinemployment,providedthatworkisadaptedtohumangoals,capacitiesandlimitations,andoccupationalhazardsareundercontrol.

Page 21: Kari-Pekka Martimo - UEF · Kari-Pekka Martimo Musculoskeletal disorders, disability and work Kari-Pekka Martimo Musculoskeletal disorders (MSD) are the most important causes of temporary

19

2. REvIEW Of CONCEPTS

2.1. Musculoskeletal disorders

2.1.1. general

Themusculoskeletalsystemcomprisesofbonesandjointswiththeiradjacentstructures,aswellasmuscles,tendonsandligaments.Thisstudyisconcernedwithdisabilitycausedbyorassociatedwithmusculoskeletaldisorders(MSD).InFinland,MSDarethemostimportantcausesoftemporarydisability(lastinglessthanoneyear)(Kansaneläkelaitos2008).MSDalongwithrespiratoryinfectionsarethemostcommonreasonsfortheuseofprimaryhealthservices.Inaddition,MSDandmentaldisordersaccountforthemajorityofpermanentdisabilitypensionsinFinland.

”Disorder”inthisstudyreferstoanycomplaint,symptomordiseaseofthemusculoskeletalsystem.Complaintisanexplicithealthproblemexperiencedbyanindividual.Disease,ontheotherhand,isaclinicallyverifiableentitythatisdetectedinaclinicalexamination.Standardizedclinicalexaminationprotocolsformanycommonmusculoskeletalsymp-tomsareavailableinordertoachieveamorereliableandcomparablediagnosis(Sluiteretal.2001).

Lowbackpain(LBP)andupperextremitydisorders(UED)arescru-tinizedinthisthesis,sinceLBPisthemostcommonmusculoskeletalcauseofdisabilityandthereisstrongevidenceofwork-relatednessforbothUEDandLBP(Punnettetal.2004).

2.1.2. Low back pain

LBPisdefinedaspaininthelumbarand/orglutealregionwithorwith-outradiationtothelowerextremities.Itisoftencategorisedaccording

Page 22: Kari-Pekka Martimo - UEF · Kari-Pekka Martimo Musculoskeletal disorders, disability and work Kari-Pekka Martimo Musculoskeletal disorders (MSD) are the most important causes of temporary

20

2REVIEWOfCONCEpTS

tothedurationofthesymptoms:acutepainwithlessthan4–6weeks,sub-acutebetween4–6and8–12weeksandchronicaspainofmorethan8–12weeksofduration.However,"long-lasting"or"prolonged"shouldbepreferredinsteadof"chronic"inordertoavoidunnecessarylabellingoftheemployeewithLBPbeing"chronically"ill.

VariousdiagnosesandpathologicalconditionsmaymanifestwithLBP.However,theoverwhelmingmajorityofbackpaincasesremainnonspecific.About85 %ofpatientswithisolatedLBPinprimarycarecannotbegivenanyprecisepathoanatomicaldiagnosis,andtheassocia-tionbetweensymptomsandimagingresultsisweak(Deyoetal.2001).Inabout3 %ofcasesthereasonsforLBPareneoplasia,infection,visceralpainorsystemicdisease.

Despitethefactthatbackpainisnotalifethreateningcondition,itconstitutesamajorpublichealthproblemintheWesternindustrialisedsocieties.LBPaffectsalargenumberofpeopleeachyearandisthecauseofseverediscomfortandfinanciallosses(Maniadakisetal.2000).Oneimportantfeatureofworkerswithnonspecificbackpainisthatasmallproportionofcases(<10 %)accountsformostofthecosts(>70 %)(Dionneetal.2005).Duetoitshighprevalence,backpainisaleadingreasonforphysicianvisits,hospitalisationsandotherhealthandsocialcareserviceutilisation.

TheseverityandtypeofbackpainchangewithageeventhoughLBPiscommonalreadyinadolescenceandearlyadulthood(Mikkels-sonetal.1997).Itbecomesmoreseverearoundtheageof40,showingdifferentdevelopmentofnonspecificandradiatingLBP.Accordingtoalongitudinalstudyofarepresentativepopulation,moderateaswellasmajornonspecificLBPdeclineswithage,whereastheincidenceofmajorradiatingLBPincreaseswithage(Shirietal.2010).

2.1.3. Upper extremity disorders

SofttissueMSDoftheupperlimbandshoulderregioncompriseaheterogeneousgroupofconditionsrangingfromspecificupperlimbconditions,likedeQuervain'stenosynovitis,epicondylitis,rotatorcufftendinitis,andcarpaltunnelsyndrome(CTS),tonon-specificregionalpainsyndromes.Labelssuchas"repetitivestraininjury","cumulativetraumadisorder"and"work-relatedupperlimbpain"havebeenoften

Page 23: Kari-Pekka Martimo - UEF · Kari-Pekka Martimo Musculoskeletal disorders, disability and work Kari-Pekka Martimo Musculoskeletal disorders (MSD) are the most important causes of temporary

21

2REVIEWOfCONCEpTS

used(Walker-Boneetal.2005),butshouldbeappliedwithcaution,becausetheyalreadyincludeanassumptionoftheaetiologyofthedisorder.Inaddition,"non-specificforearmpain"hasbeenadoptedasthediagnosticlabelforpatientspresentingwithforearmpainwithoutphysicalsigns(Walker-Boneetal.2005;vanTulderM2007).SomeagreedsystemsofclassificationofUEDhavebeendevelopedtoimprovethequalityofepidemiologicalresearch(Harringtonetal.1998;Sluiteretal.2001;Helliwelletal.2003).

UEDarecommonintheworkforce.Inapopulation-basedstudyofFinnishadults,theprevalenceofaclinicallydiagnosedUEDwashighestforrotatorcufftendinitisandCTS(both3.8 %),followedbylateralepicondylitis(1.1 %),bicipitaltendinitis(0.5 %),andmedialepicondylitis(0.3 %)(Shirietal.2007).InFinland,1070work-relatedMSDwerereportedtotheregisterofwork-relateddiseasesin2007representing17 %ofallconfirmedorsuspectedoccupationaldiseases(Karjalainenetal.2009).Themostcommondiagnoseswererelatedtotheupperextremities;epicondylitis(halfofallcases),tenosynovitis,andCTS.

2.1.4. Work-related musculoskeletal disorders

MSDaremultifactorialintheirorigin,andwhenaffectingworkers,theycanbework-relatedinanumberofways:MSDmaybepartiallycausedbyadverseworkconditions;theymaybeaggravated,acceleratedorex-acerbatedbyworkplaceexposures;andtheymayimpairworkcapacity.Itisalsoimportanttorememberthatpersonalcharacteristics(includinggeneticfactors),aswellasenvironmentalandsocioculturalfactorsusu-allyplayaroleasriskfactorsforwork-relateddiseases(WHO1985).Inaddition,duetothehighprevalenceandrecurrenceratesofMSD(especiallyLBP),cautionhasbeenadvisedinrelatingthesedisordersexclusivelytotheworkplace(Werneretal.2009).

AccordingtotheFinnishWorkandHealthSurveyconductedin2006(Kauppinenetal.2007),28 %ofthe2229interviewedemployeesreportedlong-termorrecurrentphysicalorpsychologicalsymptomsthathadbeencausedorworsenedbyworkduringthelastmonth.Dependingonthelocationofthesymptoms,63–91 %ofthosewithmusculoskeletalsymptomsconsideredthemtoberelatedtowork.

Page 24: Kari-Pekka Martimo - UEF · Kari-Pekka Martimo Musculoskeletal disorders, disability and work Kari-Pekka Martimo Musculoskeletal disorders (MSD) are the most important causes of temporary

22

2REVIEWOfCONCEpTS

Asystematicreviewshowedthatpotentiallywork-relateddiseasesarecommoningeneralpractice(Weeversetal.2005).Highprevalenceratesofpotentiallywork-relateddiseaseswerefoundforLBP,neckpainandshoulderpain.AccordingtotheresultsofaNorwegiansurvey,themajorityofcaseswithMSDwereassessedasbeingwork-relatedbyboththestudyparticipantsandtheexperts:80 %versus65 %forpainintheneckorshoulderregionand78 %versus72 %forarmpain(Mehlumetal.2009).

IthasbeenarguedintheNetherlandsthattoolittleattentionispaidtothepossiblework-relatednessofhealthcomplaints,andthatthiscanbeamajorcauseofsicknessabsenceanddisability(Buijsetal.2005).Ifthephysicianscannotrelatethepatients’healthcomplaintstoworkfactors,theyareatriskofmakinganinadequateassessmentortheymaymisseffectivetherapeuticmeasures.Thiscanleadtounnecessarylongsicknessabsenceperiods,and,evenpossibly,permanentdisability.

2.2. Disability

Disabilityisstudiedinthisthesisfromtheperspectiveofproblemsintheparticipationatwork,“occupational/workdisability”.Theterm“dis-ability”,however,willbeusedforsimplicity.Thespecialfocusisontherelationofdisabilityandwork,howworkaffectstheemployee’shealthandfunctioningatwork,andhowamedicalconditioncanimpactontheemployee’sabilitytocontinueworking,payingspecialattentiontocontextual,personalandenvironmentalfactors.

Occupationalorworkdisabilityisusuallydefinedastimeoffwork,reducedproductivity,orworkingwithfunctionallimitationsasaresult(outcome)ofeithertraumaticornon-traumaticclinicalconditions(Schultzetal.2007b).

Theredoesnotexistonesinglemodelofdiagnosisandrehabilitationofpain-relatedoccupationaldisability,butmany,oftencompetingandconflicting,modelscurrentlyexist.Thecoreissueistoselecttherightmodelfortherightservicerecipientattherighttime.

Inthecontextofworkdisability,observationalstudieshavedem-onstratedthatadversedisabilityoutcomesareinextricablylinkedwithcommunicationfailuresbetweentheemployeeandthecareprovider,and

Page 25: Kari-Pekka Martimo - UEF · Kari-Pekka Martimo Musculoskeletal disorders, disability and work Kari-Pekka Martimo Musculoskeletal disorders (MSD) are the most important causes of temporary

23

2REVIEWOfCONCEpTS

descriptionofsuccessfulprogrammesoftenciteeffectiveorimprovedcommunicationasanimportantelementintheirsuccess(Pranskyetal.2004).Therefore,effectivecommunicationcanbeseenasaprerequisiteforsuccess,regardlessofthespecificapproachtodisabilitymanagementandprevention.

2.2.1. Biomedical model

Thebiomedical model (alsocalledasthe"diseaseparadigm")isthepre-dominantframeworkusedbyalargegroupofhealthcareprofessionalsasmosthealthcaresystemsarestillbasedonapurelymedicalmodelofillnessandinjury.Inthismodel,illnessisconsideredtobeaconse-quenceoftheill-functioningofthehumanorganismasa"biologicalmachine",andthediseaseisdescribedasalinearsequencefromcausefactortopathology,tosymptomsormanifestations(Schultzetal.2000).Thesecondtenetofthebiomechanicalmodelholdsthatsymptomsanddisabilityaredirectlyrelatedto,andproportionateto,theseverityofbiologicalpathology.Thereforeaccordingtothistheory,eliminationofpathologicalcauseswillinevitablyresultincureorimprovement.Interventionstudiesemployingthisapproachhavefocusedontheroleofspecificmedicaltreatmentsorclinicalapproachesintendedtopreventprolongeddisability(Pranskyetal.2004).

Communicationinthebiomedicalmodelisoftenunidirectional(physiciantoemployerandpatient),notinteractive,asphysiciansissuedefinitivepronouncementsaboutcause,diagnosisandfunction.Inad-dition,patientsusuallyadheretothebiomedicalmodeldiffusedinthemedia,meaningthattheirexpectationsmaybeinconsistentwithothermodelsthatwouldbestsuittheircondition(Loiseletal.2005).

Consideringthecomplexnatureofpain,solelyfocussingonbiomedi-calpathologyresultsinalackofconsiderationofthemultidimensionalnatureofthephenomenon,thevarietyofreactionstopain,andthechangingnatureofinjuryandpainovertime(Schultzetal.2000).Thisexclusiveattentiononobjectivelyidentifiedpathologynegatestheim-portanceofpatient-centredmeasuresofpain,symptomsanddisability."Objective"measuresofpathology,however,havebeenshowntopredictdisabilityratherpoorly,andapathophysiologicalexplanationcannotbeofferedinallMSD.Thesearchforwhatisusuallyanelusive"medi-

Page 26: Kari-Pekka Martimo - UEF · Kari-Pekka Martimo Musculoskeletal disorders, disability and work Kari-Pekka Martimo Musculoskeletal disorders (MSD) are the most important causes of temporary

24

2REVIEWOfCONCEpTS

calexplanation"ofpaininmostcasesprolongsthediagnosticprocessneedlessly.Asaresult,thismodel,whenappliedtononspecificpainconditions,canincreasechronicityandhumansufferingandimposeafinancialburdenonhealthcareandcompensationsystems.

Forthosekindsofinjuriesandillnesseswherehealingprocessesarehighlypredictableandtheriskofre-injuryislow(minorlacerations,trauma,orfractures),thebiomedicalmodelperformswell(Pranskyetal.2004).Thismodelisrelevantwithrespecttomedicaldecisionmaking,particularlywithregardtouncomplicated,physicalinjuriesorpainorbothinitsacutestages,aswellasintheidentificationofmedical"redflags",i.e.,rulingoutofseriousmedicalconditions,suchastumours,infectionsandfractures(Schultzetal.2000).

2.2.2. Biopsychosocial model

Fromanepidemiologicalperspective,itappearsthatnon-clinicalfac-torsaremorelikelythanclinicalatexplaininglong-termdisabilitycases(Loisel2009).Therefore,itisnotaquestionofimprovingclinicalcareinordertoachievebettertreatmentresults.Thebiopsychosocial approachhasbeenmodifiedinmanydifferentformsandisgenerallythemostcommonlyconsideredandconsensualframeworkforunderstandingthemultidimensionalaspectsofmanyhealthproblems(Schultzetal.2007b).Thebiopsychosocialmodelrecognizesthattherelationshipsbetweenpain,physicalandpsychologicalimpairment,functionalandsocialdis-abilityarefarfromsimple;painandresponsetoMSDarecomplexandinteractingphenomena(Schultzetal.2000).Thisapproachdemandsaconceptualshiftfromthelinearwayofthinkingofthebiomedicalmodeltoanopensystemperspective.

Researchonthistopichasyieldedsubstantialevidenceonthede-terminantsofworkdisability.Thesedeterminantscanbelinkedtotheworker(personal),workplacedesignororganisation(workplace-related),healthcaresystem,compensationsystemorthenatureofthelocalcultureandsociety(Loisel2009).Theparadigmshiftfromabiomedicaltoabiopsychosocialmodelofdisabilitytransfersresponsibilityforoutcomesfromthehealthcareprovider-patientrelationshiptoamulti-playerdeci-sion-makingsystemwhichisinfluencedbycomplexprofessional,legal,administrative,andcultural(societal)interactions(Loiseletal.2005).

Page 27: Kari-Pekka Martimo - UEF · Kari-Pekka Martimo Musculoskeletal disorders, disability and work Kari-Pekka Martimo Musculoskeletal disorders (MSD) are the most important causes of temporary

25

2REVIEWOfCONCEpTS

Basedontheprinciplesofthebiopsychosocialmodel,inthecase management model,theclientisanactiveparticipantintherehabilita-tionprocess,andtherehabilitationteamonlyfacilitatesthisprocess(Schultzetal.2000).Thetherapeuticfocusistherestorationoffullfunction,notsymptomremovalor"cure",andtherestorationofemploymentstatuswithminimaldelayisoneofthemajorgoalsoftreatment(Schultzetal.2000).Earlyinterventiondesignedtorestorephysicalorrolefunction,increaseactivitylevels,andtoachieveworkmaintenanceorworkre-entryisconsideredtoexpeditethereturntowork(RTW)process.

Casemanagementisessentialwhentheclient'streatmenthastobecoordinated,plannedandmonitored.Thisemphasisstemsfromthebeliefthatthelongerthepainanddisabilitypersist,themoredifficulttheywillbetotreat.Thereforeidentificationofthosefactorsthatpredictpoorprognosisforcontinueddisabilityandidentificationofthoseworkersathighriskforcontinuedworkdisabilityareimportantcomponentsofearlyintervention(Schultzetal.2000).

2.2.3. Other models

Themajortenetoftheinsurance model (alsocalledasforensic,compensa-tionorthe"perverseincentives"model)isthatclaimantswhoanticipatefinancialbenefitsthroughcompensation,pendinglitigation,specialservicesorconsiderations,suchasjobtransferorreducedworkload,arelikelytobedishonestabouttheirsymptoms(Schultzetal.2000).Thereisastrongmoralisticelementinthismodelwhereitisnecessarytoclearlydifferentiatebetween"honest"and"dishonest"claimants.Theinsurancemodelnurturesaclimatewhereintheclaimantmustvigorouslyproveandproveagainhisorherdisabilitywithobjective,verifiable,repeatablemedicalevidenceofimpairment.

Anothersubgroupofthemedicalmodelisthepsychiatric modelwiththebasictenetthatpainiseitherorganicorpsychologicalinitsorigin(Schultzetal.2000).Painthatcannotbeattributedtophysicalcausesmustbepsychological,andpatientswithundiagnosed,intractablepainareapsychologicallyhomogenousgroup.Thediagnosisofamentaldisordercanentitleapatienttoreceiveservicesandbenefitsthatmightnototherwisehavebeenavailable.However,thepsychiatricframework

Page 28: Kari-Pekka Martimo - UEF · Kari-Pekka Martimo Musculoskeletal disorders, disability and work Kari-Pekka Martimo Musculoskeletal disorders (MSD) are the most important causes of temporary

26

2REVIEWOfCONCEpTS

forpainhasproventobeineffectiveforrehabilitationandcanbediag-nosticallymisguiding(Schultzetal.2000).

Thephysical rehabilitation modelcanalsoberelatedtothebiomedi-calmodel,becauseitsfocusindisabilitymanagementandpreventionstrategiesisonimprovedphysicalconditioning(Pranskyetal.2004).ThismodelassumesthatRTWoutcomescanbeimprovedbymuscle-strengtheningexercisesinaclinicalorworkplacesettingthatsimulatesactualworkingconditions.Onelimitationofthismodel,however,isthatworkenvironmentsmaybedifficulttosimulateespeciallywhen,inreallife,psychosocialandorganisationalfactorsaresignificantcontributorstodisability(Pranskyetal.2004).Inaddition,thetraditionalrehabili-tationmodelseemsone-sided:disabilitymanagementsimplyfocusesonimprovingworkercapabilitiestomatchjobdemandswithoutanythoughtofredesigningormodifyingjobstomatchworkerlimitations.

Ajob-match modelfordisabilitymanagementusesananalyticalstrat-egytoassessthematchbetweenanindividualwithfunctionallimitationsandaparticularjob(Pranskyetal.2004).Thismodelmayproveusefulforworkplaceaccommodationeffortswherebiomechanicalrequirementsareuniform,andergonomicrisksarerelativelyeasytodefine(forexample,assembly-lineworkers,keyboardoperators).Thisapproachassumesthattheworkercapabilitiesareeasilyquantifiedinrelationtojobtasks,allphysicaldemandsarecapturedbyphysicalmeasures,andthatdemandsarestaticovertime.Theseassumptionsarerarelyrealisticinthemodernworkenvironment.Inaddition,thejob-matchmodeldoesnotaddresspsychosocialfactorsorhowanemployee-jobmismatchistranslatedintotheappropriateaccommodation(Pranskyetal.2004).

2.3. Disability and work

Theprocessoffallingill,beingabsentfromwork,recoveringandthenreturningtoworkhasbeenrepresentedschematically(EuropeanFoun-dationfortheImprovementofLivingandWorkingConditions1997).Theonsetofdisabilityisviewedintermsofanimbalancebetweenthepersonandtheenvironment(figure2).Dependingontheopportunityandneedforabsenteeism("absenteeismbarrier"),healthproblemsmayresultinabsenteeismandincapacitytowork.RTWdependsonthe

Page 29: Kari-Pekka Martimo - UEF · Kari-Pekka Martimo Musculoskeletal disorders, disability and work Kari-Pekka Martimo Musculoskeletal disorders (MSD) are the most important causes of temporary

27

2REVIEWOfCONCEpTS

courseoftheillnessandthe"reintegrationbarrier",whichreferstothetotalityoffactorswhichaffectthecourseoftheillnessandRTW.Thiswholeprocessisinfluencedbyindividualfactors,companyandworkplacefactors,aswellasfactorspertainingtothesurroundingsociety.

Thedefinitionsofdurationofoccupationaldisabilityrangefromcumulative,asinthedurationofalldayslostfromworkstartingwiththedateoftheonsetofsymptoms,throughcategorical,forexampleRTWstatus(yes/no),tocontinuous,suchastimetoRTW.Inaddition,predictorsofdisabilityandpredictorsofRTWoftendiffer(Schultzetal.2007b).

2.3.1. Sickness absenteeism

Whenamedicalconditionissevereenoughitimpedesjobperformancetothedegreethattheemployeeisnotabletocontinueworkingbecauseofexcessivelylowfunctionalcapacityinrelationtotheexplicitorimplied

CapacityAbsenteeism

barrierreintegration

barrier

BalanceHealth

problemsreturn to

workAbsence of

work

Workload

individual factors

company/workplace factors

societal factors

FigurE 2. The process of becoming ill, being absent from work, recovering and return to work (European Foundation for the improvement of Living and Working Conditions 1997)

Page 30: Kari-Pekka Martimo - UEF · Kari-Pekka Martimo Musculoskeletal disorders, disability and work Kari-Pekka Martimo Musculoskeletal disorders (MSD) are the most important causes of temporary

28

2REVIEWOfCONCEpTS

jobdemands.Otherreasonsforabsencefromworkarethattheexposureatworkmakesthesymptomsworseormedicalcareandrehabilitationrequiresthattheemployeecannotbepresentatwork.Whentheemployeeabstainsfromworkingbecauseofadisablingmedicalcondition,thisiscalledsick-nessabsence(orsickleave),andthephenomenonsicknessabsenteeism.

Sicknessabsenceismeasuredbyaskingtheemployeehowmuchtimeheorshehasmissedfromworkbecauseofillhealth.Theotherandmorereliablealternativeistorelyonstatisticscollectedbyemployersonhowmuchtimetheemployeeshavebeenabsentfromworkbecauseofillness.Ifthestatisticsarenotavailable,self-reporteddatahavebeenfoundtobereliableandvalid,whentherecallperiodsareshort(i.e.,1–2weeks)(Mattkeetal.2007).Evenwhentherecallperiodisuptooneyear,theagreementbetweenthenumberofself-reportedandthenumberofrecordedsicknessabsencedaysisrelativelygood(Ferrieetal.2005;Vossetal.2008).Iftherecallperiodsarelonger,theresultsneedtobeviewedwithcaution.

Thefollowingbasicmeasureshavebeensuggestedforassessingsickleaves:frequency(totalnumberofsickleaveperiods/allemployees),length(sick-leavedays/sick-listedpersons), incidence(newspells/(numberofemployeesxnumberofdaysminusallsick-leavedays)),cumulativeincidence(numberofemployeeswithsickleaveperiods/allemployees),andduration(sick-leavedays/sickleaveperiods)(Hensingetal.1998).Itisalsobeneficialtoseparateshortandlongtermabsenceperiods,asonlymedicallycertified(longterm)absenceshavebeenshowntoserveasaglobalmeasureofhealth,butnotshortselfcertifiedabsences(Kivimäkietal.2003).

InalargeprospectivecohortstudywithFinnishmunicipalemploy-ees,themeasuresofsicknessabsence(longtermabsenceperiodsandsickdays)wereshowntobestrongpredictorsofallcausemortalityandmortalityduetocardiovasculardisease,cancer,alcoholrelatedcauses,andsuicide(Vahteraetal.2004).Medicallycertifiedabsencesduetocirculatorydiseases,surgicaloperations,andpsychiatricdiagnoses(butnotMSD)wereassociatedwithincreasedmortalityalsoamongBritishcivilservants(Headetal.2008).

InasurveyamongFinnishlabourunionmembers(Böckermanetal.2009),absenteeismcausedbyanyreasonwaspositivelyassociatedwithparticipationinshiftorperiodwork,whereasregularovertime

Page 31: Kari-Pekka Martimo - UEF · Kari-Pekka Martimo Musculoskeletal disorders, disability and work Kari-Pekka Martimo Musculoskeletal disorders (MSD) are the most important causes of temporary

29

2REVIEWOfCONCEpTS

wasassociatedwithlesssicknessabsenteeism.Thepossibilitytostayathomeuptothreedayswithoutanycertificatewasnotassociatedwithanyincreaseinsicknessabsenteeism.

2.3.2. Sickness presenteeism (productivity loss at work)

Healthdisordersdonotcausemerelyabsencefromwork,butalsode-creasedon-the-jobperformancewhileatwork,whichiscalled"sicknesspresenteeism".Theshorterterm"presenteeism"willbeusedinthistexttodescribeproductivitylossatworkduetoMSD,evenifpresenteeismcanalsobecausedbyfactorsotherthanhealth(forexample,organisa-tionaldysfunctionordistractingdomesticproblems).Asystematicreviewcovering37studiesconcludedthatseveralhealthconditions,suchasasthmaandallergies,aswellashealthriskfactors,likeobesityandphysi-calinactivity,areassociatedwithpresenteeism(Schultzetal.2007a).

However,themeasurementofproductivityanditslossatworkisdifficult.Insomeprofessions,liketelephonecustomeroperators,pro-ductivitycanbemeasuredobjectivelyusingkeystrokesorthenumberofreceivedtelephonecallsastheindicator.Ontheotherhand,particu-larlyininformationandservice-typeoccupationstheoutputatworkisdifficulttoquantify.Therefore,amultitudeofworkplaceproductivitymeasurementinstrumentshavebeencreatedandevaluated(Mattkeetal.2007).Nonetheless,themostcommonapproachofmeasuringpresenteeismisassessmentofperceivedimpairment,accomplishedbyaskingemployeeshowmuchtheirillnesseshindertheminperformingcommonmental,physical,andinterpersonalactivitiesandinmeetingjobdemands(Mattkeetal.2007).

Theconsequencesofpresenteeismhavebeenstudiedfromtheor-ganisationalaswellasfromtheindividualperspective.IntheNorthAmericanliterature,thefocushasbeenonhealthandproductivityasabusinessstrategy(Goetzeletal.2007).Thisapproachisbasedonthefindingthathealth-relatedproductivitycostsaresignificantlygreaterthanmedicalorpharmacycostsalone(onaverage2.3to1),andthatchronicconditionssuchasdepression/anxiety,obesity,arthritis,andback/neckpainareespeciallyimportantcausesofproductivityloss(Loeppkeetal.2009).Sinceemployersaretheultimatepurchasersofhealthcareservices

Page 32: Kari-Pekka Martimo - UEF · Kari-Pekka Martimo Musculoskeletal disorders, disability and work Kari-Pekka Martimo Musculoskeletal disorders (MSD) are the most important causes of temporary

30

2REVIEWOfCONCEpTS

forthemajorityofemployeesintheUnitedStates,thesefindingshavepromptedemployerstodevelopandevaluatethecost-effectivenessofhealthandproductivityinterventions.

IntheEuropeanliterature,moreattentionhasbeenpaidtothecon-sequencesofpresenteeismattheindividuallevel,basedonthefindingsthat63–83 %ofemployeesreportedhavingworkeddespiteillnessonatleastoneoccasionduringthepreviousyear(Bergströmetal.2009).Sicknesspresenteeismseemstobemoresensitivetoworktimearrange-mentsthansicknessabsenteeism,eventhoughthedirectionofcausalitycouldnotbeexploredinacross-sectionalstudy(Böckermanetal.2009).

AccordingtoaSwedishreviewonsicknessabsenteeismandpresentee-ism,nostudieswerefoundontheconsequencesofsicknesspresenteeismfortheindividual(SBU2004).Productivityloss,however,iscommonbothbeforeandafterperiodsofsicknessabsence(Brouweretal.2002).Perhapsthereforepresenteeismhasbeenassociatedwithmoresicknessabsenteeisminseveralstudies.ASwedishprospectivestudy(Bergströmetal.2009)concludedthatworkingdespitethefactthattheemployeefeltthatsickleaveshouldhavebeentakenwasastatisticallysignificantrisk(relativerisk1.4–1.5)forfuturesickleaveofmorethan30days.Inthesamestudy,however,takingsickleaveduringthebaselineyearwasanevengreaterriskfactorforfuturesickleave;relativeriskwas1.5–5.4dependingonthenumberofdaysonsickleave.Therefore,sickleavemaynotbeanalternativetosicknesspresenteeism,iffuturesicknessabsenteeismistobeprevented.

Alargeprospectivecohortstudywitha3-yearfollow-upamongBrit-ishcivilservantsshowedthattheincidenceofseriouscoronaryeventswastwiceashighamongemployeeswhodidnottakesickleavedespitepoorperceivedhealthatbaseline,comparedtothose"unhealthy"employeeswithmoderatelevelsofsicknessabsenteeism(Kivimäkietal.2005).Thisphenomenonhasbeenlaterstudiedthoughithasnotbeenpossibletodetectanyevidencethatworkingwhileillwouldactasashort-termtriggerforcoronaryevents(Westerlundetal.2009).Accordingtotheauthors,twopotentialexplanationsremain.Workingwhileillmightcontributetoacumulativepsychologicalburdenwithpathophysiologicconsequences,orthatsicknesspresenteeism,insteadofbeingacausalagent,isonlyamarkerofalifestyleinwhichsymptomsareignoredandmedicalcareisnotsought(Westerlundetal.2009).

Page 33: Kari-Pekka Martimo - UEF · Kari-Pekka Martimo Musculoskeletal disorders, disability and work Kari-Pekka Martimo Musculoskeletal disorders (MSD) are the most important causes of temporary

31

2REVIEWOfCONCEpTS

2.3.3. Return to work

RTWcanbeconceptualisedasthe"process"ofreturninganinjuredworkertowork(forexample,graduatedRTWorjobaccommodation)orasthemeasurablefinalcommonoutcomeofdisability:thestatusofworkingornotworking(Schultzetal.2007b).RTWasanoutcomemayinvolvereturntothepre-injuryemployerorthepre-injuryjob,withorwithoutaccommodation(Schultzetal.2007b).Consequently,theperspectiveson,andmeasurementsof,RTWinresearchandpracticevarywidelyanddependonthestakeholdersinvolvedintheevaluationprocess.

Insteadoffocusingonthecharacteristicsofworkdisability,themainemphasisshouldbeontheactionsassociatedwithsuccessfulworkre-sumption.Therefore,RTWhasbeenpresentedasanevolvingprocesscomprisingoffourkeyphases:offwork,workre-entry,retention,andadvancement(Youngetal.2005).TheendofeachRTWphasemarkstheachievementofimportantRTWoutcomes:theabilitytoattemptworkre-entry,theabilitytoperformsatisfactorily,theabilitytomaintainemployment,andtheabilitytoadvanceinone'scareer.

SicknessabsenteeismandRTWaredependentoneachother;disabilitycanbemeasuredbothasprolongedsickleaveanddelayedRTW.Therefore,itissometimesdifficulttodifferentiatewhetherthestudyhasbeenconcernedwithsicknessabsenteeismorRTW.Inthisthesis,thestudieshavebeencategorisedaccordingtothemainout-comemeasure;thelengthofsicknessabsenceorsuccessfulRTW.Theformerstudiesarelabelledasstudiesonsicknessabsenteeism,andthelatterasstudiesonRTW.

2.3.4. Work-related interventions

Thedefinitionof"work-relatedintervention"usedinthisthesishasbeenadoptedfromarecentCochranereviewoninterventionsfocusingonchangesintheworkplaceorequipment,workdesignororganisation(includingworkingrelationships),workingconditionsorworkingenvi-ronment,andoccupational(case)managementwithactivestakeholderinvolvementof(atleast)theworkerandtheemployer(vanOostrometal.2009).

Page 34: Kari-Pekka Martimo - UEF · Kari-Pekka Martimo Musculoskeletal disorders, disability and work Kari-Pekka Martimo Musculoskeletal disorders (MSD) are the most important causes of temporary

32

2REVIEWOfCONCEpTS

AccordingtoColeetal(Coleetal.2003),workplaceinterventionstoreducemechanicalexposurescanbeexecutedateightdifferentlevels:

1. Businesssector(forexample,ergonomicbestpractices)2. Organisationorcompany(forexample,ergonomicpolicy,audit)3. Plantorworkplace(forexample,ergonomicchangeteams)4. Lineordepartment(forexample,reorganisedflow)5. Workgroup(forexample,safetyclimatetraining,jobrotation)6. Job(forexample,jobenlargement,regularbreaks)7. Worker(forexample,ergonomictraining,workstationadjustment)8. Taskortool(forexample,sharpeningimprovements,newtrimming

tools,liftassists)

HealthcareactivitiesaimedatpreventingMSDandrelateddisabil-itycanbedividedintothreetheoreticalcategories(NationalResearchCouncilandInstituteofMedicine2001).Primary preventionoccurswhentheinterventionisundertakenbeforeworkersatriskhaveacquiredaconditionofconcern,forexample,educationalprogramstoreducethenumberofnewcases(incidence)ofLBP.Secondary preventionoccurswhentheinterventionisundertakenafterindividualshaveexperiencedtheconditionofconcern,forexample,introductionofjobredesignforworkerswithsymptomsofCTS.TertiarypreventionstrategiesaredesignedforindividualswithchronicallydisablingMSD;thegoalistoachievemaximalfunctionalcapacitywithinthelimitationsofthatindividual'simpairments.

Similarthree-levelapproachhasbeenintroducedtodisabilityman-agement,inwhichthemainfocusisnotontheclinicalsymptomsbutonrelateddisability(Loisel2009):(A)Primarypreventionconsistsoflookingatthework-relatedfactorsinordertopreventnotonlysymp-tomsordisordersbutalsorelateddisability;(B)Secondarypreventionincludespayingattentiontotheworkerswithsymptomsordisorders,andinstigating actionstohelptheseworkersrecoverorimprovetheirworkingsituationinsteadofsickleaveorlowerproductivityatworkduetohealthproblems;(C)Tertiarydisabilitypreventionisconceptualisedbyinterventionsthatpreventunnecessaryprolongationofsicknessab-senteeismandsupportsafeRTW.

Page 35: Kari-Pekka Martimo - UEF · Kari-Pekka Martimo Musculoskeletal disorders, disability and work Kari-Pekka Martimo Musculoskeletal disorders (MSD) are the most important causes of temporary

33

2REVIEWOfCONCEpTS

Organisationalexperimentstoimproveoccupationalhealthareusu-allyregardedaslaboratory-basedexperimentsinthenaturalsciences,evenifinorganisationstheconditionsaretotallydifferent.Theprerequisitesoftemporalpriority,controloverimportantvariables,andrandomal-locationofsubjectstotreatmentorcontrolgroupsareusuallyhardtofulfil(Griffiths1999).Intheircomprehensivereviewoninterventionstoreducework-relatedMSD(Silversteinetal.2004),SilversteinandClarkereportedthatitwasextremelydifficulttorandomiseengineeringcontrolsinmultipleworkplaces,andmucheasiertorandomisepersonalbehaviour(exercise,education,medicaltreatment).Manystudieshavebeenconfrontedwithchangesinworkplacesthatareunplannedbytheresearchersandbeyondtheircontrol.Stableworkplaceswithlargenum-bersofworkersperformingthesameworkarelargelyathingofthepast.

Quiteevidentlytheavailableresearchondisabilityismethodologi-callydifferentfromtheepidemiologicalstudiesonoccupationalrisksofMSD.Thelatterarescientificallymorerigorousinconfirmingcause-and-effectrelationshipsandallowingprediction.Studiesondisability,however,includelesstangiblefactors,suchasthedesign,management,andorganisationofwork,whereitisunrealistictoexpectthattherewouldbeanaturalscientificparadigmtoexplainthesehighlycomplex,constantlychangingsystemsandtopredictthespecificeffectsonindi-vidualbehaviourandhealth(Griffiths1999).Thishasledtothefactthatstudiesondisabilityhaveappliednotonlyquantitativebutalsomorequalitativemethodologies.

Page 36: Kari-Pekka Martimo - UEF · Kari-Pekka Martimo Musculoskeletal disorders, disability and work Kari-Pekka Martimo Musculoskeletal disorders (MSD) are the most important causes of temporary

34

3. PREvIOUS STUDIES ON MUSCULOSKELETAL DISORDERS, DISABILITY AND WORK

Thefollowingreviewisdescriptiveandprimarilybasedontheresultsofrecentlypublishedreviewsgatheredfromthemainoccupationalhealth(OH)journals.Inaddition,selectedindividualstudieshavebeenincludediftheyhavebeenpublishedrecently,ortheyareconsideredespeciallyinterestinginthecontextofthisthesis.

3.1. Work-related risk factors of musculoskeletal disorders

3.1.1. Background

Athoroughcomprehensionofthecausalassociationbetweenoccupa-tionalexposuresandMSDisnecessaryifonewishestoestablishoc-cupationalguidelinesfortheprimarypreventionofMSD,toidentifypotentialworkmodificationsforthesecondaryprevention,andtopro-videguidanceforthestakeholdersinvolvedintheprocessoflong-termdisability.This,however,isnotasimpletasktoaccomplish.

Epidemiologicalresearchreliesupontheuseofdiagnosticcriteriacapableofseparatingstatesofdiseasewithdifferentcauses,prognosis,orresponsetotreatment(Walker-Boneetal.2005).Inmoststudiesonbackpain,theoperationalisationbasedonthesymptomreportingdoesnotallowexaminationoftheriskfactorsfordifferentgroupsofbackpain,classifiedbasedoncharacteristicssuchastheduration,frequency,

Page 37: Kari-Pekka Martimo - UEF · Kari-Pekka Martimo Musculoskeletal disorders, disability and work Kari-Pekka Martimo Musculoskeletal disorders (MSD) are the most important causes of temporary

35

3pREVIOuSSTuDIESONMuSCuLOSKELETALDISORDERS,DISABILITYANDWORK

intensity,andlocalisationofthepain(Hoogendoornetal.1999).LatelyaDelphiconsensusprocesswasusedinordertoreachasubstantialagree-mentonLBPoutcomesthatwouldbecombinableintoameta-analysis(Griffithetal.2007).

ManystudiesinthefieldofMSDarecross-sectionalsurveysrelyingonself-reportedsymptomsastheindicatorsofMSD.Thisapproachhastwomajoraspectswhichneedtobetakenintoconsideration.First,theweaknessincross-sectionalstudiesisthedifficultytodistinguishcauseandeffect,aswellasriskfactorsthatprolong(andnotcause)thedisorder.Second,thedeterminantsofspecificMSDseemtodifferfromthoseofsubjectivecomplaintswithoutclinicalfindings(Mirandaetal.2005).Suchcomplaintsmaybeindicatorsofadversepsychologicalandpsychosocialfactorsratherthanthepresenceofanunderlyingpathologiccondition.

Informationonexposuresinthestudiesisoftenself-reportedandnotsupportedbyobjectiveobservationsormeasurements.Non-random(biased)associationsmayariseifsubjectswithorwithoutsymptomshaveadifferentrecallofexposures,orifthosewithexposuresthatworrythempaymoreattentiontotheirsymptoms(Viikari-Junturaetal.1996;Walker-Boneetal.2005).Inaddition,theassessmentmethodsforpsy-chosocialriskfactorsvary,becausethereisapoorconsensusabouthowthesefactorsshouldbemeasured.Severalreviewshavenotedthatthereisalackofconsistencyinhowkeyaspectsofthepsychosocialenviron-ment,suchasjobdemands,autonomy,andworkplacesupportandjobsatisfaction,aremeasuredinindividualstudies(Macfarlaneetal.2009).Thereisalsovariationinboththedomainsinvestigatedandtheapproachtocollectingdomain-specificdata.

Physicalloadisassumedtohavebothanacuteandacumulativeeffectontheoccurrenceofbackpain(Hoogendoornetal.1999).Aloadthatexceedsthefailuretoleranceofthetissue,evenifonlyappliedonce,cancausebackpain.However,thecumulativeloadresultingfromlowermagnitudeloadsmaybeevenmoreimportant.Insuchcases,backpainisassumedtobetheresultofarepeatedapplicationofloadsorthelong-termapplicationofasustainedload.

PainisthemainsymptominmostMSDandtheobjectivefindingsareusuallybasedonfunctionalrestrictionscausedbypain.Painperception,ontheotherhand,isdependentonmanyindividual,psychologicaland

Page 38: Kari-Pekka Martimo - UEF · Kari-Pekka Martimo Musculoskeletal disorders, disability and work Kari-Pekka Martimo Musculoskeletal disorders (MSD) are the most important causes of temporary

36

3pREVIOuSSTuDIESONMuSCuLOSKELETALDISORDERS,DISABILITYANDWORK

socialfactors,insteadofpathophysiologicalaspects.Therefore,anygivenriskfactorisunlikelytocausemusculoskeletalsymptomsormedicallyverifiabledisordersinallemployees,butthecontextpartlydetermineswhetherdisturbingpainisperceivedornot.

Theeffectsoftheworkenvironmentonhealthmaybemediatedbyatleasttwopathways,assuggestedinthemodeldepictedinfigure3(Coxetal.1994).Ithasbeenarguedthatthephysico-chemical andthepsycho-physiological mechanismsdonotofferalternativeexplanations,buttheyarepresentandinteracttodifferentextentsinallsituations.Whilemanyoftheeffectsofthephysicalenvironmentaremediateddirectlybythephysico-chemicalmechanism,anxietyandfearaboutthatenviron-mentmayalsohaveapsycho-physiologicalimpact.Inturn,theeffectsonhealthofthepsychosocialandorganisationalenvironmentsarelargelymediatedbypsycho-physiologicalprocesses,thoughcertainissues,likeworkplaceviolence,mayhaveadirecteffectthroughphysicalinjury.

indirect effects and moderation of effects

of physical hazards

Occupational health

Hazards in physical work environment

directeffects

Physico-chemicalpathway

mediation

indirect effects and moderation of effects of psychosocial and

organisational hazards

Cognitive and psycho-physiological pathway

mediation

Hazards in psychosocial and organisational work environments

FigurE 3. Work environment and occupational health: a model suggested by Cox and Ferguson (1994)

Page 39: Kari-Pekka Martimo - UEF · Kari-Pekka Martimo Musculoskeletal disorders, disability and work Kari-Pekka Martimo Musculoskeletal disorders (MSD) are the most important causes of temporary

37

3pREVIOuSSTuDIESONMuSCuLOSKELETALDISORDERS,DISABILITYANDWORK

Fourexplanationsfortheassociationbetweenpsychologicalworkcharacteristicsandmusculoskeletalsymptomshavebeenproposed(Hoogendoornetal.2000);(1)psychosocialworkcharacteristicscandirectlyinfluencethebiomechanicalloadthroughchangesinposture,movementandexertedforces;(2)psychosocialworkcharacteristicsmaytriggerphysiologicmechanisms,suchasincreasedmuscletensionorincreasedhormonalexcretionthatmayinthelongtermleadtoorganicchangesandthedevelopmentorintensificationofmusculoskeletalsymp-tomsormayinfluencepainperceptionandthusincreasesymptoms;(3)psychosocialfactorsmaychangetheabilityofanindividualtocopewithanillnesswhich,inturn,couldinfluencethereportingofmusculoskeletalsymptoms;(4)theassociationmaywellbeconfoundedbytheeffectofphysicalfactorsatwork.

Insystematicreviewsontheeffectivenessofthework-relatedinter-ventions,fivelevelsofevidencehavebeenusedtosummarisetheresults.MostreviewsadapttheclassificationsuggestedbytheCochraneCol-laborationBackReviewGroup(vanTulderetal.2003).Accordingtothisclassification,"strong evidence"referstoconsistentfindingsamongmultiplehighqualityrandomisedcontrolledtrials(RCTs);"moderate evidence"referstoconsistentfindingsamongmultiple lowqualityRCTsand/ornonrandomisedcontrolledclinicaltrials(CCTs)and/oronehighqualityRCT;"limited"referstoonelowqualityRCTand/orCCT;"conflicting"referstoinconsistentfindingsamongmultipletrials(RCTsand/orCCTs);and"no evidence"referstothefactthatnoRCTsorCCTshavebeenidentified.Thisclassificationwasmodifiedquiterecently(Furlanetal.2009)labellingthelevelsaccordingtothequalityoftheevidenceas"high","moderate","low","verylowqual-ity",or"noevidence".

Inconclusion,researchonMSDfacesmanychallengesrelatedtotheappropriatestudymethodsandoutcomes,exposureandsymptomverifi-cation,andthetheoreticalmodelsexplainingtheeffectsofbothphysicalandpsychosocialexposuresandtheirinteraction.Thereisalargebodyofevidencealreadyavailable,butmorehighqualityresearchisdefinitelyneeded.IftheassociationbetweenworkandMSDisrelatedtoagreaterlikelihoodofsymptomsanddisabilitythanthedisorderitself,thisshouldbereflectedinthepreventionactivitiesandergonomicmeasures.

Page 40: Kari-Pekka Martimo - UEF · Kari-Pekka Martimo Musculoskeletal disorders, disability and work Kari-Pekka Martimo Musculoskeletal disorders (MSD) are the most important causes of temporary

38

3pREVIOuSSTuDIESONMuSCuLOSKELETALDISORDERS,DISABILITYANDWORK

3.1.2. Low back pain

PreviousresearchhasfoundoveronehundredpotentialriskfactorsforLBP(Bakkeretal.2009).AsummaryoftheoccupationalriskfactorsofLBPdiscussedherearepresentedintable1.

Table 1. Work-related risk factors of lbP

Risk factors Reference

Physical risk factors

Manual material handling, including lifting, moving, carrying, and holding loads, as well as bending and twisting; whole-body vibration

Patient handling, high level of physical activity

Whole-body vibration, nursing tasks, heavy physical work, working with one's trunk in a bent and/or twisted position

Occupational bending or twisting

(Hoogendoorn et al. 1999)

(Hoogendoorn et al. 1999)

(Bakker et al. 2009)

(Wai et al. 2009)

Psychosocial risk factors

Low social support in the workplace

High job demands and low job satisfaction

Low job control and low supervisor support

(Hoogendoorn et al. 2000)

(Macfarlane et al. 2009)

(Kaila-Kangas et al. 2004)

Accordingtoareviewofphysicalloadduringworkasariskfactorforbackpain(Hoogendoornetal.1999),thereisstrongevidencethatmanualmaterialhandling,includinglifting,moving,carrying,andholdingloads,aswellasbendingandtwistingareriskfactorsforbackpain.Themagnitudeoftheriskestimate(relativerisk/oddsratio)rangedfrom1.5to3.1formanualhandling.Thereisalsostrongevidencethatwhole-bodyvibration

Page 41: Kari-Pekka Martimo - UEF · Kari-Pekka Martimo Musculoskeletal disorders, disability and work Kari-Pekka Martimo Musculoskeletal disorders (MSD) are the most important causes of temporary

39

3pREVIOuSSTuDIESONMuSCuLOSKELETALDISORDERS,DISABILITYANDWORK

isariskfactorforbackpain(effectestimate4.8),andmoderateevidencethatpatienthandlingandahighlevelofphysicalactivityareriskfactorsforbackpainwiththemagnitudeoftheriskestimatesrangingfrom1.7to2.7(forpatienthandling)andfrom1.5to9.8(forheavyphysicalwork).Inthesensitivityanalysis,however,noevidencewasfoundfortheeffectofheavyphysicalload(Hoogendoornetal.1999).

TheresultsbyHoogendoornetal.arechallengedbyamorerecentsystematicreview.Thisincluded18prospectivecohortstudiesevaluatingspinalmechanicalloadduringworkand/orleisuretimeactivitiesasriskfactorsfornonspecificLBPinpatients(>18yearsofage)freeofLBPatbaseline(Bakkeretal.2009).TheconclusionwasthatthereareseveralhighqualitystudieswithconsistentfindingsthatLBPisnotassociatedwithprolongedstanding/walkingorsittingatwork.Accordingtothisreview,evidenceisconflictingforwhole-bodyvibration,nursingtasks,heavyphysicalwork,andworkingwiththetrunkinabentand/ortwistedpositionasriskfactorsforLBP.

TheconclusionsofBakkeretalhavebeencriticised(Takalaetal.2010).First,theresultsoftheincludedstudiesshouldbeconsideredas"inconsistent",not"conflicting",becausenoneofthestudiesindicatedthatthenon-exposedgroupwouldhaveahigherriskthantheexposedgroup.Second,eveninstudieswithoutstatisticallysignificantresults,trendsdidexistforanelevatedriskwithincreasedlevelsofexposure.

Fivecase-controlstudiesandfiveprospectivecohortstudieswereincludedinanotherrecentsystematicreviewonoccupationalbendingortwistingandLBP.TheconclusionwasthatthereviewedevidencewasconflictingandnotsupportiveofanyclearcausalrelationshipbetweenoccupationalbendingortwistingandLBP(Waietal.2009).However,theresultsdidsuggestthatbendingactivitiesinvolvinghigherdegreesoftrunkflexionwereassociatedwithdisablingtypesofLBPincertainworkingpopulations.

Inadditiontophysicalloadfactorsthereisalsoevidencethatpsycho-socialfactorsplayaroleintheaetiologyofLBP.Forsymptom-freepeople,thereisstrongevidencethatindividualpsychosocialfindingsareariskfac-torfortheincidence(onset)ofLBP.However,thesizeoftheeffectissmall(Waddelletal.2001).Areviewofreviewshasalsobeenpublishedontheassociationsbetweenworkplacepsychosocialfactorsandmusculoskeletalpain(Macfarlaneetal.2009).Thisreviewclaimedthatoutofthespecific

Page 42: Kari-Pekka Martimo - UEF · Kari-Pekka Martimo Musculoskeletal disorders, disability and work Kari-Pekka Martimo Musculoskeletal disorders (MSD) are the most important causes of temporary

40

3pREVIOuSSTuDIESONMuSCuLOSKELETALDISORDERS,DISABILITYANDWORK

work-relatedpsychosocialfactorsconsidered,theimportantfactorswerejobdemands,support,jobautonomyandjobsatisfaction.Withrespecttobackpain,themostconsistentconclusions(4reviewspositiveoutof6)werewithhighjobdemandsandlowjobsatisfaction.Thereviewempha-sisedtheimportanceofdevelopingstandardisedmethodsforconductingevaluationsofexistingevidence,andtheimportanceofinvestigatingnewlongitudinalstudiestoclarifythetemporalrelationshipbetweenpsycho-socialfactorsandmusculoskeletalpainintheworkplace.

Oneoftheincludedreviews(Hoogendoornetal.2000)foundalsostrongevidenceforlowsocialsupportatworkasariskfactorforLBP.However,thisresultwassensitivetochangesintheratingsystemandthemethodologicalqualityofthestudies.Theauthorsconsideredalsothattheeffectforlowjobsatisfactioncouldbeapossibleresultofinsuf-ficientadjustmentforpsychologicalworkcharacteristicsandphysicalloadatwork.Theyconcludedthatthereseemedtobeevidenceforaneffectofpsychologicalfactorsatworkbutthattheevidencefortheroleofspecificwork-relatedpsychologicalfactorshasnotbeenestablishedyet(Hoogendoornetal.2000).

PsychosocialriskfactorsseemtovaryaccordingtothetypeofLBP.InaFinnishprospectivecohortstudy(Kaila-Kangasetal.2004),lowjobcon-trolandlowsupervisorsupportatbaselinewereassociatedwithincreasedriskofhospitalisationforbackdisordersinthe17yearfollow-up.Therewasnosimilarassociationforintervertebraldiscdisorders.Instead,ithasbeenshowninanotherFinnishstudythatphysicallydemandingworkwasariskfactorforsciaticaamongmen(Kaila-Kangasetal.2009).Theriskincreasedwiththelengthoftheexposureforthefirst20years,butdecreasedthereafter.Thisstudyfoundalsoaremarkablyhighprevalenceofsciaticaamongthosewhowerenotworking.Inthisgroup,sciaticawasstronglyassociatedwithpreviousworkexposures.Theseresultsindicatethatprematurehealth-relatedselectionoutofheavyworkhadoccurred.

TheresultsofphysicalloadexposuresasriskfactorsforLBPinmostreviewshavebeenratherinsensitivetoslightchangesintheassessmentoftheoutcomesandthemethodologicalqualityofthestudies.This,however,doesnotapplytotheresultsforpsychologicalfactors.Thisindicatesthatthebodyofevidencesupportingtheroleofphysicalloadasariskfactorforbackpainissomewhatmoreconsistentthanthatforthepsychosocialfactors.

Page 43: Kari-Pekka Martimo - UEF · Kari-Pekka Martimo Musculoskeletal disorders, disability and work Kari-Pekka Martimo Musculoskeletal disorders (MSD) are the most important causes of temporary

41

3pREVIOuSSTuDIESONMuSCuLOSKELETALDISORDERS,DISABILITYANDWORK

3.1.3. Upper extremity disorders

Table2showstheknownoccupationalphysicalriskfactorsforUED.ThemostcommonlyreportedriskfactorsforUEDasagrouparerepetitivemovements,force,andhand-armvibration,whereaspsychosocialorworkorganisationalriskfactorsincludehighjobdemand,lowdecisionlatitude,lowsocialsupport,aswellasfewrestbreakopportunities(Punnettetal.2004).

Table 2. Work-related risk factors of UeD

Diagnosis Risk factors ReferencePhysical risk factors

uED in general

repetitive movements, force, and hand-arm vibration

For men: High level of physical demand, high repetitiveness of task, postures with arms at or above shoulder levels, tasks with full elbow flexion For women: Postures with extreme wrist bending and use of vibrating hand tools

(Punnett et al. 2004)

(roquelaure et al. 2009)

Epicondylitis repetitive movements of the arms and forceful activities

Handling heavy tools or loads, high hand grip forces, repetitive movements, and work with vibrating tools

(Shiri et al. 2006)

(van rijn et al. 2009a)

CTS Work tasks with vibrating tools, handgrip with high forces, repetitive movements of the hands, and prolonged work with flexed or extended wrist

(Shiri et al. 2009; van rijn et al. 2009b)

Shoulder pain

Physically strenuous work, working with trunk forward flexed or with a hand above shoulder level

Overhead work, repetitive work with shoulder, lifting, pushing or pulling

(Miranda et al. 2001)

(Walker-Bone et al. 2005)

rotator cuff tendinitis

Cumulative working with hand above shoulder level (Miranda et al. 2005)

Forearm pain repetitive tasks (Macfarlane et al. 2000)Psychosocial risk factors

uED in general

High job demand, low decision latitude, low social support, few rest break opportunities

Both high and low job demands

For men: High psychological demand For women: Low level of decision authority in women

(Punnett et al. 2004)

(Macfarlane et al. 2009)

(roquelaure et al. 2009)

Shoulder pain Mental stress

Monotonous work, high job demands and psychological distress

(Miranda et al. 2001)

(Andersen et al. 2003)

Forearm pain Poor satisfaction with level of support from colleagues/supervisor (Macfarlane et al. 2000)

Page 44: Kari-Pekka Martimo - UEF · Kari-Pekka Martimo Musculoskeletal disorders, disability and work Kari-Pekka Martimo Musculoskeletal disorders (MSD) are the most important causes of temporary

42

3pREVIOuSSTuDIESONMuSCuLOSKELETALDISORDERS,DISABILITYANDWORK

TheriskfactorsforUEDdifferaccordingtothespecificdiagnosis.Handlingofheavytoolsorloadsandrepetitivemovementsareassoci-atedwithlateralepicondylitis,whereasrepetitivemovements,forcefulactivitiesandworkingwithvibratingtoolsareriskfactorsformedialepicondylitis(Shirietal.2006;vanRijnetal.2009a).

Worktasksdemandinghandgripwithhighforcesortheuseofvi-bratingtoolsareassociatedwithanincreasedprevalenceofCTS(Shirietal.2009).Theassociationisstrongerifthesetaskswereaccompaniedbyrepetitivemovementsofthehandorwrist.Inaddition,prolongedworkwithaflexedorextendedwristhasbeenshowntobeariskfactorforCTS(vanRijnetal.2009b)

Consistentfindingshavebeenfoundforrepetitivemovements,vibrationanddurationofemploymentasoccupationalriskfactorsofshoulderpaininareviewwith29cross-sectionalstudies(vanderWindtetal.2000).Nearlyallstudiesthathaveassessedpsychosocialriskfac-torshavereportedatleastonepositiveassociationwithshoulderpain,buttheresultswerenotconsistentacrossstudiesforhighpsychologicaldemands,poorcontrolatwork,poorsocialsupport,orjobdissatisfaction.

Anotherreviewconcludedthatthework-relatedriskfactorsforshoulderpainareoverheadwork,repetitiveworkwiththeshoulder,andlifting,pushingorpulling(Walker-Boneetal.2005).Evidencesuggeststhatcumulativeintensiveshoulderworkparticularlyincor-poratingcombinationsofexposuresisassociatedwithasignificantlyincreasedprevalenceofshoulderdisorders.Thework-relatedfactorsaspredictorsofshoulderpaindifferaccordingtothenatureofthedisorder.Aprospectivestudyfoundthatmentalstressandphysi-callystrenuouswork,aswellasworkingwithtrunkforwardflexedorwithahandabovetheshoulderlevelincreasedincidentshoulderpain,whereaspersistentsevereshoulderpainwasassociatedwithoverloadatworkandworkingwithahandabovetheshoulderlevel(Mirandaetal.2001).

Withrespecttothepsychosocialfactors,monotonouswork,highjobdemandsandpsychologicaldistresswerethreeexposuresthathavebeenshowntoincreasetheriskofshoulderpaininaprospectivestudyamongworkersinindustrialandservicecompanies.Furthermore,poorwork-placesupportfromcolleagues/supervisorsandpsychologicalmorbidityincreasetheriskofadhesivecapsulitis(Andersenetal.2003).

Page 45: Kari-Pekka Martimo - UEF · Kari-Pekka Martimo Musculoskeletal disorders, disability and work Kari-Pekka Martimo Musculoskeletal disorders (MSD) are the most important causes of temporary

43

3pREVIOuSSTuDIESONMuSCuLOSKELETALDISORDERS,DISABILITYANDWORK

Thegenderoftheemployeealsoseemstoplayaroleinriskfac-torsofUED.InaFrenchstudywherespecificUEDwerediagnosedbytrainedOHphysicians,theriskfactorsdifferedbetweenmenandwomen(Roquelaureetal.2009).Highlevelofphysicaldemands,highrepetitivenessofthetask,postureswiththearmsatoraboveshoulderlevels,andtaskswithfullelbowflexionincreasedtheriskofUEDinmen.Inwomen,UEDwereassociatedwithpostureswithextremewristbendinganduseofvibratinghandtools.PsychosocialriskfactorswereonlymodestlyassociatedwithUED,highpsychologicaldemandsinmenandalowlevelofdecisionauthorityinwomen.Anotherstudyfoundsimilarresultsandtheauthorsconcludedthatgenderdifferencesinresponsetophysicalworkexposuresmayreflectgendersegregationinworkandpotentialdifferencesinforceproducingcapacity(Silver-steinetal.2009).

Thereisevidencethatbothindividualpsychologicalfactors(worryanddistress)andworkplacefactorscorrelatewiththeonsetofpaininUED(Shawetal.2002b).Theavailableevidencealsosuggeststhatpsy-chologicalandoccupationalpsychosocialvariableshaveanimportantroleintheaetiologyofshoulderpain.Inareviewofreviews(Macfarlaneetal.2009)thereweresixreviewsconductedonneck/shoulderandforearmpainandpsychologicalfactors(altogether85individualstudies)whichconcludedthatbothhighandlowjobdemandswereassociatedfactors.Lowjobdemandsincludedthejobbeingevaluatedasmonotonousorwithinsufficientuseofskills.

Non-specificforearmpainhasbeenshowntobeassociatedwithre-petitivetasks(Macfarlaneetal.2000).Inthesamestudy,newonsetfore-armpainwasindependentlypredictedbypsychologicaldistress,aspectsofillnessbehaviour,aswellaspsychosocialfactorssuchassatisfactionwiththelevelofsupportfromcolleagues/supervisor.Infact,non-specificshoulderpainseemstobemorehighlyrelatedtopsychosocialandin-dividualpsychologicalfactors,whereaschronicrotatorcufftendinitisisrelatedtocumulativeloadingontheshoulder,ageandinsulin-dependentdiabetesmellitus(Mirandaetal.2005;Viikari-Junturaetal.2008).

Asaconclusion,itseemsthatthemorespecificthedisorder,themoreconvincingistheevidencethatcertainphysicalloadexposuresatworkareriskfactors.Psychosocialriskfactorsseemtoplayamoresignificantpartintheaetiologyofmorenon-specificUED.Therefore,thechallenge

Page 46: Kari-Pekka Martimo - UEF · Kari-Pekka Martimo Musculoskeletal disorders, disability and work Kari-Pekka Martimo Musculoskeletal disorders (MSD) are the most important causes of temporary

44

3pREVIOuSSTuDIESONMuSCuLOSKELETALDISORDERS,DISABILITYANDWORK

inmanagingwork-relatedUEDistomakethecorrectdiagnosisinordertofindthebestwork-relatedintervention.

3.1.4. Work-related interventions in preventing musculoskeletal disorders

InterventionstudiesaimingatthepreventionofMSDusuallyincludeallavailableemployeesintheworkplaceregardlessofwhethertheyhavehadthedisorderpreviouslyornot.Consequently,it ishardlyeverpossibletodistinguishbetweenprimaryandsecondarypreventionstudies.Theinterventionisdirectedtoboththosewithorwithoutpriorsymptomsandrelateddisability,andthosewithpresentsymptoms.Thesesubgroups,however,areusuallytakenintoconsiderationinthestatisticalanalyses.

Multicomponentinterventionshaveagreaterchancethansingleinterventionsintheirsuccessinreducingwork-relatedMSDaccordingtoacomprehensivereview(Silversteinetal.2004).Modifyingindividualfactorsisnotparticularlyusefulinpreventingwork-relatedMSD,butexerciseappearstobeeffectiveinmitigatingsomeoftheconsequences.Inaddition,participatoryapproacheshavebeenoften,thoughnotal-ways,successful.

Thereviewoftheevidenceontheeffectivenessoflumbarsupports,educationandexerciseintheprimarypreventionofbackpainintheworkplacewasupdatedin2004(vanPoppeletal.2004).Accordingtofivenewpapersaddedtotheelevenpreviouslyavailabletrials,therewasstillnoevidencetosupporttheuseoflumbarsupportsoreducationinthepreventiononbackpain.Moreover,evenwhenincludingtheresultsofthenewtrials,therewasstillonlylimitedevidencetosupporttheeffectivenessofexercise.

ExerciseinterventionstopreventLBPamongemployeeshaveanef-fectonnewepisodesofLBPaccordingtoanothersystematicliteraturereviewontheeffectivenessofLBPinterventionsintheworkplace(Tveitoetal.2004).Instead,education,lumbarsupportsormultidisciplinaryinterventionsshowednosupportfortheireffectivenessinpreventingbackpain.Similarconclusionswerereachedinanotherreview(Bosetal.2006):trainingandeducationalonewerenotsufficienttoachieveanydecreaseinmusculoskeletalsymptoms,butinadditiontoergonomic

Page 47: Kari-Pekka Martimo - UEF · Kari-Pekka Martimo Musculoskeletal disorders, disability and work Kari-Pekka Martimo Musculoskeletal disorders (MSD) are the most important causes of temporary

45

3pREVIOuSSTuDIESONMuSCuLOSKELETALDISORDERS,DISABILITYANDWORK

intervention(i.e.,theuseofadditionalmechanicalorotheraidequip-ment),adecreaseofmusculoskeletalsymptomscouldbeattained.

Amixedlevelofevidencewasobservedforthegeneralquestion,whetherofficeinterventionsamongcomputerterminalusershaveanyeffectonmusculoskeletalorvisualhealth(Breweretal.2006).Thisre-viewincludednotonlyRCTs,butstudiesusingdifferentstudydesigns.Moderateevidencewasobservedfor(1)noeffectofworkstationadjust-ment,(2)noeffectofrestbreaksandexercise,and(3)positiveeffectofalternativepointingdevicesonmusculoskeletaloutcomesincomparisontoaconventionalmouse.Mixedorinsufficientevidenceofeffectwasobservedforallotherinterventions.

Thereisnoevidencetosupportthebenefitsofproductionsystems/organisationalcultureinterventions(Boococketal.2007).Thatreviewidentifiednosingle-dimensionalormulti-dimensionalstrategyforinterventionthatwasconsideredasbeingeffectiveacrossoccupationalsettings.Trialshavemainlyincludedcomputerterminalworkersandshownonlyamodesteffectofworkplaceadjustments,exerciseandad-viceasapproachesforpreventingandmanagingneck/upperextremitymusculoskeletalconditions.

Burtonetal(Burtonetal.2009)haveconcludedthateffectivein-terventionsforUEDrequireamultimodalapproachinwhichspecifictreatmentwouldbecoupledwithworkplaceaccommodation.Theyalsoemphasizedthatanintegrativeapproachbyallstakeholders(employer,workerandhealthprofessional)wasafundamentalrequirementinfacili-tatinganearlyreturntowork.Othershaveemphasizedtheimportanceofcommunicatingwithsupervisors.Theirneedsandchallengeshavetobeidentifiedinadditiontotailoringtheprogramtoaccommodateproduction,work-taskneeds,andtobeasmarginallydisruptiveaspos-sible(Feuersteinetal.2006).

Inaclusterrandomisedcontrolledtrial(Haukkaetal.2010)kitchenworkersintheinterventiongroupwereencouragedtoactivelyparticipateinworkanalysis,planning,andimplementingtheergonomicchangesaimedtodecreasephysicalandmentalworkload.Duringthefollow-up,nofavourable,evenadverse,effectsonthepsychosocialfactorsatworkwerefound.Inaddition,theseauthorshavereportedpreviouslythattherewasnoevidencefortheeffectivenessoftheinterventioninreducingtheperceivedphysicalloadorpreventingMSD(Haukkaetal.

Page 48: Kari-Pekka Martimo - UEF · Kari-Pekka Martimo Musculoskeletal disorders, disability and work Kari-Pekka Martimo Musculoskeletal disorders (MSD) are the most important causes of temporary

46

3pREVIOuSSTuDIESONMuSCuLOSKELETALDISORDERS,DISABILITYANDWORK

2008).However,asignificantlyreducedriskoffutureshoulderpainwasobservedinasubgroupofemployees,whoseworktasksperceivedasthemoststrenuouswerereduced(Pehkonenetal.2009).

TheabovementionedRCTwasincludedinthereviewontheeffec-tivenessofergonomicworkplaceinterventionsonLBPandneckpain(Driessenetal.2010).Thisreviewacceptedonlyrandomisedcontrolledtrials,whichincludedinterventionstargetedatchangingthebiomechani-calexposureattheworkplaceoronchangingtheworkorganisation.Theresultswerethatthereislowtomoderatequalityevidencethatthesekindsofinterventionsarenotanymoreeffectivethannoergonomicinterven-tiononshortandlongtermLBPandneckpainincidenceorprevalence,shortandlongtermLBPintensity,andshorttermneckpainintensity.Therewaslowqualityevidencethataphysicalergonomicintervention(forexample,armboard)wassignificantlymoreeffectiveonthereduc-tionofneckpainoverthelongtermthannoergonomicintervention.

Inconclusion,theresultsofpreviousstudiesonwork-relatedriskfactorsforMSDhavenotbeenconfirmedininterventionstudies.Thisiseitherduetothefactthatinterventionstudieshavefailedtomodifyallrelevantwork-relatedfactorsattheworkplace,orthatmusculoskeletalsymptomsanddisordersareonlypartlycausedbywork-relatedfactors,andtheotherrelevantfactorsarebeingleftoutsidethescopeoftheinterventions.

3.2. Work-related risk factors of sickness absence

3.2.1. general

PainandothersymptomscausedbyMSDcanleadtosignificantpersonaldistress,lossoffunctionanddisability.Identifyingthefactorsassociatedwithdecreasedmusculoskeletalfunctionmayleadtothedevelopmentofmoreeffectiveinterventions.Toolsforearlyidentificationofworkerswithmusculoskeletalsymptomswhoareatahighriskofprolongeddis-abilitywouldhelptofocusclinicalattentiononthepatientswhoneeditmost,whilehelpingtoreduceunnecessaryinterventions(andcosts)amongothers(Dionneetal.2005).Bytargetingspecifictreatmentandrehabilitationtopotentialhigh-riskcasesearly,onecouldarguethatit

Page 49: Kari-Pekka Martimo - UEF · Kari-Pekka Martimo Musculoskeletal disorders, disability and work Kari-Pekka Martimo Musculoskeletal disorders (MSD) are the most important causes of temporary

47

3pREVIOuSSTuDIESONMuSCuLOSKELETALDISORDERS,DISABILITYANDWORK

shouldbepossibletopreventadverseoutcomesincludingunnecessaryprolongationofdisability.

ClinicalpracticeguidelineshaveprovidedusefulalgorithmsforthemedicalmanagementofLBP,butthesedonotaddresscertainfactorsthatmayinfluenceLBPrelateddisability(Shawetal.2001).Basedontheevidencethatmultiplefactorscontributetodisability,interventionsthataddressmedical,workplace,andpsychosocialissuesshould,intheory,bemorelikelytoproduceimprovedoutcomesthantraditionalmedicaltreatmentalone.

Attentionhastobepaidtothefactthatagreatdealofavailableevi-denceonMSDandrelateddisabilityhasfocusedondisordersconsideredasbeingwork-related.Inmanycountriesthisentitlestheworkertofileaworker'scompensationclaimfollowedbytherighttofreemedicalcareorotherbenefits.Ithasbeenshownearlierthatwork-relatedLBPisdistinctfromsimilarnon-work-relatedconditionsinthatasuddenonsetisusu-allyreported,anddisabilityoutcomesareusuallylessfavourabledespitemoreintensivetreatments(Shawetal.2005).ThissamephenomenonislikelytoapplytootherMSDaswell,takingintoconsiderationthesignificanceoftheindividual'sownperceptionsonthedisabilityoutcome(formore,seechapter3.4.1.).

AccordingtoaFinnishstudyinvestigatingworkerspredominantlyengagedinphysicalwork(Taimelaetal.2007),self-ratedfutureworkabilityandperceivedmusculoskeletalimpairmentwerestrongdetermi-nantsofsicknessabsence.Amongthosesusceptibletotakingsickleave,theestimatedmeannumberofabsencedaysincreasedby14 %foreachincreaseofoneunitoftheimpairmentscoreonascalefromzerototen.

3.2.2. Low back pain

AccordingtotheannualstatisticsoftheFinnishSocialInsuranceInsti-tution,backpain(M40–54inInternationalClassificationofDisease)accountedfor14 %ofallcompensateddisabilitydays,and40 %ofalldisabilitydayscausedprimarilybyMSD(Kansaneläkelaitos2008).Thedirectfinancialcostsduetoback-relateddisabilitydayswas113M€totheSocialInsuranceInstitution(15 %oftotalcosts).

Table3showswork-relatedriskfactorsofsicknessabsenceduetoLBP.Thereisepidemiologicalandclinicalevidencethatcareseekingand

Page 50: Kari-Pekka Martimo - UEF · Kari-Pekka Martimo Musculoskeletal disorders, disability and work Kari-Pekka Martimo Musculoskeletal disorders (MSD) are the most important causes of temporary

48

3pREVIOuSSTuDIESONMuSCuLOSKELETALDISORDERS,DISABILITYANDWORK

backdisabilitydependmoreoncomplexindividualandwork-relatedpsychosocialfactorsthanonclinicalfeaturesorthephysicaldemandsofwork(Waddelletal.2001).

Table 3. Work-related risk factors of sickness absence due to lbP

Risk factors ReferencePhysical risk factors

Harmful biomechanical loads

Exposure at work to trunk flexion, trunk rotation and lifting

Doing heavy physical work

Heavier occupations with no modified duty

(Wickström et al. 1998)

(Hoogendoorn et al. 2002)

(Steenstra et al. 2005)

(Shaw et al. 2001)

Psychosocial risk factors

Lack of recognition and respect at work

Perceived control and low support at the workplace

Self-reported job demands

Low job satisfaction/job dissatisfaction

(Wickström et al. 1998)

(Shaw et al. 2001; Werner et al. 2009)

(Shaw et al. 2001)

(Truchon et al. 2000; Hoogendoorn et al. 2002)

Psychological risk factors

Negative beliefs about LBP, poor coping abilities

Distress (psychological distress, depressive symptoms, and depressive mood)

Pain avoidance beliefs, pain coping, psychological distress, problem solving orientation

Subjective negative appraisal of one's ability to work

(Werner et al. 2009)

(Shaw et al. 2001; Pincus et al. 2002)

(Shaw et al. 2002b)

(Truchon et al. 2000)

Other High level of disability, social isolation, receiving a high level of compensation

Delayed reporting, severity of pain and functional impact, shorter job tenure

(Steenstra et al. 2005)

(Shaw et al. 2001)

Page 51: Kari-Pekka Martimo - UEF · Kari-Pekka Martimo Musculoskeletal disorders, disability and work Kari-Pekka Martimo Musculoskeletal disorders (MSD) are the most important causes of temporary

49

3pREVIOuSSTuDIESONMuSCuLOSKELETALDISORDERS,DISABILITYANDWORK

Nocoresetofpredictorsexistsforsicknessabsenceingeneral,accord-ingtoasystematicreviewonevidenceofpredictorsforsicknessabsenceinpatientswithnon-specificLBP(Kuijeretal.2006).Thereviewstud-iedseparatelythepredictorsforabsencethreshold(i.e.,thedecisiontoreportsick)andRTWthreshold(i.e.,decisiontoreturntowork).Withrespecttotheabsencethreshold,nopredictorswerefoundforfactorspredictingsicknessabsenceatthemomentoffollow-upmeasurement,andnoconsistentevidencewasfoundfortotalnumberofsickleavedays.

Inanon-systematicreviewthedeterminantsofsicknessabsenceduetoLBPwerestudiedseparatelyforthecharacteristicsofthesick-listedworker,thecharacteristicsofthesick-listingperson(thedoctor),work-place,andtheculturalandeconomicconditionsofthesociety(Werneretal.2009).ThisevidenceshowsthatnegativebeliefsaboutLBP,co-morbidities,andpoorcopingabilitiesseemtobethemostimportantdeterminantsforclaimingsickleaveforLPB.Moreover,thedoctorwillusuallyfollowthepatient'sdemandstobegivensickleave.Theem-ployee'sperceivedsupportandcontrolattheworkplaceseemtobeofimportanceinpreventingsickleave.Nationaldifferencesineconomiccompensationforsickleaveappeartobeassociatedwithdifferencesinratesofsicknessabsence.

AccordingtotheresultsofaFinnishstudy,thetake-upofsickleaveattributedtoLBPwaspredictedbyexposuretoharmfulbiomechanicalloads(rateratio3.1).Inaddition,lackofrecognitionandrespectatworkpredictedsickleavecausedbyLBP(rateratio2.0)(Wickströmetal.1998).

Self-reportedjobdemandsappeartobebetterpredictiveofdisabilitythanmoreobjectivejobassessmentmeasures(Shawetal.2001).Workerself-reportsofgreaterphysicaldemandsofthejobappeartobepredictiveofchronicLBPdisability,whereasmoreobjectivemeasuresofphysicaldemandsarenot.Althoughworkerperceptionsofergonomicexposuremaydifferfrommoreobjectiveworkplaceassessmentstrategies,botharesubjecttoerror,butworkerreportappearstobemorestronglycorrelatedwithdisabilityoutcomes.Theauthorsconcluded,thatself-reportsmaybemoreaccurateinidentifyingunusualorhighriskdemands.However,themodestcorrelationbetweenpain,functionallimitations,andworkdisabilitysuggeststhattheseoutcomesmaydevelopsomewhatindepend-entlyfromeachotherduringtherecoveryperiodfollowingacuteLBP(Shawetal.2009a).

Page 52: Kari-Pekka Martimo - UEF · Kari-Pekka Martimo Musculoskeletal disorders, disability and work Kari-Pekka Martimo Musculoskeletal disorders (MSD) are the most important causes of temporary

50

3pREVIOuSSTuDIESONMuSCuLOSKELETALDISORDERS,DISABILITYANDWORK

Accordingtoareviewonpsychologicalfactorsaspredictorsofchronic-ity/disability,themostconsistentfindingwasthatdistress(psychologicaldistress,depressivesymptoms,anddepressivemood)isasignificantpre-dictorofunfavourableoutcome,particularlyinprimarycare(Pincusetal.2002).Thiseffectwasindependentofclinicalfactors,suchaspainandfunctionatbaseline.Inaddition,therewasmoderateevidenceforsoma-tisationhavingaroleintheprogressiontopersistentsymptomsand/ordisability,buttheeffectsizewasfoundtovary.TheauthorsconcludedthatpsychologicalfactorsplayanimportantroleinthetransitiontochronicLBP,andthattheymaycontributeatleastasmuchasclinicalfactors.

AnumberofpsychologicalvariableshavebeenshowntomediatethefunctionallimitationsofMSD,especiallychronicLBP.Thesefactorsincludepainavoidancebeliefs,paincoping,psychologicaldistress,andproblemsolvingorientation(Shawetal.2002b).

Ina3-yearprospectivecohortstudyonriskfactorsofsicknessabsenceduetoLBP(Hoogendoornetal.2002),significantrateratios,rangingfrom2.0–3.2,werefoundforexposureatworktotrunkflexion,trunkrotation,lifting,andlowjobsatisfaction.Inaddition,non-significantrateratiosofabout1.4werefoundforlowsupervisorsupportandlowco-workersupport.

Inareviewwithonlyinceptioncohortstudies(Steenstraetal.2005),thepatientswithLBPwiththehighestriskforlongtermabsencewereolderfemalescharacterisedbyradiatingpain,highlevelofdisabilityandsocialisolation,doingheavyphysicalwork,andreceivingahighlevelofcompensation.ItseemsthatinspiteoftheeffectofhistoryofLBPonrecurrencesofbackpain,ahistoryofLBPdoesnotinfluencethedura-tionofsickleaveduetoLBP.

Asystematicreviewofstudiesonthebiopsychosocialfactorspre-dictiveofnotreturningtoworkduetoLBPexamined18prospectivestudies(Truchonetal.2000).Thework-relatedpredictivefactorswereasubjectivenegativeappraisalofone'sabilitytoworkandjobdissatisfac-tion.Theimportanceofcertainpsychologicalvariables,likeattitudesandbeliefs,aswellascopingstrategies,wasalsoemerging.

Areviewofstudiesassessingthevalueofvariousprognosticfactorstopredictextendeddisabilityafteranacuteepisodeof"occupationallyattributed"LBPfoundthatsignificantprognosticfactorsincludelowworkplacesupport,personalstress,shorterjobtenure,priorepisodes,

Page 53: Kari-Pekka Martimo - UEF · Kari-Pekka Martimo Musculoskeletal disorders, disability and work Kari-Pekka Martimo Musculoskeletal disorders (MSD) are the most important causes of temporary

51

3pREVIOuSSTuDIESONMuSCuLOSKELETALDISORDERS,DISABILITYANDWORK

heavieroccupationswithnomodifiedduty,delayedreporting,severityofpainandfunctionalimpact,radicularfindings,andextremesymptomreporting(Shawetal.2001).

ItislogicalthatclinicaldataalonedoesnotpredictreliablytheriskofsicknessabsenceinLBP.Painasasubjectiveexperienceandfunctionallimitationsinrelationtoworkdemandsmaycomplicatethepossibili-tiestocontinueworking.MoreresearchisneededtocreatealternativemethodsofsupportingworkingdespitethepresenceofLBP,takingintoaccountthecumulatingevidenceofthebenefitsofstayingactiveinthemanagementofMSD.

3.2.3. Upper extremity disorders

UEDcauseremarkabledisabilityresultinginlostproductivity.Forexample,inWashingtonStatein1990–1998,theaveragetimelostfromworkwas170–251dayspercompensationclaimrelatedtoUED(Silversteinetal.2002).

Across-sectionalstudywasperformedamongworkersrepresentingavarietyofoccupationsbutsharingacommonworkers'compensationandemployeehealthbenefitprogram(Shawetal.2002b).Theresultsshowedthatfactorsotherthanpainexplainedtwiceasmuchvariabilityinupperextremityfunctionallimitationasexplainedbypainalone.Thissuggeststhatfunctionallimitationmaypersistsomewhatindependentlyofpainamelioration.Aftercontrollingforpainandgenderinamultipleregressionanalysis,thefactorscontributingtofunctionallimitationwerenon-painrelatedupperextremitysymptoms(forexample,sleepdistur-bance,numbness,tingling),symptomsinbothhands,feelingsofbeingoverwhelmedbypain,lowconfidenceinproblemsolvingabilities,andhigherergonomicriskfactorexposuresatwork.

3.2.4. Prevention of sickness absence caused by musculoskeletal disorders

Thischapterevaluatesinterventionsaimingatreducingthefrequencyofmusculoskeletalsicknessabsence(totalnumberofspells/allemployees)orthelengthofmusculoskeletalsicknessabsence(sick-leavedays/sick-listedpersons).

Page 54: Kari-Pekka Martimo - UEF · Kari-Pekka Martimo Musculoskeletal disorders, disability and work Kari-Pekka Martimo Musculoskeletal disorders (MSD) are the most important causes of temporary

52

3pREVIOuSSTuDIESONMuSCuLOSKELETALDISORDERS,DISABILITYANDWORK

Thetreatmentchosenbythephysicianiscrucialfortherecoveryprocess.Acontrolledtrialshowedthataslittleastwodaysofbedrestinstructedbythephysicianleadtoaslowerrecoverythantheavoidanceofbedrest,aswellastolongersickleaves(Malmivaaraetal.1995).ThisstudyofworkerswithacuteLBPsuggeststhatavoidingbedrestandmaintainingordinaryactivityleadtothemostrapidrecovery.

Screeningformedical"redflags"anddiagnostictriageisimportantintheexclusionofseriousspinaldiseasesandnerverootproblems(Waddelletal.2001).Sinceindividualandwork-relatedpsychosocialfactorsplayanimportantroleinthepersistenceofsymptomsanddis-ability,screeningfor"yellowflags"canhelptoidentifythoseworkerswithLBPwhoareatriskofdevelopingchronicpainanddisability.Laterthesystemof"yellowflags"wasrefinedandworkplacefactorswerecategorisedeitheras"blackflags"includingactualworkplaceconditionsthatcanaffectdisability,or"blueflags"includingindividualperceptionsaboutwork,whetheraccurateorinaccurate,thatcanaffectdisability(Shawetal.2009b).

Blueflagshavebeenconceptualisedasworkerperceptionsofastress-ful,unsupportive,unfulfilling,orhighlydemandingworkenvironment.Blackflagsincludebothemployerandinsurancesystemcharacteristicsaswellasobjectivemeasuresofphysicaldemandsandjobcharacteristics(Shawetal.2009b).Ithasbeenclaimedthatabetterunderstandingofthemeaning(thoughts,beliefsandattitudes)thatpatientsattributetotheirpaincouldbeacriticalsteptowardimprovingreturntoworkoutcomes(Loiseletal.2005).

Althoughworkingconditionswithuncomfortableworkingposi-tions,liftingorcarryingloads,pushingandpullingloadsaswellastheuseofvibratingtools,haveallbeenfoundtobeassociatedwithsicknessabsence,ithasbeenstatedthatmanyyearsofimplementingergonomicadaptationshavenotreducedtheincidenceofsicknessabsence(Werneretal.2009).

ACochranereview(vanOostrometal.2009)hasbeenpublishedfocusingstrictlyonrandomisedcontrolledtrials.Theresultsshowedthatwhencomparedtousualcare,thereismoderate-qualityevidencetosupporttheuseofworkplaceinterventionscarriedoutclosetotheworkplaceandincollaborationwiththekeystakeholdersinordertopreventworkdisabilityandreducesicknessabsenceamongworkers

Page 55: Kari-Pekka Martimo - UEF · Kari-Pekka Martimo Musculoskeletal disorders, disability and work Kari-Pekka Martimo Musculoskeletal disorders (MSD) are the most important causes of temporary

53

3pREVIOuSSTuDIESONMuSCuLOSKELETALDISORDERS,DISABILITYANDWORK

withMSD.Noevidencewasfoundforthebenefitsofworkplacein-terventionsonhealthoutcomes(forexample,painorfunctionalsta-tus).ThiswasconsideredassupportforthehypothesisthatRTWandresolutionofsymptomsarenotequivalent.Inotherwords,workplaceinterventionstendtoaddresstheworkdisabilityproblemandnottheunderlyingmedicalproblem.

Thesupervisors'roleinthemanagementofmusculoskeletalpainhasbeenevaluatedinacontrolledcasestudy(Shawetal.2006).Elevensupervisorsinaninterventiongroupand12supervisorsinadelayedinterventioncontrolgroupfromthesameplantwereprovidedwithtwo2-hourtrainingworkshopsseparatedby4to7days.Thefundamentalmessageintheworkshopswasthatsupportive,proactive,andcollabora-tivecommunicationswithemployeesaboutergonomicriskfactorsandmusculoskeletalpainanddiscomfortwouldbelikelytoreducedisabilitycostsandimproveemployeemorale,productivityandretention.Work-ers'compensationclaimsdatainthesevenmonthsbeforeandaftertheinterventionshoweda47 %reductioninnewclaimsandan18 %reductioninactivelost-timeclaimsversus27 %and7 %,respectively,inthecontrolgroup.Accordingtothatstudy,improvingtheresponseoffrontlinesupervisorstoemployees'work-relatedhealthandsafetyconcernscouldachievesustainablereductionsininjuryclaimsanddis-abilitycosts.

Basedoninterviewswith30employeesShawetal.(2003b)devel-oped11commonthemesfortheroleofsupervisorstopreventwork-placedisabilityafterinjury:accommodationtoreduceergonomicrisksordiscomfort,communicatingwithworkers,responsiveness,concernforwelfare,empathy/support,effortstounderstandtheemployee'ssituation,fairness/respect,follow-up,shareddecisionmaking,coor-dinatingwithmedicalproviders,andobtainingco-workersupportofaccommodation.

Severalstudiesperformedindifferentcountrieshaveshownamis-matchbetweenpublicbeliefsaboutbackpainandcurrentscientificevidence(Buchbinderetal.2008).Sincebeliefsandattitudesaboutbackpainareassociatedwiththedevelopmentofchronicity,itisapparentthatstrategiesareneededthatalignpublicviewswithcurrentevidence.MediacampaignsinScotlandandNorwayhighlightingtheawarenessofstayingactivethroughanepisodeofLBPdidnotchangesickness

Page 56: Kari-Pekka Martimo - UEF · Kari-Pekka Martimo Musculoskeletal disorders, disability and work Kari-Pekka Martimo Musculoskeletal disorders (MSD) are the most important causes of temporary

54

3pREVIOuSSTuDIESONMuSCuLOSKELETALDISORDERS,DISABILITYANDWORK

behaviourdespiteimprovedbeliefsinthegeneralpublic.However,anearliercampaigninAustraliawasfollowedbyacleardeclineinthenumberofclaimsforbackpain,ratesofcompensateddaysandcostsofmedicalcare.ThepossibleexplanationforthisisthatonlyinAustraliawerespecificadvertisementsaimedatemployersshowingthebenefitsofreintegratingemployees,theimportanceofmodifiedwork,andthepenaltiesinvolvedfornoncompliance(monetaryfines).

InNorway,inadditiontoamediacampaignaimingatimprovingbeliefsaboutLBPinthegeneralpublic,aprojecttrainedpeeradvisersinsixparticipatingworkplaces(Werneretal.2007).Thetaskofthispeeradviserwastoprovideinformationaimedatreducingfearofthepain,supportiveadvice,andarrangingformodificationsofworkloadsforalimitedperiodoftime.Eventhoughtheprevalenceofbackpainremainedconstantthroughoutthestudyperiod(threeyears),thecombinationofpeersupportgivenbyatrainedforeman,unionleaderorpersonnelofficerandmodifiedworkloadseemedtohavesupplementaleffectstoageneralmediacampaigninreducingsicknessabsenceduetoLBPandimprovementsinbeliefsaboutbackpain.

3.3. Work-related determinants of sickness presenteeism

Intherecentpast,theworker'sabilityorcapacitytoproducegoodsordeliverserviceswhilesufferingfromMSDhasbeenofparticularinterestintheareaofoccupationalresearch.Escorpizohasproposedthatworkproductivitywithinthecontextofwork-relatedMSDisdeterminedbythehealthconditionitself,thecapacity,desireanddifficultyofworking,aswellaswork-lifebalanceandnon-occupationalfactors(Escorpizo2008).Themeasurementofworkproductivityiscrucialtoinitiating,evaluating,andmonitoringdisabilitymanagement,forexample,em-ployeewellnessandergonomicprograms,andclinicalinterventionsinthemanagementofMSD.

InaFinnishpostalsurveyoflabourunionmembers(Böckermanetal.2009),presenteeism("presentatworkinspiteofsickness")wasassociatedwithpermanentfull-timework,shiftorperiodwork,regularovertime,overlongweeklyworkingtime,andefficiencyrequirements

Page 57: Kari-Pekka Martimo - UEF · Kari-Pekka Martimo Musculoskeletal disorders, disability and work Kari-Pekka Martimo Musculoskeletal disorders (MSD) are the most important causes of temporary

55

3pREVIOuSSTuDIESONMuSCuLOSKELETALDISORDERS,DISABILITYANDWORK

atwork.Ontheotherhand,lowerlevelsofpresenteeismwereassoci-atedwiththepossibilityofreplacementbyasubstitute,matchbetweendesiredandactualworkinghours,andthepossibilityoftakingashortsickleavewithouttheneedforsicknesscertificate.

Accordingtoasystematicreviewonemployeehealthandpresenteeism(Schultzetal.2007a),thestudiesintheliteraturefocusingonMSDaresurprisinglyrare.Mostoftheearlierstudieshaveassessedproductivitylossrelatedtoself-reportedsymptoms,whereasthereisaverylimitednumberofstudiesonproductivitylossassociatedwithclinicallydiag-nosedMSD.Thenatureofthemusculoskeletalconditionpresumablyaffectsproductivity,andtheriskfactorsforproductivitylossrelatedtovariousdisordersmayvary.Littleisknownoftheeffectsofthemuscu-loskeletaldiagnosesonproductivityloss.

SomeNorth-AmericansurveysonpresenteeismhavenotfocusedonlyonMSDbutalsoonotherhealthconditions.Amongworkersparticipatinginatelephonesurveymeasuringbothabsenteeismandreducedperformanceduetocommonpainconditions,thosereport-ingbackpainhadaveragelostproductivetimeof5.2hoursperweek(Stewartetal.2003).Themajority(77 %)ofthelostproductivityduetoanypainconditionwasexplainedbyreducedperformancewhileatworkandnotbyworkabsence.Inanothersurvey(Loeppkeetal.2007),backorneckpainwasthetopmedicalconditionaccountingforannualmedical,drug,andproductivitylosscostsper1000fulltimeemployeesinalltypesofcompanies.

Table4liststheknownwork-relateddeterminantsofsicknesspresen-teeismduetoMSD.Poorhealthhasbeenproposedtobeaprerequisiteforsicknesspresenteeism.Inaddition,severalotherfactorsrelatedtoworkandpersonalcircumstanceshavealsobeenassociatedwithpresenteeism,suchaslowreplaceabilityorhighattendancerequirements,forexample,havingtocompensateforallworknotdoneafteraperiodofabsence,lackofworkresources,timepressure,jobstress,jobinsecurity,andlongworkhours(Bergströmetal.2009).Personalfactors,despitehavingasomewhatweakerrelationtopresenteeismthanworkfactors,includedfinancialproblems,lackofindividualboundaries,over-commitmenttowork,conservativeattitudestowardsicknessabsence,ageandlimitededucation(Bergströmetal.2009).

Page 58: Kari-Pekka Martimo - UEF · Kari-Pekka Martimo Musculoskeletal disorders, disability and work Kari-Pekka Martimo Musculoskeletal disorders (MSD) are the most important causes of temporary

56

3pREVIOuSSTuDIESONMuSCuLOSKELETALDISORDERS,DISABILITYANDWORK

Table 4. Work-related determinants of sickness presenteeism

Determinants Reference

Individual factors

Poor health, financial problems, conservative attitudes toward sickness absence, age, limited education

Worse physical health, more functional disability

Musculoskeletal complaints, worse physical, mental and general health, recent absenteeism

Physical exercise fewer than 8 times during the last month

(Bergström et al. 2009)

(Lötters et al. 2005)

(Meerding et al. 2005)

(Hagberg et al. 2002)

Work-related factors

Permanent full-time work, shift or period work, regular overtime, overlong weekly working time, and efficiency requirements at work

Low replaceability or high attendance requirements at work for example, having to compensate for all work after a period of absence, lack of work resources, time pressure, job insecurity, and long work hours

Working overtime, computer mouse use for more than 0.5 h/day

(Böckerman et al. 2009)

(Bergström et al. 2009)

(Hagberg et al. 2002)

Psychosocial and psychological factors

Job stress, lack of individual boundaries, over-commitment to work

Poorer relations with the supervisor

Job demands

(Bergström et al. 2009)

(Lötters et al. 2005)

(Hagberg et al. 2002)

Reducedproductivityafter2-to6-weeksicknessabsenceduetoMSDwasquantifiedinaprospectivecohortstudyusingself-admin-isteredquestionnaires(Löttersetal.2005).Reducedproductivitywasprevalentfor60 %oftheworkersaftertheyreturnedtowork,andfor40 %stillatthe12-monthfollow-up.Worsephysicalhealth,

Page 59: Kari-Pekka Martimo - UEF · Kari-Pekka Martimo Musculoskeletal disorders, disability and work Kari-Pekka Martimo Musculoskeletal disorders (MSD) are the most important causes of temporary

57

3pREVIOuSSTuDIESONMuSCuLOSKELETALDISORDERS,DISABILITYANDWORK

morefunctionaldisabilityandpoorerrelationswiththesupervisorwereassociatedwithproductivitylossshortlyafterreturntowork.Recurrentsickleavewasthegreatestpredictorofproductivitylossatthefollow-up.

Twoquestionnairesonproductivityloss("HealthandLaborQues-tionnaire"and"QuantityandQuality")werecomparedamongtwopopulationsdoingjobswithhighphysicaleffort(Meerdingetal.2005).Abouthalfoftheworkerswithhealthproblemsonthelastworkingdayreportedreducedworkproductivity.Thiswassignificantlyassociatedwithmusculoskeletalcomplaints,worsephysical,mentalandgeneralhealth,andrecentabsenteeism.Self-reportedproductivityusingaQuantityandQuality(QQ)instrumentcorrelatedsignificantlywithobjectiveworkoutput.

InaSwedishstudy(Hagbergetal.2002)amongwhite-collarcom-puterusers8 %ofallemployeesreportedreducedproductivityduetomusculoskeletalsymptoms.Themeanmagnitudeofreductionwas15 %forwomenand13 %formen.Workingovertimeandjobdemandswereriskfactorsforself-reportedreducedproductivityduetoneckandbacksymptoms,whereasphysicalexercisefewerthan8timesduringthelastmonthwasariskfactorforproductivitylossduetoneck,shoulderandupperlimbpain(Hagbergetal.2007).Inaddition,computermouseuseformorethan0.5h/daywasariskfactorforreducedproductivityowingtoshoulderandupperlimbsymptoms.

Inastudyof654computerworkerswithneck/shoulderorhand/armsymptoms(vandenHeuveletal.2007),productivitylosswasin-volvedin26 %,andmoreoften(36 %)incasesreportingbothneck/shoulderandhand/armsymptoms.Mostoftheproductivitylossinthearm/handcaseswasduepresenteeismandsicknessabsenteeismwaspresentinonly11 %ofthecases.Overallproductivitylosswasassociatedwithpainintensity,higheffortregardlessoftherewardlevel,andlowjobsatisfaction.

Inaone-yearfollow-upstudyamong771youngadultswhoreportedneckorupperextremitysymptoms,butnoproductivitylossatbaseline,theriskfactorsofproductivitylossweresymptomsinseverallocations,longerpersistenceofsymptoms,andcomputerterminaluseof8–14hours/weekduringleisuretime(Boströmetal.2008).Astrongerrela-tionshipwasfoundifthreeorfourriskfactorswerepresent.

Page 60: Kari-Pekka Martimo - UEF · Kari-Pekka Martimo Musculoskeletal disorders, disability and work Kari-Pekka Martimo Musculoskeletal disorders (MSD) are the most important causes of temporary

58

3pREVIOuSSTuDIESONMuSCuLOSKELETALDISORDERS,DISABILITYANDWORK

Inaddition,severalstudieshavefound,somewhatunexpectedly,thattheyoungeremployeesreportmorehealth-relatedproductivitylossthanolderemployees(Hagbergetal.2002;Collinsetal.2005;Alaviniaetal.2009).

3.3.1. Prevention of sickness presenteeism associated with musculoskeletal disorders

InaDutchstudy(vandenHeuveletal.2003),workerswithcomplaintsintheneckorupperlimbwererandomizedintoacontrolgroup,oneinterventiongroupencouragedtotakeextrabreaks,andanotherinter-ventiongroupencouragedtoperformexercisesduringtheextrabreaks.Afteran8-weekperiod,thesubjectsintheinterventiongroupwithbreaksonlyshowedhigherproductivity(morekeystrokes)thanthecontrolgroup.Thestrokeaccuracyrateinbothinterventiongroupswashigherthaninthecontrolgroup.However,therewerenosignificantdifferencesbetweenthethreegroupsinthereportedseverityorfrequencyofthecomplaintsbeforeandaftertheintervention.

Inanotherstudy(Rempeletal.2006),agroupofcomputertermi-nalworkersintheUnitedStateswasrandomisedtoreceiveergonomicstrainingonly,trainingplusatrackballorforearmsupport,ortrainingandbothatrackballandaforearmsupport.Despitethefactthattheforearmsupportcombinedwithergonomictrainingseemedtopreventupperbodymusculoskeletalsymptoms,therewerenosignificantdiffer-encesbetweentheinterventiongroupsineitherthecompanytrackedproductivitymeasuresorinself-assessedproductivity.

Cost-effectivenessofanactive implementationstrategyfortheDutchphysiotherapyguidelineforLBPhasbeenstudiedinaRCTincludingalsoproductivitycostsasanoutcomemeasure(Hoeijenbosetal.2005).Abouthalfofthepatientsatbaselinereportedproduc-tivitylossduetoLBPcorrespondingtoalmost2hoursonaverageperday.Comparedtobaseline,significantlymorepatientswereseenwithoutanyproductivitylossinboththeinterventionandcontrolgroupafter6(56 %and64 %,respectively)and12weeks(71 %inbothgroups).Thedifferencesbetweenthetwogroups,however,werenotstatisticallysignificant.

Page 61: Kari-Pekka Martimo - UEF · Kari-Pekka Martimo Musculoskeletal disorders, disability and work Kari-Pekka Martimo Musculoskeletal disorders (MSD) are the most important causes of temporary

59

3pREVIOuSSTuDIESONMuSCuLOSKELETALDISORDERS,DISABILITYANDWORK

3.4. Determinants of return to work

TheprimarygoalsofemployeerehabilitationandRTWprogramsmayappeartobethepayer'sinterestinreducingdisabilitycosts,butthereareadditionalincentives:humanrightslegislationinmanycountriesprohibitsdiscriminationinemploymentpracticesonthebasisofdis-abilitystatus(Brookeretal.2001).

AccordingtoasystematicreviewofthequantitativeliteratureonworkplacebasedRTWinterventions,thereisstrongevidencethatworkdisabilitydurationissignificantlyreducedbyworkaccommodationoffersandcontactbetweenhealthcareproviderandtheworkplace(Francheetal.2005).Moderateevidencewasfoundthatdisabilitydurationisalsoreducedbyinterventionswhichincludeearlycontactwiththeworkerbytheworkplace,ergonomicworksitevisits,andthepresenceofaRTWcoordinator.Thus,forthesefiveinterventioncomponents,therewasmoderateevidencethattheyreducecostsassociatedwithworkdisabilitydurationbuttherewasinsufficientorlimitedevidenceforthesustain-abilityoftheseeffects.

Aconsensuspanelof33researchersandstakeholdersselectedkeyfactorsinbackdisabilitypreventionfollowingaliteraturesearchontheassessmentofwhichfactorsthatpredictordeterminedisability(Guzmanetal.2007).ExistingresearchevidencehadlargelyfocusedonRTW.Amongthefactorswithahighimpactonoccupationalparticipationwerecareproviderreassurance(strongconsensus),expectationofrecoveryanddecreasedfears(moderateconsensus),andincreasedknowledgeoftheindividualwithbackpainandappropriatemedicalcare(lowconsensus).Ontheotherhand,therewasmajordisagreementastotheimpactofincreasedjobsatisfaction,decreasedpain,increasedfitness,improvedfunction,improvedworkstationdesign,decreasedphysicalworkload,andliftingdevices.

ManyoftheRTWstudieshavebeencarriedoutinNorthAmericawiththesettingbeingaworker’scompensationsystem.Therefore,ithasbeenclaimedthatthereisaneedforcomparativedatafromotherjuris-dictionswithdifferentinsuranceschemesandsocialpolicyframeworksincorporatingalternativelegislativeimperativesandeconomicincentives(Brookeretal.2001).Thisinformationcouldclarifytherelationship

Page 62: Kari-Pekka Martimo - UEF · Kari-Pekka Martimo Musculoskeletal disorders, disability and work Kari-Pekka Martimo Musculoskeletal disorders (MSD) are the most important causes of temporary

60

3pREVIOuSSTuDIESONMuSCuLOSKELETALDISORDERS,DISABILITYANDWORK

betweensocietalfactorsandtheavailabilityandqualityofworkplace-basedRTWprograms.

ThebarriersofrecoveryandRTWwereinvestigatedamongemployeeswithwork-relatedUED(Shawetal.2003a).Casemanagersidentifiedupto21barrierspercasewithinfivedomains:signsandsymptoms(36 %ofallbarriers),workenvironment(27 %),medicalcare(13 %),functionallimitations(12 %),andcopingoftheemployee(12 %).

Ina2-yearprospectivecohortstudyamongpatientswithbackpaininprimarycaresettings,theoutcomemeasurewas"RTWingoodhealth"at2yearscombiningpatient'soccupationalstatus,functionallimitationsandrecurrencesofworkabsence(Dionneetal.2005).Thebestpredictivemodelincludedsevenbaselinevariables,suchasthepa-tient'srecoveryexpectations,previousbacksurgery,painintensity,anddifficultyinsleeping.Thismodelwasparticularlyefficientatidentifyingthosepatientswithnowork-relatedfunctionalproblems.

3.4.1. Worker perceptions and expectations

Asystematicreview(Kuijeretal.2006)gatheredevidenceforpredictorsofthedecisiontoreturntowork("RTWthreshold").Consistentevidencewasfoundforownexpectationsofrecoveryinthatpatientswithhigherexpectationsofrecoveryhadlesssicknessabsencedaysatthemomentoffollow-upmeasurement.

TheimportanceofpsychosocialfactorsonRTWwasstudiedinasystematicreview(Ilesetal.2008)whichevaluated24studies.Thesestudiesproducedstrongevidencethatrecoveryexpectationandmoderateevidencethatfear-avoidancebeliefswouldbepredictiveofworkoutcomeinnon-chronic,non-specificLBP.Workers'ownbeliefsthattheirLBPwascausedbyworkandtheirownexpectationsabouttheirinabilitytoreturntoworkwereclaimedtobeparticularlyimportant(Waddelletal.2001).

Non-medicalfactors,especiallythoserelatedtoworkplaceconcerns,perceptionsofinjuryseverity,andexpectationsforrecovery,wereassoci-atedwithbackdisabilitydurationinaninceptioncohortstudy(Shawetal.2005).Patients(183female,385male)sufferingarecentonsetLBPcompletedaquestionnaire,andaftertheinitialvisittheclinicianscom-pletedanadditionalquestionnaire.Functionallimitationandworkstatuswereassessedonemonthafterthepainonset.Accordingtotheresultsof

Page 63: Kari-Pekka Martimo - UEF · Kari-Pekka Martimo Musculoskeletal disorders, disability and work Kari-Pekka Martimo Musculoskeletal disorders (MSD) are the most important causes of temporary

61

3pREVIOuSSTuDIESONMuSCuLOSKELETALDISORDERS,DISABILITYANDWORK

thatstudy,psychosocialfactorsseemedtomoderatethedisablingeffectsofpain,evenwithinthefirstweeksafterpainonset.Accordingtotheavailableevidence,subjectiveinterpretationsandappraisalsofpatientswouldbemorepowerfulpredictorsofpostbackinjuryrecoverythanphysicalexaminationvariables(Shawetal.2005).

Individuals'subjectiveperceptionsofpersonalandenvironmentalissuesinfluenceRTW.Itwasstatedthatthepersonalmeaningofdisabil-ityandRTWrelevancywouldbetwokeyconstructsinunderstandingRTWfromtheindividual'sperspective(Shawetal.2002a).Throughouttheexperienceofbecomingbetterandreturningtowork,theworkersassessedtheimpactofpersonalandexternalfactorsthatcontributedtotheirworkdisability.Theyalsoevaluatedtheirperformancecapabilities,andexaminedtheimportanceofworkandtheconsequencesofworkdisabilitywithintheirlifecircumstances.

Basedontheoriesoffearandavoidancebehaviour,Waddelletal.pos-tulatedthatpatients'beliefsabouthowphysicalactivityandworkaffecttheirLBParestronglyrelatedtosicknessabsenceduetoLBP(Waddelletal.1993).Inamorerecentlongitudinalstudythebeliefsaboutbackpainwerestudiedinrelationtorecoveryrateover52consecutiveweeks(Elferingetal.2009).Higherlevelsofwork-relatedfear-avoidancebeliefs(i.e.,beliefsregardingtheinevitableconsequencesofLBPinthefuture)predictedgreaterweeklyLBPandimpairment.Fasterrecoveryandpainreliefovertimewereseeninthosewhoreportedlesswork-relatedfearavoidanceandfewernegativebackbeliefs.

Inastudyofpatientswithoperativelytreatedhanddisordersorinjuries(Opsteeghetal.2009),threefactors,i.e.higherpainintensity,accidentattributedtoworkandsymptomsofpost-traumaticstress,werethemostimportantdeterminantsofdelayedRTW.Inanotherprospec-tivecohortstudy(Baldwinetal.2007),baselinephysicalfunctioningandoverallmentalandphysicalhealthstatusweremorepredictiveofspecificpatternsofpost-injuryemploymentthanpainintensitymeasures.

3.4.2. Work environment and work organisation

PsychosocialandphysicalworkenvironmentriskfactorswereexaminedaspredictorsofRTWinaDanishprospectivestudy(Labriolaetal.2006).Contrarytopreviousstudies,nosignificantassociationwasfound

Page 64: Kari-Pekka Martimo - UEF · Kari-Pekka Martimo Musculoskeletal disorders, disability and work Kari-Pekka Martimo Musculoskeletal disorders (MSD) are the most important causes of temporary

62

3pREVIOuSSTuDIESONMuSCuLOSKELETALDISORDERS,DISABILITYANDWORK

betweenworkplacesizeandthethreeRTWoutcomes(RTWwithinfourweeks/oneyearoftheonsetofsicknessabsenceanddurationofsicknessabsence).Lowmeaningofwork,stoopingortwistingtheback,liftingheavyloadsandrepetitivejobtaskssignificantlydecreasedthechanceofRTWwithinfourweeksoftheonsetofsicknessabsence.ThechanceofRTWafteroneyearofsicknessabsencewasdecreasedbybeingexposedtoastoopedworkpositionandhavingtodorepetitivejobtasks.Thedurationofsicknessabsencewasprolongedbylowskilldiscretion,lowmeaningofwork,liftingheavyloadsatwork,andpushingandpulling.

ModifieddutyandworkplaceaccommodationshavebeenshowntopreventprolongedworkabsencesforworkerswithMSDbydecreasingexposuretonormalworkdemandsaftermedicalevaluationandtreat-ment.Thiswasthemainfindingofareviewonthebasisof13highqualitystudies(Krauseetal.1998).Injuredworkerswhowereofferedmodifiedworkreturnedtoworkabouttwiceasoftenasthosewhowerenotgiventhisoption.

Alaterreportstrengthenedtheevidencethatworkplaceoffersofarrangementstohelptheworkerreturntoworkareassociatedwithreducedcompensationbenefitduration(Brookeretal.2001).Theaccommodationcouldbeachievedinseveralways,i.e.modifiedoralternatetasks,gradedworkexposure,worktrials,workstationredesign,activityrestrictions,reducedhours,orothereffortstotemporarilyreducephysicalworkdemands.Akeyconcernfromtheworker'sperspectiveisthatmodifiedworkarrangementsprovideasafeworkplaceenvironmentthatfacilitatesrecoveryfrominjuryratherthanexacerbatingit.Itwasreportedthatanyinterventionthatreducesabsencefromregularworkwaslikelytoreducelong-termchronicity,withallofitspersonalandfinancialcosts(Loiseletal.1997).

TheroleofasupervisorisvitalforthesuccessfulRTWofanemployee.Accordingtotheexistingevidence,theinterpersonalaspectsofsupervi-sionmaybeasimportantasphysicalworkaccommodationtofacilitateRTWafterinjury(Shawetal.2003b).Asystematicreviewofthequalita-tiveliteratureonreturntoworkafterinjuryhasbeenpublishedinordertobetterunderstandthedimensions,processes,andpracticesofRTW(MacEachenetal.2006).Thatreviewnotedtherelevanceofrecognisingthecomplexitiesrelatedtobeliefs,rolesandperceptionsofthemanyplayers.Goodwillandtrustwerethecrucialconditionsthatwerecentral

Page 65: Kari-Pekka Martimo - UEF · Kari-Pekka Martimo Musculoskeletal disorders, disability and work Kari-Pekka Martimo Musculoskeletal disorders (MSD) are the most important causes of temporary

63

3pREVIOuSSTuDIESONMuSCuLOSKELETALDISORDERS,DISABILITYANDWORK

tosuccessfulRTWarrangements.Inaddition,itwasobservedthatthereareoftensocialandcommunicationbarrierstoRTWandintermediaryplayershavethepotentialtoplayakeyroleinfacilitatingtheprocess.

Ithasbeenclaimedthatthemosteffectiveapproachestodisabilitypreventionarethosethatmaintainanopenandeffectivecommunica-tionamongworkers,physicians,andemployersinordertofacilitateasmoothandbroadlysupportedreintegrationintotheworkplace(Shawetal.2005).Thus,employerswhoprovideasupportiveandaccommodat-ingapproachtodisabilitymanagementmaynotbeabletoonlyreducedisabilitycostsbutalsoimproveworkerperceptionsoftheirfunctionalhealthaftertheinjury.

Inastudyofcasemanagementserviceforwork-relatedUED(Shawetal.2004),thetypesofaccommodationsobtainedbycasemanag-ersappearedtoberelativelyinexpensiveandincludedafullrangeofenvironmental,equipment,andadministrativechanges.Theseaccom-modationswereconsistentwithreducingupperextremitypain,eitherdirectlybyaddressingworkstationdesign(forexample,keyboard,deskedges)orindirectlybyalteringtheworkprocess(forexample,breaks,jobrotation).Inanotherreportfromthesamestudy(Lincolnetal.2002),theaccommodationswereclassifiedintothefollowingeightgeneralcategories:administrative,computer-related,furnishing,workstationlayout,environmental,accessories,lifting/carryingaids,andpersonalprotectiveequipment.

Beingcontactedbysomeonefromtheworkplacewasnotassociatedwithareductionintimereceivingcompensationbenefits(Brookeretal.2001).Itislikelythatmerelycontactingtheworkerintheabsenceofotherinterventionsisnotassociatedwithafasterreturntowork.Al-ternatively,perhapsthenatureofthecontactthatoccurredduringthestudywasnotconducivetofacilitatingafasterreturntowork.Althoughworkerswhowereofferedmodifiedworktendedtoreceivecompensationbenefitsforashortertime,theydidnotseemtohavereducedpainscores(Brookeretal.2001).Infact,asmallminorityofworkersexperiencedsubstantiallymorepainthanexpectedwhentheyresumedtheirwork.Theauthorsofthatreportrecommendedthatworkerandworkplaceas-sessmentsbeforeandafterthereturnoftheworkertoworkmayhelptoensurethatemployeesarenotreturnedtoworktooearlyortoworkplacesituationsthatreactivatetheirpain.

Page 66: Kari-Pekka Martimo - UEF · Kari-Pekka Martimo Musculoskeletal disorders, disability and work Kari-Pekka Martimo Musculoskeletal disorders (MSD) are the most important causes of temporary

64

3pREVIOuSSTuDIESONMuSCuLOSKELETALDISORDERS,DISABILITYANDWORK

3.4.3. Role of the medical provider

TreatmentstudiesonacuteLBPhavereportedone-monthRTWratesfrom70to90 %dependingonrecruitmentproceduresandinitialriskfactors.Thisratehasshownremarkableconsistencydespitejurisdictionaldifferencesinemploymentanddisabilitybenefits(Shawetal.2005).AhighrateofRTWshouldnotbeinterpretedasacompleteresolutionofpain,sincemostemployeescontinuesufferingfrompainandrelatedproductivitylossatwork(Shawetal.2009a).

Accordingtotheresultsofaliteraturereview(Hlobiletal.2005),theoptimalRTWinterventionforsubacuteLBPmightbeamixtureofexercise,education,behaviouraltreatment,andergonomicmeasures,butitwasnotclearwhichcomponent,orwhichcombinationofcom-ponents,wasthemosteffective.ThesamereviewconcludedthatRTWinterventionsusedintheearlier,acutephaseofLBPdidnotappeartobeeffectivewithrespecttoabsencefromwork.Thismaybebecauseofthefavourable,self-limitingcourseofLBPandabsencefromworkdur-ingthisacutephase.

Apopulation-basedRCTonbackpainmanagement(Loiseletal.1997)concludedthatchangestojobsandworkstationsusingpartici-patoryergonomicapproachwerepreferabletoworker-focusedstrate-giessuchasworkhardening(alternatingdaysattheoriginaljobwithprogressivelyincreasedtasksanddaysreceivingfunctionaltherapy).Inthatstudy,anintegratedclinical-occupationalmodelofmanagementofbackpainwastwotimesmoreeffectiveinincreasingtherateofreturntoregularworkthantheusualmedicalcare.

ThereisalsomoderateevidencethatthepresenceofaRTWcoordi-natorwouldbeassociatedwithasignificantreductionofworkdisabilityduration(Francheetal.2005).SixpreliminarycompetencydomainsofRTWcoordinatoractivitieshavebeenidentified(Shawetal.2008):(1)ergonomicandworkplaceassessment;(2)clinicalinterviewing;(3)socialproblemsolving;(4)workplacemediation;(5)knowledgeofbusinessandlegalissues;and(6)knowledgeofmedicalconditions.

Professionalcasemanagersmaybethesolutiontomanyofthecom-municationproblemsinvolvedindisabilitymanagement.Theseindi-vidualscouldidentifybarrierstoRTW,restorenormalcommunicationbetweenemployerandemployees,andengagethemedicalproviderinthis

Page 67: Kari-Pekka Martimo - UEF · Kari-Pekka Martimo Musculoskeletal disorders, disability and work Kari-Pekka Martimo Musculoskeletal disorders (MSD) are the most important causes of temporary

65

3pREVIOuSSTuDIESONMuSCuLOSKELETALDISORDERS,DISABILITYANDWORK

process(Pranskyetal.2004).Thenursecasemanagermaysuccessfullylegitimisethepatient’sviewpointandthusinitiateabidirectionaldialogueaboutRTWdirectlywiththeemployer.Thus,itwasclaimedthatitwasthisrestorationofcommunicationmorethananyotherinterventionthatmayhaveaccountedforthesuccessesofthismodel.However,aspatientsarenotaccustomedtocommunicatetheirconcerns,preferences,andexpectations,patienttrainingwouldbedesirabletoachievefullyeffectivebidirectionalinterchange(Pranskyetal.2004).

ParticipatoryergonomicshasbeenseenasonepromisingapproachtorehabilitationofworkerssufferingfromMSD.Loiseletal.havedescribedaprogramwithfoursteps(Loiseletal.2001):First,theergonomistmeetstheworkertocollectdataonpersonalcharacteristics.Jobdescriptionsaresoughtfromboththeworkerandhis/hersupervisor.Secondly,ameet-ingisorganisedintheworkplacewiththeworkerandthesupervisortocomparethejobdescriptions,makealistoftheriskfactorsforbackpain,andtoidentifyworkorganisationandjobdemandsrelevanttothebackpain.Thirdly,theergonomistvisitstheworkplacetoobservetheworktasksperformedbyanotherworker.Finally,theparticipatoryworkgroupmeetstoidentifyimprovementsintheworktasks.Finalacceptanceofthesesolutionsistheemployer'sresponsibility.

ErgonomicjobmodificationasacomponentofaRTWrehabilita-tionprogramisgenerallybelievedtohavepositiveeffectswithworkershavingsicknessabsenceduetobackpain(Silversteinetal.2004).Ithasbeenshown,however,thatdoctor-patientcommunicationsabouttheworkplaceandRTWareimportant,butnotsufficientintheabsenceofergonomicandorganisationalchangesintheworkplace(Dasingeretal.2001;vanDuijnetal.2005).Therefore,RTWcoordinatorsaspartofhealthserviceshavebeenclaimedtorepresentaneffectivestrategyforpromotingRTW.Accordingtoaliteraturereview(Shawetal.2008),theprincipalactivitiesofRTWcoordinationinvolveworkplaceassess-ment,planningfortransitionalduty,andfacilitatingcommunicationandagreementamongstakeholders.

InordertopromoterecoveryandearlyRTW,part-timesicknessabsenceispossibleinsomecountries(forexample,Finland,Sweden,Norway,andDenmark).However,theeffectivenessofpart-timesickleavehasbeenpoorlystudied(Kaustoetal.2008).ANorwegiancluster-randomisedstudyon"activesickleave"(returntoadjustedworksup-

Page 68: Kari-Pekka Martimo - UEF · Kari-Pekka Martimo Musculoskeletal disorders, disability and work Kari-Pekka Martimo Musculoskeletal disorders (MSD) are the most important causes of temporary

66

3pREVIOuSSTuDIESONMuSCuLOSKELETALDISORDERS,DISABILITYANDWORK

portedbysocialsecurityafterconventionalsickleavehadlasted16daysormore)showednobeneficialeffects,partlybecausethepart-timesickleavesystemwassoseldomused(Scheeletal.2002).

Almostallindividualstakingpart-timesickleavedoseemtobecon-tentwiththisarrangement;92 %ofemployeesonpart-timesickleaveinaSwedishsurveyexpressedsatisfaction(Sieurinetal.2007).Two–thirdsofthoseonfull-timesickleaveconsideredpart-timesickleaveasapotentiallygoodalternativeforthem.However,somedisadvantageshavealsobeendetected:aSwedishstudywithafollow-upof1.5yearsfoundthatpart-timesickleavestendedtolastlongerthanconventionalsickleaves(Eklundetal.2004).

Page 69: Kari-Pekka Martimo - UEF · Kari-Pekka Martimo Musculoskeletal disorders, disability and work Kari-Pekka Martimo Musculoskeletal disorders (MSD) are the most important causes of temporary

67

4. CONCEPTUAL fRAMEWORK Of ThE STUDY

Theconceptualframeworkforthestudyispresentedinfigure4.Ahealthyemployeemightdevelopsymptomsordisordersduringem-ployment(stepA).Inacaseofsymptomdevelopment,theconditioneitherallowstheemployeetocontinueworkingoralternativelytheemployeemaybeabsentfromwork(stepB).Whileatworkwiththedisorder,theemployeemayhavefullcapacitytoperformworkdutiesorhe/shemightexperienceimpairedfunctioningtosuchadegreethatproductivityatworkisreduced(stepC).Thosewhobecomesick-listedeitherreturntoworkortheirdisabilitybecomesprolonged,evenpermanent(stepD).ThisthesisaimstostudythesefourstepsusingMSDasanexample.

Page 70: Kari-Pekka Martimo - UEF · Kari-Pekka Martimo Musculoskeletal disorders, disability and work Kari-Pekka Martimo Musculoskeletal disorders (MSD) are the most important causes of temporary

68

4CONCEpTuALfRAMEWORKOfTHESTuDY

STEP B

STEP A STEP C

Healthyemployee

No symptoms or MSD

At workNormal

productivity

reduced productivity

Symptoms or/and MSD

On sick leave

return to work

Prolonged or permanent disability

rCT on effects of part-versus full-time sick leave on

rTW?

(Study V)

Productivity loss due to uED and effects of a workplace intervention?

(Studies iii, iV)

impact of disease and workplace

characteristics on work ability?

(Study ii)

Prevention of LBP caused by

exposure to lifting at work?

(Study i)

Primary prevention

Secondary prevention

Tertiary prevention

STEP D

FigurE 4. Theoretical framework of the study and the research questions

Step A

Thereisawealthofreportsinthemedicalliteratureonthehealthrisksthatworkcanposetoanemployee.Theaimofoccupationalsafetyleg-islationistosafeguardthehealthandsafetyoftheemployeesthroughriskidentification,eliminationofrisk,ormanagementoftheresidualrisk,iftheriskcannotbefullyeliminated.

Page 71: Kari-Pekka Martimo - UEF · Kari-Pekka Martimo Musculoskeletal disorders, disability and work Kari-Pekka Martimo Musculoskeletal disorders (MSD) are the most important causes of temporary

69

4CONCEpTuALfRAMEWORKOfTHESTuDY

Healthproblemsinworkingageadults,however,arenotfullypre-ventable.Thereisahighbackgroundprevalenceofmusculoskeletalsymptomseveninthegeneralpopulation,andworkcanhavearoleasanadditionalriskfactorforMSD(Waddelletal.2006).AccordingtothegeneralprinciplesofpreventionintheEUframeworkdirectiveonhealthandsafetyatwork(89/391),combatingtherisksatsourceandadaptingtheworktotheindividualshouldalwaysbegivenpriorityoverindividualprotectivemeasuresandinstructionstotheworkers.

Step B

ThedisordermaycauseimpairmentintheactivityandparticipationdomainsoftheICFmodel.Atwork,thistypicallymeansthattheem-ployeecannotcontinueworking,butinsteadremainsabsentfromwork.Contextualfactorsseemtoplayamajorroleinthisprocess(Johanssonetal.2004;Shawetal.2009b).Ithasbeenshownthat(long-term)sicknessabsenceanddisabilityduetoMSDdependmoreonindividualandwork-relatedpsychosocialfactorsthanonbiomedicalfactorsorthephysicaldemandsatwork(Walker-Boneetal.2005).

Step C

SicknessabsenteeismasareflectionofdisablinghealthconditionisoneofthemajoroutcomesappliedinOHresearch.Duringthelastyears,however,moreattentionhasbeenpaidtotheimpactofhealthconditionsamongthoseemployeeswhocontinueatwork.Thefactthathealthproblemscauseinterferencewithworkhasbeenverifiedlately,andthetermsicknesspresenteeismhasbeenintroducedtoclarifythisphenomenon.

Step D

Absencefromworkisbeneficialfortherecoveryfromcertainillnesses.InMSDandmentaldisorders,however,itisobviousthatprolongedsicknessabsenceisamajorriskfactorforpermanentdisability.Again,thisislargelynotexplainedbymedicalgrounds,butpsychologicalandcontextualfactorsareessentialintheRTWprocess(Loiseletal.2005).

Page 72: Kari-Pekka Martimo - UEF · Kari-Pekka Martimo Musculoskeletal disorders, disability and work Kari-Pekka Martimo Musculoskeletal disorders (MSD) are the most important causes of temporary

70

4CONCEpTuALfRAMEWORKOfTHESTuDY

Inordertoavoidthenegativeconsequencesofprolongedsickleave,thedisabilityhastobemanagedseparatelyfromthemanagementofthemedicalconditionitself.Theriskfactorsand,hence,themeanstoenhanceRTWprocessaredifferentfromthoseoftheunderlyinghealthdisorder.

Page 73: Kari-Pekka Martimo - UEF · Kari-Pekka Martimo Musculoskeletal disorders, disability and work Kari-Pekka Martimo Musculoskeletal disorders (MSD) are the most important causes of temporary

71

5. STUDY qUESTIONS AND hYPOThESES

1. Can the increased risk of LBP associated with heavy lifting at work be reduced by training the employees in correct lifting techniques or assistive devices? (StudyI)

BasedontheavailableevidenceonmanualmaterialhandlingasariskfactorforLBP,thehypothesisevaluatedinthissystematicreviewwasthat trainingcorrecttechniquesinliftingheavyloadsatworkand/orassistivedevicescouldreducetheriskofbackinjury(StepA).

2. What is the impact of disease and workplace characteristics on perceived work ability among employees seeking medical advice? (StudyII)

HowdoworkersvisitingtheirOHphysicianswithdifferentdiseases,andespeciallyMSD,assesstheircurrentworkability,andwhataretherelationshipsbetweentheworkers'perceptionsorexpectationsandself-assesseddisability?Thehypothesistestedwasthatperceivedpartialworkabilityandwork-relatednessofhealthproblemswouldbecommonandinterrelated(StepB).

3. How much productivity at work is impaired by medically verified UED?(StudyIII)

Productivitylosswhileatworkhasbeenshowntobecommonamongworkersreportingmusculoskeletalsymptoms.ThehypothesisforthissurveywasthatdiagnosedUEDwouldimpairworkperformanceeventhoughactualsickleavewouldnotbeneeded(StepC).

Page 74: Kari-Pekka Martimo - UEF · Kari-Pekka Martimo Musculoskeletal disorders, disability and work Kari-Pekka Martimo Musculoskeletal disorders (MSD) are the most important causes of temporary

72

5STuDYquESTIONSANDHYpOTHESES

4. Can productivity loss at work be reduced by an ergonomic in-tervention?(StudyIV)

Thestudyhypothesiswasthatproductivitylossatworkcouldbeusedasanoutcomeindicatorininterventionstudiesand,duringrecoveryfromUED,anindividuallytailoredergonomicinterventioncouldreduceproductivitylosscomparedtousualmedicalcare(StepC).

5. How can the effectiveness of part-time sick leave be evaluated in the management of MSD?(StudyV)

ThehypothesiswasthatarandomisedcontrolledtrialcouldbedesignedandimplementedintheFinnishOHStoinvestigatetheeffectsofpart-timesickleaveonreturntofull-timework(StepD).

Page 75: Kari-Pekka Martimo - UEF · Kari-Pekka Martimo Musculoskeletal disorders, disability and work Kari-Pekka Martimo Musculoskeletal disorders (MSD) are the most important causes of temporary

73

6. MATERIAL AND METhODS

6.1. Study populations

Inallindividualstudies,theparticipantswereworkingadults.Studiesincludedinthesystematicreview(studyI)wereperformedinhealthorhomecare(eightstudies)oramongbaggagehandlersorpostalworkers(threestudies).Thetotalnumberofparticipantsinthereviewwas18492.StudyIIincluded723employeesfromthechemicalindustryorpublicsector,whereas168to177employeesinstudiesIII–IVcamefromthehealthcareandcommercialsectors.

Therearesomedifferencesbetweenthestudieswithrespecttothehealthstatusofthestudypopulationsandtheuseofhealthservices(table5).Withtheexceptionofonestudy(II),inwhichpatientswereeligibleirrespectiveofanyhealthproblemsnecessitatingaconsultationwiththeOHphysician,allotherstudies(I,III–V)inthisthesisincludeonlysubjectswithMSD.

Table 5. Description of the included studies.

Type of study Population Study intervention

Main outcome

Study I

Systematic review Workers frequently exposed to heavy lifting

Lifting advice and/or devices

LBP and related sickness absence

Study II

Survey (questionnaire)

Workers seeking medical advice at OHS

- Self-assessed work ability, work-relatedness of the health problem

Study III

Survey (baseline assessment of rCT)

Workers with medically verified uED

- Self-assessed uED-related productivity loss at work

Study IV

rCT Workers with medically verified uED

Ergonomic advice and worksite visit

Self-assessed uED-related productivity loss at work

Study V

rCT(protocol)

Workers with medically verified MSD and in need of instant sick leave

Part-time sick leave

return to full-time work

Page 76: Kari-Pekka Martimo - UEF · Kari-Pekka Martimo Musculoskeletal disorders, disability and work Kari-Pekka Martimo Musculoskeletal disorders (MSD) are the most important causes of temporary

74

6MATERIALANDMETHODS

Thesystematicreview(studyI)summarisingtheevidenceonthepre-ventiveeffectsoftrainingandliftingequipmentonbackpainincludedstudieswithemployeesexposedtoheavyliftingatworkwhowerenotactivelyseekingtreatmentforcurrentbackpain.

Thesurvey(studyII)includedeachemployeeduringthestudyperiodcomingfortheirfirstappointmentwithanOHphysicianbecauseofanyhealthproblem.StudiesIIIandIVfocusedonlyonemployeeswithsymp-tomsintheupperextremitiesandnoneedforsickleave,whereasstudyVincludesallworkerswithanyMSDnecessitatingsickleave.TheemployeeswereexcludediftheconditionnecessitatedmedicalcareinstudyI,sickleaveinstudiesIII–IV,orthepainintensityscorewassevenormoreonascalefromzerototeninstudyV;ifthedisorderwascausedbymajortrauma,infection,orauto-immunedisease;ifthedisorderwascomplicatedbyanysevereco-morbidityorcondition(malignancy,fibromyalgia,mentaldisorder,occupationalinjuryordisease,scheduledorpriorsurgery);orthefollow-upinstudiesIV–Vwouldhavebeencomplicatedbyotherfactors(retirement,pregnancy,orotherlongerleavefromwork).

6.2. Methods

Theincludedfivestudiesrepresentthreedifferenttypesofstudies:systematicreview,survey(cross-sectionalquestionnaireandbaselineassessment)andRCT(table5).

6.2.1. Systematic review (Study I)

Thecurrentinterestinevidence-basedmedicinehasledtoanextensiveincreaseinthepublicationofsystematicreviewsandtothedevelopmentofmethodologicalguidelinesforsystematicreviews,becauseasystematicapproachisknowntobelesssusceptibletobiasthananarrativeapproach(vanTulderetal.1997;vanTulderetal.2003).

Thissystematicreviewincludedallstudieswithinterventionsthatmodifytechniquesforhandlingheavyobjectsorpatientsmanually,ifthestudyusedbackpain,consequentdisability,orsickleaveasthemainoutcome.Interventionsthatwerepermittedincludededucationalclasses,individualtrainingandinstructions,posters,leaflets,videos,audiotapes,orcombinationsofseveralinterventions.Inordertofindall

Page 77: Kari-Pekka Martimo - UEF · Kari-Pekka Martimo Musculoskeletal disorders, disability and work Kari-Pekka Martimo Musculoskeletal disorders (MSD) are the most important causes of temporary

75

6MATERIALANDMETHODS

relevantresearchreports,thesearchstrategydevelopedbytheCochranebackreviewgroupwasutilized(vanTulderetal.2003).TheprimarysearchfocusedonRCTswithasecondarysearchoncohortstudieswithaconcurrentcontrolgroup.

TheliteraturesearchwascarriedoutbetweenAugustandNovember2005.Searchstrategies,useddatabasesandthedetaileddescriptionofthereviewprocessaregivenintheCochraneLibraryversionofthereview(Martimoetal.2007).

Inordertomakeasecondaryanalysisusingrelevantcohortstudieswithaconcurrentcontrolgroup,thesensitivesearchstrategyforOHinterventionstudieswasapplied(Verbeeketal.2005).Twoauthorsscreenedtheobtainedtitlesandabstractsforeligibility.

ThemethodologicalqualityoftherandomisedtrialswasassessedusingthecriteriaandclassificationrecommendedbytheCochraneBackReviewGroup(vanTulderetal.2003).Thequalityofastudywasconsideredashighifmorethanhalfofthecriteriawerefulfilled.Fortheappraisalofcohortstudies,anothersetofcriteria(Slimetal.2003),validatedfornon-randomisedstudies,wereused.

Theprimaryanalysisofthereviewwasbasedontheevidencefromrandomisedtrialsonly.Inthesecondaryanalysisusingthecohortstud-ies,theresultsofeachcomparisonweresummarisedinaqualitativemanner.Thereafter,theconclusionswerecomparedfromtheprimaryandsecondaryanalyses.

6.2.2. Surveys (Studies II–III)

InstudyII,patientsattendingamedicalconsultationattwoOHcentres(oneinchemicalindustryandtheotherinpublicsectorinthecapitalarea)weregivenananonymousquestionnairebeforemeetingthephysician(N=12).Age,genderandoccupationwerecollectedtogetherwiththeresponsetoanopen-endedquestiononthenatureanddurationofthemaindiseaseorsymptomthatnecessitatedtheconsultation.Onlythefirstconsultationofeachpatientduringthestudyperiodwasincluded.

Patientassessedwork-ability(fullyorpartlyabletowork,disabled)andwork-relatednessofthehealthproblem("causedoraggravatedbywork"),andthepotentialofwork-relatedinterventionsinalleviatingthe

Page 78: Kari-Pekka Martimo - UEF · Kari-Pekka Martimo Musculoskeletal disorders, disability and work Kari-Pekka Martimo Musculoskeletal disorders (MSD) are the most important causes of temporary

76

6MATERIALANDMETHODS

symptoms.Patientsweretoldthattheirphysicianswouldnotseetheirresponses.Thephysicianswereaskedtoanswerthesamequestionsim-mediatelyaftertheconsultation.Onlypatientswhogavethesamereasonforthevisitasindicatedbytheirphysicianwereincludedintheanalysis.

StudyIIIwasalsocarriedoutincollaborationwiththreeOHunits.Allsubjectsaged18to60yearswereconsideredaspotentiallyeligible,iftheywereseekingmedicaladviceintheoccupationalhealthservices(OHS)becauseofupperextremitysymptomsthathadstartedorwereexacerbatedlessthan30dayspriortothemedicalconsultation('earlysymptoms').WithinthreedaysafterseekingmedicaladviceintheOHS,thesubjectwasexaminedattheFinnishInstituteofOccupationalHealth(FIOH)byaphysician,whodidnotparticipateinanalysingthedata.Theclinicaldiagnosiswasmadebyapplyingstandardizeddiagnosticcriteriaforeachsymptomentity(Sluiteretal.2001).

TheoutcomeofstudyIIIwasself-assessedproductivitylossatwork.ItwasassessedwithtwoquestionsabouttheimpactofUEDonworkperformance(QQmethod)duringtheprecedingfullworkday(Brouweretal.1999).Thefirstquestionwas:'Assesstheimpactofyourupperextremitysymptomsandmarkonascalefrom0("practicallynothing")to10("regularquantity")howmuchworkyouwereabletoperformascomparedtoyournormalworkday'.Thesecondquestionwas:'Assesstheimpactofyourupperextremitysymptomsandmarkonascalefrom0("verypoorquality")to10("regularquality")thequalityofyourworkascomparedtoyournormalworkday'.ThetranslationofthequestionsintoFinnishwasmadebasedontheoriginalDutchversionanditsEng-lishtranslationadheringtotheirwordingandstyleascloselyaspossible.ThevalidityoftheoriginalQQmethodhasbeenstudiedincomparisonwithothermeasurements(Brouweretal.1999;Meerdingetal.2005).Self-reportedproductivityonthismethodhasbeenshowntocorrelatewellwithobjectiveworkoutput(Meerdingetal.2005).

Adichotomousvariableforproductivityloss(yes/no)wasformedsothatthosewhoscoredavalue0–9ineitherofthetwoquestionswereclassifiedas'reportingproductivityloss',andwerecomparedtothosewhoscored10inbothquestions.Themagnitudeofproductivityloss(i.e.,howmuchproductivitywasreduced)wascalculatedusingtheformula[1–(quality/10)x(quantity/10)]x100 %,modifiedfromanearlierstudy(Hoeijenbosetal.2005).

Page 79: Kari-Pekka Martimo - UEF · Kari-Pekka Martimo Musculoskeletal disorders, disability and work Kari-Pekka Martimo Musculoskeletal disorders (MSD) are the most important causes of temporary

77

6MATERIALANDMETHODS

ThesubjectwasaskedtoratetheintensityofpaincausedbyUEDonascalefrom0to10(0correspondingto"nopain"and10to"theworstpossiblepain")andpaininterferencewithwork,leisuretimeandsleepduringthelastsevendays(from0,"nointerferenceatall",to10,"theworstpossibleinterference").SickleavesduetoUEDduringthepreceding12monthswerealsoinquired.

Fortheassessmentofphysicalexposuresatwork,theOHphysicianinterviewedthesubjectaboutthefrequencyofliftingloadsweighing5kgormore;workingwithhand(s)abovetheshoulderlevel;andwhetherworktasksrequiredfrequentorsustainedelevationsofthearms.Work-ingatakeyboard,prolongedforcefulgripping,aswellaspinchgripthateitherrequiredforcefulexertionordeviatedwristposture,werealsoinquired.Eachfactorwasdichotomizedusingacut-offofbeingexposedfor10 %oftheworktimeduringtheworkday.

JobstrainwasmeasuredwiththeJobContentQuestionnaire(Karaseketal.1998).Smokinghabitsandleisurephysicalactivitywereinquired,andwaistcircumferencewasmeasured.Fear-avoidancebeliefswereas-sessedusingfouritemsadaptedfromWaddelletal:"Physicalactivitymakesmysymptomsworse","Ifmysymptomsbecomeworse,itmeansthatIshouldstopwhatIwasdoing","Mypainiscausedbywork",and"Ishouldnotcontinueinmypresentjobbecauseofthesymptoms"(Waddelletal.1993;Estlander2003).

6.2.3. Randomised controlled trials (Studies Iv–v)

InstudyIV,theeffectivenessofaworkplacerelatedinterventionwasstudiedusingself-assessedproductivitylosscausedbyUEDasthemainoutcome.InformationfromstudyIIIservedasbaselinefortheinter-vention,andthefollow-uptimewas12weeks.Randomizationintointerventionandcontrolgroupswasperformedbythephysicianusingtablesofrandomnumbersinthreeblocks(symptomsinwristorforearm,elbow,orshoulder)andsealedenvelopes.Basedonpowercalculations,thetargetwastoinclude500subjectsinthestudy.

Allsubjectsreceivedthebestcurrentpracticetreatment(Varonenetal.2007).Thesupervisorsoftheemployeesintheinterventiongroupwerecontactedbyphonebythephysiciantodiscusspotentialaccom-modationsatwork.Afewdaysaftertheclinicalexamination,anoccu-

Page 80: Kari-Pekka Martimo - UEF · Kari-Pekka Martimo Musculoskeletal disorders, disability and work Kari-Pekka Martimo Musculoskeletal disorders (MSD) are the most important causes of temporary

78

6MATERIALANDMETHODS

pationalphysiotherapistvisitedtheworkplace.TheaimoftheworksitevisitwastoinvestigateergonomicimprovementsthatwereconsideredbeneficialfortherecoveryfromtheUED.Theassessmentincludedthephysicalworkenvironmentandtheavailabletoolsorinstruments,work-ingpostures,forcerequirements,workpaceandbreaksduringwork,aswellasassessingtheemployee'spossibilitiestocontinueworking.Theproposalswerediscussedtogetherwiththeemployeeandthesupervisorwhothenmadethefinaldecisiononthetechnicalandadministrativechangesrequiredtomodifytheworkload.

Theprimaryoutcomemeasurewasself-assessedproductivitylossatwork,asdescribedinstudyIII,measuredatbaseline,eightweeksand12weeks.Inaddition,theemployeeswereinquiredaboutthenumbersofsickleaveepisodesduetoanyreason,andexclusivelyduetoUED,dur-ingfollow-up.Thecontentsoftheergonomicinterventionsasreportedbythephysiotherapistsduringtheworkplacevisitswerealsoanalysed.

Theprotocolofthesecondinterventionstudy(studyV)aimstoassessthehealtheffectsofearlypart-timesickleavecomparedtoconventionalfull-daysickleave.Thisprotocolwasdesignedbasedontheresultsofpreviouslypublishedstudiesonpart-timesickleave(Kaustoetal.2008).Thefeasibilityofthestudydesignwasdiscussedandmodifiedwiththerepresentativesfromtheparticipatingworkplaces.PriortotheRCT,theprotocolandthequestionnairesweretestedbyoneOHSunitinapilotstudybasedonvoluntaryparticipationofsomeemployeesinpart-timesickleave.ThefinalprotocolwasapprovedbytheCoordinatingEthicsCommitteeofHospitalDistrictofHelsinkiandUusimaa.

ThisstudyVison-goingandthereforeonlytheprotocolisdescribedinthisthesis.InthosepatientswithMSDseekingmedicaladviceandfulfillinginclusioncriteria,theOHphysicianinvitesthesubjectsintothestudy.Thephysicianalsoinformstheemployeeaboutthestudyanditsaims,andiftheemployeeagreestoparticipate,informedconsentwillbesigned.Thisincludesapermissiontocontactthesupervisor,preferablyduringthepatient’svisit,inordertoinvestigatewhetherwork-relatedarrangementsforpart-timesickleavewouldbefeasible,inthecasethattheemployeeisallocatedtotheinterventiongroup.Ifthesupervisordisagrees,thentheworkerwillbeexcludedfromthetrial.

Oncetheagreementsfromtheemployeeandthesupervisorareobtainedandbeforetherandomisation,thephysiciandeterminesthe

Page 81: Kari-Pekka Martimo - UEF · Kari-Pekka Martimo Musculoskeletal disorders, disability and work Kari-Pekka Martimo Musculoskeletal disorders (MSD) are the most important causes of temporary

79

6MATERIALANDMETHODS

lengthofthesicknessabsencebasedonsymptoms,clinicalfindingsandbackgroundinformation.Subsequently,iftheemployeeisallocatedtopart-timesickleave(interventiongroup),dailyworkloadwillbereducedbylimitingtheworkingtime.Also,ifnecessary,remainingworktaskscouldbemodifiedsothatworkingispossibledespitethepresenceofsymptoms.Inthecontrolgroup,workloadiseliminatedbyfull-timesickleave.Bothgroupsreceiveappropriatemedicaladvice,andtheneedformedicaltreatmentsandacontrolvisitaredeterminedasusual.

6.3. Statistical analyses

6.3.1. Systematic review (Study I)

Fortheeligiblestudiesthatdidnotadjustforclusterrandomisation,thedesigneffectwascalculatedbasedonafairlylargeassumedintraclustercorrelationof0.10(Campbelletal.2001),followingthemethodsdefinedintheCochranehandbook(Deeksetal.2005).Thelengthoffollow-upwascategorizedasshortterm(lessthanthreemonths),intermediate(threeto12months)orlongterm(morethan12months).Thisclas-sificationisusedforthedescriptionoftheresults.

Forcomparisonswithdichotomousoutcomesandsufficientdata,theadjustedresultsofeachtrialwereplottedasoddsratios(ORs).Forcomparisonswithsimilarinterventionsbutwithbothdichotomousandcontinuousoutcomemeasurements,aneffectsizewascalculatedbasedonthelogarithmoftheORforstudieswithdichotomousoutcomes,andonthestandardisedmeandifferenceforstudieswithcontinuousoutcomes(Chinn2000).TheORsofstudieswerecombinedthatcomparedsimilarinterventionsandhavingmeasuredbackpainorbackinjurywithasimilarfollow-uptime.Theeffectsizesofstudieswithsimilarinterventionsthatmeasuredsicknessabsencerateordisabilityscoreatasimilarfollow-uptimewerecombinedbyusingthegenericinversevariancemethodusingthesoftwareasimplementedinRevMan4.2.forbothmeta-analyses.

6.3.2. Surveys (Study II–III)

InstudyII,factorsassociatedwithself-assessedworkabilitywerestudiedinamultinomiallogisticregressionmodel(SPSS®Programme,version

Page 82: Kari-Pekka Martimo - UEF · Kari-Pekka Martimo Musculoskeletal disorders, disability and work Kari-Pekka Martimo Musculoskeletal disorders (MSD) are the most important causes of temporary

80

6MATERIALANDMETHODS

12.0.1).Theoutcomevariablewasworkabilityinthreelevels('able','par-tiallyable',and'unable').Theexplanatoryvariablesweregender,agegroup,occupationalstatus,OHcentre,durationofsymptoms,diseasegroup,work-relatednessofdiseaseandpotentialofwork-relatedinterventions.

LogisticregressionmodelswereusedinstudyIIItostudythedeter-minantsofproductivityloss.TheresultsarepresentedwithORswith95 %confidenceintervals(95 %CI).Multivariablemodelsincludedage,genderandthosevariablesassociatedwithproductivitylosswithaP-value<0.20inthegender-adjustedorage-andgender-adjustedmodels.Duetothecollinearityofpainintensityandpaininterference,nomutualadjustmentwasperformed,whereastheireffectswereassessedinseparatemodelsadjustedfortheothercovariates.Inadditiontotheseparateeffectsofpainintensity,excessivejobstrainandphysicalloadfactorsonproductivityloss,theirjointeffectswerealsoestimated,sinceitwashypothesizedthatthesevariablescouldactsynergistically.Multi-plicativeinteractionswerealsotestedbyincludinginteractionproductsinthemultivariablemodel.Thepossibleeffectmodificationbyagewasalsoinvestigatedwithstratifiedanalysesusingmedianage(45years)ascut-off.STATA,version8.2,softwarewasusedfortheanalyses.

6.3.3. Randomised controlled trials (Studies Iv–v)

DatainstudyIVwereanalysedaccordingtotheintention-to-treatprinciple.Missingdataonproductivityat12weeks(7inthecontrolgroupand8intheinterventiongroup)weresubstitutedwiththevalueat8weeks.Threeoutcomeswereused:proportionofproductivityloss(dichotomized),magnitudeofproductivityloss(continuous)andchangeinmagnitudeofproductivitylossfrombaseline(continuous).At8and12weeks,thetestfordifferences(two-tailed,P<0.05)waschi-squaredtestfortheproportionandtwo-samplet-testformagnitudeandchange.Generalizedestimatingequation(GEE)wasappliedtoanalyserepeatedmeasuresdata(Hanleyetal.2003).Thelinkfunctionwasspecifiedas"logit"forthedichotomizedoutcome.Inadditiontotheallocationgroupandfollow-uptime,age(continuous),gender,exposuretophysicalworkloadfactors(liftingloads>5kg,armelevationsatoraboveshoulderlevel,orforcefulorpinchgrip)andfear-avoidancebeliefs(continuous)wereincludedascovariatesinthemodels.

Page 83: Kari-Pekka Martimo - UEF · Kari-Pekka Martimo Musculoskeletal disorders, disability and work Kari-Pekka Martimo Musculoskeletal disorders (MSD) are the most important causes of temporary

81

6MATERIALANDMETHODS

Itwasalsointendedtoidentifysomemodifiablesubgroupvariablesthatcouldaffecttheeffectivenessoftheintervention.Subgroupanalyseswereperformedbyusingthefollowingvariables:jobdemand,jobcontrol,fear–avoidancebeliefs(alldichotomizedusingthemedian),exposuretophysicalworkloadfactors,andpriorsicknessabsenceduetoUED.Totakeintoaccountthedifferenceinthemagnitudeofproductivitylossbetweentheinterventionandcontrolgroupatbaseline,thechangesinproductivitylossduringthefollow-upwereutilizedinthesub-groupanalyses.STATA,version10,software(StataCorpLP,CollegeStation,TX,USA)wasusedfortheanalyses.

InstudyV,asurvivalanalysiswillbeusedtostudythetimetoRTWintheinterventionandcontrolgroup.Theamountofsickleavedayswillbeanalysedat12and24months,andtheassociationsbetweentheoutcomesandbackgroundvariableswillbeanalysedusinggenerallinearmodels.Inaddition,thechangeinsymptomsanddisabilityindiceswillbestudiedatvarioustimepointsusinggenerallinearmodelsforrepeatedmeasurements.

Thecostsandbenefitstotheemployee,employerandsocietywillbeestimatedinbothstudygroups.CostsduetolostworkingtimewillbeanalysedseparatelytakingintoaccountthecompensationfromtheSocialInsuranceInstitutiontotheemployerduringfull-orpart-timesickleave.Dataoncostsoftheusedhealthservices,medications,andmedicalaids(duetothemainhealthproblem)willalsobecollected.Inaddition,theanalysiswillincludethecompensationofthelostworkinputusingstand-ins(salary,trainingtime)orovertime(performedbythecolleaguesofthestudysubjects),aswellasthetimethesupervisorusedtoaccommodatethenewworkarrangements.Allanalyseswillbemadebasedonanintention-to-treatprinciple.

Thenon-monetarybenefitswillbestudiedbasedonself-assessedpro-ductivityatwork(Brouweretal.1999),aswellasthereductionofpainanddisabilitymeasuredonascalefrom0to10.Ifthereisadifferencebetweenthegroupsintheoutcomemeasurements,acost-effectivenessanalysiswillbeundertakendividingthecostsbytheunitsofdifferenceintheoutcome.Ifthereisnosignificantdifferencebetweenthestudygroupsinanyofthehealthrelatedoutcomes,theanalysisoftotalcostsinbothgroupswillbeappliedindrawingthefinalconclusions.

Page 84: Kari-Pekka Martimo - UEF · Kari-Pekka Martimo Musculoskeletal disorders, disability and work Kari-Pekka Martimo Musculoskeletal disorders (MSD) are the most important causes of temporary

82

7. RESULTS

7.1. Training and lifting devices for preventing back pain (Study I)

Altogether,3547titleswerefoundastheresultoftheprimarysearchstrategyinninedatabases.Thesensitivesearchstrategyprovided47additionaltitles.Another17referenceswerefoundinamanualsearch.Thusfromthetotalof3611articles,101wereselectedforcloserevalua-tion.Eighty-ninearticlesdidnotmeettheinclusioncriteria.Twoarticles(Fanelloetal.1999;Fanelloetal.2002)reportedonthesamestudy.Consequently,11studieswereincludedinthereview.

Fouroftheincludedstudieswereclusterrandomised(Daltroyetal.1997;vanPoppeletal.1998;Yassietal.2001;Krausetal.2002),twowereindividuallyrandomised(Reddelletal.1992;Mülleretal.2001),andfivewerecohortstudies(Dehlinetal.1981;Feldsteinetal.1993;Best1997;Fanelloetal.1999;Hartvigsenetal.2005).Two(Daltroyetal.1997;vanPoppeletal.1998)randomisedtrialsandallcohortstudieswerelabelledashighquality.Thecharacteristicsoftheincludedstudiesaredescribedintable6.

Inthreerandomisedtrials(Mülleretal.2001;Yassietal.2001;Krausetal.2002)andallfivecohortstudies,manualhandlingwasrelatedtopatientcare.Postalworkerswerestudiedinone(Daltroyetal.1997),andbaggagehandlersintwo(Reddelletal.1992;vanPoppeletal.1998)trials.Inallofthejobsstudied,theparticipantswereexertingsufficientstrainonthebackleavingampleroomforalleviationbyeffectiveinter-ventions.Thenumberofparticipantsinrandomisedtrialsvariedfrom51to12,772,andthefollow-uptimefrom6monthsto5.5years.Thecohortstudiesincluded45to345participants,andthefollow-uptimesvariedfrom8weeksto2years.

Page 85: Kari-Pekka Martimo - UEF · Kari-Pekka Martimo Musculoskeletal disorders, disability and work Kari-Pekka Martimo Musculoskeletal disorders (MSD) are the most important causes of temporary

83

7RESuLTSTa

ble

6.

Ch

arac

teri

stic

s o

f in

clu

ded

stu

die

s

Des

ign

, p

arti

cip

ants

Inte

rven

tio

n v

co

ntr

ol

len

gth

of

follo

w-u

pO

utc

om

esM

eth

od

olo

gic

al

qu

alit

yD

altr

oy

1997

, uSA

Clu

ster

ran

dom

ised

35

97 p

osta

l wor

kers

Trai

ning

and

erg

onom

ic s

ite

visi

t v

stan

dard

tra

inin

g (v

ideo

)5.

5 ye

ars

Back

inju

ry r

ate

(dis

ablin

g an

d no

n-di

sabl

ing)

per

100

0 w

orke

r ye

ars

of e

xpos

ure

Hig

h (6

v 1

1)

Kra

us

2002

, uSA

Clu

ster

ran

dom

ised

, 12

772

hom

e ca

re

wor

kers

Safe

ty m

eetin

g v

back

bel

t,

no in

terv

entio

n28

mon

ths

Back

inju

ry r

ate

per

100

fu

ll tim

e eq

uiva

lent

sLo

w (5

v 1

1)

van

Popp

el

1998

, N

ethe

rland

s

Clu

ster

ran

dom

ised

, 31

2 ca

rgo

hand

lers

Trai

ning

v lu

mba

r su

ppor

t,

lum

bar

supp

ort

and

trai

ning

, no

inte

rven

tion

6 m

onth

sN

o of

sub

ject

s w

ith L

BP;

No

of s

ubje

cts

with

sic

k

leav

e an

d N

o of

day

s pe

r m

onth

with

LBP

; No

of d

ays

per

mon

th o

f si

ck le

ave

beca

use

of L

BP

Hig

h (8

v 1

1)

Yass

i 200

1,

Can

ada

Clu

ster

ran

dom

ised

, 34

6 nu

rses

“No

stre

nuou

s lif

ting”

v

“saf

e lif

ting”

pro

gram

me,

“u

sual

pra

ctic

e”

1 ye

arEx

perie

nced

wor

k re

late

d

LBP

and

its in

tens

ity d

urin

g pa

st w

eek;

Osw

estr

y di

s-ab

ility

que

stio

nnai

re; r

ate

of

back

or

trun

k re

late

d in

jurie

s

Low

(4 v

11)

Mül

ler

2001

, g

erm

any

rand

omis

ed,

51 n

urse

sTr

aini

ng v

exe

rcis

e in

sp

ace

curl

12 m

onth

sFr

eque

ncy

of L

BPLo

w (3

v 1

1)

redd

el 1

992,

u

SAra

ndom

ised

, 64

2 fle

et s

ervi

ce c

lerk

sTr

aini

ng v

bac

k be

lt, b

ack

belt

and

trai

ning

, no

inte

rven

tion

8 m

onth

sBa

ck in

jury

rat

e

(no

raw

dat

a av

aila

ble)

Low

(2 v

11)

Fane

llo 1

999,

Fr

ance

Coh

ort

stud

y,

272

nurs

es a

nd c

lean

ers

Trai

ning

and

fee

dbac

k at

wor

k v

no in

terv

entio

n2

year

sPr

eval

ence

of

LBP

Hig

h (8

v 1

2)

Best

199

7,

Aus

tral

iaC

ohor

t st

udy,

55

nur

ses

Trai

ning

v in

-hou

se o

rient

atio

n12

mon

ths

Self

repo

rted

LBP

dur

ing

pa

st w

eek

and

past

yea

rH

igh

(8 v

12)

Deh

lin 1

981,

Sw

eden

Coh

ort

stud

y,

45 n

urse

sTr

aini

ng v

phy

sica

l exe

rcis

e,

no in

terv

entio

n8

wee

ksFr

eque

ncy

of lo

w b

ack

sy

mpt

oms

Hig

h (7

v 1

2)

Feld

stei

n

1993

, uSA

Coh

ort

stud

y,

55 n

urse

sTr

aini

ng, p

ract

ical

fee

dbac

k v

no in

terv

entio

n1

mon

th“C

ompo

site

bac

k pa

in”

Hig

h (7

v 1

2)

Har

tvig

sen

20

05, D

enm

ark

Coh

ort

stud

y,

345

nurs

esTr

aini

ng v

one

inst

ruct

iona

l m

eetin

g2

year

sN

o of

epi

sode

s an

d N

o of

da

ys w

ith L

BP d

urin

g pa

st

year

Hig

h (9

v 1

2)

Page 86: Kari-Pekka Martimo - UEF · Kari-Pekka Martimo Musculoskeletal disorders, disability and work Kari-Pekka Martimo Musculoskeletal disorders (MSD) are the most important causes of temporary

84

7RESuLTS

Thetraininginterventionsfocusedonliftingtechniques,andtheirdura-tionvariedfromasinglesessiontoonceaweektrainingforaperiodoftwoyears(Table7).Inthreestudies,thetrainingwassupportedbyfollow-upandfeedbackattheworkplace.Theadvocatedliftingtechniqueswerenotdescribedindetail.Theinvolvementofsupervisorswasclearlyindicatedinthreestudies,andtheencouragementtouseavailableliftingaidswasstatedinfivestudies.Aprofessionalinstructorwasusedinmoststudies.

Compliancewiththeinstructionsandwiththeuseofassistivede-viceswasmonitoredinfivestudies(Feldsteinetal.1993;Best1997;vanPoppeletal.1998;Yassietal.2001;Hartvigsenetal.2005).Threestudiesreportedpositivechangesinliftingtechniquesinthreestudiesandthereweremarginalornochangesintwostudies.Inaddition,onestudy(Daltroyetal.1993)hasreportedseparatelythattheinterventionresultedinincreasedknowledgebutnotinanysignificantimprovementofmanualhandlingbehaviour.

Comparisonbetweengroupsreceivingtrainingornointerventionintworandomisedtrials(vanPoppeletal.1998;Yassietal.2001)in-dicatedthattherewasnodifferenceintheamountofbackpain(OR0.99,95 %CI0.54to1.81)orrelateddisability(effectsize0.04,95 %CI–0.50to0.58)atintermediatefollow-up.Thesameresultwasob-tainedinanotherrandomisedtrial(Reddelletal.1992),whichwasnotincludedinthemeta-analysisbecauseinsufficientdatawerereported.Onerandomisedtrial(Krausetal.2002)showednoeffectinbackpainatlong-termfollow-up(OR1.07,95 %CI0.06to17.96).Theresultsofthreecohortstudiessupportedthoseoftherandomisedstudiesatshort-term(Dehlinetal.1981;Feldsteinetal.1993)andlong-termfollow-up(Fanelloetal.1999).

Trainingcomparedtominoradvice(video)inonerandomisedtrial(Daltroyetal.1997)didnotshowaneffectonbackpainatlong-termfollow-up(OR1.08,95 %CI0.56to2.08).Thisconclusionwassup-portedbytheresultsoftwocohortstudies(Best1997;Hartvigsenetal.2005)usingin-houseorientationorlessextensivetrainingasthecontrolinterventions.

Comparisonoftrainingandlumbarsupportusedidnotyieldasignificantdifferenceinbackpainatintermediatefollow-upaccordingtoonerandomisedtrial(Reddelletal.1992).Anotherrandomisedtrial(Krausetal.2002)cametoasimilarconclusionwithrespecttolong-termfollow-up(OR1.04,95 %CI0.06to17.38).

Page 87: Kari-Pekka Martimo - UEF · Kari-Pekka Martimo Musculoskeletal disorders, disability and work Kari-Pekka Martimo Musculoskeletal disorders (MSD) are the most important causes of temporary

7RESuLTSTa

ble

7.

Det

ails

of

inte

rven

tio

ns

in s

tud

ies

aim

ed a

t p

reve

nti

ng

bac

k in

jury

an

d p

ain

cau

sed

by

lifti

ng

an

d h

and

ling

pat

ien

ts

or

hea

vy o

bje

cts

Stu

dy

No

an

d

du

rati

on

of

sess

ion

sTi

me

span

o

f tr

ain

ing

Trai

nin

g a

s d

escr

ibed

in

art

icle

Trai

nin

g

met

ho

ds*

Man

agem

ent

com

mit

men

t

Use

of

as

sist

ive

dev

ices

erg

on

om

ic

inte

rven

tio

n(s

) in

clu

ded

Rei

nfo

r-ce

men

t in

clu

ded

Dal

troy

2 x

1.5

hour

s1

wee

kPr

oper

lift

ing

and

carr

ying

tec

hniq

ues

BYe

sN

oYe

sYe

s

Kra

usu

ncle

aru

ncle

arSa

fety

pra

ctic

es w

hen

hand

ling

patie

nts

unc

lear

Not

men

tione

dN

oN

oN

o

van

Popp

el3

x 1.

5-2

hour

s12

wee

ksA

nato

my

and

liftin

g te

chni

ques

BN

ot m

entio

ned

No

No

No

Yass

i1

x 3

hour

sSi

ngle

tr

aini

ng“S

afe

liftin

g” o

r “n

o st

renu

ous

lif

ting.

” H

andl

ing

tech

niqu

es c

oupl

ed

with

ava

ilabl

e eq

uipm

ent

BN

ot m

entio

ned

Enco

u-ra

ged

No

No

Mül

ler

unc

lear

unc

lear

unc

lear

unc

lear

Not

men

tione

du

ncle

aru

ncle

aru

ncle

ar

redd

el1

x 1

hour

Sing

le

trai

ning

Bala

ncin

g lo

ad, p

ivot

ing

inst

ead

of

twis

ting,

get

ting

clos

e to

load

, sq

uat

lift,

squ

arin

g lo

ad, m

aint

aini

ng

thre

e po

int

cont

act

BN

ot m

entio

ned

No

No

No

Best

32 h

ours

(in

tot

al)

unc

lear

Sem

isqu

at p

ostu

re a

nd w

eigh

t

tran

sfer

tec

hniq

ues

such

as

br

acin

g, p

ivot

ing,

lung

ing,

and

co

unte

rbal

anci

ng lo

ad

unc

lear

Not

men

tione

dN

oN

oN

o

Deh

lin8

x 45

min

8 w

eeks

Shor

t le

ver

arm

s du

ring

liftin

g,

min

imis

ing

wei

ght

of b

urde

n by

lift

ing

toge

ther

AN

ot m

entio

ned

Enco

u-ra

ged

No

No

Fane

llo6

(le

ngth

unc

lear

)6

days

Met

hod

revi

sed

by P

aul D

otte

as

ap

plie

d al

so b

y Be

st e

t al

unc

lear

Not

men

tione

dEn

cou-

rage

dN

oYe

s

Feld

stei

n1

x 2

+ 8

hou

rs2

wee

ksSp

ecifi

c te

chni

que

for

patie

nt t

rans

fer

BYe

sEn

cou-

rage

dN

oN

o

Har

tvig

sen

104

x 1

hour

+

4 x

2 ho

urs

2 ye

ars

“Bob

ath

prin

cipl

e”B

Yes

Enco

u-ra

ged

No

Yes

*A=

leas

t en

gagi

ng (l

ectu

res,

pam

phle

ts, v

ideo

s); B

=m

oder

atel

y en

gagi

ng (p

rogr

amm

ed in

stru

ctio

ns, f

eedb

ack

inte

rven

tions

); C

=m

ost

enga

ging

(tra

inin

g in

beh

avio

ural

mod

ellin

g, h

ands

-on

trai

ning

).

Page 88: Kari-Pekka Martimo - UEF · Kari-Pekka Martimo Musculoskeletal disorders, disability and work Kari-Pekka Martimo Musculoskeletal disorders (MSD) are the most important causes of temporary

86

7RESuLTS

Trainingandphysicalexercisewerecomparedinonerandomisedtrial(Mülleretal.2001)andnodifferenceinbackpainwasfoundattheintermediatefollow-up.Theresultsofonecohortstudy(Dehlinetal.1981)providedsupporttotheconclusionmadeattheshort-termfollow-up.

Agroupreceivingtrainingandassistivedeviceswascomparedtothegroupsreceivingtrainingonlyornointerventionatallinonerandomisedtrial(Yassietal.2001).Nodifferenceinbackpainwasshownininterme-diatefollow-upofeithercomparison(OR0.42,95 %CI0.04to4.99).Inaddition,therewasnodifferenceinrelationtobackrelateddisability.

7.2. factors associated with self-assessed work ability (Study II)

Atotalof971consecutivepatientswereenrolledby12physicians.Questionnairescompletedbyboththepatientandthephysicianwereavailablefor950visits(98 %).Thestatisticalanalysesfocusedon723(76 %)visits,wherethereasonforthecontactgivenbythepatientandthediagnosismadebythephysicianwereinthesamemajordiseasegroup.

MSD(39 %)wasthemostcommonreasonforthevisit,followedbyrespiratory(17 %),cardiovascular(11 %),dermatological(9 %),mental(7 %),and"other"disorders(16 %).Inmostcasesthedurationofthesymptomswaslongerthansixmonths.Respiratorysymptomshadlastedforlessthantwoweeksinhalfofthecases.

Table 8. Self-assessed ability to work by the main diagnosis of the visit

Disease groupSelf-assessed ability to work

N able (%)

Partially able (%)

Unable (%)

Cannot say (%)

Musculoskeletal 283 51 28 16 5

respiratory 125 58 24 10 8

Cardiovascular 83 80 16 4 1

Dermatological 67 96 4 0 0

Mental 47 40 30 23 6

Other 118 74 19 6 2

TOTAL 723 63 22 11 4

Page 89: Kari-Pekka Martimo - UEF · Kari-Pekka Martimo Musculoskeletal disorders, disability and work Kari-Pekka Martimo Musculoskeletal disorders (MSD) are the most important causes of temporary

87

7RESuLTS

Sixty-threepercentofthepatientsreportedbeingabletoworkdespitetheirhealthproblem(table8).Intotal,partialworkabilitywasreportedby22 %andfulldisabilityby11 %ofthepatients.Thosewithmentaldisordersreportedfullorpartialdisabilitymostoften(in53 %ofthecases),followedbythosewithMSD(44 %).

Thepatientsregardedmental(85 %)andMSD(74 %)mostoftenasbeingatleastpossiblywork-related(table9).Thephysiciansweremorecautiousinassessingwork-relatednessineverydiseasecategory.Ingeneral,theyregardedthereasonaswork-relatedin13 %andpossiblywork-relatedin21%ofthevisits.Thedisordersmostoftenregardedaswork-relatedbythephysicianswerementalproblems(26 %)andMSD(22 %).

Table 9. Work-relatedness assessed by patients and physicians by the main diagnosis of the visit

N Not work-related (%)

Possibly work-related (%)

Work-related (%)

Cannot say (%)

Musculoskeletal 283

- Patients 18 41 33 8

- Physicians 42 34 22 2

respiratory 125

- Patients 51 32 6 10

- Physicians 86 8 4 2

Cardiovascular 83

- Patients 31 51 8 10

- Physicians 71 22 6 1

Dermatological 67

- Patients 66 12 6 16

- Physicians 88 7 3 1

Mental 47

- Patients 13 36 49 2

- Physicians 40 32 26 2

Other 118

- Patients 49 24 9 18

- Physicians 85 6 6 3

TOTAL 723

- Patients 34 35 20 11

- Physicians 64 21 13 2

Page 90: Kari-Pekka Martimo - UEF · Kari-Pekka Martimo Musculoskeletal disorders, disability and work Kari-Pekka Martimo Musculoskeletal disorders (MSD) are the most important causes of temporary

88

7RESuLTS

Work-relatedinterventionswereconsideredasbeneficialbythepa-tientsinonethirdofthecases,mostfrequentlywhenthereasonforthevisitwasamentalproblem(56 %)orMSD(39 %).

Inthemultinomiallogisticregressionmodel,genderhadnoeffectonself-assessedworkability(table10),butolderagemarkedlyincreasedtheriskofdisability.Bluecollaremployeesranahigherriskofbothpartialandfulldisabilitycomparedtoupperwhitecollaremployees.Ashortdurationofthesymptomswasassociatedwithbothpartialandfulldisabilitytowork.

Table 10. Odds ratios (OR) and 95 % confidence intervals (CI) for the adjusted effects of the patient and disease characteristics on self-assessed ability to work

Self-assessed ability to workPartially ablea Unablea

Predictor OR 95% CI OR 95 % CIGender (male vs. female) 1.1 0.6–2.0 0.9 0.4–2.2

age (reference category '35 years or less')

– 35–44 years 1.2 0.6–2.5 4.8 1.2–18.6

– 45–54 years 1.1 0.5–2.2 4.3 1.1–17.1

– 55 years or older 1.6 0.7–4.0 8.9 1.9–41.4

Occupational group (reference category 'upper white collar')

– lower white collar 1.8 0.8–4.3 2.4 0.6–9.2

– blue collar 6.5 2.6–16.4 8.1 2.0–33.2Duration of the symptoms before the visit (reference category 'more than 6 months')

– 2–6 months 1.0 0.4–2.2 1.5 0.5–4.3

– 2 weeks to 2 months 2.0 0.8–4.5 0.6 0.1–2.6

– less than 2 weeks 3.4 1.6–7.5 3.7 1.3–10.7

Disease group ('other disease incl. skin diseases' as reference category)

– musculoskeletal 2.5 1.2–5.1 7.7 2.2–26.6

– respiratory 2.4 1.1–5.6 2.7 0.7–10.6

– cardiovascular 1.7 0.6–4.5 2.0 0.3–14.1

– mental 2.1 0.7–6.4 17.5 3.5–86.3

Assessment of work-relatedness

– 'possible' vs. 'no' 2.9 1.4–6.0 1.3 0.4–3.7

– 'yes' vs. 'no' 5.2 2.1–12.8 12.8 3.9–41.9

Potential of work-related interventions

– 'possible' vs. 'no' 1.6 0.8–3.0 0.5 0.2–1.2

– 'yes' vs. 'no' 2.0 0.9–4.6 0.2 0.1–0.8

OH centre (A vs. B) 1.1 0.5–2.2 3.4 1.2–9.7a reference category patients with self-assessed normal ability to work

Page 91: Kari-Pekka Martimo - UEF · Kari-Pekka Martimo Musculoskeletal disorders, disability and work Kari-Pekka Martimo Musculoskeletal disorders (MSD) are the most important causes of temporary

89

7RESuLTS

MSDincreasedtherisksofbothpartialandfulldisability.Thehigh-estriskoffulldisabilitywasobservedformentaldisorders.Theriskofpartialworkabilitywasincreasedforrespiratorydiseases.Self-assessedwork-relatednessofthediseaseincreasedtherisksofbothpartialandfulldisabilitytowork,whereastheriskoffulldisabilitywassignificantlyreduced,ifthepatientconsideredwork-relatedinterventionsasbeingbeneficial.

TheOHcentrehadastatisticallysignificanteffectondisability,buteliminatingthisvariablefromthemodeldidnotaffecttheriskestimatesoftheothervariables.

7.3. Self-assessed productivity loss caused by upper extremity disorders (Study III)

Therecruitmentwasendedasplannedeventhoughthetargetof500studysubjectswasnotachieved.Thiswasduetothesmallerthanexpectednumberofsubjectsfulfillinginclusioncriteria,aswellastherelativelyslowrecruitingprocessingeneral.Altogether222subjectsparticipatedinthestudy.Forty-fivesubjectswereexcludedbecausetheydidnotmeetthecriteriaforeligibility,leaving177subjectstothestudy.Afterexclu-sionofafurtherninesubjectswithmissinginformationonproductivity,168subjects(95 %)wereincludedintheanalyses.Themostcommonoccupationswerenursesandotherhealthcareworkers(64 %),secretariesandotherclericalworkers(25 %),andwarehouseworkers(8 %).Themajority(87 %)werefemale,andtheaverageagewas45years.

ThemostprevalentUEDwereepicondylitis(29 %),specificshoulderdisorder(28 %)andnon-specificupperlimbpain(26 %).Thesubjectsreportedpainintensityandpaininterferencewithworktobeonaver-age4.7(max10)and4.8,respectively.Paininterferencewithsleepwassomewhatlower(3.3).SicknessabsenceduetoUEDduringthelast12monthswasreportedby37 %ofthesubjects.Workingatakeyboardandliftingloadswerethemostcommonphysicalworkloadfactors.Highjobstrainwasreportedby27 %ofthesubjects.Everyseventhsubjecthadelevatedscoresonfear-avoidancebeliefs,andeverysecondperceivedtheirdisorderasbeingwork-related.

Morethanhalfofthesubjects(56 %ofwomen,59 %ofmen)reportedthattheUEDhaddecreasedtheirproductivity.Theaverage

Page 92: Kari-Pekka Martimo - UEF · Kari-Pekka Martimo Musculoskeletal disorders, disability and work Kari-Pekka Martimo Musculoskeletal disorders (MSD) are the most important causes of temporary

90

7RESuLTS

productionlosswas34 %duringthepreviousworkday,correspondingtoanaverageof19 %lossofproductivityamongallstudysubjects.

Ageandgenderwerenotassociatedwithproductivityloss(table11),andneitherweresmokinghabits,waistcircumferenceorphysicalactivity.Subjectsinthediagnosticcategory"other",mainlywithmedianorulnarnerveentrapment,wereatthehighestriskofproductivityloss.

Table 11. Odds ratios (OR) of productivity loss adjusted for gender and age* or gender alone** according to background characteristics

Characteristic all* 20-45 yrs** 46-64 yrs**OR 95 % CI n OR 95 % CI n OR 95 % CI

gender

Female (reference category) 67 79

Male 1.2 0.4-3.0 13 1.5 0.4-4.9 9 0.9 0.2-3.6

Age (continuous) 1.00 0.97-1.04 - -

Diagnosis

Epicondylitis (reference category) 25 24

Shoulder disorder 1.5 0.6-3.5 21 1.4 0.4-4.6 26 1.6 0.5 -4.9

Wrist tenosynovitis 1.7 0.5-5.3 8 4.2 0.6-26.3 9 0.8 0.2-3.7

Nonspecific pain 1.9 0.8-4.4 23 2.3 0.7-7.4 20 1.5 0.4-5.0

Other 6.2 1.2-31.4 3 9 3.5 0.6-20.4

Pain intensity

1st tertile (reference category) 26 27

2nd tertile 3.7 1.6-8.2 28 3.3 1.1-10.3 27 4.0 1.3-12.6

3rd tertile 3.0 1.4-6.6 26 3.1 0.99-9.6 30 2.9 0.98-8.6

Pain interference with work

1st tertile (reference category) 23 31

2nd tertile 2.7 1.2-5.9 24 1.9 0.5-6.4 30 3.6 1.2-10.5

3rd tertile 6.2 2.6-14.4 32 6.7 2.0-22.3 23 5.1 1.5-16.9

Pain interference with leisure time

1st tertile (reference category) 21 31

2nd tertile 1.7 0.8-3.7 32 1.4 0.4-4.2 25 2.2 0.7-6.5

3rd tertile 1.8 0.8-3.8 27 1.4 0.4-4.3 28 2.2 0.7-6.2

Pain interference with sleep

1st tertile (reference category) 26 26

2nd tertile 1.6 0.7-3.4 31 0.7 0.2-2.2 25 4.2 1.3-13.5

3rd tertile 2.5 1.1-5.5 23 1.0 0.3-3.2 33 6.0 1.9-18.6

Table 11. continues...

Page 93: Kari-Pekka Martimo - UEF · Kari-Pekka Martimo Musculoskeletal disorders, disability and work Kari-Pekka Martimo Musculoskeletal disorders (MSD) are the most important causes of temporary

91

7RESuLTS

Characteristic all* 20-45 yrs** 46-64 yrs**OR 95 % CI n OR 95 % CI n OR 95 % CI

Physical exposures at work

Lifting loads, >5 kg

No (reference category) 52 68

Yes 2.1 0.99-4.5 28 1.9 0.7-5.1 18 2.3 0.7-7.2

Arm elevations or above shoulder

No (reference category) 67 77

Yes 1.9 0.7-4.9 13 2.1 0.5-7.6 9 1.6 0.3-6.8

Forceful or pinch grip

No (reference category) 69 80

Yes 1.5 0.5-4.4 11 1.5 0.4-5.8 6 1.6 0.2-9.1

Working at a keyboard

No (reference category) 39 45

Yes 0.7 0.3-1.4 41 1.4 0.5-3.5 41 0.4 0.2 -1.1

Previous sickness absence (past 12 months)

No (reference category) 46 60

Yes 2.2 1.1-4.3 34 3.4 1.3-8.7 28 1.5 0.5-3.7

High job strain

No (reference category) 50 64

Yes 1.3 0.6-2.8 23 3.9 1.3-11.8 20 0.5 0.2-1.4

Elevated score on fear-avoidance beliefs

No (reference category) 69 75

Yes 3.5 1.2-9.9 11 4.6 0.9-23.1 13 2.8 0.7-10.9

Painintensity,paininterferencewithwork,andfear-avoidancebeliefswereassociatedwithproductivityloss.Paininterferencewithsleepwasalsoassociatedwithproductivityloss,butonlyintheolderagegroup.

Withrespecttothephysicalexposuresatwork,onlyliftingatworkshowedanassociationwithproductivityloss.Highjobstrainandpriorsickleavewereassociatedwithproductivityloss,butonlyamongtheyoungersubjects.Iftheyoungersubjectswereconvincedaboutwork-relatednessofthedisorder(responseinthethirdtertile),theprevalenceofproductivitylosswasincreased(OR4.5,95 %CI1.2–16.6).Nosimilarassociationwasfoundintheoldersubjects.

Page 94: Kari-Pekka Martimo - UEF · Kari-Pekka Martimo Musculoskeletal disorders, disability and work Kari-Pekka Martimo Musculoskeletal disorders (MSD) are the most important causes of temporary

92

7RESuLTS

Inamutuallyadjustedmodelwithgender,age,painintensity,physicalexposuresatwork,previoussicknessabsence,highjobstrainandfear-avoidancebeliefs,onlypainintensityandfear-avoidancebeliefsshowedassociationswithproductivityloss.PaininterferencewithworkwasalsoassociatedwithproductivitylosswithanORof2.5(95 %CI1.1–5.7)forthe2ndtertileand5.7(95 %CI2.2–14.3)forthe3rdtertile,whenitwasincludedinthemodelinsteadofpainintensity.Intheyoungerworkersonlyhighjobstrain,andintheolderworkersonlypaininter-ferencewithsleep,remainedstatisticallysignificantafteradjustmentfortheotherfactors.

Theseparateandjointeffectsofphysicalworkloadfactors,painin-tensityandjobstrainonproductivitylosswerealsostudied.Ingeneralintheyoungersubjects,acombinationofanytwoofthesefactorswasassociatedwithahigherdegreeofproductivitylossthanthepresenceofonlyonefactor.Highjobstrainseemedtocontributemosttotheproductivitylossandphysicalexposurestheleast.Whentheinterac-tionproductswereincludedinthelogisticregressionmodels,onlytheinclusionoftheinteractionbetweenphysicalloadsandpainintensityimprovedthegoodness-of-fitofthemodel.

7.4. Effectiveness of an ergonomic interven-tion on productivity loss (Study Iv)

Atotalof177participantswererandomisedtotheintervention(91subjects)andcontrolgroup(86subjects).Duringthe12weekfollow-up,theparticipationratewas87 %intheinterventiongroupand88 %inthecontrolgroup.

Mostparticipantswerefemaleinbothgroups.Therewasnomajordif-ferenceinthedistributionofageandlife-stylerelatedriskfactorsbetweentheinterventionandcontrolgroup.Painintensity,paininterferencewithwork,leisuretimeandsleep,aswellastheprevalenceofprevioussickleavesandhighjobstrainwerealsosimilarinthetwogroups.Bothgroupshadsimilarmeanscoresforthefear-avoidancebeliefs;however,elevatedscoresonfear-avoidancebeliefswerefoundalmosttwiceasoftenintheinterventiongroupasinthecontrolgroup(18 %versus11 %).Specificshoulderdisordersweremoreprevalent(35 %versus21 %)

Page 95: Kari-Pekka Martimo - UEF · Kari-Pekka Martimo Musculoskeletal disorders, disability and work Kari-Pekka Martimo Musculoskeletal disorders (MSD) are the most important causes of temporary

93

7RESuLTS

andexposuretoliftingatworkwasmorefrequent(38 %versus18 %)inthecontrolgroupthanintheinterventiongroup.Allcasesof“otherUED”belongedtotheinterventiongrouponly.

Fromatotalof531potentialobservations,465(88 %)wereincludedintheanalyses.Nineobservationsatbaseline,36at8weeksand21at12weekswereexcluded.Incomparisonwiththoseincludedintheanalyses,theexcludedsubjectswereyounger(meanage42versus46years),theyhadhigherscoresonpainintensity(5.4versus4.7),andtheyhadbeenmoreoftenonsickleavepriortotheenrolment(57 %versus36 %).Inaddition,theexcludedemployeesweretwiceasoftenexposedtoliftingatworkthantheemployeesincludedintheanalyses(46 %versus28 %).

Withrespecttothe66excludedobservations,30(46 %)wereinthecontrolgroupand36(55 %)intheinterventiongroup.Thoseexcludedfromtotheinterventiongroupmorecommonlyreportedexposuretolifting>5kg(53 %versus34 %),andhadahigherlevelofpainintensity(mean5.6versus5.1),paininterferencewithwork(mean5.5versus4.7),paininterferencewithleisuretime(mean5.4versus4.2),andpaininterferencewithsleep(mean4.2versus2.4)atbaselineincomparisontotheexcludedsubjectsinthecontrolgroup.Ontheotherhand,excludedsubjectsintheinterventiongrouplessfrequentlyreportedproductivityloss(among39subjects,magnitude13 %versus30 %)andelevatedscoreonfear-avoidancebeliefs(0versus18.5 %)thanthoseexcludedinthecontrolgroup.Nodiffer-enceswerefoundwithrespecttoage,jobstrainandsicknessabsencepriortotheenrolment.

Eightweeksaftertheenrolment,almostallsubjects(92 %)intheinterventiongroupbutonly8 %inthecontrolgroupreportedthatanoccupationalphysiotherapisthadvisitedtheirworkplace.Theer-gonomicassessmentwasmostoftenmadetogetherwiththeemployeealone,andthesupervisorhadparticipatedin17 %oftheassessments.Atotalof412implementedorplannedmeasureshadbeenidentified.Themajority(60 %)wererelatedtoguidingtheemployeeinselfcare,workingposture,useoftoolsandinstruments,usingbothhandsinworktasks,andreorganisinghowtheworkwasdone.Therecom-mendationstobeimplementedintheimminentfuture(25 %ofthemeasures)includedpurchasinganewaidortool,andreorganisingworkoritsenvironment.Themodificationsatworkmadeduringthevisit

Page 96: Kari-Pekka Martimo - UEF · Kari-Pekka Martimo Musculoskeletal disorders, disability and work Kari-Pekka Martimo Musculoskeletal disorders (MSD) are the most important causes of temporary

94

7RESuLTS

(16 %ofthemeasures)includedchangestothekeyboardandmonitor,structuresoftheworkplace(includingarmrests),andadjustmentstothetableandthechair.

Productivitylossatbaselinewasreportedby53.8 %intheinterven-tiongroupand57.9 %inthecontrolgroup(figure5).At8weeks,boththeproportionandmagnitudeofproductivitylosswerelowerintheinterventionthaninthecontrolgroup.However,thedifferenceswerenotstatisticallysignificant.At12weeks,theproportionandmagnitudeofproductivitylosswerestatisticallysignificantlylowerintheinterventionthaninthecontrolgroup(proportion25 %versus51 %andmagnitude7 %versus18 %,respectively,P=0.001forboth).

TheanalysisofrepeatedmeasuresusingGEErevealedstatisticallysignificantdifferencesintheproportionandmagnitudeofproductivitylossbetweentheinterventionandcontrolgroupafteradjustmentforage,gender,physicalworkloadfactors,fear-avoidancebeliefsandfollow-

1

10

100

Baseline (N = 168) 8 weeks (N = 141) 12 weeks (N = 156)

Proportion (control)Proportion (intervention)Magnitude (control)Magnitude (intervention)

FigurE 5. Proportion and magnitude of productivity loss (on a logarithmic scale) at baseline, eight and twelve weeks after the intervention in the con-trol and intervention groups.

Page 97: Kari-Pekka Martimo - UEF · Kari-Pekka Martimo Musculoskeletal disorders, disability and work Kari-Pekka Martimo Musculoskeletal disorders (MSD) are the most important causes of temporary

95

7RESuLTS

uptime.Therewasaninteractionbetweeninterventionandtime,theproportion(P=0.009)andmagnitude(P=0.033)ofproductivitylossbeinglowerintheinterventiongroupthaninthecontrolgrouponlyat12weeks.

Intheemployeeswithoutanyproductivitylossatbaseline,15.6 %intheinterventiongrouphaddevelopedproductivitylossat8weeks,whereasthisproportionwasalmosttwo-foldinthecontrolgroup.Themagnitudeofproductivitylosswas3.7 %and8.1 %,respectively.At12weekstherewasalmosta4-folddifferenceintheproportionandan8-folddifferenceinthemagnitudebetweentheinterventionandcontrolgroup.WithGEEanalyses,thedifferenceswerenotedtobestatisticallysignificant.

Amongemployeeswithproductivitylossof10–20 %atbaseline,thereductioninmagnitudeofproductivitylosswasmoreprominentintheinterventiongroupthanoccurredinthecontrolgroupat8weeksand12weeks.At12weeksalsotheproportionofproductivitylosswaslowerintheinterventionthaninthecontrolgroup.Ifthebaselineproductivitylosswashigherthan20 %,therewerenosignificantdif-ferencesbetweenthestudygroupsintermsofproductivitylossduringthefollow-up.

Theimprovementofproductivityat12weekswassignificantlybetterintheinterventiongroupthaninthecontrolgroupinthesubsampleofsubjectswithnoworkingatakeyboardatworkbutexposuretootherphysicalworkloadfactors(P=0.033),withlowjobdemands(P=0.036),amongthosewithnosicknessabsenceduetoUEDbeforethestudy(P=0.043),aswellasthosewithlowfearavoidance(P=0.033).Theimprovementdidnotdifferbetweeninterventionandcontrolgroupsinthosewithloworhighjobcontrol.

Amongthosewhohadbeenonsickleaveforanyreasonduringfourweeksprecedingthefollow-upat12weeks,therewasnodifferenceinthechangeofproductivitybetweentheinterventionandcontrolgroups.Incontrast,thoseindividualsintheinterventiongroupwhohadnotbeenonsickleave,hadahigherimprovementinproductivityat12weekscomparedwiththecontrolgroup(6.5versus2.4%,P=0.033).

Therewasnodifferencebetweenthecontrolandinterventiongroupinpainintensityat12weeks(mean2.6versus2.9)orinpaininterfer-encewithwork(mean2.4versus2.5).

Page 98: Kari-Pekka Martimo - UEF · Kari-Pekka Martimo Musculoskeletal disorders, disability and work Kari-Pekka Martimo Musculoskeletal disorders (MSD) are the most important causes of temporary

96

7RESuLTS

7.5. Early part-time sick leave in musculoskeletal disorders (Study v)

Duringthepilotstudythereweresomechallengesrelatedtofindingeli-gibleindividualsattheOHS,anextraworkloadontheOHphysiciansinimplementingtheinterventiontotheemployeesandthesupervisors,aswellasthemanypracticalissuesrelatedtoadministrativequestionsatworkduringpart-timesickleave.However,thearrangementsattheworkplacewereusuallyconsideredasbeingfeasibletoimplementandtheattitudeofthesupervisorsandco-workerswasmostlypositiveandsupportive.ThisprovidedanimpetustoinitiatetheactualRCTatthebeginningof2008.TherecruitmentperiodofthisstudyendedinDe-cember2009,butthefollow-upwillnotenduntilDecember2010,andthereportingoftheresultswillstartin2011.

Page 99: Kari-Pekka Martimo - UEF · Kari-Pekka Martimo Musculoskeletal disorders, disability and work Kari-Pekka Martimo Musculoskeletal disorders (MSD) are the most important causes of temporary

97

8. DISCUSSION

8.1. Main findings

8.1.1. Primary prevention of low back pain and related disability

Wefoundnoevidencethattrainingwithorwithoutliftingequipmentwouldbeeffectiveinthepreventionofbackpainorconsequentdisabil-ity(studyquestionNoI).Thereasonmaybethateithertheadvocatedtechniquesdidnotreducetheriskofbackinjury,ortrainingdidnotleadtoanadequatechangeinliftingandhandlingtechniques.Therewerenodifferencesintheresultsbetweentheanalysesfromstudieswithdifferentdesignsorwithdifferenttypesofliftingandhandling.Tworandomisedcontrolledtrialspublishedlaterlentsupporttothepresentresults(Jensenetal.2006;Lavenderetal.2007).

Oneexplanationforthelackofanyeffectcouldbethattheinterven-tionwasnotappropriate.Astrainingmethodsbecomemoreengaging,workersacquiremoreknowledgeandthenumberofinjuriesdeclines(Burkeetal.2006).Accordingly,thetrainingmethodswereclassifiedbasedonlearners’participation,butthereviewfailedtodetectamorepositiveoutcomeforstudiesthatinvolvedmoreintensetrainingmethods.

Theriskofbackpainmightberelatednottoincorrecthandlingtechniquesbuttootherwork-relatedfactorsinherentinthepopulationsstudied(suchasnon-neutral,bent,orrotatedtrunkpostureswithoutliftingorhandling,orpsychosocialstrain).Itwasnotpossibletotestthishypothesis,however,becausenoneofthestudiesdescribedthecontextoftheinterventioninsufficientdetailtoenablefurtheranalysis.Ithasalsobeenarguedthatthesizeoftheeffectofwork-relatedphysicaldemands

Page 100: Kari-Pekka Martimo - UEF · Kari-Pekka Martimo Musculoskeletal disorders, disability and work Kari-Pekka Martimo Musculoskeletal disorders (MSD) are the most important causes of temporary

98

8DISCuSSION

islessthanthatofotherindividual,non-occupationalandunidentifiedfactors(Waddelletal.2001).

OnereasonwhytrainingincorrectliftingtechniquesandassistivedevicesdidnotreduceLBPorrelateddisabilityismostlikelythecom-plexityoftheimpactofphysicalandpsychosocialriskfactorsatwork.AsproposedbythemodelofCoxetal(Figure3),evenphysicalloadfactorswhichhaveaninfluenceontheworker’shealtharemediatedthroughcognitiveandpsycho-physiologicalpathways.Thus,thereductionofonlyphysicalloadatworkdoesnot,therefore,automaticallyresultinthereductionofmusculoskeletalsymptomsanddisability.Theneedforinfluencingsimultaneouslyonbothphysicalandpsychosocialexposurehasbeenseenasthemoreeffectiveapproachtothereductionofdis-ability(Coteetal.2008),preferablyincollaborationwiththeworkers(Hignettetal.2005).

8.1.2. factors associated with perceived disability

TheresultsofstudyIIindicatedthatperceivedpartialdisabilityiscom-mon,especiallyinmentalproblemsandMSD.Thesetwodisordersarealsomostoftenregardedaswork-relatedbythepatientsandtheirphysicians.MSDandmentaldisordersassuch,aswellasperceivedwork-relatednessofthehealthproblem,arestronglyassociatedwithimpairmentinself-assessedworkability(studyquestionNoII).

Accordingtothepatients,74 %ofMSDcasesweredefinitelyorpossiblycausedormadeworsebywork,whereasOHphysiciansfounddefinitework-relatednessinonly22 %andapossibleconnectionin34 %ofthecases.ThesefiguresarecomparabletotheresultsofaNor-wegianstudy,wherepainintheneck,shoulderandarmwasconsideredasbeingwork-relatedby78–80 %ofthesubjects(Mehlumetal.2009).Inthatstudy,thephysiciansusedspecificcriteriaforwork-relatedness,andtheyassessedwork-relatednessas"probably","possibly"and"notwork-related".Thesedifferencesexplainwhyinthepresentstudythephysicians'assessmentswerelowerthantheexperts'assessmentsintheNorwegianstudy(56 %versus65–72 %).Moreover,intheNorwegianstudy,thephysicianknewthestudysubject’sassessmentbeforemakinghis/herownevaluation.

Page 101: Kari-Pekka Martimo - UEF · Kari-Pekka Martimo Musculoskeletal disorders, disability and work Kari-Pekka Martimo Musculoskeletal disorders (MSD) are the most important causes of temporary

99

8DISCuSSION

Anotherstudyhascomparedtheassessmentsofwork-relatednessmadebypatientsonsickleaveascomparedwiththeassessmentbytheirOHphysicians(Girietal.2009).Onceagain,thepatientsmoreoftenbelievedthattheillnesshasbeencausedbyworkthanOHphysi-cians(30 %versus16 %),andthattheillnesswasmadeworsebywork(60 %versus44 %).InadditiontoMSDandotherillnesses,37 %ofthepatientshadamentalproblemasthereasonforabsence,whichmayhaveinfluencedthepatients'assessmentsofwork-relatednessoftheirailments.

Thisstudyshowedthatthepatients'negativeperceptionsabouttheirillnessandworkwouldbeassociatedwithimpairedabilitytowork.Thiswasacross-sectionalstudyand,therefore,itisnotknownifthepatientswereabsentfromworkbecauseoftheillnessaftertheconsulta-tion.However,laterstudieshavefoundevidencethatemployeeswithnegativeperceptionsabouttheirillnessarelesslikelytoreturntoworkthanthosewithpositivebeliefs(Elferingetal.2009;Girietal.2009)

Thisstudyrevealedthattheriskofperceiveddisabilitywaslowerifthepatientfoundbenefitsinpotentialwork-relatedinterventions.Inapreviousstudy(Tellnesetal.1990),apotentialforpreventionwasfoundin37 %ofthehealthproblemsunderlyingsicknesscertificates.Inthisstudy,work-relatedinterventionswereinitiatedexactlyasoftenasinanotherFinnishstudy,where9 %ofthevisitstoOHphysiciansincludedorledtowork-relatedinterventions(Räsänenetal.1997).Thereasonforthisfigurebeingconsiderablylowerthantheprevalenceofwork-relateddiseasesmaybethatwork-relatedinterventionshavebeeninitiatedalreadyduringearliervisitstotheOHphysician.

Basedontheresults,partialabilityofanemployeetoworkcanpos-siblyberestored,maintainedandpromotedbyactionsdirectedattheindividual,butitshouldalsoincludemodifyingtheworkenvironmentandorganizingworkaccordingtotheindividual’scapabilities.Inaddi-tion,recognitionofwork-relateddiseasesisimportantfortheappropriateassessmentofpatient'sill-healthandfortheeffectivenessoftherapeuticinterventions.Identifyingwork-relatednesshasthepotentialalsoformoreadequateprevention,notonlyconcerningtheindividualpatientsbutalsotheirco-workers,andforlessabsenteeismfromwork.

Page 102: Kari-Pekka Martimo - UEF · Kari-Pekka Martimo Musculoskeletal disorders, disability and work Kari-Pekka Martimo Musculoskeletal disorders (MSD) are the most important causes of temporary

100

8DISCuSSION

8.1.3. Productivity loss as an indicator of disability

InstudyIII,morethanhalfofthesubjectswithclinicallydiagnosedUEDreportedthatthedisorderimpairedtheirproductivityinvariousphysicalaswellassedentaryoccupations(studyquestionIII).Onaverage,work-erswithUEDreportedthatonethirdoftheirregularproductivityhasbeenlost,whichinanormalworkdaywouldcorrespondto2.5hoursofactiveworkingtime.

Ourresultsareconsistentwithcurrentknowledge,i.e.,painin-tensity,paininterferencewithwork,andliftingatworkareassociatedwithself-reportedproductivityloss(Hagbergetal.2007;Boströmetal.2008).Nostudieshavesofarreportedabouttheroleoffear-avoidancebeliefsinproductivityloss.Conceptually,fearfulbeliefsmaycontrib-uteconsiderablytoproductivitylosssincetheyserveasanadaptivereactiontopainwithsomeworkactivitiesbeingavoidediftheyareanticipatedtoproducepainandfearedsincetheycancause'damage'.BeliefsthatworkdeteriorateschronicLBPhavebeenshowntoincreasetheriskofbothworklossanddisabilityindailyactivities(Waddelletal.1993).Ingeneral,fear-avoidancebeliefsarestrongpredictorsoffuturedisability(Ilesetal.2008).However,itseemsthatthisisthefirststudytoreportfear-avoidancebeliefsaffectingproductivitylossinnon-chronicconditions.

Unlikethepreviousstudies,noassociationwasfoundbetweenageandproductivityloss(Collinsetal.2005;vandenHeuveletal.2007;Alaviniaetal.2009).However,itwasfoundthatagemodifiedtheeffectsofotherfactors,particularlythecombinedeffectsofphysicalwork,jobstrainandpainintensity,onproductivityloss.Thestrongestdeterminantsofproductivitylossinyoungerworkerswerehavingtwoofthefollowingfactors;intensivepain,highjobstrain,andphysicalwork.Olderwork-ers'productivitywasnotaffectedbythecombinationofthesefactors.

Similarresults,indicatingthattheyoungerworkersmaybemoresusceptibletotheeffectsofwork,havebeenfoundforexampleinaprospectivestudyonthepredictorsoflow-backpain(Mirandaetal.2008),aswellasinrelationtosicknessabsence(Taimelaetal.2007).Theage-modificationinproductivitylossmaypartlybeexplainedbyhealth-basedselectioninwhichworkerswithhealthproblemsaremorelikelytoleaveajob.Otherpossibleexplanationsareyoungeremployees'(ortheir

Page 103: Kari-Pekka Martimo - UEF · Kari-Pekka Martimo Musculoskeletal disorders, disability and work Kari-Pekka Martimo Musculoskeletal disorders (MSD) are the most important causes of temporary

101

8DISCuSSION

supervisors’)higherexpectationsfordailyperformance,aswellasolderworkers'betterskillstocompensateforhealth-relatedproductivityloss.

8.1.4. Secondary prevention of disability

TheresultsofstudyIVshowthatanearlyergonomicinterventioninadditiontomedicalcarecanhelptoreducework–relatedproductivitylossassociatedwithUEDcomparedtomedicalcareonly(studyquestionIV).Thefactthatthedifferencebetweenthecontrolandinterventiongroupwaslargestat12weeksaftertheenrolment,suggeststhattheresultisbasedonactualimpactoftheinterventionratherthanonthesubjects'satisfactionwiththeadditionalattentiontheyhadreceivedfromtheOHS.Manyofthenewaidsortoolsrecommendedbytheoccupationalphysiotherapistswerenotpurchaseduntillaterduringthecourseofthestudy.Thismayfurtherexplainwhythedifferencebetweenthestudygroupswasfoundonlyat12weeks.

Onepossibleexplanationfortheimprovedproductivityisthattheinterventionmanagedtomodifytheemployees'adverseworkstyles,whichhasbeenshowntobeariskfactorforupperextremitypainandfunctionallimitations(Nicholasetal.2005;Meijeretal.2008).Thecon-tactsbythephysicianandthephysiotherapistmightalsohavepromotedabetterunderstandingofthenatureandconsequencesofthedisorderattheworkplace.Consequently,theemployeeandthesupervisorwereabletoadjusttheworkrequirementstobettermeettherestrictionsduringrecoveryandthenthephysiotherapist'spracticalsuggestionssupportedtheimplementationofthesechanges.

Althoughtheinterventionshowedbeneficialeffectsonproductivity,nodifferenceinpainintensitywasfoundbetweenthegroupsat12weeks.Therefore,painreliefdoesnotexplaintheresults.Sincethedifferenceinproductivityat12weekswasseenalsointhesubgroupwithnosick-nessabsenceduringthefollow-up,theresultscannotalsobeduetotheinterveningimpactofsicknessabsenteeism.

Asubstantialeffectoftheinterventionwasseenamongthoseem-ployeeswithnooronlymildproductivitylossatbaseline.Theothersubgroupanalysesshowedthatthosewithlessfear-avoidancebeliefs,morephysicalloadfactorsatwork,orlowjobdemandsbenefittedmorefromtheintervention.Thissuggeststhattheimpactoftheintervention

Page 104: Kari-Pekka Martimo - UEF · Kari-Pekka Martimo Musculoskeletal disorders, disability and work Kari-Pekka Martimo Musculoskeletal disorders (MSD) are the most important causes of temporary

102

8DISCuSSION

onproductivitycouldbemediatedbyareductioninphysicalloadfactors.Iftheconditioncausedmorefunctionalimpairment(productivitylosswasmorethan20 %atbaselineortherewasprevioussickleaveduetoUED),itwasfoundthattheinterventionwasnoteffective.WhenthedisabilitycausedbyUEDwastoosevere,itseemsthatergonomicinter-ventionshavelesspotentialforrestoringnormalperformanceatwork.

8.1.5. Comparison of two disability management methods

ThetargetofthisprotocolwastodescribeaRCTwithastudyinterven-tionofadjustingwork(bothworktimeanddemands)toaccommodatethedisabledemployeesothatheorshewouldbeabletocontinueworkingduringrecoveryfromaMSD(studyquestionNoV).ThisisbelievedtobethefirstRCTtoinvestigatetheeffectivenessofearlypart-timesickleaveincomparisontoconventionalfull-timesickleaveinmusculoskeletalsymptoms.TheresultsandtheincreasedknowledgewillleadtoabetterdecisionmakingprocessregardingthemanagementofdisabilityrelatedtoMSD.

Despitethefactthatpart-timesicknessabsencehasbeenmadepossibleinmanyjurisdictions,thisoptionhasnotbeenstudiedinarandomisedcontrolledsetting(Kaustoetal.2008).Inaddition,there-sultsofstudyIIshowthatmorethaneveryfourthemployeecomingtomedicalconsultationbecauseofMSDreportedthattheywerepartiallyabletocontinueworkingdespitethedisorder(table8).

Aspointedoutearlier(Durandetal.2007),inthistypeofinterven-tionworkbecomesanobjectoftheinterventionitselfposingseveralmethodologicalchallenges.Inadditiontothemedicaljudgementbythephysician,theinterventionrequiresactionsanddecisionsmadebytheemployee,supervisor,colleaguesandemployer–eachwiththeirownvalues,objectives,interests,andtraining(Loiseletal.2005).

Sicknessabsenceisusuallyconsideredasaconsequenceofahealthdisorderratherthanitstreatmentand,therefore,inmoststudies,ithasbeenusedasanoutcomemeasure.Inthistrial,however,themodeofsickleave(part-orfull-time)isusedasaninterventiontoaffecttheoutcome,i.e.,thequantityofsickleave(cumulativenumberofsickleavedays).Thepotentialbenefitoftheintervention,i.e.,thedifferenceinthetotal

Page 105: Kari-Pekka Martimo - UEF · Kari-Pekka Martimo Musculoskeletal disorders, disability and work Kari-Pekka Martimo Musculoskeletal disorders (MSD) are the most important causes of temporary

103

8DISCuSSION

numberoffull-orpart-timesickleavedaysbetweentheinterventionandcontrolgroups,willmostlybeattributedtotheneedforeitheradditionalpart-orfull-timesickleaveduringthefollow-upperiod.

8.2. Methodological considerations

8.2.1. Study designs

Thestrengthofthiscombinationofstudiesisthattheyfollowthecourseofdisability(figure4)recognisingthefourpotentialstepsintheinterven-tions.Thestudiesrepresentsystematicreview,surveys(bothcross-sectionalquestionnaireandbaselineassessment),andrandomisedcontrolledtrials.

Systematic review

ThestrengthofthereviewisthatitadheredtothesystematicandrigorousCochranemethodsinsearchingtheliterature,selectingtheinterventionsandstudydesigns,aswellassynthesisingthedata.

Themeasurementoftheoutcomesintheprimarystudiesvariedleadingtoconsiderabledifferencesinthereportedincidencesofbackpain.Anotherlimitationwasthatalltherequireddatacouldnotbeextractedfromallstudies,limitingthepossibilitiesofpoolingthedata.Inaddition,theresultsofmostofthestudieshadtobeadjustedfortheeffectofclusterrandomisationthathadnotbeentakenintoaccountbytheoriginalauthors.

ItisnotpossibletoexcludethepossibilitythatthestudiesandthereviewlackedthepowertodetectasmallbutpossiblyrelevantdifferenceintheincidenceofLBP.Itis,however,highlyunlikelythatpoolingtheresultsofmorestudieswouldhavefoundasignificantbeneficialeffect.ThisisbecausealmostallstudiesshowedanORthatwasnearto1,andtheappliedcomparisonswereallrathersimilar,especiallyastheuseofalumbarsupportcanbeconsideredequaltonointerventionwithrespecttothepreventionofbackpain(Jellemaetal.2001).Onlyonestudyshowedamorepositive,butstillnon-significant,outcome(Yassietal.2001).Thiscouldbebecausethetypeoftheinterventionwasdifferent(“nostrenuouslifting”).

Page 106: Kari-Pekka Martimo - UEF · Kari-Pekka Martimo Musculoskeletal disorders, disability and work Kari-Pekka Martimo Musculoskeletal disorders (MSD) are the most important causes of temporary

104

8DISCuSSION

Surveys

InstudyII,onemayquestionwhetherthepatientswerecompetenttoassesstheworkrelatednessoftheirsymptoms.Itcanbearguedthatthepatient'sassessmentisbasedmoreonillness-relatedproblemsatworkratherthanonoccupationalcontributorsoftheillness,leadingtoover-reportingofwork-relatedness.Differentperceptionsofwork-relatednessbypatientsandtheirphysicianshavebeenregardedasacriticalpointofaneffectiveconsultationprocess(Plomp1993).Theworkers'confidenceintheOHphysicianisalsobasedontheirassessmentsofthephysician'smedicalexpertiseandhis/herunderstandingoftheworkersandtheirproblems(Plomp1992).Inthisstudy,however,thevalidityofpatients'assessmentsofwork-relatednessissupportedbythesimilaroccupationalexposuresreportedbythepatientsandtheirphysicians.

Onepotentialsourceofsystematicerrorinthetwosurveysisthesocalled"commonsourcebias".Whenboththeoutcome(perceiveddisabilityorself-assessedproductivityloss)andthestudyvariables(forexample,work-relatednessofthedisorderorfear-avoidancebeliefs)areinquiredfromtheemployee,thismightleadtoacommonsourcebias(Podsakoffetal.2003).Peoplerespondingtoquestionsposedbyresearch-erscanhaveadesiretoappearconsistentandrationalintheirresponsesandmightsearchforsimilaritiesinthequestionsbeingaskedofthem.However,resultssimilartothosedescribedinstudyIIandIIIhavebeenreportedalsoinotherstudiesusingmoreobjectivedatasources.

Incontrasttopreviousstudies,theincludedsubjectsinstudiesIII–IVwereexaminedbyatrainedphysicianusingstandardizeddiagnosticcri-teria.Onthewhole,validatedquestionswereusedtocollectinformationonseveralbackgroundvariables.However,unmeasuredconfoundingforexampleduetonon-occupationalormotivationalissuesmayhaveaffectedtheresults.

Thedifficultyinquantifyingproductivity,particularlyininforma-tionandservice-typeoccupations,hasledtoamultitudeofmeasure-mentinstrumentsbasedonself-reporting.TheQQmethodbyBrouwerwasadaptedbyspecifyingittoconcernUED,evenifitwasoriginallydesignedtobeusedforanydisease.ThestrengthoftheQQmethodisthattheeffectofthehealthconditiononthequantityandthequalityofproductivitycanbedifferentiated.Moreover,unlikethesituation

Page 107: Kari-Pekka Martimo - UEF · Kari-Pekka Martimo Musculoskeletal disorders, disability and work Kari-Pekka Martimo Musculoskeletal disorders (MSD) are the most important causes of temporary

105

8DISCuSSION

withmanyotherquestionnaires,thereisareferenceagainstwhichthelosscanbecompared,i.e.,therespondentsareaskedtoratetheattainedquantityandqualityofdailyworkcomparedtothatoftheirregularworkday.Naturally,thereareotherreasonsforlostproductivitythatarenotrelatedtohealth.However,theQQmethodtakesintoaccounttheseotherreasonsforproductionlossbyusingtheregularworkperformanceasaninternalstandard.

Moreover,theself-assessmentswereunlikelytohavebeenaffectedbyrecallproblemssincetherecallperiodofproductivitywasshortinthisstudy.Formostemployees,theprecedingfullregularworkingdaywasthedaybeforetheconsultationoratmostitwaswithinoneweek.Theshorttimeframealsomeansthattheproductivitylossassessedinthisstudydidnotnecessarilyreflectlongerlastingproductivityloss.ConsideringthenatureofclinicalUED,itis,however,unlikelythatthesituationwouldchangerapidlyfromonedaytothenext.

Randomised controlled trials

Therandomisedcontrolleddesignisconsideredastheleastsusceptibletobiasinscientificinterventionresearch.InstudyIV,theinterventionandcontrolgroupswerecomparablewithoutanymajordifferencesotherthantheinterventionitself.Theergonomicinterventionreachedalmostallsubjectsintheinterventiongroupandmorethan400improvementswereproposed.

Liftingatworkandspecificshoulderdisorderswere,however,some-whatmoreprevalentinthecontrolgroup,whereastheproportionofelevatedscoresinfear-avoidancebeliefswashigherintheinterventiongroup.Thesubgroupanalysesinthisstudyshowedthatthoseemployeeswhowereexposedtolifting,forcefulgrippingorelevatedarmposturesorwhohadlessfear-avoidancebeliefsbenefittedfromtheinterventionmorethanthosewhohadlessphysicalexposuresatworkormorefear-avoidancebeliefs.Therefore,thesedifferencesatbaselinemighthavedilutedthebenefitsoftheintervention.Anotherfactthatmighthavehadasimilareffectontheresultsisthemethodtoreplaceproductivitydataat12weekswiththevaluesat8weekswhichhadtobedonefor8subjectsintheinterventiongroup;thismayhaveoverestimatedtheremainingproductivitylossat12weeks.

Page 108: Kari-Pekka Martimo - UEF · Kari-Pekka Martimo Musculoskeletal disorders, disability and work Kari-Pekka Martimo Musculoskeletal disorders (MSD) are the most important causes of temporary

106

8DISCuSSION

Sincetherearenoobjectivemeasuresforproductivityinmostoccupa-tions,thegenerallyacceptedmethodistouseself-assessedproductivityaswasdoneinthisstudy.Inpreviousinterventionstudiesamongem-ployeeswithsymptomsintheupperextremitiesandneckregion,bothobjectiveandself-assessedproductivityhavebeenmeasured(vandenHeuveletal.2003;Rempeletal.2006).Incomparisontothesestudies,theweaknessofthispresentstudyisthatthatnoobjectivemeasurementofproductivitycouldbeused,whereasthestrengthisthatthedisordersweremedicallyverifiedusingstandardizeddiagnosticcriteria.

InstudyVcomparingtheeffectsofpart-andfull-timesicknessabsence,itisessentialthatthephysiciandeterminesthelengthofthedisabilitybeforeallocation,andadherestothisevaluationwhenprescribingeitherpart-orfull-timesickleave.Thisistoavoidbiasthatmightoccurifthelengthofthesickleaveisdetermineddifferentlyforpart-andfull-timesickleave.Thereisariskforbiasrelatedtothepossiblecontrolvisit,duringwhichtheallocationtofurtherpart-orfull-timesickleaveisagainopentoboththephysicianandtheemployee.Inadditiontorecurrenceofsickleave,aninappropriatelytimedreturntoregularworkineithergroupcouldbeanticipatedtoresultinsecondaryoutcomes,suchaspain,functionalstatus,employeesatisfactionandfinancialcoststotheemployer.

Despitetheextensiveamountofquantitativedatacollectedinthistrialonindividual,ergonomic,psychosocialandeconomicfactors,itisnotpossibletoquantifyalltheaspectsofthearrangementsmadeattheworkplacesduringpart-timesickleave.Acknowledgingthepotentialeffectofthiscontextualprocessontheoutcomeoftheintervention,allrelevantqualitativedatawillbecollectedduringthestudyfromtheemployeeandthesupervisor.

8.2.2. Study populations

Thestudieshaveincludedonlyworkingindividualsrepresentingawiderangeofemployeesinseveraloccupations.StudiesII–Vincludedonlyworkerswhosemusculoskeletalsymptomswereverifiedbyaphysician,whereasself-reportedLBPwasregisteredinstudyI.

Thereview(studyI)includedstudieswithemployeesexposedtoheavyliftingatwork.Theoriginalaimwastoincludeonlypreventionstudieswithworkerswithoutbackpainatbaseline.However,intheeli-

Page 109: Kari-Pekka Martimo - UEF · Kari-Pekka Martimo Musculoskeletal disorders, disability and work Kari-Pekka Martimo Musculoskeletal disorders (MSD) are the most important causes of temporary

107

8DISCuSSION

giblestudiestherewerealwayssomeworkersalreadysufferingfrombackpainatbaseline.Therefore,thisinclusioncriterionhadtobechangedtoworkerswhowerenotactivelyseekingtreatmentforcurrentbackpain.

ThepreviouslyreportedprevalencesandmagnitudesofproductivitylossassociatedwithMSDhavebeenlowerthanthatestimatedinstudyIII(Hagbergetal.2002;vandenHeuveletal.2007).Themainreasonmaybethatthepreviousstudieshaveincludedsubjectswithself-reportedsymptoms,whereasinthisstudy,subjectswiththesymptomshadsoughtmedicaladvice,andformostofthem,thephysiciandiagnosedaspecificUED.Hence,theirconditionwasmoresevereandspecificthansimplyanexperienceofpain.

ThesubjectsinstudiesIIIandIVwereactivelyworkingindividualsfromthreecompanieswithvaryingexposuretowork-relatedfactors.Theseindividualswereseekingmedicaladvicefortheirupperextremitysymptoms.Theintendednumberofstudysubjectswasnotgathered.Duetotherelativelysmallpopulation,theresultsarenotveryprecise,asindicatedbythewidthoftheconfidenceintervalsinstudyIII,andthereweresomebaselinedifferencesinstudyIV.However,despitethelimitedstudysize,theresultssupportthepositiveeffectsofanearlyergonomicintervention.

TheparticipationrateinstudyIVcanbeconsideredashigh(88 %)duringthe12weeks’follow-up.However,duetotheincompletein-formation atbaselineandlosstofollow-up,someselectionmayhaveoccurred.Itwasanalyzedwhetherthoseindividualslosttofollow-upallocatedinitiallytointerventionorcontrolgroupdifferedwithrespecttobaselinevariables.Theconclusionwasthatthedrop-outs andthosewithincompletedata inthe interventiongroup reported ahigher exposuretoliftingandhadhigherlevelsofpainintensityandpaininterferencewithwork,leisuretimeandsleepthanthoseinthecontrolgroup.Ontheotherhand, lessproductivitylossandfear-avoidancebeliefswerereportedbythedrop-outsinitiallyintheinterventiongroup.Ifaselec-tionbiasduetonon-participationhadaffectedtheseresults,itseems,however,unlikelythatitcausedanysignificantoverestimationintheobservedimpactoftheintervention.

TheOHSstaffswererequestedtorecommendstudyparticipationtoallpotentiallyeligiblesubjects,butthereisnoinformationaboutwhetherthiswasthecase.Furthermore,itisnotknownhowmanysubjectsde-

Page 110: Kari-Pekka Martimo - UEF · Kari-Pekka Martimo Musculoskeletal disorders, disability and work Kari-Pekka Martimo Musculoskeletal disorders (MSD) are the most important causes of temporary

108

8DISCuSSION

clinedtoparticipate.ItistruethatafterbeingexaminedattheFIOH,nonedeclined.Thiswasoriginallyanergonomicinterventionstudy,anditcouldbethatthoseindividualswithmoreseveresymptoms(andlowerproductivity)werelesslikelytoparticipate.

8.3. Implications for future research

Thescopeofthethesisisverywide,andthereforeitspotentialtoad-equatelyanswerallstudyquestionsissomewhatlimited.Muchresearchhastobeperformedinthefuture,beforeasignificantlybetterunder-standingaboutMSD,disabilityandworkwillbeachieved.

ThesystematicreviewonLBPandliftingadvicerevealedthatthereisaneedformoreandbetterqualityresearchwithstandardisedoutcomemeasurement,appropriatepower,andadjustmentfortheclustereffect.Suchstudiesshouldbedirectedata“noliftingpolicy”.Inadditionabetterunderstandingisneededofthecausalchainbetweenexposuretobiomechanicalstressorsatworkandthesubsequentdevelopmentofbackpaintoenablethedevelopmentofnewandinnovativewaystopreventbackpain.

SincemostoftheemployeesinstudiesonUEDandassociatedproductivitylosswerefemaleandworkinginahealthcareorofficeenvironment,thegeneralisationoftheresultsoftheinterventionhastobesomewhatlimited.MoreresearchisneededonproductivitylossandMSDinotherworkenvironments,suchasheavyindustry.

AstheinterventioninstudyIVhadtwoparts,telephonecon-tactwiththesupervisorbythephysicianandworkplacevisitbythephysiotherapist,itisimpossibletodifferentiatewhethertheybothwerecrucialfortheeffectorifone(andwhich)wouldsuffice.Therefore,moreresearchisneededfortoclarifywhichwerethecrucialpartsoftheintervention,butalsoinordertoverifytheresultsindifferentoc-cupationalsettings.

OnecanalwayscriticizethattheresultsofstudiesII–VperformedintheFinnishOHSmaynotbevalidandapplicableinothercountrieswithadifferentkindofsocialsecurityandOHSsystem.Thisisajus-tifiablecriticism,becauseasignificantamountofstudiesonMSDanddisabilityhavebeenperformedincountrieswherethejurisdictionsmake

Page 111: Kari-Pekka Martimo - UEF · Kari-Pekka Martimo Musculoskeletal disorders, disability and work Kari-Pekka Martimo Musculoskeletal disorders (MSD) are the most important causes of temporary

109

8DISCuSSION

adistinctionbetweenwork-relatedMSDandotherMSD.Itisclearthatallsocialsecuritysystemsprobablyhavesomeeffectoninterven-tionsaimedatdisabilitymanagement,butthisshouldnotdiscourageresearchespeciallytryingtotranslatesuccessfulmodelsinonecountryforimplementationinanother.

8.4. Policy implications and recommendations

ThestudiesofthisthesiswereperformedinFinland,withtheexceptionofthestudiesincludedinthesystematicreview(studyI).Inaddition,mostofthestudiesareresultsofcollaborationbetweenFIOHandOHSunits.Therefore,theresultsareapplicabletotheFinnishsocialsecurityandOHcaresystem,andsomeconclusionsaswellasrecommendationscanbemadebasedonthefindings.

Inadditiontopreventiveservices,theFinnishOHScanalsoofferprimaryhealthcarelevelcurativeservicestotheemployees.Thisofferspossibilitiesforbettermanagementofemployeeswithdisabilitiesinadditiontoearlierrecognitionofhealthandsafetyrisksatworkduringmedicalconsultations.Asinhealthcareingeneral,itcanbearguedthatthedisabilitymanagementbyOHphysicianshasbeenmainlybasedonthebiomedicalmodelwithtoolittleemphasisplacedonassociatedwork-related,psychosocialandpsychologicalfactors(fordetailsseechapter2.2.).

TheactivitiesoftheOHSpersonnelshouldbedirectedmoretowardsdisabilitymanagementinordertomeetthedemandsoftheorganisationsandsocietyonOHS.In2005,tertiarydisabilitymanagementservicestoenableandsupportsafeRTWwereavailableinlessthanhalfoftheFinnishOHunits(Kivistöetal.2008).Thecontentsoftheserviceswerebasedonthecurrentscientificevidence,butwithsubstantialvariation.

Theresultsofthisthesischallengethebiomedicalmodelofdisabilitypreventionandmanagement.TheadaptationofbiopsychosocialmodelinthedisabilitymanagementcreatesneedsfortrainingofbothOHSpersonnelandtheworkplaces,aswellasfinancialincentivesfortheem-ployerstoappreciatethevalueandtosupporttheretentionofemployeeswithdisabilities.Whennomedicalcureisattainable,theindividual's

Page 112: Kari-Pekka Martimo - UEF · Kari-Pekka Martimo Musculoskeletal disorders, disability and work Kari-Pekka Martimo Musculoskeletal disorders (MSD) are the most important causes of temporary

110

8DISCuSSION

potentialscanbeidentifiedandsupportedinordertoenablehisorhersuccessfulreturntothemodifiedwork.

MSDaremultifactorialintheirnature,andtherefore,apartfromac-cidentprevention,theirelimination (primaryprevention)bythemeansofwork-relatedinterventionsisnotrealistic.Thereismoreevidenceavailable,towhichthisstudyadds,thatrecognitionofMSDshouldleadtoearlyanalysisofboththework-relatedconsequencesandtheem-ployee'sownperceptionsconcerningthedisorder.InsteadofkeepingtheemployeeoutofworkbecauseofMSD,workactivitiescanbemodifiedandthenegativeconsequencesofthedisorderminimised.

MostcasesofLBPandmanyofUEDarenon-specific,andtheso-called“objective”measuresofpathologyhavebeenpoorinpredictingdisability.Thereisconvincingevidencethatsecondaryandtertiarypre-ventionofdisabilityiseffectiveif,afteradequatemedicalassessment,thebiopsychosocialaspectsofthedisorderandrelateddisabilityaretakenintocarefulconsideration.Workplace,supervisorandcolleaguesshouldbeincludedinthemanagementofdisabilityatanearlierstageifthedisabilityislikelytobeprolonged.AsinstudiesIV–V,thisnecessitatescollaborationandcommunicationnotonlybetweenthecareproviderandtheemployee,butalsoattheworkplacewiththesupervisorandthecolleagues.Thisapproachmostlikelyleadstostrongerinvolvementandgreaterinterestamongsupervisorsinimprovingtheworkenviron-mentandsupporttheemployeewithMSD.Asaconsequence,withanimprovementofthesupervisor'sroleandknowledgerelatedtoMSD,theresultscanbenefitalsoallemployees,withorwithoutsymptoms.

Basedonthefindingsofthisstudythefollowingrecommendationscanbemade

1. Themethodsusedforprimarypreventionofwork-relatedMSDshouldbescrutinised.Inthosecaseswheretheireffectivenessisnotsupportedbyscientificevidence,theresourcesbeingallocatedtothemshouldbedirectedtomoreeffectivemethods.Healthprofessionalsinvolvedintrainingandadvisingworkersonmanualmaterialhan-dlingshouldmodifythecontentssothatnosingleliftingtechniqueisadvocatedforliftingandhandling.Instead,theaimshouldbetoreduceliftinginthefirstplace,andtopreventworkaccidentsrelatedtohandlingheavyobjects.

Page 113: Kari-Pekka Martimo - UEF · Kari-Pekka Martimo Musculoskeletal disorders, disability and work Kari-Pekka Martimo Musculoskeletal disorders (MSD) are the most important causes of temporary

111

8DISCuSSION

2. Thebenefitsofprimary,secondaryandtertiarypreventionofdisabilityaresupportedbycredibleevidence.PreventionofMSDatworkisdif-ficultbecauseoftheirhighprevalenceandcomplexaetiology.However,thereareevidence-basedmethodswhichareabletopreventtherelateddisability.InthesurveillanceofMSDintheOHS,theemployees'ownperceptionsofworkingconditionsandtheireffectsonmusculoskeletalhealthshouldbeusedinsteadofsimplyrelyingonexperts'assessments.

3. Inthesecondarypreventionofdisability,lostproductivityatworkduetoMSDshouldbetakenintoconsideration.ThisisimportantwhensupportingworkerswithMSDincontinuingworking,andwhenundertakingeconomicevaluationsoftheconsequencesofdisabilityatworkandoftheinterventionstoreducethem.Oftensicknessabsenteeism,painorfunctionalstatusmightbetooinsensi-tiveasoutcomestodetectpossiblebenefitsofinterventions.

4. Aprerequisiteforsecondarypreventionofdisabilityisbetterknowl-edgeanduseofalternativemodelsofthebiomedicalapproach.AtOHS,moreeffortsshouldbeplacedonearlyergonomicinterventionsinvolvingboththeemployeesandtheirsupervisorsinsteadofwastingtoomuchtimeinpurelymedicalinterventions.Inthisapproach,thebiopsychosocialmodelofdisabilitymanagementismorelikelytobenefittheemployeethanthebiomedicalmodel.

5. Whenassessingtheworkabilityoftheemployeeandhis/herneedforsickleave,attentionshouldbepaidnotonlytothemedicalcon-ditionbutalsotothepsychosocialandpsychologicalriskfactorsofthedisability.Thisispivotalforrecommendingtheuseofpart-timesickleaveormodifiedworkinsteadoftraditionalsickleaveinthemanagementofMSD.

8.5. Conclusions

ThefivestudiesofthisthesisaimedatansweringfivequestionsrelatedtoMSD,disabilityandwork.• TheresultsofstudyI,asystematicliteraturereview,donotsupport

theuseoftraininginliftingtechniqueswithorwithoutassistivedevicesasawayofpreventingLBPandrelateddisabilityamongworkersfrequentlyexposedtoheavylifting.

Page 114: Kari-Pekka Martimo - UEF · Kari-Pekka Martimo Musculoskeletal disorders, disability and work Kari-Pekka Martimo Musculoskeletal disorders (MSD) are the most important causes of temporary

112

8DISCuSSION

• AccordingtostudyII,MSDareresponsiblemoreoftenforself-assessedpartialworkabilitythanfullinabilitytowork,andworkersmoreoftenthantheirphysiciansassessmanyofthehealthproblemsasbeingcausedorexacerbatedbywork.Self-assessedwork-relatednessofthedisorderisassociatedwithperceiveddisability.

• InstudyIII,workerswhodidnotneedsicknessabsencenonethelessassessedUEDtocausemajorproductivitylossatwork.

• InstudyIV,themanagementofUEDrelatedproductivitylossshowedthatearlyergonomicinterventionattheworkplaceissuperiortomedicalcareonly.

• ThechallengeofdesigninganRCTtostudytheeffectivenessofpart-timesickleaveamongworkerswithMSDwasapproachedintheprotocoldevised instudyV.

Page 115: Kari-Pekka Martimo - UEF · Kari-Pekka Martimo Musculoskeletal disorders, disability and work Kari-Pekka Martimo Musculoskeletal disorders (MSD) are the most important causes of temporary

113

REfERENCES

AlaviniaSM,MolenaarD,BurdorfA(2009).Productivitylossintheworkforce:associationswithhealth,workdemands,andindividualcharacteristics.AmJIndMed52(1):49–56.

AndersenJH,KaergaardA,MikkelsenS,JensenUF,FrostP,BondeJP,FallentinN,ThomsenJF(2003).Riskfactorsintheonsetofneck/shoulderpaininaprospectivestudyofworkersinindustrialandservicecompanies.OccupEnvironMed60(9):649–54.

BakkerEW,VerhagenAP,vanTrijffelE,LucasC,KoesBW(2009).Spinalmechanicalloadasariskfactorforlowbackpain:asystematicreviewofprospectivecohortstudies.Spine(PhilaPa1976)34(8):E281–93.

BaldwinML,ButlerRJ,JohnsonWG,CoteP(2007).Self-reportedseveritymeasuresaspredictorsofreturn-to-workoutcomesinoccupationalbackpain.JOccupRehabil17(4):683–700.

BergströmG,BodinL,HagbergJ,AronssonG,JosephsonM(2009).Sicknesspresenteeismtoday,sicknessabsenteeismtomorrow?Aprospectivestudyonsicknesspresenteeismandfuturesicknessabsenteeism.JOccupEnvironMed51(6):629–38.

BestM(1997).AnEvaluationofManutentionTraininginPreventingBackStrainandResultantInjuriesinNurses.SafSci25(1–3):207–22.

BoocockMG,McNairPJ,LarmerPJ,ArmstrongB,CollierJ,SimmondsM,GarrettN(2007).Interventionsforthepreventionandmanagementofneck/upperextremitymusculoskeletalconditions:asystematicreview.OccupEnvironMed64(5):291–303.

BosEH,KrolB,VanDerStarA,GroothoffJW(2006).Theeffectsofoccupationalinterven-tionsonreductionofmusculoskeletalsymptomsinthenursingprofession.Ergonomics49(7):706–23.

BoströmM,DellveL,ThomeeS,HagbergM(2008).Riskfactorsforgenerallyreducedproductivity–aprospectivecohortstudyofyoungadultswithneckorupper-extremitymusculoskeletalsymptoms.ScandJWorkEnvironHealth34(2):120–32.

BrewerS,VanEerdD,AmickBC,3rd,IrvinE,DaumKM,GerrF,MooreJS,CullenK,RempelD(2006).Workplaceinterventionstopreventmusculoskeletalandvisualsymptomsanddisordersamongcomputerusers:asystematicreview.JOccupRehabil16(3):325–58.

Page 116: Kari-Pekka Martimo - UEF · Kari-Pekka Martimo Musculoskeletal disorders, disability and work Kari-Pekka Martimo Musculoskeletal disorders (MSD) are the most important causes of temporary

114

REfERENCES

BrookerAS,ColeDC,Hogg-JohnsonS,SmithJ,FrankJW(2001).Modifiedwork:prevalenceandcharacteristicsinasampleofworkerswithsoft-tissueinjuries.JOccupEnvironMed43(3):276–84.

BrouwerWB,KoopmanschapMA,RuttenFF(1999).Productivitylosseswithoutabsence:measurementvalidationandempiricalevidence.HealthPolicy48(1):13–27.

BrouwerWB,vanExelNJ,KoopmanschapMA,RuttenFF(2002).Productivitycostsbeforeandafterabsencefromwork:asimportantascommon?HealthPolicy61(2):173–87.

BuchbinderR,GrossDP,WernerEL,HaydenJA(2008).Understandingthecharacteristicsofeffectivemassmediacampaignsforbackpainandmethodologicalchallengesinevaluatingtheireffects.Spine(PhilaPa1976)33(1):74–80.

BuijsP,WeelA(2005).Curativehealthcareandwork-relatedness:Ablindspot?InternationalConferenceonOccupationalHealthServices,Helsinki,Finland,FinnishInstituteofOc-cupationalHealth.

BurkeMJ,SarpySA,Smith-CroweK,Chan-SerafinS,SalvadorRO,IslamG(2006).Relativeef-fectivenessofworkersafetyandhealthtrainingmethods.AmJPublicHealth96(2):315–24.

BurtonAK,KendallNA,PearceBG,BirrellLN,BainbridgeLC(2009).Managementofwork-relevantupperlimbdisorders:areview.OccupMed(Lond)59(1):44–52.

BöckermanP,LaukkanenE(2009).Whatmakesyouworkwhileyouaresick?Evidencefromasurveyofworkers.EurJPublicHealth20(1):43–6.

CampbellMK,MollisonJ,GrimshawJM(2001).Clustertrialsinimplementationresearch:estimationofintraclustercorrelationcoefficientsandsamplesize.StatMed20(3):391–9.

ChinnS(2000).Asimplemethodforconvertinganoddsratiotoeffectsizeforuseinmeta-analysis.StatMed19(22):3127–31.

ColeDC,WellsRP,FrazerMB,KerrMS,NeumannWP,LaingAC(2003).Methodologicalissuesinevaluatingworkplaceinterventionstoreducework-relatedmusculoskeletaldisordersthroughmechanicalexposurereduction.ScandJWorkEnvironHealth29(5):396–405.

CollinsJJ,BaaseCM,ShardaCE,OzminkowskiRJ,NicholsonS,BillottiGM,TurpinRS,OlsonM,BergerML(2005).Theassessmentofchronichealthconditionsonworkperformance,absence,andtotaleconomicimpactforemployers.JOccupEnvironMed47(6):547–57.

CoteP,vanderVeldeG,CassidyJD,CarrollLJ,Hogg-JohnsonS,HolmLW,CarrageeEJ,HaldemanS,NordinM,HurwitzEL,GuzmanJ,PelosoPM(2008).Theburdenandde-terminantsofneckpaininworkers:resultsoftheBoneandJointDecade2000–2010TaskForceonNeckPainandItsAssociatedDisorders.Spine(PhilaPa1976)33(4Suppl):S60–74.

CoxT,FergusonE(1994).Measurementofsubjectiveworkenvironment.WorkStress8(2):98–109.

DaltroyLH,IversenMD,LarsonMG,LewR,WrightE,RyanJ,ZwerlingC,FosselAH,LiangMH(1997).Acontrolledtrialofaneducationalprogramtopreventlowbackinjuries.NEnglJMed337(5):322–8.

Page 117: Kari-Pekka Martimo - UEF · Kari-Pekka Martimo Musculoskeletal disorders, disability and work Kari-Pekka Martimo Musculoskeletal disorders (MSD) are the most important causes of temporary

115

REfERENCES

DaltroyLH,IversenMD,LarsonMG,RyanJ,ZwerlingC,FosselAH,LiangMH(1993).Teachingandsocialsupport:effectsonknowledge,attitudes,andbehaviorstopreventlowbackinjuriesinindustry.HealthEducQ20(1):43–62.

DasingerLK,KrauseN,ThompsonPJ,BrandRJ,RudolphL(2001).Doctorproactivecom-munication,return-to-workrecommendation,anddurationofdisabilityafteraworkers'compensationlowbackinjury.JOccupEnvironMed43(6):515–25.

DeeksJ,HigginsJ,AltmanD(2005).8.11Specialtopics.InCochranehandbookforsystematicreviewsofinterventions4.2.5.TheCochraneCollabiration.

DehlinO,BergS,AnderssonGB,GrimbyG(1981).Effectofphysicaltrainingandergonomiccounsellingonthepsychologicalperceptionofworkandonthesubjectiveassessmentoflow-backinsufficiency.ScandJRehabilMed13(1):1–9.

DeyoRA,WeinsteinJN(2001).Lowbackpain.NEnglJMed344(5):363–70.

DionneCE,BourbonnaisR,FremontP,RossignolM,StockSR,LarocqueI(2005).Aclinicalreturn-to-workruleforpatientswithbackpain.CMAJ172(12):1559–67.

DriessenMT,ProperKI,vanTulderMW,AnemaJR,BongersPM,vanderBeekAJ(2010).Theeffectivenessofphysicalandorganisationalergonomicinterventionsonlowbackpainandneckpain:asystematicreview.OccupEnvironMed67(4):277–85.

DurandMJ,VezinaN,LoiselP,BarilR,RichardMC,DialloB(2007).Workplaceinterven-tionsforworkerswithmusculoskeletaldisabilities:adescriptivereviewofcontent.JOccupRehabil17(1):123–36.

EklundM,vonGranotzH,MarklundS(2004).Deltidssjukskrivning–individ,arbetsplatsochhälsa.(Part-timesickleave–individual,workplaceandhealth)Denhögasjukfrånvaron–sanningochkonsekvens.HögstedtC,BjurvaldM,MarklundS,PalmerE,TheorellT.Stockholm,Statensfolkhälsoinstitut.

ElferingA,MannionAF,JacobshagenN,TamcanO,MullerU(2009).Beliefsaboutbackpainpredicttherecoveryrateover52consecutiveweeks.ScandJWorkEnvironHealth35(6):437–45.

EscorpizoR(2008).Understandingworkproductivityanditsapplicationtowork-relatedmusculoskeletaldisorders.IntJIndErgon38:291–7.

EstlanderAM(2003).Kipupotilaanpsykologinentutkimus(Psychologicalassessmentofapa-tientwithpain).Kivunpsykologia(Psychologyofpain).EstlanderAM.Helsinki,WSOY.

EuropeanFoundationfortheImprovementofLivingandWorkingConditions(1997).Prevent-ingabsenteeismattheworkplace.Researchsummary.Luxembourg

FanelloS,Frampas-ChotardV,RoquelaureY,JoussetN,DelbosV,JarnyJ,Penneau-FontbonneD(1999).Evaluationofaneducationallowbackpainpreventionprogramforhospitalemployees.RevRhumEnglEd66(12):711–6.

FanelloS,JoussetN,RoquelaureY,Chotard–FrampasV,DelbosV(2002).Evaluationofatrainingprogramforthepreventionoflowerbackpainamonghospitalemployees.NursHealthSci4(1–2):51–4.

Page 118: Kari-Pekka Martimo - UEF · Kari-Pekka Martimo Musculoskeletal disorders, disability and work Kari-Pekka Martimo Musculoskeletal disorders (MSD) are the most important causes of temporary

116

REfERENCES

FeldsteinA,ValanisB,VollmerW,StevensN,OvertonC(1993).TheBackInjuryPreventionProjectpilotstudy.Assessingtheeffectivenessofbackattack,aninjurypreventionprogramamongnurses,aides,andorderlies.JOccupMed35(2):114–20.

FerrieJE,KivimakiM,HeadJ,ShipleyMJ,VahteraJ,MarmotMG(2005).Acomparisonofself-reportedsicknessabsencewithabsencesrecordedinemployers'registers:evidencefromtheWhitehallIIstudy.OccupEnvironMed62(2):74–9.

FeuersteinM,HarringtonCB(2006).Secondarypreventionofwork-relatedupperextremitydisorders:recommendationsfromtheAnnapolisconference.JOccupRehabil16(3):401–9.

FrancheRL,CullenK,ClarkeJ,IrvinE,SinclairS,FrankJ(2005).Workplace-basedreturn-to-workinterventions:asystematicreviewofthequantitativeliterature.JOccupRehabil15(4):607–31.

FurlanAD,PennickV,BombardierC,vanTulderM(2009).2009updatedmethodguidelinesforsystematicreviewsintheCochraneBackReviewGroup.Spine(PhilaPa1976)34(18):1929–41.

GiriP,PooleJ,NightingaleP,RobertsonA(2009).Perceptionsofillnessandtheirimpactonsicknessabsence.OccupMed(Lond)59(8):550–5.

GoetzelRZ,ShechterD,OzminkowskiRJ,MarmetPF,TabriziMJ,RoemerEC(2007).Prom-isingpracticesinemployerhealthandproductivitymanagementefforts:findingsfromabenchmarkingstudy.JOccupEnvironMed49(2):111–30.

GriffithLE,Hogg-JohnsonS,ColeDC,KrauseN,HaydenJ,BurdorfA,LeclercA,CoggonD,BongersP,WalterSD,ShannonHS(2007).Low-backpaindefinitionsinoccupationalstudieswerecategorizedforameta-analysisusingDelphiconsensusmethods.JClinEpi-demiol60(6):625–33.

GriffithsA(1999).Organizationalinterventions:facingthelimitsofthenaturalscienceparadigm.ScandJWorkEnvironHealth25(6):589–96.

GuzmanJ,HaydenJ,FurlanAD,CassidyJD,LoiselP,FlanneryJ,GibsonJ,FrankJW(2007).Keyfactorsinbackdisabilityprevention:aconsensuspanelontheirimpactandmodifi-ability.Spine(PhilaPa1976)32(7):807–15.

HagbergM,TornqvistEW,ToomingasA(2002).Self-reportedreducedproductivityduetomusculoskeletalsymptoms:associationswithworkplaceandindividualfactorsamongwhite-collarcomputerusers.JOccupRehabil12(3):151–62.

HagbergM,VilhemssonR,TornqvistEW,ToomingasA(2007).Incidenceofself-reportedreducedproductivityowingtomusculoskeletalsymptoms:associationwithworkplaceandindividualfactorsamongcomputerusers.Ergonomics50(11):1820–34.

HanleyJA,NegassaA,EdwardesMD,ForresterJE(2003).Statisticalanalysisofcorrelateddatausinggeneralizedestimatingequations:anorientation.AmJEpidemiol157(4):364–75.

HarringtonJM,CarterJT,BirrellL,GompertzD(1998).Surveillancecasedefinitionsforworkrelatedupperlimbpainsyndromes.OccupEnvironMed55(4):264–71.

HartvigsenJ,LauritzenS,LingsS,LauritzenT(2005).Intensiveeducationcombinedwithlowtechergonomicinterventiondoesnotpreventlowbackpaininnurses.OccupEnvironMed62(1):13–7.

Page 119: Kari-Pekka Martimo - UEF · Kari-Pekka Martimo Musculoskeletal disorders, disability and work Kari-Pekka Martimo Musculoskeletal disorders (MSD) are the most important causes of temporary

117

REfERENCES

HaukkaE,Leino-ArjasP,Viikari-JunturaE,TakalaEP,MalmivaaraA,HopsuL,MutanenP,KetolaR,VirtanenT,PehkonenI,Holtari-LeinoM,NykanenJ,StenholmS,NykyriE,RiihimakiH(2008).Arandomisedcontrolledtrialonwhetheraparticipatoryergonomicsinterventioncouldpreventmusculoskeletaldisorders.OccupEnvironMed65(12):849–56.

HaukkaE,PehkonenI,Leino-ArjasP,Viikari-JunturaE,TakalaEP,MalmivaaraA,HopsuL,MutanenP,KetolaR,VirtanenT,Holtari-LeinoM,NykanenJ,StenholmS,OjajarviA,RiihimakiH(2010).Effectofaparticipatoryergonomicsinterventiononpsychosocialfactorsatworkinarandomizedcontrolledtrial.OccupEnvironMed67(3):170–7.

HeadJ,FerrieJE,AlexandersonK,WesterlundH,VahteraJ,KivimakiM(2008).Diagnosis–specificsicknessabsenceasapredictorofmortality:theWhitehallIIprospectivecohortstudy.BMJ337:a1469.

HelliwellPS,BennettRM,LittlejohnG,MuirdenKD,WigleyRD(2003).Towardsepide-miologicalcriteriaforsoft-tissuedisordersofthearm.OccupMed(Lond)53(5):313–9.

HensingG,AlexandersonK,AllebeckP,BjurulfP(1998).Howtomeasuresicknessabsence?Literaturereviewandsuggestionoffivebasicmeasures.ScandJSocMed26(2):133–44.

HignettS,WilsonJR,MorrisW(2005).Findingergonomicsolutions–participatoryapproaches.OccupMed(Lond)55(3):200–7.

HlobilH,StaalJB,SpoelstraM,AriensGA,SmidT,vanMechelenW(2005).Effectivenessofareturn-to-workinterventionforsubacutelow-backpain.ScandJWorkEnvironHealth31(4):249–57.

HoeijenbosM,BekkeringT,LamersL,HendriksE,vanTulderM,KoopmanschapM(2005).Cost-effectivenessofanactiveimplementationstrategyfortheDutchphysiotherapyguidelineforlowbackpain.HealthPolicy75(1):85–98.

HoogendoornWE,BongersPM,deVetHC,AriensGA,vanMechelenW,BouterLM(2002).Highphysicalworkloadandlowjobsatisfactionincreasetheriskofsicknessabsenceduetolowbackpain:resultsofaprospectivecohortstudy.OccupEnvironMed59(5):323–8.

HoogendoornWE,vanPoppelMN,BongersPM,KoesBW,BouterLM(1999).Physicalloadduringworkandleisuretimeasriskfactorsforbackpain.ScandJWorkEnvironHealth25(5):387–403.

HoogendoornWE,vanPoppelMN,BongersPM,KoesBW,BouterLM(2000).Systematicreviewofpsychosocialfactorsatworkandprivatelifeasriskfactorsforbackpain.Spine(PhilaPa1976)25(16):2114–25.

IlesRA,DavidsonM,TaylorNF(2008).Psychosocialpredictorsoffailuretoreturntoworkinnon-chronicnon-specificlowbackpain:asystematicreview.OccupEnvironMed65(8):507–17.

JellemaP,vanTulderMW,vanPoppelMN,NachemsonAL,BouterLM(2001).Lumbarsupportsforpreventionandtreatmentoflowbackpain:asystematicreviewwithintheframeworkoftheCochraneBackReviewGroup.Spine(PhilaPa1976)26(4):377–86.

JensenLD,GongeH,JorsE,RyomP,FoldspangA,ChristensenM,VesterdorfA,BondeJP(2006).Preventionoflowbackpaininfemaleeldercareworkers:randomizedcontrolledworksitetrial.Spine(PhilaPa1976)31(16):1761–9.

Page 120: Kari-Pekka Martimo - UEF · Kari-Pekka Martimo Musculoskeletal disorders, disability and work Kari-Pekka Martimo Musculoskeletal disorders (MSD) are the most important causes of temporary

118

REfERENCES

JohanssonG,LundbergI(2004).Adjustmentlatitudeandattendancerequirementsasdeter-minantsofsicknessabsenceorattendance.Empiricaltestsoftheillnessflexibilitymodel.SocSciMed58(10):1857–68.

Kaila-KangasL,KivimakiM,RiihimakiH,LuukkonenR,KirjonenJ,Leino-ArjasP(2004).Psychosocialfactorsatworkaspredictorsofhospitalizationforbackdisorders:a28-yearfollow-upofindustrialemployees.Spine(PhilaPa1976)29(16):1823–30.

Kaila-KangasL,Leino-ArjasP,KarppinenJ,Viikari-JunturaE,NykyriE,HeliovaaraM(2009).HistoryofphysicalworkexposuresandclinicallydiagnosedsciaticaamongworkingandnonworkingFinnsaged30to64.Spine(PhilaPa1976)34(9):964–9.

Kansaneläkelaitos.(2008)Kelansairausvakuutustilasto2007(StatisticsonsicknessbenefitsbytheSocialInsuranceInstitution2007).Helsinki

KarasekR,BrissonC,KawakamiN,HoutmanI,BongersP,AmickB(1998).TheJobContentQuestionnaire(JCQ):aninstrumentforinternationallycomparativeassessmentsofpsy-chosocialjobcharacteristics.JOccupHealthPsychol3(4):322–55.

KarjalainenA,PaloL,SaaloA,JolankiR,MäkinenI,KauppinenT,Eds.(2009).Ammattitauditjaammattitautiepäilyt2007(Occupationaldiseasesandsuspectedoccupationaldiseases2007).Helsinki,Työterveyslaitos.

KauppinenT,HanhelaR,HeikkiläP,KasvioA,LehtinenS,LindströmK,ToikkanenJ,Tossa-vainenA,Eds.(2007).TyöjaterveysSuomessa2006(WorkandHealthinFinland2006).Vammala,Työterveyslaitos.

KaustoJ,MirandaH,MartimoKP,Viikari-JunturaE(2008).Partialsickleave–reviewofitsuse,effectsandfeasibilityintheNordiccountries.ScandJWorkEnvironHealth34(4):239–49.

KivimäkiM,HeadJ,FerrieJE,HemingwayH,ShipleyMJ,VahteraJ,MarmotMG(2005).Workingwhileillasariskfactorforseriouscoronaryevents:theWhitehallIIstudy.AmJPublicHealth95(1):98–102.

KivimäkiM,HeadJ,FerrieJE,ShipleyMJ,VahteraJ,MarmotMG(2003).Sicknessabsenceasaglobalmeasureofhealth:evidencefrommortalityintheWhitehallIIprospectivecohortstudy.BMJ327(7411):364–8.

KivistöS,VerbeekJH,HirvonenM,VaronenH(2008).Return-to-workpoliciesinFinnishoccupationalhealthservices.OccupMed(Lond)58(2):88–93.

KrausJF,SchafferKB,RiceT,MaroosisJ,HarperJ(2002).AfieldtrialofbackbeltstoreducetheincidenceofacutelowbackinjuriesinNewYorkCityhomeattendants.IntJOccupEnvironHealth8(2):97–104.

KrauseN,DasingerL,NeuhauserF(1998).Modifiedworkandreturntowork:Areviewoftheliterature.JOccupRehabil8:113–40.

KuijerW,GroothoffJW,BrouwerS,GeertzenJH,DijkstraPU(2006).Predictionofsicknessabsenceinpatientswithchroniclowbackpain:asystematicreview.JOccupRehabil16(3):439–67.

LabriolaM,LundT,ChristensenKB,KristensenTS(2006).Multilevelanalysisofindividualandcontextualfactorsaspredictorsofreturntowork.JOccupEnvironMed48(11):1181–8.

Page 121: Kari-Pekka Martimo - UEF · Kari-Pekka Martimo Musculoskeletal disorders, disability and work Kari-Pekka Martimo Musculoskeletal disorders (MSD) are the most important causes of temporary

119

REfERENCES

LavenderSA,LorenzEP,AnderssonGB(2007).Cananewbehaviorallyorientedtrainingproc-esstoimproveliftingtechniquepreventoccupationallyrelatedbackinjuriesduetolifting?Spine(PhilaPa1976)32(4):487–94.

LincolnAE,FeuersteinM,ShawWS,MillerVI(2002).Impactofcasemanagertrainingonworksiteaccommodationsinworkers'compensationclaimantswithupperextremitydis-orders.JOccupEnvironMed44(3):237–45.

LoeppkeR,TaitelM,HaufleV,ParryT,KesslerRC,JinnettK(2009).Healthandproductiv-ityasabusinessstrategy:amultiemployerstudy.JOccupEnvironMed51(4):411–28.

LoeppkeR,TaitelM,RichlingD,ParryT,KesslerRC,HymelP,KonickiD(2007).Healthandproductivityasabusinessstrategy.JOccupEnvironMed49(7):712–21.

LoiselP(2009).Developinganewparadigm:Workdisabilityprevention.OccupationalHealthSouthernAfrica(ICOHSpecialissue):56–60.

LoiselP,AbenhaimL,DurandP,EsdaileJM,SuissaS,GosselinL,SimardR,TurcotteJ,LemaireJ(1997).Apopulation-based,randomizedclinicaltrialonbackpainmanagement.Spine(PhilaPa1976)22(24):2911–8.

LoiselP,BuchbinderR,HazardR,KellerR,ScheelI,vanTulderM,WebsterB(2005).Preven-tionofworkdisabilityduetomusculoskeletaldisorders:thechallengeofimplementingevidence.JOccupRehabil15(4):507–24.

LoiselP,GosselinL,DurandP,LemaireJ,PoitrasS,AbenhaimL(2001).Implementationofaparticipatoryergonomicsprogramintherehabilitationofworkerssufferingfromsubacutebackpain.ApplErgon32(1):53–60.

LöttersF,MeerdingWJ,BurdorfA(2005).Reducedproductivityaftersicknessabsenceduetomusculoskeletaldisordersanditsrelationtohealthoutcomes.ScandJWorkEnvironHealth31(5):367–74.

MacEachenE,ClarkeJ,FrancheRL,IrvinE(2006).Systematicreviewofthequalitativeliteratureonreturntoworkafterinjury.ScandJWorkEnvironHealth32(4):257–69.

MacfarlaneGJ,HuntIM,SilmanAJ(2000).Roleofmechanicalandpsychosocialfactorsintheonsetofforearmpain:prospectivepopulationbasedstudy.BMJ321(7262):676–9.

MacfarlaneGJ,PallewatteN,PaudyalP,BlythFM,CoggonD,CrombezG,LintonS,Leino-ArjasP,SilmanAJ,SmeetsRJ,vanderWindtD(2009).Evaluationofwork-relatedpsychosocialfactorsandregionalmusculoskeletalpain:resultsfromaEULARTaskForce.AnnRheumDis68(6):885–91.

MalmivaaraA,HakkinenU,AroT,HeinrichsML,KoskenniemiL,KuosmaE,LappiS,Palo-heimoR,ServoC,VaaranenV,etal.(1995).Thetreatmentofacutelowbackpain–bedrest,exercises,orordinaryactivity?NEnglJMed332(6):351–5.

ManiadakisN,GrayA(2000).TheeconomicburdenofbackpainintheUK.Pain84(1):95–103.

MartimoKP,VerbeekJ,KarppinenJ,FurlanAD,KuijerPP,Viikari-JunturaE,TakalaEP,Jauhi-ainenM(2007).Manualmaterialhandlingadviceandassistivedevicesforpreventingandtreatingbackpaininworkers.CochraneDatabaseSystRev(3):CD005958.

Page 122: Kari-Pekka Martimo - UEF · Kari-Pekka Martimo Musculoskeletal disorders, disability and work Kari-Pekka Martimo Musculoskeletal disorders (MSD) are the most important causes of temporary

120

REfERENCES

MattkeS,BalakrishnanA,BergamoG,NewberrySJ(2007).Areviewofmethodstomeasurehealth-relatedproductivityloss.AmJManagCare13(4):211–7.

MeerdingWJ,WIJ,KoopmanschapMA,SeverensJL,BurdorfA(2005).Healthproblemsleadtoconsiderableproductivitylossatworkamongworkerswithhighphysicalloadjobs.JClinEpidemiol58(5):517–23.

MehlumIS,VeierstedKB,WaerstedM,WergelandE,KjuusH(2009).Self-reportedversusexpert-assessedwork-relatednessofpainintheneck,shoulder,andarm.ScandJWorkEnvironHealth35(3):222–32.

MeijerEM,SluiterJK,Frings-DresenMH(2008).Isworkstyleamediatingfactorforpainintheupperextremityovertime?JOccupRehabil18(3):262–6.

MikkelssonM,SalminenJJ,KautiainenH(1997).Non-specificmusculoskeletalpaininpre-adolescents.Prevalenceand1-yearpersistence.Pain73(1):29–35.

MirandaH,Viikari-JunturaE,HeistaroS,HeliovaaraM,RiihimakiH(2005).Apopulationstudyondifferencesinthedeterminantsofaspecificshoulderdisorderversusnonspecificshoulderpainwithoutclinicalfindings.AmJEpidemiol161(9):847–55.

MirandaH,Viikari-JunturaE,MartikainenR,TakalaEP,RiihimakiH(2001).Aprospectivestudyofworkrelatedfactorsandphysicalexerciseaspredictorsofshoulderpain.OccupEnvironMed58(8):528–34.

MirandaH,Viikari-JunturaE,PunnettL,RiihimakiH(2008).Occupationalloading,healthbehaviorandsleepdisturbanceaspredictorsoflow-backpain.ScandJWorkEnvironHealth34(6):411–9.

MüllerK,SchwesigR,LeuchteS,RiedeD(2001).[Coordinativetreatmentandqualityoflife–arandomisedtrialofnurseswithbackpain].Gesundheitswesen63(10):609–18.

NationalResearchCouncilandInstituteofMedicine(2001)Musculoskeletaldisordersandtheworkplace:Lowbackandupperextremities.Washington,DC

NicholasRA,FeuersteinM,SuchdayS(2005).Workstyleandupper-extremitysymptoms:abiobehavioralperspective.JOccupEnvironMed47(4):352–61.

OpsteeghL,Reinders-MesselinkHA,SchollierD,GroothoffJW,PostemaK,DijkstraPU,vanderSluisCK(2009).Determinantsofreturntoworkinpatientswithhanddisordersandhandinjuries.JOccupRehabil19(3):245–55.

PehkonenI,MirandaH,HaukkaE,LuukkonenR,TakalaEP,KetolaR,Leino-ArjasP,Rii-himakiH,Viikari-JunturaE(2009).Prospectivestudyonshouldersymptomsamongkitchenworkersinrelationtoself-perceivedandobservedworkload.OccupEnvironMed66(6):416–23.

PincusT,BurtonAK,VogelS,FieldAP(2002).Asystematicreviewofpsychologicalfactorsaspredictorsofchronicity/disabilityinprospectivecohortsoflowbackpain.Spine(PhilaPa1976)27(5):E109–20.

PlompHN(1992).Workers'attitudetowardtheoccupationalphysician.JOccupMed34(9):893–901.

Page 123: Kari-Pekka Martimo - UEF · Kari-Pekka Martimo Musculoskeletal disorders, disability and work Kari-Pekka Martimo Musculoskeletal disorders (MSD) are the most important causes of temporary

121

REfERENCES

PlompHN(1993).Employees'andoccupationalphysicians'differentperceptionsofthework-relatednessofhealthproblems:acriticalpointinaneffectiveconsultationprocess.OccupMed(Lond)43 Suppl 1:S18–22.

PodsakoffPM,MacKenzieSB,LeeJY,PodsakoffNP(2003).Commonmethodbiasesinbehavioralresearch:acriticalreviewoftheliteratureandrecommendedremedies.JApplPsychol88(5):879–903.

PranskyG,ShawW,FrancheRL,ClarkeA(2004).Disabilitypreventionandcommunicationamongworkers,physicians,employers,andinsurers–currentmodelsandopportunitiesforimprovement.DisabilRehabil26(11):625–34.

PunnettL,WegmanDH(2004).Work-relatedmusculoskeletaldisorders:theepidemiologicevidenceandthedebate.JElectromyogrKinesiol14(1):13–23.

ReddellCR,CongletonJJ,DaleHuchingsonR,MontgomeryJF(1992).Anevaluationofaweightliftingbeltandbackinjurypreventiontrainingclassforairlinebaggagehandlers.ApplErgon23(5):319–29.

RempelDM,KrauseN,GoldbergR,BennerD,HudesM,GoldnerGU(2006).Arandomisedcontrolledtrialevaluatingtheeffectsoftwoworkstationinterventionsonupperbodypainandincidentmusculoskeletaldisordersamongcomputeroperators.OccupEnvironMed63(5):300–6.

RoquelaureY,HaC,RouillonC,FouquetN,LeclercA,DescathaA,TouranchetA,GoldbergM,ImbernonE(2009).Riskfactorsforupper-extremitymusculoskeletaldisordersintheworkingpopulation.ArthritisRheum61(10):1425–34.

RäsänenK,NotkolaV,HusmanK(1997).Work-relatedinterventionsduringofficevisitstooccupationalhealthphysicians.PrevMed26(3):333–9.

SBU(2004).SBUsummaryandconclusions.ScandJPublicHealth32(Suppl63):6–11.

ScheelIB,HagenKB,HerrinJ,CarlingC,OxmanAD(2002).Blindfaith?Theeffectsofpromotingactivesickleaveforbackpainpatients:acluster-randomizedcontrolledtrial.Spine(PhilaPa1976)27(23):2734–40.

SchultzAB,EdingtonDW(2007a).Employeehealthandpresenteeism:asystematicreview.JOccupRehabil17(3):547–79.

SchultzIZ,CrookJ,FraserK,W.JP(2000).Modelsofdiagnosisandrehabilitationinmuscu-loskeletalpain-relatedoccupationaldisability.JOccupRehabil10(4):271–93.

SchultzIZ,StowellAW,FeuersteinM,GatchelRJ(2007b).Modelsofreturntoworkformus-culoskeletaldisorders.JOccupRehabil17(2):327–52.

ShawL,SegalR,PolatajkoH,HarburnK(2002a).Understandingreturntoworkbehaviours:promotingtheimportanceofindividualperceptionsinthestudyofreturntowork.DisabilRehabil24(4):185–95.

ShawW,HongQN,PranskyG,LoiselP(2008).Aliteraturereviewdescribingtheroleofreturn-to-workcoordinatorsintrialprogramsandinterventionsdesignedtopreventworkplacedisability.JOccupRehabil18(1):2–15.

Page 124: Kari-Pekka Martimo - UEF · Kari-Pekka Martimo Musculoskeletal disorders, disability and work Kari-Pekka Martimo Musculoskeletal disorders (MSD) are the most important causes of temporary

122

REfERENCES

ShawWS,FeuersteinM(2004).Generatingworkplaceaccommodations:lessonslearnedfromtheintegratedcasemanagementstudy.JOccupRehabil14(3):207–16.

ShawWS,FeuersteinM,LincolnAE,MillerVI,WoodPM(2002b).Ergonomicandpsychoso-cialfactorsaffectdailyfunctioninworkers'compensationclaimantswithpersistentupperextremitydisorders.JOccupEnvironMed44(7):606–15.

ShawWS,FeuersteinM,MillerVI,WoodPM(2003a).Identifyingbarrierstorecoveryfromworkrelatedupperextremitydisorders:useofacollaborativeproblemsolvingtechnique.AAOHNJ51(8):337–46.

ShawWS,PranskyG,FitzgeraldTE(2001).Earlyprognosisforlowbackdisability:interventionstrategiesforhealthcareproviders.DisabilRehabil23(18):815–28.

ShawWS,PranskyG,PattersonW,WintersT(2005).Earlydisabilityriskfactorsforlowbackpainassessedatoutpatientoccupationalhealthclinics.Spine(PhilaPa1976)30(5):572–80.

ShawWS,PranskyG,WintersT(2009a).TheBackDisabilityRiskQuestionnaireforwork-related,acutebackpain:predictionofunresolvedproblemsat3-monthfollow-up.JOccupEnvironMed51(2):185–94.

ShawWS,RobertsonMM,McLellanRK,VermaS,PranskyG(2006).Acontrolledcasestudyofsupervisortrainingtooptimizeresponsetoinjuryinthefoodprocessingindustry.Work26(2):107–14.

ShawWS,RobertsonMM,PranskyG,McLellanRK(2003b).Employeeperspectivesontheroleofsupervisorstopreventworkplacedisabilityafterinjuries.JOccupRehabil13(3):129–42.

ShawWS,vanderWindtDA,MainCJ,LoiselP,LintonSJ(2009b).Earlypatientscreeningandinterventiontoaddressindividual–leveloccupationalfactors("blueflags")inbackdisability.JOccupRehabil19(1):64–80.

ShiriR,MirandaH,HeliovaaraM,Viikari-JunturaE(2009).Physicalworkloadfactorsandcarpaltunnelsyndrome:apopulation–basedstudy.OccupEnvironMed66(6):368–73.

ShiriR,SolovievaS,Husgafvel-PursiainenK,ViikariJ,RaitakariOT,Viikari-JunturaE(2010).Incidenceofnonspecificandradiatinglowbackpain:followupof24–39-year-oldadultsoftheYoungFinnsStudy.ArthritisCareRes62(4):455–9.

ShiriR,VaronenH,HeliovaaraM,Viikari-JunturaE(2007).Handdominanceinupperextrem-itymusculoskeletaldisorders.JRheumatol34(5):1076–82.

ShiriR,Viikari-JunturaE,VaronenH,HeliovaaraM(2006).Prevalenceanddeterminantsoflateralandmedialepicondylitis:apopulationstudy.AmJEpidemiol164(11):1065–74.

SieurinL,JosephsonM,VingårdE,Eds.(2007).Partiellellerhelsjukskrivning,konsekvenserförindividen.Delrapport1;Redovisningavdeskriptivadata.(InSwedish)(Partialorcom-pletesickleave,consequencestotheindividual).Rapport1/2007,AkademiskaSjukhuset:UppsalaUniversitetet.

SilversteinB,ClarkR(2004).Interventionstoreducework-relatedmusculoskeletaldisorders.JElectromyogrKinesiol14(1):135–52.

Page 125: Kari-Pekka Martimo - UEF · Kari-Pekka Martimo Musculoskeletal disorders, disability and work Kari-Pekka Martimo Musculoskeletal disorders (MSD) are the most important causes of temporary

123

REfERENCES

SilversteinB,FanZJ,SmithCK,BaoS,HowardN,SpielholzP,BonautoD,Viikari-JunturaE(2009).Genderadjustmentorstratificationindiscerningupperextremitymusculoskeletaldisorderrisk?ScandJWorkEnvironHealth35(2):113–26.

SilversteinB,Viikari-JunturaE,KalatJ(2002).Useofapreventionindextoidentifyindustriesathighriskforwork-relatedmusculoskeletaldisordersoftheneck,back,andupperextremityinWashingtonstate,1990–1998.AmJIndMed41(3):149–69.

SlimK,NiniE,ForestierD,KwiatkowskiF,PanisY,ChipponiJ(2003).Methodologicalindexfornon-randomizedstudies(minors):developmentandvalidationofanewinstrument.ANZJSurg73(9):712–6.

SluiterJK,RestKM,Frings-DresenMH(2001).Criteriadocumentforevaluatingthework-relatednessofupper-extremitymusculoskeletaldisorders.ScandJWorkEnvironHealth27 Suppl 1:1–102.

SteenstraIA,VerbeekJH,HeymansMW,BongersPM(2005).Prognosticfactorsfordurationofsickleaveinpatientssicklistedwithacutelowbackpain:asystematicreviewoftheliterature.OccupEnvironMed62(12):851–60.

StewartWF,RicciJA,CheeE,MorgansteinD,LiptonR(2003).LostproductivetimeandcostduetocommonpainconditionsintheUSworkforce.JAMA290(18):2443–54.

TaimelaS,LaaraE,MalmivaaraA,TieksoJ,SintonenH,JustenS,AroT(2007).Self-reportedhealthproblemsandsicknessabsenceindifferentagegroupspredominantlyengagedinphysicalwork.OccupEnvironMed64(11):739–46.

TakalaEP,AndersenJH,BurdorfA,FallentinN,HartvigsenJ,LeclercA,VeierstedKB(2010).Lackof"statisticallysignificant"associationisnotavalidargumentforconflictingfindings.Spine(PhilaPa1976)in press.

TellnesG,BruusgaardD,SandvikL(1990).Occupationalfactorsinsicknesscertification.ScandJPrimHealthCare8(1):37–44.

TruchonM,FillionL(2000).Biopsychosocialdeterminantsofchronicdisabilityandlow-backpain:Areview.JOccupRehabil10(2):117–42.

TveitoTH,HysingM,EriksenHR(2004).Lowbackpaininterventionsattheworkplace:asystematicliteraturereview.OccupMed(Lond)54(1):3–13.

VahteraJ,PenttiJ,KivimakiM(2004).Sicknessabsenceasapredictorofmortalityamongmaleandfemaleemployees.JEpidemiolCommunityHealth58(4):321–6.

vandenHeuvelSG,deLoozeMP,HildebrandtVH,TheKH(2003).Effectsofsoftwareprogramsstimulatingregularbreaksandexercisesonwork-relatedneckandupper-limbdisorders.ScandJWorkEnvironHealth29(2):106–16.

vandenHeuvelSG,IjmkerS,BlatterBM,deKorteEM(2007).Lossofproductivityduetoneck/shouldersymptomsandhand/armsymptoms:resultsfromthePROMO–study.JOccupRehabil17(3):370–82.

vanderWindtDA,ThomasE,PopeDP,deWinterAF,MacfarlaneGJ,BouterLM,SilmanAJ(2000).Occupationalriskfactorsforshoulderpain:asystematicreview.OccupEnvironMed57(7):433–42.

Page 126: Kari-Pekka Martimo - UEF · Kari-Pekka Martimo Musculoskeletal disorders, disability and work Kari-Pekka Martimo Musculoskeletal disorders (MSD) are the most important causes of temporary

124

REfERENCES

vanDuijnM,LottersF,BurdorfA(2005).Influenceofmodifiedworkonreturntoworkforemployeesonsickleaveduetomusculoskeletalcomplaints.JRehabilMed37(3):172–9.

vanOostromSH,DriessenMT,deVetHC,FrancheRL,SchonsteinE,LoiselP,vanMechelenW,AnemaJR(2009).Workplaceinterventionsforpreventingworkdisability.CochraneDatabaseSystRev(2):CD006955.

vanPoppelMN,HooftmanWE,KoesBW(2004).Anupdateofasystematicreviewofcon-trolledclinicaltrialsontheprimarypreventionofbackpainattheworkplace.OccupMed(Lond)54(5):345–52.

vanPoppelMN,KoesBW,vanderPloegT,SmidT,BouterLM(1998).Lumbarsupportsandeducationforthepreventionoflowbackpaininindustry:arandomizedcontrolledtrial.JAMA279(22):1789–94.

vanRijnRM,HuisstedeBM,KoesBW,BurdorfA(2009a).Associationsbetweenwork-relatedfactorsandspecificdisordersattheelbow:asystematicliteraturereview.Rheumatology(Oxford)48(5):528–36.

vanRijnRM,HuisstedeBM,KoesBW,BurdorfA(2009b).Associationsbetweenwork-relatedfactorsandthecarpaltunnelsyndrome–asystematicreview.ScandJWorkEnvironHealth35(1):19–36.

vanTulderM,FurlanA,BombardierC,BouterL(2003).Updatedmethodguidelinesforsystematicreviewsinthecochranecollaborationbackreviewgroup.Spine(PhilaPa1976)28(12):1290–9.

vanTulderMMA,KoesB(2007).Repetitivestraininjury.Lancet369:1815–22.

vanTulderMW,AssendelftWJ,KoesBW,BouterLM(1997).MethodguidelinesforsystematicreviewsintheCochraneCollaborationBackReviewGroupforSpinalDisorders.Spine(PhilaPa1976)22(20):2323–30.

VaronenH,Viikari-JunturaE,PasternackI,KetolaR,MalmivaaraA,RahkonenE,HavulinnaJ,ArolaH(2007)"Repetitivestraininjuriesofthehandandforearm."CurrentCareSum-mary.www.kaypahoito.fi

VerbeekJ,SalmiJ,PasternackI,JauhiainenM,LaamanenI,SchaafsmaF,HulshofC,vanDijkF(2005).Asearchstrategyforoccupationalhealthinterventionstudies.OccupEnvironMed62(10):682–7.

Viikari-JunturaE,RauasS,MartikainenR,KuosmaE,RiihimakiH,TakalaEP,SaarenmaaK(1996).Validityofself–reportedphysicalworkloadinepidemiologicstudiesonmuscu-loskeletaldisorders.ScandJWorkEnvironHealth22(4):251–9.

Viikari-JunturaE,ShiriR,SolovievaS,KarppinenJ,Leino-ArjasP,VaronenH,KalsoE,Uk-kolaO(2008).Riskfactorsofatherosclerosisandshoulderpain–isthereanassociation?Asystematicreview.EurJPain12(4):412–26.

VossM,StarkS,AlfredssonL,VingardE,JosephsonM(2008).Comparisonsofself-reportedandregisterdataonsicknessabsenceamongpublicemployeesinSweden.OccupEnvironMed65(1):61–7.

Page 127: Kari-Pekka Martimo - UEF · Kari-Pekka Martimo Musculoskeletal disorders, disability and work Kari-Pekka Martimo Musculoskeletal disorders (MSD) are the most important causes of temporary

125

REfERENCES

WaddellG,BurtonAK(2001).Occupationalhealthguidelinesforthemanagementoflowbackpainatwork:evidencereview.OccupMed(Lond)51(2):124–35.

WaddellG,BurtonAK(2006).Isworkgoodforyourhealthandwell–being?London,TheStationeryOffice.

WaddellG,NewtonM,HendersonI,SomervilleD,MainCJ(1993).AFear–AvoidanceBeliefsQuestionnaire(FABQ)andtheroleoffear-avoidancebeliefsinchroniclowbackpainanddisability.Pain52(2):157–68.

WaiEK,RoffeyDM,BishopP,KwonBK,DagenaisS(2010).Causalassessmentofoccupationalbendingortwistingandlowbackpain:resultsofasystematicreview.SpineJ10(1):76–88.

Walker-BoneK,CooperC(2005).Hardworkneverhurtanyone:ordidit?Areviewofoccu-pationalassociationswithsofttissuemusculoskeletaldisordersoftheneckandupperlimb.AnnRheumDis64(10):1391–6.

WeeversHJ,vanderBeekAJ,AnemaJR,vanderWalG,vanMechelenW(2005).Work-relateddiseaseingeneralpractice:asystematicreview.FamPract22(2):197–204.

WernerEL,CoteP(2009).Lowbackpainanddeterminantsofsicknessabsence.EurJGenPract15(2):74–9.

WernerEL,LaerumE,WormgoorME,LindhE,IndahlA(2007).Peersupportinanoc-cupationalsettingpreventingLBP–relatedsickleave.OccupMed(Lond)57(8):590–5.

WesterlundH,KivimakiM,FerrieJE,MarmotM,ShipleyMJ,VahteraJ,HeadJ(2009).Doesworkingwhileilltriggerseriouscoronaryevents?TheWhitehallIIstudy.JOccupEnvironMed51(9):1099–104.

WickströmGJ,PenttiJ(1998).Occupationalfactorsaffectingsickleaveattributedtolow-backpain.ScandJWorkEnvironHealth24(2):145–52.

WorldHealthOrganisation(2001)ICF.InternationalClassificationofFunctioning,DisabilityandHealth.Geneva

WorldHealthOrganisation(1985)Identificationandcontrolofwork-relateddiseases.Geneva

YassiA,CooperJE,TateRB,GerlachS,MuirM,TrottierJ,MasseyK(2001).Arandomizedcontrolledtrialtopreventpatientliftandtransferinjuriesofhealthcareworkers.Spine(PhilaPa1976)26(16):1739–46.

YoungAE,RoesslerRT,WasiakR,McPhersonKM,vanPoppelMN,AnemaJR(2005).Adevelopmentalconceptualizationofreturntowork.JOccupRehabil15(4):557–68.

Page 128: Kari-Pekka Martimo - UEF · Kari-Pekka Martimo Musculoskeletal disorders, disability and work Kari-Pekka Martimo Musculoskeletal disorders (MSD) are the most important causes of temporary
Page 129: Kari-Pekka Martimo - UEF · Kari-Pekka Martimo Musculoskeletal disorders, disability and work Kari-Pekka Martimo Musculoskeletal disorders (MSD) are the most important causes of temporary

127

ORIgINAL PUBLICATIONS I–v

Page 130: Kari-Pekka Martimo - UEF · Kari-Pekka Martimo Musculoskeletal disorders, disability and work Kari-Pekka Martimo Musculoskeletal disorders (MSD) are the most important causes of temporary

Orders:Finnish Institute of Occupational HealthTopeliuksenkatu 41 a AFI-00250 HelsinkiFinland

Fax +358-9 477 5071E-mail [email protected]/bookstore

ISBN 978-951-802-987-1 (paperback) 978-951-802-988-8 (PDF)ISSN-L 1237-6183ISSN 1237-6183

Cover picture: Sami Rantanen

Musculoskeletal disorders, disability and work

People and WorkResearch Reports 89

Kari-Pekka Martimo

Musculoskeletal disorders, disability and w

orkK

ari-Pekka Martim

oMusculoskeletal disorders (MSD) are the most important causes of temporary and permanent work disability. The aim of this thesis was to examine the role of work in the disability caused by MSD from various perspectives: primary prevention using lifting advice and devices, perception of work-relatedness, measurement of productivity loss, and secondary/tertiary prevention through ergonomic intervention or part-time sick leave. The original articles include a systematic review, two surveys, a randomised controlled trial, and a study protocol. The results support the early use of a biopsychosocial model for effective management of disability.

89